WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Exploring the origin of D meson elliptic flow in PbPb collisions at = 5.02 TeV using event shape engineering
Abstract
The influence of the initial-state geometry on the elliptic flow of prompt D mesons in high-energy heavy ion collisions is explored. A lead-lead (PbPb) data sample at a center-of-mass energy per nucleon pair of 5.02 TeV and with an integrated luminosity of 0.607 nb was collected in 2018 with the CMS detector at the CERN LHC. Based on these data, an event-shape engineering technique is used to isolate collisions with similar geometrical properties. An asymmetry parameter, , is first determined from the distribution of transverse energy in the forward region of the detector. This parameter is shown to be linearly correlated with the elliptic anisotropy of inclusive charged particles measured near mid-rapidity, as characterized by the second-order Fourier coefficients, . Taking the charged particle coefficients as proxies for the initial-state eccentricity, the correlation of D meson values near mid-rapidity with those of inclusive charged particles is then studied. For D mesons with transverse momenta in the range of 230 GeV and for different degrees of collision overlap, the values are found strongly correlated with those for charged particles when selected based on similar intervals. This correlation suggests that the initial-state geometry substantially impacts the development of charm-hadron flow in heavy ion collisions. A model calculation that explores the thermalization and collective motion of D mesons and charged particles is compared to the experimental results.
Introduction
Relativistic heavy ion collisions can create a quark-gluon plasma (QGP), a state of matter composed of deconfined quarks and gluons [1]. The QGP has a shear viscosity to entropy density ratio that is close to that of an ideal fluid [2] and its evolution can be described by relativistic hydrodynamics. In a near-ideal fluid, the initial spatial geometry of the QGP can be effectively transformed into momentum anisotropies in the final state, leading to collective patterns in azimuthal distributions of emitted particles [3, 4]. This azimuthal asymmetry, which has been observed in many heavy ion measurements at both the BNL RHIC and the CERN LHC, can be quantified with Fourier coefficients, , where represents the azimuthal angle of a particle, denotes the azimuthal angle of the symmetry plane for the th order harmonic [5, 6], and the is the average taken over all particles of interest in all events. The coefficient, commonly referred to as elliptic flow, is expected to exhibit a linear relationship with the corresponding initial-state eccentricity of the QGP for low transverse momentum () particles [7, 8, 9, 10]. While values for inclusive charged particles and for identified particles containing light quarks have been extensively studied, detailed investigations of values for particles containing heavy quarks, such as D mesons, offer a novel and important handle to study the properties of the QGP medium. The large mass of heavy quarks renders them sensitive to the early stages of the collision and their subsequent interaction with the medium, providing unique insights beyond those obtainable from light-quark measurements.
Positive D meson values that suggest hydrodynamic flow have been observed at both RHIC [11, 12, 13] and LHC [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21] for different collisional centralities. Centrality is defined by the fraction of the total inelastic hadronic cross section, with the 0–10% centrality representing the 10% most central collisions and, thus, the largest nuclear overlap. Measurements of -differential values of prompt D mesons in lead-lead (PbPb) collisions from the CMS experiment demonstrate a clear centrality dependence, which already suggests the influence of the initial-state geometry on the final-state momentum anisotropy of these particles [18]. A recent CMS measurement of prompt D meson anisotropic flow reaches a similar conclusion in the GeV region [22]. Recent ALICE measurements of the elliptic flow of prompt D, D, D, and in PbPb collisions provide complementary evidence for the partonic origin of charm-hadron values [23].
The average initial eccentricity of the overlap region in heavy ion collisions is related to the measured collision centrality. However, event-by-event fluctuations in the initial-state shape within a given centrality class lead to a variation in the final-state momentum anisotropy. To study the event-by-event geometry fluctuations at a fixed centrality, an event-shape engineering technique has been developed to select events according to final-state observables that are correlated with the initial-state eccentricity. A second-order flow vector is first defined as
where the sum is over the multiplicity () of charged particles at azimuths . The weights are applied to optimize the resolution of the flow vectors. A related value, which has a reduced multiplicity dependence, is defined as
The value reflects the elliptic azimuthal asymmetry of particle emission and can be determined in different pseudorapidity () ranges of the detector, either by using single particle tracks (with ) or by analyzing the transverse energy () deposits in an azimuthally segmented calorimeter detector (taking ). For a given range of collision centrality, the corresponding distribution can be used to better control the elliptic anisotropy of particle emission. The details of the values used in this analysis are provided in Section 5.2. Using such a technique, a connection between the D meson values and the bulk flow in PbPb collisions at TeV was previously found by the ALICE Collaboration based on a analysis [21].
This Letter presents a measurement of the prompt D meson values determined at midrapidity () as a function of values measured at forward in PbPb collisions at a center-of-mass energy per nucleon pair of TeV. The data were collected in 2018 using the CMS detector at the CERN LHC and correspond to an integrated luminosity of 0.607 nb. By classifying events based on values, a systematic variation of the initial-state eccentricity is achieved, enabling the study of initial-state geometry influence on the D meson values. The dependent D meson values, with GeV, are measured in five centrality classes (0–10, 10–20, 20–30, 30–40, and 40–50%), each of which is further divided into ten -based event-shape classes. The inclusive charged particle values measured for GeV are used as an experimental proxy for the event-by-event eccentricity, motivated by the approximately linear hydrodynamic response of low- charged particles to the initial geometry. These inclusive measurements have the same ranges of rapidity, centrality, and as the D mesons. The correlation between D meson values and the low- charged particle values in the ten event-shape classes for each centrality range is studied and compared to a hydrodynamic model. Pearson correlation coefficients [8] are calculated to quantify the linearity of the D meson vs. charged particle correlations. Tabulated results are provided in the HEPData record for this analysis [24].
The CMS detector
The central feature of the CMS apparatus is a superconducting solenoid of 6 m internal diameter, providing a magnetic field of 3.8 T. Within the solenoid volume, there is a silicon pixel and strip tracker that measures the trajectories of charged particles in the range , a lead-tungstate crystal electromagnetic calorimeter, and two forward rapidity hadron calorimeters. For charged particles with GeV and , the typical track resolution is 1.5% in and 25–90 (45–150) in the transverse (longitudinal) impact parameter [25]. The two hadron forward (HF) calorimeters use steel as an absorber and quartz fibers as the sensitive material and are segmented to form radians () towers. These calorimeters are located 11.2 m away from the interaction region, one on either side, and together they extend the calorimeter coverage to . In this analysis, the HF information is used for performing the offline event selection, for determining event centrality, with higher energy deposits corresponding to more central events, and for calculating the values. A detailed description of the CMS experiment can be found in Refs. [26, 27].
Events of interest are selected using a two-tiered trigger system. The first level, composed of custom hardware processors, uses information from the calorimeters and muon detectors to select events at a rate of around 100 kHz within a fixed latency of 4 s [28]. The second level, known as the high-level trigger, consists of a farm of processors running a version of the full event reconstruction software optimized for fast processing, and reduces the event rate to a few kHz before data storage [27, 29].
Event selection and simulated event samples
The data sample consists of minimum bias (MB) PbPb events corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 0.607 nb [30]. The MB selection requires signals above readout thresholds between 6–12 GeV in both of the HF calorimeters [29]. Events are required to pass selection criteria designed to reject background events such as beam-gas interactions [31]. The final results include only events with at least one reconstructed primary vertex (PV) associated with two or more tracks within 15 cm from the nominal interaction point along the beam direction, and at least two towers with energy larger than 4 GeV in each of the HF detectors. Finally, in order to suppress the contamination from events with multiple ion-ion collisions, an event is rejected if the cluster shapes in the pixel part of the tracker are not compatible with those expected in a single PbPb collision [19]. The total event selection efficiency is (97 ± 2)%.
Monte Carlo (MC) generators are employed to investigate the kinematics of D mesons in PbPb collisions. The D mesons are produced using PYTHIA8.212 [32] with the CP5 tune [33], and their decays are modeled using EVTGEN 1.3.0 [34]. Samples are generated for both prompt and nonprompt D mesons from b-hadron decays. The decay products of the D mesons are embedded into MB events generated via HYDJET 1.9 [34], which is tuned to reproduce the observed charged particle multiplicity and spectra. The CMS detector response to these combined events are simulated using the GEANT4 package [35].
Signal reconstruction and extraction
The D mesons are reconstructed using the decay channels D and ; in this Letter, these two channels are combined and collectively referred to as D. The tracks used for the reconstruction have GeV and . Only tracks passing high-purity criteria [25] are used. The relative resolution of the reconstructed D candidate is less than 10%. Other requirements for the tracks include having a minimum of 11 hits along the track trajectory in the tracker and having the track fit divided by the total number of degrees of freedom of the fit, and also divided by the total number of tracker layers having a hit along the track path, be less than 0.18. The reconstruction is performed by combining pairs of oppositely charged particle tracks with invariant mass within MeV of the world-average D meson mass of 1865 MeV [36]. Since the CMS detector does not provide particle identification information for high- charged particle tracks, both possible particle assignments (pion and kaon) are considered for each pair of selected candidate decay tracks.
Following the reconstruction of D candidates, a boosted decision tree (BDT) algorithm from the TMVA package [37] is used to optimize the significance of signal, which is given as the ratio of the signal to the signal uncertainty, obtained from fitting the data using the function described below and illustrated in Figure 1. For the training, the prompt reconstructed D mesons from MC simulations that match the D particle at the generator level are used as signal candidates, and the side bands from data within the mass range of three to six standard deviations of the MC signal distribution away from the mass peak are used to simulate the background. Training is performed separately for each range and centrality class. The variables used to discriminate the signal from the background are the probability for the D vertex, the significance of the distance between the PV and secondary vertices, and the angle between the D momentum and the vector pointing from the PV to the secondary vertex (pointing angle). The variables related to the decay products of the D meson used for the training are the significance of the distances of the closest approach (DCA) to the primary vertex, both along and perpendicular to the beam direction, and the of the decay tracks. Overtraining checks are done for all analysis bins by comparing the BDT distributions from training with those from D meson test samples. The mass spectra are corrected for D acceptance () and efficiency () effects by weighting each D candidate by a factor given by the inverse of the product of acceptance and efficiency. The product is calculated by taking the ratio of the number of reconstructed D meson passing the selection criteria to the total number of generated D mesons in the same kinematic range. To account for a possible discrepancy between the spectra from the MC and data, the MC spectra is weighted with a correction factor so that the MC spectra resemble the one from data. The acceptance and efficiency factor is calculated for each centrality and in finer bins compared to the analysis bins.
Figure 1. An example of the fit to the invariant mass spectrum in the centrality class 40–50% and for the D range 4–6 GeV.
The signal extraction is performed by fitting the mass distribution using four components: a second-order polynomial for the combinatorial background, the sum of two Gaussian functions with a common mean but different widths for the D signal to account for the variation of track momentum resolution with , one additional Gaussian function to describe the invariant mass shape due to incorrect mass assignments when swapping the () and K (K) daughters, and two Crystal Ball functions [38] to describe the decays D KK and D . The widths and the relative areas of the Gaussian functions are obtained from the fit to the simulated signal. To account for the difference in the widths of the Gaussian functions in the simulation and data, each width of the Gaussian functions is multiplied by an additional common scaling factor, obtained by fitting the mass distribution. The swap component and the Crystal Ball functions do not contribute to the signal yield. An example of the signal extraction is shown in Figure 1.
Analysis technique
The scalar product (SP) framework [39, 40] is used to determine the values for all particles of interest, whether D mesons or inclusive charged hadrons. In terms of the vectors, as defined in Eq. (1), values for the particles of interest are found using
where the subscripts A, B and C refer to different -dependent subevents. The vectors are the complex conjugates of the respective vectors. The term is the vector constructed with the particles of interest. The and vectors are based on the HF towers, and the vector is determined using the information from the tracker, with . To avoid autocorrelations and ensure an gap of at least 3 units, the scalar product uses (), covering the range (), and (), when the charged-hadron track or the reconstructed D meson is positive (negative). The weight (in Eq. (1)) is a dimensionless quantity and corresponds to the deposited in individual HF towers for and and the of the tracks for the tracker (). A unit weight is assumed for . The averages are calculated considering all events within a given centrality class above a given threshold of for the tracker and for the HF towers. The inclusive charged-hadron is measured based on all charged particle tracks with and . The D meson is measured in the ranges of 2–4, 4–6, 6–10, and 10–30 GeV with . Flattening and recentering corrections are applied to the , and vectors to account for detector acceptance effects [41, 42].
Prompt D meson measurement
To extract the D meson value for a given bin, it is necessary to correct for the value associated with the underlying background. This is done by applying a modified SP analysis. The individual D candidates are first binned according to their contribution to the SP average, , with
A separate mass spectrum is generated in each of these bins and an invariant mass fit is performed to obtain the associated D meson yield. The D candidates are split into 62 bins, with values ranging from to 15, and the bin edges are determined such that the significance of the D signal, as defined in § 4, is larger than three in each bin. The edges of the distribution is chosen such that the number of candidates beyond these limits is insignificant. The inclusive D meson value () is then obtained by taking a yield weighted average of the midpoint of each bin, , with
where is the yield in the ith bin. The statistical uncertainty associated with is derived by propagating the uncertainties of in Eq. (5) as in the Eq. (6),
where is the uncertainty in the yield in the ith bin.
The D signal in data includes both prompt and nonprompt D contributions. The DCA to the primary vertex of D candidates is used to discriminate between the prompt and nonprompt components. Invariant mass spectra are produced for D mesons corresponding to a centrality class binned in DCA ranges. After obtaining the signal yields based on fits as discussed in § 4, these yields are used to create a DCA distribution. Templates of prompt and nonprompt D distributions from MC signal simulations are used to fit the yields, with the relative yield parameters as the fit parameters. The fits are conducted using various DCA resolutions applied to the MC template to address discrepancies between the data and the MC simulations. The fit result with the minimum is selected as the nominal value for the prompt D fraction. A selection of DCA < 0.0085 cm is applied, and the resulting sample is estimated to have a 95% prompt D purity. The systematic uncertainty due to the contribution from nonprompt D is discussed in Section 6.
Event shape engineering
An event-shape engineering technique is used to classify events based on the initial-state geometry of the collision. The HF towers in the range are used for calculating the asymmetry parameter . This results in a large gap with the tracks used for D candidate reconstruction, which are restricted to the range , thus suppressing nonflow correlations. Using both the HF+ and HF- detectors, is defined as , where is the sum of weights from both detectors. The distribution is dependent on centrality and can vary significantly over centrality classes covering 10% ranges. This introduces a centrality bias where, e.g., events with smaller values are dominated by more central events. To reduce this centrality bias when selecting events based on their values, the events are divided into 1% centrality bins and, subsequently, each of these bins is further divided into ten separate bins. Since the analysis cannot be performed in 1% centrality classes because of the limited size of the sample, within a larger 10% centrality range, bins are combined into a single analysis bin, such that, e.g., all events with the lowest 10% of values in each of the centrality bins 0–1 to 9–10% are combined into the lowest 10% events of the centrality class 0–10%. A similar approach is followed in an analysis by the ALICE Collaboration [21].
To study the response of prompt D meson flow to event-shape variations, the D meson values are compared with the low- charged particle values in each interval. The charged particle is used as a data-driven proxy for the event-by-event geometry. To quantify the linearity of the correlation plots, the Pearson correlation coefficient () is calculated for all five centrality classes studied and for different ranges. The Pearson coefficient is given by
where the sum is over all points in the scatter plot, , the and are the charged particle and D meson values for each bin, respectively, the and are the statistical uncertainties associated with and respectively, and the and are the corresponding weighted-average values over all points. The term takes into account the statistical uncertainty of each point in the scatter plot. The coefficient for complete linear correlation (anticorrelation), and in the absence of any linear correlation between two parameters. To estimate the statistical uncertainty in , an MC resampling approach was employed. Each D meson value was varied according to a Gaussian distribution centered on its measured value, with a standard deviation corresponding to its statistical uncertainty. This process was iterated 50000 times to generate a distribution of values. The final statistical uncertainties were determined using the 68.3% confidence interval of the resulting distribution.
Systematic uncertainty
The sources of systematic uncertainty include the fit to the signal mass distribution, the fit to the background mass distribution, the sorting of events into ranges, the centrality determination, the nonprompt D meson contamination, and the D meson acceptance and efficiency corrections. The systematic uncertainties associated with the extraction of the D signal is obtained by changing the signal probability density function (pdf) from a double Gaussian to a triple Gaussian with the same mean but different widths, and by changing the function for the combinatorial background from a second- to a third-order polynomial. The systematic uncertainty due to how a range is selected for a given event is found by changing the boundaries of the range associated with each bin up and down by the uncertainty associated with the flow vectors. The systematic uncertainties associated with the centrality selection is obtained by shifting the centrality boundaries based on the energy deposited in the HF towers up and down. The nonprompt D meson fraction after applying the DCA selection is 5%, as discussed in § 5.1. Since nonprompt D meson values are smaller than those for prompt D mesons in the studied and centrality region, as shown in Ref. [43], the maximum relative uncertainty due to the nonprompt contamination in the value is 5%. This estimation is based on Eq. (6) from an earlier CMS publication [18]. The effect of the efficiency is studied by changing the efficiency correction values. In an alternative approach, the efficiency is based solely on simulation and does not consider any potential differences between the MC and data spectra. The values for D candidates passing the BDT selection, and for all the D candidates, are calculated from the MC samples, and the difference in is quoted as the systematic uncertainty due to BDT selection. In this analysis, no significant effect resulting from the BDT selection is observed. The summary of the uncertainties is provided in Table 1. Each of these potential sources was varied as described, with the difference in the experimental result based on the varied parameter with that found using the nominal value taken as the associated systematic uncertainty for the slope and intercept. The total uncertainty for each experimental result is taken as the quadratic sum of the individual uncertainties. For , the systematic uncertainty is calculated using a similar approach to that of the statistical uncertainty, where each individual D meson coefficient is varied according to a Gaussian distribution centered on its measured value, with a standard deviation corresponding to its total systematic uncertainty. The final systematic uncertainty was determined using the 68.3% confidence interval of the resulting distribution.
| Source | D meson | Slope | Intercept |
| Sig. mass pdf variation | |||
| Bkg. mass pdf variation | |||
| selection | |||
| Centrality selection | – | ||
| Nonprompt | – | ||
| Total | – | – | – |
Table 1. Summary of systematic uncertainties in the absolute differences between the nominal and the alternative analyses for the D meson values, slope, and intercept of the scatter plots.
Results
Figure 2 shows the dependence of the values for D mesons (upper row) with GeV and and for inclusive charged particles (lower row) with GeV and . The results are shown for the centrality classes of 10–20, 20–30, 30–40 and 40–50%. A positive, approximately linear dependence is observed, as expected if both observables are correlated with the event-by-event initial-state eccentricity. Figure 3 shows the dependence between the D meson values and the corresponding charged particle values with the same percentile classification for selected D ranges and event centrality classes. The observed linear dependence between the D meson and charged particle values indicates that the initial-shape eccentricity is the dominant contributor to the D elliptic flow. Deviations from this linear trend could arise if other physical mechanisms contribute to the D elliptic flow. For instance, a change in the viscosity of the QGP medium can lead to deviations from linearity for more central events [44]. A deviation from linear correlation at high D meson values could result from the path-length dependent energy loss of charm quarks in the QGP medium [44, 45]. Hints of such deviations from linearity are shown in Appendix § 11, where Figure 6 shows results for the 0–10% centrality range in several ranges and Figure 7 shows the results for different centrality ranges with GeV. At high , the linear correlation between the D meson and inclusive charged particle values becomes weaker, which may be an indication of the path-length dependent energy loss of charm quarks in the QGP medium.
Figure 2. Dependence of the D meson (upper row) and the charged particle (lower row) values on . The D mesons have GeV and . The inclusive charged particles have GeV and . The plots are shown for events in the centrality ranges of 10–20, 20–30, 30–40 and 40–50%. The vertical lines represent the statistical uncertainties and the boxes represent the systematic uncertainties.
Figure 3. Scatter plots of the D⁰ meson vs. charged particle values measured in common intervals. The D⁰ mesons have GeV and . The inclusive charged particles have GeV and . The vertical lines represent the statistical uncertainties, and the boxes represent the systematic uncertainties associated with the D⁰ meson . The errors associated with the charged particle are smaller than the markers. The centrality classes 10–20% (upper left), 20–30% (upper right), 30–40% (lower left), and 40–50% (lower right) are shown. The red lines are linear fits to the experimental results based on the statistical uncertainties of the data, with the shaded red band corresponding to a one standard deviation uncertainty. The PHSD model [46, 47] predictions are also shown in the plots.
Figure 6. Scatter plots of the D meson vs. charged particle values measured in common intervals. The inclusive charged particles have GeV and . The vertical lines represent the statistical uncertainties, and the boxes represent the systematic uncertainties associated with the D meson values. The uncertainties associated with the inclusive charged particle values are smaller than the markers. The D meson ranges 2–4 GeV (upper left), 4–6 GeV (upper right), 6–10 GeV (lower left), and 10–30 GeV (lower right) for the 0–10% centrality class are shown. The red lines are linear fits to the experimental results based on the statistical uncertainties of the data, with the shaded red band corresponding to a one standard deviation uncertainty. The PHSD model [46, 47] predictions are also shown in the plots.
Figure 7. The same scatter plots as Figure 6, but for the D mesons with in the 10–20, 20–30, 30–40, and 40–50% centrality classes. All other explanation for the plots are the same as in Figure 6.
Figure 3 also shows the prediction of the parton-hadron-string-dynamics (PHSD) model [46, 47]. It is found that the degree of charm-quark thermalization is underestimated in the model, as observed from the lower slope of the scatter plot for D values in the range 2–4 GeV. In this model, the D mesons are produced through initial binary collisions by using the PYTHIA event generator, accounting for the (anti-) shadowing incorporated in the EPS09 package [48].
To extract the linearity of the correlations, we calculate the Pearson correlation coefficients () as defined in Eq. (7). Figure 4 shows the coefficients as function of for different centrality classes. Other than for the most central events, it is observed that the experimental correlation for low- values ( GeV) is consistent with unity. For the range of 10–30 GeV, the coefficients tend to be less than unity, although with larger uncertainties. The model predictions are consistent with data for GeV, whereas the predictions deviate from 1 for GeV for centralities 0–10 and 40–50%.
Figure 4. The Pearson correlation coefficients () obtained from the scatter plots of the prompt meson vs. charged particle values for the indicated and centrality classes. The vertical lines correspond to the statistical uncertainties and the vertical bands correspond to the systematic uncertainties added in quadrature. The open symbols show the PHSD predictions in the meson range 2–10 GeV, with the symbols shifted along the axis for better visibility.
To further quantify the linear correlation, Figure 5 presents the slopes and intercepts of the D meson vs. charged particle as a function of for centrality classes 0–10, 10–20, 20–30, 30–40, and 40–50% in the D meson range of 2–30 GeV. The prompt D meson and charged particle values in each interval are normalized using the corresponding value for the -inclusive events (all events in a given 10% centrality class). This normalization is performed to account for the dependence of these values on and event centrality. The normalized slopes are consistent with unity for all and centrality classes. The intercepts, representing the D⁰ meson value when the charged particle value is zero, are also consistent with zero. These slope and intercept results strongly suggest that the D⁰ meson elliptic flow originates primarily from the eccentricity of the initial geometry of the collision system. The predictions from PHSD model are consistent with data at low , and at higher the predictions seem to deviate from data for 0–10% central events.
Figure 5. Slopes (upper row) and intercepts (lower row) obtained from the fits of the prompt meson vs. charged particle values for each and centrality class. The meson and charged particle values in each interval are normalized by the corresponding -inclusive value in the same and centrality class. The vertical lines correspond to the statistical uncertainties and the vertical bands correspond to the systematic uncertainties added in quadrature. The open symbols show the PHSD predictions in the meson range 2–10 GeV, with the symbols shifted along the axis for better visibility.
Summary
The elliptic-flow Fourier coefficient is measured for mesons using an event-shape engineering technique. The data sample consists of lead-lead collisions measured with the CMS detector at the CERN LHC at a center-of-mass energy per nucleon pair of 5.02 TeV and with an integrated luminosity of 0.607 nb. The azimuthal asymmetry of energy deposits in a forward-rapidity calorimeter is characterized by a parameter that can be related to the initial collision geometry. A strong linear correlation is found between this parameter and the corresponding values for inclusive charged particles measured in the pseudorapidity () and transverse momentum () ranges of and GeV, respectively. The variation between D meson and inclusive charged particle values obtained at common intervals is then explored. A strong linear correlation is found over the centrality range of 10–40%, as binned in 10% classes, for D mesons at low (2–10 GeV). A weaker linear correlation is observed for centrality ranges of 0–10 and 40–50%. The parton-hadron-string-dynamics model is compared to the experimental results and found to underestimate the degree of charm quark thermalization in the quark-gluon plasma at GeV. These findings provide compelling evidence for the importance of the initial-state geometry in determining the collective flow of heavy quarks within the quark-gluon plasma created in heavy ion collisions.
Acknowledgments
We congratulate our colleagues in the CERN accelerator departments for the excellent performance of the LHC and thank the technical and administrative staffs at CERN and at other CMS institutes for their contributions to the success of the CMS effort. In addition, we gratefully acknowledge the computing centers and personnel of the Worldwide LHC Computing Grid and other centers for delivering so effectively the computing infrastructure essential to our analyses. Finally, we acknowledge the enduring support for the construction and operation of the LHC, the CMS detector, and the supporting computing infrastructure provided by the following funding agencies: SC (Armenia), BMFWF and FWF (Austria); FNRS and FWO (Belgium); CNPq, CAPES, FAPERJ, FAPERGS, and FAPESP (Brazil); MES and BNSF (Bulgaria); CERN; CAS, MoST, and NSFC (China); MINCIENCIAS (Colombia); MSES and CSF (Croatia); RIF (Cyprus); SENESCYT (Ecuador); ERC PRG and PSG, TARISTU24-TK10 and MoER TK202 (Estonia); Academy of Finland, MEC, and HIP (Finland); CEA and CNRS/IN2P3 (France); SRNSF (Georgia); BMFTR, DFG, and HGF (Germany); GSRI (Greece); MATE and NKFIH (Hungary); DAE and DST (India); IPM (Iran); SFI (Ireland); INFN (Italy); MSIT and NRF (Republic of Korea); MES (Latvia); LMTLT (Lithuania); MOE and UM (Malaysia); BUAP, CINVESTAV, CONACYT, LNS, SEP, and UASLP-FAI (Mexico); MOS (Montenegro); MBIE (New Zealand); PAEC (Pakistan); MSHE, NSC, and NAWA (Poland); FCT (Portugal); MESTD (Serbia); MICIU / AEI and PCTI (Spain); MOSTR (Sri Lanka); Swiss Funding Agencies (Switzerland); MST (Taipei); MHESI (Thailand); TUBITAK and TENMAK (Türkiye); NASU (Ukraine); STFC (United Kingdom); DOE and NSF (USA).
Individuals have received support from the Marie-Curie program and the European Research Council and Horizon 2020 Grant, contract Nos. 675440, 724704, 752730, 758316, 765710, 824093, 101115353, 101002207, 101001205, and COST Action CA16108 (European Union); the Leventis Foundation; the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation; the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation; the Science Committee, project no. 22rl-037 (Armenia); the Fonds pour la Formation à la Recherche dans l’Industrie et dans l’Agriculture (FRIA) and Fonds voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek contract No. 1228724N (Belgium); the Beijing Municipal Science & Technology Commission, No. Z191100007219010, the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities, the Ministry of Science and Technology of China under Grant No. 2023YFA1605804, the Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant No. 12535004, and USTC Research Funds of the Double First-Class Initiative No. YD2030002017 (China); the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports (MEYS) of the Czech Republic; the Shota Rustaveli National Science Foundation (Georgia); the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG), among others, under Germany’s Excellence Strategy – EXC 2121 “Quantum Universe” – 390833306, and under project number 400140256 - GRK2497; the Hellenic Foundation for Research and Innovation (HFRI), Project Number 2288 (Greece); the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, the New National Excellence Program - ÚNKP, the NKFIH research grants K 131991, K 138136, K 143460, K 143477, K 147557, K 146913, K 146914, K 147048, TKP2021-NKTA-64, and 2025-1.1.5-NEMZ_KI-2025-00004, and MATE KKP and KKPCs Research Excellence and Flagship Research Groups grants (Hungary); the Council of Science and Industrial Research, India; ICSC – National Research Center for High Performance Computing, Big Data and Quantum Computing, FAIR – Future Artificial Intelligence Research, and CUP I53D23001070006 (Mission 4 Component 1), funded by the NextGenerationEU program, the Italian Ministry of University and Research (MUR) under Bando PRIN 2022 – CUP I53C24002390006, PRIN PRIMULA 2022RBYK7T (Italy); the Latvian Council of Science; the Ministry of Science and Higher Education, project no. 2022/WK/14, and the National Science Center, contracts Opus 2021/41/B/ST2/01369, 2021/43/B/ST2/01552, 2023/49/B/ST2/03273, and the NAWA contract BPN/PPO/2021/1/00011 (Poland); the Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (Portugal); the National Priorities Research Program by Qatar National Research Fund; MICIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, ERDF/EU, “European Union NextGenerationEU/PRTR”, projects PID2022-142604OB-C21, PID2022-139519OB-C21, PID2023-147706NB-I00, PID2023-148896NB-I00, PID2023-146983NB-I00, PID2023-147115NB-I00, PID2023-148418NB-C41, PID2023-148418NB-C42, PID2023-148418NB-C43, PID2023-148418NB-C44, PID2024-158190NB-C22, RYC2021-033305-I, RYC2024-048719-I, CNS2023-144781, CNS2024-154769 and Plan de Ciencia, Tecnología e Innovación de Asturias, Spain; the Chulalongkorn Academic into Its 2nd Century Project Advancement Project, the National Science, Research and Innovation Fund program IND_FF_68_369_2300_097, and the Program Management Unit for Human Resources & Institutional Development, Research and Innovation, grant B39G680009 (Thailand); the Eric & Wendy Schmidt Fund for Strategic Innovation through the CERN Next Generation Triggers project under grant agreement number SIF-2023-004; the Kavli Foundation; the Nvidia Corporation; the SuperMicro Corporation; the Welch Foundation, contract C-1845; and the Weston Havens Foundation (USA).
Data availability
Release and preservation of data used by the CMS Collaboration as the basis for publications is guided by the CMS data preservation, re-use and open access policy.
Scatter plots of the D meson vs. charged particle
The scatter plots of the D meson vs. charged particle values measured in common intervals for the most central events, i.e., 0–10%, are shown in Figure 6. The scatter plots for D meson GeV are shown in Figure 7.
The CMS Collaboration
Yerevan Physics Institute, Yerevan, Armenia
A. Gevorgyan, A. Hayrapetyan, V. Makarenko, A. Tumasyan1
Marietta Blau Institute for Particle Physics, Vienna, Austria
W. Adam, L. Benato, T. Bergauer, M. Dragicevic, P.S. Hussain, M. Jeitler2, N. Krammer, A. Li, D. Liko, M. Matthewman, J. Schieck2, R. Schöfbeck, M. Shooshtari, M. Sonawane, N. Van Den Bossche, W. Waltenberger, C.E. Wulz2
Universiteit Antwerpen, Antwerpen, Belgium
T. Janssen, H. Kwon, D. Ocampo Henao, T. Van Laer, P. Van Mechelen
Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussel, Belgium
D. Ahmadi, J. Bierkens, N. Breugelmans, J. D’Hondt, S. Dansana, A. De Moor, M. Delcourt, C. Gupta, F. Heyen, Y. Hong, P. Kashko, S. Lowette, I. Makarenko, S. Nandakumar, S. Tavernier, M. Tytgat3, G.P. Van Onsem, S. Van Putte, D. Vannerom, T. Wybouw
Université Libre de Bruxelles, Bruxelles, Belgium
A. Beshr, B. Bilin, F. Caviglia Roman, B. Clerbaux, A.K. Das, I. De Bruyn, G. De Lentdecker, E. Ducarme, H. Evard, L. Favart, A. Khalilzadeh, A. Malara, M.A. Shahzad, A. Sharma, L. Thomas, M. Vanden Bemden, C. Vander Velde, P. Vanlaer, F. Zhang
Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
A. Cauwels, M. De Coen, D. Dobur, C. Giordano, G. Gokbulut, K. Kaspar, D. Kavtaradze, D. Marckx, K. Skovpen, A.M. Tomaru, J. van der Linden, J. Vandenbroeck
Université Catholique de Louvain, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
H. Aarup Petersen, A. Benecke, A. Bethani, G. Bruno, A. Cappati, J. De Favereau De Jeneret, C. Delaere, F. Gameiro Casalinho, A. Giammanco, A.O. Guzel, M. Hussain, V. Lemaitre, J. Lidrych, P. Malek, S. Turkcapar
Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas Fisicas, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
G. Alves, M. Barroso Ferreira Filho, E. Coelho, M.V. Gonçalves Sales, C. Hensel, D. Matos Figueiredo, T. Menezes De Oliveira, C. Mora Herrera, P. Rebello Teles, M. Soeiro, E.J. Tonelli Manganote4, A. Vilela Pereira
Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
W.L. Aldá Júnior, H. Brandao Malbouisson, W. Carvalho, J. Chinellato5, M. Costa Reis, E.M. Da Costa, D. Da Silva Dalto, G.G. Da Silveira6, D. De Jesus Damiao, S. Fonseca De Souza, R. Gomes De Souza, S. Jesus, T. Laux Kuhn6, K. Maslova Gioseffi Defante, K. Mota Amarilo, L. Mundim, H. Nogima, J.P. Pinheiro, A. Santoro, A. Sznajder, M. Thiel, F. Torres Da Silva De Araujo7
Universidade Estadual Paulista (a), Universidade Federal do ABC (b), São Paulo, Brazil
C.A. Bernardes, L. Calligaris, J. Carvalho Leite, F. Damas, E. De Moraes Gregores, B. Lopes Da Costa, I. Maietto Silverio, P.G. Mercadante, S.F. Novaes, S. Padula, V. Scheurer, T. Tomei
Institute for Nuclear Research and Nuclear Energy, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria
A. Aleksandrov, G. Antchev, P. Danev, R. Hadjiiska, P. Iaydjiev, M. Shopova G. Sultanov
University of Sofia, Sofia, Bulgaria
A. Dimitrov, L. Litov, B. Pavlov, P. Petkov, A. Petrov
Instituto de Alta Investigación, Universidad de Tarapacá, Arica, Chile
S. Keshri, D.N. Laroze Navarrete, M. Meena, S. Thakur
Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Valparaiso, Chile
W. Brooks
Beihang University, Beijing, China
T. Cheng, T. Javaid, L. Wang, L. Yuan
Department of Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China
J. Gu, Z. Hu, Z. Liang, J. Liu, X. Wang, Y. Wang, H. Yang, S. Zhang
Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing, China
N. Bi, G.M. Chen8, H.S. Chen8, M. Chen8, Y. Chen, B. Hou, Q. Hou, F. Iemmi, C.H. Jiang, H. Liao, G. Liu, Z. Liu9, S. Song, J. Tao, C. Wang8, J. Wang, A. Zada, H. Zhang, J. Zhao
State Key Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Technology, Peking University, Beijing, China
A. Agapitos, Y. Ban, A. Carvalho Antunes De Oliveira, S. Deng, X. Geng, B. Guo, Q. Guo, Z. He, C. Jiang, A. Levin, C. Li, Q. Li, Y. Mao, S. Qian, S.J. Qian, X. Qin, C. Quaranta, X. Sun, D. Wang, J. Wang, T. Yang, M. Zhang, Y. Zhao, C. Zhou
State Key Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Technology, Institute of Quantum Matter, South China Normal University, Guangzhou, China, Guangzhou, China
X. Hua, S. Yang
Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou, China
Z. You
University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, China
N. Lu
Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing, China
G. Bauer10,11, L. Chen, Z. Cui11, B. Li12, H. Wang, K. Yi13, J. Zhang, F. Zhu
Institute of Frontier and Interdisciplinary Science, Shandong University, Qingdao, China
C. Li
Institute of Modern Physics and Key Laboratory of Nuclear Physics and Ion-beam Application (MOE) - Fudan University, Shanghai, China
Y. Li, Y. Zhou14
Zhejiang University - Department of Physics, Zhejiang, China
Z. Lin, C. Lu, M. Xiao15
Universidad de Los Andes, Bogota, Colombia
C. Avila, A. Cabrera, C. Florez, J.A. Reyes Vega
Universidad de Antioquia, Medellin, Colombia
C. Rendón, M. Rodriguez, A.A. Ruales Barbosa, J.D. Ruiz Alvarez
University of Split, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Mechanical Engineering and Naval Architecture, Split, Croatia N. Godinovic, D. Lelas, A. Sculac
University of Split, Faculty of Science, Split, Croatia
M. Kovac, A. Petkovic, T. Sculac
Institute Rudjer Boskovic, Zagreb, Croatia
P. Bargassa, V. Brigljevic, D. Ferencek, K. Jakovcic, A. Starodumov, T. Susa
University of Cyprus, Nicosia, Cyprus
A. Attikis, K. Christoforou, S. Konstantinou, C. Leonidou, L. Paizanos, F. Ptochos, P.A. Razis, H. Rykaczewski, H. Saka, A. Stepennov
Charles University, Prague, Czech Republic
M. Finger, M. Finger Jr.
Escuela Politecnica Nacional, Quito, Ecuador
E. Acurio
Universidad San Francisco de Quito, Quito, Ecuador
E. Carrera Jarrin
Academy of Scientific Research and Technology of the Arab Republic of Egypt, Egyptian Network of High Energy Physics, Cairo, Egypt
S. Elgammal{sup}16, A. Ellithi Kamel{sup}17
Center for High Energy Physics (CHEP-FU), Fayoum University, El-Fayoum, Egypt
A. Hussein, H. Mohammed
National Institute of Chemical Physics and Biophysics, Tallinn, Estonia
K. Jaffel, M. Kadastik, T. Lange, C. Nielsen, J. Pata, M. Raidal, N. Seeba, L. Tani
Department of Physics, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
E. Brücken, A. Milieva, K. Osterberg, M. Voutilainen
Helsinki Institute of Physics, Helsinki, Finland
F.I. Garcia Fuentes, T. Hilden, P. Inkaew, K.T.S. Kallonen, R. Kumar Verma, T. Lampén, K. Lassila-Perini, B. Lehtela, S. Lehti, T. Lindén, N.R. Mancilla Xinto, M. Myllymäki, M.m. Rantanen, S. Saariokari, N.T. Toikka, J. Tuominiemi
Lappeenranta-Lahti University of Technology, Lappeenranta, Finland
N. Bin Norjoharuddeen, H. Kirschenmann, P.R. Luukka, H. Petrow
IRFU, CEA, Université Paris-Saclay, Gif-sur-Yvette, France
M. Besancon, F. Couderc, M. Dejardin, D. Denegri, P. Devouge, J.L. Faure, F. Ferri, P. Gaigne, S. Ganjour, P. Gras, F. Guilloux, G. Hamel de Monchenault, M. Kumar, V. Lohezic, Y. Maidannyk, J. Malcles, F. Orlandi, L. Portales, S. Ronchi, M.Ö. Sahin, P. Simkina, M. Titov, M. Tornago
Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet, CNRS/IN2P3, Ecole Polytechnique, Institut Polytechnique de Paris, Palaiseau, France
R. Amella Ranz, F. Beaudette, G. Boldrini, P. Busson, C. Charlot, M. Chiusi, T.D. Cuisset, O. Davignon, A. De Wit, T. Debnath, I.T. Ehle, S. Ghosh, A. Gilbert, R. Granier de Cassagnac, M. Manoni, M. Nguyen, S. Obraztsov, C. Ochando, R. Salerno, J.B. Sauvan, Y. Sirois, G. Sokmen, Y. Song, L. Urda Gómez, B. Voirin, A. Zabi, A. Zghiche
Institut Pluridisciplinaire Hubert Curien (IPHC), Université de Strasbourg, CNRS/IN2P3, Strasbourg, France
J.L. Agram{sup}18, J. Andrea, D. Bloch, J.M. Brom, E.C. Chabert, C. Collard, G. Coulon, S. Falke, U. Goerlach, A.C. Le Bihan, G. Saha, A. Savoy-Navarro{sup}19, P. Vaucelle
Centre de Calcul de l’Institut National de Physique Nucléaire et de Physique des Particules, CNRS/IN2P3, Villeurbanne, France
A. Di Florio, B. Orzari
Institut de Physique des 2 Infinis de Lyon (IP2I), Villeurbanne, France
D. Amram, S. Beauceron, B. Blancon, G. Boudoul, N. Chanon, D. Contardo, P. Depasse, H. El Mamouni, J. Fay, E. Fillaudeau, S. Gascon, M. Gouzevitch, C. Greenberg, G. Grenier, B. Ille, E. Jourd’Huy, M. Lethuillier, K. Long, B. Massoteau, L. Mirabito, A. Purohit, M. Vander Donckt, C. Verollet
Georgian Technical University, Tbilisi, Georgia
I. Bagaturia{sup}20, I. Lomidze, Z. Tsamalaidze{sup}21
RWTH Aachen University, I. Physikalisches Institut, Aachen, Germany
K.F. Adamowicz, V. Botta, S. Consuegra Rodríguez, L. Feld, K. Klein, M. Lipinski, P. Nattland, V. Oppenländer, A. Pauls, D. Pérez Adán
RWTH Aachen University, III. Physikalisches Institut A, Aachen, Germany
C. Daumann, S. Diekmann, N. Eich, D. Eliseev, F. Engelke, J. Erdmann, M. Erdmann, M.Z. Farkas, B. Fischer, T. Hebbeker, K. Hoepfner, A. Jung, N. Kumar, M.y. Lee, F. Mausolf, M. Merschmeyer, A. Meyer, A. Pozdnyakov, W. Redjeb, H. Reithler, U. Sarkar, V. Sarkisovi, A. Schmidt, C. Seth, A. Sharma, J.L. Spah, V. Vaulin, U. Willemsen, S. Zaleski, F.P. Zinn
RWTH Aachen University, III. Physikalisches Institut B, Aachen, Germany
M.R. Beckers, G. Flügge, N. Hoeflich, T. Kress, A. Nowack, O. Pooth, A. Stahl
Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron, Hamburg, Germany
A. Abel, M. Aldaya Martin, J. Alimena, Y. An, I. Andreev, J. Bach, S. Baxter, H. Becerril Gonzalez, O. Behnke, A. Belvedere, F. Blekman{sup}22, K. Borras{sup}23, A. Campbell, S. Chatterjee, L.X. Coll Saravia, G. Eckerlin, D. Eckstein, E. Gallo{sup}22, A. Geiser, M. Guthoff, A. Hinzmann, M. Kasemann, C. Kleinwort, R. Kogler, M. Komm, D. Krücker, F. Labe, W. Lange, D. Leyva Pernia, J.h. Li, K.y. Lin, K. Lipka{sup}24, W. Lohmann{sup}25, J. Malvaso, R. Mankel, I.A. Melzer-Pellmann, M. Mendizabal Morentin, A.B. Meyer, G. Milella, K. Moral Figueroa, A. Mussgiller, L.P. Nair, J. Niedziela, A. Nürnberg, J. Park, E. Ranken, A. Raspereza, D. Rastorguev, L. Rygaard, M. Scham{sup}26,23, S. Schnake{sup}23, C. Schwanenberger{sup}22, D. Schwarz, P. Schütze, D. Selivanova, K. Sharko, M. Shchedrolosiev, D. Stafford, M. Torkian, S. Vashishtha, A. Ventura Barroso, R. Walsh, D. Wang, Q. Wang, K. Wichmann, L. Wiens{sup}23`, C. Wissing, Y. Yang, S. Zakharov, A. Zimmermmane Castro Santos
University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany
A.R. Alves Andrade, M. Antonello, S. Bollweg, M. Bonanomi, L. Ebeling, K. El Morabit, Y. Fischer, M. Frahm, E. Garutti, A. Grohsjean, A.A. Guvenli, J. Haller, D. Hundhausen, M. Jalalvandi, G. Kasieczka, P. Keicher, R. Klanner, W. Kordas, T. Kramer, C.c. Kuo, J. Lange, A. Lobanov, J. Matthieu, L. Moureaueux, K. Nikolopoulos, K.J. Pena Rodriguez, N. Prouvost, B. Raciti, M. Rieger, D. Savoiu, P. Schleper, M. Schröder, J. Schwandt, M. Sommerhalder, H. Stadie, G. Steinbrück, T. von Schwartz, R. Ward, B. Wiederspan, M. Wolf, C. Yede
Institut für Experimentelle Teilchenphysik, Karlsruhe, Germany
J. A Häuser, A. Brusamolino, E. Butz, Y.M. Chen, T. Chwalek, A. Dierlamm, G.G. Dincer, D. Druzhkin, U. Elicabuk, N. Faltermann, M. Giffels, A. Gottmann, F. Hartmann27, F. Hummer, U. Husemann, J. Kieseler, M. Klute, R. Kunnilan Muhammed Rafeek, O. Lavoryk, J.M. Lawhorn, S. Maier, T. Mehner, M. Molch, A.A. Monsch, M. Mormile, T. Müller, E. Pfeffer, M. Presilla, G. Quast, K. Rabbertz, B. Regnery, R. Schmieder, T. Selezneva, N. Shadskiy, I. Shvetsov, H.J. Simonis, L. Sowa, L. Stockmeier, K. Tauqeer, M. Toms, B. Topko, N. Trevisani, C. Verstege, T. Voigtländer, R.F. Von Cube, J. Von Den Driesch, C. Winter, R. Wolf, W.D. Zeuner, X. Zuo
Institute of Nuclear and Particle Physics (INPP), NCSR Demokritos, Aghia Paraskevi, Greece
G. Anagnostou, G. Daskalakis, A. Kyriakis
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece
P. Iosifidou, P. Katris, G. Melachroinos, Z. Painesis, I. Paraskevas, N. Plastiras, N. Saoulidou, K. Theofilatos, E. Tziaferi, E. Tzovara, K. Vellidis, I. Zisopoulos
National Technical University of Athens, Athens, Greece
T. Chatzistavrou, G. Karapostoli, K. Kousouris, K. Paschos, E. Siamarkou, G. Tsipolitis
University of Ioánnina, Ioánnina, Greece
I. Evangelou, C. Foudas, P. Katsoulis, P. Kokkas, P.G. Kosmoglou Kioseoglou, N. Manthos, I. Papadopoulos, J. Strologas
HUN-REN Wigner Research Centre for Physics, Budapest, Hungary
C. Hajdu, D. Horvath28,29, A. Kadlecsik, C. Lee, K. Márton, A.J. Rád l30, F. Sikler, V. Veszpremi
MTA-ELTE Lendület CMS Particle and Nuclear Physics Group, Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary
G. Balint, D. Biro, M. Csanad, K. Farkas, A. Fehérkuti31, M.M.A. Gadallah32, M. León Coello, G. Pasztor, G.I. Veres
Faculty of Informatics, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary, Debrecen, Hungary
B. Ujvari, G. Zilizi
HUN-REN ATOMKI - Institute of Nuclear Research, Debrecen, Hungary
G. Bencze, S. Czellar, J. Molnar, Z. Szillasi
Karoly Robert Campus, MATE Institute of Technology, Gyongyos, Hungary
T.F. Csorgo31, F. Nemes31, T. Novak, I. Szanyi33
Indian Institute of Technology Bhubaneswar, Bhubaneswar, India
S. Bahinipati, R. Raturi
Panjab University, Chandigarh, India
S. Bansal, S.B. Beri, V. Bhatnagar, B. Chauhan, S. Chauhan, N. Dhingra34, A. Kaur, H. Kaur, M. Kaur, S. Kumar, T. Sheokand, J. Singh, A. Singla, K. Verma
University of Delhi, Delhi, India A. Bhardwaj, A. Chhetri, B.C. Choudhary, A. Kumar, A. Kumar, M. Naimuddin, S. Phor, C. Prakash, K. Ranjan, M.K. Saini
Indian Institute of Technology Mandi (IIT-Mandi), Himachal Pradesh, India
M. Kumari, P. Palni, S. Rana, A. Rathore
University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad, India
S. Acharya{sup}35`, B. Gomber
Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Kanpur, India
S. Ganguly, S. Mukherjee
Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics, HBNI, Kolkata, India
S. Bhattacharya, S. Das Gupta, S. Dutta, S. Dutta, S. Sarkar
Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Madras, India
M.M. Ameen, P.K. Behera, S. Chatterjee, G. Dash, A. Dattamunsi, P. Jana, P. Kalbhor, S. Kamble, J.R. Komaragiri{sup}36`, P.R. Pujahari, A.K. Sikdar, R.K. Singh, P. Verma, S. Verma, A. Vijay
Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Mohali, Mohali, India
S. Nayak, H. Rajpoot, B.K. Sirasva
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research-A, Mumbai, India
L. Bhatt, S. Dugad, T. Mishra, G.B. Mohanty, M. Shelake, P. Suryadevara
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research-B, Mumbai, India
A. Bala, S. Banerjee, S. Barman{sup}37, R.M. Chatterjee, J. Chhikara, M. Guchait, S. Jain, A. Jaiswal, S. Kumar, M. Maity{sup}37, G. Majumder, K. Mazumdar, S. Parolia, R. Pramanik, R. Saxena, A. Thachayath
National Institute of Science Education and Research, Jatni, Khorda, Odisha 752050, India Homi Bhabha National Institute, Training School Complex, Anushakti Nagar, Mumbai 400094, India, Odisha, India
D. Maity{sup}38, P. Mal, K. Naskar{sup}38, A. Nayak{sup}38, K. Pal, P. Sadangi, S. Shuchi, S.K. Swain, S. Varghese{sup}38, D. Vats{sup}38`
Indian Institute of Science Education and Research (IISER), Pune, India
S. Dube, P. Hazarika, B. Kansal, A. Laha, R. Sharma, S. Sharma, K.Y. Vaish
Indian Institute of Technology Hyderabad, Telangana, India
B. Babu, S. Ghosh
Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan, Iran
H. Bakhshiansohi{sup}39, A. Jafari{sup}40, V. Sedighzadeh Dalavi, M. Zeinali{sup}41`
Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences (IPM), Tehran, Iran
S. Bashiri, S. Chenarani{sup}42, S.M. Etesami, Y. Hosseini, M. Khakzad, E. Khazaie, M. Mohammadi Najafabadi, M. Nourbakhsh, S. Tizchang{sup}43
University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland
M. Felcini, M. Grunewald
INFN Sezione di Bari{sup}a, Università di Bari{sup}b, Politecnico di Bari{sup}c`, Bari, Italy
M. Abbrescia{sup}a,b, M. Barbieri{sup}a,b, M. Buonsante{sup}a,b, A. Colaleo{sup}a,b, D. Creanza{sup}a,c, N. De Filippis{sup}a,c, M. De Palma{sup}a,b, W. Elmetenawee{sup}a,b,44, N. Ferrara{sup}a,c, L. Fiorea{sup}a, L. Generoso{sup}a,b, L. Longoa, M. Louka{sup}a,b, G. Maggi{sup}a,c, M. Maggi{sup}a, I. Margjekaa{sup}a V. Mastrapasqua, S. My, F. Nenna, S. Nuzzo, A. Pellecchia, A. Pompili, F.M. Procacci, G. Pugliese, R. Radogna, D. Ramos, A. Ranieri, L. Silvestris, F.M. Simone, A. Stamerra, Ü. Sözbilir, D. Troiano, R. Venditti, P. Verwilligen, A. Zaza
INFN Sezione di Bologna, Università di Bologna, Bologna, Italy
G. Abbiendi, C. Battilana, D. Bonacorsi, P. Capiluppi, M. Cruciani, M. Cuffiani, G.M. Dallavalle, T. Diotallevi, F. Fabbri, A. Fanfani, R. Farinelli, D. Fasanella, L. Ferragina, P. Giacomelli, C. Grandi, L. Guiducci, M. Lorusso, L. Lunerti, S. Marcellini, G. Masetti, F. Navarria, G. Paggia, A. Perrotta, A. Rossi, S. Rossi Tisbeni, T. Rovelli, G.P. Siroli
INFN Sezione di Catania, Università di Catania, Catania, Italy
S. Costa, A. Di Mattia, A. Lapertosa, R. Potenza, A. Tricomia
INFN Sezione di Firenze, Università di Firenze, Firenze, Italy
J. Altork, P. Assiouras, G. Barbagli, G. Bardelli, M. Bartolini, A. Calandri, B. Camaiani, A. Cassese, R. Ceccarelli, V. Ciulli, C. Civinini, R. D’Alessandro, L. Damenti, E. Focardi, T. Kello, G. Latino, P. Lenzi, M. Lizzо, M. Meschini, S. Paoletti, A. Papanastassiou, G. Sguazzoni, L. Viliani
INFN Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Frascati, Italy
L. Benussi, S. Colafranceschi, S. Meola, D. Piccolo
INFN Sezione di Genova, Università di Genova, Genova, Italy
M. Alves Gallo Pereira, F. Ferro, E. Robutti, S. Tosi
INFN Sezione di Milano-Bicocca, Università di Milano-Bicocca, Milano, Milano-Bicocca, Italy
A. Benaglia, F. Brivio, V. Camagna, F. Cetorelli, F. De Guio, M.E. Dinardo, P. Dini, S. Gennai, R. Gerosa, A. Ghezzi, P. Govoni, L. Guzzi, M.R. Kim, G. Lavizzari, M.T. Lucchini, M. Malberti, S. Malvezzi, A. Massironi, D. Menasce, L. Moroni, M. Paganoni, S. Palluotto, D. Pedrini, A. Perego, T. Tabarelli de Fatis
INFN Sezione di Napoli, Università di Napoli ’Federico II’, Università della Basilicata (Potenza), Scuola Superiore Meridionale (SSM), Napoli, Italy
S. Buontempo, F. Confortini, C. Di Fraia, F. Fabozzi, L. Favilla, A.O.M. Iorio, L. Lista, P. Paolucci, B. Rossi
INFN Sezione di Padova, Università di Padova, Universita degli Studi di Cagliari, Padova, Italy
P. Azzi, N. Bacchetta, D. Bisello, L. Borella, P. Bortignona, G. Bortolato, A.C.M. Bulla, P. Checchia, T. Dorigo, F. Fanzago, U. Gasparini, S. Giorgetti, P. Grutta, N. Lai, E. Lusiani, M. Margoni, A.T. Meneguzzo, M. Missiroli, J. Pazzini, F. Primavera, P. Ronchesе, R. Rossin, F. Simonetto, M. Tosia, A. Triossi, S. Ventura, M. Zanetti, P. Zotto, A. Zucchetta, G. Zumerle
INFN Sezione di Pavia, Università di Pavia, Pavia, Italy
C. Aimè, A. Braghieri, M. Brunoldi, S. Calzaferri, P. Montagna, M. Pelliccioni, V. Re, C. Riccardi, P. Salvini, I. Vai, P. Vitulo INFN Sezione di Perugia^{a}, Università di Perugia^{b}, Perugia, Italy
S. Ajmal^{a,b}, M.E. Ascoti^{a,b}, G.M. Bilei^{a}, C. Carrivale^{a,b}, D. Ciangottini^{a,b}, L. Della Penna^{a,b}, L. Fanò^{a,b}, V. Mariani^{a,b}, M. Menichelli^{a}, F. Moscatelli^{a},{sup}51`, A. Rossi^{a,b}, A. Santocchia^{a,b}, D. Spiga^{a}, T. Tedeschi^{a}
INFN Sezione di Pisa^{a}, Università di Pisa^{b}, Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa^{c}, Università di Siena^{d}, Pisa, Italy
C.A. Alexe^{a,c}, P. Asenov^{a,b}, P. Azzurri^{a}, G. Bagliesi^{a}, L. Bianchini^{a,b}, T. Boccali^{a}, E. Bossini^{a}, D. Bruschini^{a,c}, R. Castaldi^{a}, F. Cattafesta^{a,c}, M.A. Cioccia^{d}, M. Cipriani^{a,b}, R. Dell’Orso^{a}, S. Donato^{a,b}, A. Feliziani^{a,d}, R. Forti^{a,b}, A. Giassi^{a}, F. Ligabue^{a,c}, A.C. Marini^{a,b}, A. Messineo^{a,b}, S. Mishra^{a}, V.K. Muraleedharan Nair Bindhu^{a,b}, S. Nandana^{a}, F. Palla^{a}, M. Riggirello^{a,c}, A. Rizzi^{a,b}, G. Rolandi^{a,c}, S. Roy Chowdhury^{a},{sup}52`, T. Sarkar^{a}, A. Scribano^{a}, P. Solanki^{a,b}, P. Spagnolo^{a}, F. Tenchini^{a,b}, R. Tenchini^{a}, G. Tonelli^{a,b}, N. Turini^{a,d}, F. Vaselli^{a,c}, A. Venturi^{a}, P.G. Verdini^{a}
INFN Sezione di Roma^{a}, Sapienza Università di Roma^{b}, Roma, Italy
P. Akrap^{a,b}, C. Basile^{a,b}, S.C. Behera^{a}, F. Cavallari^{a}, L. Cunqueiro Mendez^{a,b}, F. De Riggi^{a,b}, D. Del Re^{a,b}, M. Del Vecchio^{a,b}, E. Di Marco^{a}, M. Diemoza, F. Errico^{a}, L. Frosina^{a,b}, R. Gargiulo^{a,b}, B. Harikrishnan^{a,b}, F. Lombardia,b, E. Longo^{a,b}, L. Martikainen^{a,b}, G. Organtini^{a,b}, N. Palmeri^{a,b}, R. Paramatti^{a,b}, T. Pauletto^{a,b}, S. Rahatlou^{a,b}, C. Rovelli^{a}, F. Santanastasio^{a,b}, L. Soffia, V. Vladimirov^{a,b}
INFN Sezione di Torino^{a}, Università di Torino^{b}, Università del Piemonte Orientale (Novara)^{c}, Torino, Italy
N. Amapane^{a,b}, R. Arcidiacono^{a,c}, S. Argiro^{a,b}, M. Arneodo^{a,c}, N. Bartosika^{a,c}, R. Bellan^{a,b}, A. Bellora^{a,b}, C. Biinoa, C. Borca^{a,b}, N. Cartiglia^{a}, M. Costa^{a,b}, R. Covarellia,b, N. Demaria^{a}, E. Ferrando^{a,b}, L. Fincoa, M. Grippo^{a,b}, B. Kiani^{a,b}, L. Lanteria,b, F. Legger^{a}, F. Luongo^{a,b}, M. Marchisio Caprioglio^{a,b}, C. Mariottia, S. Masellia, A. Mecca^{a,b}, L. Menzio^{a,b}, P. Meridiania, E. Migliore^{a,b}, M. Montenoa, M.M. Obertino^{a,b}, G. Ortonaa, L. Pachera^{a,b}, N. Pastronea, M. Ruspa^{a,c}, F. Siviero^{a,b}, V. Sola^{a,b}, A. Solano^{a,b}, A. Staianoa, C. Tarricone^{a,b}, D. Trocinoa, G. Umoreta,b, E. Vlasov^{b}, R. White^{a,b}
INFN Sezione di Trieste^{a}, Università di Trieste^{b}, Trieste, Italy
J. Babbara,b,{sup}52`, S. Belforte^{a}, V. Candelise^{a,b}, M. Casarsa^{a}, F. Cossuttia, K. De Leo^{a}, G. Della Ricca^{a,b}, R. Delli Gatti^{a,b}, C. Giraldina,b
Kyungpook National University, Daegu, Korea
S. Dogra, J. Hong, J. Kim, T. Kim, D. Lee, H. Lee, J. Lee, S.W. Lee, C.S. Moon, Y.D. Oh, S. Sekmen, B. Tae, Y.C. Yang
Department of Mathematics and Physics - Gangneung-Wonju National University, Gangneung, Korea
M.S. Kim
Chonnam National University, Institute for Universe and Elementary Particles, Kwangju, Korea
G. Bak, P. Gwak, H. Kim, H. Lee, S. Lee, D.H. Moon, J. Seo
Hanyang University, Seoul, Korea
E. Asilar, F. Carnevali, J. Choi{sup}53`, T.J. Kim, Y. Ryou, J. Song Korea University, Seoul, Korea S. Ha, S. Han, B.S. Hong, J. Kim, K. Lee, K.S. Lee, S. Lee, J. Padmanaban, J. Yoo
Kyung Hee University, Department of Physics, Seoul, Korea J. Goh, J. Shin, S. Yang
Sejong University, Seoul, Korea L. Kalipoliti, Y. Kang, H. Kim, Y. Kim, B. Ko, S. Lee
Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea J. Almond, J.H. Bhyun, J. Choi, J. Choi, W. Jun, H. Kim, J. Kim, J. Kim, T. Kim, Y. Kim, Y.W. Kim, S. Ko, H. Lee, J. Lee, J. Lee, B.H. Oh, J. Shin, U. Yang, I. Yoon
University of Seoul, Seoul, Korea W. Heo, W. Jang, D. Kim, S. Kim, J.S.H. Lee, Y. Lee, I. Park, Y. Roh, I. J. Watson
Yonsei University, Department of Physics, Seoul, Korea G. Cho, Y. Eo, K. Hwang, H. Jang, B. Kim, D. Kim, S. Kim, K. Lee, H.D. Yoo
Sungkyunkwan University, Suwon, Korea Y. Lee, I. Yu
College of Engineering and Technology, American University of the Middle East (AUM), Dasman, Kuwait T. Beyrouthy, Y. Gharbia
Kuwait University - College of Science - Department of Physics, Safat, Kuwait F. Alazemi
Riga Technical University, Riga, Latvia K. Dreimanis, O.M. Eberlins, A. Gaile, M. Klevs, C. Munoz Diaz, D. Osite, G. Pikurs, R. Plese, A. Potrebko, M. Seidel, D. Sidiropoulos Kontos
University of Latvia (LU), Riga, Latvia N.R. Strautnieks
Vilnius University, Vilnius, Lithuania M. Ambrozas, A. Juodagalvis, S. Nargelas, S. Nayak, A. Rinkevicius, G. Tamulaitis
National Centre for Particle Physics, Universiti Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia I. Yusuff54, Z. Zolkapli
University of Sonora (UNISON), Hermosillo, Mexico J.F. Benitez, A. Castaneda Hernandez, A. Cota Rodriguez, L.E. Cuevas Picos, H.A. Encinas Acosta, L.G. Gallegos Marínez, J.A. Murillo Quijada, L. Valencia Palomo
Centro de Investigacion y de Estudios Avanzados del IPN, Mexico City, Mexico G. Ayala, H. Castilla-Valdez, H. Crotte Ledesma, R. Lopez-Fernandez, J. Mejia Guisao, R. Reyes-Almanza, A. Sánchez Hernández
Universidad Iberoamericana, Mexico City, Mexico C. Oropeza Barrera, D.L. Ramirez Guadarrama, M. Ramírez García
Benemerita Universidad Autonoma de Puebla, Puebla, Mexico I. Bautista, F.E. Neri Huerta, I. Pedraza, H.A. Salazar Ibarguen, C. Uribe Estrada
University of Montenegro, Podgorica, Montenegro
I. Bubanja, J. Mijuskovic, N. Raicevic
University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand
P.H. Butler
National Centre for Physics, Quaid-I-Azam University, Islamabad, Pakistan
A. Ahmad, M.I. Asghar, A. Awais, M.I.M. Awan, W.A. Khan
AGH University of Krakow, Krakow, Poland
V. Avati, L. Forthomme, L. Grzanka, M. Malawski, K. Piotrzkowski
National Centre for Nuclear Research, Swierk, Poland
H. Awedikian, M. Bluj, M. Ghimiray, M. Górski, M. Kazana, M. Szleper, P. Zalewski
Institute of Experimental Physics, Faculty of Physics, University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
K. Bunkowski, K. Doroba, A. Kalinowski, M. Konecki, J. Krolikowski, W. Matyszkiewicz, A. Muhammad, S. Slawinski
Warsaw University of Technology, Warsaw, Poland
P. Fokow, K. Pozniak, W. Zabolotny
Laboratório de Instrumentação e Física Experimental de Partículas, Lisboa, Portugal
M. Araujo, C. Beirão Da Cruz E Silva, A. Boletti, M. Bozzo, T. Camporesi, G. Da Molin, M. Gallinaro, J. Hollar, N. Leonardo, G.B. Marozzo, A. Petrilli, M. Pisano, J. Seixas, J. Varela, J.W. Wulff
Faculty of Physics, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
P. Adzic, L. Markovic, P. Milenovic, V. Milosevic
Vinca Institute of Nuclear Science, Belgrade, Serbia
D. Devetak, M. Dordevic, J. Milosevic, L. Nadderd, V. Rekovic, M. Stojanovic
Centro de Investigaciones Energéticas Medioambientales y Tecnológicas (CIEMAT), Madrid, Spain
M. Alcalde Martinez, J. Alcaraz Maestre, J.A. Brochero Cifuentes, M. Cepeda, M. Cerrada, N. Colino, B. De La Cruz, A. Delgado Peris, A. Escalante Del Valle, C. Fernandez Bedoya, D. Fernández Del Val, J.P. Fernández Ramos, J. Flix, M.C. Fouz, M. Gonzalez Hernandez, O. Gonzalez Lopez, S. Goy Lopez, J.M. Hernandez, M.I. Josa, J. Llorente Merino, O. Manzanilla, C. Martin Perez, E. Martin Viscasillas, D. Moran, C.M. Morcillo Perez, Á. Navarro Tobar, R. Paz Herrera, J. Puerta Pelayo, A.M. Pérez-Calero Yzquierdo, I. Redondo, J. Vazquez Escobar
Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain
J.F. de Trocóniz
Universidad de Oviedo, Instituto Universitario de Ciencias y Tecnologías Espaciales de Asturias (ICTEA), Oviedo, Spain
E. Aller Gutierrez, B. Alvarez Gonzalez, J. Ayllon Torresano, A. Cardini, J. Cuevas, J. Del Riego Badas, D. Estrada Acevedo, J. Fernandez Menendez, S. Folguera, I. Gonzalez Caballero, P. Leguina, M. Obeso Menendez, E. Palencia Cortezon, J. Prado Pico, S. Sanchez Cruz, A. Soto Rodríguez, P. Vischia Instituto de Física de Cantabria (IFCA), CSIC-Universidad de Cantabria, Santander, Spain
S. Blanco Fernández, I.J. Cabrillo, A. Calderon, M. Caserta, J. Duarte Campderros, M. Fernandez, G. Gomez, C. Lasaosa García, R. Lopez Ruiz, C. Martinez Rivero, P. Martinez Ruiz del Arbol, F. Matorras, P. Matorras Cuevas, E. Navarrete Ramos, J. Piedra Gomez, C. Quintana San Emeterio, V. Rodriguez, L. Scodellaro, I. Vila, R. Vilar Cortabitarte, J.M. Vizan Garcia
University of Colombo, Colombo, Sri Lanka
D.C.W. Dhammage, B. Kailasapathy{sup}55`
University of Ruhuna, Department of Physics, Matara, Sri Lanka
W.G. Dharmaratna{sup}56`, K. Liyanage, N. Perera
CERN, European Organization for Nuclear Research, Geneva, Switzerland
D. Abbaneo, C. Amendola, R. Ardino, E. Auffray, J. Baechler, D. Barney, J. Bendavid, I. Bestintzanos, M. Bianco, A. Bocci, L. Borgonovi, C. Botta, A. Bragagnolo, C.E. Brown, C. Caillol, G. Cerminara, P. Connor, K. Cormier, D. D’Enterria, A. Dabrowski, P. Das, A. David Tinoco Mendes, A. De Roeck, M.M. Defranchis, M. Deile, M. Dobson, P.J. Fernández Manteca, B.A. Fontana Santos Alves, E. Fontanesi, W. Funk, A. Gaddi, S. Giani, D. Gigi, K. Gill, F. Glege, M. Glowacki, A. Gruber, J. Hegeman, J.K. Heikkilä, R. Hofsaess, B. Huber, T. James, P. Janot, L. Jeppe, O. Kaluzinska, O. Karacheban{sup}25, G. Karathanasis, S. Laurila, P. Lecoq, E. Leutgeb, J. León Holgado, C. Lourenco, A.m. Lyon, M. Magherini, L. Malgeri, M. Mannelli, A. Mehta, F. Meijers, J.A. Merlin, S. Mersi, E. Meschi, M. Migliorini, F. Monti, F. Moortgat, M. Mulders, M. Musich, I. Neutelings, S. Orfanelli, F. Pantaleo, M. Pari, F. Pereira Carneiro, G. Petrucciani, A. Pfeiffer, M. Pierini, M. Pitt, H. Qu, D. Rabady, A. Reimers, B. Ribeiro Lopes, F. Riti, P. Rosado, M. Rovere, H. Sakulin, R. Salvatico, S. Scarfi, S.F. Schaefer, M. Selvaggi, K. Shchelina, P. Silva, P. Sphicas{sup}57, A.G. Stahl Leiton, A. Steen, S. Summers, G. Terragni, D. Treille, P. Tropea, E. Vernazza, M. Vojinovic, J. Wanczyk{sup}58`, S. Wuchterl, M. Zarucki, P. Zehetner, P. Zejdl, G. Zevi Della Porta
PSI Center for Neutron and Muon Sciences, Villigen, Switzerland
L. Caminada{sup}59, W. Erdmann, R. Horisberger, Q. Ingram, H.C. Kaestli, D. Kotlinski, C. Lange, U. Langenegger, A. Nigamova, L. Noehte{sup}59, L. Redard-Jacot{sup}59`, T. Rohe, A. Samalan
ETH Zurich - Institute for Particle Physics and Astrophysics (IPA), Zurich, Switzerland
T.K. Aarrestad, M. Backhaus, T. Bevilacqua{sup}59, G. Bonomelli, C. Cazzaniga, K. Datta, P. De Bryas Dexmiers D’Archiacchiac{sup}58, A. De Cosa, G. Dissertori, M. Dittmar, M. Donegà, F. Glessgen, C. Grab, T.G. Harte, N. Härringer, M. Koppel, W. Lustermann, M. Malucchi, R.A. Manzoni, L. Marchese, A. Mascellani{sup}58, F. Nessi-Tedaldi, F. Pauss, A.A. Petre, J. Prendi, B. Ristic, S. Rohletter, P.M. Sander, R. Seidita, J. Steggemann{sup}58, A. Tarabini, C.Z. Tee, D. Valsecchi, P.H. Wagner, R. Wallny
Universität Zürich, Zurich, Switzerland
C. Amsler, F. Bilandzija, P. Bärtschi, M.F. Canelli, G. Celotto, T.A. Goldschmidt, V. Guglielmi, A. Jofrehei, B. Kilminster, T.H. Kwok, S. Leontsinis, V. Lukashenko, A. Macchiolo, F. Meng, J. Motta, P. Robmann, E. Shokr, F. Stäger, R. Tramontano, P. Viscone Çukurova University, Adana, Türkiye
D. Agyel, F. Dolek, I. Dumanoglu61, Y. Guler62, E. Gurpinar Guler62, O. Kara63, A. Kayis Topaksu, Y. Komurcu, G. Onengut, K. Ozdemir64, B. Tali65, U.G. Tok, E. Uslan, I.S. Zorbakir
Hacettepe University, Ankara, Türkiye
S. Sen
Middle East Technical University, Physics Department, Ankara, Türkiye
M. Yalvac66
Bogazici University, Istanbul, Türkiye
B. Akgun, I.O. Atakisi67, E. Gulmez, M. Kaya68, O. Kaya69, M.A. Sarkisla70, S. Tekten71
Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Türkiye
D. Boncukcu, A. Cakir, K. Cankocak61,72
Istanbul University, Istanbul, Türkiye
B. Hacisahinoglu, I. Hos73, B. Kaynak, S. Ozkorucuklu, O. Potok, H. Sert, C. Simsek, C. Zorbilmez
Yildiz Technical University, Istanbul, Türkiye
S. Cerci, C. Dozen74, B. Isildak, E. Simsek, D. Sunar Cerci, T. Yetkin74
National Central University, Chung-Li, Taiwan
D. Bhowmik, C.M. Kuo, P.K. Rout, S. Taj, P.C. Tiwari36
National Taiwan University (NTU), Taipei, Taiwan
L. Ceard, K.F. Chen, Z.g. Chen, A. De Iorio, G.W.S. Hou, T.h. Hsu, Y.w. Kao, S. Karmakar, F. Khuzaimah, G. Kole, Y.y. Li, R.S. Lu, E. Paganis, X.f. Su, J. Thomas-Wilsker, L.s. Tsai, D. Tsionou, H.y. Wu, E. Yazgan
High Energy Physics Research Unit, Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand
C. Asawatangtrakuldee, N. Srimanobhas
Tunis El Manar University, Tunis, Tunisia
Y. Maghrbi
Institute for Scintillation Materials of National Academy of Science of Ukraine, Kharkiv, Ukraine
A. Boyaryntsev, O. Dadazhanova, B. Grynyov
National Science Centre, Kharkiv Institute of Physics and Technology, Kharkiv, Ukraine
L. Levchuk
University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom
J.J. Brooke, A. Bundock, F.J.J. Bury, E. Clement, D. Cussans, D. Dharmender, H. Flacher, J. Goldstein, H.F. Heath, M.I. Holmberg, A. Karakoulaki, L. Kreczko, S. Paramesvaran, L. Robertshaw, M.S. Sanjrani39, J. Segal, V.J. Smith
Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Didcot, United Kingdom
A. Ball, K.W. Bell, A. Belyaev75, C. Brew, R.M. Brown, D.J. Cockerill, A. Elliot, K.V. Ellis, J. Gajownik, K. Harder, S. Harper, J. Linacre, K. Manolopoulos, M. Moallemi, D.M. Newbold, E. Olaiya, D. Petyt, T. Reis, A.R. Sahasransu, G. Salvi, T. Schuh, C. Shepherd-Themistocleous, I.R. Tomalin, K.C. Whalen, T. Williams
Imperial College, London, United Kingdom
I. Andreou, R. Bainbridge, P. Bloch, O. Buchmuller, C.A. Carrillo Montoya, D. Colling, I. Das, P. Dauncey, G. Davies, M. Della Negra, S. Fayer, G. Fedi, G. Hall, H.R. Hoorani, A. Howard, G. Iles, C.R. Knight, P. Krueper, J. Langford, K.H. Law, L. Lyons, A.M. Magnan, B. Maier, S. Mallios, A. Mastronikolis, M. Mieskolainen, J. Nash76, M. Pesaresi, P.B. Pradeep, B.C. Radburn-Smith, A. Richards, A. Rose, T.B. Runting, L. Russell, K. Savva, R. Schmitz, C. Seez, R. Shukla, A. Tapper, K. Uchida, G.P. Uttley, T. Virdee27, N. Wardle, D. Winterbottom, J. Xiao
Brunel University, Uxbridge, United Kingdom
J. Cole, A. Khan, P. Kyberd, I. Reid
The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA
B. Bam, A. Buchot Perraguin, S. Campbell, R. Chudasama, S. Cooper, C. Crovella, G. Fidalgo, S.V. Gleyzer, C. Isik, R. Kaur, A. Khukhunaishvili, K. Matchev, E. Pearson, P. Rumerio77, E. Usai, R. Yi
University of California, Davis, Davis, California, USA
S. Abbott, S. Baradia, B. Barton, R. Breedon, H. Cai, M. Calderon De La Barca Sanchez, E. Cannaert, M. Chertok, M. Citron, J. Conway, P.T. Cox, F. Eble, R. Erbacher, C. Fairchild, O. Kukral, G. Mocellin, S. Ostrom, I. Salazar Segovia, J.H. Steenis, J.S. Tafoya Vargas, W. Wei, S. Yoo
University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, California, USA
A. Aportela, A. Arora, J.G. Branson, S. Cittolin, B. D’Anzi, D. Diaz, J. Duarte, L. Giannini, Y. Gu, J. Guiang, V. Krutelyov, R. Lee, J. Letts, H. Li, R. Marroquin Solares, M. Masciovecchio, F. Mokhtar, S. Mukherjee, M. Pieri, D. Primosch, M. Quinnan, V. Sharma, M. Tadel, E. Vourliotis, F. Würthwein, A. Yagil, Z. Zhao
University of California, Los Angeles, California, USA
K. Adamidis, H. Ancelin, M. Bachtis, D. Campos, R. Cousins, S. Crossley, G. Flores Avila, J. Hauser, M. Ignatenko, M.A. Iqbal, T. Lam, Y.f. Lo, E. Manca, A. Nunez Del Prado, D. Saltzberg, V. Valuev
California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California, USA
A. Albert, S. Bhattacharya, A. Bornheim, O. Cerri, Z. Hao, R. Kansal, L. Mori, H.B. Newman, G. Reales Gutiérrez, T. Sievert, P. Simmerling, M. Spiropulu, C. Sun, J.R. Vlimant, R.A. Wynne, S. Xie, R.Y. Zhu
University of California, Riverside, Riverside, California, USA
R. Clare, J.W. Gary, G. Hanson
University of California, Santa Barbara - Department of Physics, Santa Barbara, California, USA
A. Barzdukas, L. Brennan, C. Campagnari, S. Carron Montero78, K. Downham, C. Grieco, M.M. Hussain, J. Incandela, M.W.K. Lai, A.J. Li, P. Masterson, J. Richman, S.N. Santpur, D. Stuart, T.Á. Vámi, X. Yan, D. Zhang
University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, Colorado, USA J.P. Cumalat, W.T. Ford, J. Fraticelli, A. Hart, M. Herrmann, S. Kwan, J. Pearkes, C. Savard, N. Schonbeck, K. Stenson, K. Ulmer, S.R. Wagner, N. Zipper, D. Zuolo
The Catholic University of America, Washington, DC, USA
R. Bartek, A. Dominguez, S. Raj, B. Sahu, A.E. Simsek, B. Singhal, S.S. Yu
University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA
C. Aruta, P. Avery, D. Bourilkov, P. Chang, V. Cherepanov, M. Dittrich, R.D. Field, C. Huh, E. Koenig, M. Kolosova, J. Konigsberg, A. Korytov, G. Mitselmakher, K. Mohrman, A. Muthirakalayil Madhu, N. Rawal, S. Rosenzweig, V. Sulimov, Y. Takahashi, J. Wang
Florida Institute of Technology, Melbourne, Florida, USA
B. Alsufyani, S. Das, S. Demarest, L. Hasa, M. Hohlmann, M. Lavinsky, E. Yanes
Florida State University, Tallahassee, Florida, USA
T. Adams, A. Al Kadhim, A. Askew, S. Bower, R. Goff, R. Hashmi, A. Hassani, T. Kolberg, G. Martinez, M. Mazza, H. Prosper, P.R. Prova, R. Yohay
Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, Batavia, Illinois, USA
M. Albrow, M. Alyari, O. Amram, G. Apollinari, A. Apresyan, L.A. Bauerdick, D. Berry, J. Berryhill, P.C. Bhat, K. Burkett, J.N. Butler, A. Canepa, G.B. Cerati, H. Cheung, F. Chlebana, C. Cosby, G. Cummings, I. Dutta, V.D. Elvira, J. Freeman, A. Gandrakota, Z. Gecse, L. Gray, D. Green, A. Grummer, S. Grünendahl, D. Guerrero, O. Gutsche, R.M. Harris, J. Hirschauer, V. Innocente, B. Jayatilaka, S. Jindariani, M. Johnson, U. Joshi, R.S. Kim, B. Klima, S. Lammel, D. Lincoln, R. Lipton, T. Liu, K. Maeshima, D. Mason, P. McBride, P. Merkel, S. Mrenna, S. Nahn, J. Ngadiuba, D. Noonan, S. Norberg, V. Papadimitriou, N. Pastika, K. Pedro, C. Pena{sup}79, C.E. Perez Lara, V. Perovic, F. Ravera, A. Reinsvold Hall{sup}80, L. Ristori, M. Safdari, E. Sexton-Kennedy, E. Smith, N. Smith, A. Soha, L. Spiegel, S. Stoynev, J. Strait, L. Taylor, S. Tkaczyk, N.V. Tran, L. Uplegger, E.W. Vaandering, C. Wang, I. Zoi
University of Illinois Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA
M.R. Adams, N. Barnett, A. Baty, C. Bennett, N. Brandman-hughes, R. Cavanaugh, R. Escobar Franco, O. Evdokimov, C.E. Gerber, H. Gupta, M. Hawksworth, A. Hingrajiya, D.J. Hofman, Z. Huang, J.h. Lee, C. Mills, S. Nanda, G. Nigmatkulov, B. Ozek, V. Pant, T. Phan, D. Pilipovic, R. Pradhan, E. Prifti, P. Roy, T. Roy, D. Shekar, N. Singh, F. Strug, A. Thielen, M. Tonjes, N. Varelas, M.A. Wadud, A. Wang, J. Yoo
Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois, USA
S. Dittmer, K.A. Hahn, S. King, M. Mcginnis, Y. Miao, D.G. Monk, M.H. Schmitt, A. Taliercio, M. Velasco, J. Wang
Purdue University Northwest, Hammond, Indiana, USA
N. Parashar, A. Pathak, E. Shumka
University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, Indiana, USA
G. Agarwal, R. Band, R. Bucci, S. Castells, A. Das, A. Datta, A. Ehnis, R. Goldouzian, M. Hildreth, K. Hurtado Anampa, T. Ivanov, C. Jessop, A. Karyneueu, K. Lannon, J. Lawrence, N. Loukas, D. Lutton, J. Mariano, N. Marinelli, P. Mastrapasqua, A. Masud, T. McCauley, C. Mcgrady, C. Moore, Y. Musienko{sup}21`, H. Nelson, M. Osherson, A. Piccinelli, R. Ruchti, A. Townsend, Y. Wan, M. Wayne, H. Yockey
Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA S. Chandra, A. Gu, L. Gutay, M. Huwiler, M. Jones, A.W. Jung, I.G. Karslioglu, D. Kondratyev, J. Li, M. Liu, M. Macedo, G. Negro, N. Neumeister, G. Paspalaki, S. Piperov, N.R. Saha, J.F. Schulte, F. Wang, A.L. Wesolek, A. Wildridge, W. Xie, Y. Yao, Y. Zhong
The University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa, USA M. Alhusseini, D. Blend, K. Dilsiz81, O.K. Köseyan, A. Mestvirishvili82, O. Neogi, H. Ogul83, Y. Onel, A. Penzo, C. Snyder, E. Tiras84
The University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, USA A. Abreu, L.F. Alcerro Alcerro, J. Anguiano, S. Arteaga Escatel, P. Baringer, A. Bean, R. Bhattacharya, Z. Flowers, D. Grove, J. King, G. Krintiras, M. Lazarovits, C. Le Mahieu, J. Marquez, M. Murray, M. Nickel, S. Popescu85, C. Rogan, C. Royon, S. Rudrabhatla, S. Sanders, C. Smith, G. Wilson
Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kansas, USA A. Ahmad, B. Allmond, N. Islam, A. Ivanov, K. Kaadze, Y. Maravin, J. Natoli, G.G. Reddy, D. Roy, G. Sorrentino
Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland, USA B. Blumenfeld, J. Davis, A. Gritsan, Z. Huang, L. Kang, S. Kyriacou, P. Maksimovic, N. Pinto, M. Roguljic, S. Sekhar, M.V. Srivastav, M. Swartz
University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland, USA D. Baden, A. Belloni, J. Bistany-riebman, S.C. Eno, N.J. Hadley, S. Jabeen, R.G. Kellogg, T. Koeth, B. Kronheim, S. Lascio, J. Lee, P. Major, A. Mignerey, C. Palmer, C. Papageorgakis, M.M. Paranjpe, E. Popova86, A. Shevelev, L. Zhang
Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts, USA S. Cholak, G. De Castro, Z. Demiragli, C. Erice, C. Fangmeier, C. Fernandez Madrazo, J. Fulcher, J. Garcia De Castro, F. Golf, S. Jeon, J. O’Cain, I. Reed, J. Rohlf, K. Salyer, D. Sperka, I. Suarez, A. Tsatsos, E. Wurtz, A.G. Zecchinelli
Northeastern University, Boston, Massachusetts, USA A. Aarif, G. Alverson, E. Barberis, S. Bein, J. Bonilla, B. Bylsma, M. Campana, R. Clark, J. Dervan, Y. Haddad, Y. Han, I. Israr, A. Krishna, M. Lu, N. Manganelli, R. Mccarthy, D.M. Morse, T. Orimoto, L. Skinnari, C.S. Thoreson, E. Tsai, D. Wood
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA C. Baldenegro Barrera, H. Bossi, S. Bright-Thonney, I.A. Cali, Y.c. Chen, P.c. Chou, M. D’Alfonso, J. Eysermans, C. Freer, G. Gomez Ceballos, M. Goncharov, G. Grosso, P. Harris, D. Hoang, G.M. Innocenti, K. Ivanov, G. Kopp, D. Kovalskyi, J. Lang, L. Lavezzo, Y.J. Lee, P. Lugato, C. Mcginn, E. Moreno, A. Novak, M.I. Park, C. Paus, C. Reissel, C. Roland, G. Roland, S. Rothman, T.a. Sheng, G. Stephans, D. Walter, J. Wang, Z. Wang, B. Wyslouch, T. Yang
Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan, USA S. Bhattacharya, P.E. Karchin
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA A. Alpana, B. Crossman, W.J. Jackson, C. Kapsiak, M. Krohn, D. Mahon, J. Mans, B. Marzocchi, R. Rusack, O. Sancar, R. Saradhy, N. Strobbe
Bethel University, St. Paul, Minnesota, USA
J.M. Hogan
University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, Nebraska, USA
K. Bloom, D.R. Claes, S.V. Dixit, G. Haza, J. Hossain, C. Joo, I. Kravchenko, K.H.M. Kwok, Y. Mehra, J. Morris, A. Rohilla, J.E. Siado, A. Vagnerini, A. Wightman
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, Piscataway, New Jersey, USA
B. Chiarito, J.P. Chou, S.V. Clark, S. Donnelly, D. Gadkari, Y. Gershtein, E. Halkiadakis, C. Houghton, D. Jaroslawski, A. Kobert, I. Laflotte, A. Lath, J. Martins, P. Meltzer, M. Perez Prada, B. Rand, J. Reichert, P. Saha, S. Salur, S. Somalwar, R. Stone, S.A. Thayil, S. Thomas, J. Vora
Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey, USA
H. Bouchamaoui, G. Dezoort, P. Elmer, A. Frankenthal, M. Galli, B. Greenberg, K. Kennedy, Y. Lai, D. Lange, A. Loeliger, D. Marlow, I. Ojalvo, J. Olsen, F. Simpson, D. Stickland, C. Tully, S. Yoon
State University of New York at Buffalo, Buffalo, New York, USA
H. Bandyopadhyay, L. Hay, H.w. Hsia, I. Iashvili, A. Kalogeropoulos, A. Kharchilava, A. Mandal, M. Morris, D. Nguyen, O. Poncet, S. Rappoccio, H. Rejeb Sfar, W. Terrill, A. Williams, D. Yu
Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, USA
J. Alexander, X. Chen, J. Dickinson, A. Duquette, J. Fan, X. Fan, J. Grassi, P. Kotamnives, K. Krzyzanska, J. Monroy, G. Niendorf, M. Oshiro, J.R. Patterson, A. Ryd, J. Thom, H.A. Weber, B. Weiss, P. Wittich, Y. Wu, R. Zou, L. Zygala
University of Rochester, Rochester, New York, USA
O. Bessidskaia Bylund, A. Bodek, P. de Barbaro, R. Demina, A. Garcia-Bellido, H.S. Hare, O. Hindrichs, N. Parmar, P. Parygin⁸⁶, H. Seo, R. Taus, Y.h. Yu
The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA
M. Carrigan, R. De Los Santos, L.S. Durkin, C. Hill, M. Joyce, D.A. Wenzl, B.L. Winer, B. Yates
Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
J. Alison, S. An, M. Cremonesi, V. Dutta, E.Y. Ertorer, T. Ferguson, T.A. Gómez Espinosa, A. Harilal, A. Kallil Tharayil, M. Kanemura, A. Khanal, C. Liu, M. Marchegiani, P. Meiring, S. Murthy, P. Palit, K. Park, M. Paulini, A. Roberts, A. Sanchez, Y. Zhou
University of Puerto Rico, Mayaguez, Puerto Rico, USA
S. Malik, R. Sharma
Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island, USA
G. Barone, G. Benelli, D. Cutts, S. Ellis, L. Gouskos, M. Hadley, U. Heintz, K.W. Ho, T. Kwon, L. Lambrecht, G. Landsberg, K.T. Lau, M. LeBlanc, J. Luo, S. Mondal, J. Roloff, T. Russell, S. Sagir⁸⁷, X. Shen, M. Stamenkovic, S. Sunnarborg, J. Tang, N. Venkatasubramanian
University of Tennessee, Knoxville, Tennessee, USA A. Abdelhamid, D. Ally, A.G. Delannoy, S. Fiorendi, J. Harris, T. Holmes, A.R. Kanuganti, N. Karunarathna, J. Lawless, L. Lee, E. Nibigira, B. Skipworth, S. Spanier, A. Vendrasco
Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee, USA
E. Appelt, Y. Chen, S. Greene, A. Gurrola, W. Johns, R. Kunnawalkam Elayavalli, A. Melo, D. Rathjens, F. Romeo, P. Sheldon, S. Tuo, J. Velkovska, J. Viinikainen, J. Zhang
Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas, USA
D. Aebi, M. Ahmad, T. Akhter, K. Androsov, A. Basnet, A. Bolshov, O. Bouhali88, A. Cagnotta, S. Cooperstein, V. D’Amante, R. Eusebi, P. Flanagan, J. Gilmore, Y. Guo, T. Kamon, S. Luo, R. Mueller, G. Pizzati, A. Safonov
Rice University, Houston, Texas, USA
D. Acosta, A. Agrawal, C. Arbour, T. Carnahan, K.M. Ecklund, F.J. Geurts, T. Huang, I. Krommydas, N. Lewis, W. Li, J. Lin, O. Miguel Colin, B.P. Padley, R. Redjimi, J. Rotter, C. Vico Villalba, M. Wulansatiti, E. Yigitbasi, Y. Zhang
Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas, USA
N. Akchurin, J. Damgov, Y. Feng, N. Gogate, W. Jin, S.W. Lee, C. Madrid, A. Mankel, T. Peltola, I. Volobouev
Baylor University, Waco, Texas, USA
S. Abdullin, A. Brinkerhoff, E. Collins, M.R. Darwish, J. Dittmann, K. Hatakeyama, V. Hegde, J. Hiltbrand, B. McMaster, J. Samudio, S. Sawant, C. Sutantawibul, J. Wilson
University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia, USA
B. Cardwell, H. Chung, B. Cox, J. Hakala, G. Hamilton Ilha Machado, R. Hirosky, M. Jose, A. Ledovskoy, C. Mantilla, C. Neu, C. Ramón Álvarez, Z. Wu
University of Wisconsin - Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
A. Aravind, S. Banerjee, K. Black, T. Bose, E. Chavez, R. Cruz, S. Dasu, P. Everaerts, C. Galloni, H. He, M. Herndon, A. Herve, C.K. Koraka, S. Lomte, R. Loveless, A. Mallampalli, J. Marquez, A. Mohammadi, S. Mondal, T. Nelson, G. Parida, D. Pinna, L. Pétré, A. Savin, V. Shang, V. Sharma, R. Simeon, W.H. Smith, D. Teague, M. Thakore, A. Thete, A. Warden
Authors affiliated with an international laboratory covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN
S. Afanasiev, V. Alexakhin, Y. Andreev, T. Aushev, D. Budkouski, R. Chistov, M. Danilov, T. Dimova, A. Ershov, S. Gninenko, I. Gorbunov, A. Kamenev, V. Karjavine, M. Kirsanov, V. Klyukhin, O. Kodolova89, V. Korenkov, I. Korsakov, A. Kozyrev, N. Krasnikov, A. Lanev, A. Malakhov, V. Matveev, A. Nikitenko90,89, V. Palichik, V. Perelygin, O. Radchenko, M. Savina, V. Shalaev, S. Shmatov, S. Shulha, Y. Skovpen, K. Slizhevskiy, V. Smirnov, O. Teryaev, I. Tlisova, A. Toropin, N. Voytishin, A. Zarubin, I. Zhizhin
Authors affiliated with an institute formerly covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN
L. Dudko, V. Kim21, V. Murzin, V. Oreshkin, D. Sosnov
3Also at Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
4Also at FACAMP - Faculdades de Campinas, Sao Paulo, Brazil
5Also at Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, Brazil
6Also at Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Brazil
7Also at The University of the State of Amazonas, Manaus, Brazil
8Also at University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China
9Also at University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China
10Also at School of Physics, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, China
11Now at Henan Normal University, Xinxiang, China
12Also at University of Shanghai for Science and Technology, Shanghai, China
13Also at The University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa, USA
14Also at Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing, China
15Also at Center for High Energy Physics, Peking University, Beijing, China, Beijing, China
16Now at British University in Egypt, Cairo, Egypt
17Now at Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt
18Also at Université de Haute Alsace, Mulhouse, France
19Also at Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA
20Also at Ilia State University, Tbilisi, Georgia
21Also at an institute formerly covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN
22Also at University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany
23Also at RWTH Aachen University, III. Physikalisches Institut A, Aachen, Germany
24Also at Bergische University Wuppertal (BUW), Wuppertal, Germany
25Also at Brandenburg University of Technology, Cottbus, Germany
26Also at Institute for Advanced Simulation - Jülich Supercomputing Centre, Juelich, Germany
27Also at CERN, European Organization for Nuclear Research, Geneva, Switzerland
28Also at HUN-REN ATOMKI - Institute of Nuclear Research, Debrecen, Hungary
29Now at Universitatea Babes-Bolyai - Facultatea de Fizica, Cluj-Napoca, Romania
30Also at MTA-ELTE Lendület CMS Particle and Nuclear Physics Group, Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary
31Also at HUN-REN Wigner Research Centre for Physics, Budapest, Hungary
32Also at Physics Department, Faculty of Science, Assiut University, Assiut, Egypt
33Also at The University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, USA
34Also at Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana, India
35Also at University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad, India
36Also at Indian Institute of Science (IISC), Bangalore, India
37Also at University of Visva-Bharati, Santiniketan, India
38Also at Institute of Physics, Bhubaneswar, India
39Also at Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron, Hamburg, Germany
40Also at Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan, Iran
41Also at Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
42Also at Department of Physics, University of Science and Technology of Mazandaran, Behshahr, Iran
43Also at Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, Arak University, ARAK, Iran
44Also at Helwan University, Cairo, Egypt
45Also at Centro Siciliano di Fisica Nucleare e di Struttura della Materia, Catania, Italy
46Also at James Madison University, Harrisonburg, Virginia, USA
47Also at Università degli Studi Guglielmo Marconi, Roma, Italy
48Also at Scuola Superiore Meridionale, Università di Napoli ’Federico II’, Napoli, Italy
49Also at Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, Batavia, Illinois, USA
References
- [1]E. V. Shuryak, “Theory of hadronic plasma”, Sov. Phys. JETP 47 (1978) 212.
- [2]U. Heinz and R. Snellings, “Collective flow and viscosity in relativistic heavy-ion collisions”, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 63 (2013) 123, doi:10.1146/annurev-nucl-102212-170540, arXiv:1301.2826.DOI
- [3]J. Takahashi et al., “Topology studies of hydrodynamics using two particle correlation analysis”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103 (2009) 242301, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.103.242301, arXiv:0902.4870.DOI
- [4]B. Alver and G. Roland, “Collision geometry fluctuations and triangular flow in heavy-ion collisions”, Phys. Rev. C 81 (2010) 054905, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.81.054905, arXiv:1003.0194. [Erratum: doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.82.039903].DOI
- [5]S. Voloshin and Y. Zhang, “Flow study in relativistic nuclear collisions by Fourier expansion of azimuthal particle distributions”, Z. Phys. C 70 (1996) 665, doi:10.1007/s002880050141, arXiv:hep-ph/9407282.DOI
- [6]W. Busza, K. Rajagopal, and W. van der Schee, “Heavy ion collisions: The big picture, and the big questions”, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 68 (2018) 339, doi:10.1146/annurev-nucl-101917-020852, arXiv:1802.04801.DOI
- [7]F. G. Gardim, F. Grassi, M. Luzum, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, “Mapping the hydrodynamic response to the initial geometry in heavy-ion collisions”, Phys. Rev. C 85 (2012) 024908, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.85.024908, arXiv:1111.6538.DOI
- [8]H. Niemi, G. S. Denicol, H. Holopainen, and P. Huovinen, “Event-by-event distributions of azimuthal asymmetries in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions”, Phys. Rev. C 87 (2013) 054901, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.87.054901, arXiv:1212.1008.DOI
- [9]F. G. Gardim, J. Noronha-Hostler, M. Luzum, and F. Grassi, “Effects of viscosity on the mapping of initial to final state in heavy ion collisions”, Phys. Rev. C 91 (2015) 034902, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.91.034902, arXiv:1411.2574.DOI
- [10]J. Noronha-Hostler, L. Yan, F. G. Gardim, and J.-Y. Ollitrault, “Linear and cubic response to the initial eccentricity in heavy-ion collisions”, Phys. Rev. C 93 (2016) 014909, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.93.014909, arXiv:1511.03896.
- [11]PHENIX Collaboration, “Heavy quark production in p+p and energy loss and flow of heavy quarks in Au+Au collisions at √s_NN = 200 GeV”, Phys. Rev. C 84 (2011) 044905, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.84.044905, arXiv:1005.1627.
- [12]STAR Collaboration, “Elliptic flow of electrons from heavy-flavor hadron decays in Au+Au collisions at √s_NN = 200, 62.4, and 39 GeV”, Phys. Rev. C 95 (2017) 034907, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.95.034907, arXiv:1405.6348.
- [13]STAR Collaboration, “Measurement of D⁰ azimuthal anisotropy at midrapidity in Au+Au collisions at √s_NN = 200 GeV”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118 (2017) 212301, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.212301, arXiv:1701.06060.
- [14]ALICE Collaboration, “Azimuthal anisotropy of D-meson production in Pb-Pb collisions at √s_NN = 2.76 TeV”, Phys. Rev. C 90 (2014) 034904, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.90.034904, arXiv:1405.2001.DOI
- [15]ALICE Collaboration, “D-meson azimuthal anisotropy in midcentral Pb-Pb collisions at √s_NN = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 (2018) 102301, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.102301, arXiv:1707.01005.DOI
- [16]CMS Collaboration, “Probing charm quark dynamics via multiparticle correlations in Pb-Pb collisions at √s_NN = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 (2022) 022001, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.129.022001, arXiv:2112.12236.DOI
- [17]CMS Collaboration, “Measurement of prompt D⁰ meson azimuthal anisotropy in Pb-Pb collisions at √s_NN = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 (2018) 202301, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.202301, arXiv:1708.03497.DOI
- [18]CMS Collaboration, “Measurement of prompt D⁰ and D̄⁰ meson azimuthal anisotropy and search for strong electric fields in PbPb collisions at √sₙₙ = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Lett. B 816 (2021) 136253, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2021.136253, arXiv:2009.12628.DOI
- [19]CMS Collaboration, “Overview of high-density QCD studies with the CMS experiment at the LHC”, Phys. Rept. 1115 (2025) 219, doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2024.11.007, arXiv:2405.10785.DOI
- [20]ALICE Collaboration, “Event-shape engineering for the D-meson elliptic flow in mid-central Pb-Pb collisions at √sₙₙ = 5.02 TeV”, JHEP 02 (2019) 150, doi:10.1007/JHEP02(2019)150, arXiv:1809.09371.DOI
- [21]ALICE Collaboration, “Transverse-momentum and event-shape dependence of D-meson flow harmonics in Pb-Pb collisions at √sₙₙ = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Lett. B 813 (2021) 136054, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2020.136054, arXiv:2005.11131.DOI
- [22]CMS Collaboration, “Influence of strangeness on the anisotropic flow of prompt Dₛ± mesons in PbPb collisions at √sₙₙ = 5.02 TeV”, 2026. arXiv:2602.14221. Submitted to Phys. Lett. B.DOI
- [23]ALICE Collaboration, “Evidence of different Λc-baryon and D-meson elliptic flow in PbPb collisions at √sₙₙ = 5.36 TeV with ALICE at the LHC”, 2026. arXiv:2603.18966. Submitted to Phys. Rev. Lett.arxiv.org/abs/2603.18966
- [24]HEPData record for this analysis, 2026. doi:10.17182/hepdata.168220.
- [25]CMS Collaboration, “Description and performance of track and primary-vertex reconstruction with the CMS tracker”, JINST 9 (2014) P10009, doi:10.1088/1748-0221/9/10/P10009, arXiv:1405.6569.DOI
- [26]CMS Collaboration, “The CMS experiment at the CERN LHC”, JINST 3 (2008) S08004, doi:10.1088/1748-0221/3/08/S08004.
- [27]CMS Collaboration, “Performance of the CMS high-level trigger during LHC Run 2”, JINST 19 (2024) P11021, doi:10.1088/1748-0221/19/11/P11021, arXiv:2410.17038.DOI
- [28]CMS Collaboration, “Performance of the CMS Level-1 trigger in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV”, JINST 15 (2020) P10017, doi:10.1088/1748-0221/15/10/P10017, arXiv:2006.10165.DOI
- [29]CMS Collaboration, “The CMS trigger system”, JINST 12 (2017) P01020, doi:10.1088/1748-0221/12/01/P01020, arXiv:1609.02366.DOI
- [30]CMS Collaboration, “CMS luminosity measurement using nucleus-nucleus collisions at √sₙₙ = 5.02 TeV in 2018”, CMS Physics Analysis Summary CMS-PAS-LUM-18-001, 2022.
- [31]CMS Collaboration, “Charged-particle nuclear modification factors in PbPb and pPb collisions at √sₙₙ = 5.02 TeV”, JHEP 04 (2017) 039, doi:10.1007/JHEP04(2017)039, arXiv:1611.01664.DOI
- [32]T. Sjöstrand et al., “An introduction to PYTHIA 8.2”, Comput. Phys. Commun. 191 (2015) 159, doi:10.1016/j.cpc.2015.01.024, arXiv:1410.3012.DOI
- [33]CMS Collaboration, “Event generator tunes obtained from underlying event and multiparton scattering measurements”, Eur. Phys. J. C 76 (2016) 155, doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-016-3988-x, arXiv:1512.00815.DOI
- [34]D. J. Lange, “The EvtGen particle decay simulation package”, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 462 (2001) 152, doi:10.1016/S0168-9002(01)00089-4.DOI
- [35]GEANT4 Collaboration, “GEANT4—a simulation toolkit”, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 506 (2003) 250, doi:10.1016/S0168-9002(03)01368-8.
- [36]Particle Data Group, S. Navas et al., “Review of particle physics”, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 030001, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.110.030001.
- [37]A. Hoecker et al., “TMVA, the Toolkit for Multivariate Data Analysis with ROOT”, PoS ACAT (2009) 040, doi:10.22323/1.050.0040, arXiv:physics/0703039v5.DOI
- [38]M. J. Oreglia, “A study of the reactions ψ′ → γγψ″”. PhD thesis, Stanford University, 1980. SLAC Report SLAC-R-236.DOI
- [39]STAR Collaboration, “Elliptic flow from two- and four-particle correlations in Au+Au collisions at √s_NN = 130 GeV”, Phys. Rev. C 66 (2002) 034904, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.66.034904, arXiv:nucl-ex/0206001.DOI
- [40]M. Luzum and J.-Y. Ollitrault, “Eliminating experimental bias in anisotropic-flow measurements of high-energy nuclear collisions”, Phys. Rev. C 87 (2013) 044907, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.87.044907, arXiv:1209.2323.DOI
- [41]A. M. Poskanzer and S. A. Voloshin, “Methods for analyzing anisotropic flow in relativistic nuclear collisions”, Phys. Rev. C 58 (1998) 1671, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.58.1671, arXiv:nucl-ex/9805001.DOI
- [42]NA49 Collaboration, “Directed and elliptic flow of charged pions and protons in Pb+Pb collisions at 40A and 158A GeV”, Phys. Rev. C 68 (2003) 034903, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.68.034903, arXiv:nucl-ex/0303001.DOI
- [43]CMS Collaboration, “Measurements of azimuthal anisotropy of nonprompt D⁰ mesons in PbPb collisions at √s_NN = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Lett. B 850 (2024) 138389, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2023.138389, arXiv:2212.01636.DOI
- [44]J. Noronha-Hostler et al., “Cumulants and nonlinear response of high p_T harmonic flow at √s_NN = 5.02 TeV”, Phys. Rev. C 95 (2017) 044901, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.95.044901, arXiv:1609.05171.
- [45]C. A. G. Prado et al., “Event-by-event correlations between soft hadrons and D⁰ mesons in 5.02 TeV PbPb collisions at the CERN Large Hadron Collider”, Phys. Rev. C 96 (2017) 064903, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.96.064903, arXiv:1611.02965.DOI
- [46]T. Song et al., “Tomography of the quark-gluon plasma by charm quarks”, Phys. Rev. C 92 (2015) 014910, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.92.014910, arXiv:1503.03039.DOI
- [47]T. Song et al., “Charm production in Pb+Pb collisions at energies available at the CERN Large Hadron Collider”, Phys. Rev. C 93 (2016) 034906, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.93.034906, arXiv:1512.00891.DOI
- [48]K. J. Eskola, H. Paukkunen, and C. A. Salgado, “EPS09 - A new generation of NLO and LO nuclear parton distribution functions”, JHEP 04 (2009) 065, doi:10.1088/1126-6708/2009/04/065, arXiv:0902.4154.DOI






