betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

A study for well-filtered spaces

Abstract

In this paper, we focus on well-filtered spaces. By using the Rudin sets and WD sets, we obtain the following results: (1) The product of arbitrarily many Scott well-filtered dcpos is still well-filtered with respect to the Scott topology. Thus we give positive answers for two questions proposed by Xu and Zhao; (2) Let PP be a dcpo with ΣK(P)ΣK(P) being well-filtered and QQ an RB-domain. Then ΣK(P×Q)ΣK(P\times Q) is well-filtered if K(P×Q)K(P\times Q) is a dcpo; (3) An intrinsic characterization of the WDWD sets is given in terms of Scott open filters.

Introduction

Domain theory constitutes a framework within which order and topology admit a profound integration. The Scott topology is a canonical topology induced by the order structure of a poset and plays a fundamental role in domain theory. Sobriety and well-filteredness are two kinds of important topological properties. The study of sobriety and well-filteredness for the Scott spaces clarifies two complementary aspects of the interaction between order and topology. The Scott topology on a continuous dcpo possesses favourable properties. If we extend these properties to general dcpos, it requires some topological conditions that remain useful without Hausdorff separation axiom. Well-filteredness is a desirable candidate. In this paper, we focus on well-filtered spaces.

The distinction between well-filteredness and sobriety emerged from a series of counterexamples and representation results. Johnstone constructed a dcpo whose Scott topology is not sober and not well-filtered([10]). As we know, every sober space is well-filtered([2, 3]). Kou showed that there is a dcpo which is well-filtered but non sober for the Scott topology and thus answered a question posed by Heckmann ([12, 4]). Xi and Zhao later study the models for well-filtered T1T_1 spaces and produce new non sober examples ([21]). Xi and Lawson proved that every Lawson-compact dcpo and hence every complete lattice is Scott well-filtered([20]). In addition, Lawson, Wu and Xi proved that every core-compact well-filtered T0T_0 space is sober ([13]). Topological Rudin’s lemma extended by Heckmann and Keimel provides a useful tool for constructing an irreducible closed set([5]). Shen, Xi, Xu and Zhao constructed well-filtered reflections and proved that arbitrary ordinary topological products of well-filtered spaces are well-filtered([18]). Furthermore, Xu, Shen, Xi and Zhao developed Rudin sets and well-filtered determined sets (or WD sets) to characterize well-filteredness and describe its reflections([22]). Thus the Rudin sets and WD sets are useful tools for studying well-filtered spaces.

The product preservation of well-filteredness and sobriety is already nontrivial for the Scott topology. For two posets PP and QQ, the Scott topology Σ(P×Q)\Sigma(P \times Q) can be strictly finer than the product topology ΣP×ΣQ\Sigma P \times\Sigma Q. Consequently, the ordinary product theorems with respect to sobriety and well-filteredness do not apply directly to this Scott product problem. So Xu and Zhao propose four questions for well-filtered spaces and sober spaces (Questions 4.6, 4.7, 4.8 and 4.9 in[24]). Recently, Miao, Xi, Jia, Li and Zhao construct two Scott sober dcpos whose order product is not Scott sober([14]). Later, He obtained two Scott sober complete lattices even two co-frames whose order product is not sober for the Scott topology([8]). In this paper, we solve the question 4.7 and question 4.9. Specifically, the first result is that for every family of Scott well-filtered dcpos {Pi∣i∈I}\{P_i \mid i \in I\}, Σ∏i∈IPi\Sigma\prod_{i\in I}P_i is well-filtered. The proof for the above result analyzes projections of Rudin sets and finite coordinate replacements.

The collection K(X)K(X) consists of all the nonempty compact saturated subsets of XX ordered by the reverse inclusion. The upper Vietoris topology of the Smyth power space and the Scott topology of K(X)K(X) need not coincide. Xu, Wen and Xi proved that well-filteredness of XX implies that ΣK(X)\Sigma K(X) is well-filtered([23]). However, for two dcpos PP and QQ, K(P×Q)K(P \times Q) is not equal to K(P)×K(Q)K(P) \times K(Q). So the well-filteredness of ΣK(P×Q)\Sigma K(P \times Q) is unknown under the condition that ΣK(P)\Sigma K(P) and ΣK(Q)\Sigma K(Q) are well-filtered. We first prove that for dcpos PP and QQ, ΣK(P)\Sigma K(P) and ΣK(Q)\Sigma K(Q) are well-filtered if ΣK(P×Q)\Sigma K(P \times Q) is well-filtered. Furthermore, we also show that if ΣK(P)\Sigma K(P) is well-filtered and QQ a RBRB-domain such that K(P×Q)K(P \times Q) is a dcpo, then ΣK(P×Q)\Sigma K(P \times Q) is well-filtered.

The WD sets as a useful tool for studying well-filtered spaces are defined by using all well-filtered spaces and continuous mappings. Thus it is difficult to check whether a closed subset of a topological space is a WD set. It is essential to give a characterization for WD sets of a topological space XX by just using the information on XX. Motivated by the open filters viewpoint of the Hofmann–Mislove theorem, we prove that, for every closed A⊆XA \subseteq X, A∈WD(X)A \in\mathrm{WD}(X) if and only if pA∈HXp_A \in\mathcal{H}_X, where HX\mathcal{H}_X is a subfamily of all proper Scott open filters on O(X)\mathcal{O}(X) with some rules.

Preliminaries

Let PP be a poset. For each A⊆PA \subseteq P, set ↑A={x∈P∣∃a∈A,a≤x}\mathord{\uparrow}A=\{x\in P\mid\exists a\in A,a\leq x\} and ↓A={x∈P∣∃a∈A,x≤a}\mathord{\downarrow}A=\{x\in P\mid\exists a\in A,x\leq a\}. We write ↓{x}\mathord{\downarrow}\{x\} as ↓x\mathord{\downarrow}x and ↑{x}\mathord{\uparrow}\{x\} as ↑x\mathord{\uparrow}x for each x∈Px\in P. A subset DD of PP is directed provided that DD is nonempty and ∀a,b∈D\forall a,b\in D, ↑a∩↑b∩D≠∅\mathord{\uparrow}a\cap\mathord{\uparrow}b\cap D\ne\varnothing. Dually, a nonempty subset D⊆PD\subseteq P is filtered if ∀a,b∈D\forall a,b\in D, ↓a∩↓b∩D≠∅\mathord{\downarrow}a\cap\mathord{\downarrow}b\cap D\ne\varnothing. An element xx is an upper bound for a subset AA if a≤xa\leq x for each a∈Aa\in A. A poset PP is called a directed complete poset (dcpo, for short) if every directed subset of PP has a supremum. For each pair of x,y∈Px,y\in P, we say that xx is way below yy, written x≪yx\ll y, if for each directed set D⊆PD\subseteq P whose supremum exists, y≤⋁Dy\leq\bigvee D implies ↑x∩D≠∅\mathord{\uparrow}x\cap D\ne\varnothing. An element p∈Pp\in P is compact if p≪pp\ll p. A subset U⊆PU\subseteq P is Scott open if U=↑UU=\mathord{\uparrow}U and for each directed subset DD with ⋁D\bigvee D existing, ⋁D∈U\bigvee D\in U implies D∩U≠∅D\cap U\ne\varnothing. The set of Scott open sets of PP forms the Scott topology σ(P)\sigma(P). We write ΣP\Sigma P for (P,σ(P))(P,\sigma(P)). Let P,QP,Q be dcpos. Then the mapping f:ΣP⟶ΣQf:\Sigma P\longrightarrow\Sigma Q is continuous (or called Scott continuous) if and only if ff is monotone and for each directed set D⊆PD\subseteq P, f(⋁D)=⋁d∈Df(d)f(\bigvee D)=\bigvee_{d\in D}f(d).

Let XX be a topological space. We write cl⁡X(A)\operatorname{cl}_{X}(A) for the closure of AA. A subset AA of XX is called a saturated set if AA is just the intersection of all open sets containing AA. A subset FF of XX is irreducible if FF is nonempty and for every pair of closed sets A,B⊆XA,B\subseteq X, F⊆A∪BF\subseteq A\cup B implies F⊆AF\subseteq A or F⊆BF\subseteq B. A T0T_{0} space XX is sober if every irreducible closed set is just the closure of a singleton. For a T0T_{0} space XX, the specialization order ≤\leq on XX is defined by x≤yx\leq y if and only if x∈cl⁡X({y})x\in\operatorname{cl}_{X}(\{y\}). Unless otherwise stated, throughout the paper, whenever an order-theoretic concept is mentioned in the context of a T0T_{0} space XX, it is to be interpreted with respect to the specialization order on XX. A subset AA of a topological space XX is saturated if A=↑AA=\mathord{\uparrow}A under the specialization order. We use K(X)K(X) to denote the set of all nonempty compact saturated sets of XX with the reverse inclusion order and O(X)\mathcal{O}(X) (Γ(X)\Gamma(X)) to denote the lattice of all open subsets (closed subsets) of $X ordered by inclusion. A topological space XX is well-filtered if for each filtered family F\mathcal{F} of compact saturated subsets of XX and each open set UU of XX, ⋂F⊆U\bigcap\mathcal{F}\subseteq U implies F⊆UF\subseteq U for some F∈FF\in\mathcal{F}. A dcpo PP is called Scott well-filtered if the dcpo PP endowed with the Scott topology is well-filtered. A topological space XX is a retract of a topological space YY if there are two continuous maps f:X⟶Yf:X\longrightarrow Y and g:Y⟶Xg:Y\longrightarrow X such that g∘f=id⁡Xg\circ f=\operatorname{id}_{X}.

The Scott well-filteredness of the arbitrary product

In this section, we show that the product of Scott well-filtered dcpos is still Scott well-filtered. Thus this gives positive answers to Questions 4.7 and 4.9 posed by Xu and Zhao([24]).

Definition 3.1. ([22]) Let XX be a T0T_{0} space. A nonempty closed subset AA of XX is called a Rudin set if there exists a filtered family K⊆K(X)\mathcal{K}\subseteq K(X) such that AA is minimal in

M(K)={B∈Γ(X)∣∀K∈K, B∩K≠∅}.M(\mathcal{K})=\{B\in\Gamma(X)\mid\forall K\in\mathcal{K},\ B\cap K\neq\varnothing\}.

where the order on M(K)M(\mathcal{K}) is the inclusion order. The symbol RD⁡(X)\operatorname{RD}(X) denotes the collection of all closed Rudin sets of $X.

In the following, we call the filtered family K⊆K(X)\mathcal{K}\subseteq K(X) a witness of the set A∈RD⁡(X)A\in\operatorname{RD}(X).

References

  1. [2]G. Gierz, K. H. Hofmann, K. Keimel, J. D. Lawson, M. W. Mislove and D. S. Scott, Continuous Lattices and Domains, Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, vol. 93, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2003.
  2. [7]R. Heckmann, K. Keimel, Quasicontinuous domains and the Smyth powerdomain, Electronic Notes in Theoretical Computer Science, 298 (2013) 215-232.DOI
  3. [8]Z. He, The product of two Scott sober complete lattices is not always Scott sober,arXiv:2609.39246, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2609.39246
  4. [11]X. Jia, Meet-Continuity and Locally Compact Sober Dcpos, Ph.D Thesis, University of Birmingham, 2018.
  5. [21]X. Xi, D. Zhao, Well-filtered spaces and their dcpo models, Mathematical Structures in Computer Science, 27(4)(2017)507–515.
  6. [22]X. Xu, C. Shen, X. Xi and D. Zhao, On T₀ spaces determined by well-filtered spaces, Topology and its Applications, 282(2020)107323.DOI
  7. [23]X. Xu, X. Wen and X. Xi, Scott topology on Smyth power posets, Mathematical Structures in Computer Science, 33(9)(2023)832–867.DOI
  8. [24]X. Xu, D. Zhao, Some open problems on well-filtered spaces and sober spaces, Topology and its Applications, 301(2021)107540.arxiv.org/abs/2005.00539

Paper details

vlnc:W_c2ed487f
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents