WorksPhysics and Astronomy
An Effective Theory for Hot Lines
Abstract
We develop a high-temperature effective theory for spatial conformal line defects in theories with thermal screening. The defect partition function admits a local geometric expansion, whose leading terms describe the effective tension and bending response of the line. Using a convergent bulk OPE for heavy-state defect matrix elements, we derive asymptotic relations for averaged products of defect one-point coefficients and bulk OPE coefficients in the regime . We compute the leading EFT coefficients for a twisted free scalar and for the magnetic line at the Wilson-Fisher fixed point, large- Gross–Neveu model and Chern-Simons-matter theory. For the three-dimensional Ising model, Monte Carlo simulations yield a perimeter coefficient in good agreement with a Padé interpolation of our -expansion result.
Introduction and summary
Conformal field theories (CFTs) describe the universal behavior of systems at continuous phase transitions and, more generally, fixed points of renormalization-group flows [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. Their correlation functions are encoded in the conformal data: scaling dimensions and operator product expansion (OPE) coefficients. Considerable progress has been made in determining and constraining these data through numerical and analytic bootstrap methods [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15].
Beyond local correlation functions, one can study finite-temperature observables, such as the free energy and thermal correlation functions. Although these are also determined by the conformal data, their dependence on the full spectrum and OPE coefficients makes them difficult to compute directly, motivating complementary approaches [16, 17]. Conversely, thermal observables provide access to asymptotic properties of conformal data, including the growth of the density of states described by Cardy-type formulas [18, 19, 20] and the behavior of heavy-state three-point coefficients [21, 22, 23].
A useful approach is to place the theory on a thermal background , where is the circumference of the Euclidean time circle and is the spatial manifold. Thermal periodicity, encoded in the Kubo–Martin–Schwinger (KMS) condition, constrains correlation functions and provides the basis for thermal bootstrap methods [24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29]. In the high-temperature limit, becomes small compared with the characteristic spatial scales, and locality allows the leading terms of the partition function to be expressed in terms of local geometric data [20, 30, 31, 32, 33].
Conformal defects introduce additional observables, such as defect partition functions and correlation functions, whose description requires data beyond those of the bulk CFT. These include the spectrum of defect operators and bulk-to-defect OPE coefficients [34]. Bootstrap, perturbative, and effective field theory methods have provided complementary results for conformal defects [35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43]. More recently, conformal defects have also been studied at finite temperature [44, 45, 46, 47, 48], but the relation between their thermal behavior and zero-temperature conformal data remains less understood.
In this paper, we develop a high-temperature effective theory for conformal line defects supported on spatial curves.1 We focus on the spherical geometry illustrated in Figure 1, where the defect lies at fixed Euclidean time rather than wrapping the thermal circle. At high temperature, the bulk admits an effective description in dimensions. Provided the thermal response to the defect is screened, its contribution to the partition function can be organized in a local geometric expansion along .2
Figure 1. Spatial line defect supported on a latitude at polar angle of the sphere , with Euclidean time compactified on .
Here, denotes the temperature-independent contribution, while and control the effective tension and bending response of the line, respectively. describes the combined ambient-curvature coefficient. The omitted terms involve higher-order geometric invariants, including contributions from the curvature of the spatial manifold.
Under the assumptions detailed in § 3, we further show that the thermal EFT determines the asymptotic behavior of averaged products of defect one-point coefficients and bulk OPE coefficients. The derivation relies on a bulk OPE representation of heavy-state defect matrix elements, building on the known convergence properties of Euclidean OPE expansions [55, 56]. We obtain
in the regime . Here is the defect one-point coefficient of an operator of dimension , and is its bulk OPE coefficient with two heavy operators of dimension . We have also defined , where is the zero-temperature defect expectation value, while denotes the coefficient of the leading high-temperature bulk free energy in the absence of the defect.
This result also admits a thermal interpretation under the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH). If the heavy states created by are typical, their heavy-heavy-light OPE coefficients can be related to thermal one-point functions. Under these assumptions, we obtain up to kinematic factor
where denotes the thermal one-point coefficient of .
We illustrate the effective field theory (EFT) in a twisted free scalar theory and compute its leading coefficients for the magnetic line at the Wilson–Fisher fixed point in the -expansion, the large Gross–Neveu model and the Chern–Simons matter theory. The latter is particular interesting since, differently from the others, the leading EFT coefficient is positive. We also study the case of the three-dimensional Ising model and determine the value of the leading EFT coefficient using Monte Carlo simulations and find good agreement with a Padé interpolation of our perturbative results. A recap of the results for in the various model is provided in Table 1.
| Model | method | |
| Antiperiodic Free Scalar | 0.346... | Exact |
| O() model in | eq. (72) | Perturbative in |
| Ising model () | Monte Carlo | |
| Ising model () | Padé extrapolation | |
| Gross-Neveu at large | Large | |
| Chern-Simons matter | Large |
Table 1. Prediction for the leading EFT coefficient in various models. indicated the conformal coupling of the defect (when indicated the model enjoy a continuum of conformal defects varying the coupling ).
The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. In § 2, we develop the effective theory in Equation (1) and discuss the physical interpretation of its leading coefficients. In § 3, we relate the thermal EFT to asymptotic conformal data and derive Equation (2). Finally, in § 4, we illustrate the EFT in a twisted free scalar theory, compute its leading coefficients for the magnetic line at the O() Wilson–Fisher fixed point, the case of the Gross-Neveu model at large and the Chern-Simons matter theory and the three-dimensional Ising model via Monte Carlo simulations, comparing the numerical results with perturbative ones.
Thermal effective theory for line defects
We consider a conformal field theory on in the presence of a conformal line defect supported on a circle of radius . The circle lies on a fixed two-sphere , with denoting its polar angle. We introduce finite temperature by compactifying the Euclidean time direction on a circle of circumference . The resulting geometry is , as illustrated in Figure 1.
In the high-temperature regime, , the nonzero Matsubara modes can be integrated out, yielding an effective field theory in dimensions. We expect this EFT to simplify further in the presence of thermal screening. In particular, we assume that connected correlation functions in the presence of the defect decay exponentially at large spatial separations,
where is a local bulk operator, denotes the spatial separation, and is the characteristic screening length. The correlator is understood to be normalized by the defect expectation value. When the characteristic length scale of the defect is much larger than the screening length, and no additional long-range contributions to the defect free energy are present, we expect the effective theory to be governed by local geometric invariants of the defect embedding. For the circular defect considered here, this requires
For more general curves, we also require that segments well separated along the defect do not approach each other within the screening length. Under these assumptions, we write down the effective action for a generic smooth spatial defect, independently of its precise shape. More precisely, on the round spatial sphere, the logarithm of the defect partition function admits the local derivative expansion
Here, and are the thermal partition functions with and without the defect, and is the proper length element along . The vector is the curvature of the line within the spatial sphere, and is the corresponding normal-bundle covariant derivative. For a latitude , the length is and . The coefficients , , , and are dimensionless and play the following roles:
The term is independent of temperature and includes the normalization dependence of the defect.
The coefficient multiplies the line length and is therefore the perimeter coefficient. Its leading contribution per unit length is
The corresponding excess free energy per unit length has the opposite sign.
The coefficient measures the response to bending after the perimeter contribution is accounted for, while measures the response to ambient curvature. At the equator, the bending term vanishes but the ambient-curvature term remains.
At order , and govern quartic-curvature and curvature-gradient terms, while and govern mixed and purely ambient-curvature terms.
In the locally flat limit, the terms involving vanish; for a smooth line whose curvature radius is much larger than and the screening length, gives the leading shape correction, while the terms are suppressed. § 4 uses this limit to determine and , while § 3 uses to constrain asymptotic conformal data under the assumptions stated there.
Asymptotic conformal data from the thermal EFT
In this section, we use the thermal EFT to derive asymptotic constraints on zero-temperature conformal data. We first express the defect partition function as a thermal trace and determine the asymptotic behavior of defect matrix elements in heavy states. We then use a convergent bulk OPE representation of primary-state matrix elements to constrain averaged products of defect one-point coefficients and bulk OPE coefficients.
High-energy defect matrix elements
The defect in our setup, shown in Figure 1, can be inserted into the thermal trace over the Hilbert space on the spatial sphere:
where denotes the scaling dimension of the state , and the sum includes both primary states and their descendants. To study the high-energy asymptotics, it is convenient to express this trace in terms of the density of all states:
Here, is the density of states, and the overline denotes an average over all states with scaling dimension near including both primaries and descendants. The thermal trace converges for , while the thermal EFT derived in § 2 applies at high temperature, provided the defect is much larger than the screening length. In this regime, it predicts
where is the bulk free-energy coefficient.
For comparison, the partition function without the defect is
with the high-temperature expansion
The leading term determines the leading heavy-state entropy; subleading corrections and further applications are discussed in [20]. We denote by the constant term in ; it equals if no constant bulk term has been omitted from (11).
To extract data of primary states, we must first organize the trace into conformal multiplets. Let and let labels a primary of dimension and spin . The exact defect trace can be written as
where operates on the conformal multiplet associated to the primary operator labeled by : the defect thermal block includes every descendant of . For a generic long multiplet, the corresponding unrefined character is . Define as the trace of over the primary spin multiplet, divided by . For the heavy multiplets contributing at the inverse-Laplace saddle, the defect thermal block is expected to obey
This holds uniformly as in the angular regime used below. Writing
we then have
An inverse Laplace transform of (11), evaluated by the saddle-point method, gives the Cardy-type asymptotics
As , the saddle approaches the high-temperature limit, . The primary density has the same leading exponential growth: for long multiplets, , so removing descendants changes only the power-law prefactor.
More precisely, define the primary density and the defect-weighted primary density by
By (14), these densities are obtained by inverse Laplace transforming and , respectively. For , the defect term is subleading to the bulk saddle-point action, and the common character factor cancels in their ratio. In the small-angle regime used below, this gives
where
At fixed , the leading term still controls the logarithm, but in the shift of the thermal saddle can affect the order-one prefactor.
Bulk OPE and asymptotic conformal data
We now apply the bulk OPE to the matrix element of an individual primary, before averaging over primary states. For the explicit scalar OPE below, we take the heavy operator to be a scalar primary of dimension . The unrefined trace in (7) also contains spinning primaries; using (19) for the scalar-primary average therefore requires a scalar-spin projection whose defect-to-bulk ratio has the same term and, for the prefactor below, the same , or an independent treatment of spinning primaries. We make this additional assumption in the following matching. At first sight, the matrix element does not appear to admit a bulk OPE expansion. In the corresponding flat-space configuration, the defect lies between the two insertions of . However, a suitable conformal inversion maps the straight defect to a circle, leaving the insertions in a common region where the bulk OPE converges, as illustrated in Figure 2. The resulting bulk OPE involves one-point functions of local operators in the presence of the defect, whose form is fixed by the preserved conformal symmetry up to their coefficients. Normalizing by and denoting the normalized defect one-point coefficient by , we obtain
Figure 2. A conformal inversion maps the straight line defect to a circle. In the transformed configuration, the two bulk insertions of a scalar primary lie in a region where the bulk OPE converges.
Here is the bulk OPE coefficient and is the corresponding conformal block. Although these blocks are not known in closed form in general dimensions, their large- behavior is known [56, 57]:
Here , while encodes the spin dependence, with denoting the angular polynomials for the exchanged symmetric traceless representations [56, 57]. For identical scalar external operators, only even spins contribute. The asymptotic form (22) must also remain valid in the double limit used below, where becomes large and becomes small.
The descendants of are already included in the defect thermal block (12); this is why the thermal inversion can be interpreted as a statement about primaries only after (13) is imposed. Let denote the average of over scalar primaries with in a narrow window around , and set
Using the assumed scalar-primary version of (19) and retaining the leading term at small , we obtain
where was defined in (20). The inverse transform in the angular variable constrains the OPE-weighted spectral density , understood after suitable smoothing in ; it does not isolate an individual OPE coefficient.
To extract the contribution at large dimension , we formally invert this expansion and evaluate the resulting integral by the saddle-point method. The saddle-point condition is
For , the relevant real saddle lies on the branch . In the regime , it approaches
The saddle-point approximation then gives
where the asymptotic relation concerns a suitably smoothed density in and assumes that cancellations among signed OPE weights do not invalidate the saddle estimate. The saddle lies within the regime of validity of the thermal EFT provided
Assuming that the EFT coefficients are of order ,3 the parametric window is . The result (27) is a constraint on the averaged spectral density , with included in its definition (23).
Note that what done before is rigorously speaking only valid for which means for . In the example below we will show that for some models the value of is positive while in other cases, e.g. the Ising model, is negative. In the cases in which is negative, the derivation of the asymptotic is less trivial: a direct analytic continuation of equation (27) would bring a complex phase of the form 4; this is clearly not physical and has to be interpreted in an average sense. A less disturbing way of presenting this result is to consider the absolute value in both sided: mathematically this is justified with the additional assumption that the thermal EFT proposed in this paper rule the partition function for in the whole complex -plane.
Before concluding, we observe that another possible expansion expresses the defect itself in terms of local bulk operators [53]. This expansion applies when the defect is sufficiently small and has a finite radius of convergence, as can be seen in simple free-field examples at finite temperature. In our setup, the relevant small-defect regime is , in contrast with the large-defect regime required by the thermal EFT. The two expansions therefore describe different limits of the defect partition function, making a direct comparison between them less straightforward.
Applications
In this section, we examine the scope and coefficients of the thermal line EFT in three examples. For a free scalar, periodic thermal boundary conditions leave an unscreened mode, while a -twisted trace gives a screened example whose perimeter and shape coefficients can be computed exactly. At the Wilson–Fisher fixed point, we compute the magnetic line’s perimeter coefficient through order and its leading bending coefficient . Finally, Monte Carlo simulations of the critical three-dimensional Ising model provide an estimate of , which we compare with a Padé interpolation of the result constrained by the exact value.
Free scalar field
We begin with the simplest example: a line defect in the free scalar theory in . Since the theory is Gaussian, the defect expectation value is computed exactly by a single propagator and the flat-space coefficients can be obtained in closed form. Unfortunately, with the standard thermal boundary conditions the defect is not screened, and the EFT does not apply. Screening, and with it the EFT, is restored by twisting the boundary conditions along the thermal circle by the symmetry .
Setup
Action. The bulk action and line insertion are given by
Since , the coupling is exactly marginal and is a conformal line defect for every value of . Because the theory is Gaussian, the logarithm of the defect expectation value is given exactly by a single propagator joining two source insertions,
We use dimensional regularization with temperature-independent counterterms, as in the rest of this section. In particular, the power divergence at coincident points does not contribute.
Boundary conditions. We consider two choices of boundary conditions along the thermal circle,
The periodic choice computes the standard thermal trace. The antiperiodic choice inserts the generator in the trace, and computes
We denote the periodic result by . The defect is odd under , so moving the twist across the line flips . Since depends only on , the position of the twist is immaterial. Now we will consider a circle of radius in flat space. The integrals along the circle can be performed in closed form, giving
Periodic scalar
For periodic boundary conditions, the sum is dominated by , and
This logarithmic growth lies outside the local thermal EFT because the periodic static mode is unscreened. But it is not surprising since for periodic boundary conditions we expect an appearance of the gapless mode. The same computation applies to the setup of § 3, with the latitude on . Using the propagator on , we find
On the sphere, the conformal coupling gives the static mode a mass , so the periodic sum converges. The logarithm is then cut off by the radius of the sphere,
In the limit at fixed , this reproduces (35).
Antiperiodic scalar
With antiperiodic boundary conditions, the images in (36) alternate in sign, and the harmonic series is replaced by a convergent alternating series,
Matching to (52), we obtain
For antiperiodic boundary conditions we can even make more. Since decays exponentially, only points separated by contribute to (31) for a smooth curve. The full derivative expansion of (5) can then be obtained by expanding the distance between two points of the curve. Let be the proper length along , , the unit tangent vector, and the extrinsic-curvature vector. Then
where dots denote derivatives with respect to in the ambient space. We insert this into (31) and use . After integrating by parts along , this gives
where the moments of the propagator are
and is the Dirichlet eta function. For , the integral is defined in dimensional regularization. Explicitly, , and .
Matching (41) to (5), we obtain
These results are exact in . Every term in (41) is an odd power of , so up to corrections exponentially small in the size of the defect. The bending coefficient can also be computed from the general Gaussian formula .
In the language of § 3, the twisted trace weighs each state by its charge,
In the interacting examples below, no twist is needed: screening is generated dynamically by the thermal mass.
Magnetic line at the Wilson–Fisher fixed point
We consider the Wilson–Fisher theory in on , with a magnetic line embedded in the spatial sphere at fixed Euclidean time. The goal is to compare explicit calculations in the regime to the effective action (5) in order to determine and .
Setup
Action. The bulk action and line insertion are given by
with . Here, is the conformal curvature coupling, is the determinant of the metric, and is the scalar curvature of , while is the proper length element along . We set the renormalization scale to and define
Note that counterterms are temperature-independent and thus we can use the zero-temperature ones.
Fixed point and thermal mass. At the Wilson–Fisher magnetic-line fixed point, the couplings in our normalization obey
Since , the thermal theory has separated scales. The zero-frequency mode acquires a mass of order . Although the line at fixed Euclidean time sources all modes, its response at distances much larger than is governed by the zero mode. We define the static mode by
Integrating out the nonzero modes gives an effective -dimensional theory for . Its line-sourced profile supplies the long-distance part of the perimeter coefficient in (5). The thermal mass of the bulk theory can be written at leading order as
Here is the leading mass parameter of the reduced theory; fluctuations of the static field correct the physical screening mass at higher order.
To extract the perimeter coefficient of (5), we consider a portion of the line whose curvature radius is much larger than the screening length . For a latitude at angle on the spatial sphere, this requires . Imposing this condition before taking at fixed , this gives the hierarchy
The response on the screening scale can therefore be computed using a straight line in flat space.
The perimeter coefficient
For an infinite straight line, the perimeter coefficient is determined by the term in proportional to the line length,
where denotes the length of the line. We determine both the logarithmic and finite terms as at fixed .
Since is the logarithm of the defect expectation value, it is computed by connected diagrams with source insertions on the line. The simplest contribution joins two source insertions by a single bulk propagator. We first evaluate this Gaussian contribution, with the leading thermal mass included in the static propagator. We then include diagrams with quartic interactions between static fields. As we explain below, these also contribute to the finite term and are summed by a nonlinear static profile.
Gaussian contribution. The Gaussian contribution comes from a single bulk propagator joining two source insertions on the line,
The propagator includes both the nonzero Matsubara modes and the static mode with its leading thermal mass. This accounts for distances of order , where the reduced static theory alone is insufficient. The propagator is evaluated in the bulk thermal theory without the defect insertion; the defect enters through the two source vertices.
Let denote the separation between two points on the straight line at the same Euclidean time. We denote by the propagator of between these points, with the leading thermal mass included in its static mode. At the order needed here, we evaluate it in four dimensions. For , it is given by
The first term is the massless thermal propagator. The second replaces its massless static contribution by the massive one.
The Gaussian contribution to , denoted by , is quadratic in the line source:
where we regulated coincident points with a small separation cutoff. This gives the logarithmic contribution to the perimeter coefficient, with its finite normalization fixed by including all Matsubara modes. It also includes the Gaussian static contribution, which must be accounted for when adding the nonlinear correction.
Nonlinear static contribution. We now compute the finite correction from connected static tree diagrams with quartic bulk vertices. We sum these diagrams by evaluating the nonlinear saddle and subtracting the Gaussian static contribution already included above:
Circles denote source insertions, squares represent quartic vertices, and thin lines are static propagators with thermal mass ; the thick horizontal line represents . Although , integration over the screening region gives the dimensionless combination
Since remains finite as , arbitrarily many quartic vertices contribute at the same order.
To obtain the finite correction to the perimeter coefficient, we first determine the screened field profile sourced by a straight line. We then evaluate its on-shell action and subtract the Gaussian static contribution already included above. At leading order in , the saddle is rotationally symmetric in the two transverse spatial dimensions. For , we write its nonzero component as
where is the distance from the straight line and . At this order, the profile equation and boundary conditions are
The Gaussian reference at the same and is , with the modified Bessel function. Both profiles have the same logarithmic singularity; their finite constants are defined by
where is Euler’s constant. is a constant that depends however on . It can be determined for any choice of . plays the same role for the reference profile.
The Gaussian calculation already includes the static response without quartic interactions. We therefore compare the nonlinear saddle with a Gaussian saddle at the same source strength and thermal mass, isolating the additional interaction contribution without counting the Gaussian term twice. Their common short-distance divergence cancels in the difference. Using a common short-distance regulator , the difference of the two on-shell static actions gives the finite correction
Here, as explained above, includes the line source and quartic interaction, and has the same source and mass but no quartic interaction. The contribution can be expressed as
We evaluate by solving the radial equation numerically, extracting , and computing the convergent integral. The resulting values in Table 2 determine the nonlinear contribution at order .
| 1 | |||
| 2 | |||
| 3 | |||
| 4 | |||
| 10 | |||
Table 2. Leading small- values of the finite profile correction , the fluctuation coefficient , and the perimeter coefficient through order . The last row takes after the small- calculation and reports and in the last two columns. The estimated numerical uncertainty of the computed coefficients is , separate from omitted higher-order terms.
First fluctuation correction. We now compute the order- correction by integrating fluctuations around the nonlinear static profile. Keeping terms quadratic in these fluctuations gives a one-loop determinant whose operators depend on the profile. After renormalization, this static loop contributes an amount of order per unit line length (more precisely: to the dimensionless coefficient ). The determinant includes static loop diagrams with arbitrarily many source insertions, so correcting the bulk propagator in the two-source diagram alone would be insufficient. Small fluctuations around the line profile are governed by two operators: for the sourced field component and for each of the other components. They are defined as
with , and where acts in three spatial dimensions at this order of the -expansion. Dividing their Gaussian functional integral by the defect-free one gives
The straight line allows us to Fourier transform along it, with momentum . Because depends only on the transverse distance to the defect, we may decompose each two-dimensional transverse operator into angular-momentum channels. For each and angular momentum, we compute a radial determinant relative to the defect-free operator, sum the channels, and integrate over . The first-order term in the profile-dependent potential must be treated separately. With , the prescription is
where here the index should be understood as . The last term is the finite first-order contribution in dimensional regularization. It already accounts for the soft thermal-mass correction, so we do not add that correction again. We denote this contribution by
Numerical evaluation of the determinants gives the results presented in Table 2.
Final result. We now add the finite static correction at and the first fluctuation correction to the Gaussian thermal result. This gives
Matching to Equation (52), we obtain
Using the leading thermal mass, we can write the result as
Note that the nonlinear profile contributes to the finite term already at leading order. In Table 2, we provide the explicit -expanded expression for specific .
and Padé interpolation for . In , the magnetic line cuts the thermal cylinder into a strip of width with identical fixed-spin boundary conditions. After the temperature-independent perimeter subtraction, comparing the strip and cylinder vacuum energies gives
To interpolate between and , we approximate by a Padé in . Matching the constant and terms of the expansion above and imposing the exact value at gives
At , this yields the prediction .
The bending coefficient
To extract , we consider a weakly deformed spatial line in flat thermal space at fixed Euclidean time,
Here is distance along the undeformed line, is the amplitude, and is the wave number. We take and before , at fixed . For a projected length containing an integer number of wavelengths, the EFT predicts the quadratic response relative to the straight line ,
The term accounts for the increase in length and is fixed by . Matching the term therefore determines .
Gaussian contribution. We compute the diagram (53) with the bent line. For a fixed separation measured along the line, bending brings the source insertions closer in space and changes the propagator joining them. Expanding this change to second order in curvature gives the Gaussian bending coefficient:
The nonzero Matsubara modes do not affect the leading term. The factor reflects the transverse size of the screening cloud: a broader cloud is more sensitive to bending. However, as in the perimeter calculation, the finite value of requires the nonlinear static interactions to be included at leading order.
Nonlinear static contribution. We include these interactions by computing the response of the straight-line profile to a small bend. This uses the same profile and coordinate as in the perimeter calculation. A uniform transverse displacement simply translates the profile, producing a change proportional to . When the displacement varies along the line, the surrounding field must also adjust to the curvature.
We describe this adjustment by a radial function . For local curvature directed along the transverse angle , the first curvature correction to the static field is . Linearizing the field equation about the nonlinear profile gives
The term comes from the angular dependence of a transverse displacement, while the term proportional to accounts for the interaction with the screening cloud. Thus the additional equation is linear even though the background profile is nonlinear. Keeping the line source fixed and requiring decay far from the defect selects
After the contribution from the change in length has been accounted for, the on-shell action expresses the bending coefficient as
The integral measures the overlap between the translation of the original profile and its additional response to curvature. It is convergent at both endpoints. Numerically, we therefore reuse the straight-line solution, solve one linear radial equation, and evaluate this integral. This expression includes the Gaussian contribution: inserting gives and reproduces (77) at leading order.
Final result. The leading bending coefficient takes the form
with the values of listed in Table 3. The nonlinear response reduces the Gaussian estimate substantially, confirming that the same static interactions needed for the perimeter coefficient are also essential for bending.
| 1 | 0.256469 | 0.138484 |
| 2 | 0.237472 | 0.137326 |
| 3 | 0.229872 | 0.139044 |
Table 3. Leading coefficients in the manuscript convention. The Gaussian comparison keeps the same source strength and thermal mass.
In our convention, means that bending increases after the perimeter contribution has been accounted for. The result determines the leading small- coefficient; fluctuations about the saddle are expected to give relative corrections of order and are not included here. The expansion remains valid when the deformation wavelength is much larger than the screening length.
3d Ising model
The Ising model cannot be treated analytically, if not as a limit of the -expansion discussed above or a limit of a proper large expansion. None of these options is supposed to be a good approximation and for this reason we are forced to study the model numerically and simulate it on a lattice.5
Lattice model and defect observable
We study the critical three-dimensional Ising model on a periodic isotropic cubic lattice,
with spins and bulk partition function
The coupling is the flat-space critical Ising coupling (computed e.g. in [58, 59]) and is held fixed throughout the calculation. Compactifying Euclidean time does not entail a new tuning of the bulk critical point. Our purpose is to check the EFT in equation (5) and predict the first coefficients in the high temperature expansion. For this purpose the fact that the spatial manifold is not a sphere as in the derivation of the asymptotic is not important: the EFT has to be valid in any manifold in the high temperature limit.
Perimeter coefficient for the straight line
The defect is a closed magnetic line , placed at one Euclidean-time slice and rasterized as a spatial circle of radius . Its physical definition is the fixed-spin operator
It constrains every spin on the loop to be up. This is the strong-field representative of the symmetry-breaking magnetic line fixed point. It is a local codimension-two defect: no sheet of modified bonds, frustrated plaquette, or change of bulk holonomy is introduced.
For the free-energy measurement we introduce an auxiliary line field,
The subtraction by 1 is essential: a spin already fixed to contributes unit weight, while a down spin costs a factor . Thus is only an auxiliary thermodynamic-integration coordinate.
Define
Since , differentiation gives
where and counts down spins on the loop. The desired defect one-point function is therefore obtained directly from
This formula already divides by the bulk partition function. Hence it measures the logarithm of the normalized defect one-point function, not the global bulk free energy.
The integral is evaluated up to a sufficiently large . The omitted tail is exponentially bounded. In fact it is easy to show that
The final uncertainty combines Monte-Carlo statistics, and this tail estimate.
Perimeter coefficient for the straight line
Further details of the simulations are given in Appendix § 6. The results are shown in the left panel of Figure 3.

Figure 3. Left Panel: The partition-function ratio in the three-dimensional Ising model as a function of . Orange points show the Monte Carlo data, and the black line shows the fit motivated by the thermal EFT. Right panel: Fit of in : the slope of the linear fit is expected to be .
At large , the data are consistent with the leading EFT prediction. Writing for the geometry considered here, this prediction takes the form
And we should substract from the coefficient the scheme dependent contribution contribution, that could be obtained by studying ths system at zero temperature. A fit to the simulation data gives
with a reduced chi-squared of .6 Thus we need to find the temperature dependent part. We therefore performed a new, eight-point Monte Carlo scan for various ,7 placing a straight, spatially wrapping pinned line along the direction in boxes with and . At each temperature we simulated various pinning fields between and . We used Bennett’s acceptance-ratio method8 to determine the free-energy difference between neighboring fields from the measured line magnetization, thereby avoiding a numerical quadrature of the field-dependent expectation value. After subtracting the known large-field normalization, we obtained the free energy per unit line length, , and fitted it to
The weighted linear fit yields The plot compared with the fit is shown in the right panel of Figure 3.
Longer chains and further finite-size studies are still needed for a controlled continuum estimate more accurately but we leave them for future studies.
Finally, let us compare the Monte Carlo prediction with the Padé extrapolation from the -expansion. The function of is given in equation (74) and plotted in Figure 4. In 3d the approximations gives which, considering solely the statistical error from Monte Carlo, it matches up to , confirming the prediction.

Figure 4. The Padé extrapolation for the value of as a function of compared with Monte Carlo result for 3d Ising (red point) and exact result in 2D Ising (blue dot).
Large-N Gross–Neveu model
Setup
Action. We consider two-component Dirac fermions in with the action
at the critical coupling. Since \det(i\slashed{Q}+\sigma)=Q^2+\sigma^2, integrating out the fermions gives
The field is odd under the discrete symmetry that forbids a fermion mass. At large , its dimension is , with a negative correction.
Line. We define and the unit-normalized operator , and consider
The connected -point functions of scale as . At , is therefore a Gaussian field of dimension one, and is a conformal line for every .
Thermal propagator
Fermion bubble. At , the propagator of is the inverse of the fermion bubble,
Using \operatorname{tr}[\slashed{Q}(\slashed{Q}+\slashed{P})] = 2Q \cdot(Q+P) and , the bubble becomes
Here , with and fermionic frequencies , while with . A bosonic shift preserves the fermionic frequencies, so both tadpoles equal to
Subtracting , we obtain
At zero temperature, and the propagator reduces to , i.e. in position space.
Screening. At , the finite-temperature gap equation , with , admits only . The thermal state is therefore symmetric. Expanding (4.68) at small momentum gives
which defines a static screening scale . Unlike at the Wilson–Fisher fixed point, there is no parametrically light static mode.
The integral . Combining the denominators with a Feynman parameter , integrating over , and using the fermionic sum
we find
At zero temperature this reproduces . We have also checked (99) against a direct Matsubara sum.
Endpoint layer. Substituting and using the symmetry , we can write (96) as
The integrand is exponentially small unless . In this layer , with , and . Hence the constant term cancels at large momentum, and .
Leading term in the EFT:
Line integral. For a line along , we need to make use of
To organize the zero-temperature subtraction, we add and subtract the reference propagator for an arbitrary . Its frequency sum can be performed exactly by Poisson resummation, using and . We obtain
The bracket decays as , with the coefficient fixed by the large-momentum expansion. Independence of the result from provides a check of the numerics.
Final result. We evaluate (102) numerically, using (100) for . The results are listed in Table 4. For the unit-normalized operator, . We get therefore
| 2 | −1.077361 | −2.658283 | −8.3512 |
| 3 | −1.077361 | −2.658283 | −8.3512 |
| 5 | −1.077362 | −2.658283 | −8.3512 |
Table 4. Line integral (102) for three values of the auxiliary mass , and the resulting perimeter coefficient (103). The estimated numerical uncertainty is .
The perimeter coefficient is negative. Since the fermions are antiperiodic, the correlator is screened on scales of order , and thermal decorrelation along the line dominates. This is the same mechanism that makes negative for every weakly coupled line in . It is opposite to the Wilson–Fisher magnetic line near , where a static mode of mass makes logarithmically large and positive.
Chern–Simons-matter theory
In every integer-dimensional example above, the perimeter coefficient is negative. This is not a consequence of unitarity and screening: in , the supersymmetric Chern–Simons theory with one charged chiral multiplet has a conformal line with . At large the line is described by a classical field, and the sign of follows from an exact identity.
Setup
Action. We consider a complex scalar and a two-component Dirac fermion of unit charge, coupled to a gauge field with Chern–Simons level . In Lorentzian signature, and in the conventions of [60],
The scaling dimensions are and , so that , and are dimensionless. The theory is supersymmetric for [60, 61]
These values arise from the auxiliary fields , , D of the vector multiplet, of dimensions , , : the field D multiplies and imposes , so that the potential becomes , while and the elimination of contribute and to .
Conformality. At two loops, for generic and , the beta-functions have already been computed to be equal to
One can check that the supersymmetric point is the fixed point of these equations. The theory is thus a unitary CFT for every . At large it is weakly coupled: for and real , the Euclidean action of the scalar is
so that is the loop-counting parameter.
Line. We consider the following deformation
Since , the coupling is dimensionless.9 Thus in the presence of the defect we must minimize the following quantity
Fixed point of the line. At zero temperature the saddle depends only on the distance from the line. Regularizing the source on a tube of radius , it obeys
Let be the coupling seen at distance , with , and . The field equation is equivalent to the beta functions
The term is the running of a -function source in two transverse dimensions. Alone, it would produce a Landau pole at , reflecting the fact that is unbounded below for a free field. The sextic interaction stops the growth, and both beta functions vanish at
Linearizing (111), deviations scale as with . The growing mode, , is excluded for a solution that is regular for all , and the other one decays as .10
Hence monotonically for every , and as all the lines become a single line , defined by as . The profile is invariant under the inversion about a point of the line, under which and , and therefore under the full conformal group of the line. Fluctuations obey and behave as with for transverse spin , so the corresponding defect operators have dimensions . The lowest one, , is irrelevant, in agreement with the slope of the beta function at , and is the displacement operator. These statements hold at leading order in .
Leading EFT coefficient:
Energy formula. The line at acts as an operator on the Hilbert space of the spatial slice, and . Neither nor its renormalization depends on . Differentiating with respect to and using (52), we obtain the exact relation
The sign of is the sign of the energy that the line adds to the thermal state. Since commutes with , this energy can be measured on any slice with .
Saddle point and sign. At leading order in , is the Euclidean energy of the saddle of (109) for a straight line on , where is the spatial coordinate transverse to the line:
The saddle is the positive solution of
It is unique: the difference of two solutions obeys with and vanishes at the line and at infinity, so it can have neither a positive maximum nor a negative minimum. Hence . Together with periodicity, this makes symmetric about , so that on that slice. Choosing , the negative term in (114) drops out and
Evaluating this integral numerically yields
The perimeter coefficient is therefore positive whatever the value of . The argument uses only that the line is described by a unique real saddle of scalar fields with a non-negative potential, and that it is invariant under .
Acknowledgements
It is a pleasure to thank Daniele Artico, Zohar Komargodski, for very useful discussions. We also thank Daniele Artico, Zohar Komargodski, Enrico Marchetto, Simone Giombi. for very useful comments on the draft. The authors acknowledge the use of generative AI, in particular ChatGPT (OpenAI) and Claude (Antropic), in the preparation and editing of this manuscript. All scientific results and conclusions remain the responsibility of the human authors. In the interest of full transparency, we note that this declaration was itself written by AI, creating a self-referential loop of AI disclosure. We believe this loop is finite to all orders in perturbation theory, although a nonperturbative proof remains beyond the scope of this work.
Details on the Monte Carlo simulation
The dataset used in this work is an isotropic fixed-cutoff radius scan with
The full lattice therefore contains
Ising spins. The bulk coupling is held fixed at the flat-space critical value for every radius and every source value.
We simulate eight circular pinned magnetic loops with
corresponding to
At the largest radius, , the loop remains lattice spacings away from its nearest periodic image.
For every radius, thermodynamic integration uses the uniform source grid
namely 33 integration nodes. At each pair we simulate four independent Markov chains. Each chain has
where is the number of hybrid sweeps between saved measurements. Thus each integration node contains
stored measurements before autocorrelation corrections.
A hybrid sweep consists of one local Metropolis sweep followed by one ghost-Wolff cluster update for the positive magnetic source. The actual number of sites on the rasterized loop is recorded for every radius. We therefore retain both the nominal continuum variable and the geometric diagnostic
which quantifies the finite-lattice-spacing difference between the smooth circle used in the EFT and its lattice realization.
For reproducibility of the results the Monte Carlo code used for the simulations presented in this work are publically available on GitHub. In particular the material includes both the code for reproducibility of the data and the file for the data analysis on them.
References
- [1]K. G. Wilson and J. B. Kogut, The renormalization group and the ε expansion, Physics Reports 12 (1974) 75.DOI
- [2]C. Domb and M. S. Green, eds., Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena, vol. 6. Academic Press, 1976.
- [3]D. J. Amit, Field Theory, the Renormalization Group, and Critical Phenomena. World Scientific, 2 ed., 1984.
- [4]J. Cardy, Scaling and Renormalization in Statistical Physics, vol. 5 of Cambridge Lecture Notes in Physics. Cambridge University Press, 1996, 10.1017/CBO9781316036440.
- [5]L. P. Kadanoff, Statistical Physics: Statics, Dynamics and Renormalization. World Scientific, 2000.
- [6]S. El-Showk, M. F. Paulos, D. Poland, S. Rychkov, D. Simmons-Duffin and A. Vichi, Solving the 3D Ising Model with the Conformal Bootstrap, Phys. Rev. D 86 (2012) 025022 [1203.6064].
- [7]A. L. Fitzpatrick, J. Kaplan, D. Poland and D. Simmons-Duffin, The Analytic Bootstrap and AdS Superhorizon Locality, JHEP 12 (2013) 004 [1212.3616].DOI
- [8]Z. Komargodski and A. Zhiboedov, Convexity and Liberation at Large Spin, JHEP 11 (2013) 140 [1212.4103].
- [9]S. El-Showk, M. F. Paulos, D. Poland, S. Rychkov, D. Simmons-Duffin and A. Vichi, Solving the 3d Ising Model with the Conformal Bootstrap II. c-Minimization and Precise Critical Exponents, J. Stat. Phys. 157 (2014) 869 [1403.4545].
- [10]S. Caron-Huot, Analyticity in Spin in Conformal Theories, JHEP 09 (2017) 078 [1703.00278].
- [11]D. Simmons-Duffin, D. Stanford and E. Witten, A spacetime derivation of the Lorentzian OPE inversion formula, JHEP 07 (2018) 085 [1711.03816].
- [12]D. Poland, S. Rychkov and A. Vichi, The Conformal Bootstrap: Theory, Numerical Techniques, and Applications, Rev. Mod. Phys. 91 (2019) 015002 [1805.04405].DOI
- [13]H. Anand, N. Benjamin, V. Kumar, S. Minwalla, J. Mukherjee, S. Pal et al., Semi-universality of CFT$_d$ entropy at large spin, SciPost Phys. 21 (2026) 042 [2512.00158].DOI
- [14]Z. Komargodski, A. Miscioscia and F. K. Popov, Regge’s Inferno, 2603.10197.arxiv.org/abs/2603.10197
- [15]A. Advant, H. Anand, N. Benjamin, V. Kumar, S. Minwalla, J. Mukherjee et al., From Z to a: High-temperature relations, subleading semi-universality, and conformal anomalies, 2609.03013.
- [16]E. Katz, S. Sachdev, E. S. Sørensen and W. Witzak-Krempa, Conformal field theories at nonzero temperature: Operator product expansions, Monte Carlo, and holography, Phys. Rev. B 90 (2014) 245109 [1409.3841].DOI
- [17]L. Iliesiu, M. Koloğlu, R. Mahajan, E. Perlmutter and D. Simmons-Duffin, The Conformal Bootstrap at Finite Temperature, JHEP 10 (2018) 070 [1802.10266].DOI
- [18]J. L. Cardy, Operator Content of Two-Dimensional Conformally Invariant Theories, Nucl. Phys. B 270 (1986) 186.DOI
- [19]E. Shaghoulian, Modular forms and a generalized Cardy formula in higher dimensions, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 126005 [1508.02728].DOI
- [20]N. Benjamin, J. Lee, H. Ooguri and D. Simmons-Duffin, Universal asymptotics for high energy CFT data, JHEP 03 (2024) 115 [2306.08031].DOI
- [21]I. Burić, F. Mangialardi, F. Russo, V. Schomerus and A. Vichi, Heavy-heavy-light asymptotics from thermal correlators, JHEP 04 (2026) 027 [2506.21671].
- [22]I. Burić, F. Mangialardi, F. Russo, V. Schomerus and A. Vichi, Thermal One-point Functions and Asymptotic CFT Data: QFT in AdS, 2606.17167.arxiv.org/abs/2606.17167
- [23]A. Miscioscia, D. Pavshinkin and F. K. Popov, Regge in Wonderland, 2609.35455.arxiv.org/abs/2609.35455
- [24]L. Iliesiu, M. Koloğlu and D. Simmons-Duffin, Bootstrapping the 3d Ising model at finite temperature, JHEP 12 (2019) 072 [1811.05451].DOI
- [25]E. Marchetto, A. Miscioscia and E. Pomoni, Sum rules & Tauberian theorems at finite temperature, JHEP 09 (2024) 044 [2312.13030].
- [26]J. Barrat, E. Marchetto, A. Miscioscia and E. Pomoni, Thermal Bootstrap for the Critical O(N) Model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134 (2025) 211604 [2411.00978].DOI
- [27]J. Barrat, D. N. Bozkurt, E. Marchetto, A. Miscioscia and E. Pomoni, The analytic bootstrap at finite temperature, JHEP 05 (2026) 104 [2506.06422].
- [28]J. Barrat, D. N. Bozkurt, E. Marchetto, A. Miscioscia and E. Pomoni, Analytic thermal bootstrap in momentum space: From thermal OPE to QNMs, 2607.24919.arxiv.org/abs/2607.24919
- [29]Y. Guo, Z. Li and T. Shen, Thermal Polyakov bootstrap, 2609.28627.arxiv.org/abs/2609.28627
- [30]S. Bhattacharyya, S. Lahiri, R. Loganayagam and S. Minwalla, Large rotating AdS black holes from fluid mechanics, JHEP 09 (2008) 054 [0708.1770].DOI
- [31]N. Banerjee, J. Bhattacharya, S. Bhattacharya, S. Jain, S. Minwalla and T. Sharma, Constraints on fluid dynamics from equilibrium partition functions, JHEP 09 (2012) 046 [1203.3544].DOI
- [32]K. Jensen, M. Kaminski, P. Kovtun, R. Meyer, A. Ritz and A. Yarom, Towards hydrodynamics without an entropy current, Physical Review Letters 109 (2012) 101601 [1203.3556].DOI
- [33]E. Shaghoulian, Black hole microstates in AdS, Physical Review D 94 (2016) 104044 [1512.06855].DOI
- [34]M. Billo, V. Goncalves, E. Lauria and M. Meineri, Defects in conformal field theory, JHEP 04 (2016) 091 [1601.02883].DOI
- [35]M. Billo, M. Caselle, D. Gaiotto, F. Gliozzi, M. Meineri and R. Pellegrini, Line defects in the 3d Ising model, JHEP 07 (2013) 055 [1304.4110].arxiv.org/abs/1304.4110
- [36]F. Gliozzi, P. Liendo, M. Meineri and A. Rago, Boundary and Interface CFTs from the Conformal Bootstrap, JHEP 05 (2015) 036 [1502.07217].DOI
- [37]M. Lemos, P. Liendo, M. Meineri and S. Sarkar, Universality at large transverse spin in defect CFT, JHEP 09 (2018) 091 [1712.08185].
- [38]G. Cuomo, Z. Komargodski and A. Raviv-Moshe, Renormalization Group Flows on Line Defects, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 (2022) 021603 [2108.01117].DOI
- [39]G. Cuomo, Z. Komargodski and M. Mezei, Localized magnetic field in the O(N) model, JHEP 02 (2022) 134 [2112.10634].DOI
- [40]J. Barrat, A. Gimenez-Grau and P. Liendo, A dispersion relation for defect CFT, JHEP 02 (2023) 255 [2205.09765].
- [41]O. Diatlyk, H. Khanchandani, F. K. Popov and Y. Wang, Effective Field Theory of Conformal Boundaries, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133 (2024) 261601 [2406.01550].arxiv.org/abs/2406.01550
- [42]M. Meineri and B. Radhakrishnan, The bootstrap of points and lines, JHEP 04 (2026) 040 [2506.17382].
- [43]L. Bianchi, A. Cavaglià, A. D. Gutiérrez, S. R. Kousvos and M. Meineri, Cusped Defects: Cusp Operator Expansion, Conformal Properties and Bootstrap Applications, 2609.04035.arxiv.org/abs/2609.04035
- [44]J. Barrat, B. Fiol, E. Marchetto, A. Miscioscia and E. Pomoni, Conformal line defects at finite temperature, SciPost Phys. 18 (2025) 018 [2407.14600].DOI
- [45]S. Giombi, Y.-Z. Li and J. Shan, Bouncing singularities and thermal correlators on line defects, JHEP 07 (2026) 170 [2603.11012].
- [46]Y. Li, H. Nakayama and T. Nishioka, Conformal defects of general dimensions at finite temperature, 2609.12720.arxiv.org/abs/2609.12720
- [47]D. Artico and A. Chalabi, Boundaries and defects in conformal field theories at finite temperature, 2609.38130.arxiv.org/abs/2609.38130
- [48]J. Barrat and S. Giombi, The pinning-field line defect at finite temperature, 2611.00210.arxiv.org/abs/2611.00210
- [49]O. Diatlyk, H. Khanchandani, F. K. Popov and Y. Wang, Defect fusion and Casimir energy in higher dimensions, JHEP 09 (2024) 006 [2404.05815].arxiv.org/abs/2404.05815
- [50]P. Kravchuk, A. Radcliffe and R. Sinha, Effective theory for fusion of conformal defects, J. Phys. A 58 (2025) 465402 [2406.04561].arxiv.org/abs/2406.04561
- [51]J. M. Maldacena, Wilson loops in large N field theories, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 4859 [hep-th/9803002].DOI
- [52]E. Witten, Anti-de-Sitter space, thermal phase transition, and confinement in gauge theories, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2 (1998) 505 [hep-th/9803131].
- [53]D. E. Berenstein, R. Corrado, W. Fischler and J. M. Maldacena, The Operator product expansion for Wilson loops and surfaces in the large N limit, Phys. Rev. D 59 (1999) 105023 [hep-th/9809188].DOI
- [54]L. F. Alday and J. Maldacena, Null polygonal Wilson loops and minimal surfaces in Anti-de-Sitter space, JHEP 11 (2009) 082 [0904.0663].DOI
- [55]D. Pappadopulo, S. Rychkov, J. Espin and R. Rattazzi, OPE Convergence in Conformal Field Theory, Phys. Rev. D 86 (2012) 105043 [1208.6449].DOI
- [56]E. Lauria, M. Meineri and E. Trevisani, Radial coordinates for defect CFTs, JHEP 11 (2018) 148 [1712.07668].DOI
- [57]E. Lauria, M. Meineri and E. Trevisani, Spinning operators and defects in conformal field theory, JHEP 08 (2019) 066 [1807.02522].DOI
- [58]A. M. Ferrenberg, J. Xu and D. P. Landau, Pushing the limits of monte carlo simulations for the three-dimensional ising model, Physical Review E 97 (2018) .DOI
- [59]F. Livet, Monte carlo static and dynamic simulations of a three-dimensional ising critical model, Phys. Rev. E 101 (2020) 02231.DOI
- [60]L. V. Avdeev, D. I. Kazakov and I. N. Kondrashuk, Renormalizations in supersymmetric and nonsupersymmetric nonAbelian Chern-Simons field theories with matter, Nucl. Phys. B 391 (1993) 333.
- [61]D. Gaiotto and X. Yin, Notes on superconformal Chern-Simons-Matter theories, JHEP 08 (2007) 056 [0704.3740].DOI

