betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Excess charge in the Engel-Dreizler model of atoms and molecules

Abstract

We prove an explicit excess-charge bound for the exchange-free Engel–Dreizler functional of atoms and molecules. If αλ≤1/1233αλ\le1/1233 and α3Zk2≤1/137α^3Z_k^2\le1/137 for each nucleus, every finite-mass electronic minimizer whose total energy, including nuclear repulsion, is nonpositive satisfies N−∑kZk<(5913/1000)λ3/2KN-\sum_kZ_k<(5913/1000)λ^{3/2}K. For the gradient coefficient λ=1/9λ=1/9, this gives N−∑kZk<0.219KN-\sum_kZ_k<0.219K. The energy hypothesis holds automatically for atoms and for local minima of the Born–Oppenheimer energy at which the electronic infimum is attained. The proof uses no symmetry of the density, restriction on the total nuclear charge, or minimum nuclear separation. We combine molecular Sommerfeld estimates with a convex nonlinear comparison in the variable F(p)F(p). The failure of the latter comparison at very high density is represented by a nonnegative Newton potential. A quartic coercivity estimate, obtained from nuclear repulsion and a signed localized Hardy inequality, controls the total mass of this source. The chemical potential is retained throughout. Exact covariance yields the invariant parameter domain, and all finite numerical inequalities are reduced to rational arithmetic.

Introduction

The excess charge Q:=N−ZQ := N-Z of an atomic anion is the number of bound electrons NN in excess of the nuclear charge ZZ. Experimentally, no stable doubly or more highly charged isolated atomic anions are known; see [12, 13]. Explaining the observed bound Q≤1Q \le1 from a microscopic model of ions remains a challenge to mathematical physics. A weaker formulation, the ionization conjecture, asks for a bound on QQ independent of ZZ.

Simple density functionals already capture parts of this picture. Thomas–Fermi theory does not bind negative ions, whereas its Fermi–Amaldi modification permits at most one excess electron. For the Thomas–Fermi–Weizsäcker functional, Benguria and Lieb [1] proved charge-independent bounds for atoms and bounds proportional to the number of nuclei for molecules. Solovej established such a uniform bound in reduced Hartree–Fock theory and subsequently in Hartree–Fock theory with exchange [19, 20]. These results give Q=O(1)Q=O(1) as Z→∞Z\to\infty, with a universal bound valid for all ZZ, but do not establish the sharp value 1. More recently, an OpenAI preprint [14] established a corresponding uniform bound for strictly bound states of the full nonrelativistic many-electron Coulomb Hamiltonian with two spin states. For KK fixed nuclei with real charges Zk≥1Z_k\ge1 at arbitrary distinct positions, the result is N≤Ztot+CKN\le Z_{\mathrm{tot}}+CK, with a universal constant CC. In particular, it gives Q=O(1)Q=O(1) for atoms as Z→∞Z\to\infty, and hence the analogue of Solovej’s Hartree–Fock bound for the full NN-particle model. Earlier quantitative bounds for that model grew with ZZ. The new result does not provide the sharp bound Q≤1Q\le1.

For heavy atoms, relativistic effects must also be taken into account. Although the highest velocities occur near the nucleus, their influence extends to the outer shells and to chemical and optical properties; the colour of gold is a familiar example [15]. Rigorous excess-charge results for relativistic microscopic models are comparatively scarce. Schulz [16 Section 2.2]

Date: Draft, 6 November 2026.

Support by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG), grant EXC-2111-390814868 and DFG TRR 352, grant 470903074, and FONDECYT (Chile) Project # 124–1863 is gratefully acknowledged. RB thanks the Mathematical Institute of LMU for hospitality, and HS thanks the Institute of Physics of the Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile for hospitality. The authors acknowledge the use of OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Google’s Gemini for mathematical discussions, the development and checking of arguments, and assistance in preparing the manuscript. The authors take full responsibility for the final text and proofs. reviews this problem and proves, for the fermionic Chandrasekhar model,

Q≤12(2−1)Z+O(Z1/3).Q \le\frac{1}{2}(\sqrt{2}-1)Z + O(Z^{1/3}).

Here the remainder is uniform when αZ\alpha Z stays a fixed distance below the critical coupling 2/π2/\pi; more precisely, his Theorem 2.2.1 assumes αZ<2/π\alpha Z < 2/\pi for a fixed a>1a>1.

Motivated by these questions, we consider a relativistic statistical model with a gradient correction. The relativistic Thomas–Fermi model of Vallarta and Rosen [21] suffers from collapse at a point nucleus, as discussed by Jensen [9]; see also Gombás [8], § 14, pp. 120 ff. Engel and Dreizler later obtained a relativistic analogue of the Thomas–Fermi–Weizsäcker functional through a formal derivation from the Hartree–Fock approximation to quantum electrodynamics [6]. They subsequently studied neutral and positively charged atomic solutions numerically [7]. We omit the exchange term and ask whether this model admits an explicit excess-charge bound uniform in the nuclear charges within a specified coupling domain.

The exterior estimates used below follow the Benguria–Lieb strategy, with particular use of Solovej’s refined Sommerfeld comparison after Lemma 10 of [18]: see Lemma 11, Proposition 12, and Lemma 13 there. His Proposition 14 illustrates how the improved comparison reduces the excess-charge constant. Uniform estimates for a broader family of nonrelativistic Thomas–Fermi–Weizsäcker functionals were obtained by Benguria and Siedentop [3].

There are already rigorous excess-charge estimates for the Engel–Dreizler model. Chen and Siedentop proved, for the functional without exchange, a molecular bound N<2.56∑kZkN<2.56\sum_k Z_k [5]. For the atomic functional including exchange, Chen, Frank, and Siedentop obtained N≤2Z+O(Z2/3)N\le2Z+O(Z^{2/3}) as Z→∞Z\to\infty with κ=Z/(cλ)\kappa=Z/(c\sqrt{\lambda}) and λ\lambda fixed, where cc is the speed of light in the Hartree units used there [4]. These results bound the total electron number by a quantity of order the nuclear charge. The present work estimates the difference Q=N−∑kZkQ=N-\sum_k Z_k by an explicit constant times the number of nuclei.

In the molecular argument, the repulsion of the nuclei is essential to the energy estimate used to impose restrictions on individual charges. This use of nuclear repulsion has a precedent in the ultrarelativistic Thomas–Fermi–Weizsäcker stability analysis of Benguria, Loss, and Siedentop [2]. Their homogeneous model differs from the massive Engel–Dreizler functional considered here. The relevant electrostatic localization inequalities originate in the work of Lieb and Yau [11]; we use the formulation of Lieb, Loss, and Siedentop [10]. Stability estimates for the Engel–Dreizler functional were also developed by Siedentop [17].

Our main result, Theorem 2.1, bounds the excess charge by (5913/1000)λ3/2K(5913/1000)\lambda^{3/2}K in an explicitly stated coupling domain. At λ=1/9\lambda=1/9 the constant per nucleus is 219/1000219/1000. The atomic result is a direct corollary of the molecular theorem. The molecular energy hypothesis is the nonpositivity of the actual total energy, including nuclear repulsion. A virial identity makes this hypothesis automatic at local minima of the Born–Oppenheimer energy, whenever the electronic infimum is attained.

There are two main steps in the proof. First, the exterior comparison estimates depend only on αλ\alpha\lambda and on the function H(x)=∑k=1K∣x−Rk∣−1H(x)=\sum_{k=1}^{K}|x-R_k|^{-1}, which is harmonic away from the nuclear positions. They do not depend on individual nuclear charges. Second, a nonlinear comparison between the density and the screened potential is allowed to have a nonnegative Newton-potential correction. Its source is supported where the local Fermi momentum exceeds an explicit exponentially large cutoff. A quartic energy estimate makes the electron number on this set small enough to absorb the correction. The nuclear repulsion enters only in this second step, through a restriction on each nuclear charge. Unequal charges are handled by an exact averaging over subsets of nuclei.

Section 2 states the result and specifies the rescaling from Hartree units used throughout the paper. Section 3 supplies the variational framework and the exact covariance. The exterior estimates, coercivity bound, and nonlinear comparison are proved in Sections 4, 5, and 6, respectively. Section 7 completes the charge estimate, and Section 8 treats the nuclear energy condition and the geometric factor KK. The appendices give the algebra behind the localization constant and a reproducible specification of the finite numerical checks. The large-coupling regime at fixed α\alpha is outside the present theorem and is left to a separate study.

The functional and the main results

In Hartree units, ℏ=me=e2/(4πε0)=1\hbar=m_e=e^2/(4\pi\varepsilon_0)=1 and c=α−1c=\alpha^{-1}. We rescale the spatial and density variables by

x=cxH,Rk=cRk,H,p(x)=c−1pH(x/c),ρ(x)=c−3ρH(x/c),x=cx_{\mathrm H},\qquad R_k=cR_{k,\mathrm H},\qquad p(x)=c^{-1}p_{\mathrm H}(x/c),\qquad\rho(x)=c^{-3}\rho_{\mathrm H}(x/c),

where the subscript H denotes Hartree variables. This change preserves the particle number. The Hartree energy and the functional E\mathcal{E} defined in (3) are related by

EH[pH;RH,Z]=c2E[p;R,Z].\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm H}[p_{\mathrm H};R_{\mathrm H},Z]=c^2\mathcal{E}[p;R,Z].

We omit the positive overall factor c2c^2: it rescales the energy but preserves the corresponding minimizers, their particle numbers, and the sign of the total energy. Thus the formulas below use ℏ=me=c=1\hbar=m_e=c=1, with Coulomb coupling α\alpha. Let α,λ>0\alpha,\lambda>0, and set

f(p)2=p1+p2+2p21+p2arsinh⁡p,F(p)=∫0pf(s) ds,(1)f(p)^2=\frac{p}{\sqrt{1+p^2}}+\frac{2p^2}{1+p^2}\operatorname{arsinh}p,\qquad F(p)=\int_0^p f(s)\,\mathrm{d}s, \tag*{(1)}
T(p)=1+p2−1,τ(p)=8∫0ps2T(s) ds.(2)T(p)=\sqrt{1+p^2}-1,\qquad\tau(p)=8\int_0^p s^2T(s)\,\mathrm{d}s. \tag*{(2)}

The coefficient 2 in f2f^2 is the standard Engel–Dreizler coefficient. Write

P=F(p),ρ=p33π2,N=∫R3ρ,Ztot=∑k=1KZk,Q=N−Ztot.P=F(p),\qquad\rho=\frac{p^3}{3\pi^2},\qquad N=\int_{\mathbb{R}^3}\rho,\qquad Z_{\mathrm{tot}}=\sum_{k=1}^{K}Z_k,\qquad Q=N-Z_{\mathrm{tot}}.

The nuclei have pairwise distinct positions R1,…,RKR_1,\ldots,R_K and charges Zk>0Z_k>0. Define

V(x)=∑k=1KZk∣x−Rk∣,Unn=α∑1≤k<l≤KZkZl∣Rk−Rl∣,V(x)=\sum_{k=1}^{K}\frac{Z_k}{|x-R_k|},\qquad U_{\mathrm{nn}}=\alpha\sum_{1\leq k<l\leq K}\frac{Z_kZ_l}{|R_k-R_l|},

so that each pair is counted once. The total energy is

E[p;R,Z]=3λ8π2∫∣∇F(p)∣2+18π2∫τ(p)−α∫Vρ+αD[ρ]+Unn,(3)\mathcal{E}[p;R,Z]=\frac{3\lambda}{8\pi^2}\int|\nabla F(p)|^2+\frac{1}{8\pi^2}\int\tau(p)-\alpha\int V\rho+\alpha D[\rho]+U_{\mathrm{nn}}, \tag*{(3)}

where

D[ρ]=12∬ρ(x)ρ(y)∣x−y∣ dx dy.D[\rho]=\frac{1}{2}\iint\frac{\rho(x)\rho(y)}{|x-y|}\,\mathrm{d}x\,\mathrm{d}y.

Apart from the gradient term and the fixed nuclear repulsion, (3) is the relativistic Thomas–Fermi functional introduced by Vallarta and Rosen [21]. In contrast to the nonrelativistic Thomas–Fermi kinetic energy, the local term involving τ\tau does not stabilize the energy against collapse at a point nucleus: without a gradient correction, the electronic energy is unbounded below. Various ad hoc modifications were proposed to address this difficulty, including the addition of the nonrelativistic Weizsäcker term; see Gombás [8 § 14, pp. 120 ff.] for the early approaches. The advantage of the first term in (3) is that its form comes from Engel and Dreizler’s formal QED-based gradient expansion [6], rather than an ad hoc choice. The coefficient λ\lambda is retained as a parameter; its standard value is 1/91/9.

There is no exchange term. The finite-mass energy class is p≥0p\geq0, p∈L3∩L4p\in L^3\cap L^4, F(p)∈D1,2F(p)\in D^{1,2}, and D[p3]<∞D[p^3]<\infty.

Here D1,2(R3)D^{1,2}(\mathbb{R}^3) is the completion of Cc∞(R3)C^\infty_c(\mathbb{R}^3) in the gradient norm, and all unmarked integrals are over R3\mathbb{R}^3. The first two terms of (3) are denoted by TW[p]T_{\mathrm W}[p] and TTF[p]T_{\mathrm{TF}}[p], respectively.

An electronic minimizer always means an attained infimum for fixed RR and ZZ over this energy class, with either N≤MN\leq M for a prescribed finite MM, N=MN=M for a prescribed finite MM, or no constraint on NN. In the last case we explicitly require finite mass. We use NN for the actual electron number of the minimizer, including when the constraint is relaxed. The argument applies to each such minimizer and does not require uniqueness. The underlying existence and ionization theory for the exchange-free functional is developed in [5].

Theorem 2.1 (Excess charge). Let K≥1K \ge1, let R1,…,RK∈R3R_1,\ldots,R_K \in\mathbb{R}^3 be pairwise distinct, and let Z1,…,ZK>0Z_1,\ldots,Z_K > 0. Suppose

αλ≤11233,α3Zk2≤1137(1≤k≤K).(4)\alpha\lambda\le\frac{1}{1233}, \qquad\alpha^3 Z_k^2 \le\frac{1}{137} \qquad(1 \le k \le K). \tag*{(4)}

If pp is a finite-mass electronic minimizer and its actual total energy satisfies

E[p;R,Z]≤0,(5)\mathcal{E}[p;\mathbf{R},\mathbf{Z}] \le0, \tag*{(5)}

then

N−Ztot<59131000λ3/2K.(6)N-Z_{\mathrm{tot}} < \frac{5913}{1000}\lambda^{3/2}K. \tag*{(6)}

The bound is independent of the nuclear positions and of the total nuclear charge. No lower bound on the nuclear separations is assumed.

Corollary 2.2 (The physical gradient coefficient). For λ=1/9\lambda=1/9, 0<α≤1/1370<\alpha\le1/137, and αZk≤1\alpha Z_k\le1 for every nucleus, an electronic minimizer satisfying (5) obeys

N−Ztot<2191000K.(7)N-Z_{\mathrm{tot}} < \frac{219}{1000}K. \tag*{(7)}

Proof. The stated assumptions imply (4), since α3Zk2=α(αZk)2≤1/137\alpha^3 Z_k^2=\alpha(\alpha Z_k)^2\le1/137. Moreover (5913/1000)(1/9)3/2=219/1000(5913/1000)(1/9)^{3/2}=219/1000. □\square

References

  1. [1]R. Benguria and E. H. Lieb, The most negative ion in the Thomas–Fermi–von Weizsäcker theory of atoms and molecules, J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Phys. 18 (1985), 1045–1059. doi:10.1088/0022-3700/18/6/006.DOI
  2. [2]R. D. Benguria, M. Loss, and H. Siedentop, Stability of atoms and molecules in an ultrarelativistic Thomas–Fermi–Weizsäcker model, J. Math. Phys. 49 (2008), 012302. doi:10.1063/1.2832620; arXiv:0710.4338.DOI
  3. [3]R. D. Benguria and H. Siedentop, Bound on the excess charge of generalized Thomas–Fermi–Weizsäcker functionals, J. Math. Phys. 66 (2025), 072103. doi:10.1063/5.0264498; arXiv:2502.15444.DOI
  4. [4]H. Chen, R. L. Frank, and H. Siedentop, A statistical theory of heavy atoms: energy and excess charge, in Density Functionals for Many-Particle Systems: Mathematical Theory and Physical Applications of Effective Equations, B.-G. Englert, H. Siedentop, and M.-I. Trappe (eds.), Lecture Notes Series, Institute for Mathematical Sciences, National University of Singapore, vol. 41, World Scientific, Singapore, 2023, pp. 57–68. doi:10.1142/9789811272158_0002; arXiv:2010.12074.
  5. [5]H. Chen and H. Siedentop, On the excess charge of a relativistic statistical model of molecules with an inhomogeneity correction, J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 53 (2020), 395201. doi:10.1088/1751-8121/aba4d3; arXiv:1912.00205.DOI
  6. [6]E. Engel and R. M. Dreizler, Field-theoretical approach to a relativistic Thomas–Fermi–Dirac–Weizsäcker model, Phys. Rev. A 35 (1987), 3607–3618. doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.35.3607.DOI
  7. [7]E. Engel and R. M. Dreizler, Solution of the relativistic Thomas–Fermi–Dirac–Weizsäcker model for the case of neutral atoms and positive ions, Phys. Rev. A 38 (1988), 3909–3917. doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.38.3909.DOI
  8. [8]P. Gombás, Die physikalische Theorie des Atoms und ihre Anwendungen, Springer, Wien, 1949. doi:10.1007/978-3-7091-2100-9.DOI
  9. [9]H. Jensen, Zur relativistischen Behandlung des Fermiatoms, Z. Phys. 82 (1933), 794–802. doi:10.1007/BF01334129.DOI
  10. [10]E. H. Lieb, M. Loss, and H. Siedentop, Stability of relativistic matter via Thomas–Fermi theory, Helv. Phys. Acta 69 (1996), 974–984. arXiv:cond-mat/9608060.DOI
  11. [11]E. H. Lieb and H.-T. Yau, The stability and instability of relativistic matter, Commun. Math. Phys. 118 (1988), 177–213. doi:10.1007/BF01218577.DOI
  12. [12]H. S. W. Massey, Negative Ions, 3rd ed., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1976.
  13. [13]H. S. W. Massey, Negative ions, Adv. At. Mol. Phys. 15 (1979), 1–36. doi:10.1016/S0065-2199(08)60293-6.DOI
  14. [14]OpenAI, Uniform excess charge for Coulomb molecules and the outer radius of neutral atoms, preprint, 24 September 2026. OpenAI Math repository.
  15. [15]P. Pyykkö, Relativistic effects in structural chemistry, Chem. Rev. 88 (1988), 563–594. doi:10.1021/cr00085a006.DOI
  16. [16]M. R. Schulz, Analytic Studies of Atomic Structures and the Efimov Effect, Ph.D. thesis, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, 2025. doi:10.5445/IR/1000183607.DOI
  17. [17]H. Siedentop, A statistical theory of heavy atoms: asymptotic behavior of the energy and stability of matter, in Partial Differential Equations, Spectral Theory, and Mathematical Physics: The Ari Laptev Anniversary Volume, P. Exner, R. L. Frank, F. Gesztesy, H. Holden, and T. Weidl (eds.), EMS Series of Congress Reports, EMS Press, 2021, pp. 389–403. doi:10.4171/ECR/18-1/23; arXiv:2101.06539.DOI
  18. [18]J. P. Solovej, Universality in the Thomas–Fermi–von Weizsäcker model of atoms and molecules, Commun. Math. Phys. 129 (1990), 561–598. doi:10.1007/BF02097106.DOI
  19. [19]J. P. Solovej, Proof of the ionization conjecture in a reduced Hartree–Fock model, Invent. Math. 104 (1991), 291–311.DOI
  20. [20]J. P. Solovej, The ionization conjecture in Hartree–Fock theory, Ann. of Math. 158 (2003), 509–576. doi:10.4007/annals.2003.158.509.DOI
  21. [21]M. S. Vallarta and N. Rosen, The relativistic Thomas–Fermi atom, Phys. Rev. 41 (1932), 708–726. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.41.708.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_dhn5tavk
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents