betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Chiral condensate and the equation of state at nonzero baryon density from the hadron resonance gas model with a repulsive mean field

Abstract

We study the QCD equation of state and the chiral condensate using the hadron resonance gas model with repulsive mean-field interactions. We find that the repulsive interactions improve the agreement with the lattice results on the derivatives of the pressure with respect to the baryon chemical potential up to eighth order. From the temperature dependence of the chiral condensate we estimate the crossover temperature as a function of baryon chemical potential, Tpc(μB)T_{pc}(μ_B). We find that the chiral crossover line starts to deviate significantly from the chemical freeze-out line already for μB>400μ_B>400 MeV. Furthermore, we find that the chiral pseudocritical line can be parametrized as Tpc(μB)/Tpc(0)=1−κ2(μB/Tpc(0))2−κ4(μB/Tpc(0))4T_{pc}(μ_B)/T_{pc}(0)=1-κ_2 (μ_B/T_{pc} (0))^2-κ_4 (μ_B/T_{pc} (0))^4 with κ2=0.0150(2)κ_2=0.0150(2) and κ4=3.1(6)×10−5κ_4=3.1(6) \times 10^{-5}, which are in agreement with lattice QCD results for small values of μBμ_B. For the first time we find a tiny but non-zero value of κ4κ_4 in our study.

Introduction

Understanding QCD matter at nonzero temperatures and baryon densities presents several challenges on the theory side. Apart from asymptotically large temperatures and baryon densities when perturbation theory can make predictions for thermodynamics, the problem is nonperturbative. For zero baryon density, lattice QCD methods have provided continuum extrapolated results for physical quark masses for many thermodynamic quantities. However, due to the infamous sign problem, the lattice Monte Carlo techniques based on the method of important sampling break down at finite densities. Attempts to extend the lattice QCD calculations to nonzero baryon densities through Taylor expansion in baryon chemical potential, μB\mu_B, or the imaginary chemical potential approach has allowed us to understand QCD thermodynamics μB<2.5T\mu_B < 2.5 T [1–4], which can be extended in a certain temperature regime to μB/T≈3.5\mu_B/T \approx3.5 [5].

Below the chiral crossover temperature, QCD thermodynamics can be fairly well understood using the hadron resonance gas (HRG) model. The main idea of this model is that the interactions between hadrons can be taken into account through hadronic resonances and the interacting gas of hadrons can be replaced by a gas of noninteracting hadrons and hadronic resonances treated as stable particles. This approach can be justified within the framework of relativistic virial expansion [6, 7] and the comparison between the HRG model results and the lattice data [11, 12, 13] [8, 9, 10]. Indeed, the most recent lattice QCD calculations of the QCD pressure and the second order fluctuations and correlations of conserved charges agree well with the the HRG model results [14, 15, 16, 17, 18] [2]. For some quantities like baryon-strangeness or baryon-charm correlations, it is important to include additional hadron states that are not listed by the Particle Data Group (PDG) but are predicted by lattice QCD and quark models [18, 19, 20, 21]. For strangeness-baryon number correlation, this idea is further supported by the calculation within the relativistic virial expansion with state-of-the-art phase shift analysis [22].

The temperature dependence of the chiral condensate has been studied within the HRG model [23, 24, 25, 26, 27], and attempts to use the HRG model to estimate the chiral crossover temperature at small baryon density have been made recently [27]. There is a widespread expectation that the chiral crossover may become a true phase transition at large baryon density, namely that the crossover will turn into a first-order phase transition at μB=μBCEP\mu_B = \mu_B^{CEP} corresponding to the critical end-point (CEP). Lattice QCD results strongly disfavour μBCEP<400\mu_B^{CEP} < 400 MeV for a range of temperatures around 0.85 Tpc0.85\,T_{pc}, while functional renormalization group studies estimate μBCEP\mu_B^{CEP} to be even larger, around 635 MeV [28] at T=107T = 107 MeV. Therefore, it would be interesting to estimate the chiral crossover temperature at larger values of baryon density using the HRG model framework.

The agreement between lattice QCD and the HRG model results no longer holds for higher-order fluctuations of conserved charges [29] [2, 3, 4]. This may highlight the importance of the inclusion of non-resonant attractive interactions as well as repulsive interactions among the baryons, which could become very important at higher baryon densities. The most common approach to include repulsive interactions within the HRG model is through the inclusion of a hard-core repulsive excluded volume for hadrons [30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37]. Recently these models were refined to include both repulsive and attractive nonresonant interactions via a van der Waals-like potential [38, 39, 40, 41, 42]. Another approach to include the repulsive interactions is through the mean-field approximation. Here the strength of the repulsive interaction is proportional to the baryon density [43, 44, 45]. It has been shown that this model can explain the deviations from the HRG model seen in the lattice QCD calculations of higher-order derivatives of the QCD pressure with respect to the baryon chemical potential [46]. Following this work the use of the HRG model with repulsive mean-field interactions was explored to explain the lattice results on the QCD equation of state [47, 48] and fluctuations and correlations of conserved charges [49, 50].

The aim of this paper is to study the temperature and the μB\mu_B dependence of the chiral condensate, and using this to estimate the chiral crossover temperature as a function of μB\mu_B. We will also revisit the description of the higher-order baryon number fluctuations and the QCD equation of state within the HRG model with repulsive mean-field interactions in light of the newest lattice QCD results. The paper is organized as follows: In the next section, we review the HRG model with repulsive interactions. In that section we also present the comparison of this model with the state-of-the-art lattice QCD results on fluctuations of conserved charges. In Sec. III we discuss the calculation of the chiral condensate as a function of temperature and baryon chemical potential. In Sec. IV we present our results, i.e., the estimate of the chiral crossover temperature as a function of baryon chemical potential, and the curvature of the pseudocritical line. In Sec. V, we discuss the temperature and baryon density dependence of the speed of sound for the strangeness neutral system. Finally, our conclusions are presented in Sec. VI. In the Appendices, we give some technical details of the calculations.

Including Repulsive baryon interactions within the HRG model

It is well known from nucleon-nucleon scattering experiments that there are repulsive interactions between nucleons at short distances (or equivalently at high energies). From the lattice results we know that this is also true for other baryons [51]. These interactions will become important at large baryon density. Since we are interested in extending the HRG model to high baryon density the effect of the repulsive baryon-baryon interactions has to be included. The repulsive baryon-baryon interactions could play a role also at zero or small baryon densities as the temperature increases toward TpcT_{pc}, since the abundance of baryons and antibaryons increases. But from previous analysis we know that the corresponding effect is small for the pressure and energy density [47]. However, higher-order derivatives of the pressure with respect to the baryon chemical potential are sensitive to the effect of the repulsive interactions even at zero baryon density [46]. This is because these derivatives carry information about the physics at high baryon density even when evaluated at zero baryon chemical potential. Comparison of HRG calculations with the lattice results on higher-order derivatives of the pressure with respect to baryon chemical potential allows one to constrain the contribution of the repulsive interactions. As already mentioned in the introduction in this work we use the repulsive mean-field to include the effect of repulsive baryon-baryon interactions in the HRG model.

The pressure for an interacting ensemble of baryons and anti-baryons with densities nbn_b and nbˉn_{\bar b} respectively can be represented within the repulsive mean-field model as [48, 49]

PintB{Bˉ}=T∑i∈B{Bˉ}∫gid3p(2π)3ln⁡[1+e−β(Ei−μeff)]+K2nb{bˉ}2.(1)P_{\mathrm{int}}^{B\{\bar{B}\}} = T \sum_{i \in B\{\bar{B}\}} \int g_i \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3} \ln\left[1+e^{-\beta(E_i-\mu_{eff})}\right] + \frac{K}{2}n_{b\{\bar{b}\}}^2. \tag*{(1)}

Here the effective chemical potential for the iith species is defined as μeff=BiμB−Knb{bˉ}\mu_{eff}=B_i\mu_B-Kn_{b\{\bar{b}\}}, with BiB_i being the baryon number. Bi=+1B_i=+1 for baryons, and Bi=−1B_i=-1 for antibaryons respectively, and β=1/T\beta=1/T, where TT is the temperature of this system. The number densities for baryons and anti-baryons can be solved self-consistently from the following pair of equations:

nb=∑i∈B∫gid3p(2π)31eβ(Ei−μB+Knb)+1andnbˉ=∑i∈Bˉ∫gid3p(2π)31eβ(Ei+μB+Knbˉ)+1.(2)n_b = \sum_{i \in B} \int g_i \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}\frac{1}{e^{\beta(E_i-\mu_B+Kn_b)}+1} \qquad\text{and}\qquad n_{\bar b} = \sum_{i \in\bar B} \int g_i \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}\frac{1}{e^{\beta(E_i+\mu_B+Kn_{\bar b})}+1}. \tag*{(2)}

The total pressure within the HRG model is the sum of the contributions from this interacting ensemble of the (anti)baryons and the noninteracting ensemble of mesons. We include the quark model (QM) predicted states [52, 53] in addition to the Particle Data Group (PDG) listed hadrons up to mass 3 GeV following [54, 55]. The PDG list was made considering all the states, even the ones with large uncertainties, and to avoid double counting the QM states are replaced by the experimentally determined states if they have the same mass and quantum numbers. We denote this HRG model with the extended list of particles as the QMHRG model. For μB=0\mu_B=0 we can use the Boltzmann approximation for baryons and antibaryons due to their large masses. Therefore, for the pressure and the number density we could write the following set of equations [46]:

Pint=T(nb+nbˉ)+K2(nb2+nbˉ2)andnb{bˉ}=∑i=B{Bˉ}∫gid3p(2π)3e−β(Ei−μeff).(3)P_{\mathrm{int}} = T(n_b+n_{\bar b})+\frac{K}{2}(n_b^2+n_{\bar b}^2) \qquad\text{and}\qquad n_{b\{\bar b\}} = \sum_{i=B\{\bar B\}} \int g_i \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}e^{-\beta(E_i-\mu_{eff})}. \tag*{(3)}

This approximation greatly simplifies the calculations of the baryon number susceptibilities, which are defined as

χBn=∂n[P(μB/T)/T4]∂(μB/T)n,n=2,4,6,8(4)\chi_{B}^{n}=\frac{\partial^{n}\left[P(\mu_{B}/T)/T^{4}\right]}{\partial(\mu_{B}/T)^{n}},\quad n=2,4,6,8 \tag*{(4)}

The explicit expressions of χnB\chi_{n}^{B} are presented in Appendix § 0.4.1. In this work, we have included the partial pressures of the QMHRG states with repulsive interactions among the (anti) baryons at the mean-field level. Typically in the earlier works the mean-field coefficient has been chosen to be K=450K=450 MeV fm3^{3} which is equivalent to 56.2556.25 GeV−2^{-2} [46, 56] from phenomenological considerations. Here we suggest a new way of estimating this constant. Our approach is motivated by the fact that we have high precision lattice QCD data for χ2B\chi_{2}^{B} and χ4B\chi_{4}^{B} extrapolated to the continuum limit [18, 29] [4]. Therefore, we adjust the value of KK to reproduce these lattice QCD results. In Figure 1 we show the comparison of our results for the second- and fourth-order baryon number fluctuations with the corresponding lattice QCD results. The lattice QCD results on χ2B\chi_{2}^{B} results disagree with the QMHRG model results for T>150T>150 MeV, while the lattice QCD results for χ4B\chi_4^B start to disagree with QMHRG model results already for T>140T > 140 MeV, when no repulsive interactions are taken into account. By including repulsive mean-field interactions within the QMHRG model with K=33K = 33 GeV−2^{-2}, we obtain a good agreement with the lattice QCD results for both χ2B\chi_2^B and χ4B\chi_4^B up to T≈155T \approx155 MeV. In addition there are lattice QCD results for Nτ=8N_\tau= 8 and Nτ=12N_\tau= 12 from the HotQCD Collaboration [57] and Nτ=12N_\tau= 12 results from the Wuppertal-Budapest Collaboration [2] for spatial volume V1/3T=4V^{1/3}T = 4. Here NτN_\tau is the temporal lattice extent that is related to the temperature and the lattice spacing aa, as Nτ=1/(aT)N_\tau= 1/(aT). Very recently continuum extrapolated lattice QCD results on for sixth- and eighth-order baryon number fluctuations were released for small spatial volume V1/3T=2V^{1/3}T = 2 [58].

Second, fourth, sixth, and eighth order baryon number fluctuations compared between ideal QMHRG and mean-field QMHRG models and lattice QCD results

Figure 1. The second (top left), fourth (top right), sixth (bottom left), and eighth (bottom right) order baryon number fluctuations results compared between ideal QMHRG (red line) and mean-field QMHRG (blue line) models and lattice QCD results with physical quark masses. Lattice results for Nτ=12N_{\tau}=12 and Nτ=8N_{\tau}=8 are shown as red and green points respectively with the squares representing HotQCD [57] results and the circles corresponding to Wuppertal-Budapest (WB) results [2]. The gray and yellow bands represent the fluctuation data in the continuum limit from HotQCD [57] and WB [58] Collaborations.

In the lower panels of Figure 1 we show the comparison of the QMHRG model results with the corresponding lattice QCD results for χ6B\chi_6^B and χ8B\chi_8^B. We see from the figure that the QMHRG model results with repulsive mean-field and K=33K = 33 GeV−2^{-2} agree well with the lattice QCD results for χ6B\chi_6^B and χ8B\chi_8^B within errors. The agreement with Wuppertal-Budapest lattice results is especially remarkable as these results have relatively small errors. These lattice QCD results clearly disagree with the QMHRG model without repulsive interactions; see Figure 1 (lower panels). We thus conclude that, in order to apply the QMHRG model at large values of baryon number density to describe QCD, repulsive baryon-baryon interactions have to be taken into account. Here we also note that based on the lattice QCD estimates of the charm quark pressure [59, 60] we do not expect significant contribution from quark degrees of freedom to thermodynamics quantities below TpcT_{pc}. Therefore, thermodynamic estimates based on purely hadronic models will also agree with the lattice data up to TpcT_{pc}.

In the above discussion, we assumed that both baryons and baryon resonances contribute equally to the mean field. This is certainly a very simplistic assumption. One may expect that not all baryon resonances contribute to the mean field at the same level because of their short lifetimes. As an extreme assumption, we can assume that only ground state baryons contribute to the repulsive mean field. As shown in Appendix § 0.4.1, we can describe the lattice results on χ2B\chi_2^B, χ4B\chi_4^B, χ6B\chi_6^B, and χ8B\chi_8^B also in this case if the parameter KK is increased from K=33K = 33 GeV−2^{-2} to K=100K = 100 GeV−2^{-2}. We also calculated the QCD pressure and energy density using the QMHRG model with repulsive mean-field interaction. We find that repulsive mean-field interaction has a significant effect on the pressure and energy density for μB/T≤2\mu_B/T \leq2, and its inclusion improves the agreement with the lattice QCD data. This is shown in the Appendix § 0.4.2. We will return to the calculations of the equations of state within the QMHRG model with repulsive interactions in Sec. IV D for a strangeness neutral system.

Chiral condensate in the mean-field QMHRG model

The light quark condensate at nonzero temperature and density is defined as

⟨ψˉψ⟩l,T=⟨ψˉψ⟩l,0+∂P∂ml,(5)\langle\bar{\psi}\psi\rangle_{l,T} = \langle\bar{\psi}\psi\rangle_{l,0} + \frac{\partial P}{\partial m_l}, \tag*{(5)}

where mlm_l is the light quark mass and PP is the pressure of the thermodynamic medium described by QCD. We work with two degenerate light quarks, mu=md=mlm_u = m_d = m_l. In the HRG model, the derivatives of the pressure with respect to the light quark mass can be written as the mass derivative of the interacting baryonic gas pressure and the ideal mesonic gas pressure. Using Eqs. (1) and (2) the derivative of the interacting baryonic pressure in Eq. (1) can be further written as

(∂Pint∂ml)=−∑i=BMi∂Mi∂ml∫gid3p(2π)3fibEi−∑i=BˉMi∂Mi∂ml∫gid3p(2π)3fˉiEˉi.(6)\left(\frac{\partial P_{\mathrm{int}}}{\partial m_l}\right) = -\sum_{i=B} M_i \frac{\partial M_i}{\partial m_l} \int g_i \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}\frac{f_i^b}{E_i} - \sum_{i=\bar{B}} M_i \frac{\partial M_i}{\partial m_l} \int g_i \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}\frac{\bar{f}_i}{\bar{E}_i}. \tag*{(6)}

Here fib{bˉ}f_i^{b\{\bar{b}\}} is the Fermi-Dirac distribution function corresponding to the baryons and antibaryons with the modified chemical potential μeff=Biμi−Knb{bˉ}\mu_{eff} = B_i\mu_i - K n_{b\{\bar{b}\}}. In the limit K=0K = 0 one obtains the ideal gas result of Ref. [27]. The calculations of the mass derivative of the mesonic pressure are the same as in Ref. [27].

The nontrivial input needed for the calculation of the chiral condensate is the dependence of the hadron and resonance masses on the light quark mass mlm_l. In this work, we have estimated these mass derivatives following Ref. [27]. The uncertainties in the derivatives of the hadron masses with respect to mlm_l have been estimated in Ref. [27], and we propagate these uncertainties when evaluating the temperature and μB\mu_B dependence of the chiral condensate. As in our previous work, we use the renormalized chiral condensate defined by the HotQCD Collaboration [61] as

ΔRl=d+msr14[⟨ψˉψ⟩l,T−⟨ψˉψ⟩l,0],(7)\Delta_R^l = d + m_s r_1^4 \left[\langle\bar{\psi}\psi\rangle_{l,T} - \langle\bar{\psi}\psi\rangle_{l,0}\right], \tag*{(7)}

where the parameter r1r_1 is derived from the static quark potential [62] and d=r14ms(lim⁡ml→0⟨ψˉψ⟩l,0)Rd = r_1^4m_s(\lim_{m_l\to0}\langle\bar{\psi}\psi\rangle_{l,0})^R. In the chiral limit, the light quark condensate has only a multiplicative renormalization factor. The superscript RR denotes the renormalized quantity. Taking into account the fact that (lim⁡ml→0⟨ψˉψ⟩l,0)R=2Σ(\lim_{m_l \to0}\langle\bar{\psi}\psi\rangle_{l,0})^R = 2\Sigma and using the values of the low energy constant of SU(2)SU(2) chiral perturbation theory (χ\chiPT), Σ1/3=272(5)\Sigma^{1/3} = 272(5) MeV and ms=92.2(1.0)m_s = 92.2(1.0) MeV in the MS scheme at μ=2\mu= 2 GeV from the FLAG 2022 review for the 2+1 flavor case [63], as well as r1=0.3106r_1 = 0.3106 fm [64], we obtain the value of d=0.022791d = 0.022791.

We estimate the chiral crossover temperature, TpcT_{pc} as the temperature where the renormalized chiral condensate drops to half of its vacuum value. From the lattice QCD calculations at μB=0\mu_B = 0 we know that this definition of the chiral crossover temperature agrees well with the usual definition of the chiral crossover temperature, defined as the peak position of the chiral susceptibility [61]. In our previous work, we showed that, using this definition of TpcT_{pc} and the temperature dependence of ΔlR\Delta_l^R within the QMHRG model, one obtains a value of TpcT_{pc} at μB=0\mu_B = 0 as well as for small values of μB\mu_B that is only a few MeV larger than the lattice results [27]. We expect that the above criterion to estimate TpcT_{pc} should work at larger values of μB\mu_B as long as we are far away from a true phase transition. Therefore, in this work, we assume that the chiral transition remains a crossover transition also for large values of μB\mu_B and estimate the chiral crossover temperature using the QMHRG model and the above considerations. This is reasonable since there is no definite indication from lattice QCD for a true phase transition at large μB\mu_B, and based on symmetry arguments the transition could be a crossover even for very large values of μB\mu_B [65].

Results on the chiral crossover line

Renormalized chiral condensate in the mean-field formalism:

One of the goals of this study is to study the dependence of the renormalized chiral condensate on temperature and baryon chemical potentials for a large range of μB\mu_B, including values not accessible in lattice QCD calculations. With the already estimated value of the mean-field parameter K=33 GeV−2K = 33\ \mathrm{GeV}^{-2}, we have evaluated ΔlR\Delta_l^R as a function of μB\mu_B for different temperatures, shown in Figure 2. We have also shown the ΔlR\Delta_l^R calculated in the noninteracting QMHRG model for comparison. In the figure, the uncertainty in the values of renormalized chiral condensate obtained in the QMHRG model with repulsive mean-field interactions due to the uncertainties of the quark mass derivatives is represented as the width of the lines. For the noninteracting QMHRG model, we do not show the corresponding uncertainties for better visibility. For temperatures T<100T < 100 MeV, we observe a prominent plateau in the value of ΔlR\Delta_l^R for a range of baryon chemical potentials, the extent of which reduces with increasing temperature. Furthermore, we observe that the renormalized condensate falls faster with increasing μB\mu_B from the plateau region for the noninteracting QMHRG model compared to the QMHRG model with repulsive mean-field interactions. Thus the repulsive mean-field pushes the transition point toward larger values of μB\mu_B. As stated above we use the condition of the chiral condensate dropping to half of its vacuum values to estimate the crossover point. Thus using the values of μB\mu_B where ΔRl\Delta_R^l is at half of its vacuum value for each temperature we obtain the estimate of crossover line as a function of baryon chemical potential, Tpc(μB)T_{\rm pc}(\mu_B).

Figure 2. Left: The μB\mu_B dependence of the renormalized chiral condensate at different temperatures T=25T = 25–150150 MeV. The bands are results from the QMHRG model with repulsive mean-field interaction and the lines with points are the results from the ideal QMHRG model. Right: The variation of the ΔlR\Delta_l^R with net-baryon number density normalized by the nuclear saturation density, n0=0.16 fm−3n_0 = 0.16\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3}, for the same range of temperatures. The widths of the bands represent the uncertainty of the chiral condensate due to the uncertainties in the quark mass derivatives of the hadron masses; see text for details.

We are also interested in estimating the chiral crossover temperature as a function of the net baryon density, nBn_B. Therefore, we have also studied the dependence of ΔRl\Delta_R^l on nBn_B. The right panel of Figure 2 shows the change in ΔRl\Delta_R^l at different temperatures as a function of net baryon number density nBn_B scaled by the nuclear saturation density n0=0.16 fm−3n_0 = 0.16\ {\rm fm}^{-3}. At a fixed temperature, ΔRl\Delta_R^l decreases as the net baryon density increases because baryons significantly contribute to the reduction of the chiral condensate. From this figure, we observe that the density corresponding to the chiral crossover transition for T=100T = 100 MeV slightly exceeds that for T=25T = 25 MeV, for example. This seemingly contradicts the usual expectation that nBn_B decreases as TT increases along the chiral crossover line. This is an artifact of the hadron resonance gas model at very low temperatures, as discussed in Sec. IV C.

Curvature of the crossover line in the repulsive mean-field QMHRG model

As discussed in the previous subsection, the temperature at which the observable ΔRl\Delta_R^l falls to half its zero-temperature value is used as an estimate of the pseudocritical temperature TpcT_{\rm pc} [27] for each value of μB\mu_B. The extracted pseudo-critical temperature as a function of μB\mu_B, Tpc(μB)T_{\rm pc}(\mu_B), is shown as a function of μB\mu_B in the left panel of Figure 3 using QMHRG model for K=0K = 0 and K=33 GeV−2K = 33\ {\rm GeV}^{-2}. The uncertainty in the value of ΔRl\Delta_R^l results in an uncertainty in the value of the crossover temperature, which, however, is quite small, about the size of the symbols in Figure 3 or even smaller. In the same figure, the vertical axis is scaled by the estimated pseudocritical temperatures at zero baryon density, which are Tpc(μB=0)=161.2(1.7)T_{\rm pc}(\mu_B = 0) = 161.2(1.7) MeV for the ideal case [27] and Tpc(μB=0)=161.5(1.6)T_{\rm pc}(\mu_B = 0) = 161.5(1.6) MeV for the repulsive QMHRG model with the mean-field coefficient K=33 GeV−2K = 33\ {\rm GeV}^{-2}. Our analysis is restricted to μB≤750\mu_B \leq750 MeV for reasons explained below. As one can see from the figure, the effects of repulsive baryon interactions start to have an impact on the value of TpcT_{\rm pc} for μB>300\mu_B > 300 MeV, pushing the chiral crossover temperature toward larger values and leading to a better agreement with the lattice QCD results on the curvature of the pseudocritical line. On the other hand for μB<300\mu_B < 300 MeV the effects of the repulsive mean-fields are small, and good agreement for the curvature of the pseudocritical line is obtained using QMHRG model with or without the repulsive mean fields included.

Figure 3. Left: The pseudocritical line calculated from the QMHRG model is compared with the lattice QCD results from the HotQCD Collaboration (light blue) from Ref. [66]. The ideal gas (K=0K = 0) results are shown as a line and results including the mean-field repulsion (K=33K = 33) are shown as open symbols. These are compared with the freeze-out line (magenta) using the parametrization in Ref. [67]. The gray line represents the fit performed by us to obtain the pseudocritical line; see text for details. Right: The net-baryon density in units of n0=0.16 fm−3n_0 = 0.16\ {\rm fm}^{-3} is shown as function of μB\mu_B along the pseudocritical line. The horizontal gray band represents the variance in the nB/n0n_B/n_0, which is due to the variation of TpcT_{\rm pc} arising from the uncertainties in the sigma terms. We also show the variation of the net baryon density along the freeze-out line. The color scheme is the same as in the left panel.

In Figure 3 we also show the recent parametrization of the chemical freeze-out line in heavy ion collisions from Ref. [67]. The freeze-out line is normalized by the freeze-out temperature Tf=158T_f = 158 MeV at μB=0\mu_B = 0 [67]. For μB<300\mu_B < 300 MeV the freeze-out line agrees well with the pseudocritical line. However, we observe significant differences between the pseudocritical line and the chemical freeze-out line for μB>400\mu_B > 400 MeV, which become larger as the value of the baryon chemical potential increases. Namely, the chiral crossover temperature is always larger than the chemical freeze-out temperature. For μB=400\mu_B = 400 MeV, the chiral crossover temperature is more than 8 MeV larger than the freeze-out temperature while at μB=750\mu_B = 750 MeV it is more than 20 MeV larger than the freeze-out temperature. Thus, the systems produced in heavy ion collisions in the fixed target mode of the beam energy scan (BES) program at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) as well as in heavy ion collisions at GSI are expected to undergo a significant nonequilibrium chemical evolution in the hadronic phase unlike the matter produced in heavy ion collisions at higher center-of-mass energies, like the heavy ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and at RHIC in the collider mode.

We next performed a fit to the obtained values of Tpc(μB)T_{pc}(\mu_B) with the following widely used ansatz:

Tpc(μB)Tpc(0)=1−κ2(μBTpc(0))2−κ4(μBTpc(0))4.(8)\frac{T_{pc}(\mu_B)}{T_{pc}(0)} = 1 - \kappa_2 \left(\frac{\mu_B}{T_{pc}(0)}\right)^2 - \kappa_4 \left(\frac{\mu_B}{T_{pc}(0)}\right)^4 . \tag*{(8)}

It turns out that a good fit can be obtained by this ansatz for μB≤750\mu_B \le750 MeV which results in the following values of the curvature coefficients: κ2=0.0150(2)\kappa_2 = 0.0150(2) and κ4=3.1(6)×10−5\kappa_4 = 3.1(6) \times10^{-5}. The value of κ2\kappa_2 is consistent within errors with the two most recent continuum estimates from lattice QCD studies with physical masses, κ2=0.012(4)\kappa_2 = 0.012(4) [66] and κ2=0.0153(18)\kappa_2 = 0.0153(18) [68], as well as with the earlier lattice QCD estimates [69, 70, 71]. For the first time, we could estimate a nontrivial value of κ4\kappa_4 which is distinctly different from zero given the estimated errors. Lattice QCD calculations report a κ4\kappa_4 which is compatible with zero within errors [66, 68]. The above estimate for the leading curvature coefficient is somewhat smaller than the one obtained from the relativistic nuclear mean-field model calculation, while κ4\kappa_4 has the opposite sign [72]. Allowing for a nonzero value of κ6\kappa_6 does not improve the quality of the fit, and only leads to much larger errors in κ2\kappa_2 and κ4\kappa_4. Therefore, it is fair to say that, within our accuracy, κ6\kappa_6 is consistent with zero.

Net-baryon density, energy density, and particle composition along the pseudocritical line

The right panel of Figure 3 shows the estimated values of net-baryon density normalized by the nuclear saturation density n0n_0 as function of μB\mu_B along the pseudocritical line in the T−μBT-\mu_B plane. The baryon density increases monotonically with μB\mu_B as expected, but for sufficiently large μB\mu_B it reaches a maximum and then decreases with a further increase in μB\mu_B. This behavior is clearly unphysical and therefore, the applicability of the HRG model is restricted for large values of μB\mu_B. The maximum in nBn_B of 1.53(13)n01.53(13)n_0 is reached at μB=700\mu_B = 700 MeV when K=0K = 0 and at μB=750\mu_B = 750 MeV for K=33K = 33 GeV−2^{-2}. Thus the inclusion of repulsive mean-field interaction in the QMHRG model calculation helps to extend the model to slightly larger values of μB\mu_B. However, our QMHRG model with a single repulsive mean-field is too simplistic and is not valid for very large values of μB\mu_B. The large value of nBn_B obtained at relatively small values of μB\mu_B is due to the contribution from baryon resonances. Since the chiral crossover temperature decreases with increasing μB\mu_B, the contribution from these states will eventually decrease and the large value of the net-baryon density near the crossover point should come from nucleons and possibly their attractive interactions. But the simple HRG model cannot describe this switchover. Thus for temperatures close to the chiral crossover temperatures, the QMHRG model is only applicable for μB<750\mu_B < 750 MeV.

The nonmonotonic variation of nBn_B with μB\mu_B is also observed in the Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model [73], where the mass-gap equation determines the phase transition line, resulting in a qualitatively similar trend. A similar maximum of the net-baryon density as a function of μB\mu_B was earlier observed in a HRG motivated study along the freeze-out boundary in Ref. [74], which was determined from the hadron yields at different collision energies.

It is interesting to study the variation of energy density along the pseudocritical line, which is shown in the left panel of Figure 4. One can see that the energy density along the pseudocritical line slightly decreases with increasing μB\mu_B. The relative contribution to the energy density coming from the baryon sector increases till μB=650\mu_B = 650 MeV as the baryon chemical potential increases, resulting in a shift from a meson-dominated to a baryon-dominated scenario, beyond μB=350\mu_B = 350 MeV. A comparable phenomenon can be observed in heavy-ion collisions, where a transition from meson to baryon dominance during freeze-out takes place at lower energies [75], where the net-baryon density is larger.

Figure 4. Left: Relative contributions to the energy density from mesons (blue) and baryons (red) along the pseudo-critical line compared to the total energy density (gray) calculated in the mean-field QMHRG model. Right: The relative number densities of various baryon species shown along the pseudo-critical line.

Furthermore, we would like to understand the relative abundances of different baryon species with increasing μB\mu_B. In the right panel of Figure 4 we have shown the relative contribution of different baryons and baryon resonances to the net-baryon density as a function of μB\mu_B along the pseudocritical line. As the baryon chemical potential increases, the relative contribution of the nucleons also increases. The relative contributions of the lowest lying strange baryons and of the lowest Δ\Delta resonances do not change significantly with increasing μB\mu_B, either. While the net contribution from higher lying resonances decreases with increasing μB\mu_B, this contribution remains significant up to μ=750\mu= 750 MeV. Even for the largest value of μB=750\mu_B = 750 MeV, where our HRG model is applicable, nucleons contribute less than 50% to the total net-baryon density. Thus the contribution of the baryon resonances remains important even at large values of μB\mu_B, and this contribution is responsible for the relatively large values of nBn_B. At the same time, the treatment of the repulsive interactions for baryon resonances is quite simplistic. In future, a more refined QMHRG mean-field model, which treats the repulsive interactions differently in the nucleon, strange baryon, and baryon resonance sectors will be needed to extend the reach of the QMHRG model.

Strangeness neutrality and the chiral pseudo-critical line

The system created in heavy ion collisions has zero netstrangeness, since the incoming nuclei do not contain strange particles. Therefore, it is important to estimate the pseudocritical line for the conditions realized in heavy-ion experiments, namely for zero net strangeness, nS=0n_S = 0. At nonzero values of μB\mu_B, one needs to tune the strangeness chemical potential μS\mu_S to achieve zero netstrangeness. We performed this tuning to estimate the crossover temperature and the equation of state within our QMHRG model. The values of μS\mu_S needed to achieve strangeness neutrality are shown in Appendix § 0.4.3.

In Figure 5 (left) we show the crossover temperature in the case of nS=0n_S = 0 as a function of the baryon chemical potential, while in Figure 5 (right) we show the crossover temperature as a function of the net-baryon number. For a comparison, we also show our results for TpcT_{pc} for the unconstrained, μS=0\mu_S = 0 case in the same figure. We observe that imposing strangeness neutrality pushes the crossover temperature to a slightly larger value compared to the case of μS=0\mu_S = 0 discussed in the previous subsections, whether or not one includes the effect of the repulsive mean field. The effect of imposing strangeness neutrality on the crossover temperature is considerably smaller than the effect of the repulsive interactions. Interestingly enough, the effects of the repulsive interactions are not visible on TpcT_{pc} when plotted as a function of the net-baryon density. This can seen from Figure 5 (right). The clear difference between the pseudocritical line and the freeze-out line is also apparent for the zero net-strangeness case, cf. Figure 5, especially when the results are shown in the T−nBT-n_B plane.

Figure 5. The chiral crossover temperature at finite density μB\mu_B normalized by its corresponding value at μB=0\mu_B=0 is shown as function of μB\mu_B (left) and as a function of nBn_B (right) for μS=0\mu_S=0 and under strangeness neutrality condition, nS=0n_S=0. Ideal QMHRG model results are shown in blue. Coral and green represents mean-field QMHRG results for nS=0n_S=0 and μS=0\mu_S=0 respectively.

The maximum net-baryon number density that can be reached within our model is slightly reduced compared to the unconstrained, μS=0\mu_S = 0 case to about 1.4n01.4n_0 compared to 1.53n01.53n_0 as obtained in the previous subsection. This is due to the fact that a positive nonzero value of μS\mu_S required by the condition nS=0n_S = 0 reduces the contribution of strange baryons to the partition function.

Speed of sound along the isentropic lines

In heavy-ion experiments, the chemical freeze-out surface is typically defined as a surface of constant entropy per baryon density, denoted as s/nBs/n_B [76]. Hence it is interesting to study the evolution of the QCD matter formed in heavy-ion collisions along the lines of constant s/nBs/n_B. The evolution of this matter is subject to several constraints, including strangeness neutrality (nS=0n_S = 0) and a fixed ratio of net electric charge (nQn_Q) to net-baryon number (nBn_B) density due to charge conservation. We study a particular case of strangeness-neutral system with isospin symmetry which is realized when nQ/nB=0.5n_Q/n_B = 0.5, corresponding to a nonzero μB\mu_B and μS\mu_S but μQ=0\mu_Q = 0. It has been shown that the differences in bulk thermodynamic observables that arise from deviations in nQ/nBn_Q/n_B from the isospin-symmetric value of 0.5 are minimal [29]. We have examined the isospin-symmetric scenario for a range of entropy per baryon density values, s/nB=15,20,30,50,100,s/n_B = 15, 20, 30, 50, 100, and 400400. These values effectively cover the range of center-of-mass energies explored in the RHIC BES program in the collider mode [29]. The left panel of Figure 6 illustrates the isentropic trajectories for different values of s/nBs/n_B and compares to the lattice QCD results available up to μB/T=2.5\mu_B/T = 2.5 from Ref. [29]. We have also included the pseudocritical line estimated by us in the same plot for comparison. Our estimates obtained within the mean-field repulsive QMHRG model show a good agreement with the lattice results at temperatures below the pseudo-critical temperatures. For completeness, we have also included the isentropic trajectories for s/nB=15s/n_B = 15 and s/nB=20s/n_B = 20 calculated within the repulsive QMHRG model. These trajectories are beyond the reach of lattice QCD calculations and hold significance for lower collision energies of the RHIC BES program in the fixed target mode [77].

Figure 6. Left: The isentropes for s/nB=15,20,30,50,100,s/n_B=15,20,30,50,100, and 400400 respectively are shown in the T−μBT-\mu_B plane. Right: The speed of sound as a function of the temperature is shown along these isentropes. The bands are the lattice QCD data from [29] and the points are the QMHRG model calculations with repulsive mean field. The isentropes and the speed of sound in the low temperature region 60<T<15060<T<150 MeV are shown in the insets of the left and the right figures respectively. The black line represents the pseudocritical line evaluated within our mean-field QMHRG model.

In the right panel of Figure 6, we have shown the speed of sound calculated within the mean-field repulsive QMHRG model calculated along these constant s/nBs/n_B trajectories. The speed of sound is defined as [29]

cs2=(∂P∂ϵ)s/nB,nS,nB/nQ=(∂P/∂T)s/nB,nS,nB/nQ(∂ϵ/∂T)s/nB,nS,nB/nQ(9)c_s^2 = \left(\frac{\partial P}{\partial\epsilon}\right)_{s/n_B,n_S,n_B/n_Q} = \frac{\left(\partial P/\partial T\right)_{s/n_B,n_S,n_B/n_Q}}{\left(\partial\epsilon/\partial T\right)_{s/n_B,n_S,n_B/n_Q}} \tag*{(9)}

Here, all the derivatives are taken along the lines of constant nS=0n_S = 0, nB/nQ=0.5n_B/n_Q = 0.5 for different values of s/nBs/n_B. We show the speed of sound for our QMHRG model and compare it with the latest lattice QCD results from Ref. [29]. The cs2c_s^2 calculated within the mean-field QMHRG model decreases as the temperature is increased towards TpcT_{pc} for s/nB>30s/n_B > 30. The QMHRG results with repulsive mean field for cs2c_s^2 are in agreement with the lattice QCD results for T<150T < 150 MeV. Beyond this temperature, the lattice QCD results show an increasing trend with the temperature, which cannot be reproduced within a QMHRG model, even when the effect of the repulsive interactions are included. We also observe that in the temperature range 100<T<150100 < T < 150 MeV the speed of sound decreases with increasing temperature both in the lattice QCD calculations and in the QMHRG model. This leads to a minimum of the speed of sound in the range of temperatures 140-150 MeV. From the inset of Figure 6 (right) we also observe that the speed of sound has a maximum in the low temperature region for s/nB≥30s/n_B \ge30.

The behavior of the speed of sound for s/nB=20s/n_B = 20 and s/nB=15s/n_B = 15, currently inaccessible through lattice QCD techniques, is somewhat different. From Figure 6 (right) we observe that for s/nB=20s/n_B = 20 the speed of sound has a very shallow minimum around T=145T = 145 MeV, while for s/nB=15s/n_B = 15 it is always monotonically increasing with increasing temperatures. This implies that the maximum in cs2c_s^2, evident from the plot at low temperatures T<75T < 75 MeV and small baryon densities, should disappear when baryon densities are increased. We thus do not observe a softening of the equation of state near the chiral crossover transition at large values of baryon densities corresponding to s/nB≈15s/n_B \approx15 within this mean-field treatment of repulsive baryon interactions.

Summary

In this paper, we have studied the QCD equation of state and the chiral crossover at non-zero net baryon density using the QMHRG model with repulsive mean-field interaction. We have shown that this model can describe the lattice results on the fluctuations of net baryon number up to the eighth order in the vicinity of the chiral crossover temperature if the parameter characterizing the strength of the mean-field repulsive interactions is properly chosen. This is contrary to the usual QMHRG which can describe the higher-order net baryon number fluctuations only for considerably lower temperatures.

We extended our previous calculation of the chiral crossover temperature within the QMHRG model limited to the region of small baryon chemical potential [27] to much larger values of the baryon chemical potential. We showed that for μB>400\mu_B > 400 MeV there is a significant effect of the repulsive mean field on the value of the chiral crossover temperature. We found that the μB\mu_B dependence of the chiral crossover temperature can be very well parametrized by the following form: Tpc(μB)/Tpc(0)=1−κ2(μB/Tpc(0))2−κ4(μB/Tpc(0))4T_{pc}(\mu_B)/T_{pc}(0) = 1-\kappa_2(\mu_B/T_{pc}(0))^2-\kappa_4(\mu_B/T_{pc}(0))^4 with κ2=0.0150(2)\kappa_2 = 0.0150(2) and κ4=3.1(6)×10−5\kappa_4 = 3.1(6) \times10^{-5}. The value of the leading curvature coefficient, κ2\kappa_2, agrees well with the lattice QCD results within errors. The smallness of κ4\kappa_4 is consistent with the upper bounds from lattice QCD, but for the first time we found that the corresponding value is significantly different from zero.

To realize the relevance of this study in the context of heavy-ion collision experiments, we have estimated the chiral crossover line imposing the strangeness-neutrality condition. The separation between the freeze-out curve and the pseudocritical line increases toward high density, which implies a longer-lived interacting hadronic phase at lower collision energies. Furthermore, we have used the repulsive mean-field QMHRG model to calculate the speed of sound along various isentropic (constant s/nBs/n_B) lines pertinent to heavy-ion collision experiments, constrained by the strangeness neutrality and nQ/nBn_Q/n_B ratio. In the hadron phase, there is good agreement between our calculation and the latest available data from lattice QCD. We have also predicted the isentropic trajectory and the speed of sound within this repulsive mean-field model for s/nB=15s/n_B=15, where no lattice QCD data are available. We see that starting from this value of s/nBs/n_B the previously seen characteristic softening of the QCD equation of state near the chiral crossover regions disappears.

We pointed out that the QMHRG model with a single repulsive mean field for all baryons only works for μB<750\mu_B<750 MeV. For larger values of the baryon chemical potential, a more refined mean field approach is needed, with different mean fields for different baryon species.

Acknowledgments

D.B. is supported by the Department Of Atomic Energy (DAE), India. P.P. is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, through Contract No. DE-SC0012704. S.S. gratefully acknowledges support from the Department of Science and Technology, Government of India through a Ramanujan Fellowship when a major part of this work was done. D.B. gratefully acknowledges Jishnu Goswami for helping with the lattice data from the HotQCD Collaboration. Additionally, D.B. would like to extend thanks to A. Abhishek, H. Mishra, and N. Sarkar for useful discussions. D.B. thanks P. Parotto for his assistance with the continuum extrapolated lattice data from the WB Collaboration.

Calculation of baryon number fluctuations within mean-field HRG

The fluctuations of baryon charges can be derived from the pressure using [57]

χBn=∂n[P(μB/T)/T4]∂(μB/T)n(10)\chi_B^n = \frac{\partial^n\left[P(\mu_B/T)/T^4\right]}{\partial(\mu_B/T)^n} \tag*{(10)}

In the mean-field formalism, the respective number densities for baryons and antibaryons in the Boltzmann approximation are written as [46]

nb=∑i=Bgi∫d3p(2π)3e−β(Ei−μB+Knb)andnˉb=∑i=Bˉgi∫d3p(2π)3e−β(Ei+μB+Knˉb).(11)n_b = \sum_{i=B} g_i \int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}e^{-\beta(E_i-\mu_B+Kn_b)} \quad\text{and}\quad \bar n_b = \sum_{i=\bar B} g_i \int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}e^{-\beta(E_i+\mu_B+K\bar n_b)}. \tag*{(11)}

Here, β\beta is the inverse of temperature. The above equations are transcendental equations and one can evaluate the fluctuations of the net baryon number by taking the derivative with μB/T\mu_B/T,

∂nb∂(βμB)=∑i=Bgi∫d3p(2π)3e−β(Ei−μB+Knb)[1−βK∂nb∂(βμB)]=∑i=Bni[1−βK∂nb∂(βμB)](12)\frac{\partial n_b}{\partial(\beta\mu_B)} = \sum_{i=B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}e^{-\beta(E_i-\mu_B+Kn_b)} \left[1-\beta K\frac{\partial n_b}{\partial(\beta\mu_B)}\right] = \sum_{i=B}n_i\left[1-\beta K\frac{\partial n_b}{\partial(\beta\mu_B)}\right] \tag*{(12)}

By re-arranging the above equation, one can write the first derivative as

nb′=∂nb∂(βμB)=∑i=Bni1+βK∑i=Bni=nb1+βKnb.(13)n'_b = \frac{\partial n_b}{\partial(\beta\mu_B)} = \frac{\sum_{i=B}n_i}{1+\beta K\sum_{i=B}n_i} = \frac{n_b}{1+\beta K n_b}. \tag*{(13)}

Similarly, for the antibaryon sector,

nbˉ′=∂nˉb∂(βμB)=−∑i=Bˉni1+βK∑i=Bˉni=−nˉb1+βKnˉb.(14)n'_{\bar b} = \frac{\partial\bar n_b}{\partial(\beta\mu_B)} = \frac{-\sum_{i=\bar B}n_i}{1+\beta K\sum_{i=\bar B}n_i} = \frac{-\bar n_b}{1+\beta K\bar n_b}. \tag*{(14)}

In the mean-field formalism, the total pressure in the baryon sector is written as a sum of the partial pressures of the (anti)baryons [46],

P=T(nb+nˉb)+K2(nb2+nˉb2)andPT4=β3(nb+nˉb)+β4K2(nb2+nˉb2).P=T(n_b+\bar n_b)+\frac{K}{2}(n_b^2+\bar n_b^2) \quad\text{and}\quad \frac{P}{T^4}=\beta^3(n_b+\bar n_b)+\beta^4\frac{K}{2}(n_b^2+\bar n_b^2).

Taking the first-order derivative with respect to βμB\beta\mu_B, we get

χB1=β3(nb′+nbˉ′)+β4K(nbnb′+nbˉnbˉ′)=β3nb′(1+βKnb)+β3nbˉ′(1+βKnbˉ)=β3(nb−nbˉ)(15)\begin{aligned} \chi_B^1 &= \beta^3(n_b' + n_{\bar b}') + \beta^4 K(n_bn_b' + n_{\bar b}n_{\bar b}') = \beta^3 n_b'(1+\beta K n_b) + \beta^3 n_{\bar b}'(1+\beta K n_{\bar b}) \\ &= \beta^3(n_b-n_{\bar b}) \tag*{(15)} \end{aligned}

The above equation ensures that the net baryon number is given by the difference of the number of baryons and the number of antibaryons, and vanishes for μB=0\mu_B=0.

Using the above expressions, it is easy to extend the calculations to higher-order derivatives with respect to μB/T\mu_B/T. For completeness here we list all the derivatives up to the eighth order.

χB1=β3[nb−nbˉ],(16)\chi_B^1 = \beta^3\left[n_b-n_{\bar b}\right], \tag*{(16)}
χB2=β3[nb1+βKnb+nbˉ1+βKnbˉ],\chi_B^2 = \beta^3\left[\frac{n_b}{1+\beta K n_b}+\frac{n_{\bar b}}{1+\beta K n_{\bar b}}\right],
χB3=β3[nb(1+βKnb)3−nbˉ(1+βKnbˉ)3],\chi_B^3 = \beta^3\left[\frac{n_b}{(1+\beta K n_b)^3}-\frac{n_{\bar b}}{(1+\beta K n_{\bar b})^3}\right],
χB4=β3[nb(1−2βKnb)(1+βKnb)5+nbˉ(1−2βKnbˉ)(1+βKnbˉ)5],\chi_B^4 = \beta^3\left[\frac{n_b(1-2\beta K n_b)}{(1+\beta K n_b)^5}+\frac{n_{\bar b}(1-2\beta K n_{\bar b})}{(1+\beta K n_{\bar b})^5}\right],
χB5=β3[nb(1−8βKnb+6[βKnb]2)(1+βKnb)7−nbˉ(1−8βKnbˉ+6[βKnbˉ]2)(1+βKnbˉ)7],\chi_B^5 = \beta^3\left[\frac{n_b(1-8\beta K n_b+6[\beta K n_b]^2)}{(1+\beta K n_b)^7}-\frac{n_{\bar b}(1-8\beta K n_{\bar b}+6[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^2)}{(1+\beta K n_{\bar b})^7}\right],
χB6=β3[nb(1−22βKnb+58[βKnb]2−24[βKnb]3)(1+βKnb)9+nbˉ(1−22βKnbˉ+58[βKnbˉ]2−24[βKnbˉ]3)(1+βKnbˉ)9],\chi_B^6 = \beta^3\left[\frac{n_b(1-22\beta K n_b+58[\beta K n_b]^2-24[\beta K n_b]^3)}{(1+\beta K n_b)^9}+\frac{n_{\bar b}(1-22\beta K n_{\bar b}+58[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^2-24[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^3)}{(1+\beta K n_{\bar b})^9}\right],
χB7=β3[nb(1−52βKnb+328[βKnb]2−444[βKnb]3+120[βKnb]4)(1+βKnb)11−nbˉ(1−52βKnbˉ+328[βKnbˉ]2−444[βKnbˉ]3+120[βKnbˉ]4)(1+βKnbˉ)11],\begin{aligned} \chi_B^7 = \beta^3\left[\frac{n_b(1-52\beta K n_b+328[\beta K n_b]^2-444[\beta K n_b]^3+120[\beta K n_b]^4)}{(1+\beta K n_b)^{11}} \right.\\ \left. -\frac{n_{\bar b}(1-52\beta K n_{\bar b}+328[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^2-444[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^3+120[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^4)}{(1+\beta K n_{\bar b})^{11}}\right], \end{aligned}
χB8=β3[nb(1−114βKnb+1452[βKnb]2−4400[βKnb]3+3708[βKnb]4−720[βKnb]5)(1+βKnb)13+nbˉ(1−114βKnbˉ+1452[βKnbˉ]2−4400[βKnbˉ]3+3708[βKnbˉ]4−720[βKnbˉ]5)(1+βKnbˉ)13].\begin{aligned} \chi_B^8 = \beta^3\left[\frac{n_b(1-114\beta K n_b+1452[\beta K n_b]^2-4400[\beta K n_b]^3+3708[\beta K n_b]^4-720[\beta K n_b]^5)}{(1+\beta K n_b)^{13}} \right.\\ \left. +\frac{n_{\bar b}(1-114\beta K n_{\bar b}+1452[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^2-4400[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^3+3708[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^4-720[\beta K n_{\bar b}]^5)}{(1+\beta K n_{\bar b})^{13}}\right]. \end{aligned}

It is obvious from the above equations that the odd fluctuations of net baryon number vanish for μB=0\mu_B=0.

Using the above expressions we calculated the fluctuations of the net baryon density up to the eighth order at μB=0\mu_B=0 and compared them to the available lattice results for different values of the parameter KK. The value K=33 GeV−2K=33\ {\rm GeV}^{-2} leads to a good agreement with the lattice QCD results as one sees from Figure 7. Here it is assumed that all baryons and baryon resonances contribute to the mean field. If we assume that only ground-state baryons contribute to the mean field then we do not get such a good agreement with the lattice QCD results for the same value of KK. However, using a larger value of KK, namely K=100 GeV−2K=100\ {\rm GeV}^{-2} a reasonably good agreement with the lattice QCD results can be obtained; cf. Figure 7.

Figure 7. Top row: second-order (left) and fourth-order (right) baryon number fluctuations; bottom row: sixth-order (left) and eighth-order (right) baryon number fluctuations, shown as a function of temperature and μB=0\mu_B = 0. The K=0K = 0 results represent the ideal QMHRG model, whereas the K=33K = 33 data are calculated with mean-field repulsive interactions among all the baryons with a mean-field coefficient of K=33 GeV−2K = 33\ \mathrm{GeV}^{-2}. Similarly, MF in OD represents the case where we have included repulsive mean-field interaction only among the baryons in octets and decuplets. Lattice QCD results for Nτ=8N_{\tau} = 8 and Nτ=12N_{\tau} = 12 are shown in red and green colors respectively, where the squares and circles correspond to data from the HotQCD [57] and Wuppertal-Budapest (WB) [2] Collaborations. The gray and yellow bands represent the fluctuation data in the continuum limit from the HotQCD [57] and WB [58] Collaborations.

Calculation of the equation of state within the mean-field HRG model

The energy density is defined from the pressure as

ϵ=−P−β(∂P∂β)βμ(17)\epsilon=-P-\beta\left(\frac{\partial P}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu} \tag*{(17)}

Taking the derivative of the number density with β\beta we find

(∂nb∂β)βμ=∑i=Bgi∫d3p(2π)3e−β(Ei−μB+Knb)[−Ei−Knb−βK(∂nb∂β)βμ]=−∑i=Bgi∫d3p(2π)3fibEi−Knb2−βKnb(∂nb∂β)βμ.(18)\begin{aligned} \left(\frac{\partial n_b}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu} &=\sum_{i=B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}e^{-\beta(E_i-\mu_B+Kn_b)} \left[-E_i-Kn_b-\beta K\left(\frac{\partial n_b}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu}\right]\\ &=-\sum_{i=B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}f_i^b E_i-Kn_b^2-\beta K n_b\left(\frac{\partial n_b}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu}. \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

Rearranging the above equation we get

(∂nb∂β)βμ=−∑i=Bgi∫d3p(2π)3fibEi−Knb21+βKnb.(19)\left(\frac{\partial n_b}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu} = \frac{-\sum_{i=B} g_i \int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3} f_i^b E_i - K n_b^2}{1+\beta K n_b}. \tag*{(19)}

Similarly for the antibaryon, we can write

(∂nˉb∂β)βμ=−∑i=Bˉgi∫d3p(2π)3fˉiEi−Knˉb21+βKnˉb.(20)\left(\frac{\partial\bar n_b}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu} = \frac{-\sum_{i=\bar B} g_i \int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3} \bar f_i E_i - K\bar n_b^2}{1+\beta K\bar n_b}. \tag*{(20)}

The derivative of the pressure is written as

−β(∂P∂β)βμ=+1β(nb+nˉb)−(∂nb∂β)βμ(1+βKnb)−(∂nˉb∂β)βμ(1+βKnˉb)=+1β(nb+nˉb)+∑i=Bgi∫d3p(2π)3fibEi+Knb2+∑i=Bˉgi∫d3p(2π)3fibˉEi+Knˉb2.(21)\begin{aligned} -\beta\left(\frac{\partial P}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu} = +\frac{1}{\beta}(n_b+\bar n_b)-\left(\frac{\partial n_b}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu}(1+\beta K n_b)-\left(\frac{\partial\bar n_b}{\partial\beta}\right)_{\beta\mu}(1+\beta K\bar n_b) \\ &=+\frac{1}{\beta}(n_b+\bar n_b)+\sum_{i=B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}f_i^b E_i+K n_b^2+\sum_{i=\bar B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}f_i^{\bar b}E_i+K\bar n_b^2. \tag*{(21)} \end{aligned}

Putting the derivative terms together in Eq. (17), one can derive the final expression for the energy density,

ϵ=−1β(nb+nˉb)−K2(nb2+nˉb2)+1β(nb+nˉb)+∑i=Bgi∫d3p(2π)3fibEi+∑i=Bˉgi∫d3p(2π)3fibˉEi+K(nb2+nˉb2)=∑i=Bgi∫d3p(2π)3fibEi+∑i=Bˉgi∫d3p(2π)3fibˉEi+K2(nb2+nˉb2)(22)\begin{aligned} \epsilon=-\frac{1}{\beta}(n_b+\bar n_b)-\frac{K}{2}(n_b^2+\bar n_b^2)+\frac{1}{\beta}(n_b+\bar n_b)+\sum_{i=B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}f_i^bE_i+\sum_{i=\bar B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}f_i^{\bar b}E_i+K(n_b^2+\bar n_b^2) \\ &=\sum_{i=B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}f_i^bE_i+\sum_{i=\bar B}g_i\int\frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}f_i^{\bar b}E_i+\frac{K}{2}(n_b^2+\bar n_b^2) \tag*{(22)} \end{aligned}

In the ideal limit of K=0K=0 the above formula reduces to the ideal HRG expression for energy density. In Figure 8 we

Figure 8. The pressure P/T4P/T^4 (upper row) and energy density ϵ/T4\epsilon/T^4 (lower row) normalized by T4T^4 calculated for ideal (red) and repulsive mean-field (blue) QMHRG models. Lattice results (black points) are from [1]. The results are displayed for μB/T=0\mu_B/T=0, 11, and 22, in the left, middle, and right panels respectively.

show the pressure and energy density in units of T4T^4 in QMHRG and compare them with the lattice QCD results from Ref. [1]. The results for both the ideal case and repulsive mean field case with K=33 GeV−2K=33\ \mathrm{GeV}^{-2} at μB/T=0\mu_B/T=0, 11, and 22 are displayed. For all baryon chemical potentials, the QMHRG estimations align well with lattice results up to 150 MeV. At high μB/T\mu_B/T, the effect of repulsive mean field is more pronounced due to the increased thermal abundance of baryons at high density; cf. Figure 8.

Strangeness chemical potential for strange neutrality case

In Figure 9 (left) we show the temperature normalized baryon and strangeness chemical potential along the chiral crossover line for nS=0n_{S}=0. We see that the effect of the repulsive mean field is visible for the baryon chemical potential, but is very small for the strangeness chemical potential. In Figure 9 (right) we show the ratio μS/μB\mu_{S}/\mu_{B} along the crossover line. We see that the repulsive mean-field significantly reduces this ratio compared to the ideal case.

Figure 9. The chemical potentials μB/T\mu_{B}/T and μS/T\mu_{S}/T (left) and the ratio μB/μS\mu_{B}/\mu_{S} (right) are shown for different temperatures along the pseudocritical line. K=0K=0 denotes ideal QMHRG model results, whereas K=33K=33 represents the case where we have included repulsive interaction among all baryons with a mean-field coefficient of K=33 GeV−2K=33\ \mathrm{GeV}^{-2}.

References

References

  1. [11]P. Huovinen, P. Petreczky, QCD Equation of State and Hadron Resonance Gas, Nucl. Phys. A 837 (2010) 26–53. arXiv:0912.2541, doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2010.02.015.DOI
  2. [12]S. Borsanyi, Z. Fodor, C. Hoelbling, S. D. Katz, S. Krieg, C. Ratti, K. K. Szabo, Is there still any T_c mystery in lattice QCD? Results with physical masses in the continuum limit III, JHEP 09 (2010) 073. arXiv:1005.3508, doi:10.1007/JHEP09(2010)073.DOI
  3. [13]A. Bazavov, T. Bhattacharya, C. E. DeTar, H.-T. Ding, S. Gottlieb, R. Gupta, P. Hegde, U. M. Heller, F. Karsch, E. Laermann, L. Levkova, S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, R. A. Soltz, W. Soeldner, R. Sugar, P. M. Vranas, Fluctuations and Correlations of net baryon number, electric charge, and strangeness: A comparison of lattice QCD results with the hadron resonance gas model, Phys. Rev. D 86 (2012) 034509. arXiv:1203.0784, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.86.034509.DOI
  4. [14]S. Borsanyi, Z. Fodor, C. Hoelbling, S. D. Katz, S. Krieg, K. K. Szabo, Full result for the QCD equation of state with 2+1 flavors, Phys. Lett. B 730 (2014) 201–209. arXiv:1309.5258, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2014.01.007.
  5. [15]A. Bazavov, T. Bhattacharya, C. DeTar, H.-T. Ding, S. Gottlieb, R. Gupta, P. Hegde, U. M. Heller, F. Karsch, E. Laermann, L. Levkova, S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, C. Schroeder, R. A. Soltz, W. Soeldner, R. Sugar, M. Wagner, P. Vranas, Equation of state in (2+1)-flavor QCD, Phys. Rev. D90 (2014) 094503. arXiv:1407.6387, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.90.094503.DOI
  6. [16]A. Bazavov, P. Petreczky, J. H. Weber, Equation of State in 2+1 Flavor QCD at High Temperatures, Phys. Rev. D 97 (1) (2018) 014510. arXiv:1710.05024, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.97.014510.DOI
  7. [17]R. Bellwied, S. Borsanyi, Z. Fodor, S. D. Katz, A. Pasztor, C. Ratti, K. K. Szabo, Fluctuations and correlations in high temperature QCD, Phys. Rev. D 92 (11) (2015) 114505. arXiv:1507.04627, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.114505.DOI
  8. [18]D. Bollweg, J. Goswami, O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, P. Scior, Second order cumulants of conserved charge fluctuations revisited: Vanishing chemical potentials, Phys. Rev. D 104 (7) (2021) 074512. arXiv:2107.10011, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.104.074512.DOI
  9. [19]A. Bazavov, H.-T. Ding, P. Hegde, O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, E. Laermann, Y. Maezawa, S. Mukherjee, H. Ohno, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, S. Sharma, W. Soeldner, M. Wagner, Additional Strange Hadrons from QCD Thermodynamics and Strangeness Freezeout in Heavy Ion Collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 (7) (2014) 072001. arXiv:1404.6511, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.113.072001.DOI
  10. [20]A. Bazavov, H.-T. Ding, P. Hegde, O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, E. Laermann, Y. Maezawa, S. Mukherjee, H. Ohno, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, S. Sharma, W. Soeldner, M. Wagner, The melting and abundance of open charm hadrons, Phys. Lett. B 737 (2014) 210–215. arXiv:1404.4043, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2014.08.034.DOI
  11. [21]R. Bellwied, S. Borsanyi, Z. Fodor, J. N. Guenther, J. Noronha-Hostler, P. Parotto, A. Pasztor, C. Ratti, J. M. Stafford, Off-diagonal correlators of conserved charges from lattice QCD and how to relate them to experiment, Phys. Rev. D 101 (3) (2020) 034506. arXiv:1910.14592, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.101.034506.
  12. [22]C. Fernández-Ramírez, P. M. Lo, P. Petreczky, Thermodynamics of the strange baryon system from a coupled-channels analysis and missing states, Phys. Rev. C 98 (4) (2018) 044910. arXiv:1806.02177, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.98.044910.
  13. [23]P. Gerber, H. Leutwyler, Hadrons Below the Chiral Phase Transition, Nucl. Phys. B 321 (1989) 387–429. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(89)90349–0.DOI
  14. [24]D. Toublan, J. B. Kogut, The QCD phase diagram at nonzero baryon, isospin and strangeness chemical potentials: Results from a hadron resonance gas model, Phys. Lett. B 605 (2005) 129–136. arXiv:hep-ph/0409310, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2004.11.018.
  15. [25]J. Jankowski, D. Blaschke, M. Spalinski, Chiral condensate in hadronic matter, Phys. Rev. D 87 (10) (2013) 105018. arXiv:1212.5521, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.87.105018.DOI
  16. [26]J. O. Andersen, Q. Yu, H. Zhou, Thermodynamics and quark condensates of three-flavor QCD at low temperature, Phys. Rev. D 107 (1) (2023) 014010. arXiv:2205.03072, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.107.014010.DOI
  17. [27]D. Biswas, P. Petreczky, S. Sharma, Chiral condensate from a hadron resonance gas model, Phys. Rev. C 106 (4) (2022) 045203. arXiv:2206.04579, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.106.045203.DOI
  18. [28]W.-j. Fu, J. M. Pawlowski, F. Rennecke, QCD phase structure at finite temperature and density, Phys. Rev. D 101 (5) (2020) 054032. arXiv:1909.02991, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.101.054032.DOI
  19. [29]D. Bollweg, D. A. Clarke, J. Goswami, O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, S. Sharma, Equation of state and speed of sound of (2+1)-flavor QCD in strangeness-neutral matter at nonvanishing net baryon-number density, Phys. Rev. D 108 (1) (2023) 014510. arXiv:2212.09043, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.108.014510.
  20. [30]D. H. Rischke, M. I. Gorenstein, H. Stoecker, W. Greiner, Excluded volume effect for the nuclear matter equation of state, Z. Phys. C51 (1991) 485–490. doi:10.1007/BF01548574.DOI
  21. [31]J. Cleymans, M. I. Gorenstein, J. Stalnacke, E. Suhonen, Excluded volume effect and the quark - hadron phase transition, Phys. Scripta 48 (1993) 277–280. doi:10.1088/0031-8949/48/3/004.DOI
  22. [32]G. D. Yen, M. I. Gorenstein, W. Greiner, S.-N. Yang, Excluded volume hadron gas model for particle number ratios in A+A collisions, Phys. Rev. C56 (1997) 2210–2218. arXiv:nucl-th/9711062, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.56.2210.
  23. [33]S. K. Tiwari, P. K. Srivastava, C. P. Singh, Description of Hot and Dense Hadron Gas Properties in a New Excluded-Volume model, Phys. Rev. C85 (2012) 014908. arXiv:1111.2406, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.85.014908.
  24. [34]A. Bhattacharyya, S. Das, S. K. Ghosh, R. Ray, S. Samanta, Fluctuations and correlations of conserved charges in an excluded volume hadron resonance gas model, Phys. Rev. C90 (3) (2014) 034909. arXiv:1310.2793, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.90.034909.
  25. [35]M. L. Albright, J. Kapusta, C. Young, Matching Excluded Volume Hadron Resonance Gas Models and Perturbative QCD to Lattice Calculations, Phys. Rev. C90 (2) (2014) 024915. arXiv:1404.7540, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.90.024915.
  26. [36]G. P. Kadam, H. Mishra, Dissipative properties of hot and dense hadronic matter in an excluded-volume hadron resonance gas model, Phys. Rev. C 92 (3) (2015) 035203. arXiv:1506.04613, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.92.035203.DOI
  27. [37]G. P. Kadam, Curing the acausal behavior of the sound velocity in an excluded volume hadron resonance gas model (2015). arXiv:1510.04371.arxiv.org/abs/1510.04371
  28. [38]V. Vovchenko, M. I. Gorenstein, H. Stoecker, van der Waals Interactions in Hadron Resonance Gas: From Nuclear Matter to Lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118 (18) (2017) 182301. arXiv:1609.03975, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.182301.DOI
  29. [39]V. Vovchenko, A. Motornenko, P. Alba, M. I. Gorenstein, L. M. Satarov, H. Stoecker, Multicomponent van der Waals equation of state: Applications in nuclear and hadronic physics, Phys. Rev. C 96 (4) (2017) 045202. arXiv:1707.09215, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.96.045202.DOI
  30. [40]S. Samanta, B. Mohanty, Criticality in a Hadron Resonance Gas model with the van der Waals interaction, Phys. Rev. C 97 (1) (2018) 015201. arXiv:1709.04446, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.97.015201.DOI
  31. [41]N. Sarkar, P. Ghosh, van der Waals hadron resonance gas and QCD phase diagram, Phys. Rev. C 98 (1) (2018) 014907. arXiv:1807.02948, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.98.014907.DOI
  32. [42]V. Vovchenko, Hadron resonance gas with van der Waals interactions, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 29 (05) (2020) 2040002. arXiv:2004.06331, doi:10.1142/S0218301320400029.DOI
  33. [43]K. A. Olive, The Thermodynamics of the Quark - Hadron Phase Transition in the Early Universe, Nucl. Phys. B 190 (1981) 483–503. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(81)90044-2.DOI
  34. [44]K. A. Olive, THE QUARK - HADRON TRANSITION IN SYSTEMS WITH NET BARYON NUMBER, Nucl. Phys. B 198 (1982) 461–473. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(82)90335-2.DOI
  35. [45]J. I. Kapusta, K. A. Olive, Thermodynamics of Hadrons: Delimiting the Temperature, Nucl. Phys. A 408 (1983) 478–494. doi:10.1016/0375-9474(83)90241-5.DOI
  36. [46]P. Huovinen, P. Petreczky, Hadron resonance gas with repulsive interactions and fluctuations of conserved charges, Phys. Lett. B 777 (2018) 125–130. arXiv:1708.00879, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2017.12.001.DOI
  37. [47]P. Huovinen, P. Petreczky, Hadron resonance gas with repulsive interactions, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 1070 (1) (2018) 012004. doi:10.1088/1742-6596/1070/1/012004.DOI
  38. [48]S. Pal, G. Kadam, A. Bhattacharyya, Hadron resonance gas model with repulsive mean-field interactions: Specific heat, isothermal compressibility and speed of sound, Nucl. Phys. A 1023 (2022) 122464. arXiv:2104.08531, doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2022.122464.DOI
  39. [49]S. Pal, G. Kadam, H. Mishra, A. Bhattacharyya, Effects of hadronic repulsive interactions on the fluctuations of conserved charges, Phys. Rev. D 103 (5) (2021) 054015. arXiv:2010.10761, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.103.054015.DOI
  40. [50]S. Pal, G. Kadam, A. Bhattacharyya, Conserved charge fluctuations in the relativistic mean-field hadron resonance gas model: constraints on hadronic repulsive interactions (5 2023). arXiv:2305.13212.arxiv.org/abs/2305.13212
  41. [51]S. Aoki, T. Doi, Lattice QCD and Baryon-Baryon Interactions, 2023, pp. 1–31. arXiv:2402.11759, doi:10.1007/978-981-15-8818-1_50-1.DOI
  42. [52]S. Capstick, N. Isgur, Baryons in a relativized quark model with chromodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 34 (9) (1986) 2809–2835. doi:10.1103/physrevd.34.2809.DOI
  43. [53]D. Ebert, R. N. Faustov, V. O. Galkin, Mass spectra and Regge trajectories of light mesons in the relativistic quark model, Phys. Rev. D 79 (2009) 114029. arXiv:0903.5183, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.79.114029.DOI
  44. [54]P. Alba, R. Bellwied, S. Borsanyi, Z. Fodor, J. Gunther, S. D. Katz, V. Mantovani Sarti, J. Noronha-Hostler, P. Parotto, A. Pasztor, I. P. Vazquez, C. Ratti, Constraining the hadronic spectrum through QCD thermodynamics on the lattice, Phys. Rev. D 96 (3) (2017) 034517. arXiv:1702.01113, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.96.034517.DOI
  45. [55]P. Alba, V. M. Sarti, J. Noronha-Hostler, P. Parotto, I. Portillo-Vazquez, C. Ratti, J. M. Stafford, Influence of hadronic resonances on the chemical freeze-out in heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 101 (5) (2020) 054905. arXiv:2002.12395, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.101.054905.DOI
  46. [56]J. Sollfrank, P. Huovinen, M. Kataja, P. V. Ruuskanen, M. Prakash, R. Venugopalan, Hydrodynamical description of 200-A/GeV/c S + Au collisions: Hadron and electromagnetic spectra, Phys. Rev. C 55 (1997) 392–410. arXiv:nucl-th/9607029, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.55.392.DOI
  47. [57]A. Bazavov, D. Bollweg, H.-T. Ding, P. Enns, J. Goswami, P. Hegde, O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, R. Larsen, S. Mukherjee, H. Ohno, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, S. Sharma, P. Steinbrecher, Skewness, kurtosis, and the fifth and sixth order cumulants of net baryon-number distributions from lattice QCD confront high-statistics STAR data, Phys. Rev. D 101 (7) (2020) 074502. arXiv:2001.08530, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.101.074502.DOI
  48. [58]S. Borsányi, Z. Fodor, J. N. Guenther, S. D. Katz, P. Parotto, A. Pásztor, D. Pesznyák, K. K. Szabó, C. H. Wong, Continuum extrapolated high order baryon fluctuation (12 2023). arXiv:2312.07528.DOI
  49. [59]S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky, S. Sharma, Charm degrees of freedom in the quark gluon plasma, Phys. Rev. D 93 (1) (2016) 014502. arXiv:1509.08887, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.93.014502.DOI
  50. [60]A. Bazavov, D. Bollweg, O. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, S. Sharma, Charm degrees of freedom in hot matter from lattice QCD, Phys. Lett. B 850 (2024) 138520. arXiv:2312.12857, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2024.138520.DOI
  51. [61]A. Bazavov, T. Bhattacharya, M. Cheng, C. DeTar, H.-T. Ding, S. Gottlieb, R. Gupta, P. Hegde, U. M. Heller, F. Karsch, E. Laermann, L. Levkova, S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky, C. Schmidt, R. A. Soltz, W. Soeldner, R. Sugar, D. Toussaint, W. Unger, P. Vranas, The chiral and deconfinement aspects of the QCD transition, Phys. Rev. D 85 (2012) 054503. arXiv:1111.1710, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.85.054503.DOI
  52. [62]C. Aubin, C. Bernard, C. DeTar, J. Osborn, S. Gottlieb, E. B. Gregory, D. Toussaint, U. M. Heller, J. E. Hetrick, R. Sugar, Light hadrons with improved staggered quarks: Approaching the continuum limit, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004) 094505. arXiv:hep-lat/0402030, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.70.094505DOI
  53. [63]Y. Aoki, T. Blum, G. Colangelo, S. Collins, M. D. Morte, P. Dimopoulos, S. Dürr, X. Feng, H. Fukaya, M. Golterman, et al., FLAG Review 2021, Eur. Phys. J. C 82 (10) (2022) 869. arXiv:2111.09849, doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-022-10536-1.DOI
  54. [64]A. Bazavov, C. Bernard, C. DeTar, X. Du, W. Freeman, S. Gottlieb, U. M. Heller, J. Hetherington, J. Laiho, L. Levkova, et al., Results for light pseudoscalar mesons, PoS LATTICE2010 (2010) 074. arXiv:1012.0868, doi:10.22323/1.105.0074.DOI
  55. [65]T. Schäfer, F. Wilczek, Continuity of quark and hadron matter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 (1999) 3956–3959. arXiv:hep-ph/9811473, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.82.3956.DOI
  56. [66]A. Bazavov, H.-T. Ding, P. Hegde, K. Kaczmarek, F. Karsch, N. Karthik, E. Laermann, A. Lahiri, R. Larsen, S.-T. Li, et al., Chiral crossover in QCD at zero and non-zero chemical potentials, Phys. Lett. B 795 (2019) 15–21. arXiv:1812.08235, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2019.05.013.DOI
  57. [67]A. Andronic, P. Braun-Munzinger, K. Redlich, J. Stachel, Decoding the phase structure of QCD via particle production at high energy, Nature 561 (7723) (2018) 321–330. arXiv:1710.09425, doi:10.1038/s41586-018-0491-6.DOI
  58. [68]S. Borsanyi, Z. Fodor, J. N. Guenther, R. Kara, S. D. Katz, P. Parotto, A. Pasztor, C. Ratti, K. K. Szabo, QCD Crossover at Finite Chemical Potential from Lattice Simulations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125 (5) (2020) 052001. arXiv:2002.02821, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.052001.DOI
  59. [69]C. Bonati, M. D’Elia, F. Negro, F. Sanfilippo, K. Zambello, Curvature of the pseudocritical line in QCD: Taylor expansion matches analytic continuation, Phys. Rev. D 98 (5) (2018) 054510. arXiv:1805.02960, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.98.054510.DOI
  60. [70]R. Bellwied, S. Borsanyi, Z. Fodor, J. Günther, S. D. Katz, C. Ratti, K. K. Szabo, The QCD phase diagram from analytic continuation, Phys. Lett. B 751 (2015) 559–564. arXiv:1507.07510, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2015.11.011.DOI
  61. [71]C. Bonati, M. D’Elia, M. Mariti, M. Mesiti, F. Negro, F. Sanfilippo, Curvature of the chiral pseudocritical line in QCD: Continuum extrapolated results, Phys. Rev. D 92 (5) (2015) 054503. arXiv:1507.03771, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.054503.
  62. [72]A. Abhishek, S. Sharma, Toward a universal description of hadronic phase of QCD, Phys. Rev. D 109 (1) (2024) 014007. arXiv:2303.03994, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.109.014007.DOI
  63. [73]T. M. Schwarz, S. P. Klevansky, G. Papp, The Phase diagram and bulk thermodynamical quantities in the NJL model at finite temperature and density, Phys. Rev. C 60 (1999) 055205. arXiv:nucl-th/9903048, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.60.055205.DOI
  64. [74]J. Randrup, J. Cleymans, Maximum freeze-out baryon density in nuclear collisions, Phys. Rev. C 74 (2006) 047901. arXiv:hep-ph/0607065, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.74.047901.DOI
  65. [75]J. Cleymans, H. Oeschler, K. Redlich, S. Wheaton, Transition from baryonic to mesonic freeze-out, Phys. Lett. B 615 (2005) 50–54. arXiv:hep-ph/0411187, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2005.03.074.DOI
  66. [76]J. Cleymans, K. Redlich, Unified description of freezeout parameters in relativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 (1998) 5284–5286. arXiv:nucl-th/9808030, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.81.5284.DOI
  67. [77]A. Motornenko, J. Steinheimer, V. Vovchenko, S. Schramm, H. Stoecker, Equation of state for hot QCD and compact stars from a mean field approach, Phys. Rev. C 101 (3) (2020) 034904. arXiv:1905.00866, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.101.034904.

Paper details

vlnc:W_dhra6gan
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents