In this paper
AbstractIntroductionGyrokinetic framework and linear instabilityModel and simulation setupMicrotearing instability in the absence of magnetic shearNonlinear evolution and self-organization in microtearing turbulenceAnalysis of energy evolution and fluid-moment contributionsSelf-organization of magnetic islands and zonal magnetic fieldsElectron temperature profile flattening within magnetic islandsSummaryAcknowledgementsGyrokinetic–Maxwell equations and fluid momentsGyrokinetic–Maxwell equationsFluid momentsPower balance equation for ReferencesWorksPhysics and Astronomy
Self-organization of magnetic islands and zonal magnetic fields driven by slab microtearing modes in the absence of magnetic shear
Abstract
Self-organization in collisional microtearing turbulence is investigated using gyrokinetic simulations in a slab geometry without equilibrium magnetic shear. Unlike magnetically driven conventional tearing instabilities, microtearing instabilities are driven by the electron temperature gradient. Electron temperature fluctuations are found to contain most of the gyrokinetic free energy. Although magnetic perturbations contribute little to the free energy, the magnetic field structure plays a crucial role in the nonlinear evolution of microtearing turbulence. Zonal magnetic fields emerge spontaneously through the nonlinear interaction between magnetic perturbations and electron temperature fluctuations. These zonal fields provide an effective magnetic shear that enables magnetic islands to form despite the absence of equilibrium magnetic shear. The electron temperature profile is flattened within the islands. This flattening reduces the instability drive and is expected to promote turbulence saturation.
Introduction
Microturbulence driven by electron pressure gradients causes anomalous electron heat transport in magnetic confinement devices. Understanding the heat transport is a crucial issue in the design of future fusion reactors. In conventional low- devices ( is the ratio of the plasma pressure to the magnetic pressure), electrostatic turbulence driven by the electron temperature gradient (ETG) mode and the trapped electron mode (TEM) is known to contribute to electron heat transport (see, e.g., [1, 2]). In higher- devices, electromagnetic instabilities such as microtearing and kinetic ballooning modes can also cause anomalous electron heat transport through magnetic fluctuations.
Numerous gyrokinetic simulations have shown that microtearing modes become unstable and contribute to electron heat transport in existing devices, such as spherical tokamaks (STs) [3, 4, 5, 6, 7], conventional tokamaks [8, 9, 10], reversed-field pinches (RFPs) [11, 12], and stellarators [13, 14], as well as in a conceptual ST [15, 16, 17].
The microtearing mode changes the topology of the magnetic field and generates small-scale magnetic islands. The islands may overlap to provide a stochastic magnetic field structure, thereby enhancing the electron heat transport along the field lines [18, 19, 20]. Nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations using experimental parameters of the National Spherical Torus Experiment (NSTX) showed that electron heat transport driven by microtearing turbulence increases with electron collisionality [5], consistent with the observed NSTX confinement scaling [21].
The microtearing mode is an ion-scale tearing instability and was first proposed theoretically by Hazeltine et al. [22] using a kinetic model with the rigorous Fokker–Planck collision operator. They revealed that the velocity dependence of the collision frequency is indispensable for the temperature gradient to drive the microtearing instability. Subsequently, the dependence of the microtearing mode on the electron–ion collision frequency was investigated theoretically [23] and numerically [24, 25]. These studies indicated that the mode is stable in both the collisional and collisionless limits. Based on the analysis of Drake and Lee [23], the destabilizing effect is due to pitch-angle scattering with a velocity-dependent collision frequency in the presence of electron temperature nonuniformity. In the fluid description, this destabilizing effect is represented as the time-dependent thermal force [26]. Through this force, the electron temperature nonuniformity generates a parallel inductive electric field that lags in phase behind the perturbed magnetic field [27]. This phase relation is analogous to the relation between density fluctuations and the electrostatic potential in electrostatic drift waves. The microtearing mode is fundamentally an electromagnetic drift wave and is destabilized solely by the time-dependent thermal force even in the absence of equilibrium magnetic shear [28]. Electromagnetic microinstabilities driven by the electron temperature gradient have been reported even in the collisionless regime, both in slab geometry and in toroidal geometry. These modes have been discussed as a tearing-parity electromagnetic ETG mode [29, 30] and a collisionless microtearing mode [31, 32, 33], respectively. Such collisionless modes are outside the scope of this paper.
The nonlinear saturation of microtearing turbulence has been investigated since the early drift-kinetic analysis of a slab plasma without magnetic shear by Drake et al. [34]. They showed that electron streaming along the perturbed magnetic field transfers energy from shorter- to longer-wavelength modes. Saturation occurs when the stabilizing effect of this nonlinear energy transfer balances the linear growth. The resulting saturation amplitude scales as , where and are the electron Larmor radius and temperature gradient scale length, respectively. This scaling was reproduced by nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations [19]. Several numerical studies have reported different saturation mechanisms for microtearing turbulence. One such mechanism is the local flattening of the electron temperature profile at low-order rational surfaces, which has been shown to reduce the linear drive and to play an important role in determining the saturation level of the electron heat flux [35].
The generation of zonal magnetic fields has been proposed as another saturation mechanism for microtearing turbulence. Some gyrokinetic simulations of microtearing turbulence have demonstrated that zonal magnetic fields play an important role in nonlinear saturation, as removing the zonal magnetic field component leads to a significant increase in the electron heat flux [20, 36]. In contrast, other studies using gyrokinetic simulations have reported that zonal fields do not play a significant role in nonlinear saturation [19, 35, 37]. The role of zonal magnetic fields in microtearing turbulence remains controversial. We note that zonal magnetic fields were not explicitly considered in the saturation theory of Drake et al. [34].
We investigate the self-organization mechanism of zonal magnetic fields in microtearing turbulence using the configuration without magnetic shear considered by Drake et al. [34]. This configuration retains the destabilization mechanism of the collisional microtearing mode, i.e., the time-dependent thermal force, since magnetic shear acts only to stabilize the mode [23]. A region of weak or nearly zero magnetic shear is realized in magnetic confinement devices as well, e.g., in stellarators [13, 38, 39] and in advanced tokamaks [40, 41, 42]. The insights obtained in this study are expected to contribute to the understanding of electromagnetic turbulence in weak- or nearly-zero-magnetic-shear regimes.
In this paper, we present numerical analyses of collisional microtearing turbulence in the absence of magnetic shear using a gyrokinetic model. We restrict our analyses to slab geometry as the simplest problem setup, so that toroidal effects such as the magnetic drift and trapped particle effects are excluded. We show that zonal magnetic fields are self-generated by the nonlinear interaction between magnetic perturbations and electron temperature fluctuations. The zonal magnetic fields act as an effective magnetic shear, leading to the formation of magnetic islands even in the absence of equilibrium magnetic shear. We also show that the electron temperature profile is flattened within the self-generated magnetic islands. Regardless of the presence of magnetic shear, this flattening weakens the local temperature-gradient drive of the microtearing instability and is expected to promote turbulence saturation.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In § 2, we describe the gyrokinetic model and the simulation setup, and show that the microtearing modes are unstable in the absence of magnetic shear. In § 3, we present the nonlinear simulation results, including the analysis of the gyrokinetic free energy in terms of fluid moments, the formation of magnetic islands in the absence of magnetic shear, and the generation mechanism of zonal magnetic fields. The flattening of the electron temperature profile within the magnetic islands is also shown in the same section. Finally, we summarize the paper in § 4.
Gyrokinetic framework and linear instability
Model and simulation setup
We solve the electromagnetic gyrokinetic equations of ions and electrons for the non-Boltzmann part of the perturbed distribution function , where , and the subscript is the species label (). The gyrokinetic equation and the definitions of the associated symbols are given in Appendix A.§ 1. The finite Larmor radius (FLR) effects are fully retained for ions. Electron FLR effects are also retained, but they are small for the parameters specified below. The parallel magnetic perturbation is not included in this paper.
We perform gyrokinetic simulations of electromagnetic turbulence driven by collisional microtearing modes in a 2–D slab geometry using the GS2 code [43]. We consider a non-uniform plasma with electron pressure embedded in an equilibrium magnetic field . Here, is the sheared field component with being the magnetic shear scale length. Unless otherwise stated, we consider the configuration without magnetic shear, i.e., . The electron pressure gradient is taken in the direction and is characterized by . The corresponding diamagnetic drift frequency is given by , where and are the diamagnetic drift frequencies associated with the density gradient and temperature gradient , respectively. The definitions of and are given in Appendix A.§ 1. The characteristic time scale of the system is determined by . In this paper, is evaluated at . With the parameters presented later, is related to the commonly used time scale by . The time variable is normalized by and denoted by throughout this paper.
The physical parameters are set as follows: the electron plasma beta , the temperature ratio , the density ratio , the mass ratio , the normalized temperature gradients and , and the ion charge number . GS2 employs the model Fokker–Planck collision operator [44, 45], which includes pitch-angle scattering, energy diffusion, and terms that ensure the conservation of the particle number, momentum, and energy. The electron collisionality is set to . Since we assume a single ion species with , we have . We set the ion collision frequency to be much smaller than that for electrons in this paper.
Microtearing instability in the absence of magnetic shear
We perform linear simulations to identify the range of over which microtearing modes are unstable. In linear runs, we set the numerical resolution in the velocity space to , where and denote the numbers of grid points in the pitch-angle and energy coordinates, respectively [46].
Figure 1 shows the linear growth rate (left) and real frequency (right) of microtearing modes as a function of . The eigenvalues are normalized by .
Figure 1. Growth rate (left) and real frequency (right) of microtearing modes as a function of .
The solid red lines denote the eigenvalues without magnetic shear. The microtearing modes become unstable even in the absence of magnetic shear (left) and propagate in the direction of the electron diamagnetic drift (right). For comparison, the eigenvalues with finite magnetic shear are also shown by the green circles and orange squares. The magnetic shear becomes stronger as increases at fixed . The real frequency is unaffected by magnetic shear, while the growth rate is suppressed by its stabilizing effect, consistent with theoretical [23] and numerical [13, 40] studies. In the finite magnetic shear case, sufficient grid points along the equilibrium magnetic field are used to resolve the fine structure of the mode. We have confirmed the convergence of the results.
Nonlinear evolution and self-organization in microtearing turbulence
In this section, we present the results of nonlinear simulations in the absence of magnetic shear. The simulations are performed with the numerical resolution in the domain of . Artificial hyperviscosity is included to dissipate the energy at small scales and to achieve a steady state. Its amplitude and cut-off wavenumber are chosen to be and respectively, where is the maximum wavenumber. As shown in § 3.1, reaching nonlinear saturation requires long simulation times, which makes high-resolution simulations computationally expensive. We therefore use a lower spatial resolution in this paper. We have confirmed that the conclusions of this paper do not change with resolution and hyperviscosity.
Analysis of energy evolution and fluid-moment contributions
We first consider the energetics of the system. The gyrokinetic free energy consists of the particle part and the magnetic field part , and is given by
The subscripts and denote the components parallel and perpendicular to the equilibrium magnetic field, respectively. We decompose the particle energy into contributions from low-order fluid moments by expanding in Hermite–Laguerre polynomials
where the terms on the right-hand side are defined as follows:
The quantities , , , , and are the velocity moments of defined in Appendix A.§ 2. For simplicity, (2)–(6) are derived under the drift-kinetic approximation, .
Figure 2 shows the time evolution of the energies. All energies are normalized by the maximum value of the electron particle energy over time, . Unlike conventional tearing instabilities that release energy stored in the equilibrium magnetic field, microtearing instabilities are driven by the electron temperature gradient. As shown in Figure 2, the electron particle energy dominates the gyrokinetic free energy, and the magnetic energy remains much smaller. Nevertheless, the magnetic field structure plays a crucial role in the nonlinear evolution of the turbulence, as discussed later. Most of is associated with isotropic electron temperature fluctuations (see ). The energy associated with the temperature anisotropy, , is much smaller than because pitch-angle scattering relaxes the difference between and . Although not shown in the figure, and are also much smaller than .
Figure 2. Time evolution of the gyrokinetic free energy and its components.
We divide the time evolution of the energy shown in Figure 2 into four phases. In the linear phase (), the energy grows exponentially, as it is injected from the background temperature gradient through the microtearing instability. In the subsequent early nonlinear phase (), the energy reaches its peak as the system transitions from linear growth to nonlinear dynamics. This phase consists of two stages. In the zonal-field generation stage (), coherent zonal magnetic fields, uniform in the direction, are self-generated through the nonlinear interaction between magnetic perturbations and electron temperature fluctuations. In the island formation stage (), these zonal magnetic fields act as an effective magnetic shear, thereby leading to the formation of magnetic islands. In the intermediate nonlinear phase (), the energy gradually decays. Finally, the energy becomes nearly constant in the saturation phase (). This paper focuses on the early nonlinear phase.
Self-organization of magnetic islands and zonal magnetic fields
We next examine the generation of zonal magnetic fields and their role in the formation of magnetic islands.
Figure 3 shows snapshots of the spatial distribution of the power of the electron temperature fluctuation, , in the – plane at , 480, 2910, and 4800. is normalized by . The contour lines of , also shown in Figure 3, represent the perturbed magnetic field lines in the – plane. Figure 3(a) shows that the magnetic fields are in a turbulent state. Subsequently, coherent chains of magnetic islands aligned in the direction are formed (Figure 3(b)). Note that these islands are formed even in the absence of magnetic shear. The island width then gradually decreases (Figure 3(c)), and the zonal field structure becomes dominant (Figure 3(d)). Throughout these processes, is localized along the magnetic field lines and gradually decays with time. This spatial correspondence indicates a coupling between the magnetic perturbations and the electron temperature fluctuations.
Figure 3. Snapshots of the spatial distribution of the electron temperature fluctuation power . The contour lines indicate .
Figure 4 shows the time evolution of the -averaged power of for the zonal component (, solid blue line) and the non-zonal components (, dashed red line). is normalized by . To focus on the island formation, we show the time evolution for . The non-zonal components grow exponentially in the linear phase (), and their growth stops around . The zonal component grows much more rapidly for and reaches an amplitude comparable to that of the non-zonal components.
Figure 4. Time evolution of the -averaged power of the zonal and non-zonal components of .
We decompose in the – plane at into its zonal and non-zonal components, shown in Figure 5(a) and Figure 5(b), respectively. The contour lines also denote . The chains of magnetic islands aligned in the direction are absent when the zonal component is removed (Figure 5(b)), highlighting the role of zonal magnetic fields in their formation. Figure 6 shows the profile of the zonal magnetic field at different times, where denotes the -average. is normalized by . The O-points of the magnetic islands are located near the positions where . The turbulence thus generates its own magnetic shear, allowing the magnetic perturbations to self-organize into island chains even in a shearless equilibrium.
Figure 5. A snapshot of for (a) the zonal component and (b) the non-zonal components at . The contour lines also denote .
Figure 6. Zonal magnetic field profile in the direction at different times. is plotted, where denotes the -average.
To identify the source of the zonal magnetic fields, we analyze the power balance of using the generalized Ohm’s law. The growth rate of at each is decomposed into contributions from the individual terms in the generalized Ohm’s law:
where the hat on denotes normalization by . The index labels the contributions from electron inertia, advection, nonlinear interactions between magnetic perturbations and density and temperature fluctuations, and the collision term. The detailed derivation of (7) is given in Appendix B.
Figure 7 shows the time evolution of each contribution to the growth rate of the zonal component () during the linear phase and the zonal-field generation stage (). The solid black, solid red, and dashed blue lines represent , , and , respectively, and the dotted gray line represents the sum of the other terms. For , because the zonal component has no linear drive. The zonal component grows rapidly for , driven primarily by . The term represents the nonlinear interaction between magnetic perturbations and electron temperature fluctuations in the generalized Ohm’s law. Zonal magnetic fields are generated by this nonlinear interaction.
Figure 7. Time evolution of the growth rate of for the zonal component ().
Electron temperature profile flattening within magnetic islands
In this section, we analyze the electron temperature fluctuation profile within the self-generated magnetic islands. Figure 8 shows the spatial distribution of at . The contour lines represent . Remarkably, the temperature fluctuations spontaneously organize within the self-generated magnetic islands to produce a gradient that nearly cancels the background temperature gradient. We focus on the magnetic island centered at . The island width is . With the normalized temperature fluctuation and the normalized coordinate , varies from approximately to across the island, so that . In the same normalization, the background temperature gradient is , where . Although the above estimate is based on a single island in the snapshot shown in Figure 8, we have confirmed that the flattening also occurs in other islands and at other times.
Figure 8. Snapshot of the electron temperature fluctuation during the formation of magnetic islands. The contour lines denote .
The flattening weakens the local temperature-gradient drive of the microtearing instability and is therefore expected to promote turbulence saturation. The same saturation mechanism may thus operate with and without equilibrium magnetic shear.
Summary
We have investigated the self-organization of magnetic islands and zonal magnetic fields in collisional microtearing turbulence in the absence of magnetic shear, using gyrokinetic simulations with the GS2 code.
We have shown that the gyrokinetic free energy is dominated by the electron particle energy associated with isotropic electron temperature fluctuations. The power balance analysis of based on the generalized Ohm’s law has demonstrated that zonal magnetic fields are generated by the nonlinear interaction between magnetic perturbations and electron temperature fluctuations. These self-generated zonal magnetic fields act as an effective magnetic shear, allowing the magnetic perturbations to self-organize into magnetic islands even in the absence of equilibrium magnetic shear. We have also found that, within the magnetic islands, the electron temperature fluctuations produce a gradient that nearly cancels the background temperature gradient, thereby flattening the electron temperature profile. This flattening weakens the instability drive of the microtearing modes and is therefore expected to promote turbulence saturation, suggesting that the same saturation mechanism may operate with and without equilibrium magnetic shear. The overall self-organization process is illustrated schematically in Figure 9. A detailed investigation of the subsequent evolution in the intermediate nonlinear and saturation phases is left for future work.
Figure 9. Schematic diagram of the self-organization process driven by microtearing modes in the absence of magnetic shear.
The results of this paper may have implications for electromagnetic turbulence in low-magnetic-shear regions of magnetic confinement devices. In the Wendelstein 7-X stellarator, microtearing turbulence has recently been reported in a region with nearly zero magnetic shear [13]. Weak or nearly zero magnetic shear is also relevant to advanced tokamak operating scenarios, such as those planned for JT-60SA [41, 42]. In such regions, the self-organization mechanism investigated in this work may play an important role in the nonlinear evolution of microtearing turbulence.
We speculate that the role of zonal magnetic fields in the nonlinear evolution of microtearing turbulence depends on the strength of magnetic shear. In weak-magnetic-shear regimes, self-generated zonal magnetic fields may provide an effective magnetic shear and play an important role in the nonlinear evolution, as observed in this study. In contrast, in regimes with sufficiently strong magnetic shear, such self-organization may be suppressed, and zonal magnetic fields may play a less significant role. A systematic investigation of the relationship between magnetic shear strength and the generation of zonal magnetic fields is therefore an important direction for future work.
Acknowledgements
This work was performed on “Plasma Simulator” of NIFS with the support and under the auspices of the NIFS Collaboration Research program (NIFS25KISM016). This work was supported by a research grant from Wesco Science Promotion and the Notre Dame Seishin University research grant.
Gyrokinetic–Maxwell equations and fluid moments
Gyrokinetic–Maxwell equations
The non-Boltzmann part of the perturbed distribution function of species () obeys the gyrokinetic equation given by
where is the collision term. The drift velocity is defined by . is the magnetic perturbation associated with the parallel magnetic vector potential . The gyrokinetic potential is defined as . Here, is neglected. The angle brackets denote the gyroaverage at fixed guiding-center position , where is the particle position and is the cyclotron frequency. The equilibrium distribution function is the local Maxwellian,
with and . The velocity-dependent diamagnetic drift velocity is given by
where the density and temperature gradients are characterized by and , respectively. These gradients give rise to the diamagnetic drift frequencies, defined as
where is the Larmor radius and is the wavenumber in the direction. Since the pressure gradient is given by , the diamagnetic drift frequency associated with is defined as .
The gyrokinetic equation (A.1) is closed by the quasi-neutrality condition
and the parallel component of Ampère’s law
which determine and , respectively. Here, is the vacuum permeability, and the brackets denote the gyroaverage at fixed particle position .
Fluid moments
Some low-order velocity moments of are given by
where , , , and are the density, parallel flow velocity, and parallel and perpendicular pressure fluctuations, respectively. To first order in the fluctuations, the pressure fluctuations are decomposed as and . The parallel and perpendicular temperature fluctuations are therefore given by
The isotropic temperature fluctuation is defined as
Power balance equation for
In this appendix, we derive the power balance equation for used in § 3.2. We consider the electron gyrokinetic equation (A.1) in the drift-kinetic approximation and in the absence of magnetic shear. Taking its moment yields the electron parallel momentum equation. Solving the momentum equation for , we obtain the generalized Ohm’s law,
where is the convective time derivative, is the electron diamagnetic drift velocity, and represents the contribution of the collision term to the parallel electric field. (B.1) has the dimensions of the parallel electric field, as follows from the parallel component of Faraday’s law, . The temperature gradient normalized by the density gradient is denoted by . Since the anisotropic temperature fluctuation is negligible compared with the isotropic one (Figure 2), we take .
We expand (B.1) in a Fourier series in the direction. Multiplying the component by the complex conjugate and taking the real part, we obtain the power balance equation for :
where labels the following terms:
denotes the Fourier component at , which includes the full nonlinear mode coupling. The linear diamagnetic drift term in (B.1) does not contribute to (B.2). This term is proportional to . The total -derivative vanishes upon averaging over , and the diamagnetic drift term only represents the propagation of in the direction.
Averaging (B.2) over , we obtain
with
where denotes the -average. Dividing (B.8) by and introducing the growth rate , we obtain
where is the contribution of each term to the growth rate.
References
References
- [1]Dorland W, Jenko F, Kotschenreuther M and Rogers B N 2000 Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 5579
- [2]Dannert T and Jenko F 2005 Phys. Plasmas 12 072309
- [3]Applegate D J, Roach C M, Cowley S C, Dorland W D, Joiner N, Akers R J, Conway N J, Field A R, Patel A, Valovic M and Walsh M J 2004 Phys. Plasmas 11 5085
- [4]Wong K L, Kaye S M, Mikkelsen D R, Krommes J A, Hill K, Bell R and LeBlanc B 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 135003
- [5]Gutfetter W, Candy J, Kaye S M, Nevins W M, Wang E, Zhang J and Bell R E 2012 Phys. Plasmas 19 056119
- [6]Dickinson D, Roach C M, Saarelma S, Scannell R, Kirk A and Wilson H R 2013 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 55 074006
- [7]Patel B S, Hardman M R, Kennedy D, Giacomin M, Dickinson D and Roach C M 2025 Nucl. Fusion 65 026063
- [8]Doerk H, Jenko F, Görler T, Told D, Pueschel M J and Hatch D R 2012 Phys. Plasmas 19 055907
- [9]Jian X, Holland C, Candy J, Belli E, Chan V, Garofalo A M and Ding S 2019 Phys. Rev. Lett. 123 225002
- [10]Hatch D R, Kotschenreuther M, Mahajan S M, Pueschel M J, Michoski C, Merlo G, Hassan E, Field A R, Frassinetti L, Giroud C and JET Contributors 2021 Nucl. Fusion 61 036015
- [11]Predbeon P and Sattin F 2013 Phys. Plasmas 20 040702
- [12]Carmony D, Pueschel M J and Terry P W 2013 Phys. Plasmas 20 052110
- [13]Cu-Castillo H, Navarro A B, Merlo G, Reimold F, Romba T, Ford O, Bannmann S, Vanó L, Geiger J, Goodman A, Zocco A, Jenko F and W7-X Team 2026 Phys. Rev. Lett. 137 035102
- [14]Merlo G, Navarro A B, Görler T, Jenko F and Wilms F 2026 Nucl. Fusion 66 034003
- [15]Patel B S, Dickinson D, Roach C M and Wilson H R 2022 Nucl. Fusion 62 016009
- [16]Kennedy D, Giacomin M, Casson F J, Dickinson D, Hornsby W A, Patel B S and Roach C M 2023 Nucl. Fusion 63 126061
- [17]Giacomin M, Kennedy D, Casson F J, Ajay C J, Dickinson D, Patel B S and Roach C M 2024 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 66 055010
- [18]Rechester A B and Rosenbluth M N 1978 Phys. Rev. Lett. 40 38
- [19]Doerk H, Jenko F, Pueschel M J and Hatch D R 2011 Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 155003
- [20]Giacomin M, Dickinson D, Kennedy D, Patel B S and Roach C M 2023 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 65 095019
- [21]Kaye S M, Levinton F M, Stutman D, Tritz K, Yuh H, Bell M G, Bell R E, Horton W, Kim J, LeBlanc B P, Maingi R, Mazzucato E, Menard J E, Mikkelsen D, Park H, Rewoldt G, Sabbagh S A, Smith D R, Wang W and the NSTX Group 2007 Nucl. Fusion 47 499
- [22]Hazeltine R D, Dobrott D and Wang T S 1975 Phys. Fluids 18 1778
- [23]Drake J F and Lee Y C 1977 Phys. Fluids 20 1341
- [24]Gladd N T, Drake J F, Chang C L and Liu C S 1980 Phys. Fluids 23 1182
- [25]D’Ippolito D A, Drake J F and Lee Y C 1980 Phys. Fluids 23 771
- [26]Hassam A B 1980 Phys. Fluids 23 38
- [27]Yagyu M and Numata R 2023 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 65 065003
- [28]Hassam A B 1980 Phys. Fluids 23 2493
- [29]Zocco A, Loureiro N F, Dickinson D, Numata R and Roach C M 2015 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 57 065008
- [30]Geng C, Dickinson D and Wilson H 2020 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 62 085009
- [31]Catto P J and Rosenbluth M N 1981 Phys. Fluids 24 243
- [32]Applegate D J, Roach C M, Connor J W, Cowley S C, Dorland W, Hastie R J and Joiner N 2007 Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 49 1113
- [33]Chandran B D G and Schekochihin A A 2024 J. Plasma Phys. 90 905900204
- [34]Drake J F, Gladd N T and Chang C L 1980 Phys. Rev. Lett. 44 994
- [35]Ajay C J, McMillan B F and Pueschel M J 2023 Nucl. Fusion 63 066024
- [36]Pueschel M J, Hatch D R, Kotschenreuther M, Ishizawa A and Merlo G 2020 Nucl. Fusion 60 124005
- [37]Hamed M, Hatch D R, Pueschel M J and Jitsuk T 2025 Phys. Plasmas 32 092303
- [38]Faber B J, Pueschel M J, Terry P W, Hegna C C and Roman J E 2018 J. Plasma Phys. 84 905840503
- [39]Mulholland P, Aleynikova K, Pueschel M J, Proll J H and Ishizawa A 2026 Nucl. Fusion 66 096008
- [40]Jian X, Holland C, Candy J, Ding S, Belli E, Chan V, Staebler G M, Garofalo A M, McClenaghan J and Snyder P 2021 Phys. Plasmas 28 042501
- [41]Wakatsuki T, Yoshida M, Narita E, Suzuki T and Hayashi N 2023 Nucl. Fusion 63 076017
- [42]Gabriellini S, Zotta V K, Garzotti L, Aiba N, Artaud J F, Giruzzi G, Pucella G, Sozzi C, Taylor D, Wakatsuki T, Buria L, Leoni C, Gatto R and the JT-60SA Integrated Project Team 2025 Nucl. Fusion 65 056041
- [43]Barnes M, Dickinson D, Dorland W, Hill P A, Parker J T, Roach C M, Giacomin M, Mandell N, Numata R, Schuett T, Biggs-Fox S, Christen N, Parisi J, Wilkie G, Anton L, Ball J, Baumgaertel J, Colyer G, Hardman M, Hein J, Highcock E, Howes G, Jackson A, Kotschenreuther M T, Lee J, Leggate H, Mauriya A, Patel B, Tatsuno T and Van Wyk F 2024 GS2 version 8.2.1 URL https://gyrokinetics.gitlab.io/gs2/
- [44]Abel I G, Barnes M, Cowley S C, Dorland W and Schekochihin A A 2008 Phys. Plasmas 15 122509
- [45]Barnes M, Abel I G, Dorland W, Ernst D R, Hammett G W, Ricci P, Rogers B N, Schekochihin A A and Tatsuno T 2009 Phys. Plasmas 16 072107
- [46]Barnes M, Dorland W and Tatsuno T 2010 Phys. Plasmas 17 032106








