Multiple high precision β-decay measurements are being carried out these days on various nuclei, in search of beyond the Standard Model signatures. These measurements necessitate accurate standard model theoretical predictions to be compared with. Motivated by the experimental surge, we present a formalism for such a calculation of β-decay observables, with controlled accuracy, based on a perturbative analysis of the theoretical observables related to the phenomena, including high order nuclear recoil and shape corrections. The accuracy of the corrections is analyzed by identifying a hierarchy of small parameters, related to the low momentum transfer characterizing β-decays. Furthermore, we show that the sub-percent uncertainties, targeted by on-going and planned experiments, entail an accuracy of the order of 10% for the solution of the nuclear many body problem, which is well within the reach of modern nuclear theory for light to medium mass nuclei.
Introduction
According to the Standard Model (SM), the weak interaction of quarks and weak probes has a V−A structure [1, 2], i.e., a polar-vector minus an axial-vector current, with the same magnitude but opposite signs. This has been experimentally tested in many ways, including by studying correlations in the directions of the outgoing leptons in nuclear β-decays [3, 4]. However, there are pieces of evidence showing that the SM is incomplete, even much below the Planck scale, e.g., the existence of the neutrino mass. Since the neutrino, as a low mass neutral lepton, interacts almost exclusively via the weak force, this might hint that the way we understand the weak interaction is incomplete.
These days, angular correlation and spectrum measurements in nuclear β-decays are carefully designed to probe for signatures of deviations of the weak interaction from the V−A symmetry dictated by the SM, originating in interactions with scalar, pseudo-scalar, or tensor symmetries, which are a-priori theoretically allowed in Lorentz invariant theories [5]. Such signature would be an indication for Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics. Dimensional analysis shows that the order of magnitude of such deviation is inversely proportional to the square of the new physics energy scale, e.g., a 1% deviation from the SM values of those experimental observables suggests new physics at the TeV-scale. Thus, such measurements can be viewed as low-energy counterparts for LHC measurements. New β-decay experiments are designed to have a per-mill level accuracy [6]. Such new efforts include, for example, studying the decays of 6He, 16N, and 17−23Ne isotopes at SARAF accelerator (Israel) [7, 8], 6He decay studies at the National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory (USA) [9, 10, 11], Laboratoire Physique Corpusculaire de CAEN (France) [6], the University of Washington CENPA (USA) by the He6-CRES Collaboration [12], and more (for an overview of on-going and planned experiments see [6, 13]). However, deviations from the simplistic textbook formulae are due to finite momentum transfer, radiative corrections, and nuclear structure effects (see e.g., [14, 15] and references therein). Pin-pointing these effects demands a detailed calculation of the nuclear dynamics of the weak decay. In this paper we present a general formalism, to calculate the nuclear matrix element of these observables, within the Standard Model, including e.g., recoil and (spectrum)-shape. The main advantage of the presented formalism is the possibility to assess a controlled theoretical accuracy, based on an identification of the parameters governing this accuracy.
This paper is structured as follows: We begin by identifying small parameters involved in the β-decay formalism (sec. II). Next, we introduce the β-decay multipole expansion, analyze its properties (sec. III), and employ it to formulate a general perturbative expansion of the observables, including high order corrections, for any β-decay transition (sec. IV). Following that, we demonstrate the corrections for allowed β-decays (sec. V), and for first forbidden decays (sec. VI). Finally, we discuss the expected order of magnitude of BSM signatures, then consider the accuracy required for SM calculations to detect BSM deviations in nuclear β-decay measurements (sec. VII), and summarize (sec. VIII).
Small parameters governing nuclear structure effects of β-decays of finite nuclei
The differential distribution of a β-electron of energy ϵ, momentum k and direction β=ϵk, and a neutrino ν of momentum ν, in a β∓-decay process, can be written as [16]:
Here (ϵ0,q)=(ϵ,k)+(ν,ν) is the momentum transfer in the process, i.e., the difference between the initial momentum and final momentum of the nuclear states. Ji is the total angular momentum of the decaying nucleus, and Zf is the charge of the nucleus after the decay. The deformation of the beta particle wave function, due to the long-range electromagnetic interaction with the nucleus, is taken into account at the leading order by the Fermi function F∓(Zf,ϵ) for a β∓-decay.
Corrections which do not originate purely in the weak matrix element, such as radiative corrections, finite mass and electrostatic finite size effects, and atomic and chemical effects, are represented in eq. (1) by Ccorr.. As these corrections are assumed known in the literature (see, e.g., [14]), we will not focus on them, but on those effects originating from the fact that the weak interaction of a probe with a finite nucleus is affected by the complex nuclear structure of the decaying and final nuclei. These are absorbed inside Θ(q,β⋅ν^). Current experimental efforts are divided into spectrum (shape) measurements or angular correlation measurements [6], both affected by the nuclear-structure. Our discussion will distinguish between these corrections.
In order to compare the experimental results to the theory, there is a need for a good understanding of the theoretical framework. As the momentum transfer q is limited in β-decays, usually, up to few tens MeV/c, typically up to 10 MeV/c, and small compared to other energy or momentum scales in the nuclear problem, this framework is simplified by an expansion in a set of small parameters. For example, ϵqr≡qR (for an endpoint of ≈2MeV, ϵqr≈0.01A31, where A is the mass number of the nucleus), with R the nucleus’s nuclear radius. In addition, the non-relativistic character of the nuclear problem introduces,
ϵNR≡mNPFermi≈0.2,
ϵrecoil≡mNq,(2)
where PFermi is the Fermi momentum, and mN is the nucleon mass. These are the non-relativistic expansion small parameter ϵNR, and the recoil correction ϵrecoil (e.g., for an endpoint of ≈2 MeV, ϵrecoil≈0.002), both related to the low energy assumption taken in the calculation of the currents.
A different source of deviation from the simplistic β-decay formulas arises from the Coulomb force between the β-particle and the nucleus, which deforms the wave function of the β-particle from a plane-wave [17]. This results in corrections dominated by ϵc≡αZf[18], where α≈1371 is the fine structure constant. Those can be divided, as described in [19], into two: corrections of the spectrum, reflected in the Fermi function and in additional spectrum corrections whose precise form depends upon the specific β-transition, and corrections to the recoil form factors. The latter can also be separated into two: corrections reminiscent of the spectrum corrections, and a correction of the electron energy, following the presence of the Coulomb potential.
The Fermi function is considered known and we will not discuss it here. The non-energy corrections to the form factors, are of ϵcϵqrϵrecoil order of magnitude [17], and therefore negligible at this stage. The remaining corrections are those that depend on the transition, and the correction of the electron energy.
The correction of the electron energy adds the Coulomb displacement energy to the maximal electron energy [20] appearing in the multipole operators (see appendix). This Coulomb displacement energy is usually taken by its approximation for a homogeneously charged sphere ΔEc≈56RαZf[20], but this is a very crude approximation, and for comparison with experimental measurements we suggest using the experimental value, that can be found in the literature for most nuclei (see, e.g., [21]).
The last type of Coulomb corrections is the spectrum corrections which are unique to each β-transition. Those are of the order of ϵc2 or ϵcϵqr[22]. While for particularly light nuclei these are negligible, for light-medium nuclei this is already a substantial contribution and there is a need for neat work summarizing them for the different transitions in a form useful for Ab initio calculations. As current experimental efforts focus on light nuclei, we postpone a more detailed discussion in these corrections to future work (see Refs. [20, 23], and Refs. [14, 24] for allowed transitions).
The nuclear model is a source of uncertainty, as it is a low energy effective model of QCD. It is generally solved in a few steps. First, a model is written to describe the Hamiltonian and currents representing the quantum process in the nuclear regime. There are several approaches to cope with this problem. A modern one is based on the effective field theory (EFT) approach. EFT expansion relies on scale separation in the low energy nuclear momentum-energy. As β-decays and nuclei are characterized by low-energies compared to QCD scales, they can be described effectively by an EFT which includes nucleons and pions, an EFT named chiral EFT. EFT is a systematic expansion of the Hamiltonian of the fundamental theory, order-by-order, in a small parameter ϵEFT=Q/Λb[6], where Λb is the breakdown scale of the EFT. In chiral EFT, there is more than just the nucleons and pions as effective degrees of freedom, it is combined with a specific approach to non-relativistically expand the nuclear theory, a specific cutoff regularization and more. We note that this procedure includes a systematic uncertainty, ϵEFTn, where n is the order of the EFT expansion. However, there is an additional systematic error in doing so, ϵmodel. Finally, the resulting equations are solved numerically, introducing a third source of uncertainty, the convergence error ϵconv. The combination of all these is denoted by ϵNM (NM is nuclear model). In recent years it has been shown that this procedure reaches ϵNM of a few percents [25].
In the following, we trace the scaling of different nuclear structure related corrections to the aforementioned dimensionless small parameters.
β-decay multipole expansion formalism
Assuming the Standard Model V−A coupling, the function Θ(q,β⋅ν^) depends on the nuclear wave functions, and is conveniently written using a multipole expansion [26],
where O^J is the reduced matrix element of a rank J spherical tensor operator O^J, between the initial- and final-nuclear state wave functions. We use a multipole operator decomposition of the nuclear current, viz. the Coulomb, longitudinal, electric, and magnetic operators, defined as:
References
[1]Steven Weinberg. V-a was the key. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 196(1):012002, 2009.
[2]Nathal Severijns, Marcus Beck, and Oscar Naviliat-Cuncic. Tests of the standard electroweak model in nuclear beta decay. Rev. Mod. Phys., 78:991–1040, Sep 2006.DOI
[3]C. S. Wu, E. Ambler, R. W. Hayward, D. D. Hoppes, and R. P. Hudson. Experimental test of parity conservation in beta decay. Phys. Rev., 105:1413–1415, Feb 1957.
[4]J. D. Jackson, S. B. Treiman, and H. W. Wyld. Possible tests of time reversal invariance in beta decay. Phys. Rev., 106:517–521, May 1957.DOI
[5]E. Greuling and M. L. Meeks. Electron-neutrino angular correlation. Phys. Rev., 82:531–537, May 1951.DOI
[6]Vincenzo Cirigliano, Alejandro Garcia, Doron Gazit, Oscar Naviliat-Cuncic, Guy Savard, and Albert Young. Precision beta decay as a probe of new physics. arXiv:1907.02164, 2019.
[7]Israel Mardor, Ofer Aviv, Marilena Avrigeanu, Dan Berkovits, Adi Dahan, Timo Dickel, Ilan Eliyahu, Moshe Gai, Inbal Gavish-Segev, Shlomi Halfon, Michael Hass, Tsviki Hirsh, Boaz Kaiser, Daniel Kijel, Arik Kreisel, Yonatan Mishnayov, Ish Mukul, Ben Ohayon, Michael Paul, Amichay Perry, Hitesh Rahangdale, Jacob Rodnitzki, Guy Ron, Revital Sasson-Zukran, Asher Shor, Ido Silverman, Moshe Tessler, Sergey Vaintraub, and Leo Weissman. The soreq applied research accelerator facility (saraf): Overview, research programs and future plans. Eur. Phys. J. A, 54(5):91, 2018.
[8]Ben Ohayon, Joel Cochran, Tsviki Hirsh, Ayala Glick-Magid, Yonatan Mishnayov, Ish Mukul, Hitesh Rahangdale, Sergei Vaintraub, Oded Heber, Doron Gazit, and Guy Ron. Weak interaction studies at saraf. Hyperfine Interactions, 239(1):57, Nov 2018.DOI
[9]X. Huyan, O. Naviliat-Cuncic, D. Bazin, A. Gade, M. Hughes, S. Liddick, K. Minamisono, S. Noji, S. V. Paulauskas, A. Simon, P. Voytas, and D. Weisshaar. Toward a measurement of weak magnetism in 6he decay. Hyperfine Interactions, 237(1):93, May 2016.DOI
[10]X. Huyan, O. Naviliat-Cuncic, P. Voytas, S. Chandavar, M. Hughes, K. Minamisono, and S.V. Paulauskas. Geant4 simulations of the absorption of photons in csi and nai produced by electrons with energies up to 4 mev and their application to precision measurements of the β-energy spectrum with a calorimetric technique. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 879:134 – 140, 2018.DOI
[11]O. Naviliat-Cuncic. Searches for exotic interactions in nuclear beta decay. AIP Conference Proceedings, 1753(1):060001, 2016.
[12]D. M. Asner, R. F. Bradley, L. de Viveiros, P. J. Doe, J. L. Fernandes, M. Fertl, E. C. Finn, J. A. Formaggio, D. Furse, A. M. Jones, J. N. Kofron, B. H. LaRoque, M. Leber, E. L. McBride, M. L. Miller, P. Mohanmurthy, B. Monreal, N. S. Oblath, R. G. H. Robertson, L. J. Rosenberg, G. Rybka, D. Rysewyk, M. G. Sternberg, J. R. Tedeschi, T. Thümmler, B. A. VanDevender, and N. L. Woods. Single-electron detection and spectroscopy via relativistic cyclotron radiation. Phys. Rev. Lett., 114:162501, Apr 2015.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25955048
[13]M. González-Alonso, O. Naviliat-Cuncic, and N. Severijns. New physics searches in nuclear and neutron beta decay. Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics, 104:165 – 223, 2019.
[14]Leendert Hayen, Nathal Severijns, Kazimierz Bodek, Dagmara Rozpedzik, and Xavier Mougeot. High precision analytical description of the allowed β spectrum shape. Rev. Mod. Phys., 90:015008, Mar 2018.DOI
[15]L. Hayen and N. Severijns. Beta spectrum generator: High precision allowed β spectrum shapes. Computer Physics Communications, 240:152 – 164, 2019.DOI
[16]T. D. Lee and C. N. Yang. Question of parity conservation in weak interactions. Phys. Rev., 104:254–258, Oct 1956.
[17]Lloyd Armstrong Jr and CW Kim. Coulomb correction in nuclear β decay: Elementary-particle treatment. Physical Review C, 5(3):672, 1972.DOI
[18]DH Wilkinson. The evaluation of finite nuclear size effects in allowed β-decay. Nuclear Physics A, 158(2):476–486, 1970.DOI
[19]Barry R Holstein. Electromagnetic effects and weak form factors. Physical Review C, 19(4):1467, 1979.DOI
[20]Heinrich Behrens and Wolfgang Bühring. Electron radial wave functions and nuclear betadecay. Number 67. Oxford University Press, USA, 1982.
[21]MS Antony, A Pape, and J Britz. Coulomb displacement energies between analog levels for 3 ≤ a ≥ 239. Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables, 66(1):1–63, 1997.DOI
[22]Barry R Holstein. Electromagnetic corrections to allowed nuclear beta decay. Physical Review C, 9(5):1742, 1974.DOI
[23]Heinrich Behrens, Joachim Jänecke, and H Schopper. Numerical tables for beta-decay and electron capture. Springer-Verlag Berlin, 1969.DOI
[24]Leendert Hayen and Albert R. Young. Consistent description of angular correlations in β decay for beyond standard model physics searches, 2020.arxiv.org/abs/2009.11364
[25]P. Gysbers, G. Hagen, J.D. Holt, G. R. Jansen, T. D. Morris, P. Navrátil, T. Papenbrock, S. Quaglioni, A. Schwenk, S. R. Stroberg, and K. A. Wendt. Discrepancy between experimental and theoretical beta-decay rates resolved from first principles. Nat. Phys., 15:428–431, 2019.DOI
[26]John Dirk Walecka. Theoretical Nuclear and Subnuclear Physics. World Scientific, Singapore, 2nd edition, 2004.
[27]Wick Haxton and Cecilia Lunardini. Sevenoperators, a mathematica script for harmonic oscillator nuclear matrix elements arising in semileptonic electroweak interactions. Computer Physics Communications, 179(5):345 – 358, 2008.DOI
[28]εrecoil and εqεR are about the same order of magnitude for an endpoint of ≈ 2MeV, and L̂V0 consists of these two forms of terms.
[29]Both multipoles, ĈA and M̂V, consist of these two forms of terms. ĈA has an additional smaller term, proportional to εmπ ≡ εq0/ mπ2.
[30]Ayala Glick-Magid, Yonatan Mishnay, Ish Mukul, Michael Hass, Sergey Vaintraub, Guy Ron, and Doron Gazit. Beta spectrum of unique first-forbidden decays as a novel test for fundamental symmetries. Physics Letters B, 767:285 – 288, 2017.
[31]For J^Δπ = 0− Fierz term and the angular correlation are in eq. (10) and above it, while for J^Δπ = 1− they are not well defined.
[32]Vincenzo Cirigliano, Susan Gardner, and Barry Holstein. Beta Decays and Non-Standard Interactions in the LHC Era. Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys., 71:93–118, 2013.DOI
[33]M. Ademollo and R. Gatto. Nonrenormalization theorem for the strangeness-violating vector currents. Phys. Rev. Lett., 13:264–266, Aug 1964.DOI
[34]John F. Donoghue and D. Wyler. Isospin breaking and the precise determination of vud. Physics Letters B, 241(2):243 – 248, 1990.DOI
[35]M. P. Mendenhall, R. W. Pattie, Y. Bagdasarova, D. B. Berguno, L. J. Broussard, R. Carr, S. Currie, X. Ding, B. W. Filippone, A. García, P. Geltenbort, K. P. Hickerson, J. Hoagland, A. T. Holley, R. Hong, T. M. Ito, A. Knecht, C.-Y. Liu, J. L. Liu, M. Makela, R. R. Mammei, J. W. Martin, D. Melconian, S. D. Moore, C. L. Morris, A. Pérez Galván, R. Picker, M. L. Pitt, B. Plaster, J. C. Ramsey, R. A. Saunders, S. J. Seestrom, E. I. Sharapov, W. E. Sondheim, E. Tatar, R. B. Vogelaaar, B. VornDick, C. Wrede, A. R. Young, and B. A. Zeck. Precision measurement of the neutron β-decay asymmetry. Phys. Rev. C, 87:032501, Mar 2013.DOI
[36]D. Mund, B. Märkisch, M. Deissenroth, J. Krempel, M. Schumann, H. Abele, A. Petoukhov, and T. Soldner. Determination of the weak axial vector coupling λ=g_A/g_V from a measurement of the β-asymmetry parameter a in neutron beta decay. Phys. Rev. Lett., 110:172502, Apr 2013.
[37]Tanmoy Bhattacharya, Vincenzo Cirigliano, Saul D. Cohen, Rajan Gupta, Huey-Wen Lin, and Boram Yoon. Axial, scalar, and tensor charges of the nucleon from 2 + 1 + 1-flavor lattice QCD. Phys. Rev. D, 94:054508, Sep 2016.DOI
[38]Ayala Glick-Magid, Christian Forssén, Daniel Gazda, Doron Gazit, Peter Gysbers, and Petr Navrátil. Nuclear ab initio calculations of 6He β-decay for beyond the standard model studies. arXiv:2107.10212, 2021.
[39]Yonatan Mishnayot, Ayala Glick-Magid, Hitesh R. Rahangdale, Guy Ron, Doron Gazit, Jason T. Harke, Ben Ohayon, Aaron Gallant, Nicholas D. Scielzo, Sergey Vaintraub, Tsviki Hirsch, Christian Forssén, Daniel Gazda, Peter Gysbers, Javier Menéndez, Petr Navrátil, Leonid Weissman, Arik Kreisel, Boaz Kaizer, Hodaya Dafna, and Maayan Buzaglo. Constraining new physics with a new measurement of the 23Ne branching ratio, 2021. in preparation.
[40]J. D. Walecka. Semileptonic Weak Interactions in Nuclei. In V. W. Hughes and C. S. Wu, editors, Muon Physics, Volume II: Weak Interactions, pages 113–218, 1975.DOI
Vinay Sharma, Sharadh Jois, Ryan Van Haren, Gregory M. Stephen, M. Tomal Hossain, M. Benjamin Jungfleisch, Patrick J. Taylor, Aubrey T. Hanbicki, Adam L. Friedman ·