betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

The continuum limit of three-dimensional SU(2) lattice Yang–Mills theory on a torus II: Fluctuation integration and local reconstruction

Abstract

We consider the Wilson lattice gauge measure for SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(2) on a periodic three-dimensional torus of fixed size, with bare coupling g2=g32ag^2=g_3^2a proportional to the lattice spacing aa, as dictated by the superrenormalizability of three-dimensional Yang–Mills theory. Observables are Wilson loops of the lattice configuration evolved by the Wilson flow, the lattice gradient flow of the Wilson action, at positive flow time. We prove that, at every fixed value of the coupling, the joint laws of finitely many flowed Wilson loops converge as the lattice spacing tends to zero along the sequences of lattice sides nMknM^k, for fixed odd M≥3M\ge3 and fixed positive nn divisible by four. For each such refinement class, the limits are realized by a unique probability measure on the space of gauge orbits of Yang–Mills heat-flow trajectories at positive times, a version of the state space introduced by Cao and Chatterjee. At each fixed positive time, the energies of the selected trajectories πk(U)\pi_k(U), with UU distributed under the lattice Wilson measures, are tight uniformly in the lattice spacing. The limiting measure is invariant under the lattice symmetries and the center symmetries. We also show that, at short distances, the rescaled deficits (1−W)/(g32ε)(1-W)/(g_3^2\varepsilon) of the normalized fundamental Wilson loops WW of loops x+εℓx+\varepsilon\ell, flowed for time σε2\sigma\varepsilon^2 with fixed σ>0\sigma>0, converge to explicit quadratic functions of the heat-smoothed Gaussian free field. As the coupling tends to zero, the measure concentrates on flat connections, with Gaussian fluctuations of explicit covariance near regular commuting holonomies and fluctuations governed by the constant-mode quartic form near the central holonomies. The proof is a multiscale renormalization group analysis in the tradition of Bałaban, carried out on a small-field event whose complement we show to have small probability, uniformly in the lattice spacing, using reflection positivity and chessboard estimates. It is combined with stochastic estimates for the lattice heat flow and a deterministic analysis of the Wilson flow for rough initial data.

Detail from Abraham Ortelius's Theatrum orbis terrarum

Figure 1. Image: detail from Abraham Ortelius, Theatrum orbis terrarum (1570). Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division. https://www.loc.gov/resource/g3200m.gct00126/?sp=106

WARNING!

We have extensively audited this manuscript using large language models, including adversarial reviews by multiple models. However, the proof is too complex for Lean formalization at the present time, and it has not yet undergone verification by a human expert.

Authors’ note

With the exception of this note, the entire document is machine-written. We have taken care to supervise this writing to ensure that the proofs meet a minimum standard of readability and that previous literature is appropriately cited.

The manuscript began as an attempt to pursue the program of Magnen, Rivasseau, and Sénéor [132] using large language models. Our hope was that understanding the problem on the torus might offer some insight into the general case. The construction that resulted from this starting point is three-dimensional and lattice-based and draws extensively on Bałaban’s renormalization group methods.

As we were verifying these results, we learned that Alpöge and Sussman announced that they appear to have a YM4 existence argument, following Bałaban’s program (https://github.com/ethanwsussman/Yang--Mills-LLM-experiment). We are thrilled and look forward to learning more about these exciting developments. We hope that this manuscript nonetheless contributes to understanding constructive approaches to three-dimensional Yang–Mills theory. The first version of these results was posted to the first author’s GitHub on October 17, 2026 (https://github.com/pmaronow/3d-ym-torus). Prior to posting the first version of this work, we did not inspect the ongoing work of Alpöge and Sussman. Further, to the best of our knowledge, the LLMs we used did not access their work during the mathematical development and drafting of this manuscript. This version contains additional clarifications relative to the first version; it has also been partitioned into five volumes.

We welcome suggestions concerning mathematical corrections, omitted citations, and attribution of ideas.

P. L. was partially supported by NSF grant DMS-2450004.

IV Fluctuation integration and conditional measures

Fluctuation integration and cluster expansions

In this section, we integrate out the fluctuations of a bounded number of averaging steps around the classical background field. We consider s≤Js \le J consecutive averaging steps, from a lattice of side MsmM^{sm} to a coarse lattice of side m≥4m \ge4, starting from the effective classical action Ed0E_{d_0} of some depth d0≥0d_0 \ge0; for s=Js = J this is one renormalization group step. Given a coarse field cc, the fine configurations whose average is cc are described by free logarithmic coordinates at each intermediate scale. We center these coordinates at the conditional constrained minimizer, normalize them by the coupling and the constrained Hessian, and integrate the resulting normalized fluctuation variables ww over a fixed product Ωp\Omega_p of three-dimensional balls.

There are three main results. The first is an exact formula for this integral, for one averaging step in Lemma 12.3 and for s≤Js \le J averaging steps in Theorem 12.13. The second is a convergent polymer expansion of the logarithm of the fluctuation partition function, with volume-independent bounds on all its derivatives of positive order (Theorems 12.6 and 12.7 and Proposition 12.10). The third, Lemma 12.16, concerns an input effective interaction RR, produced by the integrations at finer scales. It shows that integrating out the fluctuations replaces RR by its value on the zero-fluctuation reconstruction plus a correction of second order in the coupling. We do not estimate the probability of the domain of integration under the Wilson measure here; this is done in Section 23.

We use the conventions of Section 4, the absolute coefficient calculus of Lemma 5.3, the constraint coordinates and the exact Haar disintegration of Lemma 6.3, and the conditional constrained minimizers, the nested minimization identity, and the coefficient bounds for EdE_d of Theorems 10.10 and 10.11. In § 3, the results are used to construct the renormalization group recursion on the small-field event and to describe the conditional fluctuation kernel; they are also used in Sections 14, § 3.5, and 23. Sections 18 and 20 reuse the triangular change of variables and the graph combinatorics, and Sections 31, 33, and 35 use the coordinates of Theorem 12.13 and its dimension counts.

The integral over one averaging step. We first describe the identity of Lemma 12.3 informally. Let b(c,z)b(c,z) be the fine configuration with average cc and free logarithmic coordinates zz, and let F(c,z)=Ed0(b(c,z))F(c,z)=E_{d_0}(b(c,z)). Let z∗(c)z^*(c) be the minimizer of F(c,⋅)F(c,\cdot) and K(c)=Dz2F(c,z∗(c))K(c)=D_z^2F(c,z^*(c)) the constrained Hessian. The substitution

z=z∗(c)+gK(c)−1/2wz=z^*(c)+gK(c)^{-1/2}w

has Jacobian g3fdet⁡K(c)−1/2g^{3f}\det K(c)^{-1/2}, where 3f3f is the number of real free logarithmic coordinates. Since z∗z^* is stationary and K−1/2KK−1/2=IK^{-1/2}KK^{-1/2}=I, we have

F(c,z)g2=F(c,z∗(c))g2+12∣w∣2+O(g∣w∣3),\frac{F(c,z)}{g^2}=\frac{F(c,z^*(c))}{g^2}+\frac{1}{2}|w|^2+O(g|w|^3),

and F(c,z∗(c))/g2=Ed0+1(c)/(Mg2)F(c,z^*(c))/g^2=E_{d_0+1}(c)/(Mg^2) by the nested minimization identity. The Haar density of the free logarithmic coordinates is a reference constant times e−Lc(z)e^{-\mathcal{L}_c(z)}, and Lc(z)=Lc(z∗(c))+O(g∣w∣)\mathcal{L}_c(z)=\mathcal{L}_c(z^*(c))+O(g|w|). Thus the integral over w∈Ωpw\in\Omega_p is the product of three factors that depend on cc (the exponential of the effective classical action at the coarse scale, the determinant det⁡K(c)−1/2\det K(c)^{-1/2}, and the Haar density at the minimizer) and of the integral of e−∣w∣2/2−U(c,w)e^{-|w|^2/2-U(c,w)}, where UU is small on Ωp\Omega_p. The determinant and the Haar density at the minimizer become part of the effective interaction as functions of cc, and Ed0+1/(Mg2)E_{d_0+1}/(Mg^2) remains a separate term. We control the integral of e−∣w∣2/2−Ue^{-|w|^2/2-U} by a polymer expansion about the product of truncated Gaussian measures on the balls. This product is only a reference measure. The conditional law of ww, the conditional fluctuation kernel studied in § 3, has density proportional to e−∣w∣2/2−Ue^{-|w|^2/2-U}.

For several averaging steps the change of variables is triangular, from the coarsest intermediate scale to the finest. The minimizers, Hessians, and Haar densities at a finer scale depend on the fluctuations at all coarser scales, and the exact formula of Theorem 12.13 keeps these dependences.

Organization. § 2.1.1 defines the coefficient norms and proves the exact formula for one averaging step. § 2.1.2 proves the cluster expansion in an absolute coefficient algebra, in a form that applies to arbitrary interactions with connected supports. § 2.1.3 constructs connected supports for the interaction of one averaging step and estimates the resulting effective interaction. § 2.1.4 treats s≤Js\le J averaging steps, and § 2.1.5 treats an input effective interaction. The order in which the constants are chosen is summarized in Remark 12.17.

Conventions. All results of this section concern the periodic torus without a fixed complement. Distances are measured in units of the coarse lattice spacing. Unless stated otherwise, constants in the statements about one averaging step have the dependence described in item (2) of Definition 4.14. That is, they depend only on MM, on the fixed larger domains of the classical and Haar disintegration charts, and on fixed radius ratios, spatial decay rates, and norm bounds. They are independent of the depth d0d_0, of the side mm, and of the coupling and cutoff parameters satisfying the stated inequalities. For s≤Js\le J averaging steps, the constants may also depend on JJ, on the finitely many changes of scale between the lattices involved, and on the fixed box geometry, and no uniformity as J→∞J\to\infty is claimed. Every factor that is independent of the field, and every factor that depends only on the coarse field, is kept explicitly in the formulas.

We recall the coefficient norms of Definition 4.6. A tensor is bounded at every fixed index if, at the spatial decay rate bb, its output-fixed absolute row sum and each of its input-fixed absolute column sums, the latter with the volume normalization of Definition 4.6, are bounded. Every sum carries the weight ebte^{bt}, where tt is the length of a shortest connected network joining the locations of all indices of the coefficient; internal vertices are allowed. For a scalar function, we fix any one input index and sum over the others with the same weight, and we write ∥⋅∥b,root\lVert\cdot\rVert_{b,\mathrm{root}} for the resulting norm of a derivative tensor. Scalar values are never included in these norms. A majorant series of a family of tensors is a power series with nonnegative coefficients that dominate the corresponding sums of absolute coefficients.

Attribution. The organization of the integral into an effective classical action and connected local fluctuation terms follows Bałaban’s renormalization group analysis of lattice gauge theories [17, 19]; its three-dimensional antecedent is the stability analysis in [15]. We adapt this organization to the block averaging map, the constraint coordinates, and the truncated domains used here, and we prove the expansion below. In particular, we do not use the four-dimensional coupling renormalization of [17]. The cluster expansion combines the Mayer expansion with a convergence criterion of the type of Kotecký and Preiss [120]. The bound on connected graph sums by spanning trees comes from Penrose’s partition [136], in the form described by Fernández and Procacci [87, Section 4.1]; see also Brydges’ exposition [38]. Dimock records the finite graph estimate in the constructive renormalization group setting [68, Appendix B, Theorem 27, p. 39, and (323), p. 42]. His analysis concerns a scalar field, and no other result of [68] is used. The weighted resolvent bounds use the Combes–Thomas method [61], as in Lemma 5.3.

Coefficient norms and normalized fluctuation coordinates

Definition 12.1. Let L≥1\mathcal{L} \ge1 be an integer, the box scale; it is unrelated to the side length LL of the torus. Partition each periodic coordinate direction of the coarse lattice into integer intervals of lengths between L\mathcal{L} and 2L2\mathcal{L}; a direction that is too short for such a partition forms a single interval. The products of these intervals are the boxes. A support is a nonempty connected set XX of boxes; sets that wind around the torus are allowed, and ∣X∣|X| denotes the number of boxes in XX. A function is supported in XX if it depends only on coordinates θ\theta and ww (or θ\theta and qq, when those variables are used) whose locations lie in XX.

For a convergent series f(θ,w)=∑νfν(w)θνf(\theta,w)=\sum_\nu f_\nu(w)\theta^\nu in the coarse-field coordinates θ\theta, whose coefficients are functions of ww on a fixed product Ωp\Omega_p, and for a family {fX}\{f_X\} indexed by supports, set

∥f∥u,coeff;p=∑νu∣ν∣sup⁡w∈Ωp∣fν(w)∣,∥{fX}∥u,κ;p=sup⁡x∑X∋xeκ∣X∣∥fX∥u,coeff;p.(1)\lVert f\rVert_{u,\mathrm{coeff};p}=\sum_\nu u^{|\nu|}\sup_{w\in\Omega_p}|f_\nu(w)|,\qquad \lVert\{f_X\}\rVert_{u,\kappa;p}=\sup_x\sum_{X\ni x}e^{\kappa|X|}\lVert f_X\rVert_{u,\mathrm{coeff};p}. \tag*{(1)}

where xx ranges over the boxes. The coefficients are taken in the scalar link and color coordinates and include the Taylor factorials, that is, fνf_\nu is the coefficient of the monomial θν\theta^\nu; replacing the scalar absolute value by a fixed norm on the three color components changes only fixed constants. When the functions do not depend on ww we omit pp from the notation.

For an extensive scalar holomorphic function f(θ,q)f(\theta,q) of the coarse-field coordinates θ\theta and of variables qq, with qi=giwiq_i=g_iw_i in the applications below, set

Ju,v,b(f)=∑r+s≥1urvsr!s!∥DθrDqsf(0,0)∥b,root,(2)\mathcal{J}_{u,v,b}(f)=\sum_{r+s\geq1}\frac{u^r v^s}{r!s!}\left\lVert D_\theta^rD_q^s f(0,0)\right\rVert_{b,\mathrm{root}}, \tag*{(2)}

where the tensor norm is the scalar counting fixed-input sum: it fixes any one index of θ\theta or of qq, sums over all other indices, and uses the weight ebte^{bt}, with no mesh-volume factor. This is the scalar convention of Definition 4.6; volume normalization is retained for vector columns. The constant coefficient of ff is not restricted by Ju,v,b\mathcal{J}_{u,v,b}. For a reconstructed field, which is vector valued, we use the analogous majorant series for the output-fixed rows and for all input-fixed volume-normalized columns. In a composition of ss averaging steps the variables wiw_i and qiq_i of the ii-th step have mesh Mi−sM^{i-s}, 0≤i<s0\leq i<s, and the number of their indices, for all these steps, located in a unit cube is at most CMsM3sC_MsM^{3s}.

In (12.1), we take the supremum over w∈Ωpw\in\Omega_p of each coefficient in θ\theta and then sum with the weights u∣ν∣u^{|\nu|}. This norm dominates the supremum of the function. The symbol Ju,v,b\mathcal{J}_{u,v,b} is unrelated to the Haar disintegration densities Jc\mathcal{J}_c introduced below.

We now fix one averaging step, from side MmMm to side m≥4m\geq4, with input action Ed0E_{d_0} of depth d0≥0d_0\geq0. By Lemma 6.3 and Theorem 10.10, the fine configuration with average cc is b(c,z)=eΓc(z)U0(c)b(c,z)=e^{\Gamma_c(z)}U_0(c), where U0(c)U_0(c) is the coarse-field lift, Γc\Gamma_c solves the block averaging constraint for the eliminated edges ea∗e_a^*, a∈Ema\in\mathcal{E}_m, and zz are the free logarithmic coordinates. We write

B(θ,z)=Log⁡b(eθ,z),F(θ,z)=Ed0(b(eθ,z)),L(θ,z)=−log⁡Jeθ(z)JI(0).B(\theta,z)=\operatorname{Log} b(e^\theta,z),\qquad F(\theta,z)=E_{d_0}(b(e^\theta,z)),\qquad\mathcal{L}(\theta,z)=-\log\frac{\mathcal{J}_{e^\theta}(z)}{\mathcal{J}_I(0)}.

References

No references were extracted for this paper.

Paper details

vlnc:W_c4qhekxr
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents