betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Recent progress on electron- and magnon-mediated torques

Abstract

The growing demand for artificial intelligence and complex computing has underscored the urgent need for advanced data storage technologies. Spin-orbit torque (SOT) has emerged as a leading candidate for high-speed, high-density magnetic random-access memory due to its ultrafast switching speed and low power consumption. This review systematically explores the generation and switching mechanisms of electron-mediated torques (including both conventional SOTs and orbital torques) and magnon-mediated torques. We discuss key materials that enable these effects: heavy metals, topological insulators, low-crystal-symmetry materials, non-collinear antiferromagnets, and altermagnets for conventional SOTs; 3d, 4d, and 5d transition metals for orbital torques; and antiferromagnetic insulator NiO- and multiferroic BiFeO3-based sandwich structures for magnon torques. We emphasize that although key components of SOT devices have been demonstrated, numerous promising materials and critical questions regarding their underlying mechanisms remain to be explored. Therefore, this field represents a dynamic and rapidly evolving frontier in spintronics, offering significant potential for advancing next-generation information storage and computational technologies.

Introduction

The explosion of applications such as artificial intelligence and complex problem-solving has put forward higher requirements for data storage. Modern computer systems employ hierarchical data management, but the speed mismatch between slower storage units and the central processing unit creates a “storage wall”, limiting computational power upgrades. Magnetic random-access memory (MRAM) offers fast read/write speeds comparable to cache memory while maintaining non-volatility like external storage. This makes it a promising solution to the “storage wall” issue through a non-von Neumann in-memory computing architecture[1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. Therefore, MRAM with high-speed, low-power, and non-volatile writing capabilities has become a core objective in the development of future storage and integrated computing technologies. MRAM has undergone three generations of development. The first-generation MRAM, known as Toggle-MRAM, manipulates the magnetization of a ferromagnetic layer (FM) through a current-induced Oersted field. However, this approach results in significant thermal losses, limiting device miniaturization and chip integration. Moreover, its magnetic tunnel junction utilizes an FM with in-plane magnetic anisotropy (IMA), which leads to edge magnetization and vortex effects as device fabrication processes shrink, ultimately reducing reliability. The second-generation MRAM, based on spin-transfer torque (STT), represents a major advancement toward commercialization[6, 7, 8, 9]. Nevertheless, STT-MRAM faces several challenges, including non-separated read/write paths that can introduce read/write disturbances, tunneling currents that increase the risk of barrier breakdown, and incubation delays that limit switching speed[5, 10, 11, 12]. In contrast, third-generation spin-orbit torque (SOT)-MRAM leverages spin-orbit coupling (SOC) in a non-magnetic (NM) layer to convert charge currents into spin currents[13, 14, 15, 16]. These spin-polarized electrons accumulate at the FM/NM interface, exerting torques on the FM and inducing magnetization switching. SOT-MRAM offers distinct advantages, including separate read/write paths, reduced read currents to mitigate barrier degradation, and sub-nanosecond switching speeds[4, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22]. These attributes establish SOT-MRAM as a leading candidate for high-speed cache memory in the post-Moore era.

Copyright 2020 by American Physical Society. Copyright 2023 by Springer Nature. Copyright 2024 by Springer Nature.

Since the concept of SOT was demonstrated for manipulating FMs with IMA[29], the SOT-MRAM with in-plane MTJ has been demonstrated to be compatible with backend-of-line processes[30, 31]. The collinear relationship between the spin polarization and magnetization directions in SOT enables the field-free manipulation of FM with IMA. However, further miniaturization limits the scalability potential of in-plane SOT-MRAM. The significant breakthrough of SOT-driven switching of a perpendicular magnetization was achieved in Pt/Co systems[13, 32]. The spin current generated in the Pt layer exerts torques on the Co layer with PMA, enabling its magnetization switching with the assistance of an external magnetic field. The perpendicular switching of FM marks a milestone in the development of SOT-based memory and logic devices. Subsequently, systematic investigations into spin-source materials are conducted, initially focusing on heavy metals[13, 14, 23, 33] and topological insulators (TIs)[16, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41] due to their high charge-to-spin conversion efficiency. These materials are primarily explored to reduce the critical switching current density required for magnetization switching. However, researchers soon recognized that practical SOT device applications require not only low power consumption but also field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization[42]. This has led to remarkable interest in exploring symmetry-breaking device geometries with gradient electric field[43, 44], composition[45, 46, 47], or thickness[47, 48], and zz-spin generating materials[42], e.g., low-crystal-symmetry materials[27, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60], non-collinear antiferromagnets (NCAFMs)[61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74], altermagnets[73, 74, 75, 76, 77], and spin Hall metals[78].

Beyond spin, the orbital degree of freedom in electrons has also been utilized to manipulate FMs. Compared to spin angular momentum, orbital angular momentum exhibits a longer diffusion length and higher orbital Hall conductivity (OHC)[26, 79, 80, 81]. Moreover, strong orbital currents have been observed in cost-effective 3d and 4d light metals[26, 80, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87], enhancing the industrial compatibility of orbital torque (OT) devices. OT has emerged as a promising alternative to and potential advancement over conventional SOT, attracting significant research interest in spintronic applications. Additionally, magnon currents, as spin-wave excitations of magnetic moments, can convey spin angular momentum in insulating magnetic materials while exhibiting long spin diffusion lengths[88, 89, 90] and ultrafast transport speeds[91]. These unique properties make magnon torque (MT) a promising avenue for developing next-generation ultrafast and low-power magnetic storage devices. In this review, we systematically introduce the generation and switching mechanisms of conventional SOT, OT, and MT, followed by a discussion on recent material innovations and device advancements in these three fields, as summarized in Figure 1. Finally, we provide a comprehensive summary and offer an outlook on future developments in SOT-based spintronic devices.

Figure 1. Schematic overview of materials and device structures for conventional spin-orbit torques, orbital torques, and magnon torques. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28]. Copyright 2013 by Springer Nature. Copyright 2019 by American Association for the Advancement of Science.

Conventional spin-orbit torque

Spin Hall effect and Rashba-Edelstein effect

Spin current generation is primarily governed by two well-established mechanisms: the bulk spin Hall effect (SHE) and the interfacial Rashba-Edelstein effect (REE). The SHE occurs in an NM layer with strong SOC, where spin Berry curvature plays a crucial role. When an electric field is applied, the resulting charge current (JC\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{C}}) is converted into a transversely polarized spin current (JS\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{S}})[92, 93], leading to spin accumulation at the NM/FM interface. The direction of spin polarization (σ\boldsymbol{\sigma}) is orthogonal to both JC\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{C}} and JS\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{S}}, as illustrated in Figure 2(a). The charge-to-spin conversion process can be quantitatively described by the relation: JS=(ℏ/2e)θSH(JC×σ)\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{S}} = (\hbar/2e)\theta_{\mathrm{SH}}(\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{C}} \times\boldsymbol{\sigma}), where ℏ\hbar and ee are the reduced Planck constant and the elementary charge, respectively[10]. θSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} represents the spin Hall angle, a key parameter characterizing the efficiency of charge-to-spin conversion and serving as a crucial indicator of SOT performance. The power consumption (WW) required for magnetization switching via SOT is proportional to JC2/σjJ_{\mathrm{C}}^2/\sigma_{\mathrm{j}}, where σj\sigma_{\mathrm{j}} denotes the charge conductivity[11]. This relationship can be further expressed as: W∝1/(θSH⋅σj)=1/(θSH⋅σSH)W \propto1/(\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} \cdot\sigma_{\mathrm{j}}) = 1/(\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} \cdot\sigma_{\mathrm{SH}}), where σSH=θSH⋅σj\sigma_{\mathrm{SH}} = \theta_{\mathrm{SH}} \cdot\sigma_{\mathrm{j}} defines the spin Hall conductivity (SHC). To achieve low-power SOT device, the spin source material must exhibit both a high θSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} and a large σj\sigma_{\mathrm{j}}, thereby maximizing θSH⋅σSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} \cdot\sigma_{\mathrm{SH}}. In contrast, the REE arises from interfacial SOC in systems with broken inversion symmetry[94, 95]. When a perpendicular built-in electric field is present at the interface, electrons moving along the xx-axis experience an effective magnetic field along the yy-axis, leading to spin accumulation at the interface, as illustrated in Figure 2(b). This interfacial effect enables efficient spin generation and manipulation, complementing the bulk-dominated SHE mechanism.

Principal diagrams of the spin Hall effect, Rashba-Edelstein effect, and spin-orbit torque directions

Figure 2. The principal diagram of (a) spin Hall effect and (b) Rashba-Edelstein effect. (c) Direction of anti-damping torque (blue arrow) and field-like torque (red arrow). Green arrows indicate the magnetization direction of the ferromagnetic layer.

In NM/FM heterostructures, the coexistence of the SHE and the REE gives rise to ongoing debates regarding the precise origin of the generated spin current. However, it is widely recognized that SOT can exert two distinct torque components on the magnetization (M\mathbf{M}) by σ\boldsymbol{\sigma}[96, 97, 98], as shown in Figure 2(c). The anti-damping torque (τDL∼M×(σ×M)\boldsymbol{\tau}_{\mathrm{DL}} \sim\mathbf{M} \times(\boldsymbol{\sigma} \times\mathbf{M})) drives M\mathbf{M} toward alignment with σ\boldsymbol{\sigma}, facilitating magnetization switching. Meanwhile, the field-like torque (τFL∼(M×σ)\boldsymbol{\tau}_{\mathrm{FL}} \sim(\mathbf{M} \times\boldsymbol{\sigma})) induces magnetic moment precession around the direction of σ\boldsymbol{\sigma}. For an FM with perpendicular magnetic anisotropy (PMA), the SOT-induced torque tilts the magnetization towards the yy-direction. Upon removal of the current, thermal fluctuations cause the magnetization to stochastically switch to either the +z+z or −z-z direction in the absence of an external magnetic field. Achieving deterministic switching of perpendicular magnetization necessitates an additional in-plane magnetic field along the current direction to break mirror symmetry. However, this reliance on an external magnetic field poses a significant challenge for high-density device integration. To overcome this limitation, research efforts have not only focused on optimizing heavy metals and TIs to enhance the spin Hall angle but have also shifted toward eliminating the need for an external field and achieving field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization. Consequently, novel structural designs and material innovations, such as low-crystal-symmetry materials[27, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60], NCAFMs[61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72], and altermagnets[73, 74, 75, 76, 77], have been extensively explored. In the following sections, we review the progress in conventional SOT systems from the perspective of material development.

Heavy metals and topological insulators

Early investigations into spin source materials primarily focused on heavy metals and their alloys, such as Pt[13, 15, 23, 97, 108, 109], Ta[14, 23], W[99], Au0.25_{0.25}Pt0.75_{0.75}[100], Pd0.25_{0.25}Pt0.75_{0.75}[103], Pt1−x_{1-x}(MgO)x_x[105], Ptx_x(Si5_5N4_4)1−x_{1-x}[106], Cr1−x_{1-x}Ptx_x[107]. The strong SOC in these materials enables efficient charge-to-spin conversion, making them key candidates for SOT applications. Miron et al. attributed the current-induced perpendicular magnetization switching in Pt/Co heterostructures to REE mechanism[13]. However, Liu et al. later demonstrated that the spin current originates from the SHE in Pt[15], as illustrated in Figure 3(a). The positive spin Hall angle of Pt results in a clockwise SOT switching loop under a positive external magnetic field, as shown in Figure 3(b).

Spin-orbit torque based on heavy metals and topological insulators

Figure 3. Spin-orbit torque based on heavy metals and topological insulators. (a) Illustration of spin-orbit torque in a Co/Pt/AlOx_x heterostructure. (b) Current-induced magnetization switching in Pt/Co/AlOx_x heterostructures. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [15]. Copyright 2012 by American Physical Society. (c) Anti-damping torque efficiency as a function of thickness in heavy metal/Co/AlOx_x layers, where heavy metals are Pt, Pd, Ta, and W. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [98]. Copyright 2019 by American Physical Society. (d) Schematic of the Fermi level positions for different Sb ratios (x=0,0.93,1x = 0, 0.93, 1) of (Bi1−x_{1-x}Sbx_x)2_2Te3_3. (e) Switching current density (JCJ_\mathrm{C}) and spin-orbit torque-induced effective field (χSOT\chi_\mathrm{SOT}) as a function of Sb ratios (xx) in (Bi1−x_{1-x}Sbx_x)2_2Te3_3. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [38]. Copyright 2022 by American Physical Society. (f) The charge conductivity (σj\sigma_j) and spin Hall angle (θSH\theta_\mathrm{SH}) for various materials[14, 16, 37, 97, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107].

Subsequent studies have explored the fundamental origins of spin currents in various heavy-metal-based systems[98], as summarized in Figure 3(c). The prevailing consensus is that in most heavy metals, SOT is primarily governed by the SHE. However, the presence and contribution of the REE remain dependent on specific interface conditions[10]. Even within the same material system, variations in fabrication techniques across different research groups can lead to substantial differences in interfacial properties, which in turn significantly influence the magnitude and role of the REE.

In the pursuit of higher charge-spin conversion efficiency, TIs have emerged as highly promising materials due to their spin-momentum-locked topological surface states (TSSs)[16, 39, 110, 111]. When a charge current flows through the TSS, the resulting spin polarization is inherently locked perpendicular to the momentum direction. This unique property enables TIs to achieve exceptionally high charge-spin conversion efficiencies, even exceeding 1[16, 37, 104]. As a result, the critical switching current density (JCJ_{\mathrm{C}}) required for perpendicular magnetization switching is remarkably reduced to ∼105\sim10^{5}–10610^{6} A⋅\cdotcm−2^{-2}[37, 38, 40, 41, 104, 112, 113, 114], which is one to two orders of magnitude lower than that in heavy metal-based systems[13, 15]. The initial experimental demonstration of SOT based on TIs was reported in (Bi0.5_{0.5}Sb0.5_{0.5})2_2Te3_3/(Cr0.08_{0.08}Bi0.54_{0.54}Sb0.38_{0.38})2_2Te3_3 bilayers[34] and Bi2_2Se3_3/Ni81_{81}Fe19_{19} (permalloy, Py) heterostructures[16], respectively. Since then, extensive research has been conducted on TI-based SOT systems such as Bi2_2Se3_3[35, 36, 112, 115, 116], Bi2_2Te3_3[40], Bix_xSb1−x_{1-x}[37, 104], and (BiSb)2_2Te3_3[38, 41, 112, 113, 114, 117, 118, 119]. A key advantage of TI-based SOTs is the tunability of SOT efficiency through modulation of the Fermi level EFE_{\mathrm{F}}[38, 117, 120]. Wu et al. demonstrated that by tuning the Sb composition xx in (Bi1−x_{1-x}Sbx_x)2_2Te3_3, EFE_{\mathrm{F}} can be shifted from the bulk conduction band (x=0x = 0) to the topological surface band (x=0.93x = 0.93), and further into the bulk valence band (x=1.0x = 1.0)[38], as illustrated in Figure 3(d). Notably, the SOT efficiency reaches its peak near the Dirac point (x=0.93x = 0.93), where bulk conduction is minimized while surface-state conductivity is maximized, as shown in Figure 3(e). Beyond doping[34, 36, 38, 41, 114, 119, 120], TSSs and their associated SOT efficiencies can be modulated through various approaches, including thickness control[36], electric field application[117], interface engineering[115], ultrafast optical pumping[121], and strain engineering[122]. These methods provide additional avenues to tailor spin polarization and optimize SOT performance, further advancing the potential of TIs for next-generation spintronic applications.

