betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Towards decoupling the effects of permeability and roughness on turbulent boundary layers

Abstract

Boundary layer flow over a realistic porous wall might contain both the effects of wall-permeability and wall-roughness. These two effects are typically examined in the context of a rough-wall flow, i.e., by defining a ``roughness'' length or equivalent to capture the effect of the surface on momentum deficit/drag. In this work, we examine the hypothesis of Esteban et al. (2022), that a turbulent boundary layer over a porous wall could be modelled as a superposition of the roughness effects on the permeability effects by using independently obtained information on permeability and roughness. We carry out wind tunnel experiments at high Reynolds number (14400≤Reτ≤3310014400 \leq Re_τ \leq 33100) on various combinations of porous walls where different roughnesses are overlaid over a given permeable wall. Measurements are also conducted on the permeable wall as well as the rough walls independently to obtain the corresponding lengthscales. Analysis of mean flow data across all these measurements suggests that an empirical formulation can be obtained where the momentum deficit (ΔU+ΔU^+) is modelled as a combination of independently obtained roughness and permeability lengthscales. This formulation assumes the presence of outer-layer similarity across these different surfaces, which is shown to be valid at high Reynolds numbers. Finally, this decoupling approach is equivalent to the area-weighted power-mean of the respective permeability and roughness lengthscales, consistent with the approach recently suggested by Hutchins et al. (2023) to capture the effects of heterogeneous rough surfaces.

Introduction

Flow over porous walls comprises an extensive number of natural phenomena, ranging from blood vessels to the atmospheric boundary layer (ABL) developing over a forest canopy. The latter can be considered as a turbulent boundary layer (TBL) developing over a porous wall. An example of porous walls, constructed from packed spheres, is shown in Figure 1. Here, both walls approximately have the same permeability (resistance of a substrate to fluid flows), but the wall shown in Figure 1(a) has a roughness interface above the porous wall, while in Figure 1(b) this interface comprises of a flat surface. Thus, a realistic representation of a porous wall is both permeable and rough to some extent; for the wall in Figure 1(a), the effects of both permeability and roughness have to be considered for characterisation of a TBL developing over such wall.

Figure 1. Illustrations of realistic permeable walls with: (a) a rough wall on the interface and (b) flat interface. Adapted from Rosti et al. [16].

Rough walls

The presence of rough walls increases skin friction from that of smooth walls and thus the time-averaged streamwise velocity UU of TBLs developing over rough walls can be written as a downward shift of the logarithmic region ΔU+\Delta U^{+} from the smooth wall velocity profile

U+=1κln⁡[(y+d)Uτν]+B−ΔU+=1κln⁡(y+y0)++B−ΔU+(1)U^{+} = \frac{1}{\kappa}\ln\left[\frac{(y+d)U_{\tau}}{\nu}\right] + B - \Delta U^{+} = \frac{1}{\kappa}\ln(y+y_{0})^{+} + B - \Delta U^{+} \tag*{(1)}

The viscous-scaled velocity is defined as U+≡U/UτU^{+} \equiv U/U_{\tau}, where Uτ≡τw/ρU_{\tau} \equiv\sqrt{\tau_{w}/\rho} is the friction velocity, τw\tau_{w} and ρ\rho are the wall shear stress (WSS) and the density of fluid, respectively. The logarithmic profile is defined as follows: κ\kappa is the von Kármán constant, dd is the zero-plane displacement, ν\nu is the kinematic viscosity of fluid, and BB is the log-law intercept. The logarithmic shift ΔU+\Delta U^{+}, also known as the Hama roughness function (Hama [6]), is defined as

ΔU+=1κln⁡(ksUτν)+B−BFR=1κln⁡ks++B−BFR(2)\Delta U^{+} = \frac{1}{\kappa}\ln\left(\frac{k_{s}U_{\tau}}{\nu}\right) + B - B_{FR} = \frac{1}{\kappa}\ln k_{s}^{+} + B - B_{FR} \tag*{(2)}

where ksk_{s} is the equivalent sand grain roughness and BFR=8.5B_{FR}=8.5 is the ‘fully’ rough intercept of the velocity profile of sand grain roughness. It should be noted that ksk_{s} is a measure of roughness effect on the flow relative to that of a uniform sand grain roughness (Nikuradse [14]); it can only be determined by flow measurements. The mean streamwise velocity profile of a rough wall can therefore be written as a function of its ksk_{s}

U+=1κln⁡(y+dks)+BFR(3)U^{+} = \frac{1}{\kappa}\ln\left(\frac{y+d}{k_{s}}\right) + B_{FR} \tag*{(3)}

Permeable walls

Earlier studies of TBLs developing over permeable walls involved various types of such walls, namely: packed spheres (Zagni & Smith [19]), perforated sheets (Kong & Schetz [9]), bed of grains (Zippe & Graf [20]), and multi-layered walls (Manes et al. [12]). Permeable walls have been found to increase drag (i.e. skin friction coefficient Cf≡2(Uτ/U∞)2C_{f} \equiv2(U_{\tau}/U_{\infty})^{2}) from that of solid, impermeable walls, which is attributed to the increase of dissipation, momentum flux, and Reynolds shear stress on the interface between the fluid and the substrates ([19, 17]). Similar to the rough wall TBLs, the increase in CfC_{f} of permeable walls is also characterised by a downward shift in the logarithmic region from that of a solid, smooth wall ([5, 2]). Thus, it is probable that there is a “universal" parameter that characterise permeable walls – possibly equivalent to ksk_s for rough wall TBLs. It was suggested by Manes et al. [11] that the logarithmic region of a TBL developing over a permeable wall scales on permeability KK, and this can be further rearranged to show a downward logarithmic shift,

U+=1κln⁡(y+dK)+c1=1κln⁡(y+d)+−1κln⁡ReK+c1(4)U^{+} = \frac{1}{\kappa}\ln\left(\frac{y+d}{\sqrt{K}}\right)+c_1 = \frac{1}{\kappa}\ln(y+d)^{+}-\frac{1}{\kappa}\ln Re_K+c_1 \tag*{(4)}

where ReK=KUτ/νRe_K=\sqrt{K}U_\tau/\nu. Previous studies observed a wide range of magnitude of κ\kappa ([1, 11, 18]), which is largely attributed to the low ReRe at which these studies were conducted and thus there was not enough separation between the inner and outer layers of the wall-bounded flows ([11]). A more recent experimental work by Esteban et al. [3], conducted at a higher order of magnitude of ReRe (2000≤Reτ≤180002000 \le Re_\tau\le18000), observed that κ=0.39\kappa=0.39, similar to that of smooth and rough wall TBLs. It was further hypothesised by Esteban et al. [3] that c1c_1 in equation (4) is an additive constant related to the blockage effect of a porous substrate, as a realistic porous wall comprises of both permeable matrix and solid substrates (see, for example, Figure 1), whose size does not permit the full isolation of permeability effect ([1]). This blockage effect might be represented by a roughness function ΔUb+=1/κln⁡ksb++B−BFR\Delta U_b^{+}=1/\kappa\ln k_{sb}^{+}+B-B_{FR}, similar to that of equation (2),

U+=1κln⁡(y+d)+−1κln⁡ReK−1κln⁡ksb++BFR=1κln⁡(y+dReKksb)+BFR(5)U^{+}=\frac{1}{\kappa}\ln(y+d)^{+}-\frac{1}{\kappa}\ln Re_K-\frac{1}{\kappa}\ln k_{sb}^{+}+B_{FR}=\frac{1}{\kappa}\ln\left(\frac{y+d}{Re_K k_{sb}}\right)+B_{FR} \tag*{(5)}

where subscript ‘bb’ denote the blockage effect of the porous substrate. By comparing equation (3) and (5), the ‘equivalent sand grain roughness’ ksk_s of a porous wall (subscript ‘pp’) can be defined as

ksp=ReKksb(6)k_{sp}=Re_K k_{sb} \tag*{(6)}

In this study, we take the first steps towards exploring the possibility of decoupling permeability and roughness effects on turbulent boundary layers. We have constructed three different porous test surfaces where we maintain the permeability (ReKRe_K) but the blockage is systematically altered by adding roughness on to a given permeable substrate. Detailed hot-wire and drag-balance measurements are taken for the permeable, rough and the combination of permeable-rough surfaces over a wide range of Reynolds numbers (ensuring the flow is in fully-rough regime for all cases). We use the experimental data to explore two different approaches for decoupling the two effects. First, we extend the above-mentioned framework to include the effects of additional roughness. Second, we use a power-mean averaging approach proposed for heterogeneous roughness (Hutchins et al. [7]) to find an equivalent roughness lengthscale that can capture the combined effect of permeability and roughness.

Experimental Setup

Facility

Measurements are conducted inside the closed return boundary layer wind tunnel (BLWT) at the University of Southampton. The flow passes through a contraction section of 6:1 ratio before entering the 12 m × 1.2 m × 1 m (length × width × height) test section. The boundary layer develops over the floor (bottom surface) of the BLWT. A 220 mm-long smooth wall ramp is installed at the end of the contraction section (Figure 2(a)) to match the thickness of the test surfaces. This ramp marks the inlet towards the test section of the BLWT and the streamwise datum (x=0x = 0). The boundary layer is tripped by a 8.5 mm-wide, 0.4 mm-thick turbulator tape attached on the ramp (Figure 2(a)(b)). The tunnel has the freestream turbulence level of σu′/U∞≈0.1%\sigma_{u}'/U_{\infty} \approx0.1\%, where σu′\sigma_{u}' is the standard deviation of streamwise turbulent fluctuation at the freestream and U∞U_{\infty} is the freestream velocity. The BLWT is equipped with a water-cooled heat exchanger, maintaining the flow temperature variation of 1% for the longest measurements (∼8\sim8 hours).

Figure 2. (a) Illustration of a test surface laid inside the test section of the boundary layer wind tunnel. Combination of porous-rough test surfaces: (b) porous P–rough wall R1, and (c) porous P–rough wall R2. (d) Geometric parameters of P, R1, and R2, where kk is the thickness of the surfaces. For P: ss is the average pore size of the foam, ε\varepsilon is the porosity, and KK is the permeability, obtained from Esteban et al. [3]. For R1 and R2: AoA_o is the open area ratio of the mesh, ll is the length of the longway of the mesh, ww is the length of the shortway of the mesh, and tt is the width of the mesh strand, as illustrated in (c).

Test surfaces

Five test surfaces are constructed for this study: porous wall (denoted by ‘P’, Figure 2(a)(c)), two types of rough walls (‘R1’ and ‘R2’, Figure 2b,c), and two combinations of rough walls on top of the porous wall (‘PR1’ and ‘PR2’, Figure 2b,c). All test surfaces are assembled on the bottom surface of the BLWT, downstream of the ramp and trip (Figure 2a). The ramp and test surfaces only cover the first 10.8 m-long part of the test section, while the section from x=10.8x = 10.8 m to x=12x = 12 m comprises of a smooth wall (Figure 2a). All measurements are conducted at a constant xx location at a range freestream velocity U∞U_{\infty}, corresponding to a set of matched friction Reynolds number Reτ≡δUτ/ν±1600Re_{\tau} \equiv\delta U_{\tau}/\nu\pm1600 (here, δ\delta is the 99% boundary-layer thickness) between P, R1, and PR1, as well as another set of matched ReτRe_{\tau} for P, R2, and PR2. The first set of test surfaces has 5 matched ReτRe_{\tau} cases (Reτ≈14400Re_{\tau} \approx14400, 18600, 23400, 22900, and, 33100), while the second set has four matched cases (Reτ≈14400Re_{\tau} \approx14400, 18600, 23400, and 27700). Details of each test surfaces, including the statistics obtained from HWA and WSS measurements, are given in Table 1. Throughout this study, each test surface is denoted with a symbol (see the last column in Table 1). The same colour denotes surfaces The porous walls are constructed from sheets of 15 mm-thick (1060≤k+≡kUτ/ν≤21301060 \leq k^+ \equiv kU_\tau/\nu\leq2130), 45 ppi (pores per inch) polyurethane reticulated foam. The substrate has the average pore size of s=0.89s = 0.89 mm (63≤s+≡sUτ/ν≤12663 \leq s^+ \equiv sU_\tau/\nu\leq126) and permeability of K=3.62×10−8K = 3.62 \times10^{-8} m2^2, corresponding to 13≤ReK≤27.513 \leq Re_K \leq27.5. The rough walls are constructed from two types of diamond-shaped, expanded metal mesh sheets denoted by R1 and R2 (figure 2b,c). The mesh sheets have the thickness of k=3k = 3 and 3.5 mm (178≤k+≤476178 \leq k^+ \leq476) for R1 and R2, respectively, and the open area AoA_o (ratio of empty to total area in xzxz–plane) of 0.73 and 0.81. Both mesh sheets only cover a 1 m-wide portion (in zz) of the working section (figure 2(a)).

Caseδ\delta [mm]θ\theta [mm]U∞U_\infty [ms−1^{-1}]UτU_\tau [ms−1^{-1}]RexRe_x [×107\times10^7]ReθRe_\theta [×104\times10^4]ReτRe_\tau [×104\times10^4]ReKRe_K [–]CfC_f [×10−3\times10^{-3}]Π\Pi [–]ΔU+\Delta U^+ [–]ksk_s [mm]ks+k_s^+ [–]Sym.
201.1124.5519.841.061.183.291.4413.625.720.2712.01560◯
199.9624.4525.451.361.524.211.8517.575.740.2712.66723◯
P208.2625.3729.061.541.765.072.2120.225.650.3113.027.83832◯
211.2725.8835.461.872.146.302.7224.505.590.3413.521008◯
221.2526.4340.052.132.397.183.2027.525.670.2413.811132◯
232.4028.5114.900.860.872.821.33–6.690.1912.88773△
236.8428.7819.931.151.173.831.82–6.700.1813.641041△
R1239.3828.7025.201.461.484.822.32–6.670.1914.2313.521310△
243.7828.8429.581.711.735.682.77–6.690.1814.651539△
254.3329.5235.212.042.056.873.42–6.690.1515.081821△
241.1129.4115.100.890.892.961.44–7.010.1913.44963◇
R2229.3328.5619.741.181.153.751.79–7.090.1814.1416.171263◇
229.3428.2524.901.491.464.682.27–7.120.1814.741599◇
230.0328.6429.831.781.755.692.73–7.130.1615.211920◇
225.4126.9017.281.061.013.081.5813.327.480.1814.081235☆
218.1227.1721.471.311.263.901.9216.747.490.1514.661552☆
PR1227.9327.2826.041.601.544.782.4620.557.600.1415.1917.651906☆
226.6427.3331.491.941.855.742.9424.657.600.0915.652286☆
229.1127.2835.012.172.056.363.3127.467.670.1015.932547☆
219.4227.2915.060.950.902.791.4112.277.940.1314.231254☆
PR2221.7327.4119.971.261.203.751.9116.407.930.1314.9819.451677☆
224.4127.6125.201.591.524.772.4520.767.980.1315.582122☆
222.9628.0628.261.791.695.402.7123.168.000.1415.862368☆

Table 1. Summary of all test surfaces: baseline smooth walls (S), porous (P), rough (R1 and R2), and porous-rough (PR1 and PR2) walls. The statistics are obtained from HWA measurements: δ\delta is the 99% boundary-layer thickness and θ\theta is the momentum thickness. Reynolds number definitions are: Rex≡xU∞/νRe_x \equiv xU_\infty/\nu, Reθ≡θU∞/νRe_\theta\equiv\theta U_\infty/\nu, Reτ≡δUτ/νRe_\tau\equiv\delta U_\tau/\nu, and ReK≡KUτ/νRe_K \equiv KU_\tau/\nu. Coefficient of friction is defined as Cf≡2(Uτ/U∞)2C_f \equiv2(U_\tau/U_\infty)^2. The last column shows the symbol associated with each test surface. Colours denote test cases with approximately matched ReτRe_\tau and ReK≈14400Re_K \approx14400 and 13 (◯), 18600 and 17 (◯), 23400 and 20.5 (◯), 27700 and 24 (◯), 33100 and 27.5 (◯), with matched ReτRe_\tau and ReKRe_K (within ReK±10%Re_K \pm10\%), which runs from lighter towards darker colour as ReτRe_\tau and ReKRe_K increases.

Details of the relevant parameters regarding the porous substrate and mesh geometries are given in Figure 2(d).

Hot-wire anemometry

Hot-wire anemometry (HWA) measurements are conducted for all test surfaces listed in Table 1 by traversing the wire in wall-normal direction yy across 35–40 logarithmically-spaced points from the wall towards the freestream. All measurements are conducted at the centreline of the tunnel at x=8.8x = 8.8 m from the datum of the tunnel test section (Figure 2(a)ⓕ). A modified Dantec 55P05 single-sensor with a boundary-layer type probe (and an appropriate probe support) are used with a Streamline Pro Constant Temperature Anemometer (CTA) with an overheat ratio of 0.8. The sensor is a 5 μ\mum diameter, 1-mm long tungsten wire soldered to the tip of the hot-wire prong, satisfying the recommended wire length-to-diameter ratio of 200 ([10]) and corresponding to the viscous-scaled sensor lengths of 57≤lw+≡lwUτ/ν≤14557 \le l_w^+ \equiv l_w U_\tau/\nu\le145. The output signal is sampled from the CTA at fs=30f_s = 30 kHz, yielding viscous-scaled sampling interval of 1.6≤t+≡Uτ2/(fsν)≤101.6 \le t^+ \equiv U_\tau^2/(f_s\nu) \le10. The sampling time TsT_s at each measurement point differs between test surfaces such that the boundary-layer turnover time is maintained at TsU∞/δ≥20000T_sU_\infty/\delta\ge20000 to allow convergence of turbulence energy spectra ([8]). The sensor is traversed to the freestream and calibrated prior to and after each measurement. The relation between freestream velocity U∞U_\infty and output voltage of the sensor E∞E_\infty is defined by King’s law E∞2=C1+C2U∞3E_\infty^2 = C_1 + C_2U_\infty^3. Temperature compensation is applied to the output signal to account for a slight sensor drift.

Wall shear stress (WSS) measurements

The WSSs of all test surfaces shown in Table 1 are measured using an in-house floating element (FE) drag balance. The balance has a 200 mm ×\times 200 mm FE located at x=8.6x = 8.6 m (Figure 2(a)ⓔ), slightly upstream of the HWA measurement station. A section of each test surfaces are cut according to the size of the FE and mounted on top of the FE, leaving a 0.5 mm clearance between the FE and its housing, allowing it to move freely for WSS measurements. The housing is sealed to prevent airflow into the balance. Measurements are acquired at fs=256f_s = 256 Hz with 120 s sampling time for each test surface. Calibration of the balance is performed before measurements by loading a set of calibration weights to the balance via a pulley system. The relationship between known calibration weights and time-averaged output voltage (within ±0.96%\pm0.96\% uncertainties) from the balance is obtained by fitting the calibration data into a first order polynomial.

Figure 3(a) shows the CfC_f of all test surfaces as a function of fetch Reynolds number Rex≡xU∞/νRe_x \equiv xU_\infty/\nu. For validation, CfC_f of smooth walls (2930≤Reτ≤125002930 \le Re_\tau\le12500) are determined first using three different methods: (i) direct WSS measurements using the FE drag balance (□), (ii) fitting velocity profiles obtained from HWA measurements to the composite profile of Rodríguez-López et al. [15] (□), (iii) the analytical solution of Monty et al. [13] (▬). All three methods show a reasonable agreement with each other to within 5%.

Five-panel figure showing skin-friction coefficient, velocity profiles, logarithmic shifts, velocity defect, and permeability and roughness parameters

Figure 3. (a) CfC_f as a function of RexRe_x for all test surfaces. Validation of the WSS measurements with smooth walls (□): fitted to the composite profile of Rodríguez-López et al. [15] (■) and the analytical solution of Monty et al. [13] (▬). The same porous surface measured by Esteban et al. [3] (○). Porous wall (ks=7.83k_s = 7.83 mm) at constant ReK≡kU∞/νRe_K \equiv k U_\infty/\nu (—) and constant ks/xk_s/x (—), obtained from Monty et al. [13]. (b) U+U^+ as a function of y+y^+ for matched Reτ≈27700Re_\tau\approx27700, – – –: 1/κln⁡y++B1/\kappa\ln y^+ + B. (c) ΔU+\Delta U^+ as functions of ks+k_s^+ (white-filled symbols, bottom axis) and ReKRe_K (filled symbols, top axis). – – –: 1/κln⁡ks++B−BFR1/\kappa\ln k_s^+ + B - B_{FR}. Legends are shown in Table 1. (d) Velocity defect U∞+−U+U_\infty^+ - U^+ as a function of y/δy/\delta for matched Reτ≈27700Re_\tau\approx27700. (e) Decoupling of permeability and roughness effect using methods described in §3.

For the rest of the test surfaces P, R, and PR, CfC_f are determined from direct WSS measurements. Both rough walls (R1 and R2) have higher CfC_f than that of porous walls, which increase further as the walls are combined with the porous walls (PR1 and PR2), as shown in Figure 3(a). The logarithmic shift ΔU+\Delta U^+ and ksk_s for these surfaces are obtained by fitting the mean profile to a modified method of Rodríguez-López et al. [15], in which the log-law shift term ΔU+\Delta U^+ is added, forming equation (1) while maintaining the UτU_\tau obtained from direct WSS measurements. The fit yields κ=0.39\kappa= 0.39 and B=4.34±0.08B = 4.34 \pm0.08 (consistent with those obtained for TBLs developing over various porous walls measured by Esteban et al. [3]). Porous wall CfC_f (Figure 3(a)) is compared to the analytical solution proposed by Monty et al. [13] over constant ks/x=8.9×10−4k_s/x = 8.9 \times10^{-4} (ks=7.83k_s = 7.83 mm). Additionally, CfC_f obtained by Esteban et al. [3] for the same porous wall, ks/x=2.4×10−3k_s/x = 2.4 \times10^{-3} (ks=7.97k_s = 7.97 mm) is also compared with the analytical solution, both showing good agreement with these solutions.

Figure 3(b) shows the vertical downward shift in the logarithmic region for all test surfaces at a matched Reτ≈27700Re_\tau\approx27700 (the highest matched ReτRe_\tau for PR2 set and second highest for PR1) from a smooth wall TBL at this matched ReτRe_\tau. This shift, denoted by ΔU+\Delta U^+, is shown as a function of ks+k_s^+ in Figure 3(c) for all test surfaces (white-filled contours). All collapse to the logarithmic function 1/κln⁡ks++B−BFR1/\kappa\ln k_s^+ + B - B_{FR} (equation (2)), although this is given since ksk_s is not obtained independently from ΔU+\Delta U^+. The magnitude of ks+k_s^+ (Table 1) exceeds the threshold defined by Flack & Schultz [4], ks+≳70k_s^+ \gtrsim70, ensuring that all test surfaces are ‘fully’ rough and thus ΔU+\Delta U^+ depends solely on ksk_s. It should be noted that ΔU+\Delta U^+ here accounts for the total momentum deficit (from that of smooth wall TBLs) in both porous and rough walls, and it shows that it is possible to characterise porous wall with the same framework used for rough wall characterisation (i.e. logarithmic shift that scales on ksk_s). The effect of permeability on ΔU+\Delta U^+ is shown in Figure 3(c) for test surfaces comprises of porous walls (P, PR1, and PR2, filled contours). Although it is clear that ΔU+\Delta U^+ is logarithmically scaled by ReKRe_K, universality, as shown in Figure 3(c) with ksk_s, is not apparent. This highlights the importance of accounting for the ‘blockage’ effect (equation (5)). At high range of ReτRe_\tau tested in this study, the outer layer similarity is preserved for all test surfaces (i.e. velocity defect profiles collapse beyond y/δ≳0.2y/\delta\gtrsim0.2, Figure 3d), ensuring that a given value of ksk_s (for a surface) can be used to predict the drag at higher Reynolds numbers.

Decoupling permeability and roughness effect

Additional blockage effect

We rewrite equation (6) for porous wall (case P) in a more general term

ksp=ReKf(ksb)(7)k_{sp}=Re_K f(k_{sb}) \tag*{(7)}

where f(ksb)f(k_{sb}) is a function representing the blockage effect by the substrate. As a roughness interface is added (case PR), a roughness term, possibly a function of the characteristic lengthscale of roughness (i.e. rough wall ksk_s) increases blockage

kspr=ReKf(ksb,ksr)(8)k_{spr}=Re_K f(k_{sb},k_{sr}) \tag*{(8)}

where subscripts ‘r’ denotes the rough wall and ‘pr’ the porous-rough wall. When two substrates have an approximately matched permeability, then the additional blockage effect can be approximated by f(ksb,ksr)/f(ksb)≈kspr/kspf(k_{sb},k_{sr})/f(k_{sb}) \approx k_{spr}/k_{sp}. Case PR1 has 5 matched ReKRe_K with case P (within 5% difference, Table 1). As the ksk_s for these surfaces are known from fitting ΔU+\Delta U^+ (§ 2.4), the additional blockage is approximated by f(ksb,ksr)/f(ksb)=2.25f(k_{sb},k_{sr})/f(k_{sb})=2.25 (Figure 3e) within 10% error due to ReKRe_K difference. This is interpreted as the rough wall R1 increases the total blockage effect by approximately 2.25 times from that of porous wall.

At this point, the empirical formulation of f(ksb,ksr)f(k_{sb},k_{sr}) is unknown. Let the roughness effect be represented solely by rough wall ksk_s

f(ksb,ksr)=f(ksb)Cksr(9)f(k_{sb},k_{sr})=f(k_{sb})Ck_{sr} \tag*{(9)}

where CC is a constant. For an approximately matched ReKRe_K, C≈kspr/(kspksr)C \approx k_{spr}/(k_{sp}k_{sr}). We obtain C=0.17C=0.17 for case PR1 (Figure 3e), and further test this formulation for the second roughness PR2. Here, there are 4 matched ReKRe_K cases (within 10% difference, Table 1). The total blockage effect increases by approximately 2.5 times from the porous wall (Figure 3e), consistent with the increasing CfC_f of case R2 from that of R1 (Figure 3a). The constant CC appears to be similar to that obtained from R1, C=0.15C=0.15. This suggest that the formulation has the potential to be applicable across different cases and is not dependent on the type of roughness.

Equivalent homogeneous roughness

A recent study by Hutchins et al. [7] suggested that for a heterogeneous rough wall (i.e. a rough wall constructed from various patches of homogeneous roughness of roughness length scale ksik_{si} covering an area AiA_i), the equivalent homogeneous roughness length kehrk_{ehr} can be defined as:

kehr=[1A∑i=1NksinAi]1nwhereA=∑i=1NAi(10)k_{ehr}=\left[\frac{1}{A}\sum_{i=1}^{N}k_{si}^{n}A_i\right]^{\frac{1}{n}} \qquad\text{where}\qquad A=\sum_{i=1}^{N}A_i \tag*{(10)}

In the present study, the drag penalty from all test surfaces can be represented by the logarithmic shift ΔU+\Delta U^+ (Figure 3b), suggesting the possibility of characterising permeable walls with the same framework used for rough wall TBLs. Thus, we might consider porous-rough walls as simply a combination of two ‘homogeneous roughnesses’ overlaying each other. Equation (10) is therefore reduced to

kspr=[kspn+ksrn]1n(11)k_{spr} = \left[k_{sp}^{n} + k_{sr}^{n}\right]^{\frac{1}{n}} \tag*{(11)}

For case PR1, nn is obtained by solving equation (11) with the known ksk_s for each PR1, P, and R1, resulting in n=1.42n = 1.42. The same approach is applied to case PR2, resulting in n=1.54n = 1.54, which is relatively consistent with that obtained from case PR1.

It is still unknown, at this point, what the empirical formulation for the roughness effect is. Present results suggest that it is possibly in terms of an additional logarithmic shift similar to equation (5). Further, it is still unclear what the empirical relation with the characteristic lengthscale of roughness (rough wall ksk_s) is. For the two methods tested in § 3, it is neither understood what the physical interpretations of constants CC and nn are, nor whether these constants are universal for various types of rough walls. We are unable to answer these questions in this study. However, present results suggest a promising start towards decoupling permeability and roughness effects.

Conclusions and future work

We conduct velocity and drag measurements of TBLs developing over various porous-rough wall combinations, with the roughness effect systematically varied while maintaining the permeability effect. Measurements are conducted at relatively high Reynolds numbers (14400≤Reτ≤3310014400 \le Re_\tau\le33100), with a set of matched ReτRe_\tau (within 10%) and ReKRe_K (13≤ReK≤27.513 \le Re_K \le27.5) of each porous-rough combinations. Present results suggest that the increase in drag over porous, rough, and porous-rough walls is characterised by a downward shift in the logarithmic region ΔU+\Delta U^+ from that of smooth wall TBLs and that the mean flow follows outer-layer similarity for cases examined at these high Reynolds numbers (with substantial scale separation). Further analysis shows that ΔU+\Delta U^+ from these surfaces can be characterised by the roughness lengthscale ksk_s, suggesting the possibility of characterising porous walls with the same framework used for rough wall TBLs. Following the hypothesis of Esteban et al. [3], it is viable that for a porous-rough wall, permeability and roughness effects are represented by ReKRe_K and a total blockage function f(ksb,ksr)f(k_{sb}, k_{sr}), respectively, with the total blockage consists of the blockage effect from the porous substrate and additional roughness interface above the porous wall. Present results suggest that the rough walls increase the blockage of porous-rough walls by approximately 2.3–2.5 times from that of the porous wall for both roughnesses tested in this study. We observed that the additional roughness effect follows CksrCk_{sr}, where constant C≈0.16C \approx0.16 for both rough wall test surfaces. Analysis of the same data with the method suggested by Hutchins et al. [7] shows that the effect of porous and rough walls may be decoupled using an area-weighted power-mean (with n≈1.5n \approx1.5 for both surfaces) to obtain an equivalent roughness length for both rough wall test surfaces. The empirical formulation as well as the physical interpretation of constants observed in this study requires further data and should be the focus of future work.

Funding. We gratefully acknowledge the financial support from EPSRC (Grant Ref no: EP/S013296/1) and European Office for Airforce Research and Development (Grant No: FA9550-19-1-7022, Programme Manager: Dr. Doug Smith).

Declaration of interest. The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Data availability statement. The data that support the findings of this study will be made available upon publication.

Author ORCID. D. D. Wangsawijaya: 0000-0002-7072-4245, P. Jaiswal: 0000-0002-5240-9911, B. Ganapathisubramani: 0000-0001-9817-0486

Author contributions. PJ and DDW designed, carried out measurements, and post-processed the data. DDW analysed the data and wrote the manuscript, BG was responsible for conceptualisation, funding acquisition, editing of drafts and project management.

References

  1. [1]BREUGEM, W. P., BOERSMA, B. J. & UITTENBOGAARD, R. E. 2006 The influence of wall permeability on turbulent channel flow. J. Fluid Mech. 562, 35–72.DOI
  2. [2]EFSTATHIOU, CHRISTOPH & LUHAR, MITUL 2018 Mean turbulence statistics in boundary layers over high-porosity foams. J. Fluid Mech. 841, 351–379.DOI
  3. [3]ESTEBAN, L. B., RODRÍGUEZ-LÓPEZ, E., FERREIRA, M. A. & GANAPATHISUBRAMANI, B. 2022 Mean flow of turbulent boundary layers over porous substrates. Phys. Rev. Fluids 7 (9), 094603.DOI
  4. [4]FLACK, K. A. & SCHULTZ, M. P. 2010 Review of hydraulic roughness scales in the fully rough regime. J. Fluids Eng. 132 (4), 041203.DOI
  5. [5]HAHN, SEONGHYEON, JE, JONGDOO & CHOI, HAECHEON 2002 Direct numerical simulation of turbulent channel flow with permeable walls. J. Fluid Mech. 450, 259–285.DOI
  6. [6]HAMA, F. R. 1954 Boundary-layer characteristics for rough and smooth surfaces. Trans. SNAME 62, 333–351.
  7. [7]HUTCHINS, N., GANAPATHISUBRAMANI, B., SCHULTZ, M. P. & PULLIN, D. I. 2023 Defining an equivalent homogeneous roughness length for turbulent boundary layers developing over patchy or heterogeneous surface. Ocean Eng. 271, 113454.DOI
  8. [8]HUTCHINS, N., NICKELS, T. B., MARUSIC, I. & CHONG, M. S. 2009 Hot-wire spatial resolution issues in wall-bounded turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 635, 103–136.DOI
  9. [9]KONG, F. & SCHULTZ, J. 1982 Turbulent boundary layer over porous surfaces with different surface geometries. In the 20th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting.
  10. [10]LIGRANI, P. M. & BRADSHAW, P. 1987 Subminiature hot-wire sensors: development and use. J. Phys. E: Sci. Instrum. 20, 323–332.DOI
  11. [11]MANES, C., POGGI, D. & RIDOLFI, L. 2011 Turbulent boundary layers over permeable walls: scaling and near-wall structure. J. Fluid Mech. 687, 141–170.DOI
  12. [12]MANES, COSTANTINO, POKRAJAC, DUBRAVKA, McEWAN, IAN & NIKORA, VLADIMIR 2009 Turbulence structure of open channel flows over permeable and impermeable beds: A comparative study. Phys. Fluids 21, 125109.DOI
  13. [13]MONTY, J. P., DOGAN, E., HANSON, R., SCARDINO, A. J., GANAPATHISUBRAMANI, B. & HUTCHINS, N. 2016 An assessment of the ship drag penalty arising from light calcareous tubeworm fouling. Biofouling 32 (4), 451–464.DOI
  14. [14]NIKURADSE, J. 1933 Strömungsgesetze in rauhen rohren. VDI Forschungsheft 361, English translation: 1950 Laws of flow in rough pipes. NACA Tech. Mem. 1292.
  15. [15]RODRÍGUEZ-LÓPEZ, E., BRUCE, P. J. K. & BUXTON, O. R. H. 2015 A robust post-processing method to determine skin friction in turbulent boundary layers from the velocity profile. Exp. Fluids 56, 68.
  16. [16]ROSTI, MARCO E., CORTELEZZI, LUCA & QUADRIO, MAURIZIO 2015 Direct numerical simulation of turbulent channel flow over porous walls. J. Fluid Mech. 784, 396–442.DOI
  17. [17]SHIMIZU, Y., TSUJIMOTO, T. & NAKAGAWA, H. 1990 Experiment and macroscopic modelling of flow in highly permeable porous medium under free-surface flow. J. Hydrosci. Hydraul. Eng. 8 (1), 69–78.
  18. [18]SUGA, K., MATSUMURA, Y., ASHITAKA, Y., TOMINAGA, S. & KANEDA, M. 2010 Effects of wall permeability on turbulence. Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow 31, 974–984.DOI
  19. [19]ZAGNI, ANTHONY F. E. & SMITH, KENNETH V. H. 1976 Channel flow over permeable beds of graded spheres. J. Hydraul. Div. 102 (2), 207–222.DOI
  20. [20]ZIPPE, HANS J. & GRAF, WALTER H. 1983 Turbulent boundary-layer flow over permeable and non-permeable rough surfaces. J. Hydraul. Res. 21 (1), 51–65.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_e7vec83m
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 3

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents