betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Average amplitude and phase detuning near driven 3rd integer resonance

Abstract

For resonant slow extraction of accelerated particle beams from synchrotrons, a 3rd order resonance driven by sextupole magnets is commonly used. This note reviews the non-linear particle dynamics under these conditions as described by the Kobayashi Hamiltonian, focussing on the amplitude and phase dependent detuning. Using the Kobayashi Hamiltonian as the invariant, an expression for the action and the average detuning as a function of the Hamiltonian is derived and compared to numerically obtained results.

Introduction

We consider the particle dynamics near a 3rd order resonance driven by sextupole magnets, such as commonly used for resonant slow extraction of accelerated particle beams from synchrotrons [2]. The dynamics under these conditions are dominated by nonlinear particle motion and lead to detuning effects, typically described as detuning with amplitude [4 Whil13].

However, the detuning depends not only on the particle amplitude, but also on the angle in phase space. This is not only a consequence of the triangularly deformed phase space trajectories of the particles, where the amplitude (or action) itself depends on the angle. Moreover, the effect of the sextupole kick is — depending on the angle — either aligned or in opposite direction with the transverse momentum, causing the phase advance for the subsequent turn to be in- or decreased.

In this note, we derive an expression for the average phase advance of a particle, the trajectory of which is governed by the Kobayashi Hamiltonian. The Hamiltonian is a measure for the oscillation energy and — in contrast to the amplitude — a quantity conserved in time.

Kobayashi theory

The Kobayashi theory [6] describes the particle dynamics in the close vicinity of a driven 3rd order resonance. One defines the (linear) fractional tune as q=r+dq = r + d, where r=1/3r = 1/3 or 2/32/3 is the resonance and the distance d≪1d \ll1 is small. The resonance is driven by sextupole magnets, whose combined effect is summarized by a virtual sextupole magnet with normalized strength S=−12βx3/2k2lS = -\frac{1}{2}\beta_x^{3/2}k_{2l} in m−1/2\mathrm{m}^{-1/2} [1 pp. 30 sqq.].

It is convenient to use normalized horizontal phase space coordinates XX and X′X' (in units of m1/2\mathrm{m}^{1/2}): [Wiel5, pp. 115, 233 sqq.]

(XX′)=(1/βx0αx/βxβx)(xx′)(1)\begin{pmatrix} X \\ X' \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} 1/\sqrt{\beta_x} & 0 \\ \alpha_x/\sqrt{\beta_x} & \sqrt{\beta_x} \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} x \\ x' \tag*{(1)} \end{pmatrix}

where αx\alpha_x and βx\beta_x are the twiss parameters, xx is the horizontal displacement in m and x′x' the divergence. Equivalently, the phase space can be parametrized in polar coordinates by means of the action JJ and angle θ\theta:

X=2Jcos⁡(θ)X′=−2Jsin⁡(θ)(2)X = \sqrt{2J}\cos(\theta) \qquad X' = -\sqrt{2J}\sin(\theta) \tag*{(2)}

The Kobayashi Hamiltonian HH [5 p. 348] describes the three turn motion of a particle at the location of the sextupole:

H=3πd(X2+X′2)+S4(3XX′2−X3)(3)H = 3\pi d\left(X^2 + X'^{2}\right) + \frac{S}{4}\left(3XX'^{2} - X^3\right) \tag*{(3)}
=6πdJ−S2J3/2cos⁡(3θ)(4)= 6\pi dJ - \frac{S}{\sqrt{2}}J^{3/2}\cos(3\theta) \tag*{(4)}

The phase space trajectories (equipotential lines) have a characteristic triangular shape, as depicted in Figure 1 (left). The separatrix at Hsep=(4πd)3/S2H_{\mathrm{sep}} = (4\pi d)^3/S^2 marks the border of stable motion. The size of this stable equilateral triangle is given by the radius of the inscribed circle h=4πd/Sh = 4\pi d/S.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Left: Normalized phase space with equipotential lines of the Kobayashi Hamiltonian. The colour shading indicates the detuned three turn phase advance. Right: three turn phase advance as function of angle for identical values of HH.

Detuning

According to Hamilton’s equation, the three turn phase advance, i.e. the change of angle θ\theta per three turns, is given as

μ3=∂H∂J=6πd−3S42Jcos⁡(3θ)=3H2J−3πd(5)\mu_3 = \frac{\partial H}{\partial J} = 6\pi d - \frac{3S}{4}\sqrt{2J}\cos(3\theta) = \frac{3H}{2J} - 3\pi d \tag*{(5)}

The term 6πd6\pi d is the three turn phase advance (modulo 2π2\pi) for a linear system (S=0S=0). The additional term describes the nonlinear detuning which depends not only on the amplitude 2J\sqrt{2J}, but also on the angle θ\theta in phase space [3]. The detuning with angle is depicted in Figure 1 (right).

Average detuning

As the particle moves along the equipotential lines of the Hamiltonian over many turns, the three turn phase advance varies significantly. In the following, we derive an expression for the average phase advance a particle with given HH experiences over many turns. Therefore, we will consider a number of turns n≫1/dn \gg1/d, such that the particle has sampled the full angle along the equipotential line.

Time average over many turns

The time average of a quantity gg is given as:

⟨g⟩=∫g dt∫dt=∫g dn∫dn(6)\langle g \rangle= \frac{\int g\,\mathrm{d}t}{\int\mathrm{d}t} = \frac{\int g\,\mathrm{d}n}{\int\mathrm{d}n} \tag*{(6)}

where the integral over time tt was written as an integral over the turn number n=frevtn=f_{\mathrm{rev}}t with the revolution frequency frevf_{\mathrm{rev}}. Using the three turn phase advance μ3=dθ/(3 dn)\mu_3=\mathrm{d}\theta/(3\,\mathrm{d}n), the expression can be transformed into an integral over the phase space angle:

⟨g⟩=∫gμ3 dθ∫1μ3 dθ(7)\langle g \rangle= \frac{\int\frac{g}{\mu_3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta}{\int\frac{1}{\mu_3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta} \tag*{(7)}

This is valid, because near the 3rd order resonance the change in angle per 3 turns is in the order of 6πd≪16\pi d \ll1 and can therefore be considered infinitesimal. With g=μ3g=\mu_3 and the integration over the full angle as motivated earlier, one gets:

⟨μ3⟩=∮dθ∮1μ3 dθ=2π∮1μ3 dθ(8)\langle\mu_3 \rangle= \frac{\oint\mathrm{d}\theta}{\oint\frac{1}{\mu_3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta} = \frac{2\pi}{\oint\frac{1}{\mu_3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta} \tag*{(8)}

or for an arbitrary quantity gg:

⟨g⟩=⟨μ3⟩2π∮gμ3 dθ(9)\langle g \rangle= \frac{\langle\mu_3 \rangle}{2\pi}\oint\frac{g}{\mu_3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta \tag*{(9)}

Average phase advance as function of the Hamiltonian

To simplify the integration in equation (8), unitless quantities are introduced:

H~=HHsep=HS264π3d3J~=J(2h)2=JS264π2d2(10)\widetilde{H} = \frac{H}{H_{\mathrm{sep}}} = \frac{H S^2}{64\pi^3 d^3} \qquad \widetilde{J} = \frac{J}{(2h)^2} = \frac{J S^2}{64\pi^2 d^2} \tag*{(10)}

The three turn phase advance (equation (5)) then reads

μ3=6πd(1−2J~cos⁡(3θ))=3πd(H~2J~−1)(11)\mu_3 = 6\pi d\left(1-\sqrt{2\widetilde{J}}\cos(3\theta)\right)=3\pi d\left(\frac{\widetilde{H}}{2\widetilde{J}}-1\right) \tag*{(11)}

And inserting into equation (8) yields

6πd⟨μ3⟩=12π∮11−2J~cos⁡(3θ) dθ(12)\frac{6\pi d}{\langle\mu_3\rangle}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\oint\frac{1}{1-\sqrt{2\widetilde{J}}\cos(3\theta)}\,\mathrm{d}\theta \tag*{(12)}

In the limit of H~→0\widetilde{H}\to0 the right-hand side of equation (12) equals unity since J~=0\widetilde{J}=0. Thus, one gets ⟨μ3⟩=6πd\langle\mu_3\rangle=6\pi d, which is the phase advance per three turns for the linear case. In the limit of H~→1\widetilde{H}\to1 the integrand has a singularity at the corners of the stable triangle (fixed points) where cos⁡(3θ)=1\cos(3\theta)=1 and J~=1/2\widetilde{J}=1/2. The integral becomes infinite and the average three turn phase advance vanishes as expected for a fixed point: ⟨μ3⟩→0\langle\mu_3\rangle\to0.

To carry out the integration over angle for a given value of H~\widetilde{H}, one must express J~\widetilde{J} as function of the angle θ\theta and the invariant H~\widetilde{H}. Therefore, we consider the Kobayashi Hamiltonian (equation (3)) in unitless quantities

H~=6J~−42J~3/2cos⁡(3θ)(13)\widetilde{H}=6\widetilde{J}-4\sqrt{2}\widetilde{J}^{3/2}\cos(3\theta) \tag*{(13)}

Solving for J~\widetilde{J} yields 3 solution, of which the following describes the dependence inside the separatrix (0<H~<10<\widetilde{H}<1):

J~={H~/6if cos⁡(3θ)=0,6+R1/3(3i−1)+R−1/3(3i+1)(8H~cos⁡2(3θ)−9)16cos⁡2(3θ)otherwise\widetilde{J}= \begin{cases} \widetilde{H}/6 & \text{if }\cos(3\theta)=0,\\ \dfrac{6+R^{1/3}(\sqrt{3}i-1)+R^{-1/3}(\sqrt{3}i+1)\left(8\widetilde{H}\cos^2(3\theta)-9\right)}{16\cos^2(3\theta)} & \text{otherwise} \end{cases}
R=27−36H~cos⁡2(3θ)+4H~2cos⁡3(3θ)(2cos⁡(3θ)−2cos⁡(6θ)+2−4/H~)(14)R=27-36\widetilde{H}\cos^2(3\theta)+4\widetilde{H}^2\cos^3(3\theta)\left(2\cos(3\theta)-\sqrt{2\cos(6\theta)+2-4/\widetilde{H}}\right) \tag*{(14)}

The integral in equation (12) can now be computed numerically for a given value of H~\widetilde{H}. Figure 2 shows the resulting relation for the average phase advance as function of the invariant HH. One can see that the detuning effect is very strong close to the separatrix, with the three turn motion freezing in the limit of H→HsepH\to H_{\mathrm{sep}} as discussed before.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Three turn phase advance ⟨μ3⟩\langle\mu_3 \rangle as function of the Hamiltonian HH. The shaded region shows the range of minimum and maximum three turn phase advance, and the black line is the time average derived in this note. The coloured dots correspond to the distinct values of HH presented in Figure 1. The dotted line is the average action as function of HH.

In addition, Figure 2 shows the average action JJ as a function of HH, which is computed by numerical integration of equation (9). This shows, that the effect of detuning with angle is not negligible and the detuning for a given particle must in fact be considered with respect to HH. For reference, Figure 3 shows the average phase advance with respect to the average action.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Time average of the three turn phase advance ⟨μ3⟩\langle\mu_3\rangle as function of the time average of the action ⟨J⟩\langle J\rangle. The dashed part is numerically unstable.

Even though we can not give an analytical result for the integral in equation 12 describing the average three turn phase advance, a Taylor expansion gives a reasonably good approximation for H~<0.5\tilde{H} < 0.5 (see Figure 4)

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Average phase advance as function of the Hamiltonian HH and Taylor approximation.

⟨μ3⟩=6πd(1−232H~−233H~2+O(H~3))(15)\langle\mu_3 \rangle= 6\pi d \left(1 - \frac{2}{3^2}\tilde{H} - \frac{2}{3^3}\tilde{H}^2 + O\left(\tilde{H}^3\right)\right) \tag*{(15)}

To relate the average three turn phase advance ⟨μ3⟩\langle\mu_3 \rangle to the average phase advance per turn ⟨μ⟩\langle\mu\rangle we note that

⟨μ3⟩=3⟨μ⟩ mod⁡2π(16)\langle\mu_3 \rangle= 3\langle\mu\rangle\ \operatorname{mod} 2\pi \tag*{(16)}

Recalling the linear case where μ=2πq=2π(r+d)\mu= 2\pi q = 2\pi(r+d) we can easily find that in general:

⟨μ⟩=2πr+⟨μ3⟩/3(17)\langle\mu\rangle= 2\pi r + \langle\mu_3 \rangle/3 \tag*{(17)}

Comparison to particle tracking

The results found above agree well with results from particle tracking simulations (Figure 5, q=2/3+0.001q = 2/3 + 0.001, S=0.05 m−1/2S = 0.05\,\mathrm{m}^{-1/2}).

Image not extracted

Figure 5. Three turn (top) and average phase advance (bottom) in phase space (left) and as function of HH (right). Results from tracking simulations (coloured) are compared to the numerical results as derived above (greyscale).

References

  1. [1][Ben97] Michael Benedikt. “Optical Design of a Synchrotron with Optimisation of the Slow Extraction for Hadron Therapy”. PhD thesis. Wien, 1997. URL: https://cds.cern.ch/record/450847.
  2. [2][Ben99] Michael Benedikt et al. Proton-Ion Medical Machine Study (PIMMS): Part I. Tech. rep. CERN/PS 99-010 (DI). Geneva, 1999. URL: https://cds.cern.ch/record/385378.
  3. [3][Cor22] E. C. Cortés García et al. “Optimization of the Spill Quality for the Hadron Therapy at the Heidelberg Ion-Beam Therapy Centre”. In: Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A 1040 (Oct. 2022), p. 167137. DOI: 10.1016/j.nima.2022.167137.DOI
  4. [4][Fei94] Jörg Feikes. “Detuning Due to Sextupoles”. In: Proc. EPAC’94. European Particle Accelerator Conference. London, UK: JACoW Publishing, Geneva, Switzerland, June 1994, pp. 896–898.
  5. [5][Kob67] Y. Kobayashi and H. Takahashi. “Improvement of the Emittance in the Resonant Beam Ejection”. In: Proc. HEACC’67. International Conference on High-Energy Accelerators. Cambridge, MA, USA, Sept. 1967, pp. 347–351.
  6. [6][Kob70] Y. Kobayashi. “Theory of the Resonant Beam Ejection from Synchrotrons”. In: Nuclear Instruments and Methods 83.1 (June 1970), pp. 77–87. DOI: 10.1016/0029-554X(70)90537–9.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_dxmtz5nf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents