betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Persistence of large scale coherent structures in a turbulent pipe flow through an improved lattice Boltzmann approach

Abstract

We simulated a turbulent pipe flow within the Lattice Boltzmann Method using a multiple-relaxation-time collision operator with Maxwell-Boltzmann equilibrium distribution expanded, for the sake of a more accurate description, up to the sixth order in Hermite polynomials. The moderately turbulent flow (Reτ≈181.3Re_τ \approx 181.3) is able to reproduce up to the fourth statistical moment with great accuracy, compared with other numerical schemes and with experimental data. A coherent structure identification was performed based on the most energetic streamwise turbulent mode, which revealed a surprising memory effect related to the large scale forcing scheme used to trigger the turbulent state in the pipe. We observe that the existence of large scale motions which are out of the pipe's stationary regime do not affect the detailed single-point statistical features of the flow. Furthermore, the transitions between the coherent structures of different topological modes were analyzed as a stochastic process. We find that for finely resolved data the transitions are effectively Markovian, but for larger decimation time lags, due to topological mode degeneracy, non-Markovian behavior emerges, in agreement with previous experimental studies.

INTRODUCTION

The dynamics of turbulent flows is one of the most intriguing phenomena in classical physics. Concerning a broad set of applications turbulence is described by the Navier-Stokes (NS) equations of motion, for which, the existence of a unique and smooth solution is one of the millennium prize problems in mathematics [1]. Till nowadays, to a great extent, the literature predictions of turbulent flows are associated with statistical features, such as the investigation of the turbulent kinetic energy, and statistical moments of velocity fluctuations, not to mention many others [2, 3].

Coherent structures (CS) in turbulent flows seems to be part of the foundations of the physical background behind the output of statistical features. In wall-bounded turbulence, the CS can be related to quasi-streamwise vortices, hairpin vortices, large scales of motion (LSM), and very large scales of motion (VLSM) [4, 5, 6]. Their existence was already identified experimentally with particle image velocimetry (PIV) [4, 5, 7, 8] and numerically by direct numerical simulations (DNS) with several structure detection mechanisms, such as the proper orthogonal decomposition (POD), dimensionality reduction, a local criterion depending on the vorticity field, and from the dynamical systems point of view [9, 10, 11, 12].

In turbulent pipe flows, these CS could be assigned to a discrete azimuthal wave number, which is related to the most energetic streamwise mode [5, 10]. From this perspective, a turbulent state –instantaneous snapshot– could be thought as a superposition of different azimuthaly symmetric contributions from the turbulent streamwise kinetic energy. The aforementioned CS detection by dimensionality reduction opens the path to the study of the CS dynamics as a stochastic process [13], which could bring important information about the mean lifetime of turbulent structures and the explicit dependence of individual mode contributions to desired observables.

In order to numerically simulate the NS equations, one can make use of several numerical schemes, such as finite differences, finite element, finite volume, and pseudospectral, among others. A competitive approach is the lattice Boltzmann method (LBM), due to its locality, it turns out to be a scalable and highly parallel alternative to simulate the NS equations [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20]. Based on a discretized version of the Boltzmann equation, the LBM is a mesoscopic approach that was successfully applied to a variety of physical systems, such as magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) flows [21, 22, 23], thermal convection-diffusion [24, 25], multiphase flow [26], and more.

The potential scalability of the LBM and its current development –with advanced collision operators and an accurate expansion of the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution, to be discussed later– increases the numerical stability of LBM simulations. The method has been applied to simulate wall-bounded turbulent flows (channels and pipe) and has shown to be an excellent alternative and easy-to-implement algorithm that gives with reasonable accuracy the same outputs from the aforementioned schemes, such as statistical moments of velocity fluctuations, vorticity, and Reynolds stress, among others [27, 28, 29].

Methods

The Lattice-Boltzmann Method

The LBM can be described straightforwardly as the mesoscopic time evolution of discretized particle distributions fif_i by a two-step algorithm, which, in lattice units and in the presence of an external force, is given by

fi∗(x,t)=fi(x,t)+L[fi(x,t)]+(I−Λ2)Fi,(1)f_i^{\ast}(\mathbf{x},t)=f_i(\mathbf{x},t)+L[f_i(\mathbf{x},t)]+\left(\mathbf{I}-\frac{\mathbf{\Lambda}}{2}\right)\mathcal{F}_i, \tag*{(1)}
fi(x+ci,t+1)=fi∗(x,t),(2)f_i(\mathbf{x}+\mathbf{c}_i,t+1)=f_i^{\ast}(\mathbf{x},t), \tag*{(2)}

where ci\mathbf{c}_i is the discretized lattice velocity, LL is the collision operator, Λ\mathbf{\Lambda} is the collision matrix, and Fi\mathcal{F}_i takes into account the external forcing. Equations (1) and (2) are known as the collision and stream steps, respectively.

Macroscopic quantities as the fluid density ρ\rho and the velocity field u\mathbf{u} are obtained as the zero and first order moments of distribution fif_i, which are given by

ρ=∑ifi,(3)\rho=\sum_i f_i, \tag*{(3)}
u=1ρ∑icifi+F2ρ,(4)\mathbf{u}=\frac{1}{\rho}\sum_i \mathbf{c}_i f_i+\frac{\mathbf{F}}{2\rho}, \tag*{(4)}

where F\mathbf{F} is an arbitrary external body force.

The BGK approximation [30], also known as the single-relaxation-time (SRT) model, relax all the discretized distributions to a local equilibrium –given by Maxwell Boltzmann distribution– by the same relaxation time τ\tau, it reads as

L[fi(x,t)]≡−1τ(fi−fieq).(5)L[f_i(\mathbf{x},t)]\equiv-\frac{1}{\tau}\left(f_i-f_i^{\mathrm{eq}}\right). \tag*{(5)}

Although the SRT collision model seems straightforward, it lacks stability for small values of relaxation time, which is associated with higher values of the Reynolds number. This issue can be solved by the adoption of a more refined collision model, as the multiple-relaxation-time (MRT), which changes the space of the distributions fif_i to the space of moments mim_i and relax, with a relaxation time related to the viscosity, only the moments which are associated with the Reynolds stress [31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37]. A detailed explanation of the MRT model is given in Appendix A.

The no-slip boundary condition (u∣wall=0\mathbf{u}|_{wall}=0) was implemented by the second-order accurate Boudizi scheme [45], which is a linear interpolated version of the bounce-back scheme [46, 47] and is given by

fi(xf,t+1)=12Δf~i(xf,t)+2Δ−12Δf~i(xf,t)for Δ≥12,(6)f_i(\mathbf{x}_f,t+1)=\frac{1}{2\Delta}\tilde{f}_i(\mathbf{x}_f,t)+\frac{2\Delta-1}{2\Delta}\tilde{f}_i(\mathbf{x}_f,t) \quad\text{for } \Delta\ge\frac{1}{2}, \tag*{(6)}
fi(xf,t+1)=2Δf~i(xf,t)+(1−2Δ)f~i(xff,t)for Δ<12,(7)f_i(\mathbf{x}_f,t+1)=2\Delta\tilde{f}_i(\mathbf{x}_f,t)+(1-2\Delta)\tilde{f}_i(\mathbf{x}_{ff},t) \quad\text{for } \Delta< \frac{1}{2}, \tag*{(7)}

where Δ\Delta is the fractional distance of the wall from the near-wall lattice point, xf\mathbf{x}_f represent the fluid node, xff≡xf−ci\mathbf{x}_{ff}\equiv\mathbf{x}_f-\mathbf{c}_i, iˉ\bar{i} denotes the direction opposite to ci\mathbf{c}_i, and f~i\tilde{f}_i represents the post-collision distribution.

Turbulent pipe flow simulation setup

The computational grid chosen was nx×ny×nz=300×300×600n_x\times n_y\times n_z=300\times300\times600 with the flow driven in the zz direction. The pipe radius in lattice units is R=149.5R=149.5, which results in a streamwise length L≈4.01RL\approx4.01R. The flow is driven by a constant body force per unit volume ρh\rho h, which, at a fully developed stage should balance the viscous force [29], resulting in a friction velocity u∗u^* of

u∗=hR2.(8)u^*=\sqrt{\frac{hR}{2}}. \tag*{(8)}

The viscosity and friction velocity in lattice units are, respectively, ν=0.0032\nu=0.0032 and u∗=0.00388u^*=0.00388, and the friction Reynolds number Reτ=u∗R/ν≈181.3Re_\tau=u^*R/\nu\approx181.3. The viscous length scale is y∗=ν/u∗y^*=\nu/u^*, which gives the grid spacing in wall units of δx+=δy+=1.212\delta_x^+=\delta_y^+=1.212. All observables with the superscript ++ from now on, are normalized by the viscous length scale y∗y^* or friction velocity u∗u^*.

The no-slip boundary condition is then applied through Eqs. (6) and (7) and a periodic boundary condition is applied in the streamwise direction. The large eddy turnover time in lattice units is TLET=R/u∗=38531T^{LET}=R/u^{*}=38531 and the Reynolds number based on the bulk velocity and on the pipe’s diameter is Re≈5329.3Re\approx5329.3.

Previous works have already shown that for Reτ=180Re_{\tau}=180 the smallest length scale in turbulent pipe flow is η+=1.5\eta^{+}=1.5 [29], which is higher than the aforementioned grid spacing in the pipe’s cross-section. The pipe length used L≈4.01RL\approx4.01R, is compared with different datasets also with periodic boundary conditions and with L≈(10R,12.11R)L\approx(10R,12.11R) [29, 48]. Although it does not meet the suggested length to avoid the effects of periodic boundary conditions on turbulent statistics [49], the current pipe length was inspired in recent experimental findings which suggests that structures in turbulent pipe flow are correlated up to L≈4RL\approx4R for Re=24400Re=24400 [13].

The flow was initialized with the mean profile

U(δ+)={δ+,if δ+≤10.8,10.4ln⁡(δ+)+5.0,if δ+>10.8,(9)U(\delta^{+})= \begin{cases} \delta^{+}, & \text{if }\delta^{+}\le10.8,\\ \frac{1}{0.4}\ln(\delta^{+})+5.0, & \text{if }\delta^{+}>10.8, \end{cases} \tag*{(9)}

where δ=R−r\delta=R-r is the pipe’s wall distance. To trigger turbulence, in addition to the constant body force, it was added a non-uniform and divergence-free force during the first three TLETT^{LET} [29], which is given by

Fr=−hκA0RrkzlLsin⁡(2πtT){1−cos⁡[2π(R−r−l0)l]}cos⁡(kz2πzL)cos⁡(kθθ),Fθ=h(1−κ)A0kzkθ2πRLsin⁡(2πtT)sin⁡[2π(R−r−l0)l]cos⁡(kz2πzL)sin⁡(kθθ),Fz=−hA0Rrsin⁡(2πtT)sin⁡[2π(R−r−l0)l]sin⁡(kz2πzL)cos⁡(kθθ),(10)\begin{aligned} F_r&=-h\kappa A_0\frac{R}{r}\frac{k_zl}{L}\sin\left(\frac{2\pi t}{T}\right)\left\{1-\cos\left[\frac{2\pi(R-r-l_0)}{l}\right]\right\}\cos\left(k_z\frac{2\pi z}{L}\right)\cos(k_\theta\theta),\\ F_\theta&=h(1-\kappa)A_0\frac{k_z}{k_\theta}\frac{2\pi R}{L}\sin\left(\frac{2\pi t}{T}\right)\sin\left[\frac{2\pi(R-r-l_0)}{l}\right]\cos\left(k_z\frac{2\pi z}{L}\right)\sin(k_\theta\theta),\\ F_z&=-hA_0\frac{R}{r}\sin\left(\frac{2\pi t}{T}\right)\sin\left[\frac{2\pi(R-r-l_0)}{l}\right]\sin\left(k_z\frac{2\pi z}{L}\right)\cos(k_\theta\theta), \tag*{(10)} \end{aligned}

where kz=3k_z=3 and kθ=2k_\theta=2 are the streamwise and azimuthal wavenumbers of the perturbation force, T≈0.052TLETT\approx0.052T^{LET} and A0=50A_0=50 are the forcing period and amplitude, respectively, and κ=0.5\kappa=0.5 is the weighting parameter that distributes the force in radial and azimuthal directions. The force to trigger turbulence was applied only in the region R−l0−l≤r≤R−l0R-l_0-l\le r\le R-l_0 with l0=0.2Rl_0=0.2R and l=0.4Rl=0.4R. The numerical simulation was performed for 30TLET30T^{LET} with statistics being done with the last 10TLET10T^{LET}, taking the instantaneous vector fields at every 100 iteration.

Dimensionality reduction for coherent structure identification

The identification of CS used in this paper follows the dimensionality reduction approach which was used for moderate and highly turbulent flow (5300≤Re≤350005300 \le Re \le35000) [5, 8]. The procedure is based on the streamwise velocity-velocity correlation function RuuR_{uu}, which uses the fluctuating part of the streamwise component δuz\delta u_z, which will be represented by uzu_z for simplicity. In this case, the correlation function is represented by

Ruu(r0+Δr,Δθ)=⟨uz(r0,θ0)uz(r0+Δr,θ0+Δθ)⟩θ0uz,rms2(11)R_{uu}(r_0+\Delta r,\Delta\theta)=\frac{\left\langle u_z(r_0,\theta_0)u_z(r_0+\Delta r,\theta_0+\Delta\theta)\right\rangle_{\theta_0}}{u_{z,rms}^{2}} \tag*{(11)}

where uz,rms2=⟨uz(r0,θ0)2⟩θ0u_{z,rms}^{2}=\left\langle u_z(r_0,\theta_0)^2\right\rangle_{\theta_0}. After the computation of Eq. (11), the azimuthally dominant mode is selected as the highest peak in the power of the fast Fourier transform (FFT) of the correlation function from a reference radius r0=0.78Rr_0=0.78R.

Simulation Results

Instantaneous Observations

Instantaneous observations of the turbulent flow are shown in Figure 1. As can be seen, the presence of several vortices is displayed randomly distributed through the vector field and also by the streamwise vorticity. It is worth mentioning how the vortices usually appear in regions close to a change of sign in the streamwise velocity fluctuation, in consonance with the well-known picture of ejections and sweeps related to the Q2Q_2 and Q4Q_4 quadrant analysis [50].

Snapshot observations from turbulent pipe flow simulated through the LBM with $Re_\tau \approx 181.3$

Figure 1. Snapshot observations from turbulent pipe flow simulated through the LBM with Reτ≈181.3Re_\tau\approx181.3. Left:In-plane vector field and density plot of streamwise velocity fluctuation in lattice units. Right: Streamwise vorticity in lattice units.

The instantaneous streamwise velocity component uzu_z is shown in Figure 2, where several near-wall structures can be seen, such as the shape of Kelvin-Helmholtz and Rayleigh-Taylor like instabilities. Also, the thickness of the structures seems to agree relatively well with other simulation techniques at Reτ=180Re_\tau=180 [51], such as the pseudospectral based solver Openpipeflow [52].

Snapshot of streamwise velocity component $u_z$ in lattice units

Figure 2. Snapshot of streamwise velocity component uzu_z in lattice units.

The high/low-speed streaks can be seen by the red/blue isosurfaces of the streamwise velocity fluctuation δuz\delta u_z in Figure 3. Different structures could be targeted by different thresholds on the isosurface selection, decreasing in quantity as the value is increased as it would be related to more extreme events.

Isosurfaces of streamwise velocity fluctuations

Figure 3. Isosurfaces of streamwise velocity fluctuations. Red/blue isosurfaces are related to high/Low speed streaks, where the velocity fluctuation is 10% above/bellow the mean velocity profile.

Turbulent Statistics

In order to validate the numerical simulations, the turbulent statistics will be compared with a pseudo-spectral approach [48], a LBM approach based on a second order expansion of Maxwell Boltzmann equilibrium distribution –which will be referred to as LBM-O\mathcal{O}(2)– [29], and with experimental results using Laser Doppler Anemometry (LDA) [53], which is known for its accuracy for near-wall measurements.

MethodReτRe_{\tau}L/RL/RΔT/TLET\Delta T/T^{LET}
Peng et al.LBM-O\mathcal{O}(2)180.012.1260.1
Loulou et al.PS190.010.005.8
TahituLDA181.2437.81265.0
PresentLBM-O\mathcal{O}(6)181.34.0110.0

Table 1. Relevant parameters for turbulent pipe flow’ statistical properties.

The relevant parameters for all sets to be used are shown in table I, where ΔT\Delta T is the time window used for the statistical averages and LBM-O\mathcal{O}(6) is referred to the scheme used in this work with the equilibrium distribution expanded up to the sixth order in Hermite polynomials. The rms of the streamwise velocity fluctuation and high order statistical moments are computed through

urms(x)≡⟨δu(x,t)2⟩t,Sn(x)≡⟨δu(x,t)n⟩turms(x)n.(12)\mathbf{u}_{rms}(\mathbf{x}) \equiv\sqrt{\langle\delta\mathbf{u}(\mathbf{x},t)^2\rangle_t}, \quad S_n(\mathbf{x}) \equiv\frac{\langle\delta\mathbf{u}(\mathbf{x},t)^n\rangle_t}{\mathbf{u}_{rms}(\mathbf{x})^n}. \tag*{(12)}

The mean streamwise velocity profile normalized by the bulk velocity and the rms streamwise velocity fluctuation in wall units are shown in Figure 4. To stress the accuracy of the statistical properties of the present numerical study, skewness and flatness are shown in Figure 5, as higher statistical moments require a well converged and large enough statistical ensemble.

Mean streamwise velocity profile and root-mean-square streamwise velocity fluctuation

Figure 4. Left: Mean streamwise velocity profile normalized by the bulk velocity. Right: Root-mean-square streamwise velocity fluctuation in wall units.

High order statistical moments of the streamwise velocity component: skewness and flatness

Figure 5. High order statistical moments of the streamwise velocity component. Left: Skewness. Right: Flatness.

As one can see, all observables agree really well with the literature. Although our pipe length is approximately 2.5×2.5 \times smaller than the PS results, the time window used was almost twice the size in large eddy turnover times. The comparisons with LDA which used a very large time window for the statistical analysis, as one can see in table I, is also in very good agreement, with the peak positions and plateau of all observables being well represented by the numerical simulation.

CS Identification and Dynamics of Mode Transition

The dimensionality reduction based on the dominant azimuthal wave number of Eq. (11) was applied on the simulated turbulent data. The turbulent data set of 10TLET10T^{LET} was analyzed at every 20 time steps.

Figure 6 shows the contour plot of the velocity-velocity correlation function conditioned to the azimuthal wave number kθ=2k_{\theta}=2. Remarkably, there were found approximately 10 different azimuthal wave numbers in the produced numerical data. Modes higher than mode 10 were also found, but their statistical weight is negligible, as pointed out in the experimental findings [8, 13, 54]. The comparison between the current probability distribution of dominant azimuthal wave numbers with the experimental one is shown in Figure 7.

Velocity-velocity correlation contours conditioned to azimuthal wave number $k_\theta = 2$

Figure 6. Velocity-velocity correlation contours conditioned to azimuthal wave number kθ=2k_\theta= 2. Red contours are related to Ruu=0.05R_{uu} = 0.05 and 0.10.1, while blue has the same absolute value with opposite sign.

Probability distribution of dominant azimuthal wave numbers

Figure 7. Probability distribution of dominant azimuthal wave numbers.

The peak in the azimuthal mode kθ=2k_{\theta}=2 seems to be related to the principle of permanence of large eddies [2] and to a non-trivial memory effect regarding the force that was used to trigger turbulence (10), as the force was only active in the first 3TLET3T^{LET} and the dimensionality reduction was only applied in the range 20TLET≤t≤30TLET20T^{LET} \le t \le30T^{LET}. At the same time, the mode distributions, besides the peaked forced mode, resemble the cascade effects in three-dimensional turbulence, as expected, with the energy going from large to small scales.

The time dependence of the identified modes during the 10 analyzed turnover times is shown in Figure 8. As one can see, the dynamics between the modes seems to be approximately random for a big time interval, however, the intriguing phenomenon is the persistence of mode kθ=2k_\theta= 2 (the forced mode) intermittently. To illustrate how the modes are finely resolved in time, a zoom-in of 10×10\times is also displayed.

Time dependence of the identified dominant modes

Figure 8. Time dependence of the identified dominant modes.

A stochastics series based on the identified modes to investigate its transitions was also set, as in Ref [13]. In this case, it is given by

SLBM≡{k∗(t0),k∗(t0+Δ),…,k∗(30TLET)},(13)S^{LBM} \equiv\left\{ k^*(t_0), k^*(t_0 + \Delta), \ldots, k^*(30T^{LET}) \right\}, \tag*{(13)}

where t0=20TLETt_0 = 20T^{LET} and Δ=20δt\Delta= 20\delta t. The transition matrix among the identified modes is given by

T=(0.9750.0000.0010.0000.0020.0010.0010.0030.0000.0110.0040.9920.0060.0040.0060.0080.0080.0090.0040.0110.0030.0010.9770.0020.0010.0030.0020.0010.0000.0050.0000.0020.0070.9800.0020.0030.0020.0020.0060.0050.0030.0010.0040.0020.9780.0030.0050.0050.0040.0030.0010.0010.0010.0030.0050.9730.0030.0060.0040.0030.0040.0010.0040.0020.0050.0020.9690.0030.0040.0050.0060.0010.0000.0020.0020.0020.0050.9690.0040.0030.0000.0000.0000.0020.0010.0030.0040.0030.9700.0000.0030.0000.0010.0010.0010.0020.0020.0000.0010.953),(14)T = \begin{pmatrix} 0.975 & 0.000 & 0.001 & 0.000 & 0.002 & 0.001 & 0.001 & 0.003 & 0.000 & 0.011 \\ 0.004 & 0.992 & 0.006 & 0.004 & 0.006 & 0.008 & 0.008 & 0.009 & 0.004 & 0.011 \\ 0.003 & 0.001 & 0.977 & 0.002 & 0.001 & 0.003 & 0.002 & 0.001 & 0.000 & 0.005 \\ 0.000 & 0.002 & 0.007 & 0.980 & 0.002 & 0.003 & 0.002 & 0.002 & 0.006 & 0.005 \\ 0.003 & 0.001 & 0.004 & 0.002 & 0.978 & 0.003 & 0.005 & 0.005 & 0.004 & 0.003 \\ 0.001 & 0.001 & 0.001 & 0.003 & 0.005 & 0.973 & 0.003 & 0.006 & 0.004 & 0.003 \\ 0.004 & 0.001 & 0.004 & 0.002 & 0.005 & 0.002 & 0.969 & 0.003 & 0.004 & 0.005 \\ 0.006 & 0.001 & 0.000 & 0.002 & 0.002 & 0.002 & 0.005 & 0.969 & 0.004 & 0.003 \\ 0.000 & 0.000 & 0.000 & 0.002 & 0.001 & 0.003 & 0.004 & 0.003 & 0.970 & 0.000 \\ 0.003 & 0.000 & 0.001 & 0.001 & 0.001 & 0.002 & 0.002 & 0.000 & 0.001 & 0.953 \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(14)}

which, as one can see, is diagonally dominant, with kθ=2k_\theta= 2 being the mode with a higher probability of persistence. The Chapman-Kolmogorov (CK) equation was also tested by performing a decimation of several orders on the stochastic series (13). The results of the CK test are shown in Figure 9. In contrast with the experimental case reported in Ref [13], a qualitatively good agreement was found between the comparison of the absolute values of the eigenvalues from the original series with their respective counterparts from the decimated series.

Comparison between eigenvalues of the original transition probability matrix and eigenvalues for the transition matrices of the decimated series

Figure 9. Comparison between eigenvalues of the original transition probability matrix (Order = 1) with eigenvalues for the transition matrices of the decimated series (Order up to 5).

This was observed up to a fifth-order decimation, which reduces the amount of analyzed turbulent fields by a factor of 1/100, resulting in approximately 3850 snapshots, which might not be large enough, so the effects of low statistics may play a role. Also, the deviation from the CK prediction could be related to a transition to the scenario observed in the experiment reported in Ref [13], where the dynamics among the transitions display a non-Markovian behavior. It is worth mentioning that the temporal resolution obtained by the LBM is of the order of 10210^{2} finer than the experimental case obtained with a laser of 15 Hz. In this case, the agreement with the CK prediction could be associated with the fact that the transition matrix is diagonally dominant, so the modes, in general, don’t have a considerably high memory about the transition from different modes.

To investigate quantitatively the observed agreement between the CK prediction with the decimated stochastic time series, it was analyzes the self mode correlation function [13]

F~(t−t′)≡⟨Vm(t)⋅Vm(t′)⟩−⟨Vm⟩2,F(t−t′)≡F~(t−t′)F~(0)(15)\widetilde{F}(t-t') \equiv\langle V_m(t)\cdot V_m(t')\rangle-\langle V_m\rangle^2,\quad F(t-t')\equiv\frac{\widetilde{F}(t-t')}{\widetilde{F}(0)} \tag*{(15)}

were Vm(t)=δm,k∗(t)V_m(t)=\delta_{m,k^*(t)} and 1≤m≤101\le m\le10. Firstly the correlation function was investigated individually, for each mode, and afterwards mode averaged, which will be represented by ⟨F⟩(t−t′)\langle F\rangle(t-t'). Figure 10 shows that, in fact, the correlation function for all modes decays approximately exponentially, which is observed as a straight line in the semi-log plot. Also, as one can see, mode kθ=2k_\theta=2 is the most self correlated one, which agrees with the observed probability distribution. The average self correlation is displayed in Figure 11 together with a straight line representing an exponential decay with Ω=1/35\Omega=1/35, as it can be seen, the agreement is really evident and it holds till ∣t−t′∣≈60|t-t'|\approx60. Larger time separations are shown in the inset, in a log-log plot, which was observed to decay algebraically ∝∣t−t′∣−α\propto|t-t'|^{-\alpha}, as indicated by the black straight line, with α=1.2\alpha=1.2. This fact agrees with previous experimental findings of non-Markovian behavior in turbulent pipe flow with α≈1.0\alpha\approx1.0 for Re=24400Re=24400, recorded with a smaller frequency [13].

Semi-log plot of self mode correlation for all the identified modes

Figure 10. Semi-log plot of self mode correlation for all the identified modes.

Semi-log plot of average self correlation and straight line of exponential decay

Figure 11. Semi-log plot of average self correlation and straight line of exponential decay for comparison. Inset shows the behavior of region ∣t−t′∣≥60|t-t'| \ge60 in a log-log plot with a straight line of algebraic decay with exponent −1.2-1.2 for comparison.

The largest and mean streamwise lengths for all modes are presented in table II by means of Taylor frozen hypothesis [55]. As one can see, on average, all modes are within

kθk_{\theta}12345678910
ΔSmax⁡/R\Delta S_{\max}/R0.988.201.331.731.501.011.010.700.500.49
⟨ΔS⟩/R\langle\Delta S\rangle/R0.270.870.320.360.330.270.210.230.220.15

Table 2. The largest and average sizes of the coherent structure mode lengths from the Taylor frozen hypothesis.

the simulated pipe’s length. Although, their longest example might by related to the known LSM and VLSM –which are typically longer than three pipe radii [4, 5, 6].

CONCLUSIONS

The turbulent pipe flow simulation was performed by the LBM and validated extensively against experimental and different numerical methodologies. The turbulent data is resolved in space up to the viscous length scale and the instantaneous observations reveal the seemingly random distribution of CSs. Our pipe length followed the suggestion of the size of correlated structures in experimental turbulent pipe flow, as determined in Ref. [13], and the statistical moments of streamwise velocity fluctuation matched well previous results in the literature. The CS detection was performed in the same fashion as in previous experimental cases [5, 8, 13, 54], which revealed a non-trivial correlation with the force used to trigger the turbulent state. Also, the mode distribution agrees with the experimental findings regarding the turbulence cascade of energy from large to small scales.

The stochastic mode transitions for the finely time-resolved data resulted in a diagonally dominant transition matrix, which culminated in a good agreement of the CK prediction for the decimated time series. The indicated Markovian behavior was then checked by time self-mode correlation functions, which confirmed the exponential decay for all observed modes in a short time window. The average self-mode correlation was plotted for a larger time separation, which revealed a transition from the exponential decay to an algebraically one, recovering the observed experimental behavior of non-Markovianity. The streamwise length of the modes by Taylor’s frozen hypothesis showed that, on average, they are all within the length of our pipe simulations, but their largest instances might be related to the known LSM.

This work opens the path for many directions of further research. From the experimental point of view, it would be interesting to investigate the CS detection and stochastic mode transitions for higher frequencies with larger data sets, since this would allow the observation of the Markovian effect for small-time separations, transitioning to a non-Markovian behavior (as already observed), and finally transitioning back to a Markovian behavior for larger time separations when the memory effects of the structure decay exponentially. From the numerical point of view, it would be interesting to investigate larger time series, so that the decimation could go up to a higher order. A 20x higher should be enough to see the same effects of the experimental case with the reported acquisition frequency [13]. New numerical simulations forcing all modes evenly or with the statistical distribution of the previous literature reports [5, 8, 9, 10, 13, 54] could give a closer result to the real experiment. Finally, modeling the transition between the identified modes is also valuable information that could describe the effects of the turbulent structures more physically.

Acknowledgments

The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support from the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq), Brazil and Shell Brazil through the project “Predictive modelling of inorganic scaling in pipes and equipment subjected to multiphase flows in Pre-Salt conditions” at the Interdisciplinary Center of Fluid Dynamics (NIDF) and the strategic importance of the support given by ANP through the R&D levy regulation.

Data Availability

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

GENERAL MRT MODEL WITH EQUILIBRIUM DISTRIBUTION EXPANDED UP TO THE SIXTH ORDER IN HERMITE POLYNOMIALS

As this work is aimed to perform three-dimensional pipe flow simulations, we restrict to the case of a D3Q27 lattice model, which is represented by the lattice velocities ci=(∣cix⟩,∣ciy⟩,∣ciz⟩)\mathbf{c}_i = (\left|c_{ix}\right\rangle,\left|c_{iy}\right\rangle,\left|c_{iz}\right\rangle) as

∣cix⟩=(0,1,−1,0,0,0,1,−1,1,−1,1,−1,1,−1,0,0,0,0,1,−1,1,−1,1,−1,1,−1)T,∣ciy⟩=(0,0,0,1,−1,0,0,1,1,−1,−1,0,0,0,0,1,−1,1,−1,1,1,−1,−1,1,1,−1,−1)T,∣ciz⟩=(0,0,0,0,0,1,−1,0,0,0,0,1,1,−1,−1,1,1,−1,−1,1,1,1,1,−1,−1,−1,−1)T.(16)\begin{aligned} \left|c_{ix}\right\rangle&= (0,1,-1,0,0,0,1,-1,1,-1,1,-1,1,-1,0,0,0,0,1,-1,1,-1,1,-1,1,-1)^{T},\\ \left|c_{iy}\right\rangle&= (0,0,0,1,-1,0,0,1,1,-1,-1,0,0,0,0,1,-1,1,-1,1,1,-1,-1,1,1,-1,-1)^{T},\\ \left|c_{iz}\right\rangle&= (0,0,0,0,0,1,-1,0,0,0,0,1,1,-1,-1,1,1,-1,-1,1,1,1,1,-1,-1,-1,-1)^{T}. \tag*{(16)} \end{aligned}

The computational grid is illustrated in Figure 12. The main idea from the MRT collision model is to transform the usual space of populations,

Illustration of computational grid

Figure 12. Illustration of computational grid. Each cell is composed by the 27 lattice vectors.

∣fi⟩=(f0,…,fi,…,f26)T,(17)\left|f_i\right\rangle= (f_0,\ldots,f_i,\ldots,f_{26})^{T}, \tag*{(17)}

to the space of velocity moments,

∣mi⟩≡(m0,…,mi,…,m26)T=MT∣fi⟩,(18)\left|m_i\right\rangle\equiv(m_0,\ldots,m_i,\ldots,m_{26})^{T} = M^{T}\left|f_i\right\rangle, \tag*{(18)}

where MM is the transformation matrix, which is given by [38],

∣M0⟩=∣1,…,1⟩,∣M1⟩=∣cix⟩,∣M2⟩=∣ciy⟩,∣M3⟩=∣ciz⟩,∣M4⟩=∣cixciy⟩,∣M5⟩=∣cixciz⟩,∣M6⟩=∣ciyciz⟩,∣M7⟩=∣cix2−ciy2⟩,∣M8⟩=∣cix2−ciz2⟩,∣M9⟩=∣cix2+ciy2+ciz2⟩,∣M10⟩=∣cix2ciy2+cix2ciz2⟩,∣M11⟩=∣cix2ciy2+ciy2ciz2⟩,∣M12⟩=∣cix2ciz2+ciy2ciz2⟩,∣M13⟩=∣cixciy2−cixciz2⟩,∣M14⟩=∣cix2ciy−ciyciz2⟩,∣M15⟩=∣cix2ciz−ciy2ciz⟩,∣M16⟩=∣cixciyciz⟩,∣M17⟩=∣cix2ciy2+cix2ciz2+ciy2ciz2⟩,∣M18⟩=∣cix2ciy2+cix2ciz2−ciy2ciz2⟩,∣M19⟩=∣cix2ciy2−cix2ciz2⟩,∣M20⟩=∣cix2ciy2ciz2⟩,∣M21⟩=∣cixciy2ciz⟩,∣M22⟩=∣cixciyciz2⟩,∣M23⟩=∣cixciy2ciz2⟩,∣M24⟩=∣cix2ciyciz2⟩,∣M25⟩=∣cix2ciy2ciz⟩,∣M26⟩=∣cix2ciy2ciz2⟩.(19)\begin{aligned} \left|M_0\right\rangle&= |1,\ldots,1\rangle,\quad\left|M_1\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_2\right\rangle= \left|c_{iy}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_3\right\rangle= \left|c_{iz}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_4\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}c_{iy}\right\rangle,\\ \left|M_5\right\rangle&= \left|c_{ix}c_{iz}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_6\right\rangle= \left|c_{iy}c_{iz}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_7\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}-c_{iy}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_8\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}-c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\\ \left|M_9\right\rangle&= \left|c_{ix}^{2}+c_{iy}^{2}+c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{10}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}^{2}+c_{ix}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{11}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}^{2}+c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\\ \left|M_{12}\right\rangle&= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}+c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{13}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}c_{iy}^{2}-c_{ix}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{14}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}-c_{iy}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\\ \left|M_{15}\right\rangle&= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iz}-c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{16}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}c_{iy}c_{iz}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{17}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}^{2}+c_{ix}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}+c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\\ \left|M_{18}\right\rangle&= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}^{2}+c_{ix}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}-c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{19}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}^{2}-c_{ix}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{20}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\\ \left|M_{21}\right\rangle&= \left|c_{ix}c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{22}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}c_{iy}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{23}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{24}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle,\\ \left|M_{25}\right\rangle&= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}\right\rangle,\quad\left|M_{26}\right\rangle= \left|c_{ix}^{2}c_{iy}^{2}c_{iz}^{2}\right\rangle. \tag*{(19)} \end{aligned}

The MRT collision operator is written as

L[∣fi⟩]≡−(MT)−1ΛMT(∣fi⟩−∣fieq⟩),(20)L[\left|f_i\right\rangle] \equiv-(M^{T})^{-1}\Lambda M^{T}(\left|f_i\right\rangle-\left|f_i^{eq}\right\rangle), \tag*{(20)}

where the matrix elements of the 27×2727 \times27 collision matrix Λ\boldsymbol{\Lambda} are defined as [24, 32, 33]

Λ=diag[1,1,1,1,ω,ω,ω,ω,ω,1,…,1],(21)\boldsymbol{\Lambda} = \mathit{diag}\left[1,1,1,1,\omega,\omega,\omega,\omega,\omega,1,\ldots,1\right], \tag*{(21)}

where ω=1/τ=(ν/cs2+0.5)−1\omega= 1/\tau= (\nu/c_s^2 + 0.5)^{-1} with ν\nu being the kinematic viscosity.

Using the MRT collision operator defined in Eq. (20), the equation for the post collision distributions (1) now becomes

∣mi∗⟩=(I−Λ)∣mi⟩+Λ∣mieq⟩+(I−Λ2)∣RiMRT⟩,(22)\left|m_i^*\right\rangle= (\mathbf{I}-\boldsymbol{\Lambda})\left|m_i\right\rangle+ \boldsymbol{\Lambda}\left|m_i^{eq}\right\rangle+ \left(\mathbf{I}-\frac{\boldsymbol{\Lambda}}{2}\right)\left|R_i^{MRT}\right\rangle, \tag*{(22)}

where ∣RiMRT⟩\left|R_i^{MRT}\right\rangle is the forcing term within the MRT collision approach, which is given by [39]

∣RiMRT⟩=−MT(F⋅∇c)∣fieq⟩,(23)\left|R_i^{MRT}\right\rangle= -\mathbf{M}^{T}\left(\mathbf{F}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf{c}}\right)\left|f_i^{eq}\right\rangle, \tag*{(23)}

where F=(Fx,Fy,Fz)\mathbf{F}=(F_x,F_y,F_z) is an arbitrary external force.

In this work, the Maxwell Boltzmann equilibrium distribution is expanded up to the sixth order in Hermite polynomials Hi(n)\mathcal{H}_i^{(n)} since it was already shown that the D3Q27 lattice model can only active its full potential by making use of the 27 Hermite polynomials [34, 38, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44]. The equilibrium distribution is then written as

fieq=ωiρ{1+ci⋅ucs2+12cs4[Hixx(2)ux2+Hiyy(2)uy2+Hizz(2)uz2+2(Hixy(2)uxuy+Hixz(2)uxuz+Hiyz(2)uyuz)]+12cs6[Hixxy(3)ux2uy+Hixxz(3)ux2uz+Hixyy(3)uxuy2+Hixzz(3)uxuz2+Hiyzz(3)uyuz2+Hiyyz(3)uy2uz+2Hixyz(3)uxuyuz]+14cs8[Hixxyy(4)ux2uy2+Hixxzz(4)ux2uz2+Hiyyzz(4)uy2uz2+2(Hixyzz(4)uxuyuz2+Hixyyz(4)uxuy2uz+Hixxyz(4)ux2uyuz)]+14cs10[Hixxyzz(5)ux2uyuz2+Hixxyyz(5)ux2uy2uz+Hixyyzz(5)uxuy2uz2]+18cs12Hixxyyzz(6)ux2uy2uz2},(24)\begin{aligned} f_i^{eq} = \omega_i\rho\Bigg\{1+\frac{\mathbf{c}_i\cdot\mathbf{u}}{c_s^2} &+\frac{1}{2c_s^4}\left[\mathcal{H}_{ixx}^{(2)}u_x^2+\mathcal{H}_{iyy}^{(2)}u_y^2+\mathcal{H}_{izz}^{(2)}u_z^2+2\left(\mathcal{H}_{ixy}^{(2)}u_xu_y+\mathcal{H}_{ixz}^{(2)}u_xu_z+\mathcal{H}_{iyz}^{(2)}u_yu_z\right)\right]\\ &+\frac{1}{2c_s^6}\left[\mathcal{H}_{ixxy}^{(3)}u_x^2u_y+\mathcal{H}_{ixxz}^{(3)}u_x^2u_z+\mathcal{H}_{ixyy}^{(3)}u_xu_y^2+\mathcal{H}_{ixzz}^{(3)}u_xu_z^2+\mathcal{H}_{iyzz}^{(3)}u_yu_z^2\right.\\ &\left.\qquad+\mathcal{H}_{iyyz}^{(3)}u_y^2u_z+2\mathcal{H}_{ixyz}^{(3)}u_xu_yu_z\right]\\ &+\frac{1}{4c_s^8}\left[\mathcal{H}_{ixxyy}^{(4)}u_x^2u_y^2+\mathcal{H}_{ixxzz}^{(4)}u_x^2u_z^2+\mathcal{H}_{iyyzz}^{(4)}u_y^2u_z^2\right.\\ &\left.\qquad+2\left(\mathcal{H}_{ixyzz}^{(4)}u_xu_yu_z^2+\mathcal{H}_{ixyyz}^{(4)}u_xu_y^2u_z+\mathcal{H}_{ixxyz}^{(4)}u_x^2u_yu_z\right)\right]\\ &+\frac{1}{4c_s^{10}}\left[\mathcal{H}_{ixxyzz}^{(5)}u_x^2u_yu_z^2+\mathcal{H}_{ixxyyz}^{(5)}u_x^2u_y^2u_z+\mathcal{H}_{ixyyzz}^{(5)}u_xu_y^2u_z^2\right]\\ &+\frac{1}{8c_s^{12}}\mathcal{H}_{ixxyyzz}^{(6)}u_x^2u_y^2u_z^2\Bigg\}, \tag*{(24)} \end{aligned}

where cs=1/3c_s=1/\sqrt{3} is the lattice sound velocity, and ωi\omega_i are lattice-Boltzmann weights, defined by

ω1=…=ω6=ω0/4,ω7=…=ω18=ω0/16,ω19=…=ω26=ω0/64,(25)\omega_1=\ldots=\omega_6=\omega_0/4,\qquad\omega_7=\ldots=\omega_{18}=\omega_0/16,\qquad\omega_{19}=\ldots=\omega_{26}=\omega_0/64, \tag*{(25)}

with ω0=8/27\omega_0=8/27.

Making use of the transformation matrix (A4) and the sixth-order expanded Maxwell Boltzmann equilibrium distribution (A9), the equilibrium moments can be written as

m0eq=ρ,m1eq=ρux,m2eq=ρuy,m3eq=ρuz,m4eq=ρuxuy,m5eq=ρuxuz,m6eq=ρuyuz,m7eq=ρ(ux2−uy2),m8eq=ρ(ux2−uz2),m9eq=ρ(ux2+uy2+uz2+1),m10eq=ρcs2ux(3uy2+3uz2+2),m11eq=ρcs2uy(3ux2+3uz2+2),m12eq=ρcs2uz(3ux2+3uy2+2),m13eq=ρux(uy2−uz2),m14eq=ρuy(ux2−uz2),m15eq=ρuz(ux2−uy2),m16eq=ρuxuyuz,m17eq=ρcs2[3(ux2uy2+ux2uz2+uy2uz2)+2(ux2+uy2+uz2)+1],m18eq=ρcs4[9(ux2uy2+ux2uz2−uy2uz2)+6ux2+1],m19eq=ρcs2(uy2−uz2)(3ux2+1),m20eq=ρcs2uyuz(3ux2+1),m21eq=ρcs2uxuz(3uy2+1),m22eq=ρcs2uxuy(3uz2+1),m23eq=ρcs4ux(3uy2+1)(3uz2+1),m24eq=ρcs4uy(3ux2+1)(3uz2+1),m25eq=ρcs4uz(3ux2+1)(3uy2+1),m26eq=ρcs6(3ux2+1)(3uy2+1)(3uz2+1).(26)\begin{aligned} m_0^{eq} &= \rho,\quad m_1^{eq} = \rho u_x,\quad m_2^{eq} = \rho u_y,\quad m_3^{eq} = \rho u_z,\quad m_4^{eq} = \rho u_xu_y,\\ m_5^{eq} &= \rho u_xu_z,\quad m_6^{eq} = \rho u_yu_z,\quad m_7^{eq} = \rho(u_x^2-u_y^2),\quad m_8^{eq} = \rho(u_x^2-u_z^2),\\ m_9^{eq} &= \rho(u_x^2+u_y^2+u_z^2+1),\quad m_{10}^{eq} = \rho c_s^2u_x(3u_y^2+3u_z^2+2),\\ m_{11}^{eq} &= \rho c_s^2u_y(3u_x^2+3u_z^2+2),\quad m_{12}^{eq} = \rho c_s^2u_z(3u_x^2+3u_y^2+2),\\ m_{13}^{eq} &= \rho u_x(u_y^2-u_z^2),\quad m_{14}^{eq} = \rho u_y(u_x^2-u_z^2),\quad m_{15}^{eq} = \rho u_z(u_x^2-u_y^2),\\ m_{16}^{eq} &= \rho u_xu_yu_z,\quad m_{17}^{eq} = \rho c_s^2\left[3(u_x^2u_y^2+u_x^2u_z^2+u_y^2u_z^2)+2(u_x^2+u_y^2+u_z^2)+1\right],\\ m_{18}^{eq} &= \rho c_s^4\left[9(u_x^2u_y^2+u_x^2u_z^2-u_y^2u_z^2)+6u_x^2+1\right],\quad m_{19}^{eq} = \rho c_s^2(u_y^2-u_z^2)(3u_x^2+1),\\ m_{20}^{eq} &= \rho c_s^2u_yu_z(3u_x^2+1),\quad m_{21}^{eq} = \rho c_s^2u_xu_z(3u_y^2+1),\quad m_{22}^{eq} = \rho c_s^2u_xu_y(3u_z^2+1),\\ m_{23}^{eq} &= \rho c_s^4u_x(3u_y^2+1)(3u_z^2+1),\quad m_{24}^{eq} = \rho c_s^4u_y(3u_x^2+1)(3u_z^2+1),\\ m_{25}^{eq} &= \rho c_s^4u_z(3u_x^2+1)(3u_y^2+1),\quad m_{26}^{eq} = \rho c_s^6(3u_x^2+1)(3u_y^2+1)(3u_z^2+1). \tag*{(26)} \end{aligned}

In the absence of a forcing term, the post-collision moments are given by mi∗=mieqm_i^* = m_i^{eq} for i=(0,…,3,9,…26)i = (0,\ldots,3,9,\ldots26) and

m4∗=(1−ω)m4+ωρuxuy,m5∗=(1−ω)m5+ωρuxuz,m6∗=(1−ω)m6+ωρuyuz,m_4^* = (1-\omega)m_4+\omega\rho u_xu_y,\quad m_5^* = (1-\omega)m_5+\omega\rho u_xu_z,\quad m_6^* = (1-\omega)m_6+\omega\rho u_yu_z,
m7∗=(1−ω)m7+ωρ(ux2−uy2),m8∗=(1−ω)m8+ωρ(ux2−uz2).(27)m_7^* = (1-\omega)m_7+\omega\rho(u_x^2-u_y^2),\quad m_8^* = (1-\omega)m_8+\omega\rho(u_x^2-u_z^2). \tag*{(27)}

with

m4=∑ificixciy,m5=∑ificixciz,m6=∑ificiyciz,m_4 = \sum_i f_i c_{ix}c_{iy},\quad m_5 = \sum_i f_i c_{ix}c_{iz},\quad m_6 = \sum_i f_i c_{iy}c_{iz},
m7=∑ifi(cix2−ciy2),m8=∑ifi(cix2−ciz2).(28)m_7 = \sum_i f_i(c_{ix}^2-c_{iy}^2),\quad m_8 = \sum_i f_i(c_{ix}^2-c_{iz}^2). \tag*{(28)}

In the presence of an arbitrary external force, the last term in Eq. (22) has to be considered, where the forcing term within the MRT collision approach, will be given by Eq. (23). Making use of the aforementioned equilibrium distribution (A9), the forcing term will be given by

R0MRT=0,R1MRT=ρFx,R2MRT=ρFy,R3MRT=ρFz,R4MRT=ρ(Fyux+Fxuy),R5MRT=ρ(Fzux+Fxuz),R6MRT=ρ(Fzuy+Fyuz),R7MRT=2ρ(Fxux−Fyuy),R8MRT=2ρ(Fxux−Fzuz),R9MRT=2ρ(F⋅u),R10MRT=cs2ρ[6ux(Fyuy+Fzuz)+Fx(2+3uy2+3uz2)],R11MRT=cs2ρ[6uy(Fxux+Fzuz)+Fy(2+3ux2+3uz2)],R12MRT=cs2ρ[6uz(Fxux+Fyuy)+Fz(2+3ux2+3uy2)],R13MRT=ρ[2ux(Fyuy−Fzuz)+Fx(uy2−uz2)],R14MRT=ρ[2uy(Fxux−Fzuz)+Fy(ux2−uz2)],R15MRT=ρ[2uz(Fxux−Fyuy)+Fz(ux2−uy2)],R16MRT=ρ(Fxuyuz+Fyuxuz+Fzuxuy),R17MRT=2cs2ρ[Fxux(2+3uy2+3uz2)+Fyuy(2+3ux2+3uz2)+Fzuz(2+3ux2+3uy2)],R18MRT=2cs2ρ[Fxux(2+3uy2+3uz2)+3Fyuy(ux2−uz2)+3Fzuz(ux2−uy2)],R19MRT=2cs2ρ[3Fxux(uy2−uz2)+(Fyuy−Fzuz)(1+3ux2)],R20MRT=cs2ρ[(Fzuy+Fyuz)(1+3ux2)+6Fxuxuyuz],R21MRT=cs2ρ[(Fzux+Fxuz)(1+3uy2)+6Fyuxuyuz],R22MRT=cs2ρ[(Fyux+Fxuy)(1+3uz2)+6Fzuxuyuz],R23MRT=cs4ρ{Fx(1+3uy2)(1+3uz2)+6ux[Fzuz(1+3uy2)+Fyuy(1+3uz2)]},R24MRT=cs4ρ{Fy(1+3ux2)(1+3uz2)+6uy[Fzuz(1+3ux2)+Fxux(1+3uz2)]},R25MRT=cs4ρ{Fz(1+3ux2)(1+3uy2)+6uz[Fyuy(1+3ux2)+Fxux(1+3uy2)]},R26MRT=2cs4ρ{Fxux(1+3uy2)(1+3uz2)+(1+3ux2)[Fzuz(1+3uy2)+Fyuy(1+3uz2)]}.(29)\begin{aligned} R_0^{MRT} &= 0,\quad R_1^{MRT} = \rho F_x,\quad R_2^{MRT} = \rho F_y,\quad R_3^{MRT} = \rho F_z,\quad R_4^{MRT} = \rho(F_y u_x + F_x u_y),\\ R_5^{MRT} &= \rho(F_z u_x + F_x u_z),\quad R_6^{MRT} = \rho(F_z u_y + F_y u_z),\quad R_7^{MRT} = 2\rho(F_x u_x - F_y u_y),\\ R_8^{MRT} &= 2\rho(F_x u_x - F_z u_z),\quad R_9^{MRT} = 2\rho(\mathbf{F}\cdot\mathbf{u}),\\ R_{10}^{MRT} &= c_s^2\rho\left[6u_x(F_yu_y + F_zu_z) + F_x(2 + 3u_y^2 + 3u_z^2)\right],\\ R_{11}^{MRT} &= c_s^2\rho\left[6u_y(F_xu_x + F_zu_z) + F_y(2 + 3u_x^2 + 3u_z^2)\right],\\ R_{12}^{MRT} &= c_s^2\rho\left[6u_z(F_xu_x + F_yu_y) + F_z(2 + 3u_x^2 + 3u_y^2)\right],\\ R_{13}^{MRT} &= \rho\left[2u_x(F_yu_y - F_zu_z) + F_x(u_y^2 - u_z^2)\right],\\ R_{14}^{MRT} &= \rho\left[2u_y(F_xu_x - F_zu_z) + F_y(u_x^2 - u_z^2)\right],\\ R_{15}^{MRT} &= \rho\left[2u_z(F_xu_x - F_yu_y) + F_z(u_x^2 - u_y^2)\right],\\ R_{16}^{MRT} &= \rho(F_xu_yu_z + F_yu_xu_z + F_zu_xu_y),\\ R_{17}^{MRT} &= 2c_s^2\rho\left[F_xu_x(2 + 3u_y^2 + 3u_z^2) + F_yu_y(2 + 3u_x^2 + 3u_z^2) + F_zu_z(2 + 3u_x^2 + 3u_y^2)\right],\\ R_{18}^{MRT} &= 2c_s^2\rho\left[F_xu_x(2 + 3u_y^2 + 3u_z^2) + 3F_yu_y(u_x^2 - u_z^2) + 3F_zu_z(u_x^2 - u_y^2)\right],\\ R_{19}^{MRT} &= 2c_s^2\rho\left[3F_xu_x(u_y^2 - u_z^2) + (F_yu_y - F_zu_z)(1 + 3u_x^2)\right],\\ R_{20}^{MRT} &= c_s^2\rho\left[(F_zu_y + F_yu_z)(1 + 3u_x^2) + 6F_xu_xu_yu_z\right],\\ R_{21}^{MRT} &= c_s^2\rho\left[(F_zu_x + F_xu_z)(1 + 3u_y^2) + 6F_yu_xu_yu_z\right],\\ R_{22}^{MRT} &= c_s^2\rho\left[(F_yu_x + F_xu_y)(1 + 3u_z^2) + 6F_zu_xu_yu_z\right],\\ R_{23}^{MRT} &= c_s^4\rho\left\{F_x(1 + 3u_y^2)(1 + 3u_z^2) + 6u_x\left[F_zu_z(1 + 3u_y^2) + F_yu_y(1 + 3u_z^2)\right]\right\},\\ R_{24}^{MRT} &= c_s^4\rho\left\{F_y(1 + 3u_x^2)(1 + 3u_z^2) + 6u_y\left[F_zu_z(1 + 3u_x^2) + F_xu_x(1 + 3u_z^2)\right]\right\},\\ R_{25}^{MRT} &= c_s^4\rho\left\{F_z(1 + 3u_x^2)(1 + 3u_y^2) + 6u_z\left[F_yu_y(1 + 3u_x^2) + F_xu_x(1 + 3u_y^2)\right]\right\},\\ R_{26}^{MRT} &= 2c_s^4\rho\left\{F_xu_x(1 + 3u_y^2)(1 + 3u_z^2) + (1 + 3u_x^2)\left[F_zu_z(1 + 3u_y^2) + F_yu_y(1 + 3u_z^2)\right]\right\}. \tag*{(29)} \end{aligned}

The post-collision populations are obtained from the post-collision moments by

∣f∗⟩=M−1∣m∗⟩(30)|f^*\rangle= M^{-1}|m^*\rangle \tag*{(30)}

the collision step then ends and it is followed by the streaming step, as it was previously mentioned in Eq. (2).

References

References

  1. [1]C. L. Fefferman, “Existence and smoothness of the Navier-Stokes equation”, The Millennium Prize Problems ed J. Carlson, A. Jaffe, and A Wiles (Providencem RI: American Mathematical Society), 57–67 (2006);
  2. [2]U. Frisch, “Turbulence: The legacy of A. N. Kolmogorov” (Cambridge University Press, 1995).
  3. [3]L. Moriconi, “Minimalist turbulent boundary layer model”, Phys. Rev. E 79, 046306 (2009).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19518332
  4. [4]R. J. Adrian, “Hairpin vortex organization in wall turbulence”, Phys. Fluids 19, 041301 (2007).DOI
  5. [5]D. J. C. Dennis and F. M. Sogaro, “Distinct Organizational States of Fully Developed Turbulent Pipe Flow”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 234501 (2014).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25526130
  6. [6]B. J. Balakumar and R. J. Adrian, “Large- and very-large-scale motions in channel and boundary-layer flows”, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A. 365, 665–681 (2007);pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17244580
  7. [7]A. K. Prasad and R. J. Adrian, “Stereoscopic particle image velocimetry applied to liquid flows”, Exp. Fluids 15, 49–60 (1993).DOI
  8. [8]R. Jäckel, B. Magacho, B. E. Owolabi, L. Moriconi, D. J. C. Dennis, and J. B. R. Loureiro, “Coherent organizational states in turbulent pipe flow at moderate Reynolds numbers”, Phys. Fluids 35, 045127 (2023).
  9. [9]L. H. O. Hellstrom and A. J. Smits, “Structure identification in pipe flow using proper orthogonal decomposition”, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 375, 20160086 (2017).DOI
  10. [10]T. M. Schneider, B. Eckhardt, and J. Vollmer, “Statistical analysis of coherent structures in transitional pipe flow”, Phys. Rev. E 75, 066313 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17677363
  11. [11]E. Marensi, S. He, and A. P. Willis, “Suppression of turbulence and travelling waves in a vertical heated pipe”, J. Fluid Mech. 919, A17 (2021).DOI
  12. [12]J. H. Elsas and L. Moriconi, “Vortex identification from local properties of the vorticity field”, Phys. Fluids 29, 015101 (2017).DOI
  13. [13]R. Jäckel, B. Magacho, B. E. Owolabi, L. Moriconi, D. J. C. Dennis, and J. B. R. Loureiro, “Stochastic model of organizational state transitions in a turbulent pipe flow”, Phys. Rev. Fluids 8, 064609 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2301.05344
  14. [14]C. Körner, T. Pohl, U. Rüde, N. Thürey, and T. Zeiser, Parallel Lattice Boltzmann Methods for CFD Applications (Springer, 2006).DOI
  15. [15]H. Touil, D. Ricot, and E. Lévêque, “Direct and large-eddy simulation of turbulent flows on composite multi-resolution grids by the lattice Boltzmann method,” J. Comput. Phys. 256, 220–233 (2014).DOI
  16. [16]F. Schornbaum and U. Rüde, “Massively Parallel Algorithms for the Lattice Boltzmann Method on NonUniform Grids,” SIAM J. Sci. Comput. 38, C96–C126 (2016).DOI
  17. [17]L. Xu, P. Cheng, Z. Liu, and W. Zhang, “Parallel Algorithms of Multi-relaxation-time Lattice Boltzmann Method,” J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 1087, 022024 (2018).DOI
  18. [18]J. Latt, O. Malaspinas, D. Kontaxakis, A. Parmigiani, D. Lagrava, F. Brogi, M. B. Belgacem, Y. Thorimbert, S. Leclaire, S. Li, F. Marson, J. Lemus, C. Kotsalos, R. Conr adin, C. Coreixas, R. Petkantchin, F. Raynaud, J. Beny, and B. Chopard, “Palabos: Parallel Lattice Boltzmann Solver,” Comput. Math. Appl. 81, 334–350 (2021).DOI
  19. [19]S. Chen and G. D. Doolen, “Lattice Boltzmann Method for Fluid Flows,” Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 30, 329–364 (1998).
  20. [20]C. Cercignani, The Boltzmann Equation and Its Applications (Springer, 1988).DOI
  21. [21]B. Magacho, H. S. Tavares, L. Moriconi, and J. B. R. Loureiro, “Double multiple-relaxation-time model of lattice-Boltzmann magnetohydrodynamics at low magnetic Reynolds numbers”, Phys. Fluids 35, 013610 (2023).
  22. [22]H. S. Tavares, B. Magacho, L. Moriconi, and J. B. R. Loureiro, “A simplified lattice Boltzmann implementation of the quasi-static approximation in pipe flows under the presence of non-uniform magnetic fields”, Comp. Math. Appl. 148, 93–112 (2023).
  23. [23]P. J. Dellar, “Lattice Kinetic Schemes for Magnetohydrodynamics”, J. Comput. Phys. 179, 95–126 (2002).DOI
  24. [24]H. Yoshida and M. Nagaoka, “Multiple-relaxation-time lattice Boltzmann model for the convection and anisotropic diffusion equation”, J. Comp. Phys. 229, 7774–7795 (2010).DOI
  25. [25]L. Li, R. Mei, and J. F. Klausner, “Boundary conditions for thermal lattice Boltzmann equation method”, J. Comp. Phys. 237, 366–395 (2013).DOI
  26. [26]H. S. Tavares, L. Biferale, M. Sbragaglia, and A. A. Mailybaev, “Immiscible Rayleigh-Taylor turbulence using mesoscopic lattice Boltzmann algorithms”, Phys. Rev. Fluids 6, 054606 (2021).DOI
  27. [27]S. K. Kang and Y. A. Hassan, “The effect of lattice models within the lattice Boltzmann method in the simulation of wall-bounded turbulent flows”, J. Comp. Phys. 232, 100–117 (2013).DOI
  28. [28]P. Nathen, D. Gaudlitz, M. J. Krause, and N. A. Adams, “On the Stability and Accuracy of the BGK, MRT and RLB Boltzmann Schemes for the Simulation of Turbulent Flows”, Commun. Comput. Phys. 23, 846–876 (2018).DOI
  29. [29]C. Peng, N. Geneva, Z. Guo, and L.-P. Wang, “Direct numerical simulation of turbulent pipe flow using the lattice Boltzmann method”, J. Comp. Phys. 357, 16–42 (2018).DOI
  30. [30]P. L. Bhatnagar, E. P. Gross, and M. Krook, “A Model for Collision Processes in Gases. I. Small Amplitude Processes in Charged and Neutral One-Component Systems,” Phys. Rev. 94, 511–525 (1954).DOI
  31. [31]D. d’Humières, “Generalized lattice-Boltzmann equations,” Prog. Astronaut. Aeronaut. 159, 450–458 (1992).
  32. [32]P. V. Coveney, S. Succi, D. d’Humières, I. Ginzburg, M. Krafczyk, P. Lallemand, and L.-S. Luo, “Multiple-relaxation-time lattice Boltzmann models in three dimensions,” Philos. Trans. R. Soc., A 360, 437–451 (2002).
  33. [33]S. A. Hosseini, C. Coreaixas, N. Darabiha, and D. Thévenin, “Stability of the lattice kinetic scheme and choice of the free relaxation parameter,” Phys. Rev. E 99, 063305 (2019).DOI
  34. [34]C. Coreixas, B. Chopard, and J. Latt, “Comprehensive comparison of collision models in the lattice Boltzmann framework: Theoretical investigations,” Phys. Rev. E 100, 033305 (2019).
  35. [35]C. Coreixas, G. Wissocq, B. Chopard, and J. Latt, “Impact of collision models on the physical properties and the stability of lattice Boltzmann methods,” Philos. Trans. R. Soc., A 378, 20190397 (2020).DOI
  36. [36]T. Krueger, H. Kusumaatmaja, A. Kuzmin, O. Shardt, G. Silva, and E. M. Viggen, The Lattice Boltzmann Method: Principles and Practice (Springer, 2016).
  37. [37]P. Lallemand and L.-S. Luo, “Theory of the lattice Boltzmann method: Dispersion, dissipation, isotropy, Galilean invariance, and stability,” Phys. Rev. E 61, 6546–6562 (2000).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11088335
  38. [38]A. De Rosis, “Nonorthogonal central-moments-based lattice Boltzmann scheme in three dimensions,” Phys. Rev. E 95, 013310 (2017).DOI
  39. [39]Z. Guo, C. Zheng, and B. Shi, “Discrete lattice effects on the forcing term in the lattice Boltzmann method,” Phys. Rev. E 65, 046308 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12006014
  40. [40]A. De Rosis, R. Huang, and C. Coreixas, “Universal formulation of central-moments-based lattice Boltzmann method with external forcing for the simulation of multiphysics phenomena,” Phys. Fluids 31, 117102 (2019).DOI
  41. [41]O. Malaspinas, “Increasing stability and accuracy of the lattice Boltzmann scheme: Recursivity and regularization,” preprint arXiv:1505.06900 (2015).arxiv.org/abs/1505.06900
  42. [42]C. Coreixas, G. Wissocq, G. Puigt, J.-F. Boussuge, and P. Sagaut, “Recursive regularization step for high-order lattice Boltzmann methods,” Phys. Rev. E 96, 033306 (2017).DOI
  43. [43]C. Coreixas, “High-order extension of the recursive regularized lattice Boltzmann method,” Ph.D. thesis, INP Toulouse, 2018.DOI
  44. [44]A. De Rosis and K. H. Luo, “Role of higher-order Hermite polynomials in the central-moments-based lattice Boltzmann framework,” Phys. Rev. E 99, 013301 (2019).DOI
  45. [45]M. Bouzidi, M. Firdaouss, and P. Lallemand, “Momentum transfer of a Boltzmann-lattice fluid with boundaries,” Phys. Fluids 13, 3452–3459 (2001).DOI
  46. [46]D. P. Ziegler, “Boundary conditions for lattice Boltzmann simulations,” J. Stat. Phys. 71, 1171–1177 (1993).DOI
  47. [47]I. Ginzbourg and P. M. Adler, “Boundary flow condition analysis for the three-dimensional lattice Boltzmann model,” J. Phys. II France 4, 191–214 (1994).DOI
  48. [48]P. Loulou, R. D. Moser, N. N. Mansour , and B. J. Cantwell, “Direct Numerical Simulation of Incompressible Pipe Flow Using a B-Spline Spectral Method”, PhD dissertation. Stanford Univ., Stanford, Calif. Also, NASATM (1997).
  49. [49]C. Chin, A. S. H. Ooi, I. Marusic, and H. M. Blackburn, “The influence of pipe length on turbulence statistics computed from direct numerical simulation data”, Phys. Fluids 22, 115107 (2010).DOI
  50. [50]J. M. Wallace, “Quadrant analysis in turbulence research: History and evolution”, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 48, 131–158 (2016).DOI
  51. [51]J. Yao, S. Rezaeiravesh, P. Schlatter, and F. Hussain, “Direct numerical simulations of turbulent pipe flow up to Reτ ≈ 5200”, J. Fluid Mech. 956, A18 (2023).DOI
  52. [52]A. P. Willis, “The openpipeflow Navier–Stokes solver”, SoftwareX 6, 124–127 (2017);
  53. [53]G. Tahitu, “The possibilities for laser-doppler velocimetry in a turbulent pipe flow”. report meah-117 (delft university of technology), Ph.D. thesis, MSc-thesis (in Dutch) 1994.
  54. [54]R. Jäckel, B. Magacho, B. E. Owolabi, L. Moriconi, and J. B. R. Loureiro, “Experimental and numerical characterization of magnetohydrodynamic turbulence in pipe flow”, 10th Int. Symp. Turb. Heat Mass Transf. (2023). Accepted to IJHFF (2024).DOI
  55. [55]G. I. Taylor, “The spectrum of turbulence”, Proc. R. Soc. 164, 476–490 (1938);DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_d45a4s9z
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents