betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Relative involutions and inverses in monoidal dualities and slice constructions

Abstract

Our goal in this paper is to work towards developing a framework for characterizing dualities of weak categorical structures. It is often the case that duality involutions are characterized by relations which are more general than f2=1f^2=1. Moreover, it is also true that many dualities cannot be expressed using involutions alone. We develop a framework of relative involutions and relative inverses to express these dualities at least within categorical and bicategorical structures. In particular, we utilize this framework to express the dualities of virtual double categories and some important constructions on them. In the second part, we explore the problem of slicing and consider how dualities of monoidal structures interact with slice constructions. We end by providing a construction for both enriched slice model categories and enriched coslice model categories.

Introduction

Motivation

Our primary motivation to write this paper comes from two questions, which are broadly related under the microcosm principle. The first one concerns the dualities of categorical structures. Consider the op⁡1\operatorname{op}_{1} duality on 1Cat\mathbf{1Cat}, expressed as a 2-functor op⁡1:op⁡2(1Cat)→1Cat\operatorname{op}_{1}: \operatorname{op}_{2}(\mathbf{1Cat}) \to\mathbf{1Cat}, which satisfy the relation op⁡1∘op⁡2(op⁡1)=1\operatorname{op}_{1} \circ\operatorname{op}_{2}(\operatorname{op}_{1}) = 1. Clearly, this is not an involution in the traditional sense of satisfying op⁡1∘op⁡1=1\operatorname{op}_{1} \circ\operatorname{op}_{1} = 1, since this composition is simply not defined. Rather, it is an involution relative to a higher involution op⁡2\operatorname{op}_{2}. This motivates the definition of a relative involution.

Now consider the duality op⁡1:op⁡2(MonCatc)→MonCatl\operatorname{op}_{1}: \operatorname{op}_{2}(\mathbf{MonCat}_{c}) \to\mathbf{MonCat}_{l}. Here, the domain consists of colax monoidal functors, whereas the codomain consists of lax monoidal functors. This is again a duality, but it is no longer directly expressible even using relative involution as before. Instead, this motivates a further generalization to relative inverses.

As with many algebraic structures, specifying the complete coherence data for these definitions becomes increasingly difficult in higher dimensions. Nevertheless, it is tractable and useful enough to define these for involutive bicategories and biadjunction of bicategories. In particular, this framework is sufficiently general to express the dualities of monoidal structures. Furthermore, it is also natural to consider module structures in the presence of monoidal structures. Thus, one of the main goals of this paper is to extend this framework onto virtual double categories and the corresponding module construction.

The second question concerns slicing and its interaction with these dualities. In particular, we wish to describe a general construction of enriched slice and coslice categories, especially under the consideration of model structures. Although there are some accounts of enriched slice constructions, it is useful to have a systematic treatment that encompasses both slice and coslice constructions. Furthermore, the slice and coslice category construction is related by the op⁡1\operatorname{op}_{1} duality. This suggests that the enriched coslice case should be a dual of the enriched slice case in some appropriate sense. Establishing such a construction is the second main goal of this paper.

Main results and applications

The results can be divided into three major parts. The first part establishes a desired framework of relative involutions and relative inverses. The second part applies this framework to characterize dualities of constructions on virtual double categories. The third part discuss the slicing of module structures and establish a general construction of enriched slice and coslice model categories.

Recall that one can define a 1-category of relative involutions, called OInv⁡(C,T,α)\operatorname{OInv}(\mathcal{C}, T, \alpha), inside an arbitrary lax involutive category (C,T,α)(\mathcal{C}, T, \alpha) [34] (or see section 3.1). This is an example of the microcosm principle. Motivated by this fact, we show a similar construction for adjunctions by defining relative inverses. The main result in this part is to generalize this framework one dimension higher for weak 2-involutive bicategories and weak 2-inverses of bicategories. This can be summarized by the following proposition.

Proposition. The microcosm principle holds for weak 2-involutive bicategories and weak 2-inverses of bicategories.

In particular, this provides suitable definitions of relative weak 11-inverses, relative weak 11-involutions, and their 11-morphisms. Note that expressing the dualities of strict nn-categories only require relative involution or relative inverse (see definition 2.1.4). This is in contrast to the monoidal structures, which also require the 11-morphisms. The main result here is that the 22-functors Mod ⁣:vDblCat→vDblCat\mathbf{Mod}\colon\mathbf{vDblCat} \to\mathbf{vDblCat} and CoMod ⁣:vcoDblCat→vcoDblCat\mathbf{CoMod}\colon\mathbf{vcoDblCat} \to\mathbf{vcoDblCat} are compatible with the relevant dualities.

Theorem. The following extensions hold:

  1. Mod\mathbf{Mod} extends to a 11-morphism of involution, respecting the horizontal duality of virtual double categories.

  1. Mod\mathbf{Mod} and CoMod\mathbf{CoMod} together extend to a 11-morphism of inverses, respecting the vertical duality of virtual double categories.

In the final part, we first briefly review the slice constructions for module categories. Recall that standard definitions of an enriched model category assumes the existence of a two-variable closure adjunction relating tensoring, powering, and enrichment [20] (or see § 5.2). Hence, we focus primarily on the behavior of this two-variable adjunction under slicing. We show that it can be sliced in two dual ways, one by slicing the tensoring and the other by slicing the powering. The main result is that these slicing also respect the model structures.

Theorem. Let C\mathcal{C} be a V\mathcal{V}-enriched model categories. Let M∈VM \in\mathcal{V} and Z∈CZ \in\mathcal{C} be suitable monoid and module object, respectively. Then, both Z/CZ/\mathcal{C} and C/Z\mathcal{C}/Z are V/M\mathcal{V}/M-enriched model categories.

Overview

Section 22 discusses the dualities of strict nn-categories as a motivating example of nested algebraic structures. To formulate this more precisely, it recall the microcosm principle and define the sliced microcosm principle. A relevant example of these principles is then provided in terms of pseudomonoid and pseudomodule objects.

Section 33 begins by briefly reviewing the theory of involutions and relative involutions. Correspondingly, it defines the similar theory of inverses and relative inverses. Then, the analogues of these structures are described in one dimension higher.

Section 44 starts with reformulating the dualities of monoidal categories within the framework of relative inverses and involutions. This framework is then used to describe the corresponding dualities of internal monoid structures. Subsequently, the dualities are generalized to the level of virtual double categories, encoding the action on the module data.

Section 55 applies the sliced microcosm principle to monoidal and module structures. First, it reviews enrichment through tensoring and states the corresponding slice construction. The results are then dualized for the case of cotensoring. Finally, these constructions are extended to the setting of enriched model categories.

Preliminaries

TEXT

nCat, monoidal nn-structures, and categorical dualities

Recall that the category 1Cat=Cat\mathbf{1}\mathrm{Cat}=\mathrm{Cat} is canonically enriched over itself using the functor categories Cat(C,D)\mathrm{Cat}(\mathcal{C},\mathcal{D}). It also has a Kelly tensor product given by the cartesian product C×D\mathcal{C}\times\mathcal{D} of two categories, which forms a monoidal structure. Therefore, it is natural to ask whether this enrichment and the monoidal structure are compatible. Indeed, we can enrich the monoidal structure to a monoidal 22-structure1 in a canonical way. There exists a Cat\mathrm{Cat} enriched adjunction

Cat‾(C×D,E)≃Cat‾(C,Cat‾(D,E)),\underline{\mathrm{Cat}}(\mathcal{C}\times\mathcal{D},\mathcal{E})\simeq\underline{\mathrm{Cat}}(\mathcal{C},\underline{\mathrm{Cat}}(\mathcal{D},\mathcal{E})),

by using a general result which holds for any closed symmetric monoidal category category V\mathcal{V} [22, Prop. 3.1.11]. In this enriched adjunction, both the product and the internal hom functors are 22-functors. Furthermore, the left unitor, the right unitor, the associator, and the symmetry are now all 22-natural transformations. This defines, naturally, a symmetric cartesian closed monoidal 22-structure.

Lemma 2.1.1. The tuple (Cat,×,{∗},aCat,λCat,ρCat)(\mathrm{Cat},\times,\{\ast\},a_{\mathrm{Cat}},\lambda_{\mathrm{Cat}},\rho_{\mathrm{Cat}}) defines a symmetric cartesian closed monoidal structure on Cat\mathrm{Cat}. Furthermore, this monoidal structure can be Cat\mathrm{Cat}-enriched by canonically extending the monoidal data {×,aCat,λCat,ρCat}\{\times,a_{\mathrm{Cat}},\lambda_{\mathrm{Cat}},\rho_{\mathrm{Cat}}\} to a strict 22-functor and strict 22-natural transformations. All the coherence relations remain unchanged. This makes Cat\mathrm{Cat} a monoidal 22-category.

As a consequence, it is natural question to ask whether the same result extends to nCat\mathrm{nCat} or ωCat\omega\mathrm{Cat}. The following general lemma answers this in affirmative.

Lemma 2.1.2. Let V\mathcal{V} be a locally small, complete, and cocomplete cartesian closed monoidal category. Then, the category VCat\mathcal{V}\mathrm{Cat} (of small V\mathcal{V}-categories) is also locally small, complete, cocomplete, and cartesian closed. Furthermore, the cartesian product of VCat\mathcal{V}\mathrm{Cat} is precisely the Kelly tensor product, as given by the cartesian product of sets of objects and the corresponding products of hom-objects.

Proof. Given any symmetric closed monoidal category V\mathcal{V}, the (co)completeness of V\mathcal{V} implies the (co)completeness of VCat\mathcal{V}\mathrm{Cat} by results of [33] [6, 24]. And, the Kelly tensor product of VCat\mathcal{V}\mathrm{Cat} forms a symmetric closed monoidal structure by [23, Sec. 2.3]. We are only left to verify that the kelly tensor product is indeed the cartesian product. This last part essentially follows from the monadicity of VCat\mathcal{V}\mathrm{Cat} over VGraph\mathcal{V}\mathrm{Graph}.

In particular, this lemma provides the following desired corollary.

Corollary 2.1.3. The tuple (nCat,×,{∗},anCat,λnCat,ρnCat)(\mathrm{nCat},\times,\{\ast\},a_{\mathrm{nCat}},\lambda_{\mathrm{nCat}},\rho_{\mathrm{nCat}}) canonically defines a symmetric cartesian closed monoidal (n+1)(n+1)-structure on nCat\mathrm{nCat}.

Finally, this result also extends to ωCat\omega\mathrm{Cat}, which can be defined as a form of colimit of the enrichment process. In particular, the category of all (small) ωCat\omega\mathrm{Cat}-enriched category is just the category ωCat\omega\mathrm{Cat} itself and is cartesian closed. The interested reader maybe look up the details in [26, 32].

Using suitable universes, it is also clear that each monoidal (n+1)(n+1)-category nCat\mathrm{nCat} is equivalently a “monoidal object” inside the monoidal (n+2)(n+2)-category (n+1)Cat(n+1)\mathrm{Cat}. This provides our first example of a nested algebraic structure.

Another primary example is given by the duality involution of strict nn-categories. Consider the 11-functor op⁡1:1Cat→1Cat\operatorname{op}_{1}: 1\mathrm{Cat} \to1\mathrm{Cat} which sends each category CC to its opposite category CopC^{\mathrm{op}}. This is a duality involution 11-functor on 1Cat1\mathrm{Cat}, that is, op⁡12=1\operatorname{op}_{1}^{2}=1. However, as 1Cat1\mathrm{Cat} is naturally a strict 22-category, we may wish to upgrade this duality involution to a strict 22-functor. This is not possible. What we instead have is a strict 22-functor op⁡1:op⁡2(1Cat)→1Cat\operatorname{op}_{1}: \operatorname{op}_{2}(1\mathrm{Cat}) \to1\mathrm{Cat}, where op⁡2\operatorname{op}_{2} is a strict 11-functor op⁡2:2Cat≤1→2Cat≤1\operatorname{op}_{2}: 2\mathrm{Cat}_{\leq1} \to2\mathrm{Cat}_{\leq1} and (−)≤i(-)_{\leq i} denotes truncation of categorical structures. Moreover, the duality of op⁡1\operatorname{op}_{1} is now expressed by the equation op⁡1∘op⁡2(op⁡1)=1\operatorname{op}_{1} \circ\operatorname{op}_{2}(\operatorname{op}_{1})=1.

Thus, op⁡1\operatorname{op}_{1} duality is fully defined only in the presence of a higher dimensional op⁡2\operatorname{op}_{2} duality. More generally, let op⁡n,k\operatorname{op}_{n,k} denote the kk-cell duality on nn-categories for 1≤k≤n1 \leq k \leq n. All the 11-functors (op⁡n,k)≤1:nCat≤1→nCat≤1(\operatorname{op}_{n,k})_{\leq1}: n\mathrm{Cat}_{\leq1} \to n\mathrm{Cat}_{\leq1} are definable readily. See [3, 5] for example. This leads to the following natural proposition.

Proposition 2.1.4. For each 1≤k≤n1 \leq k \leq n, the 11-functor (op⁡n,k)≤1:nCat≤1→nCat≤1(\operatorname{op}_{n,k})_{\leq1}: n\mathrm{Cat}_{\leq1} \to n\mathrm{Cat}_{\leq1} extends to a corresponding (n+1)(n+1)-functor op⁡n,k:op⁡n+1,k+1(nCat)→nCat\operatorname{op}_{n,k}: \operatorname{op}_{n+1,k+1}(n\mathrm{Cat}) \to n\mathrm{Cat}.

Note that both nCatn\mathrm{Cat} and op⁡n+1,k+1(nCat)\operatorname{op}_{n+1,k+1}(n\mathrm{Cat}) are enriched over nCatn\mathrm{Cat} by definition as they are (n+1)(n+1)-categories. This means that our primary goal is to extend the given 11-functors to corresponding nCatn\mathrm{Cat}-enriched functor. Consequently, we first state the following more general lemma inspired by an example in [31, Ex. 4.6].

Lemma 2.1.5. Let (V,⊗,I)(\mathcal{V}, \otimes, I) be a closed symmetric monoidal category equipped with a strict symmetric monoidal functor o:V→Vo: \mathcal{V} \to\mathcal{V} satisfying o2=1o^{2}=1. Then, there exists a canonical V\mathcal{V}-enriched functor o:o∗(V)→Vo: o_{*}(\mathcal{V}) \to\mathcal{V}, which extends the 11-functor o:V→Vo: \mathcal{V} \to\mathcal{V}.

Proof. V\mathcal{V} is enriched, tensored, and cotensored over itself because it is a closed symmetric monoidal category. More precisely, V\mathcal{V} extends to a symmetric monoidal V\mathcal{V}-enriched category [22, Thm. 3.3.2]. Thus, we can do a change of base of enrichment to produce a V\mathcal{V}-enriched category o∗(V)o_{*}(\mathcal{V}). Note that the underlying category of o∗(V)o_{*}(\mathcal{V}) is still V\mathcal{V} itself because oo is a strict monoidal functor.

The key idea is to note that o∗(V)o_{*}(\mathcal{V}) is also tensored over V\mathcal{V}. We define the tensoring operation using the functor ◃:V×V→o×1V×V→⊗V\triangleleft: \mathcal{V} \times\mathcal{V} \xrightarrow{o\times1} \mathcal{V} \times\mathcal{V} \xrightarrow{\otimes} \mathcal{V}. Our goal is now to show that there is a V\mathcal{V}-isomorphism

o∗(V)(A◃X,Y)≅V(A,o∗(V)(X,Y))o_{*}(\mathcal{V})(A \triangleleft X,Y) \cong\mathcal{V}(A,o_{*}(\mathcal{V})(X,Y))

natural in all of A,X,YA,X,Y. This is a straightforward exercise using the Yoneda lemma. Thus, we have established that ◃\triangleleft is indeed a valid tensoring operation.

Finally, we note the following commuting diagram

V×V→1×oV×V→X⊗o(Y)o×1↓↓⊗↓V×V→⊗V→oV→o(X◃Y)\begin{CD} \mathcal{V}\times\mathcal{V} @>{1\times o}>> \mathcal{V}\times\mathcal{V} @>>> X\otimes o(Y) \\ @V{o\times1}VV @VV{\otimes}V @VVV \\ \mathcal{V}\times\mathcal{V} @>{\otimes}>> \mathcal{V} @>{o}>> \mathcal{V} @>>> o(X\triangleleft Y) \end{CD}

References

  1. [33]H. Wolff. V-cat and V-graph. Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra, 4(2):123–135, Apr. 1974. ISSN 0022–4049. doi: 10.1016/0022-4049(74)90018-8. p. 3DOI
  2. [34]D. Yau. Involutive Category Theory. Springer International Publishing, 2020. ISBN 9783030612030. doi: 10.1007/978-3-030-61203-0. pp. 1, 12, 16, 17, 29DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_dy4fcht8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC0-1.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents