betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Failure of disjoint additivity under magnetic Gauss constraints

Abstract

Under local magnetic Gauss constraints, vertex-disjoint regions can have commuting physical observable algebras that do not generate all observables on their union. We construct such counterexamples for every finite non-Abelian group on regular square tori, retaining the full magnetic physical space and original supports inside a fixed contractible disk. A peripheral projector selects inputs on which a joint transition preserves the constraints, while its loop factor alone fails the universal test over physical exterior completions. For a specified support family around a fixed eight-edge square loop, additivity fails if and only if the group is non-Abelian and each inner face is covered by at least one of its two prescribed peripheral edges. Leaving a face uncovered restores full additivity. For the same loop, additivity also holds with any region at vertex-set graph distance at least two. These results refute a recent group-double additivity proposition.

Whether separately admissible regional observables generate every observable on their union is a basic question for constrained quantum systems [3] [1, 2]. Mutual commutativity alone does not settle this question. We show that disjoint additivity fails for every finite non-Abelian group on a regular square torus, even when the two vertex-disjoint supports lie within a fixed contractible disk. Their physical star algebras commute, yet omit an observable supported on the union. The failure therefore does not require noncontractible winding of either support.

Disjoint additivity has been proposed as a locality principle in settings where ordinary additivity fails [4]. Our construction contradicts Proposition 4.3 of Holfester and Sorce [5], which states, “For the magnetic constraint of a GG double model, if R1R_1 and R2R_2 are disjoint in the sense of vertex adjacency, then” A0(R1∪R2)=A0(R1)∨A0(R2)\mathcal{A}_0(R_1 \cup R_2) = \mathcal{A}_0(R_1) \vee\mathcal{A}_0(R_2). We also establish a necessary and sufficient condition for failure within the contact-support family defined below around a fixed eight-edge loop. Failure requires a non-Abelian group and coverage of all four inner faces, with at least one edge retained from each associated peripheral pair. Leaving any face uncovered restores full additivity. For the same fixed loop, recovery also holds with any other region at vertex-set graph distance at least two.

The mechanism is the distinction between universal and conditional preservation of the magnetic constraints. A loop-supported operator must preserve every physical exterior completion of its input. A projector on the other region can select completions on which a noncentral loop transition is legal, although the loop operator alone fails the universal test. The resulting joint operator is already a kinematic product, but lies outside the star algebra generated by separately admissible regional operators. We retain the full magnetic physical space and the original edge supports, imposing neither electric nor global-sector projections. Our lifts obey the one-way preservation condition of Ref. [5], and an edge-wise inversion unitary relates the orientation conventions. The covering criterion and buffer theorem identify how the available exterior tests control composition in the specified geometries.

Physical observables on the original supports. Let GG be a finite group with identity ee and center Z(G)Z(G). On a periodic N×MN \times M square lattice, every edge is assigned the group algebra C[G]\mathbb{C}[G], with horizontal edges hi,jh_{i,j} oriented eastward and vertical edges vi,jv_{i,j} northward. We impose the magnetic constraint

Ci,j=hi,jvi,jhi−1,j−1vi,j−1−1=e,P=∏i,j[Ci,j=e].(1)C_{i,j}=h_{i,j}v_{i,j}h_{i-1,j}^{-1}v_{i,j-1}^{-1}=e,\qquad P=\prod_{i,j}[C_{i,j}=e]. \tag*{(1)}

The physical Hilbert space is the full magnetic subspace H0=PH\mathcal{H}_0=P\mathcal{H}, without imposing electric or global-sector projections. This framework follows the magnetic double models of Refs. [5, 6], with conventions detailed in the End Matter. A spatial region is defined as a subset of lattice edges. For any region RR, we identify all kinematic operators supported on RR that leave H0\mathcal{H}_0 invariant, and construct the physical observable algebra by taking its C∗C^*-closure on H0\mathcal{H}_0:

KR={A^=AR⊗I:(1−P)A^P=0},\mathcal{K}_R=\{\hat{A}=A_R\otimes I:(1-P)\hat{A}P=0\},
A0(R)={A^∣H0:A^∈KR},A(R)=C∗(A0(R)).(2)\mathcal{A}_0(R)=\{\hat{A}|_{\mathcal{H}_0}:\hat{A}\in\mathcal{K}_R\},\qquad\mathcal{A}(R)=C^*(\mathcal{A}_0(R)). \tag*{(2)}

The adjoint operation in A(R)\mathcal{A}(R) is the physical adjoint on H0\mathcal{H}_0; its definition does not presume the existence of an adjoint lift on the identical edge support. In particular, the defining invariance condition requires only forward preservation (1−P)A^P=0(1-P)\hat{A}P=0, not kinematic commutation [A^,P]=0[\hat{A},P]=0. For two disjoint regions RR and LL, we write B=A(R)∨A(L)\mathcal{B}=\mathcal{A}(R)\vee\mathcal{A}(L) for the generated regional join and AU=A(R∪L)\mathcal{A}_U=\mathcal{A}(R\cup L) for the algebra of the union.

A local support criterion. Throughout this construction we fix N,M≥8N,M\geq8. Let LL denote the eight-edge perimeter of the square with vertices (2,2),(4,2),(4,4),(2,4)(2,2),(4,2),(4,4),(2,4). The four straight boundary vertices of LL form cusps, where loop and exterior half-edges alternate cyclically, whereas at the four corner vertices the two loop half-edges are cyclically consecutive. We parameterize loop configurations by the counterclockwise tuple b∈G8b\in G^8, inverting the labels of the top and left edges.

The surrounding support SS comprises the three non-loop-facing edges incident to each exterior nearest neighbor of V(L)V(L). This yields 28 edges that share no vertices with LL. Let I\mathcal{I} denote the set of four inner plaquettes and O\mathcal{O} the eight outer plaquettes adjacent to LL. Their boundary union D=⋃f∈I∪O∂fD = \bigcup_{f\in\mathcal{I}\cup\mathcal{O}}\partial f contains 32 edges, splitting SS into an exterior base S0=S∖DS_0 = S\setminus D of 20 edges and a contact boundary C=S∩DC = S\cap D of 8 edges. We consider the family of regional supports

RK=S0∪K,K⊆C.(3)R_K = S_0 \cup K,\qquad K\subseteq C. \tag*{(3)}

Each inner face ff is associated with a two-edge subset Cf⊂CC_f\subset C positioned beyond its neighboring outer faces. These four pairs partition CC (see the End Matter for coordinates). We say that KK covers ff whenever K∩Cf≠∅K\cap C_f\ne\varnothing. Figure 1 illustrates two choices of equal edge count. Both LL and RKR_K embed within the coordinate square [0,6]2[0,6]^2, which lies entirely inside a contractible disk on the torus; neither region winds around noncontractible cycles.

Figure 1. Failure and restoration of additivity for a fixed eight-edge loop LL (blue) on a square torus with N,M≥8N, M \ge8. In (a,b), black edges form S0S_0 and orange dashed edges form KK. Each inner face shares a numeral with its two exterior peripheral contact edges; shading and a plus sign denote coverage, whereas a minus sign denotes an uncovered face. Unselected contacts (grey dotted) and other pale grey edges remain exterior degrees of freedom. Both supports RK=S0∪KR_K = S_0 \cup K have 24 edges and vertex-set distance 1 from LL. (a) Four contacts cover all four faces, giving strict inclusion for every finite non-Abelian group. (b) Four contacts cover only two faces, giving equality for every finite group. (c) A different 24-edge outer perimeter (black), not in the RKR_K family, has distance 2 and avoids the 32-edge union DD of the inner and adjacent outer face boundaries. Additivity again holds for every finite group. The statements use the full magnetic physical space and original edge supports. All supports shown are contained in a contractible disk of the torus; this does not assert that each support is itself a disk.

For every finite group GG and any choice of K⊆CK\subseteq C, the regional algebras commute, and failure of additivity is characterized by

BK⊊A(RK∪L)\mathcal{B}_K \subsetneq\mathcal{A}(R_K\cup L)
⟺{G is non-Abelian,K∩Cf≠∅for all f∈I.(4)\Longleftrightarrow \begin{cases} G\text{ is non-Abelian},\\ K\cap C_f\ne\varnothing\quad\text{for all }f\in\mathcal{I}. \end{cases} \tag*{(4)}

Here BK=A(RK)∨A(L)\mathcal{B}_K=\mathcal{A}(R_K)\vee\mathcal{A}(L); whenever the condition on the right fails, the inclusion becomes an equality. For a non-Abelian group, exactly 81 of the 256 possible contact subsets KK fail additivity, while the remaining 175 restore full equality. These counts follow from the four independent face-coverage conditions. Within this family, the minimal nonadditive configurations require four contact edges (∣K∣=4|K|=4), distributed one per inner face. Concentrating four edges across only two faces instead restores additivity. Consequently, edge cardinality and graph distance are insufficient to determine regional algebraic composition.

Universal tests and a conditionally legal product. The mechanism underlying this obstruction emerges from the admissible physical transitions of the isolated loop. Any assigned loop configuration b∈G8b\in G^8 admits a valid physical completion obtained by assigning potentials pf∈Gp_f\in G to lattice faces and setting

hi,j=pi,j−1pi,j,vi,j=pi,j−1pi−1,j.(5)h_{i,j}=p_{i,j}^{-1}p_{i,j},\qquad v_{i,j}=p_{i,j}^{-1}p_{i-1,j}. \tag*{(5)}

Across each vertex, the magnetic word telescopes to the identity. Selecting the four inner face potentials independently determines the eight outer potentials via po=pfbe−1p_o=p_f b_e^{-1}, since each outer face meets exactly one loop edge. At each straight cusp, the inward exterior edge separates two inner faces, allowing its value to vary over all of GG while the entire loop tuple bb remains held constant. These completions serve as physical test backgrounds rather than a complete parametrization of all topological sectors on the torus.

At the bottom straight vertex (3,2)(3,2), the counterclockwise loop tuple begins with b1=h2,2b_1=h_{2,2} and b2=h3,2b_2=h_{3,2}. The two non-loop labels are x=v3,2x=v_{3,2} on the interior side and y=v3,1y=v_{3,1} on the exterior side, and the flatness constraint reads b2xb1−1=yb_2xb_1^{-1}=y. An admissible loop transition ∣b′⟩⟨b∣|b'\rangle\langle b| must preserve this relation for every physical exterior completion, which requires

b2′x(b1′)−1=b2xb1−1for all x∈G.(6)b'_2x(b'_1)^{-1}=b_2xb_1^{-1}\quad\text{for all }x\in G. \tag*{(6)}

This condition forces adjacent loop edges to transform by a shared central element (b2′)−1b2=(b1′)−1b1∈Z(G)(b'_2)^{-1}b_2=(b'_1)^{-1}b_1\in Z(G). While this local central restriction was recognized in Ref. [5], Sec. 3, the explicit completions constructed above establish its necessary global extension premise for the square loop. As detailed below, the remaining vertices propagate this identical central shift throughout LL. Conversely, any uniform central shift leaves every vertex word invariant. The admissible physical loop matrix units are therefore precisely

∣bz⟩⟨b∣,b∈G8,z∈Z(G),(7)|bz\rangle\langle b|,\qquad b\in G^8,\quad z\in Z(G), \tag*{(7)}

represented with identical scalar coefficients across all physical exterior completions. Their physical linear span is the C∗C^*-algebra A(L)=A0(L)\mathcal{A}(L)=\mathcal{A}_0(L). The corresponding center-orbit projectors commute with all operators supported on RKR_K by spatial disjointness, and hence commute with the full join BK\mathcal{B}_K. Because kinematic lifts on disjoint edge supports commute on H0\mathcal{H}_0, star-closure of the loop algebra ensures that [A(RK),A(L)]=0[\mathcal{A}(R_K),\mathcal{A}(L)]=0.

When KK covers all four inner faces, choose an element t∉Z(G)t\notin Z(G) (with G=S3G=S_3 and t=(12)t=(12) providing the minimal instance). Let QKQ_K be the kinematic projector enforcing identity labels across all edges of RKR_K, and let TLT_L swap the uniform loop states eˉ\bar e and tˉ\bar t while annihilating all other loop tuples. The composite operator forms a kinematic product:

W^K=QKTL,\widehat{W}_K=Q_KT_L,
(1−P)W^KP=0,(1−P)TLP≠0.(8)(1-P)\widehat{W}_KP=0,\qquad(1-P)T_LP\ne0. \tag*{(8)}

References

  1. [3]S.-H. Shao, J. Sorce, and M. Srivastava, Additivity, Haag duality, and non-invertible symmetries, Journal of High Energy Physics 2025, 009 (2025), arXiv:2503.20863 [hep-th].DOI
  2. [4]D. Harlow, S.-H. Shao, J. Sorce, and M. Srivastava, Disjoint additivity and local quantum physics, Journal of High Energy Physics 2026, 025 (2026), arXiv:2509.03589.arxiv.org/abs/2509.03589
  3. [5]N. Holfester and J. Sorce, Algebraic locality and non-invertible Gauss laws (2026), arXiv:2605.21591v2 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2605.21591
  4. [6]A. Yu. Kitaev, Fault-tolerant quantum computation by anyons, Annals of Physics 303, 2 (2003), arXiv:quant-ph/9707021.
  5. [7]K. Van Acoleyen, N. Bulturnick, J. Haegeman, M. Marien, V. B. Scholz, and F. Verstraete, Entanglement of Distillation for Lattice Gauge Theories, Physical Review Letters 117, 131602 (2016), arXiv:1511.04369.
  6. [8]See the Supplemental Material following the End Matter for the complete wrapping-pair matrix-block classification, physical-adjoint and exterior-fiber analysis, one-sided locking, buffered-strip recovery, and the independent Kac–Paljutkin construction and proof.
  7. [9]P. Naaijkens, D. Penneys, and D. Wallick, Local topological order, Haag duality, and reflection positivity (2026), arXiv:2605.010693.
  8. [10]D. Wallick and H. Wilming, A nonabelian anyon violates Haag duality (2026), arXiv:2609.01267.arxiv.org/abs/2609.01267
  9. [11]R. Liu and L. van Luijk, An entropic characterization of Haag duality (2026), arXiv:2609.13550.arxiv.org/abs/2609.13550
  10. [12]B. Balsam and A. Kirillov Jr, Kitaev’s lattice model and Turaev–Viro TQFTs (2012), arXiv:1206.2308.arxiv.org/abs/1206.2308
  11. [13]O. Buerschaper and M. Aguado, Mapping Kitaev’s quantum double lattice models to Levin and Wen’s string-net models, Physical Review B 80, 155136 (2009), arXiv:0907.2670.DOI
  12. [14]O. Buerschaper, M. Christandl, L. Kong, and M. Aguado, Electric-magnetic duality of lattice systems with topological order, Nuclear Physics B 876, 619 (2013), arXiv:1006.5823.DOI
  13. [15]O. Buerschaper, J. M. Mombelli, M. Christandl, and M. Aguado, A hierarchy of topological tensor network states, Journal of Mathematical Physics 54, 012201 (2013), arXiv:1007.5283.DOI
  14. [16]S. Dăscălescu, M. C. Iovanov, and S. Preduț, Frobenius structural matrix algebras, Linear Algebra and its Applications 439, 3166 (2013), arXiv:1512.09339.
  15. [17]I. Gogić and M. Tomašević, Jordan embeddings and linear rank preservers of structural matrix algebras, Linear Algebra and its Applications 707, 1 (2025), arXiv:2409.16906.DOI
  16. [18]D.-C. Lu, A. Chatterjee, and N. Tantivasadakarn, Generalized Kramers–Wannier self-duality in Hopf-Ising models (2026), arXiv:2602.10183 [cond-mat.str-el].arxiv.org/abs/2602.10183
  17. [19]C. Meusburger, Kitaev Lattice Models as a Hopf Algebra Gauge Theory, Communications in Mathematical Physics 353, 413 (2017), arXiv:1607.01144.DOI
  18. [20]C. Meusburger and D. K. Wise, Hopf algebra gauge theory on a ribbon graph, Reviews in Mathematical Physics 33, 2150016 (2021), arXiv:1512.03966.
  19. [21]B. Yan, P. Chen, and S. X. Cui, Ribbon operators in the generalized Kitaev quantum double model based on Hopf algebras, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 55, 185201 (2022), arXiv:2105.08202.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_bux78679
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents