WorksMathematics
Iterated socles and closure operations
Abstract
Let be a -dimensional Cohen–Macaulay local ring, containing a field, and let be a parameter ideal with , also, in the mixed case via some mild assumptions. We prove for that , and that when is not regular. We show that Cohen–Macaulayness cannot be removed. We also prove the characteristic-free exact formula for parameter ideals of order with a level tangent cone, giving singular mixed-characteristic Gorenstein and non-Gorenstein examples in which the singular bound is attained.
Introduction
Let be a Noetherian local ring and let be an -primary ideal. The Goto number of is , where denotes the integral closure of . Thus, the Goto number measures how far one can enlarge by taking colons with powers of the maximal ideal while remaining inside its integral closure. Motivated by a result of Wang [7], Watanabe and Yoshida established a remarkable lower bound for this invariant:
Theorem 1.1 (Watanabe–Yoshida [8 Theorem 6.2]). Let be a -dimensional Cohen–Macaulay local ring of characteristic , where . Let and let be a parameter ideal. Then
(i) ;
(ii) if is not regular, then .
In characteristic zero, Watanabe and Yoshida obtained related results under additional hypotheses, including normality and conditions on the canonical divisor. They also raised the question of whether the characteristic assumption in the above theorem could be removed. More precisely, they asked the following.
Question 1.2 (See [8 Question 8.1]). Does the containment in Theorem 1.1 hold without any restriction on the characteristic?
They also asked whether the Cohen–Macaulay hypothesis could be removed.
Question 1.3 (See [8 Question 8.2]). Can the Cohen–Macaulay hypothesis in Theorem 1.1 be removed?
A further question, posed in [8 Question 1.2], concerns the determination of the Goto number itself. Related questions about the containment of colon ideals in integral closures were also considered in [3]. The purpose of this paper is to investigate these questions from three complementary perspectives: characteristic-free containments, mixed-characteristic methods, and exact computations of Goto numbers. Our first result is:
Theorem 1.4. Let be a Cohen–Macaulay local ring containing a field, with . Let and let be a parameter ideal. Then . If is not regular, then also .
The proof in characteristic zero uses the Lefschetz approximation theory of Aschenbrenner and Schoutens. The basic idea is to approximate a complete local ring of characteristic zero by complete local rings of positive characteristic, apply the Watanabe–Yoshida theorem to these approximating rings, and descend the resulting containment by faithful flatness.
We next turn to mixed characteristic. Here ultraproduct constructions provide a framework for comparing certain test ideals in mixed characteristic with their positive characteristic counterparts. In particular, we consider rings of the form
where the are perfect fields of a fixed positive characteristic. For monomial ideals and fixed rational exponents, we establish the comparison . The test ideals here are understood in the sense of [2 Definition 8.13]. We also establish several ultraproduct transfer results for trace-image descriptions, Skoda-type identities, and colon containments.
Our next objective is to determine the Goto number more precisely. The lower bound in Theorem 1.1 depends only on the dimension and the order of the parameter ideal. The associated graded ring, however, contains additional information that can determine the exact value.
Recall that a standard graded Cohen–Macaulay algebra is called level if its canonical module is generated in a single degree. Suppose that is a standard graded Cohen–Macaulay level algebra with Hilbert series , . For a parameter ideal , , whose initial forms constitute a homogeneous system of parameters, we obtain the following exact formulas:
and, consequently, .
Thus, the Goto number is governed not only by the dimension and the order of the parameter ideal, but also by the degree of the -polynomial of the tangent cone. In particular, the difference between the general singular lower bound and the actual Goto number can be arbitrarily large.
We give examples illustrating this phenomenon, including singular mixed-characteristic Gorenstein and non-Gorenstein rings. In the regular case, the same computation recovers , , for in a regular local ring. Then, we show that the Cohen–Macaulay hypothesis in Question 1.3 cannot be omitted. The final section considers further questions from [8] concerning the interaction between test ideals, colon ideals, and the associated graded ring, see Questions 6.1 and 6.4. In particular, we investigate the containments and , in the settings specified below.
Iterated socles under ultraproducts
Rings in this section are containing a field.
The Lefschetz approximation setup
Definition 2.1. Let be a set. An ultrafilter on is a collection of subsets of such that:
(1) and ;
(2) if and , then ;
(3) if , then ;
(4) for every , exactly one of or holds.
We say that a property holds for almost all (or -almost everywhere) if the set of for which it holds belongs to .
Definition 2.2. Let be a family of nonempty sets. On the product define . This is an equivalence relation. The ultraproduct is . The class of is denoted or . If all , one writes and speaks of the ultrapower.
Definition 2.3. If each is a ring, the componentwise operations on descend to the ultraproduct , which is again a ring with
More generally the same construction applies to groups, modules, fields and first-order structures in a fixed language.
Fact 2.4 (Łos’s theorem). A first-order sentence in the language of rings holds in if and only if it holds in for almost all .
Let be a local ring of equicharacteristic zero. Aschenbrenner–Schoutens [1 Theorem 4.3, Theorem 5.2, Lemmas 5.3–5.4] construct a faithfully flat extension , an ultraproduct of complete local rings of positive characteristic. Here runs over an index set equipped with an ultrafilter ; Each is a complete local ring with maximal ideal , and the maximal ideal of is approximated by the : the image of in is . The transfer principle says: given a fixed finite list of elements and ideals , one can choose compatible approximations and such that, for almost all ,
and (when finite);
is Cohen–Macaulay iff is;
a fixed tuple approximating a parameter sequence of is a parameter sequence of ;
all fixed ideal relations among the and hold in ;
Let and an ideal. We want to transfer statements such as:
is integral over an ideal , i.e. satisfies an equation with ;
an element lies in the integral closure of .
Dealing with Question 1.2
We give the additional numerical argument needed to transfer integral dependence. In particular, we do not assume a uniform degree for integral equations in the approximating rings.
Lemma 2.5. If is an -primary ideal of , then, for almost all , .
Proof. Let the length on the right be , and lift a composition series of to ideals . Each factor is cyclic, nonzero, and annihilated by . Choose its cyclic generator and finite generating sets of the . The corresponding generation relations, inclusions , and nonmembership of the cyclic generator in transfer to almost all . Nonmembership is preserved because the extension to is faithfully flat. Since is maximal, the resulting chain has exactly simple factors. □
Lemma 2.6. Let be a complete Cohen–Macaulay local ring of equicharacteristic zero, and let be an -primary ideal. Then for almost all .
Proof. The residue field of is infinite. Choose a -generated minimal reduction , where . Thus is a parameter ideal and, for some fixed integer , . This equality is a finite collection of ideal-membership relations. Consequently is a reduction of for almost all . For these , is Cohen–Macaulay of dimension and is a parameter ideal.
The middle equality is Lemma 2.5. □
Lemma 2.7. Let be as in Lemma 2.6. Let be -primary ideals. If for almost all , then .
Proof. Integral dependence gives . Apply Lemma 2.6 to and to obtain . A complete Cohen–Macaulay local ring is formally equidimensional. Rees’s multiplicity theorem [4 Theorem 11.3.1] now gives . □
Theorem 2.8. Let be a Cohen–Macaulay local ring containing a field, with . If and is a parameter ideal, then . If is not regular, then also .
Proof. In positive characteristic these are precisely [8 Theorem 1.1]. Suppose that has characteristic zero. First pass to the -adic completion. This preserves dimension, Cohen–Macaulayness, and regularity. It also preserves the colon condition, and integral dependence descends by faithful flatness. For completeness, if becomes integral over and , then for some . Faithful flatness gives , and hence . We may therefore assume that is complete. Take , or in the nonregular case, and fix . Choose compatible approximations of , , , and . For almost all ,
and is Cohen–Macaulay. In the nonregular case, ; dimension and embedding dimension transfer, so that almost all are nonregular. The positive-characteristic theorem yields for almost all . In particular for almost all , so . Thus is a proper -primary ideal. Apply Lemma 2.7 to . It follows that , as required. □
Mixed char.
Low dimensional approach
Proposition 3.1. Let be a two-dimensional Cohen–Macaulay local ring. For every parameter ideal , , . If is not regular, then .
Proof. If is regular, Heinzer–Swanson prove, without a characteristic restriction, , see [5 Theorem 2.2]. Since , this proves the first assertion. If is nonregular, Wang’s theorem [7 Theorems 1.1–1.2], also reproduced as [8 Theorem 1.1], gives
Thus is integral over . The inclusion gives the other assertion. □
Proposition 3.2. Let be Cohen–Macaulay and either nonregular of dimension at least two, or regular of dimension at least three. Let be a parameter ideal and put . Then, in any characteristic, .
Proof. Apply Wang’s theorem with exponent and use the increasing chain for . For , , one has . □
The containment
Notation 3.3. Fix an ultrafilter on an index set and let . If are ideals, write . This is an ideal of , called the internal ideal of the family. It need not be finitely generated.
Lemma 3.4. Suppose with the same finite for every , and put . Then . For any other family of ideals, one has
The equality of colons holds even without the bound on the number of generators of .
Proof. For the first assertion, express each element of as a sum of the same generators with coefficients in , and take their ultraproducts. For the product assertion, every element of is with . The fixed bound on the number of summands permits passage to . For the colon assertion, one inclusion is immediate. Conversely, if on a set in , choose with on that set. Then and . This proves the other inclusion. □
Definition 3.5. For a family on which the mixed-characteristic test ideals are defined, set .
Proposition 3.6. Suppose that, for each , a specified -linear map satisfies . Then the coordinatewise map defined by is -linear and satisfies .
Proof. The map is well-defined and linear by its coordinatewise definition. If , choose with on the set in where . These choices give a preimage of . The reverse containment is immediate. □
Proposition 3.7. Let the be complete normal -Gorenstein local domains of mixed characteristic. Suppose is generated by a fixed number of specified elements. Then, for every rational , .
Proof. Apply Skoda’s theorem in each factor [2 Theorem 8.7 and Corollary 8.20(b)] and then apply Lemma 3.4 to the products. □
Proposition 3.8. Let be a complete normal -Gorenstein local domain of mixed characteristic and dimension . For every parameter ideal , . Consequently, for a family of such rings of fixed dimension and parameter ideals , let J_U:=\ulim J_i and C_U:=\ulim J_i. Then .
Proof. We use monotonicity, invariance under integral closure of the ideal, and Skoda’s theorem. The integral-closure invariance for the unified ideal follows from [2 Proposition 8.6(c), Theorem 8.11, and Definition 8.13], using a common sufficiently small perturbation for the two ideals in this single ring. For any ideal and , . Indeed, for , principal Skoda gives , and monotonicity gives the containment in . Thus
Here Skoda applies to the generators of . This proves the single-ring assertion. Take ultraproducts and use the colon equality in Lemma 3.4 for the second assertion. □
An unconditional mixed-characteristic comparison
Fix a prime , an integer , and perfect fields of characteristic .
Notation 3.9. Let , , and K:=\ulim k_i. Let D:=\ulim R_i and .
The symbols on denote the classes of the corresponding variables. The field is perfect. In the formulas below, set and for .
Lemma 3.10. There is a natural isomorphism . It identifies the images of with the indicated regular parameters. In particular, is a complete Noetherian regular local ring of mixed characteristic .
Proof. For every fixed , Lemma 3.4 gives D/\mathfrak{m}^N\cong\ulim(R_i/\mathfrak{m}_i^N). Only finitely many monomials with are needed to describe ; their coefficients are respectively taken modulo . Thus they are truncated Witt vectors of bounded lengths. For each fixed , addition and multiplication on are given by the same finite list of Witt polynomials, because is fixed. Consequently \ulim W_n(k_i)=W_n(K). Applying this simultaneously to the finitely many coefficient slots gives compatible ring isomorphisms . Take the inverse limit over . This argument constructs the map ; no approximation theorem asserting faithful flatness of that map is needed or claimed. □
Let be a fixed finite nonempty set. Assume the monomial ideals
are proper. Their common Newton polyhedron is . We record a version of Dickson’s lemma that we need:
Lemma 3.11 (Dickson’s lemma). Let and let . Then has only finitely many minimal elements with respect to the coordinatewise partial order. Moreover, if is upward closed, then every element of lies above a minimal element of .
Theorem 3.12. For every rational , and . In particular, the first ideal is finitely generated by a set of monomials independent of .
Proof. The mixed-characteristic monomial formula [2 Proposition 8.21] says that
The exponent set is upward closed for the coordinatewise order. Dickson’s lemma gives a finite set of minimal exponents generating it. Both and are independent of . The first assertion now follows from Lemma 3.4. Lemma 3.10 identifies as another complete regular local ring with the same regular parameters. Applying the same monomial formula to this ring proves the second assertion.
Corollary 3.13. For fixed and as above, there exists such that, for every and rational , .
Proof. Write the nontrivial supporting inequalities of as , with integral vectors and positive integers ; there are finitely many of them. For , the numbers are integers. Choose
Then replacing by changes none of the strict integer inequalities defining the monomial test ideal. Coordinate inequalities with zero right-hand side do not change.
The Watanabe–Yoshida identity for equal parameter powers
We continue with the fixed-prime family in § 3.3, and assume . Set
Theorem 3.14. With ordinary ideal integral closure on , one has , and . Also, . Furthermore, , and .
Proof. We first record computations valid in every regular local ring of dimension with parameters , in any characteristic. Let . Every monomial of total degree is integral over , since . Also is integrally closed. Indeed, is a polynomial domain, so the -adic order is multiplicative. An integral equation over cannot hold for an element of order less than , because its highest power would be the unique term of smallest order. Therefore . The associated graded ring of is , an artinian graded Gorenstein ring with socle degree . Its perfect pairings into degree give for . To justify the filtered step, an element of order has nonzero initial form which can be multiplied by a degree- form to give a nonzero product. It therefore does not annihilate modulo . The opposite inclusion follows from . Let us apply these computations in each . The fixed finite generating sets for powers of allow all the displayed colon identities to pass to by Lemma 3.4. It remains to check that the internal integral closure is the ordinary integral closure in . If , choose a single integral equation for over . Its degree is finite, and membership of its coefficients in the fixed powers of is witnessed by finitely many equations. It follows that almost everywhere, so . Conversely, the degree- monomial equations above work directly in , and the integral closure of an ideal is an ideal. Hence . The Newton polyhedron of is . Theorem 3.12 with shows that its test ideal is generated by monomials with , i.e., . Thus . Setting in the colon formula gives , proving the first boxed identity. The same calculations apply to , proving the second one. Finally set and in that formula. The element belongs to the latter colon and not to , in each factor and hence also in .
Remark 3.15. We will present in Proposition 5.5 another argument of Theorem 3.14 without any use of mixed-characteristic test ideal from [2].
Proposition 3.16. Let have mixed characteristic . There is no faithfully flat unital map from to an ultraproduct of nonzero rings of prime positive characteristics.
Proof. If the factors have characteristic on a set in , then maps to zero, contradicting the injectivity of a faithfully flat map. Otherwise is a unit in almost every factor, and hence in the ultraproduct. This contradicts faithful flatness, since the proper ideal would extend to the unit ideal. □
The role of Cohen–Macaulayness
We show the basic containment of Theorem 1.1 fails for . The ring is reduced, complete, two-dimensional, and not Cohen–Macaulay; moreover, is a nonzerodivisor. Choosing gives examples over every field.
Proposition 4.1. Let be a complete discrete valuation ring. Define and . For every , the ideal is a parameter ideal contained in , but .
Proof. In , one has . Both ideals on the right are prime. Their quotient rings are and , of dimensions two and one. Thus is reduced and has minimal components of different dimensions. Since it is complete, it cannot be Cohen–Macaulay. Neither minimal prime contains , so is a nonzerodivisor. In mixed characteristic is a unit times a positive power of , so is also -torsionfree.
The relations in give for . In particular . Together with , this proves that is -primary and hence a parameter ideal. Let . Any degree- monomial in containing is killed by . For a monomial with , one has , since for . Thus .
Under the quotient map the ideal maps to and maps to . An integral equation descends under any ring homomorphism. But is integrally closed in the discrete valuation ring , and does not contain . Consequently . □
Bounds on Goto number
We start with some lemmas.
Lemma 5.1. Let be artinian so that is a standard graded artinian algebra whose socle is concentrated in degree . Then for .
Proof. Because for , Nakayama’s lemma gives . Thus the right-hand side is contained in the left-hand side. For the reverse inclusion let with . Its initial form is nonzero. Since the socle of is concentrated in degree , one can successively multiply by degree-one elements without obtaining zero until reaching degree . In particular, there is with . Lift to . The initial form of is , so . Hence , as required. The endpoint cases follow by the same argument. □
Lemma 5.2. Let be a local ring of positive dimension, and let . Then .
Proof. Otherwise, the ideal would be a reduction of . For sufficiently large , , which says . Nakayama’s lemma would force a positive power of to vanish, contradicting . □
The following has application to Question 1.2 when the ring is of mixed char.
Theorem 5.3. Let be a -dimensional Cohen–Macaulay local ring, . Suppose is a Cohen–Macaulay, standard graded level -algebra, with Hilbert series with . Fix and a parameter ideal , where each and the initial forms constitute a homogeneous system of parameters in . Then for , (i) , (ii) and .
Proof. The initial forms form a regular sequence in the Cohen–Macaulay ring . The standard lifting theorem for regular initial sequences gives . This Artinian graded ring is level: for a Cohen–Macaulay level graded ring, quotienting by a homogeneous regular sequence preserves levelness. One way to see this is to use the graded canonical module: it is generated in a single degree, and the canonical module of the quotient is the quotient of the canonical module, up to a grading shift. The Hilbert series of the quotient is , so its top socle degree is . Lemma 5.1, applied to , proves (i).
We next verify that is a reduction of . Since has finite length, for all sufficiently large one has . Lifting to gives . Nakayama’s lemma implies . Taking for large , we obtain , as required. Consequently . Let . Formula (i) gives . At the next exponent the same formula gives , which is not contained in by Lemma 5.2. Thus . Finally . If is nonregular, then : indeed, would imply , forcing the Cohen–Macaulay local ring to be regular. □
Corollary 5.4. Under the tangent-cone hypotheses of Theorem 5.3, if the residue field is infinite, the -tuples that satisfy the theorem form a nonempty Zariski-open subset. Thus the exact formula 5.3(ii) holds for a general -generated parameter ideal of order .
Proof. A standard graded Cohen–Macaulay algebra over an infinite field admits a linear homogeneous system of parameters . Their -th powers are a homogeneous system of parameters of degree , so the asserted locus is nonempty. The homogeneous-system-of-parameters condition is open in (equivalently, the condition that the quotient have dimension zero is open). Theorem 5.3 applies to every lift of such a tuple. □
Proposition 5.5. Suppose is a complete mixed-characteristic discrete valuation ring. Let be any regular local ring of dimension , with regular system of parameters . For , let . Then and .
Proof. The associated graded ring of is , an Artinian graded complete intersection of socle degree . The local ring is Gorenstein. Lemma 5.1 gives for all . Every degree- parameter monomial is integral over , since . Hence is integral over . Also is integrally closed: the -adic order is multiplicative because is a polynomial domain, and taking orders in an integral equation excludes elements of order less than . Thus . For the displayed colon is . For it is and contains . This proves the exact value of . □
Theorem 1.1 holds for these parameter ideals in every residue characteristic. For , the exponent is best possible even among singular mixed-characteristic Cohen–Macaulay domains:
Example 5.6. Let be either over any field, or over a complete mixed-characteristic discrete valuation ring , with . Fix . Set and . Then is a singular complete Cohen–Macaulay domain, , and .
Proof. The ring is a hypersurface of dimension and embedding dimension , so it is Cohen–Macaulay and nonregular. Its associated graded ring is
The displayed binomial is irreducible in every characteristic: view it as a primitive polynomial of degree one in over the unique factorization domain . Consequently, is a domain. Separatedness of the -adic filtration shows that is a domain, and its -adic order is multiplicative. The ring is free over , with basis . Thus the initial forms form a regular sequence in , and
This is an artinian graded complete intersection with Hilbert series and socle degree . The local ring is also artinian Gorenstein. It follows from Lemma 5.1 that
Write . The equation for shows that is integral over , so is integral over . Also is integral over , by the same monomial equations as in Proposition 5.5. Powers and transitivity of integral dependence therefore show that is integral over . Since is a domain, the order argument used above shows that is integrally closed. Hence . For , formula gives . At it gives , which contains . The claimed Goto number follows.
The singular bound in Theorem 1.1 is sharp in mixed characteristic even for non-Gorenstein domains, in every dimension :
Example 5.7. Let be a complete discrete valuation ring of mixed characteristic, let and and . Then is a complete, Cohen–Macaulay domain of dimension , but is not Gorenstein. For these parameter ideals, and .
Proof. The three relations reduce all monomials in to -linear combinations of . To prove independence, consider the finite -algebra . It is a complete regular local ring of dimension , with regular parameters ; in particular it is a domain. As an -module it is free with basis for . The substitutions , respect the displayed relations, and are -linearly independent. Consequently is a domain and is free over the regular local ring with basis . In particular is Cohen–Macaulay of dimension . The relations are homogeneous of degree two for the maximal-ideal filtration, and the displayed free basis is compatible with that filtration. Writing for initial forms, we obtain
It is the homogeneous coordinate ring of the rational normal cubic curve, with the extra polynomial variables . In particular is a standard Gorenstein-free (non-Gorenstein), Cohen–Macaulay level domain, and as a module over it has homogeneous basis of degrees . More explicitly, the quotient of by the linear regular sequence is , with socle concentrated in degree one; this verifies levelness. Thus , and so . The initial forms are a homogeneous system of parameters, so Theorem 5.3 gives and . As is a domain, the -adic order on is multiplicative, so each is integrally closed; hence . Finally, is , whose socle has dimension two. Therefore has Cohen–Macaulay type two and is not Gorenstein. Its embedding dimension is , so it is also nonregular.
Additional investigations
A non containment
In this subsection, denotes the classical positive-characteristic Hara–Yoshida test ideal used in [8]. They asked:
Question 6.1. ([8], Question 5.8.) When ?
Normality is not assumed in the question. The following example disproves the containment, even for a complete Gorenstein domain with Cohen–Macaulay associated graded ring.
Proposition 6.2. Let for any prime , and set . Then is a one-dimensional complete Gorenstein domain, is Cohen–Macaulay, and , . For every integer , , and . In particular, . Proof. Let . Let , , and . The numerical semigroup . Recall that if is a numerical semigroup and , the Apéry set of with respect to is defined by . Equivalently, it consists of the least elements of in each residue class modulo . Since , we have , where the displayed elements are the least elements of in the residue classes , respectively. In residue classes modulo , these are the least members of . Consequently is free of rank over , with basis . There is a presentation . Here is a verification that this presentation has no extra component. The quotient on the right has dimension one and is a complete intersection: modulo its quotient is , of length . It is therefore Cohen–Macaulay, is a nonzerodivisor, and it is free of rank over . Its natural surjection onto , also free of rank , is an isomorphism. In particular, is Gorenstein. For each , let . Recall that . Every has a unique expression
The -adic orders of the corresponding Apéry monomials are
Indeed, these orders follow directly from
and the fact that . We claim that . To see this, multiplication by increases the order by at least one. Conversely, the valuation of every element of is at least , and the displayed Apéry orders give the required upper bound. Thus equality follows. Every element has a unique expression
Since the five summands have distinct valuations modulo , there is no cancellation between their terms of lowest valuation. It follows that for every nonzero . Consequently, multiplication by is injective on . Since , we conclude that is Cohen–Macaulay. Since is a homogeneous nonzerodivisor of degree one on , we have . Moreover, , whose -basis is . These elements have -adic orders , respectively. Hence . It follows that . Recall that if is a standard graded Cohen–Macaulay ring of dimension , its -invariant is defined by . In particular, since is one-dimensional and Cohen–Macaulay, its -invariant is .
The gaps of are . Thus is the normalization of and its conductor is
The one-dimensional test-ideal/conductor formula gives ; see [9 Theorem 3.3]. For completeness, this formula has an elementary verification here. For every nonzero ideal , the valuation criterion and the conductor give . For the nontrivial inclusion, choose of least valuation. If , then ; for a fixed nonzero , for every . Conversely, a tight-closure equation implies by letting tend to infinity. It follows that for every , so . Taking with gives , and forces . Hence .
The ideal is a reduction of . Indeed, using the relations we can verify that every monomial of degree four in belongs to . For the monomials not involving , we have
Consequently, . The reverse inclusion is immediate, and hence . Therefore, is a reduction of . Reduction invariance and the principal multiplication formula for test ideals [6 Proposition 1.11(1)–(2)] therefore give, for every integer ,
Alternatively, just the containment suffices for the counterexample; it follows from [8 Lemma 2.6(1)]. Since , every generator of is a product of elements, each of which has valuation at least 5. Consequently, . On the other hand, . Therefore, . Since , we conclude that for every . In particular, taking , we obtain . This proves the claim. □
The proposed exponent in Question 6.1 is too large by the following:
Proposition 6.3. For every integer , let . Then is a one-dimensional complete intersection, is Cohen–Macaulay, and
For every integer , and .
Proof. Recall that the previous result is the special case . Also, . Let and . A presentation is given by . Similar to Proposition 6.2, we use the following basis over . Its valuations form the Apéry set
These have all the distinct residues modulo . Their orders are respectively and , and each equals the floor of its valuation divided by . As before, for . Hence is Cohen–Macaulay and its Hilbert numerator is
It follows that . The largest Apéry element is ; the conductor exponent is therefore . The conductor formula and the principal reduction give the stated test ideal, exactly as above. Finally, with . The first element of that test ideal has order , and all of its elements have order at least . □
for monomial parameter ideals
Question 6.4. (See [8 Question 8.6]). When ?
The next theorem gives a complete answer for monomial parameter ideals in regular parameters. The same answer holds for the mixed-characteristic test ideal used earlier in this note.
Proposition 6.5. Let be a complete regular ring of dimension and positive residue characteristic, and let be a regular system of parameters. Let with . In equal characteristic, assume also that is -finite. Then
In particular, $Q\subseteq\tau(R,Q^{d-1})\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad\sum_{i=1}^{d}\frac{1}{a_i}>d-2.
Proof. The Newton polyhedron of is . The monomial test-ideal formula gives (*); see [6 Theorem 4.8], [8 Example 2.8], and [2 Proposition 8.21]. For the generator , the strict inequality in that formula becomes . It is independent of , and is equivalent to the boxed condition. Monomial membership in ideals generated by monomials in a regular system of parameters is determined by divisibility of their exponent vectors, so this checks every generator of . □
Corollary 6.6. If all entries with deleted, and arrange the remaining entries in increasing order, then the containment in Proposition 6.5 holds exactly in the following cases:
(1) , with arbitrary remaining exponents;
(2) and the triple is one of
Also, it never holds if .
Proof. After removing the entries equal to 1, the criterion is . This is automatic for . For , the left side is at most . If and , the inequality forces . If , it always holds; if , it forces ; and if , it fails. □
Corollary 6.7. Adopt the notation from subsection 3.3, and fix . Set , , and . Then the following conditions are equivalent:
Moreover, .
Proof. In view of Theorem 3.12, we see the same finite monomial generators in every factor and in . It remains to apply the membership test in Proposition 6.5. □
M. ASGHARZADEH
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]M. Aschenbrenner and H. Schoutens, Lefschetz extensions, tight closure, and big Cohen–Macaulay algebras, Israel J. Math. 161 (2007), 221–310.DOI
- [2]B. Bhatt, L. Ma, Z. Patakfalvi, K. Schwede, K. Tucker, J. Waldron, and J. Witaszek, with an appendix by R. Datta, Test ideals in mixed characteristic: a unified theory up to perturbation, arXiv:2401.00615v2arxiv.org/abs/2401.00615
- [3]A. Corso, S. Goto, Shiro; C. Huneke, C. Polini, B.Ulrich, Iterated socles and integral dependence in regular rings, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 370 (2018), no. 1, 53-72.arxiv.org/abs/1409.5481
- [4]C. Huneke and I. Swanson, Integral Closure of Ideals, Rings, and Modules, London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series, vol. 336, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2006.
- [5]W. Heinzer and I. Swanson, The Goto numbers of parameter ideals, J. Algebra 321 (2009), 152–166.arxiv.org/abs/0801.0685
- [6]N. Hara and K. Yoshida, A generalization of tight closure and multiplier ideals, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 355 (2003), 3143–3174.DOI
- [7]H.-J. Wang, Links of symbolic powers of prime ideals, Math. Z. 256 (2007), 749–756.
- [8]K.-i. Watanabe and K. Yoshida, A variant of Wang’s theorem, J. Algebra 369 (2012), 129–145.
- [9]J. C. Vassilev and A. N. Vraciu, When is tight closure determined by the test ideal?, J. Commut. Algebra 1 (2009), no. 3, 591–602.arxiv.org/abs/0809.1891