WorksMathematics
A large ultrafilter number at
Abstract
Gitik constructed a model where is strong limit, and every strongly uniform ultrafilter on has character . We show that in fact every uniform ultrafilter on has character in that model.
Introduction
An ultrafilter on an infinite set is uniform if for every . For an ideal on and , write if . A base of modulo is a family such that for every there is some such that . Set
So when is the trivial ideal these recover the usual character and ultrafilter number , and in general we have and .
We shall mainly be concerned with the case when is a singular cardinal and ; here we also denote by respectively. At one point we shall also consider the slightly more general case for some set ; here we also denote by .
Garti and Shelah [3] initiated the study of ultrafilter numbers at singular cardinal; in particular they showed the consistency of relative to a supercompact cardinal. Garti, Gitik and Shelah [2] achieved this at and lowered the large cardinal hypothesis to the optimal one, a measurable cardinal with . There have since been many further results on for singular [1, 5, 8].
A natural question is whether or even is consistent for a strong limit singular . Gitik [4] made important progress in this direction: starting from a model of GCH with a -extender, he constructed a model that satisfies the following:
(i) is a strong limit and ;
(ii) every strongly uniform ultrafilter on satisfies .
Here an ultrafilter on a singular cardinal is called strongly uniform if there is a strictly increasing cofinal sequence of regular cardinals below such that
The exact value of in this model was left open, and Gitik suggested that it might be . Here we shall show that in fact it is , thus answering the above question in the positive. This is a simple consequence of two facts: a dichotomy about uniform ultrafilters on and a lower bound for the character of a regular ultrafilter under suitable pcf hypotheses.
Lemma 1. Let be a uniform ultrafilter on . Then either is -regular, or is Rudin–Keisler above a strongly uniform ultrafilter on .
Recall that is -regular if there is a family of many sets in such that the intersection of any many of them is empty.
Lemma 2. Suppose are strictly increasing regular cardinals cofinal in . Also suppose and the bounding number of is at least . If is an ultrafilter on a set and is -regular for some , then .
We only need this Lemma 2 for the case , but we feel it better to distinguish between the underlying set and the regularity parameter .
Granted these two lemmas, we can prove in Gitik’s model as follows. Let be a uniform ultrafilter on . By Lemma 1 it is either -regular or Rudin–Keisler above a strongly uniform ultrafilter . In the latter case it is easy to see that , and by Gitik’s result, so . In the former case, by standard facts from pcf theory there is some increasing sequence of regular cardinals below that carries a scale of length (Gitik [4] also gave such a set explicitly), so in particular the bounding number of is , and we apply Lemma 2 with , and .
It remains to prove the two lemmas.
Proof of Lemma 1. Our proof resembles that of Kanamori [6 Theorem 2.5]. First note that whenever a uniform ultrafilter on is not strongly uniform, we can project it as follows. The sequence fails to witness strong uniformity, so there exists for which for all large enough ; by discarding an initial segment of , we may assume this is true for every , and moreover . Take . We can define an injection that maps into for each ; note that . Extend to by letting be identity outside ; it has the same projection effect as .
Now suppose is uniform and does not project to any strongly uniform ultrafilter on . Recursively for define and as follows:
.
.
Apply the above construction to to get , and , and let .
For limit , let be the eventual value of the non-increasing sequence .
We need to verify that is uniform in order for the recursion to go through. For let be the finite set of stages where the value at changes. We claim that and together recover ; this is because the maps are all injective. Thus uniformly for we have
Consequently, if has size strictly smaller than then so does . This shows is uniform.
Now for let . Note that if and only if , so no can belong to infinitely many ’s. The sequence then witnesses is -regular. □
Proof of Lemma 2. Our proof resembles Solomon’s proof of [7]. Suppose has size smaller than . We are going to find a set that splits every , i.e., and , so cannot be a base modulo .
By assumption there is a sequence such that each is in and the intersection of any of them is empty; in other words, for each the set has size strictly smaller than . Note that every set has size at least . Temporarily fix and . The set has size at least , so we can choose with size . Let , so . Let be as in the assumption; we may assume . For , we can choose above every ordinal in .
As and vary, we get fewer than many such functions , so by assumption they are -bounded by some ; we may assume for , so in particular is strictly increasing. Define
Let , and be as above. Take such that for all . We claim that for all and we have . Clearly because . Now suppose and ; we have , so and , a contradiction.
Considering the even and odd respectively and , we see that both and have size at least for any , hence at least , as desired. □
AI disclosure: no human intelligence was involved in writing this paper. All ideas are due to GPT 6 Astra.
References
Department of Mathematics, University of California, Irvine, Irvine, CA 92697
Email address: f [email protected]
References
- [1]Tom Benhamou and Sittinon Jirattikansakul. A small ultrafilter number at every singular cardinal. Acta Mathematica Hungarica, 171(1):12–38, 2023.arxiv.org/abs/2302.07311
- [2]Shimon Garti, Moti Gitik, and Saharon Shelah. Cardinal characteristics at ℵω. Acta Mathematica Hungarica, 160(2):320–336, 2020.
- [3]Shimon Garti and Saharon Shelah. The ultrafilter number for singular cardinals. Acta Mathematica Hungarica, 137(4):296–301, 2012.
- [4]Moti Gitik. On spectrum of strongly uniform ultrafilters over a singular cardinal, 2019. https://www.math.tau.ac.il/~gitik/str-spectrum2.pdf.DOI
- [5]Radek Honzik and Šárka Stejskalová. Small u(κ) at singular κ with compactness at κ⁺⁺. Archive for Mathematical Logic, 61(1):33–54, 2022.
- [6]Akihiro Kanamori. Weakly normal filters and irregular ultrafilters. Transactions of the American Mathematical Society, 220:393–399, 1976.DOI
- [7]R. C. Solomon. Families of sets and functions. Czechoslovak Mathematical Journal, 27(4):556–559, 1977.DOI
- [8]Toshimichi Usuba. Monotonicity of the ultrafilter number function. Archive for Mathematical Logic, 65(4):545–568, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2501.14988