betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Optimisation of amplification and gas mixture for directional Dark Matter searches with the CYGNO/INITIUM project

Abstract

Astrophysical and cosmological observations suggest the existence of beyond standard model ingredient known as dark matter (DM). One of the most supported class of theories suggests that DM is composed of weakly interactive massive particles (WIMPs), possibly detectable via weak interaction with standard matter resulting in the recoil of the latter. The motion of the Sun and Earth with respect to the Galactic Centre is expected to induce a strong directional dependence in the recoil spectrum. Direct detection experiments capable of measuring the angular features of the recoils gain access to a wide range of advantages such as the possibility to positively claim a discovery of DM. The CYGNO project sets into this context, with the aim of deploying a large directional detector for rare event searches as DM. It exploits a gaseous time projection chamber filled with a He:CF4 gas mixture with a segmented amplification stage and granular optical readout. In this thesis, it is presented the work carried out with small CYGNO prototypes to maximise the light yield without degrading spatial and energy resolution, the addition of highly electronegative gases to induce a reduction of the electron cloud diffusion while drifting towards the amplification stage, very relevant to precisely measure the topological information of the recoil tracks. Moreover, the potential performances of directional detectors in the context of a direct DM search are analysed with the use of rigorous statistical tools both in the improvement in setting limits in the WIMP to nucleon sensitivity and in the capability of discerning two different DM models exploiting a directional detector.

Gran Sasso Science Institute

Astroparticle Physics

PhD in Astroparticle Physics

G S

GRAN SASSO SCIENCE INSTITUTE

S I

SCHOOL OF ADVANCED STUDIES

Scuola Universitaria Superiore

Supervisor: Prof.ssa Elisabetta Baracchini

Candidate: Giorgio Dho

Astrophysical and cosmological observations performed within the last century provide extensive evidences that the comprehension of the Universe is not complete and that an ingredient known as dark matter (DM) is required to interpret the measurements. One of the most supported class of theories suggests that dark matter is composed of weakly interactive massive particles (WIMPs). As the Milky Way is expected to reside in a halo of these particles, a possible experimental methodology to observe them is to exploit the potential weak interaction between WIMPs and standard matter, which results in the recoil of the latter. Due to the strength of this interaction, direct detection experiments for WIMPs are searching for ultra rare events, by exposing large volume of instrumented mass to detect recoils of regular matter. The motion of the Sun and Earth with respect to the Galactic Rest Frame and the foreseen non relativistic nature of the WIMPs, induces an apparent wind of DM particles coming from the Cygnus constellation, which imprints a strong directional dependence in the recoil spectrum. Direct detection experiments capable of measuring the angular features of the recoils gain access to a wide range of advantages. These include the possibility to positively claim a discovery of DM, along with the ability to constrain DM properties. The CYGNO project sets into this context, with the aim to deploy a large directional detector for rare event searches as DM. It comprises a gaseous time projection chamber filled with a He:CF4\mathrm{CF}_{4} gas mixture, an amplification stage based on a triple stack of gas electron multiplier (GEM) optically readout employing scientific CMOS cameras and photomultiplier tubes (PMTs). This setup allows to perform the imaging of the recoil tracks, measuring on an event by event basis the energy, the direction and the topology of the tracks.

The advantage of the optical readout through sCMOS cameras is that it allows to image large areas with an high granularity but a reduced amount of sensors. The major drawback is that the resulting small solid angle coverage of the optical setup ends up limiting the number of photons that reach the light detectors, effectively affecting the energy threshold. In this thesis, it is presented the work carried out with small CYGNO prototypes in order to maximise the light yield without degrading spatial and energy resolution. Different number of GEMs of various thicknesses are tested together with the addition of an extra electrode to produce strong electric fields below the last GEM. The latter addition proved to be an innovative way to enhance the light production below the GEM holes for the He:CF4\mathrm{CF}_{4} gas mixture, which allowed to improve the light yield by a

Acknowledgements

Part of this project is funded by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the ERC Consolidator Grant Agreement No 818744.

In questo percorso di quattro anni abbondanti, tantissime persone mi sono state accanto in vari momenti e mi hanno aiutato ancora a crescere e maturare. Innanzi tutto ringrazio la Prof.ssa Baracchini, mia advisor. Mi ha insegnato tanto, sia dentro sia fuori dal laboratorio, dalla prima settimana dentro il bunker a Frascati fino all’ultima settimana nell’ormai collaudato e attrezzato laboratorio al Gran Sasso. Inoltre sono grato anche per la sua pazienza e aiuto nella stesura della tesi!

Una persona molto importante da ringraziare per questi anni è sicuramente Cecilia che, nonostante la lontananza, mi ha aiutato e insieme abbiamo condiviso gioie, feste, viaggi, sogni, insomma tutto. Il suo senso pratico mi ha spesso direzionato saldamente verso le decisioni prese e mi ha su/opportato durante la scrittura della tesi.

Ringrazio anche tanto la mia famiglia, mamma, papà e mio fratello, per tutte le quasi regolari chiamate skype domenicali e per farmi sentire sempre a casa. Il loro supporto si è fatto sentire da sempre, quando mi hanno accompagnato a L’Aquila e in questi anni ogni volta ne avessi bisogno.

Ringrazio il GSSI che permette a noi studenti di fruire di un percorso di dottorato di alto livello fornendo un ambiente altamente stimolante e pieno di persone che diventano amici e che alla fine si trasformano in una nuova famiglia da cui imparare tradizioni, conoscere luoghi e soprattutto mangiare cibi da tutto il mondo.

In modo particolare una menzione importante va alla mia classe del 34° Asish, Δημητρης (I know the last letter is wrong!), Teena, Francesca, Tomislav, Benedikt, Vittoria, Priyanka, Samuele, Mattia (sempre adottato dai fisici!) e Sig. Pilo per le mille cene e avventure di questi anni. In particolare ringrazio Dimitris per la compagnia nel basket in tutte le salse e Francesca e Vittoria, tra le altre cose, per avermi involontariamente spinto a suonare uno strumento.

Un ringraziamento particolare va a Benedikt in quanto mio primo storico coinquilino. Insieme abbiamo passato la quarantena, il trasloco, gli insetti e un sacco di altre avventure. Inoltre gli sono grato per avermi riavvicinato a Age of Empires!

Un altro ringraziamento speciale va a Mattia Seagull. Dopo esserci conosciuti a Torino e ritrovati a L’Aquila abbiamo trascorso 4 anni di follie e anche coinquilinaggio pazzesco, dalle feste, alla bici con una mano rotta, alle sciate, al basket e anche alle briciole sul tavolo.

Un’altra persona importante è Giulia con cui mi sono divertito tantissimo e ho condiviso moltissimo specie nell’ultimo anno, dallo sport alla vita di tutti i giorni.

Ringrazio anche Carlo con cui le lunghe chiacchierate e riflessioni hanno aggiunto tantissime sfaccettature alla mia esperienza a L’Aquila oltre a fornirmi, come Giulia, uno sguardo in un campo di ricerca completamente lontano dal mio. E non può mancare anche Cecilia con tutte le serate e gli aperitivi matti al bar del corso.

Vorrei sottolineare il grande ruolo dei cygni del GSSI, Samuele, Flaminia, Atul, David e André con cui abbiamo condiviso molto apertamente il lavoro, la frustrazione (siamo sperimentali) e il divertimento (siamo sperimentali) in questi anni. In particolare, Samuele e David, mastro e compagno di laboratorio fin dal principio, per le feste, compagnia e supporto continuo.

Una menzione particolare va a tutti i Cygners con cui ho potuto in qualche modo lavorare soprattutto Davide, Giovanni e Stefano. Inoltre sono grato a William per il lavoro svolto insieme, prima collaborazione personale intercontinentale del mio dottorato.

Per la facilità, immediatezza e naturalezza con cui sono stato accolto e incluso voglio ringraziare i due gruppi di basket e in particolare Fabio e Moreno grazie a cui non mi sono spiaggiato e ho finalmente riportato la mia prima frattura.

Inoltre ringrazio i miei amici a Torino che riesco a vedere ogni volta che torno su e con cui mi confronto sempre, Giorgio, Bob, Luke e Cocco.

Tutte queste persone insieme alla moltitudine di cui non ho modo di scrivere, come i nuovi amici del Del Nuovo, sono state ingredienti per questa tempesta perfetta che è stato il mio dottorato.

Introduction

The last sixty years saw the flourishing of fundamental particle physics, with the development and experimental verification of the Standard Model (SM), capped with the discovery of the Higgs Boson in 2012. Recent years also witnessed the first detection of gravitational waves, phenomena predicted by the fundamental theory of gravity, the General Relativity. This detection, followed by many others, marked an extreme agreement of experimental data with the theoretical predictions. Yet, the SM is known to have various limitations and issues, such as the complete lack of the description of the gravitational force. Moreover, at the same time, numerous astrophysical and cosmological observations suggest the knowledge of the Universe is still incomplete, with the leading cosmological model, the Λ\LambdaCDM, advocating for the existence of new constituents of the Universe, the dark matter (DM) and the dark energy. In particular, DM is observed to behave gravitationally as a mass, challenging the current knowledge of either gravity or particle physics. One of the most supported hypotheses speculates that DM is composed of one or more types of particles different from the ones described in the Standard Model. Indeed, theories such as the supersymmetric model or the QCD axions were developed in order to tackle some issues of the Standard Model and ended up predicting the existence of a particle which turned out to be a perfect candidate for DM. Among these, the Weakly Interactive Massive Particles (WIMPs) are a class of DM matter candidates in which DM consists in a non relativistic, with GeV/c2\mathrm{GeV}/c^2 to TeV/c2\mathrm{TeV}/c^2 masses, that weakly interacts with Standard Model particles. Indeed, a stable, weakly-interacting particle in thermal equilibrium with the early Universe would be able to reproduce the observed relic DM density.

The measurements of the rotation curve of the Milky Way suggest the presence of high concentrations of DM at the Galactic radius of the Sun, with an halo embedding the entire Galaxy. Assuming DM can interact with SM matter other than gravitationally, in order to detect it, it is possible to exploit the weak interaction with regular matter and measure the recoils induced by a DM interaction. This is known as direct detection and the fundamental strategy is to expose large amount of instrumented mass and wait for DM to produce recoils in it. Direct detection experiments look for nuclear recoils of low energy, 1-100 keV, with an expected rate below 1 event per kg year. Such very low expected rates imply detectors with extremely challenging requirements on the allowed experimental backgrounds. Classical background minimisation techniques are deep underground operation (to suppress cosmic rays), use of radio-pure components (to avoid natural radioactivity) and active or passive shielding of the detector. The motion of the Sun and Earth around the centre of the Galaxy induces an apparent wind of WIMPs coming from a fixed direction in the frame of reference in which the Galaxy is at rest. This motion imprints a strong directional feature in the distribution of the recoils, which cannot be mimicked by any form of background, also thanks to the rotation of the Earth around its own axis. Thus, differently from the energy distribution of the recoils, which is expected to possess a generic falling exponential shape, the access to the angular distribution opens the possibility for a positive claim for a DM discovery and even constrain some characteristics of the DM models.

The CYGNO project intends to construct a large, O(30) m3O(30)\ \mathrm{m}^{3}, directional detector for rare event searches, such as DM. The detector is a gaseous time projection chamber, a detector intrinsically sensitive to the topology of the recoil tracks which allows to measure their direction. A helium and fluorine rich gas mixture is employed, in order to be sensitive to both spin-dependent and spin-independent interactions. CYGNO will be equipped with an amplification stage composed of three gas electron multipliers (GEMs) and will be optically readout with photomultiplier tubes and scientific CMOS cameras. The latter allows to image large readout areas with high sensitivity while maintaining extremely good granularity. This, in turn, grants the capability to measure the direction of the recoils. Various CYGNO prototypes have been built and tested both overground and underground, to determine their performances and their viability in a realistic environment for the DM search.

This work has been carried out in the context of the CYGNO experiment with the goal of optimising the light yield and diffusion properties of the detector. These are extremely relevant parameters as they directly characterise the quality direction and energy can be measured with. In addition, an assessment of the potential of such directional detectors in the directional search is dealt with in this work. The structure of the thesis is outlined in the following.

In Chapter 1, a brief overview of the theoretical arguments and experimental observations which lead to consider the existence of DM a paradigm of modern physics is presented. The Chapter also addresses the most relevant theoretical models which are proposed to explain its nature.

In Chapter 2, the phenomenology of the WIMP scattering with nuclei is given in the context of the direct detection of DM. The basic principles, the observables and the challenges of the direct detection technique are also discussed and the current status of the direct detection is presented. In addition, large focus is dedicated to the directional search, presenting its numerous advantages and portraying the state of the art of directional detectors for DM searches.

In Chapter 3, an extensive description of the CYGNO experiment is provided. The concept of the detector is thoroughly described with particular attention to the main feature of the CYGNO project, the optical readout. The most important results obtained with several prototypes are also depicted and a glimpse to the future prospects is furnished.

Dark matter

In the last decades, the fact that a broad number of astrophysical and cosmological observations is suggesting that something is lacking in the description of the Universe has become a well established paradigm of modern physics. The measurements indicate that an ingredient different from the known forces and particles is required to account for the experimental findings. As it behaves like a mass, it is also known as dark matter (DM). Even though experimental efforts in the years unveiled details of its phenomenology, its nature is still elusive and unknown. One of the most credited possible explanations assumes that this is indeed a form of matter which makes up the 84% of total [1] and plays a fundamental role in the formation of the organised structures of the Universe [2]. A plethora of theoretical models have being trying to correctly describe this elusive phenomena, while experimental efforts have being relentlessly aimed at detecting clear signatures of DM, pushing the current research activities to become very active and relevant in the context of present and future research. In the following, Section 1.1 is dedicated to a short overview on the astrophysical and cosmological measurements which lead to DM hypothesis, whilst Section 1.2 focuses on the description of the most supported theoretical explanation of this phenomenon.

Evidence for dark matter

Evidences for the presence of an ulterior ingredient to the Universe, commonly referred to as dark matter (DM), are present is many astronomical observations spanning all the scales of the Universe, from single galaxies to the largest structures. In the following Sections, the most critical and decisive will be briefly illustrated, starting from the galactic scale up to the cosmological one. For a more comprehensive review, see the reference [3].

Galactic rotation curves

One of the most compelling and established evidences of DM derives from the observation of the rotation curves of spiral galaxies, including the Milky Way [4, 5]. In these galaxies, most of the stars are located in the central part, called bulge, around which largely flat spiral arms composed of stars and gas clouds are moving in approximately circular orbits. The rotation curve is the profile of the circular velocities of the stars and gas clouds of the galaxy along the radial distance from the centre. When considering a rotating galaxy as a closed system, an object of mass mm at a radius RR from the centre is subject to a centripetal force equal to the gravitational force of the overall mass present within the same radius M(R)M(R):

mv2R=GM(R)mR2,(1)\frac{m v^2}{R} = \frac{G M(R) m}{R^2}, \tag*{(1)}

with GG the gravitational constant and vv the circular velocity of the object with mass mm. Hence, the rotational velocity of the constituents of a galaxy can be expressed as a function of RR and of the total mass MM as:

v=GM(R)R.(2)v = \sqrt{\frac{G M(R)}{R}}. \tag*{(2)}

It is reasonable to assume that the large majority of the mass of a galaxy is located within a characteristic radius RcR_{\mathrm{c}}, estimated by measurements to fall between 5 and 10 kpc [4]. So, for R<RcR < R_{\mathrm{c}} the mass density can be adopted as uniform, therefore M(R)M(R) grows linearly with the volume and the velocity rises linearly with RR. Instead, for R>RcR > R_{\mathrm{c}} the the mass M is constant and the velocity decreases as R\sqrt{R}. The rotation curve can be measured via the Doppler shift of the 21 cm emission line of the of the HI. A large set of rotation curves, extending well beyond the optical limit and down 200 kpc, has been measured, exhibiting similar results. Figure 1.1 shows, as an example, the experimental findings on the rotation curve of the galaxy NGC6503 [5]. The measured orbital velocity increases linearly as expected at small radii but stays constant at large radii, contrary to expectation. This flatness suggested the existence of an additional and invisible mass in the form of a dark galactic halo around any spiral galaxy, which does not interact electromagnetically. This halo of matter appears to be consistent at first order to a spherical distribution with a density proportional to R−2R^{-2}.

Rotation curve measurement of the galaxy NGC6503

Figure 1.1. Example of the rotation curve measurement of the galaxy NGC6503, taken from [5]. The solid line represents the combined fit of the data, while the dashed refers to the gas component, the dotted to the visible one, and the dash-dotted to the DM.

Galaxy clusters velocity dispersion

Galaxy clusters are systems composed of thousands of galaxies and gas clouds gravitationally bound to each other. By applying the Virial theorem, it is possible to relate their time average kinetic energy to the total gravitational potential energy of the system [6]:

∑imivi2=∑i∑j≠iGmimjrij(3)\sum_i m_i v_i^2 = \sum_i \sum_{j \ne i} \frac{Gm_i m_j}{r_{ij}} \tag*{(3)}

with ii and jj representing the index on the galaxies of the cluster, mm the mass of a galaxy, vv the time average velocity of the galaxy, GG the gravitational constant and rijr_{ij} the distance between the galaxies ii and jj. By performing an average on the galaxies, a relation can be obtained that correlates the total mass of the cluster to the dispersion of the velocities of its galaxies:

M≃53RG⟨v2⟩G,(4)M \simeq\frac{5}{3}R_G\frac{\langle v^2\rangle}{G}, \tag*{(4)}

where it is assumed that the galaxies are uniformly distributed in a sphere of radius RGR_G.

The application of the Virial theorem to the Coma Cluster by Zwicky in 1933 provided the first experimental observation of a missing mass component in the Universe [6,7]. By measuring the line of sight velocities of the galaxies of this globular cluster via redshift and assuming a spherical distribution, Zwicky obtained the velocity dispersion of the Coma cluster and its gravitational mass through the Virial theorem. In parallel, Zwicky estimated the cluster mass from its luminous component assuming an average luminosity to mass ratio of galaxies. The mass estimated from the gravitational component resulted O(102)O(10^2) larger than measured luminous mass, advocating for the presence of matter in the galaxy cluster structure that is not interacting electromagnetically. Many other measurements on different galaxy clusters soon followed with consistent results [8]. Basically, the velocities of the galaxies appear too large to be explained by the gravitational potential caused by the luminous matter of the cluster.

X-ray emission from galaxy clusters

The large amount of gas present in between galaxies can be used to assess the galaxy cluster mass by studying their X-rays emission, whose intensity is strongly related to the gravitational potential experienced due to the surrounding mass. Assuming the gas plasma to be in hydrostatic equilibrium, it is possible to relate gas density ρ\rho and pressure PP at a given distance rr from the centre of the system to the mass MM of the cluster as [9]:

1ρ(r)dP(r)dr=−GM(r)r2,(5)\frac{1}{\rho(r)}\frac{dP(r)}{dr}=-\frac{GM(r)}{r^2}, \tag*{(5)}

Inserting the perfect gas law to make the dependence on the temperature of the gas explicit, the relation can be transformed in:

dlog⁡ρdlog⁡r+dlog⁡Tdlog⁡r=−rT(μmpkB)GM(r)r2,(6)\frac{d\log\rho}{d\log r}+\frac{d\log T}{d\log r}=-\frac{r}{T}\left(\frac{\mu m_p}{k_B}\right)\frac{GM(r)}{r^2}, \tag*{(6)}

where μ\mu is the average molecular weight of the primordial gas of about 0.6, and mpm_p is the mass of the proton, TT is the temperature of the gas and kBk_B the Boltzmann constant. Direct measurements suggest that ρ\rho is a power law in rr with a spectral index between -1.5 and -2 [9]. By adding this density model, the temperature of the gas can be parametrised as follows:

kBT∼(1.3–1.8) keV(Mr1014M⊙)(1Mpcr),(7)k_B T \sim(1.3\text{--}1.8)\,\mathrm{keV}\left(\frac{M_r}{10^{14}M_\odot}\right)\left(\frac{1\mathrm{Mpc}}{r}\right), \tag*{(7)}

where a typical mass of a cluster of 101410^{14} solar masses and a radius of 1 Mpc were assumed in the calculation. Typical measured temperatures of galaxy clusters are of the order of 10 keV, pointing at the existence of non-luminous matter which adds gravitational potential to the visible one which is required in order to reproduce the observations under these assumptions.

Gravitational lensing

The gravitational lensing provides additional evidences of the presence of DM. This phenomenon is predicted by General Relativity and is caused by the space-time distortions induced by the energy and mass distributed within it. In a flat region of space, particles and light travel on a straight path in the 3D space. Yet, in presence of a large mass concentrated in a small region, the space-time around it is distorted so that the straight paths are deflected in the direction of the mass. A schematic illustration of the gravitational lensing principle is shown in left panel of Figure 1.2. When a massive object is present between an observer and a source of photons, its gravitational potential modifies the space-time, effectively deflecting the light coming from the source and generating multiple images of the original object at the source, as shown in right panel of Figure 1.2. In this context, the mass distribution between the observer and the photon source is

Scheme of gravitational lensing and a horseshoe Einstein ring

Figure 1.2. On the left, a scheme of the working principle of the gravitational lensing (© Horst Frank/Designergold). On the right, an example of a horseshoe Einstein ring due to gravitational lensing taken from a Hubble image [10].

Evidence for dark matter

called lens. The angle θ\theta of deflection from the straight path of a light ray passing at a distance rr from a lens of mass MM is expressed in the simple Schawrzschild approximation by [11]:

θ=4GMrc2,(8)\theta= \sqrt{\frac{4GM}{rc^{2}}}, \tag*{(8)}

with cc the speed of light in vacuum. As a result, measuring the deflection allows to infer the mass of the object causing it.

Depending on the mass and the mass distribution of a lens, the effects of the gravitational lensing are different. Strong lensing happens when mass of the lens is large and its position change in the sky is small compared to Earth’s velocity. The effects are resolvable with telescopes in single images [12]. Weak lensing is produced by smaller masses and results in a distortion of galaxy images due to the bending of light [13]. Finally, when the mass of a lens is so small that it does not produce visible deformation, but only affects the light intensity of the luminous sources, it is called microlensing [14]. Different experimental and analysis techniques allow to retrieve evaluation of the masses distributions in between the observer and the luminous sources.

An example of a strong proof of the presence of missing mass in galaxy clusters can be obtained by studying the ones that are merging one into the other, comparing the X-rays emission of the hot gases to the mass distribution inferred from gravitational lensing. In this context, while stars are not expected to collide due to their small size with respect to the dimension of the cluster, the intergalactic hot gas interacts mainly electromagnetically. As a consequence, the gas slows down in the direction of the motion of the galaxies, while its temperature rises and the X-rays emission becomes more intense. In Figure 1.3, the example of the Bullet cluster is presented. The red halo highlights where the X-ray emission is the strongest and the green contour lines show the gravitational potential estimated with lensing. The observed displacement between these two measurement strongly support the hypothesis that more mass than the one visible has to be present, along with the hint that DM is not collisional, being unscathed by the encounter of the two clusters.

Observation of the bullet cluster with gravitational potential contours

Figure 1.3. Observation of the bullet cluster performed with the Chandra X-ray telescope [12]. Superimposed in green are the contour lines representing the gravitational potential measured with gravitational lensing.

Cosmological scale

One of the most compelling indications of DM existence is inferred by measurements of cosmological-related quantities. The currently most supported theory of cosmology is the Big Bang model, which states that the Universe was once very small, dense and hot, and later expanded to reach the shape it has today [15]. The Friedmann equations describe the expansion of space-time in a homogeneous and isotropic Universe within the context of General Relativity. These assumptions originate from the cosmological principle, or else the notion that the Universe is homogeneous and isotropic when viewed on a large enough scale. The cosmological principle implies a Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson–Walker metric, that, when applied to General Relativity, allows to express the space-time evolution and its geometry as a function of the energy density of some constituents fluid. The velocity of the expansion of the Universe can be then expressed:

H2:=(a˙a)2=8πG3ρ(a)−ka2,(9)H^2 := \left(\frac{\dot{a}}{a}\right)^2 = \frac{8\pi G}{3}\rho(a) - \frac{k}{a^2}, \tag*{(9)}

with HH the Hubble parameter, aa the scale factor of the Universe, ρ\rho the energy density of the fluid, kk the curvature of the 4-dimensional space-time. The scale factor of the Universe is a normalisation term which represents the dimension of the Universe. In general, its value at the time t=0t = 0 is taken as zero and subsequently grows with time due to the Universe adiabatic expansion. The fluid which constitutes the Universe can be described as a composed by different components. The most supported theoretical framework which depicts the composition and evolution of the Universe is the Λ\LambdaCDM model [16]. The Λ\LambdaCDM assumes that the energy density ρ\rho is, in fact, the sum of the energy densities of fluids with different properties:

Evidence for dark matter

  • Radiation ρr\rho_r which comprises ultra-relativistic particles such as photons and neutrinos for which ρr∝a−4\rho_r \propto a^{-4} is valid;

  • Matter ρm\rho_m which includes the non-relativistic matter among which the baryonic matter and also the non-baryonic matter like the DM. In this case ρm∝a−3\rho_m \propto a^{-3};

  • Cosmological constant ρΛ\rho_\Lambda that accounts for the dark energy (DE), an unknown and mysterious form of energy which is responsible for the acceleration of the Universe’s expansion. For the DE, ρΛ\rho_\Lambda is independent of aa.

All of these constituents of the Universe combined with (9), describe the evolution of the Universe.

A common notation used to express all the Universe constituents into the Friedmann equation is to relate each one’s energy density with the critical density ρc\rho_c, the density required for the Universe to be perfectly flat:

Ωi=ρiρc,(10)\Omega_i = \frac{\rho_i}{\rho_c}, \tag*{(10)}

Friedmann equation can be rewritten as:

H2=H02(Ωr,0(1+z)4+Ωm,0(1+z)3+ΩΛ,0+Ωk,0(1+z)2),(11)H^2 = H_0^2\left(\Omega_{r,0}(1+z)^4+\Omega_{m,0}(1+z)^3+\Omega_{\Lambda,0}+\Omega_{k,0}(1+z)^2\right), \tag*{(11)}

with zz the redshift which replaces aa following z=a0a−1z = \frac{a_0}{a} - 1, the subscript 0 denotes that the variable is evaluated now, and Ωk,0\Omega_{k,0} does not represent a constituent of the Universe, but is the curvature term of (9). If the sum of all the Ω\Omega components is 1, then the total energy density of the Universe is equal to the critical one and the Universe is flat. The term Ωm\Omega_m can be further split into the baryonic part and the DM one. Any measurement able to constrain Ω\Omega parameters provides information on the structure of the Universe and help quantify the amount of DM.

Cosmic microwave background (CMB)

A possible method to constrain the Ω\Omega parameters is to exploit the measurement of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), a relic radiation originated during a period called recombination. At the very early stages of the Universe, few seconds after the Big Bang, the temperature, inversely proportional to the adiabatic expansion of the Universe [17], was of the order of 100 MeV. The cosmic plasma comprised photons, neutrinos, electrons, positrons and baryons in thermal equilibrium. Every photon emitted at those times is lost as they interacted soon after with other particles, being in thermal equilibrium. With the expansion of the Universe, the temperature dropped resulting in reduction of the intensity of the interactions. When the temperature reached values around 1 eV, the energy carried by photons started to be not enough to prevent protons and electrons from combining and forming the first atoms. This is known as the recombination period. As a consequence, the photons emitted in that era were not absorbed and can be still detected today as the CMB. This relic radiation possesses a spectrum which follows the black body radiation spectrum, and its isotropy reaches levels of ΔTT∼10−5\frac{\Delta T}{T} \sim10^{-5} [1]. Nevertheless, small anisotropies exist and are shown in Figure 1.4, from the measurement of the PLANCK collaboration. These anisotropies are related to fluctuations in the local gravitational potential and any kind of phenomenon which mirrors its behaviour on the energy density [18]. Examining them carefully can provide constraints on various scenarios hypothesised for the early Universe. The temperature anisotropies are usually decomposed in the spherical harmonic functions

CMB anisotropies measured by the PLANCK satellite

Figure 1.4. CMB anisotropies measured by the PLANCK satellite. Figure by ESA https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2013/03/Planck_CMB.

ΔTT=∑l∑m=−lm=lalmYlm(θ,ϕ),(12)\frac{\Delta T}{T} = \sum_l \sum_{m=-l}^{m=l} a_{lm}Y_l^m(\theta,\phi), \tag*{(12)}

and the power spectrum is computed from:

Cl=⟨∣alm∣2⟩m(13)C_l = \langle|a_{lm}|^2 \rangle_m \tag*{(13)}

Figure 1.5 shows the temperature anisotropies as presented by PLANCK collaboration as a function of the spherical harmonics. The blue line represents the fit of the Λ\LambdaCDM model, the simplest parametric model of the Big Bang which includes DM and DE. The temperature fluctuations follow the oscillation of gravitational wells, matter, DM and photon plasma. The first intense peak is related to the base frequency of the energy and matter density oscillation. Its position is strongly related to the value of total curvature of the Universe at the recombination time. The other peaks are overtones of the fundamental frequency. The difference in intensity is related to the amount of baryonic matter (for the second peak) and non-baryonic one (for the subsequent peaks) as plasma oscillation can interact destructively with the fluctuation of the gravitational potential

Temperature anisotropies spectrum in spherical harmonics

caption: Temperature anisotropies spectrum in spherical harmonics presented by PLANCK [1]. The blue line is the Λ\LambdaCDM model fit of the experimental data.

wells. The model fits very well the data and allows to measure the Ω\Omega components from the relative intensity of the peaks and their position, even though more complete and precise analyses which include other measurable quantities is described in [1]. The CMB anisotropy description is one of the possible cosmological measurements which can provide information on the Ω\Omega components of the Λ\LambdaCDM model. The art on the Ω\Omega relative densities which are summarised in Table 1.1, taken from [1]: The Ωtot\Omega_{tot} is perfectly consistent with 1, suggesting that the Universe is flat. The non-baryonic matter which is considered to mostly be DM is a required constituent of the Universe. On top of this, its abundance is about 26% of the total energy density, comprising 84% of total matter.

ComponentDensity parameterPlanck results with 68% CL
RadiationΩr\Omega_r∼9×10−5\sim9 \times10^{-5}
Baryonic matterΩb\Omega_b0.0489±0.00030.0489 \pm0.0003
Non-baryonic matterΩnb\Omega_{nb}0.2607±0.00190.2607 \pm0.0019
Dark energyΩΛ\Omega_\Lambda0.6889±0.00560.6889 \pm0.0056
TotalΩtot\Omega_{tot}0.9993±0.00190.9993 \pm0.0019

Table 1.1. Table summarising the Planck combined results on the Ω\Omega parameters of the Λ\LambdaCDM model, taken from [1].

Structure formation

The formation of large scale structures, such as galaxies and clusters of galaxies, is a very relevant test bench for the DM characteristics and evidence of its presence. Since today’s highly inhomogeneous Universe evolved from a very uniform and smooth state at the time of recombination (when density fluctuations were of the order 10−510^{-5}), the analysis of the large structures can provide constraint on what influenced such evolution. The homogeneity of the Universe can be expressed as the fluctuation intensity of the fluid energy density of the Universe ρ\rho defined in the previous Section. As a simple approximation, until the Universe is radiation dominated (ρr≫ρm,ρΛ\rho_r \gg\rho_m, \rho_\Lambda), δρρ\frac{\delta\rho}{\rho} can grow as the logarithm of the scale factor aa. Only in a matter dominated epoch, the perturbations can inflate linearly. However, if only baryonic matter existed, the linear growth of the perturbations would start only after recombination. Scaling them to the present day, δρρ\frac{\delta\rho}{\rho} would still be of the order of 10−210^{-2}, a quite uniform Universe. A non linear growth of the perturbations can be induced if a different matter species that decouples from photon before recombination is introduced in this picture. This would generate potential wells where baryonic matter falls into immediately after the recombination, provoking non linear enhancement of the perturbations. This different, non baryonic form of matter would perfectly fit as DM.

In order to better detail the peculiarities of this DM assumption in the evolution of these large structures, complex N-body simulations are used. A set quantity of particles belonging to the primordial fluids (radiation, DM and baryonic matter) is prepared in the abundance present at the very early stages of the Universe, inferred by the PLANCK results. The system is left to evolve following the gravitational attraction of the constituents and the interactions between the fluids as derived from particle physics. The evolution is continued until the present day and the large structure formed and formation processes are checked with the astronomical observations. Various N-body simulations like Millennium [20], ν2\nu^{2}GC [21] and Illustris [19] are employed and typically utilise billions of particles in order to generate a modern universe few hundreds of light-years wide. Figure 1.6 exemplifies the outcome of some of these simulations. For example, in the hypothesis that DM is made of particles (see next Section), some physical characteristics can modify the result of the simulation. If DM were made of relativistic particles at the moment of decoupling from baryonic matter, the pressure they induce would be enough to eliminate the small perturbations and large scale gas-structure would form first. The galaxies would be generated only afterwards from the collapse of these gaseous systems. Recent observation rule out the hypothesis of hot DM as they are too different from the simulation outputs [22]. As a consequence, the most supported model endorses a cold or warm DM hypothesis, with non-relativistic or semi-relativistic particles at the decoupling time, as simulations results succeed in reproducing the current measurements.

Example of the N-body simulation result for the Illustris at different redshifts

Figure 1.6. Example of the N-body simulation result for the Illustris [19]. Different redshift are displayed: top left z=7z=7, top right z=3z=3, bottom left z=1z=1, bottom right z=0z=0.

Candidates for dark matter

Astronomical and cosmological observations based on gravitational probes are not consistent with the current picture of Universe particle and forces content. Thus, an ulterior ingredient is believed to be necessary to explain the measurements performed. Nevertheless, all of these hints derive from gravitational probes of observables. Various theories to explain these anomalies exist, and in the following, the most established will be reviewed.

Modified Newtonian Dynamics

References

  1. [76][76–78]

Paper details

vlnc:W_bqf4hx3b
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 9

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents