WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Emergence and Persistence of Maximal Atom-Field Entanglement in the Jaynes-Cummings model
Abstract
We investigate the emergence and persistence of maximal entanglement between a two-level atom and a single-mode quantized electromagnetic field inside a cavity, whose dynamics are governed by the Jaynes-Cummings Hamiltonian. Using the von Neumann entropy as a measure of entanglement, we establish a direct connection between entanglement, atomic coherence, and atomic population inversion. This establishment shows that maximal atom-field entanglement is achieved when both the atomic population inversion and the -norm of atomic coherence simultaneously vanish. By considering the atom initially in its excited state, we further demonstrate that the persistence of maximal atom-field entanglement strongly depends on the initial state of the field. For field states whose photon-number distributions have no two consecutive occupied photon-number levels, the local atomic coherence remains zero throughout the evolution. Consequently, complete collapse of the atomic population inversion for an extended period leads to persistent maximal atom-field entanglement. In contrast, for other field states, the interaction generates local atomic coherence, resulting in transient maximal entanglement. Our results demonstrate how the choice of the initial field state controls the temporal characteristics of entanglement in the Jaynes-Cummings system. The generation and persistence of maximal atom-field entanglement in such systems could be valuable for applications in quantum information processing.
Submitted to: Phys. Scr.
Introduction
Quantum entanglement is an interesting phenomenon in which two or more quantum systems become correlated so that the quantum state of each system cannot be described independently [1]. Instead, the composite system must be described by a single joint quantum state, even if the subsystems are separated by a large distance [2]. There are several applications of quantum entanglement, including quantum teleportation [3], quantum dense coding [4], and quantum cryptography [5, 6]. Therefore, the generation and quantification of entanglement have attracted considerable attention in recent years. Several theoretical proposals have been put forward for the generation of entangled states in various physical systems, including cavity-QED systems [7, 8, 9, 10], superconducting systems [11, 12, 13], and optomechanical systems [14]. In cavity QED systems, schemes for high-fidelity generation of entanglement between atoms [15, 16, 17, 18], between cavities [19, 20, 21, 22, 23], and between atoms and cavities [16, 24, 25] have been proposed, and a few of them have been realized experimentally [26, 27, 28, 29]. However, in addition to the generation of entangled states, understanding the mechanisms responsible for the emergence of entanglement and its persistence for a longer period is equally important [30, 31, 32, 33].
In this study, we investigate the emergence of entanglement in an atom-cavity system governed by the Jaynes-Cummings interaction and its persistence during time evolution. The Jaynes-Cummings model describes the interaction between a single-mode quantized field and a two-level atom [34]. Since its introduction, it has become a standard model for understanding the complex interaction between light and matter in quantum optics [35, 36]. It explains many experimentally observed phenomena, such as spontaneous emission [37], vacuum-Rabi splitting [38, 39], photon blockade in a cavity [40], the collapse and revival of atomic population inversion [34, 35, 41, 42], etc., that cannot be explained if we assume the electromagnetic field to be a classical wave. Moreover, the model has been investigated for generating various nonclassical states of light, including Fock states [43, 44, 45, 46, 47], squeezed states [48, 49], Schrödinger-cat states [50], and number-state filtered coherent states [51, 52].
Here, in an atom-field system whose dynamics is governed by the Jaynes-Cummings Hamiltonian [34], we find a direct connection between the dynamics of atomic observables and entanglement generated through the atom–field interaction. This connection shows that the emergence of maximal atom–field entanglement can be understood in terms of the simultaneous vanishing of the atomic population inversion and the local coherence of the atom, specifically the -norm of coherence [53]. Starting with the atom in its excited state, for which the -norm of coherence of the atom is zero, we consider various initial field states for studying the temporal characteristics of entanglement and demonstrate that the persistence of maximal entanglement for a longer duration depends strongly on the initial state of the field. For the field states having a photon-number distribution with no two consecutive photon-number states occupied, the -norm of coherence remains zero throughout the evolution. In such cases, the complete collapse of the atomic population inversion directly leads to maximal atom–field entanglement, which persists over an extended period. In contrast, for other initial field states, the atomic coherence develops during the evolution, and the -norm of coherence becomes non-zero. As a result, maximal entanglement is attained only for a short duration, when both the -norm of coherence and atomic population inversion vanish.
Physical System: The Jaynes-Cummings Model
Consider a two-level atom interacting with a single-mode quantized electromagnetic field inside a cavity. The atom-field interaction can be described by the Jaynes-Cummings Hamiltonian, given by [34, 35, 8, 9, 10]
where is the atomic transition frequency, is the cavity resonance frequency, is the atom–field coupling strength, is the photon annihilation (creation) operator for the field mode, is the atomic energy operator and , are the atomic raising and lowering operators respectively. Under the resonance condition , the energy eigenvalues of the Hamiltonian are with the corresponding eigenvectors .
Let the atom initially be in its excited state , and the field mode be in an arbitrary superposition of Fock states , where is the probability amplitude for the -photon state. These amplitudes can be calculated by expressing the initial field state in the Fock basis. We have provided the Fock basis representation of various field states in the Appendix A.
Under the evolution governed by the Hamiltonian with , the evolved state of the atom-field system at time is [42, 54]
where is the Rabi frequency. For the non-resonant conditions, the evolved state of the atom-field system is given in the Appendix B. Throughout this work, we consider the resonant condition unless the non-resonant condition is explicitly specified.
Atomic coherence
For a two-level atom, the density matrix in the basis is of the form
If , then the state is maximally incoherent [53]. Therefore, the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix represent the coherence between and , which can be quantified by the -norm of coherence. The -norm of coherence of the quantum state is defined as [53]
The density matrix corresponding to the atom-field state is . By taking the partial trace over the field degree of freedom, we get the reduced density matrix for the atom to be [35]
where the matrix elements are
Then, we find the -norm of coherence of the atom to be
Atomic population inversion
The atomic population inversion, defined as the difference between the probabilities of finding the atom in its excited state and ground state, can be calculated for the state given in Eq. (2) as
where is the probability of finding photons in the field state . The atomic population inversion when the atom is in the excited state, whereas when the atom is in the ground state. However, for some field states, for a longer period of time [34, 35, 55, 56], which can be attributed to destructive interference between the cosine terms in Eq. (11). This phenomenon is known as the collapse of atomic population inversion [42].
Emergence of Maximal Atom-field entanglement
To investigate the emergence of maximal entanglement between the two-level atom and the cavity field, we consider the von Neumann entropy [57, 58] to quantify entanglement in the pure state . For any bi-partite pure state, here the atom-field state , we have
where is the reduced density matrix of the atom given in Eq. (5). The quantity varies between 0 and 1. If , then the composite state is separable, indicating the absence of entanglement between the atom and the field. For a non-zero value of , the state is entangled, and for , it is maximally entangled.
Using Eq. (5), Eq. (12) is simplified to
where are the eigenvalues of . Interestingly, from Eqs. (4) and (11), we find . Consequently, Eq. (13) becomes
This expression connects the dynamics of atomic observables, which are the properties of a single-partite system, to atom-field entanglement, a property of a bipartite system. Such connections between the properties of single-partite and bipartite systems have been studied for qubit [59] and qudit systems [60].
It is important to note that Eq. (14) is true for any initial pure atomic states and pure field states for both resonant and non-resonant cases. Therefore, the emergence of entanglement can be understood in terms of both atomic coherence and atomic population inversion . Specifically, the quantity , which satisfies , governs the degree of entanglement. The entanglement in the state is zero if , whereas the entanglement is maximum for . Therefore, the atom-field system becomes maximally entangled when both and become zero simultaneously:
The above results can also be understood geometrically in terms of the length of the Bloch vector on the Bloch sphere. We find that the magnitude of the Bloch vector that represents the state is (see Appendix § 8). Therefore, Eq. (14) becomes
which leads to maximum entanglement when , corresponding to a maximally mixed atomic state .
Persistence of Maximal Atom–Field Entanglement
To understand the persistence of maximal atom-field entanglement, we study the interplay between atomic coherence () and atomic population inversion () by considering various initial field states. For simplicity, we consider the initial state of the atom to be , so that the element , and all other elements are zero in the atomic density matrix . Therefore, at time , we have (no coherence between and ) and the population inversion . With this initial condition, we identify two distinct types of dynamical behavior: (a) the atomic coherence remains zero throughout the evolution, and (b) the atomic coherence develops during the evolution. Based on these temporal behaviors, we investigate the conditions under which the maximal atom–field entanglement becomes persistent or transient.
Vanishing atomic coherence
We identify a class of initial field states for which the -norm of coherence of the atom remains zero throughout the evolution, i.e., for all . As follows from Eq. (10) that this occurs if and only if either or (for every ) in an initial field state . Equivalently, the field state must have a photon-number distribution with no two adjacent occupied photon-number levels. Several well-known nonclassical field states, including Fock states, even coherent states, odd coherent states, squeezed vacuum states, squeezed number states, photon-added squeezed vacuum states, photon-subtracted squeezed vacuum states, and compass states satisfy this condition. The corresponding Fock state representations of these states are given in Appendix § 6. Interestingly, the photon-number distributions of these field states have a special structure: their Fock-basis expansion contains photon-number states which are separated by fixed integer steps. Such field states are invariant under discrete phase space rotations (see Appendix § 9) [61, 62]. However, in general, discrete rotational symmetry alone cannot fully be the reason for the persistent vanishing of the local atomic coherence during the evolution. Rather, the absence of adjacent occupied photon-number levels ensures that the atomic coherence remains zero at all times. As the -norm of coherence remains zero throughout the evolution, the atom-field entanglement is determined solely by the atomic population inversion . Therefore, Eq. (14) becomes
The atom and the field are maximally entangled () when . Therefore, for any initial field states for which the atomic population inversion exhibits complete collapse () for a longer period of time, the atom-field entanglement persists at its maximum over the same period of time.
We found that, among the aforementioned states, only even coherent states, odd coherent states, photon-added squeezed vacuum states, photon-subtracted squeezed vacuum states, and compass states, with larger mean photon numbers, exhibit complete collapse () for a longer period when they interact resonantly with the atom, and hence, they generate maximal atom-field entanglement that persists over an extended period. The minimum mean photon number required for the aforementioned field states to exhibit complete collapse is given in Table E1 in Appendix § 10. For any arbitrary initial field state, the collapse of atomic population inversion is determined by its photon-number distribution, as can be seen from Eq. (11). An appropriate photon-number distribution can lead to destructive interference among Rabi oscillations associated with individual photon-number states. Therefore, the persistence of maximal atom-field entanglement also depends on how the photon-number distribution spreads over the Fock space.
| Initial field states | Minimum mean photon number |
| Even coherent states | 15 |
| Odd coherent states | 14 |
| Yurke-Stoler states | 7 |
| Coherent states | 7 |
| Photon added squeezed vacuum | 17 |
| Photon subtracted squeezed vacuum | 18 |
| Compass states | 35 |
| Photon added coherent states | 5 |
| Displaced number states | 10 |
| Squeezed coherent states | 6 |
| Binomial states | 6 |
Table E1. Minimum mean photon numbers required in various initial field states for the collapse of atomic population inversion in the Jaynes-Cummings system.
We show the atom-field entanglement , the -norm of coherence , and the atomic population inversion as a function of normalized time in Figure 1 when the field is initialized in an (a) even coherent state and (b) odd coherent state. For these initial states, we calculate , , and using Eqs. (11), (10) and (14), respectively. As the atom displays complete collapse () over an extended period of time when it interacts with these initial field states, the atom-field entanglement attains its maximum value () and persists for the same period of time. Although we have discussed the dynamics specifically for even and odd coherent states, we observed similar behavior for photon-added squeezed vacuum states, photon-subtracted squeezed vacuum states, and compass states.
Figure 1. Atomic population inversion (black-continuous), -norm of coherence (blue-dash-dot), and entanglement (red-dot) as a function of normalized time when the cavity field is prepared in an (a) even coherent state, and (b) odd coherent state with .
In contrast, under non-resonant conditions, approaches a nonzero constant value for an extended period of time (see Eq. (B.4) in Appendix § 7). As a result, the entanglement persists at a value less than unity in that period (see Figure B1). Nevertheless, the entanglement is transient when and , and reaches its maximum value (see Figure B1).
Figure B1. Atomic population inversion (black-continuous), -norm of coherence (blue-dash-dot), and entanglement (red-dot) as a function of normalized time for the non-resonant case with . The cavity field is prepared in an even coherent state with .
On the other hand, states such as Fock states, squeezed vacuum states, and squeezed number states do not display complete collapse, even though their photon-number distributions spread across multiple photon numbers (except for Fock states). Consequently, they do not generate persistent maximal entanglement; instead, the maximal entanglement is transient (Table 1). The entanglement is maximum at the zero crossings of atomic population inversion. For a Fock state , the zero-crossing occurs at (see Appendix § 11) and the interval between consecutive zero crossings decreases as the photon number () increases. However, for the squeezed vacuum states and squeezed number states, does not exhibit regularly spaced zero crossings (see Appendix § 11). Nevertheless, the time of the first zero-crossing of atomic population inversion decreases with increasing mean photon number of the field state (see Figure F1).
| Initial field states | -norm of coherence of atom | Atomic population inversion | Entanglement |
| Fock states [42] | Vanishing coherence | Does not show collapse | Transient |
| Even coherent states [63] | Vanishing coherence | Shows collapse | Persistent |
| Odd coherent states [63] | Vanishing coherence | Shows collapse | Persistent |
| Squeezed vacuum [64] | Vanishing coherence | Does not show collapse | Transient |
| Squeezed number states [65] | Vanishing coherence | Does not show collapse | Transient |
| Photon-added squeezed vacuum [66] | Vanishing coherence | Shows collapse | Persistent |
| Photon-subtracted squeezed vacuum [67] | Vanishing coherence | Shows collapse | Persistent |
| Compass states [68, 69] | Vanishing coherence | Shows collapse | Persistent |
| Coherent states [70] | Dynamically generated coherence | Shows collapse | Transient |
| Yurke-Stoler states [71] | Dynamically generated coherence | Shows collapse | Persistent |
| Photon added coherent states [72] | Dynamically generated coherence | Shows collapse | Transient |
| Displaced number states [73] | Dynamically generated coherence | Shows collapse | Transient |
| Squeezed coherent state [64] | Dynamically generated coherence | Shows collapse | Transient |
| Binomial state [74] | Dynamically generated coherence | Shows collapse | Transient |
| Single number-state filtered coherent state [51] | Dynamically generated coherence | Does not show collapse | Transient |
Table 1. Table for temporal behavior of atomic coherence, atomic population inversion, and entanglement for various initial field states
Figure F1. Atomic population inversion as a function of normalized time when the cavity field is prepared in a (a) squeezed vacuum state with mean photon number , 8, and 15 and (b) squeezed number state with mean photon number , 8, and 20
Dynamically generated atomic coherence
When an atom with zero coherence () interacts with this class of field states, it gradually develops local atomic coherence. This class includes coherent states, Yurke-Stoler states, photon-added coherent states, displaced number states, squeezed coherent states, binomial states, and number-state filtered coherent states. These states do not satisfy the condition that no two adjacent photon-number states are populated in their Fock-basis expansions. Therefore, these states are not invariant under discrete phase space rotations. For these initial field states, the atom-field entanglement is determined by and . Consequently, persistence of maximal atom-field entanglement becomes unlikely, since both and must simultaneously vanish for a longer period. Therefore, in most of the cases, the maximal atom-field entanglement is transient. The temporal behaviors of atomic coherence, atomic population inversion, and entanglement for these field states are tabulated in Table 1.
We show the atom-field entanglement , -norm of coherence , and atomic population inversion as a function of normalized time in Figure 2 when the field is initialized in a (a) coherent state and (b) Yurke-Stoler state. As can be seen in Figure 2(a), the -norm of coherence does not become zero when the field is in a coherent state. Therefore, the atom-field entanglement becomes transient even though the atomic population inversion displays collapse. This happens for other states too, except for the Yurke-Stoler states. For Yurke-Stoler states with a larger mean photon number, we find that the entanglement persists for a longer period (see Figure 2(b)). This is because, for Yurke-Stoler states, the -norm of coherence grows very slowly from zero (see Figure G1) and remains much smaller than unity for an extended period (see Figure 2(b)). It is non-zero due to the constructive interference between two coherent state components and , which have a relative phase of (see Appendix § 12). This is also supported by the fact that the Yurke-Stoler state is not invariant under a discrete phase space rotation. However, there is a significant overlap between the region where and the atomic population inversion collapse region (). Consequently, the atom-field entanglement becomes nearly persistent in the overlapping region, as can be seen in Figure 2(b).
Figure 2. Atomic population inversion (black-continuous), -norm of coherence (blue-dash-dot), and entanglement (red-dot) as a function of normalized time when the cavity field is prepared in a (a) coherent state, and (b) Yurke-Stoler state with .

Figure G1. Comparison between approximate result (Eq. (G.4)) with analytical result (Eq. (G.2)) for .
Summary
We investigated the emergence and persistence of maximal atom–field entanglement in an atom-cavity system. By quantifying the atom-field entanglement using the von Neumann entropy, we found a direct relation between entanglement and the atomic dynamical variables such as the atomic coherence (-norm of coherence), and atomic population inversion. This relation showed that the emergence of maximal atom–field entanglement is possible when the atomic population inversion and the -norm of coherence simultaneously vanish. Further, we considered the atom in its excited state, for which the -norm of coherence of the atom is zero, and studied the role of initial field states on the time dynamics of entanglement. With this consideration, we showed that the persistence of maximal entanglement for a longer period depends strongly on the initial state of the field. We categorized the atom-field dynamics into two:
(1) For initial field states, having photon-number distributions with no two consecutive photon-number levels occupied, the -norm of coherence of the atom remains zero throughout the evolution. This condition is satisfied by well-known nonclassical states such as Fock states, even coherent states, odd coherent states, squeezed vacuum states, squeezed number states, photon-added squeezed vacuum states, photon-subtracted squeezed vacuum states, and compass states. Therefore, for these initial field states, the complete collapse of the atomic population inversion with zero local atomic coherence directly leads to maximal atom–field entanglement, which persists over an extended period.
(2) For other initial field states, in which at least two consecutive photon-number levels are occupied, the local atomic coherence develops during the evolution, and the -norm of coherence becomes non-zero. This condition is satisfied by states such as coherent states, Yurke-Stoler states, photon-added coherent states, displaced number states, squeezed coherent states, binomial states, and number-state filtered coherent states. As a result, even when the population inversion vanishes, maximal entanglement is attained only for a short duration. Therefore, the atom-field entanglement shows transient behavior except for the Yurke-Stoler states. The Yurke-Stoler states with larger mean photon numbers exhibit persistent maximal atom-field entanglement. In summary, we demonstrated how the choice of the initial field state controls the temporal characteristics of entanglement in the Jaynes–Cummings system. The generation and persistence of maximal atom–field entanglement in such systems could be valuable for applications in quantum information processing.
An interesting direction for future work is to extend the present study to more complex atom-field systems including the nonlinear Jaynes-Cummings models [75, 76, 77], where the nonlinear coupling between the atom and the field may influence the nature of atom-field entanglement for a given field state.
Quantum field states in the Fock basis
Here, we give the Fock state representation of various field states. In Fock basis ,
Coherent state [70]
where is the coherent state amplitude.
Even coherent state [63]
where .
Odd coherent state [63]
where .
Yurke-Stoler state [71]
Squeezed vacuum state [42]
where is the squeezing parameter, is the squeezing strength, and is the squeezing angle.
-Photon added coherent state [72]
where is the number of photons added to the coherent state and is the Laguerre polynomial of order .
Displaced number state [73]
where is the associated Laguerre polynomial of order with parameter .
Number state filtered coherent state [51]
This state is formed by removing the number state from the coherent state .
Squeezed number state [78]
where is the normalization constant, , and are squeezing parameters, is the squeeze operator, , and is the greatest integer function.
-Photon added squeezed vacuum state [66]
where is the number of photons added to the squeezed vacuum state, and .
-Photon subtracted squeezed vacuum state [67]
where is the number of photons subtracted from the squeezed vacuum state.
Squeezed coherent state [42]
where is the Hermite polynomial of order and .
Binomial state [79]
where is the maximum photon number and is the probability parameter.
Non-resonant dynamics
Under the non-resonance condition , the evolved state of the atom-field system at time is [36]
where and .
The density matrix corresponding to the atom-field state is . By taking the partial trace over the field degree of freedom, we get the reduced density matrix for the atom whose matrix elements are
From these matrix elements, we calculate the -norm of coherence of the atom to be
and the atomic population inversion to be
We show , , as a function of normalized time in Figure B1 for the non-resonant case. The field is initialized in an even coherent state. As can be seen in the figure, remains zero in the non-resonant case too. However, as we note from Eq. (B.4), contains an oscillatory term and a non-oscillatory term. For an extended period of time, the oscillatory term vanishes and equalizes to a constant term
Consequently, the entanglement does not reach its maximum value in that duration, as can be seen in Figure B1.
Bloch vector, -norm of coherence and population inversion
A density matrix () is represented by a vector on the Bloch sphere. The length of the Bloch vector is given by [80]
where , and are Pauli matrices and , with . The length of the Bloch vector satisfies . For pure states, and for mixed states, .
Now, considering the reduced density matrix of the atom given in Eq. (5), and using Eqs. (4), and (11), we get
Therefore, Eq. (14) becomes
The maximum atom-field entanglement occurs when , corresponding to the maximally mixed state of the atom.
Discrete Rotational Symmetry
A field state is said to have -fold rotational symmetry in phase space if it is invariant under a phase-space rotation by an angle , up to a global phase [61, 62]. Mathematically,
where is the phase space rotation operator, , and is a phase. For density matrices,
As an example, to examine whether the even coherent state is invariant under a discrete phase-space rotation, we consider the action of the rotation operator on it. We obtain,
For , we have , then,
which shows that the even coherent state possesses a two-fold () rotational symmetry. Similarly, we can show that odd coherent states, squeezed vacuum states, squeezed number states, photon-added squeezed vacuum states, and photon-subtracted squeezed vacuum states are also invariant under discrete phase space rotations with two-fold rotational symmetry. However, the compass states exhibit four-fold rotational symmetry. This rotational invariance of these states arises from the fact that they are superpositions of Fock states which are separated by fixed integer steps. Furthermore, a correspondence has been established between the rotational invariance of states and the states obtained after filtering Fock states separated by fixed integer steps [62].
In contrast, states such as coherent states, Yurke–Stoler states, squeezed coherent states, photon-added coherent states, displaced number states, and binomial states contain all Fock states. Therefore, they do not exhibit rotational invariance under a non-trivial discrete phase space rotation.
Atomic population inversion
The atomic population inversion for a field state having a photon-number distribution is [42]
For certain field states, remains close to zero for an extended period, indicating the collapse of atomic population inversion. To quantify this behavior, we consider the following numerical criterion: collapse is considered to occur if persists for a duration of at least . According to this criterion, the well-known field states listed in Table E1 exhibit collapse when the mean photon number exceeds a state-dependent threshold value.
Zero crossings of W(t)
For the Fock state , the probability amplitude is . Therefore, from Eq. (11), we calculate the atomic population inversion when the cavity field is in the Fock state to be
Therefore, the zero-crossing occurs when , which gives
For the squeezed vacuum state, the atomic population inversion is
For the squeezed-number state,
In these cases, the atomic population inversion does not exhibit regular oscillatory behavior (see Figure F1). As a result, a well-defined period for the zero-crossings can not be determined. Nevertheless, in both cases, the time of the first zero-crossing of the atomic population inversion decreases with increasing mean photon number of the field state (see Figure F1).
Analysis for cat states
Consider a superposition of two coherent states, and , with a relative phase , given by
where . The -norm of coherence of the above state is
As can be noted from the above equation, for corresponding to the even coherent state and corresponding to the odd coherent state, we get for all due to the destructive interference between two coherent states and .
In the short-time limit, we use and , and simplified the above expression to
For , corresponding to the Yurke-Stoler state, the -norm of coherence is approximately given by
which is non-zero, due to constructive interference between and . We compare this approximate result with the analytical expression given in Eq. (G.2) in Fig. G.1. This indicates that the -norm of coherence is non-zero, although very small.
Data availability statement
No new data were created or analysed in this study.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
References
- [1]Einstein A, Podolsky B and Rosen N 1935 Physical review 47 777
- [2]Bell J S 1964 Physics Physique Fizika 1 195
- [3]Bennett C H, Brassard G, Crépeau C, Jozsa R, Peres A and Wootters W K 1993 Physical review letters 70 1895
- [4]Bennett C H and Wiesner S J 1992 Phys. Rev. Lett. 69(20) 2881–2884 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.69.2881DOI
- [5]Bennett C H and Brassard G 2014 Theoretical computer science 560 7–11
- [6]Bennett C H, Brassard G and Ekert A K 1992 Scientific American 267 50–57
- [7]Haroche S and Kleppner D 1989 Physics Today 42 24–30
- [8]Haroche S 2013 Rev. Mod. Phys. 85(3) 1083–1102 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/RevModPhys.85.1083DOI
- [9]Reiserer A and Rempe G 2015 Rev. Mod. Phys. 87(4) 1379–1418 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/RevModPhys.87.1379DOI
- [10]Meher N and Sivakumar S 2022 The European Physical Journal Plus 137 985
- [11]Blais A, Huang R S, Wallraff A, Girvin S M and Schoelkopf R J 2004 Physical Review A—Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics 69 062320
- [12]Wallraff A, Schuster D I, Blais A, Frunzio L, Huang R S, Majer J, Kumar S, Girvin S M and Schoelkopf R J 2004 Nature 431 162–167 ISSN 1476-4687 URL https://doi.org/10.1038/nature02851
- [13]Blais A, Grimsmo A L, Girvin S M and Wallraff A 2021 Reviews of Modern Physics 93 025005
- [14]Aspelmeyer M, Kippenberg T J and Marquardt F 2014 Reviews of Modern Physics 86 1391–1452
- [15]Ritter S, Nölleke C, Hahn C, Reiserer A, Neuzner A, Uphoff M, Mücke M, Figueroa E, Bochmann J and Rempe G 2012 Nature 484 195–200 ISSN 1476-4687 URL https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11023
- [16]Raimond J M, Brune M and Haroche S 2001 Rev. Mod. Phys. 73(3) 565–582 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/RevModPhys.73.565DOI
- [17]Hagley E, Maître X, Nogues G, Wunderlich C, Brune M, Raimond J M and Haroche S 1997 Phys. Rev. Lett. 79(1) 1–5 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.79.1DOI
- [18]Cirac J I and Zoller P 1994 Phys. Rev. A 50(4) R2799(R)–R2802(R) URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.50.R2799DOI
- [19]Liew T C H and Savona V 2013 New Journal of Physics 15 025015 URL https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/15/2/025015
- [20]Meher N, Sivakumar S and Panigrahi P K 2017 Scientific reports 7 9251
- [21]Alexanian M 2011 Phys. Rev. A 84(5) 052302 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.84.052302DOI
- [22]Tan H T, Zhang W M and Li G x 2011 Phys. Rev. A 83(6) 062310 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.83.062310DOI
- [23]2000 Optics Communications 184 417–423 ISSN 0030-4018 URL https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0030401800009494
- [24]Solano E, Agarwal G S and Walther H 2003 Phys. Rev. Lett. 90(2) 027903 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.90.027903DOI
- [25]Aguilar L M A 2006 Physica Scripta 73 317 URL https://doi.org/10.1088/0031-8949/73/4/001
- [26]Axline C J, Burkhart L D, Pfaff W, Zhang M, Chou K, Campagne-Ibarcq P, Reinhold P, Frunzio L, Girvin S M, Jiang L, Devoret M H and Schoelkopf R J 2018 Nature Physics 14 705–710
- [27]Rauschenbeutel A, Bertet P, Osnaghi S, Nogues G, Brune M, Raimond J M and Haroche S 2001 Phys. Rev. A 64(5) 050301(R) URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.64.050301DOI
- [28]Davidovich L, Zagury N, Mairaud M, Raimond J and Haroche S 1994 Phys. Rev. A 50(2) R895(R)–R898(R) URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.50.R895DOI
- [29]Wang H, Mariantoni M, Bialczak R C, Lenander M, Lucero E, Neeley M, O’Connell A D, Sank D, Weides M, Wenner J, Yamamoto T, Yin Y, Zhao J, Martinis J M and Cleland A N 2011 Phys. Rev. Lett. 106(6) 060401 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.060401DOI
- [30]Gabbasov E and Kempf A 2025 Quantum Science and Technology 10 045054
- [31]Amrita, Singh R, Krishna A N and Verma K 2021 Resonance 26 1705–1720
- [32]Xie Q and Huang J 2019 International Journal of Theoretical Physics 58 4033–4041
- [33]Pandit M, Das S, Roy S S, Dhar H S and Sen U 2018 Journal of Physics B: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics 51 045501
- [34]Jaynes E T and Cummings F W 1963 Proceedings of the IEEE 51 89–109
- [35]Shore B W and Knight P L 1993 Journal of Modern Optics 40 1195–1238
- [36]Larson J and Mavrogordatos T 2021 The Jaynes–Cummings model and its descendants: modern research directions (IoP Publishing)DOI
- [37]Purcell E M 1995 Spontaneous emission probabilities at radio frequencies Confined electrons and photons: new physics and applications (Springer) pp 839–839DOI
- [38]Thompson R, Rempe G and Kimble H 1992 Physical review letters 68 1132
- [39]Boca A, Miller R, Birnbaum K M, Boozer A D, McKeever J and Kimble H J 2004 Phys. Rev. Lett. 93(23) 233603 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.93.233603DOI
- [40]Birnbaum K M, Boca A, Miller R, Boozer A D, Northup T E and Kimble H J 2005 Nature 436 87–90
- [41]Cummings F 1965 Physical Review 140 A1051
- [42]Gerry C C and Knight P L 2023 Introducatory quantum optics (Cambridge university press)
- [43]Premaratne S P, Wellstood F C and Palmer B S 2017 Nature Communications 8 14148 ISSN 2041-1723 URL https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms14148
- [44]Uria M, Solano P and Hermann-Avigliano C 2020 Phys. Rev. Lett. 125(9) 093603 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.093603
- [45]Domokos P, Janszky J and Adam P 1994 Phys. Rev. A 50(4) 3340–3344 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.50.3340DOI
- [46]Varcoe B T H, Brattke S, Weidinger M and Walther H 2000 Nature 403 743–746 ISSN 1476-4687 URL https://doi.org/10.1038/35001526
- [47]Bertet P, Osnaghi S, Milman P, Auffeves A, Maioli P, Brune M, Raimond J M and Haroche S 2002 Phys. Rev. Lett. 88(14) 143601 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.88.143601DOI
- [48]Ourjoumtsev A, Kubanek A, Koch M, Sames C, Pinske P W, Rempe G and Murr K 2011 Nature 474 623–626
- [49]Zheng S B 2007 Optics Communications 273 460–463 ISSN 0030-4018 URL https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0030401807001162
- [50]Brune M, Haroche S, Raimond J M, Davidovich L and Zagury N 1992 Phys. Rev. A 45(7) 5193–5214 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.45.5193DOI
- [51]Meher N and Sivakumar S 2018 Quantum Information Processing 17 233 ISSN 1573-1332 URL https://doi.org/10.1007/s11128-018-1995-6
- [52]Meher N and Sivakumar S 2019 Quantum Information Processing 19 51 ISSN 1573-1332 URL https://doi.org/10.1007/s11128-019-2553-6
- [53]Baumgratz T, Cramer M and Plenio M B 2014 Physical Review Letter 113 140401
- [54]Sugumar H and Meher N 2026 Physical Sciences Forum 13 8 URL https://doi.org/10.3390/psf2026013008
- [55]Gea-Banacloche J 1990 Physical review letters 65 3385
- [56]Bužek V, Moya-Cessa H, Knight P L and Phoenix S J D 1992 Phys. Rev. A 45(11) 8190–8203 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.45.8190DOI
- [57]von Neumann J 1927 Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, Mathematisch-Physikalische Klasse 273–291
- [58]Von Neumann J 2018 Mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics: New edition (Princeton university press)
- [59]Jakob M and Bergou J A 2010 Optics Communications 283 827–830
- [60]Jakob M and Bergou J A 2007 Physical Review A 76 052107
- [61]Grimsmo A L, Combes J and Baragiola B Q 2020 Physical Review X 10 011058
- [62]López-Saldívar J A 2020 Physica Scripta 95 065206
- [63]Dodonov V, Malkin I and Man’Ko V 1974 Physica 72 597–615
- [64]Stoler D 1970 Physical Review D 1 3217
- [65]Kim M, De Oliveira F and Knight P 1989 Physical Review A 40 2494
- [66]Kun S, Xiao-Hui J and Huan-Yu J 2010 Chinese Physics B 19 064205
- [67]Meng X g, Wang Z, Fan H y and Wang J s 2012 Journal of the Optical Society of America B 29 3141–3149
- [68]Zurek W H 2001 Nature 412 712–717
- [69]Agarwal G and Pathak P 2004 Physical Review A—Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics 70 053813
- [70]Glauber R J 1963 Physical Review 131 2766
- [71]Yurke B and Stoler D 1986 Physical review letters 57 13
- [72]Agarwal G S and Tara K 1991 Phys. Rev. A 43(1) 492–497 URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevA.43.492DOI
- [73]De Oliveira F, Kim M S, Knight P L and Bužek V 1990 Physical Review A 41 2645
- [74]Stoler D, Saleh B and Teich M 1985 Optica Acta: International Journal of Optics 32 345–355
- [75]Man’ko V I, Marmo G, Sudarshan E C G and Zaccaria F 1997 Physica Scripta 55 528–541
- [76]Uhdre G M, Cius D and Andrade F M 2022 Physical Review A 105 013703
- [77]Medina-Dozal L, Urzúa A R, Aranda-Lozano D, González-Gutiérrez C A, Récamier J and Román-Ancheyta R 2024 Physical Review A 110 043703 Nieto M M 1997 Physics Letters A 229 135–143
- [79]Mandal K, Alam N, Verma A, Pathak A and Banerji J 2019 Optics Communications 445 193–203 ISSN 0030-4018 URL https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000304019303232
- [80]Nielsen M A and Chuang I L 2010 Quantum computation and quantum information (Cambridge university press)



