betaFeedback

WorksComputer Science

Ground-Wing: A Parametric 3D Wing-in-Ground-Effect Dataset for Benchmarking Neural Surrogate Models

Abstract

This paper presents a CFD dataset of a highly parametrized 3D wing operating in ground effect, designed for benchmarking neural surrogate models for aerodynamic prediction, using a wing shape and flow conditions typically encountered in motorsport applications. The dataset comprises 770 RANS simulations of 194 unique wing configurations, sampled across 27 airfoil profile variants and 4 distances from the ground, spanning variations in wing sweep, chord, taper, angle of attack, and tip twist. Six neural network architectures representing distinct paradigms — convolutional (DoMINO), graph-based (X-MeshGraphNet), transformer-based (AB-UPT, GeoTransolver, GAOT), and JEPA-based (AeroJEPA) — are evaluated on their ability to predict surface pressure coefficient and wall shear stress distributions, from which integral drag and lift coefficients are recovered. The dataset is intended to be used as a challenging benchmark for surrogate CFD models, due to the uniqueness of the ground effect being absent from other wing and airfoil datasets. The dataset is available for download at https://huggingface.co/datasets/andreacenzato/Ground-Wing

Nomenclature

ClC_l = lift coefficient

CdC_d = drag coefficient

CpC_p = pressure coefficient

CpTC_{pT} = total pressure coefficient

ws\mathbf{w}_s = wall shear stress vector, Pa

αc\alpha_c = centerline angle of attack, ∘^\circ

θt\theta_t = tip twist angle, ∘^\circ

ccc_c = centerline chord length, mm

ctc_t = tip chord length, mm Λ\Lambda = sweep angle, ° ss = wing semispan, mm PP = airfoil profile identifier U\mathbf{U} = velocity vector u\mathbf{u} = non-dimensional velocity vector U∞U_{\infty} = freestream velocity, m s−1^{-1} ρ\rho = freestream air density, kg m−3^{-3} Y+Y^{+} = non-dimensional wall distance

Introduction

The aerodynamic design of front wings for automotive applications relies heavily on computational fluid dynamics (CFD), which, while accurate, demands substantial computational resources and turnaround time. In motorsport applications, for example, fast-paced design cycles require hundreds of geometry iterations within months, making the computational cost of fluid simulations a significant bottleneck.

The reason for this cost is that a direct analytical solution to the equations which describe the motion of viscous fluids, such as air, has not yet been discovered. The equations in question are known as the Navier-Stokes equations [1], which CFD software aims to resolve iteratively through finite volume methods. Even with these strategies, however, simplified modeling of the most complex flow behaviors has to be employed in order to keep the simulation time within reasonable limits. One such simplification, used in this paper, is the usage of the RANS (Reynolds Averaged Navier Stokes) [2] equations instead, whose solution provides the time-averaged flow field across the simulation domain, while using models [3] to calculate the effects of instantaneous turbulence. In addition, to allow for these methodologies to produce meaningful results, newly designed geometries require extensive preprocessing even before the simulation itself can start. CAD surfaces need to be made perfectly watertight, discretization of the airflow volume needs to be obtained through meshing, and boundary conditions for all relevant surfaces need to be set, all of which require a combination of manpower and computational effort.

Data-driven surrogate models based on neural networks can help alleviate most of these issues. By learning a mapping from geometric inputs directly to flow field solutions, they can provide predictions of flow variables by avoiding the iterative residual minimization of traditional CFD solvers altogether. They also do not require a mesh to produce a result, as they can operate on simpler representations of the objects of interest, such as simple 3D point clouds, sampled directly from a CAD geometry. This reduces the need for resource intensive meshing pipelines. By leveraging architectures such as Neural Operators [4] they feature the possibility for predictions on arbitrarily (i.e. distinct from the training setup) dense grids.

However, the deployment of such models hinges on their ability to provide reliable results outside of their training envelope. In order to verify this capability, one option is that of evaluating a trained model on a benchmark dataset related to the desired usecase. The model can be trained on part of the benchmark dataset itself or on other, external, data. What matters is that the evaluation set reflects the type of application which the model will be used for in a production environment. Therefore, to expand the usability of surrogate models to a new engineering field, a relevant benchmark dataset is required. One such example is high-performance motorsport, where the complexity of the typical aerodynamic features and the range of geometrical changes between designs make current surrogates unable to provide satisfactory results. In order to reduce this performance gap, exploratory steps can be taken by beginning with evaluating model predictions on single vehicle components, such as the front wing of LMDh prototypes [5]. This component is a crucial element of the vehicle’s aerodynamic package, as it greatly affects steering performance, and, subsequently, tire wear and vehicle driveability. This work aims to accomplish this exploratory goal with two main contributions:

  • Presenting a dataset of RANS solutions of the flow around a 3D downforce-generating wing running in ground effect. The wing geometry is parametrized along five continuous dimensions plus a discrete profile shape parameter, producing a diverse set of configurations that test a model’s ability to generalize across planform shape, incidence, and proximity to the ground. Section IV describes the geometry parametrization, the sampling strategy, and the CFD methodology used to generate the dataset in detail, together with the file formats and fields distributed with each simulation.

  • Benchmarking six state-of-the-art surrogate models [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11] against the presented dataset. § 5 introduces the evaluated neural surrogate architectures, which span the major paradigms in geometric deep learning (convolutional neural operators, graph neural networks, and transformers). It additionally explains the utilized train/validation/test

splits, and reports the models’ performance on the integral aerodynamic coefficients as well as on the surface fields themselves. Section VI discusses the reproducibility of the benchmarks run on the presented dataset.

The development and comparison of neural surrogate models rests on the availability of standardized datasets that capture the complexity of real-world aerodynamic problems. To be useful as a benchmark rather than merely as training data, such a dataset has to supply a geometry family parametrized along documented dimensions, a validated and reproducible CFD setup, surface and volume fields published in open formats, and defined splits on which competing architectures can be compared. A growing number of public CFD datasets meet a subset of these requirements. From them, two main families can be identified: road-car and bluff-body aerodynamics, and wing aerodynamics in free air.

The road-car family spans a wide range of geometric complexity. The earliest entry is the car dataset of Umetani and Bickel [12], commonly referred to as ShapeNet-Car. It contains shapes taken from the car category of the ShapeNet repository [13], stripped of mirrors, spoilers, and wheels, and simulated with an in-house finite-element solver using a kk-ε\varepsilon model, yielding a drag coefficient together with surface pressure and velocity fields. Its shapes are not parametrized, so it supports shape-to-field learning but not a controlled study of parameter generalization, which other bluff-body datasets aim to achieve. AhmedML [14] contains 500 variants of the Ahmed body generated from 6 geometric parameters, each simulated with a hybrid RANS-LES approach in OpenFOAM, while WindsorML [15] contains 355 variants of the Windsor body driven by 7 parameters, computed with a wall-modeled LES on a Cartesian immersed-boundary grid of more than 280M cells. Both distribute time-averaged surface and volume fields, geometry in STL and STEP, and force and moment coefficients. WindsorML additionally publishes deterministic benchmark splits, including geometry- and drag-extrapolation regimes. The remaining road-car datasets use production vehicle geometry. DrivAerNet [16] morphs the DrivAer fastback along 50 geometric parameters into 4000 designs, simulated in OpenFOAM as steady RANS with the kk-ω\omega SST model on 16M-cell meshes. DrivAerNet++ [17] extends this to 8000 designs across fastback, notchback, and estateback bodies with varying underbody and wheel configurations, described by 26 parameters and 24M-cell meshes, and adds parametric models, part annotations, and point clouds to the flow data. DrivAerML [18] applies the same hybrid RANS-LES methodology as AhmedML and WindsorML to 500 morphed DrivAer notchback variants on approximately 160M cells. DrivAerStar [19] is the largest of the family at 12,000 STAR-CCM+ simulations spanning three vehicle configurations deformed through 20 CAD parameters, and the only one to model the engine compartment and cooling system with their internal airflow. Finally, SHIFT-SUV [20] morphs the AeroSUV reference vehicle with a deformation cage sampled by Latin hypercube and computes each variant with a transient detached-eddy simulation.

The wing family is smaller and, with one exception, transonic. AirFRANS [21] is the most widely used reference: 1000 two-dimensional steady RANS solutions over NACA four- and five-digit sections at Reynolds numbers between 2 and 6×1066 \times10^{6} and varying angle of attack, computed with OpenFOAM and the Spalart-Allmaras model. Its primary contribution is methodological rather than data-centric, in that it ships four explicitly defined learning tasks, covering abundant and scarce training regimes as well as Reynolds-number and angle-of-attack extrapolation. Three-dimensional wing datasets are instead more recent. SuperWing [22] comprises 4239 parametrized swept wings and 28,856 RANS solutions, with the geometry parametrization varying airfoil shape, twist, and dihedral along the span rather than perturbing a single baseline, with each shape simulated across a range of Mach numbers and angles of attack. SHIFT-Wing [23] instead parametrizes the NASA high-speed Common Research Model through six spanwise airfoil stations and resolves each case with automated mesh adaptation. Emmi-Wing [24] is the largest, with roughly 30,000 samples of unique geometry and inflow condition in the highly turbulent transonic regime, computed with a steady compressible OpenFOAM solver and distributed with both surface and volumetric fields.

What none of these datasets contains is a body operating in close proximity to a wall. Every one of them places its geometry either in free air or, for the road cars, at a fixed ride height that is not itself a design variable, so ground clearance never appears as a dimension along which a surrogate model is asked to generalize. Ground effect introduces pronounced nonlinearities in the pressure field due to the confined flow between the wing and the ground plane, with phenomena such as enhanced Venturi acceleration and potential flow choking at low clearances, and it is precisely this regime that is of greatest interest to front-wing design in motorsport. The dataset presented in Section IV is built to fill that gap, varying both the wing shape and its distance from a moving ground plane, and pairing the simulations with the splits and metrics needed to use them as a benchmark.

Dataset Presentation

Geometry Parametrization

The geometry is a single-element wing with rectangular endplates, shown in Figure 1a, designed to loosely resemble and occupy the same design space as the front splitter of an LMDh prototype racecar [5]. This choice was guided by the desire to maintain real-world relevance. The geometry is designed to achieve two competing characteristics: complexity representative of modern race cars, and simplicity required for parametric shape generation. A single element was retained because the additional complexity introduced by the interaction between multiple closely coupled profiles is beyond the scope of this dataset. Endplates, conversely, were included on every geometry, since wings used in motorsport almost never operate without them or without an equivalent tip device, given the performance benefit they provide [25, 26].

Rendering of a wing geometry sampleTop view of the ground plane, with the slip floor in purple, the moving belt in blue and the wing in green

Figure 1. Wing geometry sample and its placement on the wind-tunnel ground plane.

The CAD model was built parametrically in Dassault’s CATIA, with the design space defined by classifying parameters into variable inputs that drive aerodynamic performance and fixed values that maintain relevance to the specific application and CAD model stability (Table 2). Beyond the parameters of Table 2, the CAD model exposes a set of endplate and fillet dimensions that are held fixed across all geometries, as their influence on the aerodynamic coefficients was found to be secondary to that of the primary parameters, and keeping them fixed reduces the dimensionality of the design space without sacrificing geometric realism. The endplate sizing follows recommendations from the ground-effect literature [25, 26], while the fillet radii serve to smooth the overall shape of the wing and were sized to avoid local flow separation. The values of these parameters, the reasoning behind each of them, and additional information about the geometry definition are described in Appendix A.

VariableFixedRide Heights
ParameterSymbolMinMaxParameterValueEndplateProfile
ProfilePP--Wing span2000 mm30 mm87 mm
Centerline AoAαc\alpha_c−10∘-10^\circ5∘5^\circ45 mm102 mm
Tip Twistθt\theta_t−10∘-10^\circ10∘10^\circ60 mm117 mm
Centerline Chordccc_c550 mm700 mm75 mm132 mm
Tip Chordctc_t350 mm700 mm
Sweep AngleΛ\Lambda−8.5∘-8.5^\circ20∘20^\circ

Table 2. Wing geometry parameters: variable design-space ranges (left), fixed values (center), and the ride heights simulated for every geometry (right).

The wing span and the minimum profile ground clearance are taken from the corresponding dimensions of the reference racecar’s front wing, where the span is dictated by the vehicle’s bodywork. Variations in ground clearance are achieved through a ride-height sweep described in Section IV.C. Throughout this paper the ride height denotes the clearance between the ground and the lowest point of the endplate, which is the lowest point of the whole assembly on every geometry (Figure 2a). Extending the endplates as far downwards as possible follows the aforementioned design guidelines, and compensates for the reference vehicle controlling the flow underneath the wing with other aerodynamic devices rather than with endplates. The bounds on the two chord lengths and on the sweep angle follow from the regulatory legality box, which limits how far forward the wing may reach, and from the front wheel arches, which limit it rearwards. Figure 2c illustrates the legality-box constraint on the planform, discussed further in Section IV.B. The lower chord bounds were instead selected as a reasonable minimum size for the application. Finally, the angle of attack and twist ranges are chosen such that every used airfoil profile operates without stall or large-scale separation along the entire span, avoiding flow features that are generally undesired in front wing design. Figure 2b visualizes the centerline angle of attack αc\alpha_c and tip twist θt\theta_t definitions.

Geometric constraints and angular parameters of the wing planform, and its ride-height and ground-clearance conventions

Figure 2. Geometric constraints and angular parameters of the wing planform, and its ride-height and ground-clearance conventions.

Additionally, two further simplifications were introduced to keep the CAD model stable and the parameter count tractable, at a modest cost in geometric realism:

  • Constant profile and ground clearance along span: both the airfoil profile and the minimum ground clearance are held constant along the span, precluding a raised center section or a spanwise blend between two profiles, in exchange for a much lower-dimensional design space. This is achieved by having the lowest point of the airfoil section be tangent to a horizontal plane across the entire span.

  • Linear sweep and twist: the sweep angle and tip twist vary at a constant rate across the span, rather than allowing a curved leading edge or abrupt local twist changes, so that the planform is fully described by a single sweep and twist value each rather than a spanwise distribution.

The profile parameter PP determines which airfoil profile is used to construct the main wing body. It is drawn from a pool of 27 total options, constructed as follows:

  • Base set: 12 publicly available [27, 28] high-lift shapes commonly used in motorsport applications, or developed specifically for motorsport use [29, 30], complemented by three standard NACA sections. The non-NACA sections all share high camber and comparatively small thickness. These profiles form the main corpus of the dataset.

  • Interpolated set: 15 additional sections, used to evaluate model performance on profile shapes unseen during training:

    • 2 high-lift profiles (S1223RTL, S3021), retrieved from [27]

    • 13 pairwise interpolated blends between BE122-125 and each of the other base set sections and the 2 additional high-lift profiles listed above, obtained as simple coordinate averages with XFOIL [31].

Appendix B names all 27 variants and identifies which of them belong to the base set, and the same appendix describes how the profiles were selected and how the interpolated ones were generated.

Sampling Strategy

To determine which geometries to generate from the available parameter combinations, two objectives were pursued:

  1. The samples must cover the five-dimensional continuous design space of Table 2 without leaving blind spots, so that no region of the space is systematically mispredicted for lack of training data.

  1. Samples should be denser where the aerodynamic response to parameter variations changes most rapidly, as these regions are the most complex areas of the design space for the model to learn. Concentrating samples where the informativeness of an additional sample is highest is common practice in data-centric machine learning [32], where it is normally used to select or weight samples of an existing dataset. The same reasoning is applied here one step earlier, to decide which simulations to even run.

The first objective is addressed by filling the design space with a Sobol sequence [33], a sampling strategy that fills a unit hypercube by aiming to distribute samples as evenly as possible across all dimensions, avoiding the clusters and voids produced by random sampling at any finite sample count. An additional feasibility filter is applied to every candidate generated by the Sobol sequence, to eliminate combinations of parameters that, while each individually lying inside the boundaries of Table 2, produce geometries that do not respect the constraints of Sec. IV.A. The filter is implemented as two families of constraints. The first bounds the sum of centerline angle of attack and tip twist, to ensure that no spanwise station of the wing operates outside the incidence range in which all profiles of the pool remain free of separation and stall. The second keeps the planform within the legality box of Section IV.A. Since the semispan is fixed, sweeping the wing displaces its tip longitudinally with respect to the centerline, so a large sweep angle combined with a large chord pushes the geometry beyond the allowed margins even when both parameters are individually admissible. Candidates violating any of these conditions are discarded before any selection takes place. Appendix C provides a further explanation of the application of the Sobol sequence, and of the constraint equations used in the feasibility filter.

The second objective is addressed by not simulating the Sobol points directly. Instead, a Sobol set large enough that at least three times the target number of geometries survives the feasibility filter is generated, and the surviving candidates are then reduced to the final sample count by a weighted selection driven by a sensitivity function

S(p)=∣∂Cl∂p∣+∣∂Cd∂p∣,(1)S(p) = \left|\frac{\partial C_l}{\partial p}\right| + \left|\frac{\partial C_d}{\partial p}\right|, \tag*{(1)}

defined separately for every continuous parameter pp of Table 2. The rationale for this particular form is that the predicted quantities the surrogate models are ultimately judged on are the integral coefficients, so a region of the design space is considered informative exactly when a small geometric perturbation there produces a large change in ClC_l or CdC_d. The usage of the absolute value ensures that high gradients in any direction produce a refinement of the sampling region.

The derivatives in Eq. (1) are obtained by CFD. First, each parameter is independently swept over its full range about a fixed baseline geometry, with all other parameters held constant and with the same solver setup used for the dataset itself (Section IV.C). From the results of the simulations, cubic splines are fitted through the resulting Cl(p)C_l(p) and Cd(p)C_d(p) curves for each parameter, and are differentiated analytically. This univariate construction deliberately ignores interactions between parameters: resolving the full five-dimensional response surface would have required a number of simulations comparable to the dataset itself, which would defeat the purpose of using it to decide where to sample. No sensitivity function is defined for the discrete profile parameter PP, since it does not correspond to a continuously variable dimension and a derivative with respect to it is meaningless. Profiles are instead assigned to the selected parameter sets through a separate Sobol distribution.

In the weighted selection, the sensitivity weight of a candidate sample is the product of the S(p)S(p) values of its parameters, so that a sample is rated informative only if it is informative in every dimension at once. That weight is combined with a coverage term, recomputed after every draw, which favors candidates far from the already-selected set. The two weights are normalized and given equal importance. These terms pull in opposite directions by construction, and weighting them equally is what keeps the sensitivity weighting from collapsing the sample set onto the most sensitive corners of the design space.

Applying this procedure yields the 194 unique wing geometries that constitute the dataset: 174 from the base set of profiles, and 20 built from the interpolated set of airfoil variants (Section IV.A). Figure 3 shows the resulting sampling density of each geometric parameter over the geometries built with the base set of airfoils, together with the sensitivity function of Eq. (1), normalized to its maximum over each parameter range. The distributions do not follow S(p)S(p) exactly, as they are not meant to: the coverage term and the feasibility filter both flatten them, the latter visibly so at the edges of the αc\alpha_c and ctc_t ranges, where large parts of the hypercube are infeasible. The imprint of the sensitivity weighting is nonetheless clear, most notably in the peaks of the θt\theta_t and Λ\Lambda distributions and in the higher density at small ccc_c and ctc_t, where S(p)S(p) is largest.

Figure 3. Sampling density of each geometric parameter across the 174 base set geometries (blue, left axis), with the sensitivity function S(p)S(p) of Eq. (1) overlaid as a percentage of its maximum over each parameter range (red, right axis). The discrete profile parameter PP is shown as counts.

Appendix C describes the setup used to obtain the sensitivity functions in detail, along with a deeper breakdown of the weighted selection process. Appendix D instead inspects the magnitude of the error introduced by not considering cross-parameter interactions in the computation of the sensitivity functions.

CFD Methodology

All simulations are performed using Siemens STAR-CCM+ with an incompressible RANS approach, a realizable kk-ε\varepsilon turbulence model [3], and a runtime of 1000 iterations. The freestream velocity is U∞=50U_{\infty} = 50 m s−1^{-1}, parallel to the wing’s centerline chord direction, with ρ=1.188 58\rho= 1.188\,58 kg m−3^{-3}. The computational domain measures 30 m ×\times 40 m ×\times 80 m (height ×\times width ×\times length). A slip condition is applied to the bottom surface of the simulation domain, except for a 3 m ×\times 10 m area beneath the wing, which moves at U∞U_{\infty}, and where a no-slip condition is applied (Figure 1b).

The hexahedral mesh uses a base size of 750 mm with 9 levels of refinement, halving the cell edge length at each level and yielding a minimum surface cell size of 1.5 mm and approximately 28 million cells per simulation (Figure 4). A dedicated mesh independence study, varying the base size between 625 mm and 1125 mm (Figure 5), showed that the chosen 28M-cell mesh is within 1% of a 77M-cell reference mesh for both ClC_l and CdC_d, a compromise favoring the large number of simulations required for the dataset over marginal per-case accuracy. A separate study increasing the number of prism-layer inflation cells (from 5 to 20, at fixed total height) to drive the wall-adjacent Y+Y^+ from the range of 30–100 down to Y+≃1Y^+ \simeq1 changed both coefficients by only 0.6%, confirming that wall-function modeling of the boundary layer is adequate at the chosen resolution. With the selected settings, each simulation required around 560 s on 320 CPU cores. For the complete dataset, this translates to ≃120\simeq120 h of real compute time, and ≃38300\simeq38300 core hours.

Mesh section at the wing centerline plane

Figure 4. Mesh section at the wing centerline plane.

Figure 5. (a) ClC_l convergence; (b) ClC_l percentage error; (c) CdC_d convergence; (d) CdC_d percentage error. Aerodynamic coefficient sensitivity to mesh base size, relative to the 28M-cell configuration used for the dataset.

The ride heights of Table 2 span the range of ground clearances relevant to race-car setup work. Each is reproduced as a rigid vertical translation of the wing relative to the bottom surface of the simulation domain. On the reference vehicle that distance is set by the suspension ride height, which is 10 mm lower than the values quoted here because of the offset between the suspension reference and the endplate’s lower edge. Only flat setups, i.e. equal front and rear ride heights, are included in the dataset, as with no other body present in the flow field, a change in chassis rake angle is equivalent to a change in angle of attack up to the rotation of the endplates, and would therefore duplicate information already carried by αc\alpha_c. Appendix A details this equivalence.

Figure 6 shows the aerodynamic envelope covered by the dataset across all 770 simulated samples, with each unique wing geometry assigned a distinct color across its simulated ride heights.

Figure 6. CdC_d vs. ClC_l for all 770 simulated samples, with each unique wing geometry distinguished by color.

Ground-effect wings are additionally susceptible to a nonlinear “choking” phenomenon at very low clearances, in which the flow beneath the wing separates and downforce collapses [34]. A dedicated ride-height sweep, reported in Appendix E, confirms that all four ride heights of Table 2 lie within the linear, well-behaved operating region.

Simulation Output and File Format

Each simulation is identified by one four-digit run id which identifies a unique geometry, and one four-digit ride height, which identifies the distance from the ground of a specific sample. The resulting name convention is the following: sample 0123 at a distance from the ground of 75 mm will be named run_0123_7575.

For each simulation, three files are distributed: a surface-only .stl geometry (no field data, provided for reference and for direct use by geometry-only models), a surface .vtp file with the cell-centered fields CpC_p, CpTC_{pT}, and wsw_s (in Pa), and a volumetric .vtu file with point data for CpC_p, CpTC_{pT}, UU and uu. Additionally, a machine readable database, run_db.csv, provides information about each run’s geometric parameters and integrated force coefficients. The surface meshes contain approximately 1.2M surface cells, while the volume meshes contain approximately 28M cells.

Neural Surrogate Benchmarking

The benchmark phase of this paper focuses on testing the performance of current state-of-the-art surrogate models on the task of predicting the surface variables CpC_p and ws\mathbf{w}_s. The models used in the benchmark were selected due to their stated prediction performance, their ability to handle large, multi-million element meshes, and their distinct architectural paradigms.

Section V.A defines the train/validation/test splits on which the models are trained and evaluated. Section V.B describes the main concept behind each model and how it was configured, and Section V.C defines the error metrics. The results follow in Sections V.D and V.E, with Section V.F assessing whether the models rank geometries correctly and Section V.G providing a qualitative comparison of the local surface pressure error.

Dataset Splits

Three separate dataset splits are utilized, to evaluate its capabilities on samples lying both inside and outside of the training envelope.

Stratified Split

The collection of wings generated using the base set of airfoil profiles is split into training, validation, and test subsets using iterative stratification [35]. This splitting strategy is designed for datasets characterized by multiple continuous and categorical parameters, and aims to preserve the marginal distribution of every parameter across all subsets. The split acts on the 174 unique geometries rather than on the 690 individual simulations, and the available ride heights of a geometry are re-attached to whichever subset that geometry was assigned to. No geometry is therefore shared between training, validation, and test at a different ride height, which would otherwise let a model recognize a test shape it had already been trained on. To build the label vector that stratification operates on, the five continuous parameters of Table 2 are discretized into 15 uniform bins each and one-hot encoded together with the categorical profile parameter PP, turning every geometry into a multi-label indicator vector. The resulting set is then split twice, first 80/20 and then the 20% half again into equal parts. The procedure is stated in full in Appendix F.

This is the split whose test set the results of § 5.D refer to. Six cases are missing from the full 174×4=696174 \times4 = 696 configurations due to processing errors, and the simulations were not repeated.

Drag-Outlier Split

This is an alternative split of the same 174 geometries from the stratified split, in which 50% of the validation and test sets are filled with the highest- and lowest-drag geometries, by round-robin assignment of the runs with the highest CdC_d deviation from the mean. The rest of these sets are then composed of randomly assigned geometries, to obtain a final 80/10/10 split. This distribution probes performance at the edges of the aerodynamic envelope. Its training set is a different subset of the geometries, so every model is retrained from scratch on it under the same configuration as for the stratified split. Its benchmark results are reported in § 5.E.

Interpolated Split

This split replaces the test set of the stratified split with the 20 geometries built from the 15 additional profiles of the interpolated set (Section IV.B), giving 80 test simulations on profile shapes that appear in no training geometry, while leaving the training and validation sets untouched. Because its training and validation sets are identical to those of the stratified split, no retraining is required or performed. These geometries are evaluated with the checkpoints trained on the stratified split. This split therefore probes generalization to unseen profile shapes. Its benchmark results are also reported in § 5.E.

Table 3 lists the contents of each split, in terms of number of total simulations and of unique geometries.

SplitTrainingValidationTestPurpose
Stratified547 (138)72 (18)71 (18)Training and primary benchmark
Drag-outlier558 (141)68 (17)64 (16)Extremes of the aerodynamic envelope
Interpolated547 (138)72 (18)80 (20)Unseen airfoil profiles

Table 3. The number of simulations in each of the three splits, with the number of unique geometries in parentheses.

Surrogate Models

The six architectures below span the three architectures currently used for large-scale surface-field prediction: convolutional neural operators, graph neural networks, and transformers. For each model, the description states the paradigm it belongs to, the mechanism by which it encodes geometry and produces localized predictions, and, where one was needed, the adaptation made to apply it to this dataset.

  1. DoMINO (NVIDIA) [7]: A convolutional neural operator that processes 3D point clouds using spherical point convolution kernels at multiple scales. Geometric features are encoded into a structured latent representation, from which localized predictions are made via stencil-based aggregation. For this dataset, explicit inclusion of the wind tunnel moving belt in the training data was required to correctly encode ride height variations, as the model otherwise struggled to distinguish different ride heights of the same wing geometry.

  1. X-MeshGraphNet (NVIDIA) [8], an extension of MeshGraphNet [36]: A graph neural network that constructs a custom graph directly from the wing CAD surface, with message-passing layers propagating information between nodes across multiple spatial scales. Custom preprocessing was developed for this dataset, including cell-normal-based edge filtering, to prevent non-physical information leakage across thin wing sections and sharp corners.

  1. AB-UPT (JKU Linz) [6]: A transformer-based neural operator using an anchor-branched attention mechanism that reduces the computational complexity of attention from O(N2)O(N^{2}) to O(N)O(N) by computing keys and values only from a small subset of anchor points. Separate geometry, surface, and volume branches communicate via cross-attention. For the benchmark it is run in a surface-only configuration, with the volume branch disabled. The variant trained with the addition of volumetric targets is reported in Appendix § 15.

  1. AeroJEPA [9]: A JEPA-based (Joint-Embedding Predictive Architecture) model that learns semantic latent representations for aerodynamic field modeling. It encodes geometry with a context encoder and a conditioned predictor, then calculates the latent loss against the outputs of the target encoder, which encodes the ground truth flow variables. A separate INR decoder provides flowfield predictions at arbitrary resolutions.

  1. GeoTransolver (NVIDIA) [10]: A geometry-aware evolution of Transolver [37] that adds GALE (Geometry-Aware Latent Embedding) attention, in the spirit of DoMINO, to inject local and global geometric context. In addition, it persistently re-projects geometry and boundary-condition information into the physical state space at every transformer block via cross-attention.

  1. GAOT (ETH Zurich) [11]: A geometry-aware operator transformer that uses a multiscale attentional graph neural operator (MAGNO) as encoder and decoder, together with geometry embeddings derived from local statistical shape descriptors. A vision-transformer processor operates on an equispaced latent token grid for computational efficiency, while the MAGNO decoder still enables evaluation at arbitrary query points.

All six models are trained to predict the surface fields CpC_p and wsw_s from the wing geometry, which is the task the benchmark compares them on, and every one of them is trained on those surface fields alone. Where an architecture supports combined surface and volumetric training, it was run in its surface-only configuration. AB-UPT was customized to remove the volumetric branch, as its default configuration is designed to use it. To verify reproducibility, the original model was also trained on the splits described in this paper with otherwise identical settings. It is reported in Appendix § 15 as additional information.

Integral aerodynamic coefficients ClC_l and CdC_d are obtained by numerically integrating the predicted surface fields over the wing and endplate surfaces.

The model architecture-specific settings were determined by a combination of hyperparameter optimization with Optuna [38] and empirical testing on the validation set of the stratified split. The number of epochs and the learning-rate settings, in contrast, were deliberately left at the values found in each model’s reference implementation, so that no architecture is advantaged by a better-tuned optimization schedule than its authors intended. Table 4 reports the primary parameters of interest for the trained models, while Appendix G reports the full configuration of each.

ModelWidthLayersHeadsSampled pointsEpochsLearning rate
AB-UPT1926316 384 surface, 2 000 geometry5005×10−55 \times10^{-5}
GeoTransolver256134100 000 surface, 50 000 geometry5003×10−43 \times10^{-4}
AeroJEPA128648 192 surface, 512 tokens3001×10−31 \times10^{-3}
GAOT25610864×32×3264 \times32 \times32 latent grid3008×10−48 \times10^{-4}
DoMINO256UNet—16 384 surface, 300 000 geometry5005×10−45 \times10^{-4}
X-MeshGraphNet25615—40 000 graph nodes5001×10−31 \times10^{-3}

Table 4. Principal training configuration per model. “Width” is the latent or hidden dimension of the main processor, “layers” the depth of the processor and “heads” the number of attention heads where attention is used. The point counts are per forward pass.

Error Metrics

Throughout this section a hat (^) denotes a predicted quantity and an unhatted symbol the corresponding CFD ground truth. Accuracy is reported at two levels: on the integral aerodynamic coefficients, which are what a design workflow ultimately consumes, and on the surface fields themselves, which are what the models actually regress.

For the coefficients, the primary metric is the absolute percentage error of a single simulation,

Err⁡(Ci)=∣C^i−CiCi∣×100%,i∈{l,d},(2)\operatorname{Err}(C_i) = \left|\frac{\widehat{C}_i-C_i}{C_i}\right| \times100\%, \qquad i \in\{l,d\}, \tag*{(2)}

of which the mean and the standard deviation over a test set are reported. Two coefficients of determination are reported alongside it, to evaluate whether models respect the order of the design space. The first,

Rfit2=corr⁡(Ci,C^i)2,(3)R_{\mathrm{fit}}^2 = \operatorname{corr}\left(C_i,\widehat{C}_i\right)^2, \tag*{(3)}

is the squared Pearson correlation between prediction and ground truth, equivalently the coefficient of determination of the least-squares line fitted through the predicted-versus-true scatter. It measures how well a model tracks the coefficient trend across the design space and is by construction insensitive to a constant offset or a systematic scale error. The second,

R1:12=1−∑k(C^i,k−Ci,k)2∑k(Ci,k−Ci‾)2,(4)R_{1:1}^2 = 1 - \frac{\sum_k\left(\widehat{C}_{i,k}-C_{i,k}\right)^2}{\sum_k\left(C_{i,k}-\overline{C_i}\right)^2}, \tag*{(4)}

with kk running over the simulations of the test set, is taken about the 1:1 line rather than a fitted one and therefore penalizes bias and scale errors as well as scatter. A high Rfit2R_{\mathrm{fit}}^2 combined with a lower R1:12R_{1:1}^2 highlights a prediction that is well correlated with the truth but offset from it.

For a field ϕ∈{Cp,ws}\phi\in\{C_p,w_s\} with element-wise error ej=ϕ^j−ϕje_j=\widehat{\phi}_j-\phi_j over the NN surface elements of one simulation,

MSE⁡(ϕ)=1N∑j=1Nej2,L1(ϕ)=∑j∣ej∣∑j∣ϕj∣,L2(ϕ)=∑jej2∑jϕj2.(5)\begin{aligned} \operatorname{MSE}(\phi) &= \frac{1}{N}\sum_{j=1}^{N}e_j^2, \qquad L_1(\phi) = \frac{\sum_j |e_j|}{\sum_j |\phi_j|}, \qquad L_2(\phi) = \sqrt{\frac{\sum_j e_j^2}{\sum_j \phi_j^2}}. \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

The mean squared error is left in the physical units of the field, while the two norm-based measures are normalized by the corresponding norm of the ground truth, which makes them dimensionless and therefore comparable between the dimensionless CpC_p and the wall shear stress in Pa. All three are computed per simulation and then averaged over the test set. The wall shear stress is evaluated on its magnitude. Every field metric reported below was recomputed element-wise from the prediction meshes themselves, with one implementation applied to all models.

Benchmarking Results

Table 5 summarizes the coefficient accuracy of all six models on the test set of the stratified split (§ 5.A), ordered by mean ClC_l error. Transformer-based architectures lead the benchmark, and the ranking is the same for both coefficients except for DoMINO, which moves up one place on CdC_d. Drag is the harder quantity for five of the six models, with the widest gaps for X-MeshGraphNet and AeroJEPA, whose CdC_d error is ≃1.6\simeq1.6 times their ClC_l error. The two coefficients of determination distinguish scatter from bias. GAOT reaches a high Rfit2R_{\mathrm{fit}}^2 on ClC_l (0.989) despite a higher mean error, so its predictions follow the correct trend and the error is concentrated in a small number of badly mispredicted cases. X-MeshGraphNet is the only model whose two ClC_l scores differ appreciably (0.961 against 0.898), the signature of a prediction that correlates well with the truth but is systematically offset from the 1:1 line.

Figure 7 shows the full per-simulation error distribution as box plots, confirming that AB-UPT’s advantage holds not only in the mean but throughout the distribution, while GAOT and X-MeshGraphNet show markedly heavier tails, GAOT for ClC_l and X-MeshGraphNet for CdC_d. Figure 8 plots the same predictions against the ground truth. It makes the two failure modes visible directly: GAOT’s ClC_l panel is tight around the 1:1 line except for a handful of far outliers, whereas X-MeshGraphNet’s scatter is broad and tilted, with the highest-downforce cases systematically under-predicted in magnitude and the highest-drag cases over-predicted.

Figure 8. Predicted versus true CdC_d (top row) and ClC_l (bottom row) on the test set of the stratified split, with both coefficients of determination annotated in each panel. The solid diagonal is the 1:1 line.

Figure 7. Distribution of per-simulation CdC_d (left) and ClC_l (right) relative error on the test set of the stratified split.

Integral coefficients are the quantities a design workflow ultimately consumes, but they are integrals: cancellation between over- and under-predicted regions can hide substantial local error. Table 6 therefore reports the surface field metrics of Eq. (5) on the same test set, and Figure 9 shows the relative L2L_2 error with its spread across the test set. The field ranking reproduces the coefficient ranking model for model, with one exception: DoMINO, fifth on ClC_l, is fourth on both fields, ahead of GAOT, which is consistent with its comparatively strong CdC_d prediction. The agreement between the two levels indicates that the coefficient errors of Table 5 are not an artifact of favorable cancellation. For every model the relative L1L_1 error is smaller than the relative L2L_2 error, by between 10% and 32% on CpC_p and by between 26% and 62% on the wall shear stress. This places the field error predominantly in localized regions, such as the suction peak, the endplate junctions, and the wake-facing side of the flap, rather than spreading it evenly over the surface.

ModelArchitectureClC_l Err. [%, σ\sigma]Rfit2R_{\mathrm{fit}}^2R1:12R_{1:1}^2CdC_d Err. [%, σ\sigma]Rfit2R_{\mathrm{fit}}^2R1:12R_{1:1}^2
AB-UPTTransformer0.85, 0.890.9990.9990.89, 0.740.9990.999
GeoTransolverTransformer2.33, 2.810.9950.9943.15, 2.490.9900.990
AeroJEPAJEPA2.83, 2.460.9950.9944.38, 3.010.9870.977
GAOTTransformer5.62, 11.010.9890.9877.48, 6.510.9630.957
DoMINOCNN7.05, 6.010.9720.9666.24, 3.930.9770.971
X-MeshGraphNetGNN8.87, 5.530.9610.89813.80, 10.860.9040.897

Table 5. Coefficient accuracy on the test simulations of the stratified split, ordered by mean ClC_l error.

ModelCpC_p∣ws∣|w_s|
MSEL1L_1 [%]L2L_2 [%]MSE [Pa2^2]L1L_1 [%]L2L_2 [%]
AB-UPT0.00172.002.630.1021.512.46
GeoTransolver0.00423.574.440.1842.283.19
AeroJEPA0.00715.516.190.3973.955.30
GAOT0.028512.5614.191.5337.9710.66
DoMINO0.01799.7710.750.7755.877.42
X-MeshGraphNet0.102221.2326.893.94611.9417.01

Table 6. Surface field accuracy on the test set of the stratified split. All quantities are averaged over the test set.

Figure 9. Mean relative L2L_2 error of the predicted surface fields on the test set of the stratified split. Error bars span one standard deviation across the test simulations.

Interpolated and Drag-Outlier Test Sets

Table 7 reports the same coefficient and field metrics on the two additional test sets of § 5.A, and Figure 10 places all three test sets side by side. The two sets are evaluated differently, as described in § 5.A. The interpolated set of profiles is predicted by the checkpoints trained on the stratified split, whereas the drag-outlier split has its own training set and every model was retrained on it. Both additional sets are harder than the stratified one for every model, but with two separate failure modes.

ModelDrag-outlier ClC_l Err. [%, σ\sigma]Drag-outlier CdC_d Err. [%, σ\sigma]Drag-outlier CpC_p L2L_2 [%]Drag-outlier ∣ws∣|w_s| L2L_2 [%]Interpolated ClC_l Err. [%, σ\sigma]Interpolated CdC_d Err. [%, σ\sigma]Interpolated CpC_p L2L_2 [%]Interpolated ∣ws∣|w_s| L2L_2 [%]
AB-UPT2.82, 4.151.92, 1.964.183.761.56, 1.254.51, 3.585.003.85
GeoTransolver7.89, 11.146.44, 5.769.105.524.70, 4.6518.98, 18.9313.476.41
AeroJEPA8.75, 12.676.14, 6.3910.387.726.54, 6.315.22, 4.8411.177.55
GAOT13.58, 24.658.45, 5.5016.3811.325.84, 4.799.03, 7.6817.3511.95
DoMINO10.25, 12.169.58, 6.8114.579.395.52, 4.5913.80, 16.4015.028.24
X-MeshGraphNet20.58, 25.3414.01, 9.5232.9219.6312.82, 12.1738.37, 45.0629.8318.14

Table 7. Performance on the drag-outlier and interpolated test sets.

Figure 10. Mean relative ClC_l (left) and CdC_d (right) error of every model on the three test sets. Error bars span one standard deviation across the test simulations. Note the logarithmic ordinate.

The drag-outlier set, whose validation and test geometries are drawn from the extremes of the drag distribution, hurts lift far more than drag: every model’s ClC_l error grows by a factor of between 1.5 and 3.4, while the CdC_d error grows more slowly, by at most a factor of 2.2. The only exception is DoMINO, where the trend reverses. For most models the standard deviations grow at least as fast as the means, so the degradation is dominated by a minority of extreme geometries rather than by a uniform loss of accuracy. As expected, extrapolation outside of the training boundary produces worse results than mere interpolation.

The interpolated set, built from profile shapes that appear in no training geometry, reverses the pattern. Lift remains comparatively well predicted, whereas drag degrades sharply.

Directional Consistency of Predicted Deltas

Beyond the absolute prediction error, a practically relevant question for a surrogate model used in an iterative design workflow is whether it correctly predicts the direction of change in ClC_l and CdC_d between two related geometries, even if the absolute magnitude carries some error. For every ordered pair of the stratified test-set simulations, we compute the true and predicted coefficient deltas relative to one another and classify each pair as a directional match if sign⁡(ΔC^i)=sign⁡(ΔCi)\operatorname{sign}(\Delta\hat{C}_i) = \operatorname{sign}(\Delta C_i). Figure 11 shows the resulting diagram for AB-UPT’s ClC_l predictions, and Figure 12 for X-MeshGraphNet, illustrating the gap between the best- and worst-performing models of Table 5. AB-UPT reproduces the correct sign of the delta in 99.0% of pairs and keeps every predicted delta within 10% of the true one, while X-MeshGraphNet reproduces the correct sign in 91.5% of pairs, meets the 10% tolerance in only 63.1%, and shows visibly larger scatter around the perfect-match line. On ClC_l the other models lie between these two at 97.7% (GeoTransolver), 96.5% (AeroJEPA and GAOT, tied), and 93.9% (DoMINO). Directional agreement on CdC_d is lower than on ClC_l for five of the six models and ranges from 98.9% for AB-UPT down to 85.3% for X-MeshGraphNet.

AB-UPT predicted versus true $C_l$ deltas between all pairs of test-set geometries

Figure 11. AB-UPT: predicted vs. true ClC_l deltas between all pairs of test-set geometries.

Figure 12. X-MeshGraphNet: predicted vs. true ClC_l deltas between all pairs of test-set geometries. panel is viewed from below, looking towards +Z+Z, so the visible surface is the suction side that generates most of the downforce and has the highest CpC_p magnitude.

Predicted Field Visualizations

A necessary addition to the metrics of the preceding sections is an evaluation of the spatial distribution of the errors on the wing surface. This subsection therefore shows the local surface pressure error on one reference case: test run 0169_7575, a geometry from the stratified test set at the 75 mm ride height. It is chosen as a representative sample, as its median relative ClC_l error across the six models, 2.8%, coincides with the median across the whole test set. Every

Figure 13 places the CpC_p prediction of the best-performing model, AB-UPT, next to the CFD ground truth together with its signed error, and Figure 14 shows the signed error ΔCp=Cppred−CpCFD\Delta C_p = C_p^{\mathrm{pred}} - C_p^{\mathrm{CFD}} of all six models.

Surface pressure coefficient ground truth, prediction, and signed error

Figure 13. Surface CpC_p prediction and local error of AB-UPT on test run 0169_7575 (stratified test set, 75 mm ride height). Viewed from below, looking towards +Z+Z.

Figure 14. Signed surface pressure error ΔCp=Cppred−CpCFD\Delta C_p = C_p^{\mathrm{pred}} - C_p^{\mathrm{CFD}} on test run 0169_7575. Viewed from below, looking towards +Z+Z.

In Figure 13 the AB-UPT prediction reproduces the main features of the CFD ground truth: the spanwise suction band, the stagnation line along the leading edge and the recovery towards the endplates. Together with the R2R^2 values of Table 5, this indicates that the models differ in the accuracy of the field rather than in its topology. The error maps of Figure 14 separate them. AB-UPT is close to uniform, with only faint chordwise banding. GeoTransolver, AeroJEPA, GAOT and DoMINO show progressively stronger error fields concentrated on the suction band, where the pressure gradients are largest. X-MeshGraphNet is qualitatively different, as its error distribution is affected by the graph construction on each geometry. Quantitatively, the error range of Figure 14 contains all but 0.4% of AB-UPT’s surface elements on this run, against 14.5% for X-MeshGraphNet.

Reproducibility

Table 8 maps the dataset and benchmark against the items of the ML Reproducibility Checklist v2.0.1

Checklist itemReference / Value
Model/algorithm descriptionSection V.B
Model complexity analysisOut of scope. Reported by the respective architecture papers [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11]
Dataset statisticsSection V.A, Table 2
Train/val/test split detailsSection V.A, Appendix F, Table 3
Pre-processing descriptionSection IV.D
Downloadable dataset linkhttps://huggingface.co/datasets/andreacenzato/Ground-Wing
Dependency specification, training/evaluation codeOut of scope. Reported by the respective architecture papers [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11]
Pretrained model weightsOut of scope. Can be regenerated by training the models with the given configurations.
Hyperparameters usedAppendix G, Table 4. Selection method in Section V.B
Number of training/evaluation runsTwo per model (stratified and drag-outlier split)
Definition of reported metricsSection V.C, Eqs. (2)–(5)
Central tendency and variation of resultsTable 5, Table 6 and Table 7
Excluded dataBelow
Average runtime / energy costOut of scope. Training and inference cost per architecture is reported by the respective architecture papers [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11]
Computing infrastructure descriptionNVIDIA DGXH100 and DGXA100

Table 8. Dataset and benchmark status against the ML Reproducibility Checklist v2.0.

For completeness, the following data are excluded from the reported results:

  • The airfoil profile used for the sensitivity analysis sweep is a proprietary internal design, and cannot be shared, therefore it does not appear in any simulation shared with this dataset.

  • The mesh convergence, Y+ study, and ride height analysis were also performed using this proprietary profile.

Conclusion

This work introduces a parametric 3D wing-in-ground-effect CFD dataset, comprising 770 RANS simulations across 194 unique wing geometries and 4 ride heights, together with an associated benchmark of six neural surrogate architectures spanning convolutional, graph-based, and transformer paradigms. Transformer-based architectures dominate the benchmark, with AB-UPT achieving the lowest error on both aerodynamic coefficients (0.85% mean ClC_l error, 0.89% mean CdC_d error), followed by GeoTransolver and AeroJEPA. The two additional test sets separate the failure modes cleanly, with the drag-outlier set degrading lift prediction and the interpolated profiles degrading drag prediction.

The dataset and its documentation, including the fully described CAD parametrization, sampling strategy, and CFD methodology (Section IV), are intended to serve as a standardized, ground-effect-specific benchmark for future data-driven aerodynamic prediction methods. The difficulty of the models in maintaining accuracy outside of the training envelope demonstrates that this dataset is a challenging benchmark evaluating model generalization.

Wing CAD Model and Geometry Constraints

In addition to the primary wing parameters (Table 2), the CAD model exposed the endplate parameters (Table 9), and the fillet parameters (Table 10). The first group is, by a wide margin, the most influential on the aerodynamic performance of the wing, which is why it is the only one varied across the dataset and the only one subject to the sensitivity analysis of Section IV.B. The other two groups are held constant at the values given below.

ParameterDescriptionValue
Endplate UPWDVertical distance between the trailing edge at the tip and the top of the endplate105 mm
Endplate RWDHorizontal distance between the trailing edge at the tip and the rear edge of the endplate20 mm
Endplate FWDHorizontal distance between the leading edge at the tip and the front edge of the endplate50 mm
Endplate thicknessThickness of the endplate in the yy direction15 mm
Endplate edge filletRadius of the fillet between the wing tip and the endplate10 mm

Table 9. Fixed endplate parameters.

ParameterDescriptionValue
Leading edge filletRadius of the fillet between the two semispans at the leading edge, in the xyxy plane1000 mm
Leading edge center filletRadius of the fillet between the two semispans at the leading edge, in the yzyz plane500 mm
Leading edge tip filletRadius of the fillet in the yzyz plane between the leading edge at the tip and the yy direction500 mm
Trailing edge filletRadius of the fillet between the two semispans at the trailing edge, in the xyxy plane500 mm
Trailing edge center filletRadius of the fillet between the two semispans at the trailing edge, in the yzyz plane500 mm
Trailing edge tip filletRadius of the fillet in the yzyz plane between the trailing edge at the tip and the yy direction500 mm

Table 10. Fixed fillet parameters.

The endplate dimensions are derived from the ground-effect literature [25, 26], but deviate from those references in two ways. First, the endplate extends rearward past the trailing edge of the profile to ensure CAD model stability. Second, the downward extension of the endplate is set by a fixed clearance of its lower edge from the ground (Table 2) rather than by a dimension relative to the wing. Keeping that lower edge at a constant height provides a clean definition for the ride height, at the cost of a small variation in total endplate area across geometries. The fillet radius joining the wing tip to the endplate was set to 10 mm to prevent the triggering of local flow separation.

The fillet parameters of Table 10 exist purely to smooth the overall shape of the wing, in particular the transition between the two semispans at the centerline and the transition towards the wing tips. Their influence on the integral aerodynamic coefficients was found to be negligible compared to that of the primary parameters, so they were kept identical across all geometries.

Finally, the vertical positions at which the wing is simulated were set from the suspension ride heights of the reference vehicle, so that the setup could be defined with the same reference parameters used in full-vehicle work. Eqs. (6a) and (6b) below are written in terms of the suspension ride heights, as the rotation axis corresponds to the front axle of the reference vehicle. Configurations with a non-zero rake angle (i.e. the rotation of the chassis about the yy axis, positive when the rear of the vehicle sits higher than the front) were also simulated. Such a configuration is reproduced by rotating the wing about the point given by Eq. (6a) by the angle of Eq. (6b),

(x,y,z)=(−Front Axis Position,0,Front Ride Height),(6)(x, y, z) = (-\mathit{Front\ Axis\ Position}, 0, \mathit{Front\ Ride\ Height}), \tag*{(6)}
θ=arctan⁡(Front Ride Height−Rear Ride HeightWheelbase).(7)\theta= \arctan\left(\frac{\mathit{Front\ Ride\ Height} - \mathit{Rear\ Ride\ Height}}{\mathit{Wheelbase}}\right). \tag*{(7)}

Raked configurations were subsequently excluded from the final dataset. Since the wing is the only body present in the flow field, rotating it about the front axle is equivalent to changing its angle of attack, except for the rotation of the endplates. With the ride-height combinations of interest, Eq. (6b) yields rake angles below 1°, making that difference negligible. Configurations with a non-zero roll angle were considered as well, but were deemed outside the scope of this work. The four flat ride heights of Table 2 therefore span the relevant range of ground clearances without duplicating information already contained in the angle of attack parameter.

Airfoil Profile Selection and Generation

The coordinates of every profile used in this work were obtained from the UIUC Airfoil Coordinates Database [28], the Airfoil Tools database [27], or specific publications [29, 30]. The custom profile used on the front splitter of the reference racecar was part of the original profile pool but is not part of this dataset, as it is proprietary. No coordinate file is available for it, which also precluded its use in the interpolation described below.

Because in real applications the profile of a wing is often a customized version of a commonly available one, the profile pool was enlarged by interpolating between the named profiles using XFOIL’s [31] airfoil interpolation feature. Pairs of profiles were combined with an interpolation weight of 0.5, producing a profile that is a simple coordinate average of the two inputs. Figure 15 shows one such blend. This method produced the 13 blends between BE122-125 and each of the other 13 profiles, then used to generate wing geometries together with the two named profiles that are not part of the base set of profiles. The resulting profile identifiers are listed in Table 11. Profiles P=13P = 13–27 appear exclusively in the 20 geometries of the interpolated test set, which evaluates the models trained on profiles P=1P = 1–12 on unseen but “familiar” shapes. Several of the additional profiles are combined with more than one parameter set, so that the loss of prediction quality can be attributed to the profile shape separately from the remaining wing parameters.

Figure 15. Interpolation between BE122-125 and E214.

PPProfileTypePPProfileType
1BE122-125named15BE122-125 + E214interpolated
2E214named16BE122-125 + E423interpolated
3E423named17BE122-125 + FX 63-137interpolated
4FX 63-137named18BE122-125 + LA2573Ainterpolated
5LA2573Anamed19BE122-125 + LNV109Ainterpolated
6LNV109Anamed20BE122-125 + M06-13-128interpolated
7M06-13-128named21BE122-125 + MSHDinterpolated
8MSHDnamed22BE122-125 + NACA 2412interpolated
9NACA 2412named23BE122-125 + NACA 4412interpolated
10NACA 4412named24BE122-125 + NACA 6412interpolated
11NACA 6412named25BE122-125 + S1223RTLinterpolated
12S1223named26BE122-125 + S1223interpolated
13S1223RTLnamed27BE122-125 + S3021interpolated
14S3021named

Table 11. The 27 airfoil profile variants of the dataset. Profiles P=1P = 1-12 are used in the base set. Profiles P=13P = 13-27 are used only for the interpolated set. Interpolated variants are denoted A+BA + B, the coordinate average of profiles AA and BB.

Sample Generation Details

This appendix collects the details of the sampling procedure summarized in Section IV.B: the formal statement of the space-filling property of the Sobol sequence, the CFD sweeps from which the sensitivity functions were built, the feasibility constraints, and the step-by-step generation procedure.

The Sobol sequence [33] belongs to the family of quasi-random low-discrepancy sequences. Letting IS=[0,1]SI^{S} = [0,1]^{S} be the SS-dimensional unit hypercube and ff a real integrable function over ISI^{S}, the objective of such a sequence is to produce points xix_i satisfying

lim⁡n→∞1n∑i=1nf(xi)=∫ISf,(8)\lim_{n\to\infty} \frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^{n} f(x_i) = \int_{I^{S}} f, \tag*{(8)}

with the convergence being as fast as possible. Since the equality must hold for any integrable ff, the points have to fill ISI^{S} leaving as few holes as possible, which is precisely the property required of a set of geometries meant to train a surrogate model over the whole design space. Figure 16 compares a pseudorandom distribution with a Sobol sequence of the same size in two dimensions: the clusters and voids of the former are absent from the latter.

Figure 16. Comparison between a pseudorandom distribution and a Sobol sequence in two dimensions.

The sensitivity functions S(p)S(p) of Eq. (1) were built from univariate CFD sweeps about a baseline geometry with αc=θt=0∘\alpha_c = \theta_t = 0^\circ, cc=600c_c = 600 mm, ct=455c_t = 455 mm and Λ=0∘\Lambda= 0^\circ, using the solver setup of Section IV.C. The values at which each parameter was tested are listed in Table 12. They span the full range of each parameter. Cubic splines were fitted through the resulting Cl(p)C_l(p) and Cd(p)C_d(p) curves and differentiated analytically to obtain the two derivatives of Eq. (1).

ParameterTested valuesUnit
αc\alpha_c−10-10, −8-8, −6-6, −4-4, −2-2, 00, 22, 44, 55°
θt\theta_t−10-10, −8-8, −6-6, −4-4, −2-2, 00, 22, 44, 66, 88, 1010°
ccc_c550550, 575575, 600600, 625625, 650650, 675675, 700700mm
ctc_t350350, 400400, 455455, 500500, 550550, 600600, 650650, 700700mm
Λ\Lambda−8.5-8.5, −4-4, 00, 44, 88, 1212, 1616, 2020°

Table 12. Parameter values simulated to build the sensitivity functions of Eq. (1). Each parameter was swept individually, with all others held at their baseline value.

The geometric parameters do not act independently of one another: they combine into a single shape, which may be infeasible even when every individual parameter lies within its bounds. Two families of constraints, described in Sec. IV.B, were therefore imposed. Equation (8a) prevents flow separation due to excessive AoA values on the wing tips, Eq. (8b) bounds the forward and rearward extent of the centerline section, and Eq. (8c) additionally limits the tip chord. The symbols are those of Figs. 2c and 2b. Every candidate violating any of Eqs. (8) is discarded before the weighted selection.

−10∘<αc+θt<5∘,(9)-10^\circ< \alpha_c + \theta_t < 5^\circ, \tag*{(9)}
350 mm≤cc−stan⁡Λ≤700 mm,(10)350\ \mathrm{mm} \le c_c - s\tan\Lambda\le700\ \mathrm{mm}, \tag*{(10)}
ct−cc+stan⁡Λ≤700 mm,(11)c_t - c_c + s\tan\Lambda\le700\ \mathrm{mm}, \tag*{(11)}

Complete Sample Generation Procedure

The complete sample generation procedure, implemented as a single Python script, is given as Algorithm 1.

The rounding bases Δi\Delta_i are [αc θt cc ct Λ]=[0.5∘ 0.5∘ 5 mm 5 mm 1∘][\alpha_c\ \theta_t\ c_c\ c_t\ \Lambda] = [0.5^\circ\ 0.5^\circ\ 5\ \mathrm{mm}\ 5\ \mathrm{mm}\ 1^\circ]. Each range is enlarged by half its rounding base before rescaling so that the rounding does not deplete the two outermost bins relative to the interior ones. The 3N3N survivor threshold of the constraint-filtering loop keeps the following weighted selection meaningful. The sensitivity weight WjW_j is a product over the five sensitivity functions, so a candidate is rated informative only if it is informative in every dimension simultaneously. The coverage term djd_j is the Euclidean distance to the nearest already-selected sample and is therefore recomputed at every draw. Both terms are normalized by their maximum over the remaining candidates before being combined into the score

σj=wcdjmax⁡kdk+(1−wc)Wjmax⁡kWk,(12)\sigma_j = w_c \frac{d_j}{\max_k d_k} + (1-w_c)\frac{W_j}{\max_k W_k}, \tag*{(12)}

of which the maximum is selected at each iteration; the first sample is instead drawn at random with probability proportional to WjW_j, since no distance can be defined for an empty selection. The coverage weight was set to wc=0.5w_c = 0.5, giving the two criteria equal importance, to prevent the selection from collapsing onto the most sensitive corners of the design space. The selected samples are finally written to a .csv file, which is read by CATIA to drive the parametric model and produce the CAD geometries used for the CFD simulations.

The procedure yields the 174 geometries from the stratified split reported in Section IV.B, whose parameter distributions are those shown in Figure 3. The 20 geometries of the interpolated split, built on profiles P=13P = 13-2727, were generated with the same parameter sampling.

Algorithm 1: Sensitivity- and coverage-weighted sample generation

Input: parameter bounds (Table 2), sensitivity functions Si(p)S_i(p), rounding bases Δi\Delta_i, target sample count NN, coverage weight wcw_c

Output: NN selected parameter vectors with assigned profiles

M←M0M \leftarrow M_0;

repeat

generate a scrambled 5-D Sobol sequence of MM points and rescale each axis to the corresponding parameter range (enlarged by Δi/2\Delta_i/2);

round each coordinate to the nearest multiple of Δi\Delta_i; remove duplicates;

C←C \leftarrow candidates satisfying Eqs. (8);

if ∣C∣<3N\lvert C\rvert< 3N then

M←2MM \leftarrow2M

until ∣C∣≥3N\lvert C\rvert\ge3N;

draw p1∈Cp_1 \in C with probability ∝Wj=∏i=15Si(pi,j)\propto W_j = \prod_{i=1}^{5} S_i(p_i,j);

S←{p1}S \leftarrow\{p_1\}; C←C∖{p1}C \leftarrow C \setminus\{p_1\};

for k←2k \leftarrow2 to NN do

foreach pj∈Cp_j \in C do

Wj←∏i=15Si(pi,j)W_j \leftarrow\prod_{i=1}^{5} S_i(p_i,j);

dj←min⁡p∈S∥pj−p∥d_j \leftarrow\min_{p \in S} \lVert p_j-p\rVert;

σj←wc dj/max⁡kdk+(1−wc) Wj/max⁡kWk\sigma_j \leftarrow w_c\,d_j/\max_k d_k + (1-w_c)\,W_j/\max_k W_k; // Eq. (12)

j∗←arg⁡max⁡jσjj^* \leftarrow\arg\max_j \sigma_j;

S←S∪{pj∗}S \leftarrow S \cup\{p_{j^*}\}; C←C∖{pj∗}C \leftarrow C \setminus\{p_{j^*}\};

assign each p∈Sp \in S a profile via a separate scrambled 1-D Sobol sequence rescaled to [0.5,12.5][0.5, 12.5] and rounded to the nearest integer;

export SS (parameters + profile) to the CATIA-driving database;

Sensitivity Analysis on an In-Dataset Profile

The sensitivity functions used above were built from a sweep that used a proprietary internal wing profile, which is not part of the released profile pool of Appendix B and cannot be shared (see the excluded-data discussion of Section VI). To confirm that the resulting sensitivity functions are still representative of the profiles actually distributed with the dataset, the same univariate sweep, with the identical baseline and ride height, was repeated on profile 12 (S1223). Unlike the spline-based derivative of Section IV.B, this one-off validation estimates ∂Cl/∂p\partial C_l/\partial p and ∂Cd/∂p\partial C_d/\partial p directly at the sweep’s tested values with a non-uniform-grid, second-order-accurate three-point (central) finite difference.

Figure 17 compares the resulting S(p)S(p) for the two profiles across all five parameters. The Pearson correlation between the two curves ranges from 0.909 (θt\theta_t) to 0.997 (ctc_t) across the five parameters, and the relative L2L_2 difference between them ranges from 4% (αc\alpha_c) to 24% (ccc_c). Most importantly for the sampling procedure, the resulting importance ranking of the five parameters by mean S(p)S(p) (αc\alpha_c, θt\theta_t, Λ\Lambda, ccc_c, ctc_t, from most to least sensitive) is identical for both profiles, indicating that the sensitivity-weighted sampling of Section IV.B would have concentrated its samples in the same regions of the design space regardless of which profile the baseline sweep had used.

Figure 17. Sensitivity function S(p)S(p) of Eq. (1) for each continuous parameter, computed from the original internal profile sweep (red) and from an equivalent repeat sweep on profile 12 (S1223, green dashed), both via the central-difference estimate described above.

Interaction of Geometric Parameters

The sensitivity-weighted sampling strategy of Section IV.B relies on sensitivity functions S(p)S(p) (1) computed by varying one parameter at a time, which implicitly assumes that the influence of each geometric parameter on the aerodynamic coefficients is independent of the others, i.e., that the total change in ClC_l or CdC_d can be approximated by the linear superposition of the individual marginal effects. To evaluate this assumption, a post-hoc analysis was performed on the subset of the dataset at the 45 mm/45 mm ride height, isolating geometric dependencies from ground-effect variations.

A polynomial regression model with interaction terms was fitted to the standardized primary parameters of Table 2

(Profile PP, αc\alpha_c, θt\theta_t, ccc_c, ctc_t, Λ\Lambda, normalized to zero mean and unit variance). Letting x∈Rn\mathbf{x} \in\mathbb{R}^n denote this parameter vector and y\mathbf{y} the target coefficient (ClC_l or CdC_d), the response surface is

y^=β0+∑i=1nβixi+∑i=1n∑j>inβijxixj(13)\hat{y} = \beta_0 + \sum_{i=1}^{n} \beta_i x_i + \sum_{i=1}^{n} \sum_{j>i}^{n} \beta_{ij}x_i x_j \tag*{(13)}

where βi\beta_i is the linear effect of parameter ii and the interaction strength Iij=∣βij∣I_{ij} = \lvert\beta_{ij}\rvert quantifies how strongly the effect of parameter ii depends on parameter jj. A high IijI_{ij} indicates a violation of the independence assumption used during sampling. Figure 18 shows the results of this analysis.

Figure 18. Interaction strength matrices (∣βij∣|\beta_{ij}|) for ClC_l (left) and CdC_d (right) at the 45 mm ride height.

The two coefficients are dominated by the same pair but differ in overall magnitude. For ClC_l, the strongest coupling is between the tip twist θt\theta_t and the tip chord ctc_t (I≈0.095I \approx0.095). This is consistent with the local lift increment produced by twist scaling with the chord over which it acts. It suggests the independence assumption led to some undersampling where a large tip chord combines with extreme tip twist. For CdC_d, the same θt\theta_t-ctc_t pair remains strongest, but interaction strengths are roughly an order of magnitude smaller overall (maximum I≈0.007I \approx0.007), indicating that individual parameter contributions to drag are largely additive and that the univariate sensitivity functions used for sampling remain an accurate basis for this coefficient.

These results suggest that future iterations of the sampling strategy could augment S(p)S(p) with a term proportional to the cross-parameter interaction strengths IijI_{ij}, biasing sample selection toward regions where highly-interacting parameter pairs (e.g., θt\theta_t and ctc_t) are simultaneously near their bounds, in order to better capture the non-linear aerodynamic phenomena in those configurations.

Ride-Height Sweep and Choking Assessment

The efficiency of a downforce-generating wing increases as its distance from the ground decreases: the gap between the wing and the ground acts as a Venturi channel, accelerating the flow and further lowering the pressure on the suction side, so that downforce grows considerably faster than drag. This behavior has a limit [34]. Below a critical clearance, the pressure beneath the wing becomes so low that the flow can no longer recover to ambient conditions before the trailing edge and it separates. This causes the mass flow between the wing and the ground to become choked, and the wing suffers a sharp increase in drag together with a stark loss of downforce. Correia et al. [34] test this effect on a single-element inverted wing, showing that its downforce peaks at a height-to-chord ratio h/c≈0.09h/c \approx0.09 and falls off below it. This dataset’s lowest clearance corresponds to h/cc=0.145h/c_c = 0.145 for a centerline chord of 600 mm. Therefore, it had to be established that none of the simulated configurations fall into this nonlinear regime, which the RANS setup of Section IV.C would not resolve reliably, and which a surrogate model trained predominantly on well-behaved configurations could not be expected to predict.

The verification was carried out during the development of the CFD methodology, before the parametric model was frozen, and therefore uses a fixed development geometry rather than one of the sampled geometries of the dataset. That geometry was simulated at 11 flat ride heights between 30 mm and 100 mm, thus covering the four ride heights of Table 2. Each configuration was obtained by translating the wing rigidly in the vertical direction and regenerating the mesh, and was solved with the same solver, turbulence model, and freestream conditions as the dataset simulations. Only flat setups are considered, for the reasons given in Appendix A.

Figure 19 reports the resulting coefficient trends, against both the ride height, measured at the lower edge of the endplate, and the corresponding normalized ground clearance h/cch/c_c, defined with hh as the profile clearance. Both coefficients vary smoothly and monotonically over the entire range. This is the expected unchoked ground-effect behavior, and it confirms that the four ride heights of the dataset, and the whole interval between them, lie in the linear operating region. The absolute coefficient values of Figure 19 belong to the development geometry and are not directly comparable to those of the dataset samples.

Figure 19. Aerodynamic coefficients of the development geometry over the swept ride heights. The shaded band marks the interval covered by the dataset, whose four ride heights are highlighted.

Dataset Splitting Procedure

This appendix states the splitting procedure summarized in § 5.A. Two strategies were used: iterative stratification, which produced the stratified split, and drag-outlier allocation, which produced the drag-outlier split used to probe the edges of the aerodynamic envelope. Both operate on the 174 unique base-set geometries rather than on the 690 individual simulations, and both re-attach every simulated ride height of a geometry to whichever subset that geometry was assigned to. The target proportions are 80% training, 10% validation, and 10% test in both cases.

The stratifying problem is recast as a multi-label one and solved with the iterative stratification algorithm of Ref. [35], which allocates samples one label at a time, always serving the label that is currently scarcest in the subset that it furthest from its quota. The procedure is as follows:

  1. Label construction: The five continuous parameters of Table 2 are each discretized into 15 uniformly spaced bins, and the resulting bin indices are one-hot encoded together with the categorical profile parameter PP. Every geometry is thereby turned into a binary indicator vector over the union of all parameter bins and all profiles.

  1. First split: Iterative stratification is applied to the full set of geometries with a test fraction of 0.2, yielding the training set and a held-out remainder of 20%.

  1. Second split: The same algorithm is applied to the remainder with a test fraction of 0.5, dividing it into the validation and test sets.

  1. Ride-height re-attachment: Each geometry contributes its run identifiers, one per simulated ride height (Table 2), to the subset it was assigned to, and the three lists of run identifiers are written to a configuration file that the training pipelines read directly.

The drag-outlier split replaces steps 1–3 while keeping step 4 unchanged. Its purpose is to place the extremes of the drag distribution deliberately in the validation and test sets. Given nn geometries and validation and test fractions v=t=0.1v=t=0.1:

  1. CdC_{\mathrm{d}} Ranking: The geometries are ranked by their drag coefficient at the 45 mm ride height, and the n×(v+t)÷2n \times(v+t) \div2 most extreme of them, rounded down to an even number and taken half from each end of the ranking, are marked as outliers.

  1. Outlier Selection: The outliers are re-sorted by their absolute deviation from the median drag coefficient, most extreme first, and dealt alternately to the test and the validation set, with the test set receiving the most extreme geometry.

  1. Random Fill: The remaining geometries are randomly shuffled and used to fill the rest of the validation and test quotas, while whatever is left forms the training set.

Model Configurations

This appendix documents the configuration each of the six models was trained with. Tables 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, and 18 cover the architecture-specific choices that have no counterpart in the other models. As stated in § 5.B, the architecture-specific settings were determined by a combination of Optuna [38] search and empirical testing on the validation set of the stratified split, whereas the number of epochs and the learning-rate settings were kept at the values found in each model’s reference implementation. The released dataset contains the .yaml configuration files used for each model.

Architecture
Hidden dimension192 (all blocks)
Attention heads3
MLP hidden dimension768
Position embeddingsRotary
Geometry branch depth1 block
Supernode pooling20 000→2 00020\,000 \to2\,000 points (radius 0.25, normalized coordinates)
Physics trunk6 blocks (1 perceiver + 5 self-attention)
Surface domain decoder6 blocks
Cross-attention / volume decoderNone (volume branch disabled)
Attention anchors2 000 surface points

Table 13. AB-UPT configuration.

Architecture
Transformer blocks13
Width256
Attention heads4
MLP ratio2
Dropout0.05
Physics slices per block128
Ball-query radii[0.045, 0.25, 1.25, 6.5]\left[0.045,\,0.25,\,1.25,\,6.5\right]
Ball-query neighbors[4, 10, 25, 64]\left[4,\,10,\,25,\,64\right]
Local feature channel width64
Sampled points100 000 surface, 50 000 geometry

Table 14. GeoTransolver configuration.

Architecture
Token dimension128
Point tokensUp to 512 (farthest-point-sampling tokenizer, cluster size 16)
Context / target encoder, decoder6 transformer layers, 4 heads (each)
JEPA predictor head6 layers
Sampled points8 192 surface (geometry input, target encoder, query set)

Table 15. AeroJEPA configuration.

Architecture
Latent token grid64×32×3264 \times32 \times32
GNO radius0.033
AttentionCosine
Projection width256
Node sampling ratio0.7
Geometry embeddingStatistical local shape descriptor (encoder side only)
ViT processor10 layers, hidden size 256, 8 heads

Table 16. GAOT configuration.

Architecture
ModeSurface-only
Geometry grid64×32×3264 \times32 \times32, processed by a UNet (8 base filters)
Multiscale point-conv radii[0.01, 0.05, 0.1, 0.5, 1.0]
Multiscale point-conv neighbors[8, 16, 24, 30, 36]
Basis-function / aggregation networksWidth 256, Fourier features (20 / 10 modes)
Sampled points300 000 geometry, 16 384 supervised surface (7 neighbors/point)

Table 17. DoMINO configuration.

Architecture
Graph resolutions10 000, 20 000, 40 000 nodes
Node degree6
Partitions per geometry2
Node placementCurvature-driven (curvature weight 0.3)
Edge filtering120∘120^\circ normal threshold, 45∘45^\circ edge-angle threshold
Message-passing steps15
Hidden dimension256
ActivationGELU

Table 18. X-MeshGraphNet configuration.

AB-UPT Trained with Volumetric Targets

AB-UPT is the only architecture in the benchmark whose surface and volume branches are coupled by default with cross-attention and, a single domain model is not directly available in the reference code. It was therefore also trained against both the surface fields and the volumetric CpC_p and uu fields. The benchmark of § 5 does not use this capability. Every model there is trained on the surface fields alone, so that no architecture is supervised on target fields the others never see. This appendix reports the volume-trained variant separately, as additional information on what the extra supervision costs or buys on the surface task.

The two configurations differ only along the volume path. The volume-trained variant instantiates a volume domain decoder of six blocks alongside the surface one, replaces two of the five self-attention blocks of the physics trunk with cross-attention blocks so that the surface and volume branches exchange information, and evaluates attention against 10 000 volume anchor points in addition to the 2000 surface anchors. Every other setting is shared with the surface-only run of Appendix G. Both variants were trained on the stratified and on the drag-outlier split and evaluated on all three test sets under the identical protocol, so Table 19 compares training targets and nothing else.

Test setTraining targetsClC_l Err. [%, σ\sigma]CdC_d Err. [%, σ\sigma]CpC_p L2L_2 [%]∣ws∣\lvert\mathbf{w}_s \rvert L2L_2 [%]
StratifiedSurface only0.85, 0.890.89, 0.742.632.46
Surface + volume0.62, 0.641.04, 0.862.522.36
Drag-outlierSurface only2.82, 4.151.92, 1.964.183.76
Surface + volume4.54, 6.553.71, 2.725.264.39
InterpolatedSurface only1.56, 1.254.51, 3.585.003.85
Surface + volume1.86, 1.464.90, 3.935.333.78

Table 19. AB-UPT trained on the surface fields alone against the variant additionally trained on the volumetric targets, on all three test sets. Both variants are evaluated on the surface fields only.

The additional supervision costs accuracy on all dataset splits. This is a change one would expect: the volumetric term consumes part of a fixed model capacity and a fixed optimization budget on a task the surface metrics do not reward.

The surface accuracy reported for AB-UPT in Table 5 is therefore a property of the architecture rather than a byproduct of extra supervision that the other five models never receive. Consequently, restricting every model to the surface fields costs the comparison nothing and removes an asymmetry that would otherwise be impossible to interpret.

The volumetric fields themselves are not evaluated in this paper. The variant is characterized here purely by what it was trained on and by its surface accuracy. Quantifying volumetric prediction error on this dataset is left to future work.

Acknowledgments

The authors acknowledge BMW M Motorsport and BMW Group IT for providing computational resources and technical support. They acknowledge NVIDIA Corporation for technical support with their [39] software suite, and Siemens AG for providing access to STAR-CCM+licenses. A. Cenzato acknowledges support from RWTH Aachen University. AI assistance (an LLM-based coding agent) was used to help draft LaTeX formatting, generate the data-analysis notebooks and figures, and adapt prose from the authors’ prior internal reports into this manuscript. All technical content, figures, and claims were reviewed and verified by the authors against the underlying dataset and simulation results.

References

  1. [1]Pope, S. B., Turbulent Flows, Cambridge University Press, 2000.DOI
  2. [2]Reynolds, O., “On the dynamical theory of incompressible viscous fluids and the determination of the criterion,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series A: Containing Papers of a Mathematical or Physical Character, , No. 186, 1895, pp. 123–164. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.1895.0004.
  3. [3]Shih, T.-H., Liou, W. W., Shabbir, A., Yang, Z., and Zhu, J., “A new k-ε eddy viscosity model for high Reynolds number turbulent flows,” Computers & Fluids, Vol. 24, No. 3, 1995, pp. 227–238.DOI
  4. [4]Kovachki, N., Li, Z., Liu, B., Azizoddanesheli, K., Bhattacharya, K., Stuart, A., and Anandkumar, A., “Neural operator: learning maps between function spaces with applications to PDEs,” J. Mach. Learn. Res., Vol. 24, No. 1, 2023.
  5. [5]International Motor Sports Association and Automobile Club De L’Ouest, “LMDh Technical Regulations,” , 2025. URL https://www.imsa.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2025/04/02/LMDh-Technical-Regulations-2025.04.02-blackline.pdf.
  6. [6]Alkin, B., Bleeker, M., Kurle, R., Kronlachner, T., Sonnleitner, R., Dorfer, M., and Brandstetter, J., “AB-UPT: Scaling Neural CFD Surrogates for High-Fidelity Automotive Aerodynamics Simulations via Anchored-Branched Universal Physics Transformers,” Transactions on Machine Learning Research, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2502.09692
  7. [7]Ranade, R., Nabian, M. A., Tangsali, K., Kamenev, A., Henning, O., Cherukuri, R., and Choudhry, S., “DoMINO: A Decomposable Multi-scale Iterative Neural Operator for Modeling Large Scale Engineering Simulations,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.13350, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2501.13350
  8. [8]Nabian, M. A., Liu, C., Ranade, R., and Choudhry, S., “X-MeshGraphNet: Scalable Multi-Scale Graph Neural Networks for Physics Simulation,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2411.17164, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2411.17164
  9. [9]Giral, F., Vishwasrao, A., Ramo, A. A., Golestanian, M., Tonti, F., Lozano-Duran, A., Brunton, S. L., Hoyas, S., Gomez, H., Clainche, S. L., and Vinuesa, R., “AeroJEPA: Learning Semantic Latent Representations for Scalable 3D Aerodynamic Field Modeling,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2605.05586, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2605.05586
  10. [10]Adams, C., Ranade, R., Cherukuri, R., and Choudhry, S., “GeoTransolver: Learning Physics on Irregular Domains Using Multi-scale Geometry Aware Physics Attention Transformer,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2512.20399, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2512.20399
  11. [11]Wen, S., Kumbhat, A., Lingsch, L., Mousavi, S., Zhao, Y., Chandrashekar, P., and Mishra, S., “Geometry Aware Operator Transformer as an Efficient and Accurate Neural Surrogate for PDEs on Arbitrary Domains,” Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2505.18781
  12. [12]Umetani, N., and Bickel, B., “Learning Three-dimensional Flow for Interactive Aerodynamic Design,” ACM Transactions on Graphics, Vol. 37, No. 4, 2018, pp. 1–10.DOI
  13. [13]Chang, A. X., Funkhouser, T., Guibas, L., Hanrahan, P., Huang, Q., Li, Z., Savarese, S., Savva, M., Song, S., Su, H., Xiao, J., Yi, L., and Yu, F., “ShapeNet: An Information-Rich 3D Model Repository,” arXiv preprint arXiv:1512.03012, 2015.arxiv.org/abs/1512.03012
  14. [14]Ashton, N., Maddix, D. C., Gundry, S., and Shabestari, P. M., “AhmedML: High-Fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics Dataset for Incompressible, Low-Speed Bluff Body Aerodynamics,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2407.20801, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2407.20801
  15. [15]Ashton, N., Angel, A. S., Jordan B. and Ghate, Kenway, G. K. W., Wong, M. L., Kiris, C., Walle, A., Maddix, C. D., and Page, G., “WindsorML: High-Fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics Dataset For Automotive Aerodynamics,” Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2407.19320
  16. [16]Elrefaie, M., Dai, A., and Ahmed, F., “DrivAerNet: A Parametric Car Dataset for Data-Driven Aerodynamic Design and Prediction,” Journal of Mechanical Design, Vol. 147, No. 4, 2025, p. 041712.DOI
  17. [17]Elrefaie, M., Morar, F., Dai, A., and Ahmed, F., “DrivAerNet++: A Large-Scale Multimodal Car Dataset with Computational Fluid Dynamics Simulations and Deep Learning Benchmarks,” Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems (Datasets and Benchmarks Track), 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2406.09624
  18. [18]Ashton, N., Mockett, C., Fuchs, M., Fliessbach, L., Hetmann, H., Knacke, T., Schonwald, N., Skerdas, V., Fotiadis, G., Walle, A., Huppertz, B., and Maddix, D., “DrivAerML: High-Fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics Dataset for Road-Car External Aerodynamics,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2408.11969, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2408.11969
  19. [19]Qiu, J., Kuang, L., Wang, G., Xu, Y., Cui, L., Fu, S., Zhu, Y., and Zhang, R., “DrivAerStar: An Industrial-Grade CFD Dataset for Vehicle Aerodynamic Optimization,” Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems (Datasets and Benchmarks Track), 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2510.16857
  20. [20]Luminary Cloud, “SHIFT-SUV: High-Fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics Dataset for SUV External Aerodynamics,”, 2025. URL https://huggingface.co/datasets/luminary-shift/SUV.
  21. [21]Bonnet, F., Mazari, A. J., Cinnella, P., and Gallinari, P., “AirFRANS: High Fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics Dataset for Approximating Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes Solutions,” Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems (Datasets and Benchmarks Track), 2022.arxiv.org/abs/2212.07564
  22. [22]Yang, Y., Tang, W., Liu, M., Thuerey, N., Zhang, Y., and Chen, H., “SuperWing: a comprehensive transonic wing dataset for data-driven aerodynamic design,” Scientific Data, Vol. 13, No. 1, 2026, p. 1113. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-026-07769-0.
  23. [23]Luminary Cloud, “SHIFT-Wing: High-Fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics Dataset for Transonic Aerospace External Aerodynamics,”, 2025. URL https://huggingface.co/datasets/luminary-shift/Wing.
  24. [24]Paischer, F., Cotteler, L., Dreze, Y., Kurle, R., Rubini, D., Bleeker, M., Kronlachner, T., and Brandstetter, J., “Going with the Speed of Sound: Pushing Neural Surrogates into Transonic and Highly Turbulent Regimes,” NeurIPS 2025 Workshop on ML for Physical Sciences, Track on Datasets and Benchmarks, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2511.21474
  25. [25]Jung, J. H., Kim, M. J., Yoon, H. S., Hung, P. A., Chun, H. H., and Park, D. W., “Endplate effect on aerodynamic characteristics of three-dimensional wings in close free surface proximity,” International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, Vol. 4, No. 4, 2012, pp. 477–487.DOI
  26. [26]Park, K., and Lee, J., “Influence of endplate on aerodynamic characteristics of low-aspect-ratio wing in ground effect,” Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, Vol. 22, No. 12, 2008, pp. 2578–2589.DOI
  27. [27]Airfoil Tools, “Airfoil Tools: Airfoil Database,” Online airfoil database and analysis tool, 2026. URL http://airfoiltools.com/, accessed: 21 August 2026.
  28. [28]Selig, M. S., “UIUC Airfoil Coordinates Database,” Department of Aerospace Engineering, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2026. URL https://m-selig.ae.illinois.edu/ads/coord_database.html, accessed: 21 August 2026.
  29. [29]Sriram, P. S., Gopalarathnam, A., and Misenheimer, A., “High-Downforce Airfoil Design for Motorsports,” SAE Int. J. Mater. Manuf., Vol. 5, No. 2, 2012, pp. 478–489.DOI
  30. [30]Benzing, E., Ali/Wings: Their Design and Application to Racing Cars, Giorgio Nada Editore, Vimodrone, Italy, 2012.
  31. [31]Drela, M., XFOIL: An Analysis and Design System for Low Reynolds Number Airfoils, Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 1989, Lecture Notes in Engineering, Vol. 54, pp. 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-84010-4_1.
  32. [32]Katharopoulos, A., and Fleuret, F., “Not All Samples Are Created Equal: Deep Learning with Importance Sampling,” Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Machine Learning, Proceedings of Machine Learning Research, Vol. 80, PMLR, 2018, pp. 2525–2534.arxiv.org/abs/1803.00942
  33. [33]Sobol’, I. M., “On the distribution of points in a cube and the approximate evaluation of integrals,” Zhurnal Vychislitel’noi Matematiki i Matematicheskoi Fiziki, Vol. 7, No. 4, 1967, pp. 784–802.DOI
  34. [34]Correia, J., Roberts, L. S., Finnis, M. V., and Knowles, K., “Scale effects on a single-element inverted wing in ground effect,” The Aeronautical Journal, Vol. 118, No. 1205, 2014, pp. 797–809.DOI
  35. [35]Sechidis, K., Tsoumakas, G., and Vlahavas, I., “On the Stratification of Multi-label Data,” Machine Learning and Knowledge Discovery in Databases, 2011, pp. 145–158.
  36. [36]Pfaff, T., Fortunato, M., Sanchez-Gonzalez, A., and Battaglia, P. W., “Learning Mesh-Based Simulation with Graph Networks,” International Conference on Learning Representations, 2021.arxiv.org/abs/2010.03409
  37. [37]Wu, H., Luo, H., Wang, H., Wang, J., and Long, M., “Transolver: A Fast Transformer Solver for PDEs on General Geometries,” International Conference on Machine Learning, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2402.02366
  38. [38]Akiba, T., Sano, S., Yanase, T., Ohta, T., and Koyama, M., “Optuna: A Next-generation Hyperparameter Optimization Framework,” Proceedings of the 25th ACM SIGKDD International Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining, 2019, pp. 2623–2631. https://doi.org/10.1145/3292500.3330701.
  39. [39]NVIDIA, “NVIDIA PhysicsNeMo,” https://developer.nvidia.com/physicsnemo, 2025.

Paper details

vlnc:W_eee2s2sy
Version
v2 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 14

downloads · 2

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Computer Science

an LLM-based coding agent

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents