In this paper
AbstractIntroductionThe graviton-induced curvatureSecond-order metric and normalisationThe zero-shear potential and its enhancementTensor modes are not enhancedThe second-order tensor equationThe causal solutionPower spectrumMomentum window versus temporal supportThe exit from de SitterWhat the exit clock has to doA zero-shear clock with a finite windowClock, sink and the physical curvatureSolving through the transitionSpectrum and tiltConservation through the radiation eraObservational consequencesThe allowed windowTensor-to-scalar ratio and consistency relationThe gravitational-wave background todaySpectral distortions and small scalesDiscussionAcknowledgmentsReferencesSecond-order equationsConsistency of the pure- solutionTensor time integralsNumerical scheme for the window clockUniform density versus zero shearGravitational-wave spectrum and sensitivitiesThe homogeneous scalar mode and graviton backreactionWorksPhysics and Astronomy
Gravitational waves and the exit from de Sitter in Inflation without an Inflaton
Abstract
In Inflation without an Inflaton (IWI), second-order de Sitter (dS) gravitons generate primordial curvature as the Coulomb-type potential of their gradient stress. Each pair contributes , yielding exponential enhancement over the contributing e-folds. With exact Bunch-Davies evolution, this solution satisfies all four scalar second-order Einstein equations in pure dS. The retarded transverse-traceless solution instead has a UV kernel of order unity, below the scalar kernel, and a one-loop correction . Its source acts before internal freeze-out, but oscillatory cancellations prevent tensor enhancement. We evolve the curvature through a smooth exit into radiation domination. Conserved curvature resides on the vacuum-decay hypersurface. A global depletion clock holds each scale on zero-shear time for e-folds after horizon exit before local release, giving all scales equal enhancement. Energy-momentum conservation feeds the depleted vacuum energy into a non-vacuum sector, modeled as radiation. Deep in radiation domination, , with clock-dependent , , and . The spectrum is adiabatic and Gaussian; super-horizon is conserved to better than , and changing the adiabatic exit fluid alters it by less than . A direct radiation exit requires , or . At interferometer frequencies, –, accessible to BBO for and ultimate DECIGO for ; CMB B-mode searches probe . Above , the scalar spectrum steepens to , suppressing -distortions for sharp release when .
Introduction
In standard inflation, a scalar field seeds the curvature perturbation through its quantum fluctuations and ends inflation through its classical roll, while the tensor modes are the vacuum fluctuations of the graviton. The Inflation without an Inflaton (IWI) framework, recently developed in Refs. [1–4], removes the scalar field. De Sitter (dS) space is described as a coherent state of gravitons [5, 6], the vacuum energy ends through the quantum break of that state, and the curvature perturbation is produced by the gravitons themselves at second order. Hence, there is no first-order scalar source. For tensor perturbations in a dS background, we consider the Bunch-Davies state of the graviton, with and , and the curvature perturbation is the second-order response of the metric to it, , where is the second-order metric. At this order, the Einstein equations fix the scalar potential through a constraint, and the potential is the Coulomb-type potential of the gravitons’ gradient stress, . A pair of gravitons with momenta and total momentum contributes an amount that grows as , once both modes have frozen. Summing over pairs up to a maximum ratio gives [2], where is the number of observed e-folds and is the tensor power spectrum. Ref. [2] takes the same ratio for every scale, and interprets the fixed ratio as a nonlinear coupling between modes, either between phases of the graviton condensate or through interactions between particles and gravitons. A slow drift of the Hubble rate, which can be tied to the depletion of the coherent state [4, 6, 7, 8], gives the small red tilt [4].
If a pair of gravitons can produce an enhanced scalar, the same second-order equations might also produce an enhanced second-order tensor, with a tensor-to-scalar ratio of order unity that would rule the scenario out. We find that this does not happen. The TT sector obeys a wave equation rather than an elliptic scalar constraint, and the oscillatory Bunch-Davies evolution suppresses the retarded tensor response without requiring the source to vanish before internal freeze-out, leaving a small second-order correction that is finite in the ultraviolet.
We then study what happens to the scalar when dS ends. The second-order response is computed in pure GR+, whereas the Hubble rate drifts and the vacuum energy eventually decays. Such a vacuum energy cannot be conserved by itself, and the Bianchi identity forces it to feed a non-vacuum sector. In pure dS there is no matter whose density or velocity could define the usual conserved curvature , and what IWI computes is the curvature of the zero-shear slices. After the exit, the conserved of the radiation era is the curvature of the hypersurface on which the vacuum energy decays [9, 10], so the clock that ends de Sitter decides what survives (§ 1.3 C). In standard inflation, this clock is the inflaton, and is the number of e-folds each patch accumulates before the field reaches its final value [11, 12, 13].
We show that in IWI the enhanced scalar survives, together with the observed tilt, if the vacuum decays on a global clock that keeps each comoving scale on zero-shear time for a fixed number of e-folds after the scale leaves the horizon. After that, the clocks keep their readings and tick with local proper time. Since the window is the same for every scale, the spectrum is scale invariant, and the drift of the Hubble rate across the window supplies the tilt. Such a clock is necessarily non-local; it is carried by the depleting vacuum energy, and we model the sector that receives the energy as a passive sink. For adiabatic sinks, we find that a change in the equation of state moves the result by less than 0.2 per cent, and the local entropy and anisotropic responses we have tested rescale the amplitude, but do not produce the window. Any microscopic completion has to produce the window through the response of the vacuum and the sector it feeds taken together.
We also clarify the relation with Refs. [1, 2]. The solution , of Ref. [1] is the late-time limit of the exact Bunch-Davies solution, which satisfies all four scalar Einstein equations in pure GR+ (Appendix B). The second-order equations of Ref. [1] in pure GR+ are consistent without additional matter. An apparent over-constraint, which would make a fluid term necessary for consistency [2], arises only when time derivatives are set to zero before the late-time limit is taken. The fluid of Ref. [1], which is the averaged stress of the sub-horizon gravitons, is therefore not needed for consistency. In the present construction, the drift and the exit come instead from the depleting vacuum and the sector it feeds, and the physical curvature is that of the surface on which the vacuum decays. Our Einstein tensor reproduces the source kernels of Ref. [2] and, to 2 per cent, its amplitude (Sec. II). The window used here is a dynamical realisation of the fixed-ratio prescription of Ref. [2], with in place of , and it has to respect the end of dS (§ 1.3 C).
In section II we present the setup of the second-order calculation. Section III studies the second-order tensors, while section IV describes the exit, the role of the depletion sector and the evolution of the curvature through the transition. In section V we discuss the observational consequences, and we conclude in section VI. The technical material is collected in the Appendixes.
The graviton-induced curvature
Second-order metric and normalisation
We write the metric to second order as
Here, is the first-order TT graviton, is the second-order TT tensor, and are second-order scalars. There are no first-order scalars. In the Poisson gauge, , the IWI potentials .
In de Sitter (dS), the scale factor reads , where is the energy scale of inflation. The gravitons are the Bunch-Davies vacuum fluctuations, and every second-order field below is a response to them. More precisely, the tensor modes are with , normalised so that outside the horizon, and the tensor power per logarithmic interval is , with the Planck mass. We use the canonical normalisation , with polarisation tensors satisfying and a power per helicity. Refs. [1, 2, 3] use per helicity, which multiplies every scalar power spectrum by a factor of 4; hence, at fixed their window , introduced below, is shorter by .
We compute the mixed Einstein tensor exactly to second order, with a first-order field made of two plane waves of generic momenta and polarisations,
where the are the internal momenta, are the TT tensors encoding the polarisation and amplitude of each helicity , while are the Bunch-Davies mode functions, with and .
The second-order fields sit at , and we read their equations off the bilinear cross term. We denote as the graviton-bilinear part of . The result reproduces the second-order source kernels of Ref. [2] to , so the two describe the same second-order system. Moreover, its tensor sector reproduces Maldacena’s graviton bispectrum exactly, in shape, polarisation structure and amplitude [14]; its TT source agrees with that of Ref. [15] to ; and under the full four-scalar operator changes by exactly . The second-order equations are listed in Appendix A.
The zero-shear potential and its enhancement
In vacuum, the scalar sector is algebraic at every instant. Combining the and equations gives a comoving Poisson equation, and the traceless part of the equation gives the anisotropic-stress relation,
These constraints determine the inhomogeneous scalar response at . The exactly homogeneous mode is governed instead by the spatially averaged Einstein equations, as discussed in Appendix G.
At late times and tends to , where is the inverse-Laplacian functional of the frozen gravitons given in Ref. [1]. The late-time limit is thus the solution , identified there. The exact solution satisfies all four scalar Einstein equations (see Appendix B). Once the internal modes have frozen, we get and the inverse Laplacians give a kernel , so the curvature of the zero-shear slices,
grows as per pair 1. In pure dS, is a well-defined geometric quantity, but it is not by itself the observable, since there is no matter whose density could define uniform-density slices (see the discussion in section IV C).
Writing a second-order field as
with the helicity amplitudes and the symmetrised pair kernel, its power spectrum is
where , are dimensionless variables, and . The normalisation of (7) follows from Wick’s theorem with two contractions. For the zero-shear curvature , we obtain at large (see Figure 1). Every pair contributes equally, and
Figure 1. We plot , which is the helicity-summed, -integrated squared kernel of Eq. (7), as a function . For the zero-shear curvature , tends to a constant (solid blue line), so its power grows with the number of contributing graviton pairs. The constant tensor mode behaves the same way, so tends to a constant value (dashed orange line). On the other hand, the retarded Bunch-Davies tensor decays as (solid green line), and its loop converges.
where is the largest that contributes 2. The ultraviolet dominates because at fixed time the graviton stress is a local bilinear dominated by the shortest frozen modes, so on large scales it behaves as white noise and is its Poisson potential. How large is, and whether it is the same for every , is decided by the exit from dS, as we will discuss in section IV.
Tensor modes are not enhanced
The second-order tensor equation
The TT projection of the second-order equation gives
with the TT projector, which removes exactly the trace and longitudinal parts of that carry the of (4). The tensors and are constant, built from momenta and polarisations alone, and the source does not contain -dependent terms, with all the time dependence of the source in the two mode-function products. The term, , is a pure field redefinition, since in exponential variables, , the source is purely gradient, as in Maldacena’s cubic action [14].
The causal solution
The retarded Green function of the operator in Eq. (9) is
For Bunch-Davies gravitons, , and the solution of Eq. (9) that vanishes in the far past, at late time, is
with (Appendix C). A direct numerical integration along a rotated contour reproduces these closed forms to . For , they tend to and , so the response kernel is of order one, a factor below the zero-shear scalar.
This absence of the enhancement comes from oscillatory cancellations across the full retarded Bunch-Davies integral. Although the TT source is nonzero before internal freeze-out, the combined contributions from the subhorizon and frozen regimes yield an tensor response, so . The fact that the scalar acquires the enhancement follows because Eqs. (3) and (4) are constraints that hold at every instant, whereas Eq. (9) is a wave equation whose response is built up over time. To see this more clearly, suppose instead that the source were treated as frozen from the moment the external mode crosses the horizon, i.e. , even though the internal modes are still oscillating at that time. The solution would then be , with constant mode ; both carry the same as the scalar that is removed by the oscillatory evolution.
Power spectrum
Inserting Eq. (11) into Eq. (7) gives (see Figure 1), so the loop converges and depends neither on the ultraviolet cutoff nor on the duration of dS. Over the hard region , we find , dominated by
, and giving a second-order tensor power
Considering the constant mode would instead give (see Figure 1) and , i.e. , and the solution with the source switched on at is smaller by and gives , still above the bound [16]. Only the full retarded Bunch-Davies evolution brings the tensor down to Eq. (12).
The soft and collinear parts of contain the usual phase-accumulation poles at , which are not specific to IWI. We expect them to cancel against in the complete one-loop result, as the same poles cancel in the tree-level bispectrum once the operator ordering is consistent. We have not computed ; power counting bounds the remainder by .
With no first-order scalars, is invariant under second-order gauge transformations, since second-order generators only shift and the vectors. The tensors therefore do not depend on the slicing on which dS ends, and super-horizon tensors cross the transition unchanged. The tree-level tensor bispectrum is exactly that of GR, with and in the helicity basis, which corresponds to a fractional non-Gaussianity . Once the enhanced scalar exists, it sources tensors in the radiation era only at order [17, 18, 19, 20, 21], and tensor-induced tensors in the radiation era are of order [15]. Both are negligible as we will discuss in § 1.4 C.
Momentum window versus temporal support
The scalar mechanism of § 1.3 restricts the pairs that count to . Imposing the same momentum window on the tensor loop changes nothing: with the retarded Bunch-Davies kernel the part of the loop beyond is a fraction of Eq. (12), below for any . The momentum window is therefore irrelevant to the tensors.
In fact, the tensor result depends only on the time over which the TT source acts. The tensor is small because the internal gravitons oscillate and average out, while the external mode is already outside the horizon. A source acting from the external crossing would instead give a constant and in the range – (Sec. III C). Our tensor result therefore holds provided the depletion acts as a scalar clock and adds no long-range, correlated spin-2 response that anticipates or replaces the Bunch-Davies evolution of the TT source.
In the model of § 1.3 this condition is met automatically. The clock perturbation is isotropic, , and the radiation sink is a perfect fluid whose TT stress starts at fourth order. A free-streaming sink would also carry a first-order TT stress that damps the tensor legs, as neutrinos do in the radiation era [22], but with an energy fraction below the effect is below a per cent. A scalar anisotropic stress of the sink, on the other hand, has no TT projection and enters only the scalar sector. The scalar perturbations that the clock leaves behind source tensors only at second order in themselves, at the scalar-induced level (see § 1.4 C), and cross terms between the enhanced scalar and the gravitons correct the tensor power at relative order . A microscopic depletion carrying long-range spin-2 correlations would be a new source of gravitational waves, and the tensor calculation would have to be redone with it included. Within the present model, no such source is present, and the gravitational waves of IWI are the first-order vacuum gravitons, with a tensor tilt of , where parametrizes the slow drift in the Hubble rate.
The exit from de Sitter
What the exit clock has to do
The vacuum energy converts into radiation on a hypersurface defined by some clock. For super-horizon modes, the junction conditions for a transition from to [9, 10] give
where is the delay of relative to the zero-shear slice. The value is the curvature of itself, and it is conserved afterwards because the radiation era starts as a single adiabatic fluid. A smooth transition computed without junction conditions gives the same result (see § 1.3 D).
We split the exit time of each patch into its proper time and an offset, . Considering the proper-time part, we find that it is local and bounded. Along the comoving geodesics of dS, the vacuum Einstein equations give exactly , so Raychaudhuri’s equation reads . Writing , the local number of e-folds at fixed proper time is . For a graviton pair and with , one obtains
which tends to a constant for . The curvature of the constant-proper-time slice differs from this volume term by an anisotropic piece, in synchronous gauge, which is also local and bounded. For in exact dS and .
The whole enhancement is thus in the offset , and a clock that carries it has to follow zero-shear time. Such a clock is non-local, because any clock built from local physics ends dS on a surface whose curvature is the bounded local term. In standard inflation, the inflaton plays this role, since its fluctuation , generated at horizon exit and carried locally, makes different patches reach the end at different times.
Finally, the clock must also give a scale-invariant spectrum. By Eq. (8), the spectrum is set by how many pairs each scale collects, and a scale collects pairs for as long as its patches stay synchronised on zero-shear time. For the amplitude to be the same for every scale, every scale must collect pairs for the same number of e-folds, counted from its own horizon exit.
A zero-shear clock with a finite window
We have seen in § 1.3 A the requirements on the clock, i.e. a non-local, zero-shear clock with a per-scale window. Here, we take a global clock that holds each comoving scale on zero-shear time while the scale is less than e-folds outside the horizon, . After that, the clocks keep their readings and tick with local proper time, and dS ends when they reach a common value. Equivalently, the synchronising influence reaches a fixed physical distance of Hubble radii at every moment (see Figure 2), which corresponds to – Hubble radii across the allowed range. We postulate this clock and identify it with the break of the dS coherent state as a whole [6, 7]. The depletion fixes the common reading at which dS ends, and the coherence of the state across super-horizon distances fixes the window. This is a property of the state as a whole and is distinct from the coherence of individual graviton pairs, which become classical within 9–23 e-folds of horizon exit [8].
Figure 2. We show the picture of the mechanism by plotting the comoving scale as a function of the number of e-folds . A comoving scale (solid orange line) leaves the Hubble radius (solid black line) and remains synchronised on zero-shear time within the synchronisation reach (dashed blue line), where is the window’s number of e-folds. The moment of horizon crossing is shown with circles, while the release happens e-folds later and it is shown with a square. Internal modes that freeze before this release are recorded in the clock offset (solid green line). Internal modes that freeze later contribute only a bounded local term (solid gray lines). The dotted gray line shows the end of the de Sitter phase.
Let be the time shift from the zero-shear slices to the clock slices, , so that the clock slices have curvature and in Eq. (13). Then, the clock is defined by
synchronised: ; \qquad free-running: .
The free-running condition is that the clock reads proper time along the zero-shear normals, . We spread the release smoothly over e-folds around . Since the vacuum energy is uniform on the clock slices, in Poisson gauge it carries and .
Considering a single pair, it builds its zero-shear offset while its internal modes freeze, at . If the scale is still synchronised at that time, then the clock carries the whole offset forward. On the other hand, if it is not synchronised, the free-running clock integrates the lapse, which cancels the offset and leaves only the local term. Only pairs with therefore contribute. By the dilation symmetry of dS, the kernel depends on , and but not on , so every scale receives the same enhancement. This requires each clock to keep, after the release, the offset it has acquired instead of resetting to local time.
Clock, sink and the physical curvature
The calculation of § 1.1 is pure GR+, whereas in the cosmology we want to describe the Hubble rate drifts, the vacuum depletes, and dS ends. A vacuum component satisfies identically, so if changes the Bianchi identity requires a second sector with
Within GR, the minimal content of the model is therefore a depleting vacuum together with a non-vacuum sector that absorbs its energy. Because , the transfer is not a free function, but it is fixed by the slices on which is uniform, with no momentum transfer in their frame. A different would require the depleting component to depart from at the perturbative level, for instance by carrying momentum or anisotropic stress. The sink is a product of the depletion, analogous to the reheating products of standard inflation but produced continuously at order . It is the non-vacuum enthalpy that any drift of requires, since , and in the background it plays the role that plays in standard inflation, but, unlike the inflaton, it is not the source of the curvature perturbation. We model the sink as a passive fluid.3 The homogeneous quadratic stress of the Bunch-Davies gravitons is distinct from this depletion-generated sector. Its finite-window contribution is of order , far below the background required by the observed tilt. The corresponding homogeneous backreaction and its renormalized interpretation are examined in Appendix G.
The clock and the sink play different roles. A slicing can be built from any background scalar with , and its curvature is
For a perfect fluid with no exchange , and this reduces to the familiar . Pure has and defines no clock, which is why alone is not observable. The depleting vacuum, on the other hand, has , so its uniform slices define one even though . In our construction, these are the clock slices of Eq. (15), with . This identifies the slices on which the clock is read, but it does not give the law by which they are synchronised, released, and keep their memory, which we describe in Sec. IV B, and the post-exit curvature depends on that law. The sink cannot take over the clock’s role. After freeze-out, its uniform-density slices converge to the zero-shear ones, as do those of the total density (Appendix E), with an offset larger by a factor , although both decay as . Reading the curvature on the sink’s slices would therefore record every pair up to and give .
After the exit the matter is an ordinary fluid, and the curvature on uniform total density,
is defined and conserved. This is the quantity to which refers. It equals the curvature of the clock surface, hence for a zero-shear exit, and it follows from the clock dynamics, the transfer, and the matching (see Appendix E). During quasi-dS, while the clock is synchronised and once the internal modes have frozen, the density term in Eq. (17) reduces to the velocity term and decays as . After a zero-shear exit, the uniform-density curvature equals to about , and with the window clock the post-exit value does not depend on when the exit happens, to .
We consider radiation as a natural sink. With ,
so a steady drift has . For a sink with energy fraction and equation of state the same relation reads . Acceleration ends at , so , which requires the transfer to grow to . A steady depletion does not get there by itself. In fact, for with constant the background approaches a fixed point with for any sink with , and inflation continues. The exit therefore needs a change in the rate or in the state, which we impose on the clock slices over . If the radiation is replaced by a fluid with constant and rest-frame sound speed , the velocity term becomes , independent of . For adiabatic sinks () and for the post-exit then changes by at most for all the pairs we tested, up to with , and the same bound holds for every closure when the pair freezes before or during the release (). For the post-release tail is numerically ill-conditioned in our formulation (see Appendix E).
We also tested a non-passive sink, adding to the radiation either a non-adiabatic pressure or a scalar anisotropic stress , active while the vacuum depletes and through the exit. Here, is the local volume bilinear of the graviton pair and is a kinetic bilinear that vanishes once the internal modes freeze (see more details in Appendix E). We find that the non-adiabatic pressure changes the post-exit by , a local term of order whose share of the enhanced curvature falls as ( at to at ). The anisotropic stress, entering the traceless constraint through , carries the same as the gravitons’ own stress. For it lowers by – for all , and by for . The change is linear in ; it rescales and moves the window by e-folds. A persistent stress , as in a purely elastic medium, would instead grow as and dominate the spectrum, which excludes a response of that form. A viscoelastic response, whose memory of the strain relaxes on a finite time, as well as a spatially non-local response lie outside these tests. None of the responses we tested selects pairs. A response that is local in space cannot distinguish from without correlations over Hubble radii. A produced sector that implemented the window would carry exactly the non-locality that we assign to the clock, since it would be a realisation of the clock, with its density, entropy, stress and memory entering its dynamics. Also, a response of the sink correlated with the gravitons does not double count their stress, because is the Bunch-Davies fluctuation, with no occupied quanta, while the sink is made of the quanta that the depletion produces. Within the passive closure, then, the sink adds no free function to the observables: its enthalpy is fixed by the tilt (Sec. IV E), and the other responses we tested either drop out or rescale . Clearly, these tests cover the responses listed here, not every medium the depletion could produce.
The window is distinct from the end of dS. The condition is a fixed ratio between internal and external scales, i.e. , whereas the requirement that the internal modes freeze before the end, , depends on . Notice that a fixed ratio is the prescription of Ref. [2], which takes for every . Our clock realises that prescription dynamically and adds the transfer to the post-exit curvature. However, needs internal modes up to for every , and these modes never leave the horizon before the end. With both conditions, the effective count is , and it is the same for every scale only below , beyond which it produces the tail (see Sec. IV E). Hence, has to be shorter than by at least , plus half the release width (Sec. V). For the smallest scale that must be scale invariant, this implies about e-folds at the pivot and at . For the break would sit at . In our realisation, the clock selects the pairs through its perturbation , an isotropic spin-0 response whose pair kernel sets the ratio of Figure 3. This relation identifies the clock slices, but does not give the microscopic equation for , which may involve the produced sector and the vacuum. We therefore state the selection as a requirement on any microscopic completion: the response of the coupled system of depleting vacuum and produced sector has to reproduce the fixed ratio , and the density, entropy, stress and memory of the produced medium may all take part in it. The window makes the spectrum scale invariant, and the tilt comes from the drift of across it.

Figure 3. Left: Curvature after the exit for one pair (, positive helicities), with windows , 30 and 100 released over e-folds. Each curve tracks the never-released zero-shear value (solid black line) up to its window (dotted lines) and falls steeply beyond. The gray dashed line is a clock released inside the horizon. Right: Ratio against , for three release widths. Curves with different at the same agree to better than half a per cent. The dashed black line is the schematic classical-pair limit, in which only pairs frozen before the release are recorded.
Solving through the transition
We integrate the exact second-order equations for single graviton pairs from inside the horizon, at with Bunch-Davies modes, through the dS phase and a smooth exit, and into the radiation era. The background is quasi-dS, with a vacuum energy that decays slowly into the radiation sink of Eq. (18) with , and at the end converts completely over e-folds on the clock slices. We evolve the scalar sector in Poisson gauge, Eqs. (26)–(29), with the vacuum perturbation above and the clock of Eq. (15), while the gravitons evolve on the exact background. After the exit we evaluate on uniform-density slices, Eq. (17), which for radiation is . The details are in Appendix D.
A clock that is never released reproduces a direct Poisson-gauge evolution to . A clock released deep inside the horizon approaches the proper-time value, for release at with , compared with from a synchronous-gauge evolution on the same background. Moving the exit from 3 to 10 e-folds after the release changes by less than .
Figure 3 shows the result for the curvature . We see that for the curvature is the zero-shear one, while for it falls steeply, as between and for . At fixed , the ratio depends on : at and , for example, and give 0.253 and 0.254. Near –10, the kernel is enhanced, because pairs that cross the horizon during the release hand their partly formed offset to the clock. The effect shrinks as the release slows down. At the is 2.8, 0.77 and 0.25 for , 1 and 2, while at we get , 0.02 and 0.008, respectively.
Spectrum and tilt
Since the kernel is the same for every ,
with
where is Eq. (7) evaluated with the curvature that each pair leaves after the exit, so that for . The smallest value, , is obtained from the full loop over all configurations and helicities for a sharp release, in which each pair is recorded with the zero-shear value it has when the window closes. For pairs that freeze close to the release, this exceeds their late-time value. A release spread over a finite number of e-folds also records part of the offset of pairs that cross the horizon during the release, and from the positive-helicity slice of the dynamical runs we estimate , 18 and 71 for , 1 and 0.5, respectively. A release much faster than an e-fold would also record the sub-horizon, vacuum part of the zero-shear offset, so we regard as the physical range. Only the combination enters the amplitude, so the release profile moves the lower edge of the allowed window by only .
The dominant pairs have , a factor that is absorbed into . They freeze a fixed number of e-folds after exits, with , and since the scalar carries four tensor legs, , giving the consistency relation
Then, the scalar and tensor tilts read
respectively. The running is found to be if evolves as in Ref. [4]. The observed $n_s = 0.965 [23] fixes . Since , the tilt fixes the enthalpy fraction of the sink, , and not or separately. For example, for radiation we obtain . The relation also assumes that the dimensionless response does not depend on scale. Indeed, writing , a scale-dependent response gives . The window sets the enhancement and makes it scale-independent, whereas a count running to the end for every scale would give . Therefore, the red tilt comes entirely from the drift of across the window. Modes that exit less than e-folds before the end have fewer pairs available, , so beyond the spectrum falls as .
Because all patches end on the same clock, the radiation era starts with a single adiabatic mode and no isocurvature. The curvature is a sum over independent pairs, and power counting of the one-loop bispectrum gives at the lower edge of the window, the same scaling as in Ref. [3].
Conservation through the radiation era
After the exit, the matter is a single radiation fluid. The frozen gravitons stay frozen until they re-enter, and then behave as radiation with a locally determined stress. The non-adiabatic pressure vanishes, so on uniform density is conserved on super-horizon scales [22, 24]. Figure 4 shows this for pairs inside and outside () the window. From the exit until the external mode approaches the horizon, stays constant between and while , including across the re-entry of the internal modes. The rise near is the usual gradient term of the adiabatic mode, and after that sets the amplitude of the acoustic oscillations in the standard way.
Observational consequences
The allowed window
Several numbers of e-folds enter here, and they have to be kept apart. The duration of dS, , runs from the exit of the first mode to the end and is set by the lifetime of the depleting state 4. Here, only has to exceed . In Ref. [2], the observable number of e-folds is taken to be , the separation between the largest observable scale and the last mode to exit. , with , is the time that scale spends outside the horizon before the end. is the part of that time over which collects pairs, and it sets the amplitude through . Finally, and are the widths of the release and of the exit. Only is a parameter of the clock. Because depends only on the comoving scales, it is fixed by and by what follows the end of dS, and lengthening the dS phase raises , but leaves unchanged.
We take IWI’s natural exit, directly into radiation at with the reduced Planck mass. The number of e-folds between the pivot and the end is then fixed by . Because of the drift, the Hubble rate at the end is lower than at the pivot, , and the legs that set the amplitude at the pivot freeze with . For each , Eq. (19) with
then fixes , the tensor-to-scalar ratio and . Since falls as grows, the window is bounded from below by the BICEP/Keck limit [16], where .
From above, every scale that has to be scale invariant needs its window to close before the end. The release of scale is complete e-folds after it exits. With the exit placed one e-fold after the centre of the release, for and 1, the post-exit curvature of pairs with –30 agrees with that of a late exit to 0.2%, and to 0.3%, although the pairs with are still inside the horizon at the exit. After the release, the clock reads local proper time, so the offset it has recorded is complete and the remaining pairs do not have to freeze before the end. An exit during the release instead records more of the zero-shear offset, instead of 1.39 for an exit at the centre of a release with , so the scales whose release is under way at the end form a transition of width around before the tail. Requiring scale invariance down to therefore means . For the sharp release, , this gives
For () the range is . Across the window runs from 61.1 to 58.7, so is between 8 and 31 e-folds shorter than .
These bounds hold for the direct radiation exit. Under this exit, the literal prescription of Ref. [2], , has no room, because for every it would need pairs that exit after the end. A history with a phase of different equation of state between the end of dS and the radiation era changes , and with it the upper bound. That would be a different realization, which needs its own curvature matching, so we do not consider it here. Table I lists the results for a direct radiation exit. The reheating temperature is –, and the end of dS corresponds to – today.
| 30.5 | 55.7 | 1.65 | |||
| 32 | 55.5 | 1.65 | |||
| 35 | 55.2 | 1.65 | |||
| 40 | 54.6 | 1.65 | |||
| 43 | 54.2 | 1.61 | |||
| 45 | 54.0 | 1.23 | |||
| 48 | 53.6 | 14 | 0.24 | ||
| 50.3 | 53.3 | 1.0 | 0.02 |
Table I. Direct radiation exit with the Hubble drift included, for , and . We report: the window ; the tensor-to-scalar ratio at the pivot ; the Hubble rate at ; the e-folds from the pivot to the end, ; the small-scale break ; and the chemical-potential distortion for a sharp break. Without the break, throughout.
Tensor-to-scalar ratio and consistency relation
The tensor-to-scalar falls by a factor per unit of (Figure 5, right). B-mode programmes that target [25, 26] probe for , or for . Whatever the value of , the tensor tilt in IWI is , which differs from the single-field relation5 .
Figure 5. Left: Scalar spectrum for . The spectrum is flat, with , through the CMB and large-scale-structure range (gray band), and steepens to beyond . The orange band marks the -distortion scales. Right: Tensor-to-scalar ratio against for (solid line) and (dashed line). The upper shaded region is excluded because , while the right-hand one is excluded because the window would reach the end of de Sitter for . The dotted line is the LiteBIRD/CMB-S4 reach. Circles are the scrambling-time windows of Eq. (24). The top axis gives -distortion for .
A natural candidate for the window is the dS scrambling time, , with , which is the time over which the degrees of freedom of a horizon scramble information [27, 28, 29]. Identifying it with the window assumes that regions which have left each other’s horizon stay coherent for that long. Setting , evaluated when the window closes, gives exactly and
where the factor accounts for the drift between the pivot and its legs. The ratio then no longer depends on . The tilt changes as well, because when the window closes. With the bound requires for and for , so the window has to exceed the scrambling time by a few e-folds. For up to 7, the window is –37 for and lies between and the current limit, within reach of the next generation of B-mode experiments. Such a window would violate the consistency relation of (21) and Ref. [4], and it needs a drift twice as large. A measurement of therefore separates the two cases.
The gravitational-wave background today
The stochastic background is dominated by the first-order tensors. For modes that re-enter during radiation domination [30], the stochastic gravitational-wave background today is
up to , with and the temperature at re-entry.
Figure 6 shows the result for across the window. At 0.3 Hz, runs from at the lower edge to at the upper edge. We compare it with approximate power-law-integrated sensitivities [31] for four years of data at signal-to-noise ratio 10 (see more details in Appendix F), assuming that astrophysical foregrounds can be subtracted. BBO [32] detects the background for , that is for . The baseline DECIGO [33] would need , which is already excluded, while LISA [34] and ground-based interferometers [35] are far from the signal. An ultimate DECIGO, with [36], reaches or . Expressed in terms of , these reaches depend neither on the normalisation convention nor on .
Figure 6. Gravitational-wave background today, , against frequency , across the allowed window (solid lines, labelled by and ), with the scalar-induced background for (dotted red line). Black curves are approximate power-law-integrated sensitivities (SNR = 10, four years) for LISA, BBO and DECIGO. Bars mark representative levels for an ultimate DECIGO and for ET/CE. The dotted gray line is the integrated bound and the gray band the CMB scales. Each spectrum ends at , while the steps are the changes in
The scalar-induced gravitational wave background is times the factor of Eq. (25), about on scales , and it falls steeply beyond. It was computed at second order in the Einstein-de Sitter and radiation eras in Refs. [17, 18] and revisited in Refs. [19, 20, 21]. Tensor-induced tensors are of order . The integrated energy density is at most , reached at the lower edge, nine orders of magnitude below the bound. Therefore, both contributions are negligible throughout the window.
Spectral distortions and small scales
The break at is a distinctive feature of the mechanism. For it lies beyond the scales that produce -distortions, and keeps its standard value, for these parameters [37]. For larger windows the break moves into the era, , and drops to at , at , at and at the upper edge of the window. A measured below the standard value, with no detected B-modes, would therefore point to a long window. The same steepening suppresses the small-scale power relevant for primordial black holes and for the induced background at high frequencies, as these values assume a sharp break. For a release of finite width, the scales whose release is under way at the end receive more than the plateau value (Sec. V), so the spectrum can rise before it falls; we have not computed the shape of this transition, and for the value of is uncertain in both directions.
Discussion
We have shown that the tensor modes of Inflation without an Inflaton (IWI) are not enhanced at second order, and that the enhanced graviton-induced curvature can be carried into the radiation era with the observed tilt.
The tensors are not enhanced because the transverse-traceless (TT) sector obeys a wave equation whose retarded Bunch-Davies response is suppressed by oscillatory cancellations across the full time integral, whereas the scalar potential is fixed by an elliptic constraint that responds at once to the stress of all frozen gravitons. The gravitational waves of IWI are then the vacuum gravitons, Gaussian to a part in , with tensor tilt , as long as the depletion adds no long-range spin-2 response of its own (Sec. III D).
For the scalar, the curvature that survives is that of the hypersurface on which de Sitter (dS) ends, and its enhanced part is the offset between this hypersurface and local proper time, which the clock carries by following zero-shear time. In the picture, the inflaton is both the source of this offset and the clock that reads it. In IWI the two roles can be distinguished, although their dynamics need not be independent. The Bunch-Davies gravitons provide the source through the second-order constraints, and in our construction the depleting vacuum provides a clock that reads it within a finite reach, , which makes the enhancement scale independent. This is the fixed-ratio prescription of Ref. [2], realised in time and made compatible with the end of dS. The non-vacuum sector fed by the depletion is the sink required by energy-momentum conservation, i.e. the counterpart of the reheating products. For adiabatic sinks, we find that it changes the amplitude by less than 0.2 per cent. The radiation era then begins with a single adiabatic and Gaussian mode, conserved on super-horizon scales, with amplitude and tilt , which steepens beyond . On the other hand, Refs. [4, 8] read the spectrum at horizon crossing, where the populated pairs have loop momenta of order the external scale. The result for the scalar tilt is the same, but which of the two readings carries the observed amplitude is to be investigated.
Several results follow directly from the Einstein equations: the sourcing of the scalar by graviton pairs, the enhancement of the zero-shear curvature, the consistency of the pure- solution with all four scalar second-order equations, the absence of tensor enhancement in the hard-region loop with Bunch-Davies sources and the need for a sink once the vacuum depletes. We have checked numerically that the post-exit uniform-density curvature is conserved for the radiation sink, and that it is insensitive to the sink for adiabatic sinks and for . However, for our runs did not converge, so we do not draw any conclusion from them. The local entropy and anisotropic responses we tested either leave unchanged up to an unenhanced local term or rescale by about 5 per cent for a response of relative strength , while a persistent stress proportional to the strain is excluded. We assume the global zero-shear clock, which we identify with the break of the dS coherent state as a whole and which synchronises regions up to Hubble radii apart. We also assume the value of the window, with a few e-folds beyond the scrambling time as a natural candidate; the memory of the clock after the release, which sets but moves the lower edge of the window by only a few e-folds; and the end of dS, which a steady depletion does not produce. The transfer of the enhanced curvature into the radiation era therefore follows, given the hypotheses of the adopted clock: synchronisation on zero-shear time for e-folds, release, and memory afterwards. How the system composed of the vacuum and produced sector realises them remains open to further investigation.
Moreover, within the passive closure, we have seen that the equation of state of the sink matters little. The main open problem is to derive from the dynamics of the coherent state how the depletion synchronises each scale with zero-shear time for a fixed , how it realises the finite reach and why it keeps its memory afterwards, and it has to do so through the response of the vacuum and the produced sector together. The same calculation should fix the transfer and the perturbative properties of the sink, including any density, entropy, stress and memory response, decide how the produced sector takes part in the selection, and establish whether the depletion produces a long-range spin-2 response, which would be a new source of primordial gravitational waves. We are studying these questions in ongoing work with G. Dvali on horizon memory and a state-resolved quantum-break clock [38, 39], which separates the coherent occupation of the dS state from the activity of its microscopic channels. Its connection to the selection remains to be established.
A natural candidate for the microscopic identity of the clock is suggested by the operator-algebraic program of Gómez [40, 41, 42, 43]. There, a clock is not optional: the local observables of a dS patch form a type III factor whose reparametrization-invariant subalgebra is trivial, so gauge-invariant observables exist only after the algebra is extended by a clock and the operators are clock dressed (the crossed product), and the limit of the gauge-invariant algebra is argued to be algebraically nonexistent [43]. Gómez’s model-independent clock for the planar patch [42] has, one by one, the properties postulated in § 1.3 B. It is a two-mode system, one mode inside and one beyond the horizon, whose state, i.e. the EPR squeezed pair generated by the de Sitter Bogolyubov transformation, is coherent across super-horizon distances: the non-locality the window requires is the entanglement of the clock state. It is a spin-0 number-phase system, , so it adds no long-range spin-2 response (Sec. III D). Its energy is , which is the enthalpy of the sink, so the background bookkeeping is already the clock’s. And the gravitational bound on clock precision gives the dressing a maximal reach [42], of the kind a finite window needs, with its natural scale, i.e. the scrambling-time candidate of Eq. (24). What the algebraic clock does not yet provide is the value of and the release-and-memory law of § 1.3 B; these are precisely the properties the state-resolved quantum-break clock is meant to derive in [39]. If the identification holds, the window clock postulated here is not an addition to the scenario but the crossed-product dressing that any dS observable requires.
Several predictions are independent of these details. The tensor tilt is directly connected to the scalar one via , or for a scrambling-time window, whatever the value of , so a measurement of both tests the mechanism and distinguishes the two cases. The tensor-to-scalar ratio lies between and the current limit, and the scalar spectrum has a small-scale break whose position is tied to through . Finally, the gravitational-wave background is that of the vacuum gravitons, within reach of BBO for and of an ultimate DECIGO for .
Acknowledgments
The work of RJ is supported by the Simons Foundation. Funding for the work of MT and RJ was partially provided by project PID2022-141125NB-I00, and grant CEX2024-001451-M funded by MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033. DB and SM acknowledge support from the COSMOS network (www.cosmosnet.it) through ASI (Italian Space Agency) Grants 2016-24-H.0, 2016-24-H.1-2018 and 2020-9-HH.0. This work is supported in part by the MUR Departments of Excellence grant “Quantum Frontiers” of the Physics and Astronomy Department of Padova, Italy. MA acknowledges the hospitality of the Institute of Cosmos Sciences of the University of Barcelona (ICCUB), where this work was carried out. The project that gave rise to these results received the support of a fellowship from “la Caixa” Foundation (ID 100010434), awarded to MT with code LCF/BQ/D124/12070012.
AI usage: Claude Code was used to assist with coding, computations, and graphic generation. The ideas, inferences, and results all originate in the (human) brains of the authors. Claude and ChatGPT were used to check citations, spelling, grammar, inconsistencies and also to enhance the flow of the text and its logic. Handwritten notes were transcribed to Latex using these tools. The original text was written by the authors, who are responsible for the results, findings, and conclusions of this article.
References
Second-order equations
We take and denote as the graviton-bilinear part of . At the order of the bilinear cross term, the scalar equations in an arbitrary gauge are as follows ():
with defined in Eq. (4). We have checked symbolically, for a generic , that under the operator transforms by exactly , and that its graviton-bilinear parts are the same in every gauge.
In Poisson gauge, the dynamical equation is Eq. (29)}, with $\psi=\phi-T$ and $\delta\rho$ taken from Eq. (A1)`. For the window clock , with , and the curvature on uniform total density is
Consistency of the pure- solution
In pure GR+ we have . We take from the comoving Poisson equation (3), and $\psi=\phi-T from Eq. (4), with exact Bunch-Davies legs, and evaluate on this solution the full second-order operator , metric and graviton parts together. The derivatives , , and are those of the functions themselves. We compute them by fourth-order finite differences with step in 80-digit arithmetic. Table II gives, for each pair, the largest residual of the four scalar projections (00, , trace, and longitudinal ) over seven times in , each divided by the larger of its metric and graviton parts. All four vanish to the precision of the differencing, . The frozen form of the same solution , with , instead fails the 00, trace and longitudinal equations at order one (see Table II). Its residual is the quantity defined below, which vanishes as , but , which appears in the 00 equation, stays finite.
| pair , helicities | exact all four | frozen ansatz 00 | frozen ansatz trace | frozen ansatz long. |
| 0.70 | 0.70 | 1.00 | ||
| 1.01 | 1.01 | 1.00 | ||
| 0.51 | 0.51 | 1.00 | ||
| 1.28 | 1.28 | 1.00 | ||
| 1.75 | 1.75 | 1.00 |
Table II. Relative residuals of the four scalar Einstein equations in pure GR+. Exact: the Bunch-Davies solution evaluated with its own time derivatives. We find that all four residuals are comparable, so we quote their maximum over seven times in . Frozen ansatz: , , with exact Bunch-Davies legs in , at . The residuals differ by equation, so we list the 00, the trace, and the longitudinal residual (the residual vanishes as and is omitted). The last two pairs are non-planar random configurations.
The reason the frozen ansatz fails is that three combinations stay finite at late times although the frozen limit sets each of them to zero. Each is a power of multiplying quantities that vanish, or tend to constants, in conformal time. The first is the graviton term , which tends to because for Bunch-Davies legs. It appears only in , since , and have no part proportional to . The other two come from the 00 and the equation. Writing , which tends to , the 00 equation gives . Since in exact dS, it also gives in the longitudinal equation. Keeping all three, the late-time system reads
The last two relations express momentum and energy conservation of the frozen graviton stress, which the Bianchi identity guarantees, while the last says that frozen tensor gradients act as a component.
For with positive helicities, at , we find and , of which comes from the term. The equation then gives , the longitudinal component is and the trace is . These are real parts, and the imaginary parts are about . If instead is imposed before the limit is taken, the three finite combinations are lost: the 00 equation gives , the trace equation , the traceless equation still gives , and the longitudinal equation demands , although it should give . This is the apparent overconstraint that motivated the effective fluid of [1]: the second-order equations of [1], including the equation for , are correct, and their large-scale solution , is the late-time limit of the exact solution. The overconstraint is an artifact of the order in which the limits are taken.
Tensor time integrals
The late-time tensor is
with the retarded Green function of Eq. (10) at ,
For Bunch-Davies legs, the two source structures carry and , each of which is times a polynomial, with . The integrals are then elementary once the contour is tilted into the damping direction, so that provides the convergence factor. The integrals carry a short-distance regulator (the lower limit of ): the and pieces of a cutoff regularisation cancel and leave the real closed forms of Eq. (11). For , and , while for we obtain and (see Sec. III B). We checked the closed forms against numerical integration along , , finding agreement to for and in units of .
Numerical scheme for the window clock
We use as the time variable and evolve the vacuum and radiation densities, the two graviton modes, the Poisson-gauge potential with , and the clock offset , with an eighth-order Runge-Kutta integrator at relative tolerance . The release is a quintic smooth-step in of width centered on . While clock is synchronised, the condition of Eq. (15) is enforced softly, by driving to zero at rate . The exit is a smoothstep in of width 0.3, placed a few e-folds after both the release and the freezing of the internal pair. We have checked that the results are robust to where the exit is placed. Moving it to one e-fold after the centre of the release, with and –30, changes by at most 0.2 per cent for and 1 (§ 1.4).
An unreleased clock reproduces the direct Poisson-gauge evolution to . A clock released deep inside the horizon approaches the synchronous-gauge result, for , releasing progressively deeper, at , 201 and 546, gives , 0.15 and 0.125, converging to that value from below. The ratio to the zero-shear value depends on and only through , to better than half a per cent. After the exit, is constant to while (Figure 4). These runs use a single pair configuration, with positive helicities, but the dilation argument of § 1.3 B holds for all configurations.

Figure 4. Relative change of after the exit, , against in the radiation era, for four pairs inside (, 0.3, 1) and outside () the window. Dotted vertical lines mark the re-entry of the internal modes, . On super-horizon scales, the curvature is conserved to better than .
Uniform density versus zero shear
Eliminating between Eqs. (26) and (27) gives the exact decomposition
where is the velocity of the sink and its comoving density, which is suppressed by .
The left panel of Figure 7 shows during quasi-dS for four pairs, with a zero-shear exit, and the clock synchronised throughout. Equation (32) holds to , and the velocity term dominates, with the comoving density below of it from one e-fold after freeze-out and below after five e-folds. A few e-folds after freeze-out, we find numerically for all four pairs. This value follows from the Euler equation of the sink, which for radiation injected at rest in steady state reads , the term being the drag of the injected energy. With and it gives up to corrections of order . Since –, the correction to is – and carries no factor . Dropping in Eq. (26) would instead have given , about 330 times larger (dashed curves in Figure 7, left).
Figure 7. Left: We show the density contribution in quasi-de Sitter () against , the e-folds since the internal pair froze, for four pairs (solid lines overlapping). Dashed lines show the estimate that dropping in Eq. (26) would give. The dotted line shows . Right: We show the pair through a zero-shear exit and into the radiation era, against . The split between (blue) and the density term (red) changes when the internal modes re-enter (, orange line), while the uniform-density (black dashed) stays constant. The lapse (green) goes from while the modes are frozen to the adiabatic value as they re-enter. Dotted horizontal lines mark , and , i.e. the adiabatic-mode values the curves relax to.
After a zero-shear exit, the uniform-density curvature equals the late dS to , and for , 10 and 30, respectively, whose internal modes froze 8.5, 7.3 and 6.2 e-folds before the exit. Both quantities approach the frozen value as . With the window clock released before the exit, moving the exit from 3 to 6 to 10 e-folds after the release changes by less than for , and , respectively, because the free-running clock integrates the decaying lapse.
In the radiation era, we see from the right panel of Figure 7 that the split changes when the internal gravitons re-enter. While they are frozen, and . Once they re-enter, their anisotropic stress disappears, and the potentials relax to the standard adiabatic mode, , with and . The uniform-density does not change, to at . This requires the graviton-volume term : when the internal modes of the pair re-enter () drifts by 2% without it and by with it.
To test the dependence on the sink, we replaced the radiation by a fluid with constant and rest-frame sound speed , for which [44], with and including the exchange. We kept and converted the vacuum into the same fluid at the exit. The velocity term becomes , independent of . Table III gives the fractional change of after the exit relative to radiation, for positive helicities. After a zero-shear exit, the changes of come from the change in the background fraction of the sink, at fixed , and the effect of is only . The window ratio at lies between 1.0152 and 1.0160 for all closures.
| zero shear | ||||||
| 0 | 0 | |||||
| 1 | 1 | |||||
| 1 | ||||||
| 0 | ||||||
| 0.05 | n.c. | |||||
| 1 | n.c. |
Table III. Effect of changing the sink, for sinks with equation of state and sound speed (first two columns), for positive helicities. The third column reports the density term , measured three e-folds after freeze-out, and it equals to to . The last four columns show how much the post-exit shifts when radiation is replaced by that sink. Each entry is the fractional change from the radiation result (), in units of . Considering different exits and pairs: zero shear is a clock never released (), while the columns are the released windows, with , at , and , respectively. The run, , matches the column for the first four sinks. n.c.: not converged (see text).
When the pressure contains , and has to be inferred from Eq. (27) by dividing by . While the internal modes are inside the horizon, this division amplifies the integration error. For , and for , the entries of Table III do not change when the tolerance is tightened from to . For and they do change. For at the change is at and at , and at it has not converged. These closures need a formulation that evolves the density and velocity of the sink explicitly.
For the responses of a non-passive sink, we kept radiation and added either to the pressure or to the traceless equation, , with the corresponding in Eq. (29). The factor switches the response off after the exit. We used the volume bilinear , which is the mean pair part of , and the kinetic bilinear , which decays as after freeze-out. The runs use with positive helicities and a zero-shear exit 7.6 e-folds after the external mode leaves the horizon. Both changes are linear in ( halves them). The pressure term gives the same for and 0.0088, which shows that it is generated during the exit, where the sink is no longer a small fraction. With in the anisotropic stress, the elastic case, the post-exit is for at every , and of order at the exit.
Gravitational-wave spectrum and sensitivities
Eq. (25) uses a smooth fit to the Standard Model and [45] and neglects neutrino damping, which matters only below . The frequency is with the scale factor today, and follows from the radiation exit. The sensitivity curves are power-law integrated [31], for SNR and four years of data. For LISA we use the sky-averaged noise of Ref. [46] in autocorrelation, and for BBO and DECIGO the effective noise fits of Ref. [47] for a cross-correlated pair. The minima of the curves are for LISA, for BBO and for DECIGO. They are indicative only, and a change in sensitivity by a factor moves the BBO reach by in . The -distortion is computed with
with in [37].
The homogeneous scalar mode and graviton backreaction
The scalar response to quadratic graviton fluctuations and the homogeneous backreaction belong to distinct sectors of the second-order Einstein equations. For nonzero external momentum, the scalar potential obeys the elliptic constraint
where is the quadratic graviton contribution to . For internal momenta , the inverse Laplacian generates the enhancement. The scalar evolution equation containing introduces no independent propagating degree of freedom: the Bianchi identities relate it to the constraints once the graviton equations hold. By contrast, the TT sector evolves through a retarded Green function and its source can contain terms, but the TT projection removes the longitudinal and trace structures responsible for the scalar enhancement. Oscillatory cancellations across the full retarded Bunch-Davies integral, including the sub-horizon and frozen regimes, leave an order-one tensor kernel.
a. The homogeneous mode. Separating the quadratic source into its mean and fluctuation, , statistical homogeneity gives for . The connected scalar fluctuations are sourced by , whereas the mean belongs to the homogeneous Einstein equations. The exact mode cannot be obtained from Eq. (34), since the inverse Laplacian is undefined there and the scalar momentum constraint involves division by . For the homogeneous metric
the undivided temporal and spatial equations give
There is no independent homogeneous scalar momentum constraint, and compatibility follows from the Bianchi identities. The correction to the expansion rate is
where and . The homogeneous backreaction is therefore sourced by the averaged quadratic stress, not the enhanced inhomogeneous scalar response.
b. The quadratic graviton stress. Expanding the ADM Hamiltonian constraint, , to quadratic order in the TT perturbation and spatially averaging gives
The mixed term remains finite at late times despite mode by mode, and must therefore be retained before taking the super-horizon limit. Using the exact Bunch-Davies mode function and , the bare energy density follows from Eq. (37), while the pressure is obtained from , applied to each shell at fixed comoving momentum (see also [4]):
The bare effective energy density is negative for because of the mixed expansion term in Eq. (37), reflecting the non-positive-definite character of the gravitational effective stress at long wavelengths. In the homogeneous gauge , the constraint also yields, for each comoving shell,
The constant fixes the homogeneous background convention, and requiring the shell contribution to vanish as sets . Thus, is not a gauge-independent observable, and absorbing the homogeneous correction into the renormalized background defines the convention , while retaining the physical backreaction in the background geometry.
c. Magnitude and interpretation of the backreaction. The homogeneous expansion obeys . To characterize a finite population of Bunch-Davies gravitons, define
For a scale-invariant tensor spectrum in exact dS, , so (see [4]). With and the tensor-amplitude range considered here, $6\times10^{-16}\lesssim|\mathcal{E}(1)|\lesssim8\times10^{-12}$, far below the associated with the observed scalar tilt. The finite-window quantity is not the renormalized slow-roll parameter. At fixed , the moving cutoff introduces a flux of modes, so the selected sector is not separately conserved, unlike the individual fixed-comoving-momentum shells. The full backreaction instead requires the renormalized homogeneous stress and gravitational counterterms. A dS-invariant renormalized vacuum contribution satisfies and shifts the expansion scale without generating a nonzero , so the Gaussian graviton stress is distinct from the depletion-generated sector whose enthalpy determines . Although linear tensors are gauge-invariant, the homogeneous second-order geometry retains a background-definition freedom, and its contributions to and \zeta_{\mathrm{P}}$ is not the physical uniform-density curvature, which requires a non-vacuum clock. The scalar spectrum is determined by connected fluctuations at .
References
- [1]D. Bertacca, R. Jimenez, S. Matarrese, and A. Ricciardone, Phys. Rev. Res. 7, L032010 (2025), arXiv:2412.14265 [astro-ph.CO].arxiv.org/abs/2412.14265
- [2]M. Taforetti, M. Abdelaziz, D. Bertacca, R. Jimenez, S. Matarrese, and A. Ricciardone, Phys. Rev. D 113, 094011 (2011). 023553 (2026), arXiv:2511.11808 [astro-ph.CO].
- [3]M. Abdelaziz, M. Traforetti, D. Bertacca, R. Jimenez, S. Matarrese, and A. Ricciardone, Phys. Rev. D 114, 023517 (2026), arXiv:2603.15036 [astro-ph.CO].
- [4]R. Jimenez, D. Bertacca, M. Abdelaziz, S. Matarrese, A. Ricciardone, and M. Traforetti, (2026), arXiv:2610.20378 [astro-ph.CO].arxiv.org/abs/2610.20378
- [5]G. Dvali and C. Gomez, JCAP 01, 023, arXiv:1312.4795 [hep-th].DOI
- [6]G. Dvali, C. Gomez, and S. Zell, JCAP 06, 028, arXiv:1701.08776 [hep-th].DOI
- [7]C. Gomez and R. Jimenez, Phys. Dark Univ. 36, 101035 (2022), arXiv:2111.05380 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2111.05380
- [8]D. Bertacca, R. Jimenez, and S. Matarrese, in preparation (2026).
- [9]W. Israel, Nuovo Cim. B 44S10, 1 (1966), [Erratum: Nuovo Cim.B 48, 463 (1967)].
- [10]N. Deruelle and V. F. Mukhanov, Phys. Rev. D 52, 5549 (1995), arXiv:gr-qc/9503050.DOI
- [11]A. A. Starobinsky, JETP Lett. 42, 152 (1985).
- [12]M. Sasaki and E. D. Stewart, Prog. Theor. Phys. 95, 71 (1996), arXiv:astro-ph/9507001.DOI
- [13]D. H. Lyth, K. A. Malik, and M. Sasaki, JCAP 05, 004, arXiv:astro-ph/0411220.
- [14]J. M. Maldacena, JHEP 05, 013, arXiv:astro-ph/0210603.DOI
- [15]F.-Y. Chen, J.-Z. Zhou, D. Wu, Z.-C. Li, and P.-Y. Wu, (2025), arXiv:2507.22688 [astro-ph.CO].arxiv.org/abs/2507.22688
- [16]P. A. R. Ade et al. (BICEP, Keck), Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 151301 (2021), arXiv:2110.00483 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
- [17]S. Matarrese, S. Mollerach, and M. Bruni, Phys. Rev. D 58, 043504 (1998), arXiv:astro-ph/9707278.DOI
- [18]S. Mollerach, D. Harari, and S. Matarrese, Phys. Rev. D 69, 063002 (2004), arXiv:astro-ph/0310711.DOI
- [19]K. N. Ananda, C. Clarkson, and D. Wands, Phys. Rev. D 75, 123518 (2007), arXiv:gr-qc/0612013.DOI
- [20]D. Baumann, P. J. Steinhardt, K. Takahashi, and K. Ichiki, Phys. Rev. D 76, 084019 (2007), arXiv:hep-th/0703290.DOI
- [21]K. Kohri and T. Terada, Phys. Rev. D 97, 123532 (2018), arXiv:1804.08577 [gr-qc].DOI
- [22]S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. D 69, 023503 (2004), arXiv:astro-ph/0306304.DOI
- [23]Y. Akrami et al. (Planck), Astron. Astrophys. 641, A10 (2020), arXiv:1807.06211 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
- [24]D. Wands, K. A. Malik, D. H. Lyth, and A. R. Liddle, Phys. Rev. D 62, 043527 (2000), arXiv:astro-ph/0003278.DOI
- [25]E. Allys et al. (LiteBIRD), PTEP 2023, 042F01 (2023), arXiv:2202.02773 [astro-ph.IM].DOI
- [26]K. N. Abazajian et al. (CMB-S4), CMB-S4 Science Book, First Edition (2016) arXiv:1610.02743 [astro-ph.CO].arxiv.org/abs/1610.02743
- [27]Y. Sekino and L. Susskind, JHEP 10, 065, arXiv:0808.2096 [hep-th].DOI
- [28]L. Susskind, (2011), arXiv:1101.6048 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/1101.6048
- [29]L. Alsma and G. Shiu, JHEP 05, 152, arXiv:2002.01326 [hep-th].
- [30]Y. Watanabe and E. Komatsu, Phys. Rev. D 73, 123515 (2006), arXiv:astro-ph/0604176.DOI
- [31]E. Thrane and J. D. Romano, Phys. Rev. D 88, 124032 (2013), arXiv:1310.5300 [astro-ph.IM].DOI
- [32]J. Crowder and N. J. Cornish, Phys. Rev. D 72, 083005 (2005), arXiv:gr-qc/0506015.DOI
- [33]S. Kawamura et al., Classical and Quantum Gravity 28,
- [34]P. Amaro-Seoane et al. (LISA), (2017), arXiv:1702.00786 [astro-ph.IM].
- [35]M. Punturo et al., Class. Quant. Grav. 27, 194002 (2010).
- [36]H. Kudoh, A. Taruya, T. Hiramatsu, and Y. Himemoto, Phys. Rev. D 73, 064006 (2006), arXiv:gr-qc/0511145.DOI
- [37]J. Chluba, A. L. Erickcek, and I. Ben-Dayan, Astrophys. J. 758, 76 (2012), arXiv:1203.2681 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
- [38]D. Bertacca, G. Dvali, and R. Jimenez, in preparation (2026).
- [39]D. Bertacca, G. Dvali, and R. Jimenez, in preparation (2026).
- [40]C. Gomez, (2022), arXiv:2207.06704 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2207.06704
- [41]C. Gomez, (2023), arXiv:2302.14747 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2302.14747
- [42]C. Gomez, (2023), arXiv:2304.11845 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2304.11845
- [43]C. Gomez, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 40, 2540013 (2025), arXiv:2407.20671 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2407.20671
- [44]W. Hu, Astrophys. J. 506, 485 (1998), arXiv:astro-ph/9801234.DOI
- [45]K. Saikawa and S. Shirai, JCAP 05, 035, arXiv:1803.01038 [hep-ph].DOI
- [46]T. Robson, N. J. Cornish, and C. Liu, Class. Quant. Grav. 36, 105011 (2019), arXiv:1803.01944 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
- [47]K. Yagi and N. Seto, Phys. Rev. D 83, 044011 (2011), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 95, 109901 (2017)], arXiv:1101.3940 [astro-ph.CO].DOI




