WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Wobbling Motion in the Many-Nucleon System
Abstract
The purpose of this Perspective is not to present a new progress but to shed light on another stream of the study of the nuclear wobbling motion from a viewpoint of the many-body theory under an external field. Special attention is paid to the moments of inertia, which are microscopically calculated as a response of the full -body system to rapid rotations described by the cranked RPA formalism. They depend on the rotation frequency, and it is shown that approach of two moments of inertia leads to the instability of rotating triaxial mean fields.
Introduction
Exploring how matter responds to extreme environments has been always one of frontiers in physics and physical sciences. The atomic nucleus, which is governed by strong interaction, is also the case. In particular, when probed with low energies, the nucleus must be treated as a strongly correlated, finite many-body system. Mayer-Jensen’s independent-particle picture in the selfconsistently formed mean field, the shell model, describes the ground and low-lying states in medium and heavy nuclei very well. The shape of the nucleus or that of the mean field is spherical at the magic numbers as those of electrons in the atom. When nucleon numbers deviate from the magic numbers in the shell, axially symmetric quadrupole deformation is expected. When large angular momenta are introduced to such a system, for example, by peripheral reactions with low incident energies, say, MeV, the nucleus collectively rotates about an axis perpendicular to the symmetry axis. This rotation is one-dimensional and uniform. As this rotation becomes rapid, the centrifugal force drives the shape to triaxial, and consequently, the nucleus can possess angular-momentum components about other axes. The resulting non-uniform rotation is the wobbling motion well known in classical mechanics [1].
The lowest-energy states with given angular momenta are called yrast states. The spectra of such states experimentally define the moment of inertia of the rotating body. Historically, there have been two models for nuclear matter in the rotating drop; the irrotational (irr) model and the rigid-body (rig) model (see Fig. 6A-2 in Ref. [2]). Their absolute magnitudes can be related to the axially-symmetric deformation parameter but it has been known that , where is determined from the energies of rotational states in even-even nuclei. Their dependence on the deformation parameter can be extended to triaxial cases. When the nucleus stands still, the triaxial parameter runs from to , where and indicate prolate and oblate axially-symmetric shapes, respectively. When a rotation sets in, needs three times wider range depending on the relation between the shape and the direction of rotation because triaxial nuclei can rotate about any axes, and therefore three moments of inertia (MOI) become relevant.
Now, there are two conventions for the definition of the range of . One is the Bohr-Mottelson (BM) convention,
where denote the , , axes and runs from to . The other is the so-called Lund convention, widely adopted in the Strutinsky calculations those days and also in the present article hereafter,
where runs from to $60^\circ (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Irrotational moments of inertia in the Lund convention normalized to ().
This convention-dependent terminology was explicitly used for describing physics as explained below.
Wobbling Models Without Valence Particle
Asymmetric Rotor Model
By abstracting such underlying nucleon dynamics and specific forms of MOI, Bohr and Mottelson (Sect. 4-5e of Ref. [2]) discussed a small amplitude deviation from a one-dimensional rotation in terms of an asymmetric rotor with given MOI. It should be noted that non-uniform rotations were first investigated in the field of chemical physics [3] as clearly stated in Ref. [2]. The settings in Ref. [2] are briefly summarized as follows. All the necessary assumption is that the main rotation occurs about the axis of the largest inertia. Throughout this article, is set to 1.
Three axes are numbered accordingly to MOI, in descending order such as , then, for the yrast states, where is the total angular momentum.
The commutation relation of the angular-momentum components in the principal-axis (PA) frame holds, where .
In terms of bosonic creation and annihilation operators, , , , the Hamiltonian of the rotor
can be cast into the form by diagonalizing the cross terms such as and , where is the number operator of the wobbling phonon and its eigenvalues are constrained as (in even-even nuclei) by signature symmetry with respect to rotation about the first axis.
The resulting frequency of the harmonic wobbling excitation is , as in the classical mechanics.
These are the bases of all the following discussions.
Right after Bohr and Mottelson, Andersson et al. [4] made an exploratory calculation of wobbling bands in at - 60 by adopting the rigid-body MOI. Its background was Lund group’s calculations that predicted triaxial shapes triggered by rapid rotations. Liotta and Sorensen [5] invoked the BM model above to study multiplicities and continuum gamma rays following heavy-ion reactions, paying attention to its fast electric quadrupole () transitions, see Fig. 1 in Ref. [6]. Theoretically, vibrations around triaxial deformed shapes are possible. Based on this, it was proposed by Mikhailov and Janssen [7] that wobbling might be found as a high-spin continuation of the odd-spin sequence of the band, just before the full cranked random-phase approximation (RPA) theory of Marshalek [8]. This is consistent with that wobbling motion in the PA frame can be described as a shape fluctuation in the uniformly rotating (UR) frame as stated below, see Fig. 3 in Ref. [6].
Cranked RPA
The first step of the cranked RPA calculation is the UR mean field obtained by cranking about an axis, named ;
where is the Nilsson plus BCS Hamiltonian, for example. The commutation relation among the angular-momentum components is the same as that in the laboratory frame. The yrast configuration, which is the vacuum of the quasiparticle excitations, is implicitly regarded as even-even systems, but can be straightforwardly set to odd systems (see Eq. (4) in Ref. [9]). The cranking term in the one-body Hamiltonian, , acts on all the nucleons even in the cases with the vacuum is taken to be odd-. This includes the centrifugal force causing alignments of individual nucleon’s angular momenta to the rotation axis and leading to collective rotation. Residual two-body interactions among nucleons in the rotating mean field, , the doubly-stretched - for example, are taken into account within the RPA, that is a linear response theory, in the form of the equation of motion, , for the eigenmode , which are superpositions of two-quasiparticle states. Importantly, that for the negative signature (odd spin in the even-even case) sector can be cast into the form of the implicit function,
where the argument stresses that are calculated mode by mode and the superscript (eff) in Ref. [9] is omitted here. Their complete expressions in terms of two-quasiparticle energies and matrix elements and are given in Ref. [10].
Its essence to describe wobbling motion is as follows [8, 11, 12]:
The RPA in the UR frame gives many individual (modified) two-quasiparticle- as well as collective vibrational normal modes and a Nambu-Goldstone (NG) mode with to restore rotational symmetry.
The PA frame is defined by vanishing off-diagonal quadrupole moments. The two coordinate frames are related in terms of dynamical Euler angles. In the RPA order, this results in
where and are off-diagonal quadrupole operators, and and are static deformations, with , see Ref. [12] for details of the notations. It should be noted that the factors “” in both of Eq. (4.1) there are redundant.
The transformation above recovers the commutation relation in the PA frame, .
Further, can be expanded in terms of RPA eigenmodes and excluding the NG mode. This is the reason why the angular-momentum dynamics in the PA frame can be described in the RPA based on the UR mean field. It should be noted here that the condition of the vanishing off-diagonal quadrupole moments leads to the separation of the NG mode [8, 12, 13, 14].
WOBBLING IN ODD-A NUCLEI
Experimental evidence
Prerequisite for wobbling motion is equilibrium triaxial deformations by definition. The existence of such deformation has been a long dispute since 1950’s [15, 16]. Theories such as the angular-momentum projection and the Strutinsky shell correction result in small but non-zero triaxial deformations, say, , in many cases. But it must be larger than the zero-point vibration in order that the picture of asymmetric rotor is meaningful, see Sect. 4.4 of Ref. [2]. In the so-called -soft nuclei, it is expected that triaxial shapes are stabilized by alignments. According to this expectation, the experimental data of and after the -band crossing were examined in Ref. [12] but the results were not conclusive. And accordingly, no information was available about in what nuclei, at what spins, and with what , wobbling motion appears.
Owing to the great developments of gamma ray detectors such as Euroball from the 1990’s, the first firm data on wobbling excited on top of the triaxial super-/strongly deformed (TSD) band in was reported in 2001 [17]. In Ref. [17], the wobbling band, named TSD2, is excited on top of the yrast TSD band, TSD1, which is expected to be strongly deformed such as and . Note here that the sign of is important as discussed below. In addition to the characteristic energy spectra; parallel to TSD1 and the opposite signature quantum number, the interband transition probabilities, that prove large collectivity and to which Liotta and Sorensen paid attention, were also reported in the form of ratios to the inband rotational . Similar bands were also found in nearby nuclei, and [18, 19, 20, 21]. These experimental results that wobbling excitations were found in odd- nuclei, rather than in even-even nuclei being expected to have simpler structure, opened up rich theoretical studies.
Theoretical models
The first realistic calculation was done by Hamamoto [17, 22] in terms of the particle-rotor model (PRM), given by (1) replacing in the Hamiltonian of the asymmetric rotor model by , where , and are the -th components of the angular momentum of the rotor, the total system and the valence unpaired particle in the single- shell, respectively, and (2) adding its deformed potential. The former procedure produces the Coriolis coupling . The essential input parameters in the PRM are MOI as in the original asymmetric rotor model. Those of the irrotational model, whose dependence is accepted aside from its absolute magnitude, are often adopted.
For the Lu isotopes in which wobbling excitations were observed, the equilibrium shape is understood to be (in the Lund convention) because of the shape driving effect of the odd-. This means as can be seen in Figure 1, if the irrotational model is adopted. This would lead to an imaginary . In order to avoid this, Hamamoto [22] inverted the sign of in the irrotational MOI of the rotor. The result reproduced the characteristics of the data including the collective interband transitions well. But the physical reasoning of this inversion was not clear.
Matsuzaki et al. [23] found from the viewpoint of the nucleonic mean field that the physical reason why wobbling exists in odd- nuclei could be traced back to character of the models; only the rotor that represents the (even) nucleons rotates in the PRM, whereas full nucleons rotate in the cranked RPA description. They confirmed that of the full -body could become larger than by virtue of the alignment of the last odd proton in the high- orbital, in spite of the main rotation about the shortest axis in the positive- rotation scheme. With increasing , its contribution is getting relatively weak in comparison with that of increasing collective angular momentum. Then, approaches zero, as in the cases of Fig. 5 in Ref. [6], consequently does. In other words, the wobbling excitation becomes unstable.
This is contrary to a naive expectation that it is proportional to the total angular momentum provided MOI do not depend on . This is a characteristic of the wobbling excited around the shortest-axis rotation. This mechanism can be translated into the PRM picture as shown in Ref. [6]. Similar expressions were presented in Ref. [24] ten years later.
This work of Frauendorf and Dönau [24] clarified the two physically different types of wobbling motion described in rather complicated convention-dependent terminology such as “wobbling on positive- rotation” so far. As discussed above, must be fulfilled for wobbling excitation to exist when the main rotation is about the axis. In usual situations, collective rotation occurs about the axis of the intermediate length — the negative- rotation according to the Lund convention. The wobbling excitation in this scheme, which was considered by Bohr and Mottelson, was named longitudinal wobbling. On the other hand, collective rotation occurs about the shortest axis in the cases of the positive- rotation according to the Lund convention. The situation that prevents wobbling from occurring is dissolved by the alignment of the last odd nucleon as shown in [23]. The wobbling excitation in this scheme, which was thought to be realized in Lu isotopes, was named transverse wobbling. Consequently, two types of wobbling can be transparently designated with the shape parameter runs only - , by not restricting the main collective rotation to the axis.
PERSPECTIVE
Generally speaking, there are two paths to approach when one investigates an unknown phenomenon: One is to set up a phenomenological variable directly relevant to that phenomenon and the other is to look for how that phenomenon emerges from underlying degrees of freedom in the sub hierarchy. In the case of nuclear wobbling motion in odd- nuclei, the former corresponds to the PRM and the latter to the cranked RPA. The former is a fully quantum model for two vector degrees of freedom, but MOI, the most decisive internal quantities to determine experimental observables, energy spectra and transition probabilities between energy levels, are input parameters. Recently, fingerprints of wobbling motion in nuclei with normal or weak deformations in various mass regions are reported. Results of various input MOI for these data are intensively studied in Ref. [25], for example.
The latter is a quantum many-body model but the rotation is introduced as an external field. Whether collective wobbling excitation appears or not is determined as a response of the many-body system to the external field. When a wobbling state appears among huge number of normal modes, MOI are calculated at the same time as its excitation energy, as a linear response of the whole nucleus to the externally exerted rotation.
Its another virtue as a many-body model is to exhibit a general notion of symmetry breaking and associated soft modes, “the phase transition of the mean field” in other words, although they are in an approximated manner because of the finiteness,
a spherical mean field becomes unstable as the quadrupole vibration excited on top of it softens, then an axially-symmetric mean field substitutes,
this axially-symmetric mean field can become unstable as the vibration softens, then a triaxially-deformed mean field substitutes.
Similarly to these well-known cases,
the one-dimensionally rotating triaxial mean field, (irrespective of the axis of rotation,) may become unstable as the wobbling mode softens, then a two- or three-dimensionally tilted-axis rotating mean field [26] substitutes [27, 28, 29],
as its variant in weakly deformed cases, a mean field rotating about the shortest axis becomes unstable as the transverse wobbling mode softens with (with an adequate relabeling), via a tilted-axis rotation, then that rotating about the intermediate axis, which is a usual collective rotation and might support the longitudinal wobbling mode, substitutes,
are relevant for the wobbling modes.
On the other hand, some limitations and future problems exist:
Conceptually, since the one-dimensional rotation is semiclassically introduced and fluctuations around it are treated within a small amplitude approximation,
the cranking picture is not very accurate for relatively low spin states in which angular-momentum vectors are inferred to wobble with rather large amplitudes,
multi-phonon states are beyond the scope, although anharmonicities in the spectra, , seen in the rotating frame [29] were found experimentally [30].
Numerically,
beyond the traditional RPA calculations with schematic separable (pairing plus quadrupole-quadrupole or its generalization [31]) residual interactions, the finite amplitude method (FAM) [32] calculations based on the Skyrme (and other types) energy density functionals are already available for collective vibrational states [33], for example. Three MOI including effects of residual interactions are desirable for non-uniform rotational motions.
Deep understanding of the responses of the nuclear many-body systems to rapid rotations, in particular those related to the stability of the collective wobbling modes in triaxial nuclei, is expected as soon as the limitations addressed here are resolved.
References
- [1]L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics (Pergamon, London, 1960).
- [2]A. Bohr and B. R. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure, Vol. 2 (Benjamin, New York, 1975).
- [3]S. Golden and J. K. Bragg, J. Chem. Phys. 17, 439 (1949).
- [4]G. Andersson et al., Nucl. Phys. A 268, 205 (1976).
- [5]R. J. Liotta and R. A. Sorensen, Nucl. Phys. A 297, 136 (1978).
- [6]Y. R. Shimizu, M. Matsuzaki, and K. Matsuyanagi, in Proc. Fifth Japan-China Joint Nuclear Physics Symp., edited by Y. Gono, N. Ikeda, and K. Ogata (Kyushu Univ., Fukuoka, Japan, 2004) p. 317, arXiv:nucl-th/0404063.
- [7]I. N. Mikhailov and D. Matsuzaki, Nucl. Phys. B 72, 303 (1978).
- [8]E. R. Marshalek, Nucl. Phys. A 331, 429 (1979).
- [9]M. Matsuzaki, Y. R. Shimizu, and K. Matsuyanagi, Phys. Rev. C 69, 034325 (2004).
- [10]M. Matsuzaki, Nucl. Phys. A 509, 269 (1990).
- [11]D. Janssen and I. N. Mikhailov, Nucl. Phys. A 318, 390 (1979).
- [12]Y. R. Shimizu and M. Matsuzaki, Nucl. Phys. A 588, 559
- [13]N. Onishi, Nucl. Phys. A 456, 279 (1986).
- [14]K. Kaneko, Phys. Rev. C 45, 2754 (1992).
- [15]L. Wilets and M. Jean, Phys. Rev. 102, 788 (1956).
- [16]A. S. Davydov and G. F. Filippov, Nucl. Phys. 8, 237 (1958).
- [17]S. W. Ødegård et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 5866 (2001).
- [18]P. Bringel et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 24, 169 (2005).
- [19]G. Shoenwasser et al., Phys. Lett. B 552, 9 (2003).
- [20]H. Amro et al., Phys. Lett. B 553, 197 (2003).
- [21]D. J. Hartley et al., Phys. Rev. C 80, 041304 (2009).
- [22]I. Hamamoto, Phys. Rev. C 65, 044305 (2002).
- [23]M. Matsuzaki, Y. R. Shimizu, and K. Matsuyanagi, Phys. Rev. C 65, 041303(R) (2002).
- [24]S. Fraundorf and F. Dönau, Phys. Rev. C 89, 014322 (2014).
- [25]H. Zhang et al., Phys. Rev. C 105, 034339 (2022).
- [26]H. Frisk and R. Bengtsson, Phys. Lett. B 196, 14 (1987).
- [27]F. Cuypers, Nucl. Phys. A 468, 237 (1987).
- [28]W. D. Heiss and R. G. Nazmitdinov, Phys. Rev. C 65, 054304 (2002).
- [29]M. Matsuzaki and S.-I. Ohtsubo, Phys. Rev. C 69, 064317 (2004).
- [30]D. R. Jensen et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 142503 (2002).
- [31]T. Shoji and Y. R. Shimizu, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 15, 1407 (2006).
- [32]T. Nakatsukasa, T. Inakura, and K. Yabana, Phys. Rev. C 76, 024318 (2007).
- [33]N. Hinohara, M. Kortelainen, and W. Nazarewicz, Phys. Rev. C 87, 064309 (2013).
