betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Irregular weight-one Eisenstein series and Euler systems

Abstract

Let f=E1(χ1,χ2)f=E_1(χ_1,χ_2) be an irregular Eisenstein series of weight one, that is, with χ1(p)=χ2(p)χ_1(p)=χ_2(p), and consider the generically cuspidal ordinary family passing through it. When χ1χ_1, χ2χ_2 and χ1χ2−1χ_1χ_2^{-1} are primitive of the same conductor, we show that the specialization at ff of the modular-symbol pp-adic LL-function of this family, with periods taken in the cohomology of the compactified modular curves, factors as a product of two Kubota–Leopoldt pp-adic LL-functions attached to χ1χ_1 and χ2χ_2. Since there are no complex critical values in weight one, the factorization is obtained directly from the cohomological construction: we compute the tame-twisted modular measure by means of the localized Sharifi map and explicit reciprocity, and show that tame twisting identifies the compact period modules at weight one. This gives a weight-one analogue of the factorization of Bellaïche–Dasgupta for critical-slope Eisenstein series. As applications, and under explicit specialization hypotheses, we compare Kato classes with circular units, Heegner classes with elliptic units, and diagonal cycles with Kato classes through two successive Eisenstein degenerations. We also discuss the passage from compact to open periods, and include an exposition of the congruence and degeneration methods underlying these comparisons.

Introduction

The decomposition of an Eisenstein Galois representation into characters suggests a corresponding factorization of its pp-adic LL-function into Dirichlet pp-adic LL-functions. At an Eisenstein point lying on a generically cuspidal family, the function we consider is obtained by specializing a modular-symbol measure in that family, with periods chosen in a cohomological realization; its value at the Eisenstein point therefore depends on these periods, and the expected factorization need not follow from interpolation of complex values. In a primitive common-conductor setting, we prove that, when the periods are taken in the cohomology of the compactified modular curves, the specialization of this measure at an irregular weight-one Eisenstein point E1(χ1,χ2)E_1(\chi_1, \chi_2) is nonzero and factors as a product of two Kubota–Leopoldt pp-adic LL-functions attached to χ1\chi_1 and χ2\chi_2, and we then study the consequences for Euler systems.

Our main result may be seen as a weight-one analogue of the factorization established by Bellaïche–Dasgupta [6 Theorem 1.1]. For a critical-slope Eisenstein series of weight at least two, their formula expresses the pp-adic LL-function, on the appropriate sign component, as the product of two Dirichlet pp-adic LL-functions and an explicit cyclotomic logarithm. Here we consider an ordinary Eisenstein series of weight one whose two Hecke roots at pp coincide, that is, an irregular one; since weight one has no complex critical integers, we must obtain the factorization from the modular-symbol construction in families.

Our starting point is the work of Shih–Wang [33 SW22] on the exceptional case of Sharifi’s conjecture, whose factorization concerns a weight-one Eisenstein series with one trivial constituent and uses an integral Gorenstein hypothesis to choose periods. We work instead with the cohomology of the compactified modular curves in characteristic zero, where local freeness follows from Betina–Dimitrov–Pozzi, and pass to two nontrivial constituents by tame twisting. This requires control of the twisting correspondence on the period modules, including its nonvanishing at the Eisenstein point, which we establish by evaluating the twisted modular symbols through local reciprocity. The same calculation thus gives the two Dirichlet factors and the nonvanishing needed to identify the compact periods at weight one.

A related factorization occurs for Katz pp-adic LL-functions restricted to the cyclotomic line: in the CM case, [SW22, Corollary 2.3] connects the modular pp-adic LL-function with the Katz pp-adic LL-function and Gross’s formula. Our common-conductor result treats a different range, where both constituents are nontrivial. More broadly, the comparison of Euler systems as a way of proving instances of pp-adic Artin formalism is also central in Dasgupta’s factorization of the Rankin pp-adic LL-function of a tensor square [16].

We then compare Kato classes with circular units, and consider analogous questions for Heegner classes and for two successive Eisenstein degenerations of diagonal cycles; in each case, the analytic factorizations suggest which Euler systems should occur after specialization. To compare the classes themselves, we also need regular specialization in the chosen cohomological realization and a certain compatibility with the local conditions, which we state as explicit hypotheses.

The weight-one factorization

1.1. The weight-one factorization. Let f=E1(χ1,χ2)f = E_1(\chi_1, \chi_2), with χ1\chi_1 even and χ2\chi_2 odd, and assume that ff is irregular at pp, that is, χ1(p)=χ2(p)\chi_1(p) = \chi_2(p); we write α\alpha for this common value. Since the two roots of the Hecke polynomial at pp coincide, ff has a unique ordinary pp-stabilization, which we still denote by ff. The Galois representation of ff is the sum of the two characters χ1\chi_1 and χ2\chi_2, and this is why one expects its pp-adic LL-function to involve two Dirichlet factors. The geometry of [9] gives a generically cuspidal ordinary branch through ff, étale over weight space; we write f\mathbf{f} for the family and A=L[[X]]A = L[[X]] for its completed local ring, with X=0X = 0 at weight one.

The periods in our formula come from ordinary cohomology along the tower of compactified modular curves: its signed torsion-free quotient on which the Hecke operators act through the eigenvalues of f\mathbf{f} is a free AA-module of rank one, denoted by Pf,cpt\mathscr{P}_{f,\mathrm{cpt}}. Ordinary modular symbols define a measure with values in this module, and choosing a basis γf\gamma_f gives a scalar measure in the family, whose specialization at weight one we denote by Lpcpt(f)\mathcal{L}^{\mathrm{cpt}}_p(f). We refer to this as the compact period normalization, where cpt refers to the compactified modular curve; the precise quotient, measure and interpolation formula at classical cuspidal points are given in §6.2.

For z∈Zp×z \in\mathbb{Z}_p^\times, write z=ω(z)⟨z⟩z = \omega(z)\langle z\rangle, with ω\omega the Teichmüller character. On its trivial component, Lpcpt(f,j)\mathcal{L}^{\mathrm{cpt}}_p(f,j) is the evaluation at z↦⟨z⟩jz \mapsto\langle z\rangle^j. We use LpKL(β,s)L^{\mathrm{KL}}_p(\beta,s) for the standard Kubota–Leopoldt function of an even Dirichlet character β\beta. Theorem 6.3 and Corollary 6.5 give the following formula.

Theorem A. Suppose that χ1\chi_1, χ2\chi_2 and χ1χ2−1\chi_1\chi_2^{-1} are primitive of the same conductor M>1M>1, that p≥5p\geq5 and p∤Mφ(M)p\nmid M\varphi(M), and that χ1(p)=χ2(p)\chi_1(p)=\chi_2(p). Then

Lpcpt(f,j)=Cf,γ⟨M⟩−jLpKL(χ1,1+j)LpKL(χ2−1ω,−j),Cf,γ∈L×.\mathcal{L}^{\mathrm{cpt}}_p(f,j)=C_{f,\gamma} \langle M\rangle^{-j}L^{\mathrm{KL}}_p(\chi_1,1+j)L^{\mathrm{KL}}_p(\chi_2^{-1}\omega,-j),\qquad C_{f,\gamma}\in L^\times.

The constant is independent of jj, and the resulting bounded measure is nonzero. Its normalization is determined by the chosen compact period.

To prove the theorem, we write f=f0⊗ηf=f_0\otimes\eta, where η=χ1\eta=\chi_1 and f0=E1(1,χ2χ1−1)f_0=E_1(1,\chi_2\chi_1^{-1}). The twisting correspondence gives a regular map from the compact period module of ff to that of the auxiliary family f0f_0. We compute the image measure using the localized Sharifi map, which sends its modular symbols to cup products of cyclotomic units. Explicit reciprocity expresses their local invariants as traces: the logarithm of the first entry gives one Dirichlet factor, and the conjugates of the Coleman logarithmic derivative of the second give the other. The nonvanishing of the resulting product shows that the twisting map is an isomorphism on the weight-one fibre, hence also over the local weight ring, and allows us to recover the factorization in the compact periods of ff.

The reflected argument and the conductor factor can also be understood from the point of view of complex Artin formalism. For an even finite-order character ρ\rho of conductor prp^r, one has

L(f⊗ρ−1,s)=L(χ1ρ−1,s)L(χ2ρ−1,s).L(f\otimes\rho^{-1},s)=L(\chi_1\rho^{-1},s)L(\chi_2\rho^{-1},s).

Applying the functional equation to the second factor at s=1s=1 replaces it by a value of L(χ2−1ρ,0)L(\chi_2^{-1}\rho,0). The Gauss sum of χ2ρ−1\chi_2\rho^{-1} contributes χ2(p)rρ(M)−1τM(χ2)τpr(ρ−1)\chi_2(p)^{r_\rho(M)-1}\tau_M(\chi_2)\tau_{p^r}(\rho^{-1}); the first factor cancels the ordinary eigenvalue α−1\alpha^{-1}, and the wild Gauss sum cancels the one in the interpolation formula, so that only ρ(M)\rho(M) survives. This accounts for ⟨M⟩−j\langle M\rangle^{-j} and the argument −j-j in the theorem. The first factor, at s=1s=1 with even character, is represented pp-adically by Leopoldt’s logarithmic formula. This heuristic explains the shape of the formula, although the proof has to proceed through local reciprocity, since complex interpolation is not available at weight one.

For example, take M=19M=19, p=83p=83 and a character ϑ\vartheta modulo 19 with ϑ(2)=ζ18\vartheta(2)=\zeta_{18}. The pair (χ1,χ2)=(ϑ9,ϑ5)(\chi_1,\chi_2)=(\vartheta^9,\vartheta^5) satisfies the hypotheses: both characters take the value ζ1812\zeta_{18}^{12} at 83, and their ratio is primitive. Since ζ1812≠1\zeta_{18}^{12}\ne1, this example also satisfies the additional condition α≠1\alpha\ne1 needed in Corollary B below. We return to these data in Example 7.9.

The appearance of logarithms of units also connects this result with the weight-one comparisons of Darmon–Lauder–Rotger [17] and Rivero–Rotger [29], where logarithmic regulators describe specializations or deformations of Euler-system classes. In our setting, the first Kubota–Leopoldt factor arises from a sum of logarithms of cyclotomic units in the evaluation of the compact modular-symbol measure.

Kato classes and circular units

The factorization of Theorem A suggests a corresponding relation between Euler systems. Recall that Kato’s classes are attached to cusp forms, while circular units are attached to Dirichlet characters. When a cuspidal family passes through an Eisenstein point, its Galois representation becomes reducible, and it is natural to ask whether the specialization of Kato’s class can be expressed in terms of circular units. Section 5 approaches this question from the point of view of Euler systems, following the critical-slope comparison of [28].

Write κ(f)χ1\kappa(f)_{\chi_1} for the χ1\chi_1-component of the specialized Kato class and c(χ1)c(\chi_1) for the circular-unit class. In the cohomological normalization used to compare them, both have coefficients in the cyclotomic deformation of L(χ1−1)(1)L(\chi_1^{-1})(1): the dual and Tate twist are those of Kummer theory. Under our hypotheses, the other character component vanishes on even cyclotomic components for parity reasons. The comparison is suggested by the explicit reciprocity laws: the regulator of the circular unit gives the first Kubota–Leopoldt factor in Theorem A, and cancelling this factor should leave the second one as the coefficient of c(χ1)c(\chi_1).

The choice of periods matters here, since Theorem A uses compact periods, whereas Kato’s reciprocity law uses those of the Euler-system construction, and their comparison may introduce a zero at the Eisenstein point. The normalization of [28] also contributes an auxiliary LL-value and an adjoint factor. Our strategy is to keep these weight-dependent factors together: if the class and its regulator specialize regularly, the nonvanishing of the compact measure in Theorem A forces their combined contribution to be regular.

Hypothesis 5.9 specifies the required regular specialization: the family class extends to the chosen split realization, and its ordinary regulator becomes the circular-unit Coleman map, with the stated coordinate factor. Let Df(j)\mathcal{D}_{f}(j) denote the combined weight factor at ff, together with the tame Euler and coordinate factors. Its expression is given in (59).

Corollary B. Assume the hypotheses of Theorem A, that α≠1\alpha\ne1, and Hypothesis 5.9. On the trivial Teichmüller component,

κ(f)χ1=Df(j)⟨M⟩−jLpKL(χ2−1ω,−j)c(χ1)\kappa(f)_{\chi_1}=\mathcal{D}_{f}(j)\langle M\rangle^{-j}L^{\mathrm{KL}}_{p}(\chi_2^{-1}\omega,-j)c(\chi_1)

over the fraction field of the cyclotomic distribution algebra. If the coefficient is analytic, the equality holds in global cohomology. The comparison factor defining Df\mathcal{D}_{f} is regular in weight, but its value may be zero, and κ(f)χ1≠0\kappa(f)_{\chi_1}\ne0 if and only if this value is nonzero.

Hence the second Dirichlet pp-adic LL-function gives the coefficient of the circular-unit class, up to the factors appearing in the two reciprocity laws. The passage from regulators to global classes uses Leopoldt’s theorem for abelian fields, as explained in Proposition 5.6. § 5 establishes the comparison before evaluating its analytic coefficient; § 7.5 then deduces Corollary B from Theorem A.

The critical-slope comparisons of Loeffler–Rivero [23] and Polo–Rivero [28] provide the model for this use of cohomological realizations and crystalline periods. We also study the period map itself, and we show that for the Drinfeld–Manin realization of the auxiliary family f0f_0 it has a simple zero, so that it carries a nonzero compact value to a first derivative in the weight direction. Question 6.9 asks for the corresponding comparison with the realization selected by Kato’s periods.

Heegner classes and elliptic units

After considering circular units over Q\mathbb{Q}, we turn to elliptic units over an imaginary quadratic field and their relation with Heegner classes. This anticyclotomic comparison has a simpler starting point: the geometry places the localization of a Heegner class in the positive ordinary direction, so its image in the natural rank-one quotient is zero before any factorization of pp-adic LL-functions is used, and we can work directly with the positive regulator as in [23 §C3].

Here f=E1(χ1,χ2)f=E_1(\chi_1,\chi_2) is an irregular Eisenstein series as in §1.1; this comparison does not use Theorem A, and the split prime realization it requires is part of the hypotheses of § 8. Let KK be an imaginary quadratic field in which pp and every prime of the tame level split. The construction of [20], with the twists and specialization hypotheses in § 8, gives a class κ(f,K)\kappa(f,K) varying over anticyclotomic characters. The two Eisenstein constituents give rank-one coefficient modules ViacV_i^{\mathrm{ac}}, with elliptic-unit classes uiu_i. Their local regulators are the Katz functions Li\mathcal{L}_i, for i=1,2i=1,2.

Under the interpolation compatibility of Hypothesis 7.3, the BDP–Katz comparison gives

LBDPp2=A(f,K)L1L2.\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{BDP}}^{p^2}=\mathcal{A}(f,K)\mathcal{L}_1\mathcal{L}_2.

where A(f,K)\mathcal{A}(f,K) records the Euler and period factors. We therefore form

u(f,K)=vf,χ1⊗L2u1+vf,χ2⊗L1u2.u(f,K)=v_{f,\chi_1}\otimes\mathcal{L}_2u_1+v_{f,\chi_2}\otimes\mathcal{L}_1u_2.

Each elliptic-unit class is thus weighted by the Katz function of the other constituent. Under the local compatibility of §7.4, this combination satisfies the Heegner local condition and can be compared with the geometric class.

References

  1. [1][AOPR26] Raúl Alonso, Lois Omil-Pazos, and Óscar Rivero, Anticyclotomic diagonal classes and Beilinson–Flach elements, Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN (2026), no. 20, Paper No. rnag236. 5, 43, 44, 46, 48, 50arxiv.org/abs/2509.07564
  2. [2][BB22] Denis Benois and Kâzim Büyükboduk, Interpolation of Beilinson–Kato elements and p-adic L-functions, Ann. Math. Qué. 46 (2022), no. 2, 231–287. MR 4493258 22
  3. [3][BC06] Joël Bellaïche and Gaëtan Chenevier, Lissité de la courbe de Hecke de GL₂ aux points Eisenstein critiques, J. Inst. Math. Jussieu 5 (2006), no. 2, 333–349. 13DOI
  4. [4][BCD+14] Massimo Bertolini, Francesc Castella, Henri Darmon, Samit Dasgupta, Kartik Prasanna, and Victor Rotger, p-adic L-functions and Euler systems: a tale in two trilogies, Automorphic forms and Galois representations. Vol. 1, London Math. Soc. Lecture Notes, vol. 414, Cambridge Univ. Press, 2014, pp. 52–101. MR 3444223 16, 39
  5. [5][BD14] Massimo Bertolini and Henri Darmon, Kato’s Euler system and rational points on elliptic curves I: a p-adic Beilinson formula, Israel J. Math. 199 (2014), no. 1, 163–188. MR 3219532 19
  6. [6][BD15] Joël Bellaïche and Samit Dasgupta, The p-adic L-function of evil Eisenstein series, Compos. Math. 151 (2015), no. 6, 999–1040. 2
  7. [7][BD16] Joël Bellaïche and Mladen Dimitrov, On the eigencurve at classical weight 1 points, Duke Math. J. 165 (2016), no. 2, 245–266. MR 3457673 7DOI
  8. [8][BDP12] Massimo Bertolini, Henri Darmon, and Kartik Prasanna, p-adic Rankin L-series and rational points on CM elliptic curves, Pacific J. Math. 260 (2012), no. 2, 261–303. MR 3001796 38
  9. [9][BDP22] Adel Betina, Mladen Dimitrov, and Alice Pozzi, On the failure of Gorensteinness at weight 1 Eisenstein points of the eigencurve, Amer. J. Math. 144 (2022), no. 1, 227–265. MR 4367418 2, 7, 8, 14, 24, 26, 29arxiv.org/abs/1804.00648
  10. [10][Bel12] Joël Bellaïche, Critical p-adic L-functions, Invent. Math. 189 (2012), no. 1, 1–60. MR 2929082 13DOI
  11. [12]Armand Brumer, On the units of algebraic number fields, Mathematika 14 (1967), no. 2, 121–124. 18DOI
  12. [13]Massimo Bertolini, Marco Adamo Seveso, and Rodolfo Venerucci, Balanced diagonal classes and rational points on elliptic curves, Astérisque (2022), no. 434, 175–201, Heegner points, Stark-Heegner points, and diagonal classes. MR 4489474 50
  13. [14]———, Reciprocity laws for balanced diagonal classes, Astérisque (2022), no. 434, 77–174, Heegner points, Stark-Heegner points, and diagonal classes. MR 4489473 7
  14. [15]Francesc Castella and Kim Tuan Do, Diagonal cycles and anticyclotomic Iwasawa theory of modular forms, preprint, arXiv:2303.06751, 2023. 5arxiv.org/abs/2303.06751
  15. [16]Samit Dasgupta, Factorization of p-adic Rankin L-series, Invent. Math. 205 (2016), no. 1, 221–268. MR 3514962 2, 19DOI
  16. [17]Henri Darmon, Alan Lauder, and Victor Rotger, First order p-adic deformations of weight one newforms, L-functions and automorphic forms (Jan Hendrik Bruinier and Winfried Kohnen, eds.), Contributions in Mathematical and Computational Sciences, vol. 10, Springer, Cham, 2017, pp. 39–80. 3arxiv.org/abs/1903.02818
  17. [18]Takako Fukaya and Kazuya Kato, On conjectures of Sharifi, Kyoto J. Math. 64 (2024), no. 2, 277–420. 11, 21, 24DOI
  18. [19]Haruzo Hida, Arithmetic of adjoint L-values, p-adic aspects of modular forms, World Sci. Publ., Hackensack, NJ, 2016, pp. 185–236. MR 3587958 8
  19. [20]Dimitar Jetchev, David Loeffler, and Sarah Livia Zerbes, Heegner points in Coleman families, Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. 122 (2021), no. 1, 124–152. MR 4210260 4, 38, 39, 40DOI
  20. [21]Nicholas M. Katz, p-adic interpolation of real analytic Eisenstein series, Ann. of Math. (2) 104 (1976), no. 3, 459–571. MR 0506271 38DOI
  21. [22]Kazuya Kato, p-adic Hodge theory and values of zeta functions of modular forms, Astérisque (2004), no. 295, ix, 117–290, Cohomologies p-adiques et applications arithmétiques. III. 22, 39
  22. [23]David Loeffler and Óscar Rivero, Eisenstein degeneration of Euler systems, J. Reine Angew. Math. 814 (2024), 241–282. MR 4793345 4, 6, 13, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 44DOI
  23. [25]Tadashi Ochiai, A generalization of the Coleman map for Hida deformations, Amer. J. Math. 125 (2003), no. 4, 849–892. MR 1993743 22DOI
  24. [26]Masami Ohta, Ordinary p-adic étale cohomology groups attached to towers of elliptic modular curves, Compos. Math. 115 (1999), no. 3, 241–301. 25DOI
  25. [27]Alice Pozzi, The Eigencurve at Weight One Eisenstein Points, Ph.D. thesis, McGill University, Montréal, 2019. MR 4197785 14DOI
  26. [28]Javier Polo and Óscar Rivero, Eisenstein degeneration of Beilinson–Kato classes and circular units, With an appendix by Ju-Feng Wu, arXiv:2501.01514v3, 2025. 3, 4, 6, 13, 15, 16, 19, 20, 22, 33, 37arxiv.org/abs/2501.01514
  27. [29]Óscar Rivero and Victor Rotger, Beilinson–Flach elements, Stark units and p-adic iterated integrals, Forum Math. 31 (2019), no. 6, 1517–1531. 3DOI
  28. [30]Óscar Rivero and Victor Rotger, Motivic congruences and Sharifi’s conjecture, Amer. J. Math. 146 (2024), no. 6, 1691–1721. 9, 10, 12, 18arxiv.org/abs/2101.09972
  29. [31]Romyar T. Sharifi, A reciprocity map and the two-variable p-adic L-function, Ann. of Math. (2) 173 (2011), no. 1, 251–300. 11, 25arxiv.org/abs/0709.3591
  30. [32]Glenn Stevens, Arithmetic on modular curves, Progress in Mathematics, vol. 20, Birkhäuser Boston, Inc., Boston, MA, 1982. 11DOI
  31. [33]Sheng-Chi Shih and Jun Wang, On Sharifi’s conjecture: exceptional case, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 374 (2021), no. 12, 8531–8546. 2, 7, 20, 24, 28, 29, 35arxiv.org/abs/2009.07336

Paper details

vlnc:W_bxdedjya
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 4

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

GPT-6 Astra, Claude Opus 5.5

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents