betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Origin of yield stress and mechanical plasticity in model biological tissues

Abstract

During development and under normal physiological conditions, biological tissues are continuously subjected to substantial mechanical stresses. In response to large deformations cells in a tissue must undergo multicellular rearrangements in order to maintain integrity and robustness. However, how these events are connected in time and space remains unknown. Here, using computational and theoretical modeling, we studied the mechanical plasticity of epithelial monolayers under large deformations. Our results demonstrate that the jamming-unjamming (solid-fluid) transition in tissues can vary significantly depending on the degree of deformation, implying that tissues are highly unconventional materials. Using analytical modeling, we elucidate the origins of this behavior. We also demonstrate how a tissue accommodates large deformations through a collective series of rearrangements, which behave similarly to avalanches in non-living materials. We find that these tissue avalanches are governed by stress redistribution and the spatial distribution of vulnerable spots. Finally, we propose a simple and experimentally accessible framework to predict avalanches and infer tissue mechanical stress based on static images.

Introduction

During morphogenesis and under normal physiological conditions, biological tissues continuously experience substantial mechanical stresses [1]. Research efforts to understand the remarkable deformability of epithelial tissues employ both experimental and simulation approaches. Experimentally, studies focus on the tissue’s responses to external stresses [2, 3, 4, 5, 6], where a stress-driven unjamming transition has been noted [6]. On the simulation front, the cellular Potts and Vertex-based models are utilized to probe tissue rheology [7, 8], uncovering nonlinear elasticity and rheological properties [8, 9]. However, with few exceptions [10], research have predominantly focused on the shear startup regime. This leaves a gap in our understanding of tissue behavior under steady shear and the mechanisms underpinning yield-stress behavior in tissues. Beyond the yield stress, materials typically flow through plastic rearrangements. Similarly, within tissues, mechanical plasticity occurs through cellular rearrangements, enabling the maintenance of integrity and robustness. While there is extensive literature on how individual cells rearrange with their neighbors [11, 12, 13, 14], significant gaps remain in understanding how these localized events connect over time and space. Moreover, a major challenge lies in elucidating how these collective interactions lead to mechanical responses at the tissue level. In the context of material plasticity, avalanche-like behavior, prevalent in phenomena ranging from earthquakes to ferromagnets, involves small perturbations triggering significant collective responses [15]. Systems exhibiting these instabilities display self-organized criticality [16] and power law scaling in their observables, indicating the universality class of the process. Proliferation-driven avalanche-like behavior has recently been studied using numerical simulations of the Drosophila eye disc, suggesting that avalanches provide a macroscopic mechanism for epithelial tissues to alleviate accumulated proliferative stress [17]. Additionally, there is suggestive evidence of motility-induced avalanches in the epithelial tissue of Trichoplax adhaerens [18], where dynamic forces from the organism’s motility trigger localized microfractures that cascade into larger fractures, a hallmark of avalanche dynamics. Moreover, shear-induced avalanches have been documented in vertex-based models first in [19] and also [9, 10], yet a detailed examination of these avalanches’ growth and evolution is still lacking.

In this work, we investigate tissue mechanical plasticity using the Voronoi-based Vertex model under quasi-static shear. Our results demonstrate that the solid-fluid transition—also referred to as the jamming-unjamming transition in recent literature [20, 21, 22]—does not occur at a singular point but varies depending on the degree of shear deformation the tissue undergoes. Furthermore, challenging traditional definitions, we discover states where tissues possess yield-stress properties but lack a conventional shear modulus. These states exist in a solid-fluid coexistence phase near the jamming-unjamming transition, which we explore through a modified version of the Soft Glassy Rheology model to elucidate the origins of these complex states. The coexistence of fluid and solid phases suggests that even traditionally fluid-like tissues can accumulate stress in response to deformation, highlighting the need for a parameter-free, model-independent tissue stress inference method. Here, we propose a easily implementable metric to estimate tissue stress from static snapshots of tissue configuration without requiring any prior knowledge of the system. Additionally, our research not only clarifies how tissue manages large deformations through multicellular rearrangements akin to avalanches observed in non-living materials but also connects these phenomena to the tissue-level mechanical responses discussed earlier. These “tissue avalanches” are driven by stress redistribution and the spatial distribution of soft spots [23, 24, 25, 26], elements that echo the earlier discussions on mechanical responses and rheological properties. By quantifying the spatiotemporal correlations within these rearrangements, we propose a new methodological framework capable of predicting collective rearrangements.

Results

The confluent jamming transition is not unique

To investigate the mechanical behavior of dense epithelial tissues under substantial deformation, we employed a Voronoi-based Vertex model [9, 21]. The cell centers {ri}\{\mathbf{r}_i\} and their geometric configurations are derived from Voronoi tessellation. The biomechanical interactions are captured through a dimensionless mechanical energy functional [27] expressed as:

ϵ=∑i=1N[κA(ai−1)2+(pi−p0)2]\epsilon= \sum_{i=1}^{N} \left[\kappa_A(a_i-1)^2 + (p_i-p_0)^2\right]

where aia_i and pip_i are the dimensionless area and perimeter of each cell, κA\kappa_A is the rescaled area elasticity, and p0p_0 is the preferred cell shape index illustrating the cells homeostatic shape (see Methods). To probe tissue response, we applied quasi-static simple-shear deformation using Lees-Edwards boundary conditions, incrementally increasing strain with the FIRE algorithm to minimize energy (see Methods).

In the absence of shear, it has been demonstrated that the preferred cell shape index p0p_0 drives a rigidity transition at p0=p0∗≈3.81p_0=p_0^*\approx3.81, where the linear response shear modulus vanishes [20]. Recent studies [9, 28] have shown that beyond this transition point, in the liquid phase (p0>p0∗p_0>p_0^*), the model can undergo strain-stiffening, indicating a rigidity gain upon strain application. In our quasi-static shearing protocol, we explore beyond the linear response and shear startup regimes into the large deformation or steady-shear limit. In this regime, the tissue exhibits plastic flow primarily through cell-cell rearrangements, or T1 transitions. Here, the tissue’s yield stress is given by

σyield=lim⁡γ˙→0⟨σ(γ˙)⟩(1)\sigma_{\mathrm{yield}}=\lim_{\dot{\gamma}\to0}\langle\sigma(\dot{\gamma})\rangle \tag*{(1)}

where σ\sigma is the xyxy-component of the stress tensor as we apply simple shear (see Methods for definition). The average is taken over all strain values in the steady shear regime. As illustrated in Figure 1(a), while the startup shear modulus G0≡lim⁡γ→0∂σ/∂γG_0\equiv\lim_{\gamma\to0}\partial\sigma/\partial\gamma computed using Eqn. (S.1) vanishes [9] at the rigidity transition at p0≈3.81p_0\approx3.81, signaling a solid-to-fluid transition, the yield stress σyield\sigma_{\mathrm{yield}} does not disappear. Instead, it vanishes at a higher cell shape index, p0≈4p_0\approx4. This underscores a drastic difference in tissue responses between the transient shear startup and steady-shear regimes.

Discrepancy between shear start-up and steady-shear regime, probability of solid state, stress-strain curves, SGR energy landscape, and simulation snapshots

Figure 1. (a) Discrepancy between shear start-up and steady-shear regime. Top: The shear modulus of the un-sheared tissue (γ=0\gamma= 0). The shear modulus is obtained using linear-response calculation (see Methods). Bottom: The yield stress σyield\sigma_{\mathrm{yield}} obtained from the steady-state shear regime of quasi-static simulations is shown together with the yield stress obtained from the SGR model, where the only fitting parameter in the model, the elastic constant of an element was chosen to be k=0.0386k = 0.0386. (b) The probability of finding the system in solid state as a function of p0p_0. Inset: Distribution of tissue stress at different p0p_0. (c) Stress-strain curve example showing different yielding types: a fluid state yields to another fluid states a→b\mathrm{a} \to\mathrm{b}, a solid state yields to another solid one c→d\mathrm{c} \to\mathrm{d}, and a solid state yields to a fluid state e→f\mathrm{e} \to\mathrm{f}. (d) Schematic of the dynamics of elements in the SGR model: The energy landscape of the material consists of traps with different depth EE drawn from a distribution ρ(E)\rho(E) that characterizes the structural disorder of the material. Yielding events are captured by transitions from one trap to another. The three types of transition illustrates the transitions observed in simulation. (e) Simulation snapshots at different stages of a stress build-up and relaxation process. The edge thickness represents the edge tension, with thicker edges indicating higher tension. Here the states correspond to the ones labeled in panel e.

Under steady shear and at shape indices higher than the rigidity transition associated with shear startup (i.e., at p0>p0∗p_0>p_0^*), initially fluid-like systems can intermittently exhibit solid-like behavior before reverting to fluid-like states after yielding (Figure 1(c)). Here the solid-like states are characterized by a non-zero shear modulus, (e.g., states c, d, e in Figure 1(c)), while states that do not resist shear deformation, indicated by having zero shear modulus, are fluid-like (e.g., states a, b, f in Figure 1(c)). To transition from state b to state c, the system gains rigidity under shear, moving from a fluid-like to a solid-like state. Stress then builds up, as indicated by edges experiencing high tension (Figure 1e). Once sufficient stress is stored, the system yields, relaxing this stress via collective rearrangements, commonly referred to as avalanches, and transitions from state c to state d. In the steady-shear regime, we can compute the instantaneous shear modulus (see Methods) to quantify solid vs. fluid-like states. The solid-fluid coexistence shows up as a bi-modal distribution of the shear modulus, p.d.f(G)p.d.f(G) shown in Figure 1B, where the fluid phase is associated with a peak near the numerical noise floor of shear modulus (∼10−12\sim10^{-12}) while the solid phase corresponds to a finite shear modulus. The shifting behavior in the distributions can be quantified by the fraction of solid states ρsolid\rho_{\mathrm{solid}} shown in Figure 1(b). States below the rigidity transition p0=p0∗≈3.81p_0=p_0^*\approx3.81 therefore are always in the solid phase, which we term a pure solid. In the range of p0∈[3.81,4]p_0\in[3.81,4], ρsolid\rho_{\mathrm{solid}} drops below 1 indicating a solid-fluid coexistence, which we will refer to as marginal. For p0>4p_0>4 the tissue remains always in the fluid phase as it cannot build up stresses in respond to shear strain. This is also consistent with the yield stress vanishing at p0≃4.0p_0\simeq4.0. The fact that the material response depends on the application of shear is reminiscent of shear jamming in granular materials, where an state below the isotropic (un-sheared) jamming threshold can be jammed with the application of shear [29, 30, 31, 32]. The coexistence of solid and fluid phases also has analogs in dense suspensions near shear jamming [33] and discontinuous shear thickening [10, 34].

Predicting the tissue yield stress using a refined Soft Glassy Rheology model

Given the continuous behavior of yield stress across the pure solid - marginal state transition, we aimed to develop a unified model to deepen our qualitative understanding of the steady-shear regime properties using the Soft Glassy Rheology (SGR) framework [35, 36]. In the SGR model, mesoscopic elements, characterized by elastic constant κ\kappa and local strain ll, are confined within energy traps EE, where they accumulate elastic energy as macroscopic strain increases, approaching a yield point either directly or through an activated "hop" driven by mechanical fluctuations from neighboring elements yielding. The material’s dynamics under shear are governed by the probability P(E,l,t)P(E,l,t) evolving in time tt, which follows the Fokker-Planck equation [35, 36]:

∂∂tP(E,l,t)=−γ˙∂P∂l−Γ0e[−E−κl2/2]/xP+Γ(t)p(E)δ(l).(2)\frac{\partial}{\partial t}P(E,l,t)=-\dot{\gamma}\frac{\partial P}{\partial l}-\Gamma_0 e^{[-E-\kappa l^2/2]/x}P+\Gamma(t)p(E)\delta(l). \tag*{(2)}

The first term in Eq. (2) represents the motion of the elements driven by the applied shear rate, γ˙\dot{\gamma}. The second term describes thermally activated hopping from a trap with an effective depth of E−κl2/2E-\kappa l^2/2, which corresponds to the remaining distance to yielding. xx and Γ0\Gamma_0 represents the mechanical noise in the system akin to temperature and the hopping rate, respectively. The final term represents the transition to a new trap with energy EE drawn from a quenched random distribution p(E)p(E). The Dirac-delta function δ(l)\delta(l) reflects the assumption that the local strain ll is reset to zero after yielding. The total yielding rate at tt, Γ(t)\Gamma(t), is explicitly defined in the SI text.

In the SGR model, the choice of p(E)p(E)’s functional form critically influences material behavior [36]. Direct measurement of energy barrier distributions is challenging, leading prior studies to adopt generic or ad hoc assumptions for ρ(E)\rho(E), such as exponential distributions [37, 38, 39, 40]. In this work, we introduce a novel approach based on distinct mesoscopic tissue phases observed: (1) fluid elements with zero yielding energy (E=0E = 0) and (2) solid elements with finite yielding energy (E>0E > 0). Consequently, we propose a refined ρ(E)\rho(E):

ρ(E)=f0δ(E)+(1−f0)Eκ−1e−E/x0Γ(κ)x0κ.(3)\rho(E) = f_0\delta(E) + (1-f_0)\frac{E^{\kappa-1}e^{-E/x_0}}{\Gamma(\kappa)x_0^\kappa}. \tag*{(3)}

Here, f0f_0 denotes the probability of an element transitioning to a state with E=0E = 0, and 1−f01-f_0 corresponds to transitions into states with energy sampled from a k-gamma distribution, parameterized by mean x0x_0 and shape factor κ\kappa. This is based on the previous observation that the energy barriers to the T1 transition follow a k-gamma distribution [20, 41] with κ≈2\kappa\approx2. Together, Eqs. 2 and 3 describe three potential transitions in the energy landscape, depicted in Figure 1: (1) fluid to fluid a→b\mathrm{a} \to\mathrm{b}, (2) solid to solid c→d\mathrm{c} \to\mathrm{d}, and (3) solid to fluid e→f\mathrm{e} \to\mathrm{f}.

We next examine the steady state behavior of Eq. 2 in the quasi-static limit (γ→0\gamma\to0), with details shown in the SI text. The behavior is governed by three parameters: the dimensionless ratio of mechanical noise to mean yielding energy χ=x/x0\chi= x/x_0, the probability f0f_0 of transitioning to a fluid state, and the elastic constant kk of solid elements.

An important aspect of the SGR model is that the fluctuations that drive element rearrangements come from the mechanical noise due to other surrounding rearrangement events in the system. These fluctuations are analogous to the energies released during yielding events observed in our simulations. To correlate this mechanical noise with our empirical data, we introduce the following relationship:

χ=xx0∝⟨ΔE⟩⟨E⟩.(4)\chi= \frac{x}{x_0} \propto\frac{\langle\Delta E\rangle}{\langle E\rangle}. \tag*{(4)}

Here, ⟨ΔE⟩\langle\Delta E\rangle represents the average energy dissipated during yielding events, while ⟨E⟩\langle E\rangle denotes the average energy of cells in their solid state. Next, by analyzing the steady-state solution of Eq. 2, we determine the probability that an element is in the solid phase as a function of f0f_0 (details in SI, Eq. S.12). This corresponds precisely to ρsolid\rho_{\mathrm{solid}} in our simulations (Figure 1B). Finally, we treat the elastic constant kk of the elements as a constant, independent of the shape index p0p_0. Given that both ⟨ΔE⟩/⟨E⟩\langle\Delta E\rangle/\langle E\rangle and ρsolid\rho_{\mathrm{solid}} depend on p0p_0, the yield stress predicted by the SGR model (detailed in the SI) effectively varies only with p0p_0. This approach contrasts with previous studies that employed the SGR model [37, 38, 39, 42], where χ=x/x0\chi= x/x_0 was often used as a fitting parameter. In our research, we derive χ\chi directly from simulation data, enhancing the predictive accuracy of our theoretical results and distinguishing our use of the SGR model as predictive rather than merely descriptive. In Figure 1(a), we plot the SGR-predicted yield stress as a function of p0p_0. This demonstrates that the SGR model accurately predicts the yield stress vanishing point and its dependence on the cell shape index σyield(p0)\sigma_{\mathrm{yield}}(p_0).

The dual-state SGR model identifies two primary mechanisms responsible for the yield stress transition: (1) As p0p_0 increases, states with zero yielding energy barriers become more prevalent, leading to frequent yielding under deformation. This behavior is depicted by transitions such as a →\to b and e →\to f in Figure 1d; (2) Concurrently, mechanical noise from stress redistributions approaches the scale of the yielding energy barriers, enhancing the likelihood of solid-solid transitions through activated processes induced by neighboring rearrangements, as illustrated by c →\to d and e →\to f.

A novel method to infer tissue stresses based on instantaneous snapshots.

The coexistence of phases observed in the Vertex-based model reinforces the idea that tissues function as yield stress materials while also displaying fluid-like behavior. When combined with Soft Glassy Rheology (SGR) theory, this coexistence provides predictions for tissue yield stress based on the homeostatic cell shape index p0p_0. Given p0p_0, the Vertex based model could also provide estimation of the instantaneous tissue stress using Eqn. (9). However, determining the homeostatic-target shape index p0p_0 remains an experimental challenge. In contrast, segmented cell configurations in tissues are experimentally accessible and have been utilized in several non-invasive stress inference methods such as Bayesian Inference method [43, 44] and the image-based Variational method [45]. Although the Bayesian Stress Inference method proposed by Ishihara and Sugimura [44] has been applied to various systems, including Drosophila notum, retinal ommatidia, germband, and the quail early embryo [46, 47], its results strongly depend on a prior distribution of edge tension and cell pressure, which is not necessarily normally distributed, as originally proposed. Additionally, the method faces the challenge of having more unknowns than constraints. In contrast, the Variational Method proposed by Noll et al. [45] addresses the issue of underconstrained variables but relies on a computationally expensive fitting approach. Here, we propose a fast, non-invasive, image-based tissue stress inference method that is both convenient and accurate. It has been shown that edge length distribution is closely related to the distance to the yield stress in monolayers [19]. However, the connection between edge length distribution and tissue stress has not been quantified. In this work, we demonstrate that the cumulative distribution of edge length elegantly serves as a robust estimator of tissue stress.

In systems under deformation, the configuration exhibits anisotropy, with preferred orientations dictated by the deformation direction. To analyze this anisotropy and its strain evolution, we examined the distribution of edge vectors in the system, represented as polar distributions. In these distributions, color encodes the frequency of edges with lengths and orientations defined by radial distance and azimuthal angle, respectively. The polar distribution for an isotropic system therefore looks like a circle with dots scattered randomly inside. This is not what we observed in our system due to the anisotropy. To systematically study across different systems and time frames, we used the normalized edge length l=L/Lˉl = L/\bar{L}, obtained by normalizing the edge lengths by the average edge length in the current snapshot. Figure 2a displays the polar distribution of the normalized edge vectors l⃗\vec{l} in a low-stress, stable system far from yielding. Conversely, Figure 2b depicts the edge vector distribution in a high-stress, unstable system close to yielding. In both cases, anisotropy emerges, with longer edges aligning with the shear direction (about 45 degrees with respect to horizontal) and shorter edges perpendicular to it. However, the trend is more pronounced in unstable systems, illustrated by the red color band representing high population of short edges with orientation about 135 degrees with respect to horizontal (Figure 2b), implying a connection between instability and edge vector distribution. Furthermore, these polar plots reveal a strong dependence between edge length and orientation in deformed configurations.

Figure 2. A new approach to infer tissue stress: (a) Polar distribution of cell edge vectors in a stable state. (b) Polar distribution of cell edge vectors in an unstable state. (c) Edge length density distribution at different instability. Panels (a-c) were created using p0=3.72p_0 = 3.72. (d) The stress-strain curve is overlaid with C(l)C(l)-strain curve at different ll. The green box denotes the trace with high correlation between σ\sigma and C(l)C(l). (e) The correlation between tissue stress and the cumulative edge length distribution Rσ,C(l)R_{\sigma,C(l)} suggests a robust critical normalized edge length l∗l^*. Inset: The correlation between tissue stress and the portion of edges at different orientation Rσ,F(ω)R_{\sigma,F(\omega)}. (f) Color-plot of the correlation RC,FR_{C,F} between edges length distribution and edges orientation distribution. The black-dashed circle indicates the region in where the correlation is maximized, from which l∗l^* could be determined.

The correlation between edge length and orientation suggests that the edge length distribution can effectively represent the overall edge vector distribution. To investigate how edge configuration influences instability, we compared the edge length distributions of stable and unstable states. As illustrated in Figure 2c, both distributions exhibit a bimodal shape due to anisotropy. However, in the distribution of unstable system, the separation between the two peaks is larger, reflecting stronger anisotropic effects and an abundance of short edges, which are more prevalent in the unstable configuration. This motivated us to study the evolution of the edge length distribution as strain increase.

Investigating the evolution of the edge length cumulative distribution C(l)C(l) in our quasi-static simple shear simulations, we observed a correlation between C(l)C(l) and σ\sigma, with the correlation level depending on ll. As shown in Figure 2d, while the correlation Rσ,CR_{\sigma,C} between tissue stress σ\sigma and C(l)C(l) varies with ll, there exists a range of ll where C(l)C(l) is highly correlated with σ\sigma. We denote the ll value that maximizes the correlation Rσ,CR_{\sigma,C} as l∗l^*, and the corresponding cumulative distribution C(l∗)C(l^*) as C∗C^*. Interestingly, both l∗l^* and Rσ,CR_{\sigma,C} remain robust with changes in p0p_0, with the critical correlation Rσ,C∗R_{\sigma,C^*} exceeding 0.9, as shown in Figure 2e. Given the strong correlation between C∗C^* and σ\sigma, as well as the fact that cell edge lengths can be directly extracted from imaging, C∗C^* could serve as a non-invasive metric for inferring tissue-level stress.

While l∗≈0.61l^* \approx0.61 is consistent across various p0p_0 values in our quasi-static simulations, its practical value may depend on system properties and the shearing direction. Thus, developing a metric to experimentally determine l∗l^* is crucial for the stress inference method. Recognizing the strong relationship between edge length and orientation in anisotropic systems, we investigated tissue stress and edge orientation correlations. To quantify the edge orientation distribution, we used the proportion of edges a given orientation ω\omega:

F(ω)=N(ω−Δω,ω+Δω)NedgesF(\omega) = \frac{N(\omega-\Delta\omega,\omega+\Delta\omega)}{N_{\mathrm{edges}}}

Here, N(ω−Δω,ω+Δω)N(\omega-\Delta\omega,\omega+\Delta\omega) represent the number of edges in a cone with the open angle of 2Δω2\Delta\omega at the ω\omega direction and NedgesN_{\mathrm{edges}} is the total number of edges in the system. In this section, all angular values are in degrees. Tracking the evolution of F(ω)F(\omega) at different ω\omega as strain increased, we observed a critical orientation ω∗≈120∘\omega^* \approx120^\circ, where FωF_\omega was highly correlated with tissue stress, with a correlation coefficient Rσ,F(ω∗)>0.9R_{\sigma,F(\omega^*)} > 0.9 (Figure 2e inset). Although Rσ,FR_{\sigma,F} depends on the cone wideness Δω\Delta\omega, which we chose as Δω=18∘=π/10\Delta\omega= 18^\circ= \pi/10 to optimize Rσ,FR_{\sigma,F}, the critical orientation ω∗\omega^* is independent of Δω\Delta\omega. Additionally, ω∗\omega^* was robust across variations in p0p_0 (Figure 2e inset). Given the high correlations Rσ,CR_{\sigma,C} and Rσ,FR_{\sigma,F}, the critical edge length l∗l^* could potentially be determined from the correlation between edge length and edge orientation, RC,FR_{C,F}. As suggested by Figure 2e, we only focus on the range l<1l < 1 in which C(l)C(l) is known to positively correlates with tissue stress σ\sigma. By computing the correlation RC(l),F(ω)R_{C(l),F(\omega)} at different (l,ω)(l,\omega), we identified a region where the correlation is exceptionally high (greater than 0.93), as indicated by the dashed circle in Figure 2f. The ll values in this region align excellently with the critical edge length l∗l^*, suggesting that l∗l^* can be estimated as the normalized edge length value ll maximizing RC(l),F(ω)R_{C(l),F(\omega)}. With l∗l^* in hand, ones could

use C∗=C(l∗)C^* = C(l^*) to extract an estimation of the tissue stress as it evolves during the deformation process. Our stress inference method could be conveniently validated by experiments such as the monolayer stretching protocol [3]. Although C∗C^* could be use directly as the inference for tissue stress, more complicated functional models are available and discussed in more detail in the SI.

Dynamics of tissue plasticity

So far, we know that for a system in the coexistence phase to transitions from solid to fluid, a collective rearrangement event is required to significantly remodel the configuration. However, the mechanism that govern the occurrences of these events and the evolution of the system during the events is still not fully understood. To explore the yielding behavior of biological tissues, it is essential to describe the dynamics of plastic events during avalanches. In this study, we examine the plasticity dynamics by investigating the spatiotemporal evolution of the plastic rearrangements created by other rearrangements during an avalanche [48, 49]. Figure 3a displays a space-time plot of the occurrences of T1 transitions during an avalanche, with the cells labeled in red indicating participation in the T1 transitions.

Figure 3. Spatiotemporal map of plastic events in tissue. (a) Space-time map of plastics rearrangement in the form of T1 transition during an avalanche. Cells that participated in T1 transitions are labeled in red. The example avalanche was selected from a system at p0=3.72p_0 = 3.72. (b) Number of accumulative plastic rearrangement and tissue shear stress as the avalanche progresses.

As depicted in Figure 3a, an avalanche involving numerous plastic rearrangements could originate from a single T1 tran sition, which we refer to as the initial trigger. Starting from the initial trigger, the stress redistribution from each event can also stimulate surrounding cells to become unstable and undergo T1 transitions. These soft cells, whose mechanical characteristics are distinct from the surrounding cells, experience larger deformation than the neighboring cells and have been observed in multicellular tumor spheroids using 3D light microscopy [50]. From amorphous solid point of view, these cells are referred to as soft spots [23, 24, 25, 26] or Shear Transformation Zones [51, 52]. This cascade of cellular rearrangements can therefore lead to an avalanche, which continues until the population of soft spots are sufficiently depleted. In Figure 3b, we show the number of accumulated T1 transitions and the tissue shear stress during a typical avalanche. The stress relaxation due to an avalanche therefore is the origin of the discontinuous yielding of stress during quasistatic shear. In Figure 3a, the location of rearrangments over time suggests that there is a preferred direction for the avalanche to propagate. In order to quantify this and to establish a causal relationship in time, we define a two-point, two-time correlation function:

ϕ(r,Δt)=⟨P(r0,t0)P(r0+r,t0+Δt)⟩,(5)\phi(\mathbf{r},\Delta t) = \langle P(\mathbf{r}_0,t_0)P(\mathbf{r}_0+\mathbf{r},t_0+\Delta t)\rangle, \tag*{(5)}

where P(r,t)P(\mathbf{r},t) is a binary field, representing the occurrence of a T1 transition (1 if a T1 transition at occurs at r\mathbf{r} and time tt and 0 otherwise). ⟨...⟩\langle...\rangle represents spatial and ensemble averaging. With this definition, ϕ\phi is therefore the conditional probability of observing a T1 transition at location r0+r\mathbf{r}_0+\mathbf{r} and time t0+Δtt_0+\Delta t, given that a transition has already occurred at (r0,t0)(\mathbf{r}_0,t_0).

In Figure 4a, we illustrate the evolution of the field ϕ\phi as Δt\Delta t increases. The field ϕ\phi behaves like a wave that propagates away from the causal rearrangement and prefers to propagate in the x-direction, coinciding with the direction of the external shear force. The evolution of the field ϕ\phi reflects the interplay between the stress redistribution from a plastic rearrangement and the population of soft spots which could rearrange under the effect of the strain field.

Propagation of plastic events

Figure 4. Propagation of plastic events. (a) Evolution of the probability field ϕ\phi at p0=3.72p_0 = 3.72. Each image corresponds to the probability field at a particular time lag Δt\Delta t. Bright regions indicate a high probability of finding another rearrangement in the region relative to the causal rearrangement. (b) Spatial distribution of the correlation field ϕx\phi_x as a function of the relative horizontal position Δx\Delta x. The distribution has a diffusing bimodal shape, indicating a convection process alongside diffusion. (c) Spatial distribution of the correlation field ϕy\phi_y as a function of the relative vertical position Δy\Delta y. The distribution is bell-shaped, with the width of the bell increasing as time progresses, indicating a pure diffusion process. (d) The separation of the peaks in ϕx\phi_x and the Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM) of ϕy\phi_y as functions of the time lag Δt\Delta t.

We first focus on the angular dependence of ϕ\phi, which shows an anisotropic four-fold pattern. This anisotropy is consistent with the stress redistribution field due to a rearrangement in an elastic medium as predicted by elastoplastic models [19, 53]. However, it differs from the isotropic probability field observed in ductile, soft disk systems [54]. This contradiction likely arises from the difference in shape anisotropy between soft disks and cells in our system. While soft disk systems exhibit minimal particle shape anisotropy, cells in our system can sustain large deformations and have highly anisotropic shapes. Consequently, deviatoric strain triggers rearrangements in soft disk systems, whereas simple shear strain is responsible for triggering rearrangements in our system.

To better understand how the rearrangement probability field propagates, we looked at ϕx=ϕ(x,y=0)∑xϕ(x,y=0)\phi_x = \frac{\phi(x,y=0)}{\sum_x \phi(x,y=0)} and ϕy=ϕ(x=0,y)∑yϕ(x=0,y)\phi_y = \frac{\phi(x=0,y)}{\sum_y \phi(x=0,y)} separately. ϕx\phi_x, as observed in Figure 4b, is a bimodal distribution that evolves in time such that the distance between the two peaks dpeaksd_{\mathrm{peaks}} increases as time goes. The diffusing bimodal distribution suggests that the propagation is a combination of convection and diffusion, and the drift velocity could be captured by the rate at which the peaks' separation increases. Conversely, ϕy\phi_y is a bell-like shape distribution that gets broader as time progresses (Figure 4c), indicating that the propagation in the y-direction is similar to a purely diffusion process with the diffusivity can be captured by the evolution of the FWHM-ϕy\phi_y. Since the rearrangement probability field is the result of the shear stress redistribution and the population of soft spots, the propagating mechanism of the field also should agree with the propagation of the stress redistribution.

The phenomenon that the shear stress redistribution tends to propagate in the direction of shear has also been observed in particle-based systems governed by inverse-power-law pair-wise potentials [49]. Remarkably, this behavior bears a striking resemblance to the propagation of elastic waves. In the theory of elasticity, longitudinal waves, characterized by displacement in the direction of propagation, outpace transverse waves [55]. Moreover, longitudinal elastic waves involve changes in local density [55], akin to the xx-propagating excitation wave’s modulation of local density via T1 transitions. Conversely, transverse elastic waves do not induce density changes, resembling the infrequent involvement of T1 transitions in yy-propagating excitation waves. Notably, the mechanism driving stress redistribution to preferentially propagate in the shear direction appears universal, independent of p0p_0. However, since p0p_0 governs the elastic response in our system, with higher values corresponding to a less elastic state, there is a negative correlation between the stress redistribution wave’s speed and p0p_0.

Statistics of tissue avalanches

In addition to the universal propagation mechanism, we wondered if the statistics of tissue yielding events also exhibit universality. In Figure 5a, both the average yielding size Sˉ\bar{S}, denoting the total number of T1 transitions after a yielding event, and the average stress drop, representing the amount of stress relaxed by the event, exhibit the same dependence on p0p_0. In the solid regime, while the stress decreases with increasing p0p_0, the average yielding size shows minimal variation. This trend of Sˉ\bar{S} versus p0p_0 is akin to that observed in Figure 1b for the proportion of the solid state.

Figure 5. Avalanches statistics. (a) Dependence of average yielding size Sˉ\bar{S} and average stress relaxed Δσˉ\Delta\bar{\sigma} on p0p_0. Inset: Dependence of average avalanche size Sˉs\bar{S}_s on p0p_0. (b) Distribution of avalanche size follows a power-law distribution. Inset: Distribution of scaled average stress relaxed by avalanches also follows the same power law

However, in the marginal phase, there are different types of yielding events as discussed previously (Figure 1c). In the yielding events that occur while the system is fluid-like, illustrated by the a → b transition in Figure 1c (Type I), the tissue lacks rigidity and therefore is unable to transmit stress to initiate a cascade of rearrangements. Conversely, yielding events following a solid state, illustrated by c → d and e → f transitions (Type II), tend to be cascading as the rigid tissue is capable of propagating the stress redistribution. It is this latter type that we refer to as tissue avalanches from now on. Since the avalanches growing mechanism is universal, we expect their statistics to also be independent of p0p_0.

Excluding yielding events of type I from the analysis and specifically analyzing only the avalanches, we indeed find that the average avalanche size S‾s\overline{S}_s does not vary significantly with p0p_0 (Figure 5a inset), suggesting universal avalanches size statistics . To rigorously assess this universality, we examine the distribution of avalanche sizes across various p0p_0 values (see Figure 5b). Strikingly, we observe a consistent power-law distribution, reminiscent of the Gutenberg–Richter law observed in earthquakes [56, 57], with an exponent τ=−1.36\tau= -1.36, which agrees with the analogous exponent observed in overdamped elastoplastic models under shear [58, 59] and in vertex model on spherical surface [60]. This shared characteristic suggests a parallel between biological and seismic avalanches and supports the argument that the vertex model and epithelial tissues belong to the universality class of plastic amorphous systems.

Furthermore, we find that the same power law applies to the distribution of average stress drops during avalanches when scaled by the average (Figure 5b inset). This collapse after rescaling implies that the stress relaxation mechanism via avalanches is independent of the shape index p0p_0, and p0p_0 only affects the average stress relaxed by governing tissue overall stiffness. Moreover, the similarity in the stress drop distribution and avalanches size distribution indicates that each plastic rearrangement, on average, releases a similar amount of stress that depends only on p0p_0. The convergence of these distributions suggests that the growth of avalanches remains unaffected by changes in p0p_0, providing additional evidence for the universal propagation mechanism discussed earlier.

Predicting tissue avalanches based on static structural information

While the first cells to undergo a T1 transition triggers the avalanche, in order for the avalanche to grow, it is necessary to have soft spots in the system that are susceptible to undergo T1s. In the framework of the elastoplastic model, it has been established that the distance to yield xx, which represents the additional stress required to trigger a yielding event, follows a power-law distribution, p(x)∝xθp(x) \propto x^\theta [61, 62, 63]. The exponent θ\theta has been suggested as a measure of the system’s instability, with a higher value indicating a more stable state.

In the vertex-based model family, it has been proposed that the distance to yield xx exhibits a linear relationship with the length of cell edges LL, and that the distribution of edge lengths should follow the same power-law behavior as p(x)p(x) [19]. While this argument establishes a connection between system configuration and instability, the efficacy of using the distribution of short edges to describe instability remains uncertain.

To address this ambiguity, we investigate this concept within our Voronoi model and observed an intriguing correlation between the exponent θ\theta and system instability (see S.I and Figure S2). However, θ\theta is not a reliable metric because it is derived from a power-law fit that heavily depends on the range of fitting [19]. In practice, the cumulative distribution function (c.d.f) of LL exhibits power-law behavior only within a specific range, which varies from sample to sample. Therefore, we propose using C∗C^* as the parameter of instability to avoid the uncertainties and biases associated with fitting.

A proposed exponent of instability

Figure S2. A proposed exponent of instability. (a) An example of the evolution of tissue shear stress σxy\sigma_{xy} and θ\theta exponent as strain increases. (b) Dependence of average avalanche size and the exponent of instability θ\theta. Inset: the probability to yield p+p_+ versus θ\theta. (c) The polar distribution of edges vector in an unstable and stable configuration. Data shown in Figure 3 is extracted from a system with shape index p0=3.74p_0 = 3.74 in the solid regime.

Using C∗C^* as the parameter of instability, with higher C∗C^* corresponding to a more unstable state, we observed a relationship between instability and avalanche size. To quantify the relation between instability and avalanche size, we focus on the failure states, i.e states that are about to yield, indicated by having a stress drop in the next strain step and a corresponding avalanche. We computed C∗C^* for those states and then grouped the avalanche sizes based on C∗C^* (Figure 6a). At low C∗C^*, if the tissue yields, the size of the yielding event is likely to be small, indicated by a rapid increase to 1 in the cumulative distribution function (c.d.f.) of SS. As C∗C^* increases, the likelihood of larger yielding events grows. The probability of observing an avalanche of size 25 or greater is summarized in Figure 6b.

Figure 6. Predicting avalanches. (b)An example of the evolution of tissue shear stress σxy\sigma_{xy} and C∗C^* as strain increases. (b) Scatter plot of shear stress and C∗C^* at different p0p_0 in the solid regime. (c) c.d.f.(S) at different C∗C^* level at p0=3.79p_0=3.79. (d) Probability of having avalanches of size greater than 25 at different C∗C^*

While C∗C^* can provide predictions about avalanche size, it cannot determine when an avalanche will occur. Therefore, we require another tool to forecast yielding events. In amorphous solids, the locations of plastic rearrangements during an avalanche largely depend on the material’s structural configuration, with areas more likely to experience plastic events called soft spots. Various frameworks have been proposed to link structure and plasticity, such as the Shear Transformation Zone theory [25, 51, 52, 64, 65] and lattice-based models. The most promising theoretical approach for predicting the locations of soft spots involves identifying these areas based on soft vibrational modes [24, 66, 67]. As a system approaches a plastic rearrangement, at least one normal mode is supposed to approach zero frequency [24]. However, the vibrational mode analysis is not applicable to the vertex-based model family due to the cuspiness of the energy landscape [20, 41]. In such systems, the energy cusp at a plastic event prevents the corresponding low-frequency mode from vanishing as it would in systems with smooth, analytic energy landscape. As shown in Figure S3, in our system, no low-frequency mode approaches zero frequency except at the onset of the plastic event. Hence, an alternative approach is necessary.

Figure S3. Evolution of low-frequency mode near avalanches.

In our model, the deformation of edges immediately following shear strain is deterministic. Through simple geometry, we deduce the existence of a range of orientations wherein edges are prone to shortening upon shearing, rendering them more susceptible. In the vertex model, under the condition γ˙≪1\dot{\gamma} \ll1, the change in edge length δL\delta L due to shear is approximated as δL≈γ˙Lsin⁡(2ϕ)\delta L \approx\dot{\gamma} L \sin(2\phi), where LL and ϕ\phi represent the edge length and orientation, respectively. Consequently, in the vertex model, the most susceptible orientation is 3π4\frac{3\pi}{4}. If an edge is sufficiently weak (or short) and happens to align with this susceptible orientation, it may yield under the influence of shearing, potentially triggering further rearrangements in its vicinity. We refer to these susceptible edges as triggers. Since triggers are local elements, their presence is not captured by the cumulative distribution function of edge lengths, c.d.f(LL), thereby explaining why C∗C^{*} alone cannot predict imminent system failure. In summary, the presence of a trigger is the necessary condition, while a high C∗C^{*} in the current state is the sufficient condition for a large avalanche in a tissue monolayer.

Discussion

We studied the response of tissue monolayers to external quasi-static shear stress in the long-term steady-shear regime. For a tissue monolayer initially in a fluid state, it behaves like a yield-stress material in the shear buildup regime but eventually enters a marginal phase in the long-term steady shear regime. Incorporating the coexistence phase into the SGR model, we elucidated the discrepancy between the rigidity transition and the yield stress transition observed in the Vertex model under simple shear.

Besides the yield stress, tissue plasticity is also reflected in avalanches of plastic rearrangements. Understanding those local rearrangements would help reveal the mechanism of mechanical homeostasis and reparation in biological tissue. By studying the dynamics of tissue avalanches, we observed a universal propagation mechanism of plastic events that is independent of the shape index p0p_{0} and has two preferred directions, with the direction of the external shear being the one with faster propagation. The rearrangement probability ϕ\phi studied here is closely related to, but not identical with, the stress redistribution predicted by elastoplastic models [19, 53] or the strain field due to rearrangement [54]. Instead, ϕ\phi captured the interplay between stress redistribution and spatial distribution of weak spots. Since most edges that participated in T1 transition in our system orient at −π/4-\pi/4 with respect to the horizontal (Figure S4), the positive shear stress is expected to symmetrically redistribute along the horizontal and vertical directions [19]. Although ϕ\phi does propagate mainly in the horizontal and vertical directions, it does not possess the vertical-horizontal symmetry seen in stress redistribution or in the strain field. This difference arises from highly heterogeneity and anisotropic in the spatial distribution of weak spots. The rearrangement dynamics studied in this work could help identify regions where rearrangements are anticipated in the near future. Predictions based on our analysis are most reliable in systems where external forces dominate cellular activity or under quasi-static conditions. In these scenarios, rearrangements occur systematically, driven solely by stress redistribution from regions of high stress to relax global stress. Conversely, in systems with high cellular activity, rearrangements happen randomly due to the stochastic motion of cells, blurring the impact of stress redistribution. Although capturing avalanches experimentally is challenging due to the competition between various timescales in active tissue, tracking the spatiotemporal evolution of local rearrangements is feasible within timescales where activities such as cell division are negligible. Such experiments could provide valuable evidence to support our analysis of rearrangement dynamics. One such experiment is the fracturing of Trichoplax Adhaerens, during which regions with significant non-affine motion exhibit spatial correlations along the direction of the driving shear force [18].

The orientation distribution of T1-edges

Figure S4. The orientation distribution of T1-edges (edges undergo T1 transitions) at various values of p0p_0.

The universality of tissue avalanches is not only reflected in the propagation of plastic events but also captured by a power-law distribution of avalanche sizes, with an exponent τ=−1.36\tau=-1.36, strengthening the argument that epithelial tissues behave like plastic amorphous materials. We also propose a metric to not only predict tissue avalanches but also infer tissue stress in highly anisotropic systems based on an instantaneous static snapshot. In finite size system, the cut off avalanche size ScS_{c} depends on the system size NN as Sc∝Ndf/dS_{c} \propto N^{d_{f}/d}, where dfd_{f} is fractal dimension of avalanches and dd is the dimension of the system [62]. Future possible work can be performed with different system size to obtain the avalanches fractal dimension dfd_{f} and further understand the finite size effect on avalanches.

We also propose a metric to not only infer tissue stress based on an instantaneous static snapshot but also predict tissue avalanches. Quantification of tissue-level force and stress is necessary to understand the physics of many biological processes. However, direct measurement of stress in vivo is considerably challenging [68, 69, 70]. Compare to other non-invasive methods to estimate tissue stress such as Bayesian Force Inference [44] and Variational Method for Image-Based Inference [45], our approach using C∗C^{*} offers a simple and fast method to estimate tissue stress. The advantage of C∗C^{*} lies in its independence from fitting parameters and system properties. Given a segmented movie of a monolayer undergoing deformation, C∗C^{*} can be easily derived from the segmented images and offers a decent estimate of tissue relative stress evolution during the process without requiring prior knowledge of the monolayer’s mechanical properties. The downside of our approach is that it cannot provide a spatial distribution of local stress. The strong agreement between σxy\sigma_{xy} and C∗C^{*} is noteworthy, especially since C∗C^{*} does not incorporate information about edge orientation, which directly affects stress. In an isotropic system, edge length alone is insufficient to infer stress. However, in a system undergoing large deformation and thus highly anisotropic, the influence of edge orientation diminishes, making edge length alone sufficient for stress inference. The impact of shape anisotropy is evident during the buildup phase or when the system is in a fluid state. In these scenarios, edges may have negligible tension, making edge tension independent of edge length. Consequently, it is possible that systems with similar C∗C^* values could exhibit significantly different stress levels.

The impact of triggers on avalanches goes beyond simply initiating them; we observed a significant dependence of avalanche size on the trigger location. By manually shrinking vanishing edges at various locations within the same configuration, we noted that the size of the resulting avalanches varied markedly. This indicates that the location of the initial excitation has a profound influence on the final size of the avalanche. A promising future research direction could involve developing a theoretical framework that moves beyond the mean field approach to more accurately capture the spatial heterogeneity in the tissue.

Method

Simulation Model

To numerically study the behavior of dense epithelial tissues under large deformation, we use a Voronoi-based version [21] of the Vertex Model [71], where the degrees of freedom are the set of cell centers denoted as {ri}\{\mathbf{r}_i\} and the geometric configurations of cells are derived from their respective Voronoi tessellation. The biomechanics governing interactions both within and between cells can be effectively represented at a coarse-grained level [27, 72], expressed in terms of a mechanical energy functional associated with cell shapes, given by:

E=∑i=1N[KA(Ai−A0)2+KP(Pi−P0)2],(6)E = \sum_{i=1}^{N} \left[K_A(A_i-A_0)^2+K_P(P_i-P_0)^2\right], \tag*{(6)}

where AiA_i and PiP_i represent the area and perimeter of the ii-th cell, respectively. The parameters KAK_A and KPK_P denote the area and perimeter moduli, respectively. The values A0A_0 and P0P_0 correspond to the preferred area and perimeter values, with A0A_0 specifically set to the average area per cell Aˉ\bar{A}. Without the loss of generality, we choose KPA0K_PA_0 as the energy unit and A0\sqrt{A_0} as the length unit. This leads to the dimensionless form of the energy

ε=∑i=1NκA(ai−1)2+(pi−p0)2,(7)\varepsilon= \sum_{i=1}^{N} \kappa_A(a_i-1)^2+(p_i-p_0)^2, \tag*{(7)}

where κA=KAA0/KP\kappa_A=K_AA_0/K_P represents the rescaled area elasticity, governing the cell area stiffness relative to the perimeter stiffness, ai=Ai/A0a_i=A_i/\sqrt{A_0} and pi=Pi/A0p_i=P_i/\sqrt{A_0} are the rescaled area and perimeter, respectively, and p0=P0/A0p_0=P_0/\sqrt{A_0} the cell shape index. In this particular work, we studied only the regime with KA=0K_A=0 and KP=1K_P=1. To investigate the mechanical response of the tissue, we apply simple-shear deformation to the simulated tissues utilizing Lees-Edwards boundary conditions [73]. Initially, strain-free configurations (γ=0\gamma=0) are generated with randomly distributed cell centers. The FIRE algorithm [74] is subsequently employed to minimize the energy functional in accordance with Eq. (7). Strain is then incrementally applied in steps of Δγ=2×10−3\Delta\gamma=2\times10^{-3} until reaching a maximum value of γmax⁡=6\gamma_{\max}=6. Alongside the modification of periodic boundary conditions to account for the strain, an affine displacement field Δri=Δγ yi x^\Delta\mathbf{r}_i=\Delta\gamma\,y_i\,\hat{\mathbf{x}} is applied to the cell centers. Following each increment of strain, the FIRE algorithm is again utilized to minimize the energy functional (Eq.7) until the residual forces acting on cell centers fall below 10−1410^{-14}, so that all resultant tissue states are meta-stable. This procedural approach effectively corresponds to investigating the system within the athermal quasi-static limit (γ˙→0\dot{\gamma}\to0). The tissues under examination consist of cell populations with N=400N=400, accompanied by varying cell shape indices p0p_0. A total of 84 random initial samples were simulated for each set of parameter values. The shape indices were incrementally varied from 3.66 to 4, with a step size of 0.2, except near the rigidity transition p0∗=3.81p_0^*=3.81. For 3.8≤p0≤3.823.8\leq p_0\leq3.82, the parameter was incremented with a finer step size of 0.02 to study the transition. We calculate the tension, denoted as Tij\mathbf{T}_{ij}, acting along an edge lijl_{ij} shared by cells ii and jj using the equation [43, 44, 75]

Tij=∂ε∂lij=2[(pi−p0)+(pj−p0)]l^ij,(8)\mathbf{T}_{ij}=\frac{\partial\varepsilon}{\partial l_{ij}}=2[(p_i-p_0)+(p_j-p_0)]\hat{\mathbf{l}}_{ij}, \tag*{(8)}

where l^ij\hat{\mathbf{l}}_{ij} represents the unit vector along lijl_{ij}. Furthermore, the global tissue shear stress σ\sigma can be obtained by

σ=σxy≡1N∑i<jTijxlijy,(9)\sigma=\sigma_{xy}\equiv\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i<j}T^x_{ij}l^y_{ij}, \tag*{(9)}

where TijxT^x_{ij} denotes the xx-component of Tij\mathbf{T}_{ij} and lijyl^y_{ij} stands for the yy-component of lijl_{ij}.

Data Availability

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Code Availability

The custom code developed for this study is available at GitHub Repository (https://github.com/jxhuangphys/shared_voronoi_model) under the MIT license. For further inquiries, please contact the corresponding author.

Acknowledgments

We thank Craig E. Maloney, Marko Popović, and Jie Lin for insightful discussions. We acknowledge support from the National Science Foundation (grant nos. DMR-2046683 and PHY-2019745), the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, the Human Frontier Science Program (Ref.-No.: RGP0007/2022), the NIGMS of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) under award number R35GM15049, and the Northeastern University Discovery Cluster.

Author Contributions

All authors contributed to the research design. A.Q.N. and J.H. performed and analyzed the numerical simulations with guidance from D.B. The manuscript was written by A.Q.N. and D.B., with input from J.H.

Supplementary Text for Origin of yield stress and mechanical plasticity in model biological tissues

Computing tissue level linear mechanical response

The tissue level mechanical response was quantified by the shear modulus GG. We computed GG using Born-Huang formulation in the limit of infinitesimal affine strain γ\gamma [76, 77]:

G=1Atotal(∂2E∂γ2−ΞiαHiαjβ−1Ξjβ)(10)G = \frac{1}{A_{\mathrm{total}}}\left(\frac{\partial^2 E}{\partial\gamma^2} - \Xi_{i\alpha}H^{-1}_{i\alpha j\beta}\Xi_{j\beta}\right) \tag*{(10)}

where the Roman indexes ii, jj label cells and Greek indexes α,β\alpha,\beta denote Cartesian components. Ξiα\Xi_{i\alpha} is the derivative of the force on cell iith with respect to the strain γ\gamma:

Ξiα=∂2E∂riα∂γ(11)\Xi_{i\alpha} = \frac{\partial^2 E}{\partial r_{i\alpha}\partial\gamma} \tag*{(11)}

HH is the Hessian matrix given by the second derivative of the tissue energy EE with respect to position cells position:

Hiαjβ=∂2E∂riα∂rjβ(12)H_{i\alpha j\beta} = \frac{\partial^2 E}{\partial r_{i\alpha}\partial r_{j\beta}} \tag*{(12)}

Steady state solution and asymptotic behavior in dual-state SGR

In the Fokker-Planck equation of motion (Eqn.(2) in the Main Text), the total yielding rate Γ(t)\Gamma(t) can be obtained [36]:

Γ(t)=Γ0∫dE dl P(E,l,t)exp⁡[−E−kl2/2x].(13)\Gamma(t) = \Gamma_0 \int dE\,dl\,P(E,l,t)\exp\left[-\frac{E-kl^2/2}{x}\right]. \tag*{(13)}

Since we are interested in the long-term steady shear, we look for a steady state solution to Eqn.(2). In steady state, Eqn.(2) becomes an ODE with respect to ll:

∂P∂l+Γ0γ˙exp⁡[−E−kl2/2x]P=Γγ˙ρ(E)δ(l)\frac{\partial P}{\partial l}+\frac{\Gamma_0}{\dot{\gamma}}\exp\left[-\frac{E-kl^2/2}{x}\right]P=\frac{\Gamma}{\dot{\gamma}}\rho(E)\delta(l)

The steady-state solution is [36]:

P(E,l)=Γγ˙ρ(E)exp⁡(−ze−E/x)(14)P(E,l)=\frac{\Gamma}{\dot{\gamma}}\rho(E)\exp\left(-ze^{-E/x}\right) \tag*{(14)}

Where z(l)z(l) is:

z(l)=Γ0γ˙∫0ldl′ ekl′2/2x(15)z(l)=\frac{\Gamma_0}{\dot{\gamma}}\int_0^l dl'\,e^{kl'^2/2x} \tag*{(15)}

In steady state, the total yielding rate Γ\Gamma is just a constant and can be found by normalizing P(E,l)P(E,l), giving the steady state solution for P(E,l)P(E,l) of the form:

P(E,l)=ρ(E)exp⁡(−ze−E/x)∫0∞dl Gρ(z)P(E,l)=\frac{\rho(E)\exp\left(-ze^{-E/x}\right)}{\int_0^\infty dl\,G_\rho(z)}

Where GρG_\rho is:

Gρ(z)=∫0∞dE ρ(E)exp⁡(−ze−E/x)G_\rho(z)=\int_0^\infty dE\,\rho(E)\exp\left(-ze^{-E/x}\right)

GρG_\rho can be separated into two parts. The first part, denoted by GδG_\delta, comes from the contribution of the zero energy traps (the Dirac-delta function in ρ(E)\rho(E)). GΓG_\Gamma denotes the second part coming from the non-zero energy traps (the Gamma function in ρ(E)\rho(E)):

Gδ(z)=∫dE δ(E)exp⁡(−ze−E/x)=exp⁡(−z)G_\delta(z)=\int dE\,\delta(E)\exp\left(-ze^{-E/x}\right)=\exp(-z)
GΓ(z)=∫dE Eκ−1e−E/x0Γ(κ)x0κexp⁡(−ze−E/x)G_\Gamma(z)=\int dE\,\frac{E^{\kappa-1}e^{-E/x_0}}{\Gamma(\kappa)x_0^\kappa}\exp\left(-ze^{-E/x}\right)
Gρ(z)=f0Gδ+(1−f0)GΓG_\rho(z)=f_0G_\delta+(1-f_0)G_\Gamma

The steady-state solution in the long-time limit can be studied more conveniently using the following auxiliary functions:

I0δ=∫dl GδI_{0\delta}=\int dl\,G_\delta
I1δ=kδ∫dl lGδ≈0I_{1\delta}=k_\delta\int dl\,lG_\delta\approx0
I0Γ=∫dl GΓI_{0\Gamma}=\int dl\,G_\Gamma
I1Γ=k∫dl lGΓI_{1\Gamma}=k\int dl\,lG_\Gamma

Since our main focus is the rheological response of the system, reflected in the macroscopic stress, we compute the system stress by ensemble averaging the local stress [36]:

σ=⟨kl⟩=∫∫dE dl klP(E,l)(16)\sigma=\langle kl\rangle=\int\int dE\,dl\,klP(E,l) \tag*{(16)}

Using the auxiliary functions and the steady-state solution, the stress is therefore given by:

σ=(1−f0)I1Γf0I0δ+(1−f0)I0Γ(17)\sigma=\frac{(1-f_0)I_{1\Gamma}}{f_0I_{0\delta}+(1-f_0)I_{0\Gamma}} \tag*{(17)}

For an element with zero yielding energy, the strain of the element is of order γ˙/Γ0\dot{\gamma}/\Gamma_0. Therefore, in the low strain-rate limit, the strain of the element with zero yield energy is typically small so GδG_\delta can be approximated in this limit as:

Gδ=exp⁡(−lΓ0/γ˙)G_\delta=\exp(-l\Gamma_0/\dot{\gamma})

In the case of κ=2\kappa= 2 and let χ=xx0<2\chi= \frac{x}{x_0} < 2, using the substitution u=e−E/xu = e^{-E/x} and integration by part, GΓ(z)G_{\Gamma}(z) can be integrated as follow:

GΓ(z)=∫10χ2ln⁡(u)uχ−1exp⁡(−zu) du=χ2(χ−1)!zχ∑n=1∞(−z)nnn!G_{\Gamma}(z) = \int_{1}^{0} \chi^2 \ln(u)u^{\chi-1}\exp(-zu)\,du = \frac{\chi^2(\chi-1)!}{z^\chi}\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{(-z)^n}{nn!}

The series ∑n=1∞(−z)nnn!\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{(-z)^n}{nn!} converges by alternating series test and therefore GΓ(z)G_{\Gamma}(z) scales as z−χz^{-\chi}. We then obtain the following scaling relations:

I0δ≈γ˙Γ0(18)I_{0\delta} \approx\frac{\dot{\gamma}}{\Gamma_0} \tag*{(18)}
I0Γ≈C(χ)γ˙χ(19)I_{0\Gamma} \approx C(\chi)\dot{\gamma}^{\chi} \tag*{(19)}
I1Γ≈D(χ)γ˙χ(20)I_{1\Gamma} \approx D(\chi)\dot{\gamma}^{\chi} \tag*{(20)}

Using, the steady state solution, the proportion of time that elements spends in the zero yielding energy traps (fluid state) PP can be expressed in terms of f0f_0:

P=f0I0δf0I0δ+(1−f0)I0Γ(21)P = \frac{f_0 I_{0\delta}}{f_0 I_{0\delta} + (1-f_0)I_{0\Gamma}} \tag*{(21)}

Combining Eq. (S.8) and Eq. (S.12), the yield stress can be calculated as:

σy(x)=(1−f0)I1Γf0I0δ+(1−f0)I0Γ=(1−P)I1ΓI0Γ=(1−P)σ0(22)\sigma_y(x) = \frac{(1-f_0)I_{1\Gamma}}{f_0 I_{0\delta} + (1-f_0)I_{0\Gamma}} = (1-P)\frac{I_{1\Gamma}}{I_{0\Gamma}} = (1-P)\sigma_0 \tag*{(22)}

Where σ0\sigma_0 is the yield stress that arises solely from elements in a solid state, which is finite based on the scaling relation (S.10) and (S.11).

Modeling tissue stress as a function of edge length critical cumulative distribution

Plotting C∗C^* against σxy\sigma_{xy} for p0p_0 in the plastic regime reveals a clear exponential relationship (Figure S1). However, due to the limited range of C∗C^*, distinguishing between an exponential and a power-law relationship remains challenging. To address this, we tested both the exponential model (σxy=mexpeαC∗\sigma_{xy} = m_{\mathrm{exp}}e^{\alpha C^*}) and the power-law model (σxy=mpowC∗β\sigma_{xy} = m_{\mathrm{pow}}C^{*\beta}). The only fitting parameters for each model are α\alpha and β\beta, for the exponential and power-law models, respectively. As shown in figure S1(b,c), both models provide excellent estimates of tissue stress over a wide range of strain. The dependence of α\alpha and β\beta on p0p_0 is shown in figure S1(d,e), with both α\alpha and β\beta increasing as p0p_0 increases. To compare the two models, we first determined the unit conversion factors as mexp=⟨σ/eαC∗⟩m_{\mathrm{exp}} = \langle\sigma/e^{\alpha C^*}\rangle and mpow=⟨σ/C∗β⟩m_{\mathrm{pow}} = \langle\sigma/C^{*\beta}\rangle. Here, ⟨⋯ ⟩\langle\cdots\rangle represents ensemble averaging, and ⋯‾\overline{\cdots} represents averaging over different strains in a single simulation. The mean squared error (MSE) for both models was computed at different p0p_0 values, as shown in figure S1f. The MSE values indicate that the residuals are approximately two orders of magnitude smaller than the observed stress, demonstrating the high accuracy of both models. In addition, as a consequence of the decrease in yield stress with increasing p0p_0, the MSE also decreases as p0p_0 increases.

Figure S1. Dependence of stress inference model fitting parameters α\alpha and β\beta on p0p_0.

An exponent of instability

We extract the instability exponent, θ\theta, from the cumulative distribution function (c.d.f) of edge lengths, denoted as c.d.f(LL), by fitting a power law to c.d.f(LL) in the interval 0.05<L<0.50.05 < L < 0.5. This interval specifically represents the short edges that are capable of undergoing T1 transitions.

We focused on tissues exclusively in the solid regime (shape index p0p_0 less than 3.81) and integrated this understanding with the dual-state coexistence proportion to extend the analysis to higher shape indices. For purely solid tissues, as stress builds up, the instability exponent θ\theta gradually decreases. Conversely, when stress is relieved through avalanches, θ\theta experiences a sharp increase (Figure S2), indicating that a significant number of soft spots are relaxed, making the system considerably more stable.

Furthermore, the θ\theta exponent is correlated with avalanche properties, as evidenced by its relationship with the average avalanche size (Sˉ\bar{S}) and the probability of avalanche occurrence. Systems with a lower θ\theta exponent, indicating greater instability, tend to experience larger avalanches on average (Figure S2) and are more prone to yielding (Figure S2 inset).

Normal modes unable to identify the soft spots in the Vertex-based model

In amorphous solids, localization plays a crucial role in understanding the rheology of the material. An example of localization is shear transformation zone (STZ) [25, 51, 52, 64, 65], localized regions in which sudden and irreversible rearrangements occur when the material is subjected to shear. These STZ, also referred to as weak spots, can interact and lead to avalanches of irreversible plastic events, making the identification of these weak spots in disordered systems a crucial and challenging task. Research has indicated that the local yield stress could serve as a reliable predictor for these weak spots [25]. However, locally probing the system is impractical and does not align with our objective of making predictions based solely on current and historical snapshots. Another approach to this task involves analyzing the normal mode of the system near failure. Studies on systems of harmonic repulsive particles have demonstrated that low-frequency modes typically correspond to low energy barriers [78], making them dominant modes during a plastic event [78, 79, 80]. Furthermore, in systems with explicit separation dependence potential (such as Hertzian and Lennard-Jones potentials), under the quasistatic limit, the evolution of low-frequency modes follows a distinct pattern: as the system approaches failure, a gradual decrease in frequency towards zero is anticipated [24, 80].

To see whether the normal modes of the Hessian could help to identify failure events, whenever there is a known avalanche in our simulation, we rerun the simulation starting at this particular strain but with the strain step decreased by 100 times and let the system approach the avalanche again in the more detailed fashion. The low-frequency modes at the starting strain were then extracted from the Hessian. To keep track of the mode while the system evolves, we found the most similar mode to these starting low-frequency modes at each step and used them to represent the starting modes using the overlapping function Ω=ei⋅ej\Omega= \mathbf{e}_i \cdot\mathbf{e}_j, where ei\mathbf{e}_i and ej\mathbf{e}_j are eigenvectors of comparison. The overlap is shown on the right panel of Figure S3. In contrast to what was observed in other systems, we did not see a gradual decrease in the low-frequency mode eigenvalues. Instead, it is always a sharp decrease but not zero right at the onset of avalanches, no matter how detailed we zoom in on the approaching process. This non-smooth sudden drop in the eigenvalues at the onset of avalanches arises from the cuspiness of the energy landscape. Because of the cuspiness, there is no saddle point when the system approaches a rearrangement event and therefore the curvature is always positive.

References

References

  1. [1]A. Bonfanti, J. Duque, A. Kabla, G. Charras. Fracture in living tissues, Trends in Cell Biology 32, 537 (2022).DOI
  2. [2]A. R. Harris, et al.. Characterizing the mechanics of cultured cell monolayers, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109, 16449 (2012).DOI
  3. [3]A. R. Harris, et al.. Generating suspended cell monolayers for mechanobiological studies, Nature protocols 8, 2516 (2013).DOI
  4. [4]E. Sadeghipour, M. A. Garcia, W. J. Nelson, B. L. Pruitt. Shear-induced damped oscillations in an epithelium depend on actomyosin contraction and e-cadherin cell adhesion, eLife 7 (2018).DOI
  5. [5]Y. Bashirzadeh, S. Dumbali, S. Qian, V. Maruthamuthu. Mechanical response of an epithelial island subject to uniaxial stretch on a hybrid silicone substrate, Cellular and Molecular Bioengineering 12, 33 (2018).
  6. [6]G. Cai, et al.. Compressive stress drives adhesion-dependent unjamming transitions in breast cancer cell migration, Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology 10 (2022).DOI
  7. [7]F. Villemot, M. Durand. Quasistatic rheology of soft cellular systems using the cellular pots model, Physical Review E 104, 055303 (2021).DOI
  8. [8]A. Merzouki, O. Malaspinas, B. Chopard. The mechanical properties of a cell-based numerical model of epithelium, Soft Matter 12, 4745 (2016).DOI
  9. [9]J. Huang, J. O. Cochran, S. M. Fielding, M. C. Marchetti, D. Bi. Shear-driven solidification and nonlinear elasticity in epithelial tissues, Physical Review Letters 128, 178001 (2022).DOI
  10. [10]M. J. Hertaeg, S. M. Fielding, D. Bi. Discontinuous shear thickening in biological tissue rheology, Physical Review X 14, 011027 (2024).
  11. [11]S. S. Lienkamp, et al.. Vertebrate kidney tubules elongate using a planar cell polarity–dependent, rosette-based mechanism of convergent extension, Nature genetics 44, 1382 (2012).
  12. [12]R. Etournay, et al.. Interplay of cell dynamics and epithelial tension during morphogenesis of the Drosophila pupal wing, eLife 4, e07090 (2015).DOI
  13. [13]E. Heller, K. V. Kumar, S. W. Grill, E. Fuchs. Forces generated by cell intercalation top epidermal sheets in mammalian tissue morphogenesis, Developmental Cell 28, 617 (2014).DOI
  14. [14]S. Curran, et al.. Myosin ii controls junction fluctuations to guide epithelial tissue ordering, Developmental Cell 43, 480 (2017).DOI
  15. [15]A. Ruina. Slip instability and state variable friction laws, Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 88, 10359 (1983).DOI
  16. [16]P. Bak, C. Tang, K. Wiesenfeld. Self-organized criticality: An explanation of the 1/f noise, Physical review letters 59, 381 (1987).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10035754
  17. [17]G. Courcoubetis, C. Xu, S. V. Nuzhdin, S. Haas. Avalanches during epithelial tissue growth; uniform growth and a drosophila eye disc model, PLOS Computational Biology 18, e1009952 (2022).DOI
  18. [18]V. N. Prakash, M. S. Bull, M. Prakash. Motility-induced fracture reveals a ductile-to-brittle crossover in a simple animal’s epithelia, Nature Physics 17, 504 (2021).DOI
  19. [19]M. Popović, V. Druelle, N. A. Dye, F. Jülicher, M. W. Yart. Inferring the flow properties of epithelial tissues from their geometry, New Journal of Physics 23, 033004 (2021).arxiv.org/abs/2002.05133
  20. [20]D. Bi, J. H. Lopez, J. M. Schwarz, M. L. Manning. A density-independent rigidity transition in biological tissues, Nature Physics 11, 10741079 (2015).DOI
  21. [21]D. Bi, X. Yang, M. C. Marchetti, M. L. Manning. Motility-driven glass and jamming transitions in biological tissues, Phys. Rev. X 6, 021011 (2016).DOI
  22. [22]M. J. O’Sullivan, et al.. Irradiation induces epithelial cell unjamming, Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology 8 (2020).
  23. [23]M. L. Falk, J. S. Langer. Deformation and failure of amorphous, solidlike materials, Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. 2, 353 (2011).DOI
  24. [24]M. L. Manning, A. J. Liu. Vibrational modes identify soft spots in a sheared disordered packing, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 108302 (2011).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21981537
  25. [25]S. Patinet, D. Vandembroucq, M. L. Falk. Connecting local yield stresses with plastic activity in amorphous solids, Physical Review Letters 117 (2016).DOI
  26. [26]H. Yang, A. Q. Nguyen, D. Bi, M. J. Buehler, M. Guo. Multicell-fold: geometric learning in folding multicellular life, ArXiv pp. arXiv–2407 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2407.07055
  27. [27]D. B. Staple, et al.. Mechanics and remodelling of cell packings in epithelia, The European Physical Journal E 33, 117 (2010).DOI
  28. [28]S. M. Fielding, J. O. Cochran, J. Huang, D. Bi, M. C. Marchetti. Constitutive model for the rheology of biological tissue, Phys. Rev. E 108, L042602 (2023).DOI
  29. [29]D. Bi, J. Zhang, B. Chakraborty, R. P. Behringer. Jamming by shear, Nature 480, 355 (2011).DOI
  30. [30]R. P. Behringer, B. Chakraborty. The physics of jamming for granular materials: a review, Reports on Progress in Physics 82, 012601 (2018).DOI
  31. [31]V. Babu, S. Sastry. Criticality and marginal stability of the shear jamming transition of frictionless soft spheres, Physical Review E 105, L042901 (2022).DOI
  32. [32]V. Babu, H. Vinutha, D. Bi, S. Sastry. Discontinuous rigidity transition associated with shear jamming in granular simulations, Soft Matter 19, 9399 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2301.12179
  33. [33]P. Shah, S. Arora, M. M. Driscoll. Coexistence of solid and liquid phases in shear jammed colloidal drops, Communications Physics 5, 222 (2022).arxiv.org/abs/2111.10868
  34. [34]J. F. Morris. Shear thickening of concentrated suspensions: Recent developments and relation to other phenomena, Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 52, 121 (2020).DOI
  35. [35]P. Sollich, F. Lequeux, P. Hébraud, M. E. Cates. Rheology of soft glassy materials, Physical Review Letters 78, 2020 (1997).DOI
  36. [36]P. Sollich. Rheological constitutive equation for a model of soft glassy materials, Physical Review E 58, 738 (1998).
  37. [37]G. Yin, M. J. Solomon. Soft glassy rheology model applied to stress relaxation of a thermoreversible colloidal gel, Journal of Rheology 52, 785 (2008).DOI
  38. [38]D. Bonn, P. Coussot, H. T. Huynh, F. Bertrand, G. Debrégeas. Rheology of soft glassy materials, Europhysics Letters (EPL) 59, 786 (2002).DOI
  39. [39]K. K. Mandadapu, S. Govindjee, M. R. Mofrad. On the cytoskeleton and soft glassy rheology, Journal of Biomechanics 41, 1467 (2008).DOI
  40. [40]D. Bi, B. Chakraborty. Rheology of granular materials: dynamics in a stress landscape, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 367, 5073 (2009).
  41. [41]D. Bi, J. H. Lopez, J. M. Schwarz, M. L. Manning. Energy barriers and cell migration in densely packed tissues, Soft Matter 10, 1885 (2014).DOI
  42. [42]J. R. Samaniuk, E. Hermans, T. Verwijlen, V. Pauchard, J. Vermant. Soft-glassy rheology of asphaltenes at liquid interfaces, Journal of Dispersion Science and Technology 36, 1444 (2015).DOI
  43. [43]K. K. Chiu, L. Hufnagel, B. I. Shraiman. Mechanical stress inference for two dimensional cell arrays, PLoS Computational Biology 8, e1002512 (2012).
  44. [44]S. Ishihara, K. Sugimura. Bayesian inference of force dynamics during morphogenesis, Journal of Theoretical Biology 313, 201–211 (2012).DOI
  45. [45]N. Noll, S. J. Streichan, B. I. Shraiman. Variational method for image-based inference of internal stress in epithelial tissues, Physical Review X 10, Not available (2020).DOI
  46. [46]S. Ishihara, et al.. Comparative study of non-invasive force and stress inference methods in tissue, The European Physical Journal E 36, 1 (2013).arxiv.org/abs/1301.4298
  47. [47]W. Kong, et al.. Experimental validation of force inference in epithelia from cell to tissue scale, Scientific reports 9, 14647 (2019).DOI
  48. [48]E. Stanifer, M. L. Manning. Avalanche dynamics in sheared athermal particle packings occurs via localized bursts predicted by unstable linear response, Soft Matter 18, 2394–2406 (2022).DOI
  49. [49]D. Richard, A. Elgallai, D. Vandembroucq, M. L. Manning, C. E. Maloney. Mechanical excitation and marginal triggering during avalanches in sheared amorphous solids, Physical Review E 107, 034902 (2023).
  50. [50]D. Jaiswal, Z. Moscato, Y. Tomizawa, K. P. Claffey, K. Hoshino. Elastography of multicellular spheroids using 3d light microscopy, Biomedical Optics Express 10, 2409 (2019).
  51. [51]M. L. Falk, J. S. Langer. Dynamics of viscoplastic deformation in amorphous solids, Physical Review E 57, 7192 (1998).DOI
  52. [52]M. L. Manning, J. S. Langer, J. M. Carlson. Strain localization in a shear transformation zone model for amorphous solids, Physical Review E 76 (2007).DOI
  53. [53]G. Picard, A. Ajdari, F. Lequeux, L. Bocquet. Elastic consequences of a single plastic event: A step towards the microscopic modeling of the flow of yield stress fluids, The European Physical Journal E 15, 371 (2004).DOI
  54. [54]G. Zhang, S. A. Ridout, A. J. Liu. Interplay of rearrangements, strain, and local structure during avalanche propagation, Physical Review X 11, 041019 (2021).arxiv.org/abs/2009.11414
  55. [55]L. D. Landau, L. Pitaevskii, A. M. Kosevich, E. M. Lifshitz, Theory of elasticity: volume 7, vol. 7 (Elsevier, 1959).
  56. [56]H. Kawamura, T. Hatano, N. Kato, S. Biswas, B. K. Chakrabarti. Statistical physics of fracture, friction, and earthquakes, Reviews of Modern Physics 84, 839–884 (2012).DOI
  57. [57]B. Gutenberg, C. F. Richter. Frequency of earthquakes in california, Bulletin of the Seismological society of America 34, 185 (1944).DOI
  58. [58]M. Talamali, V. Petäjä, D. Vandembroucq, S. Roux. Avalanches, precursors, and finite-size fluctuations in a mesoscopic model of amorphous plasticity, Physical Review E 84, 016101 (2011).DOI
  59. [59]K. Karimi, E. E. Ferrero, J.-L. Barrat. Inertia and universality of avalanche statistics: The case of slowly deformed amorphous solids, Physical Review E 95, 013003 (2017).DOI
  60. [60]A. Amiri, C. Duclut, F. Jülicher, M. Popović. Random traction yielding transition in epithelial tissues, Physical Review Letters 131, 188401 (2023).DOI
  61. [61]J. Lin, M. Wyart. Mean-field description of plastic flow in amorphous solids, Physical Review X 6 (2016).arxiv.org/abs/1506.03639
  62. [62]J. Lin, E. Lerner, A. Rosso, M. Wyart. Scaling description of the yielding transition in soft amorphous solids at zero temperature, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111, 14382–14387 (2014).DOI
  63. [63]J. Lin, A. Saade, E. Lerner, A. Rosso, M. Wyart. On the density of shear transformations in amorphous solids, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 105, 26003 (2014).DOI
  64. [64]D. Richard, G. Kapteijns, J. A. Giannini, M. L. Manning, E. Lerner. Simple and broadly applicable definition of shear transformation zones, Physical Review Letters 126 (2021).
  65. [65]J. LANGER. Shear-transformation-zone theory of deformation in metallic glasses, Scripta Materialia 54, 375–379 (2006).DOI
  66. [66]J. Rottler, S. S. Schoenholz, A. J. Liu. Predicting plasticity with soft vibrational modes: From dislocations to glasses, Physical Review E 89, 042304 (2014).
  67. [67]J. Ding, S. Patinet, M. L. Falk, Y. Cheng, E. Ma. Soft spots and their structural signature in a metallic glass, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111, 14052 (2014).DOI
  68. [68]K. Haase, A. E. Pelling. Investigating cell mechanics with atomic force microscopy, Journal of The Royal Society Interface 12, 20140970 (2015).DOI
  69. [69]K. Bambardekar, R. Clément, O. Blanc, C. Chardès, P.-F. Lenne. Direct laser manipulation reveals the mechanics of cell contacts in vivo, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112, 1416 (2015).DOI
  70. [70]I. Bonnet, et al. Mechanical state, material properties and continuous description of an epithelial tissue, Journal of The Royal Society Interface 9, 2614 (2012).arxiv.org/abs/1205.2454
  71. [71]A. G. Fletcher, R. E. Osterfield, R. E. Baker, S. Y. Shvartsman. Vertex models of epithelial morphogenesis, Biophysical Journal 106, 2291 (2014).DOI
  72. [72]R. Farhadifar, J.-C. Röper, B. Aigouy, S. Eaton, F. Jülicher. The influence of cell mechanics, cell–cell interactions, and proliferation on epithelial packing, Current Biology 17, 2095 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18082406
  73. [73]A. W. Lees, S. F. Edwards. The computer study of transport processes under extreme conditions, Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 5, 1921 (1972).DOI
  74. [74]E. Bitzek, P. Koskinen, F. Gähler, M. Moseler, P. Gumbsch. Structural relaxation made simple, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 170201 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17155444
  75. [75]X. Yang, et al. Correlating cell shape and cellular stress in motile confluent tissues, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2017).DOI
  76. [76]C. E. Maloney, A. Lemaître. Amorphous systems in athermal, quasistatic shear, Phys. Rev. E 74, 016118 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16907162
  77. [77]X. Li, A. Das, D. Bi. Mechanical heterogeneity in tissues promotes rigidity and controls cellular invasion, Physical review letters 123, 058101 (2019).DOI
  78. [78]N. Xu, V. Vitelli, A. J. Liu, S. R. Nagel. Anharmonic and quasi-localized vibrations in jammed solids—modes for mechanical failure, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 90, 56001 (2010).DOI
  79. [79]C. Brito, M. Wyart. Heterogeneous dynamics, marginal stability and soft modes in hard sphere glasses, Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment 2007, L08003 (2007).DOI
  80. [80]C. Maloney, A. Lemaître. Universal breakdown of elasticity at the onset of material failure, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 195501 (2004).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_c38zu3hn
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents