betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Finite-Temperature Ferroelectric Phase Transitions from Machine-Learned Force Fields

Abstract

Simulating finite temperature phase transitions from first-principles is computationally challenging. Recently, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations using machine-learned force fields (MLFFs) have opened a new avenue for finite-temperature calculations with near-first-principles accuracy. Here we use MLFFs, generated using on-the-fly training, to investigate structural phase transitions in four of the most well-studied ferroelectric oxides; BaTiO3_3, PbTiO3_3, LiNbO3_3 and BiFeO3_3. Only using the 0 K ground state structure as input for the training, the resulting MLFFs can qualitatively predict all the main structural phases and phase transitions, while the quantitative results are sensitive to the choice of exchange correlation functional with PBEsol found to be more robust than LDA and r2^2SCAN. MD simulations also reproduce the experimentally observed order-disorder character of Ti displacements in BaTiO3_3, the abrupt first order transitions of BiFeO3_3 and PbTiO3_3, and the mixed order-disorder and displacive character of the ferroelectric transition in LiNbO3_3. Finally, we discuss the potential and limitations of using MLFFs for simulating ferroelectric phase transitions.

Introduction

Ferroelectric oxides, particularly perovskites, are of great technological and scientific interest and find applications in, e.g. sensors, actuators, transducers, and non-volatile memory technologies [1, 2, 3]. The mechanisms of their ferroelectric phase transitions are imperative in order to understand the microscopic origins of spontaneous polarisation, and is thus enabling knowledge for designing new and improved ferroelectrics. Although first-principles computational approaches have been tremendously successful in elucidating fundamental properties and mechanisms at 0 K [4, 5, 6, 7], the corresponding finite-temperature calculations have been prohibitively expensive. ab initio molecular dynamics has been feasible only for relatively small systems where long-range electrostatic interactions, such as those in ferroelectrics, are not well captured or described.

Machine-learned force fields (MLFFs), and in particular on-the-fly MLFFs [8, 9] have recently opened a new avenue for finite-temperature calculations with near-first-principles accuracy. Potentials are trained using a combination of molecular dynamics (MD), density functional theory (DFT), and machine learning to decide when to perform DFT steps and update force fields [10]. This approach can be utilised to train force fields for complex functional materials and allow for calculations of very large supercells that are not feasible using standard DFT. MLFFs have recently been used to predict phase transitions in a wide range of materials [11–20], but ferroelectric materials and their phase transitions pose an additional challenge with their sensitivity to pressure and lattice parameters, and inherent balance between long- and short-range forces [21, 22].

Ferroelectric materials show an electric field-switchable spontaneous electric polarisation that emerges from a phase transition from a centrosymmetric high-temperature structure to a non-centrosymmetric low-temperature structure at the Curie temperature (TCT_\mathrm{C}). BaTiO3_3, PbTiO3_3, BiFeO3_3, and LiNbO3_3 are prototypical ferroelectric materials, with the first three belonging to the perovskite family, whereas LiNbO3_3 adopts a closely related structure. These four ferroelectric oxides span I-V, II-IV and III-III distributions of formal oxidation states, they include two examples of d0d^0-driven second-order Jahn-Teller mechanism of stabilising polarisation, and two examples of A-site 6s26s^2 lone pair-driven polarisation, the latter two of which we find one multiferroic with a non-d0d^0 B-site (BiFeO3_3) and one with a d0d^0 B-site (PbTiO3_3) cation. These four well-studied oxides thus constitute a robust testing ground for applying MLFFs to understand ferroelectric phase transitions and we briefly review the basics of their phase transitions below.

BaTiO3_3 undergoes three phase transitions upon heating; R3m↔∼193 KAmm2↔∼273 KP4mm↔393 KPm3ˉmR3m \xleftrightarrow[\sim193\ \mathrm{K}]{} Amm2 \xleftrightarrow[\sim273\ \mathrm{K}]{} P4mm \xleftrightarrow[393\ \mathrm{K}]{} Pm\bar{3}m with the latter being the paraelectric aristotype phase [23]. All three phase transitions are first order and are associated with diverging dielectric constants and discontinuous volumes. While BaTiO3_3 is a prototypical displacive (soft-mode driven) ferroelectric, recent studies support a microscopic order-disorder picture rather than coherent, uniform displacements of Ti4+^{4+} relative to the centre of mass of the TiO6_6 octahedra [24–29].

In contrast to BaTiO3_3, PbTiO3_3, LiNbO3_3, and BiFeO3_3 each exhibit only a single bulk ferroelectric phase. PbTiO3_3 undergoes a first-order transition, P4mm↔768 KPm3ˉmP4mm \xleftrightarrow[768\ \mathrm{K}]{} Pm\bar{3}m [30], which is accompanied by a large, discontinuous decrease in molar volume. LiNbO3_3 keeps its trigonal symmetry across the polar to non-polar ferroelectric transition, R3c↔∼1480 KR3ˉcR3c \xleftrightarrow[\sim1480\ \mathrm{K}]{} R\bar{3}c [31, 32].

The ferroelectric phase transition of BiFeO3_3 initially proved difficult to study experimentally [33, 34] because of the high TCT_\mathrm{C}, the volatility of Bi, and the chemical incompatibility towards common sample supporting materials like platinum, alumina (Al2_2O3_3) and silica (SiO2_2) [35]. Arnold et al. conclusively established the nature of the ferroelectric transition of BiFeO3_3 to be R3c↔∼1100 KPbnmR3c \xleftrightarrow[\sim1100\ \mathrm{K}]{} Pbnm [36]. The absence of a group-subgroup relationship between $Pbnm and R3cR3c implies that this transition must be first order, and this is corroborated by a large negative change in molar volume and discontinuous enthalpy and electrical resistivity across TCT_{\mathrm{C}}[36, 37]. An even more debated phase transition of BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3} is that from paraelectric PbnmPbnm (the β\beta-phase, PnmaPnma is the standard setting) to the elusive γ\gamma-phase, occurring just ∼10\sim10 K below the peritectic decomposition temperature of ∼1200\sim1200 K [34, 35, 38].

In this work, we generate and use machine-learned force fields (MLFFs) as interatomic potentials to accurately predict phase transitions in the well-known ferroelectric oxides BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_{3}, PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO}_{3}, LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3} and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3}. We use only their ground state structure as input for training the force fields. Similar to 0 K first-principles calculations, we show that the quantitative results are strongly dependent on the choice of exchange-correlation functional. Finally, we discuss the potential and limitations of MLFFs for studying ferroelectrics.

Methods

Density functional theory (DFT) and molecular dynamics (MD) calculations were performed using the VASP code [39–41]. Interactions between core and valence electrons (Ba: (5s25s^{2}, 5p65p^{6}, 5d0.015d^{0.01}, 6s1.996s^{1.99}), Ti: (3s23s^{2}, 3p63p^{6}, 3d33d^{3}, 4s14s^{1}), O: (2s22s^{2}, 2p42p^{4}), Pb: (5d105d^{10}, 6s26s^{2}, 6p26p^{2}), Li: (1s21s^{2}, 2s12s^{1}), Nb: (4s24s^{2}, 4p64p^{6}, 4d44d^{4}, 5s15s^{1}), Bi: (5d105d^{10}, 6s26s^{2}, 6p36p^{3}), Fe: (3s23s^{2}, 3p63p^{6}, 3d73d^{7}, 4s14s^{1})) were described using the projector-augmented wave (PAW) method [42, 43]. A large plane-wave energy cutoff of 700 eV was used for all DFT calculations to avoid Pulay stresses associated with the large volume changes during the training of the MLFFs. Three sets of MLFFs were generated using LDA [44], PBEsol [45] and r2^{2}SCAN [46] and used for MD simulations to assess the consequences of generating interatomic potentials using different functionals. MD simulations were performed within the NpT ensemble using the Parrinello-Rahman barostat [47, 48] with a pressure of 1 atm and the Langevin thermostat [49]. Langevin friction coefficients were set to 5 ps−1^{-1} for all atoms. A fictitious mass of 1000 amu and a friction coefficient of 5 ps−1^{-1} were used for the lattice degrees of freedom for all simulations. DFT calculations of BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3} were initialised with a G-type antiferromagnetism, and a Hubbard UU of 4 eV was used when generating MLFFs with LDA and PBEsol.

An initial equilibration was first performed of the DFT optimised ground state structures using the on-the-fly scheme at temperatures of 50 K, 300 K, 500 K and 500 K for BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_{3}, PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO}_{3}, LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3} and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3}, respectively. The equilibrations were performed using 50000 time steps with a step length of 1 fs. Supercells of 120 atoms, similar to a 2×2×12 \times2 \times1 expansion of the conventional R3cR3c unit cell of LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3} and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3}, were used for the initial equilibrations and all training. This supercell allows for anti-phase tilting of O octahedra in all directions and maximises the cell size without making the generation of interatomic potentials too computationally demanding. γ\gamma-centred k-point grids of 3×3×23 \times3 \times2 were used for all DFT calculations. All interatomic potentials generated during the initial equilibriums were discarded.

Generation of MLFFs was done by heating (100 steps per K) the equilibrated structures from the initial temperatures to temperatures well above the respective ferroelectric phase transition (BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_{3}: 500 K, PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO}_{3}: 1000 K, LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3}: 1700 K and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3}: 1300 K) using the on-the-fly scheme. A cutoff radius of 8 Å was used to limit the atomic environments described by MLFFs. Generated MLFFs are uploaded to zenodo [50].

Thereafter, production runs were done with equilibrium MD simulations at specific temperatures using the generated potentials. Production runs were carried out in series, meaning that simulations were performed from low to high temperature, where the final structure of the previous calculation was used as the initial structure of the next calculation. The length of all production runs was 40 ps with a time step of 1 fs. For all calculations, the lattice parameters converged within 20 ps, and only the final 20 ps of each simulation were analysed. For PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO}_{3}, LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3} and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3} a supercell containing 2000 atoms, similar to a 5×5×45 \times5 \times4 expansion of the conventional PbnmPbnm unit cell of BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3}, was used for all production runs. Due to narrow temperature intervals of the different phases, simulations of BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_{3} were performed using a 4900 atom supercell (7×7×57 \times7 \times5 expansion) to reduce thermal fluctuations.

Results

Lattice parameters as a function of temperature for BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_{3}, PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO}_{3}, LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3} and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3} are displayed in Figure 1, Figure 4, Figure 5 and Figure 7, respectively. The top panels show average lattice parameters from equilibrium MD simulations using MLFFs generated with the PBEsol functional, while the bottom panels show experimental lattice parameters from the literature [36, 51–53]. In SI Figure S4, Figure S7, Figure S11 and Figure S15 the experimental and simulated lattice parameters are plotted together as a function normalised to the TCT_{\mathrm{C}}. Results from simulations using MLFFs generated with LDA and r2^{2}SCAN are displayed in the SI Figure S6, Figure S10, Figure S14 and Figure S18.

Evolution of lattice parameters as a function of temperature for BaTiO3

Figure 1. Evolution of lattice parameters as a function of temperature for BaTiO3_3. The top panel displays predicted lattice parameters from MD simulations performed using MLFFs generated with the PBEsol functional, while the bottom panel shows experimental results from Kay et al. [51]. The dashed and dotted vertical black lines indicate the phase transition temperatures.

Evolution of lattice parameters as a function of temperature for PbTiO3

Figure 4. Evolution of lattice parameters as a function of temperature for PbTiO3_3. The top panel displays predicted lattice parameters from the MD simulations using MLFFs generated with the PBEsol functional, while the bottom panel shows experimental results from Shirane et al. [52]. The dashed and dotted vertical black lines indicate the phase transition temperatures.

Evolution of lattice parameters as a function of temperature for LiNbO₃

Figure 5. Evolution of lattice parameters as a function of temperature for LiNbO₃. Lattice parameters are converted from the hexagonal conventional unit cell to a pseudocubic cell by dividing aa and cc by 2\sqrt{2} and 12\sqrt{12}, respectively. The top panel displays predicted lattice parameters from the MD simulations using MLFFs generated with the PBEsol functional, while the bottom panel shows experimental results from Lehnert et al. [53]. The dashed and dotted vertical black lines indicate the phase transition temperatures.

Evolution of lattice parameters as a function of temperature for BiFeO3

Figure 7. Evolution of lattice parameters as a function of temperature for BiFeO3_3. Similar to LiNbO3_3, in the rhombohedral phase, lattice parameters are converted from the hexagonal conventional unit cell to a pseudocubic cell by dividing aa and cc by 2\sqrt{2} and 12\sqrt{12}, respectively. Lattice parameters from the orthorhombic structure are converted by dividing a/ba/b and cc by 2\sqrt{2} and 22, respectively. The top panel displays predicted lattice parameters from the MD simulations in this work, while the bottom panel shows experimental results from Arnold et al. [36]. The dashed and dotted vertical black lines indicate the phase transition temperatures.

Lattice parameters calculated using PBEsol compared to experimental lattice parameters

Figure S4. Lattice parameters, calculated using PBEsol, compared to experimental lattice parameters by Kay et al. [7] as a function of temperature normalised to TCT_\mathrm{C}.

Image not extracted

Figure S6. Average lattice parameters as a function of temperature calculated with MLFFs generated using the LDA (first panel), PBEsol (second panel) and r²SCAN (third panel) functional. The fourth panel show experimental data by Kay et al. [7].

Image not extracted

Figure S7. Calculated lattice parameters compared to experimental lattice parameters by Shirane et al. [8] as a function of temperature normalised to TCT_\mathrm{C}.

Image not extracted

Figure S10. Average lattice parameters as a function of temperature calculated with MLFFs generated using the LDA (first panel), PBEsol (second panel) and r2r^{2}SCAN (third panel) functional. The fourth panel show experimental data by Shirane et al. [8].

Image not extracted

Figure S11. Calculated lattice parameters compared to experimental lattice parameters by Lehnert et al. [9] as a function of temperature normalised to TCT_\mathrm{C}. Lattice parameters are converted from the hexagonal conventional unit cell to a pseudocubic cell by dividing a/b and c by 2\sqrt{2} and 12\sqrt{12}, respectively.

Image not extracted

Figure S14. Average lattice parameters as a function of temperature calculated with MLFFs generated using the LDA (first panel), PBEsol (second panel) and r2^{2}SCAN (third panel) functional. The fourth panel show experimental data by Lehnert et al. [9].

Calculated and experimental lattice parameters as a function of normalised temperature

Figure S15. Calculated lattice parameters compared to experimental lattice parameters by Arnold et al. [10] as a function of temperature normalised to TCT_\mathrm{C}. Similar to LiNbO3_3, in the rhombohedral phase, lattice parameters are converted from the hexagonal conventional unit cell to a pseudocubic cell by dividing a/ba/b and cc by 2\sqrt{2} and 12\sqrt{12}, respectively. Lattice parameters from the orthorhombic structure are converted by dividing a/ba/b and cc by 2\sqrt{2} and 22, respectively.

Average lattice parameters as a function of temperature

Figure S18. Average lattice parameters as a function of temperature calculated with MLFFs generated using the LDA (first panel), PBEsol (second panel) and r2^{2}SCAN (third panel) functional. The fourth panel show experimental data by Arnold et al. [10].

BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_{3}

Equilibrium MD simulations, using MLFFs generated with PBEsol, qualitatively predict all the correct phases and transitions for BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_{3} upon heating. Estimated phase transition temperatures are systematically about 70 K lower than experimentally observed transition temperatures [51]. The calculated lattice parameters are in general about 0.01 Å larger than the experimental values, which can be attributed to the subtle underbinding tendency of PBEsol [54]. Except for the underestimated transition temperatures, the main difference between the experimental and our calculated lattice parameters is the change in volume over the phase transitions. Kay et al. [51] reports a small increase in volume at the transition from R3mR3m to Amm2Amm2 and from Amm2Amm2 to P4mmP4mm. While our calculations predict a subtle decrease in volume at these transitions, the negative volume change across the ferroelectric transition is correctly reproduced by our simulations.

The LDA and r2^{2}SCAN functionals also predict the correct phases and transitions. However, LDA underestimates the lattice parameters (SI Figure S6), due to its well-known tendency to overbind [55], while r2^{2}SCAN overestimates the lattice parameters. Furthermore, this is reflected in the estimated phase transition temperatures, where LDA predicts erroneously low transition temperatures, while transition temperatures from r2^{2}SCAN are closer to the experimental values than those predicted from PBEsol (Figure 1).

The probability distributions of the absolute Ti displacements in BaTiO3_3 at various temperatures, shown in Figure 2, reveal a decrease in the Ti displacements upon heating up to the formation of the cubic phase. As the temperature increases further, the Ti displacements gradually increase. Each phase transition is marked by a step-like shift in the peak position, as indicated by the dashed vertical lines. Additionally, the probability distributions broaden with increasing temperature, reflecting enhanced thermal fluctuations.

Probability distribution of absolute displacements of Ti in BaTiO3

Figure 2. Probability distribution of absolute displacements of Ti in BaTiO3_3 from equilibrium MD simulations using MLFFs generated with PBEsol. The colours indicate the average space groups (turquoise: R3mR3m, orange: Amm2Amm2, blue: P4mmP4mm, green: Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m) and the dashed vertical lines are guidelines for the peak positions.

The direction of the Ti displacements at 50 K, 150 K, 250 K and 350 K are displayed using Mercator projections shown in Figure 3. At 50 K, all Ti atoms are displayed in one of the ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1, 1, 1\rangle directions, consistent with the R3mR3m space group. At 150 K, Ti atoms are displaced in two different ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1, 1, 1\rangle directions, and the average orientation of the displacements gives rise to the direction of the macroscopic polarisation observed in orthorhombic BaTiO3_3. Moreover,

Mercator projections showing the direction of the Ti displacements in BaTiO3 at 50 K, 150 K, 250 K and 350 K

Figure 3. Mercator projections showing the direction of the Ti displacements in BaTiO3_3 at 50 K, 150 K, 250 K and 350 K extracted from equilibrium MD simulations using MLFFs generated with the PBEsol functional. Small orange data points display the direction of the displacement of single Ti atoms from the centre of the respective O octahedra relative to the ⟨1,0,0⟩\langle1,0,0\rangle (green squares) and ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle (blue diamonds) directions. Mercator projections for the orientation of the Ba displacements are shown in SI Figure S5.

at 250 K, Ti atoms are disordered in between four different ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1, 1, 1\rangle directions, where the average gives rise to tetragonal BaTiO3_3. At 350 K, the orientation of the Ti displacements is disordered between all ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1, 1, 1\rangle directions. A similar cation off-centring has, for instance, been reported by K. Page et al. for Nb-substituted cubic BaTiO3_3 [56]. Thermal energy gives broader distributions, making the disorder between ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1, 1, 1\rangle directions at higher temperatures less obvious.

The temperature-dependent evolution of Ti displacements, as visualised in the Mercator projections, clearly supports the order-disorder picture of phase transitions in BaTiO3_3 [24–27, 57, 58]. Similar to work by Holma et al. [28], our calculations do not support the formation of static linear chains of correlated displacements proposed by Comes et al. [24, 58], but are instead more consistent with the dynamic description by Hüller et al. and Harada et al. [29, 59, 60].

PbTiO3_3

Simulations of PbTiO3_3 using PBEsol, Figure 4, show the same lattice parameter evolution as reported from the seminal experiments by Shirane et al. [52], albeit a significantly lower transition temperature of about 230 K. Both simulations and experiments show a slowly decreasing cell volume with increasing temperature up until the phase transition followed by a significant reduction at the transition temperature. Thereafter, a slow increase in volume with increasing temperature is observed. Similar results are shown by

LDA and r2^2SCAN and are displayed in SI Figure S10. LDA, again, severely underestimates the lattice parameters and the phase transition temperature, while r2^2SCAN overestimates the lattice parameters.

Probability distributions of the displacements of Pb and Ti from the centre of oxygen polyhedra, in SI Figure S1, show that both cations are significantly displaced at all temperatures. These distributions show a clear change in trend and jump in peak position from 500 K to 550 K (see also plotted peak positions in SI Figure S2). Similar to the ferroelectric transition in BaTiO3_3, at the TC_\mathrm{C}, the average atomic displacements from polyhedral centres reverts from decreasing, go through a minimum and start increasing upon further heating.

Contrary to BaTiO3_3, in the P4mm phase, cation displacements in PbTiO3_3 are not disordered and only displaced along one ⟨0,0,1⟩\langle0,0,1\rangle direction, as reported experimentally by Kwei et al. [26] and supported by the Mercator projections in SI Figure S8 and SI Figure S9. Above the TC_\mathrm{C}, in the paraelectric phase, the displacements are fully disordered in all directions.

The average B-cation displacement was also fitted as a function of the temperature to the power law A(TC−T)βA(T_\mathrm{C}-T)^\beta, giving a value of 0.27 for the critical exponent β\beta. This is reasonably close to the theoretical prediction of 0.25 for a tricritical phase transition, as expected for PbTiO3_3. For more details on the calculation of critical exponents, see SI Section II.

LiNbO₃

Similar to lattice parameters from experiments by Lehnert et al. [53] and Sugii et al. [61], the calculated aa lattice parameter increases linearly up to and beyond the phase transition, while the cc parameter starts decreasing when approaching the phase transition temperature (Figure 5). Due to the second-order nature of the phase transition in LiNbO₃, the Curie temperature is very difficult to estimate exclusively from the changes in lattice parameters alone. However, similar to the probability distributions for cation displacements in BaTiO₃, PbTiO₃ and BiFeO₃ (SI Figure S1), there is a clear abrupt change in the evolution of the absolute displacements of Li and Nb from 1100 K to 1200 K, indicating the TCT_\mathrm{C} to be in between these temperatures. Using MLFFs generated with PBEsol, the predicted TCT_\mathrm{C} is about 300 K lower than the experimentally observed TCT_\mathrm{C}. With LDA and r²SCAN, lattice parameters are again underestimated and overestimated, respectively, see SI Figure S14.

Below the TCT_\mathrm{C}, both Li and Nb are displaced along the same ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle direction. Displacements along this [1, 1, 1] direction, displayed in Figure 6, highlight the differences between Li and Nb when approaching the phase transition temperature. Li, Figure 6 (a), clearly show an order-disorder transition, while Nb show a displacive transition. Similar distributions and results have been reported from ab initio MD by Sanna et al. [62]. The order-disorder and the displacive transitions are also clearly shown in the Mercator projections in SI Figure S12 and S13, respectively. Mixed displacive and order-disorder characteristics of a ferroelectric transition have also been observed for other uniaxial ferroelectrics like hexagonal manganites, h-RMnO₃ [63].

Probability distributions of Li and Nb displacements

Figure 6. Probability distributions, from equilibrium MD simulations using MLFFs generated with the PBEsol functional, of Li (a) and Nb (b) displacements in the polar direction [1, 1, 1] direction. The colours indicate the space groups (blue: R3cR3c, green: R3ˉcR\bar{3}c) and the gradient shows the temperature.

From 1100 K to 1200 K, at the estimated TCT_\mathrm{C}, there is a jump in the evolution of the displacements of both Li and Nb. However, the distributions of Li and Nb indicate that the material is still weakly polar, which could be explained by insufficient thermal energy to reach full ergodicity within the limited simulation time analysed.

A power law fitting of the average B-cation displacement resulted in a β\beta-value of 0.34, in very good agreement with the expected value for a second-order ferroelectric phase transition, as well as the experimental value of β=0.355\beta= 0.355 measured for isostructural LiTaO₃ [64].

BiFeO₃

Both the non-linearity and the thermal stability of the ferroelectric R3cR3c phase of BiFeO₃ is fairly well described by the PBEsol-based simulations, including the premonitory phenomenon of the lattice parameter cc, parallel to the spontaneous polarisation (similar to LiNbO₃), starting to contract as TCT_\mathrm{C} is approached [36]. The large negative and discontinuous volume change across the ferroelectric phase transition of BiFeO₃ is also reproduced, as shown in Figure 7, in agreement with Arnold et al. [36].

At the TCT_\mathrm{C}, MLFFs generated using LDA and PBEsol predict a transition from rhombohedral R3cR3c to orthorhombic PbnmPbnm, with LDA again underestimating the lattice parameters. r²Scan, on the other hand, gives a qualitatively different result and shows a transition from R3cR3c directly to cubic Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m. Using LDA and PBEsol, the difference between the calculated aa, bb, and cc lattice parameters in the PbnmPbnm phase is substantially larger than experimentally reported. However, DFT-optimised lattice parameters at 0 K give similar values, see SI Table S1.

The volume contraction of the unit cell is also reflected in the distributions of absolute cation displacements, shown in SI Figure S1, with drastic changes to the peak positions for both the Bi and Fe distributions. Except for the abnormal changes at the TCT_\mathrm{C}, these peak positions show only a weak temperature dependence (SI Figure S2). These distributions show increased broadening as a function of increasing temperature for the displacements of both Bi and Fe.

The Mercator projections for Bi and Fe, in SI Figure S16 and S17, are relatively similar to the Mercator projections for LiNbO₃, with the main differences being a very abrupt phase transition in BiFeO₃ and the fact that the displacements of Bi are not disordered, but instead ordered in an alternating fashion in the high-temperature phase, in agreement with the structural degrees of freedom of the paraelectric PbnmPbnm phase.

Discussions

The observed underestimation of phase transition temperatures may be caused by several factors. Finite size effects, due to the use of limited cell sizes and periodic boundary conditions during both generation of MLFFs and production runs, will prevent the system from behaving as it would have done at the thermodynamic limit. As ferroelectric phase transitions are governed by long-range collective displacements of atoms, local fluctuations of the positions of individual atoms may easily destabilise the ferroic order. Moreover, MLFFs in VASP only describe the environment around atoms closer than a specific cutoff radius (default: 8 Å), and thus, long-range interactions are not directly described by the generated MLFFs. Furthermore, ferroelectric materials often experience decreasing and more diffuse TCT_{\mathrm{C}} with decreasing particle sizes [65–72]. Strain from the surfaces hinders the collective displacements and suppresses the ferroelectric phase.

A larger cutoff radius as well as larger supercells for both production runs and training of the interatomic potentials may mitigate the present errors in transition temperatures. However, increasing the cell size significantly will be computationally expensive. Supporting this notion, it has been reported that for LiNbO3_3 performing ab initio MD with a 80 atom supercell underestimates the TCT_{\mathrm{C}} significantly [62], while a 640 atom supercell gives a TCT_{\mathrm{C}} very close to the experimental value [73]. Additionally, generating MLFFs using different exchange correlation functionals has proven to give vastly different transition temperatures [12, 13], and thus, finding the optimal functional for the system is crucial. As of now, there is no "safe" choice of a single functional for training MLFFs for predicting ferroelectric phase transitions.

In BaTiO3_3, the spontaneous polarisation is solely due to second-order Jahn-Teller distortions caused by partial covalency between Ti 3d3d and O 2p2p. This results in Ti being displaced towards one of the faces of the O octahedron, causing polarisation in one of the ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle directions. The other directions of polarisation observed experimentally are just combinations of polarisation in multiple ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle directions, as visualised with the Mercator projections in Figure 3. PbTiO3_3 also has Ti d0d^0, but only shows polarisation in the ⟨0,0,1⟩\langle0,0,1\rangle directions, reflecting that the lone pair, caused by hybridisation of Pb 6s6s and 6p6p states, dictates the direction of the polarisation and the strongly coupled unit cell distortion. Furthermore, G. Laurita et al. showed that the introduction of lone pair cations, by Sn-substitution in BaTiO3_3, drives local ordering and results in a behaviour closely resembling that of PbTiO3_3 [74].

Similar to BaTiO3_3, polarisation in LiNbO3_3 is only caused by d0d^0 second-order Jahn-Teller distortions. In spite of this, LiNbO3_3 only show two different phases (R3cR3c and R3ˉcR\bar{3}c). The small size of Li atoms stabilises antiferrodistortive rotations and thus also the R3cR3c and R3ˉcR\bar{3}c phases. This also explains the order-disorder character of Li observed in Figure 6 (a) and in the Mercator projections in SI Figure S12. Li is too small to be stable in the centre of the O polyhedra even at temperatures above the TCT_{\mathrm{C}}.

Image not extracted

Figure S12. Mercator projections showing the direction of the Li displacements in LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3} at 500 K, 1000 K, 1200 K and 1400 K relative to the ⟨1,0,0⟩\langle1,0,0\rangle (green squares) and ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle (blue diamonds) directions.

The simulated lattice parameters differ quantitatively from the experimental for the high-temperature PbnmPbnm phase of BiFeO3_3, with the simulated unit cell being more metrically distorted. This is one possible reason why a transition to the experimentally observed γ\gamma-phase is not found in our simulations. Another obvious reason for the discrepancy is the possible evaporation of Bi and O at high temperatures, which would be very challenging to accurately predict and represent computationally. Our current simulations within the isothermal-isobaric NpT ensemble do not allow exchange of particles, and extending the MLFF approach to the grand canonical ensemble implies several challenges we will not discuss further here. Experiments where 30 molar % of Fe has been replaced by Mn to lower the structural phase transition temperatures agree on the TCT_{\mathrm{C}} and the symmetries of the ferroelectric and the paraelectric phases, but not on the γ\gamma-phase [75, 76], emphasizing the challenging nature of this particular phase transition and the need for further work to clarify e.g. the possible role of non-stoichiometry.

In general, except for special situations, the choice of functional does not change the results qualitatively. Moreover, disregarding thermal expansion, the generated MLFFs closely follow lattice parameters from regular DFT calculations with the respective functional. LDA is known to underestimate lattice parameters [77], which is reflected in the MD simulations using MLFFs generated with LDA. This leads to further underestimation of phase transition temperatures, which can make it difficult to separate and study phases that experimentally show narrow temperature windows such as BaTiO3_3. Similarly, r2^2SCAN has been shown to, on average, overestimate lattice parameters [46], and our MD simulations, performed using MLFFs generated with r2^2SCAN, also tend to overestimate lattice parameters. Furthermore, these MLFFs fail to correctly describe both phase transitions in BiFeO3_3, which may partly be due to the overestimate[d] lattice parameters. Our results suggest that functionals that agree well with experimental values at the DFT level also result in MLFFs that accurately describe lattice parameters at elevated temperatures. Therefore, PBEsol is, in most situations, a good choice in terms of both speed and accuracy.

A major advantage of using MD simulations is access to massive supercells. This can allow for calculations of larger phenomena such as surfaces, grain boundaries, superstructures, amorphous materials, nanoparticles, and domain walls and their interactions with defects. The flexibility of using on-the-fly machine-learned interatomic potentials makes it easy to apply the methodology shown in this work to phenomena such as those mentioned above, as well as to completely new and unknown systems. The balance between long-range and short-range electrostatic forces, and the dipole-stabilizing second-order Jahn-Teller effect (or improper ferroelectric mechanisms) is particularly challenging for MLFFs, necessarily leading to difficult trade-offs between cost and accuracy. However, this also implies that ferroelectrics are ideal test beds for further method development of MLFF approaches to achieve near-first-principles accuracy at a fraction of the cost.

Conclusions

We have demonstrated that we can accurately predict lattice parameters and phase transitions of ferroelectric materials using MLFFs trained from first-principles calculations. Qualitatively, our calculations get all the correct phases and transitions, except for the β\beta-γ\gamma transition in BiFeO3_3, although predicted phase-transition temperatures are in general significantly lower than what is observed experimentally. This method can be used to resolve and describe more subtle structural changes, such as the magnitude of the B-cation displacements and the orientation of these displacements.

Acknowledgments

The simulations were performed with resources provided by Sigma2 - the National Infrastructure for High-Performance Computing and Data Storage in Norway through project NN9264K. Support for this project was provided from the Research Council of Norway through projects 302506, 301954, and 354614.

SI - Finite-Temperature Ferroelectric Phase Transitions from Machine-Learned Force Fields

Kristoffer Eggestad; Ida C. Skogvoll; Øystein Gullbrekken; Benjamin A. D. Williamson; Sverre M. Selbach

All data presented in figures in the SI, unless explicitly stated, show results from MD simulations using MLFFs generated with the PBEsol functional. In general, the different functionals lead to qualitatively similar results, and thus, presenting all the data from the three different functionals investigated in this work is somewhat superfluous. We chose PBEsol to represent our results as it has been shown to give lattice parameters close to experimental values [1, 2, 3]. The main differences between the different functionals are the calculated lattice parameters and are highlighted in SI Figure S6, S10, S14 and S18.

A- AND B-CATION DISPLACEMENTS

Figure S1 shows probability distributions of the absolute displacements of cations from the O polyhedra centre calculated using the MLFFs generated using the PBEsol functional. From top to bottom, the panels show distributions for BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO_3}, PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO_3}, LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO_3} and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3}. The left and right panels display A-and B-cation displacements, respectively. The different colours indicate different phases and the brightness shows the temperature from which the distribution is extracted. The brightness of the colours increases with increasing temperature within the same phase. The peak position of the B-cation distributions is shown in SI Figure S2.

Probability distributions of the absolute displacements of A- and B-cations from O polyhedral centres for BaTiO₃, PbTiO₃, LiNbO₃ and BiFeO₃

Figure S1. Probability distributions of the absolute displacements of A- and B-cations from O polyhedral centres for BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO}_{3}, PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO}_{3}, LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3} and BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO}_{3}. The colours indicate different phases.

PbTiO3\mathrm{PbTiO_3} shows the largest B-cation displacements in the ferroelectric phase. In the paraelectric phase, the magnitude of the displacements is closely linked to the temperature, consequently BaTiO3\mathrm{BaTiO_3} shows the smallest displacements while LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO_3} shows the largest displacements. All compounds in the ferroelectric phase, except BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3}, show a clear reduction in B-cation displacements with increasing temperature. In contrast, the Fe displacements in BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3} increase slightly at low temperatures and start decreasing when approaching the phase transition temperature. In the paraelectric phase, displacements increase approximately linearly with increasing temperature for the investigated materials.

Peak position of distributions absolute B-cation displacements from the O octahedral centres for BaTiO3, PbTiO3, LiNbO3, and BiFeO3

Figure S2. Peak position of distributions absolute B-cation displacements from the O octahedral centres seen in SI Figure S1.

Critical Exponents

To verify the correct characteristics of the ferroelectric to paraelectric phase transitions, we also investigated the power law behaviour of the order parameters and determined the critical exponent β\beta. This value can indicate whether the transition is strictly first-order, second-order or shares features of both. For each material, the average B-cation displacement as a function of the temperature was fitted to the expression f(T)=A(TC−T)βf(T)=A(T_C-T)^\beta. For the β\beta-values and the curve fit, see Figure S3. For BaTiO3_3 and BiFeO3_3, the values are very small, consistent with an abrupt jump in the order parameter, as expected from first-order transitions. This also means that the values do not correspond to any theoretical models.

Average B-cation displacements as a function of temperature for LiNbO3, PbTiO3, BaTiO3, and BiFeO3

Figure S3. Average B-cation displacements as a function of temperature up to the ferroelectric phase transitions together with curve fits used to determine the critical exponents.

However, for PbTiO3_3 and LiNbO3_3 the values fit well with experiment and theoretical predictions. For PbTiO3_3, β=0.27\beta=0.27 is close to the theoretical value of 0.25 for a tricritical phase transition, which represents the boundary between first-order and second-order. This agrees with the first-order transition of PbTiO3_3 becoming second-order under applied pressure [4, 5]. A β\beta-value of 0.34 is the observed and theoretically predicted value for a second-order ferroelectric transition, and has been measured to be 0.355 for isostructural LiTaO3_3 [6].

Fitting the strain instead of the polarization, in the form of the tetragonal distortion (c−a)/c(c-a)/c, resulted in essentially the same values. Fitting to other critical exponents than β\beta was not attempted due to the difficulty of fitting a diverging parameter so close to the critical point.

BaTiO3_3

SI Figure S4 shows lattice parameters, calculated using PBEsol, plotted on top of experimental lattice parameters as a function of temperature normalised to TCT_\mathrm{C}. The trend of the lattice parameters is relatively similar for all phases. For the R3mR3m phase the calculated lattice parameters are about 0.01 Å longer. The Amm2Amm2 and P4mmP4mm phases show good overlap for the a-parameter, while our calculations tend to overestimate the longer lattice parameters. For the Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m phase, our calculations show perfect overlap with the experimental data from Kay et al. [7].

Mercator projections showing the direction of Ti displacements at 4 different temperatures are displayed in Figure 3. SI Figure S5 displays Mercator projections showing the direction of the Ba displacements at the same temperatures. The directions of the Ba displacements closely follow the Ti displacements, albeit they appear to be a bit more widespread. However, this is likely mainly an artefact of Ba being less displaced than Ti, see SI Figure S1.

SI Figure S6 shows calculated lattice parameters using MLFFs generated using different functionals for BaTiO3_3. The training of interatomic potentials was carried out using the procedure described in the method section in the main text. The MLFFs predict all the correct phases and phase transitions, albeit with very different lattice parameters and transition temperatures. There is a clear connection between calculated lattice parameter and transition temperatures, where increasing separation between the lattice parameters gives higher transition temperatures. r2r^{2}SCAN gives transition temperatures closest to the experimental values, but significantly overestimates the lattice parameters. PBEsol results in lattice parameters closest to experimental values. Lattice parameters from LDA are not well described, as the temperature intervals are narrow and close to the transition temperature, lattice parameters tend to fluctuate between the different phases.

Image not extracted

Figure S5. Mercator projections showing the direction of the Ba displacements in BaTiO3_3 at 50 K, 150 K, 250 K and 350 K relative to the ⟨1,0,0⟩\langle1,0,0\rangle (green squares) and ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle (blue diamonds) directions.

PbTiO3_3

Experimental and calculated lattice parameters as a function of temperature normalised to TCT_\mathrm{C}, shown in SI Figure S7, perfectly align both below and above the Curie temperature.

Similar to the relation between a- and b-cations in BaTiO3_3, Mercator projections showing the direction of Pb and Ti displacements in PbTiO3_3, SI Figure S8 and S9, show that the Pb displacements follow the Ti displacements, but again appear more widespread. Moreover, in PbTiO3_3 the magnitude of the Pb displacements is larger than the Ti displacements and can therefore not explain the difference. However, the Pb displacements may look more widespread as Pb is larger and more polarisable and thus less energy is needed to slightly move it from its equilibrium position.

Image not extracted

Figure S8. Mercator projections showing the direction of the Pb displacements in PbTiO3_3 at 200 K, 500 K, 550 K and 700 K relative to the ⟨1,0,0⟩\langle1,0,0\rangle (green squares) and ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle (blue diamonds) directions.

Estimated lattice parameters as a function of temperature for PbTiO3_3 using interatomic potentials trained using different functionals are displayed in SI Figure S10. All the MLFFs underestimate the transition temperature. PBEsol results in lattice parameters that are very close to the experimental values, while LDA and r2^2SCAN severely underestimates and overestimates the lattice parameters, respectively.

Image not extracted

Figure S9. Mercator projections showing the direction of the Ti displacements in PbTiO3_3 at 200 K, 500 K, 550 K and 700 K relative to the ⟨1,0,0⟩\langle1,0,0\rangle (green squares) and ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle (blue diamonds) directions.

LiNbO3_3

Calculated and experimental lattice parameters as a function of temperature normalised to TCT_\mathrm{C}, displayed in SI Figure S11, show a similar evolution of the structure with temperature. The calculated c-parameters are systematically larger than the experimental values, while the a-parameters are shorter. However, there is an almost perfect overlap between the calculated and experimental volumes.

The Mercator projections in SI Figure S12 clearly show the order-disorder transition of the Li displacements. At low temperatures, Li is displayed along one of the ⟨1×1×1⟩\langle1 \times1 \times1 \rangle directions, while at higher temperatures the displacements are split between two opposite ⟨1×1×1⟩\langle1 \times1 \times1 \rangle directions. Mercator projections for Nb, SI Figure S13, show Nb following a displacive transition.

Image not extracted

Figure S13. Mercator projections showing the direction of the Nb displacements in LiNbO3\mathrm{LiNbO}_{3} at 500 K, 1000 K, 1200 K and 1400 K relative to the ⟨1,0,0⟩\langle1,0,0\rangle (green squares) and ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle (blue diamonds) directions.

SI Figure S14 shows calculated lattice parameters using MLFFs generated using different functionals for LiNbO3_3. The different interatomic potentials result in the correct phases, but the different functionals all underestimate the transition temperature.

BiFeO3_3

SI Figure S15 shows large discrepancies between calculated and experimental lattice parameters of BiFeO3_3 for both the ferroelectric and paraelectric phases. However, the trends show a relatively good match. Additionally, calculated lattice parameters closely follow lattice parameters expected using standard DFT when considering thermal expansion. DFT optimised lattice parameters for the PbnmPbnm structure are shown in Table S1 and are relatively similar to the lattice parameters calculated using MLFFs at elevated temperatures.

aa5.415
bb5.641
cc7.793
α\alpha, β\beta, γ\gamma90∘90^\circ

Table S1. DFT optimised lattice parameters for PbnmPbnm BiFeO3_3 using the PBEsol functional.

The Mercator projections for Bi in BiFeO3_3, shown in SI Figure S16, appear very similar to Li in LiNbO3_3. However, at elevated temperatures, Bi displacements are not disordered between two directions, but instead ordered alternatingly. On the other hand, Fe shows a very abrupt change from being displaced in the ferroelectric phase to not being displaced above the TCT_\mathrm{C}, see SI Figure

Mercator projections showing the direction of the Bi displacements in $\mathrm{BiFeO_3}$ at 500 K, 950 K, 1000 K and 1200 K

Figure S16. Mercators projection showing the direction of the Bi displacements in BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3} at 500 K, 950 K, 1000 K and 1200 K relative to the ⟨1,0,0⟩\langle1,0,0\rangle (green squares) and ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle (blue diamonds) directions.

Mercator projections showing the direction of the Fe displacements in $\mathrm{BiFeO_3}$ at 500 K, 950 K, 1000 K and 1200 K

Figure S17. Mercator projections showing the direction of the Fe displacements BiFeO3\mathrm{BiFeO_3} at 500 K, 950 K, 1000 K and 1200 K relative to the ⟨1,0,0⟩\langle1,0,0\rangle (green squares) and ⟨1,1,1⟩\langle1,1,1\rangle (blue diamonds) directions.

Lattice parameters calculated using MLFFs generated with LDA, PBEsol and r2r^2SCAN are shown in SI Figure S18 together with experimental lattice parameters by Arnold et al. [10]. LDA and PBEsol underestimates the lattice parameters, but show a transition from R3cR3c to PbnmPbnm at a temperature relatively close to the experimental Curie temperature. On the other hand, r2r^{2}SCAN shows a transition from R3cR3c to Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m at a temperature far above the experimental TCT_{\mathrm{C}}.

References

  1. [1]S. Amounas, A. Hbab, H. Chaib, and T. Ait-Taleb, Physica B: Condensed Matter 663, 415002 (2023).
  2. [2]K. Eggestad, B. A. D. Williamson, D. Meier, and S. M. Selbach, J. Mater. Chem. C , (2024).
  3. [3]N. S. A. Satar, A. W. Aziz, M. K. Yaakob, M. Z. A. Yahya, O. H. Hassan, T. I. T. Kudin, and N. H. M. Kaus, The Journal of Physical Chemistry C 120, 26012 (2016).
  4. [4]A. Sani, M. Hanfland, and D. Levy, Journal of Solid State Chemistry 167, 446 (2002).
  5. [5]G. A. Rossetti and N. Maffei, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 17, 3953 (2005).
  6. [6]A. Hushur, S. Gvasaliya, B. Roessli, S. Lushnikov, and S. Kojima, Phys. Rev. B 76, 064104 (2007).
  7. [7]H. Kay and P. Vousden, The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 40, 1019 (1949).
  8. [8]G. Shirane, S. Hoshino, and K. Suzuki, Phys. Rev. 80, 1105 (1950).
  9. [9]H. Lehnert, H. Boysen, F. Frey, A. Hewat, and P. Radaelli, Zeitschrift für Kristallographie - Crystalline Materials 212, 712 (1997).
  10. [10]D. C. Arnold, K. S. Knight, F. D. Morrison, and P. Lightfoot, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 027602 (2009).

Paper details

vlnc:W_cghzedyf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents