betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Perturbative QCD reveals the softening of matter in the cores of massive neutron stars

Abstract

The cores of neutron stars (NSs) contain the densest matter in the universe. Rapid advancements in neutron-star observations allow unprecedented empirical access to cold, ultra-dense Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) matter. The combination of these observations with theoretical calculations has revealed previously inaccessible features of the equation of state (EoS) and the QCD phase diagram. In this thesis, I demonstrate how perturbative-QCD calculations at asymptotically high baryon densities provide robust constraints on the EoS at neutron-star densities. The method for constraint propagation is based solely on thermodynamical causality, stability, and consistency of the EoS. By constructing a large ensemble of EoSs using Gaussian processes regression and incorporating it into a Bayesian inference of EoS, I demonstrate that the novel pQCD constraints go beyond those obtained from current astrophysical observations alone, forcing the EoS to soften at the maximum densities of stable neutron stars. This softening of the EoS can be interpreted as an indication of approximate conformal symmetry restoration, a sign of a first-order phase transition (FOPT), or potentially both. I show that the conformal symmetry restoration is consistent with the hypothesis of quark matter cores inside the most massive NSs. Although current astrophysical data and theoretical inputs cannot definitively distinguish between the two scenarios, they slightly favor the occurrence of a phase transition of some kind - whether a crossover to quark matter or a destabilizing FOPT - in the cores of the most massive neutron stars.

OLEG KOMOLTSEV FACULTY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

PhD: Thesis UiS No. 851

Image not extracted

Figure 1.

Speed of sound cs2c_{\mathrm{s}}^2

Density n/nsatn/n_{\mathrm{sat}}

Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of PHILOSOPHIAE DOCTOR (PhD)

University of Stavanger NO-4036 Stavanger NORWAY www.uis.no

©2025 Oleg Komoltsev

ISBN: 978-82-8439-357-5 ISSN: 1890-1387 PhD: Thesis UiS No. 851

Preface

This thesis is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Philosophiae Doctor (PhD) at the University of Stavanger, Faculty of Science and Technology, Norway. The research has been carried out at the University of Stavanger from April 2021 to March 2025.

I would like to express my deepest gratitude to my supervisor, Aleksi Kurkela, who has dedicated an extraordinary amount of time to my development. Over the past four years, I have received his undivided attention and unwavering support with every challenge I faced. I am profoundly grateful for his guidance in the scientific world, and for numerous conversations that kept my enthusiasm for physics at its peak.

I also extend my sincere appreciation to my close scientific collaborator, Tyler Gorda, for his invaluable help with all aspects of my PhD research. My gratitude further goes to my co-supervisor, Alex Nielsen, as well as my colleagues and fellow PhD students at the University of Stavanger for providing a fantastic research environment with an incredibly friendly atmosphere. I am also grateful to Aleksi Vuorinen and Joonas Nättilä for their valuable insights and for a rewarding collaboration. Additionally, I am grateful for the many engaging scientific conversations. In particular, I thank Kenji Fukushima, Aleksas Mazeliauskas, Rahul Somasundaram, Ingo Tews, Jérôme Margueron, Hauke Koehn, Luciano Rezzolla, Krishna Rajagopal and Sanjay Reddy, for their inspiring discussions.

A special thanks goes to my parents and my brother, Ilya, without whom this scientific journey would not have been possible. Their love and support are what made this thesis possible!

Oleg

Stavanger, February 2025

List of papers

I How Perturbative QCD Constrains the Equation of State at Neutron Star Densities. O. Komoltsev and A. Kurkela. Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 202701 (2022), arXiv:2111.05350 [nucl-th] [1]

II Ab-initio QCD Calculations Impact the Inference of the Neutron-star-matter Equation of State. T. Gorda, O. Komoltsev, A. Kurkela. Astrophys.J. 950 (2023) 2, 107, arXiv:2204.11877 [nucl-th] [2]

III Bayesian uncertainty quantification of perturbative QCD input to the neutron-star equation of state. T. Gorda, O. Komoltsev, A. Kurkela, A. Mazeliauskas. JHEP 06 (2023) 002, arXiv:2303.02175 [hep-ph] [3]

IV Strongly interacting matter exhibits deconfined behavior in massive neutron stars. E. Annala, T. Gorda, J. Hirvonen, O. Komoltsev, A. Kurkela, J. Nättilä, and A. Vuorinen. Nature Commun. 14, 8451 (2023), arXiv:2303.11356 [astro-ph.HE] [4]

V Equation of state at neutron-star densities and beyond from perturbative QCD. O. Komoltsev, R. Somasundaram, T. Gorda, A. Kurkela, J. Margueron, I. Tews. Phys.Rev.D 109 (2024) 9, 094030, arXiv:2312.14127 [nucl-th] [5]

VI First-order phase transitions in the cores of neutron stars. O.Komoltsev. Phys.Rev.D 110 (2024) 7, L071502, arXiv:2404.05637 [nucl-th] [6]

Introduction

Neutron stars

The concept of dense stars, even denser than white dwarfs, was originally proposed by Lev Landau in 1931 (published in 1932 [7]). According to Chandrasekhar’s prediction [8], white dwarfs have a maximum mass limit beyond which the pressure of relativistic degenerate electrons is insufficient to counteract gravity. Landau speculated about an even denser form of star that could exist beyond this limit. Described by Lev Davidovich as “one gigantic nucleus,” these dense stars were theorized well before the experimental discovery of neutron stars and, remarkably, even before the discovery of the neutron itself. Following the discovery of the neutron in 1932, Walter Baade and Fritz Zwicky made the first explicit prediction of neutron stars [9] as an attempt to explain the energy released during supernova explosions.

Landau’s pioneering work inspired Oppenheimer and his student Volkoff to incorporate general relativity into their analysis of dense stellar objects. Collaborating with Tolman, who had formulated the general relativistic equations for static spherically symmetric fluids, they numerically solved these equations for a non-interacting fluid of neutrons [10, 11]. This collaboration led to the development of the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equations, as presented in next section eq. (1). These equations remain fundamental in modern astrophysics and is utilized extensively throughout this thesis.

Theoretical efforts from this period onward aimed at modeling the behavior of ultradense matter under extreme conditions, such as advancements made by Harrison and Wheeler, who extended the analysis by incorporating a mixture of nuclei (modeled via the liquid drop model), electrons, and a free neutron gas [12]. Cameron further expanded on this approach by including nuclear interactions [13] described using the Skyrme model [14]. He also highlighted the potential presence of hyperons — baryons containing strange quarks — at such extreme densities, with further developments contributed by Salpeter, Ambartsumyan, and Saakyan in [15–17]. The subsequent theoretical works introduced the possibility of neutron superfluidity [18, 19], meson condensates (such as pions and kaons) [20] and explored potential phase transitions to quark matter at even higher densities [21–23]. The modern theoretical understanding of the behavior of dense matter are summarized in the following § 3.3. For a historical overview, see [24–26].

Despite these early theoretical predictions, it was not until 1967 that the first observational evidence of neutron stars was obtained. Jocelyn Bell-Burnell, then a PhD student of Antony Hewish, detected periodic radio signals with millisecond-to-second timescales and extraordinary precision, with period stability on the order of 10−1010^{-10} to 10−2110^{-21} [27]. The initial hypothesis of “LGM-1” (Little Green Men) was ruled out after the discovery of additional sources with similar characteristics from different sky locations. The rapid periods and short emission timescales could only be explained by rapidly rotating neutron stars, dubbed pulsars. The theoretical work of Pacini [28] and Gold [29] proposed that the periodicity of these signals was due to rotating neutron stars with strong magnetic fields.

The first pulsar in a binary system with another neutron star, PSR1913+16, was discovered by Joseph Taylor and Russell Hulse in 1975 [30]. Their observations provided the first indirect evidence that the system was losing energy through gravitational wave (GW) emission.

Beyond testing general relativity, binary pulsars offer a surprisingly rich opportunity to study the behavior of cold, ultra-dense matter. Radio observations of pulsars in binary systems provide the most precise measurements of neutron star masses to date. In such systems with a visible companion, such as a white dwarf or a main sequence star, radial velocities can be measured due to the regular pulsing of the neutron star and the visibility of the companion. The ratio of their radial velocities provides the mass ratio between the two objects. If the companion’s mass is determined through methods like spectroscopy (e.g., as demonstrated in [31] for white dwarfs), the pulsar’s mass can be accurately inferred.

In cases where the binary companion is not directly observable, additional general relativistic corrections can be used to constrain the pulsar’s mass. One such method is the Shapiro time delay [32], which measures the delay in the radio pulses caused by the gravitational field of the companion. The effect is maximized when the orbital plane’s inclination is close to 90∘90^\circ, meaning it lies along the line of sight. In this alignment, the pulses pass through the companion, undergo time delays that depend on the companion’s mass, and remain detectable by radio telescopes. This allows for precise mass measurements [33–36]. One of the recent breakthroughs in the astrophysical observation of pulsars is the discovery of two-solar-mass neutron stars [33], first measured using the Shapiro time delay. As will be discussed later, this discovery imposes some of the strongest constraints on the properties of cold, ultra-dense matter.

On the other side of the spectrum, different sources X-ray emission can provide simultaneous constraints on the mass and radius of neutron stars. One of such source is a hot spot on the pulsar’s surface. The rotation of a neutron star introduces periodic variations in the observed X-ray intensity, which can be modeled to infer properties of the hotspots, such as their size, temperature, and location on the star’s surface. The neutron star’s intense gravitational field causes relativistic effects, including light bending, which change the periodicity and intensity of the observed signals. Modeling these effects requires accounting for local radiation beaming due to the bulk motion of material on the rotationally deformed surface, as well as ray propagation through the star’s curved spacetime. These relativistic phenomena depend on the star’s compactness (the ratio of its mass to radius), providing simultaneous constraints on both the mass and radius of the star. Observationally, these studies are conducted using X-ray observatories like the Neutron Star Interior Composition Explorer (NICER), a soft X-ray telescope installed on the International Space Station in 2017, and XMM-Newton, a space observatory launched by the European Space Agency in 1999. The analysis of such data produces two-dimensional mass-radius probability distributions for neutron stars, as demonstrated in the studies of pulsars such as PSR J0030+0451 [37, 38] and PSR J0740+6620 [36, 39, 40].

Another source of X-ray emission is thermonuclear X-ray bursts that frequently appears in low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs). By observing these bursts and modeling their cooling processes, it is possible to constrain the size of the emitting region. The most precise constraint to date comes from the neutron star in the binary system 4U J1702-429 [41], achieved through direct atmosphere model fits to the time-evolving energy spectra of these bursts. Additionally, two other binary systems, 4U 1724-307 [42] and SAX J1810.8−260 [42], have been studied using the cooling-tail method for mass-radius constraints. Another approach to constraining the NS radius involves spectral fitting in quiescent LMXBs, referring to periods of minimal accretion in these systems. By analyzing the X-ray flux and surface temperature of a NS with a reliable distance measurement, the radius of the emitting region can be constrained [43, 44]. The data is collected using ROSAT, Chandra, and XMM-Newton, which are space-based telescopes designed to observe X-ray emissions from cosmic sources.

Lastly, neutron stars can be studied through the rapidly evolving field of gravitational wave and multimessenger astronomy. Coalescing binary neutron stars generate a quadrupole moment, which, according to general relativity, produces ripples in spacetime known as gravitational waves. Modeling GW requires understanding the tidal deformability (TD) of compact objects—i.e., how such objects respond to the gravitational field of a nearby massive body, as in the case of a binary neutron star (BNS) merger. Determining the binary TD from observed mergers provides additional information about the neutron-star matter, as detailed in eq. (92). GW data is collected using the ground-based detectors operated by the LIGO and Virgo Scientific Collaborations.

Gravitational waves can be accompanied by an electromagnetic counterpart, hence the term “multimessenger astronomy”. Astrophysical modeling of BNS mergers suggests that these events exhibit distinct signatures across the electromagnetic spectrum [45, 46], including short gamma-ray bursts (sGRBs) [47–51] and longer-lived afterglows.

The timing and spectral properties of sGRBs and kilonovae (gamma-ray bursts caused by the radioactive decay of heavy r-process nuclei) can be used to constrain the behavior of matter in extreme conditions.

Such multimessenger event was the first simultaneous observation of a gravitational wave signal from a binary NS merger, GW170817 [52–54], and its electromagnetic counterpart with a lag of ≲2\lesssim2 s, GRB 170817A [55]. The GW signal provided novel constraints on binary TD. Additional constraints arise from the electromagnetic counterpart’s properties. Astrophysical modeling of jet generation and launching suggests that the merger remnant collapsed into a black hole [56–60]. Furthermore, the spectral properties of sRGB imply that the remnant either underwent a prompt collapse into a black hole or formed a supramassive/hypermassive neutron star that subsequently collapsed into a black hole shortly afterward.

TOV equation

The connection between the described experimental data and the behavior of cold, ultra-dense matter is established through the TOV equation. This equation is a solution of Einstein’s equations for a spherically symmetric, static body, with the approximation that an isolated star can be modeled as a perfect fluid:

dPdr=−Gmr2ε(1+Pεc2)(1+4πr3Pmc2)(1−2Gmrc2)−1dmdr=4πr2ε(1)\begin{aligned} \frac{dP}{dr} &= -\frac{Gm}{r^2}\varepsilon\left(1+\frac{P}{\varepsilon c^2}\right)\left(1+\frac{4\pi r^3P}{mc^2}\right)\left(1-\frac{2Gm}{rc^2}\right)^{-1}\\ \frac{dm}{dr} &= 4\pi r^2\varepsilon \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

where rr represents the radial coordinate, and m(r)m(r) is the total mass within the radius rr. The initial condition for these equations are

P(r=0)=Pcentral,m(r=0)=0.(2)P(r=0)=P_{\mathrm{central}},\qquad m(r=0)=0. \tag*{(2)}

The only input required to solve TOV equation is the equation of state (EoS). For the TOV equation EoS is expressed as the pressure as a function of energy density, p(ε)p(\varepsilon). The next section provides an overview of the EoS.

The solution of the TOV equation provides a sequence of neutron star masses (MM) and radii (RR) as a function of central pressure or density. The stability condition for neutron stars is determined by the sign of dM/dPcentraldM/dP_{\mathrm{central}} [61]:

  • Stable branch: dM/dPcentral>0dM/dP_{\mathrm{central}}>0.

  • Unstable branch: dM/dPcentral<0dM/dP_{\mathrm{central}}<0 (mass decreases with increasing density, leading to gravitational collapse into a black hole).

The point where dM/dPcentral=0dM/dP_{\mathrm{central}}=0 marks the maximum stable mass MTOVM_{\mathrm{TOV}}.

Next, I examine how GW data can be used to extract information about neutron-star matter. The early inspiral phase of two coalescing neutron stars is affected by the internal structure of NSs. To linear order, this impact can be characterized by a single parameter — the tidal deformability λ\lambda, which is defined as the ratio of the induced quadrupole moment of the star to the tidal field, i.e., how much the star deforms due to the external gravitational field of the companion.

Following the approach of [62, 63], the relevant equations are derived using linearized metric perturbations and are presented in appendix eqs. (92) and (5.5). By inputting an EoS, these first-order differential equations can be solved numerically alongside the TOV equation to predict the dimensionless tidal deformability Λ=λ/M5\Lambda=\lambda/M^5 as a function of the central density. The dimensionless tidal deformability of a star is used in § 4.6 to calculate the binary tidal deformability Λ~\tilde{\Lambda} (see eq. (47)), which can be compared to the observations, such as those provided by the LIGO/Virgo collaborations.

The system of equations can also include an additional equation to calculate the total baryonic number:

dNdr=4πr2n[1−2m(r)r]−1,(3)\frac{dN}{dr}=4\pi r^2 n\left[1-\frac{2m(r)}{r}\right]^{-1}, \tag*{(3)}

where n is baryon number density. This is essential for utilizing constraints derived from multi-messenger observations of events like GW170817, as described in the § 4.6.

Solving the system of eqs. (1), (3) and (5.5) establishes a one-to-one correspondence between a neutron star’s mass, radius, and tidal deformability with the equation of state:

M(R)⇔p(ε),Λ(R)⇔p(ε).(4)M(R)\Leftrightarrow p(\varepsilon),\qquad\Lambda(R)\Leftrightarrow p(\varepsilon). \tag*{(4)}

Consequently, neutron stars serve as natural laboratories for exploring matter under the most extreme conditions.

Equation of state

The theory of strong interaction, known as Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), is a quantum field theory that describes the interactions between quarks, mediated by gluons. The QCD phase diagram, shown in Figure 1.2, represents temperature TT as a function of baryon chemical potential μ\mu. At relatively low temperatures and low densities (corresponds to the small chemical potential), matter exists in the form of hadrons — bound states of quarks, such as protons and neutrons. In contrast, at extreme temperatures or densities, quarks become deconfined, transitioning from hadronic matter to a quark matter.

Image not extracted

Figure 1.2. An artistic representation of the phase diagram of QCD.

As illustrated in the figure, heavy-ion collision experiments (such as RHIC, FAIR, and LHC) primarily probe the high-temperature, low-density region of the phase diagram. In contrast, neutron stars are generally considered cold because their density far exceeds their temperature. This is particularly true for old isolated NSs, as the temperature can rise significantly during supernovae or BNS mergers. Neutron stars are currently the only observational probe of cold dense matter, with typical central densities falling within the intermediate regime between hadronic and quark matter.

In this thesis, the focus is on the zero-temperature EoSs in β\beta-equilibrium, meaning that weak processes are balanced and have reached equilibrium. Neutron stars are transparent to neutrinos, and at zero temperature, flavor equilibration is achieved through two Urca processes (named by George Gamow and Mário Schenberg while visiting a casino called Cassino da Urca [64]):

n→p+e−+νˉe,p+e−→n+νe.(5)n \to p + e^{-} + \bar{\nu}_{e}, \qquad p + e^{-} \to n + \nu_{e}. \tag*{(5)}

These reactions establish the condition for β\beta-equilibrium in nuclear matter:

μn=μp+μe,(6)\mu_{n} = \mu_{p} + \mu_{e}, \tag*{(6)}

where μn\mu_{n}, μp\mu_{p}, and μe\mu_{e} are the chemical potentials of neutrons, protons, and electrons, respectively. The local charge neutrality of NSs requires equal densities of protons and electrons, i.e., np=nen_{p} = n_{e}.

In terms of quark degrees of freedom, the condition for β\beta-equilibrium can be written as μd=μu+μe\mu_{d} = \mu_{u} + \mu_{e}. When strange quarks are present, their contribution to charge neutrality can fully balance the quark charges. In the case of massless three-flavor quark matter (for justification, see later), the conditions for β\beta-equilibrium, along with charge neutrality, can be expressed as:

μu=μd=μs=μ/3=μq,(7)\mu_u = \mu_d = \mu_s = \mu/3 = \mu_q, \tag*{(7)}

where the subscripts uu, dd, ss correspond to up, down, and strange quarks. The baryon chemical potential and quark chemical potential are denoted as μ\mu and μq\mu_q, respectively.

Next, I summarize the current theoretical understanding of the EoS from ab initio calculations. In principle, the behavior of strongly interacting matter is governed by the Lagrangian of QCD. In practice, calculations can only be performed with certain approximations. Several first-principles approaches derive the EoS from the QCD Lagrangian, including perturbative methods and lattice QCD. Additionally, effective field theory (EFT) provides a useful framework for systematically approximating the EoS.

Performing numerical calculations in lattice QCD for cold, ultradense matter is particularly challenging due to the sign problem (see e.g., [65]). Lattice QCD relies on statistical methods, such as Monte Carlo sampling, to evaluate the partition function in the Euclidean path integral formalism. However, at finite chemical potential μ\mu, the standard Monte Carlo techniques for lattice QCD simulations does not work, as the Dirac determinant becomes complex.

However, EFT and perturbative methods remain accurate within their respective limits of applicability, as illustrated in Figure 1.3. The low-density regime, corresponding to hadronic matter, is constrained by Chiral Effective Field Theory (cEFT), while perturbative Quantum Chromodynamics (pQCD) calculations at high densities inform us about the behavior of quark matter. The details of both calculations are presented below.

Image not extracted

Figure 1.3. The summary of current theoretical inputs to the EoS of cold dense matter. It includes the crust EoS from the BPS model [66], cEFT calculations [67], and the pQCD limit [68, 69]. The inferred TOV region corresponds to maximal pressures and energy densities reached in NSs, with the details of the inference provided in the subsequent sections.

At small densities shown in the figure, n≲0.5nsatn \lesssim0.5n_{\mathrm{sat}}, where nsat=0.16/fm3n_{\mathrm{sat}} = 0.16/\mathrm{fm}^{3} is the nuclear saturation density, EoS of the outer crust of a neutron star follows the BPS model [66], named after its authors: Baym, Pethick, and Sutherland. This calculation accounts for measured nuclear masses, the electron degeneracy pressure from a relativistic Fermi gas, and the Coulomb lattice structure of atomic nuclei.

Around nuclear saturation density, quarks are confined within hadrons, such as baryons and mesons. Nuclear interactions can be effectively described using these degrees of freedom rather than quarks and gluons, employing a Lagrangian consistent with the approximate chiral symmetry of QCD. The development of cEFT has started by Weinberg’s pioneering work [70, 71] and has provided a systematic framework for expanding nuclear forces at low momenta. In this approach, nucleons interact through pion exchanges and short-range interactions, with parameters constrained by two- and few-body observables [72]. State-of-the-art cEFT calculations provides constraints on the EoS up to [1.1−2]nsat[1.1 - 2]n_{\mathrm{sat}} [67, 73–76]. The cEFT band in fig. 1.3 corresponds to the “soft” and “stiff” EoS from [67].

Perturbative QCD calculations are possible only at asymptotically high densities, where the QCD coupling αs\alpha_s is small. This occurs when the baryon chemical potential μ\mu significantly exceeds the QCD energy scale, i.e., μ≫ΛQCD\mu\gg\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}. Note that the perturbative expansion is an asymptotic series, not convergent. The expansion of the pressure in terms of αs\alpha_s can be expressed as:

p=pFD+αsp1+αs2p2+αs3p3+…(8)p = p_{\mathrm{FD}} + \alpha_s p_1 + \alpha_s^2 p_2 + \alpha_s^3 p_3 + \ldots \tag*{(8)}

where pFDp_{\mathrm{FD}} is the pressure of a free Fermi gas of quarks while the other terms are interaction corrections. Starting from p2p_2, the dependence on log⁡(αs)\log(\alpha_s) appears in the coefficients.

The relevant results of pQCD calculations, shown in Figure 1.3, are constrained to zero-temperature matter composed of three flavors of massless quarks in β\beta-equilibrium. This is well justified, as the chemical potential where the perturbative expansion is valid is much larger than the up, down, and strange quark masses, while the relevant region, as discussed later, remains below the charm threshold.

The details of the calculation and the current state-of-the-art result for the QCD grand canonical potential, which is computed at partial next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order (N3LO∗\mathrm{N}^{3}\mathrm{LO}^{*}), are presented in [68, 69]. An asterisk in N3LO∗\mathrm{N}^{3}\mathrm{LO}^{*} indicates that it is not a fully computed order. While N2LO\mathrm{N}^{2}\mathrm{LO} is fully computed, at N3LO\mathrm{N}^{3}\mathrm{LO}, only the soft contribution1 to the pressure is known and included.

The resulting pQCD pressure depends on the chemical potential μ\mu and the renormalization scale Λˉ\bar{\Lambda}, which is related to a dimensionless parameter:

X=3Λˉ2μ.(9)X = \frac{3\bar{\Lambda}}{2\mu}. \tag*{(9)}

A conventional approach for estimating theoretical uncertainties involves varying the renormalization scale by a factor of 2, resulting in X∈[1/2,2]X \in[1/2, 2]. The dependence on the logarithm of Λˉ\bar{\Lambda} naturally arises with 2μ/32\mu/3, motivating the choice of the central scale X=1X = 1 to ensure the cancellation of logarithmic dependence in the perturbative expansion presented in eq. (8).

The pQCD results are most relevant for neutron star physics at the lowest density where perturbative uncertainties remain under control. A conventional choice for the lowest chemical potential is set at μ≥μpQCD=2.6\mu\geq\mu_{\mathrm{pQCD}} = 2.6 GeV as in [77], corresponding to number densities npQCD≳40nsatn_{\mathrm{pQCD}} \gtrsim40n_{\mathrm{sat}}. This choice ensures a consistent uncertainty estimation, roughly matching the relative uncertainties of cEFT at 1.1nsat1.1n_{\mathrm{sat}}. Both the estimation of theoretical uncertainties and the reference density at which the pQCD pressure is used are explored in detail in § 4.11.

At these densities, Cooper pairs form due to attractive QCD interaction between quark pairs. This leads to a color-superconducting phase [78–82], where the EoS receives a nonperturbative contribution of order O(Δ2μ2)O(\Delta^{2}\mu^{2}). Here, Δ\Delta represents the color superconducting gap, an energy gap that forms at the Fermi surface of quarks. In this thesis, these contributions are neglected because their effect is suppressed relative to the leading-order pressure, which scales as O(μ4)O(\mu^{4}). Various models estimate the gap at densities that are not asymptotically large to be in the range of 50–150 MeV [78, 79, 82–89].

First-principle theoretical calculations at intermediate densities between cEFT and pQCD limit are unavailable. Therefore, to explore neutron star physics and predict the mass-radius relation, it is necessary to model the EoS in the density range above the cEFT and up to the TOV density — the maximum density of a stable NS. One approach is to construct phenomenological models, which incorporate specific assumptions about the underlying physics. While numerous such models exist, their predictions vary significantly depending on the assumptions and model parameters (e.g., see the CompOSE database of NS models [90]).

An alternative method, which is utilized throughout this thesis and detailed in § 4.6, is the model-agnostic generation of EoSs [39, 67, 77, 91–107]. A large variety of different EoSs is generated to probe the physics of neutron star cores. The inference of a realistic EoS then involves constraining the generated EoSs with current astrophysical and theoretical inputs, excluding EoS that are incompatible with the data. The focus of this thesis is the inference of the EoS of neutron-star matter, with the main objective summarized in the next section.

Thesis objective

It is essential to incorporate all possible inputs when inferring the EoS to study the physics of neutron stars. However, prior to my PhD, QCD input was largely overlooked, except for a few groups that attempted to interpolate across two orders of magnitude in energy density and pressure between the cEFT and pQCD limits [77, 91, 92, 96, 100, 108]. The majority of studies instead anchored different interpolation functions to the low-density limit only, as neutron stars collapse at densities much lower than 40nsat40n_{\mathrm{sat}}, where pQCD calculations become reliable. It was unclear whether pQCD provides nontrivial information about the EoS of cold dense matter.

The difference between works that interpolate all the way up to the pQCD limit and those that do not was evident (e.g., see Fig. 3 of [109]). The key difference is in the softening of the EoS, characterized by a reduction in the speed of sound at the highest densities reached in neutron stars. This observation required further study and became the basis question that initially motivated this research.

The objective of this thesis is to explore how pQCD calculations impact the inference of the EoS of neutron-star matter.

My collaborators and I developed a framework that utilizes thermodynamic relations to impose robust global constraints on the EoS. This allows us to propagate pQCD constraints from asymptotically high densities to the densities reached in NSs. We explicitly demonstrated the impact of the novel QCD input on the inference of the EoS of cold ultradense matter. Our findings suggest that the QCD input is crucial for understanding the physics of the cores of the most massive neutron stars.

The thesis consists of three main chapters. The first chapter is an introduction, which you are currently finishing. The second chapter explores the role of high-density calculations in EoS inference, addressing why pQCD provides nontrivial constraints for the EoS and demonstrating the impact of the QCD input. The final chapter examines what the QCD input can reveal about neutron star cores, including the potential existence of quark matter and the possibility of a first-order phase transition. While it remains a fundamental open question whether the phase transition occurs within the density range reached in the cores of the most massive neutron stars, I quantify the probability and find strong evidence supporting such phase change.

The utility of pQCD for neutron stars

In this chapter, I explore how perturbative QCD can be used to impose robust constraints on the EoS of neutron stars. First, an analytical method is derived in § 4.1 to propagate constraints from asymptotically high densities to lower densities [1]. In § 4.6, this method is used in Bayesian inference of the EoS of neutron-star matter, explicitly showing the impact of the QCD input [2]. The following two sections address potential caveats of this new input. § 4.11 focuses on analyzing the impact of theoretical uncertainties in QCD calculations on Bayesian inference [3], arising from missing higher-order terms, the unphysical renormalization scale parameter XX, and the choice of the reference density where pQCD calculations are used. Finally, § 4.16 examines how the choice of termination density, up to which the EoS is modeled, affects Bayesian inference [5].

Analytical derivation

In this section, I demonstrate how assuming full thermodynamic potential for the low- and high-density limits, which provides the triplets of values {μlow,nlow,plow}\{\mu_{\mathrm{low}}, n_{\mathrm{low}}, p_{\mathrm{low}}\} and {μhigh,nhigh,phigh}\{\mu_{\mathrm{high}}, n_{\mathrm{high}}, p_{\mathrm{high}}\}, introduces global constraints on the EoS between these two points. The subscripts "low" and "high" correspond to the cEFT and pQCD limits but are used to emphasize the generality of the construction. This construction explicitly shows how information arising from pQCD calculations can propagate to neutron-star densities.

These constraints are analytic and independent of any specific interpolation function. They arise from the fundamental requirement that the EoS remains stable, causal, and consistent between the low- and high-density limits.

These requirements and the resulting constraints on the μ−n\mu-n plane are discussed in subsection a. In subsections b and c, these constraints are first extended to the three-dimensional μ−n−p\mu-n-p space and then mapped to the ε−p\varepsilon-p plane. Finally, in subsection d it is shown how to apply a simpler yet equivalent check against the derived constraints for the modeled EoS, which is known up to some termination density.

Stability, causality and consistency

While the only input required for the TOV equation for the hydrodynamic description of neutron-star matter is the EoS in the form of the pressure as a function of the energy density p(ε)p(\varepsilon), the complete information about the EoS is available through the thermodynamic potential. At zero temperature and finite chemical potential, in β\beta-equilibrium, the grand canonical potential is given by Ω(μ)=−p(μ)\Omega(\mu)=-p(\mu). Knowing the full thermodynamic potential allows access to various thermodynamic quantities, such as the pressure pp, the chemical potential μ\mu, the number density n=∂μp(μ)n = \partial_{\mu}p(\mu) and the energy density ε\varepsilon calculated using

ε=−p+μn.(10)\varepsilon= -p + \mu n. \tag*{(10)}

The easiest way to derive constraints is to start with the number density nn as a function of the chemical potential μ\mu, as presented in Figure 2.1. The triplet {μhigh,nhigh,phigh}\{\mu_{\mathrm{high}}, n_{\mathrm{high}}, p_{\mathrm{high}}\} is provided by pQCD calculation for the central scale X=1X = 1 and μhigh=μQCD=2.6\mu_{\mathrm{high}} = \mu_{\mathrm{QCD}} = 2.6 GeV. It is represented by the purple line in the upper right corner of Figure 2.1. A systematic discussion of uncertainty estimation related to the choice of scale XX and μQCD\mu_{\mathrm{QCD}} is provided in § 4.11. The low-density limit {μlow,nlow,plow}\{\mu_{\mathrm{low}}, n_{\mathrm{low}}, p_{\mathrm{low}}\}, obtained using cEFT at 1.1nsat1.1n_{\mathrm{sat}} (corresponding to μlow≈0.978\mu_{\mathrm{low}} \approx0.978 GeV), is represented by the dark blue line in the bottom left corner of Figure 2.1 (corresponding to ”stiff” EoS from [67]).

Image not extracted

Figure 2.1. Baryon number density as a function of baryon chemical potential. Arrows indicate the minimal allowed slope dictated by causality, ∂μn(μ)≥n/μ\partial_{\mu} n(\mu) \ge n/\mu. The red regions are excluded due to the simultaneous requirements of stability, causality, and consistency. The constructions of Δpmin⁡/max⁡\Delta p_{\min/\max} for an arbitrary point μ0,n0\mu_0,n_0 are defined in eqs. (13) and (17)

In principle, the EoS in β\beta-equilibrated matter at zero temperature is a single line on this plane, which is unknown. Between these two limits, the only available theoretical information is that the EoS must be thermodynamically stable, causal, and able to connect the two endpoints. Consequently, not all possible interpolations between these limits will result in a valid and consistent EoS. These requirements can be summarized as follows.

  • Stability. The grand canonical potential must be a concave function of the chemical potential. Consequently, the number density should be a monotonically increasing single-valued function, ∂μn=∂μ2(−Ω(μ))≥0\partial_{\mu}n = \partial_{\mu}^{2}(-\Omega(\mu)) \ge0. Therefore, any lines in Figure 2.1 must be monotonic function to represent a valid EoS.

  • Causality. Speed of sound cannot be bigger than the speed of light:

cs−2=μn∂n∂μ≥1.(11)c_{\mathrm{s}}^{-2} = \frac{\mu}{n}\frac{\partial n}{\partial\mu} \ge1. \tag*{(11)}

This imposes a minimal slope on the number density ∂μn(μ)≥n/μ\partial_{\mu}n(\mu) \ge n/\mu for a fixed point on the μ−n\mu- n plane.

References

  1. [169]G. D. Moore and T. Gorda, “Bounding the QCD Equation of State with the Lattice”, JHEP 12, 133 (2023), arXiv: 2309.15149.arxiv.org/abs/2309.15149
  2. [170]M. Evans et al., “A Horizon Study for Cosmic Explorer: Science, Observatories, and Community”, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2109.09882, arXiv:2109.09882 (2021), arXiv: 2109.09882.arxiv.org/abs/2109.09882
  3. [171]M Punturo et al., “The third generation of gravitational wave observatories and their science reach”, Classical and Quantum Gravity 27, 084007 (2010).DOI
  4. [172]L. Baiotti and L. Rezzolla, “Binary neutron star mergers: a review of einstein’s richest laboratory”, Reports on Progress in Physics 80, 096901 (2017).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_caj2b2ca
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents