betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

ErAl_\mathrm{Al}:Al2_2O3_3 for Telecom-Band Photonics: Electronic Structure and Optical Properties

Abstract

Er-doped Al2_2O3_3 is a promising host for telecom-band integrated photonics. Here we combine ab initio calculations with a symmetry-resolved analysis to elucidate substitutional Er on the Al site (ErAl_\mathrm{Al}) in αα-Al2_2O3_3. First-principles relaxations confirm the structural stability of ErAl_\mathrm{Al}. We then use the local trigonal crystal-field symmetry to classify the Er-derived impurity levels by irreducible representations and to derive polarization-resolved electric-dipole selection rules, explicitly identifying the symmetry-allowed ff\textendashdd hybridization channels. Kubo–Greenwood absorption spectra computed from Kohn–Sham states quantitatively corroborate these symmetry predictions. Furthermore, we connect the calculated intra-4f4f line strengths to Judd–Ofelt theory, clarifying the role of 4f4f\textendash5d5d admixture in enabling optical activity. Notably, we predict a characteristic absorption near 1.47 μm1.47~μ\mathrm{m} (telecom band), relevant for on-chip amplification and emission. To our knowledge, a symmetry-resolved first-principles treatment of Er:Al2_2O3_3 with an explicit Judd–Ofelt interpretation has not been reported, providing a transferable framework for tailoring rare-earth dopants in wide-band-gap oxides for integrated photonics. Our results for the optical spectra are in good agreement with experimental data.

Introduction

Rare-earth (RE) doped materials have emerged as promising candidates for integrated photonics, providing an alternative to conventional III–V semiconductor compounds for on-chip light amplification and generation. These materials offer several notable advantages: they are highly compatible with silicon photonics platforms,[1, 2] possess long excited-state lifetimes, and are easy to implement experimentally. RE doping has been realized in various semiconductors and insulators. Among the different rare-earth ions, erbium holds a significant advantage because it emits in the telecom wavelength range (∼1.5 μm\sim1.5\,\mu\mathrm{m}), allowing signal transmission through optical fibers with minimal losses in modern fiber-optic technology.[3, 4]

One of the main advantages of doping RE ions into various semiconductors and insulators is their unique property of having electrons in the unfilled 4f4f shell, which is strongly shielded from the crystal environment by the surrounding completely filled 5p5p and 5s5s shell. This property leads generally to high quantum yields, atom-like narrow bandwidths for optical transitions, long lifetimes, long decoherence times, high photostability, and large Stokes shifts. A prime example is Er-doped semiconductors and optical fibers that emit 1.5 μm1.5\,\mu\mathrm{m} light with ultra-narrow bandwidth and are therefore crucial for optoelectronic devices and optical telecommunication.

To achieve maximum gain and improve the efficiency of Er-doped materials, it is essential to carefully consider factors such as the compatibility of Er impurities with the host material. SiO2_2 is widely regarded as a reliable optical host material; however, it is not suitable for hosting Er impurities because of its inherently low solubility.[5, 6] This limitation gives rise to undesirable transitions that significantly reduce optical gain while increasing noise in Er-doped systems. An equally critical challenge lies in the precise incorporation of impurities into the host: excessive doping concentrations promote non-radiative transitions, which in turn quench the absorption peaks and severely degrade device performance. Recently, it has been demonstrated that among various wide band gap materials, Al2_2O3_3 stands out as a suitable choice of host material for Er impurities due to its similarity with Er2_2O3_3 in terms of both valency and lattice constant.[1, 2, 7, 8]

Er-doped Al2_2O3_3 (ErAl:Al2_2O3_3) underpins on-chip light sources and amplifiers in the telecom band, yet a symmetry-resolved, first-principles framework for its optical activity is lacking. In particular, the Er impurity levels in the local C3vC_{3v} crystal field have not been systematically classified by irreducible representations, the ensuing electric-dipole selection rules have not been established from group theory, and the connection to Judd–Ofelt[9, 10] (JO) theory has not been articulated within an ab initio context. Here we address this gap by combining density-functional theory with a comprehensive group-theoretical analysis to identify the A1/EA_1/E manifolds, derive polarization-resolved dipole selection rules, and quantify the role of symmetry-allowed 4f4f–5d5d admixture. We validate these predictions against Kubo–Greenwood absorption spectra computed from Kohn–Sham states and show how the JO framework naturally emerges from the calculated line strengths. This symmetry-grounded approach links crystal-field physics to device-relevant spectral features in Er:Al2_2O3_3.

In free ions, 4f→4f4f \rightarrow4f electric-dipole transitions are parity-forbidden; in crystals they acquire intensity via opposite-parity admixture, consistent with the Judd–Ofelt mechanism. For Er substituting Al in α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3, local relaxation lowers the site symmetry to noncentrosymmetric C3vC_{3v}, allowing odd crystal-field components that mix 4f4f and 5d5d character within matching irreducible representations (A1A_1–A1A_1, EE–EE). This 4f4f–5d5d admixture activates nominally forbidden 4f4f–4f4f lines and renders them optically active.

Building on methodology we previously validated for impurity/defect-bound optical transitions,[11, 12, 13, 14] we compute the symmetry-resolved electronic structure and polarization-dependent absorption of substitutional Er (ErAl_\mathrm{Al}) in α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 from first principles. Our analysis predicts a telecom band resonance near 1.47 μm1.47\,\mu\mathrm{m} and attributes it to transitions within the A1/EA_1/E manifolds, activated by symmetry-allowed 4f4f–5d5d admixture. While the wavelength agrees with prior spectroscopy on Er-doped glasses and Er:Al2_2O3_3,[7, 15, 16, 17, 18] the present work provides, to our knowledge, the first ab initio, symmetry-resolved assignment of its microscopic origin and polarization selection rules in this host.

In this work, by combining ab initio Density Function Theory (DFT), Kubo–Greenwood susceptibility formula, and a C3vC_{3v} group-theoretical analysis, we demonstrate: (i) the presence of Er-derived localized states within the bandgap of α\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3; (ii) narrow, atom-like intra-4ff optical transitions; (iii) polarization-resolved electric-dipole selection rules dictated by the local symmetry; and (iv) a Judd–Ofelt (JO) interpretation whereby electric–dipole activity of intra-4ff lines arises from symmetry-allowed 4f4f–5d5d admixture.

Band structure

Numerical Analysis

All numerical calculations are carried out using DFT. The generalized gradient approximation (GGA) is used with the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) parametrization [19] of the correlation energy for geometrical optimization. The calculations are implemented within the Synopsis Atomistix Toolkit (ATK) 2021.06.[20] The periodic structure of the supercell allows one to characterize the electron states by the band structure εn(k)\varepsilon_n(\mathbf{k}), where k\mathbf{k} is the vector in the first Brillouin zone of the supercell and nn enumerates different bands. Semilocal GGA functionals are known to underestimate band gaps of semiconductors and insulators, largely due to self-interaction errors and the missing derivative discontinuity of the exchange–correlation functional. Quasiparticle GWGW calculations can correct this deficiency, but they are computationally prohibitive for the large supercells (hundreds of atoms) considered here. Hybrid functionals—mixing a fraction of exact (Hartree–Fock) exchange with a semilocal functional—often improve gap predictions, but at a substantially higher computational cost. As a practical and accurate alternative, meta-GGA functionals[21] (which depend on the density, its gradient, and the kinetic-energy density) frequently yield better band gaps and more realistic placement of localized states than GGA, at a cost far lower than hybrids. In this work we therefore employ a meta-GGA functional to compute the band structure of α\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3, obtaining a band gap close to experiment.

We first calculated the band structure of pristine Al2_2O3_3. The formula unit of Al2_2O3_3 contains five atoms. α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 crystallizes in the corundum structure (space group R3ˉcR\bar{3}c, No. 167). The primitive rhombohedral unit cell contains one lattice point with a basis of two formula units (Al4_4O6_6), i.e., 10 atoms. Equivalently, the structure may be described in the conventional hexagonal setting, which comprises six close-packed oxygen layers stacked along cc; the smaller Al cations occupy two-thirds of the octahedral interstitial sites. In this representation the conventional hexagonal cell[22] has three times the volume of the primitive rhombohedral cell and therefore contains six formula units (30 atoms), as shown in Figure 1(a). Pristine α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 belongs to the D3dD_{3d} point group and is centrosymmetric. With inversion and time-reversal symmetry, the host bands of α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 remain spin-degenerate and spin–orbit coupling (SOC) effects on the Al/O edges are small relative to the wide gap. By contrast, SOC on Er

Conventional cell, electronic band structure, density of states, and susceptibility tensor of pristine $\alpha$-$\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3$

Figure 1. a) Conventional cell of pristine α\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3 (space group R-3c) containing six formula units (30 atoms). Pink circles denote Al atoms; red circles denote O atoms. b) Electronic band structure of pristine α\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3, showing a direct gap at Γ\Gamma of Eg=8.8E_{\mathrm{g}} = 8.8 eV. Symmetry labels at Γ\Gamma VB-1/-2 (degenerate) →Eu\rightarrow E_{\mathrm{u}}, VB →A1u\rightarrow A_{1\mathrm{u}} and CB →A1g\rightarrow A_{1\mathrm{g}}. The corresponding DOS is shown: shaded-mGGA; dotted-GGA, which underestimates the gap (Eg=6.46E_{\mathrm{g}} = 6.46 eV). The dashed line at 0 eV is the Fermi Energy EFE_{\mathrm{F}}. (c) α\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3 has two polarization-resolved onsets separated by 0.07 eV (z vs. x/y) as shown in the susceptibility tensor χ∥,⊥\chi_{\parallel,\perp} (χ∥=(χxx+χyy)/2\chi_{\parallel} = (\chi_{xx} + \chi_{yy})/2 and χ⊥=χzz\chi_{\perp} = \chi_{zz}).

4f4f states sets the JJ-multiplet fine structure. Our C3vC_{3v} analysis targets the symmetry labels and polarization selection rules that govern allowed electric–dipole transitions; SOC refines the fine structure without altering these rules. Therefore, we performed unpolarized DFT calculations using a meta-GGA hybrid exchange correlation functional to obtain the band structure, density of states, and electric susceptibility. We obtain a band gap (direct) of 8.8 eV at the Γ point, which is in very close agreement with experimental values.[23, 24] At the Γ-point Al2_2O3_3 has two polarization-resolved onsets separated by 0.07 eV (z vs. x/y). At the Γ-point the valence-band maximum transforms as A2uA_{2u} and the conduction-band minimum as A1gA_{1g} IR’s (irreducible representations of D3dD_{3d}). Consequently, the direct A2u→A1gA_{2u} \rightarrow A_{1g} transition is electric-dipole allowed for z-polarization (π\pi), since A2u⊗A2u⊗A1g=A1gA_{2u} \otimes A_{2u} \otimes A_{1g} = A_{1g}. The next two valence bands (VB–1 and VB–2) form a degenerate EuE_u doublet at Γ; their transitions to A1gA_{1g} conduction band are allowed for in-plane (x,y) polarization (σ)(\sigma), because Eu⊗Eu⊗A1g=A1g⊕A2g⊕EgE_u \otimes E_u \otimes A_{1g} = A_{1g} \oplus A_{2g} \oplus E_g. The matrix elements of the susceptibility tensor in three dimensions can be evaluated using the Kubo–Greenwood formula for the electric susceptibility

χij(ω)=e2ℏme2V∑uvkfuk−fvkωuv2(k)[ωuv(k)−ω−iΓ/ℏ]puvipvuj,(1)\chi_{ij}(\omega)=\frac{e^2}{\hbar m_e^2 V}\sum_{uv\mathbf{k}}\frac{f_{uk}-f_{vk}}{\omega_{uv}^2(\mathbf{k})[\omega_{uv}(\mathbf{k})-\omega-i\Gamma/\hbar]}p_{uv}^i p_{vu}^j, \tag*{(1)}

where ppqj=⟨uk∣pj∣vk⟩p_{pq}^j=\langle u_k|p^j|v_k\rangle is the jjth component of dipole matrix element between states uu and vv with the Bloch state ⟨r∣uk⟩=ψuk(r)\langle r|u_k\rangle=\psi_{u_k}(r), VV the volume of the crystal, ff the Fermi function, and Γ\Gamma the broadening, which is set to be 0.01 eV. When recasting the k\mathbf{k}-point sum in Eq. (1) as an energy integral, the relevant quantity is the joint density of states (JDOS), which counts pairs of initial and final states at the same k\mathbf{k} whose energy difference matches ℏω\hbar\omega, and it must be weighted by the dipole matrix elements. In this representation, the imaginary part of the response can be written as

Im⁡χij(ω)=πe2ℏme2∑uvω−2Juvij(ω),\operatorname{Im}\chi_{ij}(\omega)=\frac{\pi e^2}{\hbar m_e^2}\sum_{uv}\omega^{-2}\mathcal{J}_{uv}^{ij}(\omega),

where Juvij(ω)\mathcal{J}_{uv}^{ij}(\omega) is the matrix-element-weighted JDOS. The optical response is relatively weak (Figure 1 (c)), as the density of states (DOS) near the conduction-band edge is small.

For an ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}} impurity, we consider a 2×2×12 \times2 \times1 (see Figure 1) supercell having 120 atoms with a doping percentage of 0.83%. In pristine α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 (space group R3ˉcR\bar{3}c), the two Al atoms in the primitive rhombohedral cell belong to a single crystallographic Al site (same Wyckoff orbit), so all Al sites are symmetry-equivalent. The Brillouin zone of the supercell is sampled by a 4×4×24 \times4 \times2 k\mathbf{k}-mesh. All the structures are geometrically optimized with a force tolerance of 0.01 eV/Å. First we calculate the stability of the Er impurity in Al2_2O3_3. The formation energy Ef,impE_{\mathrm{f,imp}} of ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}}:Al2_2O3_3 is defined with respect to the chemical potentials of Al and Er, and is obtained as the energy difference between the total energy of the ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}}:Al2_2O3_3 structure and the corresponding combination of reference reservoirs for Er and Al. The formation energy can be expressed as

Ef,imp(ErAl47O72)=Etot(ErAl47O72)−Etot(Al48O72)−μEr+μAl.E_{\mathrm{f,imp}}(\mathrm{ErAl}_{47}\mathrm{O}_{72})=E_{\mathrm{tot}}(\mathrm{ErAl}_{47}\mathrm{O}_{72})-E_{\mathrm{tot}}(\mathrm{Al}_{48}\mathrm{O}_{72})-\mu_{\mathrm{Er}}+\mu_{\mathrm{Al}}.

where, Etot(ErAl:(Al2O3))E_{\mathrm{tot}}(\mathrm{ErAl}:(\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3)) is the total energy of the ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}}:Al2_2O3_3 structure, μX\mu_X (X=Er,AlX=\mathrm{Er},\mathrm{Al}) are the chemical potentials of atom XX, calculated from their bulk counter parts. The calculated value of Ef,impE_{\mathrm{f,imp}} per defect for ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}}:(Al2_2O3_3) is 2.638 eV. The calculated formation energy corresponds to the substitution of one Al atom in Al2_2O3_3 by an Er atom, referenced to the chemical potentials of elemental Al and Er. An alternative way is to calculate the formation energy of ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}}:Al2_2O3_3 with respect to the gas phase[25] of Er, Al and O atoms by using the following relation

Efgas(ErAl47O72)=Etot(ErAl47O72)−μErgas−47μAlgas−72μOgas.E_{\mathrm{f}}^{\mathrm{gas}}(\mathrm{ErAl}_{47}\mathrm{O}_{72})=E_{\mathrm{tot}}(\mathrm{ErAl}_{47}\mathrm{O}_{72})-\mu_{\mathrm{Er}}^{\mathrm{gas}}-47\mu_{\mathrm{Al}}^{\mathrm{gas}}-72\mu_{\mathrm{O}}^{\mathrm{gas}}.

where μXgas\mu_X^{\mathrm{gas}} (X=Er,Al,OX=\mathrm{Er},\mathrm{Al},\mathrm{O}) is the chemical potential of XX atom in the gas phase. This formulation enables a consistent comparison of stability across pristine and Er doped Al2_2O3_3 by anchoring all formation energies to a common gas-phase reference. The calculated value of Efgas(ErAl47O72)=−14.83E_{\mathrm{f}}^{\mathrm{gas}}(\mathrm{ErAl}_{47}\mathrm{O}_{72})=-14.83 eV per atom indicates that the ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}}:Al2_2O3_3 structure is thermodynamically stable. It should be noted that Er-doped Al2_2O3_3 samples have been realized experimentally.[4, 26]

In Er-doped Al2_2O3_3, Er3+^{3+} is an isovalent substitute for Al3+^{3+}, so no charge compensation is required. Despite its larger ionic radius (Er3+≈0.89^{3+}\approx0.89 Å, CN=6) compared with Al3+^{3+} (∼0.535\sim0.535 Å), the Al2_2O3_3 lattice can accommodate Er3+^{3+} on the octahedral cation site (local C3vC_{3v} symmetry) at dilute concentrations, with only local distortions. The global crystal symmetry (R–3c) is preserved, while the non-centrosymmetric local site enables weakly allowed 4f–4f transitions via f–d mixing. At higher Er loadings, strain and Er–Er interactions promote photoluminescence quenching and clustering toward Er2_2O3_3, so device design typically targets sub-percent atomic fractions.

Figure 2 shows the band structure of ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}}:Al2_2O3_3. Al2_2O3_3 has a wide band gap and the presence of ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}} impurity in Al2_2O3_3 leads to localized impurity states (LIS) which can be seen as dispersionless electronic states within the band gap region of Al2_2O3_3. Vertical arrows show some of the allowed optical transitions between different ff–orbitals of ErAl_{\mathrm{Al}} impurity, observed in the optical spectra (see Figure 2 c).

Structure of ErAl impurity, band structure, and electric susceptibility

Figure 2. a) Structure of ErAl impurity in 2×2×12 \times2 \times1 Al2_2O3_3. The minimum impurity seperation is ∼10\sim10 Å in this configuration. b) Band structure of 2×2×12 \times2 \times1 of ErAl:Al2_2O3_3. Vertical arrows indicate optical transitions corresponding to resonances in the electric susceptibility plot as shown in c). Impurity states in the band structure belonging to the A1_1, A2_2 and E (doubly degenerate) representations of the C3v_{3v} point group. The inset magnifies the region near the Fermi level, at Γ-point; the dashed line at 0 eV marks EFE_F. Density of states plot is also shown in (b), shaded grey region shows the total density of states and the blue (red) curve shows the projected density of states of ff- (dd-) orbital of the Er atom, of 2×2×12 \times2 \times1 supercell of ErAl:Al2_2O3_3. The dispersionless localized impurity states (LIS) corresponding to the ff-orbitals of Er are clearly visible as dispersionless (localized) states, lying within the bandgap region of Al2_2O3_3. Vertical arrows show some of the dipole allowed transitions. Allowed transitions appears as resonance peaks in the susceptibility tensor χ∥,⊥\chi_{\parallel,\perp} shown in (c).

When considering impurities in a crystal, the

D3dD_{3d}EE2C32C_33C2′3C'_2ii2S62S_63σd3\sigma_dLinear Rotations
A1gA_{1g}111111
A2gA_{2g}11−1-111−1-1RzR_z
EgE_g2−1-102−1-10(Rx,Ry)(R_x,R_y)
A1uA_{1u}111−1-1−1-1−1-1
A2uA_{2u}11−1-1−1-1−1-11pzp_z
EuE_u2−1-10−2-210(px,py)(p_x,p_y)
D3dD_{3d}A1gA_{1g}A2gA_{2g}EgE_gA1uA_{1u}A2uA_{2u}EuE_u
A1gA_{1g}π\piσ\sigma
A2gA_{2g}π\piσ\sigma
EgE_gσ\sigmaσ\sigmaσ,π\sigma,\pi
A1uA_{1u}π\piσ\sigma
A2uA_{2u}π\piσ\sigma
EuE_uσ\sigmaσ\sigmaσ,π\sigma,\pi

Table 2. Character table of the point symmetry group D3dD_{3d} and Dipole allowed transitions of symmetry group D3dD_{3d}. σ\sigma denotes the allowed dipole transitions along the basal plane xy while π\pi denotes transitions along z-axis

LIS transform according to the IRs of the symmetry group of the crystal site in which the impurity resides. While the translational symmetry of the crystal is broken, point group symmetries are partially or completely preserved. The ErAl impurity locally breaks the D3dD_{3d} symmetry of Al2O3Al_2O_3 and is therefore represented locally by a lower symmetry group C3vC_{3v} the irreducible representations (IRs) of which are shown in tbl:3. We can identify the IR’s of the impurity states by plotting the Bloch states at the Γ\Gamma-point.

ErAl impurity with nearest neighbor O atoms, forming C3v symmetry

Figure 3. ErAl impurity with nearest neighbor O atoms, forming C3vC_{3v} symmetry.

ErAl in α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3: trigonal crystal field and ff-level splitting. Er3+^{3+} substituting Al3+^{3+} in Al2_2O3_3 occupies the octahedral cation site in a trigonal environment. In a local frame with z^∥C^3\hat{z} \parallel\hat{C}_3, the impurity is described by

H=Hhost+HCF(Er),(2)H = H_{\mathrm{host}} + H_{\mathrm{CF}}(\mathrm{Er}), \tag*{(2)}
HCF=∑k=2,4,6∑q=0,±3,±6BkqCkq.(3)H_{\mathrm{CF}} = \sum_{k=2,4,6} \sum_{q=0,\pm3,\pm6} B_k^q C_k^q. \tag*{(3)}

where CkqC_k^q are spherical-tensor (Wybournе/Racah) operators acting within the l=3l=3 ff-manifold and BkqB_k^q are crystal-field parameters allowed by the C3vC_{3v} symmetry (only q=0,±3,±6q=0,\pm3,\pm6 survive the threefold rotation). Reducing the seven-dimensional ff-orbital representation to the effective trigonal site symmetry of the Al2_2O3_3 cage (conveniently taken as C3vC_{3v} for selection rules) gives

Γf↓C3v=2A1⊕A2⊕2E=3A⊕2E,\Gamma_f \downarrow C_{3v} = 2A_1 \oplus A_2 \oplus2E = 3A \oplus2E,

hence the seven ff-orbitals split into three singlets and two doubly degenerate EE levels at an ErAl_\mathrm{Al} site with local trigonal symmetry. It should be noted that the above description is true only when ff-orbitals are involved. However it can be seen in Figure 2 (b) that substantial admixture of 5d5d-orbitals is also present in ff-orbitals. In C3vC_{3v} symmetry, the ff- and dd-orbital manifolds decompose as

f:2A1⊕A2⊕2E(7 orbitals),(4)f: 2A_1 \oplus A_2 \oplus2E \quad(7\ \text{orbitals}), \tag*{(4)}
d:A1⊕2E(5 orbitals).(5)d: A_1 \oplus2E \quad(5\ \text{orbitals}). \tag*{(5)}

Allowing symmetry-preserving ff–dd hybridization (only between states of the same irrep: A1↔A1A_1 \leftrightarrow A_1, E↔EE \leftrightarrow E), the combined orbital content is

(f⊕d)∣C3v=3A1⊕A2⊕4E,(f \oplus d)\big|_{C_{3v}} = 3A_1 \oplus A_2 \oplus4E,

which corresponds to a total of

3×1+1×1+4×2=123 \times1 + 1 \times1 + 4 \times2 = 12

orbital states. The A2(f)A_2(f) level has no dd-orbital counterpart in C3vC_{3v} and therefore remains essentially unmixed to first order. Out of these 12 states most lie in-gap; two reside well inside the conduction band.

Optical Response

The presence of localized in-gap states (LIS) in the band structure gives rise to sharp peaks in the susceptibility tensor, which we calculate using the Kubo–Greenwood (KG) formula, Eq. (1). In Figure 2 (c) results for the χ∥,⊥\chi_{\parallel,\perp} component of the electric susceptibility tensor, which corresponds to the z-polarization, is presented for ErAl_\mathrm{Al}:Al2_2O3_3. The electric susceptibility provides valuable insights into the optical selection rules for transitions between states across the Fermi level. We are interested in transitions involving states with energy near the gap edges or inside the gap. Appearance of impurity states inside the band gap EgE_g or close to the band edges leads to the resonances at single frequency ℏωuv=∣ϵu−ϵv∣\hbar\omega_{uv} = |\epsilon_u-\epsilon_v|, where ϵu\epsilon_u is the eigenenergy of the Bloch state ψuk(r)\psi_{u\mathbf{k}}(\mathbf{r}). The dipole matrix element puvnjp_{uv}^{nj} determines the strength of an optical transition and whether it is allowed or prohibited by symmetries.

Radiative transitions between ff-orbitals have been the subject of extensive research since the 1960s, as they are nominally dipole-forbidden due to electric dipole selection rules. The Judd–Ofelt theory[9, 10] accounts for these transitions by incorporating odd-parity terms in the crystal field Hamiltonian, which can exist only in non-centrosymmetric crystal environments. Using second-order perturbation theory, it has been shown that ff-orbitals can mix with 5d5d-orbitals, i.e., ⟨f∣H^cry∣d⟩≠0\langle f|\hat{H}_{\mathrm{cry}}|d\rangle\ne0, only when H^cry\hat{H}_{\mathrm{cry}} contains odd-parity components, thereby enabling radiative transitions. In the present case, the Er impurity in Al2_2O3_3 resides at a Al with C3vC_{3v} symmetry, which lacks inversion symmetry, thereby permitting odd terms in the crystal field Hamiltonian. The crystal field potential is given by H^CF=B20O^20+B30O^30+B40O^40+⋯\hat{H}_{\mathrm{CF}} = B_2^0\hat{O}_2^0+B_3^0\hat{O}_3^0+B_4^0\hat{O}_4^0+\cdots. The odd-parity term B33B_3^3, O^33\hat{O}_3^3 arises solely due to the non-centrosymmetric nature of the C3_3 point group and is responsible for enabling coupling between the 4f4f- and 5d5d- orbitals of Er, as evidenced by the blue and red curves in the density of states as shown in Figure 2 (b). The largest 4f4f–5d5d admixture occurs in the electronic states at 0.66 eV and 0.80 eV; a moderate component is present at the Fermi level (EFE_F), and a smaller but finite contribution appears in the states at −2.12-2.12 eV. On basis of Judd–Ofelt analysis, stronger 4f4f–5d5d admixture yields relatively more pronounced peaks in χ(ω)\chi(\omega). Consistent with this expectation, the resonances observed at 1.88 μm1.88\,\mu\mathrm{m}, 1.47 μm1.47\,\mu\mathrm{m}, 0.44 μm0.44\,\mu\mathrm{m}, and 0.42 μm0.42\,\mu\mathrm{m}—assigned to transitions with substantial 4f4f–5d5d admixture—are markedly more pronounced in the susceptibility tensor.

Examples of the Bloch states at $\Gamma$-point for the $\mathrm{Er}_{\mathrm{Al}}$ impurity in $2 \times 2 \times 1$ super cell of $\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3}$

Figure 4. Examples of the Bloch states at Γ\Gamma-point for the ErAl\mathrm{Er}_{\mathrm{Al}} impurity in 2×2×12 \times2 \times1 super cell of Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3}. The green ball shows the ErAl\mathrm{Er}_{\mathrm{Al}} impurity atom.

The appearance of LIS inside the band gap leads to sharp resonances in electric susceptibility χ\chi at frequencies corresponding to the energy differences between LIS. In particular we are able to identify a signature resonance peak of Er at 1.47 μm1.47\,\mu\mathrm{m}, which is in very good agreement with the absorption peak found in Er glass lasers [15] and also in recently realized Er-doped single layer MoS2\mathrm{MoS}_{2} [27].

Group theory provides an excellent framework to investigate electronic transitions both within the dipole approximation and beyond. Within the dipole approximation, a transition is considered allowed when the matrix element puvjp_{uv}^{j} transforms according to the totally symmetric irreducible representation of the symmetry group of the supercell. In this context, the initial state ∣vk⟩|v\mathbf{k}\rangle, the final state ∣uk⟩|u\mathbf{k}\rangle, and the momentum operator pjp^{j} transform according to the irreducible representations Γ(∣vk⟩)\Gamma(|v\mathbf{k}\rangle), Γ(∣uk⟩)\Gamma(|u\mathbf{k}\rangle), and Γ(pj)\Gamma(p^{j}), respectively. The electric dipole transition between two states is allowed if the direct product

Γ(∣vk⟩)⊗Γ(pj)⊗Γ(∣uk⟩)\Gamma(|v\mathbf{k}\rangle) \otimes\Gamma(p^{j}) \otimes\Gamma(|u\mathbf{k}\rangle)

contains the identity representation Γ(I)\Gamma(I) in its decomposition. For example, in the C3vC_{3v} point group, the identity representation corresponds to A1A_{1}. This is strictly related to the polarization of the radiation. One needs to consider separately the in plane and out of plane components of pvujp_{vu}^{j} because they transform according to different IRs of C3vC_{3v}. The selection rules for electric dipole transitions for IRs are summarized in Table 4.

C3vC_{3v}EEC3C_33σv3\sigma_vLinear Rotationsquadratic functionsCubic functions
A1A_1111zzz2z^2<br>x2+y2x^2+y^2z3z^3, x(x2−3y2)x(x^2-3y^2), z(x2+y2)z(x^2+y^2)
A2A_211−1-1RzR_z-y(3x2−y2)y(3x^2-y^2)
EE210(x,y)(x,y)<br>(Rx,Ry)(R_x,R_y)(x2−y2,xy)(x^2-y^2,xy)<br>(xz,yz)(xz,yz)(xz2,yz2)(xz^2,yz^2) [ xyzxyz, z(x2−y2)z(x^2-y^2) ]<br>[x(x2+y2),y(x2+y2)][x(x^2+y^2),y(x^2+y^2)]
C3C_3A1A_1A2A_2EE
A1A_1π\piσ\sigma
A2A_2π\piσ\sigma
EEσ\sigmaσ\sigmaπ,σ\pi,\sigma

Table 4. Character table of the group C3vC_{3v} and Dipole selection rules for C3vC_{3v} symmetry.

We want to comment about the device relevance. The prominent 1.47 μm1.47\,\mu\mathrm{m} resonance observed in both the out-of-plane (χ⊥\chi_{\perp}) and in-plane (χ∥\chi_{\parallel}) responses indicates mixed A1/EA_{1}/E character at the ErAl\mathrm{Er}_{\mathrm{Al}} site. In planar Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} photonics, this enables polarization-diverse coupling: A1A_{1}-like components couple efficiently to TM-like modes (large EzE_{z}), while EE-like components couple efficiently to TE-like modes (in-plane EE). Consequently, the same spectroscopic feature can be harnessed in either TE or TM device families by tailoring field profiles (waveguide height/aspect ratio, slot geometries) or by orienting microresonators (rings/disks) to favor the desired polarization. The mixed character also suggests practical routes to polarization control: cavity designs that enhance EzE_z selectively boost the A1A_1 contribution, whereas high-confinement TE modes emphasize the EE contribution, enabling dichroic operation and polarization-multiplexed amplification/emission near 1.47 μm. Since the degree of optical activation scales with symmetry-allowed 4f4f–5d5d admixture, modest engineering of the local crystal field (strain, co-dopants, composition) provides a symmetry-guided knob to optimize coupling without sacrificing spectral selectivity.

Conclusions

We have presented a symmetry-resolved, first-principles framework for Er-doped α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 that connects local crystal-field physics to device-relevant optical response. Substitutional ErAl_\mathrm{Al} is structurally stable and yields Er-derived localized states within the wide bandgap. Using the C3vC_{3v} site symmetry, we classified the impurity levels into A1A_1 and EE manifolds and derived the corresponding polarization-resolved electric–dipole selection rules. Kubo–Greenwood spectra computed from Kohn–Sham states corroborate these symmetry assignments and reveal a prominent telecom band feature near 1.47 μm. Consistent with the Judd–Ofelt mechanism, line strengths increase with symmetry-allowed 4f4f–5d5d admixture (A1↔A1A_1 \leftrightarrow A_1, E↔EE \leftrightarrow E), while the A2A_2 level remains essentially dark. Together, these results provide actionable design rules for Er:Al2_2O3_3: target IRs that maximize opposite-parity mixing, align device polarization with A1/EA_1/E characters, and engineer the local environment to tune ff–dd hybridization. This framework is transferable to other rare-earth dopants and wide-band-gap oxides, offering a microscopic route to symmetry-guided photonic functionality.

Acknowledgement J. D. C. acknowledges support by an appointment with the AMMTO Summer Internships program sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), EERE Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technologies Office (AMMTO). J. D. C. also acknowledges support by the DOE fellowship Office of Science Graduate Student Research (SCGSR) Program. M. N. L. and D. R. E. acknowledge support by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research (AFOSR) under award no. FA9550-23-1-0472.

References

  1. [1]van den Hoven, G. N.; Snoeks, E.; Polman, A.; van Uffelen, J. W. M.; Oei, Y. S.; Smit, M. K. Photoluminescence characterization of Er-implanted Al2O3 films. Applied Physics Letters 1993, 62, 3065–3067.DOI
  2. [2]Smit, M.; Acket, G.; van der Laan, C. Al2O3 films for integrated optics. Thin Solid Films 1986, 138, 171–181.DOI
  3. [3]Bonneville, D. B.; Osornio-Martinez, C. E.; Dijkstra, M.; García-Blanco, S. M. High on-chip gain spiral Al2O3:Er3&#x002B; waveguide amplifiers. Opt. Express 2024, 32, 15527–15536.
  4. [4]Worhoff, K.; Bradley, J. D. B.; Ay, F.; Geskus, D.; Blauwendraat, T. P.; Pollnau, M. Reliable Low-Cost Fabrication of Low-Loss Al2O3:Er3+ Waveguides With 5.4-dB Optical Gain. IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics 2009, 45, 454–461.DOI
  5. [5]Kenyon, A. Recent developments in rare-earth doped materials for optoelectronics. Progress in Quantum Electronics 2002, 26, 225–284.DOI
  6. [6]Kik, P.; Polman, A. Erbium-Doped Optical-Waveguide Amplifiers on Silicon. MRS Bulletin 1998, 23, 48–54.DOI
  7. [7]Ronn, J.; Karvonen, L.; Kauppinen, C.; Perros, A. P.; Peyghambarian, N.; Lipsanen, H.; Saynatjoki, A.; Sun, Z. Atomic layer engineering of Er-ion distribution in highly doped Er: Al2O3 for photoluminescence enhancement. Acs Photonics 2016, 3, 2040–2048.DOI
  8. [8]Bradley, J. D. B.; Agazzi, L.; Geskus, D.; Ay, F.; Worhoff, K.; Pollnau, M. Gain bandwidth of 80 nm and 2 dB/cm peak gain in Al2O3:Er3+ optical amplifiers on silicon. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 2010, 27, 187–196.
  9. [9]Judd, B. R. Optical Absorption Intensities of Rare-Earth Ions. Phys. Rev. 1962, 127, 750–761.DOI
  10. [10]Ofelt, G. S. Intensities of Crystal Spectra of Rare-Earth Ions. The Journal of Chemical Physics 1962, 37, 511–520.DOI
  11. [11]Khan, M. A.; Leuenberger, M. N. Ab initio calculations for electronic and optical properties of ErW defects in single-layer tungsten disulfide. Journal of Applied Physics 2021, 130, 115104.DOI
  12. [12]Khan, M.; Leuenberger, M. N. First-principles study of the electronic and optical properties of HoW impurities in single-layer tungsten disulfide. Scientific Reports 2022, 12, 11437.DOI
  13. [13]Khan, M. A.; Erementchouk, M.; Hendrickson, J.; Leuenberger, M. N. Electronic and optical properties of vacancy defects in single-layer transition metal dichalcogenides. Phys. Rev. B 2017, 95, 245435.DOI
  14. [14]Erementchouk, M.; Khan, M. A.; Leuenberger, M. N. Optical signatures of states bound to vacancy defects in monolayer MoS2. Phys. Rev. B 2015, 92, 121401.DOI
  15. [15]Snitzer, E.; Woodcock, R. Yb3+–Er3+ GLASS LASER. Applied Physics Letters 1965, 6, 45–46.DOI
  16. [16]Malinowski, M.; Frukacz, Z.; Szuflińska, M.; Wnuk, A.; Kaczkan, M. Optical transitions of Ho3+ in YAG. Journal of Alloys and Compounds 2000, 300–301, 389–394.DOI
  17. [17]Aisaka, T.; Fujii, M.; Hayashi, S. Enhancement of upconversion luminescence of Er doped Al2O3 films by Ag island films. Applied Physics Letters 2008, 92.DOI
  18. [18]Xiao, P.; Wang, B. Design of an erbium-doped Al2O3 optical waveguide amplifier with on-chip integrated laser pumping source. Optics Communications 2022, 508, 127709.DOI
  19. [19]Perdew, J. P.; Burke, K.; Ernzerhof, M. Generalized Gradient Approximation Made Simple. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1996, 77, 3865–3868.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10062328
  20. [20]VNL-ATK 2019.12. http://www.quantumwise.com/ 2021.6,
  21. [21]Tran, F.; Blaha, P. Accurate Band Gaps of Semiconductors and Insulators with a Semilocal Exchange-Correlation Potential. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2009, 102, 226401.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19658882
  22. [22]Galasso, F. S. Structure and properties of inorganic solids: international series of monographs in solid state physics; Elsevier, 2013; Vol. 7.
  23. [23]French, R. H. Electronic Band Structure of Al2O3, with Comparison to Alon and AlN. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 1990, 73, 477–489.DOI
  24. [24]Bortz, M. L.; French, R. H. Optical reflectivity measurements using a laser plasma light source. Applied Physics Letters 1989, 55, 1955–1957.DOI
  25. [25]Khan, M. A.; Atif, M.; Leuenberger, M. N. Tuning the electronic and optical properties of impurity-engineered two-dimensional graphullerene half-semiconductors. Phys. Rev. Mater. 2025, 9, 034001.arxiv.org/abs/2405.16743
  26. [26]Vázquez-Córdova, S. A.; Dijkstra, M.; Bernhardi, E. H.; Ay, F.; Wörhoff, K.; Herek, J. L.; García-Blanco, S. M.; Pollnau, M. Erbium-doped spiral amplifiers with 20 dB of net gain on silicon. Opt. Express 2014, 22, 25993–26004.
  27. [27]Yang, H.; Dai, Z.; Sun, Z. Upconversion luminescence and kinetics in Er3+:YAlO3 under 652.2nm excitation. Journal of Luminescence 2007, 124, 207–212.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_ed28mh9b
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents