We continue our study of the invariants of the L-functions of deree 2 twisted by Dirichlet characters. In a previous paper, we proved that twisting does not change degree and internal shift. Our aim now is to show a corresponding theorem for the conductor. This paper is intended as the second part of a series aiming to prove a general version of the Weil converse theorem with minimal assumptions on the shape of the functional equation of twists.
Dedicated to Helmut Maier on the occasion of his 70th birthday
Mathematics Subject Classification (2010): 11M41
Introduction
We continue our study of the invariants of the L-functions of degree 2 twisted by Dirichlet characters. We keep the general notation introduced in [6], where we proved that twisting does not change degree and internal shift. Here we show a corresponding result for the conductor. This paper is intended as the second part of a series aiming to prove a general version of the Weil converse theorem with minimal assumptions on the shape of the functional equation of twists. For the readers’ convenience, we recall all the necessary notation in the next section.
Theorem. Let F∈S♯ be of degree 2 with integer conductor qF. Let D be a squarefree positive integer, D≡1(modqF), such that F splits polynomially of degree 2 at every prime p∣D. Moreover, suppose that F is saturated (mod D) and for every Dirichlet character χ(modD), the twist Fχ∗ belongs to S♯. Then the conductors of Fχ∗, F and χ are related by
holds in much greater generality. In particular, we expect (2) to hold for every F∈S, with any degree dF and integer conductor qF, and every primitive character χ(modfχ), (fχ,qF)=1, such that the twist Fχ also belongs to S; see conjecture (III.4) in [3]. Note that (2) holds for all classical L-functions.
Acknowledgements
This research was partially supported by the Istituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica, by grant PRIN 2022 “The arithmetic of motives and L-functions” and by grant 2021/41/BST1/00241 “Analytic methods in number theory” from the National Science Centre, Poland.
Notation
In this paper
F(s)=n=1∑∞nsa(n)(σ>1)
stands for a generic function from the extended Selberg class S#. Recall that every such function satisfies a functional equation of the form
γ(s)F(s)=ωγ(1−s)F(1−s),
where
γ(s)=Qsj=1∏rΓ(λjs+μj)
and Q>0, λj>0, ℜ(μj)≥0, ∣ω∣=1. The Selberg class S is the subclass of the functions F∈S# having a rather general Euler product expansion and satisfying the Ramanujan conjecture a(n)≪nε. Degree, conductor, internal shift and root number of F are defined, respectively, by
If Fχ∈S#, then its degree, conductor, internal shift and root number are denoted, respectively, by dFχ, qFχ, θFχ and ωFχ∗. In the important special case β=0 and α=0, F(s,0,α) is called the standard twist of F and is denoted by F(s,α). Concerning the standard twist, we define the spectrum of F as
Spec(F)={α>0:a(nα)=0},where nα=qFdFαdF and a(x)=0 if x∈/N.
The relevance of Spec(F) to the polar structure of F(s,α) is reported in Lemma 3.
We say that F∈S# splits polynomially of degree 2 at a prime p if
F(s)=j=1∏2(1−psαj(p))−1p∤n∑nsa(n)
for certain complex numbers αj(p)=0. We say that F∈S# is saturated (mod D) if for every integer M and every residue class a (mod D), (a,D)=1, there exists a positive integer ν≡a (mod D) with (ν,M)=1 such that a(ν)=0. Moreover, we say that F∈S# is normalized if θF=0 and the first non-zero Dirichlet coefficient of F equals 1.
For a Dirichlet character χ, we denote by χ∗ the primitive character inducing χ. As usual, we denote by fχ the conductor of χ, thus χ∗ is a Dirichlet character (mod fχ). Sometimes, in cases where no confusion may occur, when χ is a character (mod q) we simply write q∗ instead of fχ. Finally, the Gauss sum of χ is denoted by τ(χ).
Lemmas
Lemma 1. Let D be a positive squarefree integer and (a,D)=1, and suppose that F∈S♯ with dF=2 splits polynomially of degree 2 at all primes p∣D. Then for σ>1 we have
Proof. This is a special case of Lemma 3 in [6] with λ=1/2. Note that in such a Lemma 3, the analog of equation (3) has m∣(fχD)∗ in place of m∣(fχD)2. Here we have simply m∣(fχD)2 thanks to the hypothesis that F splits polynomially of degree 2 at all primes p∣D. □
Lemma 2. Let F∈S♯ with dF=2 be normalized. Then for β>0 and α∈R we have
Proof. This is the Lemma in [5] with a slightly changed notation. □
Lemma 3. The standard twist F(s,α) of F∈S♯ is meromorphic on C for every α∈R∖{0}. Moreover, if F∈S♯ has dF=2 and θF=0, then for α∈Spec(F) we have
ress=3/4F(s,α)=c0(F)nα1/4a(nα),(4)
where c0(F)=0 is a constant depending on F and nα=qFα2/4.
Proof. This follows from Theorems 1 and 2 in [4]. □
We remark that (4) holds also if 0<α∈/Spec(F), in the sense that both sides equal zero in this case.
Lemma 4. Let F, D and χ be as in the Theorem. Then dFχ∗=2 and θFχ∗=θF.
Proof. This is the main result of part I of the series, see [6]. □
Lemma 5. If the Theorem is true for every entire F∈S♯ with dF=2, then it holds true for all F∈S♯ with dF=2.
Proof. Let F∈S♯ with dF=2 have a pole of order mF>0 at s=1, fix a prime p0∤D and write
G(s)=(1−p0sp0+1+p02sp0)mF.
We easily check that G∈S♯, and has degree 0 and conductor qG=p02mF. Thus the function F1(s)=G(s)F(s) belongs to S♯, is entire and has dF1=2 and qF1=qGqF=p02mFqF. Moreover, it is easily seen that Gχ∈S♯ for every character χ, and qGχ=qG. Hence applying the Theorem to F1 we get
qF1χ∗=qF1fχ2.
endsmid=1
But F1χ=GχFχ and qF1χ∗=qGχ∗qFχ∗=p02mFqFχ∗. Therefore
p02mFqFχ∗=p02mFqFχfχ2
and the result follows.
Lemma 6. Let ψ(modq) be a Dirichlet character induced by ψ∗(modq∗). Then
τ(ψ)=μ(q/q∗)ψ∗(q/q∗)τ(ψ∗).
Proof. This is a well-known property of the Gauss sums, see Theorem 9.10 in [7].
Proof of the Theorem
Using Lemma 5, we may assume without loss of generality that F is entire. Shifting the variable s by a suitable purely imaginary constant and multiplying by an appropriate non-zero constant, we can further assume that F is normalized, thus we may apply Lemma 2. Taking into account that D≡1(modqF), for σ>1 we obtain
Note that (7) is proved for σ>1, but both sides are meromorphic for σ>1/2 thanks to Lemmas 2 and 3; thus (7) holds in this larger half-plane. Observe that θFχ∗=0 by Lemma 4 and hence, according to Lemma 3, Fχ∗(s,mα) has a pole at s=3/4 whenever mα∈Spec(Fχ∗). Taking residues of both sides of (7) and using Lemma 3 again, we obtain
Moreover, for k(χ,m)=k0 we have m=(D/fχ)2. Thus, for (ν,M)=1, (11) reads as
a(ν)χ(modD)k(χ)=k0∑cF(χ)χ(ν)=0.
where cF(χ):=c(χ,(D/fχ)2). Note that, according to (10), these coefficients are non-zero. Since F is saturated (mod D), for every residue class a(modD), (a,D)=1, we can find ν≡a(modD), (ν,M)=1, such that a(ν)=0. Hence for every (a,D)=1 we have
χ(modD)k(χ)=k0∑cF(χ)χ(a)=0.
This contradicts the linear independence of characters, thus we have k0=1.
Finally we show that k(χ)=1 for every character χ(modD). Since k0=1, (9) reads as
For (ν,M)=1, we have k(χ,m)ν∈/N, and hence the corresponding terms on the right hand side vanish. In particular, non-zero terms must have k(χ,m)=1. Recalling that in the latter case m=(D/fχ)2, equation (12) takes the form
As before, we use the assumption that F is saturated (mod D), thus getting that
e(DaqF1−D)=χ(modD)k(χ)=1∑cF(χ)χ(a)(13)
for all (a,D)=1. Suppose that the sum on the right hand side of (13) does not contain all characters (mod D). For instance, suppose that k(ψ)=1 for a certain ψ(modD). Multiplying both sides of (13) by ψ(a) and summing over all (a,D)=1 we obtain, by the orthogonality of characters, that
and hence is non-zero since D is square-free. This contradiction shows that k(χ)=1 and consequently qχ=qFfχ2 for all χ (mod D). The proof is complete.
Jerzy Kaczorowski, Faculty of Mathematics and Computer Science, A. Mickiewicz University, 61-614 Poznań, Poland. e-mail: [email protected]
Alberto Perelli, Dipartimento di Matematica, Università di Genova, via Dodecaneso 35, 16146 Genova, Italy. e-mail: [email protected]
References
[1]J.Kaczorowski - Axiomatic theory of L-functions: the Selberg class - In Analytic Number Theory, C.I.M.E. Summer School, Cetraro (Italy) 2002, ed. by A.Perelli and C.Viola, 133–209, Springer L.N. 1891, 2006.DOI
[2]J.Kaczorowski, A.Perelli - The Selberg class: a survey - In Number Theory in Progress, Proc. Conf. in Honor of A.Schinzel, ed. by K.Györy et al., 953–992, de Gruyter 1999.DOI
[3]J.Kaczorowski, A.Perelli - On the structure of the Selberg class, II: invariants and conjectures - J. reine angew. Math. 524 (2000), 73–96.DOI
[4]J.Kaczorowski, A.Perelli - On the structure of the Selberg class, VI: non-linear twists - Acta Arith. 116 (2005), 315–341.DOI
[5]J.Kaczorowski, A.Perelli - A weak converse theorem for degree 2 L-functions with conductor 1 - Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci. 53 (2017), no. 2, 337–347.DOI
[6]J.Kaczorowski, A.Perelli - On the invariants of L-functions of degree 2, I: twisted degree and internal shift - Preprint.
[7]H.L.Montgomery, R. C.Vaughan - Multiplicative Number Theory. I. Classical Theory - Cambridge U. P. 2007.
[8]A.Perelli - A survey of the Selberg class of L-functions, part I - Milan J. Math. 73 (2005), 19–52.DOI
[9]A.Perelli - A survey of the Selberg class of L-functions, part II - Riv. Mat. Univ. Parma (7) 3* (2004), 83–118.