betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

First inverse kinematics measurement of resonances in 7^7Be(α,γα,γ)11^{11}C relevant to neutrino-driven wind nucleosynthesis using DRAGON

Abstract

A possible mechanism to explain the origin of the light pp-nuclei in the Galaxy is the nucleosynthesis in the proton-rich neutrino-driven wind ejecta of core-collapse supernovae via the νpνp-process. However this production scenario is very sensitive to the underlying supernova dynamics and the nuclear physics input. As far as the nuclear uncertainties are concerned, the breakout from the pppp-chains via the 7^7Be(α,γα,γ)11^{11}C reaction has been identified as an important link which can influence the nuclear flow and therefore the efficiency of the νpνp-process. However its reaction rate is poorly known over the relevant temperature range, T = 1.5-3 GK. We report on the first direct measurement of two resonances of the 7^7Be(α,γα,γ)11^{11}C reaction with previously unknown strengths using an intense radioactive 7^7Be beam from the ISAC facility and the DRAGON recoil separator in inverse kinematics. We have decreased the 7^7Be(α,γα,γ)11^{11}C reaction rate uncertainty to ∼\sim 9.4-10.7% over the relevant temperature region.

Introduction

The origin of the roughly 35 neutron–deficient stable isotopes with masses A≥74A \ge74 — between 74Se^{74}\mathrm{Se} and 196Hg^{196}\mathrm{Hg} — in the proton–rich side of the valley of stability, known as the “pp–nuclei”, is a long–standing puzzle in nuclear astrophysics [1, 2, 3]. The pp–nuclei were also traditionally referred to as “excluded” nuclei, since they were “shielded” by the ss– and the rr–process reaction paths [4]. For this reason their observed solar abundances [5], are 1–2 orders of magnitude smaller than their ss– and rr–process counterparts in the same mass region. It is generally accepted that the pp–nuclei in the solar system have been produced by more than one process; however their synthesis mechanism is commonly referred to as “pp–process”.

The photodisintegration of pre–existing neutron–rich seeds, which is one of the most promising nucleosynthesis scenarios of pp–nuclei synthesis and is thought to take place in the oxygen–neon layer of core–collapse supernovae (ccSNe), cannot reproduce the solar abundances of the light 92,94Mo^{92,94}\mathrm{Mo} and 96,98Ru^{96,98}\mathrm{Ru} isotopes, as well as the rare species 113In^{113}\mathrm{In}, 115Sn^{115}\mathrm{Sn} and 138La^{138}\mathrm{La}. Additional astrophysical sites/nucleosynthesis scenarios have been proposed, such as the thermonuclear explosions of Chandrasekhar mass carbon–oxygen white dwarfs (CO WD) [6], which is also supported by Galactic Chemical Evolution (GCE) models and the rprp–process in Type I X–ray bursts [7]. It is remarkable that despite the variety of astrophysical models, all these processes can reproduce the solar abundances of most of the pp–nuclei to within a factor of 3 [e.g. see the sensitivity studies in References [8, 9]].

The advancement of multi–dimensional core–collapse supernova simulations with sophisticated neutrino transport methods, see References [10, 11] for the first studies that discussed this and [12, 13] for some more recent results, suggests that the composition of the early innermost ejecta of the neutrino–driven wind that drives the explosion are mostly proton–rich (the electron fraction YeY_e is greater than 0.51 [15, 16], and that gives rise to a new nucleosynthesis scenario, the νp\nu p–process [17, 18, 19], which can produce the lighter of the pp–nuclei.

To summarize the νp\nu p–process, the neutrino–driven wind ejects very hot (T>10T > 10 GK) and proton–rich material from the protoneutron star (PNS) (see Figure 1). At these extreme temperatures, the ejecta consist mainly of nucleons from dissociated nuclei. As the wind expands and cools down, nuclear statistical equilibrium (NSE) assembles these nucleons into mainly 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} and α\alpha particles (which are synthesised via the hot pppp–chain sequence [20]) with an excess of free protons. At T<3T < 3–44 GK, 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} can rapidly capture free protons. However, the reaction flow cannot move beyond 64Ge{}^{64}\mathrm{Ge}, which has a relatively long β+\beta^{+} half–life of 1.06 min. This issue is resolved by electron antineutrino captures on free protons via the p(νˉe,e+)np(\bar{\nu}_e,e^{+})n reaction, which produce a small amount of free neutrons, 10−1110^{-11}–10−1210^{-12} of the total mass. At temperature drops from 3 to 1.5 GK, the much faster (n,p)(n,p) reaction on 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}, followed by a sequence of radiative proton captures, i.e. (p,γ)(p,\gamma) reactions, and further (n,p)(n,p) reactions bypass 64Ge{}^{64}\mathrm{Ge} and similar waiting–points, such as 68Se{}^{68}\mathrm{Se} and 72Kr{}^{72}\mathrm{Kr} with half–lives of 35.5 s and 17.1 s, respectively. The reaction flow follows the Z=NZ=N line up to the molybdenum region and then moves into more neutron–rich isotopes (Z<NZ<N) between molybdenum and tin. Finally, as the temperature drops below T<1.5T<1.5 GK, (p,γ)(p,\gamma) reactions freeze–out due to the Coulomb barrier, and the produced nuclei decay back to stability, with 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} still being the most abundant nucleus in the plasma.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Simplified schematic of the nucleosynthesis in neutrino–driven wind ejecta. The different stages and outcomes (νp\nu p–process and weak rr–process) are shown. The figure is adapted from José and Iliadis [21].

The uncertainties of νp\nu p–process nucleosynthesis, mainly attributed to the supernova dynamics and the underlying nuclear physics input, have been explored by many groups [14, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26] since it was first proposed. The most crucial component for a successful νp\nu p–process is the electron fraction YeY_e of the ejecta. Recent hydrodynamical studies with proper neutrino transport have shown that YeY_e can lie between 0.5 and 0.6 before the onset of νp\nu p–processing at T=3T=3 GK. Sensitivity studies have explored a variety of YeY_e values, ranging from 0.5 to 0.8, and suggest that a higher YeY_e leads to a more efficient νp\nu p–process (i.e. production of heavier nuclei).

Concerning the nuclear physics input of the νp\nu p–process the main uncertainties arise from a handful of reactions, and the nuclear masses along the reaction path. The two most important reactions that dominate the nucleosynthesis in this scenario are the bottleneck 56Ni(n,p)56Co{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}(n,p){}^{56}\mathrm{Co} and triple–α\alpha–4He(α,γ)12C{}^{4}\mathrm{He}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{12}\mathrm{C} reactions. The former is always the first step of the νp\nu p–process and as a result controls the reaction flow, with a smaller rate yielding a more efficient nucleosynthesis, since the free neutrons synthesized from neutrino captures are captured by nuclei with 30≤Z≤4230\leq Z\leq42, acting as “neutron poisons”.

The triple–α\alpha reaction controls the production of α\alpha–particles, protons and the 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} seed before the onset and during the νp\nu p–process. Therefore it controls completely the neutron–to–seed ratio Δn\Delta_n, as defined by Pruet et al. [19]. Our current knowledge of this reaction, despite its importance, is still limited and bears large experimental uncertainties. The three rates that are most commonly used in nucleosynthesis studies are those from References [27, 28, 29]. In addition, Jin et al. [30] recently showed that an enhanced triple–α\alpha reaction, due to an in–medium width change of the Hoyle state, suppresses the production of pp–nuclei in the νp\nu p–process.

In the sensitivity study of Wanajo et al. [22], some alternative pathways were explored. In particular, the authors found that there are a couple of two–body reaction sequences, namely 7Be(α,γ)11C(α,p)14N{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,p){}^{14}\mathrm{N} and 7Be(α,p)10B(α,p)13C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,p){}^{10}\mathrm{B}(\alpha,p){}^{13}\mathrm{C}, which compete with the triple–α\alpha reaction, the main link between the pppp–chain (A<12A<12) and CNO (A≥20A\geq20) region, at the relevant temperature region T=1.5T=1.5–33 GK. This competition affects the Δn\Delta_n factor and as a result, the reaction flow and the final elemental abundances. The authors studied the sensitivity of the final abundances by multiplying and dividing the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction rate by factors of 2 and 10. This rate variation affected the production of light pp–nuclei with 90<A<11090<A<110 up to an order of magnitude. A faster 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} rate leads to increased production of intermediate–mass nuclei that remove protons from the environment, acting as “proton poisons”. Subsequent studies, such as that by Nishimura et al. [26], also acknowledge the importance of the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction, but do not provide a quantitative impact in the production of pp–nuclei. As we shall discuss in detail in Section § 0.2, the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction rate is not well known in the relevant temperature range due to unknown resonance strengths, and thus an experimental study is required.

In the present work we report on the first inverse kinematics study of the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction, using the DRAGON recoil separator and an intense 7Be^{7}\mathrm{Be} radioactive ion beam from ISAC. The paper is structured as follows: in § 0.2 we discuss the previous measurements regarding resonances of the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction. In Sections III and IV we present the experimental details of the present work along with the analysis procedures, and finally we discuss our results and conclusions in § 1 and VI.

Previous Measurements

Our current understanding of the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction over the energy region relevant to νp\nu p–process nucleosynthesis is based on three experimental studies [31, 32, 33].

