WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Collapsars Are Not Heavy -Process Factories
Abstract
Collapsar disks are proposed sources of -process elements, but neutron-rich disk ejecta require gas to be both neutronized in the disk and ejected before accretion. The magnetic field that enables ejection also thickens the disk and accelerates the inflow, lowering both the density and the time available for weak processing. To compute the resulting neutronization, we evolve the electron fraction of the inflowing gas, adopting at each radius the temperature that maximizes the net neutronization rate for the local density and instantaneous composition. This yields a lower limit on that is independent of the disk's thermal history. We adopt an optimistic unbinding radius of for all magnetic fluxes capable of launching outflows. Combining this ejection condition with favorable assumptions of low black hole mass, ejection of midplane gas, and the upper end of the -ray burst (GRB) engine-power scale, which limits the accretion rate to , gives a fiducial lower bound , above the characteristic threshold for heavy -process production. Stronger magnetic flux, toward which jet-launching engines evolve, raises the lower bound to . We conclude that collapsar disk outflows cannot supply the heavy -process yields invoked for a dominant enrichment channel. Only engines with unusually high accretion rates, potentially including exceptionally luminous GRBs, such as GRB 221009A, and direct-horizon collapsars, may produce heavy -process ejecta.
Introduction
The rapid neutron-capture process (-process) is responsible for roughly half of the abundances of nuclei heavier than iron. Producing the heavy -process requires ejecta with a large neutron-to-seed ratio, set primarily by the electron fraction, entropy, expansion timescale, and subsequent neutrino irradiation (e.g., Hoffman et al. [37]; Lippuner & Roberts [57]); see Cowan et al. [20, 19]; Arnould et al. [5]; Qian & Wasserburg [79]; Thielemann et al. [101, 100]; Kajino et al. [46]; Thielemann & Cowan [99] for reviews. Neutron star (NS) mergers have long been predicted to synthesize -process material (Lattimer & Schramm [54]), and the kilonova (Li & Paczyński 1998; Metzger et al. [67]; Metzger [65]) associated with GW170817 (Abbott et al. [1]) demonstrated that binary NS mergers are an important -process source (e.g., [47, 73, 92, 96, 104] (Cowerthwaite et al. 2017)).
Nevertheless, it remains unclear whether mergers alone account for the full diversity of -process enrichment. The discovery of -process-enhanced extremely metal-poor stars indicates that some enrichment occurred early, in low-metallicity environments (e.g., [78, 28, 83, 27, 91] (Ji et al. 2016; Ji et al. 2019)), motivating rare channels associated with massive-star deaths, whose short evolutionary timescales naturally couple them to early star formation ([105, 36, 48, 49, 102, 84] (Côté et al. 2019)).
Collapsars — rapidly rotating massive-star collapses that form proto-neutron stars followed by collapse into spinning black holes (BHs) surrounded by accretion disks [106, 59, 60, 107] – have long been among the most promising massive-star alternatives (e.g., [76, 93, 95, 64, 30, 42]. If the disk becomes sufficiently dense and neutrino-cooled, electron degeneracy favors electron captures on protons, which can drive the gas neutron-rich [74, 7, 77, 50, 17]. The neutron-rich gas must then be ejected from the disk before it is accreted onto the BH.1
Siegel et al. [89] performed general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations to follow the interplay between outflow dynamics and nucleosynthesis, finding substantial -process production in disk outflows. Similarly, accreting proto-magnetars in the pre-BH phase can also eject neutron-rich disk material through interaction with the stellar magnetosphere [75]. However, those calculations began from an idealized, pre-assembled torus and did not include the ram pressure of the stellar envelope, self-consistent disk formation, or the continued interaction between fallback and the disk. The robustness of -process production in such idealized tori was questioned by simulations with detailed neutrino transport [68].
The core difficulty became clearer in recent global hydrodynamic collapsar simulations [45, 29, 22 b]. These studies found that, although neutron-rich gas can form in the inner disk during the neutrino-dominated accretion flow (NDAF) phase, it is accreted before being ejected. These works suggested that magnetic fields may be essential, as sufficiently strong magnetic stresses could more efficiently launch neutron-rich material before it is swallowed by the BH. Indeed, Metzger et al. [66] showed that a strong poloidal field allows NDAF outflows to retain their neutron excess, provided that the gas is neutron-rich where it is launched.
The first 3D global collapsar simulations with both magnetic fields and neutrino transport found that this tension is fundamental [38], and axisymmetric simulations similarly find that -process elements are only weakly synthesized once a jet is launched (Shi et al. 2025). The two requirements for robust -process outflows are not independent. First, the gas in the disk must cool and neutronize before being advected onto the BH, which requires neutrino cooling and weak-interaction timescales shorter than the inflow time. Second, the resulting neutron-rich gas must be unbound by magnetic stresses before it is swallowed. Magnetic fields help satisfy the second requirement, but they also enhance angular-momentum transport, shorten the inflow time, provide magnetic and thermal support, and thicken the disk. These effects suppress the neutrino-cooled, mildly degenerate state required for low electron fraction material, thereby making neutronization more difficult. Thus, the same magnetic stresses needed to eject neutron-rich gas can also erase the conditions required to produce it.
In the simulation suite of [38], neutron-rich outflows appeared only in the most extreme high-accretion-rate progenitors, where the disk remained neutrino cooled despite strong magnetic stresses. Therefore, these models do not demonstrate that collapsars associated with the observed long -ray burst (GRB) population are -process factories. Such engines produce outflow power well above that inferred for GRBs or similarly energetic engine-driven supernova-like transients. In this paper, we address whether collapsar disk outflows can satisfy the neutronization and ejection requirements while remaining consistent with the observed GRB engine power scale.
Two loopholes remain in that engine-power scale. The first is a quasi-steady compromise between the weakly magnetized, efficiently cooled standard-and-normal-evolution disk (SANE; [71]) limit and the strongly magnetized magnetically arrested disk (MAD; [70, 98]) limit. In this picture, an intermediate state resembling a rocking accretion disk (RAD; [51]) could retain enough coherent magnetic flux to eject material while still allowing the disk to cool and neutronize. The second is temporal separation: the disk first neutronizes while weakly magnetized, and only later, as magnetic flux accumulates near the BH and generates a coherent, large-scale field via the dynamo process (e.g., [41, 16]), does it eject the gas that was neutronized beforehand. These two scenarios define the remaining ways in which collapsars associated with observed GRBs could still act as heavy -process factories.
We test these possibilities by computing the lowest electron fraction that inflowing gas can reach before ejection. Magnetic ejection becomes dynamically important only outside an effective unbinding radius, .
Thus, disk-wind -process production requires neutron-rich gas to be present at . Figure 1 illustrates how collapsars associated with observed GRBs fail the above condition. In weakly magnetized disks, gas can cool and neutronize but remains bound and is accreted. In more strongly magnetized disks, magnetic stresses can unbind gas from , but the same stresses thicken the disk and shorten the inflow time, such that the gas reaches that radius only weakly neutronized.
Figure 1. Disk neutronization and ejection regimes of dimensionless magnetic flux, . Colors show the electron fraction (blue for , and red for ). SANE: efficient neutrino cooling makes a dense, neutron-rich midplane, but winds cannot overcome fallback ram pressure and lies outside the disk. sub-MAD: finite coherent flux threading the disk (purple bundles) launches winds, but the same magnetic support shortens the inflow and lowers the density, such that even the optimized bound at stays above down to . MAD: fields readily drive jets and disk winds, but the stronger stresses thicken the disk and erase the degenerate, neutrino-cooled state. The accompanying reduction in the allowed accretion rate further suppresses the integrated neutronization. On the GRB ceiling, rises from 0.33 at to 0.49 at . Therefore, none of the states ejects gas with .
The structure of this paper is as follows. In § 2, we use the observed long GRB luminosity scale to estimate the accretion rates and magnetic powers relevant for collapsars. In § 3, we test whether gas in such disks can neutronize before reaching the adopted launching radius, considering the SANE–MAD magnetization sequence and the possibility of gradual magnetization. In § 4, we discuss the implications for luminous GRBs and rare high-accretion-rate collapsars. We summarize our conclusions in § 5.
GRB Observational constraints
The power of magnetically driven Blandford-Znajek (Blandford & Znajek [11]) outflows can be written as (Gottlieb et al. [34])
where is the BH Kerr parameter, is the mass accretion rate onto the BH, parameterizes the efficiency with which the BH rotational energy is extracted (Lowell et al. [58]),
and parameterizes the fraction of the MAD-level dimensionless magnetic flux, , threading the BH (Tchekhovskoy et al. [98]),
where
with being the poloidal magnetic flux threading the BH, and is the BH gravitational radius.
The mass accretion rate, , in Eq. (1) is constrained by the observed luminosities of long GRB jets. For jets with , the beaming-corrected prompt -ray peak luminosities, , are typically $10^{49}\ {\rm erg,s^{-1}}\lesssim L_j\lesssim 10^{51}\ {\rm erg,s^{-1}}$ (Wanderman & Piran [103]). Adopting a fiducial prompt radiative efficiency (Zhang et al. [108]; Beniamini et al. [8]; Aksulu et al. [3]), the total jet power is $P_j\sim L_j/\eta_\gamma\lesssim . Eq. (1) then gives a maximum mass accretion rate
over the observed GRB duration. Thus, high accretion rates are possible only if the launching efficiency is well below unity.
The flux factor, however, cannot be arbitrarily small as jets emerge from the ergosphere only once ([38, 52]), corresponding to . The remaining suppression must therefore come largely from the spin factor. Collapsar BHs are moderately spinning with ([31, 40]), for which Eq. (2) gives . Substantially larger spins would produce jet luminosities well above the observed GRB range, as found in simulations initialized with rapidly spinning BHs ([32, 86]). Lower spins are not directly excluded by the GRB luminosity distribution, because their lower BZ efficiency can be compensated by a larger accretion rate to produce the same jet power. However, jets powered by slower-spinning BHs would be less powerful than the confining accretion flow ([63, 71, 97, 12]), making them more susceptible to choking before breakout. While such low-spin, high engines could then remain hidden while hosting neutron-rich disk outflows, reconciling such a population with GRB observations would require a systematic anti-correlation between BH spin and accretion rate. Otherwise, the same high population should also include some BHs with higher spins whose jets would again conflict with the observed GRB luminosity distribution. Such a tuned natal anti-correlation is not a generic prediction of current progenitor models ([82]).
The value of , and hence , is expected to grow during the collapse, for example if the magnetic flux threading the BH is generated or amplified by dynamo processes ([87, 16]). Once a jet is launched, mass accretion suppression and ongoing disk dynamo would further increase until the flow approaches the MAD state, where . Thus, although the MAD accretion rate during most of the observed GRB emission is limited to , the transition toward MAD can temporarily allow higher accretion rates. Using Eq. (5), and plugging in as the minimum magnetic flux for sustained jet launching, the maximum mass accretion rate is
where the normalization uses Eq. (2) at , while the spin dependency follows the low-spin scaling, . We adopt this value as an optimistic upper limit for collapsars. In §4, we return to the possibility of atypical, much higher- progenitors.
Failure across the magnetic-flux sequence
In this section, we examine the collapsar problem across the magnetic-flux sequence. We first consider the weak-flux limit, where magnetic ejection is ineffective and neutron-rich gas is predominantly accreted. We then consider sub-MAD/MAD disks capable of launching winds, assigning all of them the same favorable unbinding radius, , and computing the minimum electron fraction there. Finally, we consider whether temporal separation between neutronization and magnetic-flux accumulation can evade this constraint.
Weak-flux/SANE limit
The weak-flux/SANE limit corresponds to , below which no jet emerges. Without a jet, the disk launches magnetically driven winds only once it becomes MAD ([38]), so any outflow in this regime must be driven hydrodynamically. This regime is also the most favorable for neutronization since the residence time is long and the density is high. Global hydrodynamic calculations with prescribed viscous angular momentum transport provide a useful proxy for the weak coherent flux limit. These simulations find that the low material formed in the inner neutrino-cooled disk is predominantly accreted rather than ejected ([45, 29, 22 b]). Outflows emerge only after the disk has become less efficiently cooled and correspondingly less neutron rich. As a result, the ejecta contain negligible abundances of -process.
The global calculations suggest that hydrodynamic disks inhibit neutron-rich ejecta through the combination of (i) limited available thermal energy in the efficiently cooled inner disk to drive outflows, and (ii) ram pressure of the fallback material:
(i) In the NDAF regime, the neutrino cooling time is much shorter than the accretion time,
Therefore, most of the thermal energy generated by dissipation is radiated before it can be advected, leaving only a small residual thermal energy reservoir to launch a hydrodynamic wind from the NDAF region2. Thus, the mechanical power of such a wind satisfies
where is the local inward accretion rate through the disk, and the characteristic binding energy per unit mass of Keplerian disk gas is
To unbind a hydrodynamic wind with mass flux , one must supply at least the local binding energy,
Combining Eqs. (7), (8) and (10) gives
(ii) Unlike a post-merger disk, a collapsar disk remains embedded in and continuously replenished by the infalling star. The disk wind must push against the ram pressure of the freefalling gas with velocity . For a broad hydrodynamic wind with mass flux and velocity , we compare the radial momentum fluxes per solid angle to find
Approximating , this gives
but this condition cannot be satisfied since Eq. (11) implies that the L.H.S. is very small whereas must be comparable to in order for disk outflows to emerge.
These arguments do not exclude hydrodynamic outflows, but disfavor the massive, sufficiently low- wind required for collapsars to dominate -process enrichment. Coherent magnetic stresses provide a different route to angular-momentum removal and ejection.
Sub-MAD/MAD regime
As sub-MAD/MAD disks can launch outflows, the question is no longer whether ejection occurs but whether it takes place in neutron-rich regions. We adopt an optimistic inner launching radius and compute the lowest electron fraction attainable before the gas reaches it.
We define as an effective magnetic unbinding radius: the radius at which the available magnetic work per loaded mass becomes comparable to the local binding energy of the gas. We adopt a common unbinding radius,
This choice is motivated by the global MAD simulations of Lalakos et al. [52], whose mass-loss profiles show dynamically important outflows beginning at . These simulations are non-radiative, allowing the gas to retain dissipated heat that can assist ejection. Neutrino cooling removes part of this thermal support, while stellar fallback further resists disk winds. We therefore adopt as an optimistic launching radius for collapsar outflows. Assigning the same radius to sub-MAD disks grants them the favorable ejection condition of the MAD state. This allows the gas to accumulate weak processing down to at every magnetic flux capable of launching a wind. If appreciable mass loss instead begins at larger radii, the gas has less time to neutronize along the same inflow trajectory, and the resulting composition is less neutron rich.
The conventional NDAF ignition condition, obtained by comparing viscous heating with optically thin neutrino cooling by electron and positron captures on free nucleons, has commonly been used to estimate the neutron richness in disks ([7, 17, 66]). However, efficient cooling alone is not sufficient for self-neutronization as the gas must also reach a sufficiently neutron-rich thermodynamic state, and weak interactions must act faster than the inflow time. Indeed, Agarwal et al. [2] found that for some massive BHs, the ignition condition can be satisfied while self-neutronization fails. Moreover, the agreement between the conventional ignition condition and the composition found in previous simulations pertains to an MRI-turbulent, effectively viscous accretion regime, rather than to the coherent high-flux sub-MAD/MAD flows required for mass ejection, in which the disk dynamics is modified by large-scale magnetic torques ([10]). These torques do not obey the local viscous-heating closure entering the standard ignition estimate. In the discussion below, we therefore estimate the composition directly.
Local turbulent transport has inward velocity , where is the Keplerian velocity and is the disk scale height. In contrast, coherent magnetic torques scale linearly with and can drive substantially faster accretion in thinner disks ([25, 15, 72, 39]). Numerical simulations of MADs have found that angular-momentum transport is dominated by coherent large-scale torques for ([85]), while even in geometrically thick adiabatic MADs, these torques can contribute comparably to turbulent transport ([62]). In collapsars, spans a broad range, from near the innermost stable circular orbit, , to at [see e.g., Figure 2(a)]. A fully general treatment would therefore need to account for both transport channels, with coherent torques dominating close to the BH and turbulent stresses becoming more important at larger radii. For simplicity, we retain only the dependence expected for coherent large-scale torques and introduce a radial function, , to capture the behavior farther from the BH. Thus, we write
Figure 2. Comparison of analytic fits with two GRMHD simulations, pBsA8 () and pBsA5 (). The models are based on model pBs from Issa et al. [38], with the indicated BH spins and a corrected neutrino absorption scheme. (a) Time-averaged profiles, and representative values of our fit: , , and (red markers). (b) Time-averaged profiles, and our fit to the numerical profile at in Eq. (17) (red dashed line). (c) Time evolution in of Eq. (19) at . (d) Time evolution of different characteristic at : instantaneous density-weighted average (dark solid lines), equilibrium value (faint solid lines), and the analytic estimate for the minimum value from Eq. (29) (dashed lines). The comparison demonstrates that at all times, and that the analytic estimate provides a reasonable lower bound.
where is a kinematic parameter. We adopt a quasi-steady flow with ignition-friendly low BH mass of .
If coherent torques dominate the accretion velocity ([25, 15, 39]), then is determined by
where is the thermal pressure, and and are the coherent components of latitudinal and azimuthal fields. In MAD, it is expected that and . Therefore, we expect as long as the disk is magnetically dominated and coherent torques dominate accretion. Figure 2(a),(Figure 2b) depicts our fits to the numerical data of and in neutrino-cooled disks in GRMHD simulations from Issa et al. [38]. For the inflow normalization in Figure 2(b), we fit3
The corresponding accretion timescale is
To estimate the radial density profile, we write the vertically integrated disk mass conservation
where . Then
Figure 2(c) demonstrates that the mass-flux estimate in Eq. (19) agrees with the GRMHD collapsar simulations to within a factor of two.
We estimate the finite net neutronization rate using the electron and positron capture integrals of Beloborodov [7], Eqs. (6)–(7). We assume free, nondegenerate nucleons and negligible neutrino absorption (see Appendix § 6.§ 4, Figure 7), while retaining arbitrary electron degeneracy through the chemical potential determined by charge neutrality. The net rate is
Figure 7. Time evolution of the electron neutrinosphere radius, , at which the integrated effective optical depth reaches , where are absorption/scattering opacities respectively. are shown with dashed horizontal lines. The neutrinosphere remains inside , supporting the transparent-matter approximation over the radial domain used in § 3.2.
where the capture coefficients are rates per target nucleon. We neglect the formation of particles when evaluating the weak-interaction rates, which makes our neutronization bound conservative because it overestimates the free nucleon fraction (see Appendix § 6.§ 3). At each density and instantaneous composition, we find the temperature that maximizes the instantaneous net conversion rate (Appendix § 6.§ 2),
The numerical integration proceeds from with inward to . Beyond , the heat per nucleon of an advective disk, , where accounts for the zero-torque inner boundary (Beloborodov [7], Eqs. 36–41), falls below the binding energy per nucleon of particles, which do not capture electrons. Starting instead at in nuclear statistical equilibrium lowers by at most $0.02 along the ceiling (see Appendix § 6.§ 1).
Taking inside (see e.g., Lalakos et al. [52]), Figure 3 shows the minimum attainable as a function of and , while fixing the other parameters to their canonical values. The contour (thin solid line), adopted as the threshold for heavy -process production (e.g., Lippuner & Roberts [57]), remains above the GRB ceiling (thick line). Along this ceiling, the minimum attainable electron fraction increases from to . In Appendix § 6.§ 1, we show that allowing additional weak processing at larger lowers the most favorable value to –. Furthermore, the most favorable state, , is likely to be transient. Continued accumulation of coherent magnetic flux and suppression of accretion tend to drive the flow toward MAD, which lowers the permitted accretion rate and suppresses neutronization. The most favorable conditions therefore likely operate only during a limited sub-MAD phase. To understand the dependencies of on the collapsar disk properties, we additionally provide an analytic bound. Using the mildly degenerate expansion and charge-neutrality relation of Beloborodov [7], the net rate is
Figure 3. Minimum in . The thin solid (dashed) line shows the contour using the numerical (analytic) estimate. The thick line delineates the ceiling of the GRB population: , for , , and . Along the GRB ceiling, for any value of .
where , , , , and . Maximizing over temperature gives and . Comparison with the full capture integrals gives a conservative rate upper limit4,
At fixed temperature, the states and have identical per-target capture rates since they scale with . Hence,
where the rates on the R.H.S. are those evaluated at . Multiplying by and comparing with Eq. (21) gives
Maximizing over temperature therefore gives an upper bound on the net neutronization rate,
where in the R.H.S. we applied Eq. (24) at the rescaled density, and assumed .
We define the integrated rate bound
Using Eq. (27) and integrating from then gives
Therefore, the condition is sufficient to exclude reaching the adopted threshold . Finally, evaluating for the reference profiles and from to gives
where and are radially constant multipliers of the complete reference profiles, and the spin dependence follows in Eq. (2). Figure 2(d) shows that the analytic bound (dashed line) provides a reasonable estimate to the in the collapsar simulations (dark solid line) after jet launching, (depending on spin). At early times, before jet launching, the neutrinosphere reaches (Figure 7), such that the transparent rates of Eq. (21) do not apply, and . However, before jet launching, the gas remains bound, so this transitional phase has no effect on the ejecta composition.
For the adopted GRB power ceiling and fiducial BH parameters, collapsar disks cannot reach at . We stress that our estimates correspond to the most favorable corner of the collapsar parameter space: the upper end of the GRB peak luminosity distribution, low BH mass and spin, substantial sub-MAD jet launching, an unbinding radius of at every flux, and negligible ram pressure on disk outflows. Additionally, our estimates are evaluated at the midplane, which is favorable for low- ejecta, since winds are launched from the disk surface or high-latitude regions, where the density and degeneracy are lower and weak interactions drive toward unity ([66]). This optimistic analysis is further demonstrated in Figure 2(d), which shows that the analytic bound, consistent with the full numerical estimate (Figure 3), vastly underestimates the values found in full GRMHD simulations.
Gradual magnetization
A possible loophole is temporal separation: the disk may first neutronize while weakly magnetized, and only later accumulate enough coherent flux to eject the gas that was neutronized earlier. This requires the field to reach ejection strength before that material is accreted, , where is its remaining residence time. The local weak-interaction relaxation time is
In the hot, nondegenerate limit, this reduces to
using the capture-rate approximation of Beloborodov [7]. If the magnetized disk has at [Figure 2(d)], then at the launching densities along the GRB ceiling, –, and Eq. (31) gives . Since is shorter than the magnetic flux advection timescale (Jacquemin-Ide et al. [41]), even fully neutronized gas relaxes to before ejection. Under these conditions, earlier neutronization cannot preserve sufficiently neutron-rich gas until ejection.
Implications
The constraint on high at can be evaded by changing the origin of the low- material or the difficulty of ejecting it. Compact-object mergers differ from collapsars in both respects. Some ejecta are launched dynamically from NS matter and therefore do not need to be neutronized in the disk. Post-merger disk winds are also launched into a comparatively clean, highly aspherical environment, rather than against the quasi-spherical ram pressure and baryon loading of a collapsing stellar envelope. Merger disks can therefore unbind material with much weaker magnetic flux, or plausibly through thermal and viscous driving (Fernández & Metzger [24]; Siegel & Metzger [90]). Indeed, numerical simulations find that even weakly magnetized merger engines with can launch polar outflows into the cleaner surrounding medium (e.g., Gottlieb et al. [35]).
A different way to evade the collapsar bound is to relax the intrinsic engine power constraints. Weaker engines, including weak jets that fail to break out, only exacerbate the problem: at fixed magnetic flux, reducing lowers the allowed accretion rate and density, further suppressing neutronization. However, if the engine power is much larger than the observed long GRB scale, then a MAD-level outflow can, in principle, satisfy both the launching and neutronization requirements. This is the regime found by Issa et al. [38], where extremely high accretion rates allow the disk to remain neutrino cooled while still powering strong magnetic outflows. To visualize the dependency of on the GRB properties, Figure 4 shows the jet power and BH spin dependencies of Eq. (30) with the full of Eq. (2) (dashed line) and of the full numerical calculation (solid line). It shows that under optimistic assumptions, reaching requires the upper end of the GRB luminosity distribution and the lowest BH spin for which the jet can still dominate over disk outflows (McKinney et al. [63]; Tchekhovskoy & McKinney [97]).
Figure 4. Most favorable composition bound as a function of black hole spin and isotropic-equivalent -ray luminosity . Colors show derived from Eq. (22) with of Eq. (2), assuming , , and , and minimizing over (minimum is reached at ). The circle marks the ceiling reference model (, ), for which . The solid curve marks from the full numerical calculation and the dashed curve , where the analytic bound of Eq. (29) reaches . Thin gray curves show , , and . Horizontal lines mark observed isotropic-equivalent peak luminosities: the break of the long-GRB luminosity function, (line and shaded uncertainty; [103]) and GRB 221009A (; [55]). Peak luminosities overestimate the sustained jet power and hence : GRB 221009A radiated over more than 600 s at [55], corresponding to a mean luminosity of . The color scale is linear in below 0.25 (blue) and logarithmic in above it (red).
This leaves two possible transient classes in which collapsar-like -process ejecta may still be produced.
The first is the extreme high-luminosity tail of the long-GRB population, including events such as GRB 221009A (Burns et al. [14]; Lesage et al. [55]). However, a large isotropic-equivalent luminosity allows low- ejecta only if it originates in an unusually high accretion rate. Since the isotropic-equivalent jet power depends strongly on BH spin and the jet opening angle, the brightest GRBs are more naturally produced, at least in part, by higher spins and/or narrower angles rather than by proportionally larger accretion rates. In such cases, their large apparent luminosities do not allow low- ejection as their increased luminosity is not translated to increased .
Even if some extremely luminous GRBs are powered by larger accretion rates, their volumetric rate is likely too small to represent the generic missing source of prompt -process enrichment in low-metallicity environments, unless each event ejects an exceptionally large mass of heavy -process material. Observationally, despite its extreme luminosity, the supernova of the nearby GRB 221009A showed no evidence for an additional -process-powered component (Blanchard et al. [9]). More broadly, optical/near-infrared searches of SNe Ic-BL and GRB–SNe for the -process signatures predicted by Barnes & Metzger [6] have found no compelling evidence for an -process component (Anand et al. [4]; Rastinejad et al. [81]; Blanchard et al. [9]). Thus, the high-luminosity GRB tail may remain a rare exception, but it does not rescue collapsars as generic heavy--process factories. Stellar abundances also imply that collapsars are difficult to reconcile with metal-poor stars, which require early -process production to be separated from iron production (Macias & Ramirez-Ruiz [61]), and metallicity-suppressed collapsars cannot be the dominant -process source in the Milky Way (Fraser & Schönrich [26]). However, Brauer et al. [13] argued that collapsar yields can reproduce the [Eu/Fe] scatter in metal-poor stars, such that abundances alone do not settle the question.
The second possibility is direct-horizon collapsars. These events may be rare at low redshift but more common in the early Universe. In metal-poor environments, reduced line-driven mass loss allows very massive stars to retain larger helium cores and greater angular momentum, increasing the likelihood of direct BH formation with much larger disk masses and accretion rates (Siegel et al. [88]; Gottlieb et al. [33]), allowing them to overcome the constraints imposed for collapsars. The full neutrino-transport calculation in GRMHD simulations of direct-horizon collapsars will be presented in Issa et al., in prep.
Conclusions
We have examined whether collapsar accretion disks can produce heavy -process ejecta through disk outflows. The basic requirement is that gas must become neutron-rich at the radius outside which magnetic stresses can do enough work per loaded baryon to unbind the gas. We expressed this requirement as . For the adopted GRB engine parameters, this condition is not satisfied at any point along the magnetic-flux sequence.
In the weak-flux limit, the disk can remain dense, cool efficiently, and neutronize, but the effective unbinding radius lies far outside the disk. Any hydrodynamic wind is limited by the small residual advected thermal-energy fraction that cannot drive outflows against ongoing stellar fallback. Coherent magnetic stresses enable ejection but also shorten the inflow time and thicken the disk relative to a viscous flow, thereby inhibiting neutronization. Our calculation considers favorable conditions for neutronization: the jet power lies at the upper end of the bulk peak luminosity of the long-GRB population, sub-MAD jet launching is efficient, the BH mass is , the temperature maximizes the net neutronization rate at every radius, and the ejecta carry the composition of the dense midplane. Even under these favorable conditions, the gas reaches with for every flux capable of ejection, from minimum ejecting flux through the MAD regime. In particular, is obtained for the minimum flux needed for sustaining jet launching. As jet launching drives the flow toward MAD, that phase is likely short-lived.
The obstruction identified here applies specifically to disk-wind nucleosynthesis in collapsars. It does not apply to compact-object mergers, not simply because some of their ejecta begin as neutron-rich NS matter, but because the ejection problem is fundamentally different.
Merger remnants are not embedded in a quasi-spherical stellar fallback flow, so their winds encounter a much lower ram-pressure and baryon-loading barrier. In addition, part of the ejecta can be launched dynamically without requiring a disk wind to neutronize and unbind the same gas parcel. The collapsar bound can instead be evaded only by moving to more extreme high-power engines. Direct-horizon collapsars or other rare systems with much larger accretion rates may remain neutrino cooled despite strong magnetic stresses, as their engine power is not constrained by GRB observations.
This research used resources of the Argonne Leadership Computing Facility, a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science user facility at Argonne National Laboratory and is based on research supported by the U.S. DOE Office of Science-Advanced Scientific Computing Research Program, under Contract No. DE-AC02-06CH11357 (NeutronStar-Remnants project). JJ acknowledge support from NASA grants 80NSSC22K0826, 80NSSC24K0941, and 80NSSC24K1174. J.J. acknowledges support by NSF grants AST-2307983.
Neutronization along inflow trajectories
We follow Eq. (22) along individual inflow trajectories to show where the neutronization accumulates, which temperatures the optimization selects, and whether the free-nucleon, neutrino-transparent rates of § 3.2 are appropriate along those paths. We consider the GRB ceiling with from Eq. (6). Each trajectory starts at with and is integrated inward to with Eq. (22). The density and inflow speed follow from Eqs. (15) and (20), with numerical fits to and , , and . The optimized rate is tabulated from the full capture integrals, maximizing over temperature. The temperature is the maximizing temperature at the local and .
Figure 5 shows . Along the ceiling the final values are – (–). The processing decreases monotonically from to , because the ceiling accretion rate scales as , lowering the density along the same inflow trajectory.
Figure 5. Temperature-optimized composition along the inflow. Curves show from Eq. (22), integrated inward from with , for points on the GRB ceiling with , 30, 40, and 50. Circles mark the common adopted launching radius, , where , 0.44, 0.48, and 0.49 for , 30, 40, and 50, respectively.
Dependence on the outer radius
Using the rate envelope , the maximum neutronization per logarithmic radius scales as . With , this becomes , which rises outward wherever grows more slowly than . It therefore falls as between and , but rises as between and . As a result, the free-nucleon bound does not converge with : extrapolating the profiles to gives at . However, outside an increasing fraction of the nucleons is bound in particles. We therefore repeat the integration from assuming nuclear statistical equilibrium of neutrons, protons, and particles, and maximize the net rate of Eq. (36) over temperature. The result converges, since starting at gives the same values: at , below the value for , while for the change is . The approximation , which holds at and sets in § 3.2, gives . This likely overestimates the heating in our coherent-torque picture, in which part of the released energy is carried away by the wind [25].
Rate-maximizing temperature
The rate-maximizing temperatures in Figure 6 range from at to at along the ceiling. Their scaling follows from the mildly degenerate expansion of Eq. (23), whose maximum lies at
Figure 6. Rate-maximizing temperature along the four ceiling trajectories of Figure 5; each panel lists the maximum . Solid curves show at the local density and composition [Eq. (22)]. Dashed curves show the degeneracy temperature [Eq. (34)], and dotted curves show , the temperature at which particles carry half the mass in nuclear statistical equilibrium of neutrons, protons, and particles with [Eq. (35)]. In the shaded ranges, and the free-nucleon rates overestimate the neutronization.
where is the temperature above which the equilibrium composition of transparent, free-nucleon matter becomes proton-rich [7 Eq. 14]. The full integrals give – for at . At higher temperature, the matter is less degenerate and positron captures increasingly offset electron captures, reversing the net rate above . At temperatures lower than the degeneracy temperature (dashed curves),
electrons are degenerate (Beloborodov [7], Eq. 4), but fewer electrons exceed the capture threshold. also falls as the matter neutronizes, since a lower reduces the degeneracy. Therefore, the optimal state lies near or above along all paths.
particles
The capture rates assume free nucleons. In nuclear statistical equilibrium of neutrons, protons, and particles with , half of the mass is in particles when (e.g., Qian & Woosley [80])
At , the optimized temperature falls below for (shaded in Figure 6), consistent with the region that Beloborodov [7]Fig. 1) marks as dominated by composite nuclei. Nucleons bound in particles do not capture electrons or positrons, such that at fixed , , and the net rate of Eq. (21) becomes
Wherever , which holds along all the trajectories considered here, formation lowers the net rate. Where , both and are negative for . Therefore, , and remains a lower limit. Heavier nuclei, which appear at still lower temperatures, typically have much smaller capture rates per nucleon than free protons at these densities (Langanke & Martínez-Pinedo [53]). At the mass fraction reaches 0.99 and 0.93 in the outer parts of the and 40 paths, where the -dominated ranges contribute 46% and 33% of the final . The path falls below only near , where it accrues of its . Along the path, , which lowers the net rate by about 3%. However, the rate-maximizing temperature then shifts slightly upward, such that including particles and re-maximizing over temperature raises by only 0.001–0.004 along the ceiling.
Neutrino absorption
The GRMHD simulation data in Figure 7 show that the electron neutrinosphere recedes to once the jet is launched, and to after , such that the gas at , where we integrate Eq. (22), is transparent. In our model, the capture spectra at , , and per nucleon (Beloborodov [7], Eqs. 54, 59) give an optical depth across the flow at of along the ceiling and along the boundary of Figure 3.
However, a transparent flow can still absorb neutrinos emitted by the rest of the disk (Surman & McLaughlin [93] (2005)). Integrating the and emission of the whole flow at , extending each ceiling path inward to with and , we find absorption rates at of – for and – for , compared with –, such that each nucleon absorbs neutrinos before it is launched. Since electron captures dominate at , the disk emits 1.9–2.5 times more than , driving toward 0.6–0.7 and raising by . A hotter inner disk, at the maximum temperature of Beloborodov [7], drives toward , raising by 0.07 for , while leaving it largely unchanged for –50. Therefore, neglecting neutrino absorption keeps the minimum along the ceiling a lower limit.
References
- [1]Abbott, B. P., Abbott, R., Abbott, T. D., et al. 2017, ApJL, 848, L12, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/aa91c9DOI
- [2]Agarwal, A., Siegel, D. M., Metzger, B. D., & Nagele, C. 2026, ApJ, 998, 57, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ae2856DOI
- [3]Aksulu, M. D., Wijers, R. A. M. J., van Eerten, H. J., & van der Horst, A. J. 2022, MNRAS, 511, 2848, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stac246DOI
- [4]Anand, S., Barnes, J., Yang, S., et al. 2024, ApJ, 962, 68, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad11dfDOI
- [5]Arnould, M., Goriely, S., & Takahashi, K. 2007, PhR, 450, 97, doi: 10.1016/j.physrep.2007.06.002DOI
- [6]Barnes, J., & Metzger, B. D. 2022, ApJL, 939, L29, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ac9b41DOI
- [7]Beloborodov, A. M. 2003, ApJ, 588, 931, doi: 10.1086/374217DOI
- [9]Blanchard, P. K., Villar, V. A., Chornock, R., et al. 2024, Nature Astronomy, 8, 774, doi: 10.1038/s41550-024-02237-4DOI
- [10]Blandford, R. D., & Payne, D. G. 1982, MNRAS, 199, 883, doi: 10.1093/mnras/199.4.883DOI
- [11]Blandford, R. D., & Znajek, R. L. 1977, MNRAS, 179, 433, doi: 10.1093/mnras/179.3.433DOI
- [12]Bopp, J., & Gottlieb, O. 2025, ApJL, 982, L56, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/adbdcdDOI
- [13]Brauer, K., Ji, A. P., Drout, M. R., & Frebel, A. 2021, ApJ, 915, 81, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac00b2DOI
- [14]Burns, E., Svinkin, D., Fenimore, E., et al. 2023, ApJL, 946, L31, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/acc39cDOI
- [15]Casse, F., & Ferreira, J. 2000, Astronomy and Astrophysics, 353, 1115. http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2000A%26A...353.1115C
- [16]Chan, H.-S., Gottlieb, O., Jacquem in-Ide, J., Cantiello, M., & Renzo, M. 2026, ApJL, 1007, L41, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ae9156DOI
- [17]Chen, W.-X., & Beloborodov, A. M. 2007, ApJ, 657, 383, doi: 10.1086/508923DOI
- [19]Cowan, J. J., Sneden, C., Lawler, J. E., et al. 2021, Reviews of Modern Physics, 93, 015002, doi: 10.1103/RevModPhys.93.015002DOI
- [20]Cowan, J. J., Thielemann, F.-K., & Truran, J. W. 1991, PhR, 208, 267, doi: 10.1016/0370-1573(91)90070-3DOI
- [22]Dean, C., & Fernández, R. 2024a, PhRvD, 109, 083010, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.109.083010DOI
- [24]Fernández, R., & Metzger, B. D. 2013, MNRAS, 435, 502, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stt1312DOI
- [25]Ferreira, J., & Pelletier, G. 1995, Astronomy and Astrophysics, 295, 807. http://cdsads.u-strasbg.fr/abs/1995A%26A...295..807F
- [26]Fraser, J., & Schönrich, R. 2022, MNRAS, 509, 6008, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stab3385DOI
- [27]Frebel, A., & Ji, A. P. 2023, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2302.09188, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2302.09188DOI
- [28]Frebel, A., & Norris, J. E. 2015, ARA&A, 53, 631, doi: 10.1146/annurev-astro-082214-122423DOI
- [29]Fujibayashi, S., Sekiguchi, Y., Shibata, M., & Wanajo, S. 2023, ApJ, 956, 100, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/acf5e5DOI
- [30]Fujimoto, S.-i., Nishimura, N., & Hashimoto, M.-a. 2008, ApJ, 680, 1350, doi: 10.1086/529416DOI
- [31]Gottlieb, O., Jacquemin-Ide, J., Lowell, B., Tchekhovskoy, A., & Ramirez-Ruiz, E. 2023a, ApJL, 952, L32, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ace779DOI
- [32]Gottlieb, O., Liska, M., Tchekhovskoy, A., et al. 2022, ApJL, 933, L9, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ac7530DOI
- [33]Gottlieb, O., Metzger, B. D., Issa, D., et al. 2025, ApJL, 993, L54, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ae0d81DOI
- [34]Gottlieb, O., Metzger, B. D., Quataert, E., et al. 2023b, ApJL, 958, L33, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ad096e
- [35]Gottlieb, O., Issa, D., Jacquemin-Ide, J., et al. 2023c, ApJL, 954, L21, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/aceeffDOI
- [36]Haynes, C. J., & Kobayashi, C. 2019, MNRAS, 483, 5123, doi: 10.1093/mnras/sty3389DOI
- [37]Hoffman, R. D., Woosley, S. E., & Qian, Y.-Z. 1997, ApJ, 482, 951, doi: 10.1086/304181DOI
- [38]Issa, D., Gottlieb, O., Metzger, B. D., et al. 2025, ApJL, 985, L26, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/adc694DOI
- [39]Jacquemin-Ide, J., Ferreira, J., & Lesur, G. 2019, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 490, 3112, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stz2749DOI
- [40]Jacquemin-Ide, J., Gottlieb, O., Lowell, B., & Tchekhovskoy, A. 2024a, ApJ, 961, 212, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad02f0
- [41]Jacquemin-Ide, J., Rincon, F., Tchekhovskoy, A., & Liska, M. 2024b, MNRAS, 532, 1522, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stae1538
- [42]Janiuk, A. 2014, A&A, 568, A105, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201423822DOI
- [45]Just, O., Aloy, M. A., Obergaulinger, M., & Nagataki, S. 2022, ApJL, 934, L30, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ac83a1DOI
- [46]Kajino, T., Aoki, W., Balantekin, A. B., et al. 2019, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics, 107, 109, doi: 10.1016/j.ppnp.2019.02.008
- [47]Kasen, D., Metzger, B., Barnes, J., Quataert, E., & Ramirez-Ruiz, E. 2017, Nature, 551, 80, doi: 10.1038/nature24453DOI
- [48]Kobayashi, C., Karakas, A. I., & Lugaro, M. 2020, ApJ, 900, 179, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/abae65DOI
- [49]Kobayashi, C., Mandel, I., Belczynski, K., et al. 2023, ApJL, 943, L12, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/acad82DOI
- [50]Kohri, K., Narayan, R., & Piran, T. 2005, ApJ, 629, 341, doi: 10.1086/431354DOI
- [51]Lalakos, A., Tchekhovskoy, A., Bromberg, O., et al. 2024, ApJ, 964, 79, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad0974DOI
- [52]Lalakos, A., Tchekhovskoy, A., Most, E. R., et al. 2025, PhRvD, 112, 123044, doi: 10.1103/zkq5-bj75DOI
- [53]Langanke, K., & Martínez-Pinedo, G. 2003, Reviews of Modern Physics, 75, 819, doi: 10.1103/RevModPhys.75.819
- [54]Lattimer, J. M., & Schramm, D. N. 1974, ApJL, 192, L145, doi: 10.1086/181612DOI
- [55]Lesage, S., Veres, P., Briggs, M. S., et al. 2023, ApJL, 952, L42, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ace5b4DOI
- [57]Lippuner, J., & Roberts, L. F. 2015, ApJ, 815, 82, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/815/2/82DOI
- [58]Lowell, B., Jacquemin-Ide, J., Tchekhovskoy, A., & Duncan, A. 2024, ApJ, 960, 82, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad09afDOI
- [59]MacFadyen, A. I., & Woosley, S. E. 1999, The Astrophysical Journal, 524, 262, doi: 10.1086/307790
- [60]MacFadyen, A. I., Woosley, S. E., & Heger, A. 2001, ApJ, 550, 410, doi: 10.1086/319698DOI
- [61]Macias, P., & Ramirez-Ruiz, E. 2019, ApJL, 877, L24, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ab2049DOI
- [62]Manikantan, V., Kaaz, N., Jacquemin-Ide, J., et al. 2024, ApJ, 965, 175, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad323dDOI
- [63]McKinney, J. C., Tchekhovskoy, A., & Blandford, R. D. 2012, MNRAS, 423, 3083, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.21074.xDOI
- [64]McLaughlin, G. C., & Surman, R. 2005, NuPhA, 758, 189, doi: 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2005.05.036DOI
- [65]Metzger, B. D. 2020, Living Reviews in Relativity, 23, 1, doi: 10.1007/s41114-019-0024-0
- [66]Metzger, B. D., Thompson, T. A., & Quataert, E. 2008, ApJ, 676, 1130, doi: 10.1086/526418DOI
- [67]Metzger, B. D., Martínez-Pinedo, G., Darbha, S., et al. 2010, MNRAS, 406, 2650, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2010.16864.xDOI
- [68]Miller, J. M., Sprouse, T. M., Fryer, C. L., et al. 2020, ApJ, 902, 66, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/abb4e3DOI
- [69]Mumpower, M. R., Lee, T.-S. H., Lloyd-Ronning, N., et al. 2025, ApJ, 982, 81, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad b1e3
- [70]Narayan, R., Igumenshchev, I. V., & Abramowicz, M. A. 2003, PASJ, 55, L69, doi: 10.1093/pasj/55.6.L69DOI
- [71]Narayan, R., Sądowski, A., Penna, R. F., & Kulkarni, A. K. 2012, MNRAS, 426, 3241, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.22002.xDOI
- [72]Petrucci, P. O., Ferreira, J., Henri, G., Malzac, J., & Foellmi, C. 2010, A&A, 522, A38, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201014753DOI
- [73]Pian, E., D’Avanzo, P., Benetti, S., et al. 2017, Nature, 551, 67, doi: 10.1038/nature24298DOI
- [74]Popham, R., Woosley, S. E., & Fryer, C. 1999, ApJ, 518, 356, doi: 10.1086/307259DOI
- [75]Prasanna, T., Parfrey, K., Metzger, B. D., et al. 2026, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2609.00190, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2609.00190DOI
- [76]Pruet, J., Thompson, T. A., & Hoffman, R. D. 2004, ApJ, 606, 1006, doi: 10.1086/382036DOI
- [77]Pruet, J., Woosley, S. E., & Hoffman, R. D. 2003, ApJ, 586, 1254, doi: 10.1086/367957DOI
- [78]Qian, Y.-Z. 2000, ApJL, 534, L67, doi: 10.1086/312659DOI
- [79]Qian, Y.-Z., & Wasserburg, G. J. 2007, PhR, 442, 237, doi: 10.1016/j.physrep.2007.02.006DOI
- [80]Qian, Y.-Z., & Woosley, S. E. 1996, ApJ, 471, 331, doi: 10.1086/177973DOI
- [81]Rastinejad, J. C., Fong, W., Levan, A. J., et al. 2024, ApJ, 968, 14, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad409cDOI
- [82]Renzo, M., Gottlieb, O., Chan, H. S., et al. 2026, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2606.21824, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2606.21824DOI
- [83]Roederer, I. U., Mateo, M., Bailey, III, J. I., et al. 2016, AJ, 151, 82, doi: 10.3847/0004-6256/151/3/82DOI
- [84]Saleem, M. C., Chen, H.-Y., Siegel, D. M., et al. 2026, ApJ, 1010, 59, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/aea6aaDOI
- [85]Scepi, N., Begelman, M. C., & Dexter, J. 2024, MNRAS, 527, 1424, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stad3299DOI
- [86]Shibata, M., Fujibayashi, S., Lam, A. T.-L., Ioka, K., & Sekiguchi, Y. 2024, PhRvD, 109, 043051, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.109.043051DOI
- [87]Shibata, M., Fujibayashi, S., Wanajo, S., et al. 2025, PhRvD, 111, 123017, doi: 10.1103/msy2-fwhxDOI
- [88]Siegel, D. M., Agarwal, A., Barnes, J., et al. 2022, ApJ, 941, 100, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac8d04DOI
- [89]Siegel, D. M., Barnes, J., & Metzger, B. D. 2019, Nature, 569, 241, doi: 10.1038/s41586-019-1136-0DOI
- [90]Siegel, D. M., & Metzger, B. D. 2017, PhRvL, 119, 231102, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.119.231102DOI
- [91]Simon, J. D., Brown, T. M., Mutlu-Pakdil, B., et al. 2023, ApJ, 944, 43, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/aca9d1DOI
- [92]Smartt, S. J., Chen, T.-W., Jerkstrand, A., et al. 2017, Nature, 551, 75, doi: 10.1038/nature24303DOI
- [93]Surman, R., & McLaughlin, G. C. 2004, ApJ, 603, 611, doi: 10.1086/381672DOI
- [95]Surman, R., McLaughlin, G. C., & Hix, W. R. 2006, ApJ, 643, 1057, doi: 10.1086/501116DOI
- [96]Tanvir, N. R., Levan, A. J., González-Fernández, C., et al. 2017, ApJL, 848, L27, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/aa90b6DOI
- [97]Tchekhovskoy, A., & McKinney, J. C. 2012, MNRAS, 423, L55, doi: 10.1111/j.1745-3933.2012.01256.xDOI
- [98]Tchekhovskoy, A., Narayan, R., & McKinney, J. C. 2011, MNRAS, 418, L79, doi: 10.1111/j.1745-3933.2011.01147.xDOI
- [99]Thielemann, F.-K., & Cowan, J. J. 2026, European Physical Journal A, 62, 105, doi: 10.1140/epja/s10050-026-01865-wDOI
- [100]Thielemann, F.-K., Eichler, M., Panov, I. V., & Wehmeyer, B. 2017, Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science, 67, 253, doi: 10.1146/annurev-nucl-101916-123246DOI
- [101]Thielemann, F.-K., Arcones, A., Käppeli, R., et al. 2011, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics, 66, 346, doi: 10.1016/j.ppnp.2011.01.032DOI
- [102]van de Voort, F., Pakmor, R., Grand, R. J. J., et al. 2020, MNRAS, 494, 4867, doi: 10.1093/mnras/staa754DOI
- [103]Wanderman, D., & Piran, T. 2010, MNRAS, 406, 1944, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2010.16787.xDOI
- [104]Watson, D., Hansen, C. J., Selsing, J., et al. 2019, Nature, 574, 497, doi: 10.1038/s41586-019-1676-3DOI
- [105]Wehmeyer, B., Pignatari, M., & Thielemann, F.-K. 2015, MNRAS, 452, 1970, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stv1352DOI
- [106]Woosley, S. E. 1993, ApJ, 405, 273, doi: 10.1086/172359DOI
- [107]Woosley, S. E., & Bloom, J. S. 2006, ARA&A, 44, 507, doi: 10.1146/annurev.astro.43.072103.150558DOI
- [108]Zhang, B., Liang, E., Page, K. L., et al. 2007, ApJ, 655, 989, doi: 10.1086/510110DOI