betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Helicity amplitudes of N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) including pentaquark components

Abstract

We investigate the helicity amplitudes of the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances in the electromagnetic transition process γ∗p→N∗γ^*p\to N^*, where the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) are assumed to include both the L=1L=1 three-quark and L=0L=0 spatial symmetric q4qˉq^4\bar q pentaquark components. The helicity transition amplitudes A1/2A_{1/2}, A3/2A_{3/2} (for spin 3/2 states) and S1/2S_{1/2} are computed within the constituent quark model. The inclusion of the q4qˉq^4 \bar q pentaquark components via the γ∗→qqˉγ^*\to q\bar q diagram significantly improves the theoretical description of the helicity amplitudes for both N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535), yielding a closer agreement with experimental data compared to the pure three-quark picture. The work reveals that the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances may contain a considerable pentaquark components.

Introduction

In the past two decades, new data on the electroproduction of low-lying nucleon resonances which have been accumulated at JLab [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9] and by the Mainz group [10, 11, 12] provides us important information to reveal their inner structures. As the most common representation of inner structure, helicity amplitudes in all the γ∗N→N∗\gamma^*N \to N^* transitions are parametrized in terms of the three different photon polarizations, including two transverse amplitudes A1/2A_{1/2} and A3/2A_{3/2} (for spin 3/23/2 states) and one longitudinal amplitude S1/2S_{1/2}. One may see some good reviews about helicity amplitudes in Refs. [13, 14, 15].

Numerous theoretical approaches have been developed to describe the helicity amplitudes of N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535), such as a variety of quark models: single quark transition model [16], light-front quark models [17, 18, 19, 20, 21], hypercentral constituent quark model [22, 23, 24], and QCD sum rules [25, 26]. In particular, the electromagnetic properties of N(1520)N(1520), N(1535)N(1535), and several other nucleon resonances have been studied in the soft-wall Ads/QCD approaches [27, 28].

Beyond the pure three-quark picture, more complex internal structures involving hadronic degrees of freedom have been explored. These include meson cloud effects, baryon-meson hadronic molecular components, and pentaquark components which all indicate a qqq(qqqˉ)qqq(qq\bar{q}) quark content, have been proposed for a better understanding of the γ∗p→N(1520)/N(1535)\gamma^*p \to N(1520)/N(1535) transitions [9, 20, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37]. For the N(1520)N(1520) resonance, several studies suggest that baryon-meson molecular-like configurations could play a dominant role in its structure [9, 32, 33]. Dynamical coupled-channel models further provide a unified framework in which both the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) emerge naturally as baryon-meson resonant states [29, 30]. Similarly, within the unitary chiral model, N(1535)N(1535) is interpreted as a dynamically generated state with a strong baryon-meson component [31]. And additional qqq(qqqˉ)qqq(qq\bar{q}) components are incorporated into the wave functions of N(1535)N(1535) to improve the description of its helicity amplitudes, using distinct spatial scale parameters in Refs. [36, 37].

In this work, we investigate the helicity amplitudes of the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances in a mixing structure of three-quark and pentaquark components, by extending a constituent quark model originally developed from the first principle to compute the helicity transition amplitudes of three-quark nucleon resonances within the quantum field theory framework [38, 39]. In Ref. [39] we have pushed the three-quark contribution to its upper limit, but it is found that only the A1/2A_{1/2} of N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) can be fairly described. In the previous work [40] the N(1535)1/2−N(1535)1/2^- and N(1520)3/2−N(1520)3/2^- masses were described by including the ground-state pentaquark components into the three-quark configurations. This may suggest that both the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) include a considerable pentaquark components.

The paper is organized as follows. All possible quark configurations of ground state non-strange q4qˉq^4\bar{q} pentaquarks are worked out in the language of permutation groups, the mass spectrum are also estimated in Sec. II. In Sec. III we briefly introduce the formalism of helicity amplitudes A1/2A_{1/2}, A3/2A_{3/2}, and S1/2S_{1/2} of the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances in the photoproduction transitions γ∗p→N∗\gamma^*p \to N^*, where both the three-quark and pentaquark configurations are considered. The helicity amplitudes of the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) are calculated in the conventional three-quark picture and the mixing picture of three-quark and pentaquark components in the range 0≤Q2<4.5 GeV20 \leq Q^2 < 4.5\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 and fitted to the experimental data in Sec. IV. Finally a discussion of the results and conclusions are given in Sec. V.

::::

q4 pentaquark states

The construction of pentaquark wave functions has been described in a group theory approach in Refs. [40, 41, 42], and the masses of light-quark and charmonium-like pentaquark states are calculated in a non-relativistic quark model. In this section, for the completeness of the article and the convenience to audiences, we present the main points and results of Refs. [40, 41, 42].

The construction of q4qˉq^{4}\bar q states follow the rules that a q4qˉq^{4}\bar q state must be a color singlet and the q4qˉq^{4}\bar q wave function should be antisymmetric under any permutation between identical quarks. The pentaquark should be a color singlet demands that the color part of the pentaquark wave function must be a [222]1[222]_{1} singlet. Since the color part of the antiquark in pentaquark states is a [11]3[11]_{3} anti-triplet, the color wave function of the four-quark configuration must be a [211]3[211]_{3} triplet. The total wave function of the four quark configuration is antisymmetric implies that its spatial-spin-flavor part must be a [31][31] state by conjugation.

The total wave function of the q4q^{4} configuration may be written in the general form,

Ψtotal=∑i,j=ρ,λ,ηaijψ[211]icψ[31]josf,(1)\Psi_{total}=\sum_{i,j=\rho,\lambda,\eta}a_{ij}\psi^{c}_{[211]_{i}}\psi^{osf}_{[31]_{j}}, \tag*{(1)}

with

ψ[31]ρ,λ,ηosf=∑i,j=S,A,ρ,λ,ηbijψ[X]iosψ[Y]jsf,\psi^{osf}_{[31]_{\rho,\lambda,\eta}}=\sum_{i,j=S,A,\rho,\lambda,\eta}b_{ij}\psi^{os}_{[X]_{i}}\psi^{sf}_{[Y]_{j}},
ψ[Y]sf=∑i,j=S,A,ρ,λ,ηcijψ[x]isψ[y]jf,(2)\psi^{sf}_{[Y]}=\sum_{i,j=S,A,\rho,\lambda,\eta}c_{ij}\psi^{s}_{[x]_{i}}\psi^{f}_{[y]_{j}}, \tag*{(2)}

where ψc\psi^{c}, ψosf\psi^{osf}, ψsf\psi^{sf}, ψs\psi^{s} and ψf\psi^{f} are respectively the color, spatial-spin-flavor, spin-flavor, spin and flavor parts of the q4q^{4} cluster. SS, AA, ρ\rho, λ\lambda, η\eta stand for fully symmetric, fully antisymmetric, ρ\rho-type, λ\lambda-type and η\eta-type functions. The coefficients in Eqs. (1) and (2) can be determined by acting the permutations (12), (23) and (34) of the S4S_{4} group on both sides of the general wave functions. The fully antisymmetric wave function for the q4q^{4} cluster is worked out,

ψ=13(ψ[211]λcψ[31]ρosf−ψ[211]ρcψ[31]λosf+ψ[211]ηcψ[31]ηosf)(3)\psi=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\left(\psi^{c}_{[211]_{\lambda}}\psi^{osf}_{[31]_{\rho}}-\psi^{c}_{[211]_{\rho}}\psi^{osf}_{[31]_{\lambda}}+\psi^{c}_{[211]_{\eta}}\psi^{osf}_{[31]_{\eta}}\right) \tag*{(3)}

For L=0L=0 spatial symmetric pentaquark states, both spatial-spin-flavor and spin-flavor wave functions are in the [31][31] configuration, and all possible spin and flavor configurations are shown in Table I. As an example, the explicit spin-flavor wave functions of [31]FS[22]F[31]S[31]_{FS}[22]_{F}[31]_{S} for the q4q^{4} cluster are derived as,

[31]FS[31]_{FS}
[31]FS[31]F[22]S[31]_{FS}[31]_{F}[22]_{S}[31]FS[31]F[31]S[31]_{FS}[31]_{F}[31]_{S}[31]FS[31]F[4]S[31]_{FS}[31]_{F}[4]_{S}
[31]FS[211]F[22]S[31]_{FS}[211]_{F}[22]_{S}[31]FS[211]F[31]S[31]_{FS}[211]_{F}[31]_{S}[31]FS[22]F[31]S[31]_{FS}[22]_{F}[31]_{S}
[31]FS[4]F[31]S[31]_{FS}[4]_{F}[31]_{S}

Table I. [31]FS[31]_{FS} spin-flavor configurations

ψ[31]λsf=−12ϕ[22]ρχ[31]ρ+12ϕ[22]λχ[31]λ+12ϕ[22]λχ[31]η\psi^{sf}_{[31]_{\lambda}}=-\frac{1}{2}\phi_{[22]_{\rho}}\chi_{[31]_{\rho}}+\frac{1}{2}\phi_{[22]_{\lambda}}\chi_{[31]_{\lambda}}+\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\phi_{[22]_{\lambda}}\chi_{[31]_{\eta}}
ψ[31]ρsf=−12ϕ[22]ρχ[31]λ−12ϕ[22]λχ[31]ρ+12ϕ[22]ρχ[31]η\psi^{sf}_{[31]_{\rho}}=-\frac{1}{2}\phi_{[22]_{\rho}}\chi_{[31]_{\lambda}}-\frac{1}{2}\phi_{[22]_{\lambda}}\chi_{[31]_{\rho}}+\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\phi_{[22]_{\rho}}\chi_{[31]_{\eta}}
ψ[31]ηsf=12ϕ[22]ρχ[31]ρ+12ϕ[22]λχ[31]λ(4)\psi^{sf}_{[31]_{\eta}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\phi_{[22]_{\rho}}\chi_{[31]_{\rho}}+\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\phi_{[22]_{\lambda}}\chi_{[31]_{\lambda}} \tag*{(4)}

The spatial wave functions of the q4qˉq^{4}\bar q pentaquark states may be expanded in the complete basis constructed from the harmonic oscillator wave functions, which take the general form,

ΨNLMq4qˉ[X]Y=∑{ni,li}A(nρ,nλ,nη,nξ,lρ,lλ,lη,lξ) ψnρlρ(ρ⃗)⊗ψnλlλ(λ⃗)⊗ψnηlη(η⃗)⊗ψnξlξ(ξ⃗)=∑{ni,li,mi}Cnρ,lρ,mρ,nλ,lλ,mλ,nη,lη,mη,nξ,lξ,mξ ψnρlρmρ(ρ⃗)ψnλlλmλ(λ⃗)ψnηlηmη(η⃗)ψnξlξmξ(ξ⃗)(5)\begin{aligned} \Psi^{q^{4}\bar q[X]_{Y}}_{NLM}=\sum_{\{n_{i},l_{i}\}}A(n_{\rho},n_{\lambda},n_{\eta},n_{\xi},l_{\rho},l_{\lambda},l_{\eta},l_{\xi})\, \psi_{n_{\rho}l_{\rho}}(\vec{\rho})\otimes\psi_{n_{\lambda}l_{\lambda}}(\vec{\lambda})\otimes\psi_{n_{\eta}l_{\eta}}(\vec{\eta})\otimes\psi_{n_{\xi}l_{\xi}}(\vec{\xi}) \\ &=\sum_{\{n_{i},l_{i},m_{i}\}}C_{n_{\rho},l_{\rho},m_{\rho},n_{\lambda},l_{\lambda},m_{\lambda},n_{\eta},l_{\eta},m_{\eta},n_{\xi},l_{\xi},m_{\xi}}\, \psi_{n_{\rho}l_{\rho}m_{\rho}}(\vec{\rho})\psi_{n_{\lambda}l_{\lambda}m_{\lambda}}(\vec{\lambda})\psi_{n_{\eta}l_{\eta}m_{\eta}}(\vec{\eta})\psi_{n_{\xi}l_{\xi}m_{\xi}}(\vec{\xi}) \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

with ψnilimi\psi_{n_{i}l_{i}m_{i}} being harmonic oscillator wave functions in the Jacobi coordinates ρ\rho, λ\lambda, η\eta, and ξ\xi,

ρ⃗=12(r⃗1−r⃗2)\vec{\rho}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\vec r_{1}-\vec r_{2})
λ⃗=16(r⃗1+r⃗2−2r⃗3)\vec{\lambda}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}(\vec r_{1}+\vec r_{2}-2\vec r_{3})
η⃗=112(r⃗1+r⃗2+r⃗3−3r⃗4)\vec{\eta}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{12}}(\vec r_{1}+\vec r_{2}+\vec r_{3}-3\vec r_{4})
ξ⃗=120(r⃗1+r⃗2+r⃗3+r⃗4−4r⃗5)(6)\vec{\xi}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{20}}(\vec r_{1}+\vec r_{2}+\vec r_{3}+\vec r_{4}-4\vec r_{5}) \tag*{(6)}

where the antiquark is assigned the coordinate r⃗5\vec r_{5}. NN, LL, and MM are respectively the total principle quantum number, total angular momentum and magnetic quantum number of the pentaquark, with

N=2nρ+lρ+2nλ+lλ+2nη+lη+2nξ+lξ(7)N=2n_{\rho}+l_{\rho}+2n_{\lambda}+l_{\lambda}+2n_{\eta}+l_{\eta}+2n_{\xi}+l_{\xi} \tag*{(7)}

[X]Y[X]_{Y} in (5) stand for all possible permutation symmetries of the q4q^{4} cluster, that is, [X]Y=[4]S[X]_{Y}=[4]_{S}, [31]ρ,λ,η[31]_{\rho,\lambda,\eta}, [211]ρ,λ,η[211]_{\rho,\lambda,\eta}, [22]ρ,λ[22]_{\rho,\lambda}. Coupling the antiquark to the q4q^{4} subsystem preserves the permutation symmetry properties of the q4q^{4} component within the q4qˉq^{4}\bar q pentaquark states, since ψnξlξ(ξ⃗)\psi_{n_{\xi}l_{\xi}}(\vec{\xi}) is fully symmetric for any permutation between quarks.

In principle, one can construct the harmonic oscillator basis for pentaquark states to any order by applying the permutations symmetry of the q4qˉq^{4}\bar q system to the general form in (5). The explicit normalized harmonic oscillator basis up to N=4N=4 are listed in Table II, where lρl_{\rho}, lλl_{\lambda}, lηl_{\eta}, and LL are limited to 0 only.

Ψ1[5]S\Psi^{[5]S}_{1}ψ000(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ000(η)ψ000(ξ)\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)\psi_{000}(\xi)
Ψ2[5]S\Psi^{[5]S}_{2}13[ψ100(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ000(η)ψ000(ξ)+ψ000(ρ)ψ100(λ)ψ000(η)ψ000(ξ)+ψ000(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ100(η)ψ000(ξ)]\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}[\psi_{100}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)\psi_{000}(\xi)+\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{100}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)\psi_{000}(\xi)+\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{100}(\eta)\psi_{000}(\xi)]
Ψ3[5]S\Psi^{[5]S}_{3}ψ000(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ000(η)ψ100(ξ)\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)\psi_{100}(\xi)
Ψ4[5]S\Psi^{[5]S}_{4}533[ψ200(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ000(η)+ψ000(ρ)ψ200(λ)ψ000(η)+ψ000(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ200(η)+65ψ100(ρ)ψ100(λ)ψ000(η)+65ψ100(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ100(η)+65ψ000(ρ)ψ100(λ)ψ100(η)]ψ000(ξ)\sqrt{\frac{5}{33}}[\psi_{200}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)+\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{200}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)+\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{200}(\eta)+\sqrt{\frac{6}{5}}\psi_{100}(\rho)\psi_{100}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)+\sqrt{\frac{6}{5}}\psi_{100}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{100}(\eta)+\sqrt{\frac{6}{5}}\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{100}(\lambda)\psi_{100}(\eta)]\psi_{000}(\xi)
Ψ5[5]S\Psi^{[5]S}_{5}13[ψ100(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ000(η)ψ100(ξ)+ψ000(ρ)ψ100(λ)ψ000(η)ψ100(ξ)+ψ000(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ100(η)ψ100(ξ)]\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}[\psi_{100}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)\psi_{100}(\xi)+\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{100}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)\psi_{100}(\xi)+\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{100}(\eta)\psi_{100}(\xi)]
Ψ6[5]S\Psi^{[5]S}_{6}ψ000(ρ)ψ000(λ)ψ000(η)ψ200(ξ)\psi_{000}(\rho)\psi_{000}(\lambda)\psi_{000}(\eta)\psi_{200}(\xi)

Table II. Normalized q4qˉq^{4}\bar q symmetric-type spatial wave functions.

Then, we calculate the q4qˉq^{4}\bar q pentaquark masses in the Hamiltonian [40, 42],

H=H0+HhypOGE,H=H_{0}+H_{\mathrm{hyp}}^{\mathrm{OGE}},
H0=∑k=1N(mk+p⃗k 22mk)+∑i<jN(−38λiC⋅λjC)(Aijrij−Bijrij),H_{0}=\sum_{k=1}^{N}\left(m_{k}+\frac{\vec{p}_{k}^{\,2}}{2m_{k}}\right)+\sum_{i<j}^{N}\left(-\frac{3}{8}\boldsymbol{\lambda}_{i}^{C}\cdot\boldsymbol{\lambda}_{j}^{C}\right)\left(A_{ij}r_{ij}-\frac{B_{ij}}{r_{ij}}\right),
HhypOGE=−COGE∑i<jλiC⋅λjCmimjσ⃗i⋅σ⃗j(8)H_{\mathrm{hyp}}^{\mathrm{OGE}}=-C_{\mathrm{OGE}}\sum_{i<j}\frac{\boldsymbol{\lambda}_{i}^{C}\cdot\boldsymbol{\lambda}_{j}^{C}}{m_{i}m_{j}}\vec{\sigma}_{i}\cdot\vec{\sigma}_{j} \tag*{(8)}

where AijA_{ij} and BijB_{ij} are mass-dependent coupling parameters, taking the form

Aij=amijmu,Bij=bmumij.(9)A_{ij}=a\sqrt{\frac{m_{ij}}{m_{u}}},\qquad B_{ij}=b\sqrt{\frac{m_{u}}{m_{ij}}}. \tag*{(9)}

with mijm_{ij} being the reduced mass of iith and jjth quarks, defined as mij=2mimjmi+mjm_{ij}=\frac{2m_{i}m_{j}}{m_{i}+m_{j}} which corresponds to the relative Jacobi coordinates of two-body system, COGE=Cmmu2C_{\mathrm{OGE}}=C_{m}m_{u}^{2}, with mum_{u} being the constituent uu quark mass and CmC_{m} a constant. λiC\boldsymbol{\lambda}^{C}_{i} in the above equations are the generators of color SU(3) group.

The three model coupling constants and four constituent quark masses are fitted to the low-lying baryon and ground heavy baryon spectra,

mu=md=327 MeV,ms=498 MeV,m_{u}=m_{d}=327\ \mathrm{MeV},\qquad m_{s}=498\ \mathrm{MeV},
mc=1642 MeV,mb=4960 MeV,m_{c}=1642\ \mathrm{MeV},\qquad m_{b}=4960\ \mathrm{MeV},
Cm=18.3 MeV,a=49500 MeV2,b=0.75(10)C_{m}=18.3\ \mathrm{MeV},\qquad a=49500\ \mathrm{MeV}^{2},\qquad b=0.75 \tag*{(10)}

The mass spectra of the ground state q4qˉq^{4}\bar q pentaquarks are evaluated by solving the Schrödinger equation in the Hamiltonian in Eq. (8), including the mixtures of the configurations of the identical flavor parts. The results are presented in Table III. It is predicted in the calculation that the pentaquark state with the [31]F[22]F[31]S[31]_{F}[22]_{F}[31]_{S} configuration and the quantum numbers I(JP)=12(12−)I(J^{P})=\frac{1}{2}(\frac{1}{2}^{-}) has the lowest mass, around 1680 MeV.

JPJ^{P}q4qˉq^{4}\bar q configurations(Sq4,Sqˉ,S)(S^{q^{4}},S^{\bar q},S)MEV(q4qˉ)M^{EV}(q^{4}\bar q) (MeV)
52−\frac{5}{2}^{-}Ψ[31]F[4]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[31]_{F}[4]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(2,1/2,5/2)(2,1/2,5/2)2269
32−\frac{3}{2}^{-}Ψ[4]F[31]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[4]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(1,1/2,3/2)(1,1/2,3/2)2269
32−\frac{3}{2}^{-}Ψ[31]F[4]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[31]_{F}[4]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(2,1/2,3/2)(2,1/2,3/2)1805
32−\frac{3}{2}^{-}Ψ[31]F[31]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[31]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(1,1/2,3/2)(1,1/2,3/2)2269
32−\frac{3}{2}^{-}Ψ[22]F[31]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[22]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(1,1/2,3/2)(1,1/2,3/2)2049
12−\frac{1}{2}^{-}Ψ[4]F[31]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[4]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(1,1/2,1/2)(1,1/2,1/2)2562
12−\frac{1}{2}^{-}Ψ[31]F[31]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[31]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(1,1/2,1/2)(1,1/2,1/2)1986
12−\frac{1}{2}^{-}Ψ[31]F[22]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[31]_{F}[22]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(0,1/2,1/2)(0,1/2,1/2)2162
12−\frac{1}{2}^{-}Ψ[22]F[31]Ssf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{sf}_{[22]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)(1,1/2,1/2)(1,1/2,1/2)1683

Table III. q4qˉq^{4}\bar q ground state pentaquark masses.

Formalism of helicity amplitudes in qL=13q^{3}_{L=1} and q4qˉL=0q^{4}\bar q_{L=0} mixing picture

We study the helicity amplitudes in the photoproduction transitions γ∗N→N(1520)/N(1535)\gamma^{*}N\to N(1520)/N(1535), as shown in Figure 1, where both the N(1520)3/2−N(1520)3/2^{-} and N(1535)1/2−N(1535)1/2^{-} resonances (N∗N^{*}) are considered in the mixing pictures of L=1L=1 three-quark configuration and L=0L=0 spatial symmetric q4qˉq^{4}\bar q pentaquark components,

Diagram of the $\gamma^*p \to N^*$ process

Figure 1. γ∗p→N∗\gamma^*p \to N^* process.

∣N∗,J⟩=B3q∣q3,L=1,J⟩+B5q∣q4qˉ,L=0,J⟩(11)\lvert N^{*},J\rangle=B_{3q}\lvert q^{3},L=1,J\rangle+B_{5q}\lvert q^{4}\bar q,L=0,J\rangle \tag*{(11)}

with B3q2+B5q2=1B_{3q}^{2}+B_{5q}^{2}=1 and J=1/2J=1/2 for N(1535)N(1535) and J=3/2J=3/2 for N(1520)N(1520). The momentum and mass of the initial NN and final N∗N^{*} in Figure 1 are denoted as (pi,MN)(p_{i},M_{N}) and (pf,MN∗)(p_{f},M_{N^{*}}), respectively. The helicity amplitudes are defined in the N∗N^{*} rest frame, where the square of the four-momentum transfer is expressed by Q2=−k2=∣k⃗∣2−ω2Q^{2}=-k^{2}=\lvert\vec{k}\rvert^{2}-\omega^{2} with the photon k=(ω,0,0,∣k⃗∣)k=(\omega,0,0,\lvert\vec{k}\rvert). The momentum conservation reads, pf=pi+kp_{f}=p_{i}+k. One has

ω=MN∗2−MN2−Q22MN∗\omega=\frac{M_{N^{*}}^{2}-M_{N}^{2}-Q^{2}}{2M_{N^{*}}}
∣k∣=[Q2+(MN∗2−MN2−Q22MN∗)2]12(12)|\mathbf{k}|=\left[Q^2+\left(\frac{M_{N^*}^2-M_N^2-Q^2}{2M_{N^*}}\right)^2\right]^{\frac{1}{2}} \tag*{(12)}

The general helicity amplitudes A1/2A_{1/2}, A3/2A_{3/2} and S1/2S_{1/2} for N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) consist of the contributions from both the three-quark and pentaquark components, according to Eq. (11).

The helicity amplitudes of N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) in the L=1L=1 three-quark picture has been evaluated within the approach in Refs. [38, 39], using the impulse approximation,

Ai(3q)=12K⟨N∗,Jz′=i|q1′q2′q3′⟩×T+(q1q2q3→q1′q2′q3′)⟨q1q2q3|N,Jz=i−1⟩,S12(3q)=12K⟨N∗,Jz′=12|q1′q2′q3′⟩×T0(q1q2q3→q1′q2′q3′)⟨q1q2q3|N,Jz=12⟩.(13)\begin{aligned} A_i^{(3q)}&=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2K}}\left\langle N^*,J'_z=i\middle|q'_1q'_2q'_3\right\rangle\\ &\quad\times T^+(q_1q_2q_3\to q'_1q'_2q'_3)\left\langle q_1q_2q_3\middle|N,J_z=i-1\right\rangle,\\ S_{\frac{1}{2}}^{(3q)}&=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2K}}\left\langle N^*,J'_z=\frac{1}{2}\middle|q'_1q'_2q'_3\right\rangle\\ &\quad\times T^0(q_1q_2q_3\to q'_1q'_2q'_3)\left\langle q_1q_2q_3\middle|N,J_z=\frac{1}{2}\right\rangle. \tag*{(13)} \end{aligned}

The wave functions of the proton, and the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances in the q3q^3 configuration are constructed in group theory approach [40, 41, 42], and their spatial wave functions are expanded in the harmonic oscillator basis in the three-quark picture [38, 39].

Then the helicity amplitudes of N∗N^* in the pentaquark picture with L=0L=0 symmetric spatial wave functions are derived through γ∗→qqˉ\gamma^*\to q\bar q mechanism shown in the Feynman diagram in Figure 2. This mechanism has been applied in Refs. [36, 37] to account for the pentaquark component and give a proper description of A1/2A_{1/2} of N(1535)N(1535). The helicity amplitudes A1/2A_{1/2}, A3/2A_{3/2} and S1/2S_{1/2} in the pentaquark picture are,

Diagram of the $\gamma^*p \to N^*(q^4\bar q)$ process via $\gamma^* \to q\bar q$ mechanism

Figure 2. Diagram of γ∗p→N∗(q4qˉ)\gamma^*p \to N^*(q^4\bar q) process via γ∗→qqˉ\gamma^* \to q\bar q mechanism.

Ai(5q)=12K⟨N∗,Jz′=i|q1′q2′q3′q4′qˉ5′⟩×T+(q1q2q3γ∗→q1′q2′q3′q4′qˉ5′)⟨q1q2q3|N,Jz=i−1⟩,S12(5q)=12K⟨N∗,Jz′=12|q1′q2′q3′q4′qˉ5′⟩×T0(q1q2q3γ∗→q1′q2′q3′q4′qˉ5′)⟨q1q2q3|N,Jz=12⟩.(14)\begin{aligned} A_i^{(5q)}&=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2K}}\left\langle N^*,J'_z=i\middle|q'_1q'_2q'_3q'_4\bar q'_5\right\rangle\\ &\quad\times T^+(q_1q_2q_3\gamma^*\to q'_1q'_2q'_3q'_4\bar q'_5)\left\langle q_1q_2q_3\middle|N,J_z=i-1\right\rangle,\\ S_{\frac{1}{2}}^{(5q)}&=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2K}}\left\langle N^*,J'_z=\frac{1}{2}\middle|q'_1q'_2q'_3q'_4\bar q'_5\right\rangle\\ &\quad\times T^0(q_1q_2q_3\gamma^*\to q'_1q'_2q'_3q'_4\bar q'_5)\left\langle q_1q_2q_3\middle|N,J_z=\frac{1}{2}\right\rangle. \tag*{(14)} \end{aligned}

with

K=MN∗2−MN22MN∗.(15)K=\frac{M_{N^*}^2-M_N^2}{2M_{N^*}}. \tag*{(15)}

where i=12i=\frac{1}{2} for A1/2A_{1/2} and i=32i=\frac{3}{2} for A3/2A_{3/2}, and KK in Eq. (12) is the real-photon momentum in the N∗N^* rest frame. ⟨q1q2q3∣N,Jz⟩\langle q_1q_2q_3\mid N,J_z\rangle in Eqs. (13) and (14) are the proton wave function, ⟨q1′q2′q3′∣N∗,Jz′⟩\langle q'_1q'_2q'_3\mid N^*,J'_z\rangle in Eq. (13) and ⟨q1′q2′q3′q4′qˉ5′∣N∗,Jz′⟩\langle q'_1q'_2q'_3q'_4\bar q'_5\mid N^*,J'_z\rangle in Eq. (14) are the wave functions of $L=1$ three-quark and $L=0$ pentaquark states respectively. The transition amplitudes $T(q_1q_2q_3\to q'_1q'_2q'_3q'_4\bar q'_5)$ through the $\gamma^*\to q\bar q$ process, as displayed in Fig. 2`, are calculated in the standard relativistic approach,

Tλ(q1q2q3γ∗→q1′q2′q3′q4′qˉ5′)=4equˉs′(p′)γμvs(p)ϵμλ(k)⟨q1′q2′q3′∣q1q2q3⟩=4eqTs′sλ⟨q1′q2′q3′∣q1q2q3⟩.(16)\begin{aligned} T^\lambda(q_1q_2q_3\gamma^*\to q'_1q'_2q'_3q'_4\bar q'_5) &=4e_q\bar u_{s'}(p')\gamma^\mu v_s(p)\epsilon_\mu^\lambda(k)\langle q'_1q'_2q'_3\mid q_1q_2q_3\rangle\\ &=4e_qT^\lambda_{s's}\langle q'_1q'_2q'_3\mid q_1q_2q_3\rangle. \tag*{(16)} \end{aligned}

where us′u_{s'} and vsv_s are the Dirac spinors of the corresponding quark and antiquark, eqe_q is the electric charge of the quark, and λ\lambda is the helicity of the photon. A factor of 4 is multiplied, considering the permutation symmetry of the four constituent quarks. The photon polarization vectors ϵμλ(k)\epsilon^\lambda_\mu(k) take ϵμ0=(1,0,0,0)\epsilon^0_\mu=(1,0,0,0) and ϵμ+=−12(0,1,i,0)\epsilon^+_\mu=-\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(0,1,i,0). ⟨q1′q2′q3′∣q1q2q3⟩\langle q'_1q'_2q'_3\mid q_1q_2q_3\rangle leads to three δ\delta functions, and thus the helicity amplitudes, TλT^\lambda are dominated by the transition amplitudes Ts′sλT^\lambda_{s's} in the quark-antiquark pair creation process γ∗→qqˉ\gamma^*\to q\bar q. The explicit matrix elements Ts′sλT^\lambda_{s's} for different spins of the quark-antiquark pair and the helicity λ=0,+1,−1\lambda=0,+1,-1, are presented in Eq. (22) in Appendix A. In this work, the mass of uu and dd quarks are taken to be the dynamical quark mass, m=5m=5 MeV.

The helicity amplitudes of pentaquark states, defined in Eq. (14), are calculated for all q4qˉq^4\bar q configurations listed in Table III. The helicity amplitudes for both J=12J=\frac{1}{2} and 32\frac{3}{2} pentaquark states took the general form,

Ai(5q)=12K⟨ΨNX|⟨ΨNSF|⟨ΨNC|T+(q1q2q3γ∗→q1′q2′q3′q4′qˉ5′)|ΨNC⟩|ΨNSF⟩|ΨNX⟩A_i^{(5q)}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2K}}\left\langle\Psi_N^X\middle|\left\langle\Psi_N^{SF}\middle|\left\langle\Psi_N^C\middle|T^+(q_1q_2q_3\gamma^*\to q'_1q'_2q'_3q'_4\bar q'_5)\middle|\Psi_N^C\right\rangle\middle|\Psi_N^{SF}\right\rangle\middle|\Psi_N^X\right\rangle

@page 4/8 starts_mid=0 ends_mid=1

A1/2(5q)=4e2K⟨ΨN∗X∣⟨ΨN∗SF∣⟨ΨN∗C∣Ts′s+∣ΨNC⟩∣ΨNSF⟩∣ΨNX⟩A_{1/2}^{(5q)}=\frac{4e}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|\langle\Psi^{SF}_{N^{*}}|\langle\Psi^{C}_{N^{*}}|T^{+}_{s's}|\Psi^{C}_{N}\rangle|\Psi^{SF}_{N}\rangle|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle
S1/2(5q)=e2K⟨ΨN∗X∣436(T↑↓0+T↑↓0)∣ΨNX⟩(17)S_{1/2}^{(5q)}=\frac{e}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|\frac{4}{3\sqrt{6}}(T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow}+T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow})|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle \tag*{(17)}
S1/2(5q)=12K⟨ΨN∗X∣⟨ΨN∗SF∣⟨ΨN∗C∣T0(q1q2q3γ∗→q1′q2′q3′q4′qˉ5′)∣ΨNC⟩∣ΨNSF⟩∣ΨNX⟩=4e2K⟨ΨN∗X∣⟨ΨN∗SF∣⟨ΨN∗C∣Ts′s0∣ΨNC⟩∣ΨNSF⟩∣ΨNX⟩(18)\begin{aligned} S_{1/2}^{(5q)}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|\langle\Psi^{SF}_{N^{*}}|\langle\Psi^{C}_{N^{*}}|T^{0}(q_{1}q_{2}q_{3}\gamma^{*}\to q'_{1}q'_{2}q'_{3}q'_{4}\bar q'_{5}) |\Psi^{C}_{N}\rangle|\Psi^{SF}_{N}\rangle|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle\\ &=\frac{4e}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|\langle\Psi^{SF}_{N^{*}}|\langle\Psi^{C}_{N^{*}}|T^{0}_{s's}|\Psi^{C}_{N}\rangle|\Psi^{SF}_{N}\rangle|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

where e=4παe=\sqrt{4\pi\alpha} with α=1/137\alpha=1/137 being the fine-structure constant, and the wave functions of L=0L=0 spatial symmetric pentaquark components and proton are written in terms of the spatial, color, spin-flavor parts ΨN∗X\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}, ΨN∗C\Psi^{C}_{N^{*}}, ΨN∗SF\Psi^{SF}_{N^{*}} and ΨNX\Psi^{X}_{N}, ΨNC\Psi^{C}_{N}, ΨNSF\Psi^{SF}_{N}, respectively. After calculating the matrix elements of color-spin-flavor parts ⟨ΨN∗SF∣⟨ΨN∗C∣Ts′sλ∣ΨNC⟩∣ΨNSF⟩\langle\Psi^{SF}_{N^{*}}|\langle\Psi^{C}_{N^{*}}|T^{\lambda}_{s's}|\Psi^{C}_{N}\rangle|\Psi^{SF}_{N}\rangle for all q4qˉq^{4}\bar q pentaquark configurations, the transition amplitudes, TλT^{\lambda} are derived as listed in Table IV.

q4qˉq^{4}\bar q configurationsJPJ^{P}M(q4qˉ)M(q^{4}\bar q) (MeV)A1/2q4qˉA_{1/2}^{q^{4}\bar q}A3/2q4qˉA_{3/2}^{q^{4}\bar q}S1/2q4qˉS_{1/2}^{q^{4}\bar q}
Ψ[211]C[31]FS[31]F[4]Scsf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{csf}_{[211]_{C}[31]_{F}S[31]_{F}[4]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)52−\frac{5}{2}^{-}2269000
32−\frac{3}{2}^{-}2025000
Ψ[211]C[31]FS[4]F[31]Scsf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{csf}_{[211]_{C}[31]_{F}S[4]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)12−\frac{1}{2}^{-}256200
32−\frac{3}{2}^{-}2269000
Ψ[211]C[31]FS[31]F[31]Scsf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{csf}_{[211]_{C}[31]_{F}S[31]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)12−\frac{1}{2}^{-}2123233T↑↑+\frac{2}{3\sqrt{3}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}233(T↑↓0−2T↑↓0)\frac{2}{3\sqrt{3}}(T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow}-2T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow})
32−\frac{3}{2}^{-}2049−436T↑↑+-\frac{4}{3\sqrt{6}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}−432T↑↑+-\frac{4}{3\sqrt{2}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}−436(T↑↓0+T↑↓0)-\frac{4}{3\sqrt{6}}(T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow}+T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow})
Ψ[211]C[31]FS[31]F[22]Scsf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{csf}_{[211]_{C}[31]_{F}S[31]_{F}[22]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)12−\frac{1}{2}^{-}2025−23T↑↑+-\frac{2}{\sqrt{3}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}23T↑↓0\frac{2}{\sqrt{3}}T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow}
Ψ[211]C[31]FS[22]F[31]Scsf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{csf}_{[211]_{C}[31]_{F}S[22]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q)12−\frac{1}{2}^{-}1683−233T↑↑+-\frac{2}{3\sqrt{3}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}−233(T↑↓0−2T↑↓0)-\frac{2}{3\sqrt{3}}(T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow}-2T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow})
32−\frac{3}{2}^{-}2049436T↑↑+\frac{4}{3\sqrt{6}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}432T↑↑+\frac{4}{3\sqrt{2}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}436(T↑↓0+T↑↓0)\frac{4}{3\sqrt{6}}(T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow}+T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow})

Table IV. Helicity amplitudes for the γ∗p→Nq4qˉ\gamma^{*}p \to N_{q^{4}\bar q} process (through γ∗→qqˉ\gamma^{*} \to q\bar q mechanism) in all configurations of ground state pentaquarks with isospin I=1/2I=1/2, expressed in terms of transition matrix elements Ts′sλT^{\lambda}_{s's}.

Results of helicity amplitudes of N(1520) and N(1535)

In the present calculation, we consider the simplest case that the L=0L=0 q4qˉq^{4}\bar q components mix with only one pentaquark state. The pentaquark state in the configuration Ψ[211]C[31]FS[22]F[31]Scsf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{csf}_{[211]_{C}[31]_{F}S[22]_{F}[31]_{S}}(q^{4}\bar q) is chosen as the representative since it has the lowest mass for JP=1/2−J^{P}=1/2^{-} and does not mix with other configurations. The helicity amplitudes of other (q4qˉ)(q^{4}\bar q) configurations differ only by an overall sign or multiplicative factor. For J=3/2J=3/2 (q4qˉ)(q^{4}\bar q) which contributes to γ∗p→N(1520)\gamma^{*}p\to N(1520) process, we have,

A1/2(5q)=e2K⟨ΨN∗X∣436T↑↑+∣ΨNX⟩A_{1/2}^{(5q)}=\frac{e}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|\frac{4}{3\sqrt{6}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle
A3/2(5q)=e2K⟨ΨN∗X∣432T↑↑+∣ΨNX⟩A_{3/2}^{(5q)}=\frac{e}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|\frac{4}{3\sqrt{2}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle
S1/2(5q)=e2K⟨ΨN∗X∣436(T↑↓0+T↓↑0)∣ΨNX⟩(19)S_{1/2}^{(5q)}=\frac{e}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|\frac{4}{3\sqrt{6}}(T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow}+T^{0}_{\downarrow\uparrow})|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle \tag*{(19)}

For J=1/2J=1/2 (q4qˉ)(q^{4}\bar q) which contributes to γ∗p→N(1535)\gamma^{*}p\to N(1535) process, the helicity amplitudes take the form,

A1/2(5q)=e2K⟨ΨN∗X∣−463T↑↑+∣ΨNX⟩A_{1/2}^{(5q)}=\frac{e}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|-\frac{4}{6\sqrt{3}}T^{+}_{\uparrow\uparrow}|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle
S1/2(5q)=e2K⟨ΨN∗X∣−463(T↑↓0−2T↓↑0)∣ΨNX⟩(20)S_{1/2}^{(5q)}=\frac{e}{\sqrt{2K}}\langle\Psi^{X}_{N^{*}}|-\frac{4}{6\sqrt{3}}(T^{0}_{\uparrow\downarrow}-2T^{0}_{\downarrow\uparrow})|\Psi^{X}_{N}\rangle \tag*{(20)}

The helicity amplitudes A1/2A_{1/2}, A3/2A_{3/2}, and S1/2S_{1/2} for N(1520)N(1520), as well as A1/2A_{1/2} and S1/2S_{1/2} for N(1535)N(1535) are computed for the L=1L=1 q3q^{3} and L=0L=0 q4qˉq^{4}\bar q components by integrating over all internal quark momenta of the proton and N(1520)N(1520) as well as N(1535)N(1535).

The theoretical helicity amplitudes A1/2A_{1/2}, A3/2A_{3/2}, and S1/2S_{1/2} for N(1520)N(1520), and A1/2A_{1/2} and S1/2S_{1/2} for N(1535)N(1535), calculated in the framework of the mixed three-quark and pentaquark configurations, are fitted to experimental data.

In the calculations, the proton spatial wave function is taken from Ref. [38], determined by fitting to experimental data of the proton electric form factor, and the spatial wave functions of the L=1L=1 q3q^{3} and L=0L=0 q4qˉq^{4}\bar q components of N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) as well as the mixing coefficients in Eq. (11) are adjusted by the fitting. The results of the helicity amplitudes for the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances are shown in Figure 3 and Figure 4, where the red solid lines represent the total helicity amplitudes obtained from the mixing picture, the blue dashed lines denote the contributions from the pentaquark component, and the green long-dashed lines correspond to the three-quark contributions. For comparison, we include two additional theoretical results for the helicity amplitudes. The first, derived within the same framework as the present work but restricted to pure L=1L=1 three-quark configurations [39], is shown as black dashed-dotted curves. The second, obtained from soft-wall AdS/QCD approaches [27, 28], is represented by shaded bands, that account for variation of model parameters by up to 20%. The predictions of the present model exhibit overall consistency with the soft-wall AdS/QCD predictions for both the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances, particularly in the low-Q2Q^2 region.

Helicity amplitudes of N(1520) in the mixing picture of three-quark and pentaquark components

Figure 3. Helicity amplitudes of N(1520)N(1520) in the mixing picture of three-quark and pentaquark components. Experimental data are taken from CLAS(JLab) data: circles (empty) [5], circles (bold) [6], triangle (bold) [8], triangle (empty) [9]; MAID(Mainz) data: diamond (empty) [10], diamond (bold) [11] and Particle Data Group (PDG) squares (empty) [43].

Helicity amplitudes of N(1535) in the mixing picture of three-quark and pentaquark components

Figure 4. Helicity amplitudes of N(1535)N(1535) in the mixing picture of three-quark and pentaquark components. Experimental data are taken from CLAS(JLab) data: circles (empty) [5], circles (bold) [6], squares (bold) [7]; MAID(Mainz) data: diamond (empty) [10], diamond (bold) [11] and Particle Data Group (PDG) squares (empty) [43].

The coefficients, B3q2B_{3q}^{2} and B5q2B_{5q}^{2} in Eq. (11), which represent the contributions of the q3q^3 and q4qˉq^4\bar{q} components, are derived,

N(1520):B3q2:B5q2=0.91:0.09,N(1520): B_{3q}^{2}:B_{5q}^{2}=0.91:0.09,
N(1535):B3q2:B5q2=0.75:0.25(21)N(1535): B_{3q}^{2}:B_{5q}^{2}=0.75:0.25 \tag*{(21)}

The studies in Refs. [36, 37], employing a non-relativistic framework and incorporating pentaquark components in both proton and the N(1535)N(1535) resonance, achieve an improved description of the helicity amplitude A1/2A_{1/2} for N(1535)N(1535) when assuming pentaquark admixtures of approximately 45% in N(1535)N(1535) and 20% in the proton. In contrast, our results indicate that a smaller pentaquark component in N(1535)N(1535) is sufficient to achieve a good agreement with the data. Moreover, all helicity amplitudes of the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) are simultaneously better reproduced in a smaller pentaquark components, suggesting a more moderate role of five-quark configurations.

As shown in Figure 3 and Figure 4, the three-quark contributions in the mixing picture remain largely consistent with the ones in the three-quark picture and still roughly describe the experimental data of the helicity amplitudes. It demonstrates that the three-quark L=1L = 1 states are still the main components in the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances. Notable deviations arise in the A1/2A_{1/2} and S1/2S_{1/2} amplitudes of N(1535)N(1535), particularly in the low-Q2Q^2 region, where the pentaquark components in N∗N^* yield significant contributions. The pentaquark components in N(1520)N(1520) contribute constructively to the helicity amplitude A3/2A_{3/2} and destructively to S1/2S_{1/2}. For N(1535)N(1535) the pentaquark components give a constructive contribution to S1/2S_{1/2} and significantly improve the agreement with experimental data, especially for Q2≤2 GeV2Q^2 \le2\ \mathrm{GeV}^2.

Summary and Discussion

In the present work we have fitted the helicity amplitudes of the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) in the γ∗p→N∗\gamma^*p \to N^* transition process to experimental data, where the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) are assumed including both the L=1L = 1 three-quark and L=0L = 0 symmetric pentaquark component. By introducing the pentaquark component of the Ψ[211]C[31]F[22]F[31]Scsf(q4qˉ)\Psi^{csf}_{[211]_C[31]_F[22]_F[31]_S}(q^4\bar{q}) configuration into the N∗N^*, a fairly well description of the helicity amplitudes A1/2A_{1/2}, A3/2A_{3/2}, and S1/2S_{1/2} for the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances over the region 0≤Q2≤4.5 GeV20 \le Q^2 \le4.5\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 is achieved. The extracted pentaquark components are approximately 9% for N(1520)N(1520), and 25% for N(1535)N(1535). The clear improvements to the N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) helicity amplitudes in the mixing picture suggest that pentaquark components in N∗N^* via the γ∗→qqˉ\gamma^* \to q\bar{q} process may play an important role in the lower Q2Q^2 regions, especially for the S1/2S_{1/2} amplitudes.

The only notable discrepancies with data occur in the transverse helicity amplitudes of N(1520)N(1520) at Q2≤0.5 GeV2Q^2 \le0.5\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 and the longitudinal amplitude of N(1535)N(1535) at Q2>2 GeV2Q^2 > 2\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. These deviations may originate from meson cloud contributions, higher-order gluonic exchange contributions, or other dynamical mechanisms, which are not included in the present model. This work serves a starting point for future comprehensive studies that will incorporate contributions of pentaquark components, meson-clouds, and higher-order gluonic exchanges.

Acknowledgments

This research has received funding support from the NSRF via the Program Management Unit for Human Resources and Institutional Development, Research and Innovation (PMU-B) [grant number B05F640055]. K. X. is additionally supported by SUT (Full-Time66/02/2024) and the NSRF via PMU-B (grant number B13F660067). A. L. and Y. Y. acknowledge the support of (i) Suranaree University of Technology (SUT), (ii) Thailand Science Research and Innovation (TSRI), and (iii) the National Science, Research and Innovation Fund (NSRF), project No. 204211.

Matrix elements of γ∗→qqˉ\gamma^* \to q\bar{q} process

The matrix elements Tλs′sλ′T_{\lambda s's}^{\lambda'} in Eq. (16) for the process γ∗→qqˉ\gamma^* \to q\bar{q} with the helicity λ=0,1\lambda= 0,1 are derived in the standard language of quantum field theory,

T↑↑0=(E′+m)(E+m)4E′E[p−E+m+p−′E′+m],T_{\uparrow\uparrow}^{0}=\sqrt{\frac{(E'+m)(E+m)}{4E'E}}\left[\frac{p_-}{E+m}+\frac{p'_-}{E'+m}\right],
T↑↓0=−(E′+m)(E+m)4E′E[pzE+m+pz′E′+m],T_{\uparrow\downarrow}^{0}=-\sqrt{\frac{(E'+m)(E+m)}{4E'E}}\left[\frac{p_z}{E+m}+\frac{p'_z}{E'+m}\right],
T↓↑0=(E′+m)(E+m)4E′E[pzE+m+pz′E′+m],T_{\downarrow\uparrow}^{0}=\sqrt{\frac{(E'+m)(E+m)}{4E'E}}\left[\frac{p_z}{E+m}+\frac{p'_z}{E'+m}\right],
T↓↓0=−(E′+m)(E+m)4E′E[p+E+m+p+′E′+m],T_{\downarrow\downarrow}^{0}=-\sqrt{\frac{(E'+m)(E+m)}{4E'E}}\left[\frac{p_+}{E+m}+\frac{p'_+}{E'+m}\right],
T↑↑+=2(E′+m)(E+m)4E′E[1−pz′pz(E′+m)(E+m)],T_{\uparrow\uparrow}^{+}=\sqrt{2}\sqrt{\frac{(E'+m)(E+m)}{4E'E}}\left[1-\frac{p'_z p_z}{(E'+m)(E+m)}\right],
T↑↓+=−2(E′+m)(E+m)4E′E[2pz′p+(E′+m)(E+m)],T_{\uparrow\downarrow}^{+}=-\sqrt{2}\sqrt{\frac{(E'+m)(E+m)}{4E'E}}\left[\frac{\sqrt{2}p'_z p_+}{(E'+m)(E+m)}\right],
T↓↑+=−2(E′+m)(E+m)4E′E[2p+′pz(E′+m)(E+m)],T_{\downarrow\uparrow}^{+}=-\sqrt{2}\sqrt{\frac{(E'+m)(E+m)}{4E'E}}\left[\frac{\sqrt{2}p'_+p_z}{(E'+m)(E+m)}\right],
T↓↓+=−2(E′+m)(E+m)4E′E[2p+′p+(E′+m)(E+m)](22)T_{\downarrow\downarrow}^{+}=-\sqrt{2}\sqrt{\frac{(E'+m)(E+m)}{4E'E}}\left[\frac{2p'_+p_+}{(E'+m)(E+m)}\right] \tag*{(22)}

where E′(p′)E'(p') and E(p)E(p) are respectively the energies (momenta) of the quark and antiquark, and p±=12(px±ipy)p_{\pm}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(p_x\pm ip_y). The quark and antiquark Dirac spinors take the form,

us′(p′)=E′+m2m(χs′σ⋅p′E′+mχs′),u_{s'}(p')=\sqrt{\frac{E'+m}{2m}}\begin{pmatrix}\chi_{s'}\\ \dfrac{\boldsymbol{\sigma}\cdot\mathbf{p}'}{E'+m}\chi_{s'}\end{pmatrix},
vs(p)=E+m2m(σ⋅pE+mχˉsχˉs)(23)v_s(p)=\sqrt{\frac{E+m}{2m}}\begin{pmatrix}\dfrac{\boldsymbol{\sigma}\cdot\mathbf{p}}{E+m}\bar{\chi}_s\\ \bar{\chi}_s\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(23)}

where the spin states of the antiquark are linked to the quark spin states by the charge conjugation C=iγ2γ0C=i\gamma^2\gamma^0, that is, χˉs=−iσ2χs\bar{\chi}_s=-i\sigma_2\chi_s. Thus we have,

↑=(10),↓=(01),↑ˉ=(01),↓ˉ=(−10)(24)\uparrow=\begin{pmatrix}1\\0\end{pmatrix},\quad\downarrow=\begin{pmatrix}0\\1\end{pmatrix},\quad\bar{\uparrow}=\begin{pmatrix}0\\1\end{pmatrix},\quad\bar{\downarrow}=\begin{pmatrix}-1\\0\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(24)}

References

References

  1. [1]R. Thompson et al. (The CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 1702 (2001).
  2. [2]I. G. Aznauryan, Phys. Rev. C 68, 065204 (2003).
  3. [3]M. M. Dalton et al., Phys. Rev. C 80, 015205 (2009).
  4. [4]I. G. Aznauryan, V. D. Burkert, W. Kim, K. Park, G. Adams, M. J. Amaryan, P. Ambrozewicz, M. Anghinolfi, G. Asryan, H. Avakian, H. Bagdasaryan, N. Baillie, J. P. Ball, N. A. Baltzell, S. Barrow, et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C 78, 045209 (2008).
  5. [5]I. G. Aznauryan et al., Phys. Rev. C 71, 015201 (2005).
  6. [6]I. G. Aznauryan et al. (CLAS), Phys. Rev. C 80, 055203 (2009), arXiv:0909.2349 [nucl-ex].
  7. [7]H. Denizli et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C 76, 015204 (2007).
  8. [8]V. I. Mokeev et al. (CLAS), Phys. Rev. C 86, 035203 (2012), arXiv:1205.3948 [nucl-ex].
  9. [9]V. I. Mokeev, V. D. Burkert, D. S. Carman, L. Elouadrhiri, G. V. Fedotov, E. N. Golovatch, R. W. Gothe, K. Hicks, B. S. Ishkhanov, E. L. Isupov, and I. Skorodumina, Phys. Rev. C 93, 025206 (2016).
  10. [10]D. Drechsel, S. S. Kamalov, and L. Tiator, Eur. Phys. J. A 34, 69 (2007), arXiv:0710.0306 [nucl-th].
  11. [11]L. Tiator, D. Drechsel, S. S. Kamalov, and M. Vanderhaeghen, Chin. Phys. C 33, 1069 (2009), arXiv:0909.2335 [nucl-th].
  12. [12]L. Tiator, D. Drechsel, S. S. Kamalov, and M. Vanderhaeghen, Eur. Phys. J. ST 198, 141 (2011), arXiv:1109.6745 [nucl-th].
  13. [13]D. Drechsel, S. S. Kamalov, and L. Tiator, The European Physical Journal A 34, 69 (2007).
  14. [14]I. Aznauryan and V. Burkert, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 67, 1 (2012).
  15. [15]G. Ramalho and M. T. Peña, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 136, 104097 (2024).
  16. [16]V. D. Burkert, R. De Vita, M. Battaglieri, M. Ripani, and V. I. Mokeev, Phys. Rev. C 67, 035204 (2003).
  17. [17]S. Capstick and B. D. Keister, Phys. Rev. D 51, 3598 (1995), arXiv:nucl-th/9411016.
  18. [18]E. Pace, G. Salmè, F. Cardarelli, and S. Simula, Nuclear Physics A 666-667, 33 (2000), the Structure of the Nucleon.
  19. [19]I. T. Obukhovsky, A. Faessler, D. K. Fedorov, T. Gutsche, and V. E. Lyubovitskij, Phys. Rev. D 100, 094013 (2019).
  20. [20]I. G. Aznauryan and V. D. Burkert, Phys. Rev. C 85, 055202 (2012).
  21. [21]I. G. Aznauryan and V. D. Burkert, Phys. Rev. C 95, 065207 (2017).
  22. [22]M. M. Giannini and E. Santopinto, Chin. J. Phys. 53, 020301 (2015), arXiv:1501.03722 [nucl-th].
  23. [23]M. M. Giannini, E. Santopinto, and A. Vassallo, Eur. Phys. J. A 12, 447 (2001), arXiv:nucl-th/0111073.
  24. [24]E. Santopinto and M. M. Giannini, Phys. Rev. C 86, 065202 (2012).
  25. [25]V. M. Braun, G. Göckeler, R. Horsley, T. Kaltenbrunner, A. Lenz, Y. Nakamura, D. Pleiter, P. E. L. Rakow, J. Rohrwild, A. Schäfer, G. Schierholz, H. Stüben, N. Warkentin, and J. M. Zanotti, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 072001 (2009).
  26. [26]I. V. Anikin, V. M. Braun, and N. Offen, Phys. Rev. D 92, 014018 (2015).
  27. [27]T. Gutsche, V. E. Lyubovitskij, and I. Schmidt, Phys. Rev. D 101, 034026 (2020).
  28. [28]V. E. Lyubovitskij and I. Schmidt, Phys. Rev. D 102, 094008 (2020).
  29. [29]V. D. Burkert and T. S. H. Lee, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 13, 1035 (2004), arXiv:nucl-ex/0407020.
  30. [30]H. Kamano, S. X. Nakamura, T.-S. H. Lee, and T. Sato, Phys. Rev. C 88, 035209 (2013).
  31. [31]D. Jido, M. Döring, and E. Oset, Phys. Rev. C 77, 065207 (2008).
  32. [32]G. Ramalho and M. T. Peña, Phys. Rev. D 89, 094016 (2014).
  33. [33]G. Ramalho and M. T. Peña, Phys. Rev. D 95, 014003 (2017).
  34. [34]G. Ramalho, D. Jido, and K. Tsushima, Phys. Rev. D 85, 093014 (2012).
  35. [35]B. Julia-Diaz, T. S. H. Lee, A. Matsuayama, T. Sato, and L. C. Smith, Phys. Rev. C 77, 045205 (2008), arXiv:0712.2283 [nucl-th].
  36. [36]C. S. An and B. S. Zou, The European Physical Journal A 39, 195 (2009).
  37. [37]B.-S. Zou, Nuclear Physics A 835, 199 (2010).
  38. [38]A. Kaewsnod, K. Xu, Z. Zhao, X. Y. Liu, S. Srisuphaphon, A. Limphirat, and Y. Yan, Phys. Rev. D 105, 016008 (2022).
  39. [39]A. Kaewsnod, K. Xu, Z. Zhao, X. Liu, S. Srisuphaphon, A. Limphirat, and Y. Yan, The European Physical Journal A 58, 185 (2022).
  40. [40]K. Xu, A. Kaewsnod, Z. Zhao, X. Y. Liu, S. Srisuphaphon, A. Limphirat, and Y. Yan, Phys. Rev. D 101, 076025 (2020).
  41. [41]K. Xu, N. Tr? [text unclear]
  42. [42]K. Xu, A. Kaewsnod, X. Y. Liu, S. Srisuphaphon, A. Limphirat, and Y. Yan, Phys. Rev. C 100, 065207 (2019).
  43. [43]S. Navas et al. (Particle Data Group), Phys. Rev. D 110, 030001 (2024).

Paper details

vlnc:W_ccewxssc
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents