WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Scalar and pseudoscalar glueballonia: do they bind?
Abstract
We investigate the existence of molecular two-glueball bound states, so-called glueballonia, in pure Yang-Mills (YM) theory. We mainly concentrate on the scalar and pseudoscalar channels, thus studying scalar-scalar and scalar-pseudoscalar bound states, respectively. Near the onset of binding, when a bound state first appears just below threshold, a nonrelativistic framework is justified. We employ an attractive scalar-exchange Yukawa potential together with a smeared contact term contribution and determine the critical attraction required for binding. For two scalar glueballs, we use the scalar dilaton effective theory to determine the parameters of the non-relativistic potential: the Yukawa interaction is generated by t- and u-channels involving the exchange of one scalar glueball, while the repulsion emerges by the s-channel annihilation and contact interaction. Using lattice-YM input to fix the dilaton parameters, we find that the attraction is strong enough: the scalar glueballonium binds, and the result is quite robust with respect to parameter variations. In a minimal scalar-pseudoscalar extension, the Yukawa attraction is again given by the t-channel scalar glueball, while the crossed u-channel pseudoscalar exchange induces an attractive local contribution, making the pseudoscalar glueballonium also bind in pure gauge. Importantly, both the scalar and pseudoscalar glueballonia are stable in the YM vacuum. Next, we briefly comment on the pseudoscalar-pseudoscalar, scalar-tensor, and tensor-tensor channels: all these channels are attractive too and could form bound states, which, however, would be unstable in pure YM due to decay into two lighter glueballs. Finally, as a cross-check, our formalism confirms that Higgs-Higgs bound state does not form.
Introduction
Glueballs are color-singlet excitations built entirely from the gluonic degrees of freedom of quantum chromodynamics (QCD). The existence of such states is a direct consequence of non-Abelian gauge dynamics; their identification in experiment is complicated by mixing with conventional mesons, nearby thresholds, and hadronic decays; for recent reviews about glueball candidates, see Refs. [1, 2, 3, 4].
In the pure Yang–Mills (YM) limit, quark degrees of freedom and decay channels into conventional quark-antiquark mesons are absent. Lattice YM calculations then predict a discrete low-lying glueball spectrum, with the lightest scalar followed by tensor and pseudoscalar excitations, [5, 6, 7, 8, 9]; see also their mutual comparison in Ref. [10]. These low-lying glueballs are stable in pure YM. This fact makes glueball–glueball interactions, and especially possible bound states of two glueballs, a well-defined subject of investigation.
The possibility that two scalar glueballs form a composite bound state, denoted as glueballonium, was first studied in Ref. [11]. Within a dilaton effective Lagrangian, relativistically unitarized scattering generates a bound-state pole once the attraction becomes sufficiently strong. For lattice-motivated parameters, a scalar glueballonium close to threshold was predicted. However, the quantitative conclusions retain some dependence on the unitarization procedure, motivating a complementary analysis.
The present work returns to the formation point from a complementary direction: rather than determining an entire relativistic scattering amplitude, we ask when the first two-body level appears in a nonrelativistic (NR) potential, for which the zero-energy Schrödinger equation provides a well-defined non-perturbative criterion. In fact, for constituent masses , , reduced mass , and binding energy , the binding momentum tends to zero as [12, 13]. Here the long-distance motion is then nonrelativistic, and the formation criterion may be studied with familiar potential-model methods [14, 15, 16].
At the same time, deriving a nonrelativistic interaction from a relativistic field theory requires matching, here naturally provided by the dilaton/scalar glueball Lagrangian as an effective low-energy YM theory [17, 18]. Namely, exchange of the lightest scalar glueball in the t- and u-channels between two glueballs generates an attractive Yukawa interaction in the NR limit [19]. The dilaton potential also contains a direct four-glueball vertex that, together with the s-channel annihilation channel, generates an additional contact term repulsion. This term requires special care: an ordinary Dirac delta is unproblematic as a potential in one spatial dimension, but in general a three-dimensional point interaction needs a regularization, renormalization, or self-adjoint-extension prescription [20, 21, 22, 23, 24]. A finite-length regularization is suitable for the present case, since glueballs are composite objects with a finite radius: the contact term is smeared out. We therefore calculate the binding threshold as a function of both the Yukawa attraction and the strength and spatial range of the contact term. Matching the interaction to the dilaton couplings at the central lattice-motivated parameters yields (at least) one GG bound state: the scalar glueballonium is predicted to exist. Moreover, since it is lighter than the lowest two-glueball threshold, it is a stable state in pure YM theory. This conclusion is robust under variation of the parameters of the model.
We extend the discussion beyond the lightest scalar pair. In particular, a mixed scalar–pseudoscalar pair has in an wave. The t-channel involves a scalar glueball exchange and generates the Yukawa attraction. The u-channel crossed interaction contains a pseudoscalar glueball exchange that, within the local-threshold approximation, reduces to an attractive contact interaction that is larger in absolute value than the s-channel and four-leg interaction’s contributions: the resulting contact interaction is here attractive. We find that the channel also binds over the parameter range investigated; importantly, the Yukawa attraction is sufficiently strong to bind even without the additional attractive contact term. In this respect, the existence of a bound state does not depend on the detail of the short-range term. This molecule, called pseudoscalar glueballonium, is also stable against strong decay in pure YM for a CP-parity-conserving YM theory (hence, without the -term).
We comment also on pseudoscalar-pseudoscalar, scalar-tensor, and tensor-tensor glueballonia. Although attraction, and possibly bound states, also occurs in these channels, the corresponding putative states are not stable in pure YM, since they can decay into lighter glueball pairs. They might rather appear as resonances in pure YM theory, making their identification more challenging on the lattice. Finally, as a cross-check, we apply our formalism also to Higgs-Higgs interaction, recovering a known result: no Higgsionium forms in the Standard Model. Glueball interactions and composite configurations have attracted attention from different theoretical perspectives. Lattice determinations of inter-glueball potentials, particularly in Yang–Mills theory, have found significant attraction and provided low-energy scattering information [9, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29]. These studies support a potential-based approach, although their differing Yukawa fits and gauge groups prevent a direct matching to the dilaton model. In addition, recent lattice calculations of the scalar glueball gravitational form factors indicate a relatively small mass radius, fm [30]. This supplies a useful physical length scale for estimating the spatial range of a local four-glueball interaction. In related phenomenological approaches, glueball-meson molecules as possible components of excited hadrons were studied in Ref. [31], whereas glueballonia as topological Hopfions, predicting both tightly and loosely bound configurations, are described in Ref. [32]. In a complementary work, S-matrix bootstrap methods have been used to constrain glueball couplings [33], while a recent effective field theory study examined scalar-glueball form factors and interaction radii [34]. Within this topic, our work aims to show that novel states in pure YM gauge theory are expected to exist, motivating further research in this direction. The paper is organized as follows. § 2 introduces the Yukawa-plus-contact problem and its -wave threshold condition. § 3 applies the construction to , , and exploratory , , and pairs and compares it with lattice information; a short excursus on Higgs-Higgs is also presented. § 4 presents a brief summary and outlook. The appendix Appendix § 6 discusses the radius scan, compares alternative finite-range realizations, and presents the pseudoscalar glueballonium beyond the local approximation. Unless stated otherwise, , , and denote the , , and glueballs in parity-conserving pure Yang–Mills theory, with .
Yukawa interaction and a smeared Dirac delta
Potential, scaling, and binding criterion
For two particles with reduced mass , we study the NR potential
The exchanged mass is , the Yukawa coupling is , the contact coefficient is with units of mass, and the normalized spherical regulator is taken as
Thus, is repulsive and attractive. The -wave radial equation is
At zero energy, the outer solution () is asymptotically linear:
where is the scattering length. The first binding threshold occurs for : the regular, nodeless radial solution approaches a constant and the scattering length diverges. This is the standard zero-energy resonance criterion; the sign and magnitude of the scattering length govern the nearby bound or virtual pole [16, 24]. This marginal zero-energy state is not normalizable. Below threshold, a bound solution has and .
Introducing the dimensionless quantities
Eq. (3) becomes:
For this regulator, the first -wave threshold is a surface . The pure-Yukawa result reads [35]:
see also the spectral estimates, numerical calculations, and systematic approximations of Refs. [36, 37, 38].
Next, we determine the onset of bound states by solving Eq. (6) at , with the regular origin expansion, valid for ,
A continuous phase , is convenient for identifying the first threshold:
The threshold is determined by requiring as , with a nodeless zero-energy solution. Numerically, this condition is imposed at a sufficiently large finite radius. Independent shooting of the radial equation and variation of the large-distance integration cutoff provide cross-checks. The results are displayed in Figure 1, with a separate examination of the small-radius limit in § 3 and in Appendix § 6.
Figure 1. First -wave threshold for three physical radii using . The dotted horizontal reference is the pure-Yukawa value .
The contact-only solution
The contact-only problem () is exactly soluble and deserves a separate discussion because it helps to understand the meaning and the need of a nonzero parameter . For a repulsive spherical barrier (), matching the zero-energy wavefunctions at gives
Since , the scattering length necessarily vanishes as , regardless of how the nonnegative strength depends on . More generally, the entire scattering amplitude vanishes at any fixed finite momentum. Thus, a repulsive interaction becomes ineffective in the zero-range limit, even if its integrated strength remains finite or diverges. This behavior provides an example of nonrelativistic triviality. Indeed, the finite range acts as an ultraviolet regulator, with a characteristic momentum scale . Removing this regulator causes the physical scattering amplitude to vanish, despite the presence of a repulsive bare interaction. This is connected to the nonrelativistic triviality of theory established in Ref. [20]; see also Ref. [22]. A related phenomenon occurs in relativistic theory in four spacetime dimensions, whose continuum limit is likewise trivial [39]. The underlying ultraviolet behavior is, however, different: the relevant divergence is linear in the cutoff in the present nonrelativistic problem, whereas it is logarithmic in the relativistic theory.
On the other hand, for an attractive core (), the trigonometric expression instead is
The first contact-only bound state appears at , or
Thus, for , the attraction provided by the core already binds at ; our threshold plots therefore set the minimal nonnegative to zero.
Equations (10)–(12) also reveal a fundamental difference between repulsive and attractive contact interactions in three dimensions. In the repulsive case, the scattering length satisfies and necessarily vanishes as , irrespective of how the barrier strength is varied. An attractive core, instead, can admit a nontrivial zero-range limit if its strength is appropriately tuned to keep a finite scattering length. This is possible both for , corresponding to a bound state, and for , corresponding to an attractive interaction without a bound state (on the first resonance branch).
For the reasons described above, throughout this work we retain a finite interaction radius , both for the repulsive contact interaction in the GG channel, which becomes trivial in the zero-range limit, and for the effective attractive contact in the GP channel, where a nontrivial zero-range limit would require an appropriate tuning of the coupling. It is worth noting that the direct four-point interaction in the GP channel is actually repulsive: the net attraction of the contact term arises from the local approximation to crossed pseudoscalar exchange. When the latter is retained explicitly, the remaining contact interaction is again repulsive, as discussed later on and in Appendix § 6. Thus, we regard as a physical model parameter associated with the finite spatial extent of the interaction.
From scattering amplitudes to potentials
We briefly recall how to obtain a nonrelativistic potential from a relativistic scattering amplitude calculated using standard Feynman rules [40]. Consider two distinguishable scalar fields and , with masses and , interacting by exchange of a scalar field of mass . We also allow for a direct quartic interaction,
The corresponding vertex factors are , , and . The two tree-level contributions to are illustrated in Figure 2. With the usual Feynman diagram convention, we obtain at tree-level -channel and contact amplitudes as:
Figure 2. Tree-level scattering: (a) -channel exchange of the scalar (thicker internal line), with vertices and ; (b) the direct quartic vertex . All lines represent scalar fields.
leading to the total amplitude as
In the nonrelativistic limit the energy transfer is negligible. With , we have and thus
To relate this amplitude to a potential, recall that for elastic scattering in the center-of-mass frame, standard relativistic state normalization gives, near threshold,
where in the r.h.s. the usual phase convention has been adopted. On the other hand, the first Born approximation in quantum mechanics reads
Equating the two expressions and taking the inverse Fourier transform leads directly to
In particular, the factor follows from the conversion between relativistically normalized scattering states and nonrelativistic two-body states.
Substituting Eq. (16) into Eq. (19) and using the standard Fourier transforms gives
We therefore recover precisely the Yukawa-plus-contact structure of Eq. (1), with
For , scalar exchange is attractive; a positive gives a repulsive short-range interaction.
It is useful to recall when the Yukawa attraction alone can bind. Setting , the first -wave bound state appears if
or, equivalently, . With a quartic interaction, the contact term must be treated together with the Yukawa attraction. Once a finite range is specified, its effect on the binding threshold is described by the dimensionless function of § 2.1, illustrated in Figure 1.
Applications to glueball pairs
In this section we study the emergence of glueballonia in different channels, with particular attention to the scalar-scalar and scalar-pseudoscalar bound states. We use the central lattice glueball mass GeV, as well as the pseudoscalar and tensor masses GeV, and GeV from [7].
Scalar Glueballonium:
From the Dilaton Potential to Interactions
We employ the standard dilaton potential for a scalar glueball field, as motivated by the gluonic trace anomaly [11, 17],
The dilaton parameters are fixed using the lattice determinations of the scalar glueball mass and its gluonic matrix element by Chen et al. [7]. With their normalization, the input values are
Using the trace-anomaly matching relation
one obtains GeV and [41]. These are model-matched parameters, and not direct determinations of two-glueball scattering. The pure-gauge treatment is compatible with large- arguments, but large- counting by itself does not determine the finite- values of the dilaton couplings or of the two-glueball scattering length [42, 43]. We recall also that the dilaton potential is the starting point of the extended Linear Sigma Model for low-energy QCD [44, 45] and the state can be interpreted as the resonance [46].
After shifting the vacuum expectation value, (we retain the symbol for the fluctuation), one obtains
The cubic and quartic interactions in Eq. (26) give rise to the four diagrams in Figure 3. For , the tree-level invariant amplitude reads
Figure 3. All four contributions to the amplitude: scalar exchange in the , , and channels, and the local four-glueball vertex. External lines represent identical scalar glueballs.
For identical scalar glueballs, the nonrelativistic Born amplitude must be Bose symmetrized. In particular, the - and -channel diagrams correspond to the direct and exchange contributions of a single Yukawa potential, rather than to two independent interactions. The local four-point and -channel contributions must likewise be matched to the symmetrized amplitude, which introduces an additional factor of two in their normalization. Following the prescription of § 2.3, the resulting potential is
with reduced mass . The attractive Yukawa interaction arises from scalar exchange, with strength
The contact interaction receives contributions from the quartic vertex and the -channel exchange. Namely, since we focus on the onset of binding, the -channel propagator can be evaluated at the two-body threshold . and replaced by a local contact interaction. Corrections from its energy dependence vanish as the binding energy approaches zero, making this approximation suitable for determining the first-binding threshold. Both contributions are repulsive:
As a consistency check, the tree-level threshold amplitude agrees with the symmetrized Born expression:
The Yukawa and contact strengths are not independent, but are correlated by the dilaton relations:
with and . When is kept fixed, the actual value of the pair is confined to a straight line, followed by the red dilaton trajectory in Figure 4. The critical value of is determined by the first-binding condition introduced in the previous section.
Figure 4. Scalar first-binding condition for GeV and fm. The blue curve separates bound (above; pale blue) and unbound (below; pale orange) parameter sets. The red trajectory fixed by Eq. (33). The open circle shows the first threshold, while the filled dot shows our central lattice-matched point GeV.
For the value fm, corresponding to , the first binding threshold occurs at
with and . We recall that:
Without the repulsive contact interaction, the corresponding threshold is , slightly larger than the value quoted above. At the central lattice-matched dilaton scale:
The value is sizably smaller (by a factor of about 2.22) than . Similarly, . Visually, the black dot of Figure 4 lies deeply in the bound region. This statement concerns the existence of at least one model bound state, but the employed nonrelativistic approach should not be used to infer its deeply bound mass at these strong couplings. Parameter variation is discussed below.
Dependence of the binding threshold on the contact radius
An important outcome of our analysis is the robustness of the binding prediction under variations of the contact radius . To illustrate this point, we repeat the calculation of the first binding threshold for different values of .
Figure 5 displays the resulting threshold points in the plane for eight representative radii between 0.05 and 0.40 fm. All points lie on the same straight line, as required by Eq. (33), since the dilaton Lagrangian fixes the relation between and (once the glueball mass is kept fixed). The physical lattice-matched point is also shown for comparison. The inset magnifies the region containing the threshold points, which are labeled by their corresponding values of .
Figure 5. First-binding threshold points in the plane for contact radii – fm at GeV. The orange markers are labeled by in the inset. The blue line is the dilaton trajectory, while the star denotes the central lattice-matched point at GeV.
The dependence on is nonmonotonic. Among the tested values, the smallest critical dilaton scale is found at fm, where GeV, corresponding to the largest critical Yukawa coupling, . For larger radii, the critical dilaton scale increases, reaching GeV at fm. As discussed in Appendix § 6, the repulsive contact interaction becomes ineffective in the limit , and the critical scale approaches continuously the pure-Yukawa value GeV.
The central lattice-matched parameters lie in the bound region for all radii considered in Figure 5. To characterize the distance from the onset without treating the correlated Yukawa and contact couplings as independent, we introduce the nominal separation , with GeV. As summarized in Table 1, for the benchmark fm, while it decreases to 2.51 near fm, where binding is the least favored radius range among the points shown in Figure 5.
| Channel | [fm] | [GeV] | |
| (benchmark) | 0.30 | 0.8241 | 5.26 |
| (least favorable) | 0.10 | 0.5877 | 2.51 |
| (benchmark, local) | 0.30 | 0.7945 | 4.91 |
| (least favorable, local) | 0.40 | 0.7924 | 4.89 |
Table 1. Critical dilaton scales for the two channels and , calculated at the central lattice glueball masses. The last column gives the nominal separation . Below, the least favorable entries refer to the numerical values tested in Figure 5 and Figure 7. The entries refer to the local-threshold approximation; see § 3.2.
These values represent nominal separations in units of the quoted uncertainty of , rather than Gaussian exclusion significances. Indeed, depends nonlinearly on the original lattice inputs, while the binding threshold also changes with . Furthermore, no probability distribution for is assumed, so these separations cannot be interpreted as an overall probability for the existence of glueballonium. Yet, the overall picture is that binding takes place for any case considered here.
Finally, it is useful to compare this result with the earlier relativistic studies of scalar glueballonium [11, 47]. Using a twice-subtracted on-shell unitarization of the dilaton scattering amplitude, these works obtained for . An alternative treatment in Ref. [11] yielded the very similar value .
Thus, these relativistic approaches also predict scalar glueballonium for the central lattice-matched scale . However, their critical values of are smaller than even the minimum found in our nonrelativistic analysis. Since binding occurs for , our approach, which is particularly suited to investigating the onset of bound-state formation, favors the existence of scalar glueballonium over a wider range of dilaton parameters.
Comparison with lattice scattering
An early lattice study of pure Yang–Mills theory yielded an estimate of the scalar three-glueball coupling, [25]. More recently, preliminary finite-volume results presented at LATTICE2024 [9, 48] were found to be compatible with this earlier estimate. For comparison, our dilaton model predicts , corresponding to , thus the lattice estimate is even larger.
Moreover, the HAL QCD studies by N. Yamanaka et al. extracted interglueball potentials and phase shifts, primarily in [26, 27]. An exploratory calculation also exists but does not yield comparably precise scattering observables [28]. These are valuable tests of a potential description and show substantial attraction. In the convention , the dimensionless strength is . Here is the scalar glueball mass in Yang–Mills theory, determined on the lattice to be approximately , where denotes the corresponding Yang–Mills scale. In particular, the analysis of Ref. [26] gives , or , while the later calculation of Chu et al. reports , or [29]. These fitted strengths are manifestly not mutually compatible as determinations of a universal Yukawa coefficient, and they should not be averaged.
Our lattice-matched dilaton value belongs qualitatively to the strong-attraction regime indicated by the Yamanaka fit rather than the much weaker single-Yukawa Chu fit. This is encouraging qualitatively, but there is no quantitative agreement test: both of those potentials are results, have different fitted smeared contact term forms (Chu et al. favor a two-Gaussian fit), and depend on the chosen potential extraction or fit procedure. The true scattering observables should be scheme independent if a nonlocal HAL QCD potential and its derivative expansion are treated consistently [49]. In particular, the reported cross-section magnitude constrains , not its sign, which is essential for distinguishing a shallow bound pole from a virtual one. An calculation of signed , effective range , and the scalar pole residue would be the clean input for our potential matching.
A further interesting comparison can be made using large- scaling. Since the three-glueball coupling scales as , the Yukawa strength behaves as at leading order [42]. Applying this scaling to the Yukawa fit of Ref. [26], we obtain an estimate for ,
comparable to our dilaton prediction .
In summary, the results and comparisons above are promising, but novel and more precise scattering parameters on the lattice are needed.
Scalar–pseudoscalar glueballonium:
In addition to the scalar dilaton/glueball field , we introduce a pseudoscalar glueball . A minimal potential, including an independent stabilizing pseudoscalar self-interaction, is [41]:
Lattice spectroscopy places a pseudoscalar glueball among the low-lying pure-gauge states [7], motivating a second molecular channel.
The pseudoscalar glueball and its couplings to the axial anomaly and ordinary mesons have a substantial effective-theory literature [50, 51, 52, 53]. As a recent experimental development, it is worth mentioning the pseudoscalar resonance X(2370), observed by BESIII and exhibiting striking glueball-like features [54, 55, 56, 57]. Remarkably, its decays can be understood within a theory implementing fractional ’t Hooft determinants [41].
Shifting , Eq. (39) generates
The mass relation assumes no independent bare mass term, in agreement with dilatation symmetry. The interaction does not contribute directly to at tree level, but enters and ensures that the potential is bounded from below along the direction for . Numerically, we use GeV [7].
The tree diagrams are shown in Figure 6. Since the two external particles are distinguishable, the -channel exchange is a genuine additional contribution, rather than the Bose symmetrization of the channel. The invariant amplitude reads

Figure 6. The tree diagrams: -channel scalar exchange, - and -channel pseudoscalar exchange, and the local vertex.
Matching the -channel contribution to the nonrelativistic potential, without identical-particle symmetrization, gives the Yukawa coefficient and reduced mass
The remaining three diagrams are approximated by a local interaction evaluated at the elastic threshold, where and . We obtain
Here is the attractive crossed -channel contribution, whereas and arise from the repulsive -channel exchange and the four-point vertex, respectively. For the masses considered here, the crossed exchange slightly overcompensates the two repulsive terms, resulting in a net attractive contact interaction.
The resulting potential in the local-threshold approximation is therefore
The local-threshold approximation does not necessarily reproduce the effects of retaining the full momentum dependence of crossed exchange. A related distinction arises in other contexts [58], although that analysis does not provide an additional matching condition for the present system. The alternative treatment retaining the finite-range crossed pseudoscalar exchange is examined in Appendix § 6, where we find that the central binding prediction survives, although the quantitative thresholds change slightly.
At fm, the first binding threshold occurs at
corresponding to and . At the central lattice-matched scale GeV, well within the bound region of the model. The corresponding values read:
The channel behaves differently from : the first-binding threshold depends only weakly on the contact radius. As shown in Figure 7, decreases from 0.8215 to 0.7924 GeV as increases from 0.05 to 0.40 fm. The corresponding nominal separations from GeV are approximately 4.9 quoted standard uncertainties (Table 1), with the same statistical qualifications discussed in the channel.
Figure 7. First-binding threshold points for the potential in the plane, for – fm and the central lattice masses GeV and GeV. The calculation uses the local-threshold approximation for the short-range interaction. The orange markers, labeled by in the inset, lie along the dilaton trajectory. The star denotes the central lattice-matched point at GeV. Notice the very weak dependence on .
In fact, for , it is sufficient to verify whether the Yukawa interaction alone supports a bound state. Its dimensionless strength at the central parameters is , considerably larger than the pure-Yukawa critical value . Hence, a bound state exists even in the absence of the contact interaction. Adding the attractive contact term can only reinforce binding, independently of its radius or spatial profile (see Appendix § 6 where the treatment beyond the local approximation is discussed).
An -wave molecule has and mass . In parity-conserving pure Yang–Mills theory, it cannot decay into two glueballs: requires relative , implying positive parity. The final state also has positive parity for , since is required. Furthermore, for the Chen et al. central masses, the and thresholds, approximately 4.78 and 5.13 GeV, lie above the threshold of 4.27 GeV. Thus, a molecule is stable against strong decay in pure Yang–Mills theory without CP-breaking terms.
What about other glueballonia? , , and
The strong scalar-exchange coupling motivates the investigation of further glueball pairs. We treat the constituent glueballs as stable pure-gauge degrees of freedom and study binding relative to their two-body thresholds. Such bound configurations may nevertheless couple to lighter channels and appear as resonances.
. For two identical pseudoscalars, the vertex with generates scalar exchange in the , , and channels, while the quartic interaction provides an additional contact contribution. The tree-level amplitude is
As for , the - and -channel contributions correspond to a single Bose-symmetrized Yukawa potential. The resulting coefficients are
Both contributions to are repulsive for . At GeV, we obtain and . For , the Yukawa attraction is sufficiently strong to generate a bound state. For fm, our model predicts binding up to . This large formal value should not be interpreted as a quantitatively reliable bound on the physical self-coupling, but merely shows that the contact repulsion should be large to prevent binding1. An -wave state has and can decay into two scalar glueballs. It would therefore generally appear as a resonance rather than a stable glueballonium.
. We now introduce the tensor glueball with . Unlike a scalar field, a massive spin-2 field has five physical polarization states and requires an appropriate tensor kinetic structure. As a minimal mass-generating interaction, we consider
The quadratic tensor structure has the Fierz–Pauli form required for a free massive spin-two field [60]. The trace term vanishes for physical on-shell tensor polarizations. Above, denotes the unshifted dilaton field. For physical tensor polarizations the trace vanishes. After shifting , we find
where is defined through the trilinear interaction in the physical tensor sector.
The leading -channel scalar exchange is spin diagonal in the nonrelativistic limit. It generates an attractive Yukawa interaction with strength
With GeV and GeV, this gives and , considerably above the pure-Yukawa threshold .
This illustrates the strong attraction generated by scalar exchange, but does not establish a complete bound-state pole. Indeed, the same interaction in Eq. (49) also generates a local vertex, while the trilinear vertex contributes through crossed tensor exchange. Their proper treatment requires the tensor propagator and its spin projectors. Additional derivative interactions and coupled channels may also modify the result.
An -wave configuration has . Since GeV exceeds GeV, decay into two scalar glueballs in a wave is kinematically allowed2. Thus, a corresponding state would generally be resonant.
. The interaction introduced in Eq. (49) also determines the coupling of two tensor glueballs to the scalar glueball. Hence, it naturally leads to scattering through scalar exchange in the , , and channels.
The tensor nature of the particles is now essential. For two identical spin-2 particles in an wave, Bose symmetry allows total spin . Following the spin decomposition discussed in Ref. [10], the leading nonrelativistic amplitudes take the form
Thus, the -channel contribution appears only for , where it is repulsive near threshold. For , the leading interaction consists entirely of the - and -channel scalar exchanges, represented by a single Bose-symmetrized Yukawa potential.
The corresponding Yukawa strength is
For the central parameters, we obtain and . Since , the minimal scalar-exchange potential supports bound states in the channels.
The channel additionally receives a repulsive local contribution from -channel scalar exchange,
Its effect on binding depends on the short-range realization of this interaction.
These observations concern the minimal scalar-exchange model. An independent interaction, as well as further derivative and tensor couplings, is not fixed by Eq. (49) and may modify the binding conditions. Moreover, -wave states have and lie above the two-scalar threshold. They may therefore decay into through the corresponding even partial waves when suitable couplings are present. A complete description would require the associated coupled-channel analysis.
A comparison: the absence of Higgsonium in the Standard Model
As a final application, it is interesting to consider the interaction between two Higgs bosons within the Standard Model (SM) [61]. The possible formation of a Higgs–Higgs bound state, called Higgsonium, was recently studied in Ref. [62] using relativistic unitarization methods, finding no bound state for the SM self-couplings. For earlier studies, see Refs. [63, 64, 65].
The Higgs potential, expanded around its minimum, takes the form
where denotes the physical Higgs fluctuation, , and .
Applying the same nonrelativistic matching as for the system, we obtain
with
As for the case, the -channel exchange and the quartic vertex both contribute to the repulsive contact interaction, while the - and -channel exchange generate the Bose-symmetrized Yukawa attraction.
Since the exchanged particle and the constituents have the same mass, , and the dimensionless Yukawa strength is simply . This value is much smaller than the pure-Yukawa critical coupling . Hence, even in the absence of the repulsive contact term, the attraction is far too weak to produce a bound state. Including the positive contact interaction can only make binding more difficult, independently of its nonnegative normalized spatial profile.
Thus, within the present potential framework, the Standard Model does not predict Higgsonium, in agreement with the relativistic analysis of Ref. [62]. In contrast, the dilaton self-interactions generate a much stronger Yukawa attraction between scalar glueballs. Extensions of the SM with enhanced Higgs self-couplings may nevertheless allow Higgsonium, as investigated in Ref. [62].
Conclusions
In this work, we have investigated the possible formation of glueballonia using a nonrelativistic potential approach, with particular attention to the onset of bound-state formation. The attractive Yukawa interaction generated by scalar-glueball exchange is supplemented by a smeared contact term. We have established the conditions for the onset of binding and examined the role of the finite range of the contact interaction, including the subtleties of its zero-range limit in three spatial dimensions.
For two scalar glueballs, the parameters of the NR potential are fixed through matching with the dilaton effective Lagrangian. The main result is clear: at the central lattice-matched parameters, the dilaton potential supports at least one bound state, the scalar glueballonium. This conclusion is robust under the investigated variations of the range of the repulsive interaction. The uncertainty analysis also identifies where this conclusion becomes sensitive to the lattice inputs and the short-range interaction.
The same approach, applied to an extension of the dilaton potential that incorporates the pseudoscalar glueball, favors the formation of a pseudoscalar glueballonium made of a scalar and a pseudoscalar glueball. In the local-threshold approximation, the net contact interaction is attractive. The Yukawa interaction alone already supports a bound state, so adding the contact term can only reinforce binding, independently of its radius or nonnegative spatial profile. This conclusion also survives the input variations considered in our uncertainty analysis.
Interestingly, both and glueballonia states, if existent, are stable in CP-conserving YM vacuum.
Strong scalar-exchange attraction is also found in the , , and systems. These channels offer further possibilities for glueballonium formation, although their near-threshold configurations have open decay channels and would generally appear as resonances, even in pure gauge. Establishing their properties requires a more complete treatment of the short-range interactions, tensor spin structure, and coupled channels.
As a comparison and cross-check, we have also considered the Standard Model Higgs boson. In that case, the Yukawa attraction is far too weak to form a Higgs–Higgs bound state, in agreement with previous outcomes on the subject.
Our results therefore motivate further investigations of scalar and pseudoscalar glueballonia in pure Yang–Mills theory, particularly through lattice studies along two complementary directions.
(i) Determinations of low-energy glueball scattering amplitudes in would provide a direct test of the predicted attraction and the possible formation of bound states. In parallel, a better understanding of finite-volume effects, the momentum dependence of the interactions, and coupled channels would allow more quantitative predictions for the properties of these states.
(ii) A detailed investigation of the excited spectrum in the scalar and pseudoscalar channels could provide a complementary way to identify glueballonia. Indeed, if they exist, these states belong to the spectrum of pure Yang–Mills theory and should appear in lattice calculations, just as conventional glueballs do. In particular, optimized two-glueball interpolating operators could be constructed to enhance their overlap with molecular configurations, facilitating the identification of possible additional states and the study of their finite-volume behavior.
More generally, confirming glueballonia on the lattice would provide a new test of effective descriptions of gluodynamics and help constrain their underlying parameters more precisely.
We conclude with a more general question: is a glueballonium itself a glueball? Actually, yes, since it is also a bound state made entirely of gluons. Yet, its nature is different, since it is a molecular bound state of two (or more) glueballs. It is thus a nonconventional glueball state. This distinction becomes particularly clear when varying the number of colors . While conventional glueballs survive at large , molecular glueballonia disappear abruptly from the bound-state spectrum once the attraction falls below its critical strength, and do not survive in the large-$N_c limit [43]. As the critical value of is approached from the binding side, the glueballonium mass tends toward the corresponding two-glueball threshold. Following this evolution on the lattice would offer an additional way to distinguish molecular states from conventional glueballs. Thus, glueballonia would be a genuine, but intrinsically finite-, feature of the Yang–Mills spectrum.
Acknowledgments
We thank E. Trotti, N. Yamanaka, R. Porowski for a preliminary discussion and study on this subject. We also thank L. Tinti and M. Rohrmoser for useful discussions, and A. Pniak for her comments on the case. This work was supported by the Polish Minister of Science under the ‘Regional Excellence Initiative’ program (project RID/SP/0015/2024/01). ChatGPT (OpenAI) was used to assist in refining the authors ideas, revising the language and providing feedback. The scientific ideas and results are those of the author.
Smeared contact term and GP beyond local approximation
Dependence on
The finite-radius calculation treats as a physical range of the regulated potential rather than a removable ultraviolet cutoff. To make its influence transparent we hold the tree-level dilaton relations fixed and repeat the first-threshold calculation for – fm in steps of fm. Selected results are given in Table 2, with the continuous scan in Figure 8. The nonmonotonicity in the column is not a numerical artifact: as the repulsive core shrinks from a large radius, its central height initially grows and can make the Yukawa interaction less effective, but at sufficiently small its physical reach disappears. Within the local approximation, the contact interaction is attractive, . At fixed negative , its shrinking spatial range leads to an increasingly deep potential well, which eventually supports bound states even without Yukawa attraction. Consequently, unlike the repulsive case, the critical dilaton scale does not approach the pure-Yukawa limit as . Instead, within the local model, asymptotically. This formal limit should not be regarded as a physical prediction, since the local approximation to crossed exchange is not controlled at arbitrarily small radii.
| [fm] | (local) | (crossed) | ||
| 0.05 | 0.433 | 0.6828 | 0.8215 | 0.7384 |
| 0.10 | 0.867 | 0.5877 | 0.8093 | 0.7093 |
| 0.15 | 1.300 | 0.6486 | 0.8029 | 0.8075 |
| 0.20 | 1.733 | 0.7364 | 0.7989 | 0.8716 |
| 0.25 | 2.166 | 0.7901 | 0.7963 | 0.9092 |
| 0.30 | 2.600 | 0.8241 | 0.7945 | 0.9329 |
| 0.35 | 3.033 | 0.8471 | 0.7933 | 0.9488 |
| 0.40 | 3.466 | 0.8633 | 0.7924 | 0.9600 |
Table 2. First-binding thresholds for the and systems at different contact radii, using the central lattice glueball masses of Chen et al.. For , the local approximation combines the short-distance contributions into a single contact term, whereas the crossed treatment retains the finite-range -channel pseudoscalar exchange. Both calculations use the same normalized top-hat profile for their respective contact interactions.
Figure 8. Sensitivity of the critical dilaton scale to the finite-core radius for the and local models. At fm, the first-threshold scale has a pronounced minimum. The benchmark fm is marked by the dotted vertical line. The horizontal reference is the limit as , namely the pure Yukawa critical GeV.
Note, the result beyond local approximation is also nonmonotonic and is discussed in A.3.
Different representations of the smeared contact term
Next, we turn to the representation of the contact term. In the main text we regularized the short-range interaction by means of the normalized top-hat distribution. One may, in addition, consider other normalized realizations of a short-range interaction, such as a Gaussian or an exponential form. Summarizing:
For a fixed value of , the corresponding potentials read
One may determine, as in the main text, the critical Yukawa strength for the onset of the first -wave bound state.
In Figure 9 we compare the resulting critical curves for the three realizations at the illustrative value . As expected, all curves meet at , where the contact term vanishes and one recovers the pure-Yukawa threshold. For a repulsive contact interaction (), the critical Yukawa strength shows a mild dependence on the shape of the regularized contact. At the common nominal width used here, the top-hat profile produces the largest critical attraction, followed by the Gaussian and the exponential profiles. Thus the top-hat repulsion most strongly hinders binding among the three realizations considered, reinforcing the conclusions in the main text. For an attractive contact interaction (), the additional short-range attraction lowers the critical Yukawa strength.
Figure 9. Critical Yukawa coupling as a function of for three normalized realizations of the smeared contact interaction at fixed : top-hat, Gaussian, and exponential. The three curves coincide at , where the contact term is absent.
Finite-range treatment of crossed pseudoscalar exchange
In Sec. 3.2, the -channel exchange of the pseudoscalar glueball was approximated by a contact interaction evaluated at threshold. Here we examine the effect of retaining its momentum dependence. This provides a test of the local approximation used in our main analysis.
The crossed contribution to the amplitude is
Unlike the -channel exchange, the -channel involves a nonzero energy transfer at threshold, . Neglecting recoil corrections, its nonrelativistic form reads
The corresponding interaction is nonlocal in the relative coordinate, acting as
For an wave, , so the crossed exchange reduces to an additional attractive Yukawa potential.
The resulting -wave interaction is therefore
The smeared repulsive contact contributions and are those defined in Eq. (43). Clearly, now the -channel contribution must not be included again in the contact coefficient. Indeed, its zero-momentum limit gives
recovering the local matching used in the main text.
For the central masses and GeV, we obtain
The range of the crossed Yukawa interaction is fm, shorter than the scalar Yukawa range fm.
We determine the first-binding threshold by solving the zero-energy radial equation for Eq. (63), using the same normalized top-hat profile for the remaining contact interaction. The results are compared with the local approximation in Table 2.
The two prescriptions lead to comparable but different numerical thresholds and, remarkably, to a qualitatively different dependence on . While the local approximation exhibits only a weak, nearly monotonic dependence, the explicit crossed-exchange potential develops a minimum, similarly to the case. Among the radii listed in Table 2, the minimum occurs at fm. A finer numerical scan places it near fm, where GeV. This nonmonotonic behavior reflects the competing effects of the finite-range Yukawa attractions and the remaining repulsive contact interaction, whose influence eventually vanishes as its spatial range shrinks.
The two prescriptions also differ in their formal zero-radius limit. In the local approximation, the attractive contact interaction leads to , which diverges as . When the crossed exchange is retained explicitly, however, the remaining contact interaction is repulsive and becomes ineffective in this limit. The potential then approaches the sum of two attractive Yukawa interactions, whose first-binding threshold is GeV for the central masses. These limiting results characterize the two potential models and should not be interpreted as predictions at arbitrarily small physical interaction radii.
The central lattice-matched scale GeV remains below all these critical values. Thus, the prediction of binding survives throughout the investigated range of contact radii, although the quantitative threshold is sensitive to the treatment of crossed exchange.
References
References
- [1]Vincent Mathieu, Nikolai Kochelev, and Vicente Vento. The physics of glueballs. Int. J. Mod. Phys. E, 18(1):1–49, 2009. doi:10.1142/S0218301309012124. arXiv:0810.4453.DOI
- [2]Wolfgang Ochs. The status of glueballs. J. Phys. G, 40:043001, 2013. doi:10.1088/0954-3899/40/4/043001. arXiv:1301.5183.DOI
- [3]Felipe J. Llanes-Estrada. Glueballs as the Ithaca of meson spectroscopy: From simple theory to challenging detection. Eur. Phys. J. ST, 230(6):1575–1592, 2021. doi:10.1140/epjs/s11734-021-00143-8. arXiv:2101.05366.
- [4]Cyrille Chevalier and Vincent Mathieu. Glueballs: hadrons without quarks, 2026. doi:10.48550/arXiv.2609.16790; arXiv:2609.16790.DOI
- [5]Colin J. Morningstar and Mike J. Peardon. The glueball spectrum from an anisotropic lattice study. Phys. Rev. D, 60:034509, 1999. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.60.034509. arXiv:hep-lat/9901004.DOI
- [6]Harvey B. Meyer. Glueball Regge trajectories. arXiv preprint, 2005. doi:10.48550/arXiv.hep-lat/0508002.DOI
- [7]Ying Chen et al. Glueball spectrum and matrix elements on anisotropic lattices. Phys. Rev. D, 73:014516, 2006. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.73.014516. URL https://arxiv.org/pdf/hep-lat/0510074.
- [8]Andreas Athenodorou and Michael Teper. The glueball spectrum of SU(3) gauge theory in 3 + 1 dimensions. JHEP, 11:172, 2020. doi:10.1007/JHEP11(2020)172. arXiv:2007.06422.DOI
- [9]Colin Morningstar. Update on Glueballs. PoS, LATTICE2024:004, 2025. doi:10.22323/1.466.0004. arXiv:2502.02547.DOI
- [10]Enrico Trotti, Shahryar Jafarzade, and Francesco Giacosa. Thermodynamics of the Glueball Resonance Gas. Eur. Phys. J. C, 83(5):390, 2023. doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-023-11557-0. arXiv:2212.03272.DOI
- [11]Francesco Giacosa, Alessandro Pilloni, and Enrico Trotti. Glueball–glueball scattering and the glueballonium. Eur. Phys. J. C, 82(5):487, 2022. doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-022-10403-z. arXiv:2110.05582.DOI
- [12]Feng-Kun Guo, Christoph Hanhart, Ulf-G Meißner, Qian Wang, Qiang Zhao, and Bing-Song Zou. Hadronic molecules. Reviews of Modern Physics, 90(1):015004, 2018. doi:https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.90.015004.
- [13]Christoph Hanhart. Hadronic molecules and multiquark states. Encyclopedia of Particle Physics, 2026. doi:10.1016/B978-0-443-26598-3.00018-3.DOI
- [14]Wolfgang Lucha and Franz F. Schöberl. Phenomenological aspects of nonrelativistic potential models. Technical Report HEPHY-PUB-527/89, UWThPh-1989-71, Institut für Hochenergiephysik and Universität Wien, Vienna, 1989. URL https://inspirehep.net/literature/286021.
- [15]W. Lucha, F. F. Schoberl, and D. Gromes. Bound states of quarks. Phys. Rept., 200:127–240, 1991. doi:10.1016/0370-1573(91)90001-3. URL https://inspirehep.net/literature/317049.
- [16]Eric Braaten and Hans-Werner Hammer. Universality in few-body systems with large scattering length. Phys. Rept., 428:259–390, 2006. doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2006.03.001. arXiv:cond-mat/0410417.DOI
- [17]Alexander A. Migdal and Mikhail A. Shifman. Dilaton Effective Lagrangian in Gluodynamics. Phys. Lett. B, 114:445–449, 1982. doi:10.1016/0370-2693(82)90089-2.DOI
- [18]A. Salomone, J. Schechter, and T. Tudron. Properties of Scalar Gluonium. Phys. Rev. D, 23:1143, 1981. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.23.1143.DOI
- [19]Hideki Yukawa. On the Interaction of Elementary Particles. I. Proc. Phys. Math. Soc. Jap., 17:48–57, 1935. doi:10.1142/ppmsj1919.17.0_48.
- [20]M. A. B. Beg and R. C. Furlong. λϕ⁴ theory in the nonrelativistic limit. Phys. Rev. D, 31:1370–1373, 1985. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.31.1370.DOI
- [21]R. Jackiw. Delta-function potentials in two- and three-dimensional quantum mechanics. Technical Report MIT-CTP-1937, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1991. URL https://lib-extopc.kek.jp/preprints/PDF/2000/0032/0032443.pdf. Contribution to the M. A. B. Bég Memorial Volume.
- [22]P. Gosdzinsky and R. Tarrach. Learning quantum field theory from elementary quantum mechanics. Am. J. Phys., 59:70–74, 1991. doi:10.1119/1.16691.DOI
- [23]Sydney Geltman. Bound States in Delta Function Potentials. J. At. Mol. Opt. Phys., 2011:573179, 2011. doi:10.1155/2011/573179.DOI
- [24]Aaron Farrell and Brandon P. van Zyl. s-wave scattering and the zero-range limit of the finite square well in arbitrary dimensions. Can. J. Phys., 88:817–824, 2010. doi:10.1139/P10-061. arXiv:1009.1918.DOI
- [25]Ph. de Forcrand, G. Schierholz, H. Schneider, and M. Teper. The 0++ glueball mass in su(3) lattice gauge theory: Towards definitive results. Phys. Lett. B, 152:107–112, 1985. doi:10.1016/0370-2693(85)91149-9.
- [26]Nodoka Yamanaka, Hideaki Iida, Atsushi Nakamura, and Masayuki Wakayama. Glueball scattering cross section in lattice SU(2) Yang–Mills theory. Phys. Rev. D, 102:054507, 2020. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.102.054507. arXiv:1910.07756.DOI
- [27]Nodoka Yamanaka, Hideaki Iida, Atsushi Nakamura, and Masayuki Wakayama. Dark matter scattering cross section and dynamics in dark Yang–Mills theory. Phys. Lett. B, 813:136056, 2021. doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2020.136056. arXiv:1910.01440.DOI
- [28]Nodoka Yamanaka, Hideaki Iida, Atsushi Nakamura, and Masayuki Wakayama. Interglueball potential in SU(N_c) lattice gauge theory. PoS, LATTICE2019:013, 2020. doi:10.22323/1.363.0013. arXiv:1911.03048.DOI
- [29]Min-Huan Chu, Jun-Hui Lai, Wei Wang, Jialu Zhang, and Qianteng Zhu. A comparative lattice analysis of SU(2) dark glueballs. Chin. Phys. C, 48:083108, 2024. doi:10.1088/1674-1137/ad4e24. arXiv:2402.03959.DOI
- [30]Ryan Abbott, Daniel C. Hackett, Dimitra A. Pefkou, Fernando Romero-López, and Phiala E. Shanahan. Lattice evidence that scalar glueballs are small. Phys. Rev. Lett., 136(4):041901, 2026. doi:10.48550/arXiv.2508.21821.arxiv.org/abs/2508.21821
- [31]Alexey A. Petrov. Glueball-meson molecules. Phys. Lett. B, 843:138030, 2023. doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2023.138030. arXiv:2204.11269.DOI
- [32]Yuki Amari, Muneto Nitta, Chihiro Sasaki, Kenta Shigaki, Satoshi Yano, and Shigehiro Yasui. Glueballonia as Hopfions. Phys. Lett. B, 867:139805, 2025. doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2025.139805.DOI
- [33]Andrea L. Guerrieri, Aditya Hebbar, and Balt C. van Rees. Constraining glueball couplings. Phys. Rev. D, 112(9):094023, 2025. doi:10.1103/f46t-xp36.DOI
- [34]Adamu Issifu, Orlando Oliveira, and Tobias Frederico. Effective field theory of scalar glueballs: Form factors and interaction radii. arXiv preprint arXiv:2610.01988 [hep-ph], 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/pdf/2610.01988.
- [35]James P. Edwards, Urs Gerber, Christian Schubert, Maria A. Trejo, and Axel Weber. The Yukawa potential: ground state energy and critical screening. Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys., 2017:083A01, 2017. doi:10.1093/ptep/ptx107. arXiv:1706.09979.DOI
- [36]Richard L. Hall. The Yukawa and Hulthén potentials in quantum mechanics. J. Phys. A: Math. Gen., 25:1373–1382, 1992. doi:10.1088/0305-4470/25/5/035.DOI
- [37]Yongyao Li, Xiangqian Luo, and Helmut Kröger. Bound states and critical behavior of the Yukawa potential. Sci. China Ser. G, 49:60–71, 2006. doi:10.1007/s11433-004-0020-5. arXiv:hep-ph/0407258.DOI
- [38]M. Napsuciale and S. Rodríguez. Complete analytical solution to the quantum Yukawa potential. Phys. Lett. B, 816:136218, 2021. doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2021.136218. arXiv:2012.12969.DOI
- [39]Michael Aizenman and Hugo Duminil-Copin. Marginal triviality of the scaling limits of critical 4D Ising and φ⁴ models. Annals of Mathematics, 194(1):163–235, 2021. doi:10.4007/annals.2021.194.1.3.DOI
- [40]Michael E. Peskin and Daniel V. Schroeder. An Introduction to quantum field theory. Addison-Wesley, Reading, USA, 1995. ISBN 978-0-201-50397-5.
- [41]Francesco Giacosa, Shahriyar Jafarzade, Győző Kovács, Péter Kovács, Robert D. Pisarski, and Fabian Rennecke. Glueballs and fractional anomalous determinants at nonzero θ, and the decays of the X(2370), 2026. doi:10.48550/arXiv.2610.00484; arXiv:2610.00484.DOI
- [42]Gerardus ’t Hooft. A planar diagram theory for strong interactions. Nucl. Phys. B, 72(3):461–473, 1974. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(74)90154-0.DOI
- [43]Francesco Giacosa. Introductory Visual Lecture on QCD at Large Nc: Bound States, Chiral Models, and Phase Diagram. Acta Phys. Polon. B, 55(4):4–A1, 2024. doi:10.5506/APhysPolB.55.4-A1. arXiv:2402.14097.DOI
- [44]Francesco Giacosa, Péter Kovács, and Shahriyar Jafarzade. Ordinary and exotic mesons in the extended Linear Sigma Model. Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys., 143:104176, 2025. doi:10.1016/j.ppnp.2025.104176.DOI
- [45]Denis Parganlija, Peter Kovacs, Gyorgy Wolf, Francesco Giacosa, and Dirk H. Rischke. Meson vacuum phenomenology in a three-flavor linear sigma model with (axial-)vector mesons. Phys. Rev. D, 87(1):014011, 2013. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.87.014011.DOI
- [46]Stanislaus Janowski, Francesco Giacosa, and Dirk H. Rischke. Is f0(1710) a glueball? Phys. Rev. D, 90(11):114005, 2014. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.90.114005.DOI
- [47]Enrico Trotti and Francesco Giacosa. On the mass of the glueballonium. Supl. Rev. Mex. Fis., 3(3):0308014, 2022. doi:10.31349/SuplRevMexFis.3.0308014. arXiv:2112.15010.DOI
- [48]Maxwell T. Hansen, Mattia Bruno, and Antonio Rago. Towards glueball scattering in lattice yang–mills theory, 2024. URL https://conference.ippp.dur.ac.uk/event/1265/contributions/7479/. Presentation at LATTICE2024, Liverpool, August 1, 2024.
- [49]Daisuke Kawai, Sinya Aoki, Takumi Doi, Yoichi Ikeda, Takashi Inoue, Takumi Iritani, Noriyoshi Ishii, Takaya Miyamoto, Hidekatsu Nemura, and Kenji Sasaki. I = 2 ππ scattering phase shift from the HAL QCD method with the LapH smearing. Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys., 2018:043B04, 2018. doi:10.1093/ptep/pty032. arXiv:1711.01883.DOI
- [50]C. Rosenzweig, A. Salomone, and J. Schechter. A Pseudoscalar Glueball, the Axial Anomaly and the Mixing Problem for Pseudoscalar Mesons. Phys. Rev. D, 24:2545–2548, 1981. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.24.2545.DOI
- [51]A. Masoni, C. Cicalo, and G. L. Usai. The case of the pseudoscalar glueball. J. Phys. G, 32:R293–R335, 2006. doi:10.1088/0954-3899/32/9/R01.DOI
- [52]Walaa I. Eshraim, Stanislaus Janowski, Francesco Giacosa, and Dirk H. Rischke. Decay of the pseudoscalar glueball into scalar and pseudoscalar mesons. Phys. Rev. D, 87(5):054036, 2013. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.87.054036. arXiv:1208.6474.
- [53]Francesco Giacosa, Michał Zakrzewski, Shahriyar Jafarzade, and Robert D. Pisarski. Emergence of the polydeterminant in QCD. Lett. Math. Phys., 115:119, 2025. doi:10.1007/s11005-025-02000-4. arXiv:2502.15617.DOI
- [54]M. Ablikim et al. Confirmation of the X(1835) and observation of the resonances X(2120) and X(2370) in J/ψ → γπ+π−η′. Phys. Rev. Lett., 106:072002, 2011. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.072002. arXiv:1012.3510.
- [55]M. Ablikim et al. Determination of Spin-Parity Quantum Numbers of X(2370) as 0+− from J/ψ → γK0SK0Sη′. Phys. Rev. Lett., 132:181901, 2024. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.181901. arXiv:2312.05324.
- [56]M. Ablikim et al. Observation of the X(2370) in J/ψ → γK⁰_S K⁰_S π⁰ and J/ψ → γπ⁰π⁰η. Chin. Phys. C, 50(10):101001, 2026. doi:10.1088/1674-1137/ae88acd. arXiv:2605.26495.
- [57]M. Ablikim et al. Lightest 0⁻⁺ Glueball as Dominant Constituent of X(2370), 2026. doi:10.48550/arXiv.2607.20366; arXiv:2607.20366.
- [58]Xun-Jie Xu and Bingrong Yu. On the short-range behavior of neutrino forces beyond the Standard Model: from 1/r⁵ to 1/r⁴, 1/r², and 1/r. JHEP, 02:008, 2022. doi:10.1007/JHEP02(2022)008. arXiv:2112.03060.DOI
- [59]Agata Pniak. Kula gluonowa pseudo-skalarna: zderzenia i stany związane (Pseudoscalar glueball: scattering and bound states). Master’s thesis, Jan Kochanowski University, Kielce, Poland, 2026. In Polish.
- [60]Adrian Koenigstein, Francesco Giacosa, and Dirk H. Rischke. Classical and quantum theory of the massive spin-two field. Annals Phys., 368:16–55, 2016. doi:10.1016/j.aop.2016.01.024.DOI
- [61]A Djuadi. The anatomy of electro–weak symmetry breaking, tome i: The higgs boson in the standard model. arXiv preprint hep-ph/0503172, 2005. URL https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2007.10.004.
- [62]Vanamali Shastry and Francesco Giacosa. Higgs–Higgs scattering and the (non-)existence of the Higgsionium. Eur. Phys. J. C, 83(8):713, 2023. doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-023-11883-3.DOI
- [63]R. N. Cahn and M. Suzuki. The Higgs - Higgs Bound State. Phys. Lett. B, 134:115–119, 1984. doi:10.1016/0370-2693(84)90997–3.DOI
- [64]J. A. Grifols. Higgsonium. Phys. Lett. B, 264:149–153, 1991. doi:10.1016/0370-2693(91)90719–7.DOI
- [65]L. Di Leo and Jurij W. Darewych. Bound states in the Higgs model. Phys. Rev. D, 49:1659–1662, 1994. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.49.1659.DOI