Figure 2 shows the current level structure of 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} along with its mirror 11B^{11}\mathrm{B}, and in Table I we summarize the resonance parameters for the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction from the A=11A=11 evaluation of Kelley et al. [34].

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Partial level scheme of the mirror nuclei 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} and 11B^{11}\mathrm{B} adopted from Kelley et al. [34], with the addition of the Ex=8.900E_x=8.900 MeV state from Yamaguchi et al. [33]. The dashed lines indicate isobaric analog states, and next to the 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} scheme we present the α\alpha separation energy QαQ_\alpha, the resonances of the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction, ErE_r, in keV and the relevant energy region for νp\nu p–process nucleosynthesis.

The two lowest–lying energy resonances of the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction, which correspond to the Ex=8.105E_x=8.105 and 8.4208.420 MeV levels in 11C^{11}\mathrm{C}, were studied by Hardie et al. [31] in forward kinematics at Argonne National Laboratory. The authors used two methods to calculate the resonance strengths: the first was the thick target yield formula (similar to Equation (4)), and the second was a complementary relative method which employed the presence of 7Li^{7}\mathrm{Li} in the target, and the fact that they were studying the 7Li(α,γ)11B^{7}\mathrm{Li}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{B} reaction in the same campaign. More specifically, the relative method provided the resonance strength ratio between the resonances of interest in 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} and the known 660 keV (Ex=9.272E_x=9.272 MeV in 11B^{11}\mathrm{B}) resonance of the 7Li(α,γ)11B^{7}\mathrm{Li}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{B} reaction, reported in the same work. The main advantage of this method is that both the 7Li:7Be^{7}\mathrm{Li}:^{7}\mathrm{Be} ratio in the target and the detector efficiencies are more accurately known than the number of 7Be^{7}\mathrm{Be} atoms alone and the absolute efficiencies. Nevertheless, one has to include an extra uncertainty factor from the 7Li(α,γ)11B^{7}\mathrm{Li}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{B} resonance. The adopted values for the two resonance strengths in Table I are the weighted averages of the two methods.

Wiescher et al. [32] studied the Ex=8.654E_x=8.654 and 8.6998.699 MeV levels in 11C^{11}\mathrm{C}, which correspond to the 1110 and 1155 keV7 resonances of the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction. They used the 10B(p,γ)11C^{10}\mathrm{B}(p,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction in forward kinematics employing three different linear accelerators, covering a wide energy range (Ex=8−10.7E_x=8-10.7 MeV). In all three experimental setups, several detectors were used, allowing for angular distribution measurements. The authors observed primary γ\gamma transitions from the Ex=8.654E_x=8.654 and

8.6998.699 MeV states and calculated the ratio Γγ/Γα\Gamma_\gamma/\Gamma_\alpha for them using the cross sections from the γ\gamma ray and α\alpha–particle channels, σ(p,γ)/σ(p,α)\sigma(p,\gamma)/\sigma(p,\alpha).

The most recent study relevant to the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction was performed by Yamaguchi et al. [33] using the low-energy radioactive ion beam facility CRIB [35] at CNS in RIKEN, Japan. The 7Be+α^{7}\mathrm{Be}+\alpha resonant scattering and 7Be(α,p)^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,p) reaction measurements were performed using the thick–target method in inverse kinematics and provided the excitation functions for Ex=8.7E_x=8.7–13.013.0 MeV. The RR–matrix analysis of the data shows two small peaks in the low energy region, between 8.908.90 and 9.209.20 MeV. The first one is considered to be the known 5/2+5/2^+ state at 9.209.20 MeV observed by Wiescher et al. [32]. The second one, located at around 8.908.90 MeV, is regarded by the authors as a new resonance. However, they argue that this spectral feature could also originate from either the Ex=8.655E_x=8.655 or the 8.699 MeV states since their the energy uncertainty was quite large in this energy region. Finally, all this information about the 7^{7}Be(α,γ)11(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}C resonances is summarised in Table I.

ExE_x (MeV)ErE_r (keV)JπJ^\piΓα\Gamma_\alphaΓγ\Gamma_\gammaΓp\Gamma_pℓ\ellωγ\omega\gamma (eV)
7.4997(15)−43.9(15)3/2+3/2^+2.2(1.6) eV1.15 eV∥^{\parallel}-1⋯\cdots
8.1045(17)560.5(17)3/2−3/2^-6−2+66^{+6}_{-2} eV0.350(56) eV-00.331(41)
8.420(2)†^\dagger876(2)5/2+5/2^+12.6(38) eV3.1(13) eV-23.80(57)
8.654(4)†^\dagger1110(4)7/2+7/2^+≤5\leq5 keV--3⋯\cdots
8.699(2)†^\dagger1155(2)5/2+5/2^+15(1) keV1.15(16) eV∥^{\parallel}-1⋯\cdots
8.900⋄^\diamond(9/2+)(9/2^+)>8>8 keV-(3)(1.2)
9.645(50)2101(50)(3/2−)(3/2^-)210(40) keV17 eV∥^{\parallel}48(9) eV0⋯\cdots
9.780(50)2236(50)(5/2−)(5/2^-)240(50) keV1 eV∥^{\parallel}520(100) eV2⋯\cdots
9.970(50)2426(50)(7/2−)(7/2^-)120(20) keV1 eV∥^{\parallel}760(140) eV2⋯\cdots
10.083(5)2539(5)9/2+9/2^+≈230\approx230 keV<0.2<0.2 eV∥^{\parallel}900(180) eV3⋯\cdots

Table 1. Resonance parameters for the 7^{7}Be(α,γ)11(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}C reaction from Kelley et al. [34]. The parameters for the resonance noted with a ⋄\diamond are adopted from Yamaguchi et al. [33]. Tentative assignments and estimates are presented in parentheses. The resonances noted with a †\dagger were studied in the present work. Values noted with a ∥\parallel were adopted from the mirror nucleus 11^{11}B. The proton partial widths Γp\Gamma_p have been calculated using C2S=1C^2S=1.

The current 7^{7}Be(α,γ)11(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}C reaction rate is based on a calculation from NACRE (I and II) [28, 36] and includes contributions only from the 561 and 876 keV resonances, for which experimentally measured strengths exist, and the non-resonant (DC) contribution is adopted with the same parameters as those of the mirror 7^{7}Li(α,γ)11(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}B reaction, for T<0.7T<0.7 GK. Contributions from the broad resonances at 2101, 2236, 2426 & 2539 keV were also included in NACRE–II and affect the reaction rate for T>2T>2 GK. In NACRE–I the same high energy part of the reaction rate was estimated using Hauser–Feshbach calculations. The rate that was used in the sensitivity study by Wanajo et al. [22] was the one from Angulo et al. [28] (NACRE–I), which is uncertain by factors of 1.87–2.54 in the relevant temperature region. The NACRE–II reaction rate is uncertain by factors of 1.76–1.91 for T=1.5T=1.5–3 GK. The uncertainties are derived from their Potential Model (PM), which is used to reproduce the experimental astrophysical SS–factor data. S(E)≡(E/e−2πη)σ(E)S(E)\equiv(E/e^{-2\pi\eta})\sigma(E), where EE is the center of mass energy, and η\eta is the Sommerfeld parameter, which is related to the charges and velocities of the interacting particles. More specifically, the uncertainties are calculated by using the maximum and minimum parameters of the PM. It is also worth noting that the sub-threshold resonance at Ex=7.50E_x=7.50 MeV (Er=−43.9E_r=-43.9 keV) has a large contribution at low temperatures, below T≈0.3T\approx0.3 GK and according to Descouvemont [37], it could affect the production of 7^{7}Li (fed by the decay of 7^{7}Be) in classical novae [38].

Experimental Details

The measurements of this work were carried out using the DRAGON recoil separator [39] at TRIUMF, Canada’s particle accelerator centre in Vancouver, BC.

Intense beams of 7^{7}Be+^+ were produced using the ISOL technique, by bombarding thick ZrC and graphite targets with 55 μ\muA 500 MeV protons from the TRIUMF cyclotron. The A=7A=7 isobars, mainly 7^{7}Li and 7^{7}Be, were extracted from the target through a high-resolution mass separator, and the beryllium ionization was enhanced using the TRIUMF Resonant Ionization Laser Ion Source (TRILIS) [40]. After the ion source, the beam was transported through the ISAC high resolution (M/Δ\DeltaM = 2000) mass separator and then accelerated through the ISAC-I Radio-Frequency Quadrupole (RFQ) and Drift-Tube Linac (DTL) to energies so that each resonance was centered in the gas target (see Table II for details). The beam energies were chosen in order to cover center-of-mass windows of 1157 ±\pm 24 keV, 1111 ±\pm 13 keV, and 878 ±\pm 17 keV, across the gas target volume. To ensure a pure, contaminant-free radioactive ion beam, an additional carbon stripping foil of 20 μ\mug/cm2^2 was placed downstream of the DTL allowing fully stripped 7^{7}Be4+^{4+} to be selected using a bending magnet for transport to DRAGON, thus eliminating the main isobaric contaminant 7^{7}Li. This technique has also been used in other radioactive beam facilities [41]. Finally, 7^{7}Be4+^{4+} was delivered at the helium-filled windowless gas target of DRAGON at mean intensities of ∼1.3\sim1.3–5.8×1085.8\times10^8 pps (see Section IV C for normalisation details of the intensities).

EbeamE_{\mathrm{beam}} (A keV)ElabE_{\mathrm{lab}} (MeV)Ibeam×108I_{\mathrm{beam}} \times10^8 (s−1^{-1})PtargetP_{\mathrm{target}} (Torr)
Run 1464.2(3)3.249(2)1.33(7)7.9(1)
Run 1442.7(2)3.099(1)2.06(8)5.06(6)
Run 2441.8(2)3.093(1)5.83(2)4.89(3)
Run 2351.8(3)2.463(2)3.45(12)5.75(4)

Table 2. Beam and gas target properties for the two independent measurements of the present studya^a.

DRAGON has four main components: (a) the windowless, differentially pumped, recirculating gas target, (b) the γ\gamma ray detector array, (c) the electromagnetic mass separator and (d) the recoil detection system, which are shown in the schematic of Figure 3.

Schematic representation of the DRAGON recoil separator

Figure 3. Schematic representation of the DRAGON recoil separator. The main components are shown.

The γ\gamma ray array consists of 30 BGO scintillator crystals with photo–multiplier tubes (PMTs) covering 89 − 92% of the 4π4\pi solid angle [42]. The segmented array allows for the detection of individual prompt γ\gamma rays from the radiative capture reactions inside the gas target and the tagging of the associated recoil particles, which provides an additional background reduction in the focal plane detectors.

The DRAGON electromagnetic mass separator consists of two magnetic (M) and two electric dipoles (E) in a MEME configuration. The two–stage separation begins with the first magnetic dipole (MD1), which selects a single charge stage to be transmitted through DRAGON. For our study, we tuned DRAGON to the q=2+q = 2^{+} charge state for all resonances. Recoils that do not have the aforementioned charge are deflected to slits that are located downstream of the MD1. Subsequently, the recoils are led to the first electric dipole (ED1) where they are separated according to mass. ED1 is followed by the second stage of magnetic and electric dipoles (MD2 and ED2), until the beam reaches the focal plane, where the heavy ion detectors are located.

Close to the focal plane of DRAGON we employed a microchannel plate (MCP) and a double–sided silicon–strip detector (DSSSD). The MCP provided the starting timing signal for a local time–of–flight (TOF) transmission measurement [43]. In the DSSSD, the recoils are stopped, their kinetic energy and position are measured and the stopping timing signal is recorded. In addition, we employed the prompt γ\gamma rays from the BGO array as a starting signal for a “separator TOF” measurement for the coincidence analysis (see Section IV B). The data were recorded using a state–of–the–art time–stamp–based data acquisition system (DAQ) [44].

It is worth mentioning that such a measurement using DRAGON, and any other recoil separator dedicated to resonance strength measurements, is quite challenging, due to geometric considerations. The maximum recoil angle of the reaction at the resonance energies of interest can be calculated using the following equation,

θr,max⁡=arctan⁡(E+Q2m1c2(m1+m2m2)E)(1)\theta_{r,\max} = \arctan\left(\frac{E+Q}{\sqrt{2m_1c^2\left(\frac{m_1+m_2}{m_2}\right)E}}\right) \tag*{(1)}

where EE is the center of mass energy, QQ is the reaction QQ value and m1,m2m_1,m_2 are the masses of the projectile and the target nuclei, respectively. This corresponds to a single γ\gamma ray emission to the recoil nucleus ground state at 90∘90^\circ in the center–of–mass system.

For the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction maximum recoil angles are θr,max⁡=42.67\theta_{r,\max} = 42.67 mrad for the 1155 keV, 43.3 mrad for the 1110 keV and 47.42 mrad for the 876 keV. These numbers far exceed the nominal angular acceptance of DRAGON, θDRAGON=±21\theta_{\mathrm{DRAGON}} = \pm21 mrad). For this reason, we performed detailed GEANT simulations of DRAGON [45, 46] to extract the transmission of the recoils through the separator (ηseparator\eta_{\mathrm{separator}}), and in addition, the BGO array efficiency (ηBGO\eta_{\mathrm{BGO}}), which are used for the resonance strength calculations. References [42, 47, 48] provide an in-depth discussion about this approach, and in Section IV F we provide the specifics for the study of the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction.

Data Analysis

We performed yield measurements for three beam energies, corresponding to the 1155, 1110 and 876 keV resonances of the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction (see Figure 2). As we have already discussed in § 0.2, the 876 keV resonance strength has been measured by Hardie et al. [31], while the latter two resonances have unknown strengths. Our reasoning to re-measure that resonance is two-fold: on the one hand it is believed to have the greatest impact on the current reaction rate at νp\nu p-process energies [36] and on the other hand it will provide one additional demonstration that DRAGON can measure resonance strengths for reactions in which the angular spread of the recoils exceeds its nominal acceptance [47, 48].

Thick target yield and resonance strength

The calculation of thermonuclear reaction rates in a laboratory setting requires the determination of the reaction cross section. Instead, what is actually measured in experimental studies is the reaction yield, which can be simply expressed as:

Y=NRNB(2)Y = \frac{\mathcal{N}_{R}}{\mathcal{N}_{B}} \tag*{(2)}

where NR\mathcal{N}_{R} is the number of reactions that occur and NB\mathcal{N}_{B} is the number of incident beam particles. In fact, an experimental setup has a finite detection efficiency, in our case ηDRAGON\eta_{DRAGON}, meaning that it does not detect the total number of reactions, but rather a fraction of it, Nr\mathcal{N}_{r}. According to the analysis mode that we use, singles or coincidences (see Section IV B), ηDRAGON\eta_{DRAGON} can be either ηDRAGONsingles=ηseparatorfq ηMCP ηDSSSD ηlivesingles\eta_{DRAGON}^{singles}=\eta_{separator} f_{q}\,\eta_{MCP}\,\eta_{DSSSD}\,\eta_{live}^{singles}, or ηDRAGONcoinc=ηseparatorfq ηBGO ηMCP ηDSSSD ηlivecoinc\eta_{DRAGON}^{coinc}=\eta_{separator} f_{q}\,\eta_{BGO}\,\eta_{MCP}\,\eta_{DSSSD}\,\eta_{live}^{coinc}, respectively. The experimental yield is then given by:

Y=NrNB ηDRAGON(3)Y = \frac{\mathcal{N}_{r}}{\mathcal{N}_{B}\,\eta_{DRAGON}} \tag*{(3)}

We can also express the energy-dependent reaction yield as a relation between the cross section σ(E)\sigma(E) and the target thickness ΔE\Delta E, or better, the stopping power of the target ε(E)\varepsilon(E), for beam energy EbeamE_{\mathrm{beam}} using:

Y(Ebeam)=∫E−ΔEEσ(E)ε(E) dE(4)Y(E_{\mathrm{beam}}) = \int_{E-\Delta E}^{E} \frac{\sigma(E)}{\varepsilon(E)}\,dE \tag*{(4)}

For narrow resonances with constant stopping power over the resonance width, which can be found in reactions relevant for astrophysics, we can calculate the integral of Equation (4) analytically using a single-level Breit–Wigner (Lorentzian) cross section profile [49]. Specifically, in the case of an infinitely thick target, that is ΔE→∞\Delta E \to\infty, or equivalently ΔE≫Γ\Delta E \gg\Gamma, we have:

Y(Ebeam)=λr2ωγ2πεr[tan⁡−1(Ebeam−ErΓ/2)+π2](5)Y(E_{\mathrm{beam}}) = \frac{\lambda_{r}^{2}\omega\gamma}{2\pi\varepsilon_{r}}\left[\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{E_{\mathrm{beam}}-E_{r}}{\Gamma/2}\right)+\frac{\pi}{2}\right] \tag*{(5)}

where λr\lambda_{r} and εr\varepsilon_{r} are the de Broglie wavelength and the target stopping power in the center of mass system, ErE_{r} is the energy of the resonance, Γ\Gamma is its width and ΔE\Delta E is the target thickness. Solving for Ebeam=ErE_{\mathrm{beam}}=E_{r}, we can obtain a simple expression for the reaction yield and the resonance strength ωγ\omega\gamma:

ωγ=2YΔE→∞ελr2m1m1+m2(6)\omega\gamma= \frac{2Y_{\Delta E\to\infty}\varepsilon}{\lambda_{r}^{2}}\frac{m_{1}}{m_{1}+m_{2}} \tag*{(6)}

where the reaction yield YΔE→∞Y_{\Delta E\to\infty} is given by Equation (3) and ε\varepsilon is the target stopping power in the laboratory frame – a discussion on how it is measured in DRAGON experiments can be found in Section IV E.

Particle Identification

The first step towards determining the reaction yield and subsequently the strength of a resonance is the identification of the reaction products or recoils. For this, we employed two distinct methods: a detection of 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} recoils in singles, using the DSSSD and a local TOF (MCP–DSSSD), and in γ\gamma–recoil coincidences using the separator TOF (BGO–DSSSD). Figure 4 shows typical particle identification plots for the three resonances of the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction both in singles (grey points) and in coincidences (coloured points), with additional software cuts, such as the energy range of the γ\gamma rays in the BGO array and the energy deposited in the DSSSD, providing further recoil discrimination. It is evident that for the 876 and 1110 keV resonances the yield is low, but the signal is clear and without any unwanted background, such as unreacted, “leaky” beam. This is consistent with the fact that DRAGON is able to reject unreacted beam particles from (α,γ)(\alpha,\gamma) reactions very efficiently and has demonstrated a beam suppression of >1013>10^{13} [50]. In the present experiment, the rejection is higher, due to the use of a fully-stripped beam and the fact that the selected carbon recoils have a very different charge state (4+4+ vs 2+2+).

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Particle identification plot for the 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} recoils for each of the resonances we studied in the present work using the local Time–Of–Flight transmission measurement and the energy deposited in the DSSSD at the focal plane of DRAGON. The coloured and grey points correspond to coincident and singles recoils events, respectively. For the 1110 keV, we show the two independent measurements in separate panels. See the text for details.

In addition to the aforementioned methods, we could also identify the recoils of interest using a timing signal of the 11.8 MHz ISAC-I radio frequency quadrupole (RF) accelerator and the capture of a coincidence γ\gamma ray by the BGO array (BGO–RF) [39, 44]. Figure 5 shows the results for each resonance.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. Particle identification plot using the BGO versus accelerator RF Time–Of–Flight for coincident recoil events. The RF period is τRF=84.8\tau_{\mathrm{RF}} = 84.8 ns.

Beam Normalization

We monitored the 7^{7}Be beam current throughout the experiment using silicon surface barrier detectors (SSB) at well defined laboratory angles of 30∘30^\circ and 57∘57^\circ with respect to the beam axis by detecting the elastically scattered target particles. Due to the low count rate in the SSB detectors, we did not use SSB measurements for short time windows Δt\Delta t, before and after each yield measurement to calculate the beam normalization R\mathcal{R} factor, as is typical in DRAGON experiments (see for example the works in References [39, 51, 52, 53]). Instead, we first ensured that the beam current during each run was stable by checking the current on the charge slits after the first magnetic dipole and used the total integrated counts in the SSBs per yield run to calculate the R\mathcal{R} factor, which is given by:

R=I∣q⋅e∣ΔtNαPEb2ηtarget(7)\mathcal{R} = \frac{I}{|q\cdot e|}\frac{\Delta t}{N_{\alpha}}\frac{P}{E_{b}^{2}}\eta_{target} \tag*{(7)}

where II is the average current reading at the upstream Faraday Cup before the gas target, qq is the beam charge state (4+4+), ee is the elementary charge (e=1.6×10−19e=1.6\times10^{-19} C), NαN_{\alpha} is the number of scattered α\alpha particles detected by the surface barrier detectors during the yield run time Δt\Delta t, PP is the gas target pressure in Torr, EbE_{b} is the beam energy in keV/u and ηtarget\eta_{target} is the transmission through an empty target. We assume only elastic Rutherford scattering for the target particles and the Eb2/PE_{b}^{2}/P factor enters

Equation 7 to make R\mathcal{R} invariant to the chosen beam energy and target pressure [54].

The normalized number of beam particles NbeamN_{\mathrm{beam}}, is then given by:

Nbeam=RNαEb2P(8)N_{\mathrm{beam}} = \mathcal{R}N_{\alpha}\frac{E_b^2}{P} \tag*{(8)}

Table III shows the R\mathcal{R} factor results for all the yield measurements of the present work. Note that in our two independent experimental runs we used different SSB gains, threshold settings, and pre-scalers. For this reason, the NαN_{\alpha} that we use in Equations 7 and 8 to extract NbeamN_{\mathrm{beam}} are also different.

Carbon in helium charge state distribution

DRAGON is tuned to select and transport a single charge state to the final focal plane. For this reason, an accurate knowledge of the recoil charge state distribution (CSD) is necessary to determine the total reaction yield. Since the recoil nucleus, in our case 11C^{11}\mathrm{C}, is unstable, an abundant and stable isotope of the same element is used instead — 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}. The stable ion beam for this measurement was provided from the microwave ion source (MWIS) of the ISAC Off–Line Ion Source (OLIS) [55].

At DRAGON, the charge state distributions can be

determined experimentally by measuring the beam current on Faraday cups before and after the gas target, and comparing it to the current on a Faraday cup downstream from the first magnetic dipole (see Figure 3). We chose to tune DRAGON to the 2+2^{+} charge state because according to theoretical calculations [56], it is the maximum of the distribution, thus providing the highest recoil yield. Figure 6 shows the results for this charge charge for energies corresponding to the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} resonance strengths.

Image not extracted

Figure 6. Experimentally measured carbon in helium Charge State Distribution. The fit to the experimental data is a Gaussian function, and the band gives the 1σ1\sigma confidence interval to the fit.

7Be stopping power in 4He

The stopping power ϵ\epsilon of the gas target is an important component for the calculation of the reaction yield. The advantage of recoil separators, such as DRAGON, is that the stopping power is measured directly and it is not based on semi–empirical estimates that can introduce an additional uncertainty factor in the final result. At DRAGON, the stopping power is measured by varying both the pressure of the gas target and the magnetic field strength needed to center the beam at a momentum dispersed angular focus after the first magnetic dipole. Our experimental results agree to within 6% with calculations using the SRIM code [57], as shown in Table IV.

EbeamE_{\mathrm{beam}} (A keV)ϵDRAGON\epsilon_{\mathrm{DRAGON}}ϵSRIM\epsilon_{\mathrm{SRIM}}
464.2(3)40.7(15)38.2
442.6(2)39.7(15)38.8
441.9(2)39.5(15)38.8
351.8(3)41.5(18)39.6

Table IV. Summary of the 7Be{}^{7}\mathrm{Be} in 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} stopping power measurements. The experimental results are compared with the calculations of SRIM [57]. The units of ϵ\epsilon are eV/(10^{15} atoms/cm2^{2}).

GEANT simulations of DRAGON

As we have already pointed out in the above, detailed simulations using Geant are needed to determine the recoil transmission ηseparator\eta_{\mathrm{separator}} and the efficiency of the BGO array ηBGO\eta_{\mathrm{BGO}}, which are used to calculate the reaction yield, and subsequently the resonance strength ωγ\omega\gamma as part of the recoil detection efficiency of DRAGON, ηDRAGON\eta_{\mathrm{DRAGON}}. The DRAGON Geant simulation toolkit9 has been extensively used for experimental planning, such as in the study of the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction [58], and its results show agreement with experimental data to within 1–10% [46].

The simulation input file includes all the information Geant requires to perform the simulation such as the energy, spin, lifetime, and γ\gamma branching ratios for each nuclear level and in addition the energy and width of the resonance of interest (see Table V for an overview). For the study of the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction, the nuclear information was adopted from the A=11 evaluation of Kelley et al. [34]. Specifically for the 1110 keV resonance, since there are no experimentally measured γ\gamma branching ratios, we adopted those of the mirror state in 11B{}^{11}\mathrm{B}. For the γ\gamma ray angular distribution W(θ)W(\theta), which affects both the transmission of the recoils and the BGO array efficiency [42, 47], we calculated all the possible W(θ)W(\theta) for each cascade, following the prescription of Rose and Brink [59]. In addition, we changed the gas target pressure in the simulation, in order to obtain the same stopping power as in the experiment (see Section IV E).

QuantityEr=876E_r = 876 keVEr=1110E_r = 1110 keVEr=1155E_r = 1155 keV
Excited state lifetime0.030 fs1.31×10−191.31 \times10^{-19} s4.3×10−204.3 \times10^{-20} s
Resonance energy (keV)874–8781106–1114 keV1153–1157 keV
Particle (α\alpha) partial width12.6 eV5 keV15 keV
γ\gamma branching ratiosExfE_x^f (MeV) \quad ExfE_x^f (MeV) \quad B.R.ExfE_x^f (MeV) \quad ExfE_x^f (MeV) \quad B.R.ExfE_x^f (MeV) \quad ExfE_x^f (MeV) \quad B.R.
8.420 \quad 0 \quad 938.654 \quad 0 \quad 0.9±0.30.9 \pm0.38.699 \quad 0 \quad 42±1042 \pm10
4.319 \quad 74.319 \quad 86.6±2.386.6 \pm2.34.319 \quad 42±1042 \pm10
6.478 \quad 12.5±1.112.5 \pm1.14.804 \quad 2.4±1.52.4 \pm1.5
6.478 \quad 13.6±4.613.6 \pm4.6

Table V. Settings of the Geant3 simulation for the 7Be(α,γ)11C^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{C} data analysis. Nuclear properties were adopted from Kelley et al. [34]. For the 1110 keV resonance, the branching ratios of the mirror nucleus 11B^{11}\mathrm{B} are used.

We performed simulations for each resonance energy within its uncertainty, ±2\pm2, ±4\pm4 and ±2\pm2 keV for the 1155, 1110 and 876 keV resonance respectively. The final results used in the data analysis are the averages of these simulations and the systematic uncertainty is attributed mainly to the uncertainty in the γ\gamma branching ratios and the range of possible γ\gamma angular distributions.

Figure 7 shows the results from a simulation of the Er=1155E_r = 1155 keV resonance. It is evident that transitions with a cascade of multiple γ\gamma rays, such as the 8.699 MeV →\to 4.32 MeV provide more favourable conditions for transmission through the separator, since their recoil angular distribution from multiple decay vectors averages out with resulting maximum intensity at lower angles, as Ruiz et al. [42] argue.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. Angular distribution for recoils of the Er=1155E_r = 1155 keV resonance that hit the focal plane detector (DSSSD) using Geant. The contributions from different cascades are shown. The vertical dashed line defines the angular acceptance of DRAGON, θDRAGON=21\theta_{\mathrm{DRAGON}} = 21 mrad.

Figure 4. Clusters of 33 and 49 recoil events in coincidence and singles modes were detected, despite the low recoil transmission through the separator (ηseparator=0.141(28)\eta_{\mathrm{separator}} = 0.141(28), see also Table VIII).

Source1155 keV1110 keV (Run 1)1110 keV (Run 2)876 keV
Detected recoils, NrecsinglesN_{\mathrm{rec}}^{\mathrm{singles}}49(7) (14.3%)14−3.7+4.314^{+4.3}_{-3.7} (+31% −26%)9−2.7+3.89^{+3.8}_{-2.7} (+42% −30%)16−3.8+4.316^{+4.3}_{-3.8} (+27% −24%)
Detected recoils, NreccoincN_{\mathrm{rec}}^{\mathrm{coinc}}33(6) (18.2%)9−2.7+3.89^{+3.8}_{-2.7} (+42% −30%)7−2.8+3.37^{+3.3}_{-2.8} (+47% −40%)13−3.7+4.313^{+4.3}_{-3.7} (+33% −28%)
Charge state fraction, fqf_q0.40(1) (2.5%)0.41(1) (2.4%)0.41(1) (2.4%)0.41(1) (2.4%)
Beam particles, Nbeam×1013N_{\mathrm{beam}} \times10^{13}1.07(2) (1.9%)1.76(5) (2.8%)1.53(5) (3.2%)2.12(3) (1.41%)
BGO efficiency, ηBGO\eta_{\mathrm{BGO}}0.77(1) (1.3%)0.81(7) (8.6%)0.81(7) (8.6%)0.80(18) (22.5%)
Separator transmission, ηseparator\eta_{\mathrm{separator}}0.141(28) (19.9%)0.266(18) (6.8%)0.266(18) (6.8%)0.016(3) (18.8%)
MCP efficiencya^{a}, ηMCP\eta_{\mathrm{MCP}}0.545(59) (10.8%)0.650(61) (9.4%)0.321(25) (7.8%)0.351(19) (5.4%)
Live time, ηlivesingles\eta_{\mathrm{live}}^{\mathrm{singles}}0.95409(5) (0.005%)0.95777(5) (0.005%)0.99099(5) (0.005%)0.93408(5) (0.005%)
Live time, ηlivecoinc\eta_{\mathrm{live}}^{\mathrm{coinc}}0.80381(4) (0.005%)0.80434(4) (0.005%)0.82156(4) (0.005%)0.81571 (0.005%)
Stopping power, ϵ\epsilon (eV/(101510^{15}/cm2^2))40.7(15) (3.7%)39.7(15) (3.8%)39.5(15) (3.8%)41.5(18) (4.3%)
Beam energy (A keV)462.2(3) (0.06%)442.6(2) (0.05%)441.8(2) (0.05%)351.8(3) (0.09%)
Total uncertainty in singles14.3% (stat.)+31%−26%+31\%_{-26\%} (stat.)+42%−30%+42\%_{-30\%} (stat.)+27%−24%+27\%_{-24\%} (stat.)
(statistical & systematic)23.2% (syst.)12.8% (syst.)11.8% (syst.)20.2% (syst.)
Total uncertainty in coincidences18.2% (stat.)+42%−30%+42\%_{-30\%} (stat.)+47%−40%+47\%_{-40\%} (stat.)+33%−28%+33\%_{-28\%} (stat.)
(statistical & systematic)23.2% (syst.)15.4% (syst.)14.6% (syst.)30.3% (syst.)

Table VIII. Values given with uncertainties for the quantities used to calculate the resonance strengths in singles and coincidences modes. The relative errors are quoted in parentheses.

The Geant simulations we performed for this resonance are in very good agreement with the experimental results, as Figure 8 shows (see also Figure 2 of Ref. [60] for the same resonance). It is worth noting that DRAGON is more sensitive to the detection of recoils that γ\gamma decay to the Ex=4.319E_x = 4.319 MeV state, compared to the ground state, as we discussed in Section IV F.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. Comparison between the experimental data (points) and the Geant simulation (histograms) for a BGO γ\gamma ray energy spectrum from the 1155 keV resonance. The two dominant γ\gamma transitions to the Ex=4.319E_x = 4.319 MeV and the ground state can be clearly seen in the simulation results. We do not depict the weak transition to the Ex=4.804E_x = 4.804 MeV state. See the text for details.

Results

In the following, we shall discuss the results from each resonance studied in the present work and then present the uncertainties and the calculation of the new thermonuclear reaction rate NA⟨σv⟩N_A\langle\sigma v\rangle.

Strength of the 1155 keV resonance

For the highest energy resonance we studied in the present work, 1155 keV, we detected a strong, background-free signal, as is evident in the PID plot of Figure 4.

The final result for the resonance strength is ωγ1155=1.73±0.25  (stat.)±0.40  (syst.)\omega\gamma_{1155} = 1.73 \pm0.25\;(\mathrm{stat.}) \pm0.40\;(\mathrm{syst.}) eV was adopted from the singles analysis and had a smaller uncertainty compared to the coincidence analysis result. However, the two results are in agreement (see also Table VI).

ErE_{\mathrm{r}} (keV)LiteratureSinglesCoincidencesAdopted
5610.331(41)⋯\cdots⋯\cdots0.331(41)
8763.80(57)3.00−0.72+0.81(stat.)±0.61(syst.)3.00^{+0.81}_{-0.72}(\mathit{stat.}) \pm0.61(\mathit{syst.})3.91−1.10+1.29(stat.)±1.18(syst.)3.91^{+1.29}_{-1.10}(\mathit{stat.}) \pm1.18(\mathit{syst.})3.61(50)
1110⋯\cdots0.125−0.025+0.027(stat.)±0.015(syst.)0.125^{+0.027}_{-0.025}(\mathit{stat.}) \pm0.015(\mathit{syst.})0.161−0.041+0.043(stat.)±0.024(syst.)0.161^{+0.043}_{-0.041}(\mathit{stat.}) \pm0.024(\mathit{syst.})0.125(31)
1155⋯\cdots1.73±0.25(stat.)±0.40(syst.)1.73 \pm0.25(\mathit{stat.}) \pm0.40(\mathit{syst.})1.79±0.33(stat.)±0.42(syst.)1.79 \pm0.33(\mathit{stat.}) \pm0.42(\mathit{syst.})1.73(47)

Table VI.

Strength of the 1110 keV resonance

The 1110 keV resonance was studied in two independent experimental runs, due to the low recoil yields. We detected 14−3.7+4.314^{+4.3}_{-3.7} and 9−2.7+3.89^{+3.8}_{-2.7} events in singles, with different integrated beam fluxes 1.76(5)×10131.76(5) \times10^{13} and 1.53(5)×10131.53(5) \times10^{13} ions, respectively (see also Table III). The asymmetric uncertainty in the amount of detected recoils was calculated according to the prescription of Feldman and Cousins [61] for a poissonian signal with zero background, as we can see from the PID plots of Figure 4.

EbeamE_{\mathrm{beam}} (A keV)R\mathcal{R}-factor (7Be/α{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}/\alpha) (Torr/keV2^{2})NbeamN_{\mathrm{beam}} ×1013\times10^{13} ions
Run 1464.2(3)1.15(2) ×1011\times10^{11}1.07(2)
Run 1442.6(2)1.22(2) ×1011\times10^{11}1.76(5)
Run 2441.8(2)1.74(4) ×1010\times10^{10}1.53(4)
Run 2351.8(3)2.77(6) ×1010\times10^{10}2.12(4)

Table III. Beam normalization results for the yield measurements of the present work.8

To account for the asymmetric uncertainties and provide a realistic statistical uncertainty for the number of detected 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} recoils, we proceeded as follows: we first used Fechner’s two-piece normal distribution [62] for the two independent runs, using the Feldman and Cousins [61] prescription for the variances (see Figure 9 - Top). After that, we created a combined probability distribution by calculating averages by randomly sampling from the two individual distributions. The final results for the detected 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} recoils and their respected 11 and 2σ2\sigma uncertainties are then calculated from the combined distribution. We find 12.1−2.5+2.712.1^{+2.7}_{-2.5} (1σ1\sigma) and −4.8+5.3^{+5.3}_{-4.8} (2σ2\sigma) events for the 1110 keV resonance in singles, corresponding to −20.7+22.3%^{+22.3}_{-20.7}\% (1σ1\sigma) and −39.7+43.8%^{+43.8}_{-39.7}\% (2σ2\sigma) statistical uncertainty, respectively as we show in in Figure 9.

Image not extracted

Figure 9. (Top) Individual probability distributions for the detected 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} recoils in singles mode from the two independent measurements of the 1110 keV resonance. (Bottom) Combined probability distribution from the same measurements. The solid line shows the central value, while the dashed and dotted lines show the 11 and 2σ2\sigma uncertainties, respectively. See the text for details.

The resonance strengths resulting from singles and coincidence analysis are ωγ1110,singles=125−25+27(stat.)±15(syst.)\omega\gamma_{1110,\mathrm{singles}} = 125^{+27}_{-25}(\mathit{stat.}) \pm15(\mathit{syst.}) meV and ωγ1110,coinc=161−41+43(stat.)±24(syst.)\omega\gamma_{1110,\mathrm{coinc}} = 161^{+43}_{-41}(\mathit{stat.}) \pm24(\mathit{syst.}) meV, respectively, from which we choose the former as the final result. The large difference compared to the 1155 keV resonance strength – almost an order of magnitude – can be attributed to the difference in the orbital angular momentum, ℓα=1\ell_{\alpha} = 1 for the former state and ℓα=2\ell_{\alpha} = 2 for the latter (see Table I).

Strength of the 876 keV resonance

For the lowest energy in this study, the maximum recoil angle is θr,max⁡=47\theta_{r,\max} = 47 mrad, which is the largest ever attempted by DRAGON10. Nevertheless, one can see a clear signal in the PID plots (see Figure 4 and Figure 5). We detected 13−3.7+4.313^{+4.3}_{-3.7} 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} recoil events corresponding to −28.5+33.1%^{+33.1}_{-28.5}\% 1σ1\sigma statistical uncertainty, following the Feldman and Cousins [61] prescription for a poissonian signal with zero background.

Our final result for its strength from the singles analysis is ωγ876=3.00−0.72+0.81(stat.)±0.61(syst.)\omega\gamma_{876} = 3.00^{+0.81}_{-0.72}(\mathit{stat.}) \pm0.61(\mathit{syst.}) eV. We calculated the weighted average of our measurement and the value by Hardie et al. [31] to get the adopted resonance strength ωγ876=3.61(50)\omega\gamma_{876} = 3.61(50) eV, which will be used for the calculation of the thermonuclear reaction rate in

Section V E. It is worth noting that for all resonances the results for the strength ωγ\omega\gamma agree both in coincidence and singles analysis modes.

Also, from a nuclear structure standpoint, our results for the two previously unknown resonance strengths are in very good agreement with their 7Li(α,γ)11B^{7}\mathrm{Li}(\alpha,\gamma)^{11}\mathrm{B} analogs [34], namely Ex=9.182E_x = 9.182 (7/2+7/2^{+}) and 9.2719.271 MeV (5/2+5/2^{+}), as they are shown in Table VII. The 5/2−5/2^{-} state Ex=8.921E_x = 8.921 in 11B^{11}\mathrm{B} is the only exception, were its resonance strength differs more than two orders of magnitude to its 11C^{11}\mathrm{C} analog.

JπJ^\piNucleusExE_{\mathrm{x}}(MeV)ωγ\omega\gamma (eV)
5/2−5/2^-11B{}^{11}\mathrm{B}8.921(1)(8.8±1.4)×10−3(8.8 \pm1.4) \times10^{-3}
5/2−5/2^-11C{}^{11}\mathrm{C}8.420(2)3.61(50)
7/2+7/2^+11B{}^{11}\mathrm{B}9.182(2)0.303(26)
7/2+7/2^+11C{}^{11}\mathrm{C}8.654(4)0.125(31)
5/2+5/2^+11B{}^{11}\mathrm{B}9.271(2)1.72(24)
5/2+5/2^+11C{}^{11}\mathrm{C}8.699(2)1.73(47)

Table VII.

Uncertainties

The uncertainties of the final results of the resonance strengths of this study are of systematic and statistical nature. The former are dominated by the efficiencies of the BGO array (ηBGO\eta_{\mathrm{BGO}}) and the recoil transmission through the separator (ηseparator\eta_{\mathrm{separator}}), which are inferred from GEANT simulations (Section IV F) [42]. Other sources of systematic uncertainty are the MCP detec-

TABLE VI. Resonance strengths ωγ\omega\gamma of the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction resonances from the literature [31, 34] and the present work (in singles and coincidences modes) that were used for the calculation of the new thermonuclear reaction rate. All results are reported in eV and the statistical and systematic uncertainties are presented separately. The adopted value for the 876 keV resonance strength is the weighted average of our singles measurement and the one from Hardie et al. [31]. See the text for details.

TABLE VII. Comparison of resonance strengths ωγ\omega\gamma for analog states in 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} and 7Li(α,γ)11B{}^{7}\mathrm{Li}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{B} reactions. Literature data were taken from Kelley et al. [34].

tion efficiency, the stopping power measurements and the charge state fractions.

Furthermore, the statistical uncertainties are due to the low recoil detection yield, caused by the very low transmission of the recoils through the separator, but this parameter is well understood and quantified. As we already pointed out, for the 1110 and 876 keV resonances, we used the prescription of Feldman and Cousins [61] for poissonian signals in zero background to extract the statistical uncertainties.

Table VIII shows a detailed breakdown of the uncertainties for each of the three resonances we measured in the present study. Note that for the 1110 keV resonance the uncertainty of the average final result was calculated using the procedure discussed in § 1 B.

Thermonuclear Reaction Rate

The new 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} thermonuclear reaction rate was calculated using the RatesMC11 code [64]. Within the RatesMC framework, each nuclear physics input quantity (e.g. resonance energy and resonance strength) has an assigned probability density function (PDF). The code samples these functions randomly many times (>103> 10^3) using a Monte Carlo algorithm and outputs reaction rates and associated rate probability densities. According to the central limit theorem, a random variable that is determined by the product of many factors will be distributed according to a lognormal density function [64, 65, 66]. Using a lognormal PDF, the “low”, “recommended”, and “high” Monte Carlo rates are the 16th, 50th (median), and 84th percentile respectively of the cumulative reaction rate distribution. In Table IX we present the adopted thermonuclear reaction rate for 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C}.

T (GK)LowMedianHighf.u.
0.0123.463×10−343.463 \times10^{-34}8.835×10−348.835 \times10^{-34}2.348×10−332.348 \times10^{-33}2.590
0.0134.535×10−334.535 \times10^{-33}1.153×10−321.153 \times10^{-32}3.066×10−323.066 \times10^{-32}2.588
0.0144.594×10−324.594 \times10^{-32}1.168×10−311.168 \times10^{-31}3.097×10−313.097 \times10^{-31}2.586
0.0153.758×10−313.758 \times10^{-31}9.552×10−319.552 \times10^{-31}2.528×10−302.528 \times10^{-30}2.584
0.0162.563×10−302.563 \times10^{-30}6.511×10−306.511 \times10^{-30}1.725×10−291.725 \times10^{-29}2.583
0.0187.618×10−297.618 \times10^{-29}1.935×10−281.935 \times10^{-28}5.129×10−285.129 \times10^{-28}2.579
0.0201.407×10−271.407 \times10^{-27}3.572×10−273.572 \times10^{-27}9.463×10−279.463 \times10^{-27}2.576
0.0254.793×10−254.793 \times10^{-25}1.208×10−241.208 \times10^{-24}3.195×10−243.195 \times10^{-24}2.568
0.0304.012×10−234.012 \times10^{-23}1.008×10−221.008 \times10^{-22}2.665×10−222.665 \times10^{-22}2.560
0.0402.466×10−202.466 \times10^{-20}6.147×10−206.147 \times10^{-20}1.616×10−191.616 \times10^{-19}2.544
0.0502.309×10−182.309 \times10^{-18}5.693×10−185.693 \times10^{-18}1.495×10−171.495 \times10^{-17}2.528
0.0607.225×10−177.225 \times10^{-17}1.766×10−161.766 \times10^{-16}4.628×10−164.628 \times10^{-16}2.513
0.0701.117×10−151.117 \times10^{-15}2.705×10−152.705 \times10^{-15}7.081×10−157.081 \times10^{-15}2.498
0.0801.057×10−141.057 \times10^{-14}2.548×10−142.548 \times10^{-14}6.647×10−146.647 \times10^{-14}2.483
0.0906.993×10−146.993 \times10^{-14}1.681×10−131.681 \times10^{-13}4.372×10−134.372 \times10^{-13}2.468
0.1003.570×10−133.570 \times10^{-13}8.501×10−138.501 \times10^{-13}2.201×10−122.201 \times10^{-12}2.453
0.1101.472×10−121.472 \times10^{-12}3.490×10−123.490 \times10^{-12}8.984×10−128.984 \times10^{-12}2.439
0.1205.172×10−125.172 \times10^{-12}1.216×10−111.216 \times10^{-11}3.106×10−113.106 \times10^{-11}2.424
0.1301.580×10−111.580 \times10^{-11}3.679×10−113.679 \times10^{-11}9.412×10−119.412 \times10^{-11}2.410
0.1404.322×10−114.322 \times10^{-11}9.999×10−119.999 \times10^{-11}2.548×10−102.548 \times10^{-10}2.396
0.1501.078×10−101.078 \times10^{-10}2.473×10−102.473 \times10^{-10}6.275×10−106.275 \times10^{-10}2.382
0.1602.482×10−102.482 \times10^{-10}5.656×10−105.656 \times10^{-10}1.429×10−91.429 \times10^{-9}2.367
0.1801.116×10−91.116 \times10^{-9}2.459×10−92.459 \times10^{-9}6.115×10−96.115 \times10^{-9}2.310
0.2004.918×10−94.918 \times10^{-9}9.604×10−99.604 \times10^{-9}2.208×10−82.208 \times10^{-8}2.096
0.2505.348×10−75.348 \times10^{-7}6.305×10−76.305 \times10^{-7}7.894×10−77.894 \times10^{-7}1.251
0.3002.666×10−52.666 \times10^{-5}3.051×10−53.051 \times10^{-5}3.506×10−53.506 \times10^{-5}1.147
0.3504.586×10−44.586 \times10^{-4}5.215×10−45.215 \times10^{-4}5.955×10−45.955 \times10^{-4}1.142
0.4003.813×10−33.813 \times10^{-3}4.334×10−34.334 \times10^{-3}4.923×10−34.923 \times10^{-3}1.139
0.4501.950×10−21.950 \times10^{-2}2.209×10−22.209 \times10^{-2}2.507×10−22.507 \times10^{-2}1.137
0.5007.106×10−27.106 \times10^{-2}8.022×10−28.022 \times10^{-2}9.077×10−29.077 \times10^{-2}1.135
0.6004.816×10−14.816 \times10^{-1}5.413×10−15.413 \times10^{-1}6.105×10−16.105 \times10^{-1}1.130
0.7001.860×1001.860 \times10^{0}2.083×1002.083 \times10^{0}2.340×1002.340 \times10^{0}1.125
0.8005.136×1005.136 \times10^{0}5.726×1005.726 \times10^{0}6.390×1006.390 \times10^{0}1.118
0.9001.139×1011.139 \times10^{1}1.265×1011.265 \times10^{1}1.401×1011.401 \times10^{1}1.111
1.0002.178×1012.178 \times10^{1}2.407×1012.407 \times10^{1}2.651×1012.651 \times10^{1}1.105
1.2507.217×1017.217 \times10^{1}7.907×1017.907 \times10^{1}8.638×1018.638 \times10^{1}1.095
1.5001.633×1021.633 \times10^{2}1.792×1021.792 \times10^{2}1.953×1021.953 \times10^{2}1.094
1.7502.946×1022.946 \times10^{2}3.236×1023.236 \times10^{2}3.538×1023.538 \times10^{2}1.095
2.0004.578×1024.578 \times10^{2}5.041×1025.041 \times10^{2}5.522×1025.522 \times10^{2}1.098
2.5008.379×1028.379 \times10^{2}9.262×1029.262 \times10^{2}1.021×1031.021 \times10^{3}1.103
3.0001.235×1031.235 \times10^{3}1.370×1031.370 \times10^{3}1.516×1031.516 \times10^{3}1.107
3.5001.612×1031.612 \times10^{3}1.801×1031.801 \times10^{3}2.003×1032.003 \times10^{3}1.116
4.0001.955×1031.955 \times10^{3}2.195×1032.195 \times10^{3}2.468×1032.468 \times10^{3}1.129
5.0002.515×1032.515 \times10^{3}2.876×1032.876 \times10^{3}3.332×1033.332 \times10^{3}1.167
6.0002.924×1032.924 \times10^{3}3.398×1033.398 \times10^{3}4.121×1034.121 \times10^{3}1.210
7.0003.202×1033.202 \times10^{3}3.812×1033.812 \times10^{3}4.777×1034.777 \times10^{3}1.250
8.0003.386×1033.386 \times10^{3}4.112×1034.112 \times10^{3}5.325×1035.325 \times10^{3}1.284
9.0003.503×1033.503 \times10^{3}4.324×1034.324 \times10^{3}5.765×1035.765 \times10^{3}1.312
10.0003.558×1033.558 \times10^{3}4.460×1034.460 \times10^{3}6.079×1036.079 \times10^{3}1.335

Table IX. Total thermonuclear reaction rates for 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C}. The rate below T<0.012T < 0.012 GK is zero. The rates are expressed in units of cm3 mol−1 s−1\mathrm{cm}^{3}\,\mathrm{mol}^{-1}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}. Columns 2, 3 and 4 list the 16th, 50th and 86th percentiles of the total rate probability density (PDF) at given temperatures. “f.u.” is the factor uncertainty, and is obtained from the 16th and 84th percentiles.

For our calculation, we used resonance parameters as reported in Kelley et al. [34]. More specifically, we included the contribution of the sub-threshold resonance at Ex=7.4997E_{\mathrm{x}} = 7.4997 MeV (Er=−43.9E_{\mathrm{r}} = -43.9 keV) using a γ\gamma partial width from the mirror state in 11B{}^{11}\mathrm{B} (Γγ=1.14(4)\Gamma_\gamma= 1.14(4) eV), and assumed a reduced α\alpha width of 1. According to Descouvemont [37] this resonance can dominate the reaction rate for T<0.3T < 0.3 GK, which can affect the evolution of Population III stars via the hot pppp-chains [20] and the production of 7Li{}^{7}\mathrm{Li} in classical novae [38]. In addition to the narrow resonances at 561, 876, 1110 & 1155 keV, we also included contributions from the broad resonances at 2101, 2236, 2426 & 2539 keV (see Table I for details). For the γ\gamma partial widths of the latter states, since we used values from the mirror analog 11B{}^{11}\mathrm{B}, we assigned them a factor of 2 uncertainty.

The new reaction rate uncertainty has been decreased to ∼9.4\sim9.4–10.7%10.7\% over T=1.5T = 1.5–33 GK, the relevant temperature window for vpvp-process nucleosynthesis, compared to factors of 1.76–1.91 of the NACRE–II compilation. While our new rate includes the new measurements of the 1110 and 1155 keV resonance strengths and the updated adopted value for ωγ876\omega\gamma_{876}, it is worth noting that this decrease in the thermonuclear reaction rate is mainly caused from using a Monte Carlo error propagation of the relevant quantities (e.g. ErE_{\mathrm{r}}, ωγ\omega\gamma etc.) [64], and not by the individual contribution of the previously unmeasured resonance strengths. In Figure 10 we compare the new thermonuclear reaction rate to the NACRE rate [28, 36] and an older reaction rate compilation from Caughlan and Fowler [27] (CF88).

Image not extracted

Figure 10. The new 7^{7}Be(α,γ\alpha,\gamma)^{11}$C reaction rate for T = 0.1–10 GK compared to the rates by References [27, 28, 36] over the same temperature region.

Figure 11 shows the individual resonant contributions to the total 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction rate. For temperatures T≲0.2T \lesssim0.2 GK, the sub-threshold resonance at −43.9-43.9 keV dominates the reaction rate, while for 0.20.2 GK <T<1.0< T < 1.0 GK the 561 keV contributes the most, since Γα≫Γγ\Gamma_\alpha\gg\Gamma_\gamma (see Table I) and it is the lowest-lying energy resonance [see the discussion in Ref. [67], Chapter 3]. For the temperatures relevant for vpvp-process,

Image not extracted

Figure 11. Resonant contributions to the 7^{7}Be(α,γ\alpha,\gamma)11^{11}C thermonuclear reaction rate. The dotted line at the bottom right corner shows the contribution of the 1110 keV resonance.

the 876 keV has a ∼60%\sim60\% contribution to the total rate, followed by the 561 keV with ∼30%\sim30\%. The 1155 keV resonance has a ≲10%\lesssim10\% contribution, while the 1110 keV contributes negligibly to the total reaction rate.

The effect of the new reaction rate will be studied extensively in a future publication, taking into account new measurements of the 10^{10}B(α,p\alpha,p)13^{13}C reaction [68], which was also included in the sensitivity study of Wanajo et al. [22], and the 60^{60}Cu(p,αp,\alpha)56{}^{56}Ni [69] which may be responsible for the Ni–Cu cycle [23].

In addition to the thermonuclear reaction rate, we also calculated the astrophysical SS-factor. In Figure 12 we present the astrophysical SS-factor for 7^{7}Be(α,γ\alpha,\gamma)11^{11}C with the individual resonant contributions. Our results agree well with the NACRE-II data, with the exception of the 2101 keV resonance which seems to be mis-placed to lower energies [see Figure 42 in Ref. [36]].

Figure 12. The astrophysical SS-factor for the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction based on our RatesMC calculations. Contributions from different resonances are shown. The narrow resonances at 561, 876 & 1110 keV are shown with the vertical dotted lines. The astrophysical SS-factor from NACRE-II [36] is also shown.

Discussion and Conclusions

In the present work we performed the first inverse kinematics study of the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction to measure unknown resonance strengths at energies relevant to νp\nu p-process nucleosynthesis. We report the first measurement of the 1155 & 1110 keV resonances with strengths of 1.73±0.25(stat.)±0.40(syst.)1.73 \pm0.25(stat.) \pm0.40(syst.) eV and 125−25+27(stat.)±15(syst.)125^{+27}_{-25}(stat.) \pm15(syst.) meV, respectively. We also re-measured the 876 keV resonance strength (ωγ876=3.00−0.72+0.81(stat.)±0.61(syst.)\omega\gamma_{876} = 3.00^{+0.81}_{-0.72}(stat.) \pm0.61(syst.) eV) and our result agrees with the measurement of Hardie et al. [31] (ωγ=3.80(57)\omega\gamma= 3.80(57) eV).

As we have also demonstrated in Psaltis et al. [47], the present work shows that DRAGON is capable of handling measurements in which the maximum recoil cone angle exceeds its acceptance, after a systematic study of the BGO array efficiency and its transmission using extensive GEANT simulations. That opens a new avenue for future experiments using DRAGON, that were previously thought to be inaccessible due to large maximum recoil angles (e.g. 18O(α,γ)22Ne{}^{18}\mathrm{O}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{22}\mathrm{Ne}, 20Ne(α,γ)24Mg{}^{20}\mathrm{Ne}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{24}\mathrm{Mg} and others).

The new 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction rate is constrained to 9.4-10.7 % for T = 1.5-3 GK which is sufficient for nucleosynthesis calculations. The effect of the rate, along with other measured reactions relevant to nucleosynthesis in neutrino–driven winds will be explored in a subsequent study. According to the work of Wanajo et al. [22], the 7Be(α,γ)11C{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{11}\mathrm{C} reaction rate in the relevant energies can affect the number of the neutron–to–seed ratio Δn\Delta_n, regulating the νp\nu p-process efficiency in synthesizing neutron–deficient isotopes. This is a particularly interesting result, since most recent self-consistent 3D core–collapse supernova simulations favour proton–rich conditions [70]. In addition, a rigorous study of the astrophysical conditions of the proton–rich neutrino driven ejecta, and how they produce different nucleosynthesis outputs, using all the up–to–date nuclear physics input is desired. The intense 7Be^{7}\mathrm{Be} RIBs produced with carbide targets can be utilized for more demanding experiments, such as 7Be(p,γ)^{7}\mathrm{Be}(p,\gamma) and 7Be^{7}\mathrm{Be} α–scattering. Pure graphite targets bombarded by protons at 100 μA100\ \mu\mathrm{A} (or a UCx_x target at 40 μA40\ \mu\mathrm{A}) could produce as much as 1010 s−110^{10}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1} of 7Be^{7}\mathrm{Be}.

Acknowledgements

The authors gratefully acknowledge the beam delivery and ISAC operations groups at TRIUMF. In particular, we thank F. Ames, T. Angus, A. Gottberg, S. Kiy, J. Lassen and O. Shelbaya for all their help during the experiment. The authors thank the anonymous referee for useful comments that improved the manuscript. The core operations of TRIUMF are supported via a contribution from the federal government through the National Research Council of Canada, and the Government of British Columbia provides building capital funds. Authors from McMaster University are funded by the National Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC). DRAGON is funded through NSERC grant SAPPJ-2019-00039. AP also acknowledges support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation)-Project No. 279384907-SFB 1245, and the State of Hesse within the Research Cluster ELEMENTS (Project ID 500/10.006). RL and CM acknowledge support from the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics under Grant Nos. DE-SC0017799 and DE-FG02-97ER41042. CRB, RG and SP acknowledge support from the U.S. Department of Energy, under grants number DE-FG02-88ER40387 and DE-NA0003883. Authors from Colorado School of Mines acknowledge support from U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science DE-FG02-93ER40789 grant. Authors from the UK are supported by the Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC). This work benefited from discussions at the “Nuclear Astrophysics at Rings and Recoil Separators” Workshop supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. PHY-1430152 (JINA Center for the Evolution of the Elements).

References

  1. [1]M. Arnould and S. Goriely, Phys. Rep. 384, 1 (2003).
  2. [2]T. Rauscher et al., Rep. Prog. Phys. 76, 066201 (2013).
  3. [3]M. Pignatari et al., Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 25, 1630003 (2016).
  4. [4]G. W. Cameron, Publ. Astron. Soc. Pac 69, 201 (1957).
  5. [5]K. Lodders et al., in Solar system (Springer, 2009) pp. 712–770.
  6. [6]C. Travaglio et al., Astrophys. J 795, 141 (2014).
  7. [7]H. Schatz et al., Phys. Rep. 294, 167 (1998).
  8. [8]W. Rapp et al., Astrophys. J 653, 474 (2006).
  9. [9]T. Rauscher et al., Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 463, 4153 (2016).
  10. [10]L. Hüdepohl et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 251101 (2010).
  11. [11]T. Fischer et al., Astron. Astrophys. 517, A80 (2010).
  12. [12]O. Just et al., Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 453, 3386 (2015).
  13. [13]E. O’Connor, Astrophys. J Supplement Series 219, 24 (2015).
  14. [14]A. Arcones and F. Montes, Astrophys. J 731, 5 (2011).
  15. [15]S. Wanajo et al., Astrophys. J 852, 40 (2018).
  16. [16]D. Vartanyan et al., Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 482, 351 (2019).
  17. [17]C. Fröhlich et al., Phys. Rev. Lett 96, 142502 (2006).
  18. [18]S. Wanajo, Astrophys. J 647, 1323 (2006).
  19. [19]J. Pruet et al., Astrophys. J 644, 1028 (2006).
  20. [20]M. Wiescher et al., Astrophys. J 343, 352 (1989).
  21. [21]J. José and C. Iliadis, Rep. Prog. Phys. 74, 096901 (2011).
  22. [22]S. Wanajo et al., Astrophys. J 729, 46 (2011).
  23. [23]A. Arcones, C. Fröhlich, and G. Martínez-Pinedo, Astrophys. J 750, 18 (2012).
  24. [24]C. Fröhlich and T. Rauscher, in AIP Conference Proceedings, Vol. 1484 (American Institute of Physics, 2012) pp. 232–239.
  25. [25]M. Jacobi, Influence of astrophysical and nuclear physics uncertainties on the nucleosynthesis in proton-rich neutrino-driven winds, Master’s thesis, Technische Universität Darmstadt (2018).
  26. [26]N. Nishimura et al., Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 489, 1379 (2019).
  27. [27]G. R. Caughlan and W. A. Fowler, At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 40, 283 (1988).
  28. [28]C. Angulo et al., Nucl. Phys. A 656, 3 (1999).
  29. [29]H. O. Fynbo et al., Nature 433, 136 (2005).
  30. [30]S. Jin et al., Nature 588, 57 (2020).
  31. [31]G. Hardie et al., Phys. Rev. C 29, 1199 (1984).
  32. [32]M. Wiescher et al., Phys. Rev. C 28, 1431 (1983).
  33. [33]H. Yamaguchi et al., Phys. Rev. C 87, 034303 (2013).
  34. [34]J. Kelley et al., Nucl. Phys. A 880, 88 (2012).
  35. [35]Y. Yanagisawa et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res A 539, 74 (2005).
  36. [36]Y. Xu et al., Nucl. Phys. A 918, 61 (2013).
  37. [37]P. Descouvemont, Nucl. Phys. A 584, 532 (1995).
  38. [38]M. Hernanz, J. José, A. Coc, and J. Isern, Astrophys. J Lett. 465, L27 (1999).
  39. [39]D. Hutcheon et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res A 498, 190 (2003).
  40. [40]J. Lassen et al., Hyperfine Interact. 162, 69 (2005).
  41. [41]M. Gaelens et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res B 204, 48 (2003).
  42. [42]C. Ruiz et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 99 (2014).
  43. [43]C. Vockenhuber et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res A 603, 372 (2009).
  44. [44]G. Christian et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 75 (2014).
  45. [45]D. G. Gigliotti et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res B 204, 671 (2003).
  46. [46]D. G. Gigliotti, Efficiency calibration measurement and GEANT simulation of the DRAGON BGO gamma ray array at TRIUMF, Master's thesis, University of Northern British Columbia, Prince George, Canada (2004).DOI
  47. [47]A. Psaltis et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res A 987, 164828 (2021).
  48. [48]A. Psaltis, Radiative alpha capture on ⁷Be with DRAGON at νp–process nucleosynthesis energies, Ph.D. thesis, McMaster University (2020).DOI
  49. [49]W. A. Fowler et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 20, 236 (1948).
  50. [50]S. Sjue et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res A 700, 179 (2013).
  51. [51]U. Hager et al., Phys. Rev. C 85, 035803 (2012).
  52. [52]D. Connolly et al., Phys. Rev. C 97, 035801 (2018).
  53. [53]M. Williams et al., Phys. Rev. C 102, 035801 (2020).
  54. [54]J. M. D’Auria et al., Phys. Rev. C 69, 065803 (2004).
  55. [55]K. Jayamanna, Hyperfine Interact. 225, 51 (2014).
  56. [56]W. Liu et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res A 496, 198 (2003).
  57. [57]J. F. Ziegler et al., Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res B 268, 1818 (2010).
  58. [58]C. Matei et al., Phys. Rev. Lett 97, 242503 (2006).
  59. [59]H. Rose and D. Brink, Rev. Mod. Phys. 39, 306 (1967).
  60. [61]G. J. Feldman and R. D. Cousins, Phys. Rev. D 57, 3873 (1998).
  61. [62]K. F. Wallis, Statistical Science 29, 106 (2014).
  62. [63]D. Lebhertz et al., Phys. Rev. C 85, 034333 (2012).
  63. [64]R. Longland et al., Nucl. Phys. A 841, 1 (2010).
  64. [65]J. H. Gaddum, Nature 156, 463 (1945).
  65. [66]C. Iliadis et al., J Phys G Nucl Part Phys 42, 034007 (2015).
  66. [67]C. Iliadis, Nuclear physics of stars (John Wiley & Sons, 2015).
  67. [68]Q. Liu et al., Phys. Rev. C 101, 025808 (2020).
  68. [69]J. S. Randhawa et al., Phys. Rev. C 104, L042801 (2021).
  69. [70]R. Bollig et al., Astrophys. J 915, 28 (2021).

Paper details

vlnc:W_c249w2p7
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents