WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Study of the neutrino-oxygen cross sections of the charged-current reaction 16O()16N(0 MeV,) and the neutral-current reaction 16O(')16O(12.97/12.53 MeV,), producing high-energy gamma rays
Abstract
In the previous work, we discussed the cross section and the detection of 4.4-MeV rays produced in the neutrino neutral-current (NC) reaction O()O(12.97 MeV and 12.53 MeV, ) in a water Cherenkov detector at the low energy below 100 MeV. In this report, we further investigated both the charged-current (CC) reaction O()N(0 MeV, ) and the NC reactionO()O(12.97 MeV and 12.53 MeV, ), producing high-energy rays, in which the more solid identification of the reactions can be applied via the coincidence method.
Introduction
The 12.97-MeV and 12.53-MeV states are the first strong excited states of just above the proton separation energy (12.1 MeV). The 12.97-MeV state, which is nearly an isospin state, is one of the dominant multipoles in the neutrino-oxygen interactions at low energy below 100 MeV. The electromagnetic form factors of these states were measured in reactions in 1960 [1–4]. No new measurements of those states in reactions have been performed since then. Donnelly and Walecka [5–7] calculated the neutrino- cross sections at -20 MeV precisely with accuracy of 15-20% after they analysed the data of -20 MeV) scattering and semi-leptonic weak interactions (muon capture and decay) and evaluated the reduction factors -0.7) to the transition amplitudes. of their model. This reduction in transition amplitudes of a calculation model (or in the coupling constant) is sometimes called a quenching factor. Haxton [8] calculated the cross sections of the charged-current (CC) neutrino-oxygen and reactions, using the quenching factors for negative parity states, which were evaluated in Ref. [5–7]. He further examined the CC cross sections to the bound states (, , , and ) of , which are followed by the decay to the ground state or the excited state (6.13 MeV) of . The total energy given by and ray (6.13 MeV) was estimated to be about 8 MeV. He concluded that since the CC cross section to the bound states of never exceeds 1% of the dominant inverse beta decay (IBD) reaction in supernova neutrino bursts, the extra delayed signal of 8 MeV scattered over the decay time (=7.13 sec) gives only negligible effect on the event timing, which is determined by the dominant IBD events.
At the time of these analysis, the isospin mixing of the two states at 12.53 MeV and 12.97 MeV was not known and was not considered. There have been several reports on the isospin mixing between the 12.97 MeV () and 12.53 MeV () states previously [10, 11, 12] [1, 9]. These physical two states (the higher energy state and the lower energy state ) are written in terms of the pure isospin states as,
where is the isospin mixing parameter. A well-known example of the isospin mixing is that between the two excited states of at 12.71 MeV () and 15.11 MeV () [13, 14, 15].
In our previous work [16], we followed the analysis by Donnelly and Walecka, evaluating both the quenching factor of the spin factor and the isospin-mixing parameter of the two states to be and , respectively, and also determining the quenching factor of the axial-vector coupling constant to be . Then, we discussed the cross section of 4.4-MeV ray production in the neutrino neutral-current (NC) reaction in a water Cherenkov detector at the low energy below 100 MeV.
The Super-Kamiokande (SK) experiment summarizes the following three detection channels from supernova (SN) neutrino bursts as described in Ref. [17, 18]: (1) the IBD reaction , (2) the neutrino-electron elastic scattering, and (3) the CC reactions, and . The first IBD reaction is the main interaction channel, responsible for about 90% of the reactions in water. The second one is a subdominant channel, useful for determining the direction of the SN. The third CC neutrino-oxygen interactions are also subdominant ones. Their cross sections were calculated initially by the authors of Ref. [19] [8] and recently in Ref. [20], and the electron spectra of the CC reactions were discussed by the authors of Ref. [17, 21] [22].
The JUNO experiment [23], a Liquid Scintillator detector of 20-kton fiducial mass, uses the 15.11-MeV -ray emission of the NC reaction , and the CC reactions, and [24], as the main detection channels for the analysis of the SN neutrino bursts, in addition to the IBD reaction, elastic – scattering and elastic – scattering [25–27]. We denote the ground state as g.s. hereafter.
This study on the CC/NC neutrino-oxygen reactions using () states of and is motivated by the well-studied CC/NC neutrino-carbon reactions using () ground states of , and , where both CC and NC reactions of neutrino- are already measured by the low-energy neutrino experiments [28–36]. We investigate both the CC and its decay to . Furthermore, we investigate the NC reaction cross sections from the two states (12.97 MeV and 12.53 MeV) of , producing high-energy rays. We discuss a possible coincidence method to identify these CC and NC reactions unambiguously, which can be used not only in the SK experiment but also in the future Hyper-K experiment [22].
The three states, , and , form a triplet (). The energy levels of , and near their ground states are shown in Figure 1. Just above the ground state , there are also bound states at 0.120 MeV (), 0.298 MeV () and 0.397 MeV (). They all decay electromagnetically to , emitting a small ray. We call these bound states including the ground state () as the g.s. group of in the present report. There are no bound states in .

Figure 1. Energy levels of , and near the ground state with isospin [38].
Charged-current reaction 16O(e, e+)16N(g.s. group)
The calculations of the electron/positron spectra from and reactions were fully described in Ref. [21] and the implications of the mixture in water on SN neutrino events were discussed in Ref [37]. In this section, we discuss on the CC reaction , where the g.s. group consists of the bound states at 0 MeV (), 0.120 MeV (), 0.298 MeV () and 0.397 MeV (). The bound states (, , ) decay electromagnetically to the ground state (), emitting a small ray. All of them are followed by the decay from to . We discuss the g.s. group together, since the four bound states of the g.s. group in the CC reactions cannot be distinguished in a water-Cherenkov detector unless a small ray (0.120 MeV, 0.298 MeV, 0.397 MeV) can be identified. We describe some unique features of these CC reaction as compared to other CC reactions. The formula of the cross section calculation for the CC neutrino-oxygen reactions are given in Eq.(1) of Ref. [21] and we calculated the cross section of using the quenching factors and , which were evaluated in the previous work [16] [37].
First, the reaction can be uniquely identified by the coincidence between a prompt positron from the primary reaction and a 6.13-MeV ray (and partly 7.12-MeV and 8.87-MeV rays) from the subsequent decay of , , both of which are produced at the same interaction point during the time interval of the decay. The detailed parameters of the decay of to [38] are summarized in Table 1 and the schematic diagram of the decay is also shown in dashed lines in Figure 1. This coincidence method with the constraint on the same vertex position during on the decay interval will reduce the accidental background significantly. The identification of this reaction by applying the coincidence will reject other CC reactions and [21], which have larger cross sections than this reaction and have no delayed signals. Though some of these other CC reactions may be accompanied by the prompt rays above 5 MeV which are emitted from the strong-decay products as or within a microsecond, they can be further removed if the second signals from the first one microsecond in the coincidence are excluded out of from the long decay time ().
| decay of (g.s.) to of | Branching ratio (%) | (MeV) | Range of (MeV) |
| 8.87 MeV | 8.87 MeV | MeV | |
| 7.12 MeV | 7.12 MeV | MeV | |
| 6.13 MeV | 6.13 MeV | MeV | |
| 0 MeV | 0.0 | MeV |
Table 1. Parameters of the decay of (g.s.), (g.s.) [38]. The half life of the decay is sec. While the 6.13-MeV and 7.12-MeV states decay to the ground state, producing a single 6.13-MeV and 7.12-MeV ray, the 8.87-MeV state () decays through cascade to the ground state, producing mostly two rays (2.74 MeV + 6.13 MeV, or 1.75 MeV + 7.12 MeV) and partly a single 8.87-MeV ray.
Secondly, the visible energy of the positron from the primary reaction of this channel (g.s. group) can be used to determine the incident neutrino energy as MeV above the threshold energy ( MeV). A small ray (0.12 MeV, 0.298 MeV, 0.397 MeV) of the g.s. group is negligible as compared to 11.44 MeV. The electron or positron signal from other CC reactions cannot give the incident neutrino energy without knowing the excited states () of and . This CC reaction from to (g.s. group) has the lowest energy threshold among the neutrino-oxygen reaction, except for the CC reaction ( MeV) [37].
The cross section of (g.s. group) is shown as a function of neutrino energy in Figure 2 and also given in Table 2. The cross section of the CC reaction from (g.s.) to (g.s., ) is the largest among the CC reaction to the g.s. group, that to the state is about of that to the state below 50 MeV and that to the state is about 15% of that to the state between 12 and 20 MeV. This feature is qualitatively explained by the strength of the transition ( and ) proportional to (). Above 50 MeV, the cross section is contributed to by the transition ( and ) from (g.s.) to the and states. The cross section to the state becomes even larger and that to the state becomes significant, about 10% of that to the state, at higher energy than 100 MeV.
Figure 2. The cross sections of the CC reactions (black dashed line), (black dash-dotted line), and (black solid line); the NC cross sections of the 4.4-MeV ray from and states, (red dashed line) and (red dash-dotted line), and the sum of them (red solid line); the NC cross sections of the high-energy rays (12.97 MeV and 12.53 MeV) via electromagnetic decay of the and states, (blue dashed line), (blue dash-dotted line), and the sum of them (blue solid line) as a function of the neutrino energy. The IBD cross section is shown in black dotted lines for comparison.
| (MeV) | Sum (, , , ) | ||||
| 12 | 1.59E−04 | 4.04E−05 | 2.51E−05 | 0.0 | 2.24E−04 |
| 14 | 2.10E−03 | 1.46E−03 | 3.03E−04 | 0.0 | 3.86E−03 |
| 16 | 7.79E−03 | 5.74E−03 | 8.69E−04 | 0.0 | 1.44E−02 |
| 18 | 1.98E−02 | 1.44E−02 | 1.73E−03 | 1.20E−06 | 3.60E−02 |
| 20 | 4.13E−02 | 2.92E−02 | 2.88E−03 | 4.24E−06 | 7.34E−02 |
| 22 | 7.57E−02 | 5.20E−02 | 4.32E−03 | 1.23E−05 | 1.32E−01 |
| 24 | 1.27E−01 | 8.46E−02 | 6.07E−03 | 3.11E−05 | 2.18E−01 |
| 26 | 2.00E−01 | 1.29E−01 | 8.13E−03 | 7.07E−05 | 3.37E−01 |
| 28 | 2.97E−01 | 1.87E−01 | 1.05E−02 | 1.48E−04 | 4.95E−01 |
| 30 | 4.25E−01 | 2.60E−01 | 1.32E−02 | 2.88E−04 | 6.99E−01 |
| 32 | 5.86E−01 | 3.51E−01 | 1.62E−02 | 5.29E−04 | 9.54E−01 |
| 34 | 7.86E−01 | 4.60E−01 | 1.95E−02 | 9.27E−04 | 1.27E+00 |
| 36 | 1.03E+00 | 5.88E−01 | 2.32E−02 | 1.56E−03 | 1.64E+00 |
| 38 | 1.31E+00 | 7.36E−01 | 2.72E−02 | 2.52E−03 | 2.08E+00 |
| 40 | 1.65E+00 | 9.06E−01 | 3.16E−02 | 3.95E−03 | 2.59E+00 |
| 50 | 4.11E+00 | 2.06E+00 | 5.90E−02 | 2.57E−02 | 6.25E+00 |
| 60 | 7.88E+00 | 3.64E+00 | 9.63E−02 | 1.07E−01 | 1.17E+01 |
| 70 | 1.27E+01 | 5.37E+00 | 1.44E−01 | 3.31E−01 | 1.85E+01 |
| 80 | 1.80E+01 | 6.96E+00 | 2.02E−01 | 8.22E−01 | 2.60E+01 |
| 90 | 2.32E+01 | 8.18E+00 | 2.69E−01 | 1.73E+00 | 3.34E+01 |
| 100 | 2.78E+01 | 8.93E+00 | 3.43E−01 | 3.18E+00 | 4.02E+01 |
Table 2. Cross sections of the CC reaction (g.s. group) as functions of the neutrino energy, (MeV). The unit of the cross section is .
The cross section of the CC reaction (g.s. group) was first calculated by Haxton [8]. We find that our calculation of the CC cross section for (g.s. group) is larger by about 40% than his calculation. We note that our evaluations of the quenching factors for these bound states, and , were validated by the transverse form factor of the cross section near 13 MeV (, , ) [1, 2, 4], the rate of the partial muon capture from the 1s orbit on (g.s., ) to the bound states (, , , ) of and the total muon capture rate from to (g.s., ) [16].
Below 30 MeV, this cross section of (g.s. group) is dominant among all CC reactions. There are several excited states (, ) of -25 MeV) with significant CC cross sections and they all decay hadronically to [21]. Above 30 MeV, the cross section to the g.s. group becomes smaller than the sum of other CC cross sections by an order of magnitude. However, we note again that the neutrino energy can be reconstructed, only when the electron/positron energy of other CC reactions can be measured and the excited states () of the nucleus in the reaction, either or , are measured for each event. In addition, those excited states () will decay hadronically and sometimes emit rays from 5 to 9 MeV, which will diffuse the primary electron/positron signal. On the other hand, the CC reaction (g.s. group) can be unambiguously identified and the neutrino energy can be reconstructed, if the delayed coincidence method can be used. This is a unique feature.
While the 6.13-MeV and 7.12-MeV states decay electromagnetically via transition to the ground state, producing a single 6.13-MeV and 7.12-MeV ray, the 8.87-MeV state () decays mostly through cascade to the ground state, producing two rays (2.74 MeV + 6.13 MeV, or 1.75 MeV + 7.12 MeV) and partly a single 8.87-MeV ray. After the decay and the electromagnetic transitions, the branching ratios of emitting rays becomes , and [38] and the sum of them is . The probability of no ray is . We note that the visible energy of the delayed signal is for all decay modes, including the decay of (g.s) to (g.s), where is the neutrino energy from the decay, (g.s.) . The delayed signal is further contributed to by the kinetic energy from the decay by 1-2 MeV as shown in Table 1 and this will make the detection efficiency larger.
The decay of (g.s.) goes to (g.s.) with the branching ratio 28.0%, producing an electron with MeV and no ray. Even for this decay mode, the delayed coincidence between the primary positron and the delayed coincidence signal may be possible for the case of MeV. The kinetic energy spectrum of this decay mode is shown in Figure 3, where -value is equal to 10.42 MeV. About 49% of the electrons have MeV and they can be detected. This will add a probability of about 14% (= 0.28 · 0.49) to that of the delayed coincidence signal producing rays with MeV (72%) and the total probability of the delayed coincidence signal with visible energy greater than 5 MeV, from the decay of (g.s.), is estimated to be about 86%.
Figure 3. The electron energy spectrum of the decay, (g.s.) (g.s.)+ + . The product of the nuclear shape factor , the phase space factor, and the Fermi function is shown as a function of the electron kinetic energy (MeV). Here, and are electron energy and momentum, respectively, and is the -value for the reaction.
The SNO experiment and SK experiment use rays of 6.13 MeV and 7.12 MeV from (g.s., ) decay for a PMT calibration [39, 40]. The SK experiment also uses a 6.13-MeV ray to measure the NC neutrino-oxygen quasielastic interaction [41–44], which are consistent with the calculation [45]. Thus, it is clear that a 6.13-MeV ray can be observed in a water Cherenkov detector.
We comment on the unique feature of this CC reaction channel to (g.s. group). A detector such as SK-Gd [48–50] can measure the neutrino energy of the IBD reaction unambiguously by the neutron tagging and reconstruct the incident neutrino spectrum , using its well-known IBD cross section [25, 26] and the relation MeV. Then, we can measure the CC cross section , using the measured neutrino spectrum , since we can measure from the measurement of the primary electron spectrum , using the relation MeV, where is the CC cross section to (g.s. group). We can compare the measured cross section with our calculated one and confirm/improve the calculation. The measurement of this CC reaction will also validate the calculation of the NC cross sections which we describe in the next section, since the calculations of these CC and NC reactions are related by the CVC hypothesis [16] [46, 47]. We also note that the delayed coincidence method to this reaction can be applied in the Hyper-K detector, even without the neutron tagging method.
Neutral-current reaction and the branching ratios of the two states producing rays
We briefly review a feature of the NC reaction from the and states, which produces a 4.4-MeV ray from the decay of these states [16]. Next, we discuss a high-energy ray emission from the electromagnetic decay of these two states. The latter cross sections for high-energy rays are small, but the signature of the events is so distinct with high-energy visible energy above 10 MeV that those events can be clearly identified. In these calculations, we use both the quenching factors of the spin factor () and of the axial-vector coupling constant (), and the isospin-mixing parameter of the two states (). We summarize the decay properties of the two states in Table 3, which we use in the present paper as in the previous paper [16]. We also illustrate the NC reactions in Figure 4 which are relevant in this section.
Table 3. The two states of and their decay properties. The numbers are not yet established, but still uncertain [16]. We used and .
Figure 4. Illustrative figure for the NC reactions, .
First, we review the 4.4-MeV ray from the decay of the two states. The decay of the states to is forbidden by the angular momentum conservation and the decay of the states to is allowed through the component. The three experiments reported the -decay branching ratio , which we denote as : Leavitt et al. [10], Zijderhand and van der Leun [11], and Charity et al. [12] reported to be , , and , respectively. We took a simple mean of the three values [10, 11, 12] and used this mean value, , to evaluate the 4.4-MeV -ray production cross section in the previous paper [16] as well as in the present paper. We denote the NC cross section of the and states as and , respectively, and the sum of them as . We also denote the 4.4-MeV -ray production cross section of the and states as and , respectively, and the sum of them as . We note that the NC cross sections and are calculated for an average of one neutrino flavor and its anti-neutrino flavor. In the previous work [16], only the figures for the state, and , were shown. This time, (red dashed line) and (red dash-dotted line), with and , respectively, are shown in Figure 2. The sum of them (red solid line) is also shown and it is larger than by about 16%, since the ratio at .
Next, we discuss the high-energy -ray production via electromagnetic decay of the two states. The direct electromagnetic transition from the two $2^-$ states to the ground state is suppressed and electromagnetic transitions to the ground state go through the cascade transitions producing more than two rays. Gorodetzky et al. [51] measured both the electromagnetic cascade decay and the decay from the and states in the proton capture experiment. Zijderhand and der Leun [11] also measured both a single ray from the electromagnetic decay and the $\alpha decay from the two states in the proton capture experiment. Their values are shown in Table 3. We use the radiative decay widths measured by Gorodetzky et al. [51] in the present paper. The latest evaluation for the decay parameters of can be found in Ref. [38] and the values for the radiative decay widths are the same as those we use in the present paper. As shown in Table 3, we use the total decay widths (keV) and (keV) for the and states, respectively, to calculate the branching ratios of the two states producing rays, and . If we take eV of Gorodetzky et al. [51] for the state,
we naturally obtain the total width to be (keV), which agrees with the total width of the state listed in Ref. [38]. Thus, the branching ratio of the state producing rays is . We note that Zijderhand and van der Leun [11] adopted the total width keV by taking the average of the three previous measurements of the total width [10] [52, 53], including the measurement by Leavitt et al. [10]. Thus, the measurements of the branching ratios for the state are consistent with each other except for the -ray width. On the other hand, the measurements for the states are not consistent with each other.
As shown in Table 4, the cascade electromagnetic decay of the state produces a pair of two (sometimes three) rays, 6.84 MeV + 6.13 MeV (63%), 5.85 MeV + 7.12 MeV (12%), 4.10 MeV + 8.87 MeV (25%). As explained in the previous section, the 8.87-MeV state decays mostly through cascade to the ground state, producing two rays. Similarly, the cascade electromagnetic decay of the state produces a pair of two (sometimes three) rays, 6.40 MeV + 6.13 MeV (60%), 5.41 MeV + 7.12 MeV (15%), 3.66 MeV + 8.87 MeV (25%). We note that the electromagnetic decay will produce mostly two rays at the same time and at the same vertex position and that the sum of them is as high as 12.97 MeV and 12.53 MeV from the and states, respectively. This feature can be used to identify this reaction channel and the coincidence method can be also used if the multiple-ring reconstruction can be developed [54].
The branching ratios of the electromagnetic decay from the two states of . Gorodetzky et al. [51] measured the widths of the cascade rays as in the first column and we calculated the branching ratios in the second column to compare them with the measurements by Zijderhand and van der Leun [11]. The sum of the branching ratios is normalized to 100% (the radiative width ).
| 12.53 MeV () Transition to the state | (eV) | Branching ratio (%) | Branching ratio (%) |
| 0 MeV () | - | - | 6.00.6 |
| 8.87 MeV () | 0.860.10 | 253 | 332 |
| 7.12 MeV () | 0.510.10 | 153 | 12.00.7 |
| 6.13 MeV () | 2.10.2 | 606 | 492 |
| All states | 3.40.3 | 100 | 100 (0.550.06) |
| Reference | Gorodetzky et al. [51] | Zijderhand and van der Leun [11] | |
| 12.97 MeV () Transition to the state | (eV) | Branching ratio (%) | Branching ratio (%) |
| 0 MeV () | - | - | 2.10.4 |
| 8.87 MeV () | 0.900.10 | 256 | 422 |
| 7.12 MeV () | 0.440.10 | 122 | 61 |
| 6.13 MeV () | 2.30.3 | 636 | 502 |
| All states | 3.60.3 | 100 | 100 (1.60.3) |
| Reference | Gorodetzky et al. [51] | Zijderhand and van der Leun [11] |
Table 4. The branching ratios of the electromagnetic decay from the two states of .
We show the cross section of the high-energy -ray production via electromagnetic decay of the and states in Figure 2 and also in Table 5. We denote them as , and the sum of them . Since the branching ratios for the and states are and , respectively, each of their cross sections is smaller than the CC cross section by three orders of magnitude. However, it should be reminded that all flavors of neutrinos and antineutrinos contribute to the number of NC events while the CC reaction depends on the flavor. Only new measurements will resolve the above inconsistencies in the branching ratios between Gorodetzky et al. [51] and Zijderhand and van der Leun [11].
| (MeV) | ||||
| 12 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 14 | 4.61E−05 | 1.55E−05 | 3.56E−07 | 5.81E−07 |
| 16 | 5.41E−04 | 1.17E−04 | 4.17E−06 | 4.37E−06 |
| 18 | 1.95E−03 | 3.82E−04 | 1.51E−05 | 1.43E−05 |
| 20 | 4.88E−03 | 9.10E−04 | 3.76E−05 | 3.40E−05 |
| 22 | 1.00E−02 | 1.82E−03 | 7.74E−05 | 6.81E−05 |
| 24 | 1.83E−02 | 3.26E−03 | 1.41E−04 | 1.22E−04 |
| 26 | 3.05E−02 | 5.39E−03 | 2.36E−04 | 2.01E−04 |
| 28 | 4.79E−02 | 8.37E−03 | 3.69E−04 | 3.13E−04 |
| 30 | 7.14E−02 | 1.24E−02 | 5.51E−04 | 4.63E−04 |
| 32 | 1.02E−01 | 1.76E−02 | 7.89E−04 | 6.59E−04 |
| 34 | 1.42E−01 | 2.43E−02 | 1.09E−03 | 9.08E−04 |
| 36 | 1.91E−01 | 3.26E−02 | 1.47E−03 | 1.22E−03 |
| 38 | 2.50E−01 | 4.26E−02 | 1.93E−03 | 1.59E−03 |
| 40 | 3.22E−01 | 5.47E−02 | 2.48E−03 | 2.04E−03 |
| 50 | 8.90E−01 | 1.49E−01 | 6.87E−03 | 5.58E−03 |
| 60 | 1.86E+00 | 3.10E−01 | 1.43E−02 | 1.16E−02 |
| 70 | 3.21E+00 | 5.33E−01 | 2.48E−02 | 1.99E−02 |
| 80 | 4.85E+00 | 8.02E−01 | 3.74E−02 | 3.00E−02 |
| 90 | 6.59E+00 | 1.09E+00 | 5.08E−02 | 4.06E−02 |
| 100 | 8.24E+00 | 1.36E+00 | 6.35E−02 | 5.07E−02 |
Table 5. NC cross sections of 4.4-MeV -ray production ( and ), 12.97-MeV and 12.53-MeV -ray production ( and ) from the and states as functions of the neutrino energy, (MeV). We note that each of the NC cross section is calculated for an average over one neutrino flavor and its anti-neutrino flavor. The unit of the cross section is cm.
Estimation of the number of events from and , induced by supernova neutrinos
We evaluate the number of these CC and NC events induced by neutrinos from SN explosion which can be observed by the SK, a 32 kton water Cherenkov detector [55] in the Earth . The four bound states of the g.s. group of , 0 MeV (), 0.120 MeV (), 0.298 MeV () and 0.397 MeV (), in the CC reactions cannot be distinguished in a water-Cherenkov detector unless a small ray can be identified. We thus estimate the number of and (g.s. group).
We calculate the number of events using the following parametrization (called KRJ fit [56, 57]) for the normalized SN neutrino spectra as we used in the previous work [16]:
where is the average neutrino energy. In this expression, is the Gamma function and is the pinching parameter. As the value becomes larger, the high-energy tail of the distribution is more suppressed for the same average energy. We only calculate the number of events using three typical values of the KRJ fit with and , 12 and 14 MeV, and assume that the neutrino spectra are flavor independent in Table 6.
| KRJ parameters | Condition | |||
| IBD | ||||
| CC | ||||
| NC | ||||
Table 6. Expected number of neutrino events from a core-collapse SN at 10 kpc to be detected at SK (32-kton fiducial volume) for the models with KRJ fit.
The time-integrated number spectrum of neutrinos emitted from a SN core, , is related to the normalized neutrino spectra as
where is the total energy emitted by one neutrino flavor. Hereafter, we set erg for each neutrino flavor. We calculate the number of events at various average energies using the neutrino flux at a detector on the Earth, which is given as
We set the distance from a detector to the SN to kpc.
We calculate the number of events produced in the energy range from to for the IBD reaction and the CC reactions by folding the neutrino flux and the cross sections as,
where stands for the cross section of either IBD or CC reaction and is the number of either protons or targets for the case of a 32 kton fiducial volume of the SK detector [18]. For the IBD reaction (CC reactions), the relation MeV (11.44 MeV) between the neutrino energy and the visible energy () of the positron holds. In Figure 5, the number of events of the CC reactions are compared with that of the IBD reaction as a function of the visible energy with an energy width of MeV, for the KRJ fit with and MeV. The numbers of events of the CC reactions integrated over the neutrino energy up to 100 MeV are summarized in Table 6, for the KRJ fit with and , 12 and 14 MeV, where we show the effect of the requirement on the kinetic energy of a positron with MeV or MeV (Threshold). The primary positron spectrum from the CC reaction depends on the assumed SN flux and the cross section, and about 2% of the spectrum lies below 5 MeV for the KRJ fit ( and MeV). We do not consider the efficiency of having the coincidence signal with the visible energy greater than 5 MeV, which is estimated to be about 86%. We point out again the importance of the low threshold energy of the CC reactions, since 98%, 54% and only 18% of the SN neutrino flux remain after the requirement of MeV (IBD reaction), 11.44 MeV (CC reaction) and 18 MeV (typical value for CC MeV) reactions) [21], respectively, for the typical KRJ fit with and MeV, and the effect of the requirement on the positron kinetic energy will be imposed additionally.
Figure 5. The visible energy spectrum of (g.s. group) (open triangles) and that of the IBD event spectrum (open circles) are also plotted with an energy-bin width of 2 MeV as a function of the visible energy for the KRJ fit with and MeV. The total numbers of those NC events due to and are plotted in filled black squares at MeV and at MeV, for the same KRJ fit values.
For the NC reactions, the ray of 4.4 MeV, 12.53 MeV or 12.97 MeV is produced independently of the incident neutrino energy , we can calculate only the total number of events integrated over as
where stands for the cross section of any type of NC reactions and is the number of targets in a 32 kton fiducial volume of the SK detector and we set MeV.
We show in Table 6 the total numbers of the NC events containing 4.4-MeV rays due to and as well as those containing 12.97-MeV and 12.53-MeV rays due to and , for the KRJ fit with and , 12 and 14 MeV. We also plot in Figure 5 the total numbers of those NC events due to at MeV and at MeV in filled black squares, for the KRJ fit with and MeV, assuming that the detection efficiency is 100% without considering the energy resolution.
The number of events due to the (g.s. group) reaction is smaller by two or three orders of magnitude than that of the IBD events. The total cross section of NC events are summed over 3 flavors of a neutrino and anti-neutrino, namely, 6 times the average NC cross section. That explains why the number of the NC events producing a 4.4-MeV ray due to and is nearly the same as that of the (g.s. group) reaction. The numbers of NC events producing 12.97 and 12.97/12.53-MeV ray due to and , respectively, are smaller by two orders of magnitude than that of the (g.s. group) reaction.
Summary
In the previous work, we discussed the detection of a single 4.4-MeV ray produced in the neutrino NC reaction MeV and 12.53 MeV, , after evaluating both the isospin-mixing parameter and the quenching factors, of the spin factor and of the axial-vector coupling constant , of the two states [16]. In this report, we have further examined both the decay of the CC reaction and the electromagnetic decay of the NC reaction and producing high-energy rays of 12.97 MeV and 12.53 MeV, using the same quenching factors for the two states. We have evaluated the number of these CC and NC reactions induced by neutrinos from SN explosion which can be observed by the SK, a 32 kton water Cherenkov detector [55] in the Earth.
Even though the cross sections of these CC/NC reactions are small, the application of the present work for the future SN neutrino events by water Cherenkov detectors has some unique features. Above all, the coincidence method can be applied for the more solid identification in the former CC reaction. In the latter NC reaction, the large visible energy of 12.97 MeV and 12.53 MeV can be produced and the coincidence method can be also used if the multiple-ring reconstruction can be developed [54]. Further, it is important for the study of SN physics to have the detection channels which have significant sensitivities at as low neutrino energy as 10 to 20 MeV, where the majority of the neutrino energy spectra from SN bursts lie.
These neutrino-oxygen reactions have the lowest energy thresholds (11.44 MeV and 12.97 MeV) among the neutrino-oxygen reactions, which correspond to the energy levels of the ground states of and . They have the dominant cross sections from 12 to 30 MeV, above which the cross sections of other CC and NC reactions from the excited states dominate.
We also note that the delayed coincidence method to this reaction can be applied in the Hyper-K detector, even without the neutron tagging method using Gd. The recent study by the Hyper-K Collaboration on the detection of the SN neutrino events [22] comments that they do not consider the -ray emission from the NC interactions on nuclei, since a dominant channel mainly produces only rays with an energy of 5 MeV to 9 MeV [58] and the visible energy from these events would typically be below 5 MeV (Hyper-K energy threshold) after Compton scattering on an electron or electron-positron pair production. Our study for the coincidence method including the high energy rays may turn out to be useful.
The JUNO experiment [23] uses the NC reaction and CC reactions with the subsequent decay and with the subsequent decay [24], as the main detection channels for the analysis of the SN neutrino bursts, in addition to the IBD reaction, elastic –p scattering and elastic –e scattering [25–27]. It is important to note some basic features of the CC/NC neutrino-oxygen reactions which are different from those of the CC/NC neutrino-carbon reactions. The neutrino-carbon cross sections related to the state are larger by two orders of magnitude than the neutrino-oxygen cross sections from the 12.97 and 12.53 states () since the former neutrino- reactions have a large matrix element causing the spin-flip transition from to , while the latter neutrino- reactions go through the spin-dipole transition from fully occupied shells to shells, which is smaller by an order of magnitude than the former. In addition, the electromagnetic decay branching ratio () of the former state [59] is larger by two order of magnitude than that () of the states of . This is because in the former state , the electromagnetic decay is dominant and the hadronic decay to p+ decay is suppressed due to the threshold (), while in the latter states of , the hadronic decays are allowed ( for p+ decay) and the electromagnetic decay branching ratio becomes relatively very small.
We hope that new accurate measurements of the cross section of and the branching ratios of decaying to the , and channels will be performed in the near future at the low-energy electron accelerators (-100 MeV), at MESA accelerator [60] or at the ULQ2 facility at the Research Center for Electron-Photon Science (Tohoku University) [61], so that the prediction of both the CC/NC neutrino-oxygen cross sections for 12.53 MeV and 12.97 MeV () can be accurate to a level of 10% or less.
Acknowledgment
This work was partially supported by JSPS Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (No. JP19K03855, JP20K03973, No. JP20K03989, and No. JP24K07021) and also by JSPS Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research on Innovative Areas ”Unraveling the History of the Universe and Matter Evolution with Underground Physics” (No. JP19H05802 and No. JP19H05811), Grant-in-Aid for Transformative Research Areas ”The creation of multimessenger astrophysics” (No. JP24H01817), and Grant-in-Aid for Transformative Research Areas ”Investigation on the Origin and Evolution of Matter in the Universe by Extremely Rare Events: Frontier of Creating a New Insight on the Matter in the Universe” (No. JP24H02245).
References
- [10]Phys. A 410, 93 (1983).
- [11]F. Zijderhand and C. van der Leun, Nucl. Phys. A 460, 181 (1986).
- [12]R.J. Charity et al., Phys. Rev. C 99, 044304 (2019).
- [13]E. Adelberger, R. Marrs, K. Snover and J. Bussoletti, Phys. Rev. C15, 484 (1977).
- [14]J.B. Flanz, R. Hicks, R. Lindgren, G. Peterson, J. Dubach and W. Haxton, Phys. Rev. Lett. 43, 1922 (1979).
- [15]P. von Neumann-Cosel, H.-D. Gräf, U. Krämer, A. Richter and E. Spamer, Nucl.Phys. A669, 3 (2000).
- [16]M. Sakuda, T. Suzuki, M.S. Reen, K. Nakazato and H. Suzuki, PTEP 2023, 013D02 (2023).
- [17]K. Abe et al. (SK Collaboration), Astropart. Phys. 81, 39 (2016).
- [18]M. Ikeda et al. (SK Collaboration), Astrophys. J. 669, 519 (2007).
- [19]E. Kolbe, K. Langanke, G. Martínez-Pinedo and P. Vogel, J. Phys. G 29, 2569 (2003).
- [20]T. Suzuki, S. Chiba, T. Yoshida, K. Takahashi, and H. Umeda, Phys. Rev. C98, 034613 (2018).
- [21]K. Nakazato, T. Suzuki, M. Sakuda, PTEP 2018, 123E02 (2018).