For the realization of low-power SOT devices, an ideal spin source material should not only exhibit a high θSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} but also possess high σJ\sigma_{\mathrm{J}}. If the spin source material has low σJ\sigma_{\mathrm{J}}, a significant portion of the current will pass through the adjacent FM, leading to excessive power dissipation and reduced device efficiency. Figure 3(f) illustrates the inherent trade-off between θSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} and σJ\sigma_{\mathrm{J}} across various materials. For instance, Pt offers the highest σJ\sigma_{\mathrm{J}} but suffers from a relatively low θSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}}[97], whereas TIs exhibit a large θSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} but are constrained by poor σJ\sigma_{\mathrm{J}}[16, 37, 104]. Addressing this trade-off remains a critical challenge in the development of high-efficiency SOT devices. Moreover, most conventional spin source materials exhibit high crystal symmetry, which allows for the generation of only yy-polarized spin currents, necessitating an external magnetic field along the current direction to achieve deterministic switching of perpendicular magnetization. To eliminate the requirement for assistive magnetic fields, researchers have explored various approaches to break system symmetry, including structural asymmetry[48, 123], gradient electric field[43, 44], exchange interaction engineering[124] [125], magnetization tilting[126, 127, 128, 129], and hybrid manipulation techniques[43, 130]. Besides, the interlayer Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction usually realized in Pt/Co stacks[131, 132] provides a field-free switching strategy that is compatible with perpendicular SOT-MRAM. While these methods can enable field-free magnetization switching, they introduce additional complexities in device design and may lead to extrinsic effects. A promising alternative is leveraging materials with inherently low symmetry to generate zz-polarized spin currents, thereby breaking system symmetry[42].

Low-crystal-symmetry materials

Breaking lateral symmetry at the film surface has emerged as a common strategy for generating zz-spins. This approach requires the absence of any nn-fold (n>1n > 1) rotational symmetry about the surface normal (zz-axis) while allowing at most a single mirror plane to be preserved in the lattice structure. Such symmetry breaking can be achieved in specific crystallographic planes of low-crystal-symmetry materials. The first reported low-crystal-symmetry material capable of generating zz-spins is the Weyl semimetal TdT_d-phase WTe2_2[49], whose crystal structure is depicted in Figure 4(a). WTe2_2 belongs to the Pmn21Pmn2_1 space group, where glide symmetry is broken along the low-symmetry aa-axis, while mirror symmetry along the bb-axis is preserved. When a charge current is applied along the aa-axis, both yy- and zz-polarized spin currents are generated. These spin currents give rise to in-plane (τy\tau_y) and out-of-plane (τz\tau_z) anti-damping torques, as well as field-like torques on the adjacent FM[27], as illustrated in Figure 4(b). The first experimental demonstration of the out-of-plane anti-damping torque in WTe2_2/Py bilayers is reported by MacNeill et al. using spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance (ST-FMR) measurements[49, 137]. The mixed voltage signal (VmixV_{\mathrm{mix}}) obtained from ST-FMR can be decomposed into symmetric (VSV_S) and antisymmetric (VAV_A) components, which correspond to the in-plane (τ∥\tau_{\parallel}) and out-of-plane (τ⊥\tau_{\perp}) torques, respectively. Figure 4(c) presents the angular (ϕ\phi) dependence of VSV_S and VAV_A[49]. When the current is applied along the aa-axis, the curves can be fitted using VS=Asin⁡2ϕcos⁡ϕV_S=A\sin2\phi\cos\phi and VA=Bsin⁡2ϕcos⁡ϕ+Csin⁡2ϕV_A=B\sin2\phi\cos\phi+C\sin2\phi, confirming the presence of an out-of-plane anti-damping torque and the corresponding generation of zz-spins. In contrast, when the current flows along the bb-axis, the fitting follows VA=Bsin⁡2ϕcos⁡ϕV_A=B\sin2\phi\cos\phi, which is consistent with the absence of an out-of-plane anti-damping torque. The ability to generate zz-spins has enabled field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization in various WTe2_2/FM heterostructures. Experimental demonstrations have been reported across a diverse range of FMs, including two-dimensional (2D) magnets[56, 59, 138, 139], perovskite oxides[140], and metallic multilayers[141, 142].

Figure 4. Spin-orbit torque based on low-crystal-symmetry materials. (a) Crystal structure of Td\mathrm{T_d}-WTe2\mathrm{WTe_2} (Pmn21Pmn2_1), where MxM_x and MyM_y represent the pure mirror and glide mirror plane, respectively. (b) Schematic of the spin-orbit torque device in a heavy metal/ferromagnet bilayer, where the in-plane charge current can generate both yy- and zz-polarized spins. The zz-polarized spins exert an out-of-plane anti-damping torque, which enables field-free magnetization switching of the ferromagnetic layer. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [27]. Copyright 2024 by Springer Nature. (c) Schematic of WTe2\mathrm{WTe_2}/Py bilayers and the angular dependence of spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance signals. φ\varphi is the angle between the current direction and the external magnetic field. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [49]. Copyright 2016 by Springer Nature. (d) The dd dependence of in-plane and out-of-plane spin Hall conductivity (σs,y\sigma_{s,y} and σs,z\sigma_{s,z}) in PtTe2\mathrm{PtTe_2} (dd)/WTe2\mathrm{WTe_2} (8−d8-d)/Py heterostructures. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [27]. Copyright 2024 by Springer Nature. (e) Spin-to-spin conversion from an in-plane polarized spin Hall current generated in PtTe2\mathrm{PtTe_2} layer to an out-of-plane polarized spin current in WTe2\mathrm{WTe_2} layer. (f) aa-cc plane of the β\beta-MoTe2\mathrm{MoTe_2} crystal structure, where the mirror plane is within the page and the Mo chains run into the page. (g) The in-plane and out-of-plane spin Hall conductivity for various materials[16, 27, 49, 50, 52, 53, 54, 57, 58, 64, 74, 97, 133, 134, 135, 136].

Despite its ability to generate zz-spins, WTe2_2 suffers from a critical drawback: low yy-SHC (σs,y=8×103 (ℏ/2e) (Ω⋅m)−1\sigma_{s,y}=8\times10^3\,(\hbar/2e)\,(\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})^{-1}), which leads to huge current shunting through the FM, thereby increasing device power consumption. To address this limitation, Wang et al. fabricated a PtTe2_2/WTe2_2 heterostructure, leveraging the high SHC of PtTe2_2[27]. Their study demonstrates that the incorporation of PtTe2_2 not only enhances the yy-SHC (σs,y=2.32×105 (ℏ/2e) (Ω⋅m)−1\sigma_{s,y}=2.32\times10^5\,(\hbar/2e)\,(\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})^{-1}), but also significantly improves the zz-SHC (σs,z=0.25×105 (ℏ/2e) (Ω⋅m)−1\sigma_{s,z}=0.25\times10^5\,(\hbar/2e)\,(\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})^{-1}), as shown in Figure 4(d). This enhancement in zz-SHC is attributed to the spin-to-spin conversion (Figure 4(e)), wherein yy-spins generated in PtTe2_2 are converted into zz-spins in WTe2_2. When used for perpendicular magnetization switching, the PtTe2_2/WTe2_2 heterostructure exhibits a 33-fold reduction in power consumption compared to WTe2_2 alone[27].

The 1T′T'-MoTe2_2 monolayer is isostructural to the WTe2_2 monolayer but retains the inversion symmetry in bulk crystal and breaks the lateral symmetry at the surface (Figure 4(f))[53, 143]. In MoTe2_2/Py, the zz-spins are detected when MoTe2_2 is in the monolayer and trilayer forms, but diminish to zero in the bilayers form, which demonstrates that the breaking of lateral surface symmetry rather than bulk inversion symmetry, is the necessary condition for producing zz-spins[53]. The ternary Weyl semimetal TaIrTe4_4 has a crystal structure similar to that of WTe2_2, where Ta and Ir orderly replace W, thereby preserving its intrinsically low crystal symmetry. However, it exhibits a higher SHC due to its band structure and Fermi surface. Experiments have demonstrated that TaIrTe4_4 can provide σs,y\sigma_{s,y} of 5.437×1055.437 \times10^{5} (ℏ/2e)(\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m)−1(\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})^{-1} and σs,z\sigma_{s,z} of 2.065×1042.065 \times10^{4} (ℏ/2e)(\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m)−1(\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})^{-1}[57, 58, 60], which are one order of magnitude higher than those of WTe2_2 and MoTe2_2. The zz-spins have also been experimentally observed in non-2D materials, including MnPd3_3[133], IrO2_2[134, 144], and CaRuO3_3[135] (Figure 4(g)), where epitaxial strain engineering is utilized to induce specific lattice orientations that break lateral symmetry. This structural design facilitates the generation of zz-polarized spin currents, further expanding the material landscape for field-free switching applications.

Non-collinear antiferromagnets

In addition to low-crystal-symmetry materials, low-magnetic-symmetry materials can also generate zz-spins, enabling field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization. These materials include NCAFMs[64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 145] and altermagnets[76, 77] (discussed in § 2.5). Unlike conventional antiferromagnets (AFMs), low-magnetic-symmetry materials break P^T^\hat{P}\hat{T} and T^t^\hat{T}\hat{t} symmetries, where P^\hat{P} and T^\hat{T} denote space inversion and time reversal, respectively, and t^\hat{t} indicates a half-unit-cell translation[146]. Consequently, their band structures exhibit spin splitting, allowing for the generation of spin currents along specific crystallographic directions, even in the absence of strong SOC. Moreover, NCAFMs and altermagnets combine the advantages of both FMs and AFMs, offering efficient spin current generation and detection, non-volatility, negligible stray fields, and ultrafast spin dynamics, while overcoming the disadvantages of these conventional systems[72, 147, 148]. As a result, NCAFMs and altermagnets have garnered significant interest for their potential applications in next-generation memory and computing technologies.

In spintronics, research on NCAFMs has predominantly focused on Mn-based compounds, where Mn atoms form a distinctive kagome lattice (Figure 5(a)). In these materials, the magnetic moments of Mn atoms are oriented at 120° relative to one another, giving rise to a triangular chiral spin texture[72]. The Mn triangles are interconnected by non-magnetic atoms, typically transition or post-transition metal elements. A key feature of NCAFMs is their kagome spin texture, which breaks time-reversal symmetry and lifts the spin degeneracy of the Fermi surface, leading to the emergence of the anomalous Hall effect (AHE)[149] and the magnetic spin Hall effect (MSHE)[62, 67, 69, 150, 151]. Unlike the conventional SHE, the spin polarization generated by the MSHE is not necessarily perpendicular to both the charge current and spin current directions. Additionally, the spin polarization is highly dependent on the magnetic domain state of NCAFMs[62], allowing for active control over both the magnitude and direction of spin currents. A significant experimental breakthrough in this field is achieved by Yoshichika Otani’s group[62], demonstrating a sign reversal in the hysteretic resistance upon switching a pre-aligned magnetic field in Mn3Sn\mathrm{Mn_3Sn}/NiFe heterostructures, as shown in Figure 5(b). This provides direct evidence that the MSHE in Mn3Sn\mathrm{Mn_3Sn} exhibits odd symmetry under time-reversal operations. The same research group subsequently provides further direct observations of zz-spin generation via the MSHE, revealing that zz-spins in Mn3Sn\mathrm{Mn_3Sn} exert a magnetic spin Hall torque on an adjacent FM[151]. Moreover, they demonstrate that the magnitude of this torque can be tuned by adjusting the orientation of the magnetic octupoles. Following these pioneering studies, MSHE has also been observed in other Mn-based material systems[64, 66, 69, 70, 71, 152, 153], further expanding its potential applications in spintronic devices.

Current-driven magnetization switching based on non-collinear antiferromagnets

Figure 5. The current-driven magnetization switching based on non-collinear antiferromagnets. (a) Kagome arrangements of Mn-based compounds, leading to a triangular magnetic order. (b) Spin accumulation at the Mn3_3Sn-NiFe interface: magnetic-field dependence of resistance measured between the NiFe and Cu electrodes on the surface of Mn3_3Sn single crystal. The results are obtained after saturation of Mn3_3Sn with a magnetic field (BB) of −0.75-0.75 T (blue) and +0.75+0.75 T (red), respectively. Insets show the corresponding spin structures. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [62]. Copyright 2019 by Springer Nature. (c) The schematic of Mn3_3Sn/Cu/ferromagnet structure. (d) Current-induced perpendicular magnetization switching in the absence of magnetic field. (e) The switching polarity and switching ratio under different magnetic fields. The insets illustrate two opposite Mn3_3Sn domains to generate out-of-plane spin currents, resulting in the clockwise and anticlockwise switching polarities. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [67]. Copyright 2022 by Springer Nature.

Field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization has been experimentally demonstrated in various NCAFMs-based systems, including Mn3Sn\mathrm{Mn_3Sn}[67, 68], Mn3Pt\mathrm{Mn_3Pt}[69], Mn3Ga\mathrm{Mn_3Ga}[70], Mn3Ir\mathrm{Mn_3Ir}[71], and Mn3SnN\mathrm{Mn_3SnN}[66]. Hu et al. fabricated Mn3Sn\mathrm{Mn_3Sn}/Cu/Co/Ni heterostructures (Figure 5(c)) and successfully achieved field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization (Figure 5(d))[67]. The switching ratio, defined as the change in transverse resistance during switching divided by the anomalous Hall resistance, is found to be approximately 60%. Notably, both the switching ratio and polarity of the FM could be actively modulated by reorienting the magnetic domains of Mn3Sn\mathrm{Mn_3Sn} (Figure 5(e))[67]. This discovery underscores the critical role of domain control in tailoring spin-torque effects in NCAFMs. Following this work, domain-controlled perpendicular magnetization switching has been observed in other heterostructures where NCAFMs serve as the spin source[66, 69, 70, 71].

Altermagnets

Altermagnets represent a distinct class of magnetic materials, positioned alongside FMs and AFMs[147, 148, 154] (Figure 6(a)-Figure 6(c)). Unlike conventional FMs, which exhibit nonzero net magnetization and spin-split electronic bands, and AFMs, which feature zero net magnetization and spin-degenerate electronic bands, altermagnets possess a unique combination of both characteristics. Specifically, altermagnets maintain zero net magnetization while exhibiting spin-split electronic bands, which endow them with several advantageous properties: zero stray fields, ultrafast spin dynamics, and spin current generation[147, 148, 155]. The origin of these properties lies in the unique magnetic symmetry of altermagnets, where opposite-spin sublattices are interconnected through crystal-rotation symmetries (proper or improper, symmorphic or non-symmorphic) rather than through translation or inversion symmetries, as seen in conventional AFMs. A growing number of materials have been experimentally identified as altermagnets, including RuO2\mathrm{RuO}_{2}[156, 157], MnTe\mathrm{MnTe}[158, 159, 160, 161, 162], CrSb\mathrm{CrSb}[163, 164, 165, 166, 167, 168], Mn5Si3\mathrm{Mn}_{5}\mathrm{Si}_{3}[169], KV2Se2O\mathrm{KV}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{2}\mathrm{O}[170], and RbV2Te2O\mathrm{RbV}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{2}\mathrm{O}[171]. However, it is important to note that while MnTe2\mathrm{MnTe}_{2} exhibits spin-split electronic bands[172], it does not strictly belong to the altermagnet family due to its noncoplanar antiferromagnetic ordering. RuO2RuO_2 is a dd-wave altermagnet characterized by two spin-degenerate nodal surfaces. It is currently the only known altermagnet capable of generating spin currents through the spin-split effect (SSE). It crystallizes in a tetragonal structure belonging to the P42/mnmP4_2/mnm space group. However, due to the inequivalent local crystal environments of its two opposite spin sublattices, RuO2RuO_2 exhibits momentum-space spin-split electronic bands, making it an efficient spin current generator[75]. The spin polarization direction of the spin current generated in RuO2RuO_2 is aligned with its Néel vector along the [1] axis[73, 74, 75]. As a result, the spin current direction can be precisely controlled by tuning the crystal orientation of RuO2RuO_2. For instance, in (100)-oriented RuO2RuO_2 films, a charge current induces an additional time-reversal-odd spin current through the SSE[73]. However, in (110)-oriented RuO2RuO_2 films, a charge current generates only yy-polarized spin currents via the SHE[73]. This configuration reduces the charge-to-spin conversion efficiency compared to (100)-oriented RuO2RuO_2 films, as the contribution from the SSE is absent (Figure 6(d)).

Schematic diagrams of spin configurations and electronic bands, spin torque conductivity, multilayer structure, and magnetization switching

Figure 6. The spin-split effect and field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization based on altermagnets. Schematic diagrams of spin configurations and electronic bands of (a) collinear ferromagnet, (b) antiferromagnet, and (c) altermagnet. (d) The calculated spin torque conductivity (σSHeff\sigma_{\mathrm{SH}}^{\mathrm{eff}}) at different microwave frequencies. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [73]. Copyright 2022, The Authors, Published by American Physical Society. (e) Schematic illustration of RuO2(101)/Ru/Co/Pt\mathrm{RuO}_{2}(101)/\mathrm{Ru}/\mathrm{Co}/\mathrm{Pt} multilayer. ϕC\phi_{\mathrm{C}} represents the angle between the direction of charge current and the [10ˉ1][1\bar{0}1] direction of RuO2\mathrm{RuO}_{2}. (f) Current-induced perpendicular magnetization switching under ϕC=90∘\phi_{\mathrm{C}} = 90^\circ. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [76]. Copyright 2022 by American Physical Society.

To generate zz-spins via the SSE in RuO2RuO_2, the Néel vector of RuO2RuO_2 must deviate from, but not be perpendicular to, the film surface. Bose et al. experimentally demonstrated zz-polarized spin current generation by fabricating a (101)-oriented RuO2RuO_2 film[74]. When a current was applied along the [10] axis, they observed a tilted spin current forming an angle of approximately 35º relative to the out-of-plane direction[74]. Karube et al. then designed a RuO2RuO_2 (101)/Ru/Co/Pt multilayer structure, where the Co layer exhibits PMA[76]. By applying a current along the [10] axis, they successfully generated a tilted spin current (including xx-, yy-, and zz-spins), enabling field-free switching of the Co layer[76] (Figs. 6(e) and 6(f)). The field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization based on RuO2RuO_2 has been demonstrated by several independent groups[173-176].

Orbital torque

Mechanism of orbital torque

Electrons possess not only spin angular momentum but also orbital angular momentum. Over the past few decades, orbital angular momentum has been conventionally assumed to be quenched by the crystal field effect. However, recent theoretical and experimental studies have demonstrated that even in the absence of SOC, electrons can acquire orbital angular momentum under an external electric field[81, 177- 181]. These discoveries give rise to orbitronics, an emerging research field that explores the utilization of orbital angular momentum for the manipulation of magnetic states[81]. Analogous to the SHE, the application of an external electric field EE induces an orbital current JLJ_{\mathrm{L}} in a direction perpendicular to EE, a phenomenon known as the orbital Hall effect (OHE)[177-179]. In addition to the OHE, the orbital Rashba-Edelstein effect (OREE) can generate orbital currents at the interface of NM/FM heterostructures, similar to the conventional REE[182-184]. Unlike spin angular momentum, orbital angular momentum does not directly exchange-couple with magnetic moments. Consequently, within an FM layer, the JLJ_{\mathrm{L}} is first converted into a spin current JSJ_{\mathrm{S}} via SOC (Figure 7(a)), which subsequently exerts OTs on the magnetization[79, 82] [185, 186, 187]. In NM/FM heterostructures, OT and conventional SOT coexist, but their contributions can differ in magnitude and sign. Specifically, when the NM exhibits negative spin-orbit correlation (RNM<0R_{\mathrm{NM}}<0), as in Ta[79], W[80], Zr[87] [188], V[83] [189], Cr[82], and Mn[190], the JSJ_{\mathrm{S}} generated in the NM is opposite to the JLJ_{\mathrm{L}}. If the L-S conversion coefficient (ηL−S\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}) of the FM (or the orbital-spin conversion layer) is positive, as in Pt[82], Co[82, 84] [191], CoFe[79], and Ni[79, 82], the JSJ_{\mathrm{S}} converted from the JLJ_{\mathrm{L}} is opposite to the JSJ_{\mathrm{S}} from the SHE or REE. Conversely, if RNM>0R_{\mathrm{NM}}>0 (e.g., Ru[85], Pt[192]) with ηL−S>0\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}>0, or RNM<0R_{\mathrm{NM}}<0 with ηL−S<0\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}<0 (e.g., Ta[179], W[179], and Gd[82]), the JSJ_{\mathrm{S}} converted from the JLJ_{\mathrm{L}} has the same sign as the JSJ_{\mathrm{S}} from the SHE or REE. As a result, the net torque is determined by the interplay between OT and SOT, which can be expressed as: ξSOT,total=ξOT+ξSOT\xi_{\mathrm{SOT,total}}=\xi_{\mathrm{OT}}+\xi_{\mathrm{SOT}}, where ξSOT\xi_{\mathrm{SOT}} is primarily dependent on the θSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} of the NM, whereas OT efficiency (ξOT\xi_{\mathrm{OT}}) depends on both the orbital Hall angles (θOH\theta_{\mathrm{OH}}) of NM and ηL−S\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}} in the FM. The effective θOH\theta_{\mathrm{OH}} is defined as: θOHeff=θOH⋅ηL−S=(2e/ℏ)σOHEηL−S/σj\theta_{\mathrm{OH}}^{\mathrm{eff}}=\theta_{\mathrm{OH}}\cdot\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}=(2e/\hbar)\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}}\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}/\sigma_j, where σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}} denotes the OHC. Therefore, selecting NM materials with high σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}} and FM layers with a high ηL−S\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}} are essential for maximizing θOHeff\theta_{\mathrm{OH}}^{\mathrm{eff}}. To enhance the θOHeff\theta_{\mathrm{OH}}^{\mathrm{eff}}, an insert layer (e.g. Pt, Gd, Tb, etc.) with strong SOC has been proposed to efficiently convert the JLJ_{\mathrm{L}} into the JSJ_{\mathrm{S}} with high ηL−S\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}} (Figure 7(b))[25, 82, 84], and more details will be discussed later. Moreover, the orbital diffusion length (λOH\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}}) can be obtained from the equation[81]: ξDL=θOHEeff(1−sech⁡(tOTλOH))+ξ0\xi_{\mathrm{DL}}=\theta_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{eff}}\left(1-\operatorname{sech}\left(\frac{t_{\mathrm{OT}}}{\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}}}\right)\right)+\xi_0, where tOTt_{\mathrm{OT}} is the thickness of orbital source material, ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} is anti-damping torque efficiency, and ξ0\xi_0 is a constant arising from interfacial origins, such as the OREE and interfacial SOT. λOH\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}} is much longer than the spin diffusion length, which has been used to experimentally separate the OT contribution from SOT[191]. The long orbital diffusion length, broad material selection, and high OHC make OT highly efficient for magnetization switching. These attributes offer promising pathways for the development of low-power, high-stability orbitronic memory and logic devices. It is worth noting that the backflow effect may diminish the advantage of the long orbital diffusion length. When tOTt_{\mathrm{OT}} is smaller than λOH\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}}, the orbital current is bounced back at the NM/FM interface and neutralizes with other orbital currents. Conversely, if tOTt_{\mathrm{OT}} significantly exceeds λOH\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}}, the backflow effect can be effectively suppressed, but this will lead to increased current shunting and higher energy consumption. Therefore, a comprehensive consideration is needed to select the appropriate thickness of orbital source material in the design of OT devices.

Illustration of magnetization switching by orbital torque based on the orbital Hall effect

Figure 7. The illustration of magnetization switching by orbital torque based on the orbital Hall effect in (a) non-magnetic layer/ferromagnetic layer (NM/FM) heterostructure and (b) NM1/NM2/FM heterostructure, where NM2 is inserted as an orbital-spin conversion layer.

Materials for orbital Hall effect

Since the OHE is independent of SOC, a wide range of materials have been theoretically predicted to exhibit strong OHC, including 3d3d, 4d4d, and 5d5d transition metals, spsp-metals, and transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs)[84, 195, 196, 197, 198, 199, 200, 201, 202, 203, 204] [178, 179]. A comprehensive review of OHC values for various materials, as well as θOHeff\theta_{\mathrm{OH}}^{\mathrm{eff}} and λOH\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}} in different heterostructures, can be found in a recent review[81]. The SHE in heavy 5d5d transition metals, such as Ta[14], W[99], and Pt[97], has been extensively studied and successfully implemented in SOT devices. However, theoretical and experimental studies indicate that these materials also exhibit an exceptionally large σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}} on the order of ∼105 (ℏ/2e) (Ω⋅m)−1\sim10^{5}\,(\hbar/2e)\,(\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})^{-1}, surpassing their SHC[79] [178]. Lee et al. investigated the anti-damping torque efficiency (ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}}) in Pt/CoFeB, Ta/CoFeB, and Pt/Ni bilayers using ST-FMR[79]. They found that ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} follows the sign of SHC in Pt/CoFeB and Ta/CoFeB, consistent with conventional SOT mechanisms. However, an anomalous behavior is observed in Ta/Ni bilayers, where the sign of the net torque is opposite to the SHC of Ta[79] (Figure 8(a)). This phenomenon is well explained by the superposition of σSHETa\sigma_{\mathrm{SHE}}^{\mathrm{Ta}} and ηL−SNiσOHETa\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}^{\mathrm{Ni}}\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{Ta}}. Specifically, when σSHETa>0\sigma_{\mathrm{SHE}}^{\mathrm{Ta}}>0 and the contribution from OHE surpasses that of SHE, the resulting net torque changes sign, providing direct evidence of OT. Further experimental validation of OHE-driven torque was provided by Li et al., who demonstrated that in a Ta/Pt/thulium iron garnet (Tm3_3Fe5_5O12_{12}, TmIG) heterostructure, the orbital current generated in Ta can be converted into a spin current in Pt, thereby enhancing the torque for magnetization switching (Figure 8(b))[193]. This finding challenges the conventional belief that stacking materials with opposite θSH\theta_{\mathrm{SH}} (e.g., Ta and Pt) will necessarily lead to a reduction in net torque efficiency. Moreover, OT efficiency is highly dependent on the choice of FMs. In W/Ni and Pt/Ni bilayers, the torque efficiency increases with the Ni thickness (tNit_{\mathrm{Ni}}), even when tNit_{\mathrm{Ni}} exceeds 10 nm. This behavior is in stark contrast to conventional SOT and is attributed to the significantly longer diffusion length of orbital currents compared to spin currents[80] [192]. Moreover, in Hf/Ni bilayers, the crystallinity of the Ni layer plays a crucial role in determining OT efficiency, a phenomenon that is not observed in SOT driven by SHE[205]. Theoretical calculations have also predicted significant OHC in 4d transition metals[178]. Experimental investigations using ST-FMR have confirmed these predictions. In Nb/Ni and Ru/Ni bilayers, θOHEeff\theta_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{eff}} is measured to be 0.018 and 0.019, respectively, with λOH\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}} of approximately 2.2 nm and 2.7 nm[86] (Figure 8(c)). In Zr/Ni bilayers, the ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} increases as a function of both tNit_{\mathrm{Ni}} and tZrt_{\mathrm{Zr}}[188] (Figure 8(d)). Notably, a sign change in ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} is observed[194], similar to the behavior reported in Ta/Ni bilayers[79]. This sign reversal indicates a transition from SHE-dominated to OHE-dominated torques, highlighting the dominant role of orbital currents in magnetization dynamics. Furthermore, current-induced magnetization switching is demonstrated in Zr/CoFeB/MgO heterostructures (Figure 8(e)). Samples with 2.2 nm and 4.9 nm Zr exhibit opposite switching behavior, providing direct evidence of a crossover from conventional SHE-driven SOT to an OHE-driven mechanism[194]. Recently, Yang et al. achieved perpendicular magnetization switching in [Co/Pt]3_3 and CoFeB/Gd/CoFeB heterostructures using Zr as an orbital current source[87]. The Zr/[Co/Pt]3_3 sample exhibits the highest reported ξOT\xi_{\mathrm{OT}} (∼\sim0.78) to date, attributed to the exceptionally large σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}} of Zr (∼\sim5.3 ×\times 105^5 (ℏ\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅\Omega\cdotm)−1^{-1}[188] and the large γL−S\gamma_{\mathrm{L-S}} of [Co/Pt]3_3 (Figure 8(f))[87]. Figure 8(g) summarizes the ξOT\xi_{\mathrm{OT}} values as a function of σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}} for various orbital Hall materials, providing a comparative perspective on the efficiency of OT generation[87].

The orbital Hall effect in 4d and 5d metals and the magnetization switching driven by them

Figure 8. The orbital Hall effect in 4d4d and 5d5d metals and the magnetization switching driven by them. (a) The anti-damping torque efficiency (ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}}) and the effective spin Hall conductivity (σDL\sigma_{\mathrm{DL}}) for various ferromagnet/non-magnet (FM/NM) bilayers (FM = FeB, CoFeB, Co, Ni, NM = Pt, Ta). Reprinted with permission from Ref. [79]. Copyright 2021 by Springer Nature. (b) Current-induced magnetization switching curves for the Ta/TmIG and Ta/Pt/TmIG. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [193]. Copyright 2023 by American Chemical Society. (c) The spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance efficiency of Nb/Ni and Ru/Ni heterostructure. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [86]. Copyright 2023 by American Physical Society. (d) The Zr-layer thickness (tZrt_{\mathrm{Zr}}) dependence of ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} for the Zr/Py (orange) and Zr/Ni (blue) bilayers. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [188]. Copyright 2023 by American Physical Society. (e) Current-induced magnetization switching for Zr (2.2 nm)/CoFeB/MgO and for Zr (4.9 nm)/CoFeB/MgO. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [194]. Copyright 2020 by American Chemical Society. (f) Current-induced orbital torque switching for Zr/[Co/Pt]3_3 and Zr/CoFeB/Gd/CoFeB. (g) The summary of orbital torque efficiency (ξOT\xi_{\mathrm{OT}}) as a function of orbital Hall conductivity (σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}}) for the orbital Hall materials. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [87]. Copyright 2024 by Springer Nature.

3d transition metals have been overlooked in conventional SOT due to their weak SOC. However, recent research has highlighted their strong OHC, cost-effectiveness, environmental friendliness, and abundance, making them promising candidates for OT applications[195]. In Ti/Ni bilayers, OT has been experimentally demonstrated via magneto-optic Kerr effect (MOKE), yielding θOHEeff=0.021\theta_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{eff}} = 0.021 and λOH=60\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}} = 60 nm (Figure 9(a) and Figure 9(b)) [26]. Additionally, Hayashi et al. obtained θOHEeff=0.13\theta_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{eff}} = 0.13 and λOH=47\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}} = 47 nm for Ti/Ni bilayers using ST-FMR measurements[80]. Similarly, Cr has been shown to exhibit θOHEeff=0.28\theta_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{eff}} = 0.28 and λOH=6.6\lambda_{\mathrm{OH}} = 6.6 nm, as determined via MOKE[207]. Interestingly, Cr-based bilayers exhibit a sign reversal in OT depending on the adjacent FM. Lee et al. found that Cr/Co bilayers generate torque efficiency with an opposite sign compared to Cr/Ni, Pt/Co, and Pt/Ni bilayers (Figure 9(c))[82]. This behavior can be attributed to Cr’s large σOHECr\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{Cr}} (8.2×1058.2 \times10^{5} (ℏ/2e)(\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m)−1(\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})^{-1}) and its negative σSHECr\sigma_{\mathrm{SHE}}^{\mathrm{Cr}} (−130-130 (ℏ/2e)(\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m)−1(\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})^{-1}), which have opposite signs[195]. In Cr/Co bilayers, the ηL−SCo\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}^{\mathrm{Co}} of Co is close to zero, leading to a dominant SOT from the SHE and a negligible ξOT\xi_{\mathrm{OT}}. Conversely, in Cr/Ni and Cr/Pt bilayers, where ηL−SNi>0\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}^{\mathrm{Ni}} > 0 and ηL−SPt>0\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}^{\mathrm{Pt}} > 0, the OHE dominates, resulting in a positive ξOT\xi_{\mathrm{OT}}. As shown in Figure 9(d), in Cr/Pt/CoFeB heterostructures with PMA, the JS\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{S}} converted from the JL\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{L}} follows the relation σOHECrηL−SPt>0\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{Cr}}\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}}^{\mathrm{Pt}} > 0, whereas the spin current from the SHE follows σSHECr<0\sigma_{\mathrm{SHE}}^{\mathrm{Cr}} < 0. This results in an anticlockwise switching curve with positive θOHEeff\theta_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{eff}}. Conversely, the control Cr/CoFeB bilayer exhibits a counterclockwise switching curve with negative θOHEeff\theta_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{eff}} (Figure 9(e)) [82]. Notably, the dependence of switching efficiency on Cr thickness is similar in both structures, suggesting that the torque primarily originates from Cr rather than Pt (Figure 9(f))[82]. Beyond FMs, OT has also been utilized to manipulate AFMs. Xie et al. demonstrated AFM switching of Mn3_3Sn layers using OT from Cr[206]. Cr/Mn3_3Sn sample exhibits the same switching polarity as Mn3_3Sn/Ta, consistent with the positive θOHEeff\theta_{\mathrm{OHE}}^{\mathrm{eff}} of Cr (Figure 9(g) and (Figure 9h)). Similar AFM switching behavior has also been reported using OT from Mn[208].

The orbital Hall effect in 3d metals and the magnetization switching driven by them

Figure 9. The orbital Hall effect in 3d metals and the magnetization switching driven by them. (a) Schematic illustration of orbital torque in the Ti/Ni bilayer. (b) Ti thickness (tTit_{\mathrm{Ti}}) dependence of ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} of the Ti/Ni bilayers. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [26]. Copyright 2023 by Springer Nature. (c) Cr thickness (tCrt_{\mathrm{Cr}}) dependent ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} of Ni/Cr (red) and Co/Cr (light-green) samples. (d) Schematic illustration of the orbital-to-spin conversion in the Cr/Pt/CoFeB heterostructure. The spin (orbital) angular momentum is represented by S\mathbf{S} (L\mathbf{L}). The subscript OHE or SHE marks the source of S\mathbf{S} (L\mathbf{L}). (e) Magnetization switching curves of Cr/CoFeB and Cr/Pt/CoFeB samples under an assisting magnetic field (BxB_x) of +20 mT. The green and magenta symbols represent the samples without and with the Pt insertion layer, respectively. (f) tCrt_{\mathrm{Cr}}-dependent switching efficiency of the Cr/CoFeB and Cr/Pt/CoFeB samples. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [82]. Copyright 2021 by Springer Nature. (g) Schematic of Mn3_3Sn/X with X = Cr, Ta, or Pt structures. (h) Current dependence of Hall resistance at room temperature for Mn3_3Sn/X with X = Cr, Ta, or Pt, with a positive in-plane assistant field. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [206]. Copyright 2023 by American Chemical Society.

First-principles calculations predict that certain sp metals Al[202] and XIV group elemental crystal (Si, Ge, and α\alpha-Sn)[209] exhibit negative σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}}. Moreover, FnMn alloys have been reported to possess an exceptionally high σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}} of 5.45×1075.45 \times10^{7} (ℏ/2e\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})−1^{-1}, enabling magnetization switching in PMA CoPt heterostructures[210]. For 2D materials, OHC studies have largely focused on theoretical predictions. Tokatly revealed that in p-doped graphene, the OHE originates from Berry phase accumulation as heavy and light holes move around the degeneracy point at the Brillouin zone center[211]. Bhowal further clarified that the OHC in gapped graphene is distinct from the previously reported valley Hall effect[212]. In TMDs such as MX2_2 (M = Mo, W; X = S, Se, Te; NbS2_2), the reported σOHE\sigma_{\mathrm{OHE}} (∼105\sim10^{5}- 10710^{7} (ℏ/2e\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})−1^{-1}) is significantly larger than σSHE\sigma_{\mathrm{SHE}} and exhibits an opposite sign, indicating the potential of TMDs in orbitronic devices[196, 198, 200, 201, 213]. Furthermore, MX2_2 (M = Pt, Pd; and X = S, Se, and Te) exhibits an intrinsic OHC (∼105\sim10^{5} (ℏ/2e\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})−1^{-1}) due to orbital texture effects around momentum-space valleys[204]. Liu et al. proposed that the OHE in graphene, TMDs, and topological AFMs is primarily driven by extrinsic mechanisms, suggesting that OT in these systems could be tuned or enhanced via doping[203]. Additionally, 2D FMs and AFMs have been actively studied. Chen et al. proposed that topological phase transitions can modulate the OHE in topological AFM MnBi2_2Te4_4[214]. Zhang et al. experimentally demonstrated magnetization switching in van der Waals FM Fe3_3GaTe2_2 driven by OT from Ti, achieving a switching current density of 1.6×1061.6 \times10^{6} A⋅\cdotcm−2^{-2}[215]. While theoretical predictions for OHE in 2D materials are promising, further experimental validation is needed to fully realize their potential in orbitronic devices.

Materials for orbital Rashba-Edelstein effect

The OREE arises at the interfaces and surfaces of NM/FM heterostructures. In 2016, Ando’s group first reported a significant spin torque in Cu/Py bilayers, generated by the light metal Cu, despite its weak SOC[219]. They attributed the robust anti-damping torque in CuOx_x/Py to Berry curvature effects[220] and further demonstrated that oxygen-induced modifications of interfacial orbital hybridization could enhance the torque efficiency[221]. In 2020, Ding et al. observed a substantial enhancement in torque efficiency in TmIG/Pt heterostructures upon capping with a CuOx_x layer. They suggested that this enhancement originates from the orbital current generated at the CuOx_x/Pt interface[25]. As illustrated in Figure 10(a), the ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} in TmIG/Pt (2 nm)/CuOx_x (∼0.01\sim0.01) is an order of magnitude higher than that in TmIG/Pt, attributed to the OREE-induced OT. Similar large torque efficiencies have been observed in FM/Cu/AlOx_x[180, 184] and FM/Cu/CuOx_x[187] trilayers, where the interfacial inversion symmetry breaking results in an orbital asymmetry that induces a Rashba-type orbital angular momentum texture[195]. Consequently, under an external electric field, a finite orbital angular momentum is generated, despite its equilibrium net value remaining zero[222, 223]. As tPtt_{\mathrm{Pt}} increases, the ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} decreases, eventually reaching the same value as in TmIG/Pt when tPtt_{\mathrm{Pt}} exceeds 4 nm, due to spin current dephasing in Pt (Figure 10(a))[25]. Here, Pt serves as the conversion layer that transforms the JL\mathbf{J}_{L} into the JS\mathbf{J}_{S}, while CuOx_x does not absorb JS\mathbf{J}_{S}[224], effectively improving the ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}}. Harnessing the OREE, Huang et al. achieved field-free in-plane magnetization switching in CoFeB/CuOx_x devices without heavy metals (Figure 10(b))[216]. Similarly, Xiao et al. demonstrated perpendicular magnetization switching in Pt/Co/Cu-CuOx_x heterostructures, facilitated by the combined effect of OT from the Cu/CuOx_x interface and SOT from Pt[225]. Furthermore, field-free perpendicular magnetization switching driven by OT has been realized in TmIG/CoFeB/Cu/SiO2_2 heterostructures (Figure 10(c))[217]. In this system, TmIG exhibits PMA, while CoFeB exhibits IMA. The interfacial exchange coupling induces a tilt in the magnetization directions of TmIG and CoFeB, leading to a strong dependence of the TmIG up/down states on the CoFeB magnetization orientation. Consequently, the JL\mathbf{J}_{L} generated in Cu is converted into the JS\mathbf{J}_{S} in CoFeB, exerting OTs on TmIG and enabling deterministic switching. Beyond the CuOx_x-based system, OREE-induced OT has also been observed at Ru/Al2_2O3_3[85] and Co/CuNx_x[218] interfaces. As shown in Figure 10(d), the ξOT\xi_{\mathrm{OT}} of CoFeB(12 nm)/Ru/Al2_2O3_3 increases with CoFeB thickness and saturates at ∼0.3\sim0.3 for tCoFeB=12t_{\mathrm{CoFeB}} = 12 nm[85]. Meanwhile, in Pt/Co/CuNx_x heterostructures, ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} varies between 0.06 and 0.4, depending on the nitrogen doping concentration in CuNx_x (Figure 10(e)). This OT effect is further evidenced by magnetization switching with a critical current density of 5×1065 \times10^{6} A·cm−2^{-2} (Figure 10(f)).

The orbital torque efficiency of orbital Rashba-Edelstein effect material and the magnetization switching driven by orbital Rashba-Edelstein effect

Figure 10. The orbital torque efficiency of orbital Rashba-Edelstein effect material and the magnetization switching driven by orbital Rashba-Edelstein effect. (a) ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} as a function of Pt thickness for TmIG/Pt (series A) and TmIG/Pt/CuOx_x (series B). Reprinted with permission from Ref. [25]. Copyright 2020 by American Physical Society. (b) RxxR_{xx}-IwriteI_{\mathrm{write}} loop and its procedure for measuring. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [216]. Copyright 2023 by American Chemical Society. (c) Magnetization switching curves of TmIG (10 nm)/CoFeB (1.5 nm)/Cu (3 nm)/SiO2_2 under a series of external fields (HxH_x) along the xx-axis. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [217]. Copyright 2023 by Wiley-VCH GmbH. (d) Ferromagnetic thickness (tFt_{\mathrm{F}}) dependence of torque efficiency of CoFeB/Ru/Al2_2O3_3. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [85]. Copyright 2022 by American Physical Society. (e) ξDL\xi_{\mathrm{DL}} as functions of nitrogen doping concentration (QQ). (f) Switching loops with various maximum applied current densities. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [218]. Copyright 2022 by American Physical Society.

Magnon torque

Mechanism of magnon torque

A magnon is a quasiparticle that represents the quantized excitations of spin waves in magnetic materials[226, 227]. When magnons propagate collectively from one region to another, their coordinated motion gives rise to a magnon current. Unlike electron-mediated spin currents, magnon currents carry spin angular momentum without involving charge motion, making them particularly advantageous in magnetic insulators. This charge-free nature of magnon transport eliminates Joule heating caused by charge motion, a major limitation in conventional electron-mediated systems, thereby enabling energy-efficient spin information transport. Moreover, in magnetic insulators, magnons can propagate over micrometer-scale distances[88, 89, 90] at ultrafast velocities[91], further enhancing their potential for spin information processing. Finally, magnons exhibit excellent controllability and can be precisely manipulated using well-established techniques, including ultrafast thermal gradients[228, 229], attosecond laser pulses[230], microwave excitations[231], and electric fields[28, 232, 233]. Benefiting from the above attributes, magnons have emerged as a tool for the manipulation of magnetic moments, which manifests as domain wall motion and magnetization switching[234, 235, 236].

In a typical magnon device, the structure consists of an NM layer, an AFM insulator, and an FM, as illustrated in Figure 11. When a charge current passes through the NM layer, it generates a spin current, leading to nonequilibrium spin accumulation at the NM/AFM interface. Through interfacial exchange interactions, the nonequilibrium electron spin current is converted into a magnon current within the AFM. This magnon current subsequently propagates through the AFM layer and exerts MTs on the adjacent FM, ultimately driving its magnetization switching. The NM layer in such devices is typically required to exhibit high charge-to-spin conversion efficiency and can be selected from the materials discussed above. The AFM insulating layer is commonly composed of NiO, which possesses a high Néel temperature, or the multiferroic material BiFeO3_3. In the following sections, we will review MTs, categorizing the discussion based on different AFM insulating layers.

The principal diagram of magnon torque

Figure 11. The principal diagram of magnon torque.

NiO-based magnon torque

with permission from Ref. [238]. Copyright 2022 by American Physical Society.

In 2015, the angular momentum transfer in AFM insulator NiO was demonstrated by ST-FMR in Pt/NiO/FeNi structure[239]. Later, Hyunsoo Yang’s group achieved the in-plane magnetization switching utilizing MTs in a Bi2_2Se3_3/NiO/Py sandwich structure (Figure 12(a))[24]. ST-FMR measurements (Figure 12(b)) confirm the presence of in-plane anti-damping MT. Similar to the spin Hall angle in conventional SOT, the spin torque ratio is defined as θi=Ji/JC\theta_i = J_i/J_C, whose dependence on the thickness of NiO (tNiOt_{\mathrm{NiO}}) is shown in Figure 12(c). When the NiO layer inserted between the Bi2_2Se3_3 and Py layers is very thin (tNiO<1t_{\mathrm{NiO}} < 1 nm), the AFM ordering is absent at room temperature so that MT is negligible, and θi\theta_i purely originates from electron-mediated torques. As tNiOt_{\mathrm{NiO}} increases to 2 nm, θi\theta_i drops from 0.67 to 0 because electron tunneling is unallowed in an NM NiO layer. θi\theta_i increases as the tNiOt_{\mathrm{NiO}} increases above 10 nm and arrives at the peak value (~0.3) at tNiO=25t_{\mathrm{NiO}} = 25 nm, and then decreases. θi\theta_i of the control sample, where a 6 nm MgO layer is inserted between Bi2_2Se3_3 and NiO, is negligible, excluding the possibility that observed torque originated from the NiO (25 nm)/Py interface. In current-induced switching measurements, the Py layer is patterned into a rectangular island to avoid the current shunting. The MOKE images demonstrate the magnetization switching of the FM with a critical switching current density (JCJ_C) of ~1.27×107\times10^7 A·m−2^{-2} induced by the in-plane anti-damping MT (Figure 12(d)). This work is a milestone in MT. Afterwards, Zheng et al. fabricated an all-oxide heterostructure SrRuO3_3/NiO/SrIrO3_3 with PMA, in which the JCJ_C ~ 8.1×105\times10^5 A·m−2^{-2} is one order smaller than the conventional metallic system[240, 241]. Heavy metal Pt has been used as a spin source in MT devices, such as Pt/NiO/Y3_3Fe5_5O12_{12}[242] and Pt/NiO/CoTb[243], which can enhance the torque efficiency in < 2 nm NiO-based devices. An interesting phenomenon in Pt/NiO/CoFeB system observed by Zhu et al is the sign reversal of SOT upon cooling down[237]. As shown in Figure 12(e) and (Figure 12f), as the temperature decreases, the anti-damping torque varies from positive to negative in Pt/NiO/CoFeB sample but remains positive in Pt/CoFeB sample. Following this work, Weishengzhao’s group attributed the reversal to magnetic interactions associated with the exchange bias effect[238]. At low temperatures, the net moment at Pt/NiO interface (m1\mathbf{m}_1) receives a torque from the spin Hall current of Pt and is coupled to the net moment at NiO/CoFeB interface (m2\mathbf{m}_2), as shown in Figure 12(g). Since m2\mathbf{m}_2 is exchange-coupled to CoFeB, its antiparallel alignment with CoFeB reverses the anti-damping torque compared to that at high temperatures. As the temperature increases above the blocking temperature of NiO, the magnetic moments in NiO are significantly reduced and the transfer of the torque through exchange coupling in NiO disappears[238]. Besides, the spin source in MT devices has been expanded to topological insulators. Shi et al.[244] developed the room-temperature MT structure Bi2_2Te3_3/NiO/CoFeB, which enables the switching of perpendicular magnetization with a JCJ_C of 4.1×106\times10^6 A·cm−2^{-2} and the MT efficiency is 0.33 with a magnon diffusion length of 26.6 nm. However, Bi2_2Te3_3 suffers from a high resistivity, leading to significant power consumption issues. Zhao et al. further optimized the power consumption of magnon devices by replacing Bi2_2Te3_3 with topological crystalline insulator SnTe, reducing power consumption to approximately 22 times lower than that of Bi2_2Te3_3[245].

Magnetization switching by magnon torques through an antiferromagnetic insulator NiO

Figure 12. Magnetization switching by magnon torques through an antiferromagnetic insulator NiO. (a) Illustration of the structure of magnon torques switching device with an isolated NiFe rectangle defined on top of the NiO layer. (b) A typical spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance signal from a Bi2_2Se3_3/NiO (25 nm)/Py (6 nm) device at 10 GHz and 300 K with fits. (c) The spin torque ratio (θi\theta_\mathrm{i}) deduced from the spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance data and the terahertz emission amplitude as a function of the thickness of NiO (tNiOt_\mathrm{NiO}) at 300 K. The star symbol marks the θi\theta_\mathrm{i} from the control device. (d) Magneto-optic Kerr effect images for magnon torque-driven magnetization switching in the Bi2_2Se3_3/NiO/Py device by injecting a pulsed current (II) along the +xx axis. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [24]. Copyright 2019 by American Association for the Advancement of Science. (e) Temperature dependence of the anti-damping (ξDL\xi_\mathrm{DL}) and field-like (ξFL\xi_\mathrm{FL}) torque efficiencies per applied electric field in Pt (4 nm)/NiO (0.9 nm)/CoFeB (1.4 nm). (f) Linear dependence of VaV_\mathrm{a} on −VAH/2(Hin+Hk)-V_\mathrm{AH}/2(H_\mathrm{in}+H_\mathrm{k}) for Pt (4 nm)/NiO (0.9 nm)/CoFeB (1.4 nm) and Pt (4 nm)/CoFeB (1.4 nm) at 4 K with the slopes being anti-damping spin-orbit effective field HDLH_\mathrm{DL}, where VAHV_\mathrm{AH}, HinH_\mathrm{in}, and HkH_\mathrm{k} are anomalous Hall voltage, in-plane magnetic field, and perpendicular anisotropy field, respectively. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [237]. Copyright 2021 by American Physical Society. (g) The schematic of the anti-damping spin-orbit effective fields (HDLH_\mathrm{DL}) for the Pt/NiO/CoFeB. Reprinted

In the above discussions, perpendicular magnetization switching relying on the in-plane anti-damping MT is found to be nondeterministic, necessitating an external magnetic field aligned with the current direction to achieve deterministic switching. The realization of field-free magnetization switching remains a key challenge for the practical application of magnon devices. Recently, Wang et al. successfully demonstrated field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization using out-of-plane anti-damping MTs[246]. They fabricated a WTe2_2/NiO/CoFeB heterostructure, where the NM layer, WTe2_2, breaks mirror symmetry along the low-symmetry aa-axis. As illustrated in Figure 13(a), when a charge current is applied along the aa-axis, both yy- and zz-spins are generated. The electron-carried spins subsequently excite magnon currents in NiO, carrying yy- and zz-polarized magnon moments that exert in-plane and out-of-plane anti-damping MTs on CoFeB, respectively[246]. ST-FMR measurements with the current applied along the aa-axis exhibit distinct differences in both the shape and amplitude of the mixed voltage (VmixV_\mathrm{mix}) under positive and negative magnetic fields (Figure 13(b)), confirming the existence of the out-of-plane anti-damping MT. Moreover, they carried out tNiOt_\mathrm{NiO} dependence of in-plane (θy\theta_y) and out-of-plane (θz\theta_z) effective torque efficiencies, as shown in Figure 13(c). The initial decrease in θy\theta_y and θz\theta_z for tNiO=0t_\mathrm{NiO} = 0–3 nm is attributed to the suppression of electron-mediated torques. As tNiOt_\mathrm{NiO} increases, both θy\theta_y and θz\theta_z rise, reaching peak values (∼0.3\sim0.3) at tNiO=25t_{\mathrm{NiO}} = 25 nm, corresponding to the highest MT efficiencies. For tNiO>25t_{\mathrm{NiO}} > 25 nm, enhanced magnon-phonon and magnon-magnon interactions within NiO result in a reduction in MT efficiencies. To investigate the role of WTe2_2’s crystal symmetry, magnetization switching is performed in the absence of an external magnetic field at varying angles (α\alpha) between the low-symmetry aa-axis of WTe2_2 and the current direction (Figure 13(d)). The extracted JCJ_{\mathrm{C}}, θy\theta_y, and θz\theta_z are summarized in Figure 13(e). A significantly higher JCJ_{\mathrm{C}} is required when the current deviates from the aa-axis, indicating that the observed out-of-plane anti-damping MT is closely related to the broken crystal symmetry of WTe2_2. To reduce power consumption, Wang et al. fabricated PtTe2_2/WTe2_2/NiO (25 nm)/FM devices, achieving σs,y\sigma_{s,y} of 1.5×1041.5 \times10^{4} (ℏ/2e\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})−1^{-1} and σs,z\sigma_{s,z} of 2.6×1032.6 \times10^{3} (ℏ/2e\hbar/2e) (Ω⋅m\Omega\cdot\mathrm{m})−1^{-1}, resulting in a 190-fold reduction in power consumption compared to the Bi2_2Te3_3/NiO/CoFeB sample[246]. This work establishes an all-electric, low-power, perpendicular magnetization switching by MT, which is crucial for the advancement of magnon-based memory and logic devices.

Field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization by magnon torques

Figure 13. Field-free switching of perpendicular magnetization by magnon torques. (a) Magnetization switching by magnon torque in WTe2_2/NiO/CoFeB. (b) Spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance spectra of WTe2_2 (8 nm)/NiO (25 nm)/Py with currents applied along the aa-axis of WTe2_2. (c) NiO thickness (tt) dependence of in-plane torque efficiency (θy\theta_y) and out-of-plane torque efficiency (θz\theta_z) in WTe2_2 (8 nm)/NiO (25 nm)/Py. (d) Current-induced field-free magnetization switching of the CoFeB layer. The switching is performed under different angles (α\alpha) between the low-symmetry aa-axis of WTe2_2 and the current flow direction. (e) α\alpha dependence of critical switching current density (JCJ_\mathrm{C}), θy\theta_y, and θz\theta_z. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [246]. Copyright 2024 by Springer Nature.

BiFeO3_3-based magnon torque

When the AFM insulator NiO is replaced with a multiferroic material, an external electric field can modulate the Néel vector orientation of the multiferroic layer, thereby controlling the generation and propagation of magnon currents. BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3}, a representative multiferroic material, exhibits coexisting antiferromagnetism and ferroelectricity, which are intrinsically coupled via magnetoelectric interactions[247, 248]. As illustrated in Figure 14(a), the ferroelectric polarization of BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3} can be switched between an upward and downward state by applying a negative or positive bias exceeding the coercive voltage to the top SrIrO3\mathrm{SrIrO_3} layer[28]. To investigate the impact of ferroelectric polarization on magnon transport, La0.7Sr0.3MnO3/BiFeO3/SrIrO3\mathrm{La_{0.7}Sr_{0.3}MnO_3/BiFeO_3/SrIrO_3} heterostructures are characterized using ST-FMR[28]. The results indicate that the MT efficiency is significantly enhanced for upward polarization (negative bias) and reduced for downward polarization (positive bias), as shown in Figure 14(b). This observation confirms that MTs in BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3} can be effectively regulated via ferroelectric polarization. Magnetization switching experiments are further conducted using SrRuO3/BiFeO3/SrIrO3\mathrm{SrRuO_3/BiFeO_3/SrIrO_3} heterostructures[28], as depicted in Figure 14(c) and Figure 14(d). The corresponding current-voltage (II-VV) characteristics during ferroelectric switching are presented in Figure 14(e), where current peaks are associated with the reversal of ferroelectric polarization. Magnetization switching measurements are performed under different BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3} polarization states, as shown in Figure 14(f), revealing that the critical switching current is lower for upward polarization than for downward polarization (Figure 14(g)). This trend corresponds to enhanced spin transmission, aligning well with the ST-FMR results. This study highlights the feasibility of using ferroelectric polarization as a voltage-controlled mechanism for tuning MTs. Subsequently, Chai et al. magnon-based logic devices based on BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3} systems[233].

The magnon torque in BiFeO3 under the control of ferroelectric polarization

Figure 14. The magnon torque in BiFeO3_3 under the control of ferroelectric polarization. (a) Schematic of a La0.7_{0.7}Sr0.3_{0.3}MnO3_3/BiFeO3_3(BFO)/SrIrO3_3(SIO) heterostructure under an external electric field, with the BiFeO3_3 ferroelectric polarization under negative and positive biases. (b) The spin-orbit torque efficiency measured with the spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance technique as a function of bias voltages applied beforehand for La0.7_{0.7}Sr0.3_{0.3}MnO3_3/BiFeO3_3/SrIrO3_3. (c) Schematic of SrRuO3_3 (SRO) magnetization switching by the current-induced torques borne by the magnons transmitted through BiFeO3_3. (d) The anomalous Hall resistance (RxyR_{xy}) versus pulsed currents at 70 K under assisting magnetic fields with different polarities and strengths. (e) The current-voltage (II-VV) curve during the ferroelectric switching experiments for the heterostructure SrRuO3_3/BiFeO3_3/SrIrO3_3. (f) Ferroelectric polarization-controlled magnetization switching measurement. The magnetization switching behavior with the upward (downward) ferroelectric polarization of BiFeO3_3 is shown in red (blue). RxyR_{xy} is normalized by Rxy0R_{xy}^{0} (anomalous Hall resistance at IC=0I_{\mathrm{C}} = 0). (g) The magnitudes of the critical switching current as a function of the assisting magnetic fields. The lines are a guide to the eye. Reprinted with permission from Ref. [28]. Copyright 2024 by Springer Nature.

Conclusion and perspectives

SOT has been rapidly advancing to meet the growing demands for low-power and field-free magnetization switching, offering promising prospects for applications in magnetic data storage, logic circuits, and high-frequency spintronic devices. We have reviewed recent advancements in electron- and magnon-mediated torques, with a particular focus on their generation mechanisms and the associated spin source materials. These materials include conventional metals, TIs, 2D materials, NCAFM, and altermagnets. Despite these significant advancements, several critical challenges remain in achieving highly efficient electron- and magnon-mediated SOT switching and elucidating the underlying physical mechanisms:

  1. The exploration of more efficient low-symmetry materials is crucial for advancing SOT devices. For instance, recent experiments observed the nonlinear Hall effect in NbIrTe4\mathrm{NbIrTe_4}, indicating lateral-symmetry breaking and that NbIrTe4\mathrm{NbIrTe_4} could serve as a potential source of zz-spin currents[249]. However, its application in perpendicular magnetization switching has yet to be realized. Additionally, RuO2\mathrm{RuO_2} remains the only altermagnet experimentally verified to generate zz-spin currents through the SSE. Expanding the range of altermagnets is essential, including strategies such as inducing a phase transition from conventional AFMs to altermagnets via strain engineering[250]. Notably, the epitaxial strain may also enable gg-wave altermagnets such as CrSb\mathrm{CrSb} and MnTe\mathrm{MnTe} to generate zz-polarized spin currents[251]. Moreover, the generation and utilization

of zz-spin currents in SOT devices have yet to be demonstrated in the dd-wave altermagnet Mn5Si3\mathrm{Mn}_{5}\mathrm{Si}_{3}, highlighting the need for further experimental and theoretical investigations.

(2) Although the spin-split electronic bands and their associated phenomena in RuO2\mathrm{RuO}_{2} have been extensively studied and widely utilized, the exact magnetic ground state of RuO2\mathrm{RuO}_{2} remains controversial[252, 253, 254, 255]. This ongoing debate may stem from variations in strain conditions[256, 257] and fluctuations in the Ru/O stoichiometric ratio[252] across different RuO2\mathrm{RuO}_{2} samples. Therefore, further comprehensive experimental investigations are urgently required to unambiguously determine the antiferromagnetic properties of RuO2\mathrm{RuO}_{2}.

(3) While significant progress has been made in the study of orbital currents, further exploration is required to fully understand the underlying transport mechanisms, develop direct measurement techniques, and optimize OT performance. Many theoretically predicted orbital materials, such as graphene[211, 212] and 2D TMDs, necessitate and are undergoing experimental validation. For example, the orbital texture has been experimentally observed in 2H-WSe2\mathrm{WSe}_{2}[258] and TiSe2\mathrm{TiSe}_{2}[259]. Concurrently, the discovery of novel materials is critical, particularly ferromagnets with high ηL−S\eta_{\mathrm{L-S}} and orbital source materials with large OHC, which are expected to enhance the practical applicability of OTs. Furthermore, zz-polarized orbital currents have been demonstrated in IrO2\mathrm{IrO}_{2}[260], which potentially enables field-free magnetization switching through OTs.

(4) OT concept and orbital diffusion length remain controversial. For instance, Liu et al. proposed that the positive anti-damping torque efficiency of Ta/Ni system is a misinterpretation of a non-negligible self-induced ST-FMR signal of the FM layer, rather than OT[261]. Using first-principles scattering calculations, Rang et al. demonstrated that orbital angular momentum is relaxed within 1-2 atomic scales in transition metal/FM bilayers, challenging claims of nonlocal orbital current[262]. Additionally, Song et al., using the first-principles calculations, revealed that OHE contributions in transition metal/FM bilayers are often overshadowed by SHE or canceled by self-torques in ferromagnets like Ni[263]. These debates highlight the need for unified methodologies to distinguish OT and SOT, especially given the short orbital relaxation lengths predicted by first-principles calculations.

(5) In MT devices, NM layers are predominantly composed of conventional heavy metals (Pt) or 2D materials (Bi2Se3\mathrm{Bi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{3}, Bi2Te3\mathrm{Bi}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{3}, and WTe2\mathrm{WTe}_{2}) that serve as spin current sources. Expanding these materials to light metals with high OHC could significantly enhance the efficiency of magnon devices. Moreover, current research on AFM insulating layers has primarily focused on NiO and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3}. Replacing these with 2D AFM insulators may enable more efficient magnon conversion due to the smooth interfaces inherent to 2D materials. This advancement could ultimately lead to the development of MT devices entirely composed of 2D materials, further optimizing their performance and scalability.

(6) Integrating low-symmetry materials into SOT-MRAMs presents several technical challenges. The field-free switching strategy with low-symmetry materials relies on specific crystal and spin symmetries, which are often disrupted in the polycrystalline films commonly employed in commercial spintronic devices. Moreover, these materials (particularly 2D materials) face issues of large-scale growth and thermal stability during MgO-MTJs integration and complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor (CMOS) fabrication. To overcome these limitations, it is crucial to develop spin source materials that can keep thermal stability above 350 ∘C350\,^{\circ}\mathrm{C} and generate zz-polarized spins independently of crystal or magnetic symmetry, thereby enhancing their practical applicability.

Acknowledgment

J. L., B. B., and Z. Y. contributed equally to this work. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (U24A6002, 12174237 (X. X.), 52471253 (F. W.), 12404091 (J. L.), 52171183 (Z. Q.)). X. X. acknowledges the support from National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant nos. 2022YFB3505301). F. W. acknowledges the support from the Fund Program for the Scientific Activities of Selected Returned Overseas Professionals in Shanxi Province (20240019), and Central Government’s Special Fund for Local Science and Technology Development (YDZJSX2024D058). J. L. acknowledges the support from the Basic Research Plan of Shanxi Province (202403021212016). Z. Y. acknowledges the support from the Fundamental Research Program of Shanxi Province (202403021222252) and the Higher Education Science and Technology Innovation Plan Project of Shanxi (2024L146).

References

  1. [1]Bhatti S, Sbiaa R, Hirohata A, Ohno H, Fukami S and Piramanayagam S N 2017 Mater. Today 20 530
  2. [2]Zidan M A, Strachan J P and Lu W D 2018 Nat. Electron. 1 22
  3. [3]Dieny B, Prejbeanu I L, Garello K, et al. 2020 Nat. Electron. 3 446
  4. [4]Yang H, Valenzuela S O, Chshiev M, Couet S, Dieny B, Dlubak B, Fert A, Garello K, Jamet M, Jeong D-E, Lee K, Lee T, Martin M-B, Kar G S, Sénéor P, Shin H-J and Roche S 2022 Nature 606 663
  5. [5]Nguyen V D, Rao S, Wostyn K and Couet S 2024 npj Spintron. 2 48
  6. [6]Parkin S S, Hayashi M and Thomas L 2008 Science 320 190
  7. [7]Ralph D C and Stiles M D 2008 J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 320 1190
  8. [8]Kent A D and Worledge D C 2015 Nat. Nanotechnol. 10 187
  9. [9]Alzate J G, Arslan U, Bai P, et al. 2019 IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), December 7-11, 2019, San Francisco, CA, USA, p. 2.4.1-2.4.4
  10. [10]Song C, Zhang R, Liao L, Zhou Y, Zhou X, Chen R, You Y, Chen X and Pan F 2021 Prog. Mater Sci. 118 100761
  11. [11]Shao Q, Li P, Liu L, Yang H, Fukami S, Razavi A, Wu H, Wang K, Freimuth F, Mokrousov Y, Stiles M D, Emori S, Hoffmann A, Akerman J, Roy K, Wang J-P, Yang S-H, Garello K and Zhang W 2021 IEEE Trans. Magn. 57 1
  12. [12]Zhu L 2023 Adv. Mater. 35 2300853
  13. [13]Miron I M, Garello K, Gaudin G, Zermatten P-J, Costache M V, Auffret S, Bandiera S, Rodmacq B, Schuhl A and Gambardella P 2011 Nature 476 189
  14. [14]Liu L, Pai C-F, Li Y, Tseng H W, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2012 Science 336 555
  15. [15]Liu L, Lee O J, Gudmundsen T J, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2012 Phys. Rev. Lett. 109 096602
  16. [16]Mellnik A R, Lee J S, Richardella A, Grab J L, Mintun P J, Fischer M H, Vaezi A, Manchon A, Kim E A, Samarth N and Ralph D C 2014 Nature 511 449
  17. [17]Aradhya S V, Rowlands G E, Oh J, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2016 Nano Lett. 16 5987
  18. [18]Shi S, Ou Y, Aradhya S V, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2018 Phys. Rev. Appl. 9 011002
  19. [19]Zhu L, Zhu L, Shi S, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2020 Adv. Electron. Mater. 6 1901131
  20. [20]Grimaldi E, Krizakova V, Sala G, Yasin F, Couet S, Sankar Kar G, Garello K and Gambardella P 2020 Nat. Nanotechnol. 15 111
  21. [21]Yang D, Kim T, Lee K, Xu C, Liu Y, Wang F, Zhao S, Kumar D and Yang H 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 4046
  22. [22]Yang Q, Han D, Zhao S, Kang J, Wang F, Lee S-C, Lei J, Lee K-J, Park B-G and Yang H 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 1814
  23. [23]Emori S, Bauer U, Ahn S-M, Martinez E and Beach G S D 2013 Nat. Mater. 12 611
  24. [24]Wang Y, Zhu D, Yang Y, Lee K, Mishra R, Go G, Oh S-H, Kim D-H, Cai K, Liu E, Pollard S D, Shi S, Lee J, Teo K L, Wu Y, Lee K-J and Yang H 2019 Science 366 1125
  25. [25]Ding S, Ross A, Go D, Baldrati L, Ren Z, Freimuth F, Becker S, Kammerbauer F, Yang J, Jakob G, Mokrousov Y and Kläui M 2020 Phys. Rev. Lett. 125 177201
  26. [26]Choi Y-G, Jo D, Ko K-H, Go D, Kim K-H, Park H G, Kim C, Min B-C, Choi G-M and Lee H-W 2023 Nature 619 52
  27. [27]Wang F, Shi G, Kim K-W, Park H-J, Jang J G, Tan H R, Lin M, Liu Y, Kim T, Yang D, Zhao S, Lee K, Yang S, Soumyanarayanan A, Lee K-J and Yang H 2024 Nat. Mater. 23 768
  28. [28]Huang X, Chen X, Li Y, et al. 2024 Nat. Mater. 23 898
  29. [29]Ando K, Takahashi S, Harii K, Sasage K, Ieda J, Maekawa S and Saitoh E 2008 Phys. Rev. Lett. 101 036601
  30. [30]Fukami S, Anekawa T, Zhang C and Ohno H 2016 Nat. Nanotechnol. 11 621
  31. [31]Honjo H, Nguyen T V A, Watanabe T, et al. 2019 IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), 7-11 Dec. 2019, p. 28.5.1-28.5.4
  32. [32]Lin W W, Sang H, Liu D, Jiang Z S, Hu A, Wu X S and Xiao G 2006 J. Appl. Phys. 99 08G518
  33. [33]An H, Ohno T, Kanno Y, Kageyama Y, Monnai Y, Maki H, Shi J and Ando K 2018 Sci. Adv. 4 eaar2250
  34. [34]Fan Y, Upadhyaya P, Kou X, Lang M, Takei S, Wang Z, Tang J, He L, Chang L-T, Montazeri M, Yu G, Jiang W, Nie T, Schwartz R N, Tserkovnyak Y and Wang K L 2014 Nat. Mater. 13 699
  35. [35]Han J, Richardella A, Siddiqui S A, Finley J, Samarth N and Liu L 2017 Phys. Rev. Lett. 119 077702
  36. [36]Wang Y, Zhu D, Wu Y, Yang Y, Yu J, Ramaswamy R, Mishra R, Shi S, Elyasi M, Teo K-L, Wu Y and Yang H 2017 Nat. Commun. 8 1364
  37. [37]Dc M, Grassi R, Chen J-Y, Jamali M, Reifsnyder Hickey D, Zhang D, Zhao Z, Li H, Quarterman P, Lv Y, Li M, Manchon A, Mkhoyan K A, Low T and Wang J-P 2018 Nat. Mater. 17 800
  38. [38]Wu H, Zhang P, Deng P, Lan Q, Pan Q, Razavi S A, Che X, Huang L, Dai B, Wong K, Han X and Wang K L 2019 Phys. Rev. Lett. 123 207205
  39. [39]Wang Y and Yang H 2022 Acc. Mater. Res. 3 1061
  40. [40]Wang H, Wu H, Zhang J, Liu Y, Chen D, Pandey C, Yin J, Wei D, Lei N, Shi S, Lu H, Li P, Fert A, Wang K L, Nie T and Zhao W 2023 Nat. Commun. 14 5173
  41. [41]Tai L, He H, Chong S K, et al. 2024 Adv. Mater. 36 2406772
  42. [42]Yu Z, Yang L, Guo K, Zhao P, Hou R, Du Y, Lai J M, Quan Z, Wang F and Xu X 2025 Adv. Funct. Mater. 2505170
  43. [43]Cai K, Yang M, Ju H, Wang S, Ji Y, Li B, Edmonds K W, Sheng Y, Zhang B, Zhang N, Liu S, Zheng H and Wang K 2017 Nat. Mater. 16 712
  44. [44]Liu Q and Zhu L 2022 Appl. Phys. Rev. 9 041401
  45. [45]Zheng Z, Zhang Y, Lopez-Dominguez V, Sánchez-Tejerina L, Shi J, Feng X, Chen L, Wang Z, Zhang Z, Zhang K, Hong B, Xu Y, Zhang Y, Carpentieri M, Fert A, Finocchio G, Zhao W and Khalili Amiri P 2021 Nat. Commun. 12 4555
  46. [46]Xie X, Zhao X, Dong Y, Qu X, Zheng K, Han X, Han X, Fan Y, Bai L, Chen Y, Dai Y, Tian Y and Yan S 2021 Nat. Commun. 12 2473
  47. [47]Wu H, Nance J, Razavi S A, Lujan D, Dai B, Liu Y, He H, Cui B, Wu D, Wong K, Sobotkiewich K, Li X, Carman G P and Wang K L 2020 Nano Lett. 21 515
  48. [48]Yu G, Upadhyaya P, Fan Y, Alzate J G, Jiang W, Wong K L, Takei S, Bender S A, Chang L-T, Jiang Y, Lang M, Tang J, Wang Y, Tserkovnyak Y, Amiri P K and Wang K L 2014 Nat. Nanotechnol. 9 548
  49. [49]MacNeill D, Stiehl G M, Guimaraes M H D, Buhrman R A, Park J and Ralph D C 2016 Nat. Phys. 13 300
  50. [50]Guimarães M H D, Stiehl G M, MacNeill D, Reynolds N D and Ralph D C 2018 Nano Lett. 18 1311
  51. [51]Shi S, Liang S, Zhu Z, Cai K, Pollard S D, Wang Y, Wang J, Wang Q, He P, Yu J, Eda G, Liang G and Yang H 2019 Nat. Nanotechnol. 14 945
  52. [52]Stiehl G M, MacNeill D, Sivadas N, El Baggari I, Guimarães M H D, Reynolds N D, Kourkoutis L F, Fennie C J, Buhrman R A and Ralph D C 2019 ACS Nano 13 2599
  53. [53]Stiehl G M, Li R, Gupta V, Baggari I E, Jiang S, Xie H, Kourkoutis L F, Mak K F, Shan J, Buhrman R A and Ralph D C 2019 Phys. Rev. B 100 184402
  54. [54]Shi S, Li J, Hsu C H, Lee K, Wang Y, Yang L, Wang J, Wang Q, Wu H, Zhang W, Eda G, Liang G, Chang H and Yang H 2021 Adv. Quantum Technol. 4 2100038
  55. [55]Liu L, Zhou C, Shu X, Li C, Zhao T, Lin W, Deng J, Xie Q, Chen S, Zhou J, Guo R, Wang H, Yu J, Shi S, Yang P, Pennycook S, Manchon A and Chen J 2021 Nat. Nanotechnol. 16 277
  56. [56]Kao I H, Muzzio R, Zhang H, Zhu M, Gobbo J, Yuan S, Weber D, Rao R, Li J, Edgar J H, Goldberger J E, Yan J, Mandrus D G, Hwang J, Cheng R, Katoch J and Singh S 2022 Nat. Mater. 21 1029
  57. [57]Liu Y, Shi G, Kumar D, Kim T, Shi S, Yang D, Zhang J, Zhang C, Wang F, Yang S, Pu Y, Yu P, Cai K and Yang H 2023 Nat. Electron. 6 732
  58. [58]Zhang Y, Xu H, Jia K, et al. 2023 Sci. Adv. 9 eadg9819
  59. [59]Kajale S N, Nguyen T, Hung N T, Li M and Sarkar D 2024 Sci. Adv. 10 eadk8669
  60. [60]Zhang Y Y, Ren X L, Liu R Z, Chen Z H, Wu X Z, Pang J, Wang W, Lan G B, Watanabe K, Taniguchi T, Shi Y G, Yu G Q and Shao Q M 2024 Adv. Mater. 36 2406464
  61. [61]Železný J, Zhang Y, Felser C and Yan B 2017 Phys. Rev. Lett. 119 187204
  62. [62]Kimata M, Chen H, Kondou K, Sugimoto S, Muduli P K, Ikhlas M, Omori Y, Tomita T, MacDonald A H, Nakatsuji S and Otani Y 2019 Nature 565 627
  63. [63]Liu Y, Liu Y F, Chen M J, Srivastava S, He P, Teo K L, Phung T, Yang S H and Yang H 2019 Phys. Rev. Appl. 12 064046
  64. [64]Nan T, Quintela C X, Irwin J, et al. 2020 Nat. Commun. 11 4671
  65. [65]Chen X Z, Shi S Y, Shi G Y, et al. 2021 Nat. Mater. 20 800
  66. [66]You Y F, Bai H, Feng X Y, Fan X L, Han L, Zhou X F, Zhou Y J, Zhang R Q, Chen T J, Pan F and Song C 2021 Nat. Commun. 12 6524
  67. [67]Hu S, Shao D F, Yang H L, Pan C, Fu Z X, Tang M, Yang Y M, Fan W J, Zhou S M, Tsymbal E Y and Qiu X P 2022 Nat. Commun. 13 4447
  68. [68]Meng D, Chen S, Ren C, Li J, Lan G, Li C, Liu Y, Su Y, Yu G, Chai G, Xiong R, Zhao W, Yang G and Liang S 2023 Adv. Electron. Mater. 10 2300665
  69. [69]Cao C, Chen S, Xiao R-C, Zhu Z, Yu G, Wang Y, Qiu X, Liu L, Zhao T, Shao D-F, Xu Y, Chen J and Zhan Q 2023 Nat. Commun. 14 5873
  70. [70]Han R K, Zhao X P, Qin H R, Sun H L, Wang H L, Wei D H and Zhao J H 2023 Phys. Rev. B 107 134422
  71. [71]Pu Y, Shi G, Yang Q, Yang D, Wang F, Zhang C and Yang H 2024 Adv. Funct. Mater. 34 2400143
  72. [72]Rimmler B H, Pal B and Parkin S S P 2024 Nat. Rev. Mater. 10 109
  73. [73]Bai H, Han L, Feng X Y, Zhou Y J, Su R X, Wang Q, Liao L Y, Zhu W X, Chen X Z, Pan F, Fan X L and Song C 2022 Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 197202
  74. [74]Bose A, Schreiber N J, Jain R, Shao D-F, Nair H P, Sun J, Zhang X S, Muller D A, Tsymbal E Y, Schlom D G and Ralph D C 2022 Nat. Electron. 5 267
  75. [75]González-Hernández R, Šmejkal L, Výborný K, Yahagi Y, Sinova J, Jungwirth T and Železný J 2021 Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 127701
  76. [76]Karube S, Tanaka T, Sugawara D, Kadoguchi N, Kohda M and Nitta J 2022 Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 137201
  77. [77]Zhang Y, Bai H, Han L, Chen C, Zhou Y, Back C H, Pan F, Wang Y and Song C 2024 Adv. Funct. Mater. 34 2313332
  78. [78]Liu Q, Lin X, Shaked A, Nie Z, Yu G and Zhu L 2024 Adv. Mater. 36 2406552
  79. [79]Lee D, Go D, Park H-J, Jeong W, Ko H-W, Yun D, Jo D, Lee S, Go G, Oh J H, Kim K-J, Park B-G, Min B-C, Koo H C, Lee H-W, Lee O and Lee K-J 2021 Nat. Commun. 12 6710
  80. [80]Hayashi H, Jo D, Go D, Gao T H, Haku S S, Mokrousov Y, Lee H W and Ando K 2023 Commun. Phys. 6 32
  81. [81]Wang P, Chen F, Yang Y H, Hu S, Li Y, Wang W H, Zhang D L and Jiang Y 2025 Adv. Electron. Mater. 11 2400554
  82. [82]Lee S, Kang M G, Go D, Kim D, Kang J H, Lee T, Lee G H, Kang J, Lee N J, Mokrousov Y, Kim S, Kim K J, Lee K J and Park B G 2021 Commun. Phys. 4 234
  83. [83]Guo Q, Ren Z, Bai H, Wang X, Yu G, He W, Teng J and Zhu T 2021 Phys. Rev. B 104 224429
  84. [84]Sala G and Gambardella P 2022 Phys. Rev. Res. 4 033037
  85. [85]Liao L, Xue F, Han L, Kim J, Zhang R, Li L, Liu J, Kou X, Song C, Pan F and Otani Y 2022 Phys. Rev. B 105 104434
  86. [86]Bose A, Kammerbauer F, Gupta R, Go D, Mokrousov Y, Jakob G and Kläui M 2023 Phys. Rev. B 107 134423
  87. [87]Yang Y, Wang P, Chen J, Zhang D, Pan C, Hu S, Wang T, Yue W, Chen C, Jiang W, Zhu L, Qiu X, Yao Y, Li Y, Wang W and Jiang Y 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 8645
  88. [88]Cornelissen L J, Liu J, Duine R A, Youssef J B and van Wees B J 2015 Nat. Phys. 11 1022
  89. [89]Kajiwara Y, Harii K, Takahashi S, Ohe J, Uchida K, Mizuguchi M, Umezawa H, Kawai H, Ando K, Takanashi K, Maekawa S and Saitoh E 2010 Nature 464 262
  90. [90]Lebrun R, Ross A, Bender S A, Qaiumzadeh A, Baldrati L, Cramer J, Brataas A, Duine R A and Kläui M 2018 Nature 561 222
  91. [91]Lee K, Lee D-K, Yang D, Mishra R, Kim D-J, Liu S, Xiong Q, Kim S K, Lee K-J and Yang H 2021 Nat. Nanotechnol. 16 1337
  92. [92]Dyakonov M I and Perel V 1971 Phys. Lett. A 35 459
  93. [93]Sinova J, Valenzuela S O, Wunderlich J, Back C H and Jungwirth T 2015 Rev. Mod. Phys. 87 1213
  94. [94]Edelstein V M 1990 Solid State Commun. 73 233
  95. [95]Manchon A, Koo H C, Nitta J, Frolov S M and Duine R A 2015 Nat. Mater. 14 871
  96. [96]Fang D, Kurebayashi H, Wunderlich J, Výborný K, Zárbo L P, Campion R P, Casiraghi A, Gallagher B L, Jungwirth T and Ferguson A J 2011 Nat. Nanotechnol. 6 413
  97. [97]Liu L, Moriyama T, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2011 Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 036601
  98. [98]Manchon A, Železný J, Miron I M, Jungwirth T, Sinova J, Thiaville A, Garello K and Gambardella P 2019 Rev. Mod. Phys. 91 035004
  99. [99]Pai C-F, Liu L, Li Y, Tseng H W, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2012 Appl. Phys. Lett. 101 122404
  100. [100]Zhu L, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2018 Phys. Rev. Appl. 10 031001
  101. [101]Laczkowski P, Fu Y, Yang H, Rojas-Sánchez J C, Noel P, Pham V T, Zahnd G, Deranlot C, Collin S, Bouard C, Warin P, Maurel V, Chshiev M, Marty A, Attané J P, Fert A, Jaffrès H, Vila L and George J M 2017 Phys. Rev. B 96 140405
  102. [102]Laczkowski P, Rojas-Sánchez J C, Savero-Torres W, Jaffrès H, Reyren N, Deranlot C, Notin L, Beigné C, Marty A, Attané J P, Vila L, George J M and Fert A 2014 Appl. Phys. Lett. 104 142403
  103. [103]Zhu L, Sobotkiewich K, Ma X, Li X, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2019 Adv. Funct. Mater. 29 1805822
  104. [104]Khang N H D, Ueda Y and Hai P N 2018 Nat. Mater. 17 808
  105. [105]Zhu L, Zhu L, Sui M, Ralph D C and Buhrman R A 2019 Sci. Adv. 5 eaav8025
  106. [106]Lin X, Li J, Zhu L, Xie X, Liu Q, Wei D, Yuan G and Zhu L 2022 Phys. Rev. B 106 L140407
  107. [107]Liu Q, Li J, Zhu L, Lin X, Xie X and Zhu L 2022 Phys. Rev. Appl. 18 054079
  108. [108]Mihai Miron I, Gaudin G, Auffret S, Rodmacq B, Schuhl A, Pizzini S, Vogel J and Gambardella P 2010 Nat. Mater. 9 230
  109. [109]Wang Y, Zhang Q, Xu H, Guo X, Chang Y, Zhang J, He X, Zuo Y, Cui B and Xi L 2024 Chin. Phys. Lett. 41 067502
  110. [110]Hasan M Z and Kane C L 2010 Rev. Mod. Phys. 82 3045
  111. [111]Qi X-L and Zhang S-C 2011 Rev. Mod. Phys. 83 1057
  112. [112]Wu H, Xu Y, Deng P, Pan Q, Razavi S A, Wong K, Huang L, Dai B, Shao Q, Yu G, Han X, Rojas - Sánchez J C, Mangin S and Wang K L 2019 Adv. Mater. 31 1901681
  113. [113]Cui B, Chen A, Zhang X, Fang B, Zeng Z, Zhang P, Zhang J, He W, Yu G, Yan P, Han X, Wang K L, Zhang X and Wu H 2023 Adv. Mater. 35 2302350
  114. [114]Choi G S, Park S, An E S, Bae J, Shin I, Kang B T, Won C J, Cheong S W, Lee H W, Lee G H, Cho W J and Kim J S 2024 Adv. Sci. 11 2400893
  115. [115]Wang Y, Deorani P, Banerjee K, Koirala N, Brahlek M, Oh S and Yang H 2015 Phys. Rev. Lett. 114 257202
  116. [116]Ramaswamy R, Dutta T, Liang S, Yang G, Saifullah M S M and Yang H 2019 J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 52 224001
  117. [117]Fan Y, Kou X, Upadhyaya P, Shao Q, Pan L, Lang M, Che X, Tang J, Montazeri M, Murata K, Chang L-T, Akyol M, Yu G, Nie T, Wong K L, Liu J, Wang Y, Tserkovnyak Y and Wang K L 2016 Nat. Nanotechnol. 11 352
  118. [118]Shao Q, Wu H, Pan Q, Zhang P, Pan L, Wong K, Che X and Wang K L 2018 IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), December 1-5, 2018, San Francisco, CA, USA, p. 36.3.1-36.3.4
  119. [119]Che X Y, Pan Q J, Vareskic B, Zou J Y, Pan L, Zhang P, Yin G, Wu H, Shao Q M, Deng P and Wang K L 2020 Adv. Mater. 32 1907661
  120. [120]Kondou K, Yoshimi R, Tsukazaki A, Fukuma Y, Matsuno J, Takahashi K S, Kawasaki M, Tokura Y and Otani Y 2016 Nat. Phys. 12 1027
  121. [121]Iyer V, Chen Y P and Xu X 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett. 121 026807
  122. [122]Hu S, Liu E, Bai Y, Zhuang M, Liu W, Lei M, Zhang Y, Xu G, Xu F and Mangin S 2024 Phys. Rev. B 109 224407
  123. [123]Chen S, Yu J, Xie Q, Zhang X, Lin W, Liu L, Zhou J, Shu X, Guo R, Zhang Z and Chen J 2019 ACS Appl. Mater. Inter. 11 30446
  124. [124]Fukami S, Zhang C, DuttaGupta S, Kurenkov A and Ohno H 2016 Nat. Mater. Oh Y-W, Chris Baek S-h, Kim Y M, Lee H Y, Lee K-D, Yang C-G, Park E-S, Lee K-S, Kim K-W, Go G, Jeong J-R, Min B-C, Lee H-W, Lee K-J and Park B-G 2016 Nat. Nanotechnol. 11 878
  125. [126]You L, Lee O, Bhowmik D, Labanowski D, Hong J, Bokor J and Salahuddin S 2015 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 112 10310
  126. [127]P V M, Ganesh K R and Kumar P S A 2017 Phys. Rev. B 96 104412
  127. [128]Liu L, Qin Q, Lin W, Li C, Xie Q, He S, Shu X, Zhou C, Lim Z, Yu J, Lu W, Li M, Yan X, Pennycook S J and Chen J 2019 Nat. Nanotechnol. 14 939
  128. [129]Liang Y, Yi D, Nan T, Liu S, Zhao L, Zhang Y, Chen H, Xu T, Dai M, Hu J-M, Xu B, Shi J, Jiang W, Yu R and Lin Y-H 2023 Nat. Commun. 14 5458
  129. [130]Wang M, Cai W, Zhu D, Wang Z, Kan J, Zhao Z, Cao K, Wang Z, Zhang Y, Zhang T, Park C, Wang J-P, Fert A and Zhao W 2018 Nat. Electron. 1 582
  130. [131]Fernández-Pacheco A, Vedmedenko E, Ummelen F, Mansell R, Petit D and Cowburn R P 2019 Nat. Mater. 18 679
  131. [132]He W, Wan C, Zheng C, Wang Y, Wang X, Ma T, Wang Y, Guo C, Luo X, Stebliy M E, Yu G, Liu Y, Ognev A V, Samardak A S and Han X 2022 Nano Lett. 22 6857
  132. [133]Dc M, Shao D-F, Hou V D H, et al. 2023 Nat. Mater. 22 591
  133. [134]Patton M, Gurung G, Shao D F, Noh G, Mittelstaedt J A, Mazur M, Kim J W, Ryan P J, Tsymbal E Y, Choi S Y, Ralph D C, Rzchowski M S, Nan T and Eom C B 2023 Adv. Mater. 35 2301608
  134. [135]Han F, Zhang J, Yang F, et al. 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 7299
  135. [136]Xu H, Wei J, Zhou H, Feng J, Xu T, Du H, He C, Huang Y, Zhang J, Liu Y, Wu H C, Guo C, Wang X, Guang Y, Wei H, Peng Y, Jiang W, Yu G and Han X 2020 Adv. Mater. 32 2000513
  136. [137]MacNeill D, Stiehl G M, Guimarães M H D, Reynolds N D, Buhrman R A and Ralph D C 2017 Phys. Rev. B 96 054450
  137. [138]Wang L, Xiong J, Cheng B, et al. 2022 Sci. Adv. 8 eabq6833
  138. [139]Shi G, Wang F, Liu Y, Li Z, Tan H R, Yang D, Soumyanarayanan A and Yang H 2024 Nano Lett. 24 7302
  139. [140]Xie Q, Lin W, Sarkar S, Shu X, Chen S, Liu L, Zhao T, Zhou C, Wang H, Zhou J, Gradečak S and Chen J 2021 APL Mater. 9 051114
  140. [141]Wei L J, Yin X M, Liu P, Zhang P C, Niu W, Liu P, Yang J J, Peng J C, Huang F, Liu R B, Chen J R, Chen L A, Zhou S, Li F, Niu X H, Du J and Pu Y 2023 Appl. Phys. Lett. 123 252404
  141. [142]Wang X, Wu H, Qiu R, Huang X, Zhang J, Long J, Yao Y, Zhao Y, Zhu Z, Wang J, Shi S, Chang H and Zhao W 2023 Cell Rep. Phys. Sci. 4 101468
  142. [143]Liang S, Shi S, Hsu C H, Cai K, Wang Y, He P, Wu Y, Pereira V M and Yang H 2020 Adv. Mater. 32 2002799
  143. [144]Patton M, Pharis D A, Gurung G, Huang X, Noh G, Tsymbal E Y, Choi S Y, Ralph D C, Rzchowski M S and Eom C B 2025 Adv. Mater. 37 2414267
  144. [145]Lu S, Meng D, Khan A, Wang Z, Chen S and Liang S 2024 Chinese Physics B 33 107501
  145. [146]Gurung G, Elekhtiar M, Luo Q-Q, Shao D-F and Tsymbal E Y 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 10242
  146. [147]Bai L, Feng W, Liu S, Šmejkal L, Mokrousov Y and Yao Y 2024 Adv. Funct. Mater. 34 2409327
  147. [148]Song C, Bai H, Zhou Z, Han L, Reichlova H, Dil J H, Liu J, Chen X and Pan F 2025 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41578-025-00779-1
  148. [149]Nagaosa N, Sinova J, Onoda S, MacDonald A H and Ong N P 2010 Rev. Mod. Phys. 82 1539
  149. [150]Nakatsuji S, Kiyohara N and Higo T 2015 Nature 527 212
  150. [151]Kondou K, Chen H, Tomita T, Ikhlas M, Higo T, MacDonald A H, Nakatsuji S and Otani Y 2021 Nat. Commun. 12 6491
  151. [152]Liang S, Han L, You Y, Bai H, Pan F and Song C 2023 Phys. Rev. B 107 184427
  152. [153]Zhao Q, Zhang T, He B, Li Z, Zhang S, Yu G, Wang J, Liu Q and Wei J 2024 Chinese Physics B 33 058502
  153. [154]Bai H, Zhang Y C, Han L, Zhou Y J, Pan F and Song C 2022 Appl. Phys. Rev. 9 041316
  154. [155]Šmejkal L, Sinova J and Jungwirth T 2022 Phys. Rev. X 12 031042
  155. [156]Fedchenko O, Minár J, Akashdeep A, et al. 2024 Sci. Adv. 10 eadj4883
  156. [157]Lin Z, Chen D, Lu W, Liang X, Feng S, Yamagami K, Osiecki J, Leandersson M, Thiagarajan B, Liu J, Felser C and Ma J 2024 arXiv: 2402.04995 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]arxiv.org/abs/2402.04995
  157. [158]Krempaský J, Šmejkal L, D’Souza S W, et al. 2024 Nature 626 517
  158. [159]Lee S, Lee S, Jung S, Jung J, Kim D, Lee Y, Seok B, Kim J, Park B G, Šmejkal L, Kang C-J and Kim C 2024 Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 036702
  159. [160]Hajlaoui M, Wilfred D'Souza S, Šmejkal L, Kriegner D, Krizman G, Zakusylo T, Olszowska N, Caha O, Michalička J, Sánchez-Barriga J, Marmodoro A, Výborný K, Ernst A, Cinchetti M, Minar J, Jungwirth T and Springholz G 2024 Adv. Mater. 36 2314076
  160. [161]Amin O J, Dal Din A, Golias E, et al. 2024 Nature 636 348
  161. [162]Hariki A, Dal Din A, Amin O J, Yamaguchi T, Badura A, Kriegner D, Edmonds K W, Campion R P, Wadley P, Backes D, Veiga L S I, Dhesi S S, Springholz G, Šmejkal L, Výborný K, Jungwirth T and Kuneš J 2024 Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 176701
  162. [163]Reimers S, Odenbreit L, Smejkal L, Strocov V N, Constantinou P, Hellenes A B, Ubiergo R J, Campos W H, Bharadwaj V K, Chakraborty A, Denneulin T, Shi W, Dunin-Borkowski R E, Das S, Kläui M, Sinova J and Jourdan M 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 2116
  163. [164]Ding J, Jiang Z, Chen X, et al. 2024 Phys. Rev. Lett. 133 206401
  164. [165]Zeng M, Zhu M-Y, Zhu Y-P, et al. 2024 Adv. Sci. 11 2406529
  165. [166]Li C, Hu M, Li Z, Wang Y, Chen W, Balasubramanian, Thiagarajan, Leandersson M, Polley C, Kim T, Liu H, Fulga C, Vergniory M G, Janson O, Tjernberg O and Brink J v d 2024 arXiv: 2405.14777 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]DOI
  166. [167]Yang G, Li Z, Yang S, et al. 2025 Nat. Commun. 16 1442
  167. [168]Lu W, Feng S, Wang Y, Chen D, Lin Z, Liang X, Liu S, Feng W, Yamagami K,
  168. [195]Jo D, Go D and Lee H-W 2018 Phys. Rev. B 98 214405
  169. [196]Bhowal S and Satpathy S 2020 Phys. Rev. B 101 121112(R)
  170. [197]Bhowal S and Satpathy S 2020 Phys. Rev. B 102 035409
  171. [198]Canonico L M, Cysne T P, Molina-Sanchez A, Muniz R B and Rappoport T G 2020 Phys. Rev. B 101 161409(R)
  172. [199]Canonico L M, Cysne T P, Rappoport T G and Muniz R B 2020 Phys. Rev. B 101 075429
  173. [200]Cysne T P, Costa M, Canonico L M, Nardelli M B, Muniz R B and Rappoport T G 2021 Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 056601
  174. [201]Cysne T P, Bhowal S, Vignale G and Rappoport T G 2022 Phys. Rev. B 105 195421
  175. [202]Salemi L and Oppeneer P M 2022 Phys. Rev. Mater. 6 095001
  176. [203]Liu H and Culcer D 2024 Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 186302
  177. [204]Sahu P, Bidika J K, Biswal B, Satpathy S and Nanda B R K 2024 Phys. Rev. B 110 054403
  178. [205]Fukunaga R, Haku S, Gao T, Hayashi H and Ando K 2024 Phys. Rev. B 109 144412
  179. [206]Xie H, Zhang N, Ma Y, Chen X, Ke L and Wu Y 2023 Nano Lett. 23 10274
  180. [207]Lyalin I, Alikhah S, Berritta M, Oppeneer P M and Kawakami R K 2023 Phys. Rev. Lett. 131 156702
  181. [208]Zheng Z, Zeng T, Zhao T, Shi S, Ren L, Zhang T, Jia L, Gu Y, Xiao R, Zhou H, Zhang Q, Lu J, Wang G, Zhao C, Li H, Tay B K and Chen J 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 745
  182. [209]Baek I and Lee H-W 2021 Phys. Rev. B 104 245204
  183. [210]Gao T, Rüßmann P, Wang Q, Fukunaga R, Hayashi H, Go D, Harumoto T, Tu R, Zhang S, Zhang L, Mokrousov Y, Shi J and Ando K 2024 Nat. Phys. 20 1896
  184. [211]Tokatly I V 2010 Phys. Rev. B 82 161404
  185. [212]Bhowal S and Vignale G 2021 Phys. Rev. B 103 195309
  186. [213]Costa M, Focassio B, Canonico L M, Cysne T P, Schleder G R, Muniz R B, Fazzio A and Rappoport T G 2023 Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 116204
  187. [214]Chen Z, Li R, Bai Y, Mao N, Zeer M, Go D, Dai Y, Huang B, Mokrousov Y and Niu C 2024 Nano Lett. 24 4826
  188. [215]Zhang D, Wei H, Duan J, Chen J, Yue D, Yang Y, Gou J, Yan J, Zhai K and Wang P 2024 arXiv: 2412.04872 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]arxiv.org/abs/2412.04872
  189. [216]Huang Q, Liu S, Yang T, Xie R, Cai L, Cao Q, Lü W, Bai L, Tian Y and Yan S 2023 Nano Lett. 23 11323
  190. [217]Bi L Z, Ke J, Bai H, Li G, Zhu Z, Hu C, Cheng Y, Wang P, Jiang W, Zhang Y and Cai J W 2023 Adv. Electron. Mater. 10 2300627
  191. [218]Chen T-Y, Hsiao Y-C, Liao W-B and Pai C-F 2022 Phys. Rev. Appl. 17 064005
  192. [219]An H, Kageyama Y, Kanno Y, Enishi N and Ando K 2016 Nat. Commun. 7 13069
  193. [220]Gao T, Qaiumzadeh A, An H, Musha A, Kageyama Y, Shi J and Ando K 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett. 121 017202
  194. [221]Kageyama Y, Tazaki Y, An H, Harumoto T, Gao T, Shi J and Ando K 2019 Sci. Adv. 5 eaax4278
  195. [222]Yoda T, Yokoyama T and Murakami S 2018 Nano Lett. 18 916
  196. [223]Salemi L, Berritta M, Nandy A K and Oppeneer P M 2019 Nat. Commun. 10 5381
  197. [224]Ding S, Wang H, Legrand W, Noël P and Gambardella P 2024 Nano Lett. 24 10251
  198. [225]Xiao Z-Y, Li Y-J, Zhang W, Han Y-J, Li D, Chen Q, Zeng Z-M, Quan Z-Y and Xu X-H 2022 Appl. Phys. Lett. 121 072404
  199. [226]Chumak A V, Vasyuchka V I, Serga A A and Hillebrands B 2015 Nat. Phys. 11 453
  200. [227]Gurevich A G and Melkov G A 2020 Magnetization oscillations and waves (London: CRC press)DOI
  201. [228]Uchida K, Takahashi S, Harii K, Ieda J, Koshibae W, Ando K, Maekawa S and Saitoh E 2008 Nature 455 778
  202. [229]Bauer G E W, Saitoh E and van Wees B J 2012 Nat. Mater. 11 391
  203. [230]Siegrist F, Gessner J A, Ossiander M, Denker C, Chang Y-P, Schröder M C, Guggenmos A, Cui Y, Walowski J, Martens U, Dewhurst J K, Kleineberg U, Münzenberg M, Sharma S and Schultze M 2019 Nature 571 240
  204. [231]Li J, Wilson C B, Cheng R, Lohmann M, Kavand M, Yuan W, Aldosary M, Agladze N, Wei P, Sherwin M S and Shi J 2020 Nature 578 70
  205. [232]Parsonnet E, Caretta L, Nagarajan V, Zhang H, Taghinejad H, Behera P, Huang X, Kavle P, Fernandez A, Nikonov D, Li H, Young I, Analytis J and Ramesh R 2022 Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 087601
  206. [233]Chai Y, Liang Y, Xiao C, et al. 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 5975
  207. [234]Han J, Zhang P, Hou J T, Siddiqui S A and Liu L 2019 Science 366 1121
  208. [235]Han J, Cheng R, Liu L, Ohno H and Fukami S 2023 Nat. Mater. 22 684
  209. [236]Fan Y, Gross M J, Fakhrul T, Finley J, Hou J T, Ngo S, Liu L and Ross C A 2023 Nat. Nanotechnol. 18 1000
  210. [237]Zhu L, Zhu L and Buhrman R A 2021 Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 107204
  211. [238]Zhu D, Zhang T, Fu X, Hao R, Hamzić A, Yang H, Zhang X, Zhang H, Du A, Xiong D, Shi K, Yan S, Zhang S, Fert A and Zhao W 2022 Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 217702
  212. [239]Moriyama T, Takei S, Nagata M, Yoshimura Y, Matsuzaki N, Terashima T, Tserkovnyak Y and Ono T 2015 Appl. Phys. Lett. 106 162406
  213. [240]Zheng D, Lan J, Fang B, Li Y, Liu C, Ledesma - Martin J O, Wen Y, Li P, Zhang C, Ma Y, Qiu Z, Liu K, Manchon A and Zhang X 2022 Adv. Mater. 34 2203038
  214. [241]Zheng D, Tang M, Xu J, Liu C, Li Y, Chen A, Algaidi H, Alsayafi F, Chen M, Ma Y, Zhang S, Zhang L, Li P and Zhang X 2024 Appl. Phys. Lett. 124 102406
  215. [242]Guo C Y, Wan C H, Zhao M K, Fang C, Ma T Y, Wang X, Yan Z R, He W Q, Xing Y W, Feng J F and Han X F 2021 Phys. Rev. B 104 094412
  216. [243]Wang H, Finley J, Zhang P, Han J, Hou J T and Liu L 2019 Phys. Rev. Appl. 11 044070
  217. [244]Shi G, Wang F, Tan H R, Zhao S, Liu Y, Yang D, Lee K, Pu Y, Yang S, Soumyanarayanan A and Yang H 2023 Phys. Rev. Appl. 19 034039
  218. [245]Zhao P, Shi G, Lu W, Yang L, Tan H R, Guo K, Lai J-M, Yu Z, Soumyanarayanan A, Yuan Z, Wang F, Xu X and Yang H 2025 arXiv: 2501.15762 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]arxiv.org/abs/2501.15762
  219. [246]Wang F, Shi G, Yang D, Tan H R, Zhang C, Lei J, Pu Y, Yang S, Soumyanarayanan A, Elyasi M and Yang H 2024 Nat. Nanotechnol. 19 1478
  220. [247]Zhao T, Scholl A, Zavaliche F, Lee K, Barry M, Doran A, Cruz M P, Chu Y H, Ederer C, Spaldin N A, Das R R, Kim D M, Baek S H, Eom C B and Ramesh R 2006 Nat. Mater. 5 823
  221. [248]Chu Y-H, Martin L W, Holcomb M B, Gajek M, Han S-J, He Q, Balke N, Yang C-H, Lee D, Hu W, Zhan Q, Yang P-L, Fraile-Rodríguez A, Scholl A, Wang S X and Ramesh R 2008 Nat. Mater. 7 478
  222. [249]Lee J-E, Wang A, Chen S, Kwon M, Hwang J, Cho M, Son K-H, Han D-S, Choi J W, Kim Y D, Mo S-K, Petrovic C, Hwang C, Park S Y, Jang C and Ryu H 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 3971
  223. [250]Chakraborty A, González Hernández R, Šmejkal L and Sinova J 2024 Phys. Rev. B 109 144421
  224. [251]Belashchenko K D 2025 Phys. Rev. Lett. 134 086701
  225. [252]Smolyanyuk A, Mazin I I, Garcia-Gassull L and Valentí R 2024 Phys. Rev. B 109 134424
  226. [253]Keßler P, Garcia-Gassull L, Suter A, Prokscha T, Salman Z, Khalyavin D, Manuel P, Orlandi F, Mazin I I, Valentí R and Moser S 2024 npj Spintron. 2 50
  227. [254]Hiraishi M, Okabe H, Koda A, Kadono R, Muroi T, Hirai D and Hiroi Z 2024 Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 166702
  228. [255]Liu J, Zhan J, Li T, et al. 2024 Phys. Rev. Lett. 133 176401
  229. [256]Gyo Jeong S, Choi I H, Nair S, Buiarelli L, Pourbahari B, Oh J Y, Bassim N, Hirai D, Seo A, Choi W S, Fernandes R M, Birol T, Zhao L, Lee J S and Jalan B 2024 arXiv: 2405.05838 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]
  230. [257]Weber M, Wust S, Haag L, Akashdeep A, Leckron K, Schmitt C, Ramos R, Kikkawa T, Saitoh E, Kläui M, Šmejkal L, Sinova J, Aeschlimann M, Jakob G, Stadtmüller B and Schneider H C 2024 arXiv: 2408.05187 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]arxiv.org/abs/2408.05187
  231. [258]Beaulieu S, Schusser J, Dong S, Schüler M, Pincelli T, Dendzik M, Maklar J, Neef A, Ebert H, Hricovini K, Wolf M, Braun J, Rettig L, Minár J and Ernstorfer R 2020 Phys. Rev. Lett. 125 216404
  232. [259]Beaulieu S, Schüler M, Schusser J, Dong S, Pincelli T, Maklar J, Neef A, Reinert F, Wolf M, Rettig L, Minár J and Ernstorfer R 2021 npj Quantum Mater. 6 93
  233. [260]Patton M, Go D, Pharis D A, Huang X, Gurung G, Tsymbal E Y, Ralph D C, Rzchowski M S, Mokrousov Y and Eom C-B 2024 arXiv: 2410.02996 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]arxiv.org/abs/2410.02996
  234. [261]Liu Q and Zhu L 2025 arXiv: 2501.10260 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]arxiv.org/abs/2501.10260
  235. [262]Rang M and Kelly P J 2024 Phys. Rev. B 109 214427
  236. [263]Song Y, Tian J, Zheng F, Dong J, Zhu M and Zhang J 2025 arXiv: 2503.00910 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci]arxiv.org/abs/2503.00910

Paper details

vlnc:W_b8h2ew6r
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents