Introduction
Chemical reactions maintain many active systems away from equilibrium and couple internal chemistry to motion, transport, and structure. Examples include the cytoskeleton and chemically maintained biomolecular condensates[1 , 3 ] [2]. Reactions change composition and material properties, while mechanical forces and intermolecular interactions can change reaction rates. The modeling challenge is to combine these mechanisms under shared conservation laws and energy exchanges, and to identify which physical inputs determine the dynamics, its fluctuations, and the chemical power that sustains it.
Onsager’s variational principle (OVP) organizes dissipative dynamics through a scalar Rayleighian[4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] . For an isothermal system, its physical decomposition is
R = Φ + F ˙ − P i n . (1) \mathcal{R} = \Phi+ \dot{\mathcal{F}} - \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}. \tag*{(1)} R = Φ + F ˙ − P in . (1)
Here, Φ \Phi Φ is the dissipation potential, F \mathcal{F} F the retained free energy, and P i n \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} P in the input power; a dot denotes a time derivative. All three terms have power units, and positive P i n \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} P in denotes supply to the retained system. Their physical meaning comes from specified resistance, storage, and work mechanisms. Minimization over admissible rates at fixed state and controls selects the potential-generated dissipative dynamics. Interpreting the Rayleighian excess R − R min \mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min} R − R m i n , the difference from its fixed-state minimum, as a fluctuation cost requires matching to a specified stochastic mechanism[8 ] .
Using established nonlinear variational and reaction-fluctuation structures[9 , 10 , 13 , 14 ] , we construct and compare coupled active-matter models sharing passive and fueled conversion channels. The comparisons make three distinctions explicit. First, a two-channel model shows how nonreciprocal net-affinity response under specified controls is compatible with partial-affinity response symmetries and a fixed-state dissipation potential. Second, reproducing the selected rate r ∗ r_* r ∗ and dissipation power P \mathcal{P} P does not determine the Rayleighian excess or its fluctuation interpretation. Third, the membrane–cytosol model shows that distinct passive and fueled channel realizations can have identical total attachment and detachment rates, and hence identical protein-density trajectory statistics, but different chemical input power, showing that composition dynamics alone cannot identify fuel consumption. The coupled applications further track free-energy exchange with a finite fuel pool and distinguish the loss of reaction-channel information from the elimination of dynamical state variables.
The practical value of OVP lies in constructing and coupling models. Free energy specifies interactions and storage, dissipation potentials specify resistance, and input power identifies external supply. These ingredients also underlie active-gel constitutive models[1 ] [2]. Related continuum descriptions couple drift, diffusion, and reaction in semiconductors[15 ] , and ionic transport, electrostatics, and interfacial kinetics in electrochemistry[16 ] . Varying the Rayleighian under shared constraints incorporates reaction and transport consistently into their coupled equations and power balance. An equivalent direct construction gives the same equations; the advantage is their systematic assembly rather than a different prediction for already fixed inputs. Restricting trial fields before variation also provides a variational approximation method[17 , 18 ] .
Chemical reaction kinetics makes the distinction between deterministic dynamics and fluctuations particularly clear. The selected net rate r ρ , ∗ = r ρ + − r ρ − r_{\rho,*}=r_\rho^+-r_\rho^- r ρ , ∗ = r ρ + − r ρ − determines only the difference between the mean forward and reverse rates r ρ ± r_\rho^\pm r ρ ± , not their sum or the associated counting statistics. Different Rayleighians can therefore select the same deterministic rate while implying different fluctuation costs under their respective stochastic models. Onsager–Machlup theory connects near-equilibrium linear relaxation and Gaussian fluctuations[19 , 20 ] . For nonlinear chemical kinetics, the question is when the same Rayleighian retains both physical rate selection and a statistical meaning. A nonideal free energy changes chemical driving forces; a nonquadratic dissipation potential changes the force–rate relation at fixed kinetic scales. These are distinct constitutive choices, and both must be specified when reactions couple to phase separation.
Nonlinear variational chemistry has substantial precedents, including thermokinetic and dissipation-potential approaches[13 , 21 ] and formulations using separate forward and reverse rates[22 ] . The Gyarmati–Li generalized reciprocal relations propose symmetry of nonlinear differential response for specified conjugate forces and rates[13 , 21 ] . Bataille, Edelen, and Kestin found chemical-kinetic counterexamples when net rates are differentiated with respect to net affinities at fixed complementary thermodynamic variables[23 ] . Lengyel obtained separate symmetric blocks for partial-affinity responses[22 ] ; these statements concern different derivatives and are not contradictory. Reciprocal linear response can also persist in selected microscopically irreversible or driven models, whereas other driven states are nonreciprocal[24 , 25 , 26 ] . Neither outcome establishes a universal finite-affinity symmetry. For a common convex dissipation potential and its conjugate, the Gyarmati-type functional and Rayleighian excess coincide up to sign. Their variational equivalence must therefore be distinguished from identifying the physical inputs and fluctuation law of a reaction model.
The statistical connection also builds on established results. Grabert and Green extended short-time transition probabilities and path integrals to nonlinear irreversible processes[27 ] . Large-deviation formulations related trajectory probabilities to generalized dissipative dynamics[9 , 28 , 29 ] ; for reversible chemical jump models, the event statistics yield nonquadratic reaction potentials[9 , 10 , 14 ] . For driven Markov systems, local detailed balance and time-symmetric kinetic activity enter nonlinear Onsager–Machlup structures[30 , 31 , 32 ] ; flux-based variational formulations extend beyond detailed balance[33 ] . Kobayashi et al.[34 ] developed the Hessian geometry of the dual nonquadratic reaction potentials and associated entropy-production decompositions, and discussed quadratic alternatives representing the same kinetics. Energetic variational approaches provide related constructions coupling nonlinear reactions and diffusion[35 , 36 , 37 ] . The extension considered here uses these established structures, rather than proposing a distinct general extremum principle.
The retained variables and reaction channels carry different information. A description is dynamically sufficient at a stated resolution when its present variables and imposed controls determine the subsequent transition law without unresolved slow memory. An observed membrane density can fail this test when attachment depends on an evolving cytosolic pool[12 , 38 ] . Conditional local equilibrium of eliminated thermal degrees of freedom permits retained free energies without requiring chemical equilibrium. Resolving reaction channels is a separate requirement: channels with the same retained-state change can exchange different chemical work, so the retained-state dynamics can close without channel labels while concealing fuel consumption[39 , 40 ] . Neither dynamical closure nor timescale separation alone establishes local detailed balance[41 ] . The slow variables, thermodynamically distinct channels, and nonlinear dissipation with its event statistics are therefore complementary modeling choices.
These three modeling choices guide the analysis summarized in Figure 1 . Section II establishes the statistical and thermodynamic foundations by comparing Gaussian and Poisson fluctuations and identifying the conditions under which a physical Rayleighian also determines their fluctuation costs. We then examine three models sharing passive and fueled conversion channels. Section III distinguishes nonlinear response across controlled states from fixed-state variational symmetry, and deterministic rates from their fluctuation costs. Section IV couples the reactions to nonideal phase separation and a finite fuel pool. Section V examines how channel aggregation and state-variable reduction affect membrane–cytosol dynamics and chemical-power accounting. Section VI discusses the broader modeling implications and limitations. Appendices A–C provide supporting response relations and stochastic matching conditions.
Figure 1. Nonlinear response, fluctuation costs, and chemically driven organization. (a) Near equilibrium, L i j L_{ij} L ij relates selected molar reaction-rate densities r i , ∗ r_{i,*} r i , ∗ to molar affinities A j \mathcal{A}_j A j and satisfies the Onsager reciprocal relations (ORR), L i j = L j i L_{ij}=L_{ji} L ij = L j i . The solid curve schematically represents the response of a selected reaction-rate density r i , ∗ r_{i,*} r i , ∗ to a molar affinity A j \mathcal{A}_j A j under a chosen control protocol; the dashed line shows its near-equilibrium linear approximation. The questioned equality concerns a proposed extension to finite-driving differential response across compositions or controls; it need not hold and is distinct from the symmetry of a fixed-state trial-rate Hessian (Sec. III). (b) The physical Rayleighian combines the dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ , retained free-energy rate F ˙ \dot{F} F ˙ , and chemical input power P i n P_{\mathrm{in}} P in . For physically matched event statistics, the normalized Rayleighian excess L = ( R − R min ) / ( 2 k B T ) \mathcal{L}=(\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min})/(2k_{\mathrm{B}}T) L = ( R − R m i n ) / ( 2 k B T ) gives the leading rate-fluctuation cost per unit time. Here, the statistics are resolved Poisson counting with local detailed balance (LDB) in the frozen-state, many-event regime[9 , 10 ] . k B k_{\mathrm{B}} k B is Boltzmann’s constant and T T T the bath temperature. (c) A qualitative reaction–transport cycle couples A ⇌ B A\rightleftharpoons B A ⇌ B conversion and transport between dilute and dense phases to fuel consumption F → W F\to W F → W . Here, F F F , W W W denote fuel and waste. Adapted from the mechanism in Figure 1 (a) of Haugerud et al. [11 ] under CC BY 4.0. (d) Membrane binding beneath a solution layer of fixed height h h h . The bulk molar concentration C b ( x , z , t ) C_b(x,z,t) C b ( x , z , t ) gives the cytosolic amount per unit area c = ∫ 0 h C b d z c=\int_0^h C_b\,\mathrm{d}z c = ∫ 0 h C b d z , which exchanges with the membrane-bound molar surface density m m m . The coordinates x x x , z z z are lateral and perpendicular to the membrane; rapid perpendicular mixing is assumed. The arrows r ± r^{\pm} r ± denote total one-way attachment and detachment rate densities. The passive and fueled channels, with net rates r 0 , r F r_0,r_F r 0 , r F , produce the same conversion between cytosolic and bound protein states C C C , M M M , but carry different chemical work. The membrane schematic is informed by Weyer, Roth, and Frey [12 ] .
Extending Onsager–Machlup theory to nonlinear chemical reaction kinetics
In this section, we first revisit Onsager and Machlup’s linear Gaussian theory[19 , 20 ] to establish the deterministic and statistical roles of the physical Rayleighian. Our construction of nonlinear chemical kinetics rests on three complementary modeling choices: the retained slow variables, thermodynamically distinct reaction channels, and their nonlinear dissipation and event statistics. For a resolved Markovian reaction model, we derive the nonquadratic reaction-rate fluctuation cost from frozen-state Poisson counting statistics in the many-event regime and impose local detailed balance (LDB) to identify the statistical bias with the chemical affinity. The resulting physical Rayleighian retains the classical form of Eq. (1) , R = Φ + F ˙ − P i n \mathcal{R}=\Phi+\dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} R = Φ + F ˙ − P in , now with a nonquadratic dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ . It also preserves both roles: its minimization over admissible trial rates at fixed state and controls selects the deterministic kinetics, while its normalized excess ( R − R min ) / ( 2 k B T ) (\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min})/(2k_{\mathrm{B}}T) ( R − R m i n ) / ( 2 k B T ) gives the leading reaction-rate fluctuation cost per unit time, where R min \mathcal{R}_{\min} R m i n is the instantaneous minimum.
Onsager–Machlup theory and the physical Rayleighian
Gaussian fluctuations and irreversible dynamics. Onsager and Machlup connected near-equilibrium Gaussian fluctuations with linear irreversible relaxation[19 ] . Following Wang, Qian, and Xu[8 ] , we revisit this connection using an additive Itô stochastic model for N α N_{\alpha} N α independent retained slow coordinates α = { α 1 , … , α N α } \boldsymbol{\alpha}=\{\alpha_{1},\ldots,\alpha_{N_{\alpha}}\} α = { α 1 , … , α N α } :
d α = L X ( α , t ) d t + 2 B d W . (2) \mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{\alpha}=L\boldsymbol{X}(\boldsymbol{\alpha},t)\,\mathrm{d}t+\sqrt{2}B\,\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{W}. \tag*{(2)} d α = L X ( α , t ) d t + 2 B d W . (2)
Here, L L L is a constant response matrix and X ( α , t ) \boldsymbol{X}(\boldsymbol{\alpha},t) X ( α , t ) is a prescribed generalized force. The drift is linear in X \boldsymbol{X} X but may be nonlinear in α \boldsymbol{\alpha} α . The components of W \boldsymbol{W} W are independent standard Wiener processes, and the constant noise-amplitude matrix B B B defines the symmetric diffusion matrix D = B B T D=BB^{\mathsf{T}} D = B B T , which is assumed positive definite. We first derive the transition density without imposing Onsager reciprocity on L L L or the Einstein relation between D D D and L L L .
For the Markov model in Eq. (2) , approximate the force over a sufficiently short interval [ t n , t n + 1 ] [t_n,t_{n+1}] [ t n , t n + 1 ] by its initial value X n = X ( α n , t n ) \boldsymbol{X}_n=\boldsymbol{X}(\boldsymbol{\alpha}_n,t_n) X n = X ( α n , t n ) . This gives the Euler–Maruyama update
Δ α n = L X n Δ t + 2 Δ t B ξ n , (3) \Delta\boldsymbol{\alpha}_n=L\boldsymbol{X}_n\Delta t+\sqrt{2\Delta t}B\boldsymbol{\xi}_n, \tag*{(3)} Δ α n = L X n Δ t + 2Δ t B ξ n , (3)
where Δ α n = α n + 1 − α n \Delta\boldsymbol{\alpha}_n=\boldsymbol{\alpha}_{n+1}-\boldsymbol{\alpha}_n Δ α n = α n + 1 − α n , Δ t = t n + 1 − t n \Delta t=t_{n+1}-t_n Δ t = t n + 1 − t n , and ξ n = [ W ( t n + 1 ) − W ( t n ) ] / Δ t \boldsymbol{\xi}_n=[\boldsymbol{W}(t_{n+1})-\boldsymbol{W}(t_n)]/\sqrt{\Delta t} ξ n = [ W ( t n + 1 ) − W ( t n )] / Δ t . These Gaussian vectors have zero mean and unit covariance, with each ξ n \boldsymbol{\xi}_n ξ n independent of the history up to t n t_n t n . For this update, the conditional increment has mean L X n Δ t L\boldsymbol{X}_n\Delta t L X n Δ t and covariance 2 D Δ t 2D\Delta t 2 D Δ t . Writing α ˙ n = Δ α n / Δ t \dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_n=\Delta\boldsymbol{\alpha}_n/\Delta t α ˙ n = Δ α n /Δ t for the measured step rate, the conditional transition density is
p E M ( α n + 1 , t n + 1 ∣ α n , t n ) = exp [ − Δ t L D ( α ˙ n ) ] ( 4 π Δ t ) N α / 2 det D , (4) p_{\mathrm{EM}}(\boldsymbol{\alpha}_{n+1},t_{n+1}\mid\boldsymbol{\alpha}_n,t_n)=\frac{\exp[-\Delta t\,\mathcal{L}_D(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_n)]}{(4\pi\Delta t)^{N_{\alpha}/2}\sqrt{\det D}}, \tag*{(4)} p EM ( α n + 1 , t n + 1 ∣ α n , t n ) = ( 4 π Δ t ) N α /2 det D exp [ − Δ t L D ( α ˙ n )] , (4)
with the local fluctuation cost
L D ( α ˙ ) = 1 4 ( α ˙ − L X n ) T D − 1 ( α ˙ − L X n ) . (5) \mathcal{L}_D(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}})=\frac{1}{4}(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}-L\boldsymbol{X}_n)^{\mathsf{T}}D^{-1}(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}-L\boldsymbol{X}_n). \tag*{(5)} L D ( α ˙ ) = 4 1 ( α ˙ − L X n ) T D − 1 ( α ˙ − L X n ) . (5)
Here, α ˙ \dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}} α ˙ denotes a trial rate and L D \mathcal{L}_D L D has units of inverse-time; the measured step rate α ˙ n \dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_n α ˙ n does not imply differentiability of a Brownian trajectory. (4) is exact for the frozen update but generally only a short-time approximation to the transition density of Eq. (2) . The Gaussian cost in Eq. (5) selects L X n L\boldsymbol{X}_n L X n as the most probable step rate, but does not by itself identify the physical dissipation and energy exchanges.
Physical Rayleighian and deterministic rate. We now describe the deterministic energetics of the retained variables α \boldsymbol{\alpha} α , with the free energy, resistance, and applied forces specified independently of the noise covariance. For an isothermal system, let X = − ∇ α F + F a \boldsymbol{X}=-\nabla_{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}\mathcal{F}+\boldsymbol{F}_a X = − ∇ α F + F a , where F ( α ) \mathcal{F}(\boldsymbol{\alpha}) F ( α ) is the free energy of the retained system, with no explicit time dependence, and F a ( α , t ) \boldsymbol{F}_a(\boldsymbol{\alpha},t) F a ( α , t ) is a prescribed nonconservative force. For a trial rate α ˙ \dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}} α ˙ , the rate of free energy change and the input power are F ˙ = ∇ α F ⋅ α ˙ \dot{\mathcal{F}}=\nabla_{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}\mathcal{F}\cdot\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}} F ˙ = ∇ α F ⋅ α ˙ and P i n = F a ⋅ α ˙ \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=\boldsymbol{F}_a\cdot\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}} P in = F a ⋅ α ˙ , respectively, so that F ˙ − P i n = − X ⋅ α ˙ \dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=-\boldsymbol{X}\cdot\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}} F ˙ − P in = − X ⋅ α ˙ .
For time-reversal-even coordinates, we impose Onsager reciprocity, L = L T L=L^{\mathsf{T}} L = L T . This symmetry follows from microscopic reversibility in equilibrium linear response without time-reversal-odd controls[4 , 5 , 42 ] ; beyond that regime, it is a constitutive assumption. The second law requires nonnegative dissipation; we assume L L L to be positive definite so that L − 1 L^{-1} L − 1 defines the resistance matrix. Integrating the linear resistance force L − 1 α ˙ L^{-1}\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}} L − 1 α ˙ over the trial rates gives the dissipation potential, normalized by Φ ( 0 ) = 0 \Phi(\boldsymbol{0})=0 Φ ( 0 ) = 0 ,
Φ ( α ˙ ) = 1 2 α ˙ T L − 1 α ˙ . \Phi(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}})=\frac{1}{2}\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}^{\mathsf{T}}L^{-1}\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}. Φ ( α ˙ ) = 2 1 α ˙ T L − 1 α ˙ .
Since ∂ Φ / ∂ α ˙ = L − 1 α ˙ \partial\Phi/\partial\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}=L^{-1}\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}} ∂ Φ/ ∂ α ˙ = L − 1 α ˙ , the overdamped force balance between resistance and driving force is the stationarity condition of the physical Rayleighian
R ( α ˙ ; α , t ) = Φ − X ⋅ α ˙ = Φ + F ˙ − P i n , (6) \mathcal{R}(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}};\boldsymbol{\alpha},t)=\Phi-\boldsymbol{X}\cdot\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}=\Phi+\dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}, \tag*{(6)} R ( α ˙ ; α , t ) = Φ − X ⋅ α ˙ = Φ + F ˙ − P in , (6)
which has the classical form of Eq. (1) [8 , 18 , 19 ] . Its strict convexity gives the unique minimizing rate at fixed state and controls:
α ˙ ∗ = L X . (7) \dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{*}=L\boldsymbol{X}. \tag*{(7)} α ˙ ∗ = L X . (7)
This recovers the deterministic drift in Eq. (2) . Substitution into Eq. (6) gives R min ( α , t ) = − 1 2 X T L X \mathcal{R}_{\min}(\boldsymbol{\alpha},t)=-\frac{1}{2}\boldsymbol{X}^{\mathsf{T}}L\boldsymbol{X} R m i n ( α , t ) = − 2 1 X T L X . Along the selected deterministic evolution, the free-energy balance is
F ˙ = P i n − D , (8) \dot{\mathcal{F}}=\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}-\mathcal{D}, \tag*{(8)} F ˙ = P in − D , (8)
where D \mathcal{D} D is the nonnegative dissipation power,
D = X ⋅ α ˙ ∗ = α ˙ ∗ T L − 1 α ˙ ∗ = 2 Φ ( α ˙ ∗ ) ≥ 0. \mathcal{D}=\boldsymbol{X}\cdot\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{*}=\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{*}^{\mathsf{T}}L^{-1}\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{*}=2\Phi(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{*})\ge0. D = X ⋅ α ˙ ∗ = α ˙ ∗ T L − 1 α ˙ ∗ = 2Φ ( α ˙ ∗ ) ≥ 0.
Positive P i n \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} P in denotes work supplied to the retained system, while positive F ˙ \dot{\mathcal{F}} F ˙ denotes free-energy accumulation. The dissipation power D \mathcal{D} D measures irreversible free-energy loss along the selected deterministic evolution, not necessarily the heat current or the total dissipation of the stochastic model. The identity D = 2 Φ ( α ˙ ∗ ) \mathcal{D}=2\Phi(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{*}) D = 2Φ ( α ˙ ∗ ) follows from quadratic homogeneity and does not generally hold for nonquadratic dissipation potentials.
Einstein relation and fluctuation cost. At the same frozen state and controls as in Eq. (5) , completing the square in Eq. (6) using the minimum R min \mathcal{R}_{\min} R m i n gives
R − R min = 1 2 ( α ˙ − α ˙ ∗ ) T L − 1 ( α ˙ − α ˙ ∗ ) . \mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min}=\frac{1}{2}(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}-\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{*})^{\mathsf{T}}L^{-1}(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}-\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_{*}). R − R m i n = 2 1 ( α ˙ − α ˙ ∗ ) T L − 1 ( α ˙ − α ˙ ∗ ) .
Here, α ˙ ∗ = L X n \dot{\alpha}_* = L X_n α ˙ ∗ = L X n . For the present constant-coefficient model at bath temperature T T T , impose the Einstein relation D = k B T L D = k_{\mathrm{B}} T L D = k B T L , where k B k_{\mathrm{B}} k B is Boltzmann’s constant. Comparison with Eq. (5) then gives
L D ( α ˙ ) = R ( α ˙ ) − R min 2 k B T . (9) \mathcal{L}_{D}(\dot{\alpha}) = \frac{\mathcal{R}(\dot{\alpha})-\mathcal{R}_{\min}}{2k_{\mathrm{B}}T}. \tag*{(9)} L D ( α ˙ ) = 2 k B T R ( α ˙ ) − R m i n . (9)
for all independent trial rates α ˙ \dot{\alpha} α ˙ . Under this Einstein relation, the same physical Rayleighian both selects the deterministic rate and determines the Gaussian fluctuation cost through its excess. With F a = 0 F_a=0 F a = 0 and a quadratic free energy about a stable equilibrium, the model reduces to the equilibrium linear Gaussian setting. Appendix A derives the equilibrium counterpart for reaction extents from resolved reaction events.
Onsager–Machlup path integral and variational principle. For N N N Euler–Maruyama steps with Δ t = ( t f − t 0 ) / N \Delta t=(t_f-t_0)/N Δ t = ( t f − t 0 ) / N , multiplying the one-step transition densities in Eq. (4) gives the joint probability density of a discretized trajectory, conditioned on its initial state:
p N ( α 1 , … , α N ∣ α 0 ) = exp [ − I N ] [ ( 4 π Δ t ) N α / 2 det D ] N , (10) p_N(\alpha_1,\ldots,\alpha_N\mid\alpha_0)=\frac{\exp[-\mathcal{I}_N]}{\left[(4\pi\Delta t)^{N_\alpha/2}\sqrt{\det D}\right]^N}, \tag*{(10)} p N ( α 1 , … , α N ∣ α 0 ) = [ ( 4 π Δ t ) N α /2 det D ] N exp [ − I N ] , (10)
with I N = Δ t ∑ n = 0 N − 1 L D ( α ˙ n ) \mathcal{I}_N=\Delta t\sum_{n=0}^{N-1}\mathcal{L}_D(\dot{\alpha}_n) I N = Δ t ∑ n = 0 N − 1 L D ( α ˙ n ) . Each cost is evaluated at the current state and time ( α n , t n ) (\alpha_n,t_n) ( α n , t n ) . Integrating over the N − 1 N-1 N − 1 intermediate states, with α N = α f \alpha_N=\alpha_f α N = α f , and taking N → ∞ N\to\infty N → ∞ at fixed t f − t 0 t_f-t_0 t f − t 0 gives the formal path integral
p ( α f , t f ∣ α 0 , t 0 ) = ∫ α 0 α f D α e − I [ α ] . (11) p(\alpha_f,t_f\mid\alpha_0,t_0)=\int_{\alpha_0}^{\alpha_f}\mathcal{D}\alpha\,e^{-\mathcal{I}[\alpha]}. \tag*{(11)} p ( α f , t f ∣ α 0 , t 0 ) = ∫ α 0 α f D α e − I [ α ] . (11)
The measure carries all N N N one-step normalization factors in Eq. (10) . Under Einstein matching, the dimensionless Onsager–Machlup action in this left-endpoint representation is
I [ α ] = 1 2 k B T ∫ t 0 t f [ R ( α ˙ ; α , t ) − R min ( α , t ) ] d t . (12) \mathcal{I}[\alpha]=\frac{1}{2k_{\mathrm{B}}T}\int_{t_0}^{t_f}\left[\mathcal{R}(\dot{\alpha};\alpha,t)-\mathcal{R}_{\min}(\alpha,t)\right]\,\mathrm{d}t. \tag*{(12)} I [ α ] = 2 k B T 1 ∫ t 0 t f [ R ( α ˙ ; α , t ) − R m i n ( α , t ) ] d t . (12)
The action is evaluated as a sum over successive time steps, with R \mathcal{R} R and R min \mathcal{R}_{\min} R m i n evaluated at the current state and time. For a smooth trial trajectory, the discrete action I N \mathcal{I}_N I N converges to the time integral in Eq. (12) . At fixed time resolution, minimizing I N \mathcal{I}_N I N maximizes the corresponding discrete trajectory density, since its normalization factor is independent of the trajectory. The Onsager–Machlup variational principle (OMVP) minimizes I \mathcal{I} I over admissible smooth trajectories with prescribed initial and, when required, final states[8 , 18 ] . With only the initial state fixed, the deterministic trajectory attains I = 0 \mathcal{I}=0 I = 0 . With both endpoints fixed, minimization gives the classical linear Gaussian fluctuation path and, for nonlinear drift, the leading weak-noise transition path.
Scope of the Onsager–Machlup description. Constant coefficients D D D and L L L simplify the stochastic description; Onsager reciprocity L = L T L=L^{\mathsf{T}} L = L T allows the linear resistance to be generated by a scalar dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ ; and Einstein matching relation D = k B T L D=k_{\mathrm{B}}TL D = k B T L connects the physical Rayleighian to the Gaussian fluctuation cost. We now examine how relaxing these assumptions affects deterministic OVP and its statistical interpretation. (i) Allowing state dependence while retaining symmetric positive-definite mobility preserves deterministic OVP: L ( α ) L(\alpha) L ( α ) is held fixed during trial-rate variation, not during state evolution[18 ] . For thermal diffusion in flat independent coordinates at uniform temperature, with D = k B T L D=k_{\mathrm{B}}TL D = k B T L and no additional reversible currents, the conditional Itô drift is α ˙ i = α ˙ ∗ , i + ∇ α ⋅ D \dot{\alpha}_i=\dot{\alpha}_{*,i}+\nabla_{\alpha}\cdot D α ˙ i = α ˙ ∗ , i + ∇ α ⋅ D , where α ˙ ∗ = L X \dot{\alpha}_*=LX α ˙ ∗ = L X is the deterministic rate in Eq. (7) selected by OVP. For this multiplicative-noise model, the Einstein matching relation gives the same quadratic coefficients, but the frozen Gaussian cost is minimized at α ˙ i \dot{\alpha}_i α ˙ i , whereas the physical Rayleighian excess is minimized at α ˙ ∗ \dot{\alpha}_* α ˙ ∗ . A nonzero noise-induced ∇ α ⋅ D \nabla_{\alpha}\cdot D ∇ α ⋅ D therefore prevents their equality for the same trial rate. Appendix B gives the stochastic consistency conditions[43 ] . (ii) Onsager reciprocity must be assessed for the specified conjugate rates and forces, response protocol, and time-reversal parities[4 , 42 ] . A genuinely nonsymmetric linear resistance cannot be generated by a scalar dissipation potential alone, whose rate Hessian matrix is symmetric. The present minimization cannot then reproduce the complete response, although a physical Rayleighian may still describe a potential-generated dissipative part, with nonpotential contributions treated separately[44 ] . Nonsymmetric finite-affinity response under changing composition or reservoir controls is a different issue and need not preclude a fixed-state reaction Rayleighian (Sec. III and Appendix A). (iii) Even with constant coefficients and an unchanged reciprocal response, additional active Gaussian white noise can violate Einstein matching. If matching fails, the Gaussian cost remains computable and deterministic OVP remains valid, but the Rayleighian excess no longer gives the total fluctuation cost at the bath temperature; see Appendix C.
Extension to nonlinear chemical kinetics. We retain the physical Rayleighian in Eq. (1) , but allow nonquadratic reaction dissipation potentials. We first choose dynamically sufficient slow variables, resolve reaction channels by their state changes and chemical work, and specify their one-way reaction rates. We then derive the net-rate fluctuation cost from Poisson counts and impose local detailed balance to identify the statistical bias with the physical chemical affinity. The resulting Rayleighian selects the deterministic rates by minimization, while its excess determines their leading fluctuation cost in the frozen-state, many-event regime. This fixed-state variational construction does not require universal nonlinear differential reciprocity under changes in composition or reservoir controls, as illustrated in Sec. III.
Slow variables, reaction channels, and chemical driving
Slow variables and Markov closure. For the time-local stochastic description sought here, dynamical sufficiency is a property of the retained variables and observation resolution, within a specified range of states and controls. With the imposed control protocol fixed, it means that the conditional transition law is independent, to the stated accuracy, of earlier retained-state history:
Pr ( α n + 1 ∣ α n , α n − 1 , … ) ≃ Pr ( α n + 1 ∣ α n ) . \Pr(\alpha_{n+1}\mid\alpha_n,\alpha_{n-1},\ldots)\simeq\Pr(\alpha_{n+1}\mid\alpha_n). Pr ( α n + 1 ∣ α n , α n − 1 , … ) ≃ Pr ( α n + 1 ∣ α n ) .
Here, α n \alpha_n α n is the retained state at t n = t 0 + n Δ t t_n=t_0+n\Delta t t n = t 0 + n Δ t . To obtain such a description by eliminating rapidly relaxing variables, we seek an intermediate observation interval
τ f a s t ≪ Δ t ≪ τ s l o w . (13) \tau_{\mathrm{fast}}\ll\Delta t\ll\tau_{\mathrm{slow}}. \tag*{(13)} τ fast ≪ Δ t ≪ τ slow . (13)
Here, τ f a s t \tau_{\mathrm{fast}} τ fast is the longest relevant conditional relaxation or correlation time among eliminated variables, and τ s l o w \tau_{\mathrm{slow}} τ slow is the shortest relevant evolution time of retained variables or imposed conditions. At fixed retained state, the eliminated variables must lose relevant dependence on their preparation before that state changes appreciably. A large number of microscopic degrees of freedom does not by itself ensure this conditional relaxation or the scale separation.
A proposed closure should reproduce transition probabilities at several lags from the same fitted evolution law and show no significant residual dependence on earlier history. Chapman–Kolmogorov consistency and relaxation predictions provide practical tests, but finite data do not prove exact Markovianity.45 Agreement for mean relaxation alone is insufficient when the model is also used to predict rate fluctuations or rare histories. If relevant memory persists, additional variables or a history-dependent description are required.[46 ] The window in Eq. (13) specifies the regime of our local approximation, not a prerequisite for every valid coarse-grained theory: exact Markov projections and descriptions retaining memory provide other possibilities.[46 , 47 ] For example, the membrane–cytosol model in § 2.3 retains the evolving cytosolic pool because the membrane density alone does not determine attachment.
For the thermodynamic description, we additionally assume conditional local equilibrium (LE): at fixed slow variables, the eliminated thermal degrees of freedom are approximately equilibrated. This permits a retained free energy and chemical potentials at the current composition without requiring reaction equilibrium or small affinities.[40 ] Kinetic closure, conditional LE, and the local detailed-balance condition introduced in Sec. II C are distinct requirements.[41 ]
Reaction channels and material balances. Consider a well-mixed isothermal reactor of fixed volume V V V containing N s N_s N s retained species and N r N_r N r resolved reversible reaction channels. Let c i c_i c i be the retained molar concentrations, r ρ r_\rho r ρ the trial net reaction-rate densities, and ν i ρ \nu_{i\rho} ν i ρ the products-minus-reactants stoichiometric coefficients. The material balances are
c ˙ i = ∑ ρ = 1 N r ν i ρ r ρ , i = 1 , … , N s . (14) \dot{c}_i=\sum_{\rho=1}^{N_r}\nu_{i\rho}r_\rho,\qquad i=1,\ldots,N_s. \tag*{(14)} c ˙ i = ρ = 1 ∑ N r ν i ρ r ρ , i = 1 , … , N s . (14)
A channel denotes one specified reaction event and its reverse; a multistep pathway can contain several channels. Conserved amounts restrict the independent concentrations. Channel rates must nevertheless be distinguished from independent state rates: different channel allocations, including cycles, can produce the same concentration change. These stoichiometric distinctions matter both for reciprocal response and for chemical power.[39 , 48 , 49 ] Keeping forward and reverse event counts distinct does not by itself add dynamically necessary slow-state variables.
Free energy and chemical work. For a retained free-energy density f ( c ) f(\boldsymbol{c}) f ( c ) with no explicit time dependence, the free energy and its rate are
F = V f ( c ) , F ˙ = V ∑ ρ ( ∑ i ν i ρ μ i ) r ρ . (15) \mathcal{F}=Vf(\boldsymbol{c}),\qquad\dot{\mathcal{F}}=V\sum_\rho\left(\sum_i\nu_{i\rho}\mu_i\right)r_\rho. \tag*{(15)} F = V f ( c ) , F ˙ = V ρ ∑ ( i ∑ ν i ρ μ i ) r ρ . (15)
Here, c \boldsymbol{c} c is the concentration vector and μ i = ∂ f / ∂ c i \mu_i=\partial f/\partial c_i μ i = ∂ f / ∂ c i is a molar chemical potential. The second relation follows from the chain rule and Eq. (14) .
Reservoir exchanges supply chemical work. Let a a a label reservoir species omitted from the retained state, ν a ρ r e s \nu^{\mathrm{res}}_{a\rho} ν a ρ res their products-minus-reactants stoichiometry, and μ a r e s \mu_a^{\mathrm{res}} μ a res their maintained chemical potentials. The work per mole of forward events and the input power are
W ρ r e s = − ∑ a ν a ρ r e s μ a r e s , P i n = V ∑ ρ W ρ r e s r ρ . (16) \mathcal{W}^{\mathrm{res}}_\rho=-\sum_a\nu^{\mathrm{res}}_{a\rho}\mu_a^{\mathrm{res}},\qquad\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=V\sum_\rho\mathcal{W}^{\mathrm{res}}_\rho r_\rho. \tag*{(16)} W ρ res = − a ∑ ν a ρ res μ a res , P in = V ρ ∑ W ρ res r ρ . (16)
The resolved rates and reservoir chemical potentials determine the chemical free-energy input in this system–reservoir partition. Converting that input into a heat balance additionally requires the associated energy and entropy transfers; chemical work is not itself a heat current.[40 , 50 ] Combining the two powers identifies the complete channel affinity:
F ˙ − P i n = − V ∑ ρ A ρ r ρ . (17) \dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=-V\sum_\rho\mathcal{A}_\rho r_\rho. \tag*{(17)} F ˙ − P in = − V ρ ∑ A ρ r ρ . (17)
with the affinity
A ρ = W ρ r e s − ∑ i ν i ρ μ i . (18) \mathcal{A}_\rho=\mathcal{W}^{\mathrm{res}}_\rho-\sum_i\nu_{i\rho}\mu_i. \tag*{(18)} A ρ = W ρ res − i ∑ ν i ρ μ i . (18)
Retained and reservoir species contribute once each; no extra driving is added to an affinity that already includes the reservoirs. A chemostat fixes its own chemical potential, not generally the complete affinity.[39 , 40 ] For example, maintained fuel and waste in A + F ⇌ B + W A+F\rightleftharpoons B+W A + F ⇌ B + W supply μ F r e s − μ W r e s \mu_F^{\mathrm{res}}-\mu_W^{\mathrm{res}} μ F res − μ W res per mole of forward events. If replenishment stops, their finite amounts must instead be retained and that transfer enters the enlarged system’s free-energy @#+#+#+#+ references? no references. change. Explicit changes of energy parameters would require separate parameter-work terms and are excluded here.
Two channels with the same retained stoichiometry can have different W ρ r e s W^{\mathrm{res}}_\rho W ρ res . Their rates enter the material balance through their sum, but their separate values are needed in Eq. (16) . They must therefore remain resolved for chemical power accounting even when the concentration dynamics already closes. Choosing more state variables and resolving thermodynamically distinct channels are not the same operation.[39 , 40 ]
For comparison with Sec. II A, independent molar reaction extents can be used as α ρ = ξ ρ \alpha_\rho=\xi_\rho α ρ = ξ ρ , with α ˙ ρ = V r ρ \dot{\alpha}_\rho=V r_\rho α ˙ ρ = V r ρ and X ρ = A ρ X_\rho=A_\rho X ρ = A ρ , when this choice spans the resolved rates. For one independent concentration with c ˙ = r \dot{c}=r c ˙ = r , the corresponding choice is α = c \alpha=c α = c and X = V A X=V A X = V A . Such a coordinate identification must respect the conservation constraints and must not discard work-carrying channel cycles.
These inputs specify the retained thermodynamics and channel work, but not the mean one-way reaction rates. We next specify the stochastic reaction mechanism, derive its reaction-rate fluctuation cost, and only then identify its statistical bias with the affinity through LDB.
Poisson reaction-event statistics and nonquadratic dissipation
Poisson event counting statistics. Let r ρ + ( c ) r_\rho^+(c) r ρ + ( c ) and r ρ − ( c ) r_\rho^-(c) r ρ − ( c ) be specified positive mean one-way molar rate densities, with any imposed-control dependence left implicit. For independent Markov event clocks, freezing the current state and controls gives the counting model
Δ N ρ ± ∼ Poisson ( N A V r ρ ± Δ t ) , q ρ ± = Δ N ρ ± N A V Δ t . (19) \Delta N_\rho^\pm\sim\operatorname{Poisson}(N_{\mathrm A}V r_\rho^\pm\Delta t), \qquad q_\rho^\pm=\frac{\Delta N_\rho^\pm}{N_{\mathrm A}V\Delta t}. \tag*{(19)} Δ N ρ ± ∼ Poisson ( N A V r ρ ± Δ t ) , q ρ ± = N A V Δ t Δ N ρ ± . (19)
Here, N A N_{\mathrm A} N A is Avogadro’s constant, Δ N ρ ± \Delta N_\rho^\pm Δ N ρ ± are event counts, and q ρ ± q_\rho^\pm q ρ ± are measured one-way rate densities. A forward event changes c i c_i c i by ν i ρ / ( N A V ) \nu_{i\rho}/(N_{\mathrm A}V) ν i ρ / ( N A V ) . Independent Markov event clocks are specified at the resolved level; fixed-rate independent Poisson counts over a finite interval additionally use the frozen-state approximation.[51 , 52 ] The rate spacing is 1 / ( N A V Δ t ) 1/(N_{\mathrm A}V\Delta t) 1/ ( N A V Δ t ) . Relevant counts must be large for the continuous-rate approximation, while the state changes little. Large volume can provide this window; LE alone cannot. We work where both directions have positive rates. A forbidden direction has zero count and must instead be treated on its restricted event support.
For one reaction direction (forward or reverse), let n n n be the number of reaction events observed over an interval Δ t \Delta t Δ t at a fixed state. Assuming Poisson statistics with mean one-way rate density a > 0 a>0 a > 0 , the exact count probability is Pr ( n ) = e − λ λ n / n ! \Pr(n)=e^{-\lambda}\lambda^n/n! Pr ( n ) = e − λ λ n / n ! , where λ = N A V a Δ t \lambda=N_{\mathrm A}Va\Delta t λ = N A V a Δ t is the mean event count and q = n / ( N A V Δ t ) q=n/(N_{\mathrm A}V\Delta t) q = n / ( N A V Δ t ) is the measured one-way rate density. Applying Stirling’s approximation for large counts gives
− ln Pr ( n ) ≃ N A V Δ t h ( q ∣ a ) , (20) -\ln\Pr(n)\simeq N_{\mathrm A}V\Delta t\,h(q|a), \tag*{(20)} − ln Pr ( n ) ≃ N A V Δ t h ( q ∣ a ) , (20)
where h ( q ∣ a ) = q ln ( q / a ) − q + a h(q|a)=q\ln(q/a)-q+a h ( q ∣ a ) = q ln ( q / a ) − q + a for q ≥ 0 q\geq0 q ≥ 0 , with h ( 0 ∣ a ) = a h(0|a)=a h ( 0∣ a ) = a by continuity. Here, h ( q ∣ a ) h(q|a) h ( q ∣ a ) is the fluctuation cost per unit volume and time in molar-rate units, minimized at the mean rate q = a q=a q = a . The approximation retains the nonquadratic dependence on q q q ; a Gaussian approximation would require a further expansion about q = a q=a q = a .
A prescribed net rate sums over compatible forward/reverse counts. The leading minimization follows from
− Ω − 1 ln ∑ j e − Ω g j = g min − Ω − 1 ln ∑ j e − Ω ( g j − g min ) . (21) -\Omega^{-1}\ln\sum_j e^{-\Omega g_j}=g_{\min}-\Omega^{-1}\ln\sum_j e^{-\Omega(g_j-g_{\min})}. \tag*{(21)} − Ω − 1 ln j ∑ e − Ω g j = g m i n − Ω − 1 ln j ∑ e − Ω ( g j − g m i n ) . (21)
Here, Ω \Omega Ω is a dimensionless large scale, g j g_j g j are dimensionless costs, and g min = min j g j g_{\min}=\min_j g_j g m i n = min j g j . If the remaining weights and number of alternatives supply no additional exponential factor, the final term is subleading. Contracting the forward and reverse counting costs at fixed net rate gives the standard net-current construction[9 , 52 , 53 ] :
ℓ ( r ) = min q ± ≥ 0 , q + − q − = r { h ( q + ∣ r + ) + h ( q − ∣ r − ) } . (22) \ell(r)=\min_{\substack{q^\pm\geq0,\ q^+-q^-=r}}\{h(q^+|r^+)+h(q^-|r^-)\}. \tag*{(22)} ℓ ( r ) = q ± ≥ 0 , q + − q − = r min { h ( q + ∣ r + ) + h ( q − ∣ r − )} . (22)
The channel index is suppressed. Differentiation at fixed r r r gives ln ( q + / r + ) + ln ( q − / r − ) = 0 \ln(q^+/r^+)+\ln(q^-/r^-)=0 ln ( q + / r + ) + ln ( q − / r − ) = 0 , hence q + q − = r + r − q^+q^-=r^+r^- q + q − = r + r − . Writing s = r 2 + 4 r + r − s=\sqrt{r^2+4r^+r^-} s = r 2 + 4 r + r − , the minimizing one-way rates are q ± = ( s ± r ) / 2 q^\pm=(s\pm r)/2 q ± = ( s ± r ) /2 , and substitution gives
ℓ ( r ) = r ln r + s 2 r + − s + r + + r − . (23) \ell(r)=r\ln\frac{r+s}{2r^+}-s+r^++r^-. \tag*{(23)} ℓ ( r ) = r ln 2 r + r + s − s + r + + r − . (23)
Here, s s s and ℓ \ell ℓ have rate-density units. The cost has zero minimum at r ∗ = r + − r − r_*=r^+-r^- r ∗ = r + − r − .
To display its even and odd parts under rate reversal, define
ϑ = ln r + r − , Γ = 2 r + r − , (24) \vartheta=\ln\frac{r^+}{r^-}, \qquad\Gamma=2\sqrt{r^+r^-}, \tag*{(24)} ϑ = ln r − r + , Γ = 2 r + r − , (24)
σ = r + + r − , r ± = Γ 2 e ± ϑ / 2 . (25) \sigma=r^++r^-, \qquad r^\pm=\frac{\Gamma}{2}e^{\pm\vartheta/2}. \tag*{(25)} σ = r + + r − , r ± = 2 Γ e ± ϑ /2 . (25)
Here, ϑ \vartheta ϑ is the dimensionless forward–reverse rate bias, Γ \Gamma Γ is the geometric-mean kinetic scale, invariant under exchange of the forward and reverse rates, and σ \sigma σ is the sum of the one-way rates. These quantities simply reparametrize the prescribed positive one-way rates; their definitions neither impose local detailed balance nor assume equal activation barriers. The fluctuation cost in Eq. (23) can now be rewritten as
ℓ ( r ) = r arsinh ( r / Γ ) − r 2 + Γ 2 + σ − ϑ r 2 . (26) \ell(r)=r\operatorname{arsinh}(r/\Gamma)-\sqrt{r^2+\Gamma^2}+\sigma-\frac{\vartheta r}{2}. \tag*{(26)} ℓ ( r ) = r arsinh ( r /Γ ) − r 2 + Γ 2 + σ − 2 ϑ r . (26)
where arsinh x = ln ( x + 1 + x 2 ) \operatorname{arsinh}x=\ln(x+\sqrt{1+x^2}) arsinh x = ln ( x + 1 + x 2 ) and the channel index is again suppressed. No thermodynamic identification has entered. The kinetic scales may change with composition or controls, but their current values are fixed during trial-rate variation.
Physical Rayleighian and thermodynamic matching. The affinity A ρ A_\rho A ρ is fixed by the retained free energy and reservoir work in Eq. (18) , independently of the statistical bias ϑ ρ \vartheta_\rho ϑ ρ . A physical reaction Rayleighian additionally requires a constitutive dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ . For the even potentials considered here, with Φ ( 0 ) = 0 \Phi(0)=0 Φ ( 0 ) = 0 , it has the form R = Φ ‾ − V ∑ ρ A ρ r ρ \mathcal{R}=\overline{\Phi}-V\sum_\rho\mathcal{A}_\rho r_\rho R = Φ − V ∑ ρ A ρ r ρ . Whether its excess reproduces the counting cost is a separate matching question. Comparison of their rate-reversal-odd parts requires
R T ϑ ρ = R T ln r ρ + r ρ − = A ρ = W ρ r e s − ∑ i ν i ρ μ i . (27) RT\vartheta_\rho=RT\ln\frac{r_\rho^+}{r_\rho^-}=\mathcal{A}_\rho=W_\rho^{\mathrm{res}}-\sum_i\nu_{i\rho}\mu_i. \tag*{(27)} R T ϑ ρ = R T ln r ρ − r ρ + = A ρ = W ρ res − i ∑ ν i ρ μ i . (27)
Here, R = N A k B R=N_{\mathrm{A}}k_{\mathrm{B}} R = N A k B is the gas constant and T T T is the same isothermal bath temperature used to define the thermodynamics. This macroscopic LDB is the small-concentration-change form of the finite-number relation comparing a forward transition with its reverse from the arrival state. It does not require equal forward and reverse rates. It may hold far from chemical equilibrium and does not determine Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ [40 , 54 , 55 ] . Temperature is a bath property, not a consequence of Poisson or Gaussian statistics. Unresolved active forcing need not satisfy this identification.
The resolved jumps may represent elementary reactions or effective transitions whose Markov description is independently justified. A balanced overall reaction equation and timescale separation alone do not establish either the required counting law or physical LDB[41 , 56 ] .
The LDB relation matches the statistical bias to the physical affinity, but does not determine the rate-reversal-even contribution. For one channel, matching this contribution with φ ( 0 ; Γ ) = 0 \varphi(0;\Gamma)=0 φ ( 0 ; Γ ) = 0 requires
φ ( r ; Γ ) = R T [ ℓ ( r ) + ℓ ( − r ) − 2 ℓ ( 0 ) ] . \varphi(r;\Gamma)=RT\left[\ell(r)+\ell(-r)-2\ell(0)\right]. φ ( r ; Γ ) = R T [ ℓ ( r ) + ℓ ( − r ) − 2 ℓ ( 0 ) ] .
Substituting the Poisson cost gives the established nonquadratic reaction dissipation potential[9 , 10 , 14 ] . It is equivalent to the flux-side potential in Eq. (12) of Kobayashi et al. [34 ] , written here in molar-rate and power-density units:
φ ( r ; Γ ) = 2 R T [ r arsinh ( r / Γ ) − r 2 + Γ 2 + Γ ] . (28) \varphi(r;\Gamma)=2RT\left[r\operatorname{arsinh}(r/\Gamma)-\sqrt{r^2+\Gamma^2}+\Gamma\right]. \tag*{(28)} φ ( r ; Γ ) = 2 R T [ r arsinh ( r /Γ ) − r 2 + Γ 2 + Γ ] . (28)
Here, φ \varphi φ has units of power per volume, vanishes at r = 0 r=0 r = 0 , and is strictly convex, with ∂ r φ = 2 R T arsinh ( r / Γ ) \partial_r\varphi=2RT\operatorname{arsinh}(r/\Gamma) ∂ r φ = 2 R T arsinh ( r /Γ ) and ∂ r 2 φ = 2 R T / r 2 + Γ 2 > 0 \partial_r^2\varphi=2RT/\sqrt{r^2+\Gamma^2}>0 ∂ r 2 φ = 2 R T / r 2 + Γ 2 > 0 . For the spatially uniform reaction system, the total dissipation potential is
Φ = V ∑ ρ φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) . (29) \Phi=V\sum_\rho\varphi(r_\rho;\Gamma_\rho). \tag*{(29)} Φ = V ρ ∑ φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) . (29)
The corresponding physical Rayleighian is R = Φ + F ˙ − P i n \mathcal{R}=\Phi+\dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} R = Φ + F ˙ − P in , or equivalently,
R = V ∑ ρ [ φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) − A ρ r ρ ] . (30) \mathcal{R}=V\sum_\rho\left[\varphi(r_\rho;\Gamma_\rho)-\mathcal{A}_\rho r_\rho\right]. \tag*{(30)} R = V ρ ∑ [ φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) − A ρ r ρ ] . (30)
Minimizing R \mathcal{R} R over the trial reaction rates r ρ r_\rho r ρ at fixed composition, controls, and kinetic scales Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ gives the unique selected rates
r ρ , ∗ = Γ ρ sinh A ρ 2 R T = r ρ + − r ρ − . (31) r_{\rho,*}=\Gamma_\rho\sinh\frac{\mathcal{A}_\rho}{2RT}=r_\rho^+-r_\rho^-. \tag*{(31)} r ρ , ∗ = Γ ρ sinh 2 R T A ρ = r ρ + − r ρ − . (31)
The star denotes the selected deterministic rate. The constitutive choice in Eq. (28) matches the even part of the event cost, while Eq. (27) matches its odd part; together they yield the excess relation in Eq. (39) . Substituting Eq. (31) into Eq. (14) determines the concentration dynamics. Along the selected evolution, the free-energy balance is F ˙ = P i n − D \dot{\mathcal{F}}=\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}-\mathcal{D} F ˙ = P in − D , where D = V ∑ ρ A ρ r ρ , ∗ ≥ 0 \mathcal{D}=V\sum_\rho\mathcal{A}_\rho r_{\rho,*}\ge0 D = V ∑ ρ A ρ r ρ , ∗ ≥ 0 is the dissipation power.
The dual dissipation potential Ψ \Psi Ψ is the convex conjugate of Φ \Phi Φ at fixed state and controls[13 , 19 , 34 ] :
Ψ ( X ) = sup s [ X ⋅ s − Φ ( s ) ] . (32) \Psi(\mathbf{X})=\sup_{\mathbf{s}}\left[\mathbf{X}\cdot\mathbf{s}-\Phi(\mathbf{s})\right]. \tag*{(32)} Ψ ( X ) = s sup [ X ⋅ s − Φ ( s ) ] . (32)
Here, s = ( s ρ ) \mathbf{s}=(s_\rho) s = ( s ρ ) denotes trial rate densities and X \mathbf{X} X their conjugate force argument. At fixed state and kinetic scales, the nonlinear dual relations X = ∂ r Φ ( r ∗ ) \mathbf{X}=\partial_{\mathbf{r}}\Phi(\mathbf{r}_*) X = ∂ r Φ ( r ∗ ) and r ∗ = ∂ X Ψ ( X ) \mathbf{r}_*=\partial_{\mathbf{X}}\Psi(\mathbf{X}) r ∗ = ∂ X Ψ ( X ) , with X = V A \mathbf{X}=V\mathcal{A} X = V A , imply
D = Φ ( r ∗ ) + Ψ ( V A ) , (33) \mathcal{D}=\Phi(\mathbf{r}_*)+\Psi(V\mathcal{A}), \tag*{(33)} D = Φ ( r ∗ ) + Ψ ( V A ) , (33)
where A = ( A ρ ) \mathcal{A}=(\mathcal{A}_\rho) A = ( A ρ ) . For a quadratic homogeneous dissipation potential, Ψ ( V A ) = Φ ( r ∗ ) \Psi(V\mathcal{A})=\Phi(\mathbf{r}_*) Ψ ( V A ) = Φ ( r ∗ ) , so D = 2 Φ ( r ∗ ) \mathcal{D}=2\Phi(\mathbf{r}_*) D = 2Φ ( r ∗ ) . For the present nonquadratic reaction potential, this factor-of-two relation holds to leading quadratic order near equilibrium, but not in general. For the thermodynamically resolved isothermal reaction model, channelwise LDB identifies D = T S ˙ p r o d \mathcal{D}=T\dot{S}_{\mathrm{prod}} D = T S ˙ prod , where S ˙ p r o d \dot{S}_{\mathrm{prod}} S ˙ prod is the entropy production rate of the macroscopic rate equations[40 ] . This identification neither makes each reaction contribution a heat current nor equates D \mathcal{D} D with the complete finite-system stochastic entropy production. Equation (22) is minimized over unobserved counts at fixed r r r ; Eq. (31) instead selects the typical r r r . This also differs from minimizing the dissipation potential at a prescribed concentration-change rate, as in Kobayashi et al. [34 ] (Eq. (D12)). That constrained minimization determines a reference allocation of reaction-channel rates, not generally the actual driven rates.
Quadratic limit and mobility normalization
Expanding Eq. (28) about zero trial rate at fixed state gives
φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) = R T Γ ρ r ρ 2 + O ( R T Γ ρ 3 r ρ 4 ) ≃ r ρ 2 2 L ρ , L ρ = Γ ρ 2 R T , \varphi(r_\rho;\Gamma_\rho)=\frac{RT}{\Gamma_\rho}r_\rho^2+O\left(\frac{RT}{\Gamma_\rho^3}r_\rho^4\right)\simeq\frac{r_\rho^2}{2L_\rho},\qquad L_\rho=\frac{\Gamma_\rho}{2RT}, φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) = Γ ρ R T r ρ 2 + O ( Γ ρ 3 R T r ρ 4 ) ≃ 2 L ρ r ρ 2 , L ρ = 2 R T Γ ρ ,
for ∣ r ρ ∣ / Γ ρ ≪ 1 |r_\rho|/\Gamma_\rho\ll1 ∣ r ρ ∣/ Γ ρ ≪ 1 . Here, L ρ L_\rho L ρ is the reaction-rate-density mobility of this quadratic approximation, and L ρ − 1 L_\rho^{-1} L ρ − 1 is its resistance. For ∣ A ρ ∣ ≪ R T |\mathcal{A}_\rho|\ll RT ∣ A ρ ∣ ≪ R T , variation gives r ρ , ∗ ≃ L ρ A ρ r_{\rho,*}\simeq L_\rho\mathcal{A}_\rho r ρ , ∗ ≃ L ρ A ρ . A strict linearization about chemical equilibrium evaluates L ρ L_\rho L ρ there; it does not determine the full composition dependence of Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ . This small-affinity limit is distinct from the local Gaussian expansion of fluctuations about a finite-affinity mean in Sec. III C.
The mobility also depends on the chosen rate coordinate and its conjugate force. For a single independent conversion with c ˙ = r ρ \dot{c}=r_\rho c ˙ = r ρ and molar extent rate ξ ˙ = V r ρ \dot{\xi}=Vr_\rho ξ ˙ = V r ρ , the corresponding scalar entry of L L L in Sec. II A is V L ρ VL_\rho V L ρ for α = ξ \alpha=\xi α = ξ , X = A ρ X=\mathcal{A}_\rho X = A ρ , and L ρ / V L_\rho/V L ρ / V for α = c \alpha=c α = c , X = V A ρ X=V\mathcal{A}_\rho X = V A ρ . Appendix A checks the extent normalization through its equilibrium response and counting variance.
Independent event drivers and coupled dynamics. The channelwise sum in Eq. (30) follows from the specified independent Poisson event drivers. At fixed composition and controls, ∂ 2 Φ / ( ∂ r ρ ∂ r ρ ′ ) = 0 \partial^2\Phi/(\partial r_\rho\partial r_{\rho'})=0 ∂ 2 Φ/ ( ∂ r ρ ∂ r ρ ′ ) = 0 for ρ ≠ ρ ′ \rho\ne\rho' ρ = ρ ′ , since each term depends on one trial channel rate. This separability belongs to the resolved event-rate representation; it does not imply an uncoupled chemical network.[52 , 56 ] The diagonal kinetic matrix in the equilibrium linear limit is Onsager-symmetric: reciprocity permits cross coefficients but does not require them to be nonzero. Changing to other independent rate coordinates, with consistently transformed conjugate forces, can introduce reciprocal cross coefficients.[49 ]
Channels remain coupled through their composition-dependent affinities and kinetic scales and through the material balances. An event in one channel can change subsequent rates in other channels, so independent local event drivers do not imply independent accumulated counts along an evolving trajectory. Moreover, one event can change several species. Since a forward or reverse event in channel ρ \rho ρ changes c i c_i c i by ± ν i ρ / ( N A V ) \pm\nu_{i\rho}/(N_{\mathrm{A}}V) ± ν i ρ / ( N A V ) , the Poisson counting variances give
Cov ( d c i , d c j ∣ c ) = d t N A V ∑ ρ ν i ρ ν j ρ σ ρ + o ( d t ) , (34) \operatorname{Cov}(dc_i,dc_j\mid c)=\frac{dt}{N_{\mathrm{A}}V}\sum_\rho\nu_{i\rho}\nu_{j\rho}\sigma_\rho+o(dt), \tag*{(34)} Cov ( d c i , d c j ∣ c ) = N A V d t ρ ∑ ν i ρ ν j ρ σ ρ + o ( d t ) , (34)
where σ ρ = r ρ + + r ρ − \sigma_\rho=r_\rho^++r_\rho^- σ ρ = r ρ + + r ρ − is the sum of the mean one-way rate densities. The concentration covariance can therefore have off-diagonal entries even when the local channel cost is additive. Changing rate coordinates, or contracting the channel cost subject to prescribed concentration rates, can likewise produce a nonseparable reduced cost. The two-channel model in Sec. III illustrates correlated material and fuel conversion and distinguishes fixed-state rate variation from response under changing composition or reservoir controls.
Thus, resolving channels does not remove all coupling, and observed cross correlations alone do not establish that channels are missing. If chosen rate variables count common events, their joint statistics must be derived from the underlying event model. A simultaneous physical event is represented as one Markov jump with its complete stoichiometric change. If eliminating intermediates instead leaves slow memory, a description retaining that memory or the relevant intermediates is required. Cross terms in a fluctuation-derived dissipation potential must follow from this stochastic construction; inserting them independently requires rechecking the fluctuation interpretation.
Kinetic scales and mass-action specialization. For the specified Poisson event model, matching the counting statistics fixes the trial-rate dependence of φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) \varphi(r_\rho;\Gamma_\rho) φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) , while LDB relates the forward–reverse rate ratio to the physical channel affinity. The kinetic scale Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ and its dependence on composition and controls remain constitutive inputs, analogous to specifying mobility or resistance in quadratic OVP.[6 , 7 ] These inputs must be supplied from the reaction mechanism, kinetic measurements, or an explicit phenomenological assumption; they are not determined by the free energy, LDB, or variational minimization. Once Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ is specified, Eq. (31) determines the selected net rate without a separate constitutive law for that rate.
To express this kinetic input in chemical terms, let ν s ρ R , ν s ρ P ≥ 0 \nu_{s\rho}^{R},\nu_{s\rho}^{P}\geq0 ν s ρ R , ν s ρ P ≥ 0 be the dimensionless stoichiometric coefficients of species s s s on the reactant and product sides of channel ρ \rho ρ . They specify the reaction, not the amounts or concentrations present. For retained species, ν i ρ = ν i ρ P − ν i ρ R \nu_{i\rho}=\nu_{i\rho}^{P}-\nu_{i\rho}^{R} ν i ρ = ν i ρ P − ν i ρ R is the coefficient in Eq. (14) ; reservoir coefficients use the same products-minus-reactants convention. The index s s s below includes both retained and reservoir species, with μ s \mu_s μ s denoting the corresponding molar chemical potential. Define the stoichiometrically weighted chemical-potential sums
G ρ R = ∑ s ν s ρ R μ s , G ρ P = ∑ s ν s ρ P μ s . \mathcal{G}_\rho^{R}=\sum_s\nu_{s\rho}^{R}\mu_s,\qquad\mathcal{G}_\rho^{P}=\sum_s\nu_{s\rho}^{P}\mu_s. G ρ R = s ∑ ν s ρ R μ s , G ρ P = s ∑ ν s ρ P μ s .
Both have molar-energy units, and their difference is the complete affinity of Eq. (18) : A ρ = G ρ R − G ρ P \mathcal{A}_\rho=\mathcal{G}_\rho^{R}-\mathcal{G}_\rho^{P} A ρ = G ρ R − G ρ P . For example, A + F ⇌ B + W A+F\rightleftharpoons B+W A + F ⇌ B + W has G F R = μ A + μ F \mathcal{G}_{F}^{R}=\mu_A+\mu_F G F R = μ A + μ F and G F P = μ B + μ W \mathcal{G}_{F}^{P}=\mu_B+\mu_W G F P = μ B + μ W .
A useful parametrization is
Γ ρ = 2 κ ρ exp [ G ρ R + G ρ P 2 R T ] , (35) \Gamma_\rho=2\kappa_\rho\exp\left[\frac{\mathcal{G}_\rho^{R}+\mathcal{G}_\rho^{P}}{2RT}\right], \tag*{(35)} Γ ρ = 2 κ ρ exp [ 2 R T G ρ R + G ρ P ] , (35)
where κ ρ > 0 \kappa_\rho>0 κ ρ > 0 is a rate-density prefactor that may depend on composition and controls. Using A ρ = G ρ R − G ρ P \mathcal{A}_\rho=\mathcal{G}_\rho^{R}-\mathcal{G}_\rho^{P} A ρ = G ρ R − G ρ P in Eq. (31) gives
r ρ , ∗ = κ ρ [ e G ρ R / ( R T ) − e G ρ P / ( R T ) ] . (36) r_{\rho,*}=\kappa_\rho\left[e^{\mathcal{G}_\rho^{R}/(RT)}-e^{\mathcal{G}_\rho^{P}/(RT)}\right]. \tag*{(36)} r ρ , ∗ = κ ρ [ e G ρ R / ( R T ) − e G ρ P / ( R T ) ] . (36)
With unrestricted κ ρ \kappa_\rho κ ρ , this parametrizes a positive kinetic scale rather than predicting it. Chemical-potential exponential rate laws with a common transition-state prefactor are also used in nonequilibrium reaction kinetics.[58 , 59 ] Specifying the prefactor and its state dependence supplies kinetic information, such as activation-barrier and attempt-frequency effects, that neither LE nor LDB determines.
Write μ s = μ s ∘ + R T ln a s \mu_s=\mu_s^\circ+RT\ln a_s μ s = μ s ∘ + R T ln a s , where μ s ∘ \mu_s^\circ μ s ∘ is the standard molar chemical potential and a s a_s a s the dimensionless activity. Define the activity-based one-way prefactors by
k ρ + , a = κ ρ exp [ ∑ s ν s ρ R μ s ∘ R T ] , k_\rho^{+,a}=\kappa_\rho\exp\left[\frac{\sum_s\nu_{s\rho}^{R}\mu_s^\circ}{RT}\right], k ρ + , a = κ ρ exp [ R T ∑ s ν s ρ R μ s ∘ ] ,
k ρ − , a = κ ρ exp [ ∑ s ν s ρ P μ s ∘ R T ] . k_\rho^{-,a}=\kappa_\rho\exp\left[\frac{\sum_s\nu_{s\rho}^{P}\mu_s^\circ}{RT}\right]. k ρ − , a = κ ρ exp [ R T ∑ s ν s ρ P μ s ∘ ] .
The superscript a a a distinguishes them from concentration-based coefficients. Both have rate-density units and inherit any composition dependence of κ ρ \kappa_\rho κ ρ . Equation (35) then becomes
Γ ρ = 2 k ρ + , a k ρ − , a ∏ s a s ( ν s ρ R + ν s ρ P ) / 2 . (37) \Gamma_\rho=2\sqrt{k_\rho^{+,a}k_\rho^{-,a}}\prod_s a_s^{(\nu_{s\rho}^{R}+\nu_{s\rho}^{P})/2}. \tag*{(37)} Γ ρ = 2 k ρ + , a k ρ − , a s ∏ a s ( ν s ρ R + ν s ρ P ) /2 . (37)
Combining this scale with r ρ ± = ( Γ ρ / 2 ) e ± A ρ / ( 2 R T ) r_\rho^{\pm}=(\Gamma_\rho/2)e^{\pm A_\rho/(2RT)} r ρ ± = ( Γ ρ /2 ) e ± A ρ / ( 2 R T ) gives
r ρ + = k ρ + , a ∏ s a s ν ρ , s R , r ρ − = k ρ − , a ∏ s a s ν ρ , s P . (38) r_\rho^{+}=k_\rho^{+,a}\prod_s a_s^{\nu_{\rho,s}^{\mathrm{R}}},\qquad r_\rho^{-}=k_\rho^{-,a}\prod_s a_s^{\nu_{\rho,s}^{\mathrm{P}}}. \tag*{(38)} r ρ + = k ρ + , a s ∏ a s ν ρ , s R , r ρ − = k ρ − , a s ∏ a s ν ρ , s P . (38)
For an elementary channel, choosing κ ρ \kappa_\rho κ ρ to be composition independent at fixed temperature, controls, and standard states makes k ρ ± , a k_\rho^{\pm,a} k ρ ± , a constant and yields the constant-coefficient activity-based law of mass action. This is an additional kinetic specialization, not a consequence of stoichiometry, LE, or LDB alone. Effective multistep reaction kinetics need not have this form; composition-dependent prefactors can preserve LDB without obeying this constant-coefficient law of mass action. The Poisson assumption specifies the counting statistics and the associated cost of fluctuations once the mean one-way rates are prescribed; however, it does not constrain how the mean one-way rates depend on composition.
For a dilute ideal mixture, a s = c s / c ∘ a_s=c_s/c^\circ a s = c s / c ∘ , where c ∘ > 0 c^\circ>0 c ∘ > 0 is a fixed reference concentration. Absorbing its powers into the coefficients gives
k ρ + = k ρ + , a ( c ∘ ) − ∑ s ν ρ , s R , k ρ − = k ρ − , a ( c ∘ ) − ∑ s ν ρ , s P , k_\rho^{+}=k_\rho^{+,a}(c^\circ)^{-\sum_s\nu_{\rho,s}^{\mathrm{R}}},\qquad k_\rho^{-}=k_\rho^{-,a}(c^\circ)^{-\sum_s\nu_{\rho,s}^{\mathrm{P}}}, k ρ + = k ρ + , a ( c ∘ ) − ∑ s ν ρ , s R , k ρ − = k ρ − , a ( c ∘ ) − ∑ s ν ρ , s P ,
and hence the usual concentration form of mass action. The units of these concentration-based constants depend on the total stoichiometric power on the corresponding reaction side.[40 , 60 ]
Constitutive choices in the applications. For the passive and fueled conversions of Sec. III, constant-coefficient concentration mass action gives Γ 0 = 2 k 0 + k 0 − c A c B \Gamma_0=2\sqrt{k_0^{+}k_0^{-}c_Ac_B} Γ 0 = 2 k 0 + k 0 − c A c B and Γ F = 2 k F + k F − c A c B c F c W \Gamma_F=2\sqrt{k_F^{+}k_F^{-}c_Ac_Bc_Fc_W} Γ F = 2 k F + k F − c A c B c F c W , as used in Eq. (53) . These factors express reactant and product availability through Γ ρ = 2 r ρ + r ρ − \Gamma_\rho=2\sqrt{r_\rho^{+}r_\rho^{-}} Γ ρ = 2 r ρ + r ρ − . Their square roots, and the half powers in Eq. (37) , do not represent fractional reaction orders.
The nonideal mixture in Sec. IV instead retains chemical-potential exponentials in Eq. (76), including nonideal and gradient contributions. Its exchange-potential representation absorbs solvent factors into k 0 , κ F k_0,\kappa_F k 0 , κ F without determining their composition dependence. The membrane model in Sec. V, Eq. (89), retains ideal component activities but uses state-dependent channel prefactors to describe saturating cooperative recruitment and its allocation to the fueled channel. It is therefore not a constant-prefactor mass-action special case: ideal component thermodynamics does not fix the kinetic prefactors. The application models in Secs. III A, IV, and V A use the same Poisson-matched potential in Eq. (28) , with different constitutive functions Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ . Section III C instead compares different Rayleighian representations of the same selected rate.
Inhibition, saturation, and interactions involving activated states can invalidate the constant-prefactor approximation. If eliminated intermediates relax on the retained timescale, additional state variables or memory may be required rather than merely a modified instantaneous prefactor.[59 , 61 ] Throughout, holding Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ fixed during trial-rate variation does not make it constant along the evolving state. The further approximation Γ ρ ≃ Γ ρ , e q \Gamma_\rho\simeq\Gamma_{\rho,\mathrm{eq}} Γ ρ ≃ Γ ρ , eq , where Γ ρ , e q \Gamma_{\rho,\mathrm{eq}} Γ ρ , eq is its equilibrium value, is justified only over a neighborhood in which its relative variation is negligible. It supplies a constant coefficient for the local Onsager limit, not a general kinetic law over finite changes in composition.[6 ]
The extended Rayleighian: deterministic and statistical roles
One Rayleighian for rates and fluctuations. The resolved LDB-compatible channels realize the established nonlinear Onsager–Machlup structure.[31 , 33 ] Their frozen-state, many-event rate probability is
Pr ( { r ρ } ∣ c ) ≍ exp [ − N A V Δ t ∑ ρ ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) ] = exp [ − Δ t ( R − R min ) / ( 2 k B T ) ] . (39) \begin{aligned}
\Pr(\{r_\rho\}\mid c)\asymp\exp\left[-N_A V\Delta t\sum_\rho\ell_\rho(r_\rho)\right] \\
&=\exp\left[-\Delta t(\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min})/(2k_BT)\right]. \tag*{(39)}
\end{aligned} Pr ({ r ρ } ∣ c ) ≍ exp [ − N A V Δ t ρ ∑ ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) ] = exp [ − Δ t ( R − R m i n ) / ( 2 k B T ) ] . (39)
Here, ≍ \asymp ≍ denotes leading exponential equality, not a normalized exact finite-count density. The local fluctuation cost per unit time is L = N A V ∑ ρ ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) \mathcal{L}=N_A V\sum_\rho\ell_\rho(r_\rho) L = N A V ∑ ρ ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) . The rates must satisfy the same conservation constraints. An endpoint probability further sums over unresolved rate allocations. The instantaneous minimum is R min = − Ψ ( V A ) = − 2 R T V ∑ ρ ( σ ρ − Γ ρ ) \mathcal{R}_{\min}=-\Psi(\mathcal{V}\mathcal{A})=-2RTV\sum_\rho(\sigma_\rho-\Gamma_\rho) R m i n = − Ψ ( V A ) = − 2 R T V ∑ ρ ( σ ρ − Γ ρ ) . The corresponding Gyarmati-type local functional, expressed in power units,[13 ] satisfies
G = V ∑ ρ A ρ r ρ − Φ ( r ) − Ψ ( V A ) , (40) \mathcal{G}=V\sum_\rho A_\rho r_\rho-\Phi(r)-\Psi(V\mathcal{A}), \tag*{(40)} G = V ρ ∑ A ρ r ρ − Φ ( r ) − Ψ ( V A ) , (40)
− G = R − R min = 2 R T V ∑ ρ ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) ≥ 0. (41) -\mathcal{G}=\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min}=2RTV\sum_\rho\ell_\rho(r_\rho)\geq0. \tag*{(41)} − G = R − R m i n = 2 R T V ρ ∑ ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) ≥ 0. (41)
At fixed state and controls, maximizing G \mathcal{G} G is equivalent to minimizing R \mathcal{R} R . The nonnegative excess is the standard convex-dual gap, also written as a mixed Bregman divergence by Kobayashi et al.[34 ] (Eq. (31) ). Convex duality establishes the variational equivalence; the specified Poisson statistics and LDB identify − G / ( 2 k B T ) -\mathcal{G}/(2k_BT) − G / ( 2 k B T ) with the local fluctuation cost in the stated many-event limit. (9) is the quadratic, Einstein-matched counterpart. The corresponding dimensionless trajectory action I \mathcal{I} I is
I = N A V ∫ t 0 t f ∑ ρ ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) d t = 1 2 k B T ∫ t 0 t f ( R − R min ) d t . (42) \mathcal{I}=N_A V\int_{t_0}^{t_f}\sum_\rho\ell_\rho(r_\rho)\,\mathrm{d}t=\frac{1}{2k_BT}\int_{t_0}^{t_f}(\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min})\,\mathrm{d}t. \tag*{(42)} I = N A V ∫ t 0 t f ρ ∑ ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) d t = 2 k B T 1 ∫ t 0 t f ( R − R m i n ) d t . (42)
Here, t 0 t_0 t 0 and t f t_f t f are the initial and final times. Conditional on the initial state, the trajectory weight scales as e − I e^{-\mathcal{I}} e − I at the stated resolution and leading exponential order. The state-dependent minimum R min \mathcal{R}_{\min} R m i n must be retained when comparing trajectories.
The role of LDB is also evident from the rate-reversal asymmetry:
ℓ ( r ) − ℓ ( − r ) = − ϑ r = L D B − A r R T . (43) \ell(r)-\ell(-r)=-\vartheta r\overset{\mathrm{LDB}}{=}-\frac{\mathcal{A}r}{RT}. \tag*{(43)} ℓ ( r ) − ℓ ( − r ) = − ϑ r = LDB − R T A r . (43)
The first equality follows from Poisson counting statistics, whereas LDB identifies the statistical bias with the physical channel affinity A \mathcal{A} A through R T ϑ = A RT\vartheta=\mathcal{A} R T ϑ = A . Thus, LDB determines the physical rate-reversal asymmetry, but neither the kinetic scale Γ \Gamma Γ nor the full fluctuation cost ℓ ( r ) \ell(r) ℓ ( r ) . Along the selected evolution, the rate–affinity products give the dissipation power D \mathcal{D} D and the corresponding macroscopic entropy production by D = V ∑ ρ A ρ r ρ , ∗ = T S ˙ p r o d m a c \mathcal{D}=V\sum_{\rho}\mathcal{A}_{\rho}r_{\rho,*}=T\dot{S}^{\mathrm{mac}}_{\mathrm{prod}} D = V ∑ ρ A ρ r ρ , ∗ = T S ˙ prod mac , connecting the fluctuation asymmetry to the deterministic free-energy balance.
This frozen-state relation is consistent with fluctuation-theorem descriptions[55 , 62 ] , but does not by itself give the entropy production of a finite stochastic trajectory. The latter requires the forward and reversed path probabilities, including their initial distributions and control protocols[54 , 55 , 63 ] . Identifying heat and matter-related entropy flows further requires the corresponding energetic information. LDB permits driven chemical cycles and does not imply equilibrium detailed balance or universal finite-affinity differential reciprocity[40 ] .
Physical interpretation and scope. Near equilibrium the expansion in Sec. II C recovers linear chemical response. A different expansion at finite affinity gives ℓ ( r ) ≃ ( r − r ∗ ) 2 / ( 2 σ ) \ell(r)\simeq(r-r_*)^2/(2\sigma) ℓ ( r ) ≃ ( r − r ∗ ) 2 / ( 2 σ ) and local measured-rate variance σ / ( N A V Δ t ) \sigma/(N_{\mathrm{A}}V\Delta t) σ / ( N A V Δ t ) . This Gaussian central approximation neither linearizes the constitutive law nor retains the non-Gaussian tails.[64 ] Conversely, chemical event counts give a local equilibrium Einstein relation for reaction-extent fluctuations without a diffusion approximation (Appendix A). Gaussianity, whiteness, temperature, and thermodynamic matching are different properties.
A physical Rayleighian can retain its deterministic role when additional active fluctuations are not matched to the specified mobility and bath temperature, provided its constitutive inputs still describe the deterministic response. Its minimum then selects the deterministic rates, but its excess is not generally the total fluctuation cost. Appendix C, eq:C2 , compares the quadratic forms set by physical resistance and inverse diffusion covariance in the same retained coordinates. Their common minimizer does not establish the Einstein matching required for identical fluctuation costs. The total fluctuations must instead be calculated from the specified stochastic model; (42) is not asserted for arbitrary active noise. Appendix B derives the drift consistency condition for state-dependent thermal diffusion and contrasts it with the chemical Langevin approximation obtained from reaction counts.
The stochastic and thermodynamic descriptions must be reassessed when slow memory is discarded, channels with different work are merged, or unresolved forcing is treated as an equilibrium bath. Timescale separation alone does not guarantee physical LDB.[41 ] For general colored or heavy-tailed processes, even a local exponential rate cost may require a different state space or asymptotic description.
A physical Rayleighian requires independently justified storage, actual work mechanisms, and dissipative forces generated by the chosen potential. For independent admissible rates, write R = Φ − X ⋅ α ˙ \mathcal{R}=\Phi-\mathbf{X}\cdot\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}} R = Φ − X ⋅ α ˙ . If Φ \Phi Φ is differentiable and convex with Φ ( 0 ) = min Φ = 0 \Phi(0)=\min\Phi=0 Φ ( 0 ) = min Φ = 0 , variation selects ∂ α ˙ Φ = X \partial_{\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}}\Phi=\mathbf{X} ∂ α ˙ Φ = X and D = α ˙ ∗ ⋅ ∂ α ˙ Φ ≥ Φ ( α ˙ ∗ ) ≥ 0 \mathcal{D}=\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_*\cdot\partial_{\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}}\Phi\geq\Phi(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_*)\geq0 D = α ˙ ∗ ⋅ ∂ α ˙ Φ ≥ Φ ( α ˙ ∗ ) ≥ 0 . Homogeneous rate constraints that do not work preserve D = X ⋅ α ˙ ∗ ; \mathcal{D}=\mathbf{X}\cdot\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}}_*; D = X ⋅ α ˙ ∗ ; driven constraints require additional input-power terms. These checks do not validate an arbitrary proposed material law. Nonpotential dissipative responses and reversible couplings need their appropriate formulation.[6 , 8 ]
A local chemical relaxation illustrates the inverse ambiguity. Let ξ \xi ξ be the molar reaction-extent displacement from equilibrium. For any resistance ζ > 0 \zeta>0 ζ > 0 , the inputs Φ C = ξ ˙ 2 / 2 \Phi_{\mathrm{C}}=\dot{\xi}^{2}/2 Φ C = ξ ˙ 2 /2 and F C = λ ζ ξ ˙ 2 / 2 \mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{C}}=\lambda\zeta\dot{\xi}^{2}/2 F C = λ ζ ξ ˙ 2 /2 select the same equation ξ ˙ = − λ ξ \dot{\xi}=-\lambda\xi ξ ˙ = − λ ξ , where λ > 0 \lambda>0 λ > 0 is a relaxation frequency. Different ζ \zeta ζ describe different physical storage and resistance, not a freedom to alter measured parameters in one model; the corresponding thermally matched stochastic model has reaction-extent diffusion coefficient k B T / ζ k_{\mathrm{B}}T/\zeta k B T / ζ . A different ambiguity is
F ↦ F + G , P i n ↦ P i n + G ˙ ⟹ R ~ = R . (44) \mathcal{F}\mapsto\mathcal{F}+G,\qquad\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}\mapsto\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}+\dot{G}\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad\widetilde{\mathcal{R}}=\mathcal{R}. \tag*{(44)} F ↦ F + G , P in ↦ P in + G ˙ ⟹ R = R . (44)
Here, G G G is a differentiable state function. This changes the decomposition, not the scalar; arbitrary G G G need not describe the same experimental storage and reservoirs. Finally, only after physical matching is established can a local cost with zero minimum fix R ( α ˙ ) = 2 k B T [ L ( α ˙ ) − L ( 0 ) ] \mathcal{R}(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}})=2k_{\mathrm{B}}T[\mathcal{L}(\dot{\boldsymbol{\alpha}})-\mathcal{L}(0)] R ( α ˙ ) = 2 k B T [ L ( α ˙ ) − L ( 0 )] by the convention R ( 0 ) = 0 \mathcal{R}(0)=0 R ( 0 ) = 0 , when the zero-rate cost is finite. Such normalization does not itself determine hidden chemistry or physical resistance. These distinctions explain why a deterministic model can be constructively useful without automatically specifying its fluctuations.
A recipe for constructive modeling with OVP. OVP constructs coupled dynamics from specified physical inputs, without requiring the evolution equations in advance. First, choose dynamically sufficient slow variables and resolve reaction channels by their stoichiometric changes, including reservoir exchanges, to establish the material balances. Second, specify the retained free energy and reservoir chemical potentials to determine the free-energy rate, chemical input power, and channel affinities. Third, model the dissipation mechanisms and kinetic scales, and minimize the physical Rayleighian R = Φ + F ˙ − P i n \mathcal{R}=\Phi+\dot{F}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} R = Φ + F ˙ − P in over admissible trial rates at fixed state and controls. The selected rates and material balances then determine the deterministic evolution and its power balance. Predicting fluctuations requires a specified stochastic mechanism; obtaining them from the same Rayleighian additionally requires matching its excess to the corresponding fluctuation cost at the same resolution and in the stated probability limit.
For the resolved Poisson reaction model, the specified kinetic scales Γ ρ \Gamma_{\rho} Γ ρ and LDB give the compatible one-way rates
r ρ ± = Γ ρ 2 exp ( ± A ρ 2 R T ) . r_{\rho}^{\pm}=\frac{\Gamma_{\rho}}{2}\exp\left(\pm\frac{\mathcal{A}_{\rho}}{2RT}\right). r ρ ± = 2 Γ ρ exp ( ± 2 R T A ρ ) .
The Poisson counting statistics determine the fluctuation cost, while Eq. (28) matches its rate-reversal-even part and LDB matches its bias to the physical affinity. Consequently, the Rayleighian excess gives the leading rate-fluctuation cost in the frozen-state, many-event limit. A finite-number realization additionally requires allowed reaction jumps and reverse-edge LDB. Without such statistical and thermodynamic matching, the physical Rayleighian still selects the deterministic dynamics but does not determine their fluctuations.
Physical channels and variational dynamics
Reaction channels and thermodynamics. Fuel-driven state conversion is a basic mechanism in dissipative self-assembly. For example, carbodiimide fuel activates dicarboxylate precursors into transient anhydrides, which can assemble before hydrolyzing back[65 ] . Motivated by this system, we consider a spatially uniform model with two reversible reaction channels, passive conversion and fuel-coupled conversion:
A ⇄ B , A + F ⇄ B + W , (45) A \rightleftarrows B,\qquad A+F \rightleftarrows B+W, \tag*{(45)} A ⇄ B , A + F ⇄ B + W , (45)
where A A A , B B B denote precursor and activated states, and F F F , W W W denote fuel and waste. The subscripts 0 and F F F label the passive and fuel-coupled channels, respectively. The model omits independent fuel consumption and assembly feedback rather than reproducing the full experimental reaction network. We distinguish partial- and net-affinity responses under different chemical-potential control protocols from fixed-state Rayleighian rate variation, and compare fluctuation models that yield the same selected rate.
Consider a well-mixed isothermal reactor of volume V V V at temperature T T T , containing the four species with positive molar concentrations c s c_s c s , s = A , B , F , W s=A,B,F,W s = A , B , F , W . The trial net reaction-rate densities r 0 r_0 r 0 , r F r_F r F are positive for forward A → B A\to B A → B conversion and have units of moles per volume per time. For the closed reactor, the concentration balances are
c ˙ A = − r 0 − r F , c ˙ B = r 0 + r F , c ˙ F = − r F , c ˙ W = r F . (46) \begin{aligned}
\dot{c}_A&=-r_0-r_F, & \dot{c}_B&=r_0+r_F,\\
\dot{c}_F&=-r_F, & \dot{c}_W&=r_F. \tag*{(46)}
\end{aligned} c ˙ A c ˙ F = − r 0 − r F , = − r F , c ˙ B c ˙ W = r 0 + r F , = r F . (46)
Thus, c A + c B c_A+c_B c A + c B and c F + c W c_F+c_W c F + c W are conserved.
For this ideal four-species mixture, we choose the total free energy
F T = V ∑ s = A , B , F , W c s [ μ s ∘ + R T ( ln c s c ∘ − 1 ) ] , (47) \mathcal{F}_T=V\sum_{s=A,B,F,W}c_s\left[\mu_s^\circ+RT\left(\ln\frac{c_s}{c^\circ}-1\right)\right], \tag*{(47)} F T = V s = A , B , F , W ∑ c s [ μ s ∘ + R T ( ln c ∘ c s − 1 ) ] , (47)
where c ∘ > 0 c^\circ>0 c ∘ > 0 is a standard concentration and μ s ∘ \mu_s^\circ μ s ∘ is the standard molar chemical potential of species s s s . The corresponding chemical potential is
μ s = μ s ∘ + R T ln ( c s / c ∘ ) . (48) \mu_s=\mu_s^\circ+RT\ln(c_s/c^\circ). \tag*{(48)} μ s = μ s ∘ + R T ln ( c s / c ∘ ) . (48)
We incorporate any fixed solvent or buffer contributions to the effective reaction free energies into the standard chemical potentials μ s ∘ \mu_s^\circ μ s ∘ . Using Eq. (46) , we obtain the rate of free-energy change
F ˙ T = − V ( A 0 r 0 + A F r F ) , (49) \dot{\mathcal{F}}_T=-V(\mathcal{A}_0r_0+\mathcal{A}_Fr_F), \tag*{(49)} F ˙ T = − V ( A 0 r 0 + A F r F ) , (49)
where the channel affinities are identified as
A 0 = μ A − μ B , A F = μ A + μ F − μ B − μ W . (50) \mathcal{A}_0=\mu_A-\mu_B,\qquad\mathcal{A}_F=\mu_A+\mu_F-\mu_B-\mu_W. \tag*{(50)} A 0 = μ A − μ B , A F = μ A + μ F − μ B − μ W . (50)
Dissipation and rate selection. For the closed four-species system, use the nonquadratic dissipation potential φ \varphi φ in Eq. (28) to construct the total dissipation potential
Φ = V ∑ ρ = 0 , F φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) , (51) \Phi=V\sum_{\rho=0,F}\varphi(r_\rho;\Gamma_\rho), \tag*{(51)} Φ = V ρ = 0 , F ∑ φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) , (51)
where the positive kinetic scales Γ ρ ( c ) \Gamma_\rho(c) Γ ρ ( c ) may depend on the retained concentrations c = ( c A , c B , c F , c W ) \boldsymbol{c}=(c_A,c_B,c_F,c_W) c = ( c A , c B , c F , c W ) . Minimizing the Rayleighian R = Φ + F ˙ T \mathcal{R}=\Phi+\dot{\mathcal{F}}_T R = Φ + F ˙ T over the trial rates r 0 , r F r_0,r_F r 0 , r F at fixed state and controls, including Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ , gives the unique selected rates
r ρ , ∗ = Γ ρ sinh A ρ 2 R T , (52) r_{\rho,*}=\Gamma_\rho\sinh\frac{\mathcal{A}_\rho}{2RT}, \tag*{(52)} r ρ , ∗ = Γ ρ sinh 2 R T A ρ , (52)
for ρ ∈ { 0 , F } \rho\in\{0,F\} ρ ∈ { 0 , F } . This nonlinear rate–affinity relation does not yet specify the concentration dependence of the kinetic scales, which remains a constitutive input. To recover the law of mass action, we choose
Γ 0 = 2 k 0 + k 0 − c A c B , Γ F = 2 k F + k F − c A c B c F c W . (53) \Gamma_0=2\sqrt{k_0^+k_0^-c_Ac_B},\qquad\Gamma_F=2\sqrt{k_F^+k_F^-c_Ac_Bc_Fc_W}. \tag*{(53)} Γ 0 = 2 k 0 + k 0 − c A c B , Γ F = 2 k F + k F − c A c B c F c W . (53)
Here, the positive rate constants k ρ ± k_\rho^\pm k ρ ± have units of inverse time, while k F ± k_F^\pm k F ± have units of inverse concentration per unit time. They satisfy R T ln ( k ρ + / k ρ − ) = A ρ ∘ RT\ln(k_\rho^+/k_\rho^-)=\mathcal{A}_\rho^\circ R T ln ( k ρ + / k ρ − ) = A ρ ∘ , where A ρ ∘ \mathcal{A}_\rho^\circ A ρ ∘ is the channel affinity defined by the standard chemical potentials. Substitution into Eq. (52) yields
r 0 , ∗ = k 0 + c A − k 0 − c B ≡ r 0 + − r 0 − , (54) r_{0,*}=k_0^+c_A-k_0^-c_B\equiv r_0^+-r_0^-, \tag*{(54)} r 0 , ∗ = k 0 + c A − k 0 − c B ≡ r 0 + − r 0 − , (54)
r F , ∗ = k F + c A c F − k F − c B c W ≡ r F + − r F − . (55) r_{F,*}=k_F^+c_Ac_F-k_F^-c_Bc_W\equiv r_F^+-r_F^-. \tag*{(55)} r F , ∗ = k F + c A c F − k F − c B c W ≡ r F + − r F − . (55)
Here, r ρ + r_\rho^+ r ρ + and r ρ − r_\rho^- r ρ − denote the mean forward and reverse reaction-rate densities, respectively, and satisfy R T ln ( r ρ + / r ρ − ) = A ρ RT\ln(r_\rho^+/r_\rho^-)=\mathcal{A}_\rho R T ln ( r ρ + / r ρ − ) = A ρ . Their concentration dependence follows from the kinetic choice in Eq. (53) , not from thermodynamics or minimization alone. The selected rates determine the concentration dynamics through Eq. (46) , with F ˙ T = − D \dot{\mathcal{F}}_T=-\mathcal{D} F ˙ T = − D and
D = V ( A 0 r 0 , ∗ + A F r F , ∗ ) ≥ 0. (56) \mathcal{D}=V(\mathcal{A}_0r_{0,*}+\mathcal{A}_Fr_{F,*})\ge0. \tag*{(56)} D = V ( A 0 r 0 , ∗ + A F r F , ∗ ) ≥ 0. (56)
Chemical input from maintained fuel. We now consider the same reaction channels with F , W F,W F , W maintained by external reservoirs, retaining only A , B A,B A , B as dynamical components. Writing Δ μ F = μ F − μ W \Delta\mu_F=\mu_F-\mu_W Δ μ F = μ F − μ W , the retained free energy F \mathcal{F} F is the A , B A,B A , B part of the total free energy F T \mathcal{F}_T F T in Eq. (47) , and
F ˙ = − V A 0 ( r 0 + r F ) , P i n = V Δ μ F r F . (57) \dot{\mathcal{F}}=-V\mathcal{A}_0(r_0+r_F),\qquad\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=V\Delta\mu_Fr_F. \tag*{(57)} F ˙ = − V A 0 ( r 0 + r F ) , P in = V Δ μ F r F . (57)
Since A F = A 0 + Δ μ F A_F=A_0+\Delta\mu_F A F = A 0 + Δ μ F , the same Rayleighian is R = Φ + F ˙ − P i n \mathcal{R}=\Phi+\dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} R = Φ + F ˙ − P in . Along the selected evolution, F ˙ = P i n − D \dot{\mathcal{F}}=\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}-\mathcal{D} F ˙ = P in − D . A single fueled channel can supply chemical power, but with that channel alone, constant Δ μ F \Delta\mu_F Δ μ F , and no other driving, c ˙ B = r F , ∗ \dot{c}_B=r_{F,*} c ˙ B = r F , ∗ implies
d d t ( F − Δ μ F c B V ) = − D . (58) \frac{d}{dt}\left(\mathcal{F}-\Delta\mu_F c_B V\right)=-\mathcal{D}. \tag*{(58)} d t d ( F − Δ μ F c B V ) = − D . (58)
Such a model can relax under a tilted free energy but cannot sustain positive dissipation at a deterministic steady state. With both channels, r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ = 0 r_{0,*}+r_{F,*}=0 r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ = 0 can coexist with r F , ∗ ≠ 0 r_{F,*}\ne0 r F , ∗ = 0 : fueled activation followed by passive return consumes fuel without net A → B A\to B A → B conversion, with P i n = D = V Δ μ F r F , ∗ \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=\mathcal{D}=V\Delta\mu_F r_{F,*} P in = D = V Δ μ F r F , ∗ .
Nonlinear response and fixed-state dissipation potentials
The mass-action kinetics described above admit a fixed-state Rayleighian formulation but can exhibit nonreciprocal net-affinity responses[23 ] . We first explain why these results are compatible, then examine the partial-affinity response symmetries identified by Lengyel[22 ] .
Conversion rates and conjugate net affinities. The two physical observables are total net A → B A\to B A → B conversion and net F → W F\to W F → W fuel consumption. Their rates and conjugate affinities are
r 1 = r 0 + r F , r 2 = r F , (59) r_1=r_0+r_F,\qquad r_2=r_F, \tag*{(59)} r 1 = r 0 + r F , r 2 = r F , (59)
A 1 = A 0 , A 2 = A F − A 0 . (60) A_1=A_0,\qquad A_2=A_F-A_0. \tag*{(60)} A 1 = A 0 , A 2 = A F − A 0 . (60)
Thus, A 1 = μ A − μ B A_1=\mu_A-\mu_B A 1 = μ A − μ B is the net conversion affinity, while A 2 = μ F − μ W = Δ μ F A_2=\mu_F-\mu_W=\Delta\mu_F A 2 = μ F − μ W = Δ μ F is the fuel affinity (the fuel–waste chemical-potential difference). The full fueled-channel affinity is A F = A 1 + A 2 A_F=A_1+A_2 A F = A 1 + A 2 . This invertible transformation preserves the power-density pairing, A 0 r 0 + A F r F = A 1 r 1 + A 2 r 2 A_0r_0+A_Fr_F=A_1r_1+A_2r_2 A 0 r 0 + A F r F = A 1 r 1 + A 2 r 2 , without introducing additional reaction channels or driving forces. Along the selected evolution, the dissipation power is D = V ( A 0 r 0 , ∗ + A F r F , ∗ ) = V ( A 1 r 1 , ∗ + A 2 r 2 , ∗ ) \mathcal{D}=V(A_0r_{0,*}+A_Fr_{F,*})=V(A_1r_{1,*}+A_2r_{2,*}) D = V ( A 0 r 0 , ∗ + A F r F , ∗ ) = V ( A 1 r 1 , ∗ + A 2 r 2 , ∗ ) .
Net-affinity response. A direct nonlinear extension of Onsager reciprocity asks whether the Jacobian of selected net rates with respect to their conjugate net affinities is symmetric[23 ] [see Figure 1 (a)]. Such symmetry is necessary for a scalar force potential to generate these rates under a specified control protocol. Since the two net affinities A 1 A_1 A 1 and A 2 A_2 A 2 do not uniquely determine the four chemical potentials, two complementary variables must also be held fixed. Following the type of response test considered by Bataille, Edelen, and Kestin[23 ] , we fix the product and fuel chemical potentials μ B , μ F \mu_B,\mu_F μ B , μ F and vary μ A , μ W \mu_A,\mu_W μ A , μ W at fixed T T T , V V V , and kinetic constants. This independently varies the net affinities, d A 1 = d μ A dA_1=d\mu_A d A 1 = d μ A and d A 2 = − d μ W dA_2=-d\mu_W d A 2 = − d μ W . For the ideal mixture, fixing μ B , μ F \mu_B,\mu_F μ B , μ F is equivalent to fixing c B , c F c_B,c_F c B , c F . The chosen protocol illustrates the type of nonlinear response test considered by Bataille, Edelen, and Kestin using the present reaction network, rather than reproducing their original reaction example[23 ] .
Under this control protocol, varying A 1 A_1 A 1 changes c A c_A c A at fixed c B c_B c B , whereas varying A 2 A_2 A 2 changes c W c_W c W at fixed c F c_F c F . Using the ideal chemical potentials and the mass-action rates in Eq. (52), we obtain, for i , j = 1 , 2 i,j=1,2 i , j = 1 , 2 ,
[ ∂ r i , ∗ ∂ A j ] c B , c F = 1 R T ( r F + + r F − r F − r F + r F − ) . (61) \left[\frac{\partial r_{i,*}}{\partial A_j}\right]_{c_B,c_F}
=\frac{1}{RT}
\begin{pmatrix}
r_F^+ + r_F^- & r_F^-\\
r_F^+ & r_F^-
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(61)} [ ∂ A j ∂ r i , ∗ ] c B , c F = R T 1 ( r F + + r F − r F + r F − r F − ) . (61)
In particular, the two cross responses are ∂ A 2 r 1 , ∗ = r F − / ( R T ) \partial_{A_2}r_{1,*}=r_F^-/(RT) ∂ A 2 r 1 , ∗ = r F − / ( R T ) and ∂ A 1 r 2 , ∗ = r F + / ( R T ) \partial_{A_1}r_{2,*}=r_F^+/(RT) ∂ A 1 r 2 , ∗ = r F + / ( R T ) under the specified controls. Their difference is − r F , ∗ / ( R T ) -r_{F,*}/(RT) − r F , ∗ / ( R T ) , so reciprocity generally fails away from equilibrium when r F , ∗ ≠ 0 r_{F,*}\ne0 r F , ∗ = 0 , even though both channels satisfy LDB. At equilibrium, r F + = r F − r_F^+=r_F^- r F + = r F − and reciprocal linear response is recovered.
Compatibility with fixed-state OVP. The response in Eq. (61) changes concentrations and hence kinetic scales Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ . OVP instead holds the state and controls fixed while varying trial rates. The driving term is then linear in those rates, so
∂ 2 R ∂ r ρ ∂ r η = ∂ 2 Φ ∂ r ρ ∂ r η = 2 R T V r ρ 2 + Γ ρ 2 δ ρ η , (62) \frac{\partial^2\mathcal{R}}{\partial r_\rho\partial r_\eta}
=\frac{\partial^2\Phi}{\partial r_\rho\partial r_\eta}
=\frac{2RTV}{\sqrt{r_\rho^2+\Gamma_\rho^2}}\delta_{\rho\eta}, \tag*{(62)} ∂ r ρ ∂ r η ∂ 2 R = ∂ r ρ ∂ r η ∂ 2 Φ = r ρ 2 + Γ ρ 2 2 R T V δ ρ η , (62)
where ρ , η ∈ { 0 , F } \rho,\eta\in\{0,F\} ρ , η ∈ { 0 , F } and δ ρ η \delta_{\rho\eta} δ ρ η is the Kronecker symbol. In conversion coordinates, the same potential is Φ = V [ φ ( r 1 − r 2 ; Γ 0 ) + φ ( r 2 ; Γ F ) ] \Phi=V[\varphi(r_1-r_2;\Gamma_0)+\varphi(r_2;\Gamma_F)] Φ = V [ φ ( r 1 − r 2 ; Γ 0 ) + φ ( r 2 ; Γ F )] ; its rate Hessian remains symmetric and positive definite.
In the conversion-rate coordinates of Eq. (56), Ψ \Psi Ψ denotes the convex conjugate of the transformed Φ \Phi Φ , with conjugate forces A ( A 1 , A 2 ) \mathcal{A}(A_1,A_2) A ( A 1 , A 2 ) . Since the physical affinities A ( c ) = ( A 1 ( c ) , A 2 ( c ) ) \mathcal{A}(c)=(A_1(c),A_2(c)) A ( c ) = ( A 1 ( c ) , A 2 ( c )) are determined by the concentrations, the corresponding Rayleighian minimum satisfies R min ( c ) = − Ψ ( ∇ A ( c ) ; c ) \mathcal{R}_{\min}(c)=-\Psi(\nabla\mathcal{A}(c);c) R m i n ( c ) = − Ψ ( ∇ A ( c ) ; c ) . This pointwise convex-duality relation does not require varying the affinities independently of the state. In contrast, the response in Eq. (61) compares different compositions, where both the affinities and kinetic scales Γ ρ ( c ) \Gamma_\rho(c) Γ ρ ( c ) change. Its nonsymmetric Jacobian therefore does not contradict the existence of the fixed-state dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ or its convex conjugate Ψ \Psi Ψ .
Partial-affinity response symmetries. Nonreciprocity of the net-affinity response does not exclude other differential symmetries of mass-action kinetics. Lengyel obtained two separate symmetric response matrices by differentiating the selected rates with respect to the reactant- and product-side contributions to the affinities[22 ] . For the conversion coordinates in Eq. (56), we define
X 1 ′ = μ A / T , X 1 ′ ′ = − μ B / T , (63) X_1'=\mu_A/T,\qquad X_1''=-\mu_B/T, \tag*{(63)} X 1 ′ = μ A / T , X 1 ′′ = − μ B / T , (63)
X 2 ′ = μ F / T , X 2 ′ ′ = − μ W / T . (64) X_2'=\mu_F/T,\qquad X_2''=-\mu_W/T. \tag*{(64)} X 2 ′ = μ F / T , X 2 ′′ = − μ W / T . (64)
Then, A i = T ( X i ′ + X i ′ ′ ) A_i=T(X_i'+X_i'') A i = T ( X i ′ + X i ′′ ) for i = 1 , 2 i=1,2 i = 1 , 2 . The fueled channel contains the reactant-side combination X 1 ′ + X 2 ′ X_1'+X_2' X 1 ′ + X 2 ′ and the product-side combination X 1 ′ ′ + X 2 ′ ′ X_1^{\prime\prime}+X_2^{\prime\prime} X 1 ′′ + X 2 ′′ . These partial quantities separate chemical-potential contributions; only their sums give the net affinities.
Each response derivative below measures the change of a selected rate when one chemical potential is varied, with the other three chemical potentials, T T T , V V V , and the kinetic constants fixed. These derivatives compare selected rates at different controlled compositions, whereas Rayleighian minimization varies trial rates at a fixed composition. The constants k ρ ± k_\rho^\pm k ρ ± remain fixed, but the concentration-dependent Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ can change. Using ∂ c s / ∂ ( μ s / T ) = c s / R \partial c_s/\partial(\mu_s/T)=c_s/R ∂ c s / ∂ ( μ s / T ) = c s / R in Eq. (52) gives, for i , j = 1 , 2 i,j=1,2 i , j = 1 , 2 ,
[ ∂ r i , ∗ ∂ X j ′ ] = 1 R ( r 0 + + r F + r F + r F + r F + ) (65) \left[\frac{\partial r_{i,*}}{\partial X_j^\prime}\right]=\frac{1}{R}\begin{pmatrix}r_0^+ + r_F^+ & r_F^+ \\ r_F^+ & r_F^+\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(65)} [ ∂ X j ′ ∂ r i , ∗ ] = R 1 ( r 0 + + r F + r F + r F + r F + ) (65)
[ ∂ r i , ∗ ∂ X j ′ ′ ] = 1 R ( r 0 − + r F − r F − r F − r F − ) (66) \left[\frac{\partial r_{i,*}}{\partial X_j^{\prime\prime}}\right]=\frac{1}{R}\begin{pmatrix}r_0^- + r_F^- & r_F^- \\ r_F^- & r_F^-\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(66)} [ ∂ X j ′′ ∂ r i , ∗ ] = R 1 ( r 0 − + r F − r F − r F − r F − ) (66)
For example, increasing X 2 ′ = μ F / T X_2^\prime=\mu_F/T X 2 ′ = μ F / T changes only r F + r_F^+ r F + , giving ∂ X 2 ′ r 1 , ∗ = r F + / R = ∂ X 2 ′ r 2 , ∗ \partial_{X_2^\prime}r_{1,*}=r_F^+/R=\partial_{X_2^\prime}r_{2,*} ∂ X 2 ′ r 1 , ∗ = r F + / R = ∂ X 2 ′ r 2 , ∗ . Both blocks are symmetric because the same fueled event contributes to both conversions. They have Lengyel’s composite-rate matrix structure; here the rate transformation is invertible and retains both channels.
The two symmetric response matrices in Eq. (60) are generally different because they involve different one-way rates. Under the control protocol of Eq. (61) , varying A 1 A_1 A 1 changes μ A \mu_A μ A , whereas varying A 2 A_2 A 2 changes − μ W -\mu_W − μ W . The resulting net-affinity Jacobian therefore combines the first column of the forward partial-affinity response matrix with the second column of the reverse matrix, each divided by T T T , and need not be symmetric. By contrast, fixing μ B , μ W \mu_B,\mu_W μ B , μ W and varying μ A , μ F \mu_A,\mu_F μ A , μ F selects both columns from the forward matrix, giving equal cross responses r F + / ( R T ) r_F^+/(RT) r F + / ( R T ) . Thus, both types of response compare selected rates at different controlled compositions, but use different force variables and control conditions. The partial-affinity symmetries therefore do not imply net-affinity reciprocity under arbitrary controls. Appendix A gives the corresponding higher-order response and fluctuation constraints. We next examine whether the selected deterministic rates also determine their fluctuation statistics.
The selected rate does not determine its fluctuations
The preceding response tests compare deterministic rates at different chemical potentials. We now fix the state and controls and compare variational and statistical descriptions with the same selected net rate. For either resolved channel, suppress the index ρ \rho ρ and use the prescribed mean forward and reverse rate densities r ± > 0 r^\pm>0 r ± > 0 as reference parameters, with r ∗ = r + − r − r_*=r^+-r^- r ∗ = r + − r − , Γ = 2 r + r − \Gamma=2\sqrt{r^+r^-} Γ = 2 r + r − , σ = r + + r − \sigma=r^++r^- σ = r + + r − , and A = R T ln ( r + / r − ) \mathcal{A}=RT\ln(r^+/r^-) A = R T ln ( r + / r − ) . These quantities remain fixed when varying the trial net rate r r r .
For each representation, write the dissipation potential as Φ = V φ \Phi=V\varphi Φ = V φ and the Rayleighian as R = V [ φ ( r ) − A r ] \mathcal{R}=V[\varphi(r)-\mathcal{A}r] R = V [ φ ( r ) − A r ] . If its minimizing rate is r ∗ r_* r ∗ , the Rayleighian excess, defined as the difference from its fixed-state minimum, is
Δ R ≡ R − R min = V [ φ ( r ) − φ ( r ∗ ) − A ( r − r ∗ ) ] . \Delta\mathcal{R}\equiv\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min}=V[\varphi(r)-\varphi(r_*)-\mathcal{A}(r-r_*)]. Δ R ≡ R − R m i n = V [ φ ( r ) − φ ( r ∗ ) − A ( r − r ∗ )] .
A fluctuation cost ℓ ( r ) \ell(r) ℓ ( r ) instead specifies the leading probability weight exp [ − N A V Δ t ℓ ( r ) ] \exp[-N_A V\Delta t\,\ell(r)] exp [ − N A V Δ t ℓ ( r )] for observing a net rate r r r over an interval Δ t \Delta t Δ t . The equality ℓ = Δ R / ( 2 R T V ) \ell=\Delta\mathcal{R}/(2RTV) ℓ = Δ R / ( 2 R T V ) must be established for the selected stochastic model; it does not follow from a shared minimizing rate. We compare a Poisson model, its local Gaussian approximation, a separately specified Gaussian model, and an inverse-log deterministic representation.
Poisson event statistics. Independent forward and reverse Poisson counts Δ N ± \Delta N^\pm Δ N ± have means N A V r ± Δ t N_A V r^\pm\Delta t N A V r ± Δ t , which should be distinguished from the measured net rate, r ^ = ( Δ N + − Δ N − ) / ( N A V Δ t ) \hat r=(\Delta N^+-\Delta N^-)/(N_A V\Delta t) r ^ = ( Δ N + − Δ N − ) / ( N A V Δ t ) . The matched dissipation potential density in Eq. (28) is
φ P ( r ) = 2 R T [ r arsinh ( r Γ ) − r 2 + Γ 2 + σ ] . \varphi_P(r)=2RT\left[r\operatorname{arsinh}\left(\frac{r}{\Gamma}\right)-\sqrt{r^2+\Gamma^2}+\sigma\right]. φ P ( r ) = 2 R T [ r arsinh ( Γ r ) − r 2 + Γ 2 + σ ] .
In the frozen-state, many-event regime, the net-rate fluctuation cost satisfies ℓ P ( r ) = Δ R P / ( 2 R T V ) \ell_P(r)=\Delta\mathcal{R}_P/(2RTV) ℓ P ( r ) = Δ R P / ( 2 R T V ) , with
ℓ P ( r ) = r arsinh ( r Γ ) − A r 2 R T − r 2 + Γ 2 + σ . (67) \ell_P(r)=r\operatorname{arsinh}\left(\frac{r}{\Gamma}\right)-\frac{\mathcal{A}r}{2RT}-\sqrt{r^2+\Gamma^2}+\sigma. \tag*{(67)} ℓ P ( r ) = r arsinh ( Γ r ) − 2 R T A r − r 2 + Γ 2 + σ . (67)
This cost is obtained by minimizing the joint forward and reverse counting cost at fixed net rate r r r ; subleading probability prefactors are omitted.
Local Gaussian approximation. Expanding Eq. (67) about r ∗ r_* r ∗ gives ℓ P = ℓ l o c + O ( ( r − r ∗ ) 3 / σ 2 ) \ell_P=\ell_{\mathrm{loc}}+O((r-r_*)^3/\sigma^2) ℓ P = ℓ loc + O (( r − r ∗ ) 3 / σ 2 ) . The corresponding second-order Taylor approximation to the dissipation potential density is
φ l o c ( r ) = φ P ( r ∗ ) + A ( r − r ∗ ) + R T σ ( r − r ∗ ) 2 . \varphi_{\mathrm{loc}}(r)=\varphi_P(r_*)+\mathcal{A}(r-r_*)+\frac{RT}{\sigma}(r-r_*)^2. φ loc ( r ) = φ P ( r ∗ ) + A ( r − r ∗ ) + σ R T ( r − r ∗ ) 2 .
Its Rayleighian excess satisfies
Δ R l o c 2 R T V = ℓ l o c ( r ) = ( r − r ∗ ) 2 2 σ . (68) \frac{\Delta\mathcal{R}_{\mathrm{loc}}}{2RTV}=\ell_{\mathrm{loc}}(r)=\frac{(r-r_*)^2}{2\sigma}. \tag*{(68)} 2 R T V Δ R loc = ℓ loc ( r ) = 2 σ ( r − r ∗ ) 2 . (68)
The linear term ensures ∂ r φ l o c ( r ∗ ) = A \partial_r\varphi_{\mathrm{loc}}(r_*)=\mathcal{A} ∂ r φ loc ( r ∗ ) = A , so minimization still selects r ∗ r_* r ∗ . This is a local Taylor approximation near r ∗ r_* r ∗ , not an independently specified physical dissipation potential or reaction-event model.
Logarithmic-mean quadratic representation. The alternative dissipation potential density φ log ( r ) = r 2 / ( 2 L log ) \varphi_{\log}(r)=r^2/(2L_{\log}) φ l o g ( r ) = r 2 / ( 2 L l o g ) reproduces the same deterministic rate [34 , 66 ] , with the logarithmic-mean mobility [66 , 67 ]
L log = r + − r − R T ln ( r + / r − ) = Γ 2 R T sinh [ A / ( 2 R T ) ] A / ( 2 R T ) . (69) L_{\log}=\frac{r^+-r^-}{RT\ln(r^+/r^-)}=\frac{\Gamma}{2RT}\frac{\sinh[\mathcal{A}/(2RT)]}{\mathcal{A}/(2RT)}. \tag*{(69)} L l o g = R T ln ( r + / r − ) r + − r − = 2 R T Γ A / ( 2 R T ) sinh [ A / ( 2 R T )] . (69)
The mean rates r ± = ( Γ / 2 ) e ± A / ( 2 R T ) r^\pm=(\Gamma/2)e^{\pm\mathcal{A}/(2RT)} r ± = ( Γ/2 ) e ± A / ( 2 R T ) determine L log L_{\log} L l o g , which is held fixed during variation of r r r . Its continuous value at A = 0 \mathcal{A}=0 A = 0 is Γ / ( 2 R T ) \Gamma/(2RT) Γ/ ( 2 R T ) . Minimizing R log \mathcal{R}_{\log} R l o g gives r = L log A = r ∗ r=L_{\log}\mathcal{A}=r_* r = L l o g A = r ∗ . Assigning the normalized Rayleighian excess as a fluctuation cost specifies a separate Gaussian model:
Δ R log 2 R T V = ℓ G ( r ) = ( r − r ∗ ) 2 4 R T L log . (70) \frac{\Delta\mathcal{R}_{\log}}{2RTV}=\ell_G(r)=\frac{(r-r_*)^2}{4RTL_{\log}}. \tag*{(70)} 2 R T V Δ R l o g = ℓ G ( r ) = 4 R T L l o g ( r − r ∗ ) 2 . (70)
This model differs from the local Gaussian approximation ℓ l o c \ell_{\mathrm{loc}} ℓ loc to the Poisson cost. The same quadratic function also provides the upper bound ℓ P ( r ) ≤ ℓ G ( r ) \ell_P(r)\leq\ell_G(r) ℓ P ( r ) ≤ ℓ G ( r ) [53 ] .
Inverse-log deterministic representation. In our notation, the logarithmic dissipative force used in energetic variational chemical kinetics [35 , 36 ] is R T ln ( 1 + r / r − ) RT\ln(1+r/r^-) R T ln ( 1 + r / r − ) . Integrating this force with respect to r r r at fixed r − r^- r − gives the dissipation potential density
φ I ( r ) = R T [ ( r + r − ) ln ( 1 + r r − ) − r ] , (71) \varphi_I(r)=RT\left[(r+r^-)\ln\left(1+\frac{r}{r^-}\right)-r\right], \tag*{(71)} φ I ( r ) = R T [ ( r + r − ) ln ( 1 + r − r ) − r ] , (71)
defined for r > − r − r>-r^- r > − r − . The product r ∂ r φ I = R T r ln ( 1 + r / r − ) r\partial_r\varphi_I=RT\,r\ln(1+r/r^-) r ∂ r φ I = R T r ln ( 1 + r / r − ) is the dissipation power density, not φ I \varphi_I φ I itself. The condition ∂ r φ I = A \partial_r\varphi_I=\mathcal{A} ∂ r φ I = A again selects r ∗ = r + − r − r_*=r^+-r^- r ∗ = r + − r − , while the Rayleighian excess is
Δ R I 2 R T V = 1 2 [ ( r + r − ) ln r + r − r + − ( r − r ∗ ) ] . (72) \frac{\Delta\mathcal{R}_I}{2RTV}=\frac{1}{2}\left[(r+r^-)\ln\frac{r+r^-}{r^+}-(r-r_*)\right]. \tag*{(72)} 2 R T V Δ R I = 2 1 [ ( r + r − ) ln r + r + r − − ( r − r ∗ ) ] . (72)
This normalized Rayleighian excess differs from ℓ P ( r ) \ell_P(r) ℓ P ( r ) for the prescribed two-way Poisson events. The deterministic construction does not specify a stochastic law, so identifying this function as a fluctuation cost would require an additional stochastic model.
All four Rayleighians have the same minimizing rate r ∗ r_* r ∗ , where their excesses Δ R \Delta\mathcal{R} Δ R vanish and the selected dissipation power is D = V A r ∗ \mathcal{D}=V\mathcal{A}r_* D = V A r ∗ . The curvatures of Δ R / ( 2 R T V ) \Delta\mathcal{R}/(2RTV) Δ R / ( 2 R T V ) at r ∗ r_* r ∗ are 1 / σ 1/\sigma 1/ σ , 1 / σ 1/\sigma 1/ σ , 1 / ( 2 R T L log ) 1/(2RTL_{\log}) 1/ ( 2 R T L l o g ) , and 1 / ( 2 r + ) 1/(2r^+) 1/ ( 2 r + ) for the Poisson, local Gaussian, logarithmic-mean, and inverse-log representations, respectively. Figure 2 compares these differences in Δ R ( r ) \Delta\mathcal{R}(r) Δ R ( r ) . A common minimizing rate does not make the four representations statistically equivalent. We next couple the passive and fueled reaction channels to spatial transport and nonideal interactions in Sec. IV. Section V then examines how membrane–cytosol dynamics and chemical input power depend on state and channel resolution.
Figure 2. One selected rate and four Rayleighian representations. The axes are r / r 0 r/r_0 r / r 0 and Δ R / ( 2 R T V r 0 ) \Delta\mathcal{R}/(2RTVr_0) Δ R / ( 2 R T V r 0 ) , where r 0 > 0 r_0>0 r 0 > 0 is a reference molar rate density, distinct from the passive-channel rate; Δ R = R − R min \Delta\mathcal{R}=\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min} Δ R = R − R m i n . For r + / r 0 = 4 r^+/r_0=4 r + / r 0 = 4 and r − / r 0 = 1 r^-/r_0=1 r − / r 0 = 1 , the common minimizing rate is r ∗ / r 0 = 3 r_*/r_0=3 r ∗ / r 0 = 3 , with Γ / r 0 = 4 \Gamma/r_0=4 Γ/ r 0 = 4 , σ / r 0 = 5 \sigma/r_0=5 σ / r 0 = 5 , and A / ( R T ) = ln 4 \mathcal{A}/(RT)=\ln4 A / ( R T ) = ln 4 . The solid, dotted, and dashed curves equal ℓ P / r 0 \ell_P/r_0 ℓ P / r 0 , ℓ l o c / r 0 \ell_{\mathrm{loc}}/r_0 ℓ loc / r 0 , and ℓ G / r 0 \ell_G/r_0 ℓ G / r 0 in Eqs. (67) , (68) , (63b), respectively. They represent the Poisson model, its local Gaussian approximation, and a separately specified logarithmic-mean Gaussian model. The dash-dotted curve shows Δ R / ( 2 R T V r 0 ) \Delta\mathcal{R}/(2RTVr_0) Δ R / ( 2 R T V r 0 ) from Eq. (64b); no fluctuation interpretation is assigned to it here. It is shown only for r > − r − = − r 0 r>-r^-= -r_0 r > − r − = − r 0 . The local Gaussian approximation is valid only near r ∗ r_* r ∗ ; its continuation is shown for comparison.
Active emulsions: phase separation and fuel conversion
We now consider the passive and fueled conversions of Sec. III in a spatially varying nonideal fluid mixture. Unlike the ideal mixture in that section, the nonideal free energy can be nonconvex, although equilibrium phase coexistence also depends on which component amounts are conserved. We examine how the same free energy determines the driving forces for diffusion and reaction, and how the free-energy balance changes when externally maintained fuel and waste are replaced by a finite fuel pool [61 , 68 , 69 ] .
Nonideal thermodynamics and material balances
Reaction channels, fields, and constraints. Consider a nonadvecting incompressible mixture with two reversible reaction channels,
A ⇌ B , A + F ⇌ B + W . (73) A\rightleftharpoons B,\qquad A+F\rightleftharpoons B+W. \tag*{(73)} A ⇌ B , A + F ⇌ B + W . (73)
The chemical system contains five species: interconverting components A A A , B B B , a nonreacting solvent C C C , and fuel and waste F F F , W W W . The subscripts 0 , F 0,F 0 , F distinguish passive and fueled conversion, with trial net molar rate densities r 0 , r F r_0,r_F r 0 , r F positive for A → B A\to B A → B . We retain the composition fields of A A A , B B B , C C C , while the activities of F F F , W W W are initially prescribed by external reservoirs. Neglecting the volume contributions of fuel and waste, we describe the retained fluid as an incompressible ternary mixture. For equal, constant molecular volumes of A A A , B B B , C C C , their molar concentrations satisfy c i = c 0 ϕ i c_i=c_0\phi_i c i = c 0 ϕ i , where ϕ i > 0 \phi_i>0 ϕ i > 0 are volume fractions and c 0 = c A + c B + c C c_0=c_A+c_B+c_C c 0 = c A + c B + c C is constant. The volume-filling constraint ϕ C = 1 − ϕ A − ϕ B \phi_C=1-\phi_A-\phi_B ϕ C = 1 − ϕ A − ϕ B leaves two independent composition fields. On the fixed domain Ω \Omega Ω , the material balances are
c 0 ∂ t ϕ A = − ∇ ⋅ J A − r 0 − r F , (74) c_0\partial_t\phi_A=-\nabla\cdot\mathbf{J}_A-r_0-r_F, \tag*{(74)} c 0 ∂ t ϕ A = − ∇ ⋅ J A − r 0 − r F , (74)
c 0 ∂ t ϕ B = − ∇ ⋅ J B + r 0 + r F . (75) c_0\partial_t\phi_B=-\nabla\cdot\mathbf{J}_B+r_0+r_F. \tag*{(75)} c 0 ∂ t ϕ B = − ∇ ⋅ J B + r 0 + r F . (75)
The independent molar diffusive fluxes are J A , J B J_A,J_B J A , J B , with J C = − J A − J B J_C=-J_A-J_B J C = − J A − J B . Periodic boundaries, or impermeable walls with n ^ ⋅ J i = n ^ ⋅ ∇ ϕ i = 0 \hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\mathbf{J}_i=\hat{\mathbf{n}}\cdot\nabla\phi_i=0 n ^ ⋅ J i = n ^ ⋅ ∇ ϕ i = 0 for i = A , B i=A,B i = A , B and outward unit normal n ^ \hat{\mathbf{n}} n ^ , remove boundary power terms and conserve the total amount of A + B A+B A + B .
Free energy and its rate. Choose the nonideal mixture free energy
F [ ϕ A , ϕ B ] = c 0 ∫ Ω [ f + K A 2 ∣ ∇ ϕ A ∣ 2 + K B 2 ∣ ∇ ϕ B ∣ 2 ] d V . (76) \mathcal{F}[\phi_A,\phi_B]=c_0\int_{\Omega}\left[f+\frac{K_A}{2}|\nabla\phi_A|^2+\frac{K_B}{2}|\nabla\phi_B|^2\right]\,dV. \tag*{(76)} F [ ϕ A , ϕ B ] = c 0 ∫ Ω [ f + 2 K A ∣∇ ϕ A ∣ 2 + 2 K B ∣∇ ϕ B ∣ 2 ] d V . (76)
Here, the homogeneous molar free energy f ( ϕ A , ϕ B , ϕ C ) = R T ∑ s = A , B , C ϕ s ln ϕ s + χ ϕ B ( ϕ A + ϕ C ) + h B ϕ B f(\phi_A,\phi_B,\phi_C)=RT\sum_{s=A,B,C}\phi_s\ln\phi_s+\chi\phi_B(\phi_A+\phi_C)+h_B\phi_B f ( ϕ A , ϕ B , ϕ C ) = R T ∑ s = A , B , C ϕ s ln ϕ s + χ ϕ B ( ϕ A + ϕ C ) + h B ϕ B has the Flory–Huggins form for a ternary mixture with ϕ C = 1 − ϕ A − ϕ B \phi_C=1-\phi_A-\phi_B ϕ C = 1 − ϕ A − ϕ B . The interaction term corresponds to χ A B = χ B C = χ > 0 \chi_{AB}=\chi_{BC}=\chi>0 χ A B = χ B C = χ > 0 and χ A C = 0 \chi_{AC}=0 χ A C = 0 : mixing B B B with either A A A or C C C is unfavorable, whereas no nonideal A A A –C C C mixing term is included. The coefficient h B h_B h B specifies the standard molar free-energy difference between B B B and A A A ; terms proportional to the conserved amounts of A + B A+B A + B and C C C are omitted. Both χ \chi χ and h B h_B h B have molar energy units, while K A , K B > 0 K_A,K_B>0 K A , K B > 0 have units of molar energy times length squared. For χ = 0 \chi=0 χ = 0 , the bulk free energy has the ideal-mixing structure of Eq. (47) . With c i = c 0 ϕ i c_i=c_0\phi_i c i = c 0 ϕ i and consistent standard states, the volume-fraction and concentration forms differ only by composition-independent terms for the same retained species at fixed c 0 , V , T c_0,V,T c 0 , V , T . The standard-state bias h B h_B h B remains; the gradient terms account separately for spatial inhomogeneity.
For the homogeneous mixture, use pure-component standard states at the same temperature and pressure. In the chosen free-energy convention, μ A ∘ = μ C ∘ = 0 \mu_A^\circ=\mu_C^\circ=0 μ A ∘ = μ C ∘ = 0 and μ B ∘ = h B \mu_B^\circ=h_B μ B ∘ = h B . The component molar chemical potentials are
μ s = μ s ∘ + R T ln a s , (77) \mu_s=\mu_s^\circ+RT\ln a_s, \tag*{(77)} μ s = μ s ∘ + R T ln a s , (77)
where a s = γ s ϕ s a_s=\gamma_s\phi_s a s = γ s ϕ s are dimensionless activities for s = A , B , C s=A,B,C s = A , B , C , with
γ A = γ C = exp ( χ ϕ B 2 R T ) , γ B = exp ( χ ( 1 − ϕ B ) 2 R T ) . (78) \gamma_A=\gamma_C=\exp\left(\frac{\chi\phi_B^2}{RT}\right),\qquad\gamma_B=\exp\left(\frac{\chi(1-\phi_B)^2}{RT}\right). \tag*{(78)} γ A = γ C = exp ( R T χ ϕ B 2 ) , γ B = exp ( R T χ ( 1 − ϕ B ) 2 ) . (78)
The activity coefficients follow from the partial molar derivatives of f f f ; equal molecular volumes identify volume fractions with mole fractions. The common pressure contribution is included in the standard-state convention.
Including gradient contributions gives component potentials μ ^ s \hat{\mu}_s μ ^ s , defined up to a common incompressibility term. For admissible variations, δ F = c 0 ∫ Ω ∑ s = A , B , C μ ^ s δ ϕ s d V \delta F=c_0\int_{\Omega}\sum_{s=A,B,C}\hat{\mu}_s\delta\phi_s\,dV δ F = c 0 ∫ Ω ∑ s = A , B , C μ ^ s δ ϕ s d V . Using δ ϕ C = − δ ϕ A − δ ϕ B \delta\phi_C=-\delta\phi_A-\delta\phi_B δ ϕ C = − δ ϕ A − δ ϕ B gives δ F = c 0 ∫ Ω ∑ i = A , B μ ˉ i δ ϕ i d V \delta F=c_0\int_{\Omega}\sum_{i=A,B}\bar{\mu}_i\delta\phi_i\,dV δ F = c 0 ∫ Ω ∑ i = A , B μ ˉ i δ ϕ i d V , where
μ ˉ A ≡ μ ^ A − μ ^ C = R T ln ( a A / a C ) − K A ∇ 2 ϕ A , (79) \bar{\mu}_A\equiv\hat{\mu}_A-\hat{\mu}_C=RT\ln(a_A/a_C)-K_A\nabla^2\phi_A, \tag*{(79)} μ ˉ A ≡ μ ^ A − μ ^ C = R T ln ( a A / a C ) − K A ∇ 2 ϕ A , (79)
μ ˉ B ≡ μ ^ B − μ ^ C = h B + R T ln ( a B / a C ) − K B ∇ 2 ϕ B . (80) \bar{\mu}_B\equiv\hat{\mu}_B-\hat{\mu}_C=h_B+RT\ln(a_B/a_C)-K_B\nabla^2\phi_B. \tag*{(80)} μ ˉ B ≡ μ ^ B − μ ^ C = h B + R T ln ( a B / a C ) − K B ∇ 2 ϕ B . (80)
These exchange potentials enter both diffusion and the reaction affinities. Substituting Eq. (66) and integrating by parts gives
F ˙ = ∫ Ω [ ∑ i = A , B ∇ μ ˉ i ⋅ J i − ( μ ˉ A − μ ˉ B ) ( r 0 + r F ) ] d V . (81) \dot{\mathcal{F}}=\int_{\Omega}\left[\sum_{i=A,B}\nabla\bar{\mu}_i\cdot\mathbf{J}_i-(\bar{\mu}_A-\bar{\mu}_B)(r_0+r_F)\right]\,dV. \tag*{(81)} F ˙ = ∫ Ω i = A , B ∑ ∇ μ ˉ i ⋅ J i − ( μ ˉ A − μ ˉ B ) ( r 0 + r F ) d V . (81)
The ideal-mixing contribution is convex, whereas χ > 2 R T \chi>2RT χ > 2 R T permits interaction-driven demixing over part of the composition space. If both channels of chemical reactions are disabled, the amount of B B B is separately conserved, so the linear term c 0 h B ∫ Ω ϕ B d V c_0h_B\int_{\Omega}\phi_B\,dV c 0 h B ∫ Ω ϕ B d V is constant and does not affect diffusive equilibration. With interconversion allowed, h B h_B h B instead contributes to the chemical driving.
Variational dynamics and chemical maintenance
Chemical driving and rate selection. The chemical potentials μ s r e s \mu_s^{\mathrm{res}} μ s res of fuel and waste also obey Eq. (77) , but their activities a s a_s a s are reservoir inputs rather than consequences of F [ ϕ A , ϕ B ] \mathcal{F}[\phi_A,\phi_B] F [ ϕ A , ϕ B ] , with s = F , W s=F,W s = F , W . For the ideal fuel-pool model used here, take a s = c s R / c R ∘ a_s=c_s^R/c_R^\circ a s = c s R / c R ∘ , s = F , W s=F,W s = F , W , with a common concentration scale c R ∘ c_R^\circ c R ∘ and equal standard chemical potentials μ s ∘ \mu_s^\circ μ s ∘ . Thus, Δ μ F = μ F r e s − μ W r e s = R T ln ( a F / a W ) \Delta\mu_F=\mu_F^{\mathrm{res}}-\mu_W^{\mathrm{res}}=RT\ln(a_F/a_W) Δ μ F = μ F res − μ W res = R T ln ( a F / a W ) : initially a F , a W a_F,a_W a F , a W are uniform and maintained constant. Each mole of forward fueled conversion consumes one mole of F F F and produces one mole of W W W . The spatial form of Eqs. (16) and (57) is therefore
P i n = ∫ Ω Δ μ F r F d V , (82) \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=\int_{\Omega}\Delta\mu_F r_F\,dV, \tag*{(82)} P in = ∫ Ω Δ μ F r F d V , (82)
F ˙ − P i n = ∫ Ω [ ∑ i = A , B ∇ μ ˉ i ⋅ J i − A 0 r 0 − A F r F ] d V , (83) \dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=\int_{\Omega}\left[\sum_{i=A,B}\nabla\bar{\mu}_i\cdot\mathbf{J}_i-\mathcal{A}_0r_0-\mathcal{A}_F r_F\right]\,dV, \tag*{(83)} F ˙ − P in = ∫ Ω i = A , B ∑ ∇ μ ˉ i ⋅ J i − A 0 r 0 − A F r F d V , (83)
where A 0 = μ ˉ A − μ ˉ B \mathcal{A}_0=\bar{\mu}_A-\bar{\mu}_B A 0 = μ ˉ A − μ ˉ B and A F = μ ˉ A − μ ˉ B + Δ μ F \mathcal{A}_F=\bar{\mu}_A-\bar{\mu}_B+\Delta\mu_F A F = μ ˉ A − μ ˉ B + Δ μ F . Combining transport resistances with the reaction dissipation potential φ \varphi φ of Eq. (28) gives the total dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ :
Φ = ∫ Ω [ ∑ i = A , B ∣ J i ∣ 2 2 M i + ∑ ρ = 0 , F φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) ] d V . (84) \Phi=\int_{\Omega}\left[\sum_{i=A,B}\frac{|\mathbf{J}_i|^2}{2M_i}+\sum_{\rho=0,F}\varphi(r_\rho;\Gamma_\rho)\right]\,dV. \tag*{(84)} Φ = ∫ Ω i = A , B ∑ 2 M i ∣ J i ∣ 2 + ρ = 0 , F ∑ φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) d V . (84)
The M i > 0 M_i>0 M i > 0 are prescribed constant transport mobilities on the independent composition directions. The positive Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ may depend on the instantaneous composition fields and fuel controls; their values are fixed during trial-rate variation. Minimizing the Rayleighian R = Φ + F ˙ − P i n \mathcal{R}=\Phi+\dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} R = Φ + F ˙ − P in gives
J i , ∗ = − M i ∇ μ ˉ i , (85) \mathbf{J}_{i,*}=-M_i\nabla\bar{\mu}_i, \tag*{(85)} J i , ∗ = − M i ∇ μ ˉ i , (85)
r ρ , ∗ = Γ ρ sinh A ρ 2 R T , (86) r_{\rho,*}=\Gamma_\rho\sinh\frac{\mathcal{A}_\rho}{2RT}, \tag*{(86)} r ρ , ∗ = Γ ρ sinh 2 R T A ρ , (86)
for i = A , B i=A,B i = A , B and ρ = 0 , F \rho=0,F ρ = 0 , F . Equation (75b) gives the nonlinear rate–affinity relation at fixed Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ ; their state dependence remains a constitutive input.
Kinetic specialization and dissipation. To obtain the activity-based reaction laws used here, we choose
Γ 0 = 2 k 0 e ( μ ˉ A + μ ˉ B ) / ( 2 R T ) , (87) \Gamma_0 = 2k_0 e^{(\bar{\mu}_A+\bar{\mu}_B)/(2RT)}, \tag*{(87)} Γ 0 = 2 k 0 e ( μ ˉ A + μ ˉ B ) / ( 2 R T ) , (87)
Γ F = 2 κ F a F a W e ( μ ˉ A + μ ˉ B ) / ( 2 R T ) . (88) \Gamma_F = 2\kappa_F \sqrt{a_F a_W}e^{(\bar{\mu}_A+\bar{\mu}_B)/(2RT)}. \tag*{(88)} Γ F = 2 κ F a F a W e ( μ ˉ A + μ ˉ B ) / ( 2 R T ) . (88)
Here, k 0 , κ F > 0 k_0,\kappa_F>0 k 0 , κ F > 0 are rate-density prefactors that may depend on composition. Since a F a W e Δ μ F / ( 2 R T ) = a F \sqrt{a_Fa_W}e^{\Delta\mu_F/(2RT)}=a_F a F a W e Δ μ F / ( 2 R T ) = a F and a F a W e − Δ μ F / ( 2 R T ) = a W \sqrt{a_Fa_W}e^{-\Delta\mu_F/(2RT)}=a_W a F a W e − Δ μ F / ( 2 R T ) = a W , substitution into Eq. (75b) gives
r 0 , ∗ = k 0 ( e μ ˉ A / ( R T ) − e μ ˉ B / ( R T ) ) , (89) r_{0,*}=k_0\left(e^{\bar{\mu}_A/(RT)}-e^{\bar{\mu}_B/(RT)}\right), \tag*{(89)} r 0 , ∗ = k 0 ( e μ ˉ A / ( R T ) − e μ ˉ B / ( R T ) ) , (89)
r F , ∗ = κ F ( a F e μ ˉ A / ( R T ) − a W e μ ˉ B / ( R T ) ) . (90) r_{F,*}=\kappa_F\left(a_F e^{\bar{\mu}_A/(RT)}-a_W e^{\bar{\mu}_B/(RT)}\right). \tag*{(90)} r F , ∗ = κ F ( a F e μ ˉ A / ( R T ) − a W e μ ˉ B / ( R T ) ) . (90)
These laws follow from the chosen Γ 0 , F \Gamma_{0,F} Γ 0 , F , not from thermodynamics alone. The identity e μ ˉ i / ( R T ) = e − μ ^ C / ( R T ) e μ ^ i / ( R T ) e^{\bar{\mu}_i/(RT)}=e^{-\hat{\mu}_C/(RT)}e^{\hat{\mu}_i/(RT)} e μ ˉ i / ( R T ) = e − μ ^ C / ( R T ) e μ ^ i / ( R T ) shows that changing from component to exchange chemical potentials rescales a common kinetic prefactor. This change of representation does not fix k 0 k_0 k 0 or κ F \kappa_F κ F ; their composition dependence models kinetic effects such as catalysis or activation barriers[59 , 61 ] . In a homogeneous ideal mixture at fixed solvent concentration, consistent standard states and prefactors recover the concentration dependence of Eq. (52). Nonideal activities and gradient contributions must otherwise remain in the chemical potentials; idealization alone does not fix the same kinetic coefficients.
Equations (75a) and (77), inserted into Eq. (66), determine the coupled dynamics. Along the selected evolution, the free-energy balance F ˙ = P i n − D \dot{F}=\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}-\mathcal{D} F ˙ = P in − D of Eq. (8) holds with
D = ∫ Ω [ ∑ i = A , B M i ∣ ∇ μ ˉ i ∣ 2 + A 0 r 0 , ∗ + A F r F , ∗ ] d V ≥ 0. (91) \mathcal{D}=\int_{\Omega}\left[\sum_{i=A,B}M_i\lvert\nabla\bar{\mu}_i\rvert^2+A_0r_{0,*}+A_Fr_{F,*}\right]\,dV\geq0. \tag*{(91)} D = ∫ Ω i = A , B ∑ M i ∣ ∇ μ ˉ i ∣ 2 + A 0 r 0 , ∗ + A F r F , ∗ d V ≥ 0. (91)
For this resolved macroscopic model, D = T S ˙ p r o d m a c \mathcal{D}=T\dot{S}^{\mathrm{mac}}_{\mathrm{prod}} D = T S ˙ prod mac . It is not generally a heat current: the entropy balance also includes system entropy changes and entropy carried by exchanged matter. At a single-bath steady state with no net entropy transport by matter, the two powers coincide. Heat exchange in the present chemically open mixture requires this additional thermodynamic information[40 , 50 ] . The deterministic balance alone does not specify fluctuations. At a fixed spatial resolution, independent thermal transport noise with covariance amplitude 2 k B T M i 2k_BT M_i 2 k B T M i and resolved Poisson reaction events give additive local fluctuation costs, extending the excess relation in Eq. (39b) to coupled reaction–transport dynamics in the stated frozen-state, many-event limit[70 ] .
Chemical maintenance and spatial structure. The selected kinetics distinguish stationary composition from zero fuel consumption. First consider a homogeneous stationary state at maintained a F > a W a_F>a_W a F > a W . With no spatial gradients, Eq. (66b) requires r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ = 0 r_{0,*}+r_{F,*}=0 r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ = 0 , while Eq. (77) gives r F , ∗ = e μ ˉ A / ( R T ) k 0 κ F ( a F − a W ) / ( k 0 + κ F a W ) > 0 r_{F,*}=e^{\bar{\mu}_A/(RT)}k_0\kappa_F(a_F-a_W)/(k_0+\kappa_Fa_W)>0 r F , ∗ = e μ ˉ A / ( R T ) k 0 κ F ( a F − a W ) / ( k 0 + κ F a W ) > 0 and r 0 , ∗ = − r F , ∗ < 0 r_{0,*}=-r_{F,*}<0 r 0 , ∗ = − r F , ∗ < 0 . Thus, fueled conversion and passive return consume fuel without changing composition, as in Sec. III. A nonuniform stationary profile instead obeys r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ = ∇ ⋅ J B , ∗ r_{0,*}+r_{F,*}=\nabla\cdot\mathbf{J}_{B,*} r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ = ∇ ⋅ J B , ∗ : local net conversion need not vanish. With the stated boundaries, ∫ Ω ( r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ ) d V = 0 \int_{\Omega}(r_{0,*}+r_{F,*})\,dV=0 ∫ Ω ( r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ ) d V = 0 , while P i n = Δ μ F ∫ Ω r F , ∗ d V = D > 0 \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=\Delta\mu_F\int_{\Omega}r_{F,*}\,dV=\mathcal{D}>0 P in = Δ μ F ∫ Ω r F , ∗ d V = D > 0 [39 , 40 ] . The input power follows from the selected rates rather than being prescribed independently.
Finite-fuel relaxation and domain dissolution
Preparation of a chemically maintained domain. Figure 3 considers a periodic one-dimensional slab of length L L L and cross-sectional area S ⊥ S_\perp S ⊥ . For the prefactors specified in the caption, K = k 0 + κ F > 0 K=k_0+\kappa_F>0 K = k 0 + κ F > 0 is constant, while κ F / K \kappa_F/K κ F / K increases with local solute content ϕ A + ϕ B \phi_A+\phi_B ϕ A + ϕ B . At the maintained preparation activities, this allocation realizes the smooth composition-dependent reaction bias of Haugerud et al.[11 ] through resolved passive and fueled channels. The phase selectivity is a phenomenological constitutive choice, not a prediction of OVP or LDB. We use ℓ 0 = ( K A / R T ) 1 / 2 \ell_0=(K_A/RT)^{1/2} ℓ 0 = ( K A / R T ) 1/2 , K t 0 / c 0 = 0.002 K t_0/c_0=0.002 K t 0 / c 0 = 0.002 , and E 0 = c 0 R T S ⊥ ℓ 0 E_0=c_0RTS_\perp\ell_0 E 0 = c 0 R T S ⊥ ℓ 0 . A smooth seed with ϕ B ≃ 0.94 \phi_B\simeq0.94 ϕ B ≃ 0.94 in the central region and ϕ B ≃ 0.025 \phi_B\simeq0.025 ϕ B ≃ 0.025 outside is evolved for 8000 t 0 8000t_0 8000 t 0 at maintained a F = e 6 a_F=e^6 a F = e 6 , a W = 1 a_W=1 a W = 1 , with ⟨ ϕ A + ϕ B ⟩ = 0.51 \langle\phi_A+\phi_B\rangle=0.51 ⟨ ϕ A + ϕ B ⟩ = 0.51 ; brackets denote spatial averages. The resulting driven stationary profile defines t = 0 t=0 t = 0 and has ⟨ ϕ B ⟩ ≃ 0.498 \langle\phi_B\rangle\simeq0.498 ⟨ ϕ B ⟩ ≃ 0.498 . This preparation selects a nonuniform steady state; it does not test nucleation or convergence from arbitrary initially mixed states.
In this prepared state, fueled A → B A\to B A → B conversion in the dense region and passive B → A B\to A B → A return in the dilute region are coupled by A A A and outward B B B transport [xref}Fig. 1(c). Here, interactions favor demixing, while fuel maintains the selected B B B -rich composition and reaction–transport cycle.
Release to a finite fuel pool. At t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , external fuel replenishment and waste removal cease, while both reactions remain active and a fuel/waste pool of fixed volume V R V_R V R remains coupled to the mixture. The fields and activities are continuous across this switch; interaction parameters and kinetic functions remain unchanged. A control branch retains the original maintained activities. Assume sufficiently fast mixing and fuel/waste exchange that uniform activities a F ( t ) , a W ( t ) a_F(t),a_W(t) a F ( t ) , a W ( t ) describe the pool and its coupling to the mixture. For the ideal-pool convention already specified, the molar amounts are n s R = V R c 0 R a s n_s^R=V_Rc_0^Ra_s n s R = V R c 0 R a s , s = F , W s=F,W s = F , W . Fuel conversion gives a ˙ W = − a ˙ F \dot{a}_W=-\dot{a}_F a ˙ W = − a ˙ F and
V R c 0 R a ˙ F = − ∫ Ω r F , ∗ d V . (92) V_Rc_0^R\dot{a}_F=-\int_{\Omega}r_{F,*}\,dV. \tag*{(92)} V R c 0 R a ˙ F = − ∫ Ω r F , ∗ d V . (92)
Up to a conserved standard-state term, the pool free energy is F R = R T V R c 0 R [ a F ( ln a F − 1 ) + a W ( ln a W − 1 ) ] \mathcal{F}_R=RTV_Rc_0^R[a_F(\ln a_F-1)+a_W(\ln a_W-1)] F R = R T V R c 0 R [ a F ( ln a F − 1 ) + a W ( ln a W − 1 )] . Using (92) gives F ˙ R = − P i n \dot{\mathcal{F}}_R=-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} F ˙ R = − P in and F ˙ + F ˙ R = − D \dot{\mathcal{F}}+\dot{\mathcal{F}}_R=-\mathcal{D} F ˙ + F ˙ R = − D .
Thus, P i n P_{\rm in} P in is now the rate of free-energy transfer from the pool to the mixture, not external power supplied to their combined system. Neither a F a_F a F nor Δ μ F \Delta\mu_F Δ μ F is set to zero at release; the constant-bias argument of Eq. (58) does not replace this balance when Δ μ F ( t ) \Delta\mu_F(t) Δ μ F ( t ) evolves.
Numerical implementation. Spatial derivatives were approximated by second-order central finite differences on uniform periodic grids of 128 and 192 cells. The resulting dimensionless ordinary differential equations were integrated using the adaptive-step, variable-order backward differentiation formula (BDF) solver in SciPy’s solve_ivp, with relative and absolute error tolerances of 2 × 10 − 7 2\times10^{-7} 2 × 1 0 − 7 and 2 × 10 − 9 2\times10^{-9} 2 × 1 0 − 9 , respectively. The discrete free energy was evaluated with a gradient operator consistent with the discrete Laplacian in the evolution equations. Threshold crossings defining L d L_d L d were located by linear interpolation between adjacent grid points. The initial profiles, code, and data are available as specified in the Data Availability statement. ChatGPT (GPT-6 Pro; OpenAI) assisted analytical consistency checks and numerical-code development; its uses, purposes, and the authors’ verification procedures are detailed in the Declaration of Generative AI Use.
Dissolution and transient fuel regeneration. Initially, net fuel consumption lowers a F / a W a_F/a_W a F / a W , moving the mixture away from its maintained reaction–transport balance. The B B B -rich domain gradually narrows before its remaining core decays rapidly near 176 t 0 176t_0 176 t 0 [Figure 3 (a)]. The threshold length L d L_d L d of the region with ϕ B > 0.5 \phi_B>0.5 ϕ B > 0.5 vanishes at t / t 0 ≃ 176.4 t/t_0\simeq176.4 t / t 0 ≃ 176.4 ; neither extinction of B B B nor complete homogenization has occurred. During this terminal decay, composition and gradient contributions raise μ ˉ B \bar{\mu}_B μ ˉ B in the core. At t / t 0 = 176.5 t/t_0=176.5 t / t 0 = 176.5 , the computed affinity at the B B B -concentration maximum is Δ μ F / ( R T ) ≃ − 0.57 \Delta\mu_F/(RT)\simeq-0.57 Δ μ F / ( R T ) ≃ − 0.57 on the 128-cell grid, despite Δ μ F > 0 \Delta\mu_F>0 Δ μ F > 0 . Reverse fueled conversion and transport contribute to the peak decay.
Figure 3. Dissolution of a chemically maintained dense domain after external replenishment stops. (a) Threshold length L d = ∫ 0 L 1 { ϕ B > 0.5 } d x L_d=\int_0^L 1_{\{\phi_B>0.5\}}\,dx L d = ∫ 0 L 1 { ϕ B > 0.5 } d x , compared with a maintained-activity control. Inset: B B B profiles on 128 cells at t / t 0 = 0 , 100 , 150 , 176 , 220 t/t_0=0,100,150,176,220 t / t 0 = 0 , 100 , 150 , 176 , 220 . Loss of the threshold region does not imply extinction of B B B . (b) Change in the combined mixture–pool free energy, Δ ( F + F R ) / E 0 \Delta(\mathcal{F}+\mathcal{F}_R)/E_0 Δ ( F + F R ) / E 0 , relative to t = 0 t=0 t = 0 . The deterministic calculations use N x = 128 , 192 N_x=128,192 N x = 128 , 192 spatial grid cells. Parameters are L / ℓ 0 = 24 L/\ell_0=24 L / ℓ 0 = 24 , K A / ( R T ℓ 0 2 ) = K B / ( R T ℓ 0 2 ) = 1 K_A/(RT\ell_0^2)=K_B/(RT\ell_0^2)=1 K A / ( R T ℓ 0 2 ) = K B / ( R T ℓ 0 2 ) = 1 , M A R T t 0 / ( c 0 ℓ 0 2 ) = M B R T t 0 / ( c 0 ℓ 0 2 ) = 0.15 M_ARTt_0/(c_0\ell_0^2)=M_BRTt_0/(c_0\ell_0^2)=0.15 M A R T t 0 / ( c 0 ℓ 0 2 ) = M B R T t 0 / ( c 0 ℓ 0 2 ) = 0.15 , χ / ( R T ) = 5 \chi/(RT)=5 χ / ( R T ) = 5 , h B / ( R T ) = 1 h_B/(RT)=1 h B / ( R T ) = 1 , K t 0 / c 0 = 0.002 Kt_0/c_0=0.002 K t 0 / c 0 = 0.002 , and V R c R / ( c 0 S ⊥ ℓ 0 ) = 0.02 V_Rc_R/(c_0S_\perp\ell_0)=0.02 V R c R / ( c 0 S ⊥ ℓ 0 ) = 0.02 . The kinetic prefactors are k 0 = K ( e 6 − z ) / ( e 6 − 1 ) k_0=K(e^6-z)/(e^6-1) k 0 = K ( e 6 − z ) / ( e 6 − 1 ) and κ F = K ( z − 1 ) / ( e 6 − 1 ) \kappa_F=K(z-1)/(e^6-1) κ F = K ( z − 1 ) / ( e 6 − 1 ) , with z = exp { 3 [ 1 + tanh ( ( ψ − 0.25 ) / 0.03 ) ] } z=\exp\{3[1+\tanh((\psi-0.25)/0.03)]\} z = exp { 3 [ 1 + tanh (( ψ − 0.25 ) /0.03 )]} and ψ = ( ϕ A + ϕ B ) / 2 \psi=(\phi_A+\phi_B)/2 ψ = ( ϕ A + ϕ B ) /2 . The switching form of ln z \ln z ln z is adapted from Haugerud et al.[11 ] . The factor e 6 e^6 e 6 in these functions remains fixed as a F / a W a_F/a_W a F / a W evolves. Initial activities are a F = e 6 a_F=e^6 a F = e 6 , a W = 1 a_W=1 a W = 1 , and the conserved spatial mean is ⟨ ϕ A + ϕ B ⟩ = 0.51 \langle\phi_A+\phi_B\rangle=0.51 ⟨ ϕ A + ϕ B ⟩ = 0.51 .
The steeper decrease of the combined mixture–pool free energy [Figure 3 (b)] reflects increased total dissipation through F ˙ + F ˙ R = − D \dot{\mathcal{F}}+\dot{\mathcal{F}}_R=-D F ˙ + F ˙ R = − D . The integrated fuel rate briefly reverses, giving P i n < 0 P_{\rm in}<0 P in < 0 and F ˙ R > 0 \dot{\mathcal{F}}_R>0 F ˙ R > 0 while the combined free energy continues to decrease: this is transient fuel regeneration, not fuel exhaustion. For these parameters, net B → A B\to A B → A conversion and transport lead to a homogeneous B B B -poor state with ϕ B ≃ 1.28 × 10 − 3 \phi_B\simeq1.28\times10^{-3} ϕ B ≃ 1.28 × 1 0 − 3 , consistent with chemical equilibrium μ ˉ A = μ ˉ B \bar{\mu}_A=\bar{\mu}_B μ ˉ A = μ ˉ B and a F = a W a_F=a_W a F = a W . Disabling both reactions would instead conserve the prepared B B B amount, allowing passive phase coexistence at that composition. Thus, the observed homogenization involves chemical conversion, not a change in interactions.
Membrane–cytosol reaction–diffusion: recruitment and model reduction
In this section, we examine what reduced state and channel descriptions retain about dynamics and chemical input power P i n \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} P in .
Physical free energy, recruitment kinetics, and chemical power
We use a convex ideal free energy to distinguish recruitment-driven redistribution from the interaction-driven phase separation of Sec. IV. The cytosolic pool is retained because the membrane density alone does not determine attachment[12 , 38 ] . We first construct the physical two-field model and examine whether composition trajectories alone determine the chemical input power P i n \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} P in . We then compare an invertible change of fields with a density-only representation under a separate kinetic assumption. The fuel-channel realization below is a constitutive example, not an identified protein-specific mechanism. Coupled bulk–surface thermodynamics has also been used to study wetting with surface binding and chemically driven changes of droplet shape.[71 , 72 ] Here, we isolate recruitment and internal redistribution on a fixed geometry, rather than droplet wetting or contact-line motion.
Reaction channels, fields, and constraints. Consider the passive and fueled conversions of Secs. III and IV, now between cytosolic and membrane-bound protein states:
C ⇌ M , C + F ⇌ M + W . (93) C \rightleftharpoons M,\qquad C+F \rightleftharpoons M+W. \tag*{(93)} C ⇌ M , C + F ⇌ M + W . (93)
Here, C C C , M M M label the protein states and F F F , W W W the fuel and waste; C C C is not the solvent of Sec. IV. The subscripts 0 0 0 , F F F distinguish passive and fueled conversion.
For a fixed flat membrane beneath a thin solution layer [Figure 1 (d)], define the amounts per unit area by
c ( x , t ) = ∫ 0 h C b ( x , z , t ) d z , m ( x , t ) = σ m ( x , t ) . (94) c(x,t)=\int_{0}^{h}C_b(x,z,t)\,\mathrm{d}z,\qquad m(x,t)=\sigma_m(x,t). \tag*{(94)} c ( x , t ) = ∫ 0 h C b ( x , z , t ) d z , m ( x , t ) = σ m ( x , t ) . (94)
Here, C b C_b C b is the bulk molar concentration, σ m \sigma_m σ m the membrane molar surface density, h h h the fixed layer height, and x x x , z z z the lateral and perpendicular coordinates. This height-averaged description requires perpendicular diffusion to relax faster than binding and lateral redistribution; a spatially resolved bulk requires a separate transport problem.[71 ]
The trial net attachment rates r 0 r_0 r 0 , r F r_F r F are positive for C → M C\to M C → M and have units of moles per area per time. On a periodic membrane domain Σ \Sigma Σ , the material balances are
∂ t c = − ∇ s ⋅ J c − r 0 − r F , (95) \partial_t c=-\nabla_s\cdot\mathbf{J}_c-r_0-r_F, \tag*{(95)} ∂ t c = − ∇ s ⋅ J c − r 0 − r F , (95)
∂ t m = − ∇ s ⋅ J m + r 0 + r F . (96) \partial_t m=-\nabla_s\cdot\mathbf{J}_m+r_0+r_F. \tag*{(96)} ∂ t m = − ∇ s ⋅ J m + r 0 + r F . (96)
The lateral molar fluxes J c \mathbf{J}_c J c , J m \mathbf{J}_m J m have units of moles per length per time, and ∇ s \nabla_s ∇ s differentiates laterally. Total protein is conserved; membrane protein alone is not.
Free energy and its rate. Choose ideal component thermodynamics:
F = R T ∫ Σ [ c ( ln c m s − 1 ) + m ( ln m k b m s − 1 ) ] d A . (97) \mathcal{F}=RT\int_{\Sigma}\left[c\left(\ln\frac{c}{m_s}-1\right)+m\left(\ln\frac{m}{k_bm_s}-1\right)\right]\mathrm{d}A. \tag*{(97)} F = R T ∫ Σ [ c ( ln m s c − 1 ) + m ( ln k b m s m − 1 ) ] d A . (97)
Here, m s > 0 m_s>0 m s > 0 is a reference areal density, also chosen as the half-saturation density of the recruitment function g ( m ) g(m) g ( m ) below. The dimensionless k b > 0 k_b>0 k b > 0 specifies the passive equilibrium partition m = k b c m=k_bc m = k b c ; it incorporates the standard binding free-energy difference and the fixed layer height. The molar chemical potentials are μ c = δ F / δ c = R T ln ( c / m s ) \mu_c=\delta\mathcal{F}/\delta c=RT\ln(c/m_s) μ c = δ F / δ c = R T ln ( c / m s ) and μ m = δ F / δ m = R T ln [ m / ( k b m s ) ] \mu_m=\delta\mathcal{F}/\delta m=RT\ln[m/(k_bm_s)] μ m = δ F / δ m = R T ln [ m / ( k b m s )] . The free energy is strictly convex for c , m > 0 c,m>0 c , m > 0 . Using the material balances gives
F ˙ = ∫ Σ [ ∑ i = c , m ∇ s μ i ⋅ J i − ( μ c − μ m ) ( r 0 + r F ) ] d A . (98) \dot{\mathcal{F}}=\int_{\Sigma}\left[\sum_{i=c,m}\nabla_s\mu_i\cdot\mathbf{J}_i-(\mu_c-\mu_m)(r_0+r_F)\right]\mathrm{d}A. \tag*{(98)} F ˙ = ∫ Σ [ i = c , m ∑ ∇ s μ i ⋅ J i − ( μ c − μ m ) ( r 0 + r F ) ] d A . (98)
Dissipation and rate selection. Combining the resistances for ideal dilute lateral transport with the reaction dissipation potential φ \varphi φ of Eq. (28) gives the total dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ :
Φ = ∫ Σ [ ∣ J c ∣ 2 2 Λ c + ∣ J m ∣ 2 2 Λ m + ∑ ρ = 0 , F φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) ] d A . (99) \Phi=\int_{\Sigma}\left[\frac{|\mathbf{J}_c|^2}{2\Lambda_c}+\frac{|\mathbf{J}_m|^2}{2\Lambda_m}+\sum_{\rho=0,F}\varphi(r_\rho;\Gamma_\rho)\right]\mathrm{d}A. \tag*{(99)} Φ = ∫ Σ 2 Λ c ∣ J c ∣ 2 + 2 Λ m ∣ J m ∣ 2 + ρ = 0 , F ∑ φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) d A . (99)
where we take the mobility coefficients to be Λ c = D c c / ( R T ) \Lambda_c=D_cc/(RT) Λ c = D c c / ( R T ) and Λ m = D m m / ( R T ) \Lambda_m=D_mm/(RT) Λ m = D m m / ( R T ) , with D c > D m > 0 D_c>D_m>0 D c > D m > 0 being the diffusion coefficients. Each mobility has units mol2 ^2 2 /(J ⋅ s \mathrm{J}\cdot\mathrm{s} J ⋅ s ). With areal reaction rates, φ \varphi φ has power-per-area units. The positive kinetic scales Γ ρ \Gamma_\rho Γ ρ may depend on the state variable fields and fuel controls; all coefficients are held fixed during trial-rate variation.
For a spatially uniform maintained fuel–waste chemical-potential difference Δ μ F = μ F r e s − μ W r e s \Delta\mu_F=\mu_F^{\mathrm{res}}-\mu_W^{\mathrm{res}} Δ μ F = μ F res − μ W res , the chemical input power and the driving contribution to the Rayleighian are
P i n = Δ μ F ∫ Σ r F d A , (100) \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=\Delta\mu_F\int_{\Sigma}r_F\,\mathrm{d}A, \tag*{(100)} P in = Δ μ F ∫ Σ r F d A , (100)
F ˙ − P i n = ∫ Σ [ ∑ i = c , m ∇ s μ i ⋅ J i − A 0 r 0 − A F r F ] d A . (101) \dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}}=\int_{\Sigma}\left[\sum_{i=c,m}\nabla_s\mu_i\cdot\mathbf{J}_i-\mathcal{A}_0r_0-\mathcal{A}_Fr_F\right]\mathrm{d}A. \tag*{(101)} F ˙ − P in = ∫ Σ [ i = c , m ∑ ∇ s μ i ⋅ J i − A 0 r 0 − A F r F ] d A . (101)
where A 0 = μ c − μ m \mathcal{A}_0=\mu_c-\mu_m A 0 = μ c − μ m and A F = μ c − μ m + Δ μ F \mathcal{A}_F=\mu_c-\mu_m+\Delta\mu_F A F = μ c − μ m + Δ μ F . Minimizing the Rayleighian, R = Φ + F ˙ − P i n \mathcal{R}=\Phi+\dot{\mathcal{F}}-\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} R = Φ + F ˙ − P in , at fixed fields and controls gives
J c , ∗ = − D c ∇ s c , J m , ∗ = − D m ∇ s m , (102) \mathbf{J}_{c,*}=-D_c\nabla_s c,\qquad\mathbf{J}_{m,*}=-D_m\nabla_s m, \tag*{(102)} J c , ∗ = − D c ∇ s c , J m , ∗ = − D m ∇ s m , (102)
r ρ , ∗ = Γ ρ sinh A ρ 2 R T , (103) r_{\rho,*}=\Gamma_\rho\sinh\frac{\mathcal{A}_\rho}{2RT}, \tag*{(103)} r ρ , ∗ = Γ ρ sinh 2 R T A ρ , (103)
for ρ = 0 , F \rho=0,F ρ = 0 , F . The reaction law specifies the affinity dependence at each fixed state, but still requires the kinetic scales.
Kinetic specialization and recruitment. To obtain the cooperative-recruitment law at the prescribed fuel bias, choose
Γ 0 = 2 k d [ 1 − θ ( m ) ] k b c m , (104) \Gamma_0 = 2k_d[1-\theta(m)]\sqrt{k_bcm}, \tag*{(104)} Γ 0 = 2 k d [ 1 − θ ( m )] k b c m , (104)
Γ F = 2 k d θ ( m ) e Δ μ F / ( 2 R T ) k b c m . (105) \Gamma_F = 2k_d\theta(m)e^{\Delta\mu_F/(2RT)}\sqrt{k_bcm}. \tag*{(105)} Γ F = 2 k d θ ( m ) e Δ μ F / ( 2 R T ) k b c m . (105)
Here, k d > 0 k_d>0 k d > 0 is a detachment frequency, θ ( m ) = g ( m ) / { k b [ e Δ μ F / ( R T ) − 1 ] } \theta(m)=g(m)/\{k_b[e^{\Delta\mu_F/(RT)}-1]\} θ ( m ) = g ( m ) / { k b [ e Δ μ F / ( R T ) − 1 ]} , and g ( m ) = m 2 / ( m s 2 + m 2 ) g(m)=m^2/(m_s^2+m^2) g ( m ) = m 2 / ( m s 2 + m 2 ) . The sufficient condition Δ μ F > R T ln ( 1 + 1 / k b ) \Delta\mu_F>RT\ln(1+1/k_b) Δ μ F > R T ln ( 1 + 1/ k b ) ensures 0 < θ ( m ) < 1 0<\theta(m)<1 0 < θ ( m ) < 1 for m > 0 m>0 m > 0 . The square-root factors encode ideal reactant and product availability, while g ( m ) g(m) g ( m ) represents saturating cooperative recruitment and θ ( m ) \theta(m) θ ( m ) allocates the kinetic prefactors between passive and fueled channels. This is a composition-dependent specialization of (37) , unlike the constant-prefactor mass-action model of Sec. III. This allocation is a thermodynamically consistent realization of a prescribed constitutive recruitment law, not a prediction of that law from OVP or LDB. Its functional form must not be readjusted when varying the fuel bias of the same mechanism.
Substituting eq:89 into (103) gives
r 0 , ∗ = k d ( 1 − θ ) k b c − k d ( 1 − θ ) m , (106) r_{0,*}=k_d(1-\theta)k_bc-k_d(1-\theta)m, \tag*{(106)} r 0 , ∗ = k d ( 1 − θ ) k b c − k d ( 1 − θ ) m , (106)
r F , ∗ = k d θ k b e Δ μ F / ( R T ) c − k d θ m . (107) r_{F,*}=k_d\theta k_be^{\Delta\mu_F/(RT)}c-k_d\theta m. \tag*{(107)} r F , ∗ = k d θ k b e Δ μ F / ( R T ) c − k d θ m . (107)
The underbraced terms are the mean one-way rates of the specified event model: + + + denotes attachment and − - − detachment. Only the fueled channel changes the fuel and waste counts. At the prescribed bias, the total net attachment rate is r ∗ = r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ = k d { [ k b + g ( m ) ] c − m } r_*=r_{0,*}+r_{F,*}=k_d\{[k_b+g(m)]c-m\} r ∗ = r 0 , ∗ + r F , ∗ = k d {[ k b + g ( m )] c − m } , the dimensional cooperative-recruitment law[38 ] . Together with Eq. (82), this yields
∂ t c = D c Δ s c − r ∗ , (108) \partial_t c=D_c\Delta_s c-r_*, \tag*{(108)} ∂ t c = D c Δ s c − r ∗ , (108)
∂ t m = D m Δ s m + r ∗ , (109) \partial_t m=D_m\Delta_s m+r_*, \tag*{(109)} ∂ t m = D m Δ s m + r ∗ , (109)
where Δ s = ∇ s 2 \Delta_s=\nabla_s^2 Δ s = ∇ s 2 . The same membrane density with a different cytosolic pool therefore has a different attachment rate. The physical free-energy balance F ˙ = P i n − D \dot{\mathcal{F}}=P_{\mathrm{in}}-\mathcal{D} F ˙ = P in − D of (8) holds with
D = ∫ Σ [ ∣ J c , ∗ ∣ 2 Λ c + ∣ J m , ∗ ∣ 2 Λ m + A 0 r 0 , ∗ + A F r F , ∗ ] d A ≥ 0. (110) \mathcal{D}=\int_{\Sigma}\left[\frac{|\mathbf{J}_{c,*}|^2}{\Lambda_c}+\frac{|\mathbf{J}_{m,*}|^2}{\Lambda_m}+A_0r_{0,*}+A_Fr_{F,*}\right]\,dA\ge0. \tag*{(110)} D = ∫ Σ [ Λ c ∣ J c , ∗ ∣ 2 + Λ m ∣ J m , ∗ ∣ 2 + A 0 r 0 , ∗ + A F r F , ∗ ] d A ≥ 0. (110)
Each term is a conjugate force–rate product, although the reaction contribution is generally not twice its dissipation potential. With the fuel bias removed, Δ μ F = 0 \Delta\mu_F=0 Δ μ F = 0 , and the same kinetic allocation θ ( m ) \theta(m) θ ( m ) held fixed, the convex free energy F \mathcal{F} F provides no equilibrium demixing mechanism. Recruitment-driven domains are therefore distinct from condensation caused by attractive interactions.
Composition dynamics without channel labels
Passive and fueled events produce the same attachment or detachment changes in ( c , m ) (c,m) ( c , m ) , so the observed protein-density dynamics do not distinguish their channel identities. The total one-way rates are
r + = r 0 + + r F + = k d [ k b + g ( m ) ] c , (111) r^+=r_0^++r_F^+=k_d[k_b+g(m)]c, \tag*{(111)} r + = r 0 + + r F + = k d [ k b + g ( m )] c , (111)
r − = r 0 − + r F − = k d m . (112) r^-=r_0^-+r_F^-=k_dm. \tag*{(112)} r − = r 0 − + r F − = k d m . (112)
Writing u = Δ μ F / ( R T ) u=\Delta\mu_F/(RT) u = Δ μ F / ( R T ) , the allocation θ u ( m ) = g ( m ) / [ k b ( e u − 1 ) ] \theta_u(m)=g(m)/[k_b(e^u-1)] θ u ( m ) = g ( m ) / [ k b ( e u − 1 )] leaves both total one-way rates independent of u u u , whereas the fueled net rate is
r F , ∗ ( u ) = k d g ( m ) e u c − m / k b e u − 1 . r_{F,*}(u)=k_dg(m)\frac{e^u c-m/k_b}{e^u-1}. r F , ∗ ( u ) = k d g ( m ) e u − 1 e u c − m / k b .
Consequently, the chemical input power P i n ( u ) = R T ∫ Σ r F , ∗ ( u ) d A P_{\mathrm{in}}(u)=RT\int_{\Sigma}r_{F,*}(u)\,dA P in ( u ) = R T ∫ Σ r F , ∗ ( u ) d A generally differs between these realizations. They represent distinct channel-level kinetic models, not changes of fuel bias within a fixed mechanism. For identical initial distributions and transport statistics, the same total one-way rates give the same probability law for ( c , m ) (c,m) ( c , m ) within the specified Markov jump model. Thus, a model without channel labels can predict the retained protein dynamics under maintained conditions without identifying the underlying chemical input power. Determining fuel consumption, or predicting dynamics when the fuel pool itself evolves, requires additional channel-resolved kinetic and reservoir information.
Changing variables without changing physical forces
An invertible change of variables preserves the state information. Transform the densities and their fluxes together:
ϕ = c + m , η = c + d m , (113) \phi=c+m,\qquad\eta=c+dm, \tag*{(113)} ϕ = c + m , η = c + d m , (113)
J ϕ = J c + J m , J η = J c + d J m . (114) \mathbf{J}_{\phi}=\mathbf{J}_c+\mathbf{J}_m,\qquad\mathbf{J}_{\eta}=\mathbf{J}_c+d\mathbf{J}_m. \tag*{(114)} J ϕ = J c + J m , J η = J c + d J m . (114)
Here, d = D m / D c d=D_m/D_c d = D m / D c , ϕ , η \phi,\eta ϕ , η are areal molar densities, not volume fractions, and d < 1 d<1 d < 1 is dimensionless. The inverse fields are c = ( η − d ϕ ) / ( 1 − d ) c=(\eta-d\phi)/(1-d) c = ( η − d ϕ ) / ( 1 − d ) and m = ( ϕ − η ) / ( 1 − d ) m=(\phi-\eta)/(1-d) m = ( ϕ − η ) / ( 1 − d ) , requiring d ϕ < η < ϕ d\phi<\eta<\phi d ϕ < η < ϕ for positive components. The transformed material balances are
∂ t ϕ = − ∇ s ⋅ J ϕ , (115) \partial_t\phi=-\nabla_s\cdot\mathbf{J}_{\phi}, \tag*{(115)} ∂ t ϕ = − ∇ s ⋅ J ϕ , (115)
∂ t η = − ∇ s ⋅ J η − ( 1 − d ) ( r 0 + r F ) . (116) \partial_t\eta=-\nabla_s\cdot\mathbf{J}_{\eta}-(1-d)(r_0+r_F). \tag*{(116)} ∂ t η = − ∇ s ⋅ J η − ( 1 − d ) ( r 0 + r F ) . (116)
The conjugate chemical potentials are μ ϕ = ( μ m − d μ c ) / ( 1 − d ) \mu_{\phi}=(\mu_m-d\mu_c)/(1-d) μ ϕ = ( μ m − d μ c ) / ( 1 − d ) and μ η = ( μ c − μ m ) / ( 1 − d ) \mu_{\eta}=(\mu_c-\mu_m)/(1-d) μ η = ( μ c − μ m ) / ( 1 − d ) ; their transport forces are X a = − ∇ s μ a \mathbf{X}_a=-\nabla_s\mu_a X a = − ∇ s μ a , with a ∈ { ϕ , η } a\in\{\phi,\eta\} a ∈ { ϕ , η } . In particular, $\eta is not μ η \mu_{\eta} μ η . The chain rule preserves the transport power: J c ⋅ X c + J m ⋅ X m = J ϕ ⋅ X ϕ + J η ⋅ X η J_c \cdot X_c + J_m \cdot X_m = J_{\phi} \cdot X_{\phi} + J_{\eta} \cdot X_{\eta} J c ⋅ X c + J m ⋅ X m = J ϕ ⋅ X ϕ + J η ⋅ X η . In the new variables, the same physical Rayleighian is
R = ∫ Σ [ 1 2 ∑ a , b ( L z − 1 ) a b J a ⋅ J b + ∑ a ∇ s μ a ⋅ J a + ∑ ρ = 0 , F φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) − ( 1 − d ) μ η ( r 0 + r F ) − Δ μ F r F ] d A . (117) \mathcal{R} = \int_{\Sigma} \left[\frac{1}{2}\sum_{a,b}(L_z^{-1})_{ab}J_a \cdot J_b + \sum_a \nabla_s\mu_a \cdot J_a + \sum_{\rho=0,F}\varphi(r_{\rho};\Gamma_{\rho}) - (1-d)\mu_{\eta}(r_0+r_F)-\Delta\mu_F r_F\right]\,dA. \tag*{(117)} R = ∫ Σ 2 1 a , b ∑ ( L z − 1 ) ab J a ⋅ J b + a ∑ ∇ s μ a ⋅ J a + ρ = 0 , F ∑ φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) − ( 1 − d ) μ η ( r 0 + r F ) − Δ μ F r F d A . (117)
Here, a , b ∈ { ϕ , η } a,b \in\{\phi,\eta\} a , b ∈ { ϕ , η } label flux coordinates, not chemical species; Γ ρ \Gamma_{\rho} Γ ρ is evaluated at the inverse component fields. The mobility matrix is
L z = ( Λ c + Λ m Λ c + d Λ m Λ c + d Λ m Λ c + d 2 Λ m ) . (118) L_z =
\begin{pmatrix}
\Lambda_c+\Lambda_m & \Lambda_c+d\Lambda_m \\
\Lambda_c+d\Lambda_m & \Lambda_c+d^2\Lambda_m
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(118)} L z = ( Λ c + Λ m Λ c + d Λ m Λ c + d Λ m Λ c + d 2 Λ m ) . (118)
It is positive definite, with det L z = ( 1 − d ) 2 Λ c Λ m > 0 \det L_z=(1-d)^2\Lambda_c\Lambda_m>0 det L z = ( 1 − d ) 2 Λ c Λ m > 0 , and selects J a , ∗ = ∑ b ( L z ) a b X b J_{a,*}=\sum_b(L_z)_{ab}X_b J a , ∗ = ∑ b ( L z ) ab X b . The transport contribution to the physical dissipation in Eq. (110) is
D t r = ∫ Σ ∑ i = c , m ∣ J i , ∗ ∣ 2 Λ i d A = ∫ Σ ∑ a = ϕ , η J a , ∗ ⋅ X a d A ≥ 0. D_{\mathrm{tr}}=\int_{\Sigma}\sum_{i=c,m}\frac{\lvert J_{i,*}\rvert^2}{\Lambda_i}\,dA=\int_{\Sigma}\sum_{a=\phi,\eta}J_{a,*}\cdot X_a\,dA\ge0. D tr = ∫ Σ i = c , m ∑ Λ i ∣ J i , ∗ ∣ 2 d A = ∫ Σ a = ϕ , η ∑ J a , ∗ ⋅ X a d A ≥ 0.
The coordinate change introduces cross coefficients while preserving the physical transport dissipation and chemical input power. Variation and the material balances give
∂ t ϕ = D c Δ s η , (119) \partial_t\phi=D_c\Delta_s\eta, \tag*{(119)} ∂ t ϕ = D c Δ s η , (119)
∂ t η = ( D c + D m ) Δ s η − D m Δ s ϕ − ( 1 − d ) r ∗ ( c , m ) . (120) \partial_t\eta=(D_c+D_m)\Delta_s\eta-D_m\Delta_s\phi-(1-d)r_*(c,m). \tag*{(120)} ∂ t η = ( D c + D m ) Δ s η − D m Δ s ϕ − ( 1 − d ) r ∗ ( c , m ) . (120)
Equation (98a) shows that the instantaneous total-density rate ∂ t ϕ \partial_t\phi ∂ t ϕ also depends on Δ s η \Delta_s\eta Δ s η . Thus, ϕ \phi ϕ alone does not determine its subsequent evolution.
What a density-only equation retains
Equation (98a) still requires η \eta η to determine the total-density rate. To examine what survives its elimination, consider the special Zhou–Frey kinetic law[73 ] ,
r ∗ ( c , m ) = η − η ∗ ( ϕ ) τ ( 1 − d ) , τ > 0. (121) r_*(c,m)=\frac{\eta-\eta_*(\phi)}{\tau(1-d)},\qquad\tau>0. \tag*{(121)} r ∗ ( c , m ) = τ ( 1 − d ) η − η ∗ ( ϕ ) , τ > 0. (121)
Here, η ∗ ( ϕ ) \eta_*(\phi) η ∗ ( ϕ ) is the value of η \eta η at zero net conversion for a given total density ϕ \phi ϕ . Without diffusion, ϕ \phi ϕ is constant and ∂ t η = − [ η − η ∗ ( ϕ ) ] / τ \partial_t\eta=-[\eta-\eta_*(\phi)]/\tau ∂ t η = − [ η − η ∗ ( ϕ )] / τ , so τ \tau τ is the internal relaxation time. This is a separate kinetic assumption from Eq. (90). Near a linearly stable zero-rate state, a smooth reaction rate has this form to first order, with τ − 1 = ∂ c r ∗ − ∂ m r ∗ > 0 \tau^{-1}=\partial_c r_*-\partial_m r_*>0 τ − 1 = ∂ c r ∗ − ∂ m r ∗ > 0 evaluated there. Separate channel rates and their chemical work must be specified to give this benchmark a physical reaction model.
Using the special kinetic law in Eq. (121) , differentiating Eq. (98a) and substituting Eq. (98b) eliminates η \eta η exactly:
τ ∂ t 2 ϕ + [ 1 − τ ( D c + D m ) Δ s ] ∂ t ϕ = D c Δ s η ∗ ( ϕ ) − τ D c D m Δ s 2 ϕ . (122) \tau\partial_t^2\phi+\left[1-\tau(D_c+D_m)\Delta_s\right]\partial_t\phi
=D_c\Delta_s\eta_*(\phi)-\tau D_cD_m\Delta_s^2\phi. \tag*{(122)} τ ∂ t 2 ϕ + [ 1 − τ ( D c + D m ) Δ s ] ∂ t ϕ = D c Δ s η ∗ ( ϕ ) − τ D c D m Δ s 2 ϕ . (122)
No fast-relaxation approximation is used. The eliminated field supplies the required initial rate ∂ t ϕ ( t 0 ) = D c Δ s η ( t 0 ) \partial_t\phi(t_0)=D_c\Delta_s\eta(t_0) ∂ t ϕ ( t 0 ) = D c Δ s η ( t 0 ) ; the initial spatial mean of η \eta η is additionally needed to reconstruct c , m c,m c , m . Thus, writing a single equation does not remove the internal information needed for density evolution. The two additional terms relative to ordinary Cahn–Hilliard dynamics describe internal relaxation and resistance to spatial variations of the density rate; both are fixed by τ \tau τ , D c D_c D c , D m D_m D m .
Formal variational representation and physical information. For a constant reference mobility M > 0 M>0 M > 0 with units m o l 2 / ( J s ) \mathrm{mol}^2/(\mathrm{J\,s}) mol 2 / ( J s ) , choose an effective functional such that
M δ F e f f δ ϕ = D c η ∗ ( ϕ ) − τ D c D m Δ s ϕ . M\frac{\delta\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{eff}}}{\delta\phi}=D_c\eta_*(\phi)-\tau D_cD_m\Delta_s\phi. M δ ϕ δ F eff = D c η ∗ ( ϕ ) − τ D c D m Δ s ϕ .
Together with the auxiliary storage K a u x = τ ∫ Σ ∣ J ϕ ∣ 2 d A / ( 2 M ) K_{\mathrm{aux}}=\tau\int_{\Sigma}\lvert J_{\phi}\rvert^2\,dA/(2M) K aux = τ ∫ Σ ∣ J ϕ ∣ 2 d A / ( 2 M ) and
Φ s = ∫ Σ [ ∣ J ϕ ∣ 2 2 M + β 2 ( ∂ t ϕ ) 2 ] d A , \Phi_s=\int_{\Sigma}\left[\frac{\lvert J_{\phi}\rvert^2}{2M}+\frac{\beta}{2}(\partial_t\phi)^2\right]\,dA, Φ s = ∫ Σ [ 2 M ∣ J ϕ ∣ 2 + 2 β ( ∂ t ϕ ) 2 ] d A ,
with β = τ ( D c + D m ) / M \beta=\tau(D_c+D_m)/M β = τ ( D c + D m ) / M , the scalar R 0 = Φ s + F ˙ e f f + K ˙ a u x \mathcal{R}_0=\Phi_s+\dot{\mathcal{F}}_{\mathrm{eff}}+\dot{K}_{\mathrm{aux}} R 0 = Φ s + F ˙ eff + K ˙ aux reproduces Eq. (122) . Variation is over ∂ t ϕ , J ϕ \partial_t\phi,J_{\phi} ∂ t ϕ , J ϕ subject to ∂ t ϕ + ∇ s ⋅ J ϕ = 0 \partial_t\phi+\nabla_s\cdot J_{\phi}=0 ∂ t ϕ + ∇ s ⋅ J ϕ = 0 , at fixed ϕ \phi ϕ and flux acceleration ∂ t J ϕ \partial_tJ_{\phi} ∂ t J ϕ . This equation-level representation does not identify F e f f \mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{eff}} F eff or K a u x K_{\mathrm{aux}} K aux with the physical energy, or the Rayleighian excess with a fluctuation cost. For example, R q = q R 0 \mathcal{R}_q=q\mathcal{R}_0 R q = q R 0 with constant q > 0 q>0 q > 0 preserves the deterministic minimizer while multiplying the excess and Hessian by q q q ; interpreting that excess with a fixed thermal normalization would add a stochastic assumption. The recruitment model in Sec. V A specifies a physical free energy, chemical work, and reaction event rates. A corresponding identification for Eq. (121) requires its own compatible channel model.
Discussion and conclusions
We have used OVP to construct coupled reaction–transport models and identify the distinct inputs required for deterministic dynamics, fluctuations, and chemical input power. The physical Rayleighian combines the retained free energy F \mathcal{F} F , input power P i n \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{in}} P in , and dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ . The statistical interpretation requires a specified stochastic mechanism and its matching to these physical constitutive inputs. For the constant-coefficient Gaussian model, matching is expressed by the Einstein relation D = k B T L \mathbf{D}=k_{\mathrm{B}}T\mathbf{L} D = k B T L . For Poisson reactions, φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) \varphi(r_{\rho};\Gamma_{\rho}) φ ( r ρ ; Γ ρ ) matches the rate-reversal-even part of the counting cost ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) \ell_{\rho}(r_{\rho}) ℓ ρ ( r ρ ) , while channelwise local detailed balance (LDB) identifies the statistical bias with the physical affinity by A ρ = R T ν ρ \mathcal{A}_{\rho}=RT\nu_{\rho} A ρ = R T ν ρ . For the latter, Eq. (39) identifies ( R − R min ) / ( 2 k B T ) (\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min})/(2k_{\mathrm{B}}T) ( R − R m i n ) / ( 2 k B T ) as the local reaction-rate fluctuation cost per unit time in the frozen-state, many-event regime. This is a leading-exponential probability relation, not an exact normalized finite-count transition density. The construction builds on established nonlinear variational and reaction-fluctuation structures[10 , 13 , 14 , 22 ] . For the same convex dissipation potential and its conjugate, the Gyarmati-type functional and the Rayleighian excess differ only by a sign, as shown in Eq. (39). Conditional local equilibrium (LE) permits retained thermodynamics; LDB identifies the statistical bias ϑ ρ \vartheta_{\rho} ϑ ρ with the channel affinity A ρ A_{\rho} A ρ ; and the kinetic scales Γ ρ \Gamma_{\rho} Γ ρ supply the additional input needed to determine the mean one-way rates r ρ ± r_{\rho}^{\pm} r ρ ± . The quadratic Onsager form is recovered near equilibrium, while the law of mass action requires the corresponding concentration or activity dependence of these scales.
The examples separate complementary questions. In Sec. III, a net-affinity response can be nonreciprocal under specified chemical-potential controls even though a convex dissipation potential Φ \Phi Φ exists at each state. Changing composition changes both the affinities and kinetic scales, whereas OVP varies trial rates at a fixed state. Lengyel-type partial-affinity symmetries concern different derivatives and do not establish universal nonlinear reciprocity. At a fixed state, the Poisson and logarithmic-mean Gaussian models select the same rate r ∗ r_{\ast} r ∗ but have different fluctuation costs ℓ P \ell_{P} ℓ P and ℓ G \ell_{G} ℓ G . The local Gaussian cost ℓ l o c \ell_{\mathrm{loc}} ℓ loc approximates ℓ P \ell_{P} ℓ P near r ∗ r_{\ast} r ∗ . The inverse-log potential φ I \varphi_{I} φ I also selects r ∗ r_{\ast} r ∗ , but its Rayleighian excess Δ R I \Delta R_{I} Δ R I is not identified with a fluctuation cost.
Section IV couples nonideal thermodynamics to resolved reaction and transport. For the parameters studied, a chemically maintained dense domain dissolves after external replenishment stops through conversion and redistribution, without changing the interactions. Retaining the finite fuel pool identifies P i n P_{\mathrm{in}} P in as the free-energy transfer rate between pool and mixture, which can briefly reverse while F ˙ + F ˙ R = − D ≤ 0 \dot{F}+\dot{F}_{R}=-D\leq0 F ˙ + F ˙ R = − D ≤ 0 . Thus, chemical input power and dissipation remain distinct even during rapid domain dissolution.
Section V distinguishes reaction-channel resolution from state-variable reduction. Different passive/fueled channel realizations can have the same total attachment and detachment rates r ± r^{\pm} r ± and, with identical transport statistics and initial distributions, the same trajectory probability law for ( c , m ) (c,m) ( c , m ) , but different chemical input power P i n P_{\mathrm{in}} P in . An invertible change of fields and fluxes preserves the physical Rayleighian R R R . In contrast, the density-only equation for ϕ = c + m \phi=c+m ϕ = c + m , obtained using the special kinetic law in Eq. (121) , requires the initial rate ∂ t ϕ ( t 0 ) \partial_{t}\phi(t_{0}) ∂ t ϕ ( t 0 ) ; reconstructing c , m c,m c , m also requires the initial spatial mean of η \eta η . Thus, fewer explicit fields do not necessarily mean less dynamical information, and an equation-level variational representation does not by itself identify chemical input power or fluctuations.
For the resolved isothermal macroscopic reaction model, D = T S ˙ p r o d m a c \mathcal{D}=T\dot{S}_{\mathrm{prod}}^{\mathrm{mac}} D = T S ˙ prod mac , but it is not generally a heat current. Heat flows into individual reservoirs require the corresponding internal-energy, entropy, and matter-exchange information[40 , 50 , 63 ] . Neither a mean rate nor a trajectory probability law without reaction-channel labels supplies all these physical inputs.
Appendix A relates reaction-event fluctuations to equilibrium and higher-order response. State-dependent event rates naturally produce multiplicative noise, but their chemical Langevin approximation need not preserve the full Poisson cost or its thermodynamic matching (Appendix B). Additional active fluctuations can leave an independently justified deterministic Rayleighian valid while changing the total fluctuation cost (Appendix C). Conversely, chemical driving does not itself violate LDB. These distinctions depend on the resolved mechanisms, not simply on whether increments are Gaussian or Poisson.
OVP provides a systematic framework for constructing and approximating coupled reaction–transport dynamics from specified thermodynamic and kinetic inputs, while consistently incorporating material constraints and power balances. For resolved reaction channels with independent Poisson event drivers, the dissipation potentials are additive, although the channels remain coupled through shared states and material balances. Identifying the Rayleighian excess with a fluctuation cost additionally requires statistical and thermodynamic matching, whereas chemical input power requires channel-resolved work information. Restricting admissible trial fields before variation provides a variational approximation method[17 , 18 ] , whereas eliminating state variables requires dynamical closure or retention of the relevant memory and initial data. The common passive/fueled reaction topology of our examples therefore does not uniquely fix the kinetics: constant-coefficient mass action, composition-selective fuel coupling, and cooperative recruitment are distinct kinetic constitutive inputs that can affect driven steady states and chemical power, not merely relaxation times.
These structures also suggest computational developments. Deep Ritz methods use neural-network trial functions for variational problems, including active elastic solids[74 , 75 ] , while the deep Onsager–Machlup method (DOMM) applies neural trial trajectories to soft-matter dynamics[76 ] . Statistical and covariant Onsager–Machlup formulations and neural optimization of active-particle paths provide complementary developments[62 , 77 , 78 ] . Extending DOMM to the nonquadratic reaction action of Eq. (42) would require admissible trial trajectories that respect material balances, resolved channels, and chemical work. Its development and validation remain future work. A further goal is to constrain physical models jointly by reaction counts, mechanical response, and chemical input power, and to determine which physical information survives reduction to effective active-field theories of phase separation[79 , 80 ] [81]. In particular, such reductions should distinguish irreversibility observed at the coarse-grained field level from the physical energetic cost of the underlying reservoir coupling[82 , 83 ] .
Acknowledgements
We dedicate this work to the memory of Rudolf Podgornik, in recognition of his contributions to statistical physics, soft matter physics, and biological physics. We acknowledge unpublished notes by Rudolf Podgornik, brought to our attention by B. Zheng, concerning reaction dissipation. X.X. thanks Tiezheng Qian and Ping Sheng for their longstanding support and mentorship, and Masao Doi and Christoph A. Weber for valuable and insightful discussions. X.X. also thanks the organizers of the 2026 International Workshop on Soft Matter and Biophysics Theories at the Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, for their invitation and hospitality. Discussions with Erwin Frey and Daniel Zhou, together with the stimulating talks at the workshop, helped shape this work. For X.X., these occasions reaffirm the enduring value of honoring scientists’ legacies and exchanging ideas in person, even in the age of artificial intelligence. X.X. acknowledges support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC, No. 12374209 and No. 12131010). S.K. acknowledges support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 12274098) and from the Zhejiang Key Laboratory of Soft Matter Biomedical Materials (2025ZY01036 and 2025E10072). This work was supported by the JSPS Core-to-Core Program “Advanced core-to-core network for the physics of self-organizing active matter" (JPJSCCA20230002).
Declaration of generative AI use
X.X. used ChatGPT (GPT-6 Pro; OpenAI) for assistance with analytical derivations and consistency checks, numerical-code development, literature search and synthesis, and language editing. The tool supported exploration of mathematical formulations, implementation of the numerical model, and preparation of the paper. It also generated an initial draft of the schematic in Figure 1 , which the authors substantially revised.
The authors reviewed and corrected all AI-assisted material included in this paper. Derivations were checked against the stated assumptions, numerical implementations and results against the governing equations, and references and literature-based statements against the cited sources. The reported quantitative results were obtained by explicit analytical evaluation or numerical computation of the stated models. The authors made the final scientific judgments and take full responsibility for the scientific content, source attribution, and conclusions.
Author declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors have no conflicts to disclose.
Author contributions
Xinpeng Xu: Conceptualization; Methodology; Formal analysis; Investigation; Software; Validation; Visualization; Writing – original draft; Writing – review & editing. Changhao Li, Zhongqiang Xiong, Bin Zheng, Kento Yasuda, and Shigeyuki Komura: Conceptualization; Writing – review & editing. The research ideas and physical interpretations were refined through extensive discussions among all authors, who approved the final manuscript.
Data availability
The numerical data and code supporting the findings of this study, including the initial profiles, model parameters, and plotting scripts, are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Fluctuation constraints on nonlinear response
We examine selected rates as functions of independent conjugate forces, using the same force-control protocol for all derivatives. For time-reversal-even chemical progress coordinates near equilibrium, X = 0 \mathbf{X} = 0 X = 0 , write
α ˙ i , ∗ = ∑ j L i j X j + 1 2 ∑ j k M i j k X j X k + O ( ∣ X ∣ 3 ) . (123) \dot{\alpha}_{i,*} = \sum_j L_{ij}X_j + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{jk}M_{ijk}X_jX_k + O(|\mathbf{X}|^3). \tag*{(123)} α ˙ i , ∗ = j ∑ L ij X j + 2 1 j k ∑ M ij k X j X k + O ( ∣ X ∣ 3 ) . (123)
Here, L i j = ( ∂ X j α ˙ i , ∗ ) 0 L_{ij}=(\partial_{X_j}\dot{\alpha}_{i,*})_0 L ij = ( ∂ X j α ˙ i , ∗ ) 0 and M i j k = ( ∂ X j ∂ X k α ˙ i , ∗ ) 0 M_{ijk}=(\partial_{X_j}\partial_{X_k}\dot{\alpha}_{i,*})_0 M ij k = ( ∂ X j ∂ X k α ˙ i , ∗ ) 0 , with other independent controls fixed and 0 0 0 denoting equilibrium. Commuting force derivatives gives M i j k = M i k j M_{ijk}=M_{ikj} M ij k = M ik j , but does not exchange the output index i i i with a force index.
Use the frozen Poisson channels of Sec. IIC in fixed volume V V V , with mean one-way molar rate densities r ρ ± r_\rho^\pm r ρ ± . Let δ ρ α \delta_\rho\alpha δ ρ α be the fixed change in one forward event. The retained coordinates and forces must resolve every channel affinity: X ⋅ δ ρ α = X / N A \mathbf{X}\cdot\delta_\rho\boldsymbol{\alpha}=\mathbf{X}/N_A X ⋅ δ ρ α = X / N A . Over Δ t \Delta t Δ t , the total increment is Δ α = ∑ ρ δ ρ α ( Δ N ρ + − Δ N ρ − ) \Delta\boldsymbol{\alpha}=\sum_\rho\delta_\rho\boldsymbol{\alpha}(\Delta N_\rho^+-\Delta N_\rho^-) Δ α = ∑ ρ δ ρ α ( Δ N ρ + − Δ N ρ − ) , where the independent Poisson counts have means N A V r ρ ± Δ t N_A V r_\rho^\pm\Delta t N A V r ρ ± Δ t . Exchanging every forward and reverse count and using LDB gives
P X ( Δ α ) P X ( − Δ α ) = exp ( X ⋅ Δ α k B T ) . (124) \frac{P_{\mathbf{X}}(\Delta\boldsymbol{\alpha})}{P_{\mathbf{X}}(-\Delta\boldsymbol{\alpha})}=\exp\left(\frac{\mathbf{X}\cdot\Delta\boldsymbol{\alpha}}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}\right). \tag*{(124)} P X ( − Δ α ) P X ( Δ α ) = exp ( k B T X ⋅ Δ α ) . (124)
Here, P X P_{\mathbf{X}} P X is the increment probability at the controlled forces. All count allocations with the same increment have the same ratio, so the relation survives summation over them. It is exact for the frozen counting process; application to an evolving composition uses the frozen-state approximation.
The selected mean rate is α ˙ i , ∗ = ⟨ Δ α i ⟩ X / Δ t \dot{\alpha}_{i,*}=\langle\Delta\alpha_i\rangle_{\mathbf{X}}/\Delta t α ˙ i , ∗ = ⟨ Δ α i ⟩ X /Δ t . Define the increment covariance per unit time by C i j ( X ) = Cov X ( Δ α i , Δ α j ) / Δ t C_{ij}(\mathbf{X})=\operatorname{Cov}_{\mathbf{X}}(\Delta\alpha_i,\Delta\alpha_j)/\Delta t C ij ( X ) = Cov X ( Δ α i , Δ α j ) /Δ t and then
C i j ( X ) = N A V ∑ ρ ( δ ρ α i ) ( δ ρ α j ) σ ρ , (125) C_{ij}(\mathbf{X})=N_A V\sum_\rho(\delta_\rho\alpha_i)(\delta_\rho\alpha_j)\sigma_\rho, \tag*{(125)} C ij ( X ) = N A V ρ ∑ ( δ ρ α i ) ( δ ρ α j ) σ ρ , (125)
where σ ρ = r ρ + + r ρ − \sigma_\rho= r_\rho^{+} + r_\rho^{-} σ ρ = r ρ + + r ρ − , and averages are over the frozen counting law. (125) follows from independent Poisson variances and includes cross-correlations from shared events. Changing the summation variable Δ α → − Δ α \Delta\alpha\to-\Delta\alpha Δ α → − Δ α in (124) gives
2 ⟨ Δ α i ⟩ X = ⟨ Δ α i [ 1 − e − X ⋅ Δ α / ( k B T ) ] ⟩ X . (126) 2\langle\Delta\alpha_i\rangle_{\mathbf{X}}=\left\langle\Delta\alpha_i\left[1-e^{-\mathbf{X}\cdot\Delta\alpha/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T)}\right]\right\rangle_{\mathbf{X}}. \tag*{(126)} 2 ⟨ Δ α i ⟩ X = ⟨ Δ α i [ 1 − e − X ⋅ Δ α / ( k B T ) ] ⟩ X . (126)
At zero force, odd increment moments vanish. Expanding to second order in X \mathbf{X} X , the third moment therefore contributes only at higher order. Products of mean increments are O ( ∣ X ∣ 2 ) O(|X|^2) O ( ∣ X ∣ 2 ) , so raw second moments and covariances have the same value and first force derivative at equilibrium. Comparison with (123) yields
L i j = C i j ( 0 ) 2 k B T , L_{ij}=\frac{C_{ij}(0)}{2k_{\mathrm{B}}T}, L ij = 2 k B T C ij ( 0 ) ,
M i j k = [ ∂ X k C i j + ∂ X j C i k ] 0 2 k B T , M_{ijk}=\frac{\left[\partial_{X_k}C_{ij}+\partial_{X_j}C_{ik}\right]_0}{2k_{\mathrm{B}}T}, M ij k = 2 k B T [ ∂ X k C ij + ∂ X j C ik ] 0 ,
M i j k − M j i k = [ ∂ X j C i k − ∂ X i C j k ] 0 2 k B T . (127) M_{ijk}-M_{jik}=\frac{\left[\partial_{X_j}C_{ik}-\partial_{X_i}C_{jk}\right]_0}{2k_{\mathrm{B}}T}. \tag*{(127)} M ij k − M j ik = 2 k B T [ ∂ X j C ik − ∂ X i C j k ] 0 . (127)
Thus equilibrium fluctuations give L i j = L j i L_{ij}=L_{ji} L ij = L j i , whereas their force dependence constrains, but does not generally symmetrize, second-order response.[84 , 85 ] In particular,
∂ α ˙ i , ∗ ∂ X j − ∂ α ˙ j , ∗ ∂ X i = ∑ k ( M i j k − M j i k ) X k + O ( ∣ X ∣ 2 ) . (128) \frac{\partial\dot{\alpha}_{i,*}}{\partial X_j}-\frac{\partial\dot{\alpha}_{j,*}}{\partial X_i}=\sum_k(M_{ijk}-M_{jik})X_k+O(|X|^2). \tag*{(128)} ∂ X j ∂ α ˙ i , ∗ − ∂ X i ∂ α ˙ j , ∗ = k ∑ ( M ij k − M j ik ) X k + O ( ∣ X ∣ 2 ) . (128)
These response derivatives compare controlled states; they are not trial-rate derivatives within one fixed-state Rayleighian.
For a single molar reaction extent α \alpha α , each event changes α \alpha α by ± 1 / N A \pm1/N_{\mathrm{A}} ± 1/ N A , so C = V σ / N A C=V\sigma/N_{\mathrm{A}} C = V σ / N A . At equilibrium, σ = Γ e q \sigma=\Gamma_{\mathrm{eq}} σ = Γ eq and L = V Γ e q / ( 2 R T ) L=V\Gamma_{\mathrm{eq}}/(2RT) L = V Γ eq / ( 2 R T ) , giving the local increment diffusion coefficient D e q ≡ C ( 0 ) / 2 = k B T L D_{\mathrm{eq}}\equiv C(0)/2=k_{\mathrm{B}}TL D eq ≡ C ( 0 ) /2 = k B T L . This equilibrium Einstein relation requires neither Gaussian increments nor large counts; it is not a long-time diffusivity of bounded composition.
State-dependent mobility and stochastic matching
Thermal diffusion
Using the retained coordinates and forces of Sec. II A, consider the Itô model
d α = α ˙ I ( α , t ) d t + 2 B ( α , t ) d W . (129) d\alpha=\dot{\alpha}_{I}(\alpha,t)\,dt+\sqrt{2B(\alpha,t)}\,d\mathbf{W}. \tag*{(129)} d α = α ˙ I ( α , t ) d t + 2 B ( α , t ) d W . (129)
Here, W \mathbf{W} W contains independent standard Wiener processes, D = B B T D=BB^{\mathsf{T}} D = B B T is positive definite, and α ˙ I \dot{\alpha}_{I} α ˙ I is the conditional mean increment per time. The frozen Gaussian cost is (5) with L X L\mathbf{X} L X replaced by α ˙ I \dot{\alpha}_{I} α ˙ I .
Let p ( α , t ) p(\alpha,t) p ( α , t ) be the probability density relative to flat coordinate volume and j \mathbf{j} j its probability flux, with ∂ t p = − ∑ i ∂ α i j i \partial_t p=-\sum_i\partial_{\alpha_i}j_i ∂ t p = − ∑ i ∂ α i j i . The Itô model gives
j i = ( α ˙ I , i − ∑ j ∂ α j D i j ) p − ∑ j D i j ∂ α j p . j_i=\left(\dot{\alpha}_{I,i}-\sum_j\partial_{\alpha_j}D_{ij}\right)p-\sum_jD_{ij}\partial_{\alpha_j}p. j i = ( α ˙ I , i − j ∑ ∂ α j D ij ) p − j ∑ D ij ∂ α j p .
For symmetric positive-definite L L L , a uniform bath at temperature T T T , and no additional reversible current, the thermal flux is j i = ∑ j L i j ( X j p − k B T ∂ α j p ) j_i=\sum_jL_{ij}(X_jp-k_{\mathrm{B}}T\partial_{\alpha_j}p) j i = ∑ j L ij ( X j p − k B T ∂ α j p ) . Comparing coefficients gives[43 ]
D i j = k B T L i j , D_{ij}=k_{\mathrm{B}}TL_{ij}, D ij = k B T L ij ,
α ˙ i , ∗ = ∑ j L i j X j , \dot{\alpha}_{i,*}=\sum_jL_{ij}X_j, α ˙ i , ∗ = j ∑ L ij X j ,
α ˙ I , i = α ˙ i , ∗ + ∑ j ∂ α j D i j . (130) \dot{\alpha}_{I,i}=\dot{\alpha}_{i,*}+\sum_j\partial_{\alpha_j}D_{ij}. \tag*{(130)} α ˙ I , i = α ˙ i , ∗ + j ∑ ∂ α j D ij . (130)
Einstein matching fixes the quadratic curvature, but a nonzero noise-induced drift ∇ α ⋅ D \nabla_\alpha\cdot D ∇ α ⋅ D separates the minimizer α ˙ I \dot{\alpha}_{I} α ˙ I of the frozen Gaussian increment cost from the minimizing rate α ˙ ∗ \dot{\alpha}_{*} α ˙ ∗ of the physical Rayleighian. The matching in (9) for all trial rates additionally requires ∑ j ∂ α j D i j = 0 \sum_j\partial_{\alpha_j}D_{ij}=0 ∑ j ∂ α j D ij = 0 for every i i i at that state.
Chemical events and their diffusion approximation. For a closed A ⇄ B A\rightleftarrows B A ⇄ B reactor of fixed volume V V V , write c = c B c=c_B c = c B and c A = c t o t − c c_A=c_{\mathrm{tot}}-c c A = c tot − c , where c t o t c_{\mathrm{tot}} c tot is the conserved total molar concentration. Let r ± ( c ) r^{\pm}(c) r ± ( c ) be the mean one-way molar rate densities. During a frozen step Δ t \Delta t Δ t , independent Poisson counts Δ N ± \Delta N^{\pm} Δ N ± have means N A V r ± Δ t N_{\mathrm{A}}Vr^{\pm}\Delta t N A V r ± Δ t , and Δ c = ( Δ N + − Δ N − ) / ( N A V ) \Delta c=(\Delta N^{+}-\Delta N^{-})/(N_{\mathrm{A}}V) Δ c = ( Δ N + − Δ N − ) / ( N A V ) . Their moments are therefore
⟨ Δ c ⟩ = ( r + − r − ) Δ t , \langle\Delta c\rangle=(r^{+}-r^{-})\Delta t, ⟨ Δ c ⟩ = ( r + − r − ) Δ t ,
Var ( Δ c ) = r + + r − N A V Δ t . \operatorname{Var}(\Delta c)=\frac{r^{+}+r^{-}}{N_{\mathrm{A}}V}\Delta t. Var ( Δ c ) = N A V r + + r − Δ t .
When the rates vary little during the step and the relevant counts are numerous, their Gaussian approximation gives the Itô chemical Langevin equation[51 ]
d c = r ∗ ( c ) d t + 2 D c ( c ) d W t . (131) dc=r_{*}(c)\,dt+\sqrt{2D_c(c)}\,dW_t. \tag*{(131)} d c = r ∗ ( c ) d t + 2 D c ( c ) d W t . (131)
Here, r ∗ = r + − r − r_{*}=r^{+}-r^{-} r ∗ = r + − r − , D c = σ / ( 2 N A V ) D_c=\sigma/(2N_{\mathrm{A}}V) D c = σ / ( 2 N A V ) , σ = r + + r − \sigma=r^{+}+r^{-} σ = r + + r − . W t W_t W t is a standard Wiener process and D c D_c D c has units of concentration squared per time. This diffusion occurs in composition space. Its drift and covariance follow from the difference and sum of the mean one-way rates r ± r^{\pm} r ± ; no separate Brownian bath is introduced. The first jump moment fixes c ˙ I = r ∗ \dot{c}_I=r_{*} c ˙ I = r ∗ , so adding ∂ c D c \partial_cD_c ∂ c D c would change this approximation.
Thermodynamic matching remains a separate step. With A = R T ln ( r + / r − ) A=RT\ln(r^{+}/r^{-}) A = R T ln ( r + / r − ) and Γ = 2 r + r − \Gamma=2\sqrt{r^{+}r^{-}} Γ = 2 r + r − , the physical Poisson Rayleighian R P = V [ φ ( ⋅ ; r ) − A r ] \mathcal{R}_P=V[\varphi(\cdot;r)-Ar] R P = V [ φ ( ⋅ ; r ) − A r ] satisfies
∂ 2 R P ∂ r 2 ∣ r ∗ = 2 R T V r ∗ 2 + Γ 2 = 2 R T V σ . \left.\frac{\partial^2\mathcal{R}_P}{\partial r^2}\right|_{r_*}=\frac{2RTV}{\sqrt{r_*^2+\Gamma^2}}=\frac{2RTV}{\sigma}. ∂ r 2 ∂ 2 R P r ∗ = r ∗ 2 + Γ 2 2 R T V = σ 2 R T V .
The derivatives hold the state and controls fixed. Consequently, its local quadratic excess gives
R P − R P , min 2 k B T ≃ ( c ˙ − r ∗ ) 2 4 D c = N A V ℓ l o c ( c ˙ ) , \frac{\mathcal{R}_P-\mathcal{R}_{P,\min}}{2k_{\mathrm{B}}T}\simeq\frac{(\dot{c}-r_*)^2}{4D_c}=N_{\mathrm{A}}V\ell_{\mathrm{loc}}(\dot{c}), 2 k B T R P − R P , m i n ≃ 4 D c ( c ˙ − r ∗ ) 2 = N A V ℓ loc ( c ˙ ) ,
where the trial reaction rate is r = c ˙ r=\dot{c} r = c ˙ and ℓ l o c \ell_{\mathrm{loc}} ℓ loc is defined in (68) . Thus the event-based Rayleighian reproduces the central chemical fluctuations at the bath temperature. The diffusion approximation does not retain the full Poisson tails or automatically inherit all finite-affinity stochastic thermodynamics[64 ] . For multiple resolved channels, their contributions add to both the drift and covariance; a fueled channel is not generally an additional noise source with zero mean conversion.
Additional noise and the limits of physical matching
Experimental motivation and stochastic model. Active fluctuations can be enhanced without a comparable change in viscous response. In dilute suspensions of motile E. coli , Chen et al. observed enhanced tracer fluctuations while independent optical-tweezer measurements found approximately unchanged viscosity[86 ] . This motivates a reduced description with additional fluctuations but unchanged mobility, although such a separation is not universal. Moreover, bacterial-bath experiments show that approximately instantaneous friction can coexist with temporally correlated active fluctuations[87 ] . A white Gaussian approximation therefore requires a further timescale separation τ a ≪ Δ t ≪ τ s l o w \tau_a \ll\Delta t \ll\tau_{\mathrm{slow}} τ a ≪ Δ t ≪ τ slow , where τ a \tau_a τ a is the active-force correlation time, Δ t \Delta t Δ t the observation interval, and τ s l o w \tau_{\mathrm{slow}} τ slow the characteristic timescale of the retained dynamics. The accumulated active forcing must also be approximately Gaussian.
Under these assumptions, consider the retained state α \alpha α , physical force X X X , and constant symmetric positive-definite mobility L L L of Sec. II A. Suppose an additional mechanism produces independent fluctuations without changing the prescribed conditional drift L X LX L X or mobility:
d α = L X d t + 2 B t h d W t h + 2 B a d W a , (132) \mathrm{d}\alpha= LX\,\mathrm{d}t + \sqrt{2}B_{\mathrm{th}}\,\mathrm{d}W_{\mathrm{th}} + \sqrt{2}B_a\,\mathrm{d}W_a, \tag*{(132)} d α = L X d t + 2 B th d W th + 2 B a d W a , (132)
D t o t = k B T L + D a , D a = B a B a T . (133) D_{\mathrm{tot}} = k_{\mathrm{B}}TL + D_a,\qquad D_a = B_a B_a^{\mathsf{T}}. \tag*{(133)} D tot = k B T L + D a , D a = B a B a T . (133)
Here, W t h , W a W_{\mathrm{th}},W_a W th , W a are independent standard Wiener processes, the noise amplitudes are constant, and B t h B t h T = k B T L B_{\mathrm{th}}B_{\mathrm{th}}^{\mathsf{T}}=k_{\mathrm{B}}TL B th B th T = k B T L describes the thermal contribution. The additional noise is not assumed to originate from an equilibrium bath. Externally imposed random forces provide one realization[88 ] ; eliminating a coupled nonequilibrium environment generally requires its response and fluctuations to be determined together[89 ] . Thus, unchanged drift and mobility are modeling assumptions, not consequences of Gaussian statistics.
The additional noise represents unresolved forcing, not an identified chemical reaction channel. As shown in Appendix B, resolved Poisson reaction events generally contribute to both drift and covariance. Their counting fluctuations must not be counted again as independent active noise.
Fluctuation cost and effective temperature. For a frozen time step, define δ α = α ˙ − L X \delta\alpha=\dot{\alpha}-LX δ α = α ˙ − L X , where α ˙ \dot{\alpha} α ˙ is a trial rate. The Gaussian rate cost and the physical Rayleighian excess are
L t o t = 1 4 δ α ˙ T D t o t − 1 δ α ˙ , (134) \mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{tot}} = \frac{1}{4}\delta\dot{\alpha}^{\mathsf{T}}D_{\mathrm{tot}}^{-1}\delta\dot{\alpha}, \tag*{(134)} L tot = 4 1 δ α ˙ T D tot − 1 δ α ˙ , (134)
R − R min = 1 2 δ α ˙ T L − 1 δ α ˙ . (135) \mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min} = \frac{1}{2}\delta\dot{\alpha}^{\mathsf{T}}L^{-1}\delta\dot{\alpha}. \tag*{(135)} R − R m i n = 2 1 δ α ˙ T L − 1 δ α ˙ . (135)
Their minimizers coincide, but matching at the physical bath temperature fails for nonzero D a D_a D a . Define T e f f > 0 T_{\mathrm{eff}}>0 T eff > 0 only as a possible scalar rescaling of the Gaussian rate cost. Comparing the quadratic forms gives
L t o t = R − R min 2 k B T e f f for all independent trial rates ⟺ D t o t = k B T e f f L . (136) \mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{tot}} = \frac{\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{R}_{\min}}{2k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{eff}}}\quad\text{for all independent trial rates}
\qquad\Longleftrightarrow\qquad
D_{\mathrm{tot}}=k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{eff}}L. \tag*{(136)} L tot = 2 k B T eff R − R m i n for all independent trial rates ⟺ D tot = k B T eff L . (136)
For one coordinate with constant coefficients, this ratio always exists: T e f f = D t o t / ( k B L ) T_{\mathrm{eff}}=D_{\mathrm{tot}}/(k_{\mathrm{B}}L) T eff = D tot / ( k B L ) . For multiple coordinates, however, all independent directions must share the same ratio: proportional anisotropic tensors qualify, whereas unequal directional ratios do not. With state-dependent coefficients, a global constant T e f f T_{\mathrm{eff}} T eff additionally requires the same ratio through the considered state space and consistent drift centers, as discussed in Appendix B. Scalar rescaling cannot correct a drift mismatch or reproduce general colored or non-Gaussian fluctuations.
Comparison with chemical reaction fluctuations. The distinction can be illustrated without postulating additional reaction noise. For the concentration coordinate of (131) , Poisson counting gives D c = σ / ( 2 N A V ) D_c=\sigma/(2N_A V) D c = σ / ( 2 N A V ) , where σ = r + + r − \sigma=r^+ + r^- σ = r + + r − is the total one-way rate density. The logarithmic-mean quadratic model of Sec. III C instead uses X = V A X=V\mathcal{A} X = V A and L = L log / V L=L_{\log}/V L = L l o g / V , with L log = r ∗ / A L_{\log}=r_*/\mathcal{A} L l o g = r ∗ / A understood by continuity at A = 0 \mathcal{A}=0 A = 0 . Applying (136) to match the quadratic Rayleighian R log \mathcal{R}_{\log} R l o g to the local Poisson cost ℓ log \ell_{\log} ℓ l o g gives
T e f f T = σ 2 R T L log = A 2 R T coth ( A 2 R T ) , (137) \frac{T_{\mathrm{eff}}}{T}=\frac{\sigma}{2RT L_{\log}}=\frac{\mathcal{A}}{2RT}\coth\left(\frac{\mathcal{A}}{2RT}\right), \tag*{(137)} T T eff = 2 R T L l o g σ = 2 R T A coth ( 2 R T A ) , (137)
with limiting value 1 1 1 at A = 0 \mathcal{A}=0 A = 0 . This state-dependent rescaling matches the local quadratic counting cost, but neither changes the bath temperature nor recovers the non-Gaussian Poisson tails. By contrast, the nonquadratic Poisson Rayleighian gives the matched reaction-rate cost at the physical temperature T T T under the assumptions of Sec. II C.
Thus, even when an effective temperature reproduces a specified Gaussian rate cost, it does not identify the work or heat exchanged by unresolved mechanisms. More generally, a deterministic Rayleighian determines neither fluctuation probabilities nor an Onsager–Machlup path weight without the corresponding stochastic model and physical thermodynamic matching.