WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Probing surface vibration of spherical nuclei in relativistic heavy-ion collisions
Abstract
There has been increasing interest in recent years in using relativistic heavy-ion collisions to probe nuclear structure, such as static nuclear deformation. Here we discuss the role of quantum zero-point fluctuations of the surface vibration of spherical nuclei in relativistic heavy-ion collisions. To this end, we employ an approach to describe the vibration in the space-fixed frame, which has been well established in the field of low-energy heavy-ion fusion reactions. We particularly consider the quadrupole vibration of Ni in Ni+Ni reaction and the octupole vibration of Pb in Pb+Pb reaction. We show that the surface vibration leads to comparable eccentricity parameters to those for static deformation, while they give significantly different distributions of the initial states, suggesting the importance of the proper treatment of the surface vibration in heavy-ion collisions. We perform similar analysis also for triaxial deformation and gamma-soft vibration.
Introduction
Nuclear deformation is one of the most important concepts in nuclear structure physics [1]. When a nucleus is permanently deformed, it exhibits a characteristic rotational band, in which the excitation energies of a state with spin is proportional to . It also shows enhanced electromagnetic transition strengths as well as large quadrupole moments. Moreover, it has also been well known that nuclear deformation significantly affects low-energy nuclear reactions [2, 3]. In particular, heavy-ion fusion reactions at energies around the Coulomb barrier are sensitive to nuclear deformation [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7], and there have been many attempts to determine deformation parameters of a nucleus, especially the sign of hexadecapole deformation parameter [5, 6, 8, 9], using the fusion barrier distribution [4, 10].
In recent years, there has been increasing interest in probing nuclear deformation in relativistic heavy-ion collisions (RelHIC) [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27]. The key idea of this approach is that different deformations of the colliding nuclei lead to different distributions of the initial states on the transverse plane. Through the hydrodynamic response of the quark-gluon plasma, they turn into the event-by-event distribution of the collective flow, which is experimentally observable and carries information about the nuclear deformation. An important point here is that the energy (time) scale of heavy-ion reactions in RelHIC is much larger (shorter) than that of nuclear motions. One can thus adopt a simple picture of adiabatic approximation, i.e., the initial nuclear configuration is regarded to be frozen during a collision. This approach has been applied not only to the quadrupole deformation but also the hexadecapole deformation [17, 19], the triaxial quadrupole deformation [13, 15, 23], the octupole deformation [25], and the alpha cluster structure [28, 29, 30]. For example, the STAR Collaboration has reported in Ref. [21, 22] the deformation parameters and for . See Ref. [20] for a recent review (see, however, also Ref. [31] for a recent comment on these activities).
Whereas these studies have mainly focused on the static deformation of deformed nuclei so far, the initial states of RelHIC can also be affected by the quantum zero-point fluctuations of the deformation, whose importance is well recognized in the low-energy sub-barrier fusion reactions [2, 3, 4, 32, 33, 34, 35]. In RelHIC, a recent paper by Xu, et al. has shown that a puzzle related to the anisotropic flow observed in ultra-central collisions [36, 37, 38, 39, 40] can be resolved to a large extent by the octupole surface vibration of the nucleus [41]. The fluctuation of the triaxial deformation parameter has also been discussed in Ref. [23].
In the present Letter, we discuss the effect of the quantum fluctuations of deformation parameters on RelHIC focusing on the surface vibrations of spherical nuclei. To describe the vibrations, we employ the harmonic-oscillator model in the space-fixed frame [2, 3]. This treatment can describe harmonic vibrations in all the directions on equal footing, and connect their magnitudes to the experimental data on the electronic transition probability. Using this method, we explore the eccentricity parameters and mean-square area of the initial states of RelHIC based on the liquid-drop model with a complete overlap [14] for and . Comparing these results with the case of the static deformation, we demonstrate that these treatments lead to qualitatively different distributions from each other. The difference is especially highlighted in the skewness and kurtosis of the eccentricity parameters, suggesting their discrimination through the measurement of higher-order correlations of flow observables in the ultra-central collisions. Similar analysis is also performed for the triaxial deformation parameter .
Surface vibration
To describe the deformation of a nucleus, we use a deformed Woods-Saxon density
for the nucleon density in the space-fixed frame with the polar coordinates , where and are the central density and the diffuseness parameter, respectively. Here, is the angle dependent radius given by
with the deformation parameters in the space-fixed frame () satisfying , the radius parameter , and . The second term in the parenthesis in Eq. (2) is due to the volume conservation [1].
In the harmonic oscillator model for spherical nuclei, the classical Hamiltonian for the deformation parameters reads [1]
where the dot denotes the time derivative, and and are the inertia and the stiffness parameters of the oscillator, respectively. On the second line, we have introduced the real coordinates
for and for . (3) shows that there exist independent harmonic oscillators for a given with being the coordinates.
In quantum mechanics, the ground state of these harmonic oscillators has the zero-point fluctuation with and , where the amplitude of the zero-point motion is with . We thus have
In low-energy heavy-ion fusion reactions, is often referred to as the (dynamical) deformation parameter [2, 3]. Its value can be estimated from a measured electronic transition probability from the ground state of a spherical nucleus to an excited state as [2, 3],
where is the atomic number of the nucleus. From the measured for the transition from
the ground state to the first state at in [42], is estimated to be with . In the case of , the measured [43] for the transition from the ground state to the first state at yields with . It has been well recognized that excitations of those vibrational states considerably affect heavy-ion fusion reactions of e.g., and , at energies around the Coulomb barrier [2, 3, 33, 34, 35, 44].
It is instructive to compare the deformation parameters in Eq. (2) to those for static deformation. The static deformation is usually expressed in the body-fixed frame with an appropriate choice of the principal axes [45]. The deformation parameters in this frame are related to those in the space-fixed one as [1],
where is the Wigner function and is the Euler angle between the two frames. For , the quadrupole deformation parameters in the body-fixed frame are usually parametrized as
Substituting Eq. (8) into Eq. (7), the deformation parameters in the space-fixed system read
For an axially-symmetric shape, only has a nonzero value in , and Eq. (7) is transformed to
We mention that the surface vibration can be described in the body-fixed frame using by transforming the Hamiltonian (3) via Eq. (7). However, the Hamiltonian is no longer separable in this case. On the other hand, the rotational symmetry ensures the separable structure of Eq. (3) in the space-fixed frame, that is an advantage to use the latter for spherical nuclei.
Initial geometry of RelHIC. Next, we investigate the effect of the surface vibration in RelHIC. For high collision energies, the time scale of heavy-ion reactions is significantly shorter than that of the vibrational degrees of freedom. This justifies the use of the adiabatic approximation, where are regarded as constants during the reaction. The transverse structure of the initial states of RelHIC is determined simply by the overlap of colliding nuclei, whose shapes are specified by distributed according to Eq. (5). This property is contrasted to the low-energy heavy-ion reactions, where vibrational degrees of freedom are not slow for most nuclei and the adiabatic approximation [46] is not adequate. In this case, one needs to solve the coupled-channels equations as they are [2, 3].
In Refs. [11, 15], it has been pointed out that the initial conditions for the ultra-central collisions are approximately given by the completely overlapped collisions. In the present study, for a simple illustration of the importance of the surface vibration in RelHIC, we follow Ref. [14] and assume that the transverse distribution of the energy density in the initial state is proportional to
where is the transverse vector with the -axis chosen along the beam direction.
In the following, we focus on the eccentricity parameters and the inverse mean-square area
respectively, of the initial conditions, in which means the average with respect to . It is well established that and are strongly correlated with the anisotropic flows and the mean transverse momentum , respectively, in the final state [47]. Using the correlations, the distribution of and in the initial states is encoded in the event-by-event distribution of and that are experimentally observable [15].
In the harmonic-oscillator model (3), the distributions of obey the Gaussian function , which are independent with one another. The expectation value of over collision events, for example, is thus evaluated as
where is the eccentricity parameter in Eq. (12) for a given set of . On the other hand, for the static deformation with axial symmetry, the expectation value is given by the integral over the Euler angle as [14]
where for a given is evaluated by substituting Eq. (10) into Eq. (2) in the space-fixed frame.
Distribution of . Let us now numerically evaluate the distribution of the eccentricity parameters for spherical nuclei with the surface vibration (SV) for and collisions, and compare them with those for a static deformation (SD). For this purpose, we generate randomly according to the probability distribution in Eq. (13) for SV, while for SD only is randomly sampled with fixed for the axial shape. Figure 1 shows the probability densities of the quadrupole eccentricity parameters for the collision
Figure 1. (a) Probability densities of the quadrupole eccentricity parameter for the collision. The red, blue, and green colors denote the results for the surface vibration (SV), static deformation (SD), and the surface vibration with axial (SV-A). (b) The same as (a), but for the octupole eccentricity for the collision (upper) and the octupole eccentricity parameters for the collision (lower) with 3000 random samples. To calculate the eccentricities, we use the deformed Woods-Saxon density (1) with fm and fm, where is the mass number of a nucleus. For the () collision, we take only the () components in with (). The results for SV are shown by the red color, while the SD results with the same static deformation parameters are shown by the blue color. From the figure one finds that the surface vibration leads to as large as the static deformation [41]. Moreover, SV and SD lead to completely different distributions of the eccentricity parameters for each collision system. The difference can be clarified in the mean, standard deviation, skewness, and kurtosis of these distributions [48] as shown in Table I. In particular, the skewness has opposite signs for SV and SD.
In treating the surface vibration, one sometimes uses a similar formula to Eq. (14) but takes account of the fluctuation of the axial deformation parameter, , only [41, 49], so that the expectation value of reads
| mean | std. dev. | skewness | kurtosis | ||
| Ni, | SV | 0.112(1) | 0.0554(7) | 0.49(3) | -0.02(11) |
| SD | 0.119(1) | 0.0500(5) | -0.79(3) | -0.62(6) | |
| SV-A | 0.090(1) | 0.0816(13) | 1.22(4) | 1.12(20) | |
| Pb, | SV | 0.0822(8) | 0.0416(5) | 0.55(4) | 0.15(11) |
| SD | 0.0821(8) | 0.0461(4) | -0.38(3) | -1.29(3) | |
| SV-A | 0.0650(12) | 0.0649(11) | 1.35(5) | 1.49(22) |
Table 1. The mean, the standard deviation, the skewness, and the kurtosis of the eccentricity parameter () of Ni+Ni (Pb+Pb) collision. See Ref. [48] for the definition of these quantities. The results for surface vibration (SV), static deformation (SD), and surface vibration with axial only (SV-A) in Eq. (15) are shown with the statistical errors.
This treatment would be equivalent to Eq. (13) if the fluctuations of the non-axial deformation parameters were also taken into account in an appropriate manner, even though the non-axial degrees of freedom are not usually taken into account. The probability densities in this treatment (SV-A) are shown by the green color in Figure 1. One can see that the results are qualitatively different from both SV and SD. The statistical quantities in Table I also highlight the difference.
The large values of found in the above results for SV imply that the surface vibration substantially affects the initial states of RelHIC, and its appropriate incorporation into the dynamical modeling of RelHIC is crucial [41]. The significant difference between SV, SD, and SV-A also suggests that they are distinguishable experimentally. In particular, the behaviors of the skewness and kurtosis indicate that the higher-order cumulants of the anisotropic flow are sensitive to it. In this connection, it would be interesting to investigate not only the mean value but also the distributions of the elliptic flow shown e.g. in Fig. 2 in Ref. [21].
– correlation
To gain further insights into the difference of the three cases, in Figure 2 we plot the distribution of the initial states for each case for Ni+Ni on the – plane3. The figure shows that the distributions are significantly different for the three cases. For SV (top panel), and have almost no correlation. In contrast, for the case of SD (middle panel), they are strongly correlated with each other. The treatment with SV-A (bottom panel) has a characteristic behavior different both from SV and SD.
Figure 2. The distributions of the quadrupole eccentricity parameters for the Ni+Ni collision with the deformation parameter of . These are plotted as a function of the inverse of the mean square area, . The top, the middle, and the bottom panel show the distributions of for the dynamical deformation, the static deformation, and the fluctuation of the axial deformation parameter, respectively, which correspond to the three lines in the upper panel of Figure 1.
The behaviors for SV and SD can be understood easily in the space-fixed frame as follows. Using the sharp-cut density in Eq. (1) and to the first order of , and are analytically calculated as [14]
Because and are independent in Eq. (3), one immediately finds from Eq. (16) that and are uncorrelated in SV within this approximation. On the other hand, for SD and have one-to-one correspondence through Eq. (10). These simple arguments are another advantage of the space-fixed frame.
From the strong correlation between and , as well as and , it is suggested from Figure 2 that SV, SD, and SV-A give significantly different consequences of the experimental results, especially in the correlations of and [15, 25, 50]. It is also interesting to observe the event-by-event distribution on the – plane experimentally besides the correlation functions, as it is clearly different among SV, SD, and SV-A.
Triaxiality. Finally, in connection with these results let us briefly discuss the fluctuation in the triaxial deformation [23]. The triaxial quadrupole deformation of a nucleus is usually parametrized by and in Eq. (8).4 In Ref. [23], the difference between the static and dynamical triaxial deformations has been investigated for collision, assuming the for the former case, while is randomly distributed in the latter.
Figure 3 shows the distributions of the initial states on the – plane obtained for with and the same parameter set for the density distribution as in Figure 2. The upper panel corresponds to the case of a rigid triaxial deformation with , while the lower panel shows the results with a flat distribution of between 0 and [23]. The mean values of are 0.0157 and 0.0151 for the upper and the lower panels, respectively. The upper panel also shows the eccentricity parameters for specific values of the Euler angles, that is, (the blue squares), (the green triangles), and (the purple diamonds), which provide the edges of the distribution.
Figure 3. Same as Figure 2, but for the triaxial deformation. The upper panel corresponds to a static triaxial deformation with , while the lower panel is obtained by assuming a flat distribution of in the range from 0 to . The value of is set to be . In the upper panel, the eccentricity parameters for specific Euler angles, , , and , are denoted by the blue squares, the green triangles, and the purple diamonds, respectively.
One can see that the distributions are considerably different between these two cases, suggesting that they can be distinguished experimentally, even though the mean value of the eccentricity parameter is similar to each other. This is in a similar situation as Figure 2. Whereas the higher-order correlations of and have been investigated in Ref. [23], we advocate the event-by-event distribution on the – plane for a clearer distinction between a static and a dynamical triaxial deformation.
Summary. We have discussed the effects of the quantum zero-point fluctuations of colliding nuclei on the initial states of relativistic heavy-ion collisions in the ultracentral region. In particular, we have investigated the role of surface vibration of spherical nuclei. To deal with the vibrational degrees of freedom, we have used a formalism based on the space-fixed frame, which is widely used in low-energy heavy-ion fusion reactions. This formalism treats all the deformation parameters equally for the same multipolarity, , in contrast to the formalism in the body-fixed frame where the axial and the non-axial deformation parameters are separately treated. Applying the formalism to the and collisions, we have shown that the surface vibrations lead to comparable eccentricities to those for static deformations. Moreover, we have shown that the dynamical and the static deformations lead to considerably different correlation plots in the two-dimensional plane of the eccentricity and the inverse of the mean square area, indicating that those two can be experimentally distinguished with such plots. We have also shown that this is the case for triaxial deformation, that is, the difference between a static triaxial deformation and a flat distribution in the -direction.
In this Letter, we have used a simple model based on the complete overlap of colliding nuclei [15] to calculate the eccentricity parameters of the initial states in Rel-HIC. Although we believe that this treatment is sufficient to reveal the qualitative importance of the surface vibration, more sophisticated analyses based on dynamical models [19, 23, 25, 26, 41] are necessary for a better reproduction of the real experiments such as imperfect correlations between the initial eccentricities and the anisotropic flow in the final state, and effects of the off-central collisions. These investigations are left for future study.
Acknowledgments. We thank Jiangyong Jia and Chun-jian Zhang for useful discussions during the workshop “Intersection of nuclear structure and high-energy nuclear collisions: 2025” held at Fudan University, Shanghai, China, May 12–22, 2025. This work was supported in part by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers JP23K03414 and JP24K07049.
References
References
- [1]P. Ring and P. Schuck, The Nuclear Many-Body Problem (Springer Verlag, New York, 1980).DOI
- [2]K. Hagino and N. Takigawa, Subbarrier fusion reactions and many-particle quantum tunneling, Prog. Theo. Phys. 128, 1061 (2012).DOI
- [3]K. Hagino, K. Ogata, and A. Moro, Coupled-channels calculations for nuclear reactions: From exotic nuclei to superheavy elements, Prog. in Part. and Nucl. Phys. 125, 103951 (2022).DOI
- [4]M. Dasgupta, D. J. Hinde, N. Rowley, and A. M. Stefanini, Measuring barriers to fusion, Ann. Rev. of Nucl. and Part. Sci. 48, 401 (1998).DOI
- [5]J. R. Leigh, M. Dasgupta, D. J. Hinde, J. C. Mein, C. R. Morton, R. C. Lemmon, J. P. Lestone, J. O. Newton, H. Timmers, J. X. Wei, and N. Rowley, Barrier distributions from the fusion of oxygen ions with 144,148,154Sm and 186W, Phys. Rev. C 52, 3151 (1995).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9970861
- [6]J. R. Leigh, N. Rowley, R. C. Lemmon, D. J. Hinde, J. O. Newton, J. X. Wei, J. C. Mein, C. R. Morton, S. Kuyucak, and A. T. Kruppa, Reconciling deformation parameters from fusion with those from coulomb excitation, Phys. Rev. C 47, R437 (1993).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9968521
- [7]J. X. Wei, J. R. Leigh, D. J. Hinde, J. O. Newton, R. C. Lemmon, S. Elfstrom, J. X. Chen, and N. Rowley, Experimental determination of the fusion-barrier distribution for the 154Sm+16O reaction, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 3368 (1991).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10044716
- [8]Y. Gupta, B. Nayak, U. Garg, K. Hagino, K. Howard, N. Sensharma, M. Şenyigit, W. Tan, P. O’Malley, M. Smith, R. Gandhi, T. Anderson, R. deBoer, B. Frentz, A. Gyurjinyan, O. Hall, M. Hall, J. Hu, E. Lamere, Q. Liu, A. Long, W. Lu, S. Lyons, K. Ostdiek, C. Seymour, M. Skulski, and B. Vande Kolk, Determination of hexadecapole (β4) deformation of the light-mass nucleus 24Mg using quasi-elastic scattering measurements, Phys. Lett. B 806, 135473 (2020).
- [9]Y. Gupta, V. Katariya, G. Prajapati, K. Hagino, D. Patel, V. Ranga, U. Garg, L. Danu, A. Pal, B. Joshi, S. Dubey, V. Desai, S. Panwar, N. Kumar, S. Mukhopadhyay, P. Singh, N. Sirswal, R. Sariyal, I. Mazumdar, and B. John, Precise determination of quadrupole and hexadecapole deformation parameters of the sd-shell nucleus, 28Si, Phys. Lett. B 845, 138120 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2303.12495
- [10]H. Timmers, J. Leigh, M. Dasgupta, D. Hinde, R. Lemmon, J. Mein, C. Morton, J. Newton, and N. Rowley, Probing fusion barrier distributions with quasi-elastic scattering, Nucl. Phys. A 584, 190 (1995).DOI
- [11]G. Giacalone, Observing the deformation of nuclei with relativistic nuclear collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 202301 (2020).DOI
- [12]G. Giacalone, J. Jia, and C. Zhang, Impact of nuclear deformation on relativistic heavy-ion collisions: Assessing consistency in nuclear physics across energy scales, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 242301 (2021).DOI
- [13]B. Bally, M. Bender, G. Giacalone, and V. Somà, Evidence of the triaxial structure of 129Xe at the large hadron collider, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 082301 (2022).DOI
- [14]J. Jia, Shape of atomic nuclei in heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 105, 014905 (2022).DOI
- [15]J. Jia, Probing triaxial deformation of atomic nuclei in high-energy heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 105, 044905 (2022).DOI
- [16]C. Zhang and J. Jia, Evidence of quadrupole and octupole deformations in 96Zr+96Zr and 96Ru+96Ru collisions at ultrarelativistic energies, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 022301 (2022).DOI
- [17]W. Ryssens, G. Giacalone, B. Schenke, and C. Shen, Evidence of hexadecapole deformation in uranium-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 212302 (2023).
- [18]J. Jia and C. Zhang, Scaling approach to nuclear structure in high-energy heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 107, L021901 (2023).DOI
- [19]H.-j. Xu, J. Zhao, and F. Wang, Hexadecapole deformation of 238U from relativistic heavy-ion collisions using a nonlinear response coefficient, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 262301 (2024).DOI
- [20]J. Jia, G. Giacalone, B. Bally, J. D. Brandenburg, U. Heinz, S. Huang, D. Lee, Y.-J. Lee, C. Loizides, W. Li, M. Luzum, G. Nijs, J. Noronha-Hostler, M. Ploskon, W. van der Schee, B. Schenke, C. Shen, V. Somà, A. Timmins, Z. Xu, and Y. Zhou, Imaging the initial condition of heavy-ion collisions and nuclear structure across the nuclide chart, Nuclear Science and Techniques 35, 220 (2024).DOI
- [21]M. I. Abdulhamid et al. (STAR Collaboration), Imaging shapes of atomic nuclei in high-energy nuclear collisions, Nature 635, 67 (2024).DOI
- [22]STAR-Collaboration, Imaging nuclear shape through anisotropic and radial flow in high-energy heavy-ion collisions (2025), arXiv:2506.17785 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [23]S. Zhao, H.-j. Xu, Y. Zhou, Y.-X. Liu, and H. Song, Exploring the nuclear-shape phase transition in ultrarelativistic 129Xe+129Xe collisions at the lhc, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 192301 (2024).DOI
- [24]Y. Wang, S. Zhao, B. Cao, H.-j. Xu, and H. Song, Exploring the compactness of α clusters in 16O nuclei with relativistic 16O+16O collisions, Phys. Rev. C 109, L051904 (2024).
- [25]C. Zhang, J. Jia, J. Chen, C. Shen, and L. Liu, Probing the octupole deformation of 238U in high-energy nuclear collisions (2025), arXiv:2504.15245 [nucl-th].
- [26]N. M. Fortier, S. Jeon, and C. Gale, Heavy-ion collisions as probes of nuclear structure, Phys. Rev. C 111, L011901 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2405.17526
- [27]Y. Li, X. Zhang, G. Giacalone, and J. Yao, Benchmarking nuclear matrix elements of 0νββ decay with high-energy nuclear collisions (2025), arXiv:2502.08027 [nucl-th].DOI
- [28]R.-X. Cao, S. Zhang, and Y.-G. Ma, Effects of the α-cluster structure and the intrinsic momentum component of nuclei on the longitudinal asymmetry in relativistic heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 108, 064906 (2023).DOI
- [29]G. Giacalone, B. Bally, G. Nijs, S. Shen, T. Duguet, J.- P. Febran, S. Elhatisari, M. Frosini, T. A. Lähde, D. Lee, B.-N. Lu, Y.-Z. Ma, U.-G. Meißner, J. Nornhoha-Hostler, C. Plumberg, T. R. Rodríguez, R. Roth, W. van der Schee, and V. Somà, Exploiting ²⁰Ne isotopes for precision characterizations of collectivity in small systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 012302 (2025).
- [30]L.-M. Liu, H.-C. Wang, S.-J. Li, C. Zhang, J. Xu, Z.-Z. Ren, J. Jia, and X.-G. Huang, Directly probing existence of α-cluster structure in ²⁰Ne by relativistic heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 111, L201901 (2025).DOI
- [31]J. Dobaczewski, A. Gade, K. Godbey, R. V. F. Janssens, and W. Nazarewicz, Extraction of ground-state nuclear deformations from ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions, Nuclear structure physics context (2025), arXiv:2507.05208 [nucl-th].DOI
- [32]A. B. Balantekin and N. Takigawa, Quantum tunneling in nuclear fusion, Rev. Mod. Phys. 70, 77 (1998).DOI
- [33]A. M. Stefanini, D. Ackermann, L. Corradi, D. R. Napoli, C. Petrache, P. Spolaore, P. Bednarczyk, H. Q. Zhang, S. Beghini, G. Montagoli, L. Mueller, F. Scarlassara, G. F. Segato, F. Soramel, and N. Rowley, Influence of complex surface vibrations on the fusion of ⁵⁸Ni + ⁶⁰Ni, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 864 (1995).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10058868
- [34]C. R. Morton, A. C. Berriman, M. Dasgupta, D. J. Hinde, J. O. Newton, K. Hagino, and I. J. Thompson, Coupled-channels analysis of the ¹⁶O+²⁰⁸Pb fusion barrier distribution, Phys. Rev. C 60, 044608 (1999).
- [35]H. Esbensen and S. Landowne, Higher-order coupling effects in low energy heavy-ion fusion reactions, Phys. Rev. C 35, 2090 (1987).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9954005
- [36]K. Aamodt et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Higher harmonic anisotropic flow measurements of charged particles in Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 032301 (2011).
- [37]G. Aad et al. (ATLAS Collaboration), Measurement of the azimuthal anisotropy for charged particle production in √sNN = 2.76 TeV lead-lead collisions with the atlas detector, Phys. Rev. C 86, 014907 (2012).
- [38]S. Chatrchyan et al. (CMS Collaboration), Measurement of higher-order harmonic azimuthal anisotropy in PbPb collisions at √sNN = 2.76 TeV, Phys. Rev. C 89, 044906 (2014).
- [39]S. Acharya et al. (ATLAS Collaboration), Energy dependence and fluctuations of anisotropic flow in Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN=5.02 and 2.76 TeV, Journal of High Energy Physics 2018, 103 (2018).
- [40]M. Aaboud et al. (ATLAS Collaboration), Fluctuations of anisotropic flow in Pb+Pb collisions at √sNN= 5.02 TeV with the atlas detector, Journal of High Energy Physics 2020, 51 (2020).
- [41]H. J. Xu, D. Xu, S. Zhao, W. Zhao, H. Song, and F. Wang, A “breathing” octupole ²⁰⁸Pb nucleus: resolving the elliptical-to-triangular azimuthal anisotropy puzzle in ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions (2025), arXiv:2504.19644 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/2504.19644
- [42]S. Raman, C. Nestor, and P. Tikkanen, Transition probability from the ground to the first-excited 2⁺ state of even-even nuclides, Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables 78, 1 (2001).
- [43]NNDC, Evaluated nuclear structure data file (ensdf) (2022).
- [44]J. M. Yao and K. Hagino, Anharmonicity of multi-octupole-phonon excitations in ²⁰⁸Pb: Analysis with multireference covariant density functional theory and subbarrier fusion of ¹⁶O+²⁰⁸Pb, Phys. Rev. C 94, 011303 (2016).
- [45]W. Greiner and J. A. Maruhn, Nuclear Models (Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1996).DOI
- [46]H. Esbensen, Fusion and zero-point motions, Nucl. Phys. A 352, 147 (1981).DOI
- [47]H. Niemi, G. S. Denicol, H. Holopainen, and P. Huovinen, Event-by-event distributions of azimuthal asymmetries in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 87, 054901 (2013), arXiv:1212.1008 [nucl-th].DOI
- [48]M. Asakawa and M. Kitazawa, Fluctuations of conserved charges in relativistic heavy ion collisions: An introduction, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 90, 299 (2016), arXiv:1512.05038 [nucl-th].DOI
- [49]V. Y. Denisov, Nuclear reactions in hot stellar matter and nuclear surface deformations, Phys. Rev. C 74, 055804 (2006).DOI
- [50]P. Bożek and W. Broniowski, Transverse-momentum fluctuations in relativistic heavy-ion collisions from event-by-event viscous hydrodynamics, Phys. Rev. C 85, 044910 (2012).DOI
- [51]I. Hamamoto, Xi zhen Zhang, and Hong-xing Xie, Parametrization of octupole deformation, Physics Letters B 257, 1 (1991).
- [52]S. G. Rohoziński, Parametrization of nonaxial deformations in rotational nuclei, Phys. Rev. C 56, 165 (1997).DOI
- [53]C. Wexler and G. G. Dussel, Parametrization of the octupole degrees of freedom, Phys. Rev. C 60, 014305 (1999).DOI
- [54]K. Yoshida and X. Xing, private communications.