betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Continuous superradiant lasing on a narrow optical transition

Abstract

Lasers with ultrastable frequency are at the foundation of optical clocks, which enable precision tests of fundamental physics and relativistic geodesy at the centimetre scale. Such lasers inherit their frequency stability from the length stability of a sophisticated optical resonator, which is hard to maintain outside a well-controlled laboratory environment and limited by thermal and technical noise. Superradiant lasers promise to overcome these limitations by storing their coherence in the atoms making up the laser's gain medium. Superradiant lasing has been demonstrated on narrow optical atomic transitions with pulsed and quasi-continuous operation. However, atom loss has prevented truly continuous operation, which severely limits their suitability for clocks. Here we demonstrate a superradiant laser on a narrow optical transition in 88^{88}Sr that operates truly continuously. We sustain emission for more than eight hours and measure a linewidth of 320(40) Hz, more than 20 times below the natural linewidth. The emission frequency remains anchored to the atomic transition, making the laser itself an atomic frequency reference. Our results provide a route towards a laser that reaches short-term frequency stability comparable to that of the best resonator-stabilized lasers. Furthermore, truly continuous operation gives us access to physics beyond the transient regime, enabling the exploration of robust nonequilibrium steady states and sustained coherent collective dynamics.

Optical atomic clocks are the most precise measurement devices ever built, reaching fractional frequency uncertainties below 10−1810^{-18} [1, 2, 3, 4]. This precision originates from the ability to transfer the frequency of an ultranarrow optical atomic transition onto a laser, making it a frequency standard. Current optical clocks are passive frequency standards, in which the laser interrogates atoms spectroscopically. To ensure a narrow spectroscopy signal, the laser is frequency stabilized on short timescales to the mode of an ultrastable optical resonator (cavity). However, even small mechanical or thermal fluctuations of the cavity length are mapped directly onto the laser frequency, limiting the short-term stability of the clock [20, 21].

An elegant alternative to such passive frequency standards is an active one, in which the atoms themselves emit light at the frequency of the clock transition. Hydrogen masers have demonstrated this possibility for decades in the microwave domain [22]. In the optical domain, an active frequency reference can be realized by operating in the “bad-cavity regime”. In contrast to the conventional lasing regime [23], the lasing cavity linewidth in the bad-cavity regime greatly exceeds the gain medium linewidth and the laser’s frequency is mostly determined by the gain medium. Continuous-wave bad-cavity lasing has been demonstrated with gain medium linewidths from one to several hundred megahertz [24, 25, 26], and the influence of the bad-cavity regime on laser properties such as the linewidth was explored. However, these gain media are too broad and too strongly perturbed to serve as accurate atomic frequency references. Instead, a narrow atomic transition can provide the gain, allowing the laser itself to be an accurate atomic frequency reference. In this case, the atomic dipoles radiate collectively (superradiantly), which enhances the emission rate far beyond that of independently emitting atoms and enables lasing despite the weakness of the narrow transition [27, 28]. Such superradiant (SR) lasers are predicted to be able to reach linewidths down to the millihertz level [11, 12].

First steps towards realizing such a device have been taken, with pulsed and quasi-continuous superradiant emission of less than one second duration on narrow optical atomic transitions and engineered Raman transitions confirming the collective emission physics [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19]. Collective emission has also been studied in hot atomic beams, where phase coherence was imprinted with a phase mask [29]. However, a truly continuous superradiant laser, whose linewidth is not limited by the finite pulse duration, and that enables access to collective dynamics beyond that of a conventional laser, has remained an outstanding goal.

Here we demonstrate a truly continuous superradiant laser on the 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_{0}\to{}^{3}P_{1} intercombination line of 88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} at 689 nm, with transition linewidth γ/(2π)=7.48 kHz\gamma/(2\pi)=7.48\ \mathrm{kHz}, operating in the bad-cavity regime. In our experiment, a thermal atomic beam continuously replenishes excited-state atoms coupled to the cavity mode, and superradiant lasing persists. We realize an operation time of more than eight hours without interruption, with a steady output power of 65(1) nW. We measure a linewidth of 320(40) Hz, an upper bound on the intrinsic superradiant laser linewidth, more than 20 times below the natural linewidth of the atomic transition and more than 3 000 times below the Doppler broadening, which is the main decoherence mechanism. The frequency stays anchored to the atomic transition with an uncertainty of a few kHz. We compare the experimental observations of critical atom number, cavity pulling, and linewidth scaling to a simple superradiant-laser theory and find good agreement. In addition, by exploring the boundaries of the metrologically useful regime of this superradiant laser, we uncover signatures of multi-component superradiance, a dynamical regime characterized by long-lived, coherent amplitude oscillations.

Superradiant lasing from a beam of cold atoms

We demonstrate continuous superradiant lasing on an optical transition in the bad-cavity regime using a thermal beam of excited 88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} atoms passing through the mode of a linear optical cavity (Figure 1a). Atoms couple via the 7.48 kHz-wide 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_{0} \to{}^{3}P_{1} intercombination line at 689 nm to the resonant cavity with decay rate κ/(2π)=6.79(2)\kappa/(2\pi) = 6.79(2) MHz. Before entering the cavity, the atoms are cooled and shelved in the metastable 3P0,2{}^{3}P_{0,2} states using Swept Velocity Shelving (SVS) [30]. The cooling method delivers a state-heralded supply of collimated atoms that can be transferred to our chosen lasing state (3P1{}^{3}P_{1}) with a state-preparation laser just before the cavity (Figure 1b, left). As the atomic beam traverses the cavity mode, excited state atoms are continuously introduced, maintaining the inverted gain medium and sustaining lasing.

Schematic of continuous superradiant lasing from a beam of cold atoms

Figure 1. Continuous superradiant lasing on a narrow optical transition. (a) Schematic of the experimental apparatus. A thermal beam of 88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} atoms is transversely cooled and the atoms are prepared in long-lived 3P0,2{}^{3}P_{0,2} states (blue dots). A state preparation beam optically pumps atoms to the upper lasing state, 3P1{}^{3}P_{1} (purple dots). These atoms superradiantly lase while traversing a cavity. The photo inset shows the intensity profile of the emitted laser beam. (b) (left) Level diagram of 88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} showing the 3P1→1S0{}^{3}P_{1} \to{}^{1}S_{0} lasing transition at 689 nm and the action of the state preparation beam. (right) Spectrum of the atomic transition labelled by its linewidth γ\gamma, the Doppler broadened transition for the accessible range of linewidths γD\gamma_D and the bare cavity with linewidth κ\kappa. (c) Continuous superradiant lasing (red line, left axis). Shortly after switch-on of the state preparation beam (grey line, right axis; shaded region: beam on), lasing starts with relaxation oscillations, settles into steady state, and persists until the preparation beam is switched off. (d) Laser output power as a function of effective linewidth γeff∼γD\gamma_{\rm eff} \sim\gamma_D and intracavity 3P1{}^{3}P_{1} atom number NSRN_{\rm SR}. The theoretical lasing threshold [Eq. (1)] is shown as a white line. Inset: output power versus NSRN_{\rm SR} at our reference γeff/(2π)=1.47(4)\gamma_{\rm eff}/(2\pi) = 1.47(4) MHz, white dashed line in main graph. Vertical dashed lines indicate the lasing onset obtained from the fit, NcritexpN_{\rm crit}^{\rm exp}, and theory, NcritthN_{\rm crit}^{\rm th}. Red dashed line: linear fit to the points above 1 nW. Star: reference operating point. Error bars indicate the standard deviation of the shot-averaged signals across repeated measurements at each scan point.

The number of atoms in the excited lasing state, NSRN_{\rm SR}, is controlled via the intensity of the state-preparation beam and reaches NSR=1.57(8)×105N_{\rm SR} = 1.57(8) \times10^{5} at a maximum flux of

3.6(1)×10113.6(1) \times10^{11} atoms s−1^{-1} through the cavity mode. Atoms remaining in the metastable states do not couple directly to the cavity mode and therefore do not influence lasing. The transit time of the atoms through the cavity mode is ≈0.45 μs\approx0.45\,\mu\mathrm{s}, which gives rise to a transit time broadening of γT/(2π)≈360\gamma_T/(2\pi) \approx360 kHz. The transit time is 50 times shorter than the natural lifetime of the lasing state, which makes collective enhancement of the emission rate necessary for lasing. The dominant decoherence mechanism in the system is Doppler broadening of the atomic transition when interacting with light in the cavity. We precisely control the Doppler broadening by adjusting experimental parameters during the SVS stage and can reduce it to a minimum of γD/(2π)≈1\gamma_D/(2\pi) \approx1 MHz, while still maintaining the necessary excited state atom number to sustain lasing. The effective coherence decay rate can thus be expressed by taking into account both the transit time and the Doppler broadening:

γeff=γD+γT+γ,\gamma_{\rm eff} = \gamma_D + \gamma_T + \gamma,

where in our case γeff∼γD≫γT,γ\gamma_{\rm eff} \sim\gamma_D \gg\gamma_T,\gamma. The cavity decay rate κ\kappa exceeds γeff\gamma_{\rm eff}, placing the system in the bad-cavity regime (Figure 1b, right).

The onset of superradiant lasing occurs when the collective atomic gain overcomes the decoherence mechanisms. We initiate lasing by switching on the state-preparation beam, populating the lasing state, and allowing the atoms to couple to the cavity. At the onset of lasing, we observe relaxation oscillations lasting ≈5 μs\approx5\,\mu\mathrm{s} before the emission settles into steady-state superradiant lasing, as shown in Figure 1c. Steady-state lasing persists until the state-preparation beam is switched off. To extract the lasing threshold atom number, we measure the lasing output power in the (γD,NSR)(\gamma_D,N_{\mathrm{SR}}) plane, see Figure 1d. We observe reasonable agreement with the theoretically predicted threshold (see SI), indicated by the white line, and given by

Ncrit=κγeff2g02,(1)N_{\mathrm{crit}}=\frac{\kappa\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}{2g_{0}^{2}}, \tag*{(1)}

where g0/(2π)=11.3g_{0}/(2\pi)=11.3 kHz is the single-atom cavity coupling rate. Above threshold, we observe a linear power scaling with NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}, which is characteristic of continuous superradiant lasing in steady-state, when energy conservation prevents the quadratic scaling observed for transient superradiant bursts [31]. At our reference operating point (marked in the inset by a star, NSR≈1.53(2)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}}\approx1.53(2)\times10^{5}, γeff/(2π)≈1.47(4)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi)\approx1.47(4) MHz), the total emitted power is 65(1) nW.

Bad-cavity operation and superradiant linewidth

Because superradiant lasers exploit the phase coherence of atomic evolution, temporal drift and noise in the resonance condition of the fast-decaying cavity are suppressed in the emitted frequency spectrum. This suppression of the normal cavity pulling behaviour seen in lasers can be expressed by

ρ=ΔfSRΔfcav=γeffγeff+κ<1,(2)\rho=\frac{\Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}}}{\Delta f_{\mathrm{cav}}}=\frac{\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}{\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}+\kappa}<1, \tag*{(2)}

where ΔfSR\Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}} is the shift of the SR output frequency in response to a cavity detuning Δfcav\Delta f_{\mathrm{cav}}. In Figure 2a we demonstrate a minimum pulling coefficient of ρ=0.165(3)\rho=0.165(3), measured at the lowest effective broadening currently accessible in our apparatus, γeff/(2π)=1.47(4)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi)=1.47(4) MHz, confirming operation in the bad-cavity regime. Since γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} is dominated by the Doppler broadening γD\gamma_D, the cavity pulling ρ\rho can be varied by tuning this parameter. This behaviour can be seen in the inset of Figure 2a, where we show ρ\rho for four values of γD\gamma_D (and thus γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}), together with Eq. (2), confirming that this simple model already provides a good description of our system.

Bad-cavity operation and superradiant linewidth

Figure 2. Bad-cavity operation and superradiant linewidth. (a) Cavity pulling in the bad-cavity regime. The superradiance frequency shift ΔfSR\Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}} is measured as a function of the cavity detuning Δfcav\Delta f_{\mathrm{cav}}, for four separate Doppler linewidths γD∼γeff\gamma_D \sim\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}. Each point is the mean of five measurements. Dashed lines are linear fits to the individual scans whose slope is the cavity-pulling coefficient ρ(γeff)\rho(\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}). Inset: ρ\rho versus γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}. The solid line is the theoretical prediction, Eq. (2). (b) Superradiant emission linewidth Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} as a function of intracavity 3P1{}^{3}P_{1} atom number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}, measured at γeff/(2π)=1.47(4)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi)=1.47(4) MHz (blue disks, mean of 25-30 measurements), reaching a minimum linewidth of 320(40) Hz at our reference operating point (star). The solid black line shows the analytical result for the linewidth Eq. (3), with a minimum of γSR/(2π)≈90\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}/(2\pi)\approx90 Hz over the observed range. The dashed red line is the analytical result including an offset for the finite linewidth of the probe laser and technical noise contributions in the SR cavity. The natural linewidth of the 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_{0}\to{}^{3}P_{1} transition is shown as an orange dash-dotted line, and the Purcell-limited linewidth of γSRPurcell/(2π)=75\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}^{\mathrm{Purcell}}/(2\pi)=75 Hz is shown as an orange dotted line. Inset: single-shot beat-note spectrum for NSR=1.53(2)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}}=1.53(2)\times10^{5} atoms (blue dots) fitted with a Lorentzian (red line). Stars indicate our reference operating point. Error bars are the standard error about the mean from measurement scatter combined in quadrature with propagated Lorentzian fit uncertainties for individual shots.

We next investigate the intrinsic linewidth of the SR laser and its scaling with the intracavity atom number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}. To extract the linewidth of the SR laser, we heterodyne the SR output against an ultra-low expansion (ULE)-cavity-stabilized reference laser (ULE laser). We measure a minimum linewidth of Δνmeas=320(40)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}}=320(40) Hz, more than 20 times below the natural linewidth γ/(2π)=7.48\gamma/(2\pi)=7.48 kHz and more than 3 000 times below γD\gamma_D, demonstrating the strong phase coherence of the collective dipole and providing an upper bound for the intrinsic linewidth. We also find that the linewidth decreases with increasing intracavity atom number, which is consistent with theoretical predictions [33]. To analyse the scaling quantitatively, we consider a simple analytical model that takes into account transit time and Doppler broadening, both present in our system. The theoretical estimate for the linewidth is

γSR=κ4Nνρ2(1+2g02NSRκγeff),(3)\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}=\frac{\kappa}{4N_{\nu}}\rho^{2}\left(1+\frac{2g_{0}^{2}N_{\mathrm{SR}}}{\kappa\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}\right), \tag*{(3)}

where Nν∝NSRN_\nu\propto N_{\mathrm{SR}} is the number of intracavity photons (see SI). This expression contains two independent noise contributions, obtained by adding stochastic noise sources to the linewidth equations. The first arises from cavity shot noise, analogous to the Schawlow-Townes mechanism, but suppressed in the bad-cavity regime by the factor ρ2\rho^2, yielding a contribution proportional to κρ2/(4Nν)\kappa\rho^2/(4N_\nu). The second arises from atomic injection noise: each incoming atom contributes quantum phase noise to the collective dipole. This contribution scales as g02ρ2NSR/(2γeffNν)g_0^2\rho^2N_{\mathrm{SR}}/(2\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}N_\nu). The analytical model (solid black line in Figure 2b) predicts a minimum intrinsic linewidth of γSR/(2π)≈90\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}/(2\pi) \approx90 Hz at the lowest measured broadening, γeff/(2π)=1.47(4)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi) = 1.47(4) MHz, and an estimated intracavity atom number of NSR=1.53(2)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 1.53(2) \times10^5. The lowest measured linewidth lies above the theoretically predicted minimum, which can be attributed to technical noise sources that are not captured by the idealized analytical model. If we introduce an additional atom-independent frequency noise contribution originating from technical-noise-induced cavity pulling or the finite linewidth of the ULE laser, Δνadd=310(60)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{add}} = 310(60) Hz (see Methods), we find good agreement between the data and the analytical model (red dashed line), indicating that the measured linewidth could be reduced even further by addressing these noise contributions. Nevertheless, the narrow measured linewidth compared to the natural linewidth of the atomic transition already demonstrates the exceptional spectral purity of the superradiant laser.

Long-term stability

For stable long-term operation of the laser, the cavity resonance frequency must be kept close to the atomic transition. We achieve this through a self-locking scheme: we stabilize the cavity to a frequency derived from the superradiant output itself, forcing the cavity length to track the superradiant emission frequency (see Methods). This scheme, enabled by the suppressed cavity pulling, renders the superradiant laser a long-term stable atomic frequency reference.

To demonstrate uninterrupted operation and investigate long-term stability, we continuously monitor the SR output frequency for 500 min (Figure 3a). The measurement is performed in a three-cornered-hat configuration [34] so that the individual noise contributions of three independent lasers can be determined. Of the two lasers we compare the SR laser to, one is stabilized to the 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_0 \rightarrow{}^{3}P_1 transition in an atomic vapour cell, providing a long-term atomic frequency reference at the kHz level (Spec laser), and the other is locked to a ULE cavity, but drifts with 4215(1) Hz/h over the span of the measurement (ULE laser). While the ULE–Spec and ULE–SR beat frequencies exhibit a clear drift over the full 500 min interval, the SR–Spec beat remains nearly constant, with a standard deviation of 2.3 kHz from the mean, demonstrating that the SR frequency is self-referenced to the collective atomic transition frequency.

Figure 3. Uninterrupted superradiant lasing and long-term stability. (a) Raw beat-note frequency measurements over 500 min of continuous SR laser operation at ν0=434.829\nu_0 = 434.829 THz (100 ms gate time). We compare the superradiant (SR), spectroscopy- (Spec) and ULE-referenced (ULE) lasers in a three-cornered hat configuration. SR–Spec (orange), ULE–Spec (blue), and ULE–SR (purple) beats are shown with their mean value subtracted. (b) The fractional frequency instability σy(τ)\sigma_y(\tau) of the SR laser extracted via the overlapping Allan deviation of the three-cornered hat (TCH) measurement. Grey circles: 500 min dataset (same as a), where ULE laser drift (4215(1) Hz/h) dominates the variance decomposition at τ≳100\tau\gtrsim100 s. Blue disks: independent 140 min dataset recorded with lower ULE drift (290(10) Hz/h). A power-law fit over the grey shaded region yields a temporal scaling of τ−0.29(5)\tau^{-0.29(5)}. The instability reaches 2.9×10−132.9 \times10^{-13} at τ=400\tau= 400 s. The dotted line shows the ideal phase diffusion scaling σy∝τ−1/2\sigma_y \propto\tau^{-1/2}. Error bars indicate 1σ1\sigma confidence intervals, calculated using a chi-squared distribution with conservative T/τ−1T/\tau- 1 degrees of freedom where τ\tau is the cluster time [32].

We further use the three-cornered-hat analysis to determine the fractional frequency instability of the SR laser itself (Figure 3b). For the 500 min dataset, the long-term stability is limited by the strong drift of the ULE laser. Thus, we analyse an independent 140 min dataset recorded for a reduced ULE laser drift of 290(10) Hz/h. This measurement yields a fractional Allan deviation of σy(1 s)=2.0×10−12\sigma_y(1\ \mathrm{s})=2.0\times10^{-12} and reaches σy=2.9×10−13\sigma_y=2.9\times10^{-13} at τ=400 s\tau=400\ \mathrm{s}. The observed scaling is shallower than the ideal phase-diffusion limit σy∝τ−1/2\sigma_y\propto\tau^{-1/2}, consistent with technical noise present in our system (see Methods and SI) [35].

Multi-component superradiance

Having established our setup as a superradiant laser with a narrow optical emission frequency suitable as a frequency reference, we now push the experiment beyond the limits of this metrological regime. By increasing the Doppler linewidth, we deliberately drive the system away from steady-state superradiant lasing. As γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} increases, the mean output power decreases while the measured linewidth broadens, in overall agreement with the analytical model of Eq. (3) (Ext. Data Fig. 4). Remarkably, however, the deterioration of metrological performance is accompanied by the emergence of a new dynamical regime: we observe characteristic signatures of multi-component superradiance (MCSR), namely long-lived collective amplitude oscillations [33].

While such instabilities ultimately limit the regime of stable frequency-reference operation, they have long been of interest in bad-cavity lasers as a route to rich nonlinear dynamics, including period doubling and chaos [36, 37]. Their controlled observation in our experiment therefore demonstrates the versatility of our platform and enables the exploration of novel nonlinear dynamics in superradiant lasers.

While scanning the effective Doppler broadening γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}, we observe above γeffMCSR/(2π)=1.8(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\mathrm{MCSR}}/(2\pi)=1.8(1) MHz the appearance of sidebands in the heterodyne beat spectrum between the SR laser and the ULE laser (Figure 4a). At γeffMCSR/(2π)=3.0(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\mathrm{MCSR}}/(2\pi)=3.0(1) MHz, the dominant sideband lies at fmod,1exp=0.94(4)f_{\mathrm{mod},1}^{\mathrm{exp}}=0.94(4) MHz and a second harmonic is weakly visible at fmod,2exp=1.86(4)f_{\mathrm{mod},2}^{\mathrm{exp}}=1.86(4) MHz. The appearance of these sidebands indicates a coherent modulation of the emission, which we identify as the MCSR regime.

Figure 4. Single-frequency to multi-component lasing. (a) Beat-note frequency spectrum of the SR laser against the ULE laser as a function of effective linewidth γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}. The frequency axis is referenced to the single-mode SR peak at the lowest γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}. Sidebands emerge above γeffMCSR/(2π)=1.8(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\mathrm{MCSR}}/(2\pi)=1.8(1) MHz (horizontal red dash-dotted line). White solid lines: theoretically predicted sideband frequencies. (b) Intensity noise PSD recorded on an avalanche photodiode (DC component subtracted), same scan range as in (a). A non-zero intensity modulation emerges, consistent with (a), above the same γeffMCSR/(2π)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\mathrm{MCSR}}/(2\pi). (c) Beat-note spectrum as a function of intracavity atom number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} for γeff/(2π)=4.5(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi)=4.5(1) MHz. A significant lasing peak emerges around Ncrit=1.13(1)×105N_{\mathrm{crit}}=1.13(1)\times10^{5} atoms and sidebands develop above NMCSR=1.24(5)×105N_{\mathrm{MCSR}}=1.24(5)\times10^{5} (red dash-dotted line). The theoretical critical atom number Ncrittheo=1.18×105N_{\mathrm{crit}}^{\mathrm{theo}}=1.18\times10^{5} is shown by the horizontal grey dashed line. White solid lines: theoretically predicted sideband frequencies. (d) Intensity noise PSD for the same scan range as in (c). A non-zero intensity modulation consistent with (c) emerges above NMCSRN_{\mathrm{MCSR}}.

Theory predicts that the observed modulation originates from oscillations of the amplitude mode, which is decoupled from the phase mode of the superradiant laser. We test this prediction in two complementary ways. First, we compare the theoretically predicted amplitude-mode frequency quantitatively with the experimentally measured value. For this, we develop a microscopic description of the superradiant laser based on the atomic beam and calculate the amplitude-resonance frequencies (see Supplementary Information). For the average atom number of the γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} scan, NSR=1.57(8)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}}=1.57(8)\times10^{5}, the theoretically calculated amplitude-mode frequencies are shown as white lines in Figure 4a, closely following the measured resonance frequency. At γeffMCSR/(2π)=3.0(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\mathrm{MCSR}}/(2\pi)=3.0(1) MHz theory predicts fmodtheo=0.93(1)f_{\mathrm{mod}}^{\mathrm{theo}}=0.93(1) MHz.

Second, we directly probe the amplitude dynamics experimentally. While the heterodyne measurement contains contributions from both the phase and amplitude modes, the amplitude can be accessed independently through the intensity-noise power spectral density (PSD). Figure 4b shows the intensity PSD over the same range of γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}, with the DC component removed. Peaks emerge above the same threshold, directly demonstrating coherent oscillations of the laser-field amplitude. The peaks cross fmod,1exp=0.93(3)f_{\mathrm{mod},1}^{\mathrm{exp}}=0.93(3) MHz and fmod,2exp=1.86(3)f_{\mathrm{mod},2}^{\mathrm{exp}}=1.86(3) MHz at γeffMCSR/(2π)=3.0(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\mathrm{MCSR}}/(2\pi)=3.0(1) MHz, consistent with Figure 4a.

The rich dynamical behaviour is further highlighted by entering the MCSR regime through a different parameter scan: increasing NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} while fixing γeff/(2π)=4.5(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi) = 4.5(1) MHz (Figure 4c, Figure 4d). Beyond the theoretical lasing transition (grey dashed line) and the onset of MCSR (red dash-dotted line), two sidebands emerge from the carrier, in contrast to the onset at finite frequency observed when varying γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}. At NSR=1.54×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 1.54 \times10^{5} the observed sideband frequency in the beat spectrum (fmodexp=0.70(3)f_{\mathrm{mod}}^{\mathrm{exp}} = 0.70(3) MHz) and the PSD (fmodexp=0.71(2)f_{\mathrm{mod}}^{\mathrm{exp}} = 0.71(2) MHz), show good qualitative agreement with the theoretical prediction fmodtheo=0.53(1)f_{\mathrm{mod}}^{\mathrm{theo}} = 0.53(1) MHz. Together, the agreement between the heterodyne and intensity measurements and the microscopic model provides strong evidence that the observed sidebands originate from the collective amplitude dynamics of MCSR, giving direct access to a regime of nonlinear collective dynamics [33, 38].

Conclusion

We have realized a continuous superradiant laser on the 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_{0} \rightarrow{}^{3}P_{1} transition of 88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} in a hot-beam architecture [13]. We measured an upper bound of 320(40) Hz on the intrinsic linewidth, which is more than 3 000 times narrower than the dominant decoherence rate in the system and more than 20 times below the natural linewidth of the transition. We confirmed the predicted lasing threshold and cavity-pulling factor and achieved an output power of 65(1) nW. By using the SR laser frequency itself to stabilize the cavity length, we demonstrated uninterrupted operation for over eight hours and extracted a fractional frequency instability of 2.9×10−132.9 \times10^{-13} after 400 s of averaging using the three-cornered-hat method. Our observations agree reasonably well with a simple superradiant-laser theory [11, 13, 33, 35].

Continuous SR lasing on the 88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} intercombination line is directly transferable to other species with comparably narrow transitions, including 40Ca{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca} and 174Yb{}^{174}\mathrm{Yb}, using the same beam geometry [13]. Implementing dark atom–photon dressed states [39, 40] on the 88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_{0} \rightarrow{}^{3}P_{1} transition could suppress the dominant dephasing channels and push the emission linewidth below the two-level Purcell limit, opening a route towards fractional frequency instabilities at the 10−16/τ/s10^{-16}/\sqrt{\tau/\mathrm{s}} level. Extending continuous SR lasing to true clock transitions, namely the ultra-narrow 1S0→3P0{}^{1}S_{0} \rightarrow{}^{3}P_{0} lines in alkaline-earth(-like) atoms, could provide short-term frequency stability comparable to that of the best optical reference cavities [41, 42, 43, 44, 45], while simultaneously serving as an atomic frequency reference. As SR lasers are less sensitive to mechanical and thermal noise than cavity-stabilized lasers, they are natural candidates for transportable optical clocks [10], either as active optical clocks in their own right or in combination with a conventional passive optical clock, as is done with the hydrogen maser and caesium fountain clock in the microwave domain [46]. Both strategies offer a promising path towards the next generation of optical clocks for precision metrology. Beyond metrology, we have begun to explore complex collective dynamics, observing coherent collective amplitude oscillations, a characteristic signature of multi-component superradiance. These dynamics open promising avenues for quantum simulation of driven-dissipative phase transitions, including non-Hermitian phase transitions, spontaneous symmetry breaking, and the emergence of chaos [47, 48, 49, 50].

Methods

Experimental apparatus and calibration

Atomic source and cavity setup. A full description of the apparatus, the cooling scheme, and its characterization by normal-mode-splitting (NMS) measurements is given in Ref. 30. A schematic of the apparatus is shown in Ext. Data Fig. 1(a). A high-flux oven produces a thermal beam of 88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} atoms. The SR cavity is mounted ∼15\sim15 cm above the oven nozzle, with its axis oriented orthogonal to the atomic beam. The cavity has length L=26.65L = 26.65 mm, finesse F=828(2)\mathcal{F} = 828(2) and linewidth (FWHM) κ/2π=6.79(2)\kappa/2\pi= 6.79(2) MHz, measured at the atomic transition wavelength λ=689\lambda= 689 nm. The waist of the cavity mode, w0=87w_0 = 87 μ\mum, is estimated from the cavity design and yields a maximum single-atom coupling rate

g0/2π=−ε^⋅dℏωℏ2ϵ0V=11.3 kHz,(4)g_0/2\pi= -\frac{\hat{\varepsilon}\cdot\mathbf{d}}{\hbar}\sqrt{\frac{\omega\hbar}{2\epsilon_0 V}} = 11.3\ \mathrm{kHz}, \tag*{(4)}

where ε^⋅d\hat{\varepsilon}\cdot\mathbf{d} is the 1S0↔3P1{}^{1}S_0 \leftrightarrow{}^{3}P_1, mJ=0m_J = 0 dipole matrix element projection, ω=2πc/λ\omega= 2\pi c/\lambda is the transition frequency and V=πw02L/4V = \pi w_0^2L/4 is the effective mode volume, accounting for the Gaussian transverse intensity profile and the standing-wave mode function [51]. The single-atom coupling is used to extract the atom number from NMS measurements and to define the superradiant lasing threshold. The oven nozzle consists of a rectangular array of collimation tubes (12 mm ×\times 2 mm), elongated along the cavity direction. The oven is operated at 525 °C, which, in the Knudsen diffusion regime, corresponds to a mean atomic transverse velocity of vˉx≈345\bar{v}_x \approx345 m/s. The TEM00_{00} cavity mode has a Gaussian transverse field profile E∝exp⁡(−x2/w02)\mathcal{E} \propto\exp(-x^2/w_0^2), so that the effective mean interaction time, defined by the pulse-area integral Θ=Ω0τ\Theta= \Omega_0\tau, is

τT=πw0vˉx≈0.45 μs,(5)\tau_T = \frac{\sqrt{\pi}w_0}{\bar{v}_x} \approx0.45\ \mu\mathrm{s}, \tag*{(5)}

a factor π/2≈0.89\sqrt{\pi}/2 \approx0.89 shorter than the flat-top estimate τflat=2w0/vˉx≈0.50\tau_{\mathrm{flat}} = 2w_0/\bar{v}_x \approx0.50 μ\mus, which provides an upper bound on the interaction time. The resulting transit-time broadening is

γT=1τT=vˉxπw0≈2π×360 kHz.(6)\gamma_T = \frac{1}{\tau_T} = \frac{\bar{v}_x}{\sqrt{\pi}w_0} \approx2\pi\times360\ \mathrm{kHz}. \tag*{(6)}

The collimation from the nozzle array limits the transverse velocity spread to ∣vz∣≲10|v_z| \lesssim10 m/s if we assume no wall collisions in the tubes. This corresponds to a Doppler broadening of γD=2π×vz/λ≲2π×14.5\gamma_D = 2\pi\times v_z/\lambda\lesssim2\pi\times14.5 MHz, far exceeding that allowed by the superradiant lasing threshold condition.

Laser cooling and state preparation. Reducing γD\gamma_D to below the superradiant lasing threshold requires laser cooling parallel to the cavity axis. We employ Swept Velocity Shelving (SVS), explained in detail in Ref. 30. The SVS selection beam is Gaussian (waists wx=35w_x = 35 mm, wy=0.8w_y = 0.8 mm) and power-broadened at its peak to a linewidth of ≈900\approx900 kHz. Compared to the top-hat beam that was used for Ref. 30, the Gaussian beam gives slightly higher transfer efficiency at comparable Doppler broadening. Above the SVS zone, a tightly focused cleaning beam, propagating in the same direction as the sweep beam and resonant with 1S0→1P1{}^{1}S_0 \to{}^{1}P_1, Doppler shifts residual ground-state atoms out of resonance, suppressing their absorption of intra-cavity photons. In the final state preparation stage, atoms shelved in 3P0{}^{3}P_0 during SVS are repumped via 3S1{}^{3}S_1 and decay spontaneously into the 3P1{}^{3}P_1 manifold. The repump light is delivered in a sheet beam propagating orthogonal to both the atomic beam and the selection beam, with a waist wx=wSP=150w_x = w_{\mathrm{SP}} = 150 μ\mum chosen to place the excitation region close to the cavity mode while avoiding light shifts inside it. To maximize the population in the target state 3P1{}^{3}P_1, mJ=0m_J = 0, we include additional frequency components addressing 3P1{}^{3}P_1, mJ=±1→3S1m_J = \pm1 \to{}^{3}S_1, giving atoms in 3P1{}^{3}P_1, mJ=±1m_J = \pm1 a further chance to decay into 3P1{}^{3}P_1, mJ=0m_J = 0 and contribute to the superradiant emission.

Atom-cavity interaction and normal-mode splitting

To characterize the intra-cavity atom number and Doppler broadening, we use normal-mode splitting (NMS) [52, 53, 54] by ground-state atoms. For this measurement, the state preparation beam is positioned Δx=1.5\Delta x = 1.5 cm below the SR cavity mode, giving atoms sufficient time to decay spontaneously from 3P1{}^{3}P_1 to 1S0{}^{1}S_0 before reaching the SR cavity. At our mean beam velocity vˉx=345\bar{v}_x = 345 m/s, more than 80% of atoms have decayed to the ground state by the time they enter the SR cavity mode. The ground-state atoms then couple collectively to the cavity field, and the collective coupling strength

G=g0NC(7)G = g_0\sqrt{N_C} \tag*{(7)}

becomes comparable to or exceeds the SR cavity decay rate κ\kappa, causing the cavity transmission to split into two hybridized normal modes. The intra-cavity atom number NCN_C and the effective atomic linewidth γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} are extracted simultaneously by fitting the measured transmission spectrum with the general atom-cavity transmission model, Ref. 30, where the cavity linewidth κ\kappa is fixed from independent bare-cavity measurements in the absence of atoms. We assume the ground- and excited-state populations differ by only one spontaneously emitted photon, so that the NMS measurement on ground-state atoms provides a faithful map of the velocity distribution and atom number of the atoms that will subsequently contribute to superradiant emission. From the cavity transmission fit, the effectively coupled intra-cavity atom number is obtained as

NC=(Gg0)2.(8)N_C = \left(\frac{G}{g_0}\right)^2. \tag*{(8)}

Homogeneous broadening is characterized by the spontaneous emission at rate γ\gamma, stray-light-induced dephasing at rate γB\gamma_B, and finite interaction times with the cavity mode at rate γT\gamma_T. The total effective broadening is therefore

γhomo=γ+γB+γT≈2π×400 kHz,(9)\gamma_{\mathrm{homo}} = \gamma+ \gamma_B + \gamma_T \approx2\pi\times400\ \mathrm{kHz}, \tag*{(9)}

larger than the value quoted in Ref. 30, where the flat-top transit-time estimate τflat=2w0/vˉx\tau_{\mathrm{flat}} = 2w_0/\bar{v}_x was used. The Doppler broadening is isolated by subtracting the homogeneous contributions,

Apparatus and parameter space of continuous superradiant emission

Extended Data Figure 1. Apparatus and parameter space of continuous superradiant emission. (a) Schematic of the experimental apparatus showing the atomic beam propagating vertically against gravity, the SVS cooling zone, the cleaning zone, the state preparation beam, and the optical cavity (SR cavity). The directions of the magnetic field B\mathbf{B} and gravity g\mathbf{g} are indicated. (b) Mean steady-state SR output power PSRP_{\mathrm{SR}} as a function of switching frequency ff and duty cycle dd. (c) Effective linewidth γD∼γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} \sim\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} extracted from NMS fits Eq. (10). (d) Intra-cavity atom number NC=(G/g0)2N_{\mathrm{C}} = (G/g_0)^2 Eq. (8) extracted from the same NMS fits, with g0/2π=11.3g_0/2\pi= 11.3 kHz. The reference operating point is indicated with a star. For (b)–(d) each data pixel is the mean of four independent measurements.

γD=γeff−γhomo.(10)\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} = \gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} - \gamma_{\mathrm{homo}}. \tag*{(10)}

Because the SVS scheme selects atoms within a Lorentzian velocity class, both the homogeneous and Doppler contributions are well approximated by Lorentzian profiles, and their linewidths add directly [30].

Main tuning parameters. The superradiant emission is controlled via four main experimental parameters. The switching frequency f=1/(τsel+τsw)f = 1/(\tau_{\mathrm{sel}} + \tau_{\mathrm{sw}}) and duty cycle d=τsel⋅fd = \tau_{\mathrm{sel}} \cdot f set the relative duration of the selection and sweep pulses in the SVS scheme, and together determine the maximum NCN_{\mathrm{C}} and γD\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}. The power of the state preparation beam controls the fraction of atoms repumped into 3P1{}^{3}P_{1}, mJ=0m_{J} = 0, and its position Δx\Delta x relative to the SR cavity mode sets the excited-state fraction fef_{\mathrm{e}} at the SR cavity entrance via the natural decay of 3P1{}^{3}P_{1} (γ/2π=7.48\gamma/2\pi= 7.48 kHz). Note that changing the state preparation beam power does not change fef_{\mathrm{e}}, since atoms that are not repumped remain shelved in the metastable 3P0,2{}^{3}P_{0,2} states.

Atom number NCN_{\mathrm{C}} and Doppler broadening γD\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}. To map out the accessible parameter space, we perform NMS measurements over a two-dimensional grid of ff and dd, recording γD\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} and NCN_{\mathrm{C}} at each point (Ext. Data Fig. 1c-d), alongside the steady-state SR output power PSRP_{\mathrm{SR}} emitted through one of the cavity mirrors, i.e. half the total output power (Ext. Data Fig. 1b). The steady-state output power is measured for a duration of 100 ms, 100 ms after switch-on to ensure the system has reached steady state, using a free-space silicon avalanche photodetector (APD) (Thorlabs APD130A/M). The SR output is non-zero over a broad region of the (f,d)(f,d) plane, demonstrating that continuous superradiant emission is robust to variations in the cooling parameters. Within this region, the output power reaches a maximum, measured on one side of the cavity, of 32.8(1) nW near f=0.5f = 0.5 MHz, d=40%d = 40\%, the reference operating point that we always use unless stated otherwise. This maximum coincides with the minimum Doppler broadening γD≈2π×1\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} \approx2\pi\times1 MHz found from NMS at similar parameters (f=0.4f = 0.4 MHz, d=40%d = 40\%). This agreement indicates that the NMS diagnostic on ground-state atoms faithfully reflects the velocity distribution of the excited-state emitters. The intra-cavity atom number remains approximately constant at NC≈0.98(5)×105N_{\mathrm{C}} \approx0.98(5) \times10^{5} over the range f∈[0.4,1.3]f \in[0.4,1.3] MHz at d=40%d = 40\% (Ext. Data Fig. 1d), providing a stable window in which γD\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} can be varied, nearly independently of NCN_{\mathrm{C}}. This window includes our reference operating point (f=0.5f = 0.5 MHz). The corresponding total atomic flux through the SR cavity mode is Φ=2NCvˉx/(πw0)≈4.4(1)×1011\Phi= 2N_{\mathrm{C}}\bar{v}_{x}/(\sqrt{\pi}w_{0}) \approx4.4(1) \times10^{11} s−1^{-1}, reduced compared to Ref. 30 since now most atoms decay through 3P1{}^{3}P_{1}, mJ=0m_{J} = 0.

Excitation beam position and excited-state fraction. To adjust the excitation fraction fe(Δx)f_{\mathrm{e}}(\Delta x), we position the state preparation beam at a distance Δx\Delta x upstream of the cavity mode. Atoms then decay spontaneously from 3P1{}^{3}P_{1} during transit to the SR cavity, giving an excited-state fraction

fe(Δx)=exp⁡(−γΔxvˉx).(11)f_{\mathrm{e}}(\Delta x) = \exp\left(-\frac{\gamma\Delta x}{\bar{v}_{x}}\right). \tag*{(11)}

We scan the position of the excitation beam xexx_{\mathrm{ex}} along the atomic beam axis using a DC servo-motorized mirror mount (Thorlabs Z912), see Ext. Data Fig. 2a. The SR output power peaks at xpeakx_{\mathrm{peak}}, determined with a precision of ≈0.05\approx0.05 mm. We believe that at this position the excitation beam is located just below the SR cavity mode, maximizing the number of excited state atoms that have the full transit time to emit a photon.

We therefore estimate that the centre of the cavity mode lies ≈w0+wSP≈0.25\approx w_0 + w_{\mathrm{SP}} \approx0.25 mm ≡δxcentre\equiv\delta x_{\mathrm{centre}} above the peak. Using the estimated location of the cavity centre as the origin, we obtain Δx(xex)=xpeak−xex+δxcentre\Delta x(x_{\mathrm{ex}}) = x_{\mathrm{peak}} - x_{\mathrm{ex}} + \delta x_{\mathrm{centre}}. The reference operating point, Δxop=0.89(5)\Delta x^{\mathrm{op}} = 0.89(5) mm, is chosen sufficiently far from the SR cavity to avoid measurable light shifts while maintaining feop≃89%f_e^{\mathrm{op}} \simeq89\%. The effective emitter number is approximately

ν=ηrepump⋅feop≈0.8,(12)\nu= \eta_{\mathrm{repump}} \cdot f_e^{\mathrm{op}} \approx0.8, \tag*{(12)}

where ηrepump≈0.90\eta_{\mathrm{repump}} \approx0.90 is the repumping efficiency into 3P1,mJ=0{}^{3}P_{1},m_{J}=0. The dominant uncertainty arises from ηrepump\eta_{\mathrm{repump}}. As it enters only as an overall linear scaling of NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} it does not affect the threshold behaviour or the shape of the transition.

Effective emitter number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}. The effective emitter number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} is the total number of excited-state atoms inside the 1/e1/e cavity mode volume, i.e. without standing-wave weighting. It is calculated from the NMS atom number NCN_{\mathrm{C}}, which includes the axial average, ⟨cos⁡2(kz)⟩=1/2\langle\cos^{2}(kz) \rangle= 1/2, over the standing-wave mode function. We calculate the effective emitter number as

NSR=2νNC,(13)N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 2\nu N_{\mathrm{C}}, \tag*{(13)}

where ν≈0.8\nu\approx0.8 accounts for the excited-state fraction and repumping efficiency [Eq. (12)].

We measure NCN_{\mathrm{C}} via NMS as a function of the excitation beam intensity under the reference operating conditions f=0.5f = 0.5 MHz and d=40%d = 40\%, see Extended Data Figure 2. The resulting NSR(I)N_{\mathrm{SR}}(I) dependence is well described by

Calibration plots of state preparation beam position, effective emitter number, and effective linewidth

Extended Data Figure 2. Calibration of the state preparation beam position, the excited-state atom number, and the Doppler broadening. (a) Steady-state SR output power PSRP_{\mathrm{SR}} as a function of state preparation beam position Δx\Delta x relative to the estimated position of the SR cavity mode centre. The corresponding excited-state fraction fe(Δx)f_e(\Delta x) is shown on the top axis [Eq. (11)]. The grey shaded region (∣Δx∣<w0+wSP≈0.25|\Delta x| < w_0+w_{\mathrm{SP}} \approx0.25 mm) marks positions where the beam overlaps the intra-cavity field. (b) Effective excited-state emitter number NSR=2νNCN_{\mathrm{SR}} = 2\nu N_{\mathrm{C}} as a function of normalized state preparation beam intensity [Eq. (14)] (solid curve). (c) Effective linewidth γeff∼γD\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} \sim\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} as a function of switching frequency ff at fixed duty cycle d=40%d = 40\% and maximum state preparation beam intensity. The solid curve is the empirical power-law calibration [Eq. (15)], with the fit range f∈[0.4,1.3]f \in[0.4, 1.3] MHz indicated by the shaded region. Values taken at the reference operating point are marked by stars. Error bars in (a) are defined as in Figure 1d. Error bars in (b) and (c) indicate the sample standard deviation of fitted values across repeated measurements at each scan point, combined in quadrature with the propagated fit uncertainty of the mean.

NSR(I)=2ν(aN(1−e−I/bN)+cN),(14)N_{\mathrm{SR}}(I) = 2\nu\left(a_{N}\left(1-e^{-I/b_{N}}\right)+c_{N}\right), \tag*{(14)}

with fit results aN=1.040(5)×105a_{N} = 1.040(5) \times10^{5}, bN=39.0(8)%b_{N} = 39.0(8)\%, cN=670(530)c_{N} = 670(530) and the fit quality characterized by a reduced χ2=0.9\chi^{2} = 0.9. II is the peak preparation beam intensity normalized to 125 mW/cm2^{2} [30].

Doppler broadening calibration. At fixed duty cycle d=40%d = 40\% and maximum intensity in the state preparation beam, the switching frequency ff is the last control parameter. As established above, NCN_{\mathrm{C}} remains approximately constant at ⟨NC⟩≃0.98(5)×105\langle N_{\mathrm{C}}\rangle\simeq0.98(5) \times10^{5} over the range f∈[0.4,1.3]f \in[0.4, 1.3] MHz, so that NSR≈2ν⟨NC⟩≃1.57(8)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} \approx2\nu\langle N_{\mathrm{C}}\rangle\simeq1.57(8) \times10^{5} atoms is treated as constant. The Doppler broadening γD=γeff−γhomo\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} = \gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}-\gamma_{\mathrm{homo}}, where γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} is measured with NMS and γhomo\gamma_{\mathrm{homo}} is assumed to be constant, varies strongly with ff and is described by the empirical power law

γD(f)=aγ(f/MHz)bγ+cγ,(15)\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}(f) = a_{\gamma}(f/\mathrm{MHz})^{b_{\gamma}} + c_{\gamma}, \tag*{(15)}

as shown in Extended Data Figure 2. The fit results in aγ=0.67(8)a_{\gamma} = 0.67(8) MHz, bγ=3.8(4)b_{\gamma} = 3.8(4) and cγ=1.42(6)c_{\gamma} = 1.42(6) MHz with a reduced χ2=1.38\chi^{2} = 1.38. The fitted exponent bγb_{\gamma} reflects the nonlinear dependence of the selected velocity class on the sweep/selection pulse duration in the SVS scheme [30]. For all experiments described in the main text, except the MCSR measurements, the duty cycle is fixed at d=40%d = 40\%, the excitation beam at Δxop=0.890\Delta x_{\mathrm{op}} = 0.890 mm, and we vary the state preparation beam intensity to tune NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} and vary ff to tune γD\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}.

Optical setup and frequency stability

The frequency stability and accuracy characterization is based on three lasers: the superradiant laser itself (SR laser), a ULE-cavity-stabilized reference laser (ULE laser), and a spectroscopy laser (Spec laser). The spectroscopy laser is stabilized on short timescales (<1< 1 s) to a transfer cavity, limiting its linewidth to a few kHz, and on longer timescales to the 88Sr 1S0→3P1{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr}\ {}^{1}S_{0} \to{}^{3}P_{1} transition via modulation-transfer spectroscopy on a hot vapour cell [55, 56]. Because its linewidth far exceeds that of the ULE laser, the spectroscopy laser serves only as a long-term frequency reference. The ULE laser is stabilized to a ULE cavity (Stable Lasers Ltd. [57]) with a zero-crossing temperature of approximately 5 ∘C5\,^\circ\mathrm{C}. When operated near this temperature, the cavity drift rate is 290(10) Hz/h, sufficiently low that the beat linewidth is limited by fibre-link noise rather than cavity drift. This condition is used for the intrinsic linewidth characterization of the SR laser. To demonstrate the self-locking capability of the SR laser, we deliberately detune from the zero-crossing temperature, increasing the drift rate to 4215(1) Hz/h. Under these conditions the SR self-lock is engaged to suppress the cavity drift of the interaction cavity (Figure 3a).

Optical setup and heterodyne detection. The optical setup is schematically shown in Ext. Data Fig. 3a. The SR cavity has equal mirror coatings on both sides, resulting in bidirectional emission of equal power. The left output is directed to the detection breadboard. On the detection breadboard, a flip mirror selects between two measurement configurations: amplitude detection on a free-space APD (bandwidth 50 MHz) where the SR amplitude is measured directly, or frequency measurement using a heterodyne three-cornered hat setup. This separation improves the signal-to-noise ratio for both measurements. In the three-cornered hat configuration, the SR output is first sent through a free-space optical isolator, which prevents back-scattered light from the ULE laser or Spec laser from coupling into the SR cavity and disturbing emission, and then split equally and directed to two heterodyne beat measurements. The first beat is formed between the SR laser and the ULE laser (ULE-SR, fbeat=3.3f_{\mathrm{beat}} = 3.3 MHz), the second between the SR laser and the Spec laser (SR-Spec, fbeat=10.9f_{\mathrm{beat}} = 10.9 MHz) and detected via free-space silicon avalanche photodetectors. A third beat between the ULE laser and the Spec laser (ULE-Spec, fbeat=7.6f_{\mathrm{beat}} = 7.6 MHz) is detected on a free-space silicon photodiode on the same breadboard. All three beats are detected with a bandwidth of 50 MHz and isolated with RF bandpass filters of 3–5 MHz bandwidth centred on the respective beat frequencies.

Because the Spec laser’s linewidth far exceeds that of the ULE laser, the former is excluded from short-term linewidth measurements; short-term characterization relies on the ULE-SR beat alone. The quoted linewidths are upper bounds on the intrinsic SR linewidth. For long-term stability characterization, all three beats are recorded simultaneously with a K&K FXE phase and frequency counter, allowing a three-cornered hat comparison that isolates the individual frequency noise contribution of each laser [34]. For the strongly drifting ULE laser, shown in Figure 3b, we applied a linear drift removal before calculating the OADEV.

We additionally analyse the long-term stability shown in Figure 3. Over the measurement duration, the mean frequency offset between the spectroscopy laser and the self-referenced SR laser is 77.5(2.3) kHz (SR-Spec), where the uncertainty is the standard deviation of the offset over the full measurement. The offset may originate from the spectroscopy setup, from imperfect centring of the cavity on the transition frequency, or from shifts induced by the lock light and the intracavity atom number, as discussed in SI.

Cavity length stabilization and self-locking scheme. The length of the SR cavity is stabilized onto the SR laser frequency itself, which is possible because of the small cavity-pulling coefficient. As the SR laser output does not provide enough power to implement the cavity lock, we first beat-lock a portion of the ULE laser light to a fixed offset frequency from the SR laser (3 MHz), see “Self-locking” breadboard in Ext. Data Fig. 3a. Any slow drift of the ULE cavity is thereby absorbed by the acousto-optical modulator (AOM) feedback loop (bandwidth 100 kHz), and the cavity length stabilization laser beam follows the SR laser frequency rather than the ULE cavity, as confirmed by the τ−1\tau^{-1} scaling of the in-loop Allan deviation of the SR - lock light beat note (Ext. Data Fig. 3b). Furthermore, this SR cavity lock setup keeps the approximation of three independent oscillators in the three cornered hat valid, despite using light from the ULE laser for the SR cavity lock (100 kHz bandwidth of the lock vs 100 ms τ\tau gate time in the measurement). We use self-locking for the long-duration measurements shown in Figure 3a and Ext. Data Fig. 3b. For short-duration measurements the self-locking scheme is not beneficial and, as stated for each such measurement, we lock directly to ULE laser light shifted by a fixed frequency.

The cavity lock light is red-shifted to −2650-2650 MHz of the 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_{0} \to{}^{3}P_{1} transition via an 8-pass AOM [59], placing it on resonance with the TEM02_{02} cavity mode. The TEM02_{02} mode is chosen to separate the frequencies of the locking light and the SR emission as well as for its reduced spatial overlap with the lasing TEM00_{00} mode. Sideband modulation at 50 MHz is applied via a fibre electro-optical modulator (EOM), and a standard Pound-Drever-Hall (PDH) scheme generates the cavity length error signal. To reduce the influence of the locking light as much as possible, a free-space silicon avalanche photodetector was utilized as a PDH photodiode, allowing the locking light power to be reduced to well below 1 μ\muW. The linear locking light polarization is set orthogonal to the linear SR emission polarization allowing the lock light to be separated from the SR output on the detection side using a polarizing beam splitter (PBS). The cavity transmission is monitored with a CCD camera.

The cavity linewidth is practically the same for the lasing and the locking mode (κ/2π≈6.79\kappa/2\pi\approx6.79 MHz), resulting in a PDH error signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of only 500-1000. This limits the cavity lock precision to ∼\sim tens of kHz. However, the influence of this cavity frequency uncertainty on the SR laser frequency is suppressed by the small bad-cavity pulling coefficient ρ=0.165(3)\rho= 0.165(3), reducing its contribution to the SR frequency uncertainty to ∼\sim few kHz. We chose a slow cavity piezo lock bandwidth of ∼10\sim10 Hz as the cavity exhibits excellent passive thermal and vibrational stability [60, 61]. Increasing the lock bandwidth would degrade, rather than improve, the SR frequency stability on the 10 ms timescale relevant for linewidth extraction.

Optical setup and linewidth characterization of the superradiant laser

Extended Data Figure 3. Linewidth characterization and self-locking of the superradiant laser. (a) Schematic of the optical setup. The SR laser emits through both cavity mirrors. A flip mirror on the left selects between amplitude measurement and three-cornered hat heterodyne frequency measurement. The right cavity output is used for the self-locking scheme, forcing the cavity length to follow the SR laser frequency. (b) Overlapping Allan deviation of the SR-lock light beat note, while all locks are engaged (in-loop), with power law fit (red line). (c) Frequency noise power spectral density Sν(f)S_{\nu}(f), over 1 s measurement period, for which the SR cavity is locked directly to the ULE laser (blue) or is self-locked (red). The dotted grey line shows the β\beta-separation line βf\beta f (β=8ln⁡2/π2≈0.56\beta= 8 \ln2/\pi^2 \approx0.56). Here, the shaded areas indicate the noise contributions to the β\beta-separation linewidth [58]. No drift subtraction is applied and uncertainties are estimated by bootstrapping (n=200n = 200 Welch-segment resamples). (d) Intrinsic linewidth Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} versus FFT sweep time TT, measured via a heterodyne beat with the ULE laser (blue squares). Grey disks show the technical noise floor extracted from an RF reference signal whereas the grey dotted line is the Fourier limit 1.44/T1.44/T. The black dashed curve is a fit to Eq. (17). The sweep time for all laser linewidth measurements mentioned elsewhere is marked by the orange dashed line. Error bars: (b), as in Figure 3b; (d), as in Figure 2.

After self-locking, an external frequency reference remains in the system: the SVS selection laser, which is derived from the Spec laser. A drift of its frequency displaces the velocity class selected along the cavity axis, but does not pull the SR emission frequency. Because each atom couples to both counterpropagating components of the cavity field, the effective velocity distribution along the cavity axis is symmetrized. Consequently, a nonzero mean velocity can appear as a symmetric splitting of the gain profile rather than as a shift. This splitting is resolved only when it exceeds the gain broadening, making this signature robust against velocity offsets [62]. The emission frequency is therefore first-order insensitive to drifts of the selection laser, which also ensures the independence of the SR and Spec lasers assumed in the three-cornered hat analysis. In the future, the selection laser could be derived from the SR laser, removing the need for the spectroscopy cell.

Short-term linewidth. Two complementary quantities are used to characterize the SR laser frequency noise, each giving access to a different aspect of the emission. The frequency noise power spectral density Sν(f)S_{\nu}(f) captures the full noise spectrum including lock-induced contributions and characterizes the laser as seen by an external user on a one second timescale by the β\beta-separation linewidth Δνβ\Delta\nu_{\beta} (see Ext. Data Fig. 3c and Supplementary Information). The short-term intrinsic linewidth Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} describes short-term phase stability. This linewidth is extracted at timescales shorter than the cavity lock bandwidth (∼10\sim10 Hz), where the lock has not yet acted and the SR emission is effectively free-running. To access the intrinsic linewidth Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}}, we follow the method of Ref. 19 and restrict the measurement to FFT sweep times T≪1/flock=100T \ll1/f_{\mathrm{lock}} = 100 ms. Here, we use the ULE laser directly to stabilize the SR cavity length because of the slightly lower ΓβULE\Gamma_{\beta\mathrm{ULE}}. The ULE-SR beat signal is recorded via the oscilloscope in FFT mode (Hann window) and a Lorentzian is fitted within a 10-kHz window centred on the beat frequency for each sweep time TT:

L(f)=A(Δνmeas/2)2(f−fc)2+(Δνmeas/2)2+B,(16)L(f)=A\frac{(\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}}/2)^2}{(f-f_{\mathrm{c}})^2+(\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}}/2)^2}+B, \tag*{(16)}

where Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} is the FWHM linewidth and BB is the noise floor. Each data point represents the mean of 20 independent measurements. The measured linewidth follows

Δνmeas(T)=A/T+BTn,(17)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}}(T)=A/T+BT^n, \tag*{(17)}

with fit parameters A=1220(250)A = 1220(250) Hz·ms, B=93(40)B = 93(40) Hz/msn^n, n=0.58(13)n = 0.58(13), having a minimum at time Tmin⁡=7.1T_{\min} = 7.1 ms (Ext. Data Fig. 3d). For all laser linewidth measurements mentioned elsewhere, we choose an FFT sweep time of TFFT=11.0T_{\mathrm{FFT}} = 11.0 ms. This conservative choice provides reproducible measurements and simultaneously minimizes the Fourier limit (1.44/TFFT=1301.44/T_{\mathrm{FFT}} = 130 Hz) and the technical noise floor (107.5(6) Hz from the RF reference). At TFFTT_{\mathrm{FFT}} this data set yields its minimum measured linewidth of Δνmeas=420(80)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} = 420(80) Hz. The increase at longer sweep times reflects technical noise broadening.

As we measure the beat between the SR laser and the ULE-stabilized probe laser, the measured linewidth is Δνmeas=ΔνSR+ΔνULE\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} = \Delta\nu_{\mathrm{SR}} + \Delta\nu_{\mathrm{ULE}}. To account for the technical noise sources, the superradiant cavity lock and the finite probe linewidth, we fit a constant offset Δνadd\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{add}} with Eq. (3) to the data (Figure 2b and Ext. Data Fig. 4a), obtaining Δνadd=310(60)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{add}} = 310(60) Hz from the NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} scan and Δνadd=400(40)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{add}} = 400(40) Hz from the γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} scan. The two independent fits are consistent within 1.2σ1.2\sigma, indicating that Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} is mostly dominated by technical noise. Including this offset, the model predicts a measured linewidth of ∼400\sim400 Hz at NSR=1.57×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 1.57 \times10^5, above the lowest measured value of 320(40) Hz (obtained from an independent 30-shot measurement), as an upper bound on the intrinsic SR linewidth.

The probe laser contribution ΔνULE\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{ULE}} arises from technical noise sources. The ULE cavity itself should in the ideal case only contribute approximately ∼10\sim10 Hz due to thermal noise when operated at the zero-crossing temperature [57]. One relevant contribution is expected from the uncompensated 10 m long PM fibre between the ULE cavity and the SR laser. Thermomechanical 1/f1/f noise from structural damping of the fibre’s glass and acoustic coupling from the laboratory environment are both well-established broadening mechanisms for optical fibre paths at this length scale [63, 64, 65]. Integrating over the relevant Fourier band for our 11-ms window yields an expected contribution of ∼200\sim200–400 Hz. Additional contributions from residual cavity lock noise and cavity vibrations, as discussed above, cannot be excluded.

Cavity pulling suppression

To measure the cavity-pulling coefficient, ρ=ΔfSR/Δfcav\rho= \Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}}/\Delta f_{\mathrm{cav}}, we directly use the ULE laser light to lock the SR cavity, detune the cavity from resonance using the eight-pass AOM and measure the resulting SR frequency shift for several cavity-detuning values. The detuning points are randomized to suppress systematic shifts caused, for example, by a slowly drifting reference laser (Figure 2a). The slope of the SR emission-frequency shift ΔfSR\Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}} versus the cavity detuning Δfcav\Delta f_{\mathrm{cav}} yields the cavity-pulling coefficient. We use a heterodyne beat between the SR output and the ULE laser, recorded on an avalanche photodiode and analysed with a scanning spectrum analyser (beat frequency 3.15 MHz, span 0.1–8.1 MHz, RBW = 10 kHz). A Lorentzian is fitted to the central beat feature to extract the SR frequency. For this measurement, the ULE cavity is operated close to its zero-crossing temperature and calibrated against the Spec laser; its drift during an individual scan, which lasts only a few minutes, is negligible compared with the measured frequency shifts. This method provides a wide frequency span and is used to map the pulling slope across multiple Doppler widths γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}.

MCSR measurement

To vary γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} at fixed intracavity atom number NSR≈1.57(8)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} \approx1.57(8) \times10^5, we vary the switching frequency of the SVS scheme as described earlier and shown in Ext. Data Fig. 2c. To scan the intracavity atom number at fixed Doppler broadening, we vary the state-preparation beam power as shown in Ext. Data Fig. 2b, operating SVS at duty cycle d=30%d = 30\% and switching frequency f=1.1f = 1.1 MHz, which sets γeff/(2π)=4.5(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi) = 4.5(1) MHz at atom number NSR=1.54(5)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 1.54(5) \times10^5. In both scans, the SR laser is allowed to reach steady state for 100 ms before data acquisition, which is well justified given that the relaxation oscillations visible in Figure 1c decay on a timescale of ∼5 μ\sim5\,\mus, more than four orders of magnitude shorter than the settling time.

Two independent observables are recorded at each operating point. First, the heterodyne beat between the SR output and the ULE cavity laser is recorded on an APD and analysed with a spectrum analyser (beat frequency 3.15 MHz, frequency range 0.1–8.1 MHz, RBW = 10 kHz, frequency spacing 13.3 kHz), binned by a factor of four to a final resolution of 53 kHz. This gives access to both phase and amplitude fluctuations of the SR field, and directly reveals sidebands in the optical spectrum when the MCSR regime is entered. Second, the SR output is monitored directly on an APD without a reference laser for 10 ms at 90 MSa/s on an oscilloscope. The DC component yields the mean output power ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle, and the AC component δP(t)\delta P(t) is converted to power fluctuations. A one-sided power spectral density is computed as

Extended Data Figure 4. Mean SR output power ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle and intrinsic linewidth during transition from single frequency to multi-component lasing. (a) Mean output power ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle (red squares, left axis) and intrinsic SR laser linewidth Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} of the carrier (blue disks, right axis) as a function of γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}. Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} is extracted from a multi-peak Lorentzian fit to the spectrum and represents an upper bound on the intrinsic SR laser linewidth. The analytical model Eq. (3) is fitted to the linewidth measurements, while adding a constant offset to account for the finite probe laser linewidth and technical noise contributions (Δνadd=400(40)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{add}} = 400(40) Hz), shown as the dashed blue line. The output power model Eq. (20) (red dashed line) yields NSR=1.6(1)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 1.6(1) \times10^{5} atoms. The transition to multi-component lasing happens at γeffMCSR=1.8(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\mathrm{MCSR}} = 1.8(1) MHz (vertical red dash-dotted line). (b) Mean SR output power ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle for a large broadening γeff/(2π)=4.5(1)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi) = 4.5(1) MHz as a function of NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}. A linear fit above threshold (red dashed line) yields Ncritexp=1.13(1)×105N_{\mathrm{crit}}^{\mathrm{exp}} = 1.13(1) \times10^{5} (vertical red dotted line). The theoretical threshold Ncritth=1.18×105N_{\mathrm{crit}}^{\mathrm{th}} = 1.18 \times10^{5} is indicated with a vertical grey dashed line. The transition to multi-component lasing happens at NSRMCSR=1.24(5)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}}^{\mathrm{MCSR}} = 1.24(5) \times10^{5} (vertical red dash-dotted line). Error bars: (a), as in Figure 2b; (b), as in Figure 1d.

S(f)=2∣δP~(f)∣2fs∑nwn2,(18)S(f) = \frac{2\lvert\widetilde{\delta P}(f)\rvert^{2}}{f_s\sum_n w_n^2}, \tag*{(18)}

where δP~(f)\widetilde{\delta P}(f) is the discrete Fourier transform of the Hann-windowed signal, fsf_s is the sampling rate, and wnw_n are the window coefficients. Frequency bins are averaged to a final resolution of 50 kHz, similar to the one of the beat-note measurement.

Acknowledgements

We thank UvA’s technical workshop for electronic and mechanical assistance, in particular Daan Giesen, Edwin Baaij, Tristan van Klingeren, Ronald Hassing, Maarten Tuijl, and Johan Mozes. We also thank Ivo Knottnerus and Alex Urech for their technical support. S.B.J. gratefully acknowledges support from Corinna Kollath. We thank Helmut Ritsch and Robert Spreeuw for providing comments on the manuscript.

Funding

This work was supported by the Dutch National Growth Fund (NGF), as part of the Quantum Delta NL programme. This work has received funding from the European Union’s (EU) Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under Grant Agreement No. 820404 (iqClock project) and No. 860579 (MoSaiQC project). A.S. and S.A.S. acknowledge support from this EU programme under Grant Agreement No. 101154998 (CCSuperClock project) and Grant Agreement No. 101109698 (DarkCavityties Project), respectively. S.A.S. additionally acknowledges support from the NNF Quantum Computing Programme (NQCP) and from ESA OSIP contract No. 4000145931. S.B.J. acknowledges support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) under Projects DFG No. 277625399 – TRR 185 OSCAR (“Open System Control of Atomic and Photonic Matter”, B4), and DFG No. 277146847 – CRC 1238 (“Control and dynamics of quantum materials”, C05) and under Germany’s Excellence Strategy–Cluster of Excellence Matter and Light for Quantum Computing (ML4Q), Grant No. EXC 2004/1 – 390534769.

Author contributions

B.H., F.F., C.B.S., Y.C., S.A.S. and A.S. contributed to the construction of the SR laser. B.H. and A.S. recorded and analysed the data, and prepared the figures. S.B.J. developed the theoretical model and performed the simulations, with contributions from B.H. The manuscript was written by B.H., S.B.J., S.A.S., A.S. and F.S. The project was supervised by F.S. with support from S.A.S. and A.S. Funding was acquired by F.S., A.S., and S.A.S.

DATA AND CODE AVAILABILITY

The data, simulation and analysis tools/code used in this manuscript can be found in Reference [66].

Supplementary Information

SR output power. Superradiant emission emerges when the collective gain overcomes the decoherence in the system, γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}, which is dominated here by the Doppler linewidth γD\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}. A steady-state collective dipole can then form above the critical intracavity atom number, see Eq. (1), where the expression has been written consistently with Eq. (13). As shown in Figure 1d, the SR output power scales linearly with NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} for NSR>NcritN_{\mathrm{SR}} > N_{\mathrm{crit}}. Since both cavity mirrors have identical coatings, light of identical intensity is emitted in both directions, and the detected power at one output port is half the total emitted power. Consequently, all mathematical expressions for the measured output power contain a factor 1/21/2. We first describe the measured power by the linear approximation [31]

Pout=12blin(NSR−Ncrit)(19)P_{\mathrm{out}} = \frac{1}{2}b_{\mathrm{lin}}(N_{\mathrm{SR}}-N_{\mathrm{crit}}) \tag*{(19)}

which is fitted to all data points with Pout>1P_{\mathrm{out}} > 1 nW. This restriction excludes the near-threshold regime, where the power is not strictly linear, and yields the slope blinb_{\mathrm{lin}} and experimental threshold NcritexpN_{\mathrm{crit}}^{\mathrm{exp}} for each value of γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}. The Doppler-linewidth dependence of the measured slopes is described by the phenomenological model

Pout=12hcλbP(γTγD)αNSR−NcritτT(20)P_{\mathrm{out}} = \frac{1}{2}\frac{hc}{\lambda}b_{\mathrm{P}}\left(\frac{\gamma_{\mathrm{T}}}{\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}}\right)^{\alpha}\frac{N_{\mathrm{SR}}-N_{\mathrm{crit}}}{\tau_{\mathrm{T}}} \tag*{(20)}

valid for γD≫γT\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} \gg\gamma_{\mathrm{T}} and NSR>NcritN_{\mathrm{SR}} > N_{\mathrm{crit}}, where τT=πw0/vˉx\tau_{\mathrm{T}}=\sqrt{\pi}w_{0}/\bar{v}_{x} is the Gaussian-averaged transit time [Eq. (5)]. The factor bP(γT/γD)αb_{\mathrm{P}}(\gamma_{\mathrm{T}}/\gamma_{\mathrm{D}})^{\alpha} captures the suppression of collective emission by Doppler broadening. Fitting Eq. (20) to the measured slopes from Figure 1d and Ext. Data Fig. 4b yields bP=1.27(2)b_{\mathrm{P}}=1.27(2) and α=0.502(7)\alpha=0.502(7) with χr2=0.69\chi_{\mathrm{r}}^{2}=0.69. Accordingly, the effective emission factor bP(γT/γD)αb_{\mathrm{P}}(\gamma_{\mathrm{T}}/\gamma_{\mathrm{D}})^{\alpha} decreases from approximately 0.75 to 0.35 as γD\gamma_{\mathrm{D}} is increased from 1 to 4 MHz. Energy conservation requires this factor to remain below unity, which is satisfied for γD≳600\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}\gtrsim600 kHz and hence throughout all experimental conditions considered here. Our analytical model is derived from the same Hamiltonian used for the NMS description [30], with the addition of a coherent drive. It predicts the same linear scaling as Eq. (20) but yields a Doppler-independent emission factor corresponding to 50% effective participation atom number of in the collective emission process. Numerical simulations in Ref. 13 predict that up to 70% of the atoms can participate in the emission, which is close to the largest values we measure. A quantitative microscopic description of the observed Doppler dependence of the emission factor is beyond the scope of this work.

Now, we use Eq. (19) to extract NcritexpN_{\mathrm{crit}}^{\mathrm{exp}} from the data (an example can be seen in the inset of Figure 1d for γeff/(2π)=1.47(4)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi)=1.47(4) MHz where we retrieve Ncritexp=2.53(5)×104N_{\mathrm{crit}}^{\mathrm{exp}}=2.53(5)\times10^{4} atoms, prediction Ncritth=3.9×104N_{\mathrm{crit}}^{\mathrm{th}}=3.9\times10^{4} atoms) in Figure 1d and Ext. Data Fig. 4b. Fitting these thresholds with

Ncritexp(γeff)=aκγeff2g02(21)N_{\mathrm{crit}}^{\mathrm{exp}}(\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}})=a\frac{\kappa\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}{2g_{0}^{2}} \tag*{(21)}

yields a=0.95(1)a=0.95(1), in close agreement with the theoretical prediction a=1a=1. The fitted thresholds are systematically lower by approximately 5%. This offset can be explained because the output power initially follows the classic N2N^{2} superradiant scaling directly above threshold before crossing over to the linear regime [31]. A linear fit restricted to higher power therefore extrapolates to Pout=1P_{\mathrm{out}}=1 nW at a slightly underestimated threshold atom number. We note that for low Doppler broadening, the difference between theory and experimental measurement is larger than for larger broadening.

Cavity pulling model. The inset of Figure 2a shows the cavity-pulling suppression ρ\rho extracted from four data sets with different γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}. To test the validity of Eq. (2) (black line), we fit the data with a single-parameter scaling model,

ρ=aγeffaγeff+κ(22)\rho=\frac{a\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}{a\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}+\kappa} \tag*{(22)}

where aa is a dimensionless scaling factor applied to γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}, the quantity with the largest uncertainty. The fit yields a=1.09(9)a=1.09(9), consistent with unity. Although Eq. (2) is a simplified description of the experiment, it reproduces the data remarkably well.

Superradiant laser linewidth. Our experiment operates in the regime where neither the good-cavity (κ≪γD\kappa\ll\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}) nor the bad-cavity (κ≫γD\kappa\gg\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}) adiabatic limit fully applies. We describe the system using an analytical model that is based on previous work presented in Refs. 38, 67 that captures the dominant noise sources and reproduces the overall trends observed experimentally. We note that this analytical model is a simplification and cannot predict the linewidth near transition points, for example between steady-state superradiance and the multi-component superradiant regime (see Ext. Data Fig. 4a). The relevant dephasing rate in Refs. 38, 67 is γR\gamma_{\mathrm{R}}, which represents the rate at which atoms leave the cavity and are replaced by new excited atoms with a random phase, modelled as independent quantum noise. In our continuous atomic beam, γR\gamma_{\mathrm{R}} is set by the transit time through the cavity mode [Eq. (5), Methods], depending only on the mean atomic velocity and the cavity waist, γR≃γT=2π×360\gamma_{\mathrm{R}}\simeq\gamma_{\mathrm{T}}=2\pi\times360 kHz. Compared to this previous work, we also included Doppler broadening, the velocity spread along the cavity direction, in our analytical model.

Starting with the model, we first consider the intracavity photon number as

Nν=12κ(NSR−Ncrit)γT(23)N_{\nu}=\frac{1}{2\kappa}(N_{\mathrm{SR}}-N_{\mathrm{crit}})\gamma_{\mathrm{T}} \tag*{(23)}

where we neglect transmission losses of the cavity mirrors and vacuum windows. The threshold atom number NcritN_{\mathrm{crit}} [Eq. (1), main text] is set by Doppler broadening γD≥2π×1\gamma_{\mathrm{D}}\geq2\pi\times1 MHz >γT>\gamma_{\mathrm{T}} leading to an effective broadening of γeff≥2π×1.4\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}\geq2\pi\times1.4 MHz. The laser linewidth receives two independent contributions [Refs. 38, 67].

The first contribution is atomic coherence noise. There are two dominant mechanisms that give rise to atomic coherence noise. The first is replenishment-induced phase noise, arising from the stochastic reset or replacement of emitters as the ensemble is maintained in operation. The second mechanism is Doppler dephasing: atoms with different velocity components along the cavity axis accumulate phase at different rates during their transit through the cavity mode. Together, these two mechanisms contribute phase noise to the collective emission, modeled by the effective decoherence rate γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}, and give rise to the atomic coherence-noise contribution

γ1=2g02γeff4(κ+γeff)2NSRNν(24)\gamma_{1}=\frac{2g_{0}^{2}\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}{4(\kappa+\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}})^{2}}\frac{N_{\mathrm{SR}}}{N_{\nu}} \tag*{(24)}

The second contribution to the laser linewidth originates from photon shot noise, which gives rise to

γ2=κ4Nνγeff2(κ+γeff)2=κ4Nνρ2.(25)\gamma_{2} = \frac{\kappa}{4N_{\nu}}\frac{\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{2}}{(\kappa+\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}})^{2}} = \frac{\kappa}{4N_{\nu}}\rho^{2}. \tag*{(25)}

In the good-cavity limit ρ≈1\rho\approx1, γ2\gamma_{2} recovers the standard Schawlow-Townes linewidth, whereas in the bad-cavity limit κ≫γeff\kappa\gg\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}, it becomes γ2≃γeff2/(4Nνκ)\gamma_{2} \simeq\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}^{2}/(4N_{\nu}\kappa), corresponding to a suppression of the classical value κ/(4Nν)\kappa/(4N_{\nu}) by the factor (γeff/κ)2≪1(\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/\kappa)^{2} \ll1.

The total SR laser linewidth can be rewritten as

γSR=γ1+γ2=κ4Nνρ2(1+2g02NSRκγeff).(26)\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}} = \gamma_{1}+\gamma_{2} = \frac{\kappa}{4N_{\nu}}\rho^{2}\left(1+\frac{2g_{0}^{2}N_{\mathrm{SR}}}{\kappa\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}\right). \tag*{(26)}

In the limit NSR≫NcritN_{\mathrm{SR}} \gg N_{\mathrm{crit}}, the two terms behave fundamentally differently. Since Nν∝(NSR−Ncrit)N_{\nu} \propto(N_{\mathrm{SR}}-N_{\mathrm{crit}}), the photon noise contribution scales as γ2∝1/NSR→0\gamma_{2} \propto1/N_{\mathrm{SR}} \to0. The atomic coherence term, however, saturates to a constant because Nν∝NSRN_{\nu} \propto N_{\mathrm{SR}}. This asymptotic floor is set entirely by the single-atom coupling g0g_{0}, Doppler dephasing γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}, and transit rate γT\gamma_{T}, and is independent of the intracavity photon number. The total linewidth therefore approaches a constant at large NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}, dominated by atomic coherence noise, as visible in Figure 2b of the main text, where the data flatten for NSR≳1×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} \gtrsim1 \times10^{5}.

Fundamental superradiant linewidth limit. Deep in the bad-cavity limit (κ≫γeff\kappa\gg\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}) and far above threshold (NSR≫NcritN_{\mathrm{SR}} \gg N_{\mathrm{crit}}), the atomic coherence noise dominates and the linewidth approaches

γSRAsymptotic=g02γeffκγT.(27)\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}^{\mathrm{Asymptotic}} = \frac{g_{0}^{2}\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}{\kappa\gamma_{T}}. \tag*{(27)}

In our parameter regime, γeff>4γT\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} > 4\gamma_{T}, this asymptotic limit lies above the Purcell linewidth

γSRPurcell=4g02κ,(28)\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}^{\mathrm{Purcell}} = \frac{4g_{0}^{2}}{\kappa}, \tag*{(28)}

which is independent of the intracavity photon number, gain broadening, and the exact atom number and is set solely by the single-atom coupling g0g_{0} and the cavity linewidth κ\kappa [11]. For our parameters γSRPurcell=2π×75\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}^{\mathrm{Purcell}} = 2\pi\times75 Hz. Under our current operating conditions, the measured linewidth at NSR≈1.57(8)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} \approx1.57(8) \times10^{5} is 320(40) Hz, lying a factor of ≈4.3\approx4.3 above the Purcell floor. Our analytical model [Eq. (26)] predicts an intrinsic SR linewidth of ∼2π×90\sim2\pi\times90 Hz at this atom number, lying between the Purcell floor and the measured value. The remaining gap between the prediction and the measurement is consistent with the finite probe laser linewidth and technical noise (see Methods and SI), leaving open the possibility that the intrinsic SR linewidth is already near the Purcell floor.

In the crossover regime (ρ<1\rho< 1 and Γcoll≳κ\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}} \gtrsim\kappa), linewidths below the Purcell floor are in principle accessible. The Schawlow-Townes-like suppression factor (γeff/κ)2≪1(\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/\kappa)^{2} \ll1 in combination with a large intracavity photon number NνN_{\nu} can push the linewidth ΔνSR\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{SR}} below γSRPurcell/(2π)\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}^{\mathrm{Purcell}}/(2\pi), as shown analytically and in numerical simulations for the 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_{0} \to{}^{3}P_{1} transition in Refs. 68, 69. In our system this regime would become visible if γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} were reduced towards γT\gamma_{T}, accessible in principle by better transverse cooling of the atomic beam, and if the linewidth measurement were not limited by technical noise.

However, this improvement has a hard limit: once γeff→γT\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} \to\gamma_{T}, transit-time broadening becomes the dominant dephasing mechanism and further cooling yields no benefit. Increasing κ\kappa through cavity design is therefore the more direct route for achieving smaller intrinsic linewidth, since it simultaneously lowers the Purcell floor as 4g02/κ4g_{0}^{2}/\kappa, improves cavity pulling suppression as γeff/(γeff+κ)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}+\kappa), and carries no fundamental lower limit.

Combining an optimized cavity linewidth κ\kappa, improved transverse cooling, and higher atomic flux through the cavity mode, an intrinsic SR linewidth below 10 Hz should be achievable in future realizations of strontium hot beam SR lasers.

Lasing power dependency on cavity detuning. During the cavity-pulling measurement, we observe that the SR output power depends on the cavity detuning (for fixed γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} and NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}). We use this dependence experimentally to identify the optimal cavity-lock operating point. We measure the cavity-detuning-dependent SR output power by recording PP as a function of cavity detuning Δc\Delta_{c} (Ext. Data Fig. 5a). The output power depends on both the cavity transmission and the collective atomic gain. The measured profile is described phenomenologically by

P(Δc)=P0−a(Δc−Δ0)2,FWHMeff=2P0a,(29)P(\Delta_{c}) = P_{0} - a\left(\Delta_{c}-\Delta_{0}\right)^{2}, \qquad\mathrm{FWHM}_{\mathrm{eff}} = \sqrt{\frac{2P_{0}}{a}}, \tag*{(29)}

where the fit is used only over the measured range with P(Δc)>0P(\Delta_{c}) > 0. The centre of the parabolic fit defines the optimal operating point for the cavity lock. The effective FWHM of the measured power profile is FWHMeff=11.40(2)\mathrm{FWHM}_{\mathrm{eff}} = 11.40(2) MHz, broader than the intensity FWHM of the bare cavity transmission, κ/2π=6.79(2)\kappa/2\pi= 6.79(2) MHz. We further examine this broadening using the cavity-detuning-dependent critical atom number for lasing obtained from our simple analytical model, which is also used for the linewidth estimate,

Ncrit(Δc)=γeffg02κ(2Δc2(1−ρ)2+κ22).(30)N_{\mathrm{crit}}(\Delta_{c}) = \frac{\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}}{g_{0}^{2}\kappa}\left(2\Delta_{c}^{2}(1-\rho)^{2}+\frac{\kappa^{2}}{2}\right). \tag*{(30)}

The SR output vanishes when NSR<Ncrit(Δc)N_{\mathrm{SR}} < N_{\mathrm{crit}}(\Delta_{c}). For NSR=1.5×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 1.5 \times10^{5}, γeff=2π×1.47(4)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} = 2\pi\times1.47(4) MHz, and ρ=0.165\rho= 0.165, Eq. (30) predicts a threshold detuning of Δcth=2π×6.96(10)\Delta_{c}^{\mathrm{th}} = 2\pi\times6.96(10) MHz, below the measured value of 2π×8.06(1)2\pi\times8.06(1) MHz. At this relatively small effective broadening, the observed lasing range is therefore wider than predicted by the simplified model. We believe this discrepancy can be explained by the systematically lower atom-number threshold observed in Figure 1, as well as by atom-number fluctuations that broaden the measured detuning-dependent power envelope. Whether a comparable discrepancy persists at larger γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} remains to be investigated.

Long-term stability, systematic frequency shifts. In an ideal superradiant laser the emission frequency is set by the atomic transition, as cavity pulling is negligible (κ≫γeff\kappa\gg\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}), and the fundamental stability limit is imposed by phase diffusion.

Extended Data Figure 5. Frequency-shift characterization of the superradiant laser. (a) SR output power as a function of cavity detuning Δc\Delta_{\mathrm{c}} (blue points). The dashed red curve is a parabolic fit Eq. (29), yielding a peak power of 31.5(1) nW and an effective FWHM of 11.40(2) MHz. The solid black curve shows the bare cavity transmission, with a FWHM of κ/2π=6.79(2)\kappa/2\pi= 6.79(2) MHz, for comparison. (b) Superradiant emission frequency ΔfSR\Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}} as a function of intracavity atom number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}, measured via heterodyne beat detection against the Spec laser. The red dashed line is a linear fit, fSR=χNSR+bf_{\mathrm{SR}} = \chi N_{\mathrm{SR}} + b, yielding χ=−0.116(6)\chi= -0.116(6) Hz/atom. (c) SR frequency ΔfSR\Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}} as a function of the average intracavity intensity ⟨I⟩r<w0\langle I\rangle_{r<w_0} of the TEM02_{02} cavity-lock light, measured via heterodyne beat detection against the Spec laser. The red dashed line is a linear fit, ΔfSR=α⟨I⟩+offset\Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}} = \alpha\langle I\rangle+ \mathrm{offset}, yielding an effective lock-power-to-SR-frequency coefficient α=97(19)\alpha= 97(19) Hz (mW/cm2^2)−1^{-1}. Inset: TEM02_{02} intensity profile. The dashed circle indicates the TEM00_{00} mode area, r<w0=87 μr < w_0 = 87\ \mum. Stars indicate data taken at our reference operating point. Error bars: (a), as in Figure 1d; (b, c), as in Figure 2.

Newly arriving excited state atoms add quantum noise to the phase of the collective atomic dipole while they synchronize with it. In the regime where this diffusion dominates, this leads to a random walk of the SR laser phase [35, 70]

Sνphase=ΔνSRπ.(31)S_{\nu}^{\mathrm{phase}} = \frac{\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{SR}}}{\pi}. \tag*{(31)}

The white frequency modulation noise gives an Allan deviation scaling [70] of τ−1/2\tau^{-1/2}:

σyphase(τ)=Sνphase2ν02τ=12πν0γSRPurcellτ≈8.0×10−15τ/s.(32)\sigma_y^{\mathrm{phase}}(\tau) = \sqrt{\frac{S_{\nu}^{\mathrm{phase}}}{2\nu_0^2\tau}} = \frac{1}{2\pi\nu_0}\sqrt{\frac{\gamma_{\mathrm{SR}}^{\mathrm{Purcell}}}{\tau}} \approx\frac{8.0\times10^{-15}}{\sqrt{\tau/\mathrm{s}}}. \tag*{(32)}

The measured instability in the self-locked case (where the long-term stability is defined by the atomic transition), σy(τ)=2.0(1)×10−12(τ/s)−0.29(5)\sigma_y(\tau) = 2.0(1)\times10^{-12}(\tau/\mathrm{s})^{-0.29(5)} (Figure 3), lies more than two orders of magnitude above the Purcell limit at τ=1\tau= 1 s, indicating that technical noise sources dominate the stability at all measured timescales. The Allan deviation data reveal three distinct regimes, classified according to the noise spectra of Ref. 70. At short timescales τ≲50\tau\lesssim50 ms, the SR laser operates free-running above the cavity PDH lock bandwidth, and the upper bound on the intrinsic linewidth is Δνmeas=320(40)\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{meas}} = 320(40) Hz. The β\beta-separation linewidth Γβ,self=2720(82)\Gamma_{\beta,\mathrm{self}} = 2720(82) Hz integrates the frequency noise PSD above ∼10\sim10 Hz and captures the additional contribution from the SR cavity PDH lock (Ext. Data Fig. 3c). The ratio Γβ,self/ν0≈6×10−12\Gamma_{\beta,\mathrm{self}}/\nu_0 \approx6\times10^{-12} is consistent in order of magnitude with the observed σy(1 s)=2.0×10−12\sigma_y(1\ \mathrm{s}) = 2.0\times10^{-12}, indicating that the 1 s instability is set by the PDH lock noise rather than by phase diffusion. At the intermediate timescales 0.05 s≲τ≲4 s0.05\ \mathrm{s} \lesssim\tau\lesssim4\ \mathrm{s}, the instability is dominated by the residual SR PDH lock noise and shot-to-shot atom-number fluctuations, both of which contribute independently (Figure 3b). The

peak at τ≈0.2\tau\approx0.2 s is the servo bump arising from the PDH lock corner frequency of ∼2.5\sim2.5 Hz. At longer timescales τ≳4\tau\gtrsim4 s, the slope flattens towards the observed τ−0.29\tau^{-0.29}, consistent with flicker FM noise [70], which could be attributed to slow drifts of the atom number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} due to intensity fluctuations in the state preparation and cooling beams, and to the lock-laser intensity ⟨I⟩\langle I\rangle drift, neither of which is actively power stabilized. The overall fit exponent τ−0.29\tau^{-0.29} over the full range 0.2 s to 400 s reflects the mixture of these white FM and flicker FM contributions and does not correspond to a single noise process.

Atom-number–dependent frequency shift. We observe that the SR laser frequency depends on the intracavity atom number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} (Ext. Data Fig. 5b), and therefore atom number fluctuations lead to frequency fluctuations. A simplified analytical model, which neglects Doppler broadening and does not include the full cavity-detuning dependence, predicts an atom-number-dependent cavity-pulling factor

ρ(NSR)=11+ΓcollκτT2/32,(33)\rho(N_{\mathrm{SR}}) = \frac{1}{1+\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}\kappa\tau_T^2/32}, \tag*{(33)}

where Γcoll=2g02NSR/κ\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}} = 2g_0^2N_{\mathrm{SR}}/\kappa is the collectively enhanced emission rate and τT\tau_T is the transit time. The atom number dependence of the pulling factor leads to frequency fluctuations if the cavity is detuned from resonance. However, our analytical model neglects Doppler-broadening and other effects and therefore we cannot uniquely assign the measured dependence to this mechanism. A detailed microscopic description is left for future work. Experimentally, we observe an approximately linear dependence,

ΔfSR=χNSR,(34)\Delta f_{\mathrm{SR}} = \chi N_{\mathrm{SR}}, \tag*{(34)}

with χ=−0.116(6)\chi= -0.116(6) Hz/atom. Small variations of the fitted slope are observed between Δf(NSR)\Delta f(N_{\mathrm{SR}}) scans measured days apart. These variations might originate from residual changes in the cavity detuning. As an example, at our reference operating point of NSR=1.53×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 1.53 \times10^5 atoms a 5% atom-number fluctuation corresponds to ΔNSR=7 650\Delta N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 7\,650, leading to a frequency shift of 890(50)890(50) Hz. Here, the uncertainty includes the scatter of the measured frequency dependence beyond the statistical uncertainty of the linear fit.

Lock-light-intensity-dependent frequency shift. Another important contribution to the long-term frequency stability is the dependence of the SR laser frequency on the cavity-lock-light intensity. The cavity resonance frequency is stabilized using a PDH locking scheme. The lock light, with frequency ωlock\omega_{\mathrm{lock}}, is red detuned by 2650 MHz from the 1S0→3P1{}^{1}S_{0} \rightarrow{}^{3}P_{1} transition to avoid directly driving the SR transition. However, this detuning is not at a magic wavelength, so the lock laser induces a light shift that must be characterized and ideally controlled. Additionally, we expect that a change in intensity on the PDH photodiode could shift the lock point. The lock light is coupled into a TEM02_{02} cavity mode, which has a convenient detuning for cavity locking and reduced spatial overlap with the TEM00_{00} SR mode. This reduces the light shift experienced by the atoms. We further reduce the light shift by using less than 1 μ\muW of lock power before the cavity.

The lock laser has linear polarization orthogonal to the quantization axis, which is defined by the magnetic field B (Ext. Data Fig. 1). The intracavity power is related to the power before the cavity by

Pintra=ηcavηcoupFπPexp,(35)P_{\mathrm{intra}} = \eta_{\mathrm{cav}}\eta_{\mathrm{coup}}\frac{F}{\pi}P_{\mathrm{exp}}, \tag*{(35)}

where F=828F = 828 is the cavity finesse, ηcav=0.50\eta_{\mathrm{cav}} = 0.50 is the estimated transmission of optical elements between the last accessible point in the beam path at which PexpP_{\mathrm{exp}} is measured and the cavity, and ηcoup=0.25\eta_{\mathrm{coup}} = 0.25 is the coupling efficiency into the cavity mode. We define the effective lock-light intensity as the uniform spatial average of the TEM02_{02} intracavity intensity over the circular area r<w0r < w_0 corresponding to the TEM00_{00} waist. It is given by

⟨I⟩r<w0=2PintraI‾norm,(36)\langle I\rangle_{r<w_0} = 2P_{\mathrm{intra}}\overline{I}_{\mathrm{norm}}, \tag*{(36)}

where I‾norm\overline{I}_{\mathrm{norm}} is the transverse intensity prefactor obtained by averaging the normalized TEM02_{02} mode profile over the disk r<w0r < w_0, with w0=87 μw_0 = 87\,\mum. The factor of two accounts for the longitudinally averaged standing-wave intensity in the linear cavity, relative to the circulating travelling-wave power PintraP_{\mathrm{intra}}.

For equal intracavity powers, this spatial average is reduced by 68% for the TEM02_{02} mode compared to the TEM00_{00} mode assuming perfect longitudinal overlap. The light shift of the SR frequency is therefore expected to be linear in the lock-light intensity,

Δfshift=−Δα(ωlock)⋅⟨I⟩r<w0,(37)\Delta f_{\mathrm{shift}} = -\Delta\alpha(\omega_{\mathrm{lock}})\cdot\langle I\rangle_{r<w_0}, \tag*{(37)}

where Δα(ωlock)\Delta\alpha(\omega_{\mathrm{lock}}) is the differential polarizability of the lasing states at the lock-laser frequency, accounting for the linear polarization orthogonal to the quantization axis,

Δα(ωlock)=α1S0(ωlock)−α3P1,mJ=0(ωlock).(38)\Delta\alpha(\omega_{\mathrm{lock}}) = \alpha_{{}^{1}S_{0}}(\omega_{\mathrm{lock}}) - \alpha_{{}^{3}P_{1},m_J=0}(\omega_{\mathrm{lock}}). \tag*{(38)}

Using α1S0(ωlock)=−0.95212\alpha_{{}^{1}S_{0}}(\omega_{\mathrm{lock}}) = -0.95212 Hz/(mW/cm2^2) and α3P1,mJ=0(ωlock)=0.6798\alpha_{{}^{3}P_{1},m_J=0}(\omega_{\mathrm{lock}}) = 0.6798 Hz/(mW/cm2^2) gives Δα(ωlock)=−1.6319\Delta\alpha(\omega_{\mathrm{lock}}) = -1.6319 Hz/(mW/cm2^2) and hence a predicted positive transition-frequency shift of 1.6319 Hz/(mW/cm2^2) ((Ref. 71)).

We measure the lock-light-induced frequency shift for several lock light powers using the SR-Spec beat signal, which delivers ∼5\sim5 kHz precision (Ext. Data Fig. 5). When interpreting these data, note that changes in lock power also affect the PDH error-signal amplitude. In particular, at low powers the photodiode dark current contribution becomes significant and can shift the lock point. We therefore measure an effective lock-power-to-SR-frequency coefficient rather than the pure atomic light-shift coefficient. A linear fit yields

α=97(19) Hz (mW cm−2)−1,χred2=22.69.(39)\alpha= 97(19)\ \mathrm{Hz}\,(\mathrm{mW\,cm}^{-2})^{-1},\qquad\chi^2_{\mathrm{red}} = 22.69. \tag*{(39)}

The calculated atomic light shift amounts to ∼2%\sim2\% of α\alpha, indicating that technical lock-point shifts dominate the observed dependence. At low intensities, ⟨I⟩<100\langle I\rangle< 100 mW/cm2^2, where technical contributions are stronger, the fit describes the data poorly. At the operating point, ⟨I⟩≈190\langle I\rangle\approx190 mW/cm2^2, the data follow an approximately linear trend. For slow, quasi-static ±5%\pm5\% fluctuations of the lock-light intensity around the operating point, the corresponding frequency instability is

σf(I)=α⋅0.05⟨I⟩op=920(180) Hz,(40)\sigma_f^{(I)} = \alpha\cdot0.05\langle I\rangle^{\mathrm{op}} = 920(180)\ \mathrm{Hz}, \tag*{(40)}

corresponding to a fractional frequency instability of σy≈2×10−12\sigma_y \approx2 \times10^{-12} on time scales of minutes. This contribution is comparable to the atom-number-dependent frequency shift of 890(50) Hz from the previous subsection. Both contributions, atom-number and lock-light intensity fluctuations, can explain major parts of the observed long-term frequency stability.

The two frequency-shift mechanisms are summarized in Ext. Data Table I. Both contributions scale approximately linearly with their respective control parameters, NSRN_{\rm SR} and ⟨I⟩\langle I\rangle, around the operating point. In principle, they can be reduced through improved stabilization: the atom number through cooling-beam power stabilization and more accurate centring of the cavity resonance to the SR output frequency, and the lock light through intensity feedback control. A cavity with higher finesse at a magic frequency for the locking light would reduce the lock-light intensity shift to negligible levels.

SourceMechanismCoefficientσf\sigma_f (Hz)
Atom number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}Atom-number-dependent frequency shift−0.116(6)-0.116(6) Hz/atom890(50)890(50)
Lock-laser intensityEffective lock-power-induced frequency shift97(19)97(19) Hz/(mW/cm2^2)920(180)920(180)

Table I. Dominant frequency-shift contributions at the reference operating point (NSR=1.53(2)×105N_{\mathrm{SR}} = 1.53(2) \times10^5, γeff/(2π)=1.47(4)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi) = 1.47(4) MHz). σf\sigma_f is the estimated frequency instability from a ±5%\pm5\% fluctuation of the respective control parameter. The lock-light-induced shift is independent of the atom number and is evaluated around ⟨I⟩≈190\langle I\rangle\approx190 mW/cm2^2.

Frequency noise characterization. The frequency noise PSD Sν(f)S_{\nu}(f) is computed from the ULE-SR beat signal recorded over 1 s on a digital oscilloscope (R&S MXO44) via a Hilbert transform of the bandpass-filtered beat waveform, using Welch’s method (nseg=8n_{\rm seg}=8, Hann window, 50% overlap). The dominant noise contribution arises from the finite SNR of the cavity length PDH lock (SNR ≈500\approx500–10001000). In combination with the inverse cavity-pulling suppression factor 1/ρ≈61/\rho\approx6 (γeff/2π=1.47(4)\gamma_{\rm eff}/2\pi=1.47(4) MHz, ρ=0.165(3)\rho=0.165(3)), this limits the SR frequency noise to

ΔνSR∼κρSNR=6.79 MHz500×6≈2.3 kHz,(41)\Delta\nu_{\rm SR}\sim\frac{\kappa\rho}{\mathrm{SNR}}=\frac{6.79\ \mathrm{MHz}}{500\times6}\approx2.3\ \mathrm{kHz}, \tag*{(41)}

consistent with the β\beta-separation linewidth [58]

Δνβ=8ln⁡2∫Sν>βfSν df,β=8ln⁡2π2≈0.56,(42)\Delta\nu_{\beta}=\sqrt{8\ln2\int_{S_{\nu}>\beta f}S_{\nu}\,\mathrm{d}f},\qquad\beta=\frac{8\ln2}{\pi^2}\approx0.56, \tag*{(42)}

yielding ΔνβULE=2172(70)\Delta\nu_{\beta}^{\rm ULE}=2172(70) Hz under direct ULE laser lock of the SR cavity length and Δνβself=2720(82)\Delta\nu_{\beta}^{\rm self}=2720(82) Hz under self-lock (Ext. Data Fig. 3c). Uncertainties are estimated by bootstrapping over n=200n=200 Welch-segment resamples. The approximately 550 Hz increase under self-lock is consistent with residual ringing from the finite cavity-pulling suppression: the feedback loop has an effective gain of ρ=0.165(3)\rho=0.165(3) at the SR output, adding a noise contribution of order ρΔνβULE≈360\rho\Delta\nu_{\beta}^{\rm ULE}\approx360 Hz.

In summary, we note that Δνmeas\Delta\nu_{\rm meas} and Δνβ\Delta\nu_{\beta} characterize complementary aspects of the emission: Δνβ=2172(70)\Delta\nu_{\beta}=2172(70) Hz is extracted from the full frequency noise PSD over 1 s and reflects the laser as seen by an external user including all technical noise contributions as cavity lock-induced noise, whereas Δνmeas=320(40)\Delta\nu_{\rm meas}=320(40) Hz is extracted at T=11T=11 ms, below the lock bandwidth, and reflects an upper bound of the intrinsic SR emission linewidth. Reducing the cavity locking light linewidth to ≲50\lesssim50 kHz at similar SNR would bring ΔνSR\Delta\nu_{\rm SR} to the sub-100 Hz level, at which point the lock would no longer be limiting.

Analysis of Amplitude Modulations

In this section, we first discuss the experimentally extracted parameters and then describe the theoretical microscopic model used for comparison with the experimental data.

Single-frequency to multi-component lasing. We first discuss the atom number scan with fixed γeff≈4.5\gamma_{\rm eff}\approx4.5 MHz (see Figure 4c and Figure 4d). The emission threshold is extracted from the mean output power ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle shown in Ext. Data Fig. 4b. Above threshold, ⟨P⟩\langle P\rangle scales approximately linearly with NSRN_{\rm SR} [Eq. (19)], and the threshold atom number NcritN_{\rm crit} is determined as the zero crossing of a weighted linear fit to P(N)P(N), yielding Ncritexp=1.13(1)×105N_{\rm crit}^{\rm exp}=1.13(1)\times10^5, which is in good agreement with the theoretical prediction Ncrittheo=1.18×105N_{\rm crit}^{\rm theo}=1.18\times10^5 (grey dashed line in Figure 4c,Figure 4d and Ext. Data Fig. 4b).

The emergence of coherent amplitude oscillations is identified as the lowest scan point at which sidebands are clearly resolved above the noise floor in either the beat-note spectrum or the intensity noise PSD. Both observables yield consistent results. The uncertainty on the boundary is taken as the step size between adjacent scan points: Δγeff/(2π)=0.1\Delta\gamma_{\rm eff}/(2\pi)=0.1 MHz for the γeff\gamma_{\rm eff} scan and around ΔNSR=5000\Delta N_{\rm SR}=5000 atoms for the NSRN_{\rm SR} scan at the given transition point. This gives γeffMCSR/(2π)=1.8(1)\gamma_{\rm eff}^{\rm MCSR}/(2\pi)=1.8(1) MHz (Figure 4a, vertical red dash-dotted line) and NSRMCSR=1.24(5)×105N_{\rm SR}^{\rm MCSR}=1.24(5)\times10^5 (Figure 4c, vertical red dash-dotted line).

The amplitude modulation frequency fmodf_{\rm mod} is extracted in two different ways. First, using the intensity noise PSD spectrum itself, where the DC component is removed, and second, using the frequency beat spectrum, where the carrier frequency fcarrierf_{\rm carrier} and each sideband frequency fsidebandf_{\rm sideband} are fitted independently (using a Lorentzian distribution). The modulation frequency is fmod=∣fsideband−fcarrier∣f_{\rm mod}=|f_{\rm sideband}-f_{\rm carrier}|, with the uncertainty propagated from the individual fit errors. From the intensity PSD, fmodf_{\rm mod} is extracted directly as the peak frequency of a Lorentzian fit to the intensity noise PSD spectrum.

The two methods yield consistent values within their respective uncertainties, which is a non-trivial result: a pure phase modulation of the SR field would produce sidebands in the beat spectrum but leave the intensity noise PSD unaffected. The agreement between the two observables therefore directly confirms that our observation is driven by an oscillation of the collective dipole amplitude.

For the γD\gamma_{\rm D} scan (Figure 4a, b and Ext. Data Fig. 4a), at the well-resolved operating point γeff/(2π)=3.0\gamma_{\rm eff}/(2\pi)=3.0 MHz, NSR=1.57×105N_{\rm SR}=1.57\times10^5, the beat spectrum yields fmod,1beat=0.94(4)f_{{\rm mod},1}^{\rm beat}=0.94(4) MHz and fmod,2beat=1.86(4)f_{{\rm mod},2}^{\rm beat}=1.86(4) MHz, and the intensity PSD yields fmod,1PSD=0.93(3)f_{{\rm mod},1}^{\rm PSD}=0.93(3) MHz and fmod,2PSD=1.86(3)f_{{\rm mod},2}^{\rm PSD}=1.86(3) MHz. Both are in agreement with the theoretical predictions fmod,1theo=0.93(1)f_{{\rm mod},1}^{\rm theo}=0.93(1) MHz for this operating point. We note that in the beat spectrum an additional feature is visible on the negative-frequency side at approximately −fmod,2-f_{{\rm mod},2}, which we attribute to a beat with a spurious sideband of the ULE reference laser or to a background artefact; this feature is absent on the positive-frequency side and has no counterpart in the intensity noise PSD, confirming it is not of SR origin.

For the NSRN_{\rm SR} scan at γeff/(2π)=4.5\gamma_{\rm eff}/(2\pi)=4.5 MHz and NSR=1.54(5)×105N_{\rm SR}=1.54(5)\times10^5, the beat spectrum yields fmod,1beat=0.70(3)f_{{\rm mod},1}^{\rm beat}=0.70(3) MHz and the intensity PSD yields fmod,1PSD=0.71(2)f_{{\rm mod},1}^{\rm PSD}=0.71(2) MHz, both close to the theoretical prediction fmodtheo=0.53(1)f_{{\rm mod}}^{\rm theo}=0.53(1) MHz. The lower modulation frequency compared to the γeff\gamma_{\rm eff} scan reflects the lower gain above threshold.

Theoretical Modelling. We describe superradiant lasing from an atomic beam using the microscopic model developed in Refs. [13, 33]. The dynamics of the semiclassical cavity field α\alpha and the spin densities s(x,p,t)=∑jsjδ(x−xj)δ(p−pj)\mathbf{s}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{p},t)=\sum_j\mathbf{s}_j\delta(\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x}_j)\delta(\mathbf{p}-\mathbf{p}_j) and sz(x,p,t)=∑jsjzδ(x−xj)δ(p−pj)s^z(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{p},t)=\sum_j s_j^z\delta(\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x}_j)\delta(\mathbf{p}-\mathbf{p}_j), where sj\mathbf{s}_j and sjzs_j^z represent the corresponding operators σ^j\hat{\boldsymbol{\sigma}}_j and σ^jz\hat{\sigma}_j^z within a discrete truncated Wigner sampling, are governed by the stochastic differential equations [33, 62]

dαdt=−κ2α−ig0J+κF(t),(43)\frac{d\alpha}{dt}=-\frac{\kappa}{2}\alpha-ig_0J+\sqrt{\kappa}\mathcal{F}(t), \tag*{(43)}
∂s∂t=−pm⋅∇xs+ig0η(x)szα,(44)\frac{\partial\mathbf{s}}{\partial t}=-\frac{\mathbf{p}}{m}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf{x}}\mathbf{s}+ig_0\eta(\mathbf{x})s^z\alpha, \tag*{(44)}
∂sz∂t=−pm⋅∇xsz+i2g0η(x)(α∗s−s∗α).(45)\frac{\partial s^z}{\partial t}=-\frac{\mathbf{p}}{m}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf{x}}s^z+ i2g_0\eta(\mathbf{x})\left(\alpha^*\mathbf{s}-\mathbf{s}^*\alpha\right). \tag*{(45)}

We use an effective two-dimensional geometry, with zz along the cavity axis and xx along the atomic beam. The cavity mode function is

η(x)=cos⁡(kz)e−x2/w2.(46)\eta(\mathbf{x})=\cos(kz)e^{-x^2/w^2}. \tag*{(46)}

The collective dipole is given by J=∫dx∫dp η(x)s(x,p,t)J=\int d\mathbf{x}\int d\mathbf{p}\,\eta(\mathbf{x})\mathbf{s}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{p},t). We introduced the notation ∇x=(∂x,∂z)T\nabla_{\mathbf{x}}=(\partial_x,\partial_z)^{\mathsf{T}}. The boundary conditions at the entrance plane x0=(x0,z0)\mathbf{x}_0=(x_0,z_0), with x0→−∞x_0\to-\infty, are s(x0,p)=s0(x0,p)=∑jsj(0)δ(x−xj)δ(p−pj)\mathbf{s}(\mathbf{x}_0,\mathbf{p})=\mathbf{s}_0(\mathbf{x}_0,\mathbf{p})=\sum_j\mathbf{s}_j^{(0)}\delta(x-x_j)\delta(\mathbf{p}-\mathbf{p}_j), and sz(x0,p)=∑jsjz,(0)δ(x−xj)δ(p−pj)=s0z(p)s^z(\mathbf{x}_0,\mathbf{p})=\sum_j s_j^{z,(0)}\delta(x-x_j)\delta(\mathbf{p}-\mathbf{p}_j)=s_0^z(\mathbf{p}). The atoms enter in the excited state, sjz,(0)=1s_j^{z,(0)}=1, with sj(0)=(sx,j(0)−isy,j(0))/2\mathbf{s}_j^{(0)}=(s_{x,j}^{(0)}-is_{y,j}^{(0)})/2, where sx,j(0)s_{x,j}^{(0)} and sy,j(0)s_{y,j}^{(0)} are independently sampled from ±1\pm1. Cavity shot noise is included through F=(Fx−iFy)/2\mathcal{F}=(\mathcal{F}^x-i\mathcal{F}^y)/2, where Fx\mathcal{F}^x and Fy\mathcal{F}^y are independent zero-mean noise sources satisfying ⟨Fx(t)Fx(t′)⟩=⟨Fy(t)Fy(t′)⟩=δ(t−t′)\langle\mathcal{F}^x(t)\mathcal{F}^x(t')\rangle=\langle\mathcal{F}^y(t)\mathcal{F}^y(t')\rangle=\delta(t-t').

We assume the incoming atomic distribution to be spatially homogeneous, which is valid when the transverse beam width is much larger than the wavelength of the mode function. We can therefore restrict the spatial integration to one cavity wavelength, ∫dx=∫0λdz∫−∞∞dx\int d\mathbf{x}=\int_0^\lambda dz\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dx and the momentum integration is ∫dp=∫−∞∞dpx∫−∞∞dpz\int d\mathbf{p}=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dp_x\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dp_z. The initial longitudinal spin density is modelled as

s0z(p)=2πNSRfx(px/m)fz(pz/m)wλm2.(47)s_0^z(\mathbf{p})=\sqrt{\frac{2}{\pi}}\frac{N_{\mathrm{SR}}f_x(p_x/m)f_z(p_z/m)}{w\lambda m^2}. \tag*{(47)}

Normalization is chosen such that the mean squared collective coupling matches with NSRg02/2N_{\mathrm{SR}}g_0^2/2,

NSRg022=∫dx∫dp g02η2(x)s0z(p).(48)\frac{N_{\mathrm{SR}}g_0^2}{2}=\int d\mathbf{x}\int d\mathbf{p}\,g_0^2\eta^2(\mathbf{x})s_0^z(\mathbf{p}). \tag*{(48)}

Here, fxf_x and fzf_z are normalized velocity distributions along the xx and zz directions. Along the beam axis, we use

fx(vx)=βxmvxe−βxmvx2/2,(49)f_x(v_x)=\beta_xmv_xe^{-\beta_xmv_x^2/2}, \tag*{(49)}

which gives vˉx=π/(2mβx)≈345 m/s\bar{v}_x=\sqrt{\pi/(2m\beta_x)}\approx345\ \mathrm{m/s}. The transverse velocity distribution is taken to be Lorentzian,

fz(vz)=Δvz2π1vz2+Δvz2/4,(50)f_z(v_z)=\frac{\Delta v_z}{2\pi}\frac{1}{v_z^2+\Delta v_z^2/4}, \tag*{(50)}

corresponding to a Doppler broadening γD=kΔvz\gamma_D=k\Delta v_z. The total effective broadening is then calculated with γeff=γD+2π×360 kHz+2π×7.48 kHz\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}=\gamma_D+2\pi\times360\ \mathrm{kHz}+2\pi\times7.48\ \mathrm{kHz}.

Numerical simulation of the intensity modulation

We numerically integrate the coupled stochastic equations (43)–(45) and obtain stochastic trajectories of the intracavity photon number,

Nν(t)=∣α(t)∣2.(51)N_\nu(t)=|\alpha(t)|^2. \tag*{(51)}

The total simulation time is T=250 μsT=250\ \mu\mathrm{s}. To characterize the intensity fluctuations, we calculate the Fourier transform of the photon-number fluctuations,

N~ν(ω)=∫0Tdt eiωt[Nν(t)−Nˉν],(52)\tilde{N}_\nu(\omega)=\int_0^T dt\,e^{i\omega t}\left[N_\nu(t)-\bar{N}_\nu\right], \tag*{(52)}

where Nˉν=1T∫0Tdt Nν(t)\bar{N}_\nu=\frac{1}{T}\int_0^Tdt\,N_\nu(t) is the time-averaged photon number.

The results of N~\tilde{N} obtained from the numerical simulations are visible in Ext. Data Fig. 6. In the simulation, following the experimental setting shown in Figure 4 in the main text, we vary γD\gamma_D and fix NSR=1.57×105N_{\mathrm{SR}}=1.57\times10^5 (Ext. Data Fig. 6a) and we fix γD/(2π)=4.1 MHz\gamma_D/(2\pi)=4.1\ \mathrm{MHz} and vary NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}} (Ext. Data Fig. 6b). In addition, we fit to the numerical data a Gaussian model to extract the dominant frequency contribution. The result of this fitting procedure is displayed as solid lines in Figure 4 and Ext. Data Fig. 6. These lines represent only the dominant amplitude oscillation frequency which is the first harmonic.

Extended Data Figure 6. Extended Data Fig. 6. Theoretical modelling of the amplitude oscillations. Absolute value of the Fourier transform N~ν(ω)\tilde{N}_\nu(\omega) [Eq. (52)] as a function of frequency fmod=ω/(2π)f_{\mathrm{mod}}=\omega/(2\pi) and for (a) varied γeff\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} and (b) varied atom number NSRN_{\mathrm{SR}}. The remaining simulation parameter for (a) is NSR=1.57×105N_{\mathrm{SR}}=1.57\times10^5 and for (b) γD/(2π)=4.1 MHz\gamma_D/(2\pi)=4.1\ \mathrm{MHz}, resulting in γeff/(2π)≈4.5 MHz\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}/(2\pi)\approx4.5\ \mathrm{MHz}. The solid lines in (a) and (b) mark the frequency peaks of a Gaussian fit to N~\tilde{N}. The same solid lines are shown in Figure 4a,Figure 4c.

Since the underlying microscopic theory is nonlinear in the cavity field, it generally also predicts all higher harmonics. These are, however, progressively suppressed with increasing order and therefore not resolved in the stochastic simulations because of the limited signal-to-noise ratio.

References

References

  1. [1]T. M. Fortier, A. N. Luiten, and H. S. Margolis, Optica 13, 143 (2026).
  2. [2]A. Aeppli, W. J. Arthur-Dworschack, K. Beloy, C. M. Berry, T. Bothwell, A. Folz, T. M. Fortier, T. Grogan, Y. S. Hassan, Z. Z. Hu, D. B. Hume, B. D. Hunt, K. Kim, A. Koepke, D. Lee, D. R. Leibbrandt, B. Lewis, A. D. Ludlow, M. C. Marshall, N. V. Nardelli, H. Ranganath, D. A. R. Castillo, J. A. Sherman, J. L. Siegel, S. Thornton, W. Warfield, and J. Ye (BACON Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 033201 (2026).
  3. [3]X.-Y. Liu, P. Liu, J. Li, Y.-C. Zhang, Y.-B. Wang, Z.-P. Jia, X. Zhang, X.-Q. Zhu, D.-Q. Kong, W.-L. Song, G.-Z. Niu, Y.-M. Yang, P.-J. Feng, X.-P. Liu, X.-Y. Cui, P. Xu, X. Jiang, J. Yin, S.-K. Liao, C.-Z. Peng, H.-N. Dai, Y.-A. Chen, and J.-W. Pan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 263402 (2025).
  4. [4]K. J. Arnold, M. D. K. Lee, Q. Zhao, Q. Qin, Z. Zhang, N. Jayjong, and M. D. Barrett, Nature 658, 60 (2026).
  5. [10]T. E. Mehlstäubler, G. Grosche, C. Lisdat, P. O. Schmidt, and H. Denker, Rep. Prog. Phys. 81, 064401 (2018).
  6. [11]D. Meiser, J. Ye, D. R. Carlson, and M. J. Holland, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 163601 (2009).
  7. [12]J. Chen, Chinese Science Bulletin 54, 348 (2009).
  8. [13]H. Liu, S. B. Jäger, X. Yu, S. Touzard, A. Shankar, M. J. Holland, and T. L. Nicholson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 253602 (2020).
  9. [14]J. G. Bohnet, Z. Chen, J. M. Weiner, D. Meiser, M. J. Holland, and J. K. Thompson, Nature 484, 78 (2012).
  10. [15]M. A. Norcia, M. N. Winchester, J. R. K. Cline, and J. K. Thompson, Sci. Adv. 2, e1601231 (2016).
  11. [16]S. A. Schäffer, M. Tang, M. R. Henriksen, A. A. Jørgensen, B. T. R. Christensen, and J. W. Thomsen, Phys. Rev. A 101, 013819 (2020).
  12. [17]T. Laske, H. Winter, and A. Hemmerich, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 103601 (2019).
  13. [18]M. A. Norcia and J. K. Thompson, Phys. Rev. X 6, 011025 (2016).
  14. [19]S. L. Kristensen, E. Bohr, J. Robinson-Tait, T. Zelevinsky, J. W. Thomsen, and J. H. Müller, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 223402 (2023).
  15. [20]A. L. Parke, E. Clulow, W. Huang, N. Kaur, R. Karembera, J.-O. Gaudron, X. Zhang, M. Risaro, J. Tunesi, H. Bourne, and M. Schioppo, Optica 13, 1190 (2026).
  16. [21]D. Lee, Z. Z. Hu, B. Lewis, A. Aeppli, K. Kim, Z. Yao, T. Legero, D. Nicolodi, F. Riehle, U. Stern, and J. Ye, Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 033801 (2026).
  17. [22]J. L. Dai, T. Liu, Y. Cai, Z. Chen, and Q. Li, Front. Phys. 10, 995361 (2022).
  18. [23]A. L. Schawlow and C. H. Townes, Phys. Rev. 112, 1940 (1958).
  19. [24]S. J. M. Kuppens, M. P. Van Exter, and J. P. Woerdman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 3815 (1994).
  20. [25]M. P. Van Exter, S. J. M. Kuppens, and J. P. Woerdman, Phys. Rev. A 51, 809 (1995).
  21. [26]J. Zhang, T. Shi, J. Miao, D. Yu, and J. Chen, npj Quantum Inf. 10, 87 (2024).
  22. [27]R. H. Dicke, Phys. Rev. 93, 99 (1954).
  23. [28]G. Ferrioli, A. Gleichenstein, I. Ferrier-Barbut, and A. Browaeys, Nat. Phys. 19, 1345 (2023).
  24. [29]J. Kim, D. Yang, S.-h. Oh, and K. An, Science 359, 662 (2018).
  25. [30]F. Famà, B. Heizenreder, A. Sitaram, C. Beli, R. J. C. Spreeuw, S. A. Schäffer, and F. Schreck, Preprint at arXiv.org 10.48550/ARXIV.2607.28873 (2026).
  26. [31]M. Tang, S. A. Schäffer, and J. H. Müller, Phys. Rev. A 106, 063704 (2022).
  27. [32]W. Riley, NIST Special Publication 1065 NIST Special Publication 1065 (2008).
  28. [33]S. B. Jäger, H. Liu, J. Cooper, T. L. Nicholson, and M. J. Holland, Phys. Rev. A 104, 033711 (2021).
  29. [34]F. Vernotte, C. E. Calosso, and E. Rubiola, in 2016 IEEE International Frequency Control Symposium (IFCS) (IEEE, New Orleans, LA, USA, 2016) pp. 1–6.
  30. [35]G. A. Kazakov, S. Dubey, A. Bychek, U. Sterr, M. Bober, and M. Zawada, Phys. Rev. A 106, 053114 (2022).
  31. [36]N. B. Abraham, L. A. Lugiato, and L. M. Narducci, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 2, 7 (1985).
  32. [37]T. Ogawa, Phys. Rev. A 37, 4286 (1988).
  33. [38]B. Burbathe-Tolra, M. Robert-de Saint-Vincent, and B. Pasquieou, Preprint at arXiv.org 10.48550/arXiv.2606.21675 (2026).
  34. [39]Y. Zhang, C. Shan, and K. Mølmer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 123602 (2021).
  35. [40]B. Sundar, D. Barberenа, A. M. Rey, and A. P. Orioli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 033601 (2024).
  36. [41]J. El Badawi, M. Delehaye, and B. Bellomo, C. R. Phys. 27, 191 (2026).
  37. [42]Y. Zhang, C. Shan, and K. Mølmer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 013604 (2022).
  38. [43]J. T. Reilly, S. B. Jäger, J. Cooper, and M. J. Holland, Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 143803 (2026).
  39. [44]S. Dubey, G. A. Kazakov, B. Heizenreder, S. Zhou, S. Bennetts, S. A. Schäffer, A. Sitaram, F. Schreck, and MoSaiQC Collaboration, Phys. Rev. Research 7, 013292 (2025).
  40. [45]J. R. K. Cline, V. M. Schäfer, Z. Niu, D. J. Young, T. H. Yoon, and J. K. Thompson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 013403 (2025).
  41. [46]T. Parker, S. Jefferts, and T. Heavner, in 2010 IEEE International Frequency Control Symposium (2010) pp. 318–323.
  42. [47]Y. Yi-Xiang, J. Ye, and W.-M. Liu, Sci. Rep. 3, 3476 (2013).
  43. [48]F. Mivehvar, S. Ostermann, F. Piazza, and H. Ritsch, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 123601 (2018).
  44. [49]P. Kirton, M. M. Roses, J. Keeling, and E. G. Dalla Torre, Adv. Quantum Technol. 2, 1800043 (2019).
  45. [50]F. E. Öztürk, T. Lappe, G. Hellmann, J. Schmitt, J. Klaers, F. Vewinger, J. Kroha, and M. Weitz, Science 372, 88 (2021).
  46. [51]R. Poldy, B. C. Buchler, and J. D. Close, Phys. Rev. A 78, 013640 (2008).
  47. [52]R. J. Thompson, G. Rempe, and H. J. Kimble, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 1132 (1992).
  48. [53]M. G. Raizen, R. J. Thompson, R. J. Brecha, H. J. Kimble, and H. J. Carmichael, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 240 (1989).
  49. [54]Y. Zhu, D. J. Gauthier, S. E. Mornin, Q. Wu, H. J. Carmichael, and T. W. Mossberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 2499 (1990).
  50. [55]S. Stellmer, Degenerate Quantum Gases of Strontium, Ph.D. thesis, University of Innsbruck (2013).DOI
  51. [56]C. Qiao, C. Z. Tan, F. C. Hu, L. Couturier, I. Nosske, P. Chen, Y. H. Jiang, B. Zhu, and M. Weidemüller, Appl. Phys. B 125, 215 (2019).
  52. [57]D. R. Leibrandt, M. J. Thorpe, M. Notcutt, R. E. Drullinger, T. Rosenband, and J. C. Bergquist, Opt. Express 19, 3471 (2011).
  53. [58]G. D. Domenico, S. Schilt, and P. Thomann, Appl. Opt. 49, 4801 (2010).
  54. [59]C. Zhou, C. He, S.-T. Yan, Y.-H. Ji, L. Zhou, J. Wang, and M.-S. Zhan, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 91, 033201 (2020).
  55. [60]C. Beli Silva, Cavity-atom interactions in a thermal strontium beam: Development of a simple apparatus for quantum metrology, Ph.D. thesis, University of Amsterdam (2025).
  56. [61]F. Famà, Waltz of the Atoms: Collective Behaviors in a Sr Stream, Ph.D. thesis, University of Amsterdam (2025).
  57. [62]F. Famà, S. Zhou, B. Heizenereder, M. Tang, S. Bennetts, S. B. Jäger, S. A. Schäffer, and F. Schreck, Phys. Rev. A 110, 063721 (2024).
  58. [63]L. Duan, Phys. Rev. A 86, 023817 (2012).
  59. [64]E. Conforti, M. Rodigheri, T. Sutili, and F. J. Galdieri, Opt. Commun. 476, 126286 (2020).
  60. [65]Y. Zhang, C. P. Bandtunga, T. G. McRae, M. A. Gray, and J. H. Chow, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 2889, 012052 (2024).
  61. [66]B. Heizenereder, S. B. Jäger, F. Famà, C. B. Silva, Y. Cui, S. A. Schäffer, A. S. Jataram, and F. Schreck, Continuous superradiant lasing on a narrow optical transition – data repository (2026), data repository.arxiv.org/abs/2611.21386
  62. [70]E. Rubiola and F. Vernotte, IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech. 71, 2996 (2023).

Paper details

vlnc:W_dj9qhzvt
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents