betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Direct local parametrization of nuclear state densities using the back-shifted Bethe formula

Abstract

Level densities are often parametrized using the back-shifted Bethe formula (BBF) for nuclei that possess experimental data for s-wave neutron resonance average spacings and a complete discrete level sequence at low excitation energies. However, these parametrizations require the additional modeling of the dependence of the spin-cutoff parameter on excitation energy. Here we avoid the need to model the spin distribution of level densities by using the experimental data to parametrize directly the state densities, for which the BBF does not depend on the spin-cutoff parameter. This approach allows for a local parameterization of state densities that is independent of the spin-cutoff parameter. We provide these parameters in a tabulated form for applications in nuclear reaction calculations and for testing microscopic approaches to state densities.

Introduction

Nuclear level densities (NLDs) are important input to the Hauser-Feshbach theory [1] of compound nucleus reaction rates [2, 3, 4]. They are often parametrized in terms of the back-shifted Bethe formula [5, 6], also known as the back-shifted Fermi gas model, and assume a spin distribution which is described by the spin-cutoff model [7, 8, 9, 10]. However, this approach requires the modeling of the dependence of the spin-cutoff parameter, or alternatively the moment of inertia, on excitation energy. Furthermore, pairing correlations in even-even nuclei cause deviations of the spin distribution from the spin-cutoff model at sufficiently low excitation energies [11, 12].

In this work, we parametrize directly the state densities for nuclei that possess neutron resonance level spacings data and have a complete sequence of low-lying energy levels together with their spins. The advantage of this approach is that the BBF for the state density depends only on the single-particle level density parameter aa and the backshift parameter Δ\Delta but not on the spin-cutoff parameter σ\sigma. Thus, modeling of the dependence of σ\sigma (or alternatively the nuclear moment of inertia) on excitation energy is not needed.

The outline of this paper is as follows: In Sec. 2, we review Fermi gas models and the spin-cutoff model and discuss state densities vs. level densities. In Sec. 3, we present the method we use to determine the BBF state density parameters from experimental data. In Sec. 4 we present our results for 294 nuclei for which neutron resonance data and complete set of low-lying levels exist. Sec. 5 presents our conclusions.

Fermi gas models and spin-cutoff model

Fermi gas models

The Fermi gas formula for the state density is based on a thermodynamic approach to noninteracting fermions in the grand-canonical ensemble, in which the state density is calculated from the grand-canonical partition function in the saddle-point approximation. Assuming two kinds of fermions (i.e., protons and neutrons), the Fermi gas state density is given by [13]

ρ(E)=π12a−1/4E−5/4e2aE.(1)\rho(E) = \frac{\sqrt{\pi}}{12}a^{-1/4}E^{-5/4}e^{2\sqrt{aE}} . \tag*{(1)}

The parameter aa is given by a=π26[gp(ϵF(p))+gn(ϵF(n))]a = \frac{\pi^2}{6}[g_p(\epsilon_F^{(p)})+g_n(\epsilon_F^{(n)})], where gp(ϵ)g_p(\epsilon) is the single-particle level density of protons (neutrons) at energy ϵ\epsilon, and ϵF(p)\epsilon_F^{(p)} (ϵF(n)\epsilon_F^{(n)}) is the proton (neutron) Fermi energy. This formula is derived assuming Z≈NZ \approx N. For Z≠NZ \ne N, the state density is given by an equation similar to (1) but with an additional factor of g/(2gpgn)g/(2\sqrt{g_p g_n}) on its r.h.s. This factor is of the order of unity.

It is a challenge to calculate the level density in the presence of correlations, and most theoretical estimates are based on empirical modifications of the Fermi gas model to account for correlations. In particular, the BBF [5] is obtained from Bethe formula (1) by shifting the ground-state energy by Δ\Delta

ρ(Ex)=π12a−1/4(Ex−Δ)−5/4e2a(Ex−Δ).(2)\rho(E_x) = \frac{\sqrt{\pi}}{12}a^{-1/4}(E_x-\Delta)^{-5/4}e^{2\sqrt{a(E_x-\Delta)}} . \tag*{(2)}

The parameter Δ\Delta is known as the backshift parameter.

Shell effects can be taken into account through an energy dependence of the corresponding model’s parameters [14, 15]. The parameters are determined by fits of available experimental data in individual nuclei [16, 9, 17], which we will refer to as local fits, or by global fits [10, 17].

Spin-cutoff model

The spin-cutoff model can be derived by the random coupling of the single-particle spins [7, 8]. In this model, the distribution of the spin projection MM is a Gaussian

ρMρ=12πσe−M2/2σ2,(3)\frac{\rho_M}{\rho} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}\sigma}e^{-M^2/2\sigma^2} , \tag*{(3)}

where σ=⟨Jz2⟩1/2\sigma= \langle J_z^2\rangle^{1/2} is known as the spin-cutoff parameter. Using the equipartition theorem at temperature TT, we find

σ2=ITℏ2,(4)\sigma^2 = \frac{IT}{\hbar^2} , \tag*{(4)}

where TT is the thermodynamic temperature of the nucleus under consideration and II is the nuclear thermal moment of inertia.

The spin distribution ρJ\rho_J is determined from the spin projection distribution ρM\rho_M using ρJ=ρM=J−ρM=J+1≈−dρMdM∣M=J+1/2\rho_J = \rho_{M=J} - \rho_{M=J+1} \approx-\left.\frac{d\rho_M}{dM}\right|_{M=J+1/2}. Using Eq. (3) leads to the spin distribution in the spin-cutoff model

ρJρ=2J+122πσ3e−J(J+1)/2σ2.(5)\frac{\rho_J}{\rho} = \frac{2J+1}{2\sqrt{2\pi}\sigma^3}e^{-J(J+1)/2\sigma^2}. \tag*{(5)}

The spin-cutoff parameter σ\sigma given by Eq. (4) depends on the excitation energy through its dependence on temperature and moment of inertia II. At higher excitations, II approaches its rigid-body value [18]

Irig/ℏ2=ℏ−2(25MR2)≃0.0137A5/3 MeV−1,(6)I_{\mathrm{rig}}/\hbar^2 = \hbar^{-2}\left(\frac{2}{5}MR^2\right) \simeq0.0137A^{5/3}\ \mathrm{MeV}^{-1}, \tag*{(6)}

but pairing correlations suppresses its value in even-even nuclei at low excitation energies as confirmed in microscopic calculations based on the shell-model Monte Carlo (SMMC) method [11, 12]. Phenomenological models often assume a moment of inertia at a reduced value at low excitation energies that is interpolated to the rigid-body value at higher energies [17].

Microscopic SMMC calculations showed deviations from the spin-cutoff model in even-even nuclei at low energies in the form of an odd-even staggering effect in spin [11], which were confirmed in empirical studies [19].

State density versus level density

The state density is determined by counting the magnetic degeneracy 2J+12J+1 of each level with spin JJ, i.e.,

ρ(Ex)=∑J(2J+1)ρJ(Ex).(7)\rho(E_x) = \sum_J (2J+1)\rho_J(E_x). \tag*{(7)}

This relation is satisfied explicitly by the spin-cutoff formula (5) when the sum is replaced by an integral.

Experimentally the spin of measured levels is not always known, in which case energy levels can be counted without including their magnetic degeneracy. This leads to the level density ρ~(Ex)\tilde{\rho}(E_x)

ρ~(Ex)=∑JρJ(Ex).(8)\tilde{\rho}(E_x) = \sum_J \rho_J(E_x). \tag*{(8)}

In the spin-cutoff model, the level density is related to the state density by

ρ~(Ex)≈12πσρ(Ex),(9)\tilde{\rho}(E_x) \approx\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}\sigma}\rho(E_x), \tag*{(9)}

an expression derived by replacing the sum over JJ by an integral.

Method to determine state density parameters

The BBF has been used extensively to parametrize NLDs [20, 16]. The BBF for the state densities, Eq. (2), contains two parameters, aa and Δ\Delta that in the simplest approaches are taken as constants (i.e., independent of the excitation energy). An additional parameter that only appears in the level density is the spin cut-off parameter σ\sigma, which depends on excitation energy. In the works of Refs. [16, 21] aa and Δ\Delta are adjustable parameters and thus require two experimental data sets to be determined. One data set is the level counting at low energies assuming a complete set of levels is known, and a second data set, when available, is the neutron resonance average level spacing. The neutron resonances provide data at a single excitation energy that equals the neutron separation energy SnS_n. The spin-cutoff parameter is calculated from (4) in terms of the nuclear moment of inertia II. At higher excitation, the moment of inertia assumes its rigid-body value but at low excitations (i.e., in the counting regime), the moment of inertia II is suppressed by pairing correlations and some modeling of II as a function of excitation energy is required. Ref. [16] carried out fits for two values of the moment of inertia, IrigI_{\mathrm{rig}} and 0.5Irig0.5 I_{\mathrm{rig}} for about 200 nuclei with known neutron resonance and level counting data.

In this work, we use the BBF state density (instead of the BBF level density) which depends only on aa and Δ\Delta and does not require knowledge of the spin distribution or of the energy dependence of the spin-cutoff parameter (when the spin distribution is modeled by the spin-cutoff model).

To determine aa and Δ\Delta for a given nucleus, we use two experimental data sets: the neutron resonance average level spacing D0D_0 at the neutron separation energy SnS_n and a complete set of low-lying energy levels including their spin values.

Neutron-capture rates at relatively low energies are dominated by ss-wave resonances since higher partial waves are suppressed by the Coulomb barrier. The conversion of D0D_0 to state density at SnS_n requires knowledge of the spin/parity distribution of energy levels. At the neutron separation energy SnS_n, the spin distribution is usually well-described by the spin-cutoff model with rigid-body moment of inertia and the densities of positive and negative parity levels are equal. Denoting by I0I_0 the spin of the target nucleus, the total spin of the compound nucleus (target nucleus plus a neutron) is J=1/2J=1/2 for I0=0I_0=0 and J=I0±1/2J=I_0\pm1/2 for I0≠0I_0\ne0. The experimental state density of the compound nucleus at the neutron separation energy, ρexp⁡(Sn)\rho_{\exp}(S_n), can then be inferred from D0D_0 using the relation

2D0={ρ1/2(Sn)(I0=0)ρI0+1/2(Sn)+ρI0−1/2(Sn)(I0≠0),(10)\frac{2}{D_0} = \begin{cases} \rho_{1/2}(S_n) & (I_0=0) \\ \rho_{I_0+1/2}(S_n)+\rho_{I_0-1/2}(S_n) & (I_0\ne0), \end{cases} \tag*{(10)}

where ρJ(Ex)\rho_J(E_x) is the level density of the compound nucleus with spin JJ at excitation energy ExE_x. Assuming a spin-cutoff model (5) for ρJ\rho_J and a rigid-body moment of inertia in Eq. (4), Eq. (10) determines the total experimental state density ρexp⁡(Sn)\rho_{\exp}(S_n) at the neutron separation energy.

The second data set is a complete set of energy levels with known spin values at low excitation energies. Denoting by Nexp⁡(E)N_{\exp}(E) the cumulative number of experimental states (including the magnetic degeneracy factor of 2J+12J+1) up to excitation energy ExE_x, the total number of states between a lower excitation energy ElE_l and an upper excitation energy EuE_u is

∫ElEudE′ ρ(E′)=Nexp⁡(Eu)−Nexp⁡(El),(11)\int_{E_l}^{E_u} \mathrm{d}E'\,\rho(E')=N_{\exp}(E_u)-N_{\exp}(E_l), \tag*{(11)}

where the state density ρ(Ex)\rho(E_x) on the left hand side is the BBF (2). At very low excitation energies, the BBF breaks down, especially for positive Δ\Delta where ρ(Ex)\rho(E_x) has a singularity at Ex=ΔE_x=\Delta. The lower energy ElE_l is chosen such that the BBF is valid down to ElE_l, while the upper excitation energy EuE_u is chosen so that the spectrum below is complete (including spin values).

Eq. (11) together with ρ(Sn)=ρexp⁡(Sn)\rho(S_n)=\rho_{\exp}(S_n), where ρ(Ex)\rho(E_x) is the BBF (2) at excitation energy ExE_x, provide a set of two equations for the two unknowns aa and Δ\Delta. In this work we use the discrete level sequence and the average neutron resonance spacings data obtained from the most recent compilation of the Reference Input Parameter Library, RIPL-3 [22].

We find that numerical solution to aa is rather robust as its value is largely determined by the value of ρexp⁡(Sn)\rho_{\exp}(S_n). On the other hand, the numerical solution to Δ\Delta is quite sensitive to the chosen energy interval in the level counting regime. To obtain a suitable energy interval, we vary the lower bound ElE_l and upper bound EuE_u of the interval until a satisfactory agreement is reached between the BBF and the experimental state density in the level counting regime (which can be obtained by binning the states).

Results

In Table 1, we present the results of our approach in § 3 for 294 nuclei, for which neutron resonance data and complete set of low-lying levels exist. We display the values for the level density parameter aa and the back-shift parameter Δ\Delta, along with the ll–uu pairs that we have used to designate the lower and upper indices of nuclear levels used in Eq. (11). Figure 1 and Figure 2 show the distributions of aa and Δ\Delta values, respectively, as a function of mass number AA. Signatures of shell structure are clearly evident in the distribution of aa, and they become more pronounced for the heavier nuclei. The distribution of Δ\Delta aligns with the systematics of the pairing energies for even-even, odd-even, and odd-odd nuclei while also revealing shell effects.

Level density parameter a versus mass number A

Figure 1. Level density parameter aa vs. mass number AA. Our results (blue circles) are compared with those of Ref. [17] (red circles). The left panel displays the results of Ref. [17] for the parameter aa at the neutron resonance energy, i.e., a(Sn)a(S_n), while the right panel shows its asymptotic values, a~\tilde{a}.

Backshift parameter Delta versus mass number A

Figure 2. The backshift parameter Δ\Delta vs. mass number AA. Our results (solid symbols) are compared with those of Ref. [17] (open symbols). Up triangles represent the values for even-even nuclei, circles for odd-mass nuclei, and down triangles for odd-odd nuclei, respectively.

ZZNucl−ul-uaaΔ\DeltaZZNucl−ul-uaaΔ\Delta
1124Na^{24}\mathrm{Na}4-122.782-3.1393071Zn^{71}\mathrm{Zn}2-119.981-0.068
1225Mg^{25}\mathrm{Mg}6-242.777-1.6033170Ga^{70}\mathrm{Ga}4-109.248-0.960
1226Mg^{26}\mathrm{Mg}6-243.2881.3333172Ga^{72}\mathrm{Ga}2-109.403-1.759
1227Mg^{27}\mathrm{Mg}4-114.2250.5743271Ge^{71}\mathrm{Ge}3-79.678-0.688
1328Al^{28}\mathrm{Al}6-203.302-1.9773273Ge^{73}\mathrm{Ge}1-59.549-1.256
1429Si^{29}\mathrm{Si}3-163.4890.9663274Ge^{74}\mathrm{Ge}3-89.8930.694
1430Si^{30}\mathrm{Si}4-193.0651.2673275Ge^{75}\mathrm{Ge}6-109.640-0.706
1431Si^{31}\mathrm{Si}5-74.5030.8983277Ge^{77}\mathrm{Ge}3-69.404-0.997
1532P^{32}\mathrm{P}3-124.230-0.3213376As^{76}\mathrm{As}4-1410.358-1.695
1633S^{33}\mathrm{S}2-253.7730.1823475Se^{75}\mathrm{Se}2-510.220-1.070
1634S^{34}\mathrm{S}3-124.1741.9203477Se^{77}\mathrm{Se}3-1010.410-0.791
1635S^{35}\mathrm{S}4-65.1510.9053478Se^{78}\mathrm{Se}3-810.2410.869
1736Cl^{36}\mathrm{Cl}6-94.157-1.0353479Se^{79}\mathrm{Se}3-99.841-0.974
1738Cl^{38}\mathrm{Cl}4-95.590-0.8493481Se^{81}\mathrm{Se}8-2211.6310.774
1841Ar^{41}\mathrm{Ar}4-86.6400.7113483Se^{83}\mathrm{Se}2-510.455-0.352
1940K^{40}\mathrm{K}5-144.815-1.3713580Br^{80}\mathrm{Br}4-810.597-1.757
1942K^{42}\mathrm{K}4-114.636-2.9123582Br^{82}\mathrm{Br}2-810.917-0.907
2041Ca^{41}\mathrm{Ca}2-75.1930.1663679Kr^{79}\mathrm{Kr}8-1010.480-0.974
2043Ca^{43}\mathrm{Ca}3-135.664-0.7853681Kr^{81}\mathrm{Kr}4-611.256-0.544
2044Ca^{44}\mathrm{Ca}3-85.8570.9603684Kr^{84}\mathrm{Kr}3-68.8910.949
2045Ca^{45}\mathrm{Ca}5-105.927-0.6093685Kr^{85}\mathrm{Kr}3-119.9870.234
2146Sc^{46}\mathrm{Sc}5-115.861-2.0523687Kr^{87}\mathrm{Kr}3-610.2900.834
2247Ti^{47}\mathrm{Ti}2-65.186-1.0413786Rb^{86}\mathrm{Rb}2-89.317-0.847
2248Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ti}4-65.5600.4153788Rb^{88}\mathrm{Rb}5-1210.384-0.019
2249Ti^{49}\mathrm{Ti}5-136.150-0.0073885Sr^{85}\mathrm{Sr}5-710.870-0.267
2250Ti^{50}\mathrm{Ti}3-115.7121.4873887Sr^{87}\mathrm{Sr}2-89.4340.394
2251Ti^{51}\mathrm{Ti}3-165.9420.4733888Sr^{88}\mathrm{Sr}4-69.0392.105
2351V^{51}\mathrm{V}2-155.9980.5243889Sr^{89}\mathrm{Sr}3-59.9931.214
2352V^{52}\mathrm{V}5-96.214-1.2253990Y^{90}\mathrm{Y}2-59.024-0.514
2451Cr^{51}\mathrm{Cr}4-135.820-0.6324091Zr^{91}\mathrm{Zr}4-710.3160.862
2453Cr^{53}\mathrm{Cr}2-45.924-0.2774092Zr^{92}\mathrm{Zr}3-69.8440.975
2454Cr^{54}\mathrm{Cr}4-95.8750.8104093Zr^{93}\mathrm{Zr}3-511.3460.636
2455Cr^{55}\mathrm{Cr}2-76.220-0.8444094Zr^{94}\mathrm{Zr}3-711.2301.164
2556Mn^{56}\mathrm{Mn}9-176.609-1.6264095Zr^{95}\mathrm{Zr}3-711.7870.754
2655Fe^{55}\mathrm{Fe}2-55.634-0.5054097Zr^{97}\mathrm{Zr}2-711.9610.969
2657Fe^{57}\mathrm{Fe}3-66.255-0.5674194Nb^{94}\mathrm{Nb}3-1210.947-1.102
2658Fe^{58}\mathrm{Fe}3-86.1750.6024293Mo^{93}\mathrm{Mo}5-79.7240.220
2659Fe^{59}\mathrm{Fe}3-177.283-0.2984295Mo^{95}\mathrm{Mo}2-710.924-0.122
2760Co^{60}\mathrm{Co}4-106.929-1.6194296Mo^{96}\mathrm{Mo}3-711.4110.850
2859Ni^{59}\mathrm{Ni}4-86.222-0.4574297Mo^{97}\mathrm{Mo}3-1011.846-0.165
2860Ni^{60}\mathrm{Ni}4-106.2410.8584298Mo^{98}\mathrm{Mo}4-812.5640.982
2861Ni^{61}\mathrm{Ni}5-126.852-0.4884299Mo^{99}\mathrm{Mo}3-1012.897-0.391
2862Ni^{62}\mathrm{Ni}7-96.5770.76342101Mo^{101}\mathrm{Mo}4-613.624-0.917
2863Ni^{63}\mathrm{Ni}2-87.8170.06643100Tc^{100}\mathrm{Tc}3-613.651-1.308
2865Ni^{65}\mathrm{Ni}3-58.2690.23444100Ru^{100}\mathrm{Ru}3-612.1500.727
2964Cu^{64}\mathrm{Cu}6-128.147-0.90244101Ru^{101}\mathrm{Ru}3-612.594-0.776
2966Cu^{66}\mathrm{Cu}2-77.996-1.23444102Ru^{102}\mathrm{Ru}4-713.1840.797
3066Zn^{66}\mathrm{Zn}4-138.442-0.57244103Ru^{103}\mathrm{Ru}3-613.392-0.890
3067Zn^{67}\mathrm{Zn}2-68.523-0.59144105Ru^{105}\mathrm{Ru}3-713.670-1.043
3068Zn^{68}\mathrm{Zn}3-98.4991.20945105Rh^{105}\mathrm{Rh}3-613.858-1.295
3069Zn^{69}\mathrm{Zn}3-69.169-0.28246105Pd^{105}\mathrm{Pd}3-712.575-0.730
ZZNucl−ul-uaaΔ\DeltaZZNucl−ul-uaaΔ\Delta
46106Pd{}^{106}\mathrm{Pd}5-813.6340.87757139La{}^{139}\mathrm{La}3-712.6370.145
46107Pd{}^{107}\mathrm{Pd}1-513.965-0.60857140La{}^{140}\mathrm{La}12-1814.923-0.418
46108Pd{}^{108}\mathrm{Pd}4-813.9970.84258137Ce{}^{137}\mathrm{Ce}3-916.3040.165
46109Pd{}^{109}\mathrm{Pd}1-614.558-0.80058141Ce{}^{141}\mathrm{Ce}3-915.4390.671
46111Pd{}^{111}\mathrm{Pd}5-1315.329-0.47758142Ce{}^{142}\mathrm{Ce}3-1115.8281.077
47108Ag{}^{108}\mathrm{Ag}2-513.843-1.25058143Ce{}^{143}\mathrm{Ce}5-1417.0250.276
47110Ag{}^{110}\mathrm{Ag}2-515.616-0.90759142Pr{}^{142}\mathrm{Pr}9-1615.244-0.287
48107Cd{}^{107}\mathrm{Cd}2-612.774-0.37560143Nd{}^{143}\mathrm{Nd}2-2515.9510.759
48109Cd{}^{109}\mathrm{Cd}6-914.247-0.19860144Nd{}^{144}\mathrm{Nd}6-1215.7191.225
48111Cd{}^{111}\mathrm{Cd}2-614.058-0.48960145Nd{}^{145}\mathrm{Nd}9-1216.7920.135
48112Cd{}^{112}\mathrm{Cd}4-814.0580.92060146Nd{}^{146}\mathrm{Nd}4-916.7240.843
48113Cd{}^{113}\mathrm{Cd}2-614.686-0.37560147Nd{}^{147}\mathrm{Nd}4-2018.2760.058
48114Cd{}^{114}\mathrm{Cd}3-914.7190.93660148Nd{}^{148}\mathrm{Nd}4-1119.2930.581
48115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}3-614.900-0.59660149Nd{}^{149}\mathrm{Nd}3-818.552-0.644
48117Cd{}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}2-813.466-0.84660151Nd{}^{151}\mathrm{Nd}3-717.159-0.932
49114In{}^{114}\mathrm{In}2-914.487-0.66161148Pm{}^{148}\mathrm{Pm}3-918.951-0.683
49116In{}^{116}\mathrm{In}2-515.525-0.62562145Sm{}^{145}\mathrm{Sm}5-1514.8110.569
50113Sn{}^{113}\mathrm{Sn}4-714.1270.30462148Sm{}^{148}\mathrm{Sm}3-817.1200.751
50115Sn{}^{115}\mathrm{Sn}4-614.3090.71162149Sm{}^{149}\mathrm{Sm}6-1319.086-0.196
50117Sn{}^{117}\mathrm{Sn}4-714.3010.45562150Sm{}^{150}\mathrm{Sm}4-1318.5470.638
50118Sn{}^{118}\mathrm{Sn}5-913.7731.28662151Sm{}^{151}\mathrm{Sm}5-1618.999-0.771
50119Sn{}^{119}\mathrm{Sn}4-714.0190.16762152Sm{}^{152}\mathrm{Sm}3-718.5540.322
50120Sn{}^{120}\mathrm{Sn}4-713.5101.19662153Sm{}^{153}\mathrm{Sm}3-717.848-1.053
50121Sn{}^{121}\mathrm{Sn}4-813.324-0.11162155Sm{}^{155}\mathrm{Sm}2-417.067-0.834
50123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn}3-1312.396-0.20963152Eu{}^{152}\mathrm{Eu}3-2020.385-1.221
50125Sn{}^{125}\mathrm{Sn}4-612.4770.06663153Eu{}^{153}\mathrm{Eu}2-1317.426-0.712
51122Sb{}^{122}\mathrm{Sb}2-714.553-1.26563154Eu{}^{154}\mathrm{Eu}3-1519.653-1.149
51124Sb{}^{124}\mathrm{Sb}3-813.766-1.46763155Eu{}^{155}\mathrm{Eu}5-1918.024-0.354
52123Te{}^{123}\mathrm{Te}3-614.767-0.34263156Eu{}^{156}\mathrm{Eu}3-1218.221-0.949
52124Te{}^{124}\mathrm{Te}5-914.7101.13464153Gd{}^{153}\mathrm{Gd}6-1519.399-0.825
52125Te{}^{125}\mathrm{Te}3-814.609-0.48264154Gd{}^{154}\mathrm{Gd}5-1316.8880.307
52126Te{}^{126}\mathrm{Te}4-614.4301.07964155Gd{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}8-1619.010-0.813
52127Te{}^{127}\mathrm{Te}3-713.556-0.54264156Gd{}^{156}\mathrm{Gd}6-918.5880.449
52129Te{}^{129}\mathrm{Te}3-712.651-0.62464157Gd{}^{157}\mathrm{Gd}3-1018.463-0.632
52131Te{}^{131}\mathrm{Te}4-1514.1490.12664158Gd{}^{158}\mathrm{Gd}4-1217.9480.315
53128I{}^{128}\mathrm{I}2-714.517-1.24064159Gd{}^{159}\mathrm{Gd}3-817.354-0.856
53130I{}^{130}\mathrm{I}12-1614.255-1.38264161Gd{}^{161}\mathrm{Gd}3-617.677-0.448
54129Xe{}^{129}\mathrm{Xe}4-1013.966-0.52465160Tb{}^{160}\mathrm{Tb}2-718.756-0.948
54130Xe{}^{130}\mathrm{Xe}4-714.3320.96666157Dy{}^{157}\mathrm{Dy}8-1520.923-0.616
54131Xe{}^{131}\mathrm{Xe}3-1215.516-0.19866159Dy{}^{159}\mathrm{Dy}3-918.008-0.647
54132Xe{}^{132}\mathrm{Xe}3-513.6990.98966161Dy{}^{161}\mathrm{Dy}9-1918.564-0.615
54133Xe{}^{133}\mathrm{Xe}3-613.973-0.08166162Dy{}^{162}\mathrm{Dy}3-1518.1720.364
54135Xe{}^{135}\mathrm{Xe}6-1015.5850.76566163Dy{}^{163}\mathrm{Dy}3-817.605-0.663
54137Xe{}^{137}\mathrm{Xe}3-914.6320.56466164Dy{}^{164}\mathrm{Dy}4-1017.2690.138
55134Cs{}^{134}\mathrm{Cs}1-613.989-1.15766165Dy{}^{165}\mathrm{Dy}3-917.284-0.728
56131Ba{}^{131}\mathrm{Ba}3-515.198-0.44267166Ho{}^{166}\mathrm{Ho}3-1218.683-0.789
56133Ba{}^{133}\mathrm{Ba}6-1015.351-0.12668163Er{}^{163}\mathrm{Er}4-1219.633-0.691
56134Ba{}^{134}\mathrm{Ba}4-615.2211.15968165Er{}^{165}\mathrm{Er}3-818.310-0.781
56135Ba{}^{135}\mathrm{Ba}2-613.999-0.18268167Er{}^{167}\mathrm{Er}3-818.357-0.545
56136Ba{}^{136}\mathrm{Ba}4-813.8701.03268168Er{}^{168}\mathrm{Er}5-1117.6650.211
56137Ba{}^{137}\mathrm{Ba}6-1114.5831.07468169Er{}^{169}\mathrm{Er}3-1517.776-0.554
56138Ba{}^{138}\mathrm{Ba}6-1012.1761.27269171Tm{}^{171}\mathrm{Tm}3-1117.935-0.540
56139Ba{}^{139}\mathrm{Ba}4-713.5000.47369170Tm{}^{170}\mathrm{Tm}5-1319.132-0.656
ZZNucl−ul-uaaΔ\DeltaZZNucl−ul-uaaΔ\Delta
69171Tm{}^{171}\mathrm{Tm}3-818.686-0.28580200Hg{}^{200}\mathrm{Hg}5-1316.4070.799
70169Yb{}^{169}\mathrm{Yb}7-2320.296-0.37880201Hg{}^{201}\mathrm{Hg}6-815.188-0.618
70170Yb{}^{170}\mathrm{Yb}6-1618.0950.36080202Hg{}^{202}\mathrm{Hg}4-915.3230.525
70171Yb{}^{171}\mathrm{Yb}3-1618.033-0.63481204Tl{}^{204}\mathrm{Tl}2-714.220-0.443
70172Yb{}^{172}\mathrm{Yb}6-1518.8130.43881206Tl{}^{206}\mathrm{Tl}2-512.3590.054
70173Yb{}^{173}\mathrm{Yb}3-917.618-0.51882205Pb{}^{205}\mathrm{Pb}5-814.0320.208
70174Yb{}^{174}\mathrm{Yb}8-1518.8710.70782207Pb{}^{207}\mathrm{Pb}5-1913.4972.088
70175Yb{}^{175}\mathrm{Yb}4-817.376-0.50382208Pb{}^{208}\mathrm{Pb}2-1512.2342.607
70177Yb{}^{177}\mathrm{Yb}4-1317.497-0.55982209Pb{}^{209}\mathrm{Pb}7-2618.2602.247
71176Lu{}^{176}\mathrm{Lu}7-1919.433-0.63883210Bi{}^{210}\mathrm{Bi}8-1712.842-0.238
71177Lu{}^{177}\mathrm{Lu}6-1219.466-0.22788227Ra{}^{227}\mathrm{Ra}2-825.419-0.564
72175Hf{}^{175}\mathrm{Hf}2-718.928-0.64290229Th{}^{229}\mathrm{Th}5-1626.364-0.644
72177Hf{}^{177}\mathrm{Hf}5-1219.371-0.40890230Th{}^{230}\mathrm{Th}6-1224.5610.130
72178Hf{}^{178}\mathrm{Hf}4-819.5150.45790231Th{}^{231}\mathrm{Th}4-1526.363-0.428
72179Hf{}^{179}\mathrm{Hf}2-819.148-0.35290233Th{}^{233}\mathrm{Th}4-1826.419-0.463
72180Hf{}^{180}\mathrm{Hf}4-1218.3900.25491233Pa{}^{233}\mathrm{Pa}3-524.158-0.641
72181Hf{}^{181}\mathrm{Hf}3-1019.573-0.25592233U{}^{233}\mathrm{U}3-1225.623-0.420
73181Ta{}^{181}\mathrm{Ta}20-2720.1980.30192234U{}^{234}\mathrm{U}8-1525.3870.316
73182Ta{}^{182}\mathrm{Ta}5-1019.524-0.73792235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U}4-1025.032-0.553
73183Ta{}^{183}\mathrm{Ta}3-819.7390.02092236U{}^{236}\mathrm{U}6-1026.1410.288
74181W{}^{181}\mathrm{W}3-819.371-0.44492237U{}^{237}\mathrm{U}4-1225.881-0.374
74183W{}^{183}\mathrm{W}3-1018.777-0.42692238U{}^{238}\mathrm{U}5-925.9460.273
74184W{}^{184}\mathrm{W}3-1319.5140.45092239U{}^{239}\mathrm{U}2-526.527-0.340
74185W{}^{185}\mathrm{W}12-1820.437-0.07793237Np{}^{237}\mathrm{Np}3-922.231-0.638
74187W{}^{187}\mathrm{W}5-819.844-0.39993238Np{}^{238}\mathrm{Np}4-1026.788-0.596
75186Re{}^{186}\mathrm{Re}3-1220.378-0.66193239Np{}^{239}\mathrm{Np}3-825.668-0.493
75188Re{}^{188}\mathrm{Re}3-1520.819-0.65094239Pu{}^{239}\mathrm{Pu}3-925.413-0.292
76187Os{}^{187}\mathrm{Os}10-2019.695-0.48194240Pu{}^{240}\mathrm{Pu}4-1125.6300.282
76188Os{}^{188}\mathrm{Os}6-920.2110.68794241Pu{}^{241}\mathrm{Pu}4-925.613-0.395
76189Os{}^{189}\mathrm{Os}11-1620.180-0.33494242Pu{}^{242}\mathrm{Pu}4-626.0000.259
76190Os{}^{190}\mathrm{Os}3-719.9230.52894243Pu{}^{243}\mathrm{Pu}5-1026.931-0.252
76191Os{}^{191}\mathrm{Os}5-2219.556-0.49194245Pu{}^{245}\mathrm{Pu}7-1529.5750.224
76193Os{}^{193}\mathrm{Os}2-819.791-0.25595242Am{}^{242}\mathrm{Am}4-727.206-0.444
77192Ir{}^{192}\mathrm{Ir}4-1520.801-0.91795243Am{}^{243}\mathrm{Am}3-924.756-0.542
77193Ir{}^{193}\mathrm{Ir}2-920.144-0.32795244Am{}^{244}\mathrm{Am}3-727.708-0.369
77194Ir{}^{194}\mathrm{Ir}3-620.445-0.63096243Cm{}^{243}\mathrm{Cm}4-824.014-0.384
78193Pt{}^{193}\mathrm{Pt}2-519.878-0.43596245Cm{}^{245}\mathrm{Cm}3-825.465-0.237
78195Pt{}^{195}\mathrm{Pt}2-718.554-0.50096246Cm{}^{246}\mathrm{Cm}5-1026.4150.543
78196Pt{}^{196}\mathrm{Pt}4-818.5840.70896247Cm{}^{247}\mathrm{Cm}3-724.305-0.408
78197Pt{}^{197}\mathrm{Pt}3-1116.805-0.52396248Cm{}^{248}\mathrm{Cm}5-1026.0150.500
78199Pt{}^{199}\mathrm{Pt}3-1018.021-0.29896249Cm{}^{249}\mathrm{Cm}4-1026.039-0.399
79198Au{}^{198}\mathrm{Au}3-1217.922-0.65597250Bk{}^{250}\mathrm{Bk}3-926.605-0.731
80199Hg{}^{199}\mathrm{Hg}3-917.675-0.21198250Cf{}^{250}\mathrm{Cf}5-1025.5970.527

Table 1. BBF state density parameters aa and Δ\Delta, and l−ul-u pairs used in the parametrization (see text).

We compare our methodology with the local parametrization of the back-shifted Fermi gas model described by Koning et al. [17] across 287 nuclei analyzed by both methods. While both approaches share the use of the back-shifted Fermi gas model, the approach of Ref. [17] differs from ours in several significant aspects. Most importantly, it considers in the fits the level density which requires the modeling of the energy dependence of the spin-cutoff parameter at low excitations while our approach uses the BBF for the state density which is independent of σ\sigma. In addition, Ref. [17] incorporating an energy-dependent level density parameter aa, and implementing a modification of the BBF proposed by Grossjean and Feldmeier [23, 24] to empirically address the divergent behavior of the Fermi gas model at very low excitation energies. We note that at higher values of ExE_x, this correction becomes negligible, and the standard form of the BBF is reinstated.

In Figure 1 we compare our results for aa as a function of AA (blue circles) with the results of Ref. [17] (red circles). In the left panel we compare our results with those of Ref. [17] for a(Sn)a(S_n), the values of aa at the neutron separation energy SnS_n. We find close agreement and clear signatures of shell structure. In the right panel we compare our results with the asymptotic values a~\tilde{a} of Ref. [17]. We observe discrepancies around shell closures, as shell effects decay by design in Ref. [17].

In Figure 2, we compare the two approaches in terms of the distribution of Δ\Delta as a function of mass number AA. While we observe qualitative agreement between the two approaches regarding mass dependence, odd-even effects, and the signature of shell effects, there are noticeable variations for individual nuclei. These variations are expected, given that the values of Δ\Delta are significantly influenced by low-energy level counting regime, the consideration of which stands as the most noteworthy difference between our methodology and that of Ref. [17].

To assess the deviation between the state density estimates of the two approaches, we calculated the maximum order of magnitude deviation (max-OMD), defined as the maximum value of ∣log⁡10ρ(Ex)ρ′(Ex)∣\left|\log_{10}\frac{\rho(E_x)}{\rho'(E_x)}\right| in the excitation energy interval 0≤Ex≤100 \leq E_x \leq10 MeV. Here, ρ(Ex)\rho(E_x) is the BBF state density in our approach, and ρ′(Ex)\rho'(E_x) is the state density according to Ref. [17].

It is important to note that, unlike Ref. [17], we have not employed the Grossjean-Feldmeier modification [23]. This makes our approach susceptible to divergent behavior at low excitation energies when ExE_x approaches Δ\Delta. To address this, we have limited the comparison of the two approaches to energies where the BBF exhibits monotonic behavior with respect to ExE_x.

We have found the max-OMD values to be below 0.25 for 185 nuclei, between 0.25 and 0.5 for 79 nuclei, and exceeding 0.5 for only 23 nuclei. Figure 3 illustrates the state densities of the top 15 nuclei possessing the largest max-OMD values anywhere in the interval 0≤Ex≤100 \le E_x \le10. The plot also includes the experimental state densities obtained from state counting data (red histograms) and neutron resonance data (red triangle). Deviations between the two approaches are mostly due to discrepancies at the state counting regime (243Cm{}^{243}\mathrm{Cm}) or at the neutron resonance (85Kr{}^{85}\mathrm{Kr}), and in some cases, at both (38Cl{}^{38}\mathrm{Cl} and 152Sm{}^{152}\mathrm{Sm}). In most of the nuclei shown, we observe that the approach of Ref. [17] underestimates the state density at the level counting regime. However, the difference with our state density estimates becomes less significant at higher excitation energies.

Figure 3. State densities ρ(Ex)\rho(E_x) vs. excitation energy ExE_x, comparing of our results (solid lines) with the locally parametrized back-shifted Fermi gas model of Ref. [17] (dashed lines). We show the top 15 nuclei for which the deviations between the two approaches (as measured by max-OMD) are the highest anywhere in the excitation energy interval 0≤Ex≤100 \leq E_x \leq10 MeV. We also show state counting data (red histograms) and neutron resonance data (red triangles).

Conclusions

We carried out a local parametrization of the BBF state densities for all 294 nuclei for which neutron resonance data and a complete set of low-lying levels with their spin values exist. In comparison to other local parametrization of level densities, the novelty of our method is that we determine the two BBF parameters, aa and Δ\Delta, directly from experimental data using the BBF for state densities. Other local parameterizations in the literature use the BBF level densities which includes an additional parameter, the spin cutoff parameter σ\sigma, and thus requires a modeling of its dependence on excitation energy.

Knowledge of the spin distribution is required to convert the measured average neutron resonance spacing D0D_0 to the total state density ρexp⁡(Sn)\rho_{\exp}(S_n) at the neutron separation energy. However, at the neutron separation energy it is usually safe to assume a spin-cutoff distribution with a rigid-body moment of inertia. In contrast, using the BBF for the level density requires the modeling of the dependence of the spin-cutoff parameter σ\sigma on excitation energy at low excitation energies.

We tabulated our results for the parameters aa and Δ\Delta so that the corresponding BBF state densities can be used to benchmark the experimental results against state densities calculated by various theoretical models.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported in part by the U.S. DOE grant No. DE-SC0019521.

References

  1. [1]W. Hauser and H. Feshbach, Phys. Rev. 87, 366 (1952).
  2. [2]E.M. Burbidge, G.R. Burbidge, W.A. Fowler, and F. Hoyle, Rev. Mod. Phys. 29, 547 (1957); J.J. Cowan, F.-K. Thielemann, and J.W. Truran, Phys. Rep. 208, 267 (1991).
  3. [3]T. Rauscher and F.K. Thielemann, Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables 75, 1 (2000).
  4. [4]A. J. Koning and D. Rochman, Nucl. Data Sheets 113, 2841 (2012).
  5. [5]J. R. Huizenga, H. K. Vonach, A. A. Katsanos, A. J. Gorski, and C. J. Stephan, Phys. Rev. 182, 1149 (1969).
  6. [6]J R Huizenga, and L G Moretto, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 22, 427 (1972).
  7. [7]H.A. Bethe, Rev. Mod. Phys. 9, 69 (1937).
  8. [8]T. Ericson, Adv. Phys. 9, 425 (1960).
  9. [9]A.S. Ijilnov et. al., Nucl. Phys. A 543, 517 (1992).
  10. [10]T. Rauscher, F.-K. Thielemann, and K.L. Kratz, Phys. Rev. C 56, 1613 (1997).
  11. [11]Y. Alhassid, S. Liu and H. Nakada, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 162504 (2007).
  12. [12]Y. Alhassid, G.F. Bertsch, L. Fang and S. Liu, Phys. Rev. C 72, 064326 (2005).
  13. [13]H.A. Bethe, Phys. Rev. 50, 332 (1936).
  14. [14]A.V. Ignatyuk, G.M. Smirenkin, and A.S. Tishin, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 21, 255 (1975).
  15. [15]S.K. Kataria, V.S. Ramamurthy and S.S. Kappor, Phys. Rev. C 18 549 (1978).
  16. [16]W. Dilg, W. Schantl , H. Vonach, and M. Uhl, Nucl. Phys. A 217, 269 (1973).
  17. [17]A.J. Koning, S. Hilaire, and S. Goriely, Nucl. Phys. A 810, 13 (2008).
  18. [18]A. Bohr and B. R. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure (Benjamin, New York, 1969).
  19. [19]T. von Egidy and D. Bucurescu, Phys. Rev. C 78, 051301(R) (2008).
  20. [20]A. Gilbert and A.G.W. Cameron, Can. J. Phys 43, 1446 (1965).
  21. [21]T. von Egidy, H.H. Schmidt, and A.N.Behkami, Nucl. Phys. A 481, 189 (1988).
  22. [22]R. Capote et. al., Nucl. Data Sheets 110, 3107 (2009).
  23. [23]M.K. Grossjean, H. Feldmeier, Nucl. Phys. A 444 113 (1985).
  24. [24]P. Demetriou and S. Goriely, Nucl. Phys. A 695, 95 (2001).

Paper details

vlnc:W_c5gfv4ua
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 5

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents