betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Compatibility of recent ΞΞ-nuclear bound state signals

Abstract

J-PARC E05 reported recently a hint of a Ξ−−11BΞ^--{^{11}{\rm B}} nuclear state in the 12C(K−,K+)Ξ12Be{^{12}}{\rm C}(K^-,K^+){^{12}_Ξ}{\rm Be} spectrum, bound by BΞ−=8.9±1.4−3.1+3.8B_{Ξ^-}=8.9\pm 1.4 {^{+3.8}_{-3.1}} MeV. Using a density-dependent ΞΞ-nuclear optical potential VoptΞ(ρ)V_{\rm opt}^Ξ(ρ) we explore to what extent a Ξ1s−Ξ^-_{1s} assignment of this nuclear state is compatible with Ξ1s−Ξ^-_{1s} and Ξ1p−Ξ^-_{1p} nuclear-state interpretations of Ξ−Ξ^- capture events in light emulsion-nuclei experiments. We find that the only acceptable Ξ1s−Ξ^-_{1s} assignment at present, barring an abnormally strong repulsive ρ2ρ^2 component of VoptΞ(ρ)V_{\rm opt}^Ξ(ρ), is that for the Ξ−−11BΞ^--{^{11}{\rm B}} signal. This finding supports reassigning Ξ−Ξ^- capture events in 14^{14}N, originally assigned as Ξ1s−−14NΞ^-_{1s}-{^{14}{\rm N}} nuclear states, to Ξ1p0−14CΞ^0_{1p}-{^{14}{\rm C}} nuclear states. The depth of VoptΞ(ρ)V_{\rm opt}^Ξ(ρ) at nuclear-matter density ρ0=0.17ρ_0=0.17 fm−3^{-3} is then −VoptΞ(ρ0)∼21-V_{\rm opt}^Ξ(ρ_0)\sim 21 MeV.

Introduction

Little is known experimentally about the doubly strange (S=−2S = -2) ΛΛ\Lambda\Lambda and ΞN\Xi N two-baryon systems [1, 2]. The S=−2S = -2 dynamics is likely to play a decisive role in dense neutron-star matter, see Ref. [3] for a very recent discussion. Regarding the ΞN\Xi N interaction, a recent measurement of Ξ−p\Xi^{-}p correlations in pp-Pb ultra-relativistic collisions at the LHC [4, 5] established that the low-energy Ξ−p\Xi^{-}p interaction is attractive, in general agreement with HAL-QCD lattice QCD calculations [6]. No similar experimental verification is available yet for other charge states of the two-body ΞN\Xi N system. However, complementary information may be derived by studying Ξ\Xi-nuclear systems, which is the subject of the present work.

Very recently the J-PARC E05 experiment [7] reported a measurement of the 12C(K−,K+){}^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^{-},K^{+}) inclusive reaction spectrum at pK−=1.8 GeV/cp_{K^-}=1.8\ \mathrm{GeV}/c, with energy resolution of 8.2 MeV8.2\ \mathrm{MeV} (FWHM). Enhancements below and near the 12C(K−,K+)Ξ−12Be{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^{-},K^{+}){}^{12}_{\Xi^-}\mathrm{Be} continuum threshold were observed, see Figure 1. A hint of a Ξ−−11B\Xi^- - {}^{11}\mathrm{B} bound state at BΞ−=8.9±1.4−3.1+3.8 MeVB_{\Xi^-}=8.9\pm1.4^{+3.8}_{-3.1}\ \mathrm{MeV} was suggested for the lower enhancement, most likely a Ξ1s−−11B\Xi^-_{1s} - {}^{11}\mathrm{B} Jπ=1−J^\pi=1^- state [8]. Previous, poorer resolution 12C(K−,K+){}^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^-,K^+) experiments at KEK [9] and BNL [10, 11] did not observe it [1, 2]. The upper enhancement, at BΞ−=−2.4±1.3−1.2+2.8 MeVB_{\Xi^-}=-2.4\pm1.3^{+2.8}_{-1.2}\ \mathrm{MeV}, would then belong to the Ξ1p−−11B\Xi^-_{1p} - {}^{11}\mathrm{B} configuration, superposed on a sharply rising quasi-free excitation spectrum. It is dominated by a Jπ=2+J^\pi=2^+ state with a production cross section about 7 times larger than that of the Jπ=1−J^\pi=1^- member of the Ξ1s−−11B\Xi^-_{1s} - {}^{11}\mathrm{B} ground-state configuration [8].

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Best fit of J-PARC E05 12C(K−,K+){}^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^{-},K^{+}) endpoint spectrum [7]. Enhancements at BΞ−=8.9±1.4−3.1+3.8B_{\Xi^-}=8.9\pm1.4^{+3.8}_{-3.1} and BΞ−=−2.4±1.3−1.2+2.8 MeVB_{\Xi^-}=-2.4\pm1.3^{+2.8}_{-1.2}\ \mathrm{MeV} are marked in red, see text.

In this work we explore to what extent a Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s} assignment for the recent hint of a Ξ−−11B\Xi^- - {}^{11}\mathrm{B} nuclear state in the J-PARC E05 12C(K−,K+)Ξ−12Be{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^-,K^+){}^{12}_{\Xi^-}\mathrm{Be} end-point spectrum [7] is compatible with Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s} and Ξ1p−\Xi^-_{1p} nuclear-state interpretations of Ξ−\Xi^- capture events recorded in light emulsion-nuclei [12, 13, 14, 15]. To this end we use a density-dependent optical-potential Vopt(ρ)V_{\mathrm{opt}}(\rho) (Y=Y= hyperon) applied by us recently [16, 17] to Λ\Lambda hypernuclear states observed in several types of production experiments across the periodic table, as well as in a limited ited form to Ξ−\Xi^{-} hypernuclei [18]. In a subsequent work [19] we questioned Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s}–14N^{14}\mathrm{N} assignments of KEK-E373 and J-PARC E07 capture events in 14N^{14}\mathrm{N} made in Ref. [15]. Here we find that the only acceptable Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} assignment at present, barring an abnormally strong repulsive ρ2\rho^{2} component of VoptΞ(ρ)V^{\Xi}_{\mathrm{opt}}(\rho), is that for the J-PARC E05 Ξ−\Xi^{-}–11B^{11}\mathrm{B} bound-state signal. This finding supports reassigning Ξ−\Xi^{-} capture events in 14N^{14}\mathrm{N}, originally assigned as Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s}–14N^{14}\mathrm{N} nuclear states [15], to Ξ1p0\Xi^{0}_{1p}–14C^{14}\mathrm{C} nuclear states [19]. The depth of VoptΞ(ρ)V^{\Xi}_{\mathrm{opt}}(\rho) at nuclear-matter density ρ0=0.17 fm−3\rho_{0}=0.17\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3} is then −VoptΞ(ρ0)≈21 MeV-V^{\Xi}_{\mathrm{opt}}(\rho_{0})\approx21\ \mathrm{MeV}. Other theoretical works [20, 21, 22] using various many-body methodologies (RMF, SHF, AMD) while accepting one of the few reported binding-energy values for Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s}–14N^{14}\mathrm{N} [13, 15] find a smaller Ξ\Xi-nucleus potential depth of about 14 MeV, thereby predicting binding energy of only a few MeV for Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s}–11B^{11}\mathrm{B}.

Below we proceed as follows. In Sect. 2 we specify the density-dependent Ξ\Xi-nuclear optical potential VoptΞ(ρ)V^{\Xi}_{\mathrm{opt}}(\rho) used in the present work to calculate Ξ−\Xi^{-} nuclear binding energies. In Sect. 3 we list and discuss briefly the Ξ−\Xi^{-} capture data available in 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} and 14N^{14}\mathrm{N}, some of which are used alongside with the Ξ−\Xi^{-}–11B^{11}\mathrm{B} hint of a nuclear bound state reported recently by J-PARC E05 [7]. Results of Ξ−\Xi^{-} nuclear binding-energy calculations using VoptΞ(ρ)V^{\Xi}_{\mathrm{opt}}(\rho) are reported in Sect. 4 and concluding remarks are made in Sect. 5.

Optical potential methodology

Ξ−\Xi^{-} atomic and nuclear bound states in N=ZN=Z nuclei such as 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} and 14N^{14}\mathrm{N} are calculated using a finite-size Coulomb potential VcΞ−V^{\Xi^{-}}_{\mathrm{c}}, including vacuum-polarization terms, plus a Ξ\Xi-nuclear density-dependent optical potential,

VoptΞ(ρ)=VΞ(2)(ρ)+VΞ(3)(ρ),(1)V^{\Xi}_{\mathrm{opt}}(\rho)=V^{(2)}_{\Xi}(\rho)+V^{(3)}_{\Xi}(\rho), \tag*{(1)}

consisting of terms representing two-body ΞN\Xi N and three-body ΞNN\Xi NN interactions:

VΞ(2)(ρ)=−4π2μΞfA(2)b0A(ρ)ρ,(2)V^{(2)}_{\Xi}(\rho)=-\frac{4\pi}{2\mu_{\Xi}}f^{(2)}_{A}b^{A}_{0}(\rho)\rho, \tag*{(2)}
VΞ(3)(ρ)=+4π2μΞfA(3)B0ρ2ρ0,(3)V^{(3)}_{\Xi}(\rho)=+\frac{4\pi}{2\mu_{\Xi}}f^{(3)}_{A}B_{0}\frac{\rho^{2}}{\rho_{0}}, \tag*{(3)}

with strength parameters b0A(ρ),B0b^{A}_{0}(\rho),B_{0} in units of fm (ℏ=c=1\hbar=c=1). In these expressions AA is the mass number of the nuclear core, ρ\rho is a nuclear density normalized to AA, μΞ\mu_{\Xi} is the Ξ−\Xi^{-}-nucleus reduced mass and fA(2,3)f^{(2,3)}_{A} are kinematical factors transforming b0A(ρ)b_0^A(\rho) and B0B_0 from the ΞN\Xi N and ΞNN\Xi NN center-of-mass (c.m.) systems, respectively, to the Ξ\Xi-nucleus c.m. system:

fA(2)=1+A−1AμΞmN,fA(3)=1+A−2AμΞ2mN.(4)f_A^{(2)} = 1 + \frac{A-1}{A}\frac{\mu_{\Xi}}{m_N}, \qquad f_A^{(3)} = 1 + \frac{A-2}{A}\frac{\mu_{\Xi}}{2m_N}. \tag*{(4)}

The effective density-dependent ΞN\Xi N isoscalar c.m. scattering amplitude b0A(ρ)b_0^A(\rho) is given by

b0A(ρ)=Re⁡b01+(3kF/2π)fA(2)Re⁡b0+iIm⁡b0,(5)b_0^A(\rho) = \frac{\operatorname{Re} b_0}{1 + (3k_F/2\pi)f_A^{(2)}\operatorname{Re} b_0} + i\operatorname{Im} b_0, \tag*{(5)}

where kFk_F is the Fermi momentum associated with density ρ\rho: kF=(3π2ρ/2)1/3k_F = (3\pi^2\rho/2)^{1/3}. The density dependence of b0A(ρ)b_0^A(\rho) accounts for long-range Pauli correlations in ΞN\Xi N in-medium multiple scatterings, starting at ρ4/3\rho^{4/3} in a nuclear-density expansion [23, 24] as practised in our K−K^--atom studies [25]. Introducing it also in VΞ(3)V_{\Xi}^{(3)} makes little difference, which is why it is skipped in Eq. (3). Short-range NNNN correlations, starting at order ρ2\rho^2 of the optical-potential density expansion, have little effect at densities below ρ0\rho_0 where the main contribution arises in the present context from three-body ΞNN\Xi NN interactions. Precisely the same functional form of Vopt(ρ)V_{\rm opt}(\rho), including V(3)(ρ)V^{(3)}(\rho), was used by us recently for constructing the Λ\Lambda-nuclear optical potential VoptΛ(ρ)V_{\rm opt}^{\Lambda}(\rho) [16, 17]. Three-body YNNYNN interactions appear at order N2^2LO in EFT formulations and are promoted to NLO by adding the baryon SU(3) decuplet to the ground-state octet [26]. For Y=ΞY = \Xi, ΞN1N2\Xi N_1N_2 interactions occur by exciting the octet Ξ\Xi hyperon to a decuplet Ξ∗(1530)\Xi^*(1530) hyperon on nucleon N1N_1, ΞN1→Ξ∗N1\Xi N_1 \to\Xi^*N_1, and deexciting it back to Ξ\Xi on nucleon N2N_2, Ξ∗N2→ΞN2\Xi^*N_2 \to\Xi N_2.

The nuclear densities ρ(r)=ρp(r)+ρn(r)\rho(r) = \rho_p(r) + \rho_n(r) used by us to construct VoptΞ(ρ)V_{\rm opt}^{\Xi}(\rho) are harmonic-oscillator type densities with the same radial parameters for neutrons and protons [27]. The corresponding r.m.s. radii follow closely values derived from experiment by relating proton densities ρp(r)\rho_p(r) to charge densities and including the proton charge finite size and recoil effects. This approach is equivalent to assigning some finite range to the ΞN\Xi N interaction. Folding reasonably chosen ΞN\Xi N interaction ranges other than corresponding to the proton charge radius, varying the spatial form of the charge density, or introducing realistic differences between neutron and proton r.m.s. radii, made little difference. In Ξ1p−(12C)\Xi^-_{1p}({}^{12}\mathrm{C}), for example, all such calculated binding energies varied within 20% of the ±0.15\pm0.15 MeV measurement uncertainty of BΞ−1p(12C)B_{\Xi^-}^{1p}({}^{12}\mathrm{C}). Finally, a fairly small absorptivity, Im⁡b0=0.01\operatorname{Im} b_0 = 0.01 fm in Eq. (5), was assumed in all of the fits shown and discussed below. Using only VΞ(2)V_{\Xi}^{(2)}, BΞ−1p(12C)=0.82±0.15B_{\Xi^-}^{1p}({}^{12}\mathrm{C})=0.82\pm0.15 MeV was fitted by Re⁡b0=0.495±0.030\operatorname{Re} b_0=0.495\pm0.030 fm; doubling Im⁡b0\operatorname{Im} b_0 was found to increase the fitted value of Re⁡b0\operatorname{Re} b_0 by only 1% [18]. Such small absorptivities reflect the small statistical weight, 1/16 in nuclear matter, of the S=I=0S=I=0 ΞN\Xi N channel in which ΞN→ΛΛ\Xi N\to\Lambda\Lambda conversion occurs.

Ξ−\Xi^- nuclear capture events input

Ξ−\Xi^- capture events identified during the last three decades in light (C,N,O) emulsion nuclei at KEK and J-PARC provide evidence for Ξ−\Xi^- nuclear states bound by about 1 MeV in 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} [12] and in 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} [12, 13, 14]. Ξ−\Xi^- atomic cascade in these light emulsion nuclei terminates normally with a 3D→2P3D\to2P radiative E1E1 atomic transition [28] and the formed Ξ1p−\Xi^-_{1p} Coulomb-assisted nuclear states undergo hadronic capture driven by a Ξ−p→ΛΛ\Xi^-p\to\Lambda\Lambda strong-interaction conversion. Forming radiatively Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} nuclear bound states is suppressed by almost two orders of magnitude [29, 30]. Hence, recent Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} assignments of two capture events in 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} by J-PARC E07 [15] are questionable. The reported Ξ−\Xi^{-}–14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} spectrum is shown in Figure 2. Here we focus on two out of the four capture events, IBUKI for Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p} and IRRAWADDY assigned as Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s}. The other two events agree with the former ones, KISO with IBUKI and KINKA with IRRAWADDY, provided the smaller BΞ−B_{\Xi^{-}} value is chosen for KISO and for KINKA respectively.

Figure 2. Ξ−−14N\Xi^- - {}^{14}\mathrm{N} spectrum deduced from Ξ−\Xi^- capture events identified by their twin-Λ\Lambda hypernuclear decays in KEK-E373 and J-PARC E07 emulsion experiments, see text. Figure provided by Dr. Kazuma Nakazawa, based on recent results from Refs. [13, 14, 15].

Thus, there are two Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} nuclear candidates: (i) the J-PARC E07 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} capture event IRRAWADDY and (ii) the J-PARC E05 hint of a bound state in the 12C(K−,K+){}^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^{-},K^{+}) inclusive spectrum, with binding energies

BΞ−1s(14N)=6.27±0.27 MeV,BΞ−1s(11B)=8.9±3.7 MeV,(6)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}({}^{14}\mathrm{N}) = 6.27 \pm0.27\ \mathrm{MeV}, \qquad B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B}) = 8.9 \pm3.7\ \mathrm{MeV}, \tag*{(6)}

where statistical and systematic uncertainties were added quadratically for BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B}). We note that the more bound of these two Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s}-assumed states appears to be in the lighter 11B{}^{11}\mathrm{B} nucleus rather than in the heavier 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} nucleus. This contrasts the steady increase with AA of BΛ(A)B_{\Lambda}(A) in Λ\Lambda hypernuclei [1]. Nevertheless, as demonstrated in the next section, the fairly large BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B}) uncertainty of ±3.7\pm3.7 MeV prevents one from making definite statements on this issue. An improved resolution (K−,K+)(K^{-},K^{+}) experiment such as J-PARC E70 [31] is called for, as well as state-of-the-art few-body calculations of these Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} candidates. Unfortunately, calculations using the HAL-QCD ΞN\Xi N interaction [32, 33] or χ\chiEFT at NLO [34] have not reached to date sufficiently high values of AA required to explore this issue.

In addition to Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} one needs also some Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p} binding-energy input to assess the relative weights of VΞ−(2)(ρ)V_{\Xi^{-}}^{(2)}(\rho), Eqs. (2),(5), and VΞ−(3)(ρ)V_{\Xi^{-}}^{(3)}(\rho), Eq. (3). The only available Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p} nuclear candidates are in 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} [12] and in 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} [12, 13, 14]. However, Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p}–14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} states are expected to spread out over a range somewhat larger than 1.2 MeV owing mostly to a quadrupole-quadrupole (QΞ⋅QNQ_{\Xi}\cdot Q_{N}) residual interaction unaccounted for by VoptΞ(ρ)V_{\mathrm{opt}}^{\Xi}(\rho) [18]. This QΞ⋅QNQ_{\Xi}\cdot Q_{N} interaction affects Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p} states attached to nuclear levels with total angular momentum values JA≥1J_{A}\geq1, as in 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} with Jg.s.π=1+J_{\mathrm{g.s.}}^{\pi}=1^{+}. For comparison, the splitting of the Jπ=(12−,32−)J^{\pi}=\left(\frac{1}{2}^{-},\frac{3}{2}^{-}\right) spin-orbit doublet in Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p}–12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} is not expected to go beyond its experimental uncertainty of ±0.15\pm0.15 MeV. Hence, out of the two Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p} candidates we keep only the Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p}–12C^{12}\mathrm{C} state with Ξ−\Xi^{-} binding energy given by

BΞ−1p(12C)=0.82±0.15 MeV.(7)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C}) = 0.82 \pm0.15\ \mathrm{MeV}. \tag*{(7)}

Results

In this section, using VoptΞ−(ρ)V_{\mathrm{opt}}^{\Xi^{-}}(\rho), we study to what extent the three BΞ−B_{\Xi^{-}} values listed in Eqs. (6),(7) are compatible with each other. We also estimate spin and isospin dependent contributions to BΞ−B_{\Xi^{-}} of the Jπ=1−J^{\pi}=1^{-} level of Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s}–11B^{11}\mathrm{B} observed by J-PARC E05. Preliminary partial results were presented in MESON 2023 [35].

Compatibility

Two Ξ\Xi-nuclear scenarios are outlined in Table 1. Choosing BΞ−1p(12C)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C}), Eq. (7), to fit the strength b0b_{0} of the attractive ΞN\Xi N-induced component VΞ−(2)(ρ)V_{\Xi^{-}}^{(2)}(\rho), Eqs. (2),(5), results in Ξ−\Xi^{-} nuclear binding energies listed in the first row. Choosing instead BΞ−1s(14N)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}(^{14}\mathrm{N}) from Eq. (6) results in values listed in the second row. Clearly, a single VΞ−(2)(ρ)V_{\Xi^{-}}^{(2)}(\rho) component of VoptΞ−(ρ)V_{\mathrm{opt}}^{\Xi^{-}}(\rho) is incapable of reproducing both given BΞ−1p(12C)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C}) and BΞ−1s(14N)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}(^{14}\mathrm{N}) values. Moreover, each of these two choices predicts completely different values for BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}(^{11}\mathrm{B}) and for the Ξ\Xi-nuclear attractive potential depth DΞ−(2)D_{\Xi^{-}}^{(2)}. We note in passing that the Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p}–12C^{12}\mathrm{C} capture event constrained by IRRAWADDY (second row) comes out hardly bound, by about 37±437\pm4 keV, with respect to a purely Coulomb 2P2P atomic state from which it evolves when VoptΞ−(ρ)V_{\mathrm{opt}}^{\Xi^{-}}(\rho) is switched on. The listed calculated BΞ−1p(12C)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C}) value strongly disagrees, by about 0.50.5 MeV, with the KEK-E176 [12] input value listed in boldface in the first row.

BΞ−1p(12C)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C})BΞ−1s(14N)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}(^{14}\mathrm{N})BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}(^{11}\mathrm{B})b0b_{0}DΞ−(2)D_{\Xi^{-}}^{(2)}
0.82±0.150.82 \pm0.1511.8±0.611.8 \pm0.69.03±0.529.03\pm0.520.495±0.0300.495\pm0.03021.2±0.721.2\pm0.7
0.320±0.0040.320 \pm0.0046.27±0.276.27 \pm0.274.20±0.254.20\pm0.250.247±0.0110.247\pm0.01113.6±0.413.6\pm0.4

Table 1. Input (boldface) and calculated values of Ξ−\Xi^{-} binding energies (MeV) in optical potential fits limited to VΞ−(2)(ρ)V_{\Xi^{-}}^{(2)}(\rho) with a strength parameter b0b_{0} (fm). Resulting potential depths are DΞ−(2)=−VΞ−(2)(ρ0)D_{\Xi^{-}}^{(2)}=-V_{\Xi^{-}}^{(2)}(\rho_{0}) (MeV) at ρ0=0.17 fm−3\rho_{0}=0.17\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3}.

Complementary to Table 1 are level-width values which were calculated for our standard choice of absorptivity in Eq. (5), Im⁡b0=0.01 fm\operatorname{Im} b_{0}=0.01\ \mathrm{fm}. These are ΓΞ−1p(12C)=0.23\Gamma_{\Xi^-}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C})=0.23 MeV and ΓΞ−1s(11B)=0.92\Gamma_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{11}\mathrm{B})=0.92 MeV for line 1 in the table, and ΓΞ−1s(14N)=0.87\Gamma_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{14}\mathrm{N})=0.87 MeV for line 2. These width values vary linearly to a good approximation with the input value of Im⁡b0\operatorname{Im} b_0 which was varied up to Im⁡b0=0.04\operatorname{Im} b_0=0.04 fm. The effect of absorptivity within this range of Im⁡b0\operatorname{Im} b_0 values on the calculated BΞ−B_{\Xi^-} values is small, well within the quoted experimental uncertainties.

Next, we add BΞ−1s(11B)=8.9±δBB_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{11}\mathrm{B})=8.9\pm\delta B (MeV) to the input values BΞ−1p(12C)B_{\Xi^-}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C}) and BΞ−1s(14N)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{14}\mathrm{N}) boldfaced in Table 1, attempting to fit these three binding energies simultaneously in terms of two strength parameters, b0b_0 and B0B_0, of an attractive ΞN\Xi N-induced component VΞ(2)(ρ)V_{\Xi}^{(2)}(\rho) plus a repulsive ΞNN\Xi NN-induced component VΞ(3)(ρ)V_{\Xi}^{(3)}(\rho), respectively, of VoptΞV_{\mathrm{opt}}^{\Xi}. This gives rise to a substantial repulsive partial depth DΞ(3)D_{\Xi}^{(3)} that cancels out almost completely the excessively large attractive partial depth DΞ(2)D_{\Xi}^{(2)}, as shown in Table 2 for two choices of the experimental uncertainty: δB=3.7\delta B=3.7 MeV for the J-PARC E05 nominal uncertainty, and reducing it to 1.4 MeV by suppressing its systematic component. We note that the fitted b0b_0 and B0B_0 are 100% anti-correlated and hence the partial potential depths DΞ(2)D_{\Xi}^{(2)} and DΞ(3)D_{\Xi}^{(3)} are also 100% anti-correlated.

δB\delta Bχ2\chi^2b0b_0B0B_0DΞ(2)D_{\Xi}^{(2)}DΞ(3)D_{\Xi}^{(3)}DΞD_{\Xi}
3.70.991.13±0.201.13\pm0.200.54±0.080.54\pm0.0831.0−2.2+1.831.0^{+1.8}_{-2.2}29.0±4.329.0\pm4.32.0−2.5+2.12.0^{+2.1}_{-2.5}
1.46.801.16±0.511.16\pm0.510.54±0.210.54\pm0.2131.3−6.8+3.831.3^{+3.8}_{-6.8}29.0±11.329.0\pm11.32.3−7.5+4.52.3^{+4.5}_{-7.5}

Table 2. Optical potential fits of three BΞ−B_{\Xi^-} input values: BΞ−1p(12C)B_{\Xi^-}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C}), BΞ−1s(14N)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{14}\mathrm{N}) (boldfaced in Table 1) and BΞ−1s(11B)=8.9±δBB_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{11}\mathrm{B})=8.9\pm\delta B (MeV). χ2\chi^2 values are listed along with fitted strength parameters b0b_0, B0B_0 (fm) and their respective Ξ\Xi-nuclear potential depths: DΞ(2)=−VΞ(2)(ρ0)D_{\Xi}^{(2)}=-V_{\Xi}^{(2)}(\rho_0), DΞ(3)=VΞ(3)(ρ0)D_{\Xi}^{(3)}=V_{\Xi}^{(3)}(\rho_0) (MeV) at ρ0=0.17 fm−3\rho_0=0.17\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3}. The total depth (positive) is DΞ=DΞ(2)−DΞ(3)D_{\Xi}=D_{\Xi}^{(2)}-D_{\Xi}^{(3)}.

The χ2≈1\chi^2\approx1 listed in the first row of Table 2 is perfectly acceptable for a two-parameter three-data-points fit. The relatively large fitted values for both b0b_0 and B0B_0 are needed to make the input values of BΞ−1p(12C)B_{\Xi^-}^{1p}(^{12}\mathrm{C}) and BΞ−1s(14N)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{14}\mathrm{N}) compatible with each other. The high value of χ2≈7\chi^2\approx7 for one degree of freedom in the second-row fit makes it unacceptable, implying that an improved resolution (K−,K+K^-,K^+) experiment is necessary to demonstrate the incompatibility of the present values of BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{11}\mathrm{B}) and BΞ−1s(14N)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}(^{14}\mathrm{N}).

Finally, we note that the ΞNN\Xi NN-induced repulsive VΞ(3)V_{\Xi}^{(3)} contribution to the BΞ−1sB_{\Xi^-}^{1s} values listed in Table 2 is huge, about 13±113\pm1 MeV in 11B^{11}\mathrm{B} and 14N^{14}\mathrm{N}, as estimated by switching off VΞ(3)V_{\Xi}^{(3)} in the Ξ−\Xi^- bound-state calculations. This is roughly factor of 3 larger than ΛNN\Lambda NN repulsive contributions evaluated along time ago in pp-shell Λ\Lambda hypernuclei [36], consistently with the corresponding ratio of three-body repulsive potential depths: DΞ(3)∼30D_{\Xi}^{(3)} \sim30 MeV listed in the table to DΛ(3)∼10D_{\Lambda}^{(3)} \sim10 MeV repulsion obtained by fitting recently BΛB_{\Lambda} data across the periodic table [16, 17]. A ratio that large goes against one’s normal expectation that YNYN and YNNYNN potential contributions decrease with increasing strangeness ∣S∣\lvert S\rvert [37].

Spin and isospin contributions to BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B})

To estimate spin and isospin contributions to BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B}) we start from the most general spin and isospin dependent ss-wave ΞN\Xi N interaction:

VΞN=V0+Vσσ⃗Ξ⋅σ⃗N+Vττ⃗Ξ⋅τ⃗N+Vστσ⃗Ξ⋅σ⃗Nτ⃗Ξ⋅τ⃗N.(8)V_{\Xi N}=V_{0}+V_{\sigma}\vec{\sigma}_{\Xi}\cdot\vec{\sigma}_{N}+V_{\tau}\vec{\tau}_{\Xi}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{N}+V_{\sigma\tau}\vec{\sigma}_{\Xi}\cdot\vec{\sigma}_{N}\vec{\tau}_{\Xi}\cdot\vec{\tau}_{N}. \tag*{(8)}

The Ξ\Xi nucleus optical potential VΞ(2)(ρ)V_{\Xi}^{(2)}(\rho) used in Table 1 to evaluate values of BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B}) accounts only for the spin-isospin independent term V0V_{0} of VΞNV_{\Xi N} in Eq. (8). It disregards spin-isospin dependent terms specified by VσV_{\sigma}, VτV_{\tau} and VστV_{\sigma\tau}. Using HAL-QCD [6] ratios of volume integrals of Vσ(rΞN)V_{\sigma}(r_{\Xi N}), Vτ(rΞN)V_{\tau}(r_{\Xi N}) and Vστ(rΞN)V_{\sigma\tau}(r_{\Xi N}) to that of V0(rΞN)V_{0}(r_{\Xi N}), we estimate energy shifts and splitting of the 1sΞ−1s_{\Xi^-} Jπ=(1−,2−)J^{\pi}=(1^-,2^-) g.s. doublet levels in Ξ−−11B\Xi^- -{}^{11}\mathrm{B}. We find that the VτV_{\tau} term makes both 1−1^- and 2−2^- levels less bound by about 0.5 MeV with respect to the BΞ−1s(11B)B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B}) value listed in Table 1, whereas the VσV_{\sigma} and VστV_{\sigma\tau} terms push the 1−1^- level about 0.5 MeV deeper, back to BΞ−1s(11B)=9B_{\Xi^-}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B})=9 MeV listed in Table 1. The 2−2^- level becomes then less bound by about 0.3 MeV, lying altogether about 0.8 MeV above the Ξ1s−−11B\Xi^-_{1s}-{}^{11}\mathrm{B} 1−1^- g.s.

Concluding remarks

In this work we explored to what extent a Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s} assignment for the recent ‘hint’ of a Ξ−−11B\Xi^- -{}^{11}\mathrm{B} nuclear state in the J-PARC E05 12C(K−,K+)Ξ12Be^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^-,K^+){}^{12}_{\Xi}\mathrm{Be} end-point spectrum [7] is compatible with Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s} and Ξ1p−\Xi^-_{1p} nuclear-state interpretations of Ξ−\Xi^- capture events seen in light emulsion-nuclei [12, 13, 14, 15]. We used for this purpose a density-dependent optical-potential methodology applied by us recently to Λ\Lambda hypernuclear states extracted from several types of production experiments across the periodic table [16, 17]. This methodology was applied as well to Ξ−\Xi^- hypernuclei using scarce Ξ−\Xi^- capture events data derived by observing weak-decay products following Ξ−\Xi^- capture in light emulsion nuclei [18, 19]. Unfortunately, assignments made to such Ξ−\Xi^--nuclear states are not necessarily unique. One conclusion that may be drawn from the present work is that confirming a Ξ−\Xi^{-} nuclear state with BΞ−∼9B_{\Xi^{-}} \sim9 MeV in a good-resolution 12C(K−,K+){}^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^{-}, K^{+}) experiment will rule out definitively a Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s}–14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} assignment for the KINKA and IRRAWADDY Ξ−\Xi^{-} capture events in 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N}. A perfectly natural assignment of Ξ1p0\Xi^{0}_{1p}–14C{}^{14}\mathrm{C} for these events was already discussed by us in Ref. [19]. Another consequence of confirming BΞ−1s(11B)∼9B_{\Xi^{-}}^{1s}({}^{11}\mathrm{B}) \sim9 MeV would be that only little ΞNN\Xi NN three-body contribution is needed, if at all, to determine the Ξ\Xi-nuclear potential depth at normal nuclear density, here found to be approximately 21 MeV (attraction).

Our well-depth value is within the range of values 17±617 \pm6 MeV derived in Ref. [38] from a K+K^{+} quasi-free spectrum measured by BNL-AGS E906 in (K−,K+)(K^{-}, K^{+}) on 9Be{}^{9}\mathrm{Be} [11], covering also deductions made from KEK-E224 [9] and BNL-AGS E885 [10] on 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} targets. On the other hand, a value of 21 MeV is considerably larger than reported in some recent model evaluations, e.g., HAL-QCD [39]: 4 MeV, χ\chiEFT@NLO [40]: 9 MeV, and SU(6) [41]: 6 MeV. A notable exception is provided by versions ESC16*(A,B) of the latest Nijmegen extended-soft-core ΞN\Xi N interaction model [42] where Ξ\Xi-nuclear potential depths larger than 20 MeV are derived. However, these large values are reduced substantially by ΞNN\Xi NN three-body contributions within the same ESC16* model.

Acknowledgments

This work started as part of a project funded by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research & innovation programme, grant agreement 824093.

References

  1. [1]A. Gal, E.V. Hungerford, D.J. Millener, Rev. Mod. Phys. 88 (2016) 035004.
  2. [2]E. Hiyama, K. Nakazawa, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 68 (2018) 131.
  3. [3]I. Vidana, V. Mantovani Sarti, J. Haidenbauer, D.L. Mihaylov, L. Fabbietti, Eur. Phys. J. A 61 (2025) 59.
  4. [4]S. Acharya, et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 123 (2019) 112002.
  5. [5]S. Acharya, et al. (ALICE Collaboration), Nature 588 (2020) 232.
  6. [6]K. Sasaki, et al. (HAL QCD Collaboration), Nucl. Phys. A 998 (2020) 121737.
  7. [7]Y. Ichikawa, et al. (J-PARC E05), Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2024 (2024) 091D01.
  8. [8]C.B. Dover, A. Gal, Ann. Phys. (NY) 146 (1983) 309; see in particular Fig. 12.
  9. [9]T. Fukuda, et al. (KEK E224), Phys. Rev. C 58 (1998) 1306.
  10. [10]P. Khaustov, et al. (BNL-AGS E885), Phys. Rev. C 61 (2000) 054603.
  11. [11]J.K. Ahn, et al. (BNL-AGS E906), Phys. Rev. Lett. 87 (2001) 132504.
  12. [12]S. Aoki, et al. (KEK E176), Nucl. Phys. A 828 (2009) 191, and earlier E176 publications cited therein.
  13. [13]K. Nakazawa, et al. (KEK PS-E373), Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2015 (2015) 033D02.
  14. [14]S.H. Hayakawa, et al. (J-PARC E07), Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 (2021) 062501.
  15. [15]M. Yoshimoto, et al. (J-PARC E07), Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2021 (2021) 073D02.
  16. [16]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 837 (2023) 137669.
  17. [17]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Nucl. Phys. A 1039 (2023) 122725.
  18. [18]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 820 (2021) 136555.
  19. [19]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 837 (2023) 137640.
  20. [20]T.T. Sun, E. Hiyama, H. Sagawa, H.-J. Schulze, J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 94 (2016) 064319.
  21. [21]Y. Tanimura, H. Sagawa, T.T. Sun, E. Hiyama, Phys. Rev. C 105 (2022) 044324.
  22. [22]M. Isaka, T. Tada, M. Kimura, Y. Yamamoto, Phys. Rev. C 109 (2024) 044317.
  23. [23]C.B. Dover, J. Hüfner, R.H. Lemmer, Ann. Phys. (NY) 66 (1971) 248.
  24. [24]T. Waas, M. Rho, W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 617 (1997) 449.
  25. [25]E. Friedman, A. Gal, Nucl. Phys. A 959 (2017) 66, and references listed there to earlier work on K⁻ atoms.
  26. [26]S. Petschauer, J. Haidenbauer, N. Kaiser, U.-G. Meißner, W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 957 (2017) 347.
  27. [27]L.R.B Elton, Nuclear Sizes, Oxford University Press, 1961.
  28. [28]C.J. Batty, E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Rev. C 59 (1999) 295.
  29. [29]D. Zhu, C.B. Dover, A. Gal, M. May, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 2268.
  30. [30]T. Koike, JPS Conf. Proc. 17 (2017) 033011.
  31. [31]T. Gogami (for the S-2S Collaboration), J-PARC E70 presentation at the 38th J-PARC PAC (2024).
  32. [32]E. Hiyama, K. Sasaki, T. Miyamoto, T. Doi, T. Hatsuda, Y. Yamamoto, Th.A. Rijken, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 (2020) 092501.
  33. [33]E. Hiyama, M. Isaka, T. Doi, T. Hatsuda, Phys. Rev. C 106 (2022) 064318.
  34. [34]H. Le, J. Haidenbauer, Ulf-G. Meißner, A. Nogga, Eur. Phys. J. A 57 (2021) 339.
  35. [35]E. Friedman, A. Gal, EPJ Web of Conf. 291 (2024) 05001.
  36. [36]A. Gal, J.M. Soper, R.H. Dalitz, Ann. Phys. (NY) 63 (1971) 53, 72 (1972) 445, 113 (1978) 79.
  37. [37]C.B. Dover, H. Feshbach, Ann. Phys. (NY) 217 (1992) 51.
  38. [38]T. Harada, Y. Hirabayashi, Phys. Rev. C 103 (2021) 024605.
  39. [39]T. Inoue (for the HAL-QCD Collaboration), AIP Conf. Proc. 2130 (2019) 020002.
  40. [40]M. Kohno, Phys. Rev. C 100 (2019) 024313.
  41. [41]T. Gaitanos, A. Chorozidou, Nucl. Phys. A 1008 (2021) 122153.
  42. [42]M.M. Nagels, Th.A. Rijken, Y. Yamamoto, Phys. Rev. C 102 (2020) 054003.

Paper details

vlnc:W_drnrht5r
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents