WorksMathematics
Topology optimization for microchannel heat sinks with nanofluids using an Eulerian-Eulerian approach
Abstract
The demand for high-performance heat sinks has significantly increased with advancements in computing power and the miniaturization of electronic devices. Among the promising solutions, nanofluids have attracted considerable attention due to their superior thermal conductivity. However, designing a flow field that effectively utilizes nanofluids remains a significant challenge due to the complex interactions between fluid and nanoparticles. In this study, we propose a density-based topology optimization method for microchannel heat sink design using nanofluids. An Eulerian-Eulerian framework is utilized to simulate the behavior of nanofluids, and the optimization problem aims to maximize heat transfer performance under a fixed pressure drop. In numerical examples, we investigate the dependence of the optimized configuration on various parameters and apply the method to the design of a manifold microchannel heat sink. The parametric study reveals that the number of flow branches increases with the increased pressure drop but decreases as the particle volume fraction increases. In the heat sink design, the topology-optimized flow field achieves an 11.6% improvement in heat transfer performance compared to a conventional parallel flow field under identical nanofluid conditions.
Introduction
The increasing computational demands and trend toward highly integrated circuits have led to a rise in the power consumption of electronic devices. Thermal dissipation has become a critical concern due to high heat flux generation and the miniaturization of electronic devices [1]. To address this issue, the microchannel heat sink (MCHS), first proposed by Tuckerman and Pease [2], has become an attractive solution due to its high heat transfer performance and compact size [3]. Over the past decades, numerous studies have sought to improve MCHS from various perspectives, including operating conditions [4, 5], coolant types [6, 7], material selection [8, 9, 10], and channel configurations [11, 12, 13].
In terms of coolants, nanofluids introduced by Choi and Eastman [14] have attracted significant attention due to their superior heat transfer properties. The fundamental concept of nanofluids is to disperse nanoscale particles into a base fluid to enhance heat transfer performance, and they have been widely applied in the field of heat dissipation [15, 16, 17]. Although typical flow field designs—such as parallel [18], fin-and-pin [19], and wavy [20]—are widely employed with nanofluids, the complex interactions between nanoparticles and the base fluid present significant challenges in designing efficient flow fields for nanofluids. Meanwhile, numerous studies have conducted parametric investigations based on these designs [21, 22, 23]; however, their limited design freedom has constrained the performance improvements in MCHS.
As a method with high design flexibility, topology optimization can generate optimized configurations without relying on the designer’s intuition. In topology optimization, the density method employs a continuous design variable field, which enables smooth variations of material distribution throughout the design domain during the optimization process. The introduction of a penalization factor eliminates intermediate values of these design variables, resulting in a binary distribution of material [24]. Based on the idea of the density method, Borrvall and Petersson proposed a topology optimization approach for Stokes flow, introducing a fictitious force based on design variables as a no-slip boundary condition to determine the material distribution of the pseudo-solid region [25]. Further research has also developed topology optimization methods for heat sink design. Dede [26] and Yoon [27] first proposed a topology optimization method for forced convection heat transfer problems. Koga et al. proposed a topology optimization method for heat sinks, defining a multi-objective function to maximize heat dissipation while simultaneously minimizing power dissipation in their study [28]. Matsumori et al. developed a topology optimization method for heat sinks that accounts for constrained input power [29]. Yaji et al. developed a topology optimization method to maximize heat exchange, using a level set boundary expression to control the geometric complexity of the optimized configurations [30]. Dilgen et al. proposed a topology optimization method for turbulent forced convection heat transfer systems [31]. Zeng et al. developed a two-layer model for topology optimization to reduce the computational cost of 3D heat sink design and experimentally verified that the optimized result exhibits superior performance [32]. Zhou et al. introduced a topology optimization method for manifold microchannel heat sinks and investigated the optimized results numerically and experimentally [33]. Although these studies proposed topology optimization methods for heat sinks, they did not consider nanofluids as potential coolants. In terms of nanofluids, Zhang et al. proposed a topology optimization method for MCHS [34]. Due to the diluteness of nanoparticles, a single-phase model is employed to simulate the behavior of nanofluids, with its physical properties being temperature-dependent. In their study, while optimized configurations can be obtained using a single-phase model, the performance of the structures optimized with nanofluids was inferior to those optimized with pure water.
| Nomenclature | |
| velocity vector (m/s) | |
| position vector (m) | |
| specific heat capacity (J/kg · K) | |
| drag coefficient | |
| design domain | |
| particle diameter (m) | |
| plate length (m) | |
| volumetric heat exchange coefficient (W/m · K) | |
| fluid-particle heat transfer coefficient (W/m · K) | |
| number of flow simulation iterations | |
| objective function | |
| momentum exchange coefficient (kg/m · s) | |
| thermal conductivity (W/m · K) | |
| inlet length (m) | |
| number of optimization iterations | |
| Nusselt number | |
| pressure (Pa) | |
| Prandtl number | |
| volumetric heat generation coefficient (W/m · K) | |
| convex parameter | |
| filter radius (m) | |
| fluid Reynolds number | |
| particle Reynolds number | |
| temperature (K) | |
| velocity component in the -direction (m/s) | |
| velocity component in the -direction (m/s) | |
| tol | convergence tolerance for flow simulation |
| Greek symbols | |
| inverse permeability (kg/m · s) | |
| projection parameter | |
| convergence tolerance for optimization | |
| threshold parameter | |
| boundary of the analysis domain | |
| design variable | |
| viscosity (Pa · s) | |
| fluid domain | |
| volume fraction | |
| density (kg/m) | |
| Subscripts | |
| ave | average |
| f | fluid phase |
| p | particle phase |
| Superscripts | |
| in | inlet |
| out | outlet |
| w | wall |
Table 5.
In the field of numerical investigations for nanofluids, although the single-phase model is frequently used, recent studies have increasingly focused on the two-phase model for nanofluids. In the two-phase model, the particle phase is treated as a continuous phase to account for the complex interactions between nanoparticles and the fluid. Bianco et al. investigated the laminar forced convection flow of AlO nanofluid in a circular pipe with the single-phase and two-phase models. The maximum difference in the average heat transfer coefficient between the single-phase model and the two-phase model is 11% in their study [35]. Kalteh et al. conducted numerical simulations of nanofluid forced convection in a microchannel using the Eulerian-Eulerian approach. The average Nusselt number enhancement obtained with the Eulerian-Eulerian approach is higher than that achieved with the single-phase model [36]. In terms of experimental validation, Fard et al. compared the simulation results of single-phase and two-phase models for nanofluids with copper nanoparticles and found that the two-phase model results aligned more closely with experimental data [37]. Beheshti et al. conducted a comparative numerical study of heat transfer with turbulent nanofluids in an annular channel. In their study, the single-phase model underestimates the experimental data at concentrations (1% and 1.5%). In contrast, the two-phase model yields results that are closer to the experimental values [38]. In summary, these studies have demonstrated that the two-phase model provides more accurate results and serves as an effective alternative for simulating the heat transfer of nanofluids.
Several studies have employed topology optimization to address particle flow problems. In these studies, the Eulerian-Lagrangian approach has been extensively utilized to optimize particle trajectory and manipulation [39, 40, 41]. However, this approach leads to high computational costs when applied to the collective behavior of nanofluids. In contrast, although Chen et al. demonstrated that the Eulerian–Eulerian approach can effectively tackle topology optimization problems for particle flows [42], the assumption of one-way coupling in their study limits the ability to capture the bidirectional interactions between the fluid and particles in nanofluids.
Based on the above, we propose a topology optimization method for flow field design in MCHS with nanofluids using an Eulerian-Eulerian approach. In the numerical model, the particle phase is treated as a continuous phase, and fluid-particle bidirectional interactions are incorporated into the momentum and energy equations for both phases based on the Eulerian-Eulerian approach. The optimization problem is defined as a heat transfer maximization problem under a fixed pressure drop. The sensitivity information is derived using automatic differentiation, and GCMMA (Globally Convergent Method of Moving Asymptotes) is employed for solving the optimization problem [43]. This study includes two numerical examples. In the first example, we optimize the flow field in a square design domain commonly used for topology optimization in thermal management. This example serves as a preliminary exploration of various parameters to validate the proposed optimization method. In the second numerical example, we consider a manifold microchannel heat sink (MMCHS) for optimization, as shown in Figure 1. In the MMCHS, dividers segment the microchannels into multiple sections, allowing fluid to flow downward into each section and upward out of it. Since the MMCHS consists of periodic unit cells, we optimize the flow field in a unit cell with a simplified two-dimensional model in this study.
Figure 1. Schematic diagram of a manifold microchannel heat sink: (a) The flow direction and key components in the MMCHS (b) Top view of a unit cell in the MMCHS.
The subsequent sections of this paper are organized as follows: In Section 2, we demonstrate the formulation of the governing equations and boundary conditions. In Section 3, we describe the representation of fluid and solid regions in the topology optimization method and formulate the optimization problem for flow field design in MCHS. In Section 4, we provide an overview of the algorithm used in the fluid solver and outline the optimization process. In Section 5, we compare the effects of different parameters on the optimized flow field and optimize the flow field in the unit cell of MMCHS. Finally, we present the summary of findings and future work in Section 6.
Analysis model
Assumptions
The particle volume fraction has a significant impact on the behavior of nanofluids. Although increasing the particle volume fraction can enhance heat transfer, excessive concentration may lead to nanoparticle aggregation, which increases viscosity and reduces heat transfer efficiency [44]. Therefore, the volume fraction of nanofluids is typically low to prevent these negative effects. In this study, we adopt the two-way coupling assumption, meaning that the behaviors of the fluid and particles influence each other, while interactions between particles are neglected. Additionally, we consider a steady-state laminar flow for the numerical examples due to the broad range of laminar flow applications in MCHS [45, 46, 47]. Although the fluid in the MMCHS exhibits both upward and downward flow behaviors, under high aspect ratio conditions—where the channel width is significantly greater than its depth—the distributions of physical quantities remain sufficiently uniform [48, 49]. Consequently, the flow field can be approximated as two-dimensional. In addition, we further consider a uniform heat distribution along the channel’s height and simplify the volumetric heat generation into the two-dimensional energy equation. The basic assumptions are summarized as follows:
The flow fields are treated as two-dimensional.
The fluid is treated as a steady incompressible laminar flow.
Heat distribution is uniform along the channel’s height.
Particle-particle interactions are not considered.
The gravity effect is not considered.
Shape effects are neglected, and particles are spherical.
Particle aggregation is not considered.
Governing equations
Based on the assumptions in § 2.1 and the Eulerian-Eulerian model proposed by Kalteh et al. [36], the governing
equations for the fluid phase, including continuity, momentum, and energy, are as follows:
where is the velocity vector, is the pressure, is the viscosity, is the density, is the volume fraction, is the momentum exchange coefficient, is the temperature, is the specific heat capacity, is the heat exchange coefficient, and is the effective thermal conductivity. The subscripts ‘f’ and ‘p’ denote the fluid and particle phases. Similarly, the governing equations for the particle phase are described as follows:
The momentum exchange coefficient in Eqs. (2) and (5) can be expressed as follows:
where is the particle diameter. As mentioned by Kolve [50], the is the drag coefficient, which is defined as follows:
The particle Reynolds number in Eq. (8) is described as:
For monodispersed spherical particles, the heat exchange coefficient in Eqs. (3) and (6) can be expressed in the following equation.
According to Wakao and Kaguei [51], the fluid-particle heat transfer coefficient can be obtained using the empirical correlation as follows:
where is the Prandtl number for the fluid phase. Besides, as proposed by Kuipers et al. [52], the effective thermal conductivities for both phases and are shown below:
where and can be further expressed as follows:
where and in Eqs. (15) and (16) are given by the equations and , respectively. According to Kalteh et al. [36], the value of is chosen as in this study.
Figure 2 shows the analysis domain and dimensions for the optimization problems. To account for the effect of pumping power on heat transfer performance, we fixed the pressure drop between the inlet and the outlet in the numerical examples. The boundary conditions for state variables in the first numerical example are shown below:
Figure 2. Schematic representation of the fluid domain and the solid domain in the fixed design domain , including the corresponding boundary expressions for the inlet , outlet , and wall .
In addition, we apply the symmetric boundary condition in the first numerical example to reduce computational cost. In the second numerical example, since we optimize the flow field in the unit cell, free-slip boundary conditions are applied to the walls. The types of the remaining boundary conditions are the same as those in the first numerical example.
Problem formulation
Representation of solid and fluid regions
Topology optimization aims to enhance the objective function by optimizing the material distribution within the design domain . Initially, we define a characteristic function for the representation of solid and fluid regions to determine the material distribution, as follows:
where is the position in , and represents the flow domain in . The characteristic function is inherently discontinuous, which necessitates the relaxation techniques to facilitate a smooth transition for numerical analysis. In this study, we employ a continuous function, , commonly used in the density method, with values ranging .
Checkerboard patterns may arise in the material distribution due to numerical instabilities [53]. To address this issue, we implement convolution filtering as outlined below [54]:
Here, represents the filtered design variable on node , denotes the set of nodes located within the filtering radius , and is the weighting function defined as below.
Although filtering can address the checkerboard pattern issue, it often results in the presence of gray-scale design variables in the material distribution. To address this issue, we employ the projection function to obtain the optimized configuration closer to a binary distribution as follows [55]:
where is the projection parameter, is the threshold parameter and is the design variable after projection.
Governing equations with fluid and solid representations
In Section 3.1, we defined the design variables used to represent the solid and fluid regions. To determine the distribution of design variables during the optimization process, we further introduced fictitious forces and heat sources dependent on the design variables and incorporated them into the equations. The re-formulated equations are presented as follows:
The inverse permeability and volumetric heat generation coefficient can be described as follows [29]:
where and are the maximum and minimum values of the inverse permeability, respectively, is the maximum value of the volumetric heat generation coefficient, and is the convex parameter. It is worth noting that is also necessary when converting a three-dimensional problem into a two-dimensional problem. By employing methods such as the two-layer model [56], results comparable to those obtained in three dimensions can be achieved if the height of the flow path is sufficiently small. However, for simplicity, we follow previous research [29, 30] and determine based on prior parameter investigations. By incorporating fictitious forces and heat sources into the equations, we can evaluate the influence of design variables on the objective function through sensitivity analysis.
Heat transfer maximization problem
Heat transfer between the solid and fluid regions is a critical factor in the design of MCHS. In this optimization problem, since the pressure drop between the inlet and outlet is fixed, the objective function only needs to account for the heat transfer between the solid and the fluid. Therefore, the optimization problem is formulated as a heat generation maximization problem as follows:
where represents the temperature in the solid region, represents the average temperature of the fluid phase and the particle phase, expressed as follows [57], where denotes the phase with .
Numerical implementation
We develop a custom finite difference flow solver incorporating the NAPPLE (Nonstaggered Artificial Pressure for Pressure-Linked Equation) algorithm. This algorithm allows state variables to be defined on a collocated grid under specific assumptions. Based on these assumptions, we can derive the pressure-linked equation and discretize it using the harmonic scheme to eliminate the checkerboard pressure pattern. For further details, refer to [42, 58]. Besides, the momentum and energy equations are discretized for both phases using a weighting function scheme [59]. In fluid simulation, we use the maximum residual values among all grid points as the convergence criteria expressed by the following equations:
where represents iteration count, and are the velocity components in the - and -directions, respectively. The convergence criteria for the state variables , and for both phases are denoted as , and and are set to , respectively.
Figure 3 shows the flowchart of the optimization process. In the first step, we initialize all the state and design variables. In the second step, we apply the filter in Eq. (25) and projection in Eq. (27) on the design variables. In the third and fourth steps, the numerical simulation is performed, and the sensitivities are obtained using the automatic differentiation with Adept C++ [60]. In the fifth step, we use the GCMMA algorithm [43] to determine the distribution of design variables. In the optimization process, we adopt a continuation method, gradually increasing the value of in Eq. (27) to remove gray-scale design variables. If the optimization meets the convergence criterion, the value of is doubled, and the process returns to the second step. This loop continues until all continuation steps are completed. If the criterion is unmet, the process returns to the second step without modifying . The convergence criterion for the optimization is as follows:
Figure 3. Flowchart of the topology optimization process.
Here, represents the number of optimization iterations, represents the criterion for the optimization convergence and is set to in this study.
Results and discussion
Validation of numerical method
We validate the feasibility of the numerical scheme through a numerical example from prior research [36]. In this problem, the nanofluid flows between two parallel plates separated by . Each plate has a length 100 times its inlet width
(), as shown in Figure 4. The analysis domain is discretized with a quadrilateral mesh of 2000 × 30. The nanofluid consists of water as the base fluid and copper as the nanoparticle material. At the inlet, the nanofluid enters with a uniform velocity and a temperature of 293 K, while the static pressure at the outlet is set to zero. The side walls are subjected to no-slip boundary conditions, with the wall temperature set to 303 K. In addition, the symmetry boundary condition is utilized for the numerical analysis. The material properties of the nanofluid are summarized in the Table 1.
Figure 4. Analysis domain for the numerical scheme validation.
| Parameters | Symbols | Values | Unit |
| Fluid viscosity | 0.001 | Pa · s | |
| Fluid density | 1000 | kg/m | |
| Fluid heat capacity | 4181.8 | J/kg K | |
| Fluid thermal conductivity | 0.6 | W/m K | |
| Particle viscosity | Pa · s | ||
| Particle density | 8954 | kg/m | |
| Particle heat capacity | 383.1 | J/kg K | |
| Particle thermal conductivity | 386 | W/m K | |
| Particle diameter | 100 | nm |
Table 1. Material properties of the Cu-water nanofluid.
In this study, we first compare the average Nusselt number variations with the Reynolds number at different particle volume fractions. The definitions and calculations of Reynolds and Nusselt numbers are based on those provided by Kalteh et al. [36]. As illustrated in Figure 5, the numerical results align well with those reported in the previous study. An increase in Reynolds number enhances the convective heat transfer effect, while a higher particle volume fraction improves the effective thermal conductivity of the nanofluid. Consequently, the average Nusselt number increases accordingly. Additionally, we examined the average Nusselt number for different particle diameters under and . As reported in Kalteh et al. [36], the ratio of the Nusselt number for nanofluids to water is 40.43% and 42.47% for nm and nm, respectively, with the Nusselt number of water reported as 9.3. Based on these values, the average Nusselt numbers for nm and nm can be calculated as 13.06 and 13.25, respectively. Under the same conditions, the average Nusselt numbers for nm and nm in this study are 12.74 and 13.42, showing a deviation of less than 2.5% compared to the prior study.
Figure 5. Average Nusselt number is evaluated with the Reynolds number at different particle volume fractions in the analysis domain shown in Figure 4.
Heat transfer optimization problem
Details of numerical setting
In the first numerical example, the default material properties for the nanofluid are listed in Table 1. Figure 6 shows the schematic diagram of the analysis domain in this problem, with the inlet length set to 30 m. Although the overall size of the analysis domain is relatively small for MCHS, this configuration is commonly used in topology optimization problems for heat sinks [29, 30]. As a preliminary validation case, this setup allows for evaluating the influence of different parameters on the optimized flow field at a reasonable computational cost and verifies whether the proposed method can generate flow fields with superior performance.
Figure 6. Dimensions of the design domain utilized for the heat transfer optimization problem.
In the fluid simulation setup, the analysis domain is discretized using a quadrilateral mesh of . The pressure drop is set to 5000 Pa, and the inlet particle volume fraction is 1%. The corresponding fluid Reynolds number is 67.1. For the temperature boundary conditions, the inlet temperature for both phases is set to 300 K, while solid temperature is set to 360 K.
In the optimization setup, the initial design variable is set to 0.9, while the inverse permeability and the volumetric heat generation coefficient have maximum values of and , respectively. The convex parameter is set to 0.05. In the filtering and projection, the filter radius is set to 1.8 m, and the maximum value of the projection parameter is set to 64.
Optimized flow field
The optimized flow field is obtained using the default parameters outlined in § 5.2.1. Figure 7 illustrates the optimized flow field alongside the velocity and temperature distributions for both phases. From Figure 7(c) and (f), it can be observed that as the nanofluid flows around the heat sink fins, it absorbs heat generated by the solid through the thermal exchange, thereby achieving a cooling effect. Due to the interactions between the fluid and particles, the velocity and temperature distributions of the fluid phase and particle phase are nearly identical. Notably, as shown in Figure 7(d), the particle volume fraction is distributed uniformly across the design domain, even within the solid regions. This is due to the limitations of the fictitious body force formulation, which causes particles to remain inside the solid regions. However, since the particle velocity within the solid regions is extremely low, its influence on the optimization results is minimal.
Figure 7. Optimized Results and distribution of physical quantities with: (a) optimized flow field (b) fluid velocity magnitude(c) fluid phase temperature (d) particle volume fraction (e) particle velocity magnitude (f) particle phase temperature. The maximum values on the color bar for velocity and temperature for both phases are 1.77 m/s and 355.8 K, respectively.
Figure 8 illustrates the convergence history for the optimized flow field, showing a progressive increase in the objective function value with each iteration. However, the objective function value may occasionally experience a sudden drop. This is because the projection function in Eq. (27) imposes abrupt changes to the design variable field, resulting in short-term performance reduction.
Figure 8. Convergence history of the objective function for the optimized flow field shown in Figure 7.
Effect of pressure drop
First, we examine the effects of different pressure drops on the optimized configurations, as shown in Figure 9. The results indicate that the number of branches in the optimized flow field increases as the pressure drop increases. An increase in pressure drop enhances the overall convective effects within the flow field, promoting the formation of additional flow branches. Although increased branching leads to greater flow resistance, it also enhances heat dissipation performance by providing additional heat transfer surfaces and disrupting the thermal boundary layer. Table 2 presents the results of the crosscheck. It can be observed that the flow fields optimized under specific pressure drop conditions exhibit the best performance at their corresponding pressure drops. This demonstrates that the proposed method can generate optimized flow fields under different pressure drop conditions.
| Analysis | Optimization | |||
| 1000 | 3000 | 5000 | 7000 | |
| 1000 | 11.0 | 9.3 | 7.4 | 6.3 |
| 3000 | 14.6 | 16.4 | 15.6 | 14.6 |
| 5000 | 15.8 | 19.0 | 19.3 | 19.1 |
| 7000 | 16.4 | 20.4 | 21.8 | 21.9 |
Table 2. Crosscheck of objective function () with pressure drop.
Figure 9. Optimized Results and distribution of physical quantities with different pressure drop: (a) optimized flow field (b) average temperature. The maximum values on the color bar for the average temperature are 359.3 K, 358.3 K, and 354.3 K with Pa, 3000 Pa and 7000 Pa, respectively.
Effect of particle volume fraction
Figure 10 presents the optimized configurations for various particle volume fractions. As the particle volume fraction increases, the number of branches in the optimized flow field decreases. An increase in the particle volume fraction also raises the fluid viscosity, leading to greater flow resistance. Consequently, reducing the number of branches minimizes flow losses under a fixed pressure drop. This adjustment allows nanofluids with higher particle volume fractions to sustain sufficient flow velocity, thereby improving convective heat transfer performance. Table 3 presents the crosscheck results at different particle volume fractions. Under a fixed pressure drop, the flow field optimized at exhibits the best performance. Although the performance of each optimized flow field generally improves with higher particle volume fractions, the flow field optimized for a specific fraction consistently outperforms those optimized for other fractions.
Figure 10. Optimized Results and distribution of physical quantities with different particle volume fraction: (a) optimized flow field (b) average temperature. The maximum values on the color bar for the average temperature are 354.6 K, 356.0 K, and 357.9 K with , 3% and 6%, respectively.
| Analysis | Optimization | ||||
| 0% | 1% | 3% | 6% | ||
| 0% | 18.2 | 18.1 | 17.5 | 17.0 | |
| 1% | 19.2 | 19.6 | 19.4 | 19.1 | |
| 3% | 19.5 | 20.2 | 20.4 | 20.2 | |
| 6% | 19.8 | 20.5 | 21.0 | 21.1 |
Table 3. Crosscheck of objective function () with volume fraction.
Effect of particle diameter
Figure 11 illustrates the optimized flow fields for different particle diameters. The topological structures of the optimized flow fields remain unchanged for nm and 50 nm, with only minor variations in shape. Similarly, the optimized flow fields for nm and 30 nm show slight differences in their topological structures. In summary, particle diameter has a minor effect compared to the influence of particle volume fraction on the optimized flow field. As reported by Zhang et al. [34], a single-phase model was used to examine the effect of particle diameter, and it similarly showed that particle diameter has a relatively minor impact on the optimized flow field.
Figure 11. Optimized flow fields with different particle diameters.
In addition, as shown in the crosscheck results in Table 4, the differences in the objective function values among the particle diameters are minimal for each optimized flow field. This is because, within the conditions explored in this study, the relatively low Reynolds number and particle volume fraction minimize the influence of particle diameter variation on nanofluid behavior. In the prior work, Kalteh et al. [36] employed an Eulerian-Eulerian model to investigate the effect of particle diameter on the Nusselt number enhancement at and , using the same nanofluid and the analysis domain shown in Figure 4. Their results indicated that even at , reducing the particle diameter from 100 nm to 30 nm yielded only a 2% improvement. Given the lower Reynolds number with the same particle volume fraction in this study, the effect of particle diameter is further diminished. Consequently, the configurations of the optimized flow fields exhibit little variation, and their performance across different particle diameters is nearly identical.
| Analysis | Optimization | ||||
| 30 | 50 | 70 | 100 | ||
| 30 | 18.9 | 19.2 | 19.2 | 19.3 | |
| 50 | 19.0 | 19.4 | 19.4 | 19.5 | |
| 70 | 19.0 | 19.4 | 19.4 | 19.5 | |
| 100 | 19.0 | 19.3 | 19.4 | 19.6 |
Table 4. Crosscheck of objective function () with particle diameter.
Flow field design for a manifold microchannel heat sink
Details of numerical setting
In the second numerical example, we optimize the flow field for a unit cell of the MMCHS and compare its performance with that of a conventional parallel flow channel. Table 1 presents the material properties for the nanofluid, and Figure 12 illustrates the geometric configuration of this problem, with the inlet length set to 50 m. The analysis domain is discretized using a quadrilateral mesh of . The pressure drop between the inlet and outlet is set to 2000 Pa, where the corresponding fluid Reynolds number is 70.7. The particle volume fraction at the inlet is set to 0.5%. In this case, the inlet and solid temperatures are identical to those in the first numerical example.
Figure 12. Dimensions of the design domain utilized for flow field design in a unit cell of the manifold microchannel heat sink.
In the optimization setup, we set the maximum values of inverse permeability and the volumetric heat generation coefficient are and , respectively. The initial values of design variables are set to 0.9 in the design domain. The convex parameter is set to 0.05. The filter radius is set to 4 m, and the maximum value of the projection parameter is set to 64.
Optimized flow field
Figure 13(a) presents the optimization results for a unit cell of the MMCHS, with an objective function value of W/m. As shown in Figure 13(a), the fins are primarily distributed along the central line, forming multiple branches to increase the heat dissipation area. It can be observed that the fluid flows from the inlet primarily along the bottom edge and absorbs heat as it flows around the branches. To evaluate the performance of the optimized flow field compared to a conventional parallel flow field, we constructed a straight channel within the design domain by aligning solid fins, represented by design variables, along the upper and lower boundaries. The fin thickness was adjusted to determine the optimal performance of the straight flow channel. Figure 14 illustrates the objective function values of the straight flow channel with different fin thicknesses using the same nanofluid. The optimal performance is achieved at a
Figure 13. Comparison of the optimized flow field and straight flow channel using the nanofluid with nm and : (a) optimized flow field (b) straight flow channel. The maximum values on the color bar for the fluid velocity and average temperature are 0.80 m/s and 347.6 K, respectively.
Figure 14. Objective function values of the straight flow channel with different fin thicknesses. The maximum value of is W/m at a fin thickness of 7.5 m.
fin thickness of 7.5 m, yielding an objective function value of W/m. Figure 13(b) depicts the straight flow channel with a fin thickness of 7.5 m, along with its corresponding velocity and temperature distributions. These findings indicate that the proposed topology optimization method can generate a superior unit cell for MMCHS, achieving an 11.6% enhancement in heat transfer performance over a conventional parallel flow field.
Conclusion
In this study, we proposed a density-based topology optimization method for microchannel heat sinks using nanofluids. The behavior of the nanofluid was simulated using an Eulerian–Eulerian model. In the optimization setup, we formulated the problem as a heat generation maximization problem under a fixed pressure drop. The optimization was performed using the GCMMA algorithm, with sensitivities computed through automatic differentiation. In the numerical examples, we used water as the base fluid and copper as the nanoparticle material. We first validated our numerical scheme against the results from prior works. Subsequently, we examined the effects of different parameters on the optimized flow field and employed this method to design the MMCHS unit cell. The findings are summarized as follows:
An increased pressure drop enhances convective effects within the flow field, resulting in more branches in the optimized flow field and enhanced heat transfer.
While an increase in particle volume fraction enhances the effective thermal conductivity of the nanofluid, it also increases its viscosity. Under a fixed pressure drop, the higher viscosity reduces the number of branches in the optimized flow field to maintain flow velocity. Nevertheless, the improved thermal conductivity ensures enhanced heat transfer with increasing particle volume fractions.
Within the scope of this study, particle diameter has a minor effect compared to particle volume fraction. Due to its minor effect on nanofluid behavior, the variations in the optimized flow field are also minimal.
In the MMCHS unit cell using a nanofluid with a 0.5% particle volume fraction and 100 nm particle diameter, the topology-optimized flow field achieves 11.6% higher heat transfer performance compared to a size-optimized parallel flow field.
In future work, as the simplified two-dimensional model is employed under high aspect ratio conditions in this study, we aim to focus on designing three-dimensional flow fields in microchannel heat sinks using nanofluids. This focus addresses the limitations of the current two-dimensional model and highlights the broader applicability of three-dimensional flow fields in microchannel heat sinks [61, 62, 63].
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Chih-Hsiang Chen: Writing – original draft, Conceptualization, Methodology, Software, Validation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Data curation, Visualization. Kentaro Yaji: Writing– review & editing, Conceptualization, Methodology, Supervision, Resources, Project administration, Funding acquisition.
Acknowledgement
This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI (Grant No. 23H01323).
References
- [1]Z. He, Y. Yan, Z. Zhang, Thermal management and temperature uniformity enhancement of electronic devices by micro heat sinks: A review, Energy 216 (2021) 119223.DOI
- [2]D. B. Tuckerman, R. F. W. Pease, High-performance heat sinking for VLSI, IEEE Electron device letters 2 (5) (1981) 126–129.
- [3]J. Gao, Z. Hu, Q. Yang, X. Liang, H. Wu, Fluid flow and heat transfer in microchannel heat sinks: Modelling review and recent progress, Thermal Science and Engineering Progress 29 (2022) 101203.
- [4]M. M. Rahman, Measurements of heat transfer in microchannel heat sinks, International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer 27 (4) (2000) 495–506.
- [5]W. Qu, I. Mudawar, Experimental and numerical study of pressure drop and heat transfer in a single-phase micro-channel heat sink, International journal of heat and mass transfer 45 (12) (2002) 2549–2565.
- [6]H. M. Maghrabie, A. Olabi, E. T. Sayed, T. Wilberforce, K. Elsaid, M. H. Doranegard, M. A. Abdelkareem, Microchannel heat sinks with nanofluids for cooling electronic components: Performance enhancement, challenges, and limitations, Thermal Science and Engineering Progress 37 (2023) 101608.
- [7]M. Saeed, A. S. Berrouk, M. S. Al-Shahehi, Y. F. AlWahedi, Numerical investigation of the thermohydraulic characteristics of microchannel heat sinks using supercritical CO2 as a coolant, The Journal of Supercritical Fluids 176 (2021) 105306.
- [8]H. Kepekci, A. Asma, Comparative analysis of heat sink performance using different materials, American Journal of Engineering Research 9 (4) (2020) 204–210.
- [9]A. Muhammad, D. Selvakumar, A. Iranzo, Q. Sultan, J. Wu, Comparison of pressure drop and heat transfer performance for liquid metal cooled mini-channel with different coolants and heat sink materials, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry 141 (2020) 289–300.
- [10]A. U. Kumar, A. Javed, S. K. Dubey, Material selection for microchannel heatsink: Conjugate heat transfer simulation, in: IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, Vol. 346, IOP Publishing, 2018, p. 012024.
- [11]H. A. Kose, A. Yildizeli, S. Cadirci, Parametric study and optimization of microchannel heat sinks with various shapes, Applied Thermal Engineering 211 (2022) 118368.
- [12]Y.-H. Pan, R. Zhao, X.-H. Fan, Y.-L. Nian, W.-L. Cheng, Study on the effect of varying channel aspect ratio on heat transfer performance of manifold microchannel heat sink, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 163 (2020) 120461.
- [13]B. Dash, J. Nanda, S. K. Rout, The role of microchannel geometry selection on heat transfer enhancement in heat sinks: A review, Heat Transfer 51 (2) (2022) 1406–1424.
- [14]S. U. Choi, J. A. Eastman, Enhancing thermal conductivity of fluids with nanoparticles, Tech. rep., Argonne National Lab.(ANL), Argonne, IL (United States) (1995).
- [15]R. Chein, G. Huang, Analysis of microchannel heat sink performance using nanofluids, Applied thermal engineering 25 (17-18) (2005) 3104–3114.
- [16]S. P. Jang, S. U. Choi, Cooling performance of a microchannel heat sink with nanofluids, Applied Thermal Engineering 26 (17-18) (2006) 2457–2463.
- [17]M. Sohel, S. Khaleduzzaman, R. Saidur, A. Hebbasi, M. Sabri, I. Mahbubul, An experimental investigation of heat transfer enhancement of a minichannel heat sink using Al2O3–H2O nanofluid, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 74 (2014) 164–172.
- [18]C.-J. Ho, W. Chen, An experimental study on thermal performance of Al2O3/water nanofluid in a minichannel heat sink, Applied Thermal Engineering 50 (1) (2013) 516–522.
- [19]M. I. Hasan, Investigation of flow and heat transfer characteristics in micro pin fin heat sink with nanofluid, Applied thermal engineering 63 (2) (2014) 598–607.
- [20]M. U. Sajid, H. M. Ali, A. Sufyan, D. Rashid, S. U. Zahid, W. U. Rehman, Experimental investigation of TiO2–water nanofluid flow and heat transfer inside wavy mini-channel heat sinks, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry 137 (4) (2019) 1279–1294.
- [21]Y. J. Lee, P. K. Singh, P. S. Lee, Fluid flow and heat transfer investigations on enhanced microchannel heat sink using oblique fins with parametric study, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 81 (2015) 325– 336.
- [22]J. Wu, J. Zhao, K. Tseng, Parametric study on the performance of double- layered microchannels heat sink, Energy conversion and management 80 (2014) 550–560.DOI
- [23]L. Chai, G. D. Xia, H. S. Wang, Parametric study on the thermal and hy- draulic characteristics of laminar flow in microchannel heat sink with fan-shaped ribs on sidewalls–Part 1: Heat transfer, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 97 (2016) 1069–1080.DOI
- [24]M. P. Bendsoe, O. Sigmund, Topology optimization: theory, methods, and applications, Springer Science & Business Media, 2013.
- [25]T. Borrvall, J. Petersson, Topology optimization of fluids in Stokes flow, International journal for numerical methods in fluids 41 (1) (2003) 77– 107.
- [26]E. M. Dede, Multiphysics topology optimization of heat transfer and fluid flow systems, in: proceedings of the COMSOL Users Conference, Vol. 715, 2009.
- [27]G. H. Yoon, Topological design of heat dissipating structure with forced convective heat transfer, Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 24 (6) (2010) 1225–1233.DOI
- [28]A. A. Koga, E. C. C. Lopes, H. F. V. Nova, C. R. De Lima, E. C. N. Silva, Development of heat sink device by using topology optimization, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 64 (2013) 759–772.DOI
- [29]T. Matsumori, T. Kondoh, A. Kawamoto, T. Nomura, Topology optimiza- tion for fluid–thermal interaction problems under constant input power, Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization 47 (2013) 571–581.DOI
- [30]K. Yaji, T. Yamada, M. Yoshino, T. Matsumoto, K. Izui, S. Nishiwaki, Topology optimization in thermal-fluid flow using the lattice Boltzmann method, Journal of Computational Physics 307 (2016) 355–377.DOI
- [31]S. B. Dilgen, C. B. Dilgen, D. R. Huhman, O. Sigmund, B. S. Lazarov, Density based topology optimization of turbulent flow heat transfer sys- tems, Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization 57 (2018) 1905– 1918.DOI
- [32]S. Zeng, B. Kanargi, P. S. Lee, Experimental and numerical investigation of a mini channel forced air heat sink designed by topology optimization, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 121 (2018) 663–679.
- [33]J. Zhou, M. Lu, Q. Zhao, Q. Li, X. Chen, Topologically optimized man- ifold microchannel heat sink with extreme cooling performance for high heat flux cooling of electronics, Applied Thermal Engineering 241 (2024) 122426.DOI
- [34]B. Zhang, J. Zhu, L. Gao, Topology optimization design of nanofluid- cooled microchannel heat sink with temperature-dependent fluid proper- ties, Applied thermal engineering 176 (2020) 115354.DOI
- [35]V. Bianco, F. Chiachio, O. Manca, S. Nardini, Numerical investigation of nanofluids forced convection in circular tubes, Applied Thermal Engi- neering 29 (17-18) (2009) 3632–3642.DOI
- [36]M. Kalteh, A. Abbassi, M. Saffar-Avval, J. Harting, Eulerian–Eulerian two-phase numerical simulation of nanofluid laminar forced convection in a microchannel, International journal of heat and fluid flow 32 (1) (2011) 107–116.DOI
- [37]M. H. Fard, M. N. Esfahany, M. Talaie, Numerical study of convec- tive heat transfer of nanofluids in a circular tube two-phase model ver- sus single-phase model, International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer 37 (1) (2010) 91–97.
- [38]A. Beheshti, M. K. Moraveji, M. Hezajian, Comparative numerical study of nanofluid heat transfer through an annular channel, Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 67 (1) (2015) 100–117.
- [39]C. S. Andreasen, A framework for topology optimization of inertial mi- crofluidic particle manipulators, Structural and Multidisciplinary Opti- mization 61 (6) (2020) 2481–2499.DOI
- [40]G. H. Yoon, Transient sensitivity analysis and topology optimization for particle motion in steady state laminar fluid, Computer Methods in Ap- plied Mechanics and Engineering 367 (2020) 113096.DOI
- [41]G. H. Yoon, Transient sensitivity analysis and topology optimization of particle suspended in transient laminar fluid, Computer Methods in Ap- plied Mechanics and Engineering 393 (2022) 114696.DOI
- [42]C.-H. Chen, K. Yaji, Topology optimization for particle flow problems us- ing eulerian-eulerian model with a finite difference method, arXiv preprint arXiv:2412.19619 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2412.19619
- [43]K. Svanberg, A class of globally convergent optimization methods based on conservative convex separable approximations, SIAM journal on opti- mization 12 (2) (2002) 555–573.DOI
- [44]S. Chakraborty, P. K. Panigrahi, Stability of nanofluid: A review, Applied Thermal Engineering 174 (2020) 115259.DOI
- [45]P. S. Lee, J. C. Ho, H. Xue, Experimental study on laminar heat transfer in microchannel heat sink, in: ITherm 2002. Eighth intersociety conference on thermal and thermomechanical phenomena in electronic systems (Cat. No. 02CH37258), IEEE, 2002, pp. 379–386.DOI
- [46]L. Chai, G. D. Xia, H. S. Wang, Numerical study of laminar flow and heat transfer in microchannel heat sink with offset ribs on sidewalls, Applied Thermal Engineering 92 (2016) 32–41.DOI
- [47]Q. Zhu, R. Su, H. Xia, J. Zeng, J. Chen, Numerical simulation study of thermal and hydraulic characteristics of laminar flow in microchannel heat sink with water droplet cavities and different rib columns, Interna- tional Journal of Thermal Sciences 172 (2022) 107319.DOI
- [48]H. Li, M. G. Olsen, Aspect ratio effects on turbulent and transitional flow in rectangular microchannels as measured with microPIV (2006).
- [49]H. Kamal, A. Dewan, Analysis of interrupted rectangular microchannel heat sink with high aspect ratio, Journal of applied fluid mechanics 10 (1) (2017) 117–126.DOI
- [50]D. Gidaspow, Multiphase Flow and Fluidization: Continuum and Kinetic Theory Descriptions, Academic press, 1994.
- [51]N. Wakao, S. Kagei, Heat and mass transfer in packed beds, Vol. 1, Taylor & Francis, 1982.
- [52]J. Kuipers, W. Prins, W. P. M. Van Swaaij, Numerical calculation of wall-to-bed heat-transfer coefficients in gas-fluidized beds, AIChE Jour- nal 38 (7) (1992) 1079–1091.DOI
- [53]A. Diaz, O. Sigmund, Checkerboard patterns in layout optimization, Structural optimization 10 (1) (1995) 40–45.
- [54]B. Bourdin, Filters in topology optimization, International journal for nu- merical methods in engineering 50 (9) (2001) 2143–2158.DOI
- [55]F. Wang, B. S. Lazarov, O. Sigmund, On projection methods, conver- gence and robust formulations in topology optimization, Structural and multidisciplinary optimization 43 (2011) 767–784.DOI
- [56]S. Yan, F. Wang, J. Hong, O. Sigmund, Topology optimization of mi- crochannel heat sinks using a two-layer model, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 143 (2019) 118462.DOI
- [57]P. Boulet, S. Moissette, Influence of the particle–turbulence modulation modelling in the simulation of a non-isothermal gas–solid flow, Interna- tional Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 45 (20) (2002) 4201–4216.DOI
- [58]S. Lee, R. Tzong, Artificial pressure for pressure-linked equation, Inter- national journal of heat and mass transfer 35 (10) (1992) 2705–2716.DOI
- [59]L. Shong-Leih, Weighting function scheme and its application on multi- dimensional conservation equations, International journal of heat and mass transfer 32 (11) (1989) 2065–2073.
- [60]R. J. Hogan, Fast reverse-mode automatic differentiation using expression templates in C++, ACM Transactions on Mathematical Software (TOMS) 40 (4) (2014) 1–16.
- [61]A. G. Fedorov, R. Viskanta, Three-dimensional conjugate heat transfer in the microchannel heat sink for electronic packaging, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 43 (3) (2000) 399–415.DOI
- [62]J. Ryu, D. H. Choi, S. Kim, Three-dimensional numerical optimization of a manifold microchannel heat sink, International journal of heat and mass transfer 46 (9) (2003) 1553–1562.
- [63]C.-J. Ho, L. Wei, Z. Li, An experimental investigation of forced convec- tive cooling performance of a microchannel heat sink with Al2O3/water nanofluid, Applied Thermal Engineering 30 (2-3) (2010) 96–103.DOI








