betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Quadrupole-Octupole Residual Interaction in the Proxy-SU(3)SU(3) Scheme

Abstract

The octupole deformation of atomic nuclei is a relevant research area given its implications in the nuclear structure and fundamental physics, however, inclusion of octupole degrees of freedom in the nuclear interaction has been explored little in SU(3)SU(3) symmetry-based models. In this article we expand the octupole operator Oμ3\mathcal{O}^3_μ in the SU(3)SU(3) second quantization formalism and use it to formulate an octupole-octupole residual interaction O3⋅O3\mathcal{O}^3\cdot \mathcal{O}^3 which is incorporated in Elliott's model Hamiltonian. We compute the matrix elements of this extended Hamiltonian and use them to calculate energy levels and analyse the B(E3;31−→01+)B(E3; 3^-_1\rightarrow 0^+_1) transition strength of the isotope 224^{224}Th using the semi-microscopic algebraic quartet model (SAQM) based on the proxy-SU(3)SU(3) scheme.

INTRODUCTION

The atomic nucleus is a primary component of ordinary matter and its structure is one of the main subjects of study in quantum mechanics. Since the nucleus is an extended body, it is a legitimate area of research to investigate its geometrical shape [1–3], the interactions influencing it [4] and its variation across isotopes as well as between excited states [5, 6]. It is known that some nuclei organize in spherical shapes while others lower its energy through deformation. This phenomenon is described theoretically using the multipole moments where the most relevant for the atomic nucleus are the first four, viz. dipole (Q1Q_{1}), quadrupole (Q2Q_{2}), octupole (Q3Q_{3}) and hexadecapole (Q4Q_{4}) moments.

Over the years, several non-zero values of electric quadrupole moments have been reported [7] which indicate axially symmetric ellipsoidal deformations of the nucleus. Negative values correspond to oblate deformations while positive ones to prolate deformations, with a clear prolate dominance observed across all nuclei [4, 8]. The largest quadrupole values are generally found in half-filled shells defined by the magic numbers 2, 8, 20, 28, 50, 82, and 126. This breaking of spherical symmetry allows for rotational degrees of freedom to populate excited states observed as characteristic energy level patterns called rotational bands.

For certain configurations of proton (ZZ) and neutron (NN) numbers around ≈\approx 34, 56, 88, and 134 [9], the nucleus lowers its energy further through a static octupole deformation [10, 11]. This combined with a prolate quadrupole moment gives the nucleus a so-called “pear shape” [12, 13]. Such mirror asymmetric shape causes a displacement between the centers of charge and mass, creating an electric dipole moment as well. Although few direct measurements of the Q3Q_{3} moments have been reported in the literature, certain low energy spectra, enhanced E3E3 and E1E1 transition probabilities serve as indirect indicators of octupole deformation [9].

In particular, for even-even nuclei, the presence of a negative parity band LΠ=1−,3−,5−,…L^{\Pi}=1^{-},3^{-},5^{-},\ldots near the ground state band LΠ=0+,2+,4+,…L^{\Pi}=0^{+},2^{+},4^{+},\ldots is a characteristic spectrum of “pear shape” deformation along with enhanced 31−→01+3_{1}^{-}\to0_{1}^{+} and 11−→01+1_{1}^{-}\to0_{1}^{+} transitions. In Figure 1 are shown the energies of the lowest 11−1_{1}^{-} and 31−3_{1}^{-} excited states for even-even nuclei. It can be observed that the lowest values are found in the actinide region for the isotopes 224Ra{}^{224}\mathrm{Ra}, 224Th{}^{224}\mathrm{Th}, 226Th{}^{226}\mathrm{Th}, 222Ra{}^{222}\mathrm{Ra}, 226Ra{}^{226}\mathrm{Ra} and 228Th{}^{228}\mathrm{Th} in increasing order up to 0.4MeV0.4\mathrm{MeV}. In Figure 2 are shown the evaluated B(E3;31−→01+)B(E3;3_{1}^{-}\to0_{1}^{+}) values where a maximum can be found around that region. Previous calculations [14] with relativistic Hartree–Bogoliubov (RHB) theory predicted stable octupole deformations for isotopes 222–226Ra{}^{222\text{–}226}\mathrm{Ra} and 224–228Th{}^{224\text{–}228}\mathrm{Th} suggesting them as the best even-even candidates for research on “pear shape” deformation.

Lowest 1− (left) and 3− (right) energy levels in even-even nuclei

Figure 1. Lowest 1−1^{-} (left) and 3−3^{-} (right) energy levels in even-even nuclei reported in ENSDF [24].

Evaluated B(E3) values in even-even nuclei

Figure 2. Evaluated B(E3)B(E3) values in even-even nuclei reported in ENSDF [24]. The vertical lines indicate the octupole magic numbers obtained in [25].

One of the main interests of studying octupole collectivity in nuclei goes further than the nuclear structure itself, having implications in the strong nuclear interaction and the symmetries of nature [15, 16]. Experimental efforts are being made to measure Q1Q_{1}, Q3Q_{3} and E3E3 transitions that will provide more insight about fundamental physics [18] [17]. In this article we continue the work on the isotope 224Th{}^{224}\mathrm{Th} in the semi-microscopic algebraic quartet model (SAQM) [19] based on the proxy-SU(3)SU(3) scheme [20, 21] started in [22, 23] by including a residual octupole-octupole interaction in Elliott’s Hamiltonian. An analysis of octupole effective charges and B(E3;31−→01+)B(E3;3_{1}^{-}\to0_{1}^{+}) transition are made as well. We begin explaining the two-shell model space of the system required for the residual octupole interaction to be defined, then show the expansion of the octupole operator in terms of SU(3)SU(3) irreducible tensors and the calculations for the low-energy spectrum of 224Th{}^{224}\mathrm{Th} along comparison with observed energy levels.

MODEL SPACE

Since the octupole operator r3Yμ3(Ω)r^{3}Y_{\mu}^{3}(\Omega) has negative parity, at least two consecutive shells are required for its minimal realization [26]. We will focus on heavy even-even nuclei in the actinide region so that proton (π\pi) and neutron (ν\nu) degrees of freedom must be distinguished. These two statements imply that the full model space has to be composed of two-shells which represent the valence and excited shells states for each proton and neutron spaces (ηπ=5,6\eta_{\pi}=5,6 and ην=6,7\eta_{\nu}=6,7 respectively) along with their couplings to total irreducible representations (irreps).

The spectrum generating algebra (SGA) [27] will be U(2(Ωσ−+Ωσ+))U(2(\Omega_{\sigma-}+\Omega_{\sigma+})) for each proton and neutron spaces where σ=π,ν\sigma=\pi,\nu, the sub-indexes −- and ++ indicate lower and upper shells respectively and Ω=(η+1)(η+2)/2\Omega=(\eta+1)(\eta+2)/2. Since nucleons are fermions, their SGA irreps must be totally anti-symmetric given by {1Nσ}\{1^{N_{\sigma}}\} where NσN_{\sigma} represents the number of particles. This algebra can be separated into spin and spatial parts as a product {U(Ωσ−)⊗U(Ωσ+)}⊗{SUσ−(2)⊗SUσ+(2)}\left\{U(\Omega_{\sigma-})\otimes U(\Omega_{\sigma+})\right\}\otimes\left\{SU_{\sigma-}(2)\otimes SU_{\sigma+}(2)\right\}. The corresponding spatial representations will be denoted as [f]σ−⊗[f]σ+[f]_{\sigma-}\otimes[f]_{\sigma+}.

In the SAQM, the ground state (0ℏω0\hbar\omega) will be given by setting the upper shell empty in a configuration like [2I]σ−⊗[0]σ+[2^{I}]_{\sigma-}\otimes[0]_{\sigma+} where II denotes the number of quartets [19, 22]. Excited (1ℏω1\hbar\omega) states will be given by occupying one orbital in the excited shell in the proton or neutron space (not simultaneously) denoted as [2I−1,1]σ−⊗[0]σ+[2^{I-1},1]_{\sigma-}\otimes[0]_{\sigma+}. These irreps guarantee that the quartet symmetry [4I][4^{I}] for the total proton-neutron space is maintained. The U(2)U(2) spin irreps are the conjugates [fˉ]σ−⊗[fˉ]σ+[\bar{f}]_{\sigma-}\otimes[\bar{f}]_{\sigma+} from which the spins of each shell Sσ−⊗Sσ+S_{\sigma-}\otimes S_{\sigma+} can be obtained along with the total coupling to spin Sσ=0S_{\sigma}=0 by means of regular angular momentum coupling methods. The total nuclear spin SS is obtained straightforwardly as well. The next step in defining the nuclear state is the reduction of the spatial algebras into trivial algebras. The proxy-SU(3)SU(3) requires such reduction to include SU(3)SU(3) which can be done by solving the branching problem U(Ω)⊃SU(3)U(\Omega) \supset SU(3) [28]. This decomposition has to be performed independently for each shell involved in the model, i.e, U(Ωσ−)⊗U(Ωσ+)⊃α−SU(3)σ−⊗α+SU(3)σ+U(\Omega_{\sigma-}) \otimes U(\Omega_{\sigma+}) \supset\alpha_{-}SU(3)_{\sigma-} \otimes\alpha_{+}SU(3)_{\sigma+} where the α\alpha represent multiplicities. The total nucleon irreps ρσ(λ,μ)σ\rho_{\sigma}(\lambda,\mu)_{\sigma} where ρσ\rho_{\sigma} represent the multiplicities arises from the irreps in the Kronecker product (λ,μ)σ−⊗(λ,μ)σ+(\lambda,\mu)_{\sigma-} \otimes(\lambda,\mu)_{\sigma+}. Then, in a similar way the total nucleus irreps ρ(λ,μ)\rho(\lambda,\mu) are obtained from the Kronecker product (λ,μ)π⊗(λ,μ)ν(\lambda,\mu)_{\pi} \otimes(\lambda,\mu)_{\nu}. The physical basis decomposition SU(3)⊃SO(3)SU(3) \supset SO(3) is adopted in the subsequent branching in order to obtain the total orbital angular momentum LL.

Recall that the step SU(3)⊃SO(3)SU(3) \supset SO(3) is non-canonical so that an additional label KK appears that accounts for the multiplicities of LL in a given irrep (λ,μ)(\lambda,\mu) [29]. This quantum number is usually called Elliott label which is used to denote rotational bands and its values are K=min⁡(λ,μ),min⁡(λ,μ)−2,min⁡(λ,μ)−4,…,0K=\min(\lambda,\mu),\min(\lambda,\mu)-2,\min(\lambda,\mu)-4,\ldots,0 or 11 from which the Vergados label χˉ\bar{\chi} is obtained by orthogonalization [30]. The final coupling involves the product of total orbital angular momentum LL and total spin SS which form the total angular momentum JJ and its projection MM.

The algebra chain and the corresponding state can be seen in equations (1) and (2) respectively. For convenience reasons, the state will be denoted sometimes as ∣Ψπ+ν⟩=∣Ω;J,M⟩|\Psi_{\pi+\nu}\rangle=|\Omega;J,M\rangle where the label Ω\Omega encompasses all quantum numbers of higher algebras than those of total angular momentum SUJ(2)SU_J(2) and its projection UM(1)U_M(1).

U(2(Ωπ−+Ωπ+))⊗U(2(Ων−+Ων+))⊃{[(U(Ωπ−)⊗U(Ωπ+))⊃(SUπ−(3)⊗SUπ+(3))⊃SUπ(3))⊗((SUπ−(2)⊗SUπ+(2))⊃SUπ(2))]⊗[(U(Ων−)⊗U(Ων+))⊃(SUν−(3)⊗SUν+(3))⊃SUν(3))⊗((SUν−(2)⊗SUν+(2))⊃SUν(2))]}⊃{[SU(3)π+ν⊃SOπ+ν(3)]⊗SUπ+ν(2)⊃SUJ(2)⊃UM(1)},(1)\begin{aligned} U(2(\Omega_{\pi-}+\Omega_{\pi+}))\otimes U(2(\Omega_{\nu-}+\Omega_{\nu+})) &\supset\\ &\left\{\left[\left(U(\Omega_{\pi-})\otimes U(\Omega_{\pi+}))\supset(SU_{\pi-}(3)\otimes SU_{\pi+}(3))\supset SU_{\pi}(3)\right)\otimes\left((SU_{\pi-}(2)\otimes SU_{\pi+}(2))\supset SU_{\pi}(2)\right)\right]\right.\\ &\left.\otimes\left[\left(U(\Omega_{\nu-})\otimes U(\Omega_{\nu+}))\supset(SU_{\nu-}(3)\otimes SU_{\nu+}(3))\supset SU_{\nu}(3)\right)\otimes\left((SU_{\nu-}(2)\otimes SU_{\nu+}(2))\supset SU_{\nu}(2)\right)\right]\right\}\\ &\supset\left\{\left[SU(3)_{\pi+\nu}\supset SO_{\pi+\nu}(3)\right]\otimes SU_{\pi+\nu}(2)\supset SU_J(2)\supset U_M(1)\right\}, \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}
∣Ψπ+ν⟩={[1Nπ],[fπ−]⊗[fπ+],απ−(λ,μ)π−⊗απ+(λ,μ)π+;ρπ(λ,μ)π,Sπ−⊗Sπ+;Sπ}⊗{[1Nν],[fν−]⊗[fν+],αν−(λ,μ)ν−⊗αν+(λ,μ)ν+;ρν(λ,μ)ν,Sν−⊗Sν+;Sν};ρ(λ,μ),K,L,S;J,M.(2)\begin{aligned} |\Psi_{\pi+\nu}\rangle={}&\left\{\left[1^{N_{\pi}}\right],[f_{\pi-}]\otimes[f_{\pi+}],\alpha_{\pi-}(\lambda,\mu)_{\pi-}\otimes\alpha_{\pi+}(\lambda,\mu)_{\pi+};\rho_{\pi}(\lambda,\mu)_{\pi},S_{\pi-}\otimes S_{\pi+};S_{\pi}\right\}\\ &\otimes\left\{\left[1^{N_{\nu}}\right],[f_{\nu-}]\otimes[f_{\nu+}],\alpha_{\nu-}(\lambda,\mu)_{\nu-}\otimes\alpha_{\nu+}(\lambda,\mu)_{\nu+};\rho_{\nu}(\lambda,\mu)_{\nu},S_{\nu-}\otimes S_{\nu+};S_{\nu}\right\};\\ &\rho(\lambda,\mu),K,L,S;J,M. \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

OCTUPOLE OPERATOR

The octupole operator is defined as a sum of proton and neutron contributions

Oμ3=Oπμ3+Oνμ3,(3)\mathcal{O}^{3}_{\mu}=\mathcal{O}^{3}_{\pi\mu}+\mathcal{O}^{3}_{\nu\mu}, \tag*{(3)}

with the single nucleon term given by

Oσμ3=∑i=1Z(N)rσ3(i)Yμ3(r^σ(i)),(4)\mathcal{O}^{3}_{\sigma\mu}=\sum_{i=1}^{Z(N)}r^{3}_{\sigma}(i)Y^{3}_{\mu}(\hat{r}_{\sigma}(i)), \tag*{(4)}

where σ=π,ν\sigma=\pi,\nu. Following the methodology in [23], the mathematical form of the operator in terms of one-body SU(3)SU(3) tensors is given by equation 5 where the expansion coefficients VσLσ=3\mathcal{V}^{L_{\sigma}=3}_{\sigma} are displayed in Table I. These coefficients condense the products of SUJ(2)SU_J(2) reduced matrix elements [31] and coupling coefficients. Notice that the sum over η,η′\eta,\eta' runs over the two shells where the operator is defined; these are 5,6 and 6,7 for the proton and neutron cases respectively.

(λo,μo)(\lambda_o,\mu_o)(6,7),(7,6)(6,7),(7,6)(5,6),(6,5)(5,6),(6,5)(4,5),(5,4)(4,5),(5,4)(3,4),(4,3)(3,4),(4,3)(2,3),(3,2)(2,3),(3,2)(1,2),(2,1)(1,2),(2,1)
KoK_o02130213021
νπ3\nu_{\pi}^{3}9.7515-9.9778-5.14845.8693-7.272713.101216.0658-7.16070.2676
νν3\nu_{\nu}^{3}2.2092-16.02251.6038-8.1959-6.615515.1021-2.677215.848222.1137-14.1431-5.3526

Table I. Expansion coefficients νσLo=3(η,η′,λo,μo,Ko)\nu_{\sigma}^{L_o=3}(\eta,\eta',\lambda_o,\mu_o,K_o) of Oσμ3O^3_{\sigma\mu} for actinides.

OMoMoLσ=3=∑η,η′,(λo,μo),KoVσLσ=3(η,η′,λo,μo,Ko)×{a(η′,0)12†a(η,0)12}σ,Moρo=1,(λo,μo),Ko,Lo=Jo=3.(5)\mathcal{O}^{L_{\sigma}=3}_{\frac{M_{o}}{M_{o}}}=\sum_{\eta,\eta',(\lambda_{o},\mu_{o}),K_{o}}\mathcal{V}^{L_{\sigma}=3}_{\sigma}(\eta,\eta',\lambda_{o},\mu_{o},K_{o})\times\left\{a^{\dagger}_{(\eta',0)\frac{1}{2}}a_{(\eta,0)\frac{1}{2}}\right\}^{\rho_{o=1},(\lambda_{o},\mu_{o}),K_{o},L_{o}=J_{o}=3}_{\sigma,M_{o}}. \tag*{(5)}

The irrep (λo,μo)(\lambda_{o},\mu_{o}) arises from the Kronecker product between the single particle irreps (η′,0)⊗(0,η)(\eta',0)\otimes(0,\eta). A sum over the label KoK_{o} must be explicit since the angular momentum Lo=3L_{o}=3 may have several multiplicities in a single (λo,μo)(\lambda_{o},\mu_{o}) as indicated in Table I. Notice that the coefficients Vσ\mathcal{V}_{\sigma} of the irreps (λo,μo)(\lambda_{o},\mu_{o}) and (μo,λo)(\mu_{o},\lambda_{o}) are equal.

HAMILTONIAN AND MATRIX ELEMENTS

Elliott’s original model included a mean field and a residual quadrupole-quadrupole interaction in the nuclear Hamiltonian which accounted for collective excitations of nuclei. We include an octupole-octupole two-body residual term in order to consider such degree of freedom as well. This extended Hamiltonian is given by

H=ℏωn^+χQ2⋅Q2+τO3⋅O3−Hg.s.,(6)H = \hbar\omega\hat{n} + \chi Q^2 \cdot Q^2 + \tau O^3 \cdot O^3 - H_{\mathrm{g.s.}}, \tag*{(6)}

where the first term is the harmonic oscillator mean field with n^\hat{n} the U(3)U(3) Casimir operator of order 1 that accounts for the number of particles in the excited shell and the strength ℏω=45A−1/3−25A−2/3\hbar\omega= 45A^{-1/3}-25A^{-2/3} MeV. The second term represents the quadrupole residual interaction which in SU(3)SU(3) symmetry-based models is given by the relation Q2⋅Q2=4C2(λ,μ)−3L2Q^2 \cdot Q^2 = 4C^2(\lambda,\mu)-3L^2 with the SU(3)SU(3) Casimir operator of order two given by C2(λ,μ)=λ2+μ2+λμ+3(λ+μ)C^2(\lambda,\mu)=\lambda^2+\mu^2+\lambda\mu+3(\lambda+\mu) and the total orbital angular momentum denoted by LL. The third term is the octupole residual interaction which is constructed as a scalar product of the expansion in equation (5). The last term Hg.s.H_{\mathrm{g.s.}} is the energy eigenvalue of the ground state which sets it to 0 MeV. The parameters χ\chi and τ\tau are obtained from fitting procedure to experimental energy levels.

The reduced matrix elements (RME) of the term O3⋅O3O^3 \cdot O^3 are given by equation (7) where an identity ∑Ψη′′ν′′′′∣Ψη′′ν′′′′⟩⟨Ψη′′ν′′′′∣\sum_{\Psi''_{\eta''\nu''}}|\Psi''_{\eta''\nu''}\rangle\langle\Psi''_{\eta''\nu''}| had to be introduced and the tensor expansion of equation (5) was replaced explicitly. The RME on the right hand side of equation (7) can be computed with equation 10 of reference [32], which separates the proton and neutron spaces in products of recoupling coefficients and triple-barred RME. The later factors however, require an additional mathematical procedure for their calculation as explained in appendix A. Computer codes were developed for the calculation of these octupole interaction double-barred RME.

⟨Ω;J∥O3⋅O3∥Ω′;J′⟩=∑σ,σ′(−1)J+J′′δJJ′2J+12J′′+1 νσ(λo,μo,Ko,η,η′)νσ′(λo′,μo′,Ko′,η′′,η′′′)×⟨Ω;J∥{a(η′,0)12†a~(0,η)12}(λo,μo),Ko,Lo=Jo=3∥Ω′′;J′′⟩×⟨Ω′′;J′′∥{a(η′′,0)12†a~(0,η′′)12}(λo′,μo′),Ko′,Lo=Jo=3∥Ω′;J′⟩(7)\begin{aligned} \langle\Omega;J\|O^3\cdot O^3\|\Omega';J'\rangle ={}&\sum_{\sigma,\sigma'}(-1)^{J+J''}\delta_{JJ'}\sqrt{\frac{2J+1}{2J''+1}}\,\nu_{\sigma}(\lambda_o,\mu_o,K_o,\eta,\eta')\nu_{\sigma'}(\lambda'_o,\mu'_o,K'_o,\eta'',\eta''')\\ &\times\left\langle\Omega;J\left\|\left\{a^\dagger_{(\eta',0)\frac12}\tilde a_{(0,\eta)\frac12}\right\}^{(\lambda_o,\mu_o),K_o,L_o=J_o=3}\right\|\Omega'';J''\right\rangle\\ &\qquad\times\left\langle\Omega'';J''\left\|\left\{a^\dagger_{(\eta'',0)\frac12}\tilde a_{(0,\eta'')\frac12}\right\}^{(\lambda'_o,\mu'_o),K'_o,L_o=J_o=3}\right\|\Omega';J'\right\rangle \tag*{(7)} \end{aligned}

224^{224}Th SPECTRUM

As stated above, the isotope 224^{224}Th is one of the best candidates for research on “pear shape” deformation. Its low energy spectrum has been studied previously in [22] where a Hamiltonian involving the SU(3)SU(3) Casimir operators of orders two and three was formulated. In this section we take the Hamiltonian in 6 and use equation (7) to calculate its matrix elements which are degenerate with respect to the total angular momentum projection MM. The harmonic oscillator strength has the value of ℏω=6.7318\hbar\omega=6.7318 MeV.

This isotope has 16 particles in the valence shell; 8 protons and 8 neutrons which allow for the formation of 4 quartets. Thus, its ground state is given by the spatial representation [24]π−⊗[0]π+⊗[24]ν−⊗[0]ν+[2^4]_{\pi_-}\otimes[0]_{\pi_+}\otimes[2^4]_{\nu_-}\otimes[0]_{\nu_+}. The reduction U(N)⊃SU(3)U(N)\supset SU(3) is given by the leading [33] irreps (26,4)π−⊗(0,0)π+⊗(34,4)ν−⊗(0,0)ν+(26,4)_{\pi_-}\otimes(0,0)_{\pi_+}\otimes(34,4)_{\nu_-}\otimes(0,0)_{\nu_+} which couple to a leading (60,8)(60,8). The band Kπ=0+K^\pi=0^+ contained in this irrep corresponds to the ground state band observed experimentally. As explained above, the excited state has two contributions; the proton excitation given by [23,1]π−⊗[1]π+⊗[24]ν−⊗[0]ν+[2^3,1]_{\pi_-}\otimes[1]_{\pi_+}\otimes[2^4]_{\nu_-}\otimes[0]_{\nu_+} and the neutron excitation given by [24]π−⊗[0]π+⊗[23,1]ν−⊗[1]ν+[2^4]_{\pi_-}\otimes[0]_{\pi_+}\otimes[2^3,1]_{\nu_-}\otimes[1]_{\nu_+}. The SU(3)SU(3) reductions are the leading (25,2)π−⊗(6,0)π+⊗(34,4)ν−⊗(0,0)ν+(25,2)_{\pi_-}\otimes(6,0)_{\pi_+}\otimes(34,4)_{\nu_-}\otimes(0,0)_{\nu_+} and (26,4)π−⊗(0,0)π+⊗(32,2)ν−⊗(7,0)ν+(26,4)_{\pi_-}\otimes(0,0)_{\pi_+}\otimes(32,2)_{\nu_-}\otimes(7,0)_{\nu_+}, respectively, both of which couple to total leading (65,6)(65,6). The band Kπ=0−K^\pi=0^- contained in this irrep corresponds to the octupole excited band observed experimentally.

The Hamiltonian matrix elements to be calculated are those between the states observed experimentally which can be used to fit the parameters χ\chi and τ\tau. The ground state band has angular momentum Jπ=0+,2+,…,18+J^\pi=0^+,2^+,\ldots,18^+ and those of the excited band are Jπ=1−,3−,…,17−J^\pi=1^-,3^-,\ldots,17^-. They are a total of 28 states distinguishing between the proton and neutron excited states. The intermediate states ∣Ψπ+ν′′⟩|\Psi^{\prime\prime}_{\pi+\nu}\rangle of equation 7 are too many to consider them all in a realistic calculation, thus we propose a truncation of the full model space to the ground and excited bands (60,8)0+(60,8)0^+ and (65,6)0−(65,6)0^-. These are a total of 97 intermediate states, even though not all of them will contribute because many will cancel the one-body RME due to angular momentum selection rules. Adopting these restrictions, there will be 37 non-zero independent matrix elements of the Hamiltonian, 9 of which are non-diagonal. In this restricted space the products Oπ3⋅Oπ3O^3_{\pi}\cdot O^3_{\pi} and Oν3⋅Oν3O^3_{\nu}\cdot O^3_{\nu} will contribute to the diagonal terms while the Oπ3⋅Oν3O^3_{\pi}\cdot O^3_{\nu} and Oν3⋅Oπ3O^3_{\nu}\cdot O^3_{\pi} will form the non-diagonal matrix elements. These matrix elements are shown in appendix B.

The Elliott Hamiltonian fit to 224Th{}^{224}\mathrm{Th} spectrum results in a quadrupole-quadrupole interaction strength of χ=−0.0032\chi=-0.0032 and a mean square error (MSE) of 0.1771 MeV20.1771\ \mathrm{MeV}^2 to the experimental energy levels. The two-parameter Hamiltonian proposed in [22] obtains an improvement with a MSE of 0.1180 MeV20.1180\ \mathrm{MeV}^2. The states of the negative parity band have two contributions from the model, taken into account as a superposition ∣ΨJ⟩=α∣ΨJ(π)⟩+1−α∣ΨJ(ν)⟩|\Psi_J\rangle=\sqrt{\alpha}|\Psi_J^{(\pi)}\rangle+\sqrt{1-\alpha}|\Psi_J^{(\nu)}\rangle, where the proton and neutron excited states are denoted as ∣ΨJ(π)⟩|\Psi_J^{(\pi)}\rangle, ∣ΨJ(ν)⟩|\Psi_J^{(\nu)}\rangle respectively and the parameter α\alpha expresses the contribution of each nucleon type wavefunction to the total nuclear wavefunction. While the matrix elements of the ground state band are diagonal, the energy of the negative parity band states are be given by

⟨ΨJ∣H∣ΨJ⟩=ℏω+χ(4C2(65,6)−3L(L+1))+τ(α⟨ΨJ(π)∣O3⋅O3∣ΨJ(π)⟩+2α(1−α)⟨ΨJ(π)∣O3⋅O3∣ΨJ(ν)⟩+(1−α)⟨ΨJ(ν)∣O3⋅O3∣ΨJ(ν)⟩)−Hg.s..(8)\begin{aligned} \langle\Psi_J|H|\Psi_J\rangle={}&\hbar\omega+\chi\left(4\mathcal{C}^2(65,6)-3L(L+1)\right)\\ &+\tau\left(\alpha\langle\Psi_J^{(\pi)}|O^3\cdot O^3|\Psi_J^{(\pi)}\rangle\right.\\ &\quad+2\sqrt{\alpha(1-\alpha)}\langle\Psi_J^{(\pi)}|O^3\cdot O^3|\Psi_J^{(\nu)}\rangle\\ &\quad\left.+(1-\alpha)\langle\Psi_J^{(\nu)}|O^3\cdot O^3|\Psi_J^{(\nu)}\rangle\right)-H_{\mathrm{g.s.}}. \tag*{(8)} \end{aligned}

Computer codes were developed to calculate these Hamiltonian expectation values and fit its three parameters resulting in χ=−0.0032\chi=-0.0032, τ=−0.0016\tau=-0.0016 and α=0.2398\alpha=0.2398. It is equivalent to a simultaneous diagonalization and fit of the parameters. This model has a MSE of 0.1739 MeV20.1739\ \mathrm{MeV}^2 and its spectrum is shown in figure 3.

Experimental and theoretical low energy spectra of 224Th

Figure 3. Experimental and theoretical low energy spectra of 224Th{}^{224}\mathrm{Th}. The energy is measured in MeV. The labels of each band are n(λ,μ)KΠn(\lambda,\mu)K^{\Pi}.

B(E3; 3−₁ → 0⁺₁) Strength

Using the scheme and equations shown above, we can study the 31−→01+3^-_1\to0^+_1 electromagnetic transition strength. The electric octupole transition operator is [34]

Tμ3(E)=b03(eπOπμ3+eνOνμ3),(9)T^3_\mu(E)=b_0^3\left(e_\pi O^3_{\pi\mu}+e_\nu O^3_{\nu\mu}\right), \tag*{(9)}

where the harmonic oscillator amplitude parameter is b0=A1/6 fmb_0=A^{1/6}\ \mathrm{fm}, the proton and neutron effective charges are eπe_\pi and eνe_\nu, respectively. The reduced transition probability is be given by

B(E3;31−→01+)=17∣⟨ΨJ=0∣∣T3(E)∣∣ΨJ=3⟩∣2,(10)B(E3;3^-_1\to0^+_1)=\frac{1}{7}\left|\langle\Psi_{J=0}||T^3(E)||\Psi_{J=3}\rangle\right|^2, \tag*{(10)}

with the reduced matrix element

⟨ΨJ=0∣∣T3(E)∣∣ΨJ=3′⟩=b03(a⟨ΨJ=0∣∣Oπ3∣∣ΨJ=3′(π)⟩+b⟨ΨJ=0∣∣Oν3∣∣ΨJ=3′(ν)⟩),(11)\begin{aligned} \langle\Psi_{J=0}||T^3(E)||\Psi'_{J=3}\rangle={}&b_0^3\left(a\langle\Psi_{J=0}||O^3_\pi||\Psi^{\prime(\pi)}_{J=3}\rangle\right.\\ &\left.+b\langle\Psi_{J=0}||O^3_\nu||\Psi^{\prime(\nu)}_{J=3}\rangle\right), \tag*{(11)} \end{aligned}

where ∣ΨJ=3(σ)⟩|\Psi^{(\sigma)}_{J=3}\rangle represents the excited state of nucleon σ\sigma according to the scheme of equation 2, parameters aa, bb involve the effective charges and superposition parameter α\alpha in the total excited state ∣ΨJ=3⟩|\Psi_{J=3}\rangle as a=eπαa=e_\pi\sqrt{\alpha} and b=eν1−αb=e_\nu\sqrt{1-\alpha} [23]. Recall that the latest evaluated experimental values of the transition 31−→01+3^-_1\to0^+_1 are shown in figure 2.

From the collective model the following relation can be demonstrated [35] [9]

B(E3;31−→01+)=17(3ZeR3β34π)2,(12)B(E3;3^-_1\to0^+_1)=\frac{1}{7}\left(\frac{3ZeR^3\beta_3}{4\pi}\right)^2, \tag*{(12)}

using the experimental value for quadrupole deformation β2=0.174(6)\beta_2=0.174(6) [24], the calculation for octupole deformation β3=−0.153\beta_3=-0.153 [36] for 224Th{}^{224}\mathrm{Th} and the approximation for the nuclear radius R≈1.2A1/3 fmR\approx1.2A^{1/3}\ \mathrm{fm}, results in a transition strength of 77.6001 W.u. This value is close to the one reported in [37, 38] by different methods.

Assuming b≈−a/2b \approx-a/2 according to the results in [23] and considering the collective transition strength, one can estimate the value of a≈0.7805ea \approx0.7805e. Under these assumptions and the value for α\alpha obtained in the previous section, minimums for eπe_{\pi} and eνe_{\nu} are set in the model. A direct measurement of the B(E3;31−→01+)B(E3; 3^{-}_{1} \to0^{+}_{1}) transition for 224^{224}Th is required for further analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

We obtained the mathematical form of the octupole operator r3Yμ3(Ω)r^{3}Y_{\mu}^{3}(\Omega) in terms of SU(3)SU(3) tensors for the actinide region which is minimally defined in the shells 5,6 in the proton space and 6,7 in the neutron space. The scalar operator O3⋅O3\mathcal{O}^{3} \cdot\mathcal{O}^{3} is constructed from this expansion and its reduced matrix elements in the two-shell states formalism are computed in terms of products of recoupling coefficients and single-shell reduced matrix elements. Computer codes were developed that integrate several SU(3)SU(3) libraries [28, 39, 40, 41] in order to perform the calculations of this work. These are available under request to the authors. Essential algebraic expressions for this work are presented in appendix A along with identities used to check the computer codes developed.

The Hamiltonian proposed carries three parameters χ\chi, τ\tau and α\alpha that account for the strength of the quadrupole, octupole residual interactions and nucleon contributions respectively. This model was applied to the low-lying spectrum of the isotope 224^{224}Th obtaining a slight improvement with respect to the original Elliott model. Increasing the number of parameters of the model would improve the fit but decrease its explanatory capabilities. A possible improvement might be achieved by a weaker truncation of the intermediate states in equation 7, for the influence of the octupole-octupole interaction is too little in this reduced space. An analysis on the transition B(E3;31−→01+)B(E3; 3^{-}_{1} \to0^{+}_{1}) involving previous works on collective models, density functional theory and the scheme in this article allows to estimate the octupole effective charges of the model under certain assumptions, however, the lack of experimental data is challenging for this theoretical aspect. We hope to motivate research on this isotope from the experimental side as well.

The octupole deformation of nuclei is a research area that will help physicists obtain a better understanding of the nuclear structure and gain insight of the fundamental symmetries of nature. With this work, we expect to increase interest in this topic from the SU(3)SU(3)-symmetry based models and await the results of experimental efforts from novel radioactive beams accelerators which will allow the exploration of previously inaccessible nuclei.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank professors J. G. Hirsch, V. K. B. Kota, D. Langr and J. Cseh for very valuable discussions. We thank the Institute of Physics at University of Antioquia for supporting this research.

SU(3) one-body triple-barred reduced matrix elements in two-shell states

The one-body double-barred reduced matrix elements (RME) of equation 7 can be computed with equation 10 of reference [32], which separates the proton and neutron spaces obtaining a mathematical expression in terms of recoupling coefficients and triple-barred RME. The former can be computed by SU(3)SU(3) libraries [40] while the latter require an additional mathematical calculation.

The proton and neutron spaces are formed each by two shells; a lower shell denoted by sub-index −- and an upper one denoted by sub-index ++, with the creation an destruction operators acting on different quantum numbers. A separation of states of two shells [42] can be performed as shown in equation A4 where two situations can happen; ai†a^{\dagger}_{i} creates a particle in the −- shell and a~\tilde{a} destroys a particle in ++ shell, or ai†a^{\dagger}_{i} creates a particle in the ++ shell and a~\tilde{a} destroys a particle in shell −-. The first case is a de-excitation of the nucleus while the second is an excitation process. These two cases will imply a minimal change in their mathematical expressions which are distinguished with the labels ss and tt as follows: s=+s=+ and t=−t=- identify the de-excitation process and s=−s=- and t=+t=+ identifies the excitation process as indicated in A4. The triple-barred RME appearing on the right hand side of equation A4 are in a single shell which can be evaluated using computer packages [41, 43]. A computer program was developed to perform the calculation of equation A4 depending on the case as explained above. The following relation is useful

({a(η0)12†a~(η′0)12}ML0,MS0ρ0=1,(λμ)0,K0,L0,S0)†=(−1)η−η′−L0−ML0−MS0{a(η′0)12†a~(η0)12}−ML0,−MS0ρ0=1,(λμ)0,K0,L0,S0(13)\left(\left\{a^{\dagger}_{(\eta0)\frac{1}{2}}\tilde{a}_{(\eta'0)\frac{1}{2}}\right\}^{\rho_0=1,(\lambda\mu)_0,K_0,L_0,S_0}_{M_{L_0},M_{S_0}}\right)^\dagger =(-1)^{\eta-\eta'-L_0-M_{L_0}-M_{S_0}} \left\{a^{\dagger}_{(\eta'0)\frac{1}{2}}\tilde{a}_{(\eta0)\frac{1}{2}}\right\}^{\rho_0=1,(\lambda\mu)_0,K_0,L_0,S_0}_{-M_{L_0},-M_{S_0}} \tag*{(13)}

and the next identities [30, 44] must be hold which were used to check the computer codes

⟨L′,S′∥TL0,S0∥L,S⟩=(−1)L−L′+S−S′(2L+1)(2S+1)(2L′+1)(2S′+1)⟨L,S∥TL0,S0∥L′,S′⟩∗(14)\langle L',S'\Vert T^{L_0,S_0}\Vert L,S\rangle =(-1)^{L-L'+S-S'}\sqrt{\frac{(2L+1)(2S+1)}{(2L'+1)(2S'+1)}}\langle L,S\Vert T^{L_0,S_0}\Vert L',S'\rangle^{*} \tag*{(14)}
⟨(λ1,μ1)∥T(λ2,μ2)∥(λ3,μ3)⟩⟨(λ3,μ3)∥T(λ2,μ2)∥(λ1,μ1)⟩=(−1)12(μ1+μ2−μ3−λ1−λ2+λ3)dim⁡(λ3,μ3)dim⁡(λ1,μ1).(15)\frac{\langle(\lambda_1,\mu_1)\Vert T^{(\lambda_2,\mu_2)}\Vert(\lambda_3,\mu_3)\rangle}{\langle(\lambda_3,\mu_3)\Vert T^{(\lambda_2,\mu_2)}\Vert(\lambda_1,\mu_1)\rangle} =(-1)^{\frac{1}{2}(\mu_1+\mu_2-\mu_3-\lambda_1-\lambda_2+\lambda_3)} \sqrt{\frac{\dim(\lambda_3,\mu_3)}{\dim(\lambda_1,\mu_1)}}. \tag*{(15)}
\begin{aligned} &\langle[f^{-}] \otimes[f^{+}],(\lambda'_{-}\mu'_{-}) \otimes(\lambda'_{+}\mu'_{+}),\rho'(\lambda'\mu'),S'\middle\|\middle\|a^{\dagger}_{(\eta'0)\frac{1}{2}} \widetilde{a}_{(\eta0)\frac{1}{2}}\|^{\rho_{0}=1,(\lambda_{0}\mu_{0})S_{0}}\middle\|[f^{-}] \otimes[f^{+}],(\lambda_{-}\mu_{-}) \otimes(\lambda_{+}\mu_{+}),\rho(\lambda\mu),S\rangle_{\bar{\rho}} \\ &= \{ \begin{array}{ccc} (\lambda_{-},\mu_{-}) & (\alpha,\beta) & (\lambda'_{-},\mu'_{-}) \quad\rho=1 \\ (\lambda_{+},\mu_{+}) & (\gamma,\delta) & (\lambda'_{+},\mu'_{+}) \quad\rho=1 \\ (\lambda,\mu) & (\lambda_{0},\mu_{0}) & (\lambda',\mu') \quad\bar{\rho} \\ \rho& \rho=1 & \rho' \end{array} \} \chi \{ \begin{array}{ccc} S_{-} & \frac{1}{2} & S'_{-} \\ S_{+} & \frac{1}{2} & S'_{+} \\ S & S_{0} & S' \end{array} \} (-1)^{\phi} \sqrt{\frac{\dim(\lambda_{s}\mu_{s})}{\dim(\lambda'_{s}\mu'_{s})}} \sqrt{\frac{2S_{s}+1}{2S'_{s}+1}} \\ &\quad\times\langle[f'_{t}],(\lambda'_{t}\mu'_{t}),S'_{t}\middle\| \middle\| a^{\dagger}_{(\eta'0)\frac{1}{2}}\middle\| \middle\|[f_{t}],(\lambda_{t}\mu_{t})S_{t}\rangle_{\rho=1} \langle[f_{s}],(\lambda_{s}\mu_{s}),S_{s}\middle\| \middle\| a_{(\eta0)\frac{1}{2}}\middle\| \middle\|[f'_{s}],(\lambda'_{s}\mu'_{s}),S'_{s}\rangle_{\rho=1}, \\ &\phi=\eta+\frac{1}{2}+S_{+}-S'_{+}+\lambda'_{+}-\lambda_{+}+\mu'_{+}-\mu_{+}, \\ &\qquad(\alpha,\beta)=(\eta',0)\text{ and }(\gamma,\delta)=(0,\eta)\qquad\text{if }s=+\text{ and }t=- \\ &\phi=\eta'+\frac{3}{2}+S_{-}-S'_{-}-S_{0}+\lambda'_{-}-\lambda_{-}+\mu'_{-}-\mu_{-}-\lambda_{0}-\mu_{0}, \\ &\qquad(\alpha,\beta)=(0,\eta)\text{ and }(\gamma,\delta)=(\eta',0)\qquad\text{if }s=-\text{ and }t=+. \tag*{(16)} \end{aligned}

OO matrix elements

In this section we present the matrix elements of the operator O⋅OO \cdot O in table II as defined in equation 7.

0+0^+2+2^+4+4^+6+6^+8+8^+10+10^+12+12^+14+14^+16+16^+18+18^+1π−1^-_\pi3π−3^-_\pi5π−5^-_\pi7π−7^-_\pi9π−9^-_\pi11π−11^-_\pi13π−13^-_\pi15π−15^-_\pi17π−17^-_\pi1ν−1^-_\nu3ν−3^-_\nu5ν−5^-_\nu7ν−7^-_\nu9ν−9^-_\nu11ν−11^-_\nu13ν−13^-_\nu15ν−15^-_\nu17ν−17^-_\nu
0+0^+4.5946000000000000000000000000000
2+2^+025.897400000000000000000000000000
4+4^+0036.64370000000000000000000000000
6+6^+00032.0281000000000000000000000000
8+8^+000030.436000000000000000000000000
10+10^+0000029.47800000000000000000000000
12+12^+00000028.8096000000000000000000000
14+14^+000000028.386500000000000000000000
16+16^+0000000028.24910000000000000000000
18+18^+00000000028.4693000000000000000000
1π−1^-_\pi00000000000.0583000000000.805700000000
3π−3^-_\pi000000000000.8027000000005.86530000000
5π−5^-_\pi0000000000000.743200000003.9895000000
7π−7^-_\pi00000000000001.036200000004.177600000
9π−9^-_\pi000000000000001.455600000004.652000000
11π−11^-_\pi0000000000000001.990800000005.2846000
13π−13^-_\pi00000000000000002.643900000006.040000
15π−15^-_\pi000000000000000003.420300000006.90570
17π−17^-_\pi0000000000000000004.327200000007.8818
1ν−1^-_\nu00000000000.80570000000012.792900000000
3ν−3^-_\nu000000000005.86530000000050.66210000000
5ν−5^-_\nu0000000000003.9895000000032.9312000000
7ν−7^-_\nu00000000000004.1776000000029.997400000
9ν−9^-_\nu000000000000004.6520000000028.228600000
11ν−11^-_\nu0000000000000005.2846000000026.7378000
13ν−13^-_\nu00000000000000006.0400000000025.367600
15ν−15^-_\nu000000000000000006.9057000000024.11920
17ν−17^-_\nu0000000000000000007.8818000000023.0470

Table 2. Reduced matrix elements of O⋅OO \cdot O. The notation of the states JσΠJ^\Pi_\sigma indicates the angular momentum, parity and the excited nucleon σ\sigma. In the ground state band, this last label is omitted.

References

  1. [18]T. F. Thorsteinsen, K. Nybø, and G. Løvhoiden, Levels in 226Ra populated by inelastic deuteron scattering, Physica Scripta 42, 141 (1990).DOI
  2. [19]J. Cseh, Algebraic models for shell-like quarteting of nucleons, Physics Letters B 743, 213 (2015).DOI
  3. [20]D. Bonatsos, I. E. Assimakis, N. Minkov, A. Martinou, R. B. Cakirli, R. F. Casten, and K. Blaum, Proxy-su(3) symmetry in heavy deformed nuclei, Phys. Rev. C 95, 064325 (2017).DOI
  4. [21]D. Bonatsos, A. Martinou, S. K. Peroulis, T. J. Mertzimekis, and N. Minkov, The proxy-su(3) symmetry in atomic nuclei, Symmetry 15, 10.3390/sym15010169 (2023).DOI
  5. [22]J. Cseh, Shell-like quarteting in heavy nuclei: Algebraic approaches based on the pseudo- and proxy-su(3) schemes, Phys. Rev. C 101, 054306 (2020).DOI
  6. [23]A. Restrepo and J. P. Valencia, Inter-band b(e1) strengths in heavy nuclei based on the proxy-su(3) scheme (2024), arXiv:2405.04679 [nucl-th].
  7. [24]B. Singh and S. Singh, From ENSDF database as of March 08, 2022. Version available at http://www.nndc.bnl.gov/ensarchivals/.
  8. [25]A. Martinou and N. Minkov, Microscopic derivation of the octupole magic numbers from symmetry considerations, Physica Scripta 99, 075311 (2024).DOI
  9. [26]P. V. Isacker and S. Pittel, Symmetries and deformations in the spherical shell model, Physica Scripta 91, 023009 (2016).DOI
  10. [27]A. Frank, J. Jolie, and P. van Isacker, Symmetries in Atomic Nuclei: From Isospin to Supersymmetry, Springer Tracts in Modern Physics (Springer New York, 2008).
  11. [28]J. Draaÿer, Y. Leschber, S. Park, and R. Lopez, Representations of u(3) in u(n), Computer Physics Communications 56, 279 (1989).DOI
  12. [29]F. Sloane, Lie Algebras and Applications, Lecture Notes in Physics (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2014).
  13. [30]J. Vergados, Su(3) r(3) wigner coefficients in the 2s-1d shell, Nuclear Physics A 111, 681 (1968).
  14. [31]M. Moshinsky and Y. Smirnov, The Harmonic Oscillator in Modern Physics, Contemporary concepts in physics (Harwood Academic Publishers, 1996).
  15. [32]D. Troltenier, C. Bahri, and J. Draayer, Generalized pseudo-su(3) model and pairing, Nuclear Physics A 586, 53 (1995).
  16. [33]V. K. Kota, SU(3) Symmetry in Atomic Nuclei (Springer Nature Singapore, 2020).DOI
  17. [34]P. Brussaard and P. Glaudemans, Shell-model Applications in Nuclear Spectroscopy (North-Holland Publishing Company, 1977).
  18. [35]G. Leander and R. Sheline, Intrinsic reflection asymmetry in odd-a nuclei, Nuclear Physics A 413, 375 (1984).DOI
  19. [36]P. Möller, A. Sierk, T. Ichikawa, and H. Sagawa, Nuclear ground-state masses and deformations: Frdm(2012), Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables 109-110, 1 (2016).
  20. [37]L. M. Robledo and P. A. Butler, Quadrupole-octupole coupling in the light actinides, Phys. Rev. C 88, 051302 (2013).DOI
  21. [38]L. P. Gaffney, Octupole collectivity in 220Rn and 224Ra, Phd thesis, University of Liverpool (2012), available at https://cds.cern.ch/record/1547569/files/CERN-THESIS-2012-309.pdf.DOI
  22. [39]B. G. Wybourne, Schur Group Theory Software (2022).
  23. [40]T. Dytrych, D. Langr, J. P. Draayer, K. D. Launey, and D. Gazda, Su3lib: A c++ library for accurate computation of wigner and racah coefficients of su(3), Computer Physics Communications 269, 108137 (2021).
  24. [41]C. Bahri and J. Draayer, Su(3) reduced matrix element package, Computer Physics Communications 83, 59 (1994).DOI
  25. [42]D. J. Millener, Su(3) in shell-model calculations (1991).
  26. [43]G. J. Hirsch, C. Bahri, J. Draayer, O. Castaños, and P. Hess, Reduced matrix elements for the leading spin zero states in the su ( 3 ) scheme * (2007).
  27. [44]J. Suhonen, From Nucleons to Nucleus: Concepts of Microscopic Nuclear Theory, Theoretical and Mathematical Physics (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2007).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_c65vmj4q
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents