betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The state of nuclear data for fusion activation simulations

Abstract

This report compares decay-heat calculations made with four nuclear data libraries, TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0 and JENDL-5, against the JAEA FNS decay-heat benchmark. The main comparison uses the 2000 campaign, in which 73 foils were irradiated for five minutes in a mostly 14 MeV neutron field and their decay heat was measured for about an hour. The 1996 seven-hour campaign, with 29 foils and cooling times of up to 400 days, is compared separately and is not included in the rankings. Over the 69 elemental foils solved by all four libraries, the median deviation from the measurement (the mean absolute C/E deviation of each foil) is JENDL-5 17 percent, TENDL-2025 19 percent, JEFF-4.0 22 percent and ENDF/B-VIII.1 44 percent. No library is best everywhere: JENDL-5 on 24, JEFF-4.0 on 18, TENDL-2025 on 17 and ENDF/B-VIII.1 on 10 of the foils. For each element the report breaks the heat down by product and lists the nuclear data on which the libraries differ, and the final sections propose measurements, including enriched-isotope irradiations, that would resolve the largest differences.

The benchmark

The JAEA Fusion Neutronics Source (FNS) decay-heat experiments are distributed by the IAEA through CoNDERC. Samples were irradiated with D-T neutrons, moved to a calorimeter, and their decay heat was measured as they cooled. The benchmark covers 73 foils, 132 irradiations and four irradiation positions, each with a measured neutron spectrum.

The calculations use the published spectrum for each position directly, so no neutron transport is needed. Cross sections are collapsed with the spectrum to one-group reaction rates, and the Bateman equations are solved over the irradiation and cooling history. The main comparison uses the 2000 five-minute campaign because it is the only one that includes all 73 foils, all irradiated at position 3 and measured at the same cooling times.

The 1996 seven-hour campaign irradiated 29 foils at position 7 and followed some of them for up to 400 days, so it is more sensitive to long-lived products. Its results are shown separately and are not used in the periodic tables, win counts or distributions. The campaigns differ in spectrum, irradiation history and measurement, so they are not pooled. Iron shows why: with the same libraries, its median calculated heat is 6 to 9 percent above the 2000 five-minute measurements and 5 to 8 percent below the 1996 five-minute measurements.

Periodic table showing elements irradiated in the FNS decay-heat benchmark (69). Black: irradiated; white: not irradiated. Elements shown by period: H He; Li Be B C N O F Ne; Na Mg Al Si P S Cl Ar; K Ca Sc Ti V Cr Mn Fe Co Ni Cu Zn Ga Ge As Se Br Kr; Rb Sr Y Zr Nb Mo Tc Ru Rh Pd Ag Cd In Sn Sb Te I Xe; Cs Ba Hf Ta W Re Os Ir Pt Au Hg Tl Pb Bi Po At Rn; Fr Ra Rf Db Sg Bh Hs Mt Ds Rg Cn Nh Fl Mc Lv Ts Og; La Ce Pr Nd Pm Sm Eu Gd Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb Lu; Ac Th Pa U Np Pu Am Cm Bk Cf Es Fm Md No Lr.

Figure 1. Elements irradiated in the benchmark. Four alloy samples were also irradiated.

Library configurations

Each calculation takes its neutron cross sections, reaction channels and isomeric branching from one library, and uses that library’s decay data and fission yields where it has them. TENDL-2025 has neither, so the TENDL calculations use UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, the UKAEA libraries FISPACT-II pairs with TENDL. These are published as ENDF-6 files in the FISPACT-II nuclear data repository and were converted for this work. A difference between two curves can therefore come from the neutron data, the decay data or both. The table in the next section lists the source of every input.

All data are used as published. Values that look wrong are left in place, because adjusting them to match the benchmark would hide the effect being tested.

Previous validation

The 2020 UKAEA validation analysed this benchmark with FISPACT-II and TENDL-2019, ENDF/B-VIII.0, JEFF-3.3, EAF2010 and, where it had coverage, IRDFF-II. All of those libraries have since been superseded.

This report repeats the comparison with TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0 and JENDL-5, and goes further for each element. It breaks the heat down by product, compares the inputs behind each product, separates reaction rates from isomeric branching, and plots the energy-dependent cross sections or branching ratios where the libraries differ. Covariance results are given with the fraction of production they cover. This narrows a disagreement down to particular evaluated data, but it cannot say which library is right. That needs differential measurements, such as those in EXFOR, or direct measurements of isomeric ratios.

Interpreting C/E values

A C/E value applies to the spectrum, irradiation time and cooling times of its campaign. Agreement in a field dominated by 14 MeV neutrons says little about spectra in which low-energy reactions dominate. The median experimental uncertainty is about 7 percent and larger for some foils, so differences smaller than this are not significant. Calculation uncertainties matter too. When all four libraries miss the measurement by a similar amount, the measurement may be at fault, but so may data or methods that the libraries share.

Nuclear data used

The table gives the source of each input for the 408 calculations, covering 73 five-minute and 29 seven-hour foils including alloys. Each column is one calculation configuration. Cross sections, reaction channels and isomeric branching come from the named library; the decay data and fission-yield sources are read from each result’s recorded metadata, and where results record different sources all of them are listed. Failed calculations, if any, are listed in their own section.

InputTENDL-2025ENDF/B-VIII.1JEFF-4.0JENDL-5
Neutron cross sectionsTENDL-2025ENDF/B-VIII.1JEFF-4.0JENDL-5
Neutron reaction channelsTENDL-2025ENDF/B-VIII.1JEFF-4.0JENDL-5
Isomeric branchingTENDL-2025ENDF/B-VIII.1JEFF-4.0JENDL-5
Decay half-lives and modesUKDD-2020*ENDF/B-VIII.1JEFF-4.0JENDL-5
Decay energies and photon emissionUKDD-2020*ENDF/B-VIII.1JEFF-4.0JENDL-5
Fission yieldsUKFY-4.2*ENDF/B-VIII.1JEFF-4.0JENDL-5
Cross-section covarianceTENDL-2025ENDF/B-VIII.1JEFF-4.0JENDL-5

Table 1.

An asterisk marks an input taken from a different library. TENDL-2025 has no decay data or fission yields, so it uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields from the FISPACT-II nuclear data repository, converted locally. The transmutation chain combines the listed reaction channels, decay modes and yields. A listed covariance source does not mean that every nuclide or channel has covariance data. The other uncertainties come with the decay, branching or yield data they belong to. Every calculation uses a measured FNS neutron spectrum: position 3 for the five-minute campaign and position 7 for the seven-hour campaign. No photonuclear data are used. The energy of decay gammas is included in the decay heat.

Data releases

Data libraryReleaseSHA-256 prefix
ENDF/B-VIII.12026-11-13e04637b8bc40
JEFF-4.02026-11-130226481b9d95
JENDL-52026-11-136e47e06d399b
TENDL-20252026-11-1466deceec1b2d
UKDD-2020converted from decay2020.tar.bz2f2ff9501f6d2
UKFY-4.2converted from UKFY42data.tar.bz2e7a2505c32ef

Table 2.

The dates are those of the processed data releases, not of the evaluations. For a published release the hash is that of its manifest, which identifies the exact files used. For a library converted locally it is that of the archive downloaded from the FISPACT-II repository. The full hashes are stored with each result.

Analysis method

For each element the calculated heat is compared with the measurement and then broken down by activation product. For the products that carry the heat, the reaction rates, isomeric branching, half-lives and decay energies are compared across the libraries. Where a reaction rate or branching ratio differs, its energy dependence is plotted to show where the difference lies.

A product missing from one library’s heat breakdown may point to a missing reaction channel, but it can also come from a different state assignment or a reporting threshold. Likewise, agreement between the libraries does not rule out an error they share, so a deviation common to all of them calls for a check of both the shared data and the experiment.

An input that differs between libraries is a possible explanation, not a proven cause. The product-removal test subtracts a product’s heat from the total without re-solving the inventory, so it shows how large the contribution is, not what corrected data would give.

Figure 2. The steps from a decay-heat disagreement to a single nuclear data input.

Neutron spectrum

The FNS irradiation spectrum, position 3

Figure 3. The measured neutron spectrum at irradiation position 3, used for every calculation in the main comparison.

Results by element

Elements are ordered from best to worst agreement of the closest library. Each has three figures: the calculated decay heat against the measurement, with C/E below; the share of the heat from each activation product during cooling; and the inputs for those products, each relative to its median across the libraries. Cross-section and branching plots are added where the libraries differ. A short note then lists the differences and suggests measurements. Where a long-lived product matters and the foil was in the 1996 seven-hour campaign, that comparison is also shown, but it is not included in the rankings.

Zn: Zinc

Figure 4. Zn: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 1%, JENDL-5 5%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 6%, JEFF-4.0 37%.

Figure 5. Zn: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min. Zn63 T₁/₂ 38.3 min; up to 97% of this foil's heat. Cu66 T₁/₂ 5.1 min; up to 53% of this foil's heat. Cu68 T₁/₂ 31.1 s; up to 21% of this foil's heat. Cu64 T₁/₂ 12.7 h; up to 4% of this foil's heat. Cu68_m1 T₁/₂ 3.75 min; up to 2% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. Ni65 T₁/₂ 2.52 h; up to 2% of this foil's heat. decay heat [µW/g]. time after shutdown [minutes]. TENDL-2025; ENDF/B-VIII.1; JEFF-4.0; JENDL-5. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Figure 5: Zn: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Zn: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them

Figure 6. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Zn: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Zn: Zinc

Zn cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product

Figure 7. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions. Figure 7: Zn: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Zn: Zinc

Zn: isomeric branching against neutron energy; plot of Zn68(n,p)→Cu68_m1 showing the share into this state from TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0, and JENDL-5

Figure 8. Zn: isomeric branching against neutron energy. Zn68(n,p)→Cu68_m1. no isomeric file from TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1. Fraction of each reaction that goes to the metastable state, against energy, from each library's state-resolved production cross sections or state yields. The value in the inputs figure is this curve weighted by the reaction rate over the measured spectrum. For threshold reactions that rate comes from the 14 MeV peak; for capture much of it comes from low-energy neutrons. Figure 8: Zn: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

Zn: Zinc

JEFF-4.0 stands out at 37 percent from the measurement, against 6 percent for the next furthest library and 1 percent for TENDL-2025. The median measurement uncertainty is 5 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JEFF-4.0 gives the total reaction rate of Zn64(n,2n)→Zn63\mathrm{Zn}^{64}(n,2n)\to\mathrm{Zn}^{63} as 2.337e-13, against 5.005e-13 for the median of the others, a factor of 2. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Cum168\mathrm{Cu}^{68}_{\mathrm{m1}}; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Zn has 5 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Zn64. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Ti: Titanium

Figure 9. Ti: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 2%, TENDL-2025 2%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 6%, JENDL-5 7%.

Ti: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp\_5min

Figure 10. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Ti: inputs for the main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them

Figure 11. Ti: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 12. Ti: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.57 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 402.96 days. In the five-minute calculation Sc48 (half-life 1.82 days) gives up to 60 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. JENDL-5 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Figure 13. Ti: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 4%, TENDL-2025 8%, JEFF-4.0 9%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 11%.

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 2 to 7 percent. The spread of 5 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 5 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • TENDL-2025 gives the total reaction rate of 49Ti(n,np)→48Sc^{49}\mathrm{Ti}(n,np)\to{}^{48}\mathrm{Sc} as 8.673e-15, against 1.922e-14 for the median of the others, a factor of 2. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from 46Scm1^{46}\mathrm{Sc}_{\mathrm{m1}}; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Ti has 5 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Ti49. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Ga: Gallium

Figure 14. Ga: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 3%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 3%, JEFF-4.0 6%, TENDL-2025 6%.

Figure 15. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Figure 15: Ga: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Ga: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them. Chart showing share of heat at the last cooling point for Ga68, Ga70, N16, Cu66, Zn71, and Cu68 across TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0, and JENDL-5; half-life, mean decay energy, and reaction rate inputs relative to the median across libraries for Ga71(n,p)→Zn71, Ga69(n,2n)→Ga68, Ga71(n,a)→Cu68, Ga69(n,gamma)→Ga70, Ga71(n,2n)→Ga70, O16(n,p)→N16, and Ga69(n,a)→Cu66.

Figure 16. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 16: Ga: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 17. Ga: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Ga: Gallium

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 3 to 6 percent. The spread of 3 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 6 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Suggested measurements

  • No input differs enough between the libraries to be listed. An error shared by all of them, or a smaller difference, is still possible.

Si: Silicon

Figure 18. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Figure 18: Si: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 3%, TENDL-2025 11%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 12%, JEFF-4.0 13%.

Si: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min. Four panels show Al28, Al29, Mg27, and Si31 decay heat curves for TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0, and JENDL-5.

Figure 19. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Si: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Figure 20. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Si: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Si: cross sections that differ between libraries; four plots showing Si29(n,np)→Al28 cross section, Si29(n,np)→Al28 σ × flux, the rate this spectrum drives, Si30(n,gamma)→Si31 cross section, and Si30(n,gamma)→Si31 σ × flux, the rate this spectrum drives; evaluated libraries TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0, and JENDL-5

Figure 21. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Figure 21: Si: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Si: Silicon

The libraries are between 3 and 13 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 9 percent. JENDL-5 is closest and JEFF-4.0 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of Si29(n,np)→Al28\mathrm{Si}^{29}(\mathrm{n,np})\to\mathrm{Al}^{28} as 3.612e-14, against 8.393e-15 for the median of the others, a factor of 4. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • TENDL-2025 gives the total reaction rate of Si30(n,γ)→Si31\mathrm{Si}^{30}(\mathrm{n,\gamma})\to\mathrm{Si}^{31} as 8.87e-15, against 2.219e-15 for the median of the others, a factor of 4.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Si has 3 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. Candidate parents are Si29, Si30. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Hg: Mercury

Figure 22. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Hg: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 3%, JEFF-4.0 4%, TENDL-2025 4%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 84%.

Hg: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling

Figure 23. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Hg: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Hg: Mercury

Hg: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them. Bar chart of Hg199_m1, N16, Au202, Au200, Hg197, and Hg197_m1, followed by relative-value plots for half-life, mean decay energy, reaction rate, and isomeric branching across TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0, and JENDL-5.

Figure 24. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 24: Hg: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 25. Hg: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Hg: Mercury

Hg: isomeric branching against neutron energy, showing isomeric branching for Hg201(n,3n)→Hg199_m1 across nuclear data libraries

Figure 26. Fraction of each reaction that goes to the metastable state, against energy, from each library's state-resolved production cross sections or state yields. The value in the inputs figure is this curve weighted by the reaction rate over the measured spectrum. For threshold reactions that rate comes from the 14 MeV peak; for capture much of it comes from low-energy neutrons. Figure 26: Hg: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

Hg: Mercury

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 84 percent from the measurement, against 4 percent for the next furthest library and 3 percent for JENDL-5. The median measurement uncertainty is 8 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of Hg201(n,3n)→Hg199\mathrm{Hg}^{201}(n,3n)\to\mathrm{Hg}^{199} as 1.145e-13, against 1.623e-14 for the median of the others, a factor of 7. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • JENDL-5 gives the mean decay energy of Hg197_m1 as 6.522e+05 eV, against 2.785e+05 eV for the median of the others, a factor of 2. For a given activity the heat is proportional to the mean decay energy, so this difference goes straight into the heat. Compare the decay schemes and how the emitted energy is counted.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Hg has 7 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Hg201. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • This foil makes Hg197 (half-life 2.67 days), which gives up to 5 percent of the calculated heat. A five-minute irradiation and 55 minute measurement only see the start of this contribution. There is no seven-hour FNS measurement of this foil. A longer irradiation followed for days to months would be needed to test this product’s production and decay.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Te: Tellurium

Figure 27. Te: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣\lvert C/E - 1\rvert by library: JENDL-5 3%, TENDL-2025 6%, JEFF-4.0 8%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 170%.

Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped.

Figure 28. Te: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Te: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Te: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them

Figure 29. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Te: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Te: cross sections that differ between libraries, showing Te130(n,p)→Sb130 cross section and Te130(n,p)→Sb130 σ × flux, the rate this spectrum drives

Figure 30. Te: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 170 percent from the measurement, against 8 percent for the next furthest library and 3 percent for JENDL-5. The median measurement uncertainty is 8 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of Te130(n,p)→Sb130\mathrm{Te}^{130}(n,p)\to\mathrm{Sb}^{130} as 5.555e-14, against 4.416e-15 for the median of the others, a factor of 13. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Sbm1128\mathrm{Sb}^{128}_{\mathrm{m1}}; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Sbm1130\mathrm{Sb}^{130}_{\mathrm{m1}}; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Te has 8 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Te130\mathrm{Te}^{130}. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Co: Cobalt

Figure 31. Co: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: ENDF/B-VIII.1 4%, JEFF-4.0 4%, TENDL-2025 6%, JENDL-5 8%.

Figure 32. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Figure 32: Co: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Co: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them

Figure 33. Co: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 34. Co: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

Co: Cobalt

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.57 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 402.95 days. In the five-minute calculation Co58\mathrm{Co}^{58} (half-life 70.9 days) gives up to 2 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. ENDF/B-VIII.1 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Co foil, FNS decay heat and C/E after a 27267.8 s irradiation at 14 MeV

Figure 35. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Co: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: ENDF/B-VIII.1 5%, JEFF-4.0 6%, JENDL-5 7%, TENDL-2025 10%.

Co: Cobalt

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 4 to 8 percent. The spread of 5 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 6 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • Only JENDL-5 and TENDL-2025 have the isomeric branching of 59Co(n,γ)→60Com1^{59}\mathrm{Co}(n,\gamma)\to{}^{60}\mathrm{Co}_{m1}, and they differ by a factor of 2: 0.6983 against 0.2877. Isomeric branching sets how a channel’s production is split between the ground and metastable states. It should be checked together with the total rate of the channel.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from 60Com1{}^{60}\mathrm{Co}_{m1}; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from 58Com1{}^{58}\mathrm{Co}_{m1}; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Co has a single stable isotope, so the foil is already a single-isotope target and enrichment would not help.

  • Measuring the activity of each state separately, for example by gamma spectrometry where the states have distinct lines, would constrain the isomeric ratio. This needs corrections for feeding between states, detector efficiency and irradiation history.

Br: Bromine

Br foil, FNS decay heat after a 300 s irradiation at 14 MeV · 2000exp_5min

Figure 36. Br foil, FNS decay heat after a 300 s irradiation at 14 MeV · 2000exp_5min. specific decay heat [µW/g]. TENDL-2025. ENDF/B-VIII.1. JEFF-4.0. JENDL-5. FNS measurement. time after shutdown [minutes]. measurement ±1σ. C / E. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Br: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 4%, TENDL-2025 4%, JENDL-5 25%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 27%.

Br: decay heat from each activation product, by library

Figure 37. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Br: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Figure 38. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 38: Br: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Br: Bromine

The libraries are between 4 and 27 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 11 percent. TENDL-2025 is closest and ENDF/B-VIII.1 furthest.

Suggested measurements

  • No input differs enough between the libraries to be listed. An error shared by all of them, or a smaller difference, is still possible.

F: Fluorine

Figure 39. F: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 4%, JEFF-4.0 11%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 11%, TENDL-2025 11%.

Figure 40. F: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Fluorine

Figure 41. F: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

F: Fluorine

The libraries are between 4 and 11 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 5 percent. JENDL-5 is closest and TENDL-2025 furthest.

Suggested measurements

  • No input differs enough between the libraries to be listed. An error shared by all of them, or a smaller difference, is still possible.

Cl: Chlorine

Figure 42. Cl: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 4%, TENDL-2025 11%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 44%, JEFF-4.0 44%.

Figure 43. Cl: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min. S37 T₁/₂ 4.99 min; up to 99% of this foil's heat. Cl34_m1 T₁/₂ 32.1 min; up to 58% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0. Cl38 T₁/₂ 37.2 min; up to 37% of this foil's heat. Cl34 T₁/₂ 1.53 s; up to 35% of this foil's heat. Si31 T₁/₂ 2.62 h; up to 29% of this foil's heat. P34 T₁/₂ 12.4 s; up to 24% of this foil's heat. P32 T₁/₂ 14.3 d; up to 23% of this foil's heat. decay heat [µW/g]. time after shutdown [minutes]. TENDL-2025; ENDF/B-VIII.1; JEFF-4.0; JENDL-5. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Cl: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Cl: Chlorine

Cl: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them across TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0, and JENDL-5

Figure 44. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 44: Cl: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 45. Cl: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Cl: Chlorine

The libraries are between 4 and 44 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 6 percent. JENDL-5 is closest and JEFF-4.0 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of Cl35(n,2p)→P34\mathrm{Cl}^{35}(n,2p)\to\mathrm{P}^{34} as 1.718e-15, against 5.897e-17 for the median of the others, a factor of 29. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of Cl35(n,pa)→Si31\mathrm{Cl}^{35}(n,pa)\to\mathrm{Si}^{31} as 5.084e-14, against 5.161e-15 for the median of the others, a factor of 10.

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of Cl37(n,γ)→Cl38\mathrm{Cl}^{37}(n,\gamma)\to\mathrm{Cl}^{38} as 1.019e-15, against 2.192e-15 for the median of the others, a factor of 2.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0 give no heat from Cl34_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Cl has 2 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. Candidate parents are Cl35, Cl37. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains C, H. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • This foil makes P32 (half-life 14.3 days), which gives up to 23 percent of the calculated heat. A five-minute irradiation and 55 minute measurement only see the start of this contribution. There is no seven-hour FNS measurement of this foil. A longer irradiation followed for days to months would be needed to test this product’s production and decay.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Cu: Copper

Cu foil FNS decay heat after a 300 s irradiation at 14 MeV, with decay heat and C/E plots for TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0, JENDL-5, and FNS measurement

Figure 46. Cu: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 5%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 5%, TENDL-2025 6%, JENDL-5 8%.

Cu: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min

Figure 47. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Cu: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Cu: Copper

Cu: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them

Figure 48. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 48: Cu: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Cu: cross sections that differ between libraries, showing four plots of copper reaction cross sections and cross section multiplied by neutron flux

Figure 49. Cu: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Cu: Copper

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 5 to 8 percent. The spread of 3 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 5 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • Only TENDL-2025 and JENDL-5 have the total reaction rate of Cu63(n,2p)→Co62\mathrm{Cu}^{63}(n,2p)\to\mathrm{Co}^{62}, and they differ by a factor of 4: 1.133e-18 against 3.191e-19. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Co62_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Cu has 2 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Cu63. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Fe: Iron

Figure 50. Fe: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 5%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 5%, TENDL-2025 5%, JENDL-5 9%.

Fe: Iron

Figure 51. Fe: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Fe: Iron; main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them

Figure 52. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Fe: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Fe: Iron

Figure 53. Fe: cross sections that differ between libraries. Fe57(n,np)→Mn56 cross section. Fe57(n,np)→Mn56 σ × flux, the rate this spectrum drives. Fe58(n,p)→Mn58 cross section. Fe58(n,p)→Mn58 σ × flux, the rate this spectrum drives. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions. TENDL-2025 ENDF/B-VIII.1 JEFF-4.0 JENDL-5. Fe: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 5 to 9 percent. The spread of 4 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 5 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • Only JENDL-5 and TENDL-2025 have the total reaction rate of 57Fe(n,np)→56Mn^{57}\mathrm{Fe}(n,np)\to{}^{56}\mathrm{Mn}, and they differ by a factor of 2: 6.503e-14 against 2.764e-14. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Fe has 4 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Fe57. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Mg: Magnesium

Figure 54. Figure 54: Mg: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 5%, JENDL-5 6%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 8%, JEFF-4.0 9%.

Figure 55. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Mg: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Mg: Magnesium

Mg: inputs for the main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them

Figure 56. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Mg: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 57. Mg: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 5 to 9 percent. The spread of 4 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 12 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • Only TENDL-2025 and JEFF-4.0 have the total reaction rate of Mg25(n,d)→Na24\mathrm{Mg}^{25}(n,d)\to\mathrm{Na}^{24}, and they differ by a factor of 2: 3.214e-14 against 1.424e-14. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • JEFF-4.0 gives the total reaction rate of Mg25(n,np)→Na24\mathrm{Mg}^{25}(n,np)\to\mathrm{Na}^{24} as 1.41e-14, against 3.135e-14 for the median of the others, a factor of 2.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Mg has 3 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Mg25. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Ge: Germanium

Figure 58. Ge: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 6%, JEFF-4.0 8%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 13%, JENDL-5 13%.

Figure 59. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Ge: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Ge: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them

Figure 60. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching). Figure 60: Ge: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 61. Ge: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Ge: Germanium

The libraries are between 6 and 13 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 7 percent. TENDL-2025 is closest and JENDL-5 furthest.

Suggested measurements

  • This foil makes Ge69 (half-life 1.63 days), which gives up to 11 percent of the calculated heat. A five-minute irradiation and 55 minute measurement only see the start of this contribution. There is no seven-hour FNS measurement of this foil. A longer irradiation followed for days to months would be needed to test this product’s production and decay.

  • No input differs enough between the libraries to be listed. An error shared by all of them, or a smaller difference, is still possible.

Zr: Zirconium

Zr foil, FNS decay heat after a 300 s irradiation at 14 MeV · 2000exp_5min

Figure 62. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Zr: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 6%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 6%, JEFF-4.0 7%, TENDL-2025 7%.

Figure 63. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Zr: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Zr: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries

Figure 64. Zr: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Zr: Zirconium

Zr cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product

Figure 65. Zr: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Zr: Zirconium

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.57 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 402.96 days. In the five-minute calculation Zr89 (half-life 3.27 days) gives up to 18 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. TENDL-2025 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Zr foil FNS decay heat after a 27267.8 s irradiation at 14 MeV, with decay heat and C/E curves for TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0, JENDL-5, and FNS measurement

Figure 66. Zr foil, FNS decay heat after a 27267.8 s irradiation at 14 MeV · 1996exp_7hour. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Figure 66: Zr: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 6%, JEFF-4.0 6%, JENDL-5 7%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 10%.

Zr: Zirconium

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 6 to 7 percent. The spread of 1 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 5 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of Zr90(n,d)→Y89\mathrm{Zr90}(n,d)\to\mathrm{Y89} as 7.966e-16, against 3.097e-14 for the median of the others, a factor of 39. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Zr has 5 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Zr90. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Mo: Molybdenum

Image not extracted

Figure 67. Mo: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣\lvert C/E - 1 \rvert by library: ENDF/B-VIII.1 6%, JENDL-5 10%, JEFF-4.0 14%, TENDL-2025 14%.

Image not extracted

Figure 68. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Mo: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 69. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 69: Mo: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.57 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 200.14 days. In the five-minute calculation Mo99 (half-life 2.75 days) gives up to 4 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. JEFF-4.0 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Image not extracted

Figure 70. Mo: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣\lvert C/E - 1\rvert by library: JEFF-4.0 10%, TENDL-2025 10%, JENDL-5 12%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 16%.

The libraries are between 6 and 14 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 5 percent. ENDF/B-VIII.1 is closest and TENDL-2025 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Mo91_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Nb98_m1; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Mo has 7 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

Pd: Palladium

Figure 71. Pd: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 6%, TENDL-2025 17%, JENDL-5 26%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 66%.

Image not extracted

Figure 72. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. TENDL-2025 ENDF/B-VIII.1 JEFF-4.0 JENDL-5. Figure 72: Pd: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 73. Pd: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Image not extracted

Figure 74. Pd: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Figure 75. Fraction of each reaction that goes to the metastable state, against energy, from each library's state-resolved production cross sections or state yields. The value in the inputs figure is this curve weighted by the reaction rate over the measured spectrum. For threshold reactions that rate comes from the 14 MeV peak; for capture much of it comes from low-energy neutrons.

Pd: Palladium

The libraries are between 6 and 66 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 6 percent. JEFF-4.0 is closest and ENDF/B-VIII.1 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of 106Pd(n,p)→106Rh^{106}\mathrm{Pd}(n,p)\to{}^{106}\mathrm{Rh} as 8.826e-14, against 3.195e-14 for the median of the others, a factor of 3. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Rh108_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Pd107_m1; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Pd has 6 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Pd106. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Sr: Strontium

Image not extracted

Figure 76. Sr: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 6%, TENDL-2025 9%, JENDL-5 14%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 35%.

Image not extracted

Figure 77. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Figure 77: Sr: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 78. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching). Figure 78: Sr: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 35 percent from the measurement, against 14 percent for the next furthest library and 6 percent for JEFF-4.0. The median measurement uncertainty is 6 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Sr87_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Rb86_m1; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Sr has 4 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains C, O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

Mn: Manganese

Image not extracted

Figure 79. Mn: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 6%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 17%, JEFF-4.0 17%, TENDL-2025 35%.

Figure 80. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Image not extracted

Figure 81. Mn: Manganese. Mn: main heat-producing products and the inputs behind them. TENDL-2025 ENDF/B-VIII.1 JEFF-4.0 JENDL-5. Share of heat at the last cooling point [%]. Value ÷ the median across libraries. Mn56^{56}(n,d)→Cr55^{55}; Mn55^{55}(n,X)→V52^{52}; Mn55^{55}(n,gamma)→Mn56^{56}; Mn55^{55}(n,2n)→Mn54^{54}; Mn55^{55}(n,p)→Cr55^{55}; Mn54^{54}(n,3He)→V52^{52}; Mn55^{55}(n,a)→V52^{52}. HALF-LIFE [S]: Mn56^{56}, Mn54^{54}, Cr55^{55}, V52^{52}. MEAN DECAY ENERGY [EV]: Mn56^{56}, Cr55^{55}, V52^{52}, Mn54^{54}. REACTION RATE, ALL PRODUCTS [PER PARENT ATOM]: Mn56^{56}(n,d)→Cr55^{55}; Mn55^{55}(n,X)→V52^{52}; Mn55^{55}(n,gamma)→Mn56^{56}; Mn55^{55}(n,2n)→Mn54^{54}; Mn55^{55}(n,p)→Cr55^{55}; Mn54^{54}(n,3He)→V52^{52}; Mn55^{55}(n,a)→V52^{52}. ABSENT from this run. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching). Mn: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Mn: Manganese

Image not extracted

Figure 82. Mn: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Mn: Manganese

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.17 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 402.18 days. In the five-minute calculation Mn54 (half-life 312 days) gives up to 2 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. JENDL-5 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Image not extracted

Figure 83. Mn: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 1%, TENDL-2025 1%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 1%, JEFF-4.0 6%.

Mn: Manganese

The libraries are between 6 and 35 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 6 percent. JENDL-5 is closest and TENDL-2025 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JEFF-4.0 gives the total reaction rate of 55Mn(n,α)→52V{}^{55}\mathrm{Mn}(n,\alpha)\to{}^{52}\mathrm{V} as 2.98e−152.98\mathrm{e}{-15}, against 6.86e−146.86\mathrm{e}{-14} for the median of the others, a factor of 23. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of 54Mn(n,3He)→52V{}^{54}\mathrm{Mn}(n,{}^{3}\mathrm{He})\to{}^{52}\mathrm{V} as 4.108e−204.108\mathrm{e}{-20}, against 1.561e−201.561\mathrm{e}{-20} for the median of the others, a factor of 3.

Suggested measurements

  • Mn has a single stable isotope, so the foil is already a single-isotope target, and enrichment would not help.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

V: Vanadium

Image not extracted

Figure 84. V: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 7%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 14%, TENDL-2025 15%, JEFF-4.0 16%.

Figure 85. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Figure 85: V: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 86. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching). V: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

V: Vanadium

Image not extracted

Figure 87. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions. V: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.57 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 49.73 days. In the five-minute calculation Sc48 (half-life 1.82 days) gives up to 80 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. JENDL-5 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Image not extracted

Figure 88. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Figure 88: V: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 20%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 24%, TENDL-2025 25%, JEFF-4.0 25%.

V: Vanadium

The libraries are between 7 and 16 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 5 percent. JENDL-5 is closest and JEFF-4.0 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JEFF-4.0 gives the total reaction rate of 50V(n,3He)→48Sc^{50}\mathrm{V}(n,{}^{3}\mathrm{He})\to{}^{48}\mathrm{Sc} as 3.609e-21, against 3.03e-20 for the median of the others, a factor of 8. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • TENDL-2025 gives the total reaction rate of 47Sc(n,γ)→48Sc^{47}\mathrm{Sc}(n,\mathrm{\gamma})\to{}^{48}\mathrm{Sc} as 3.222e-14, against 5.024e-15 for the median of the others, a factor of 6.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural V has 2 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. Candidate parents are Sc47, V50. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Al: Aluminum

Image not extracted

Figure 89. Al: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 7%, TENDL-2025 7%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 7%, JENDL-5 13%.

Figure 90. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Figure 90: Al: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 91. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 91: Al: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Al: Aluminum

Image not extracted

Figure 92. Al: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Al: Aluminum

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 7 to 13 percent. The spread of 6 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 6 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of Al26(n,3He)→Na24\mathrm{Al26}(n,{}^{3}\mathrm{He})\to\mathrm{Na24} as 2.233e-16, against 9.968e-17 for the median of the others, a factor of 2.

    This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

Suggested measurements

  • Al has a single stable isotope, so the foil is already a single-isotope target and enrichment would not help.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Rb: Rubidium

Figure 93. Rb: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 7%, JEFF-4.0 9%, JENDL-5 20%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 94%. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped.

Figure 94. Rb: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Rb: Rubidium

Image not extracted

Figure 95. Rb: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Image not extracted

Figure 96. Rb: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Image not extracted

Figure 97. Rb: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 94 percent from the measurement, against 20 percent for the next furthest library and 7 percent for TENDL-2025. The median measurement uncertainty is 6 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of 87Rb(n,α)→84Br^{87}\mathrm{Rb}(n,\alpha)\to{}^{84}\mathrm{Br} as 2.976e-15, against 1.195e-14 for the median of the others, a factor of 4. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from 84Rbm1^{84}\mathrm{Rb}_{m1}; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from 86Rbm1^{86}\mathrm{Rb}_{m1}; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Rb has 2 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Rb87. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains C, O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • This foil makes Rb84 (half-life 33.5 days), which gives up to 13 percent of the calculated heat. A five-minute irradiation and 55 minute measurement only see the start of this contribution. There is no seven-hour FNS measurement of this foil. A longer irradiation followed for days to months would be needed to test this product’s production and decay.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Sc: Scandium

Image not extracted

Figure 98. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Figure 98: Sc: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 7%, JENDL-5 13%, JEFF-4.0 19%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 63%.

Image not extracted

Figure 99. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Figure 99: Sc: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 100. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Figure 100: Sc: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Image not extracted

Figure 101. Sc: cross sections that differ between libraries

O18(n,t)→N16 cross section; O18(n,t)→N16 σ × flux, the rate this spectrum drives; O17(n,np)→N16 cross section; O17(n,np)→N16 σ × flux, the rate this spectrum drives; O17(n,d)→N16 cross section; O17(n,d)→N16 σ × flux, the rate this spectrum drives.

TENDL-2025; ENDF/B-VIII.1; JEFF-4.0; JENDL-5.

Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Sc: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 63 percent from the measurement, against 19 percent for the next furthest library and 7 percent for TENDL-2025. The median measurement uncertainty is 6 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of O18(n,t)→N16\mathrm{O18}(n,t)\rightarrow\mathrm{N16} as 1.751e−171.751\mathrm{e}{-17}, against 6.84e−166.84\mathrm{e}{-16} for the median of the others, a factor of 39. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of O17(n,np)→N16\mathrm{O17}(n,np)\rightarrow\mathrm{N16} as 2.295e−172.295\mathrm{e}{-17}, against 2.186e−162.186\mathrm{e}{-16} for the median of the others, a factor of 10.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of O17(n,d)→N16\mathrm{O17}(n,d)\rightarrow\mathrm{N16} as 1.096e−131.096\mathrm{e}{-13}, against 2.351e−142.351\mathrm{e}{-14} for the median of the others, a factor of 5.

Suggested measurements

  • Sc has a single stable isotope, so the foil is already a single-isotope target and enrichment would not help.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Ag: Silver

Image not extracted

Figure 102. Ag: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 7%, JEFF-4.0 9%, TENDL-2025 9%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 88%.

Ag: Silver

Image not extracted

Figure 103. Ag: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Figure 103: Ag: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 104. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching). Ag: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Image not extracted

Figure 105. Ag: cross sections that differ between libraries. Left panel: Ag107(n,a)→Rh104 cross section; σ\sigma [barn] versus neutron energy [eV]. Right panel: Ag107(n,a)→Rh104 σ×\sigma\times flux, the rate this spectrum drives; σ⋅ϕ\sigma\cdot\phi [barn n/cm²/s] versus neutron energy [eV]. Legend: TENDL-2025; ENDF/B-VIII.1; JEFF-4.0; JENDL-5. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions. Figure 105: Ag: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Ag: Silver

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 88 percent from the measurement, against 9 percent for the next furthest library and 7 percent for JENDL-5. The median measurement uncertainty is 6 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of Ag107(n,a)→Rh104\mathrm{Ag}^{107}(\mathrm{n},\mathrm{a})\to\mathrm{Rh}^{104} as 1.435e−141.435\mathrm{e}{-14}, against 6.421e−146.421\mathrm{e}{-14} for the median of the others, a factor of 4. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Ag has 2 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Ag107. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • This foil makes Agm1106\mathrm{Ag}^{106}_{\mathrm{m1}} (half-life 8.46 days), which gives up to 2 percent of the calculated heat. A five-minute irradiation and 55 minute measurement only see the start of this contribution. There is no seven-hour FNS measurement of this foil. A longer irradiation followed for days to months would be needed to test this product’s production and decay.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Ru: Ruthenium

Image not extracted

Figure 106. Ru: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 8%, JENDL-5 10%, JEFF-4.0 13%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 29%.

Image not extracted

Figure 107. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Figure 107: Ru: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 108. Ru: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Image not extracted

Figure 109. Ru: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

The libraries are between 8 and 29 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 5 percent. TENDL-2025 is closest and ENDF/B-VIII.1 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of Ru102(n,d)→Tc101\mathrm{Ru102(n,d)} \to\mathrm{Tc101} as 1.281e−141.281\mathrm{e}{-14}, against 1.107e−151.107\mathrm{e}{-15} for the median of the others, a factor of 12. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • JEFF-4.0 gives the total reaction rate of Ru102(n,p)→Tc102\mathrm{Ru102(n,p)} \to\mathrm{Tc102} as 5.795e−145.795\mathrm{e}{-14}, against 2.647e−142.647\mathrm{e}{-14} for the median of the others, a factor of 2.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Tc102_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Ru has 7 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Ru102. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

P: Phosphorus

Image not extracted

Figure 110. P foil, FNS decay heat after a 300 s irradiation at 14 MeV · 2000exp_5min. Specific decay heat [µW/g]. C/E. Time after shutdown [minutes]. FNS measurement. ENDF/B-VIII.1. JEFF-4.0. TENDL-2025. JENDL-5. Measurement ±1σ. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. P: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 8%, TENDL-2025 11%, JEFF-4.0 11%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 12%.

Image not extracted

Figure 111. P: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 112. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a reaction state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching). Figure 112: P: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

P: Phosphorus

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 8 to 12 percent. The spread of 4 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 16 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Suggested measurements

  • No input differs enough between the libraries to be listed. An error shared by all of them, or a smaller difference, is still possible.

Nb: Niobium

Image not extracted

Figure 113. Nb: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 8%, JENDL-5 9%, TENDL-2025 11%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 97%.

Image not extracted

Figure 114. Nb: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min. Y90 T1/2T_{1/2} 2.67 d; up to 100% of this foil's heat. Nb92_m1 T1/2T_{1/2} 10.2 d; up to 63% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. Y89_m1 T1/2T_{1/2} 15.7 s; up to 54% of this foil's heat. Y90_m1 T1/2T_{1/2} 3.19 h; up to 41% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. Nb94_m1 T1/2T_{1/2} 6.26 min; up to 29% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. decay heat [µW/g]. time after shutdown [minutes]. TENDL-2025; ENDF/B-VIII.1; JEFF-4.0; JENDL-5. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Nb: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 115. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Nb: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Nb: Niobium

Nb: cross sections that differ between libraries

Image not extracted

Figure 116. Nb: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Image not extracted

Figure 117. Nb: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

Nb: Niobium

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.57 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 99.89 days. In the five-minute calculation Y90\mathrm{Y}^{90} (half-life 2.67 days) gives up to 100 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. JEFF-4.0 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Image not extracted

Figure 118. Nb: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 7%, TENDL-2025 8%, JENDL-5 9%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 98%.

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 97 percent from the measurement, against 11 percent for the next furthest library and 8 percent for JEFF-4.0. The median measurement uncertainty is 7 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • Only TENDL-2025 and JEFF-4.0 have the isomeric branching of Nb93(n,pt)→Ym190\mathrm{Nb}^{93}(n,pt)\to\mathrm{Y}^{90}_{m1}, and they differ by a factor of 2: 0.0005419 against 0.0002208. Isomeric branching sets how a channel’s production is split between the ground and metastable states. It should be checked together with the total rate of the channel.

  • Only TENDL-2025 and JEFF-4.0 have the total reaction rate of Nb93(n,pt)→Y90\mathrm{Nb}^{93}(n,pt)\to\mathrm{Y}^{90}, and they differ by a factor of 2: 3.477e-30 against 1.711e-30. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Nbm192\mathrm{Nb}^{92}_{m1}; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Ym190\mathrm{Y}^{90}_{m1}; the other libraries do.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Nbm194\mathrm{Nb}^{94}_{m1}; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Nb has a single stable isotope, so the foil is already a single-isotope target and enrichment would not help.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

  • Measuring the activity of each state separately, for example by gamma spectrometry where the states have distinct lines, would constrain the isomeric ratio. This needs corrections for feeding between states, detector efficiency and irradiation history.

Ni: Nickel

Image not extracted

Figure 119. Ni: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 9%, JEFF-4.0 16%, TENDL-2025 23%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 40%.

Ni: Nickel

Image not extracted

Figure 120. Ni: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min. Co62 T₁/₂ 1.54 min — up to 95% of this foil's heat. Ni57 T₁/₂ 1.5 d — up to 79% of this foil's heat. Co62_m1 T₁/₂ 13.9 min — up to 51% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. Co60_m1 T₁/₂ 10.5 min — up to 26% of this foil's heat. Co61 T₁/₂ 1.65 h — up to 15% of this foil's heat. Fe61 T₁/₂ 5.98 min — up to 10% of this foil's heat. Co58_m1 T₁/₂ 9.1 h — up to 9% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. Co58 T₁/₂ 70.8 d — up to 7% of this foil's heat. decay heat [µW/g]. time after shutdown [minutes]. TENDL-2025; ENDF/B-VIII.1; JEFF-4.0; JENDL-5. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Ni: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 121. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Ni: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Ni: Nickel

Image not extracted

Figure 122. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Ni: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.57 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 402.94 days. In the five-minute calculation 57Ni^{57}\mathrm{Ni} (half-life 1.5 days) gives up to 79 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. ENDF/B-VIII.1 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Image not extracted

Figure 123. Ni: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣\lvert C/E - 1\rvert by library: ENDF/B-VIII.1 2%, TENDL-2025 3%, JEFF-4.0 3%, JENDL-5 7%.

Ni: Nickel

The libraries are between 9 and 40 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 7 percent. JENDL-5 is closest and ENDF/B-VIII.1 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Co62_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Ni has 5 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

Ba: Barium

Image not extracted

Figure 124. Ba: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JEFF-4.0 10%, JENDL-5 18%, TENDL-2025 22%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 79%.

Figure 125. Ba: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Image not extracted

Figure 126. Ba: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Ba: cross sections that differ between libraries

Image not extracted

Figure 127a. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Image not extracted

(a) Ba: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.17 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 24.18 days. In the five-minute calculation Ba135_m1 (half-life 1.2 days) gives up to 12 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. TENDL-2025 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Image not extracted

Figure 128. Ba: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 8%, JEFF-4.0 12%, JENDL-5 17%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 72%.

Ba: Barium

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 79 percent from the measurement, against 22 percent for the next furthest library and 10 percent for JEFF-4.0. The median measurement uncertainty is 9 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JEFF-4.0 gives the total reaction rate of Ba138(n,a)→\toXe135 as 1.896e-14, against 8.554e-15 for the median of the others, a factor of 2. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Ba135_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Xe135_m1; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Ba has 7 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Ba138. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains C, O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Sm: Samarium

Image not extracted

Figure 129. Figure 129: Sm: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 10%, JEFF-4.0 10%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 15%, JENDL-5 22%.

Figure 130. Sm: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 131. Sm: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 132. Sm: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

The libraries are between 10 and 22 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 11 percent. TENDL-2025 is closest and JENDL-5 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Sm143_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Sm has 7 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • This foil makes Sm153 (half-life 1.93 days), which gives up to 43 percent of the calculated heat. A five-minute irradiation and 55 minute measurement only see the start of this contribution. There is no seven-hour FNS measurement of this foil. A longer irradiation followed for days to months would be needed to test this product’s production and decay.

Ta: Tantalum

Figure 133. Ta: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: TENDL-2025 10%, JENDL-5 16%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 214%, JEFF-4.0 220%. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped.

Figure 134. Ta: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Image not extracted

Figure 135. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching). Ta: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 136. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions. Ta: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Image not extracted

Figure 137. Ta: isomeric branching against neutron energy

181Ta(n,γ)→182Tam2^{181}\mathrm{Ta}(n,\gamma)\to{}^{182}\mathrm{Ta}_{\mathrm{m2}} no isomeric file from TENDL-2025

181Ta(n,α)→178Lum1^{181}\mathrm{Ta}(n,\alpha)\to{}^{178}\mathrm{Lu}_{\mathrm{m1}} no isomeric file from TENDL-2025

TENDL-2025; ENDF/B-VIII.1; JEFF-4.0; JENDL-5

share into this state; neutron energy [eV]

Fraction of each reaction that goes to the metastable state, against energy, from each library's state-resolved production cross sections or state yields. The value in the inputs figure is this curve weighted by the reaction rate over the measured spectrum. For threshold reactions that rate comes from the 14 MeV peak; for capture much of it comes from low-energy neutrons.

Figure 137: Ta: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

The libraries are between 10 and 220 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 13 percent. TENDL-2025 is closest and JEFF-4.0 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • TENDL-2025 gives the isomeric branching of 181Ta(n,γ)→182Tam2^{181}\mathrm{Ta}(n,\gamma)\to{}^{182}\mathrm{Ta}_{m2} as 0.001298, against 0.3748 for the median of the others, a factor of 289. Isomeric branching sets how a channel’s production is split between the ground and metastable states. It should be checked together with the total rate of the channel.

  • TENDL-2025 gives the total reaction rate of 180Tam1(n,3He)→178Lu^{180}\mathrm{Ta}_{m1}(n,{}^{3}\mathrm{He})\to{}^{178}\mathrm{Lu} as 1.572e-24, against 4.469e-22 for the median of the others, a factor of 284. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • JENDL-5 gives no heat from Ta182_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Ta has 2 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. Candidate parents are Ta180_m1, Ta181. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

  • Measuring the activity of each state separately, for example by gamma spectrometry where the states have distinct lines, would constrain the isomeric ratio. This needs corrections for feeding between states, detector efficiency and irradiation history.

Sb: Antimony

Figure 138. Sb: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 11%, TENDL-2025 21%, JEFF-4.0 23%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 66%.

Figure 139. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Image not extracted

Figure 140. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Sb: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Sb: cross sections that differ between libraries

Image not extracted

Figure 141. Sb: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Figure 142. Sb: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

ENDF/B-VIII.1 stands out at 66 percent from the measurement, against 23 percent for the next furthest library and 11 percent for JENDL-5. The median measurement uncertainty is 6 percent.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of Sb121(n,a)→In118\mathrm{Sb121}(n,\mathrm{a})\to\mathrm{In118} as 3.638e−153.638\mathrm{e}{-15}, against 8.793e−158.793\mathrm{e}{-15} for the median of the others, a factor of 2. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • JENDL-5 gives no heat from Sb122_m1; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • TENDL-2025, ENDF/B-VIII.1, JEFF-4.0 give no heat from Sb122_m2; the other libraries do.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Sb120_m1; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Sb has 2 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Sb121. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • This foil makes Sb122 (half-life 2.7 days), which gives up to 7 percent of the calculated heat. A five-minute irradiation and 55 minute measurement only see the start of this contribution. There is no seven-hour FNS measurement of this foil. A longer irradiation followed for days to months would be needed to test this product’s production and decay.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

Ho: Holmium

Image not extracted

Figure 143. Ho: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 11%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 17%, TENDL-2025 21%, JEFF-4.0 26%.

Figure 144. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure.

Ho: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 145. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching).

Ho: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 146. Ho: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

Image not extracted

Figure 147. Fraction of each reaction that goes to the metastable state, against energy, from each library's state-resolved production cross sections or state yields. The value in the inputs figure is this curve weighted by the reaction rate over the measured spectrum. For threshold reactions that rate comes from the 14 MeV peak; for capture much of it comes from low-energy neutrons. Figure 147: Ho: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

Ho: Holmium

The libraries are between 11 and 26 percent from the measurement, which has a median uncertainty of 14 percent. JENDL-5 is closest and JEFF-4.0 furthest.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of O18(n,t)→N16\mathrm{O18}(n,t)\to\mathrm{N16} as 1.751e-17, against 6.84e-16 for the median of the others, a factor of 39.

    This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives the total reaction rate of O17(n,d)→N16\mathrm{O17}(n,d)\to\mathrm{N16} as 1.096e-13, against 2.351e-14 for the median of the others, a factor of 5.

  • JEFF-4.0 gives the total reaction rate of Ho165(n,a)→Tb162\mathrm{Ho165}(n,a)\to\mathrm{Tb162} as 7.34e-15, against 3.005e-15 for the median of the others, a factor of 2.

  • JEFF-4.0 gives the isomeric branching of Ho165(n,2n)→Ho164_m1\mathrm{Ho165}(n,2n)\to\mathrm{Ho164\_m1} as 0.2564, against 0.5954 for the median of the others, a factor of 2.

    Isomeric branching sets how a channel’s production is split between the ground and metastable states. It should be checked together with the total rate of the channel.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Ho164_m1; the other libraries do.

    The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Tb162; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Ho has a single stable isotope, so the foil is already a single-isotope target and enrichment would not help.

  • The sample is a compound that also contains O. Their activation adds to the measured heat; a metal or purer sample would remove it.

  • This foil makes Ho166 (half-life 1.12 days), which gives up to 1 percent of the calculated heat. A five-minute irradiation and 55 minute measurement only see the start of this contribution. There is no seven-hour FNS measurement of this foil. A longer irradiation followed for days to months would be needed to test this product’s production and decay.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

  • Measuring the activity of each state separately, for example by gamma spectrometry where the states have distinct lines, would constrain the isomeric ratio. This needs corrections for feeding between states, detector efficiency and irradiation history.

Re: Rhenium

Image not extracted

Figure 148. Re: decay heat against the measurement, with C/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 11%, JEFF-4.0 12%, TENDL-2025 12%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 15%.

Image not extracted

Figure 149. Re: decay heat from each activation product, by library · 2000exp_5min. Re186 T1/2T_{1/2} 3.75 d; up to 61% of this foil's heat. Re188 T1/2T_{1/2} 17 h; up to 34% of this foil's heat. W185_m1 T1/2T_{1/2} 1.67 min; up to 13% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. Re184 T1/2T_{1/2} 35.4 d; up to 10% of this foil's heat. Re188_m1 T1/2T_{1/2} 18.6 min; up to 7% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. Ta182_m2 T1/2T_{1/2} 15.8 min; up to 2% of this foil's heat; not made by ENDF/B-VIII.1. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. TENDL-2025 ENDF/B-VIII.1 JEFF-4.0 JENDL-5. Re: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Figure 150. Each input is plotted relative to its median across the libraries, which is given on the right, so quantities with different units share one axis. Points on the line agree with the median. Production into a state is the reaction rate times the branching, so if the rate agrees and the branching does not, the difference is in the branching, not the cross section. A hollow marker in the shaded strip means that library has no value: the nuclide is not produced (half-life, decay energy) or the library has no such channel (rate, branching). Figure 150: Re: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 151. Re: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Image not extracted

Figure 152. Fraction of each reaction that goes to the metastable state, against energy, from each library's state-resolved production cross sections or state yields. The value in the inputs figure is this curve weighted by the reaction rate over the measured spectrum. For threshold reactions that rate comes from the 14 MeV peak; for capture much of it comes from low-energy neutrons. Figure 152: Re: isomeric branching ratio against neutron energy for the channels whose spectrum-averaged ratio differs between libraries.

1996 seven-hour campaign

The 1996 campaign irradiated this foil for 7.17 hours at position 7 and measured it out to 402.17 days. In the five-minute calculation Re186 (half-life 3.75 days) gives up to 61 percent of the heat, and the longer irradiation and cooling test its production and decay data. JENDL-5 is closest. This campaign uses a different spectrum, so it is not included in the main rankings.

Image not extracted

Figure 153. Re foil, FNS decay heat after a 25799 s irradiation at 14 MeV · 1996exp_7hour. Each curve uses one library for cross sections, reaction channels, isomeric branching and decay data. Exception: TENDL-2025 uses UKDD-2020 decay data and UKFY-4.2 fission yields, because it has no decay data or fission yields. Shaded bands show the propagated nuclear data uncertainty; bands wider than the panel are clipped. Re: 1996 seven-hour campaign, irradiation position 7. Mean ∣C/E−1∣|C/E - 1| by library: JENDL-5 7%, JEFF-4.0 18%, TENDL-2025 18%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 29%.

Mean absolute C/E deviations range from 11 to 15 percent. The spread of 3 percentage points is smaller than the median measurement uncertainty of 10 percent, so the measurement cannot separate the libraries.

Differences in the nuclear data

  • JENDL-5 gives the isomeric branching of Re185(n,α)→Tam2182\mathrm{Re}^{185}(n,\alpha)\to\mathrm{Ta}^{182}_{m2} as 0.2181, against 0.06291 for the median of the others, a factor of 3. Isomeric branching sets how a channel’s production is split between the ground and metastable states. It should be checked together with the total rate of the channel.

  • JENDL-5 gives the total reaction rate of Re185(n,p)→W185\mathrm{Re}^{185}(n,p)\to\mathrm{W}^{185} as 2.494e-14, against 1.239e-14 for the median of the others, a factor of 2. This is the total rate of the channel over all its products, so the difference is in the cross section, not in the split between states.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Wm1185\mathrm{W}^{185}_{m1}; the other libraries do. The heat breakdown alone does not show why. Possible causes are a missing reaction channel, a different state assignment, different decay data or a reporting threshold.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Rem1188\mathrm{Re}^{188}_{m1}; the other libraries do.

  • ENDF/B-VIII.1 gives no heat from Tam2182\mathrm{Ta}^{182}_{m2}; the other libraries do.

Suggested measurements

  • Natural Re has 2 isotopes, so the measured heat combines several parents. Enriched single-isotope targets would distinguish their contributions. The candidate parent is Re185. Enrichment alone does not isolate a single reaction channel.

  • The reaction rates are averaged over the measured spectrum. Activation measurements at several well-defined neutron energies, including below 14 MeV, would show which energy range the differences come from.

  • Measuring the activity of each state separately, for example by gamma spectrometry where the states have distinct lines, would constrain the isomeric ratio. This needs corrections for feeding between states, detector efficiency and irradiation history.

Pt: Platinum

Image not extracted

Figure 154. Pt: decay heat against the measurement, with C/EC/E beneath. Mean ∣C/E−1∣\lvert C/E - 1\rvert by library: JENDL-5 12%, ENDF/B-VIII.1 13%, JEFF-4.0 32%, TENDL-2025 32%.

Image not extracted

Figure 155. One panel per product, with all libraries on the same axis. Decay heat is on a log scale, with each panel scaled to its own curves. The note under each title gives the product's largest share of the foil's heat and names any library that does not make it. Colours and line styles match the decay-heat figure. Figure 155: Pt: share of the decay heat from each activation product during cooling.

Image not extracted

Figure 156. Pt: inputs for the main heat-producing products, each relative to its median across the available libraries.

Figure 157. Left: evaluated cross sections. Right: the cross section multiplied by the measured flux, whose area is the one-group reaction rate. A difference on the left that does not appear on the right does not affect the decay heat. The energy axis covers the range where the channel is open and is linear when that range is less than a decade, as for threshold reactions.

Figure 157: Pt: cross sections of the channels whose spectrum-averaged rates differ, with the neutron spectrum and their product.

References

No references were extracted for this paper.

Paper details

vlnc:W_d3mcmy8n
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents