Dimension-seven spectator effects in charm-hadron lifetimes at NLO
Introduction
Inclusive widths of heavy hadrons are described by the heavy-quark expansion (HQE) [1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] , an expansion in inverse powers of the heavy-quark mass, reviewed in refs. [6 , 7 ] . At leading order the width of a heavy hadron is that of the free heavy quark, independent of the light degrees of freedom, so that all hadrons with the same single heavy quark would have nearly the same lifetime, as is the case for the bottom hadrons [8 ] . For the charmed hadrons the measured lifetimes differ by up to a factor of seven (Figure 1 ), from about 150 fs for the Ξ c 0 \Xi_c^0 Ξ c 0 to about 1 ps for the D + D^+ D + [8 ] . In the HQE these differences are attributed to the spectator contributions, C 6 ⋅ ⟨ Q ⟩ C_6 \cdot\langle Q\rangle C 6 ⋅ ⟨ Q ⟩ , with Q Q Q the four-quark operators of dimension six and C 6 C_6 C 6 their short-distance coefficients. They start at 1 / m c 3 1/m_c^3 1/ m c 3 , but they are enhanced by the two-body phase space, a factor of order 16 π 2 16\pi^2 16 π 2 relative to the three-body free-quark decay [9 ] , and destructive Pauli interference makes the D + D^+ D + long-lived [1 , 10 , 11 ] . The interference is in fact so large that the calculated D + D^+ D + width comes out negative [12 ] .
Figure 1. Measured lifetimes of the D D D mesons (orange) and of the singly charmed baryons (blue), and their inclusive electron branching fractions [8 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . Uncertainties are not shown.
For the Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 , by contrast, the HQE has proved predictive. At dimension six the strange quark produced in c → s c \to s c → s transitions interferes constructively with the valence strange quarks of the Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 , which was therefore expected to be the shortest-lived charmed baryon, τ ( Ξ c + ) > τ ( Λ c + ) > τ ( Ξ c 0 ) > τ ( Ω c 0 ) \tau(\Xi_c^+) > \tau(\Lambda_c^+) > \tau(\Xi_c^0) > \tau(\Omega_c^0) τ ( Ξ c + ) > τ ( Λ c + ) > τ ( Ξ c 0 ) > τ ( Ω c 0 ) [13 , 14 ] , and the fixed-target experiments WA89, E687 and FOCUS found central values between 55 and 86 fs [24 , 25 , 26 ] . In March 2018 Cheng showed that the 1 / m c 4 1/m_c^4 1/ m c 4 corrections to the spectator terms reduce this interference and could make the Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 live longer than the Λ c + \Lambda_c^+ Λ c + [27 , 28 ] . A few months later LHCb measured τ ( Ω c 0 ) = 268 ± 24 ± 10 ± 2 f s \tau(\Omega_c^0)=268\pm24\pm10\pm2\ \mathrm{fs} τ ( Ω c 0 ) = 268 ± 24 ± 10 ± 2 fs in semileptonic Ω b − \Omega_b^- Ω b − decays [22 ] , nearly four times the previous world average, a result confirmed with promptly produced Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 [21 ] , by Belle II [23 ] and in hadronic Ω b − \Omega_b^- Ω b − decays [29 ] . With the Ξ c 0 \Xi_c^0 Ξ c 0 lifetime also measured to be longer [19 , 21 , 29 ] , the hierarchy is now τ ( Ξ c + ) > τ ( Ω c 0 ) > τ ( Λ c + ) > τ ( Ξ c 0 ) \tau(\Xi_c^+)>\tau(\Omega_c^0)>\tau(\Lambda_c^+)>\tau(\Xi_c^0) τ ( Ξ c + ) > τ ( Ω c 0 ) > τ ( Λ c + ) > τ ( Ξ c 0 ) . Later HQE analyses also reproduce it [12 , 30 ] , and the framework has been extended to doubly charmed baryons [31 , 32 , 33 ] .
The two cases seem to tell very different stories. The D + D^+ D + suggests that the HQE fails for charm, the Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 that it has real predictive power. The subtlety lies at dimension seven. The dimension-seven four-quark operators P P P [34 , 35 ] contribute C 7 ⋅ ⟨ P ⟩ C_7\cdot\langle P\rangle C 7 ⋅ ⟨ P ⟩ , which in some channels is as large as C 6 ⋅ ⟨ Q ⟩ C_6\cdot\langle Q\rangle C 6 ⋅ ⟨ Q ⟩ , and, for both the D + D^+ D + and the Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 , of opposite sign. For the Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 this produces the observed hierarchy. For the D + D^+ D + it compensates more than a third of the Pauli interference but leaves a negative central value, − 0.07 p s − 1 -0.07\ \mathrm{ps}^{-1} − 0.07 ps − 1 [12 ] . The two terms are not known to the same accuracy. C 6 C_6 C 6 is known at NLO [36 , 37 , 38 , 39 , 40 ] , and at NNLO for the meson lifetime ratios [41 ] , whereas C 7 C_7 C 7 has been taken at LO in all analyses that include it. This mismatch is a plausible origin of the negative D + D^+ D + width, and leaves the LO explanation of the Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 success untested at NLO. It is therefore important to take C 7 C_7 C 7 to NLO.
In this paper we compute the connected current–current part of the dimension-seven spectator coefficients at NLO in QCD. § 2 summarizes the calculation and maps the coefficients onto bottom decays, and § 3 compares the coefficients with LO and combines them with hadronic inputs for the meson, baryon and semileptonic results. The dimension-seven Wilson coefficients are given in appendix B and in the ancillary Mathematica file charm_wilson_coefficients.m. The ancillary files also contain a notebook with examples of its use and the page charm_nlo_diagrams.html, which calculates the two-loop forward amplitudes of the full-QCD side and the one-loop operator insertions diagram by diagram, for massless quarks in strictly forward kinematics.1
Outline of the NLO calculation
For a current–current channel with CKM factor λ \lambda λ , use L = 1 − γ 5 L=1-\gamma_5 L = 1 − γ 5 and R = 1 + γ 5 R=1+\gamma_5 R = 1 + γ 5 to write
H e f f = G F λ 2 ( c 1 W 1 + c 2 W 2 ) , W 1 = ( q ˉ 1 a γ μ L c a ) ( q ˉ 2 b γ μ L q 3 b ) , W 2 = ( q ˉ 1 a γ μ L c b ) ( q ˉ 2 b γ μ L q 3 a ) . (1) \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{eff}}=\frac{G_F\lambda}{\sqrt{2}}(c_1W_1+c_2W_2),
\qquad
W_1=(\bar{q}_{1a}\gamma_\mu Lc_a)(\bar{q}_{2b}\gamma^\mu Lq_{3b}),
\qquad
W_2=(\bar{q}_{1a}\gamma_\mu Lc_b)(\bar{q}_{2b}\gamma^\mu Lq_{3a}). \tag*{(1)} H eff = 2 G F λ ( c 1 W 1 + c 2 W 2 ) , W 1 = ( q ˉ 1 a γ μ L c a ) ( q ˉ 2 b γ μ L q 3 b ) , W 2 = ( q ˉ 1 a γ μ L c b ) ( q ˉ 2 b γ μ L q 3 a ) . (1)
The width is the normalized forward matrix element of 2 Im i ∫ d 4 z T { H e f f † ( z ) H e f f ( 0 ) } 2\operatorname{Im}i\int d^4z\,\mathcal{T}\{\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{eff}}^\dagger(z)\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{eff}}(0)\} 2 Im i ∫ d 4 z T { H eff † ( z ) H eff ( 0 )} . With M = m c p o l e M=m_c^{\mathrm{pole}} M = m c pole , ⟨ O ⟩ H = ⟨ H ∣ O ∣ H ⟩ / ( 2 M H ) \langle O\rangle_H=\langle H|O|H\rangle/(2M_H) ⟨ O ⟩ H = ⟨ H ∣ O ∣ H ⟩ / ( 2 M H ) and H H H the charmed hadron, the spectator contribution to the width is
Γ s p e c ( H ) = ∑ λ , q G F 2 ∣ λ ∣ 2 M 2 6 π ∑ w = 22 , 12 , 11 ω w [ C 6 , w q ⟨ Q q ⟩ H + C 7 , w q ⟨ P q ⟩ H ] . (2) \Gamma_{\mathrm{spec}}(H)=\sum_{\lambda,q}\frac{G_F^2|\lambda|^2M^2}{6\pi}\sum_{w=22,12,11}\omega_w\left[C_{6,w}^q\langle Q^q\rangle_H+C_{7,w}^q\langle P^q\rangle_H\right]. \tag*{(2)} Γ spec ( H ) = λ , q ∑ 6 π G F 2 ∣ λ ∣ 2 M 2 w = 22 , 12 , 11 ∑ ω w [ C 6 , w q ⟨ Q q ⟩ H + C 7 , w q ⟨ P q ⟩ H ] . (2)
( ω 22 , ω 12 , ω 11 ) = ( c 1 2 , c 1 c 2 , c 2 2 ) , C n = C n ( 0 ) + a s C n ( 1 ) , a s = α s ( μ ) 4 π , l = log μ 2 M 2 . (\omega_{22},\omega_{12},\omega_{11})=(c_1^2,c_1c_2,c_2^2),
\qquad
C_n=C_n^{(0)}+a_sC_n^{(1)},
\qquad
a_s=\frac{\alpha_s(\mu)}{4\pi},
\qquad
l=\log\frac{\mu^2}{M^2}. ( ω 22 , ω 12 , ω 11 ) = ( c 1 2 , c 1 c 2 , c 2 2 ) , C n = C n ( 0 ) + a s C n ( 1 ) , a s = 4 π α s ( μ ) , l = log M 2 μ 2 .
Here λ = V c q 1 ∗ V q 2 q 3 \lambda=V_{cq_1}^*V_{q_2q_3} λ = V c q 1 ∗ V q 2 q 3 runs over the nonleptonic channels c → q 1 q 2 q ˉ 3 c\to q_1q_2\bar{q}_3 c → q 1 q 2 q ˉ 3 , namely c → s u d ˉ c\to su\bar{d} c → s u d ˉ , s u s ˉ su\bar{s} s u s ˉ , d u d ˉ du\bar{d} d u d ˉ and d u s ˉ du\bar{s} d u s ˉ , whose CKM factors are all different, and q q q is the light quark retained as an operator field. Retaining q 1 q_1 q 1 , q 2 q_2 q 2 or q 3 q_3 q 3 leaves the cut-mass pairs ( m 2 , m 3 ) (m_2,m_3) ( m 2 , m 3 ) , ( m 1 , m 3 ) (m_1,m_3) ( m 1 , m 3 ) or ( m 1 , m 2 ) (m_1,m_2) ( m 1 , m 2 ) , respectively. The mixed row contains both weak insertion orders. The retained-q 2 q_2 q 2 coefficients follow from those of q 1 q_1 q 1 by exchanging c 1 ↔ c 2 c_1\leftrightarrow c_2 c 1 ↔ c 2 and m q 1 ↔ m q 2 m_{q_1}\leftrightarrow m_{q_2} m q 1 ↔ m q 2 . The same coefficients apply to mesons and baryons. The coefficients C n C_n C n depend on the channel, the weak row w w w and the retained flavour q q q , and the operators on q q q . We suppress these labels where they are not needed. The semileptonic channels c → q ℓ + ν ℓ c\to q\ell^+\nu_\ell c → q ℓ + ν ℓ enter in the same way, with λ = V c q ∗ \lambda=V_{cq}^* λ = V c q ∗ , ω w → 1 \omega_w\to1 ω w → 1 . The cut-mass ratio z = ( m s / M ) 2 z=(m_s/M)^2 z = ( m s / M ) 2 is kept exact, while m u = m d = 0 m_u=m_d=0 m u = m d = 0 . The terms quadratic in the retained light-quark mass are dropped, however, so for q = s q=s q = s the z z z dependence of the coefficients is consistent at dimension seven but not complete.
The operator vectors in eq. (2) form the full-QCD basis, renormalized at scale μ \mu μ in the NDR–M S ‾ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} MS scheme with the finite subtraction described below and with m q = m ‾ q ( μ ) m_q=\overline{m}_q(\mu) m q = m q ( μ ) :
Q = ( Q , Q S , T , T S ) T , P = ( P 1 1 , … , P 5 1 , P 1 8 , … , P 5 8 ) T . (3) \mathbf{Q}=(Q,Q_S,T,T_S)^T,
\qquad
\mathbf{P}=(P_1^1,\ldots,P_5^1,P_1^8,\ldots,P_5^8)^T. \tag*{(3)} Q = ( Q , Q S , T , T S ) T , P = ( P 1 1 , … , P 5 1 , P 1 8 , … , P 5 8 ) T . (3)
With σ μ ν = i [ γ μ , γ ν ] / 2 \sigma^{\mu\nu}=i[\gamma^\mu,\gamma^\nu]/2 σ μν = i [ γ μ , γ ν ] /2 , the singlet operators are
Q q = ( c ˉ γ μ L q ) ( q ˉ γ μ L c ) , Q S q = ( c ˉ L q ) ( q ˉ R c ) , Q^q=(\bar{c}\gamma_\mu Lq)(\bar{q}\gamma^\mu Lc),
\qquad
Q_S^q=(\bar{c}Lq)(\bar{q}Rc), Q q = ( c ˉ γ μ L q ) ( q ˉ γ μ L c ) , Q S q = ( c ˉ L q ) ( q ˉ R c ) ,
P 1 q , 1 = 1 2 M 2 [ ( c ˉ D ‾ ρ γ μ L D ρ q ) ( q ˉ γ μ L c ) + h . c . ] , P_1^{q,1}=\frac{1}{2M^2}\left[(\bar{c}\overline{D}_\rho\gamma_\mu LD^\rho q)(\bar{q}\gamma^\mu Lc)+\mathrm{h.c.}\right], P 1 q , 1 = 2 M 2 1 [ ( c ˉ D ρ γ μ L D ρ q ) ( q ˉ γ μ L c ) + h.c. ] ,
P 2 q , 1 = − 1 M 2 [ ( c ˉ D ‾ ρ L D ρ q ) ( q ˉ R c ) + h . c . ] , P_2^{q,1}=-\frac{1}{M^2}\left[(\bar{c}\overline{D}_\rho LD^\rho q)(\bar{q}Rc)+\mathrm{h.c.}\right], P 2 q , 1 = − M 2 1 [ ( c ˉ D ρ L D ρ q ) ( q ˉ R c ) + h.c. ] ,
P 3 q , 1 = m q M [ ( c ˉ L q ) ( q ˉ L c ) + ( c ˉ R q ) ( q ˉ R c ) ] , P_3^{q,1}=\frac{m_q}{M}\left[(\bar{c}Lq)(\bar{q}Lc)+(\bar{c}Rq)(\bar{q}Rc)\right], P 3 q , 1 = M m q [ ( c ˉ L q ) ( q ˉ L c ) + ( c ˉ R q ) ( q ˉ R c ) ] ,
P 4 q , 1 = m q M [ ( c ˉ i L c j ) ( q ˉ j L q i ) + ( c ˉ i R c j ) ( q ˉ j R q i ) ] , P_4^{q,1}=\frac{m_q}{M}\left[(\bar{c}_iLc_j)(\bar{q}_jLq_i)+(\bar{c}_iRc_j)(\bar{q}_jRq_i)\right], P 4 q , 1 = M m q [ ( c ˉ i L c j ) ( q ˉ j L q i ) + ( c ˉ i R c j ) ( q ˉ j R q i ) ] ,
P 5 q , 1 = 1 M [ ( c ˉ D ‾ μ ) σ μ ν c + c ˉ σ μ ν D μ c ] ( q ˉ γ ν L q ) . (4) P_5^{q,1}=\frac{1}{M}\left[(\bar{c}\overline{D}_\mu)\sigma^{\mu\nu}c+\bar{c}\sigma^{\mu\nu}D_\mu c\right](\bar{q}\gamma_\nu Lq). \tag*{(4)} P 5 q , 1 = M 1 [ ( c ˉ D μ ) σ μν c + c ˉ σ μν D μ c ] ( q ˉ γ ν L q ) . (4)
The octet operators, with tr ( t A t B ) = δ A B / 2 \operatorname{tr}(t^{A}t^{B})=\delta^{AB}/2 tr ( t A t B ) = δ A B /2 , N c = 3 N_{c}=3 N c = 3 and C F = 4 / 3 C_{F}=4/3 C F = 4/3 , are
T q = ( c ˉ γ μ L t A q ) ( q ˉ γ μ L t A c ) , T S q = ( c ˉ L t A q ) ( q ˉ R t A c ) , P 1 q , 8 = 1 2 M 2 [ ( c ˉ D ← ρ γ μ L t A D ρ q ) ( q ˉ γ μ L t A c ) + h . c . ] , P 2 q , 8 = − 1 M 2 [ ( c ˉ D ← ρ L t A D ρ q ) ( q ˉ R t A c ) + h . c . ] , P 3 q , 8 = m q M [ ( c ˉ L t A q ) ( q ˉ L t A c ) + ( c ˉ R t A q ) ( q ˉ R t A c ) ] , P 4 q , 8 = m q M [ ( c ˉ i L c l ) ( q ˉ k L q j ) + ( c ˉ i R c l ) ( q ˉ k R q j ) ] t i j A t k l A , P 5 q , 8 = 1 M [ ( c ˉ D ← μ ) σ μ ν t A c + c ˉ σ μ ν t A D μ c ] ( q ˉ γ ν L t A q ) . (5) \begin{aligned}
T^{q}&=(\bar{c}\gamma_{\mu}L\,t^{A}q)(\bar{q}\gamma^{\mu}L\,t^{A}c),\qquad
T_{S}^{q}=(\bar{c}L\,t^{A}q)(\bar{q}R\,t^{A}c),\\
P_{1}^{q,8}&=\frac{1}{2M^{2}}\left[(\bar{c}\overleftarrow{D}_{\rho}\gamma_{\mu}L\,t^{A}D^{\rho}q)(\bar{q}\gamma^{\mu}L\,t^{A}c)+\mathrm{h.c.}\right],\\
P_{2}^{q,8}&=-\frac{1}{M^{2}}\left[(\bar{c}\overleftarrow{D}_{\rho}L\,t^{A}D^{\rho}q)(\bar{q}R\,t^{A}c)+\mathrm{h.c.}\right],\\
P_{3}^{q,8}&=\frac{m_{q}}{M}\left[(\bar{c}L\,t^{A}q)(\bar{q}L\,t^{A}c)+(\bar{c}R\,t^{A}q)(\bar{q}R\,t^{A}c)\right],\\
P_{4}^{q,8}&=\frac{m_{q}}{M}\left[(\bar{c}_{i}L c_{l})(\bar{q}_{k}L q_{j})+(\bar{c}_{i}R c_{l})(\bar{q}_{k}R q_{j})\right]t^{A}_{ij}t^{A}_{kl},\\
P_{5}^{q,8}&=\frac{1}{M}\left[(\bar{c}\overleftarrow{D}_{\mu})\sigma^{\mu\nu}t^{A}c+\bar{c}\sigma^{\mu\nu}t^{A}D_{\mu}c\right](\bar{q}\gamma_{\nu}L\,t^{A}q). \tag*{(5)}
\end{aligned} T q P 1 q , 8 P 2 q , 8 P 3 q , 8 P 4 q , 8 P 5 q , 8 = ( c ˉ γ μ L t A q ) ( q ˉ γ μ L t A c ) , T S q = ( c ˉ L t A q ) ( q ˉ R t A c ) , = 2 M 2 1 [ ( c ˉ D ρ γ μ L t A D ρ q ) ( q ˉ γ μ L t A c ) + h.c. ] , = − M 2 1 [ ( c ˉ D ρ L t A D ρ q ) ( q ˉ R t A c ) + h.c. ] , = M m q [ ( c ˉ L t A q ) ( q ˉ L t A c ) + ( c ˉ R t A q ) ( q ˉ R t A c ) ] , = M m q [ ( c ˉ i L c l ) ( q ˉ k L q j ) + ( c ˉ i R c l ) ( q ˉ k R q j ) ] t ij A t k l A , = M 1 [ ( c ˉ D μ ) σ μν t A c + c ˉ σ μν t A D μ c ] ( q ˉ γ ν L t A q ) . (5)
Only P 1 , 2 , 3 P_{1,2,3} P 1 , 2 , 3 have nonzero LO coefficients. At LO the loop of the two cut quarks (figure 2a) gives only g α β K 2 g^{\alpha\beta}K^{2} g α β K 2 and K α K β K^{\alpha}K^{\beta} K α K β , with K K K the sum of the heavy- and light-quark momenta. With the equations of motion (EOM), c ˉ K̸ L q → M c ˉ L q − m q c ˉ R q \bar{c}\not{K}Lq\to M\bar{c}Lq-m_{q}\bar{c}Rq c ˉ K L q → M c ˉ L q − m q c ˉ R q , these give only the structures of Q Q Q , Q S Q_{S} Q S and P 1 , 2 , 3 P_{1,2,3} P 1 , 2 , 3 . Hence P 4 P_{4} P 4 and P 5 P_{5} P 5 are absent at LO. With the factors of 1 / M 1/M 1/ M , all P i P_{i} P i have mass dimension six, like Q Q Q .2
The NLO matching compares two-loop forward amplitudes with one-loop insertions of the Born sources, the operator vertices of the d d d -dimensional LO amplitude. In d d d dimensions the full-theory amplitude is matched onto
A d = C ⟨ O ⟩ + C E ⟨ E ⟩ , (6) \mathcal{A}_{d}=\mathbf{C}\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle+\mathbf{C}_{E}\langle\mathbf{E}\rangle, \tag*{(6)} A d = C ⟨ O ⟩ + C E ⟨ E ⟩ , (6)
where A d \mathcal{A}_{d} A d is the forward amplitude of 2 Im i ∫ d 4 z T { H e f f † ( z ) H e f f ( 0 ) } 2\operatorname{Im}i\int d^{4}z\,T\{\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\dagger}(z)\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{eff}}(0)\} 2 Im i ∫ d 4 z T { H eff † ( z ) H eff ( 0 )} between on-shell heavy- and light-quark states in d = 4 − 2 ϵ d=4-2\epsilon d = 4 − 2 ϵ dimensions. On the right-hand side, O = ( Q , P ) \mathbf{O}=(Q,P) O = ( Q , P ) are the physical operators of eq. (3) with coefficients C = ( C 6 , C 7 ) \mathbf{C}=(C_{6},C_{7}) C = ( C 6 , C 7 ) , and ⟨ ⟩ \langle\rangle ⟨ ⟩ are their matrix elements between the same quark states for the matching. The evanescent operators E \mathbf{E} E , with coefficients C E \mathbf{C}_{E} C E , collect the Dirac structures of A d \mathcal{A}_{d} A d that do not reduce to O \mathbf{O} O in d d d dimensions but vanish at d = 4 d=4 d = 4 at LO. We expand each term in a s a_{s} a s , A d = A d ( 0 ) + a s A d ( 1 ) \mathcal{A}_{d}=\mathcal{A}_{d}^{(0)}+a_{s}\mathcal{A}_{d}^{(1)} A d = A d ( 0 ) + a s A d ( 1 ) , C = C ( 0 ) + a s C ( 1 ) \mathbf{C}=\mathbf{C}^{(0)}+a_{s}\mathbf{C}^{(1)} C = C ( 0 ) + a s C ( 1 ) and ⟨ O ⟩ = ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + a s ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) \langle\mathbf{O}\rangle=\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(0)}+a_{s}\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(1)} ⟨ O ⟩ = ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + a s ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) , and likewise C E \mathbf{C}_{E} C E and ⟨ E ⟩ \langle\mathbf{E}\rangle ⟨ E ⟩ . At O ( a s 0 ) O(a_{s}^{0}) O ( a s 0 ) eq. (6) gives the Born amplitude A d ( 0 ) = C ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) \mathcal{A}_{d}^{(0)}=\mathbf{C}^{(0)}\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(0)}+\mathbf{C}_{E}^{(0)}\langle\mathbf{E}\rangle^{(0)} A d ( 0 ) = C ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) , and at O ( a s ) O(a_{s}) O ( a s )
A d ( 1 ) = C ( 1 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + C ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) + C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) + C E ( 1 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) . (7) \mathcal{A}_{d}^{(1)}=\mathbf{C}^{(1)}\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(0)}+\mathbf{C}^{(0)}\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(1)}+\mathbf{C}_{E}^{(0)}\langle\mathbf{E}\rangle^{(1)}+\mathbf{C}_{E}^{(1)}\langle\mathbf{E}\rangle^{(0)}. \tag*{(7)} A d ( 1 ) = C ( 1 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + C ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) + C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) + C E ( 1 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) . (7)
Figure 2 shows representative full-theory graphs, with gluons connecting initial, final and intermediate fermion lines, and figure 3 the local source insertions. Covariant derivatives at dimension seven generate an additional source-to-leg gluon contact (figure 3b), absent for the nondifferentiated dimension-six sources.
Figure 2. Representative uncut forward amplitudes: (a) the LO amplitude and (b,c,d,e) two-loop amplitudes. Fermion flavours are left unspecified. Squares denote effective weak vertices and red dots denote gluon vertices. Other attachments and self-energies are not shown.
The full-theory side is the discontinuity of the forward amplitude between on-shell heavy- and light-quark states, figure 2. At LO, panel (a), it is the cut through the two intermediate quarks. At NLO the gluon is virtual or real depending on where it is attached. In panel (b) it connects the two initial lines at one weak vertex and is a virtual correction to that vertex. In panel (c) it connects an initial and a final line and spans both weak vertices, so a cut through the intermediate quarks also crosses the gluon. This three-particle cut is real-gluon emission. When the gluon is attached to the light quark, a cut can instead cross a light-quark propagator with the gluon uncut. Appendix § 6 .§ 4 works out such a graph. In panel (d) it connects an initial line with an intermediate quark and has both cuts. The two-particle cut is a virtual vertex correction, and the three-particle cut is the interference of gluon emission from the two lines. In panel (e) it connects the two intermediate quarks inside the quark loop. Its two-particle cuts are virtual exchanges between the two quarks, and its three-particle cut is real emission from them. Mirror graphs and self-energies complete the set. Each graph is Taylor-expanded about vanishing retained light-quark momentum and mass m q m_q m q . The constant term gives dimension six and the terms linear in either give dimension seven. Since P 5 P_5 P 5 vanishes in strictly forward kinematics, a small momentum transfer between the external legs is kept to first order and set to zero only after projection. Real and virtual full-theory cuts and local effective-theory insertions are expanded to the same soft order. We use an anticommuting γ 5 \gamma_5 γ 5 on open chains and M S ‾ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} MS pole subtraction. The weak and dimension-six prescriptions are those of refs. [37 , 42 ] .
The one-loop matrix elements ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) \langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(1)} ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) include the M S ‾ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} MS field factors of the external quarks and the counterterm of the retained mass. With both UV and IR divergences regulated dimensionally, they are
⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) = ( J + F ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) − 1 2 ϵ U V [ γ ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + γ E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) ] + 1 ϵ I R [ ( J I R + ϵ J I R ′ ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + J I R E ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) ] + O ( ϵ ) . (8) \begin{aligned}
\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(1)}={}&(\mathbf{J}+\mathbf{F})\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(0)}
-\frac{1}{2\epsilon_{\mathrm{UV}}}\left[\gamma^{(0)}\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(0)}+\gamma_E^{(0)}\langle\mathbf{E}\rangle^{(0)}\right]\\
&+\frac{1}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}\left[(\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{IR}}+\epsilon\mathbf{J}'_{\mathrm{IR}})\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle^{(0)}+\mathbf{J}_{\mathrm{IR}}^E\langle\mathbf{E}\rangle^{(0)}\right]+O(\epsilon). \tag*{(8)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) = ( J + F ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) − 2 ϵ UV 1 [ γ ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + γ E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) ] + ϵ IR 1 [ ( J IR + ϵ J IR ′ ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 0 ) + J IR E ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) ] + O ( ϵ ) . (8)
Here γ ( 0 ) \gamma^{(0)} γ ( 0 ) is the one-loop anomalous-dimension matrix, d ⟨ O ⟩ / d log μ = − a s γ ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ + O ( a s 2 ) d\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle/d\log\mu=-a_s\gamma^{(0)}\langle\mathbf{O}\rangle+O(a_s^2) d ⟨ O ⟩ / d log μ = − a s γ ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ + O ( a s 2 ) [42 , 43 ] . The matrix γ E ( 0 ) \gamma_E^{(0)} γ E ( 0 ) is its mixing into E \mathbf{E} E , and F \mathbf{F} F is a finite subtraction. The
trees in the pole terms are four-dimensional, so the O ( ε ) O(\varepsilon) O ( ε ) parts that multiply the UV poles are finite and belong to J . The M S ‾ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} MS counterterms, including the evanescent ones, remove the 1 / ε U V 1/\varepsilon_{\mathrm{UV}} 1/ ε UV terms. The IR term is the IR pole of the soft region of the graphs, in which the gluon momentum is small compared with M M M , with the O ( ε ) O(\varepsilon) O ( ε ) part of its residue kept. Its terms with evanescent trees appear identically in the full amplitude below and do not enter the matching. In blocks, the finite part is
\begin{bmatrix}
\langle Q\rangle_{\mathrm{fin}}^{(1)}\\
\langle P\rangle_{\mathrm{fin}}^{(1)}
\end{bmatrix}
=
\begin{bmatrix}
J_{66} & J_{67}\\
J_{76} & J_{77}
\end{bmatrix}
\begin{bmatrix}
\langle Q\rangle^{(0)}\\
\langle P\rangle^{(0)}
\end{bmatrix}
=
J\langle O\rangle^{(0)}, \tag*{(9)}\end{bmatrix}
where ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) = [ ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) , ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) , ⟨ T ⟩ ( 0 ) , ⟨ T S ⟩ ( 0 ) ] T \langle Q\rangle^{(0)}=[\langle Q\rangle^{(0)},\langle Q_S\rangle^{(0)},\langle T\rangle^{(0)},\langle T_S\rangle^{(0)}]^T ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) = [⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) , ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) , ⟨ T ⟩ ( 0 ) , ⟨ T S ⟩ ( 0 ) ] T and ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) \langle P\rangle^{(0)} ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) lists ⟨ P 1 q ⟩ ( 0 ) \langle P_1^q\rangle^{(0)} ⟨ P 1 q ⟩ ( 0 ) and then ⟨ P i q ⟩ ( 0 ) \langle P_i^q\rangle^{(0)} ⟨ P i q ⟩ ( 0 ) , i = 1 , … , 5 i=1,\ldots,5 i = 1 , … , 5 , so J is a 14 × 14 14\times14 14 × 14 matrix, with rows for the inserted operators and columns for the trees. The subtraction F has a single nonzero block, F 76 _{76} 76 , fixed by J 76 = 0 _{76}=0 76 = 0 , which sets to zero the finite mixing of the dimension-seven operators into the dimension-six ones. This mixing would violate the power counting [44 ] . The 76 block has no IR term, so its finite part depends on μ \mu μ only through the UV pole, and we set d F 76 / d log μ = − γ 76 ( 0 ) dF_{76}/d\log\mu=-\gamma_{76}^{(0)} d F 76 / d log μ = − γ 76 ( 0 ) , so that J 76 _{76} 76 remains zero at every μ \mu μ .
On the full-theory side, A n ( 1 ) \mathcal{A}_n^{(1)} A n ( 1 ) is the renormalized two-loop forward amplitude in Feynman gauge, including the weak counterterm, the field and mass counterterms of the cut quarks and the M S ‾ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} MS field factors Z c Z q Z_cZ_q Z c Z q of the external heavy and retained quarks. Here A 6 ( 1 ) \mathcal{A}_6^{(1)} A 6 ( 1 ) and A 7 ( 1 ) \mathcal{A}_7^{(1)} A 7 ( 1 ) are the zeroth-order and first-order terms of the soft expansion. For the outgoing light quark q q q the mass is written in terms of the same retained mass m q = m ‾ q ( μ ) m_q=\overline{m}_q(\mu) m q = m q ( μ ) as in P 3 P_3 P 3 and P 4 P_4 P 4 . After the real–virtual cancellation it has no UV pole and takes the form
A n ( 1 ) = 1 ε I R ( A n , I R ( 1 ) + ε A n , I R ( 1 ) ′ ) + A n , f i n ( 1 ) + O ( ε ) . (10) \mathcal{A}_n^{(1)}=\frac{1}{\varepsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}\left(\mathcal{A}_{n,\mathrm{IR}}^{(1)}+\varepsilon\mathcal{A}_{n,\mathrm{IR}}^{(1)\prime}\right)+\mathcal{A}_{n,\mathrm{fin}}^{(1)}+O(\varepsilon). \tag*{(10)} A n ( 1 ) = ε IR 1 ( A n , IR ( 1 ) + ε A n , IR ( 1 ) ′ ) + A n , fin ( 1 ) + O ( ε ) . (10)
The retained light-quark mass is kept to first order, so its one-loop self-energy is scaleless and, in this expansion, m q p o l e = m ‾ q ( μ ) ( 1 − 3 C F a s / ϵ I R ) m_q^{\mathrm{pole}}=\overline{m}_q(\mu)(1-3C_Fa_s/\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}) m q pole = m q ( μ ) ( 1 − 3 C F a s / ϵ IR ) . Writing m q m_q m q in A 4 ( 0 ) \mathcal{A}_4^{(0)} A 4 ( 0 ) in this way adds to A 7 ( 1 ) \mathcal{A}_7^{(1)} A 7 ( 1 ) the purely IR term − ( 3 C F / ϵ I R ) C P 3 ( 0 ) ⟨ P 3 ⟩ ( 0 ) -(3C_F/\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}})C_{P_3}^{(0)}\langle P_3\rangle^{(0)} − ( 3 C F / ϵ IR ) C P 3 ( 0 ) ⟨ P 3 ⟩ ( 0 ) . We have checked that, with this term included, A n , I R ( 1 ) \mathcal{A}_{n,\mathrm{IR}}^{(1)} A n , IR ( 1 ) and A n , I R ( 1 ) ′ \mathcal{A}_{n,\mathrm{IR}}^{(1)\prime} A n , IR ( 1 ) ′ are cancelled exactly by the corresponding IR terms of C ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) + C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) C^{(0)}\langle O\rangle^{(1)}+C_E^{(0)}\langle E\rangle^{(1)} C ( 0 ) ⟨ O ⟩ ( 1 ) + C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) .
The evanescent operators enter the EFT side in two roles. As inputs they are inserted with the Born coefficients C E ( 0 ) C_E^{(0)} C E ( 0 ) , and the UV poles of their one-loop insertions, C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) C_E^{(0)}\langle E\rangle^{(1)} C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) , leave finite terms. On the on-shell states used here these terms are local and reduce to physical operators [45 ] . We therefore insert E ^ = E + a s e O \widehat{E}=E+a_s eO E = E + a s e O in place of E E E , with the finite matrix e e e chosen such that the non-IR finite part of the renormalized C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ^ ⟩ ( 1 ) C_E^{(0)}\langle\widehat{E}\rangle^{(1)} C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) vanishes for d → 4 d\to4 d → 4 . With dimensional IR regularization, C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ^ ⟩ ( 1 ) C_E^{(0)}\langle\widehat{E}\rangle^{(1)} C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) then contains only ϵ / ϵ I R \epsilon/\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}} ϵ / ϵ IR terms, each an O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) part of the Born amplitude times an IR pole, so it enters only the IR terms above and C E C_E C E does not enter the matching. In practice this amounts to dropping the non-IR finite part of C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) C_E^{(0)}\langle E\rangle^{(1)} C E ( 0 ) ⟨ E ⟩ ( 1 ) in the matching.
As outputs, the evanescent operators appear as the trees ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) \langle E\rangle^{(0)} ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) of eq. (8) , produced by the insertions of the physical operators. These trees are O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) , but they multiply the UV pole, so their O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) definition is part of the scheme, and NDR–MS alone does not fix J \mathbf{J} J uniquely [45 ] . The replacement
E ⟶ E + ϵ d O , (11) E\longrightarrow E+\epsilon\,\mathbf{d}O, \tag*{(11)} E ⟶ E + ϵ d O , (11)
with a constant matrix d \mathbf{d} d , still gives ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) = 0 \langle E\rangle^{(0)}=0 ⟨ E ⟩ ( 0 ) = 0 at d = 4 d=4 d = 4 , but the UV pole of eq. (8) multiplies the O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) term and shifts J \mathbf{J} J by 1 2 γ E ( 0 ) d \frac{1}{2}\gamma_E^{(0)}\mathbf{d} 2 1 γ E ( 0 ) d . In d d d dimensions an operator and its Fierz rearrangement are different operators, and their difference is evanescent. For each of the ten inputs P i P_i P i , i = 1 , … , 5 i=1,\ldots,5 i = 1 , … , 5 , in both colours, we therefore use two representatives, the literal operator P i P_i P i and its literal Fierz form F [ P i ] \mathcal{F}[P_i] F [ P i ] . The two have the same physical UV pole, since F [ P i ] = P i \mathcal{F}[P_i]=P_i F [ P i ] = P i in four dimensions. We write E ( Z ) E(Z) E ( Z ) for the evanescent part of the UV pole of the one-loop insertion of Z = P i Z=P_i Z = P i or F [ P i ] \mathcal{F}[P_i] F [ P i ] , and d Z d_Z d Z for its freedom under eq. (11) , E ( Z ) ⟶ E ( Z ) + ϵ d Z O Z E(Z)\longrightarrow E(Z)+\epsilon\,d_ZO_Z E ( Z ) ⟶ E ( Z ) + ϵ d Z O Z . We fix the difference d P i − d F [ P i ] d_{P_i}-d_{\mathcal{F}[P_i]} d P i − d F [ P i ] by Fierz symmetry and the common part by a rule for the d d d -dimensional Dirac algebra, an ordered map Π \Pi Π that writes a d d d -dimensional Dirac structure as four-dimensional ones with coefficients through O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) , the remainder being evanescent. We use it for every d d d -dimensional Dirac structure that multiplies a pole, UV or IR, on both sides of the matching. All open-index gamma matrices are first moved to the right of a contracted core using exact Clifford algebra. The momentum-free core is then reduced by the Greek rules, with the right tails treated as part of the spinors and restored afterwards. Only then are momenta, spinors and the external EOM evaluated. Since the Greek projection does not commute with the EOM reduction, this order is part of the definition. Explicitly, we demand
⟨ P i − F [ P i ] ⟩ f i n ( 1 ) = 0 , (12) \left\langle P_i-\mathcal{F}[P_i]\right\rangle_{\mathrm{fin}}^{(1)}=0, \tag*{(12)} ⟨ P i − F [ P i ] ⟩ fin ( 1 ) = 0 , (12)
1 2 [ Π ( E i ) + ( Π ( E i † ) ) † ] = O ( ϵ 2 ) , E i = ⟨ E ( P i ) ⟩ ( 0 ) + ⟨ E ( F [ P i ] ) ⟩ ( 0 ) . (13) \frac{1}{2}\left[\Pi(\mathcal{E}_i)+\left(\Pi(\mathcal{E}_i^\dagger)\right)^\dagger\right]=O(\epsilon^2),\qquad\mathcal{E}_i=\left\langle E(P_i)\right\rangle^{(0)}+\left\langle E(\mathcal{F}[P_i])\right\rangle^{(0)}. \tag*{(13)} 2 1 [ Π ( E i ) + ( Π ( E i † ) ) † ] = O ( ϵ 2 ) , E i = ⟨ E ( P i ) ⟩ ( 0 ) + ⟨ E ( F [ P i ]) ⟩ ( 0 ) . (13)
A common shift, d P i = d F [ P i ] d_{P_i}=d_{\mathcal{F}[P_i]} d P i = d F [ P i ] , cancels in eq. (12) but moves the finite insertions of both representatives equally. The second condition fixes it by setting to zero the O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) physical image of E i \mathcal{E}_i E i . The average is needed because Π \Pi Π alone is not Hermitian, eq. (A.7). The Greek rules and the explicit insertions are given in appendices § 6 .§ 1 and A.3. The dimension-six inputs follow the same convention, reproducing the standard NDR finite terms of J 66 \mathbf{J}_{66} J 66 .
With J \mathbf{J} J fixed in this way and the IR terms removed from both sides, the remaining finite parts, denoted by the subscript fin, give the matching equations
C 6 ( 1 ) ⋅ ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) = A 6 , f i n ( 1 ) − C 6 ( 0 ) ⋅ J 66 ⋅ ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) , \mathbf{C}_{6}^{(1)} \cdot\langle Q\rangle^{(0)} = \mathbf{A}_{6,\mathrm{fin}}^{(1)} - \mathbf{C}_{6}^{(0)} \cdot\mathbf{J}_{66} \cdot\langle Q\rangle^{(0)}, C 6 ( 1 ) ⋅ ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) = A 6 , fin ( 1 ) − C 6 ( 0 ) ⋅ J 66 ⋅ ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) ,
C 7 ( 1 ) ⋅ ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) = A 7 , f i n ( 1 ) − ( C 6 ( 0 ) ⋅ J 67 ⋅ ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) + C 7 ( 0 ) ⋅ J 77 ⋅ ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) ) . (14) \mathbf{C}_{7}^{(1)} \cdot\langle P\rangle^{(0)} = \mathbf{A}_{7,\mathrm{fin}}^{(1)} - \left(\mathbf{C}_{6}^{(0)} \cdot\mathbf{J}_{67} \cdot\langle P\rangle^{(0)} + \mathbf{C}_{7}^{(0)} \cdot\mathbf{J}_{77} \cdot\langle P\rangle^{(0)}\right). \tag*{(14)} C 7 ( 1 ) ⋅ ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) = A 7 , fin ( 1 ) − ( C 6 ( 0 ) ⋅ J 67 ⋅ ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) + C 7 ( 0 ) ⋅ J 77 ⋅ ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) ) . (14)
Eq. (14) fixes the NLO coefficients C 6 ( 1 ) \mathbf{C}_{6}^{(1)} C 6 ( 1 ) and C 7 ( 1 ) \mathbf{C}_{7}^{(1)} C 7 ( 1 ) . Its first line is the usual dimension-six matching, with J 66 \mathbf{J}_{66} J 66 in the standard NDR scheme. Since J 76 = 0 \mathbf{J}_{76}=0 J 76 = 0 , no dimension-seven input enters it. In the second line the dimension-six Born coefficients enter through J 67 \mathbf{J}_{67} J 67 , which is finite and has no UV pole. The connected dimension-six coefficients from the same calculation agree with refs. [37 , 38 ] . We have checked that regulating the IR divergences with a gluon mass instead gives the same C ( 1 ) \mathbf{C}^{(1)} C ( 1 ) .
We compute the connected current–current contractions between on-shell quark states at first soft order, Figure 2 and Figure 3 a, Figure 3 b. The penguin-like contributions, in which a quark pair closes into a loop that emits a gluon, are omitted in charm. First, the eye contractions of the operators P i q P_i^q P i q , Figure 3 c, Figure 3 d, are matrix elements of the dimension-seven Darwin-type two-quark operators. Second, in the eye contractions at the weak vertex, Figure 4 , the s s ˉ s\bar{s} s s ˉ and d ˉ d \bar{d}d d ˉ d loops cancel by the GIM mechanism up to terms proportional to V c b ∗ V u b V_{cb}^{*}V_{ub} V c b ∗ V u b or suppressed by powers of z z z . Third, the penguin operators of H e f f \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{eff}} H eff come with V c b ∗ V u b V_{cb}^{*}V_{ub} V c b ∗ V u b . All three have a different flavour structure, with a closed quark loop or a sum over light flavours, and are matched by operators of the same structure. The connected contractions thus form a closed set, whose IR poles cancel on their own.
Figure 3. (a, b) One-loop insertions of the Born sources (circles): (a) gluon exchange between quark legs, (b) gluon attached to the covariant-derivative source, new at dimension seven. (c, d) Eye contractions of P i q P_i^q P i q , not calculated here. They belong to the dimension-seven two-quark operators of Darwin type. Thick lines denote the heavy quark.
Figure 4. Eye contraction at a weak vertex, not computed here. A quark–antiquark pair from one weak vertex closes into a loop, and the gluon from the loop attaches to the light-quark line. Notation as in Figure 2 .
The same coefficients describe bottom decays. With c → b c \to b c → b in the heavy fields and q 1 = c q_1=c q 1 = c , the channels b → c u ˉ d b \to c\bar{u}d b → c u ˉ d , c u ˉ s c\bar{u}s c u ˉ s , c c ˉ s c\bar{c}s c c ˉ s and c c ˉ d c\bar{c}d c c ˉ d have ( q 2 , q 3 ) = ( d , u ) , ( s , u ) , ( s , c ) , ( d , c ) (q_2,q_3)=(d,u),(s,u),(s,c),(d,c) ( q 2 , q 3 ) = ( d , u ) , ( s , u ) , ( s , c ) , ( d , c ) and λ = V c b V q 3 q 2 ∗ \lambda=V_{cb}V_{q_3q_2}^{*} λ = V c b V q 3 q 2 ∗ . The cut pairs, ( m 1 , m 3 ) (m_1,m_3) ( m 1 , m 3 ) and ( m 1 , m 2 ) (m_1,m_2) ( m 1 , m 2 ) , are ( m c , 0 ) (m_c,0) ( m c , 0 ) or ( m c , m c ) (m_c,m_c) ( m c , m c ) , that is, the charm configurations ( z , 0 ) (z,0) ( z , 0 ) and ( z , z ) (z,z) ( z , z ) . In the notation of appendix § 7 , we have
[ C d ∣ c u ˉ ] b -decays = [ C s ∣ c u ˉ ] b -decays = [ C u ∣ s d ˉ ] c -decays , \left[C^{d|c\bar{u}}\right]_{b\text{-decays}} = \left[C^{s|c\bar{u}}\right]_{b\text{-decays}} = \left[C^{u|s\bar{d}}\right]_{c\text{-decays}}, [ C d ∣ c u ˉ ] b -decays = [ C s ∣ c u ˉ ] b -decays = [ C u ∣ s d ˉ ] c -decays ,
[ C u ∣ c d ˉ ] b -decays = [ C u ∣ c s ˉ ] b -decays = [ C d ∣ s u ˉ ] c -decays , \left[C^{u|c\bar{d}}\right]_{b\text{-decays}} = \left[C^{u|c\bar{s}}\right]_{b\text{-decays}} = \left[C^{d|s\bar{u}}\right]_{c\text{-decays}}, [ C u ∣ c d ˉ ] b -decays = [ C u ∣ c s ˉ ] b -decays = [ C d ∣ s u ˉ ] c -decays ,
[ C d ∣ c c ˉ ] b -decays = [ C s ∣ c c ˉ ] b -decays = [ C u ∣ s s ˉ ] c -decays . (15) \left[C^{d|c\bar{c}}\right]_{b\text{-decays}} = \left[C^{s|c\bar{c}}\right]_{b\text{-decays}} = \left[C^{u|s\bar{s}}\right]_{c\text{-decays}}. \tag*{(15)} [ C d ∣ c c ˉ ] b -decays = [ C s ∣ c c ˉ ] b -decays = [ C u ∣ s s ˉ ] c -decays . (15)
for P 1 , 2 , 5 P_{1,2,5} P 1 , 2 , 5 , every weak row and colour, now with M = m b p o l e M=m_b^{\mathrm{pole}} M = m b pole , also in the scale logarithms, and z = ( m c p o l e / M ) 2 z=(m_c^{\mathrm{pole}}/M)^2 z = ( m c pole / M ) 2 . The coefficients are exact in z z z . The equal-mass configuration requires z < 1 / 4 z<1/4 z < 1/4 . The light quarks are massless, so P 3 , 4 P_{3,4} P 3 , 4 drop out. The coefficients c 1 , 2 c_{1,2} c 1 , 2 and α s \alpha_s α s are taken with five flavours, and C 7 ( 1 ) C_7^{(1)} C 7 ( 1 ) itself contains no closed quark loop. The map is complete for b → c u ˉ d b\to c\bar{u}d b → c u ˉ d and c u ˉ s c\bar{u}s c u ˉ s , and hence for B − B^- B − and, up to ∣ V c d ∣ 2 |V_{cd}|^2 ∣ V c d ∣ 2 terms, for B ˉ 0 \bar{B}^0 B ˉ 0 . For b → c c ˉ s b\to c\bar{c}s b → c c ˉ s and c c ˉ d c\bar{c}d c c ˉ d the c c ˉ c\bar{c} c c ˉ eye contraction and the penguin operators are also needed. The complete penguin-like contributions will be presented in a forthcoming work.
From coefficients to widths
Section 3.1 3.1 3.1 compares the NLO coefficients with LO and evolves the hadronic matrix elements to μ = M \mu=M μ = M . Sections 3.2 3.2 3.2 and 3.3 3.3 3.3 contract the coefficients with tree-level matrix elements, in the vacuum insertion approximation (VIA) for D D D mesons and in the bag model for charmed baryons. For D D D mesons we add the NLO correction to the published widths of ref. [12 ] , and for baryons we recalculate all terms from the inputs of ref. [30 ] . Without the O ( α s ) O(\alpha_s) O ( α s ) matrix elements of P 1 , 2 , 3 P_{1,2,3} P 1 , 2 , 3 these are coefficient-level estimates. The hadronic inputs are given in appendix C.
NLO coefficients and evolution of the matrix elements
We compare the NLO coefficients with LO for the Cabibbo-favoured channel c → s u d ˉ c\to su\bar{d} c → s u d ˉ . With the weights also expanded, ω w = ω w ( 0 ) + a s ω w ( 1 ) \omega_w=\omega_w^{(0)}+a_s\omega_w^{(1)} ω w = ω w ( 0 ) + a s ω w ( 1 ) , the summed coefficient reads
C P i ( 0 ) = ∑ w ω w ( 0 ) C P i , w ( 0 ) , C P i ( 1 ) = ∑ w [ ω w ( 1 ) C P i , w ( 0 ) + ω w ( 0 ) C P i , w ( 1 ) ] . (16) C_{P_i}^{(0)}=\sum_w\omega_w^{(0)}C_{P_i,w}^{(0)},\qquad C_{P_i}^{(1)}=\sum_w\left[\omega_w^{(1)}C_{P_i,w}^{(0)}+\omega_w^{(0)}C_{P_i,w}^{(1)}\right]. \tag*{(16)} C P i ( 0 ) = w ∑ ω w ( 0 ) C P i , w ( 0 ) , C P i ( 1 ) = w ∑ [ ω w ( 1 ) C P i , w ( 0 ) + ω w ( 0 ) C P i , w ( 1 ) ] . (16)
For example, a s ω 12 ( 1 ) = c 1 ( 1 ) c 2 N L O − c 1 L O c 2 ( 1 ) a_s\omega_{12}^{(1)}=c_1^{(1)}c_2^{\mathrm{NLO}}-c_1^{\mathrm{LO}}c_2^{(1)} a s ω 12 ( 1 ) = c 1 ( 1 ) c 2 NLO − c 1 LO c 2 ( 1 ) . The product a s 2 ω w ( 1 ) C P i , w ( 1 ) a_s^2\omega_w^{(1)}C_{P_i,w}^{(1)} a s 2 ω w ( 1 ) C P i , w ( 1 ) is beyond NLO. The Born term keeps the products of the NLO coefficients, including the terms quadratic in c i N L O − c i L O c_i^{\mathrm{NLO}}-c_i^{\mathrm{LO}} c i NLO − c i LO . With the inputs of section 3.3 3.3 3.3 , M = 1.59 G e V M=1.59\ \mathrm{GeV} M = 1.59 GeV , m ‾ s ( 2 G e V ) = 0.09 G e V \overline{m}_s(2\ \mathrm{GeV})=0.09\ \mathrm{GeV} m s ( 2 GeV ) = 0.09 GeV , α s ( M ) = 0.34017 \alpha_s(M)=0.34017 α s ( M ) = 0.34017 , ( c 1 , c 2 ) L O = ( 1.22932 , − 0.45991 ) (c_1,c_2)_{\mathrm{LO}}=(1.22932,-0.45991) ( c 1 , c 2 ) LO = ( 1.22932 , − 0.45991 ) and ( c 1 , c 2 ) N L O = ( 1.17025 , − 0.35078 ) (c_1,c_2)_{\mathrm{NLO}}=(1.17025,-0.35078) ( c 1 , c 2 ) NLO = ( 1.17025 , − 0.35078 ) ,3 Figure 5 shows the scale dependence of the weak-summed coefficients at LO and NLO, and Table 1 gives the values at μ = M \mu=M μ = M .
Table 1. Dimension-seven coefficients at μ = M = 1.59 \mu= M = 1.59 μ = M = 1.59 GeV, to three significant figures. Entries O ( z 2 ) ≃ 0 O(z^2) \simeq0 O ( z 2 ) ≃ 0 vanish for massless cut quarks. The LO coefficient of P 2 P_2 P 2 starts at second order in z z z , the squared cut-quark mass over M 2 M^2 M 2 , and is below 2 × 10 − 4 2 \times10^{-4} 2 × 1 0 − 4 here. C ( 0 ) C^{(0)} C ( 0 ) and C ( 1 ) C^{(1)} C ( 1 ) as in eq. (16) . All rows are for the Cabibbo-favoured channel c → s u d ˉ c \to su\bar{d} c → s u d ˉ .
Figure 5. Dimension-seven LO coefficients (dashed) and NLO coefficients (solid) for c → s u ˉ d c \to s\bar{u}d c → s u ˉ d , for both colours and all five families.
The NLO correction is largest where LO is colour suppressed. For P 1 u , 1 P_1^{u,1} P 1 u , 1 , C P 1 u , ( 0 ) C_{P_1}^{u,(0)} C P 1 u , ( 0 ) , proportional to ( c 1 + 3 c 2 ) 2 (c_1+3c_2)^2 ( c 1 + 3 c 2 ) 2 , is 0.015 and a s C P 1 u , ( 1 ) = 0.377 a_sC_{P_1}^{u,(1)}=0.377 a s C P 1 u , ( 1 ) = 0.377 . For P 1 d , 1 P_1^{d,1} P 1 d , 1 and P 1 s , 1 P_1^{s,1} P 1 s , 1 the ratio a s C P 1 q , ( 1 ) / C P 1 q , ( 0 ) a_sC_{P_1}^{q,(1)}/C_{P_1}^{q,(0)} a s C P 1 q , ( 1 ) / C P 1 q , ( 0 ) is 0.26 and 0.12, respectively. P 4 P_4 P 4 and P 5 P_5 P 5 first appear at NLO, and C P 2 ( 0 ) C_{P_2}^{(0)} C P 2 ( 0 ) starts at O ( z 2 ) O(z^2) O ( z 2 ) , in agreement with refs. [12 , 30 ] . Individual coefficient variation does not measure the scale uncertainty of a physical width, which also depends on the hadronic matrix elements.
Matrix elements given at a hadronic scale μ H \mu_H μ H have to be evolved to the scale of the coefficients, μ = M \mu=M μ = M . We evolve them in full QCD, at NLO at dimension six and at one loop at dimension seven, neglecting mixing with penguin operators, as ref. [30 ] does for ⟨ Q ⟩ \langle Q\rangle ⟨ Q ⟩ , and write η = α s ( μ H ) / α s ( M ) \eta=\alpha_s(\mu_H)/\alpha_s(M) η = α s ( μ H ) / α s ( M ) , a H = a s ( μ H ) a_H=a_s(\mu_H) a H = a s ( μ H ) , a M = a s ( M ) a_M=a_s(M) a M = a s ( M ) and δ a = a H − a M \delta a=a_H-a_M δ a = a H − a M . In this paper only the baryon matrix elements are evolved, section 3.3 3.3 3.3 . The meson matrix elements of section 3.2 3.2 3.2 are used at the scale of the coefficients.
At dimension six the two-loop anomalous dimensions are known [42 , 43 ] in the scheme of C 6 ( 1 ) C_6^{(1)} C 6 ( 1 ) , and they compensate its scheme dependence at μ = M \mu= M μ = M . The pairs ( Q , T ) (Q,T) ( Q , T ) and ( Q S , T S ) (Q_S,T_S) ( Q S , T S ) do not mix. The valence input ⟨ T ⟩ = − 2 3 ⟨ Q ⟩ \langle T\rangle= -\frac{2}{3}\langle Q\rangle ⟨ T ⟩ = − 3 2 ⟨ Q ⟩ is an eigenvector of the ( Q , T ) (Q,T) ( Q , T ) evolution at both orders, so Q Q Q and T T T carry the same factor
⟨ Q ( M ) ⟩ H = U ⟨ Q ( μ H ) ⟩ H , (17) \langle Q(M)\rangle_H = \mathbf{U}\langle Q(\mu_H)\rangle_H, \tag*{(17)} ⟨ Q ( M ) ⟩ H = U ⟨ Q ( μ H ) ⟩ H , (17)
U = ( η 4 / 9 [ 1 − 181 81 δ a ] 0 0 0 0 η 8 / 9 [ 1 + 544 81 δ a ] 0 67 12 ( a H η 8 / 9 − a M η − 1 / 9 ) 0 0 η 4 / 9 [ 1 − 181 81 δ a ] 0 0 − 5 27 a H η − 1 / 9 log η 0 η − 1 / 9 [ 1 − 641 324 δ a ] ) . \mathbf{U} =
\begin{pmatrix}
\eta^{4/9}\left[1-\frac{181}{81}\delta a\right] & 0 & 0 & 0 \\
0 & \eta^{8/9}\left[1+\frac{544}{81}\delta a\right] & 0 & \frac{67}{12}\left(a_H\eta^{8/9}-a_M\eta^{-1/9}\right) \\
0 & 0 & \eta^{4/9}\left[1-\frac{181}{81}\delta a\right] & 0 \\
0 & -\frac{5}{27}a_H\eta^{-1/9}\log\eta& 0 & \eta^{-1/9}\left[1-\frac{641}{324}\delta a\right]
\end{pmatrix}. U = η 4/9 [ 1 − 81 181 δ a ] 0 0 0 0 η 8/9 [ 1 + 81 544 δ a ] 0 − 27 5 a H η − 1/9 log η 0 0 η 4/9 [ 1 − 81 181 δ a ] 0 0 12 67 ( a H η 8/9 − a M η − 1/9 ) 0 η − 1/9 [ 1 − 324 641 δ a ] .
At dimension seven the running follows from the anomalous dimensions γ 76 ( 0 ) \gamma_{76}^{(0)} γ 76 ( 0 ) and γ 77 ( 0 ) \gamma_{77}^{(0)} γ 77 ( 0 ) , eqs. (A.14) and (A.15), which contain no penguin contractions. Q \mathbf{Q} Q does not run into P \mathbf{P} P . Although J 67 J_{67} J 67 is nonzero, it has no UV pole, γ 67 ( 0 ) = 0 \gamma_{67}^{(0)} = 0 γ 67 ( 0 ) = 0 , since UV poles are polynomial in the masses and every P i P_i P i carries an inverse power of M M M . The terms of J 67 J_{67} J 67 in l l l accompany its IR pole and define no anomalous dimension. P \mathbf{P} P does have a UV pole in Q \mathbf{Q} Q , γ 76 ( 0 ) ≠ 0 \gamma_{76}^{(0)} \ne0 γ 76 ( 0 ) = 0 . However, the subtraction F 76 F_{76} F 76 removes the running by keeping J 76 = 0 J_{76} = 0 J 76 = 0 at every μ \mu μ . With n f = 3 n_f = 3 n f = 3 this gives
⟨ P ( M ) ⟩ H = η − γ 77 ( 0 ) / 18 ⟨ P ( μ H ) ⟩ H . (18) \langle P(M)\rangle_H = \eta^{-\gamma_{77}^{(0)}/18}\langle P(\mu_H)\rangle_H. \tag*{(18)} ⟨ P ( M ) ⟩ H = η − γ 77 ( 0 ) /18 ⟨ P ( μ H ) ⟩ H . (18)
This includes the running of m ‾ s ( μ ) \overline{m}_s(\mu) m s ( μ ) in P 3 , 4 P_{3,4} P 3 , 4 .
D mesons
Let Γ r e f \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}} Γ ref denote the pole-scheme widths in ref. [12 ] , table 10, whose dimension-six matrix elements are the HQET sum-rule bag and eye parameters of refs. [40 , 48 ] . A lattice determination of the dimension-six bag parameters of the D s + D_s^+ D s + is now available [49 , 50 ] but we do not use it here. We keep these widths as published and add the NLO update of their dimension-seven term Γ 7 \Gamma_7 Γ 7 , which includes the 1 / m c 1/m_c 1/ m c corrections to the matrix elements of Q \mathbf{Q} Q :
δ Γ 7 = Γ 7 , N L O − Γ 7 , L O , Γ u p d a t e d = Γ r e f + δ Γ 7 . (19) \delta\Gamma_7=\Gamma_{7,\mathrm{NLO}}-\Gamma_{7,\mathrm{LO}},\qquad\Gamma_{\mathrm{updated}}=\Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}}+\delta\Gamma_7. \tag*{(19)} δ Γ 7 = Γ 7 , NLO − Γ 7 , LO , Γ updated = Γ ref + δ Γ 7 . (19)
For each channel, through first soft order, the correction reads
δ Γ 7 = G F 2 ∣ λ ∣ 2 M 2 6 π ∑ w { ( ω w N L O − ω w L O ) ( C 6 , w ( 0 ) ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) ∣ M − 1 + C 7 , w ( 0 ) ⟨ P ⟩ H ( 0 ) ) \delta\Gamma_7=\frac{G_F^2|\lambda|^2M^2}{6\pi}\sum_w\{(\omega_w^{\mathrm{NLO}}-\omega_w^{\mathrm{LO}})(C_{6,w}^{(0)}\langle Q\rangle_H^{(0)}\big|_{M^{-1}}+C_{7,w}^{(0)}\langle P\rangle_H^{(0)}) δ Γ 7 = 6 π G F 2 ∣ λ ∣ 2 M 2 w ∑ {( ω w NLO − ω w LO ) ( C 6 , w ( 0 ) ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) M − 1 + C 7 , w ( 0 ) ⟨ P ⟩ H ( 0 ) )
+ a s ω w L O [ C 6 , w ( 1 ) ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) ∣ M − 1 + C 7 , w ( 1 ) ⟨ P ⟩ H ( 0 ) + κ C Q S , w ( 0 ) ⟨ Q S ⟩ H ( 0 ) ∣ M − 1 ] } + δ Γ m a s s , (20) {}+a_s\omega_w^{\mathrm{LO}}[C_{6,w}^{(1)}\langle Q\rangle_H^{(0)}\big|_{M^{-1}}+C_{7,w}^{(1)}\langle P\rangle_H^{(0)}+\kappa C_{Q_S,w}^{(0)}\langle Q_S\rangle_H^{(0)}\big|_{M^{-1}}]\}+\delta\Gamma_{\mathrm{mass}}, \tag*{(20)} + a s ω w LO [ C 6 , w ( 1 ) ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) M − 1 + C 7 , w ( 1 ) ⟨ P ⟩ H ( 0 ) + κ C Q S , w ( 0 ) ⟨ Q S ⟩ H ( 0 ) M − 1 ]} + δ Γ mass , (20)
where all matrix elements are the tree-level VIA ones and ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) ∣ M − 1 \langle Q\rangle_H^{(0)}\big|_{M^{-1}} ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) M − 1 is the first-power part of ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) \langle Q\rangle_H^{(0)} ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) in a naive expansion in 1 / m c 1/m_c 1/ m c . The first term changes the weak products of the Born part from LO to NLO. The second contains the NLO coefficients with LO weak products and the α s / m c \alpha_s/m_c α s / m c term of ⟨ Q S ⟩ \langle Q_S\rangle ⟨ Q S ⟩ , given by
⟨ Q S ⟩ = ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) + κ a s ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) + O ( a s 2 ) , κ = 2 C F ( 4 + 3 l ) . (21) \langle Q_S\rangle=\langle Q_S\rangle^{(0)}+\kappa a_s\langle Q_S\rangle^{(0)}+O(a_s^2),\qquad\kappa=2C_F(4+3l). \tag*{(21)} ⟨ Q S ⟩ = ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) + κ a s ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) + O ( a s 2 ) , κ = 2 C F ( 4 + 3 l ) . (21)
The factor κ \kappa κ follows from VIA. For a massless light quark the axial Ward identity gives ⟨ Q S ⟩ = B H M H 2 / m ‾ c 2 ( μ ) \langle Q_S\rangle=B_HM_H^2/\overline{m}_c^2(\mu) ⟨ Q S ⟩ = B H M H 2 / m c 2 ( μ ) , with B H = f H 2 M H / 2 B_H=f_H^2M_H/2 B H = f H 2 M H /2 , and ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) = B H M H 2 / M 2 \langle Q_S\rangle^{(0)}=B_HM_H^2/M^2 ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) = B H M H 2 / M 2 , so that eq. (21) follows from m ‾ c ( μ ) = M [ 1 − a s C F ( 4 + 3 l ) ] \overline{m}_c(\mu)=M[1-a_sC_F(4+3l)] m c ( μ ) = M [ 1 − a s C F ( 4 + 3 l )] . Its first-power part is the κ \kappa κ term of eq. (20) . The term δ Γ m a s s \delta\Gamma_{\mathrm{mass}} δ Γ mass converts the strange cut mass of the coefficients from the on-shell to the M S ‾ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} MS mass of the reference, with the matrix elements held fixed. It changes the widths by less than 10 − 4 p s − 1 10^{-4}\ \mathrm{ps}^{-1} 1 0 − 4 ps − 1 .
As in ref. [12 ] , we use M = m c p o l e = 1.49 G e V M=m_c^{\mathrm{pole}}=1.49\ \mathrm{GeV} M = m c pole = 1.49 GeV , μ = 1.5 G e V \mu=1.5\ \mathrm{GeV} μ = 1.5 GeV , m u = m d = 0 m_u=m_d=0 m u = m d = 0 and m ‾ s ( μ ) = 0.1 G e V \overline{m}_s(\mu)=0.1\ \mathrm{GeV} m s ( μ ) = 0.1 GeV , the decay constants and meson masses of its table 16, α s ( μ ) \alpha_s(\mu) α s ( μ ) and the LO and NLO weak coefficients of its tables 20 and 21, with c 1 = C 2 , l i t c_1=C_{2,\mathrm{lit}} c 1 = C 2 , lit and c 2 = C 1 , l i t c_2=C_{1,\mathrm{lit}} c 2 = C 1 , lit , and the CKM entries of its eq. (A.1). The dimension-seven matrix elements are the VIA ones of ref. [12 ] with its inputs, including Λ ‾ u , d = 0.5 G e V \overline{\Lambda}_{u,d}=0.5\ \mathrm{GeV} Λ u , d = 0.5 GeV and Λ ‾ s = 0.6 G e V \overline{\Lambda}_s=0.6\ \mathrm{GeV} Λ s = 0.6 GeV of its eq. (4.6), to which we assign ± 0.1 G e V \pm0.1\ \mathrm{GeV} ± 0.1 GeV , except that the light-quark mass in them is set to zero, which leaves the LO term unchanged. They are given in appendix C.1, together with those of P 4 P_4 P 4 , P 5 P_5 P 5 . As in the reference, the doubly Cabibbo-suppressed channel c → d u s ‾ c\to d u\overline{s} c → d u s is not included. Semileptonic annihilation includes the electron and the massive muon, m μ = 0.105658 G e V m_\mu=0.105658\ \mathrm{GeV} m μ = 0.105658 GeV . For D s + D_s^+ D s + we keep the published reduced widths Γ ~ \widetilde{\Gamma} Γ , which exclude D s + → τ + ν τ D_s^+\to\tau^+\nu_\tau D s + → τ + ν τ , and obtain the lifetime from ref. [12 ] , eq. (2.2), with B τ ν = 0.0539 ± 0.0009 B_{\tau\nu}=0.0539\pm0.0009 B τ ν = 0.0539 ± 0.0009 from ref. [8 ] .
Table 2 and Figure 6 give the results. The reference electron widths are the branching fractions of ref. [12 ] , table 11 and eq. (4.8), divided by the lifetimes used there. The scale is varied over 1 ≤ μ ≤ 3 G e V 1\leq\mu\leq3\ \mathrm{GeV} 1 ≤ μ ≤ 3 GeV , with α s \alpha_s α s and the LO and NLO c 1 , 2 c_{1,2} c 1 , 2 evolved from their values in ref. [12 ] at 1.5 G e V 1.5\ \mathrm{GeV} 1.5 GeV at five loops, LO and NLO, respectively, with n f = 3 n_f=3 n f = 3 below and n f = 4 n_f=4 n f = 4 above 1.5 G e V 1.5\ \mathrm{GeV} 1.5 GeV . The errors of δ Γ 7 \delta\Gamma_7 δ Γ 7 combine this variation and the input errors of Λ ‾ q \overline{\Lambda}_q Λ q , f H f_H f H , M H M_H M H and G F G_F G F in quadrature. Those of τ \tau τ and Γ u p d a t e d \Gamma_{\mathrm{updated}} Γ updated add them in quadrature to the errors of Γ r e f \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}} Γ ref , whose correlations are not available. The NLO term does not uniformly reduce this scale dependence (Table 3 ), because the VIA matrix elements are not evolved and the logarithms of C 7 ( 1 ) C_7^{(1)} C 7 ( 1 ) that compensate the running of ⟨ P ⟩ \langle P\rangle ⟨ P ⟩ remain.
Table 2. Reference widths, NLO dimension-seven corrections, lifetimes and inclusive widths for one electron species, with widths in ps− 1 ^{-1} − 1 . Γ r e f \Gamma_{\rm ref} Γ ref is the pole-scheme width of ref. [12 ] , table 10. Its errors are input and scale variations, as for Γ r e f e \Gamma^{e}_{\rm ref} Γ ref e . The D s + D^{+}_{s} D s + widths exclude τ ν \tau\nu τ ν , and the D s + D^{+}_{s} D s + lifetime is ( 1 − B τ ν ) / Γ ~ (1-B_{\tau\nu})/\widetilde{\Gamma} ( 1 − B τ ν ) / Γ . An upper lifetime limit ∞ \infty ∞ means that the width interval reaches zero.
Table 3. Maximum minus minimum over 1 ≤ μ ≤ 3 1 \le\mu\le3 1 ≤ μ ≤ 3 GeV, with M M M fixed. τ \tau τ is the measured lifetime [8 ] ; for D s + D^{+}_{s} D s + , 1 / τ 1/\tau 1/ τ is replaced by ( 1 − B τ ν ) / τ (1-B_{\tau\nu})/\tau ( 1 − B τ ν ) / τ .
Figure 6. D D D -meson widths (left) and electron-channel semileptonic widths, with VIA semileptonic matrix elements (right). Blue circles: published widths Γ r e f \Gamma_{\rm ref} Γ ref . Orange diamonds: Γ r e f + δ Γ 7 \Gamma_{\rm ref}+\delta\Gamma_{7} Γ ref + δ Γ 7 . Green triangles with dashed bars: without the α s / m c \alpha_{s}/m_{c} α s / m c term of ⟨ Q S ⟩ \langle Q_{S}\rangle ⟨ Q S ⟩ . Black squares: PDG 2026 widths [8 ] (for D s + D^{+}_{s} D s + : ( 1 − B τ ν ) / τ (1-B_{\tau\nu})/\tau ( 1 − B τ ν ) / τ ). Error bars combine the input and scale components in quadrature. Red bands: negative width.
At O ( α s ) O(\alpha_s) O ( α s ) the width contains C w ( 1 ) ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) + C w ( 0 ) ⟨ P ⟩ ( 1 ) C_w^{(1)}\langle P\rangle^{(0)}+C_w^{(0)}\langle P\rangle^{(1)} C w ( 1 ) ⟨ P ⟩ ( 0 ) + C w ( 0 ) ⟨ P ⟩ ( 1 ) , eq. (7) . We include only the first term, and C w ( 0 ) ⟨ P i ⟩ ( 1 ) C_w^{(0)}\langle P_i\rangle^{(1)} C w ( 0 ) ⟨ P i ⟩ ( 1 ) is missing. VIA is inconsistent with the real-gluon class of Figure 2 c. Since it keeps only the vacuum between the two currents, this class vanishes by colour, while the subtraction of its infrared region from C ( 1 ) C^{(1)} C ( 1 ) stays. The estimate is therefore a partial NLO result, without ⟨ Q ⟩ H ∣ M − 1 ( 1 ) \langle Q\rangle^{(1)}_{H\mid M^{-1}} ⟨ Q ⟩ H ∣ M − 1 ( 1 ) and ⟨ P ⟩ H ( 1 ) \langle P\rangle^{(1)}_{H} ⟨ P ⟩ H ( 1 ) , except for the α s / m c \alpha_{s}/m_{c} α s / m c term of ⟨ Q S ⟩ \langle Q_{S}\rangle ⟨ Q S ⟩ in
eq. (21) . Without this term (green in Figure 6 ), Γ e ( D s + ) \Gamma^{e}(D_s^+) Γ e ( D s + ) is negative and the total D s + D_s^+ D s + width vanishes, which shows a substantial model dependence. For D + D^+ D + , δ Γ 7 = 0.78 p s − 1 \delta\Gamma_7 = 0.78\ \mathrm{ps}^{-1} δ Γ 7 = 0.78 ps − 1 consists of 0.44 from P 5 P_5 P 5 , 0.74 from the NLO coefficient of P 1 d , 1 P_1^{d,1} P 1 d , 1 , − 0.46 -0.46 − 0.46 from the weak products and 0.06 from the other terms, in p s − 1 \mathrm{ps}^{-1} ps − 1 .
Charmed baryons
We recalculate the baryon widths Γ r e f \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}} Γ ref from the bag-model inputs of ref. [30 ] at the common scale μ = M = 1.59 G e V \mu= M = 1.59\ \mathrm{GeV} μ = M = 1.59 GeV , with δ Γ 7 \delta\Gamma_7 δ Γ 7 and Γ u p d a t e d \Gamma_{\mathrm{updated}} Γ updated as in eq. (19) . The strange cut mass is m ‾ s ( 2 G e V ) = 0.09 G e V \overline{m}_s(2\ \mathrm{GeV}) = 0.09\ \mathrm{GeV} m s ( 2 GeV ) = 0.09 GeV , converted with the one-loop on-shell–MS relation at μ = 2 G e V \mu= 2\ \mathrm{GeV} μ = 2 GeV . Our widths are roughly 20% below the published ones, mostly through α s \alpha_s α s and the evolution. Ref. [30 ] uses the LO weak coefficients ( c 1 , c 2 ) = ( 1.298 , − 0.565 ) (c_1,c_2) = (1.298,-0.565) ( c 1 , c 2 ) = ( 1.298 , − 0.565 ) at 1.5 GeV. With the updated α s \alpha_s α s we use those of section 3.1, ( 1.2293 , − 0.4599 ) (1.2293,-0.4599) ( 1.2293 , − 0.4599 ) at LO and ( 1.1703 , − 0.3508 ) (1.1703,-0.3508) ( 1.1703 , − 0.3508 ) at NLO. We also evolve the matrix elements with eqs. (17) and (18) in place of the source’s common evolution factor. The leading and kinetic terms use their common coefficient c 3 c_3 c 3 through NLO, with the kernels of refs. [51 ] (nonleptonic) and [52 ] (semileptonic). Its NNLO correction [51 , 53 ] , about − 0.21 p s − 1 -0.21\ \mathrm{ps}^{-1} − 0.21 ps − 1 in the massless-light limit and mostly semileptonic, is not included.
The four-quark matrix elements of the published bag model are recomputed, and those of P 4 P_4 P 4 and P 5 P_5 P 5 calculated from the same wavefunctions (appendix § 8 .§ 2 ). The published kinetic and magnetic matrix elements, bag parameters and CKM inputs are retained. We take the bag-model matrix elements as the complete ones at μ H = 1.0 ± 0.2 G e V \mu_H = 1.0 \pm0.2\ \mathrm{GeV} μ H = 1.0 ± 0.2 GeV , in the scheme of this paper, and evolve them to μ = M \mu= M μ = M with five-loop running for n f = 3 n_f = 3 n f = 3 [46 ] from α s ( 1 G e V ) = 0.495 \alpha_s(1\ \mathrm{GeV}) = 0.495 α s ( 1 GeV ) = 0.495 [30 ] , used only in the evolution. δ Γ 7 \delta\Gamma_7 δ Γ 7 contracts the NLO coefficients, the semileptonic ones of appendix B.2 with ρ e = 0 \rho_e = 0 ρ e = 0 and ρ μ = m μ 2 / M 2 \rho_\mu= m_\mu^2/M^2 ρ μ = m μ 2 / M 2 , with the evolved tree-level matrix elements.
At central inputs, the correction changes the singly charmed baryon widths by at most 2% (Table 4 and Figure 7 ), and the central lifetimes keep the measured hierarchy τ ( Ξ c + ) > τ ( Ω c 0 ) > τ ( Λ c + ) > τ ( Ξ c 0 ) \tau(\Xi_c^+) > \tau(\Omega_c^0) > \tau(\Lambda_c^+) > \tau(\Xi_c^0) τ ( Ξ c + ) > τ ( Ω c 0 ) > τ ( Λ c + ) > τ ( Ξ c 0 ) . For the electron width, Table 5 , the correction is − 8 % -8\% − 8% to − 11 % -11\% − 11% of the LO dimension-seven term Γ 7 , L O e \Gamma^e_{7,\mathrm{LO}} Γ 7 , LO e for every baryon. For Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 , Γ 7 , L O e \Gamma^e_{7,\mathrm{LO}} Γ 7 , LO e cancels 78% of the lower-dimensional terms, which makes δ Γ e \delta\Gamma^e δ Γ e 29% of Γ r e f e \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}}^e Γ ref e , against 3% for Ξ c + , 0 \Xi_c^{+,0} Ξ c + , 0 and
Table 4. Recalculated baseline widths Γ r e f \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}} Γ ref , the NLO dimension-seven correction (nonleptonic, electron and muon), both in p s − 1 \mathrm{ps}^{-1} ps − 1 , updated lifetimes, inclusive widths for one electron species in p s − 1 \mathrm{ps}^{-1} ps − 1 , and the electron branching fraction B e = Γ u p d a t e d / Γ u p d a t e d \mathcal{B}^e = \Gamma_{\mathrm{updated}}/\Gamma_{\mathrm{updated}} B e = Γ updated / Γ updated . Central values use the common scale μ = M = 1.59 G e V \mu= M = 1.59\ \mathrm{GeV} μ = M = 1.59 GeV . The bands propagate the same input variations and the scale variation 1 ≤ μ ≤ 3 G e V 1 \leq\mu\leq3\ \mathrm{GeV} 1 ≤ μ ≤ 3 GeV , with M M M fixed, through the baseline, correction, full width and branching fraction.
Table 5. Central values of the LO dimension-seven term and its NLO correction, relative to the width up to dimension six, Γ r e f − Γ 7 , L O \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}}-\Gamma_{7,\mathrm{LO}} Γ ref − Γ 7 , LO for the total width and Γ r e f e − Γ 7 , L O e \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}}^e-\Gamma_{7,\mathrm{LO}}^e Γ ref e − Γ 7 , LO e for the electron width.
Figure 7. Charmed-baryon lifetimes from the recalculated baseline and the full width Γ r e f + δ Γ 7 \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}}+\delta\Gamma_7 Γ ref + δ Γ 7 (left), and the electron branching fractions B e \mathcal{B}^e B e (right). Each band propagates common input and scale variations through its complete width. Black squares show the PDG 2026 lifetimes [8 ] , and on the right the inclusive Λ c + \Lambda_c^+ Λ c + measurement of ref. [15 ] .
0.1% for Λ c + \Lambda_c^+ Λ c + . For Λ c + \Lambda_c^+ Λ c + the NNLO term would lower B e \mathcal{B}^e B e to 4. 3 − 2.4 + 2.0 % 4.3^{+2.0}_{-2.4}\% 4. 3 − 2.4 + 2.0 % , close to the measured ( 4.06 ± 0.13 ) % (4.06 \pm0.13)\% ( 4.06 ± 0.13 ) % [15 ] . The values of B e \mathcal{B}^e B e exceed those of ref. [30 ] , 4.57, 8.57, 4.40 and 1.88%, mainly through the smaller total widths. For Ω c 0 \Omega_c^0 Ω c 0 , Γ r e f e \Gamma_{\mathrm{ref}}^e Γ ref e is also twice as large, and B e \mathcal{B}^e B e comes close to the quark-model value 7.59% quoted there.
For the singly charmed baryons, whose matrix elements are evolved with the operators, the NLO term reduces the scale dependence of the nonleptonic dimension-seven term (Table 3 ). The bands of the updated widths in Table 4 are dominated by M = 1.59 ± 0.09 M = 1.59 \pm0.09 M = 1.59 ± 0.09 GeV. The scale, the four-quark matrix elements and μ H \mu_H μ H also contribute. That of δ Γ 7 \delta\Gamma_7 δ Γ 7 , the NLO minus the LO term at the same μ \mu μ , is dominated by the scale.
Conclusions
We have computed the NLO QCD corrections to the connected current–current part of the dimension-seven spectator coefficients of charm-hadron widths, for all five operator families in both colour structures, in NDR–M S ‾ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} MS with the Hermitian-averaged Greek projection for the evanescent operators. The finite subtraction removes the mixing of P \mathbf{P} P into Q \mathbf{Q} Q . In several channels the one-loop term is as large as the LO one. It dominates for P 1 u , 1 P_1^{u,1} P 1 u , 1 , whose LO coefficient is proportional to ( c 1 + 3 c 2 ) 2 (c_1+3c_2)^2 ( c 1 + 3 c 2 ) 2 , and is twice the LO value for P 1 s , 8 P_1^{s,8} P 1 s , 8 (Table 1 ). The operators P 4 P_4 P 4 and P 5 P_5 P 5 first appear at NLO. The coefficients of P 1 , 2 , 5 P_{1,2,5} P 1 , 2 , 5 also apply to the b → c ˉ u d b\to\bar{c}ud b → c ˉ u d and c ˉ u s \bar{c}us c ˉ u s channels of bottom decays.
The main result is for the D + D^+ D + . At central inputs, the NLO dimension-seven correction raises the published D + D^+ D + width from − 0.07 -0.07 − 0.07 to 0.71 p s − 1 0.71\ \mathrm{ps}^{-1} 0.71 ps − 1 . The correction, 0.78 p s − 1 0.78\ \mathrm{ps}^{-1} 0.78 ps − 1 , is about two thirds of the LO dimension-seven term. With the published pole-scheme width it gives τ ( D + ) = 1.4 1 − 0.76 + ∞ p s \tau(D^+)=1.41^{+ \infty}_{-0.76}\ \mathrm{ps} τ ( D + ) = 1.4 1 − 0.76 + ∞ ps , compatible with the measured 1.033 p s 1.033\ \mathrm{ps} 1.033 ps [8 ] . The correction is small for D 0 D^0 D 0 and about 10 % 10\% 10% for D s + D_s^+ D s + . At central inputs, it changes the singly charmed baryon widths by less than 2 % 2\% 2% and preserves their lifetime hierarchy.
Without the NLO matrix elements the result is not complete. At NLO the scale dependence of the nonleptonic dimension-seven term drops severalfold for the singly charmed baryons, but not uniformly for the D D D mesons, whose matrix elements are not evolved. Reliable dimension-seven contributions require the O ( α s ) O(\alpha_s) O ( α s ) hadronic matrix elements of P 1 , 2 , 3 P_{1,2,3} P 1 , 2 , 3 in the same scheme, the first-power part of ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 1 ) \langle Q\rangle^{(1)} ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 1 ) beyond VIA and the two-loop evolution of all dimension-seven matrix elements.
Acknowledgments
We thank Hai-Yang Cheng, Maria Laura Piscopo, and Peng-Yuan Zheng for valuable discussions. This work was supported in part by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) under Grant No. 12575096. We thank the Mainz Institute for Theoretical Physics (MITP) of the Cluster of Excellence PRISMA+ (Project ID 390831469) for its hospitality and support.
Details of the calculation
Spinor conventions and Fierz representatives
For ordered fields ( c ˉ i α , q j β , q ˉ k γ , c l δ ) (\bar{c}_{i\alpha},q_{j\beta},\bar{q}_{k\gamma},c_{l\delta}) ( c ˉ i α , q j β , q ˉ k γ , c l δ ) the spinor contractions are
D ( A , B ) α β ; γ δ = A α δ B γ β , X ( A , B ) α β ; γ δ = − A α β B γ δ . (22) D(A,B)_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}=A_{\alpha\delta}B_{\gamma\beta},\qquad X(A,B)_{\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta}=-A_{\alpha\beta}B_{\gamma\delta}. \tag*{(22)} D ( A , B ) α β ; γ δ = A α δ B γ β , X ( A , B ) α β ; γ δ = − A α β B γ δ . (22)
The minus sign in X X X includes the Grassmann interchange. For P 1 , … , P 4 P_1,\ldots,P_4 P 1 , … , P 4 , the singlet and octet colour tensors are C 1 = δ i j δ k l C_1=\delta_{ij}\delta_{kl} C 1 = δ ij δ k l and C 8 = t i j A t k l A = 1 2 ( δ i l δ k j − δ i j δ k l / N c ) C_8=t^A_{ij}t^A_{kl}=\frac{1}{2}(\delta_{il}\delta_{kj}-\delta_{ij}\delta_{kl}/N_c) C 8 = t ij A t k l A = 2 1 ( δ i l δ k j − δ ij δ k l / N c ) , respectively. Colour is held fixed during the spinor rearrangement. The endpoint momenta ( p f , r i , r f , p i ) (p_f,r_i,r_f,p_i) ( p f , r i , r f , p i ) of the heavy and light lines, with i i i and f f f for initial and final, follow this field order. The momentum transfer is Δ = p f − p i = r i − r f \Delta= p_f-p_i = r_i-r_f Δ = p f − p i = r i − r f . At tree level the derivatives act on the external lines, c ˉ D ‾ ρ → i p f ρ \bar{c}\overline{D}_\rho\to ip_{f\rho} c ˉ D ρ → i p f ρ and D ρ q → − i r i ρ D_\rho q \to-ir_{i\rho} D ρ q → − i r i ρ , and on p i p_i p i and r f r_f r f in the Hermitian conjugates, so that, with the colour suppressed, the operators of eq. (4) give
⟨ P 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) = 1 2 ( p f ⋅ r i + p i ⋅ r f ) X ( γ μ L , γ μ L ) , ⟨ P 2 ⟩ ( 0 ) = − ( p f ⋅ r i + p i ⋅ r f ) X ( L , R ) , ⟨ P 3 ⟩ ( 0 ) = m q M [ X ( L , L ) + X ( R , R ) ] , ⟨ P 4 ⟩ ( 0 ) = m q M [ D ( L , L ) + D ( R , R ) ] , ⟨ P 5 ⟩ ( 0 ) = i Δ μ D ( σ μ ν , γ ν L ) . (23) \begin{aligned}
\langle P_1\rangle^{(0)} &= \frac{1}{2}(p_f\cdot r_i+p_i\cdot r_f)X(\gamma_\mu L,\gamma^\mu L), & \langle P_2\rangle^{(0)} &= -(p_f\cdot r_i+p_i\cdot r_f)X(L,R),\\
\langle P_3\rangle^{(0)} &= \frac{m_q}{M}\left[X(L,L)+X(R,R)\right], & \langle P_4\rangle^{(0)} &= \frac{m_q}{M}\left[D(L,L)+D(R,R)\right],\\
\langle P_5\rangle^{(0)} &= i\Delta_\mu D(\sigma^{\mu\nu},\gamma_\nu L). \tag*{(23)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ P 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) ⟨ P 3 ⟩ ( 0 ) ⟨ P 5 ⟩ ( 0 ) = 2 1 ( p f ⋅ r i + p i ⋅ r f ) X ( γ μ L , γ μ L ) , = M m q [ X ( L , L ) + X ( R , R ) ] , = i Δ μ D ( σ μν , γ ν L ) . ⟨ P 2 ⟩ ( 0 ) ⟨ P 4 ⟩ ( 0 ) = − ( p f ⋅ r i + p i ⋅ r f ) X ( L , R ) , = M m q [ D ( L , L ) + D ( R , R ) ] , (23)
The map Π \Pi Π of § 2 writes a d d d -dimensional Dirac structure as four-dimensional ones with coefficients through O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) . It acts on the contracted Dirac tensors
C k χ χ ′ = γ μ 1 ⋯ γ μ k χ ⊗ γ μ 1 ⋯ γ μ k χ ′ , χ , χ ′ ∈ { L , R } . (24) C_k^{\chi\chi'}=\gamma_{\mu_1}\cdots\gamma_{\mu_k}\chi\otimes\gamma^{\mu_1}\cdots\gamma^{\mu_k}\chi',\qquad\chi,\chi'\in\{L,R\}. \tag*{(24)} C k χ χ ′ = γ μ 1 ⋯ γ μ k χ ⊗ γ μ 1 ⋯ γ μ k χ ′ , χ , χ ′ ∈ { L , R } . (24)
The reduction uses the rules of Table 6 .
Table 6. Standard NDR Greek prescription [54 ] for the contracted tensors C k χ χ ′ C_k^{\chi\chi'} C k χ χ ′ through O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) , following appendix A of Aebischer et al. [55 ] and expressed in the C k C_k C k basis. In both columns, C 0 C_0 C 0 , C 1 C_1 C 1 and C 2 C_2 C 2 are the four-dimensional tensors.
With the colour label suppressed, the tree-level amputated matrix elements of the Fierz forms F [ P i ] \mathcal{F}[P_i] F [ P i ] are
⟨ F [ P 1 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = p f ⋅ r i + p i ⋅ r f 2 D ( γ μ L , γ μ L ) , ⟨ F [ P 2 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = p f ⋅ r i + p i ⋅ r f 2 D ( γ μ R , γ μ L ) , ⟨ F [ P 3 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = m q 8 M ∑ χ = L , R D ( γ μ γ ν χ , γ μ γ ν χ ) − ( 1 − ϵ / 4 ) ⟨ P 4 ⟩ ( 0 ) , ⟨ F [ P 4 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = m q 8 M ∑ χ = L , R X ( γ μ γ ν χ , γ μ γ ν χ ) − ( 1 − ϵ / 4 ) ⟨ P 3 ⟩ ( 0 ) . (25) \begin{aligned}
\langle\mathcal{F}[P_1]\rangle^{(0)} &= \frac{p_f\cdot r_i+p_i\cdot r_f}{2}D(\gamma_\mu L,\gamma^\mu L),\\
\langle\mathcal{F}[P_2]\rangle^{(0)} &= \frac{p_f\cdot r_i+p_i\cdot r_f}{2}D(\gamma_\mu R,\gamma^\mu L),\\
\langle\mathcal{F}[P_3]\rangle^{(0)} &= \frac{m_q}{8M}\sum_{\chi=L,R}D(\gamma_\mu\gamma_\nu\chi,\gamma^\mu\gamma^\nu\chi)-(1-\epsilon/4)\langle P_4\rangle^{(0)},\\
\langle\mathcal{F}[P_4]\rangle^{(0)} &= \frac{m_q}{8M}\sum_{\chi=L,R}X(\gamma_\mu\gamma_\nu\chi,\gamma^\mu\gamma^\nu\chi)-(1-\epsilon/4)\langle P_3\rangle^{(0)}. \tag*{(25)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ F [ P 1 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) ⟨ F [ P 2 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) ⟨ F [ P 3 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) ⟨ F [ P 4 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = 2 p f ⋅ r i + p i ⋅ r f D ( γ μ L , γ μ L ) , = 2 p f ⋅ r i + p i ⋅ r f D ( γ μ R , γ μ L ) , = 8 M m q χ = L , R ∑ D ( γ μ γ ν χ , γ μ γ ν χ ) − ( 1 − ϵ /4 ) ⟨ P 4 ⟩ ( 0 ) , = 8 M m q χ = L , R ∑ X ( γ μ γ ν χ , γ μ γ ν χ ) − ( 1 − ϵ /4 ) ⟨ P 3 ⟩ ( 0 ) . (25)
For P 5 P_5 P 5 , with the density-colour tensor of eqs. (4) and (5) , the Fierz form reads
⟨ F [ P 5 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = 1 2 X ( Δ / L , R ) − X ( L , Δ / L ) + 1 4 X ( γ μ Δ / L , γ μ L ) + 1 4 X ( γ μ L , γ μ Δ / R ) . (26) \begin{aligned}
\langle\mathcal{F}[P_5]\rangle^{(0)}={}&\frac{1}{2}X(\Delta\!\!\!/ L,R)-X(L,\Delta\!\!\!/ L)\\
&+\frac{1}{4}X(\gamma_\mu\Delta\!\!\!/ L,\gamma^\mu L)+\frac{1}{4}X(\gamma_\mu L,\gamma^\mu\Delta\!\!\!/ R). \tag*{(26)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ F [ P 5 ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = 2 1 X ( Δ / L , R ) − X ( L , Δ / L ) + 4 1 X ( γ μ Δ / L , γ μ L ) + 4 1 X ( γ μ L , γ μ Δ / R ) . (26)
The terms ( 1 − ϵ / 4 ) ⟨ P 4 , 3 ⟩ ( 0 ) (1-\epsilon/4)\langle P_{4,3}\rangle^{(0)} ( 1 − ϵ /4 ) ⟨ P 4 , 3 ⟩ ( 0 ) in eq. (A.4) make Π H ⟨ F [ P i ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = ⟨ P i ⟩ ( 0 ) + O ( ϵ 2 ) \Pi_H\langle\mathcal{F}[P_i]\rangle^{(0)}=\langle P_i\rangle^{(0)}+O(\epsilon^2) Π H ⟨ F [ P i ] ⟩ ( 0 ) = ⟨ P i ⟩ ( 0 ) + O ( ϵ 2 ) for i = 3 , 4 i=3,4 i = 3 , 4 , as for i = 1 , 2 i=1,2 i = 1 , 2 .
Other orders of the gamma matrices in the second factor are first brought to the order of the table with { γ μ , γ ν } = 2 g μ ν \{\gamma^\mu,\gamma^\nu\}=2g^{\mu\nu} { γ μ , γ ν } = 2 g μν in d d d dimensions. The chiralities χ , χ ′ \chi,\chi' χ , χ ′ in the table are those next to the core. For example, γ μ γ ν p̸ L = γ μ γ ν R p̸ \gamma_\mu\gamma_\nu\not{p}L=\gamma_\mu\gamma_\nu R\not{p} γ μ γ ν p L = γ μ γ ν R p enters the table with R. We write the average in eq. (13) as
Π H ( O ) = 1 2 [ Π ( O ) + ( Π ( O † ) ) † ] . (27) \Pi_H(O)=\frac{1}{2}\left[\Pi(O)+\left(\Pi(O^\dagger)\right)^\dagger\right]. \tag*{(27)} Π H ( O ) = 2 1 [ Π ( O ) + ( Π ( O † ) ) † ] . (27)
The average in eq. (A.6) is needed because Π \Pi Π is not Hermitian. For S = X ( ̸ p f γ μ γ ν L , γ μ γ ν L ) S=X(\not{p}_f\gamma_\mu\gamma_\nu L,\gamma^\mu\gamma^\nu L) S = X ( p f γ μ γ ν L , γ μ γ ν L ) ,
Π ( S ) − ( Π ( S † ) ) † = 6 ϵ X ( ̸ p f L , L ) , (28) \Pi(S)-\left(\Pi(S^\dagger)\right)^\dagger=6\epsilon X(\not{p}_f L,L), \tag*{(28)} Π ( S ) − ( Π ( S † ) ) † = 6 ϵ X ( p f L , L ) , (28)
and such structures occur in the amplitudes of P 1 , 2 P_{1,2} P 1 , 2 .
The reference tensors E 0 ( P i c ) E_0(P_i^c) E 0 ( P i c ) and E 0 ( F [ P i c ] ) E_0(\mathcal{F}[P_i^c]) E 0 ( F [ P i c ]) , i = 1 , … , 5 i=1,\ldots,5 i = 1 , … , 5 , c = 1 , 8 c=1,8 c = 1 , 8 , are the evanescent remainders before the transformation of eq. (11) , which gives E ( Z ) = E 0 ( Z ) + ϵ d Z O Z E(Z)=E_0(Z)+\epsilon d_Z O_Z E ( Z ) = E 0 ( Z ) + ϵ d Z O Z . The ancillary Mathematica file gives all twenty E 0 ( Z ) E_0(Z) E 0 ( Z ) . As an example, with the pairings of eq. (A.1) and the colour tensors C b C_b C b , write S k , b Y = C b ∑ χ = L , R Y ( γ μ 1 ⋯ γ μ k χ , γ μ 1 ⋯ γ μ k χ ) S_{k,b}^{Y}=C_b\sum_{\chi=L,R}Y(\gamma_{\mu_1}\cdots\gamma_{\mu_k}\chi,\gamma^{\mu_1}\cdots\gamma^{\mu_k}\chi) S k , b Y = C b ∑ χ = L , R Y ( γ μ 1 ⋯ γ μ k χ , γ μ 1 ⋯ γ μ k χ ) for Y = D , X Y=D,X Y = D , X . The singlet P 3 P_3 P 3 input has the complete reference remainder
⟨ E 0 ( P 3 1 ) ⟩ ( 0 ) = m q M [ 8 3 ( d − 4 ) S 0 , 1 X + 8 S 0 , 8 D + 8 S 0 , 8 X − 4 d S 2 , 8 X ] . (29) \langle E_0(P_3^1)\rangle^{(0)}=\frac{m_q}{M}\left[\frac{8}{3}(d-4)S_{0,1}^{X}+8S_{0,8}^{D}+8S_{0,8}^{X}-\frac{4}{d}S_{2,8}^{X}\right]. \tag*{(29)} ⟨ E 0 ( P 3 1 ) ⟩ ( 0 ) = M m q [ 3 8 ( d − 4 ) S 0 , 1 X + 8 S 0 , 8 D + 8 S 0 , 8 X − d 4 S 2 , 8 X ] . (29)
At d = 4 d=4 d = 4 , the spinor identity S 2 , b X = 8 ( S 0 , b D + S 0 , b X ) S_{2,b}^{X}=8(S_{0,b}^{D}+S_{0,b}^{X}) S 2 , b X = 8 ( S 0 , b D + S 0 , b X ) makes the complete remainder vanish. Expanding − 4 / d = − 1 − ϵ / 2 + O ( ϵ 2 ) -4/d=-1-\epsilon/2+O(\epsilon^2) − 4/ d = − 1 − ϵ /2 + O ( ϵ 2 ) and applying Π H \Pi_H Π H of eq. (A.6) gives
Π H ⟨ E 0 ( P 3 1 ) ⟩ ( 0 ) = − ϵ [ 16 3 ⟨ P 3 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) + 2 ⟨ P 3 8 ⟩ ( 0 ) + 4 ⟨ P 4 8 ⟩ ( 0 ) ] + O ( ϵ 2 ) . (30) \Pi_H\langle E_0(P_3^1)\rangle^{(0)}=-\epsilon\left[\frac{16}{3}\langle P_3^1\rangle^{(0)}+2\langle P_3^8\rangle^{(0)}+4\langle P_4^8\rangle^{(0)}\right]+O(\epsilon^2). \tag*{(30)} Π H ⟨ E 0 ( P 3 1 ) ⟩ ( 0 ) = − ϵ [ 3 16 ⟨ P 3 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) + 2 ⟨ P 3 8 ⟩ ( 0 ) + 4 ⟨ P 4 8 ⟩ ( 0 ) ] + O ( ϵ 2 ) . (30)
This is the O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) image of the remainder of P 3 1 P_3^1 P 3 1 alone. The finite insertions follow from that of the sum E i \mathcal{E}_i E i of eq. (13) for the pair ( P 3 1 , F [ P 3 1 ] ) (P_3^1,\mathcal{F}[P_3^1]) ( P 3 1 , F [ P 3 1 ]) , appendix A.3.
Decomposition of a loop integral
The integrals of the matching are separated into the UV, IR and finite terms of eqs. (10) and (8) as follows, with [ d g ] = e ϵ γ E μ 2 ϵ d d g / ( i π d / 2 ) [dg]=e^{\epsilon\gamma_E}\mu^{2\epsilon}d^d g/(i\pi^{d/2}) [ d g ] = e ϵ γ E μ 2 ϵ d d g / ( i π d /2 ) . An integrand I ( g ) \mathcal{I}(g) I ( g ) is expanded at large g g g and at small g g g . In dimensional regularization a pole at d = 4 d=4 d = 4 comes only from the terms of degree − 4 -4 − 4 in g g g , which diverge logarithmically, giving the UV pole at large g g g and the IR pole at small g g g . Terms of other degree give no pole. We keep the degree-( − 4 ) (-4) ( − 4 ) terms and average their numerators over the directions of g g g in d d d dimensions. This defines the UV residue U ( ϵ ) U(\epsilon) U ( ϵ ) and the soft residue R ( ϵ ) R(\epsilon) R ( ϵ ) through the large-g g g part U ( ϵ ) / ( g 2 ) 2 U(\epsilon)/(g^2)^2 U ( ϵ ) / ( g 2 ) 2 and the small-g g g part R ( ϵ ) / ( g 2 ) 2 R(\epsilon)/(g^2)^2 R ( ϵ ) / ( g 2 ) 2 . We write U 0 = U ( 0 ) U_0=U(0) U 0 = U ( 0 ) and, through O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) , R = R 0 + ϵ R 1 R=R_0+\epsilon R_1 R = R 0 + ϵ R 1 . With
∫ [ d g ] 1 ( g 2 ) 2 = 1 ϵ U V − 1 ϵ I R , (31) \int[dg]\frac{1}{(g^2)^2}=\frac{1}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{UV}}}-\frac{1}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}, \tag*{(31)} ∫ [ d g ] ( g 2 ) 2 1 = ϵ UV 1 − ϵ IR 1 , (31)
the integral has the form
∫ [ d g ] I ( g ) = U 0 ϵ U V − R 0 + ϵ R 1 ϵ I R + I f i n + O ( ϵ ) , (32) \int[dg]\,\mathcal{I}(g)=\frac{U_0}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{UV}}}-\frac{R_0+\epsilon R_1}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}+\mathcal{I}_{\mathrm{fin}}+O(\epsilon), \tag*{(32)} ∫ [ d g ] I ( g ) = ϵ UV U 0 − ϵ IR R 0 + ϵ R 1 + I fin + O ( ϵ ) , (32)
where I f i n \mathcal{I}_{\rm fin} I fin is finite and contains the ϵ / ϵ U V \epsilon/\epsilon_{\rm UV} ϵ / ϵ UV term of the UV part. The labels record the origin of each term. As a number ϵ / ϵ I R = 1 \epsilon/\epsilon_{\rm IR}=1 ϵ / ϵ IR = 1 , so the ϵ 0 \epsilon^{0} ϵ 0 term of the integral is I f i n − R 1 \mathcal{I}_{\rm fin}-\mathcal{R}_{1} I fin − R 1 , and R 1 \mathcal{R}_{1} R 1 must be taken from the soft expansion.
For example, up to O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ )
∫ [ d g ] ( g ⋅ p ) 2 ( g 2 ) 3 = M 2 d ( 1 ϵ U V − 1 ϵ I R ) , ∫ [ d g ] ( g ⋅ p ) 2 ( g 2 ) 2 ( g 2 + 2 g ⋅ p ) = M 2 d 1 ϵ U V + M 2 4 ( l + 1 2 ) , ∫ [ d g ] 2 ( g ⋅ p ) 3 ( g 2 ) 3 ( g 2 + 2 g ⋅ p ) = − M 2 d 1 ϵ I R − M 2 4 ( l + 1 2 ) . (33) \begin{aligned}
\int[dg]\,\frac{(g\cdot p)^2}{(g^2)^3} &= \frac{M^2}{d}\left(\frac{1}{\epsilon_{\rm UV}}-\frac{1}{\epsilon_{\rm IR}}\right),\\
\int[dg]\,\frac{(g\cdot p)^2}{(g^2)^2(g^2+2g\cdot p)} &= \frac{M^2}{d}\frac{1}{\epsilon_{\rm UV}}+\frac{M^2}{4}\left(l+\frac{1}{2}\right),\\
\int[dg]\,\frac{2(g\cdot p)^3}{(g^2)^3(g^2+2g\cdot p)} &= -\frac{M^2}{d}\frac{1}{\epsilon_{\rm IR}}-\frac{M^2}{4}\left(l+\frac{1}{2}\right). \tag*{(33)}
\end{aligned} ∫ [ d g ] ( g 2 ) 3 ( g ⋅ p ) 2 ∫ [ d g ] ( g 2 ) 2 ( g 2 + 2 g ⋅ p ) ( g ⋅ p ) 2 ∫ [ d g ] ( g 2 ) 3 ( g 2 + 2 g ⋅ p ) 2 ( g ⋅ p ) 3 = d M 2 ( ϵ UV 1 − ϵ IR 1 ) , = d M 2 ϵ UV 1 + 4 M 2 ( l + 2 1 ) , = − d M 2 ϵ IR 1 − 4 M 2 ( l + 2 1 ) . (33)
The factor 1 / d 1/d 1/ d is the tensor reduction ( g ⋅ p ) 2 → g 2 M 2 / d (g\cdot p)^2\to g^2M^2/d ( g ⋅ p ) 2 → g 2 M 2 / d . The first integral is scaleless, with U = R U=\mathcal{R} U = R , and vanishes as a number. The second has no term of degree − 4 -4 − 4 at small g g g , so it has only a UV pole. The third is the first minus the second, and has only a soft term, with R 0 = M 2 / 4 \mathcal{R}_0=M^2/4 R 0 = M 2 /4 , R 1 = M 2 / 8 \mathcal{R}_1=M^2/8 R 1 = M 2 /8 and I f i n = − ( M 2 / 4 ) ( l + 1 / 2 ) \mathcal{I}_{\rm fin}=-(M^2/4)(l+1/2) I fin = − ( M 2 /4 ) ( l + 1/2 ) .
The IR divergences can also be regulated with a gluon mass λ \lambda λ , as discussed in refs. [36 , 37 ] . The two regulators are related term by term. With the gluon propagator 1 / ( g 2 − λ 2 ) 1/(g^2-\lambda^2) 1/ ( g 2 − λ 2 ) , eq. (A.10) becomes
∫ [ d g ] [ g 2 ( g 2 − λ 2 ) ] − 1 = 1 ϵ U V + log ( μ 2 λ 2 ) + 1 , \int[dg]\,[g^2(g^2-\lambda^2)]^{-1}=\frac{1}{\epsilon_{\rm UV}}+\log\left(\frac{\mu^2}{\lambda^2}\right)+1, ∫ [ d g ] [ g 2 ( g 2 − λ 2 ) ] − 1 = ϵ UV 1 + log ( λ 2 μ 2 ) + 1 ,
so in the IR term − ( R 0 + ϵ R 1 ) / ϵ I R -(\mathcal{R}_0+\epsilon\mathcal{R}_1)/\epsilon_{\rm IR} − ( R 0 + ϵ R 1 ) / ϵ IR the pole − R 0 / ϵ I R -\mathcal{R}_0/\epsilon_{\rm IR} − R 0 / ϵ IR becomes R 0 [ log ( μ 2 / λ 2 ) + 1 ] \mathcal{R}_0[\log(\mu^2/\lambda^2)+1] R 0 [ log ( μ 2 / λ 2 ) + 1 ] and the finite term − R 1 -\mathcal{R}_1 − R 1 becomes zero, while the UV term and I f i n \mathcal{I}_{\rm fin} I fin are unchanged. The UV terms and F 76 F_{76} F 76 do not depend on the IR regulator, so with a gluon mass the insertions on the tabulated outputs are
J − J I R [ log μ 2 λ 2 + 1 ] , (34) \mathbf{J}-\mathbf{J}_{\rm IR}\left[\log\frac{\mu^2}{\lambda^2}+1\right], \tag*{(34)} J − J IR [ log λ 2 μ 2 + 1 ] , (34)
up to 1 / λ 1/\lambda 1/ λ terms in the 67 block and terms that vanish as λ → 0 \lambda\to0 λ → 0 . The 1 / λ 1/\lambda 1/ λ terms arise because expanding the dimension-six insertions to first order in the light-quark momentum makes their integrand one power more singular at small g g g , of degree − 5 -5 − 5 . For example,
∫ [ d g ] [ ( g 2 − λ 2 ) 2 ( 2 g ⋅ p + i 0 ) ] − 1 = − π 2 M λ , \int[dg]\,[(g^2-\lambda^2)^2(2g\cdot p+i0)]^{-1}=-\frac{\pi}{2M\lambda}, ∫ [ d g ] [( g 2 − λ 2 ) 2 ( 2 g ⋅ p + i 0 ) ] − 1 = − 2 M λ π ,
whereas at λ = 0 \lambda=0 λ = 0 the same integral is scaleless and vanishes in dimensional regularization. These terms cancel in the matching.
Ultraviolet poles and finite insertions
In the order of eq. (3) , with rows labelling the inserted operator, the one-loop anomalous dimension of eq. (8) has the blocks
γ ( 0 ) = ( γ 66 ( 0 ) γ 67 ( 0 ) γ 76 ( 0 ) γ 77 ( 0 ) ) , γ 66 ( 0 ) = ( 0 0 12 0 0 − 16 0 0 8 3 0 − 4 0 0 0 0 2 ) , γ 67 ( 0 ) = 0 , (35) \gamma^{(0)}=
\begin{pmatrix}
\gamma_{66}^{(0)} & \gamma_{67}^{(0)}\\
\gamma_{76}^{(0)} & \gamma_{77}^{(0)}
\end{pmatrix},
\qquad
\gamma_{66}^{(0)}=
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & 0 & 12 & 0\\
0 & -16 & 0 & 0\\
\frac{8}{3} & 0 & -4 & 0\\
0 & 0 & 0 & 2
\end{pmatrix},
\qquad
\gamma_{67}^{(0)}=0, \tag*{(35)} γ ( 0 ) = ( γ 66 ( 0 ) γ 76 ( 0 ) γ 67 ( 0 ) γ 77 ( 0 ) ) , γ 66 ( 0 ) = 0 0 3 8 0 0 − 16 0 0 12 0 − 4 0 0 0 0 2 , γ 67 ( 0 ) = 0 , (35)
and the remaining block, transposed, reads
γ 76 ( 0 ) T = ( 32 9 0 0 0 − 32 9 4 3 4 27 0 0 − 56 27 16 9 0 0 0 − 64 9 0 − 40 27 0 0 − 112 27 6 2 3 0 0 8 3 − 22 9 − 2 9 0 0 − 22 9 0 − 20 3 0 0 16 3 − 2 9 20 9 0 0 − 44 9 ) . (36) \gamma_{76}^{(0)T}=
\begin{pmatrix}
\frac{32}{9} & 0 & 0 & 0 & -\frac{32}{9} & \frac{4}{3} & \frac{4}{27} & 0 & 0 & -\frac{56}{27}\\
\frac{16}{9} & 0 & 0 & 0 & -\frac{64}{9} & 0 & -\frac{40}{27} & 0 & 0 & -\frac{112}{27}\\
6 & \frac{2}{3} & 0 & 0 & \frac{8}{3} & -\frac{22}{9} & -\frac{2}{9} & 0 & 0 & -\frac{22}{9}\\
0 & -\frac{20}{3} & 0 & 0 & \frac{16}{3} & -\frac{2}{9} & \frac{20}{9} & 0 & 0 & -\frac{44}{9}
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(36)} γ 76 ( 0 ) T = 9 32 9 16 6 0 0 0 3 2 − 3 20 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 9 32 − 9 64 3 8 3 16 3 4 0 − 9 22 − 9 2 27 4 − 27 40 − 9 2 9 20 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 − 27 56 − 27 112 − 9 22 − 9 44 . (36)
γ 77 ( 0 ) = ( 0 0 0 0 16 9 44 3 0 − 4 3 − 4 − 10 3 0 − 16 0 0 − 16 27 0 8 0 − 4 4 9 0 0 − 8 0 0 0 0 8 16 0 0 0 32 3 40 3 0 0 0 8 − 8 0 0 0 0 16 3 8 3 0 0 0 − 4 0 88 27 0 − 8 27 − 8 9 4 27 100 9 0 40 9 4 3 20 9 0 16 9 0 − 8 9 − 28 81 0 46 3 − 4 − 8 3 − 11 27 0 0 16 9 32 9 0 0 0 40 3 20 3 0 0 0 16 9 − 16 9 0 0 0 − 4 − 8 0 0 0 0 28 9 0 0 0 0 11 3 8 3 ) . (37) \gamma_{77}^{(0)}=
\begin{pmatrix}
0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{16}{9} & \frac{44}{3} & 0 & -\frac{4}{3} & -4 & -\frac{10}{3}\\
0 & -16 & 0 & 0 & -\frac{16}{27} & 0 & 8 & 0 & -4 & \frac{4}{9}\\
0 & 0 & -8 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 8 & 16 & 0\\
0 & 0 & \frac{32}{3} & \frac{40}{3} & 0 & 0 & 0 & 8 & -8 & 0\\
0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{16}{3} & \frac{8}{3} & 0 & 0 & 0 & -4 & 0\\
\frac{88}{27} & 0 & -\frac{8}{27} & -\frac{8}{9} & \frac{4}{27} & \frac{100}{9} & 0 & \frac{40}{9} & \frac{4}{3} & \frac{20}{9}\\
0 & \frac{16}{9} & 0 & -\frac{8}{9} & -\frac{28}{81} & 0 & \frac{46}{3} & -4 & -\frac{8}{3} & -\frac{11}{27}\\
0 & 0 & \frac{16}{9} & \frac{32}{9} & 0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{40}{3} & \frac{20}{3} & 0\\
0 & 0 & \frac{16}{9} & -\frac{16}{9} & 0 & 0 & 0 & -4 & -8 & 0\\
0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{28}{9} & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{11}{3} & \frac{8}{3}
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(37)} γ 77 ( 0 ) = 0 0 0 0 0 27 88 0 0 0 0 0 − 16 0 0 0 0 9 16 0 0 0 0 0 − 8 3 32 0 − 27 8 0 9 16 9 16 0 0 0 0 3 40 3 16 − 9 8 − 9 8 9 32 − 9 16 9 28 9 16 − 27 16 0 0 3 8 27 4 − 81 28 0 0 0 3 44 0 0 0 0 9 100 0 0 0 0 0 8 0 0 0 0 3 46 0 0 0 − 3 4 0 8 8 0 9 40 − 4 3 40 − 4 0 − 4 − 4 16 − 8 − 4 3 4 − 3 8 3 20 − 8 3 11 − 3 10 9 4 0 0 0 9 20 − 27 11 0 0 3 8 . (37)
The finite subtraction F 76 \mathbf{F}_{76} F 76 equals the finite part of the 76 insertions, so that subtracting it imposes J 76 = 0 \mathbf{J}_{76}=0 J 76 = 0 :
F 76 = ( − 192 l + 623 108 − 48 l − 31 54 − 3 ( 16 l + 29 ) 16 0 − 7 36 143 18 − 48 l + 29 144 240 l + 589 72 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 ( 2 l + 5 ) 9 2 ( 16 l + 11 ) 9 − 2 ( 21 + 5 ) 3 − 16 l + 11 6 − 16 l + 29 24 0 11 ( 96 l + 199 ) 864 48 l − 31 432 − 48 l + 29 648 240 l + 589 324 96 l + 79 864 − 480 l + 1607 432 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 112 l + 289 108 112 l + 113 54 176 l + 431 144 176 l + 85 72 ) . (38) \mathbf{F}_{76}=
\begin{pmatrix}
-\frac{192l+623}{108} & -\frac{48l-31}{54} & -\frac{3(16l+29)}{16} & 0\\
-\frac{7}{36} & \frac{143}{18} & -\frac{48l+29}{144} & \frac{240l+589}{72}\\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\
\frac{8(2l+5)}{9} & \frac{2(16l+11)}{9} & -\frac{2(21+5)}{3} & -\frac{16l+11}{6}\\
-\frac{16l+29}{24} & 0 & \frac{11(96l+199)}{864} & \frac{48l-31}{432}\\
-\frac{48l+29}{648} & \frac{240l+589}{324} & \frac{96l+79}{864} & -\frac{480l+1607}{432}\\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\
\frac{112l+289}{108} & \frac{112l+113}{54} & \frac{176l+431}{144} & \frac{176l+85}{72}
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(38)} F 76 = − 108 192 l + 623 − 36 7 0 0 9 8 ( 2 l + 5 ) − 24 16 l + 29 − 648 48 l + 29 0 0 108 112 l + 289 − 54 48 l − 31 18 143 0 0 9 2 ( 16 l + 11 ) 0 324 240 l + 589 0 0 54 112 l + 113 − 16 3 ( 16 l + 29 ) − 144 48 l + 29 0 0 − 3 2 ( 21 + 5 ) 864 11 ( 96 l + 199 ) 864 96 l + 79 0 0 144 176 l + 431 0 72 240 l + 589 0 0 − 6 16 l + 11 432 48 l − 31 − 432 480 l + 1607 0 0 72 176 l + 85 . (38)
The dimension-six block of J \mathbf{J} J , eq. (9) , is
J 66 = ( − 16 3 16 3 − 3 ( 2 l + 7 ) 2 − 2 0 8 ( 3 l + 4 ) 3 − 3 2 3 ( 2 l + 1 ) 2 − 2 l + 7 3 − 4 9 66 l + 113 12 − 3 − 1 3 2 l + 1 3 − 1 4 30 l + 41 12 ) . (39) \mathbf{J}_{66}=
\begin{pmatrix}
-\frac{16}{3} & \frac{16}{3} & -\frac{3(2l+7)}{2} & -2\\
0 & \frac{8(3l+4)}{3} & -\frac{3}{2} & \frac{3(2l+1)}{2}\\
-\frac{2l+7}{3} & -\frac{4}{9} & \frac{66l+113}{12} & -3\\
-\frac{1}{3} & \frac{2l+1}{3} & -\frac{1}{4} & \frac{30l+41}{12}
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(39)} J 66 = − 3 16 0 − 3 2 l + 7 − 3 1 3 16 3 8 ( 3 l + 4 ) − 9 4 3 2 l + 1 − 2 3 ( 2 l + 7 ) − 2 3 12 66 l + 113 − 4 1 − 2 2 3 ( 2 l + 1 ) − 3 12 30 l + 41 . (39)
The block J 67 \mathbf{J}_{67} J 67 , transposed, is
( J 67 ) T = ( − 4 ( 6 l + 5 ) 3 0 16 9 2 l + 7 9 − 4 ( 2 l + 7 ) 3 − 16 3 0 6 l + 5 9 − 4 ( 2 l + 1 ) 3 8 3 8 9 − 2 l + 1 9 16 3 0 8 9 − 2 l + 5 9 − 2 ( 2 l + 9 ) 9 − 2 l + 5 9 2 l − 9 27 2 l + 23 54 8 2 l + 7 2 6 l − 11 6 − 2 l + 7 6 0 6 l + 5 2 2 l + 7 6 − 6 l + 1 6 4 − 2 l + 1 2 2 l − 7 6 2 l − 1 6 4 − 2 l + 5 2 − 2 2 l + 5 6 − 8 l + 27 3 2 l + 5 12 − 2 l + 9 36 − 5 l + 17 18 ) . (40) (\mathbf{J}_{67})^{T} =
\begin{pmatrix}
-\frac{4(6l+5)}{3} & 0 & \frac{16}{9} & \frac{2l+7}{9} \\
-\frac{4(2l+7)}{3} & -\frac{16}{3} & 0 & \frac{6l+5}{9} \\
-\frac{4(2l+1)}{3} & \frac{8}{3} & \frac{8}{9} & -\frac{2l+1}{9} \\
\frac{16}{3} & 0 & \frac{8}{9} & -\frac{2l+5}{9} \\
-\frac{2(2l+9)}{9} & -\frac{2l+5}{9} & \frac{2l-9}{27} & \frac{2l+23}{54} \\
8 & \frac{2l+7}{2} & \frac{6l-11}{6} & -\frac{2l+7}{6} \\
0 & \frac{6l+5}{2} & \frac{2l+7}{6} & -\frac{6l+1}{6} \\
4 & -\frac{2l+1}{2} & \frac{2l-7}{6} & \frac{2l-1}{6} \\
4 & -\frac{2l+5}{2} & -2 & \frac{2l+5}{6} \\
-\frac{8l+27}{3} & \frac{2l+5}{12} & -\frac{2l+9}{36} & -\frac{5l+17}{18}
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(40)} ( J 67 ) T = − 3 4 ( 6 l + 5 ) − 3 4 ( 2 l + 7 ) − 3 4 ( 2 l + 1 ) 3 16 − 9 2 ( 2 l + 9 ) 8 0 4 4 − 3 8 l + 27 0 − 3 16 3 8 0 − 9 2 l + 5 2 2 l + 7 2 6 l + 5 − 2 2 l + 1 − 2 2 l + 5 12 2 l + 5 9 16 0 9 8 9 8 27 2 l − 9 6 6 l − 11 6 2 l + 7 6 2 l − 7 − 2 − 36 2 l + 9 9 2 l + 7 9 6 l + 5 − 9 2 l + 1 − 9 2 l + 5 54 2 l + 23 − 6 2 l + 7 − 6 6 l + 1 6 2 l − 1 6 2 l + 5 − 18 5 l + 17 . (40)
J 67 \mathbf{J}_{67} J 67 does not depend on the dimension-seven evanescent convention. With columns in the order of P \mathbf{P} P , J 77 \mathbf{J}_{77} J 77 is
J 77 = ( − 16 3 − 8 3 0 − 1 2 − 2 ( 24 l + 95 ) 81 − 5 l + 16 34 1 3 32 l + 123 24 16 l + 35 8 13 ( 48 l + 37 ) 432 0 8 ( 3 l + 4 ) 81 0 1 2 163 162 5 3 5 ( 6 l + 17 ) 18 − 2 ( 3 l + 10 ) 9 9 l + 101 72 − 515 432 0 0 2 ( 12 l + 17 ) 3 4 3 0 0 0 3 2 − 6 l − 7 0 0 0 − 16 ( l + 2 ) 3 − 2 ( 4 l + 9 ) 3 0 0 0 − 2 ( 2 l + 3 ) 8 l − 3 2 0 16 9 16 9 − 1 3 − 8 l + 17 3 2 ( 4 l + 7 ) 9 − 4 3 − 4 3 1 4 8 l + 17 6 − 23 36 − 2 ( 5 l + 16 ) 27 2 27 32 l + 123 108 16 l + 35 36 624 l − 131 1944 38 l + 205 36 13 18 − 52 l + 21 36 − 32 l + 67 48 − 1392 l + 3215 1296 10 27 5 ( 6 l + 17 ) 81 − 4 ( 3 l + 10 ) 81 9 l + 101 324 − 216 l − 53 972 − 1 18 114 l − 37 108 66 l + 67 54 − 240 l − 13 432 432 l + 3017 2592 0 0 1 3 − 2 ( 6 l + 7 ) 9 0 0 0 6 l + 19 3 − 6 l − 13 6 0 0 0 − 4 ( 2 l + 3 ) 9 8 l − 3 9 0 0 0 12 l + 29 6 8 l + 5 0 18 l + 37 27 − 18 l − 19 27 12 l + 29 9 − 16 l + 31 18 − 23 72 − 18 l − 35 36 18 l + 53 36 − 24 l + 67 24 − 28 l + 61 12 10 l + 11 24 ) . (41) \mathbf{J}_{77} =
\begin{pmatrix}
-\frac{16}{3} & -\frac{8}{3} & 0 & -\frac{1}{2} & -\frac{2(24l+95)}{81} & -\frac{5l+16}{34} & \frac{1}{3} & \frac{32l+123}{24} & \frac{16l+35}{8} & \frac{13(48l+37)}{432} \\
0 & \frac{8(3l+4)}{81} & 0 & \frac{1}{2} & \frac{163}{162} & \frac{5}{3} & \frac{5(6l+17)}{18} & -\frac{2(3l+10)}{9} & \frac{9l+101}{72} & -\frac{515}{432} \\
0 & 0 & \frac{2(12l+17)}{3} & \frac{4}{3} & 0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{3}{2} & -6l-7 & 0 \\
0 & 0 & -\frac{16(l+2)}{3} & -\frac{2(4l+9)}{3} & 0 & 0 & 0 & -2(2l+3) & \frac{8l-3}{2} & 0 \\
\frac{16}{9} & \frac{16}{9} & -\frac{1}{3} & -\frac{8l+17}{3} & \frac{2(4l+7)}{9} & -\frac{4}{3} & -\frac{4}{3} & \frac{1}{4} & \frac{8l+17}{6} & -\frac{23}{36} \\
-\frac{2(5l+16)}{27} & \frac{2}{27} & \frac{32l+123}{108} & \frac{16l+35}{36} & \frac{624l-131}{1944} & \frac{38l+205}{36} & \frac{13}{18} & -\frac{52l+21}{36} & -\frac{32l+67}{48} & -\frac{1392l+3215}{1296} \\
\frac{10}{27} & \frac{5(6l+17)}{81} & -\frac{4(3l+10)}{81} & \frac{9l+101}{324} & -\frac{216l-53}{972} & -\frac{1}{18} & \frac{114l-37}{108} & \frac{66l+67}{54} & -\frac{240l-13}{432} & \frac{432l+3017}{2592} \\
0 & 0 & \frac{1}{3} & -\frac{2(6l+7)}{9} & 0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{6l+19}{3} & -\frac{6l-13}{6} & 0 \\
0 & 0 & -\frac{4(2l+3)}{9} & \frac{8l-3}{9} & 0 & 0 & 0 & \frac{12l+29}{6} & 8l+5 & 0 \\
\frac{18l+37}{27} & -\frac{18l-19}{27} & \frac{12l+29}{9} & -\frac{16l+31}{18} & -\frac{23}{72} & -\frac{18l-35}{36} & \frac{18l+53}{36} & -\frac{24l+67}{24} & -\frac{28l+61}{12} & \frac{10l+11}{24}
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(41)} J 77 = − 3 16 0 0 0 9 16 − 27 2 ( 5 l + 16 ) 27 10 0 0 27 18 l + 37 − 3 8 81 8 ( 3 l + 4 ) 0 0 9 16 27 2 81 5 ( 6 l + 17 ) 0 0 − 27 18 l − 19 0 0 3 2 ( 12 l + 17 ) − 3 16 ( l + 2 ) − 3 1 108 32 l + 123 − 81 4 ( 3 l + 10 ) 3 1 − 9 4 ( 2 l + 3 ) 9 12 l + 29 − 2 1 2 1 3 4 − 3 2 ( 4 l + 9 ) − 3 8 l + 17 36 16 l + 35 324 9 l + 101 − 9 2 ( 6 l + 7 ) 9 8 l − 3 − 18 16 l + 31 − 81 2 ( 24 l + 95 ) 162 163 0 0 9 2 ( 4 l + 7 ) 1944 624 l − 131 − 972 216 l − 53 0 0 − 72 23 − 34 5 l + 16 3 5 0 0 − 3 4 36 38 l + 205 − 18 1 0 0 − 36 18 l − 35 3 1 18 5 ( 6 l + 17 ) 0 0 − 3 4 18 13 108 114 l − 37 0 0 36 18 l + 53 24 32 l + 123 − 9 2 ( 3 l + 10 ) 2 3 − 2 ( 2 l + 3 ) 4 1 − 36 52 l + 21 54 66 l + 67 3 6 l + 19 6 12 l + 29 − 24 24 l + 67 8 16 l + 35 72 9 l + 101 − 6 l − 7 2 8 l − 3 6 8 l + 17 − 48 32 l + 67 − 432 240 l − 13 − 6 6 l − 13 8 l + 5 − 12 28 l + 61 432 13 ( 48 l + 37 ) − 432 515 0 0 − 36 23 − 1296 1392 l + 3215 2592 432 l + 3017 0 0 24 10 l + 11 . (41)
A worked example: emission from the light quark
For illustration, we set c 2 = 0 c_2=0 c 2 = 0 , so that only the term c 1 2 c_1^2 c 1 2 of eq. (2) contributes. Consider the forward graph in which the light spectator emits and reabsorbs the gluon, Figure 8 , with p p p , r r r the momenta of the incoming c c c , u ˉ \bar{u} u ˉ , k k k , k ′ k' k ′ those of the cut s s s , d ˉ \bar{d} d ˉ and q q q that of the gluon, and with all quarks except the charm massless. It is the graph real u u u –u u u of the page charm_nlo_diagrams.html, which evaluates it with the three cuts combined. Its discontinuity has three cuts. The real-gluon cut C g C_g C g crosses k k k , k ′ k' k ′ and the gluon. The light-quark cuts C L C_L C L and C R C_R C R cross k k k , k ′ k' k ′ and one light-quark propagator, with the gluon uncut. We follow the graph to first soft order, which gives its dimension-seven terms.
Figure 8. Gluon emission and reabsorption by the light spectator, with the real-gluon cut C g C_g C g and the light-quark cuts C L C_L C L and C R C_R C R .
Up to constant factors, collected in eq. (A.28) below, the forward amplitude of the graph is the two-loop integral
T u u = ∫ d d k d d g N ( k 2 + i 0 ) ( k ′ 2 + i 0 ) ( t + i 0 ) ( Δ u + i 0 ) 2 , (42) \mathcal{T}_{uu}=\int d^d k\,d^d g\,
\frac{\mathcal{N}}{(k^2+i0)(k'^2+i0)(t+i0)(\Delta_u+i0)^2}, \tag*{(42)} T uu = ∫ d d k d d g ( k 2 + i 0 ) ( k ′2 + i 0 ) ( t + i 0 ) ( Δ u + i 0 ) 2 N , (42)
N = − [ c ˉ γ ν L k̸ γ ρ L c ] [ q ˉ γ ρ ( r̸ − g̸ ) γ α L ̸ k ′ γ ν ( r̸ − g̸ ) γ α L q ] , \mathcal{N}=-[\bar{c}\gamma^\nu L\!\not{k}\gamma^\rho Lc][\bar{q}\gamma_\rho(\not{r}-\not{g})\gamma_\alpha L\!\not{k}'\gamma_\nu(\not{r}-\not{g})\gamma^\alpha Lq], N = − [ c ˉ γ ν L k γ ρ L c ] [ q ˉ γ ρ ( r − g ) γ α L k ′ γ ν ( r − g ) γ α L q ] ,
with k ′ = K − k − g k'=K-k-g k ′ = K − k − g , K = p + r K=p+r K = p + r and t = g 2 t=g^2 t = g 2 . Here Δ u = ( r − g ) 2 = t − 2 r ⋅ g \Delta_u=(r-g)^2=t-2r\cdot g Δ u = ( r − g ) 2 = t − 2 r ⋅ g is the inverse of both light-quark propagators. Summed over the colours of the gluon and the cut quarks, the colour factor of the graph is 4 9 δ i j δ k l + 8 3 t i j A t k l A \frac{4}{9}\delta_{ij}\delta_{kl}+\frac{8}{3}t^A_{ij}t^A_{kl} 9 4 δ ij δ k l + 3 8 t ij A t k l A , with i , j , k , l i,j,k,l i , j , k , l the colours of c ˉ \bar{c} c ˉ , q q q , q ˉ \bar{q} q ˉ and c c c suppressed in N \mathcal{N} N .
To first soft order the propagator factor is
1 ( t + i 0 ) ( Δ u + i 0 ) 2 = 1 ( t + i 0 ) 3 + 4 r ⋅ g ( t + i 0 ) 4 + O ( r 2 ) . (43) \frac{1}{(t+i0)(\Delta_u+i0)^2}=\frac{1}{(t+i0)^3}+\frac{4r\cdot g}{(t+i0)^4}+O(r^2). \tag*{(43)} ( t + i 0 ) ( Δ u + i 0 ) 2 1 = ( t + i 0 ) 3 1 + ( t + i 0 ) 4 4 r ⋅ g + O ( r 2 ) . (43)
The light-quark cuts, Δ u = 0 \Delta_u=0 Δ u = 0 , then coincide with the gluon cut, t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , so the three cuts of Figure 8 merge into one cut through k k k and k ′ k' k ′ , where the propagator factor has poles of third and fourth order, whose discontinuity in t t t is a distribution given by
1 2 π i [ 1 ( t − i 0 ) n + 1 − 1 ( t + i 0 ) n + 1 ] = ( − 1 ) n n ! δ ( n ) ( t ) , (44) \frac{1}{2\pi i}\left[\frac{1}{(t-i0)^{n+1}}-\frac{1}{(t+i0)^{n+1}}\right]=\frac{(-1)^n}{n!}\delta^{(n)}(t), \tag*{(44)} 2 π i 1 [ ( t − i 0 ) n + 1 1 − ( t + i 0 ) n + 1 1 ] = n ! ( − 1 ) n δ ( n ) ( t ) , (44)
∫ d t F ( t ) δ ( n ) ( t ) = ( − 1 ) n F ( n ) ( 0 ) . \int dt\,F(t)\,\delta^{(n)}(t)=(-1)^nF^{(n)}(0). ∫ d t F ( t ) δ ( n ) ( t ) = ( − 1 ) n F ( n ) ( 0 ) .
The cut lines k k k and k ′ k' k ′ give δ + ( k 2 ) δ + ( k ′ 2 ) \delta^+(k^2)\delta^+(k'^2) δ + ( k 2 ) δ + ( k ′2 ) . Of the components of g g g we keep the spatial ones and replace the energy by t = g 2 t=g^2 t = g 2 , so that d d g = d t d d − 1 g / ( 2 g 0 ) d^d g=dt\,d^{d-1}g/(2g^0) d d g = d t d d − 1 g / ( 2 g 0 ) with g 0 = ( g ⃗ 2 + t ) 1 / 2 g^0=(\vec{g}^{\,2}+t)^{1/2} g 0 = ( g 2 + t ) 1/2 . Then
∫ d d k d d k ′ d d g δ + ( k 2 ) δ + ( k ′ 2 ) ⋯ = ( 2 π ) 2 d − 3 ∫ d t ∫ d Φ 3 ( t ) ⋯ , (45) \int d^d k\,d^d k'\,d^d g\,\delta^+(k^2)\delta^+(k'^2)\cdots=(2\pi)^{2d-3}\int dt\int d\Phi_3(t)\cdots, \tag*{(45)} ∫ d d k d d k ′ d d g δ + ( k 2 ) δ + ( k ′2 ) ⋯ = ( 2 π ) 2 d − 3 ∫ d t ∫ d Φ 3 ( t ) ⋯ , (45)
d Φ 3 ( t ) = ( 2 π ) d δ d ( K − k − k ′ − g ) ∏ q = k , k ′ , g d d − 1 q ( 2 π ) d − 1 2 q 0 , d\Phi_3(t)=(2\pi)^d\delta^d(K-k-k'-g)\prod_{q=k,k',g}\frac{d^{d-1}q}{(2\pi)^{d-1}2q^0}, d Φ 3 ( t ) = ( 2 π ) d δ d ( K − k − k ′ − g ) q = k , k ′ , g ∏ ( 2 π ) d − 1 2 q 0 d d − 1 q ,
where d Φ 3 ( t ) d\Phi_3(t) d Φ 3 ( t ) is the standard phase space of three particles with momenta k k k , k ′ k' k ′ , g g g and masses 0 0 0 , 0 0 0 , t \sqrt{t} t . The propagator factor of eq. (A.21) depends on g g g only through t t t and the numerator r ⋅ g r\cdot g r ⋅ g , so by eq. (A.22) the three cuts together give derivatives in t t t , at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , of the integral over d Φ 3 ( t ) d\Phi_3(t) d Φ 3 ( t ) . In the rest frame of K K K we use a = 2 k ⋅ g a=2k\cdot g a = 2 k ⋅ g , b = 2 k ′ ⋅ g b=2k'\cdot g b = 2 k ′ ⋅ g and the orientation of k k k , k ′ k' k ′ and g g g as variables, so that
d Φ 3 ( t ) = ( 4 π ) 2 ϵ 128 π 3 Γ ( 2 − 2 ϵ ) ( K 2 ) ϵ − 1 G ( K 2 , t ; a , b ) − ϵ d a d b d Ω Ω , (46) d\Phi_3(t)=\frac{(4\pi)^{2\epsilon}}{128\pi^3\Gamma(2-2\epsilon)}(K^2)^{\epsilon-1}\mathcal{G}(K^2,t;a,b)^{-\epsilon}\,da\,db\,\frac{d\Omega}{\Omega}, \tag*{(46)} d Φ 3 ( t ) = 128 π 3 Γ ( 2 − 2 ϵ ) ( 4 π ) 2 ϵ ( K 2 ) ϵ − 1 G ( K 2 , t ; a , b ) − ϵ d a d b Ω d Ω , (46)
G ( K 2 , t ; a , b ) = ( K 2 − t − a − b ) [ a b − t ( K 2 − t − a − b ) ] . \mathcal{G}(K^2,t;a,b)=(K^2-t-a-b)\left[ab-t(K^2-t-a-b)\right]. G ( K 2 , t ; a , b ) = ( K 2 − t − a − b ) [ ab − t ( K 2 − t − a − b ) ] .
where d Ω / Ω d\Omega/\Omega d Ω/Ω is the measure of the orientation, normalized to unit volume, and G = 4 det ( p i ⋅ p j ) \mathcal{G}=4\det(p_i\cdot p_j) G = 4 det ( p i ⋅ p j ) is the Gram determinant of the cut momenta p i = k , k ′ , g p_i=k,k',g p i = k , k ′ , g . We write the integrand at fixed t t t as F / [ ( t + i 0 ) ( Δ u + i 0 ) 2 ] F/[(t+i0)(\Delta_u+i0)^2] F / [( t + i 0 ) ( Δ u + i 0 ) 2 ] , where F F F contains N \mathcal{N} N and d Φ 3 ( t ) d\Phi_3(t) d Φ 3 ( t ) without its constant prefactor. Then
F = ( K 2 ) ϵ − 1 G − ϵ ⟨ N ⟩ (47) F=(K^2)^{\epsilon-1}\mathcal{G}^{-\epsilon}\langle\mathcal{N}\rangle \tag*{(47)} F = ( K 2 ) ϵ − 1 G − ϵ ⟨ N ⟩ (47)
with ⟨ ⋯ ⟩ = ∫ ( d Ω / Ω ) ⋯ \langle\cdots\rangle=\int(d\Omega/\Omega)\cdots ⟨ ⋯ ⟩ = ∫ ( d Ω/Ω ) ⋯ the average over the orientation of the three momenta k k k , k ′ k' k ′ and g g g in the rest frame of K = k + k ′ + g K=k+k'+g K = k + k ′ + g , at fixed a a a , b b b and t t t . The average reduces every tensor in k k k , k ′ k' k ′ and g g g to K μ K^\mu K μ and the metric. For example, ⟨ k μ ⟩ = ( k ⋅ K ) K μ / K 2 \langle k^\mu\rangle=(k\cdot K)K^\mu/K^2 ⟨ k μ ⟩ = ( k ⋅ K ) K μ / K 2 , with k ⋅ K = ( K 2 − b − t ) / 2 k\cdot K=(K^2-b-t)/2 k ⋅ K = ( K 2 − b − t ) /2 fixed by the invariants. We write F = F 0 + F 1 F=F_0+F_1 F = F 0 + F 1 , with F 1 F_1 F 1 linear in r r r . Setting r = 0 r=0 r = 0 gives
F 0 = ( M 2 ) ϵ − 1 G − ϵ ⟨ N 0 ⟩ , N 0 = − [ c ˉ γ ν L k̸ γ α L c ] [ q ˉ γ ρ g̸ γ α L ̸ k ′ γ ν L g γ ρ q ] (48) F_0=(M^2)^{\epsilon-1}\mathcal{G}^{-\epsilon}\langle\mathcal{N}_0\rangle,\qquad\mathcal{N}_0=-[\bar c\gamma^\nu L\not{k}\gamma^\alpha Lc][\bar q\gamma^\rho\not{g}\gamma_\alpha L\not{k}'\gamma_\nu Lg\gamma_\rho q] \tag*{(48)} F 0 = ( M 2 ) ϵ − 1 G − ϵ ⟨ N 0 ⟩ , N 0 = − [ c ˉ γ ν L k γ α L c ] [ q ˉ γ ρ g γ α L k ′ γ ν Lg γ ρ q ] (48)
with G \mathcal{G} G at K 2 = M 2 K^2=M^2 K 2 = M 2 , G = ( H − t ) ( a b − t H + t 2 ) = G 0 − ( a b + H 2 ) t + 2 H t 2 − t 3 \mathcal{G}=(H-t)(ab-tH+t^2)=\mathcal{G}_0-(ab+H^2)t+2Ht^2-t^3 G = ( H − t ) ( ab − t H + t 2 ) = G 0 − ( ab + H 2 ) t + 2 H t 2 − t 3 , where H = M 2 − a − b H=M^2-a-b H = M 2 − a − b and G 0 = a b H \mathcal{G}_0=abH G 0 = ab H . The terms linear in r r r come from the numerators of the light-quark propagators, from the average through K = p + r K=p+r K = p + r and from the measure through K 2 = M 2 + 2 p ⋅ r K^2=M^2+2p\cdot r K 2 = M 2 + 2 p ⋅ r :
F 1 = ( M 2 ) ϵ − 1 G − ϵ { ⟨ N 1 ⟩ + r ⋅ ∂ K ⟨ N 0 ⟩ + 2 p ⋅ r [ ϵ − 1 M 2 − ϵ a b − 2 t ( H − t ) G ] ⟨ N 0 ⟩ } (49) F_1=(M^2)^{\epsilon-1}\mathcal{G}^{-\epsilon}\left\{\langle\mathcal{N}_1\rangle+r\cdot\partial_K\langle\mathcal{N}_0\rangle+2p\cdot r\left[\frac{\epsilon-1}{M^2}-\epsilon\frac{ab-2t(H-t)}{\mathcal{G}}\right]\langle\mathcal{N}_0\rangle\right\} \tag*{(49)} F 1 = ( M 2 ) ϵ − 1 G − ϵ { ⟨ N 1 ⟩ + r ⋅ ∂ K ⟨ N 0 ⟩ + 2 p ⋅ r [ M 2 ϵ − 1 − ϵ G ab − 2 t ( H − t ) ] ⟨ N 0 ⟩ } (49)
N 1 = [ c ˉ γ ν L k̸ γ α L c ] [ q ˉ γ ρ g̸ γ α L ̸ k ′ γ ν L r̸ γ ρ q + q ˉ γ ρ g̸ γ α L ̸ k ′ γ ν L g γ ρ q ] \mathcal{N}_1=[\bar c\gamma^\nu L\not{k}\gamma^\alpha Lc]\left[\bar q\gamma^\rho\not{g}\gamma_\alpha L\not{k}'\gamma_\nu L\not{r}\gamma_\rho q+\bar q\gamma^\rho\not{g}\gamma_\alpha L\not{k}'\gamma_\nu Lg\gamma_\rho q\right] N 1 = [ c ˉ γ ν L k γ α L c ] [ q ˉ γ ρ g γ α L k ′ γ ν L r γ ρ q + q ˉ γ ρ g γ α L k ′ γ ν Lg γ ρ q ]
where a b − 2 t ( H − t ) = ∂ G / ∂ K 2 ab-2t(H-t)=\partial\mathcal{G}/\partial K^2 ab − 2 t ( H − t ) = ∂ G / ∂ K 2 at K 2 = M 2 K^2=M^2 K 2 = M 2 .
At dimension seven the first term of eq. (A.21) multiplies F 1 F_1 F 1 and the second, linear in r r r , multiplies F 0 F_0 F 0 . With n = 2 n=2 n = 2 and n = 3 n=3 n = 3 in eq. (A.22), the contribution of this graph to A 7 ( 1 ) \mathcal{A}^{(1)}_7 A 7 ( 1 ) of eq. (10) , which by eq. (6) is the discontinuity, 2 Im 2\operatorname{Im} 2 Im , of its forward amplitude, is
A 7 , u u ( 1 ) = − 3 8 ( μ 2 M 2 ) ϵ M 4 ϵ − 2 ∫ a , b > 0 , a + b < M 2 d a d b [ 1 2 F 1 ′ ′ ( 0 ) + 2 3 ∂ 3 ∂ t 3 [ ( r ⋅ g ) F 0 ] t = 0 ] (50) \mathcal{A}^{(1)}_{7,uu}=-\frac{3}{8}\left(\frac{\mu^2}{M^2}\right)^\epsilon M^{4\epsilon-2}\int_{a,b>0,\ a+b<M^2}da\,db\left[\frac{1}{2}F_1''(0)+\frac{2}{3}\frac{\partial^3}{\partial t^3}\left[(r\cdot g)F_0\right]_{t=0}\right] \tag*{(50)} A 7 , uu ( 1 ) = − 8 3 ( M 2 μ 2 ) ϵ M 4 ϵ − 2 ∫ a , b > 0 , a + b < M 2 d a d b [ 2 1 F 1 ′′ ( 0 ) + 3 2 ∂ t 3 ∂ 3 [ ( r ⋅ g ) F 0 ] t = 0 ] (50)
with derivatives in t t t at fixed Dalitz variables. The second term comes from the 1 / t 4 1/t^4 1/ t 4 term of eq. (A.21) and has one derivative more. In it, r ⋅ g r\cdot g r ⋅ g is averaged together with N 0 \mathcal{N}_0 N 0 . The prefactor contains the weak vertices, the three-body phase space and g s 2 g_s^2 g s 2 in the MS scheme, divided by the prefactor of eq. (2) and by the d d d -dimensional normalization of the Born phase space. Its sign is the Fermi sign of the antiquark spectator. The pole of A 7 , u u ( 1 ) \mathcal{A}^{(1)}_{7,uu} A 7 , uu ( 1 ) is infrared. Its Dirac structure is projected onto ⟨ P i ⟩ ( 0 ) \langle P_i\rangle^{(0)} ⟨ P i ⟩ ( 0 ) with Π H \Pi_H Π H of eq. (A.6). For the averaged numerators of eqs. (A.26) and (A.27), with s = 2 k ⋅ k ′ = M 2 − a − b − t s=2k\cdot k'=M^2-a-b-t s = 2 k ⋅ k ′ = M 2 − a − b − t , the projections with Π H \Pi_H Π H through O ( ϵ ) O(\epsilon) O ( ϵ ) are given by
Π H ⟨ N 0 ⟩ = 8 3 M 2 { ( a + t ) 2 s + 2 M 2 ( a b − s t ) − ϵ 6 [ 18 ( a + b + 2 t ) 2 s − 10 ( a + t ) 2 s + M 2 ( a b − 55 s t ) ] } ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) − 16 3 M 2 { 2 ( a + t ) 2 s + M 2 ( a b − s t ) − ϵ 6 [ 18 ( a + b + 2 t ) 2 s − 8 ( a + t ) 2 s − M 2 ( a b + 17 s t ) ] } ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) (51) \Pi_H\langle\mathcal{N}_0\rangle=\frac{8}{3M^2}\left\{(a+t)^2s+2M^2(ab-st)-\frac{\epsilon}{6}\left[18(a+b+2t)^2s-10(a+t)^2s+M^2(ab-55st)\right]\right\}\langle Q\rangle^{(0)}
-\frac{16}{3M^2}\left\{2(a+t)^2s+M^2(ab-st)-\frac{\epsilon}{6}\left[18(a+b+2t)^2s-8(a+t)^2s-M^2(ab+17st)\right]\right\}\langle Q_S\rangle^{(0)} \tag*{(51)} Π H ⟨ N 0 ⟩ = 3 M 2 8 { ( a + t ) 2 s + 2 M 2 ( ab − s t ) − 6 ϵ [ 18 ( a + b + 2 t ) 2 s − 10 ( a + t ) 2 s + M 2 ( ab − 55 s t ) ] } ⟨ Q ⟩ ( 0 ) − 3 M 2 16 { 2 ( a + t ) 2 s + M 2 ( ab − s t ) − 6 ϵ [ 18 ( a + b + 2 t ) 2 s − 8 ( a + t ) 2 s − M 2 ( ab + 17 s t ) ] } ⟨ Q S ⟩ ( 0 ) (51)
Π H ⟨ N 1 ⟩ = 8 ϵ 3 [ a b − ( b + 2 t ) s ] ⟨ P 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) . \Pi_H\langle\mathcal{N}_1\rangle=\frac{8\epsilon}{3}\left[ab-(b+2t)s\right]\langle P_1\rangle^{(0)}. Π H ⟨ N 1 ⟩ = 3 8 ϵ [ ab − ( b + 2 t ) s ] ⟨ P 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) .
For μ = M \mu=M μ = M , in units of c 1 2 G F 2 ∣ λ ∣ 2 M 2 / ( 6 π ) c_{1}^{2}G_{F}^{2}|\lambda|^{2}M^{2}/(6\pi) c 1 2 G F 2 ∣ λ ∣ 2 M 2 / ( 6 π ) , the result reads
A 7 , u u ( 1 ) = ( − 8 27 ϵ I R + 22 9 ϵ ϵ I R − 4 27 ) ⟨ P 1 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) + ( 4 27 ϵ ϵ I R + 4 27 ) ⟨ P 2 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) + ( − 16 9 ϵ I R + 44 3 ϵ ϵ I R − 8 9 ) ⟨ P 1 8 ⟩ ( 0 ) + ( 8 9 ϵ ϵ I R + 8 9 ) ⟨ P 2 8 ⟩ ( 0 ) , (52) \mathcal{A}_{7,uu}^{(1)}=\left(-\frac{8}{27\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}+\frac{22}{9}\frac{\epsilon}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}-\frac{4}{27}\right)\langle P_{1}^{1}\rangle^{(0)}+\left(\frac{4}{27}\frac{\epsilon}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}+\frac{4}{27}\right)\langle P_{2}^{1}\rangle^{(0)}
+\left(-\frac{16}{9\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}+\frac{44}{3}\frac{\epsilon}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}-\frac{8}{9}\right)\langle P_{1}^{8}\rangle^{(0)}+\left(\frac{8}{9}\frac{\epsilon}{\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}}+\frac{8}{9}\right)\langle P_{2}^{8}\rangle^{(0)}, \tag*{(52)} A 7 , uu ( 1 ) = ( − 27 ϵ IR 8 + 9 22 ϵ IR ϵ − 27 4 ) ⟨ P 1 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) + ( 27 4 ϵ IR ϵ + 27 4 ) ⟨ P 2 1 ⟩ ( 0 ) + ( − 9 ϵ IR 16 + 3 44 ϵ IR ϵ − 9 8 ) ⟨ P 1 8 ⟩ ( 0 ) + ( 9 8 ϵ IR ϵ + 9 8 ) ⟨ P 2 8 ⟩ ( 0 ) , (52)
which for ϵ / ϵ I R = 1 \epsilon/\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}}=1 ϵ / ϵ IR = 1 are the values of the graph real u u u –u u u in charm_nlo_diagrams.html. Its ϵ / ϵ I R \epsilon/\epsilon_{\mathrm{IR}} ϵ / ϵ IR terms belong to A 7 , I R ( 1 ) ′ \mathcal{A}_{7,\mathrm{IR}}^{(1)\prime} A 7 , IR ( 1 ) ′ of eq. (10) , which cancels in the matching.
Analytical charm coefficients
We give the nonleptonic coefficients of eq. (2) without its prefactor G F 2 ∣ λ ∣ 2 M 2 / ( 6 π ) G_{F}^{2}|\lambda|^{2}M^{2}/(6\pi) G F 2 ∣ λ ∣ 2 M 2 / ( 6 π ) . The cut strange mass is in the same scheme as M M M .
In C i , w s ∣ u d , c ˉ , ( n ) C_{i,w}^{s|ud,\bar{c},(n)} C i , w s ∣ u d , c ˉ , ( n ) , the flavour before the vertical bar labels P i s , c P_{i}^{s,c} P i s , c , and ( u , d ˉ ) (u,\bar{d}) ( u , d ˉ ) is the ordered cut pair. The labels of the four charm channels are listed in Table 7 . The cut masses are fixed by the label and not displayed in the coefficients, whose z z z and scale dependence is also left implicit. The second-current down entry labels the operator flavour even when the corresponding decay particle is an antiquark. Only P 1 , P 2 , P 5 P_{1},P_{2},P_{5} P 1 , P 2 , P 5 contribute for external u , d u,d u , d , since P 3 , 4 u , c = P 3 , 4 d , c = 0 P_{3,4}^{u,c}=P_{3,4}^{d,c}=0 P 3 , 4 u , c = P 3 , 4 d , c = 0 . All five families are retained for s s s .
Table 7. Coefficient labels of the four charm channels. The pair after a label gives ( m / M ) 2 (m/M)^{2} ( m / M ) 2 of the two cut quarks, in the order of the label.
For external d d d , use
C P i , w d ∣ u d ˉ , c , ( n ) = C P i , w s ∣ u d ˉ , c ˉ , ( n ) , C P i , w d ∣ d u , c , ( n ) = C P i , w s ∣ d u , c , ( n ) , C_{P_{i,w}}^{d|u\bar{d},c,(n)}=C_{P_{i,w}}^{s|u\bar{d},\bar{c},(n)},\qquad C_{P_{i,w}}^{d|du,c,(n)}=C_{P_{i,w}}^{s|du,c,(n)}, C P i , w d ∣ u d ˉ , c , ( n ) = C P i , w s ∣ u d ˉ , c ˉ , ( n ) , C P i , w d ∣ d u , c , ( n ) = C P i , w s ∣ d u , c , ( n ) ,
C P i , w d ∣ u s , c ˉ , ( n ) = C P i , w s ∣ u s , c ˉ , ( n ) , C P i , w d ∣ s u , c , ( n ) = C P i , w s ∣ s u , c , ( n ) , (53) C_{P_{i,w}}^{d|us,\bar{c},(n)}=C_{P_{i,w}}^{s|us,\bar{c},(n)},\qquad C_{P_{i,w}}^{d|su,c,(n)}=C_{P_{i,w}}^{s|su,c,(n)}, \tag*{(53)} C P i , w d ∣ u s , c ˉ , ( n ) = C P i , w s ∣ u s , c ˉ , ( n ) , C P i , w d ∣ s u , c , ( n ) = C P i , w s ∣ s u , c , ( n ) , (53)
for n = 0 , 1 n=0,1 n = 0 , 1 . The remaining external-u u u sets follow by weak-row exchange:
C P i , w u ∣ d s , c ˉ , ( n ) = C P i , w ˉ s ∣ u s , c ˉ , ( n ) , C_{P_{i,w}}^{u|ds,\bar{c},(n)}=C_{P_{i,\bar{w}}}^{s|us,\bar{c},(n)}, C P i , w u ∣ d s , c ˉ , ( n ) = C P i , w ˉ s ∣ u s , c ˉ , ( n ) ,
C P i , w u ∣ d d ˉ , c , ( n ) = C P i , w ˉ s ∣ u d ˉ , c , ( n ) , ( 22 ‾ , 12 ‾ , 11 ‾ ) = ( 11 , 12 , 22 ) , (54) C_{P_{i,w}}^{u|d\bar{d},c,(n)}=C_{P_{i,\bar{w}}}^{s|u\bar{d},c,(n)},\qquad(\overline{22},\overline{12},\overline{11})=(11,12,22), \tag*{(54)} C P i , w u ∣ d d ˉ , c , ( n ) = C P i , w ˉ s ∣ u d ˉ , c , ( n ) , ( 22 , 12 , 11 ) = ( 11 , 12 , 22 ) , (54)
for n = 0 , 1 n=0,1 n = 0 , 1 , at fixed cut masses.
The leading-order coefficients use the printed order
( P 1 s , 1 , P 2 s , 1 , P 3 s , 1 , P 4 s , 1 , P 5 s , 1 ; P 1 s , 8 , P 2 s , 8 , P 3 s , 8 , P 4 s , 8 , P 5 s , 8 ) . (55) (P_{1}^{s,1},P_{2}^{s,1},P_{3}^{s,1},P_{4}^{s,1},P_{5}^{s,1};P_{1}^{s,8},P_{2}^{s,8},P_{3}^{s,8},P_{4}^{s,8},P_{5}^{s,8}). \tag*{(55)} ( P 1 s , 1 , P 2 s , 1 , P 3 s , 1 , P 4 s , 1 , P 5 s , 1 ; P 1 s , 8 , P 2 s , 8 , P 3 s , 8 , P 4 s , 8 , P 5 s , 8 ) . (55)
All required LO rows follow from four functions of the squared cut masses, with h i ( 0 , z ) = h i ( z , 0 ) h_i(0,z)=h_i(z,0) h i ( 0 , z ) = h i ( z , 0 ) and β = 1 − 4 z \beta=\sqrt{1-4z} β = 1 − 4 z :
h 1 ( z , 0 ) = 1 − z 3 , h 1 ( z , z ) = 1 − 2 z − 2 z 2 β , h 2 ( z , 0 ) = z 2 ( 1 − z ) , h 2 ( z , z ) = 2 z 2 β 3 , h 3 ( z , 0 ) = ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 1 + 2 z ) , h 3 ( z , z ) = β ( 1 + 2 z ) , h ~ 1 ( z , 0 ) = 1 − z 2 . (56) \begin{aligned}
h_1(z,0)&=1-z^3, & h_1(z,z)&=\frac{1-2z-2z^2}{\beta},\\
h_2(z,0)&=z^2(1-z), & h_2(z,z)&=\frac{2z^2}{\beta^3},\\
h_3(z,0)&=(1-z)^2(1+2z), & h_3(z,z)&=\beta(1+2z),\\
\tilde h_1(z,0)&=1-z^2. \tag*{(56)}
\end{aligned} h 1 ( z , 0 ) h 2 ( z , 0 ) h 3 ( z , 0 ) h ~ 1 ( z , 0 ) = 1 − z 3 , = z 2 ( 1 − z ) , = ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 1 + 2 z ) , = 1 − z 2 . h 1 ( z , z ) h 2 ( z , z ) h 3 ( z , z ) = β 1 − 2 z − 2 z 2 , = β 3 2 z 2 , = β ( 1 + 2 z ) , (56)
The first set is
C 7 , 22 s ∣ u ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 6 h 1 , 18 h 2 , − 3 h 3 , 0 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) , C^{s|\bar u\bar d,(0)}_{7,22}=(6h_1,18h_2,-3h_3,0,0;0,0,0,0,0), C 7 , 22 s ∣ u ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 6 h 1 , 18 h 2 , − 3 h 3 , 0 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) ,
C 7 , 12 s ∣ u ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 4 h 1 , 12 h 2 , − 2 h 3 , 0 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) , C^{s|\bar u\bar d,(0)}_{7,12}=(4h_1,12h_2,-2h_3,0,0;0,0,0,0,0), C 7 , 12 s ∣ u ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 4 h 1 , 12 h 2 , − 2 h 3 , 0 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) ,
C 7 , 11 s ∣ u ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 2 3 h 1 , 2 h 2 , − 1 3 h 3 , 0 , 0 ; 4 h 1 , 12 h 2 , − 2 h 3 , 0 , 0 ) . (57) C^{s|\bar u\bar d,(0)}_{7,11}=\left(\frac{2}{3}h_1,2h_2,-\frac{1}{3}h_3,0,0;4h_1,12h_2,-2h_3,0,0\right). \tag*{(57)} C 7 , 11 s ∣ u ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 3 2 h 1 , 2 h 2 , − 3 1 h 3 , 0 , 0 ; 4 h 1 , 12 h 2 , − 2 h 3 , 0 , 0 ) . (57)
For s ∣ u d ˉ s\mid u\bar d s ∣ u d ˉ the functions are taken at ( 0 , 0 ) (0,0) ( 0 , 0 ) . The same expressions with label s ∣ u s ˉ s\mid u\bar s s ∣ u s ˉ take them at ( 0 , z ) (0,z) ( 0 , z ) . The second set is
C 7 , 22 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 0 ) = C 7 , 11 s ∣ d u , ( 0 ) = ( 2 h ~ 1 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ; 12 h ~ 1 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) , C^{s|\bar d u,(0)}_{7,22}=C^{s|du,(0)}_{7,11}=(2\tilde h_1,0,0,0,0;12\tilde h_1,0,0,0,0), C 7 , 22 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 0 ) = C 7 , 11 s ∣ d u , ( 0 ) = ( 2 h ~ 1 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ; 12 h ~ 1 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) ,
C 7 , 12 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 0 ) = ( 12 h ~ 1 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) . (58) C^{s|\bar d u,(0)}_{7,12}=(12\tilde h_1,0,0,0,0;0,0,0,0,0). \tag*{(58)} C 7 , 12 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 0 ) = ( 12 h ~ 1 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) . (58)
Use h ~ 1 ( 0 , 0 ) \tilde h_1(0,0) h ~ 1 ( 0 , 0 ) for s ∣ d u s\mid du s ∣ d u and the same expressions with h ~ 1 ( z , 0 ) \tilde h_1(z,0) h ~ 1 ( z , 0 ) for s ∣ s u s\mid su s ∣ s u . External-d d d coefficients follow from eq. (B.1). For external u u u , use the reduced order ( P 1 u , 1 , P 2 u , 1 , P 5 u , 1 ; P 1 u , 8 , P 2 u , 8 , P 5 u , 8 ) (P_1^{u,1},P_2^{u,1},P_5^{u,1};P_1^{u,8},P_2^{u,8},P_5^{u,8}) ( P 1 u , 1 , P 2 u , 1 , P 5 u , 1 ; P 1 u , 8 , P 2 u , 8 , P 5 u , 8 ) :
C 7 , 22 u ∣ s ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 2 3 h 1 , 2 h 2 , 0 ; 4 h 1 , 12 h 2 , 0 ) , C^{u|\bar s\bar d,(0)}_{7,22}=\left(\frac{2}{3}h_1,2h_2,0;4h_1,12h_2,0\right), C 7 , 22 u ∣ s ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 3 2 h 1 , 2 h 2 , 0 ; 4 h 1 , 12 h 2 , 0 ) ,
C 7 , 12 u ∣ s ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 4 h 1 , 12 h 2 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 ) , C^{u|\bar s\bar d,(0)}_{7,12}=(4h_1,12h_2,0;0,0,0), C 7 , 12 u ∣ s ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 4 h 1 , 12 h 2 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 ) ,
C 7 , 11 u ∣ s ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 6 h 1 , 18 h 2 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 ) . (59) C^{u|\bar s\bar d,(0)}_{7,11}=(6h_1,18h_2,0;0,0,0). \tag*{(59)} C 7 , 11 u ∣ s ˉ d ˉ , ( 0 ) = ( 6 h 1 , 18 h 2 , 0 ; 0 , 0 , 0 ) . (59)
These rows take the functions at ( z , 0 ) (z,0) ( z , 0 ) . The same expressions with label u ∣ s s ˉ u\mid s\bar s u ∣ s s ˉ take them at ( z , z ) (z,z) ( z , z ) . The two remaining external-u u u sets follow from eq. (B.2). Both colours of P 4 P_4 P 4 and P 5 P_5 P 5 have zero Born coefficients but nonzero NLO coefficients.
Next-to-leading-order nonleptonic coefficients
The displays below give C ( 1 ) C^{(1)} C ( 1 ) , grouped by the cut masses. One massive cut line has 0 < z < 1 0<z<1 0 < z < 1 . The s s ˉ s\bar s s s ˉ cut has 0 < z < 1 / 4 0<z<1/4 0 < z < 1/4 . We use the principal dilogarithm and its real part on the cut, with
H ( z ) = 2 Li 2 ( z ) + log z log ( 1 − z ) . (60) H(z)=2\operatorname{Li}_2(z)+\log z\log(1-z). \tag*{(60)} H ( z ) = 2 Li 2 ( z ) + log z log ( 1 − z ) . (60)
For external s s s , the massless cuts ( u d ˉ ) (u\bar d) ( u d ˉ ) and ( d u ) (du) ( d u ) give constant and logarithmic coefficients. In the order of eq. (B.3), they read
C 7 , 22 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 1 ) = ( 24 , 0 , 12 l + 6 , 7 , 16 3 l + 113 9 ; 44 l + 331 6 , − 35 3 , − 16 l − 601 12 , − 36 l − 155 4 , − 10 l − 133 24 ) , C^{s|\bar d u,(1)}_{7,22}=\left(24,0,12l+6,7,\frac{16}{3}l+\frac{113}{9};44l+\frac{331}{6},-\frac{35}{3},-16l-\frac{601}{12},-36l-\frac{155}{4},-10l-\frac{133}{24}\right), C 7 , 22 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 1 ) = ( 24 , 0 , 12 l + 6 , 7 , 3 16 l + 9 113 ; 44 l + 6 331 , − 3 35 , − 16 l − 12 601 , − 36 l − 4 155 , − 10 l − 24 133 ) ,
C 7 , 12 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 1 ) = ( − 32 l − 32 3 , 32 3 , 24 l + 32 3 , − 30 , 32 9 l + 466 27 ; 16 3 l + 151 9 , − 11 3 , 4 3 l − 511 18 , − 24 l − 311 6 , − 20 3 l + 707 36 ) , C^{s|\bar d u,(1)}_{7,12}=\left(-32l-\frac{32}{3},\frac{32}{3},24l+\frac{32}{3},-30,\frac{32}{9}l+\frac{466}{27};\frac{16}{3}l+\frac{151}{9},-\frac{11}{3},\frac{4}{3}l-\frac{511}{18},-24l-\frac{311}{6},-\frac{20}{3}l+\frac{707}{36}\right), C 7 , 12 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 1 ) = ( − 32 l − 3 32 , 3 32 , 24 l + 3 32 , − 30 , 9 32 l + 27 466 ; 3 16 l + 9 151 , − 3 11 , 3 4 l − 18 511 , − 24 l − 6 311 , − 3 20 l + 36 707 ) ,
C 7 , 11 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 1 ) = ( − 112 27 l + 158 81 , 26 27 , 116 27 l − 367 81 , − 16 3 l − 446 27 , 8 9 l + 187 18 ; 316 9 l − 8 π 2 + 2467 27 , − 146 9 , − 92 9 l + 4 π 2 − 7535 108 , − 8 l − 190 9 , 10 3 l + 93 8 ) . (61) C^{s|\bar d u,(1)}_{7,11}=\left(-\frac{112}{27}l+\frac{158}{81},\frac{26}{27},\frac{116}{27}l-\frac{367}{81},-\frac{16}{3}l-\frac{446}{27},\frac{8}{9}l+\frac{187}{18};\frac{316}{9}l-8\pi^2+\frac{2467}{27},-\frac{146}{9},-\frac{92}{9}l+4\pi^2-\frac{7535}{108},-8l-\frac{190}{9},\frac{10}{3}l+\frac{93}{8}\right). \tag*{(61)} C 7 , 11 s ∣ d ˉ u , ( 1 ) = ( − 27 112 l + 81 158 , 27 26 , 27 116 l − 81 367 , − 3 16 l − 27 446 , 9 8 l + 18 187 ; 9 316 l − 8 π 2 + 27 2467 , − 9 146 , − 9 92 l + 4 π 2 − 108 7535 , − 8 l − 9 190 , 3 10 l + 8 93 ) . (61)
and
C 7 , 22 s ∣ d u , ( 1 ) = C 7 , 11 s ∣ d u , ( 1 ) = ( − 112 3 l − 64 9 π 2 − 80 3 , 4 3 , − 16 9 l − 127 9 , − 16 3 l − 104 9 , 8 3 l + 31 2 ; 316 3 l − 56 3 π 2 + 193 , − 4 , 76 3 l − 47 12 , 4 l + 8 3 , 10 l + 263 8 ) , C 7 , 12 s ∣ d u , ( 1 ) = ( − 64 3 π 2 + 560 9 , 32 3 , − 16 9 , 6 , 32 3 l + 356 9 ; − 56 l − 16 π 2 − 500 3 , − 2 , − 8 l − 373 6 , − 24 l − 113 2 , − 20 l + 121 2 ) . (62) \begin{aligned}
C_{7,22}^{s|du,(1)} &= C_{7,11}^{s|du,(1)} = \left(-\frac{112}{3}l-\frac{64}{9}\pi^2-\frac{80}{3},\frac{4}{3},-\frac{16}{9}l-\frac{127}{9},-\frac{16}{3}l-\frac{104}{9},\frac{8}{3}l+\frac{31}{2};\right.\\
&\qquad\left.\frac{316}{3}l-\frac{56}{3}\pi^2+193,-4,\frac{76}{3}l-\frac{47}{12},4l+\frac{8}{3},10l+\frac{263}{8}\right),\\
C_{7,12}^{s|du,(1)} &= \left(-\frac{64}{3}\pi^2+\frac{560}{9},\frac{32}{3},-\frac{16}{9},6,\frac{32}{3}l+\frac{356}{9};\right.\\
&\qquad\left.-56l-16\pi^2-\frac{500}{3},-2,-8l-\frac{373}{6},-24l-\frac{113}{2},-20l+\frac{121}{2}\right). \tag*{(62)}
\end{aligned} C 7 , 22 s ∣ d u , ( 1 ) C 7 , 12 s ∣ d u , ( 1 ) = C 7 , 11 s ∣ d u , ( 1 ) = ( − 3 112 l − 9 64 π 2 − 3 80 , 3 4 , − 9 16 l − 9 127 , − 3 16 l − 9 104 , 3 8 l + 2 31 ; 3 316 l − 3 56 π 2 + 193 , − 4 , 3 76 l − 12 47 , 4 l + 3 8 , 10 l + 8 263 ) , = ( − 3 64 π 2 + 9 560 , 3 32 , − 9 16 , 6 , 3 32 l + 9 356 ; − 56 l − 16 π 2 − 3 500 , − 2 , − 8 l − 6 373 , − 24 l − 2 113 , − 20 l + 2 121 ) . (62)
For external s s s with the cut ( u s ˉ ) (u\bar{s}) ( u s ˉ ) , one cut line is massive:
C P 1 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) H ( z ) − 16 z ( 2 z + 1 ) ( 3 z − 2 ) log z − 48 ( 1 − z ) z ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 + 4 z + 3 ) (63) C_{P_{1,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}=32(1-z)(z^2+z+1)H(z)-16z(2z+1)(3z-2)\log z
-48(1-z)z(2z+1)\log(1-z)+8(1-z)(5z^2+4z+3) \tag*{(63)} C P 1 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) H ( z ) − 16 z ( 2 z + 1 ) ( 3 z − 2 ) log z − 48 ( 1 − z ) z ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 + 4 z + 3 ) (63)
C P 2 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 144 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l + 96 ( 1 − z ) z 2 H ( z ) + 32 z 2 ( 3 z 2 − 13 z + 9 ) log z + 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 6 z 3 − 20 z 2 + 4 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 1 − z ) z ( 3 z − 7 ) (64) C_{P_{2,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}=-144(1-z)z^2l+96(1-z)z^2H(z)+32z^2(3z^2-13z+9)\log z
+16(1-z)(6z^3-20z^2+4z+1)\log(1-z)+8(1-z)z(3z-7) \tag*{(64)} C P 2 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 144 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l + 96 ( 1 − z ) z 2 H ( z ) + 32 z 2 ( 3 z 2 − 13 z + 9 ) log z + 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 6 z 3 − 20 z 2 + 4 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 1 − z ) z ( 3 z − 7 ) (64)
C P 3 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 12 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) l − 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) H ( z ) + 8 z ( 3 z 3 − 16 z 2 + 17 z − 2 ) log z − 8 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 3 z 2 − 10 z − 2 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 14 z 2 − 9 z + 3 ) (65) \begin{aligned}
C_{P_{3,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}={}&12(1-z)^2(2z+1)l-16(1-z)^2(2z+1)H(z)\\
&+8z(3z^3-16z^2+17z-2)\log z-8(1-z)^2(3z^2-10z-2)\log(1-z)\\
&+2(1-z)(14z^2-9z+3) \tag*{(65)}
\end{aligned} C P 3 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 12 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) l − 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) H ( z ) + 8 z ( 3 z 3 − 16 z 2 + 17 z − 2 ) log z − 8 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 3 z 2 − 10 z − 2 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 14 z 2 − 9 z + 3 ) (65)
C P 4 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 7 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) (66) C_{P_{4,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}=7(1-z)^2(2z+1) \tag*{(66)} C P 4 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 7 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) (66)
C P 5 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l + 2 z 2 ( 5 z − 13 ) 3 log z − 20 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 9 log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 148 z 2 − 204 z − 113 ) 9 (67) C_{P_{5,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}=\frac{16(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l+\frac{2z^2(5z-13)}{3}\log z-\frac{20(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{9}\log(1-z)-\frac{(1-z)(148z^2-204z-113)}{9} \tag*{(67)} C P 5 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 3 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 3 2 z 2 ( 5 z − 13 ) log z − 9 20 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 ( 1 − z ) ( 148 z 2 − 204 z − 113 ) (67)
C P 1 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 44 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l − z 2 ( 59 z + 9 ) log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 28 z 2 + 37 z + 37 ) log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 637 z 2 + 382 z + 331 ) 6 (68) C_{P_{1,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}=44(1-z)(z^2+z+1)l-z^2(59z+9)\log z-2(1-z)(28z^2+37z+37)\log(1-z)+\frac{(1-z)(637z^2+382z+331)}{6} \tag*{(68)} C P 1 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 44 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l − z 2 ( 59 z + 9 ) log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 28 z 2 + 37 z + 37 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 637 z 2 + 382 z + 331 ) (68)
C P 2 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 72 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 3 z 2 ( 59 z − 51 ) log z − 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 28 z 2 + 3 z + 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 459 z 2 − 200 z − 35 ) 2 (69) C_{P_{2,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}=72(1-z)z^2l-3z^2(59z-51)\log z-6(1-z)(28z^2+3z+3)\log(1-z)+\frac{(1-z)(459z^2-200z-35)}{2} \tag*{(69)} C P 2 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 72 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 3 z 2 ( 59 z − 51 ) log z − 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 28 z 2 + 3 z + 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 459 z 2 − 200 z − 35 ) (69)
C P 3 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 4 z − 4 ) l − z 2 ( 47 z − 63 ) log z + 22 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 1169 z 2 − 1003 z − 601 ) 12 (70) \begin{aligned}
C_{P_{3,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}={}&4(1-z)(5z^2-4z-4)l-z^2(47z-63)\log z\\
&+22(1-z)^2(2z+1)\log(1-z)+\frac{(1-z)(1169z^2-1003z-601)}{12} \tag*{(70)}
\end{aligned} C P 3 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 4 z − 4 ) l − z 2 ( 47 z − 63 ) log z + 22 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 12 ( 1 − z ) ( 1169 z 2 − 1003 z − 601 ) (70)
C P 4 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 36 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 3 z 2 ( 4 z − 9 ) log z − 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 − 3 z − 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 90 z 2 + 311 z + 155 ) 4 (71) C_{P_{4,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}=-36(1-z)(z+1)l-3z^2(4z-9)\log z-6(1-z)(2z^2-3z-3)\log(1-z)-\frac{(1-z)(90z^2+311z+155)}{4} \tag*{(71)} C P 4 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 36 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 3 z 2 ( 4 z − 9 ) log z − 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 − 3 z − 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 90 z 2 + 311 z + 155 ) (71)
C P 5 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) l − z 2 ( 5 z − 13 ) 2 log z + 5 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 3 log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 578 z 2 − 315 z − 133 ) 24 (72) C_{P_{5,22}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}=-2(1-z)(3z^2+5z+5)l-\frac{z^2(5z-13)}{2}\log z+\frac{5(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{3}\log(1-z)+\frac{(1-z)(578z^2-315z-133)}{24} \tag*{(72)} C P 5 , 22 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) l − 2 z 2 ( 5 z − 13 ) log z + 3 5 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 24 ( 1 − z ) ( 578 z 2 − 315 z − 133 ) (72)
C P 1 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l − 32 z ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z − 1 ) 3 H ( z ) − 4 z 2 ( 51 z + 44 ) 3 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 27 z 4 + 31 z 3 − z 2 + 3 z − 4 ) 3 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 32 z ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z − 1 ) 9 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 91 z 3 + 57 z 2 + 18 z − 8 ) 3 z (73) \begin{aligned}
C_{P_{1,12}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}={}&-32(1-z)(z^2+z+1)l-\frac{32z(z+1)(2z-1)}{3}H(z)-\frac{4z^2(51z+44)}{3}\log z\\
&-\frac{4(1-z)(27z^4+31z^3-z^2+3z-4)}{3z^2}\log(1-z)+\frac{32z(z+1)(2z-1)}{9}\pi^2\\
&-\frac{2(1-z)(91z^3+57z^2+18z-8)}{3z} \tag*{(73)}
\end{aligned} C P 1 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l − 3 32 z ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z − 1 ) H ( z ) − 3 4 z 2 ( 51 z + 44 ) log z − 3 z 2 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 27 z 4 + 31 z 3 − z 2 + 3 z − 4 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 9 32 z ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z − 1 ) π 2 − 3 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 91 z 3 + 57 z 2 + 18 z − 8 ) (73)
C P 2 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 192 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) 3 H ( z ) + 4 z 2 ( 48 z 2 − 217 z + 56 ) 3 log z + 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 48 z 4 − 97 z 3 − z 2 − z − 5 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) + 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) 9 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 369 z 2 + 23 z − 6 ) 3 (74) \begin{aligned}
C_{P_{2,12}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}={}&-192(1-z)z^2l-\frac{32z(6z^2-3z-1)}{3}H(z)+\frac{4z^2(48z^2-217z+56)}{3}\log z\\
&+\frac{4(1-z)(48z^4-97z^3-z^2-z-5)}{3z}\log(1-z)+\frac{32z(6z^2-3z-1)}{9}\pi^2\\
&-\frac{2(1-z)(369z^2+23z-6)}{3} \tag*{(74)}
\end{aligned} C P 2 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 192 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 3 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) H ( z ) + 3 4 z 2 ( 48 z 2 − 217 z + 56 ) log z + 3 z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 48 z 4 − 97 z 3 − z 2 − z − 5 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 9 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) π 2 − 3 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 369 z 2 + 23 z − 6 ) (74)
C P 3 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 24 ( 1 − z ) 2 ⋅ ( 2 z + 1 ) l + 64 ( 1 − z ) z 2 3 H ( z ) + 4 z 2 ⋅ ( 12 z 2 − 67 z + 51 ) 3 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ⋅ ( 12 z 4 − 19 z 3 − 5 z 2 + 5 z − 1 ) 3 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 64 ( 1 − z ) z 2 9 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 103 z 3 − 88 z 2 − 5 z − 2 ) 3 z (75) C^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}_{P_{3,12}} = 24(1-z)^2\cdot(2z+1)\,l + \frac{64(1-z)z^2}{3}H(z) + \frac{4z^2\cdot(12z^2-67z+51)}{3}\log z
- \frac{4(1-z)^2\cdot(12z^4-19z^3-5z^2+5z-1)}{3z^2}\log(1-z) - \frac{64(1-z)z^2}{9}\pi^2
- \frac{2(1-z)(103z^3-88z^2-5z-2)}{3z} \tag*{(75)} C P 3 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 24 ( 1 − z ) 2 ⋅ ( 2 z + 1 ) l + 3 64 ( 1 − z ) z 2 H ( z ) + 3 4 z 2 ⋅ ( 12 z 2 − 67 z + 51 ) log z − 3 z 2 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ⋅ ( 12 z 4 − 19 z 3 − 5 z 2 + 5 z − 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 64 ( 1 − z ) z 2 π 2 − 3 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 103 z 3 − 88 z 2 − 5 z − 2 ) (75)
C P 4 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 32 z 3 H ( z ) + 16 z 2 log z + 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z − 1 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) + 32 z 9 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 14 z 2 + 5 z + 61 ) 3 (76) C^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}_{P_{4,12}} = -\frac{32z}{3}H(z) + 16z^2\log z + \frac{32(1-z)(z^2+z-1)}{3z}\log(1-z) + \frac{32z}{9}\pi^2
- \frac{2(1-z)(14z^2+5z+61)}{3} \tag*{(76)} C P 4 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 3 32 z H ( z ) + 16 z 2 log z + 3 z 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z − 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 9 32 z π 2 − 3 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 14 z 2 + 5 z + 61 ) (76)
C P 5 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 9 l + 32 ( 1 − z ) z 9 H ( z ) + 4 z 2 ( 4 z − 17 ) 9 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 17 z 3 + 4 z 2 + 3 z + 12 ) 27 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 32 ( 1 − z ) z 27 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 151 z 3 − 75 z 2 − 239 z + 24 ) 27 z (77) C^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}_{P_{5,12}} = \frac{32(1-z)(z+1)}{9}\,l + \frac{32(1-z)z}{9}H(z) + \frac{4z^2(4z-17)}{9}\log z
- \frac{4(1-z)^2(17z^3+4z^2+3z+12)}{27z^2}\log(1-z) - \frac{32(1-z)z}{27}\pi^2
- \frac{2(1-z)(151z^3-75z^2-239z+24)}{27z} \tag*{(77)} C P 5 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 9 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 9 32 ( 1 − z ) z H ( z ) + 9 4 z 2 ( 4 z − 17 ) log z − 27 z 2 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 17 z 3 + 4 z 2 + 3 z + 12 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 27 32 ( 1 − z ) z π 2 − 27 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 151 z 3 − 75 z 2 − 239 z + 24 ) (77)
C P 1 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) 3 l − 8 ( z 2 − z + 2 ) H ( z ) − z ( 127 z 2 + 174 z + 48 ) 3 log z − ( 1 − z ) ( 49 z 4 + 169 z 3 + 145 z 2 + 9 z − 12 ) 3 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 8 z ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z − 1 ) 3 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 95 z 3 − 37 z 2 + 284 z + 72 ) 18 z (78) C^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}_{P_{1,12}} = \frac{16(1-z)(z^2+z+1)}{3}\,l - 8(z^2-z+2)H(z)
- \frac{z(127z^2+174z+48)}{3}\log z - \frac{(1-z)(49z^4+169z^3+145z^2+9z-12)}{3z^2}\log(1-z)
+ \frac{8z(z+1)(2z-1)}{3}\pi^2 + \frac{(1-z)(95z^3-37z^2+284z+72)}{18z} \tag*{(78)} C P 1 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l − 8 ( z 2 − z + 2 ) H ( z ) − 3 z ( 127 z 2 + 174 z + 48 ) log z − 3 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 49 z 4 + 169 z 3 + 145 z 2 + 9 z − 12 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 3 8 z ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z − 1 ) π 2 + 18 z ( 1 − z ) ( 95 z 3 − 37 z 2 + 284 z + 72 ) (78)
C P 2 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 24 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 8 z ( 3 z − 1 ) H ( z ) − z 2 ( 127 z − 14 ) log z − ( 1 − z ) ( 49 z 3 + 45 z 2 + 21 z + 5 ) z log ( 1 − z ) + 8 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) 3 π 2 − ( 1 − z ) ( 261 z 2 + 301 z + 52 ) 6 (79) C^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}_{P_{2,12}} = -24(1-z)z^2l - 8z(3z-1)H(z) - z^2(127z-14)\log z
- \frac{(1-z)(49z^3+45z^2+21z+5)}{z}\log(1-z) + \frac{8z(6z^2-3z-1)}{3}\pi^2
- \frac{(1-z)(261z^2+301z+52)}{6} \tag*{(79)} C P 2 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 24 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 8 z ( 3 z − 1 ) H ( z ) − z 2 ( 127 z − 14 ) log z − z ( 1 − z ) ( 49 z 3 + 45 z 2 + 21 z + 5 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 3 8 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) π 2 − 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 261 z 2 + 301 z + 52 ) (79)
C P 3 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 8 z 2 − z − 1 ) 3 l + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) H ( z ) − z ( 103 z 2 − 75 z − 24 ) 3 log z + ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 25 z 3 + 35 z 2 − 15 z + 3 ) 3 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 16 ( 1 − z ) z 2 3 π 2 − ( 1 − z ) ( 10 z 3 + 49 z 2 + 610 z − 18 ) 18 z (80) C^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}_{P_{3,12}} = -\frac{4(1-z)(8z^2-z-1)}{3}\,l + 8(1-z)(z+1)H(z)
- \frac{z(103z^2-75z-24)}{3}\log z + \frac{(1-z)^2(25z^3+35z^2-15z+3)}{3z^2}\log(1-z)
- \frac{16(1-z)z^2}{3}\pi^2 - \frac{(1-z)(10z^3+49z^2+610z-18)}{18z} \tag*{(80)} C P 3 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 3 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 8 z 2 − z − 1 ) l + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) H ( z ) − 3 z ( 103 z 2 − 75 z − 24 ) log z + 3 z 2 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 25 z 3 + 35 z 2 − 15 z + 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 3 16 ( 1 − z ) z 2 π 2 − 18 z ( 1 − z ) ( 10 z 3 + 49 z 2 + 610 z − 18 ) (80)
C P 4 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 24 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 8 z H ( z ) − 2 z 2 ( 4 z − 15 ) log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z 2 − 7 z + 2 ) z log ( 1 − z ) + 8 z 3 π 2 − ( 1 − z ) ( 90 z 2 + 347 z + 359 ) 6 (81) C^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}_{P_{4,12}} = -24(1-z)(z+1)l - 8zH(z) - 2z^2(4z-15)\log z
- \frac{4(1-z)(z+1)(2z^2-7z+2)}{z}\log(1-z) + \frac{8z}{3}\pi^2 - \frac{(1-z)(90z^2+347z+359)}{6} \tag*{(81)} C P 4 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 24 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 8 z H ( z ) − 2 z 2 ( 4 z − 15 ) log z − z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z 2 − 7 z + 2 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 3 8 z π 2 − 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 90 z 2 + 347 z + 359 ) (81)
C P 5 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) 9 l + 28 ( 1 − z ) z 9 H ( z ) − z 2 ( 17 z + 2 ) 9 log z + ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 61 z 3 + 62 z 2 − 21 z − 84 ) 18 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 28 ( 1 − z ) z 9 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 557 z 3 − 1218 z 2 + 749 z − 168 ) 36 z (82) C^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)}_{P_{5,12}} = -\frac{4(1-z)(3z^2+5z+5)}{9}\,l + \frac{28(1-z)z}{9}H(z) - \frac{z^2(17z+2)}{9}\log z
+ \frac{(1-z)^2(61z^3+62z^2-21z-84)}{18z^2}\log(1-z) - \frac{28(1-z)z}{9}\pi^2
+ \frac{(1-z)(557z^3-1218z^2+749z-168)}{36z} \tag*{(82)} C P 5 , 12 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 9 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) l + 9 28 ( 1 − z ) z H ( z ) − 9 z 2 ( 17 z + 2 ) log z + 18 z 2 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 61 z 3 + 62 z 2 − 21 z − 84 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 28 ( 1 − z ) z π 2 + 36 z ( 1 − z ) ( 557 z 3 − 1218 z 2 + 749 z − 168 ) (82)
C P 1 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 112 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) 27 l − 32 ( z 3 + z 2 − z + 1 ) 9 H ( z ) − 4 z ( 140 z 2 + 153 z + 24 ) 27 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 65 z 4 + 131 z 3 + 71 z 2 + 9 z − 12 ) 27 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 32 z ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z − 1 ) 27 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 362 z 3 + 275 z 2 − 61 z − 72 ) 81 z (83) C^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)}_{P_{1,11}} = -\frac{112(1-z)(z^2+z+1)}{27}\,l - \frac{32(z^3+z^2-z+1)}{9}H(z)
- \frac{4z(140z^2+153z+24)}{27}\log z - \frac{4(1-z)(65z^4+131z^3+71z^2+9z-12)}{27z^2}\log(1-z)
+ \frac{32z(z+1)(2z-1)}{27}\pi^2 - \frac{2(1-z)(362z^3+275z^2-61z-72)}{81z} \tag*{(83)} C P 1 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 27 112 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l − 9 32 ( z 3 + z 2 − z + 1 ) H ( z ) − 27 4 z ( 140 z 2 + 153 z + 24 ) log z − 27 z 2 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 65 z 4 + 131 z 3 + 71 z 2 + 9 z − 12 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 27 32 z ( z + 1 ) ( 2 z − 1 ) π 2 − 81 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 362 z 3 + 275 z 2 − 61 z − 72 ) (83)
C P 2 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 112 ( 1 − z ) z 2 3 l − 32 z ( 3 z 2 − 1 ) 9 H ( z ) + 4 z 2 ( 24 z 2 − 172 z + 35 ) 9 log z + 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 24 z 4 − 73 z 3 − 23 z 2 − 11 z − 5 ) 9 z log ( 1 − z ) + 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) 27 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 684 z 2 + 185 z + 17 ) 27 (84) C_{P_{2,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)} = -\frac{112(1-z)z^2}{3}\,l - \frac{32z(3z^2-1)}{9}H(z) + \frac{4z^2(24z^2-172z+35)}{9}\log z
+ \frac{4(1-z)(24z^4-73z^3-23z^2-11z-5)}{9z}\log(1-z) + \frac{32z(6z^2-3z-1)}{27}\pi^2
- \frac{2(1-z)(684z^2+185z+17)}{27} \tag*{(84)} C P 2 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 3 112 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 9 32 z ( 3 z 2 − 1 ) H ( z ) + 9 4 z 2 ( 24 z 2 − 172 z + 35 ) log z + 9 z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 24 z 4 − 73 z 3 − 23 z 2 − 11 z − 5 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 27 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) π 2 − 27 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 684 z 2 + 185 z + 17 ) (84)
C P 3 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 70 z 2 − 29 z − 29 ) 27 l + 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + z + 1 ) 9 H ( z ) + 8 z ( 9 z 3 − 76 z 2 + 57 z + 6 ) 27 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 18 z 4 − 41 z 3 − 25 z 2 + 15 z − 3 ) 27 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 64 ( 1 − z ) z 2 27 π 2 − ( 1 − z ) ( 937 z 3 − 743 z 2 + 565 z − 36 ) 81 z (85) C_{P_{3,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)} = -\frac{4(1-z)(70z^2-29z-29)}{27}\,l + \frac{16(1-z)(2z^2+z+1)}{9}H(z)
+ \frac{8z(9z^3-76z^2+57z+6)}{27}\log z - \frac{4(1-z)^2(18z^4-41z^3-25z^2+15z-3)}{27z^2}\log(1-z)
- \frac{64(1-z)z^2}{27}\pi^2 - \frac{(1-z)(937z^3-743z^2+565z-36)}{81z} \tag*{(85)} C P 3 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 27 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 70 z 2 − 29 z − 29 ) l + 9 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + z + 1 ) H ( z ) + 27 8 z ( 9 z 3 − 76 z 2 + 57 z + 6 ) log z − 27 z 2 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 18 z 4 − 41 z 3 − 25 z 2 + 15 z − 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 27 64 ( 1 − z ) z 2 π 2 − 81 z ( 1 − z ) ( 937 z 3 − 743 z 2 + 565 z − 36 ) (85)
C P 4 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 9 l − 32 z 9 H ( z ) − 4 z 2 ( 4 z − 21 ) 9 log z − 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 3 − 7 z 2 − 7 z + 4 ) 9 z log ( 1 − z ) + 32 z 27 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 66 z 2 + 181 z + 271 ) 27 (86) C_{P_{4,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)} = -\frac{16(1-z)(z+1)}{9}\,l - \frac{32z}{9}H(z) - \frac{4z^2(4z-21)}{9}\log z
- \frac{8(1-z)(2z^3-7z^2-7z+4)}{9z}\log(1-z) + \frac{32z}{27}\pi^2 - \frac{2(1-z)(66z^2+181z+271)}{27} \tag*{(86)} C P 4 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 9 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 9 32 z H ( z ) − 9 4 z 2 ( 4 z − 21 ) log z − 9 z 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 3 − 7 z 2 − 7 z + 4 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 27 32 z π 2 − 27 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 66 z 2 + 181 z + 271 ) (86)
C P 5 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 8 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 9 l − 2 z 2 ( 8 z − 9 ) 9 log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 17 z 3 − 2 z 2 + 3 z + 12 ) 9 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 39 z 3 + 57 z 2 − 199 z + 48 ) 18 z (87) C_{P_{5,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},1,(1)} = \frac{8(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{9}\,l - \frac{2z^2(8z-9)}{9}\log z
- \frac{2(1-z)^2(17z^3-2z^2+3z+12)}{9z^2}\log(1-z) - \frac{(1-z)(39z^3+57z^2-199z+48)}{18z} \tag*{(87)} C P 5 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 9 8 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) l − 9 2 z 2 ( 8 z − 9 ) log z − 9 z 2 2 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 17 z 3 − 2 z 2 + 3 z + 12 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 18 z ( 1 − z ) ( 39 z 3 + 57 z 2 − 199 z + 48 ) (87)
C P 1 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 316 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) 9 l + 8 ( 10 z 3 + z 2 − z − 8 ) 3 H ( z ) − 4 z ( 46 z 2 − 45 z + 48 ) 9 log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 314 z 4 + 497 z 3 + 473 z 2 + 36 z − 48 ) 9 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 7 z 3 − z 2 + z − 9 ) 9 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 3295 z 3 + 565 z 2 + 2395 z + 288 ) 27 z (88) C_{P_{1,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)} = \frac{316(1-z)(z^2+z+1)}{9}\,l + \frac{8(10z^3+z^2-z-8)}{3}H(z)
- \frac{4z(46z^2-45z+48)}{9}\log z - \frac{2(1-z)(314z^4+497z^3+473z^2+36z-48)}{9z^2}\log(1-z)
+ \frac{8(7z^3-z^2+z-9)}{9}\pi^2 + \frac{(1-z)(3295z^3+565z^2+2395z+288)}{27z} \tag*{(88)} C P 1 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 9 316 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l + 3 8 ( 10 z 3 + z 2 − z − 8 ) H ( z ) − 9 4 z ( 46 z 2 − 45 z + 48 ) log z − 9 z 2 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 314 z 4 + 497 z 3 + 473 z 2 + 36 z − 48 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 9 8 ( 7 z 3 − z 2 + z − 9 ) π 2 + 27 z ( 1 − z ) ( 3295 z 3 + 565 z 2 + 2395 z + 288 ) (88)
C P 2 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 124 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l + 8 z ( 30 z 2 − 27 z − 1 ) 3 H ( z ) − 4 z 2 ( 6 z 2 + 38 z − 61 ) 3 log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 4 + 310 z 3 + 65 z 2 + 17 z + 20 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) + 8 z ( 21 z 2 − 24 z + 1 ) 9 π 2 + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 1764 z 2 − 496 z − 133 ) 9 (89) C_{P_{2,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)} = 124(1-z)z^2\,l + \frac{8z(30z^2-27z-1)}{3}H(z) - \frac{4z^2(6z^2+38z-61)}{3}\log z
- \frac{2(1-z)(12z^4+310z^3+65z^2+17z+20)}{3z}\log(1-z) + \frac{8z(21z^2-24z+1)}{9}\pi^2
+ \frac{2(1-z)(1764z^2-496z-133)}{9} \tag*{(89)} C P 2 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 124 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l + 3 8 z ( 30 z 2 − 27 z − 1 ) H ( z ) − 3 4 z 2 ( 6 z 2 + 38 z − 61 ) log z − 3 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 4 + 310 z 3 + 65 z 2 + 17 z + 20 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 9 8 z ( 21 z 2 − 24 z + 1 ) π 2 + 9 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 1764 z 2 − 496 z − 133 ) (89)
C P 3 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 49 z 2 − 23 z − 23 ) 9 l − 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 2 z − 2 ) 3 H ( z ) − 2 z ( 9 z 3 + 86 z 2 − 159 z − 48 ) 9 log z + 2 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 9 z 4 + 326 z 3 + 235 z 2 − 60 z + 12 ) 9 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 14 z 2 − 9 z − 9 ) 9 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 9991 z 3 + 49 z 2 − 9119 z + 288 ) 108 z (90) C_{P_{3,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)} = \frac{4(1-z)(49z^2-23z-23)}{9}\,l - \frac{16(1-z)(5z^2-2z-2)}{3}H(z)
- \frac{2z(9z^3+86z^2-159z-48)}{9}\log z
+ \frac{2(1-z)^2(9z^4+326z^3+235z^2-60z+12)}{9z^2}\log(1-z) - \frac{4(1-z)(14z^2-9z-9)}{9}\pi^2
+ \frac{(1-z)(9991z^3+49z^2-9119z+288)}{108z} \tag*{(90)} C P 3 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 9 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 49 z 2 − 23 z − 23 ) l − 3 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 2 z − 2 ) H ( z ) − 9 2 z ( 9 z 3 + 86 z 2 − 159 z − 48 ) log z + 9 z 2 2 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 9 z 4 + 326 z 3 + 235 z 2 − 60 z + 12 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 14 z 2 − 9 z − 9 ) π 2 + 108 z ( 1 − z ) ( 9991 z 3 + 49 z 2 − 9119 z + 288 ) (90)
C P 4 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 8 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 8 z 3 H ( z ) + 4 z 2 ( z − 3 ) 3 log z + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 3 + 29 z 2 + 29 z − 32 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) − 8 z 9 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 15 z 2 − 97 z + 191 ) 9 (91) C_{P_{4,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)} = -8(1-z)(z+1)\,l + \frac{8z}{3}H(z) + \frac{4z^2(z-3)}{3}\log z
+ \frac{2(1-z)(2z^3+29z^2+29z-32)}{3z}\log(1-z) - \frac{8z}{9}\pi^2 - \frac{2(1-z)(15z^2-97z+191)}{9} \tag*{(91)} C P 4 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 8 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 3 8 z H ( z ) + 3 4 z 2 ( z − 3 ) log z + 3 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 3 + 29 z 2 + 29 z − 32 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 8 z π 2 − 9 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 15 z 2 − 97 z + 191 ) (91)
C P 5 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) 3 l + 4 ( 1 − z ) z H ( z ) + 10 z 2 ( z − 3 ) 3 log z − ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 4 ( 1 − z ) z 3 π 2 − ( 1 − z ) ( 263 z 2 − 207 z − 279 ) 24 (92) C_{P_{5,11}}^{s|u\bar{s},8,(1)} = \frac{2(1-z)(2z^2+5z+5)}{3}\,l + 4(1-z)zH(z) + \frac{10z^2(z-3)}{3}\log z
- (1-z)^2\log(1-z) - \frac{4(1-z)z}{3}\pi^2 - \frac{(1-z)(263z^2-207z-279)}{24} \tag*{(92)} C P 5 , 11 s ∣ u s ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) l + 4 ( 1 − z ) z H ( z ) + 3 10 z 2 ( z − 3 ) log z − ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 3 4 ( 1 − z ) z π 2 − 24 ( 1 − z ) ( 263 z 2 − 207 z − 279 ) (92)
With one strange cut line, the coefficients for external u u u and the cut ( s d ˉ ) (s\bar{d}) ( s d ˉ ) are
C P 1 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 112 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) 27 ℓ − 32 ( z 3 − z 2 − z − 3 ) 9 H ( z ) − 4 z ( 149 z 2 − 69 z − 72 ) 27 log z − 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 37 z 4 + 31 z 3 + 19 z 2 + 9 ) 27 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 32 z ( 2 z 2 + z + 1 ) 27 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 551 z 3 + 500 z 2 − 25 z + 108 ) 81 z (93) C^{u|s\bar{d},1,(1)}_{P_{1,22}}=-\frac{112(1-z)(z^2+z+1)}{27}\ell-\frac{32(z^3-z^2-z-3)}{9}H(z)-\frac{4z(149z^2-69z-72)}{27}\log z-\frac{8(1-z)(37z^4+31z^3+19z^2+9)}{27z^2}\log(1-z)-\frac{32z(2z^2+z+1)}{27}\pi^2-\frac{2(1-z)(551z^3+500z^2-25z+108)}{81z} \tag*{(93)} C P 1 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 27 112 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) ℓ − 9 32 ( z 3 − z 2 − z − 3 ) H ( z ) − 27 4 z ( 149 z 2 − 69 z − 72 ) log z − 27 z 2 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 37 z 4 + 31 z 3 + 19 z 2 + 9 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 27 32 z ( 2 z 2 + z + 1 ) π 2 − 81 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 551 z 3 + 500 z 2 − 25 z + 108 ) (93)
C P 2 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 112 ( 1 − z ) z 2 3 ℓ − 32 z ( 3 z 2 − 6 z + 1 ) 9 H ( z ) + 4 z 2 ( 24 z 2 − 181 z + 205 ) 9 log z + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 5 − 41 z 4 + 5 z 3 + z 2 − 1 ) 9 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) 27 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 873 z 3 + 134 z 2 − 7 z + 12 ) 27 z (94) C^{u|s\bar{d},1,(1)}_{P_{2,22}}=-\frac{112(1-z)z^2}{3}\ell-\frac{32z(3z^2-6z+1)}{9}H(z)+\frac{4z^2(24z^2-181z+205)}{9}\log z+\frac{8(1-z)(12z^5-41z^4+5z^3+z^2-1)}{9z^2}\log(1-z)-\frac{32z(6z^2-3z-1)}{27}\pi^2-\frac{2(1-z)(873z^3+134z^2-7z+12)}{27z} \tag*{(94)} C P 2 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 3 112 ( 1 − z ) z 2 ℓ − 9 32 z ( 3 z 2 − 6 z + 1 ) H ( z ) + 9 4 z 2 ( 24 z 2 − 181 z + 205 ) log z + 9 z 2 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 5 − 41 z 4 + 5 z 3 + z 2 − 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 27 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) π 2 − 27 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 873 z 3 + 134 z 2 − 7 z + 12 ) (94)
C P 5 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 8 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 9 ℓ + 16 z ( z + 1 ) 3 H ( z ) − 2 z 2 ( 5 z + 39 ) 9 log z + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 10 z − 7 ) 9 log ( 1 − z ) − 16 z ( z + 1 ) 9 π 2 − ( 1 − z ) ( 117 z 2 − 405 z − 187 ) 18 (95) C^{u|s\bar{d},1,(1)}_{P_{5,22}}=\frac{8(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{9}\ell+\frac{16z(z+1)}{3}H(z)-\frac{2z^2(5z+39)}{9}\log z+\frac{8(1-z)(5z^2-10z-7)}{9}\log(1-z)-\frac{16z(z+1)}{9}\pi^2-\frac{(1-z)(117z^2-405z-187)}{18} \tag*{(95)} C P 5 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 9 8 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) ℓ + 3 16 z ( z + 1 ) H ( z ) − 9 2 z 2 ( 5 z + 39 ) log z + 9 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 10 z − 7 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 16 z ( z + 1 ) π 2 − 18 ( 1 − z ) ( 117 z 2 − 405 z − 187 ) (95)
C P 1 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 316 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) 9 ℓ + 16 ( 5 z 3 + 4 z 2 + 4 z + 3 ) 3 H ( z ) − 2 z ( 47 z 2 − 195 z − 72 ) 9 log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 269 z 4 + 221 z 3 + 287 z 2 − 9 ) 9 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 8 ( z 3 + 8 z 2 + 8 z + 9 ) 9 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 3754 z 3 + 3229 z 2 + 2494 z + 54 ) 27 z (96) C^{u|s\bar{d},8,(1)}_{P_{1,22}}=\frac{316(1-z)(z^2+z+1)}{9}\ell+\frac{16(5z^3+4z^2+4z+3)}{3}H(z)-\frac{2z(47z^2-195z-72)}{9}\log z-\frac{2(1-z)(269z^4+221z^3+287z^2-9)}{9z^2}\log(1-z)-\frac{8(z^3+8z^2+8z+9)}{9}\pi^2+\frac{(1-z)(3754z^3+3229z^2+2494z+54)}{27z} \tag*{(96)} C P 1 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 9 316 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) ℓ + 3 16 ( 5 z 3 + 4 z 2 + 4 z + 3 ) H ( z ) − 9 2 z ( 47 z 2 − 195 z − 72 ) log z − 9 z 2 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 269 z 4 + 221 z 3 + 287 z 2 − 9 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 8 ( z 3 + 8 z 2 + 8 z + 9 ) π 2 + 27 z ( 1 − z ) ( 3754 z 3 + 3229 z 2 + 2494 z + 54 ) (96)
C P 2 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 124 ( 1 − z ) z 2 ℓ + 16 z ( 15 z 2 − 3 z − 4 ) 3 H ( z ) − 2 z 2 ( 12 z 2 + 31 z − 307 ) 3 log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 5 + 265 z 4 − 67 z 3 − 17 z 2 − 1 ) 3 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 8 z ( 21 z 2 + 3 z − 8 ) 9 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 3987 z 3 − 896 z 2 − 143 z + 6 ) 9 z (97) C^{u|s\bar{d},8,(1)}_{P_{2,22}}=124(1-z)z^2\ell+\frac{16z(15z^2-3z-4)}{3}H(z)-\frac{2z^2(12z^2+31z-307)}{3}\log z-\frac{2(1-z)(12z^5+265z^4-67z^3-17z^2-1)}{3z^2}\log(1-z)-\frac{8z(21z^2+3z-8)}{9}\pi^2+\frac{(1-z)(3987z^3-896z^2-143z+6)}{9z} \tag*{(97)} C P 2 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 124 ( 1 − z ) z 2 ℓ + 3 16 z ( 15 z 2 − 3 z − 4 ) H ( z ) − 3 2 z 2 ( 12 z 2 + 31 z − 307 ) log z − 3 z 2 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 5 + 265 z 4 − 67 z 3 − 17 z 2 − 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 8 z ( 21 z 2 + 3 z − 8 ) π 2 + 9 z ( 1 − z ) ( 3987 z 3 − 896 z 2 − 143 z + 6 ) (97)
C P 5 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) 3 ℓ + z 2 ( 7 z − 9 ) 3 log z + ( 1 − z ) 2 ( z 3 + 2 z 2 + z − 1 ) z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 323 z 3 − 399 z 2 − 315 z + 24 ) 24 z (98) C^{u|s\bar{d},8,(1)}_{P_{5,22}}=\frac{2(1-z)(2z^2+5z+5)}{3}\ell+\frac{z^2(7z-9)}{3}\log z+\frac{(1-z)^2(z^3+2z^2+z-1)}{z^2}\log(1-z)-\frac{(1-z)(323z^3-399z^2-315z+24)}{24z} \tag*{(98)} C P 5 , 22 u ∣ s d ˉ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) ℓ + 3 z 2 ( 7 z − 9 ) log z + z 2 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( z 3 + 2 z 2 + z − 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 24 z ( 1 − z ) ( 323 z 3 − 399 z 2 − 315 z + 24 ) (98)
C P 1 , 12 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) ℓ − 32 ( 2 z 3 − z 2 − z − 4 ) 3 H ( z ) − 8 z ( 27 z 2 − 15 z − 16 ) 3 log z − 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 15 z 4 + 4 z 3 − 6 z 2 + 3 ) 3 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 32 z ( 2 z 2 + z + 1 ) 9 π 2 − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 56 z 3 + 41 z 2 + 11 z + 6 ) 3 z (99) C^{u|s\bar{d},1,(1)}_{P_{1,12}}=-32(1-z)(z^2+z+1)\ell-\frac{32(2z^3-z^2-z-4)}{3}H(z)-\frac{8z(27z^2-15z-16)}{3}\log z-\frac{8(1-z)(15z^4+4z^3-6z^2+3)}{3z^2}\log(1-z)-\frac{32z(2z^2+z+1)}{9}\pi^2-\frac{4(1-z)(56z^3+41z^2+11z+6)}{3z} \tag*{(99)} C P 1 , 12 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) ℓ − 3 32 ( 2 z 3 − z 2 − z − 4 ) H ( z ) − 3 8 z ( 27 z 2 − 15 z − 16 ) log z − 3 z 2 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 15 z 4 + 4 z 3 − 6 z 2 + 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 32 z ( 2 z 2 + z + 1 ) π 2 − 3 z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 56 z 3 + 41 z 2 + 11 z + 6 ) (99)
C P 2 , 12 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 192 ( 1 − z ) z 2 ℓ − 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 9 z + 1 ) 3 H ( z ) + 8 z 2 ( 24 z 2 − 113 z + 113 ) 3 log z + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 24 z 5 − 53 z 4 + 16 z 3 + 6 z 2 − 1 ) 3 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) 9 π 2 − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 216 z 3 + 3 z 2 − 7 z + 2 ) 3 z (100) C^{u|s\bar{d},1,(1)}_{P_{2,12}}=-192(1-z)z^2\ell-\frac{32z(6z^2-9z+1)}{3}H(z)+\frac{8z^2(24z^2-113z+113)}{3}\log z+\frac{8(1-z)(24z^5-53z^4+16z^3+6z^2-1)}{3z^2}\log(1-z)-\frac{32z(6z^2-3z-1)}{9}\pi^2-\frac{4(1-z)(216z^3+3z^2-7z+2)}{3z} \tag*{(100)} C P 2 , 12 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 192 ( 1 − z ) z 2 ℓ − 3 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 9 z + 1 ) H ( z ) + 3 8 z 2 ( 24 z 2 − 113 z + 113 ) log z + 3 z 2 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 24 z 5 − 53 z 4 + 16 z 3 + 6 z 2 − 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 32 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) π 2 − 3 z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 216 z 3 + 3 z 2 − 7 z + 2 ) (100)
C P 5 , 12 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 9 ℓ + 32 z ( z + 1 ) 9 H ( z ) + 4 z 2 ( 3 z − 19 ) 9 log z + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 7 z 4 − 23 z 3 − 11 z 2 + 6 z − 3 ) 27 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 32 z ( z + 1 ) 27 π 2 − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 220 z 3 − 402 z 2 − 251 z + 12 ) 27 z (101) C^{u|s\bar{d},1,(1)}_{P_{5,12}}=\frac{32(1-z)(z+1)}{9}\ell+\frac{32z(z+1)}{9}H(z)+\frac{4z^2(3z-19)}{9}\log z+\frac{8(1-z)(7z^4-23z^3-11z^2+6z-3)}{27z^2}\log(1-z)-\frac{32z(z+1)}{27}\pi^2-\frac{2(1-z)(220z^3-402z^2-251z+12)}{27z} \tag*{(101)} C P 5 , 12 u ∣ s d ˉ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 9 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) ℓ + 9 32 z ( z + 1 ) H ( z ) + 9 4 z 2 ( 3 z − 19 ) log z + 27 z 2 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 7 z 4 − 23 z 3 − 11 z 2 + 6 z − 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 27 32 z ( z + 1 ) π 2 − 27 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 220 z 3 − 402 z 2 − 251 z + 12 ) (101)
C P 1 , 12 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) 3 l + 8 ( z 2 + z + 2 ) H ( z ) − 8 z ( 17 z 2 − 6 z − 6 ) 3 log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 29 z 4 + 50 z 3 + 56 z 2 + 9 ) 3 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 8 z ( 2 z 2 + z + 1 ) 3 π 2 − ( 1 − z ) ( 47 z 3 + 131 z 2 − 124 z + 54 ) 9 z 2 (102) C_{P_{1,12}}^{u|sd,\delta,8,(1)} = \frac{16(1-z)(z^2+z+1)}{3}\,l + 8(z^2+z+2)H(z) - \frac{8z(17z^2-6z-6)}{3}\log z
- \frac{2(1-z)(29z^4+50z^3+56z^2+9)}{3z^2}\log(1-z) - \frac{8z(2z^2+z+1)}{3}\pi^2
- \frac{(1-z)(47z^3+131z^2-124z+54)}{9z^2} \tag*{(102)} C P 1 , 12 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l + 8 ( z 2 + z + 2 ) H ( z ) − 3 8 z ( 17 z 2 − 6 z − 6 ) log z − 3 z 2 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 29 z 4 + 50 z 3 + 56 z 2 + 9 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 3 8 z ( 2 z 2 + z + 1 ) π 2 − 9 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 47 z 3 + 131 z 2 − 124 z + 54 ) (102)
C P 2 , 12 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 24 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l + 8 z ( 3 z − 1 ) H ( z ) − 8 z 2 ( 17 z − 23 ) log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 29 z 4 + 6 z 3 + 4 z 2 + 1 ) z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 8 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) 3 π 2 − ( 1 − z ) ( 225 z 3 + 125 z 2 + 14 z + 6 ) 3 z (103) C_{P_{2,12}}^{u|sd,\delta,8,(1)} = -24(1-z)z^2 l + 8z(3z-1)H(z) - 8z^2(17z-23)\log z
- \frac{2(1-z)(29z^4+6z^3+4z^2+1)}{z^2}\log(1-z) - \frac{8z(6z^2-3z-1)}{3}\pi^2
- \frac{(1-z)(225z^3+125z^2+14z+6)}{3z} \tag*{(103)} C P 2 , 12 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 24 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l + 8 z ( 3 z − 1 ) H ( z ) − 8 z 2 ( 17 z − 23 ) log z − z 2 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 29 z 4 + 6 z 3 + 4 z 2 + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 3 8 z ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) π 2 − 3 z ( 1 − z ) ( 225 z 3 + 125 z 2 + 14 z + 6 ) (103)
C P 5 , 12 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) 3 l + 28 z ( z + 1 ) 3 H ( z ) − 4 z 2 ( 3 z + 2 ) 3 log z − ( 1 − z ) ( 41 z 4 + 116 z 3 + 32 z 2 − 42 z + 21 ) 9 z 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 28 z ( z + 1 ) 9 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 74 z 3 + 1071 z 2 + 833 z − 84 ) 36 z (104) C_{P_{5,12}}^{u|sd,\delta,8,(1)} = -\frac{4(1-z)(3z^2+5z+5)}{3}l + \frac{28z(z+1)}{3}H(z) - \frac{4z^2(3z+2)}{3}\log z
- \frac{(1-z)(41z^4+116z^3+32z^2-42z+21)}{9z^2}\log(1-z) - \frac{28z(z+1)}{9}\pi^2
+ \frac{(1-z)(74z^3+1071z^2+833z-84)}{36z} \tag*{(104)} C P 5 , 12 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 3 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) l + 3 28 z ( z + 1 ) H ( z ) − 3 4 z 2 ( 3 z + 2 ) log z − 9 z 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 41 z 4 + 116 z 3 + 32 z 2 − 42 z + 21 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 28 z ( z + 1 ) π 2 + 36 z ( 1 − z ) ( 74 z 3 + 1071 z 2 + 833 z − 84 ) (104)
C P 1 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) H ( z ) − 16 z ( 2 z + 1 ) ( 3 z − 2 ) log z − 48 ( 1 − z ) z ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 + 4 z + 3 ) (105) C_{P_{1,11}}^{u|sd,\delta,1,(1)} = 32(1-z)(z^2+z+1)H(z) - 16z(2z+1)(3z-2)\log z
-48(1-z)z(2z+1)\log(1-z) + 8(1-z)(5z^2+4z+3) \tag*{(105)} C P 1 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) H ( z ) − 16 z ( 2 z + 1 ) ( 3 z − 2 ) log z − 48 ( 1 − z ) z ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 + 4 z + 3 ) (105)
C P 2 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 144 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l + 96 ( 1 − z ) z 2 H ( z ) + 32 z 2 ( 3 z 2 − 13 z + 9 ) log z + 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 6 z 3 − 20 z 2 + 4 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 1 − z ) z ( 3 z − 7 ) (106) C_{P_{2,11}}^{u|sd,\delta,1,(1)} = -144(1-z)z^2l + 96(1-z)z^2H(z) + 32z^2(3z^2-13z+9)\log z
+16(1-z)(6z^3-20z^2+4z+1)\log(1-z) + 8(1-z)z(3z-7) \tag*{(106)} C P 2 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 144 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l + 96 ( 1 − z ) z 2 H ( z ) + 32 z 2 ( 3 z 2 − 13 z + 9 ) log z + 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 6 z 3 − 20 z 2 + 4 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 1 − z ) z ( 3 z − 7 ) (106)
C P 5 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l + 2 z 2 ( 5 z − 13 ) 3 log z − 20 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 9 log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 148 z 2 − 204 z − 113 ) 9 (107) C_{P_{5,11}}^{u|sd,\delta,1,(1)} = \frac{16(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l + \frac{2z^2(5z-13)}{3}\log z - \frac{20(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{9}\log(1-z)
- \frac{(1-z)(148z^2-204z-113)}{9} \tag*{(107)} C P 5 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 1 , ( 1 ) = 3 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 3 2 z 2 ( 5 z − 13 ) log z − 9 20 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 ( 1 − z ) ( 148 z 2 − 204 z − 113 ) (107)
C P 1 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 44 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l − z 2 ( 59 z + 9 ) log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 28 z 2 + 37 z + 37 ) log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 637 z 2 + 382 z + 331 ) 6 (108) C_{P_{1,11}}^{u|sd,\delta,8,(1)} = 44(1-z)(z^2+z+1)l - z^2(59z+9)\log z
-2(1-z)(28z^2+37z+37)\log(1-z) + \frac{(1-z)(637z^2+382z+331)}{6} \tag*{(108)} C P 1 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 44 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + z + 1 ) l − z 2 ( 59 z + 9 ) log z − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 28 z 2 + 37 z + 37 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 637 z 2 + 382 z + 331 ) (108)
C P 2 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 72 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 3 z 2 ( 59 z − 51 ) log z − 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 28 z 2 + 3 z + 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 459 z 2 − 200 z − 35 ) 2 (109) C_{P_{2,11}}^{u|sd,\delta,8,(1)} = 72(1-z)z^2l - 3z^2(59z-51)\log z - 6(1-z)(28z^2+3z+3)\log(1-z)
+ \frac{(1-z)(459z^2-200z-35)}{2} \tag*{(109)} C P 2 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = 72 ( 1 − z ) z 2 l − 3 z 2 ( 59 z − 51 ) log z − 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 28 z 2 + 3 z + 3 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 459 z 2 − 200 z − 35 ) (109)
C P 5 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) l − z 2 ( 5 z − 13 ) 2 log z + 5 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 3 log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 578 z 2 − 315 z − 133 ) 24 (110) C_{P_{5,11}}^{u|sd,\delta,8,(1)} = -2(1-z)(3z^2+5z+5)l - \frac{z^2(5z-13)}{2}\log z
+ \frac{5(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{3}\log(1-z) + \frac{(1-z)(578z^2-315z-133)}{24} \tag*{(110)} C P 5 , 11 u ∣ s d , δ , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 5 z + 5 ) l − 2 z 2 ( 5 z − 13 ) log z + 3 5 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 24 ( 1 − z ) ( 578 z 2 − 315 z − 133 ) (110)
For external s s s with the cut ( s u ) (su) ( s u ) they are
C P 1 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 112 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 32 l + 32 ( 3 z 2 − 1 ) 3 H ( z ) − 8 z ( 8 z 2 − 17 z + 4 ) 3 log z − 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 3 + 7 z 2 + z + 8 ) 9 z log ( 1 − z ) − 64 9 π 2 + 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 45 z − 138 ) 27 (111) C_{P_{1,22}}^{s|su,1,(1)} = -\frac{112(1-z)(z+1)}{32}l + \frac{32(3z^2-1)}{3}H(z) - \frac{8z(8z^2-17z+4)}{3}\log z
- \frac{16(1-z)(12z^3+7z^2+z+8)}{9z}\log(1-z) - \frac{64}{9}\pi^2 + \frac{8(1-z)(5z^2-45z-138)}{27} \tag*{(111)} C P 1 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 32 112 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 3 32 ( 3 z 2 − 1 ) H ( z ) − 3 8 z ( 8 z 2 − 17 z + 4 ) log z − 9 z 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 3 + 7 z 2 + z + 8 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 9 64 π 2 + 27 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 45 z − 138 ) (111)
C P 2 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 8 z 2 9 log z + 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 3 log ( 1 − z ) + 4 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) ( 10 z + 3 ) 9 (112) C_{P_{2,22}}^{s|su,1,(1)} = \frac{8z^2}{9}\log z + \frac{16(1-z)^2}{3}\log(1-z) + \frac{4(1-z)(z+1)(10z+3)}{9} \tag*{(112)} C P 2 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 9 8 z 2 log z + 3 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 9 4 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) ( 10 z + 3 ) (112)
C P 3 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 9 l − 40 z 2 9 log z − 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 1 ) 9 z log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 40 z 2 − 357 z − 429 ) 27 (113) C_{P_{3,22}}^{s|su,1,(1)} = -\frac{16(1-z)(z+1)}{9}l - \frac{40z^2}{9}\log z - \frac{16(1-z)(3z^2+1)}{9z}\log(1-z)
+ \frac{(1-z)(40z^2-357z-429)}{27} \tag*{(113)} C P 3 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 9 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 9 40 z 2 log z − 9 z 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 27 ( 1 − z ) ( 40 z 2 − 357 z − 429 ) (113)
C P 4 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l − 16 z 2 3 log z − 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 9 z log ( 1 − z ) − 40 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 (114) C_{P_{4,22}}^{s|su,1,(1)} = -\frac{16(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l - \frac{16z^2}{3}\log z - \frac{16(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{9z}\log(1-z)
- \frac{40(1-z)(z+1)}{3} \tag*{(114)} C P 4 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 3 16 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 3 16 z 2 log z − 9 z 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 3 40 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) (114)
C P 5 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 8 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l − 4 z 2 log z − 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 88 z 2 − 255 z − 279 ) 18 (115) C^{s|su,1,(1)}_{P_{5,22}} = \frac{8(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l - 4z^2\log z - \frac{32(1-z)(z+1)}{3}\log(1-z) - \frac{(1-z)(88z^2-255z-279)}{18} \tag*{(115)} C P 5 , 22 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 3 8 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 4 z 2 log z − 3 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 18 ( 1 − z ) ( 88 z 2 − 255 z − 279 ) (115)
C P 1 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 316 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l + 16 ⋅ ( 3 z 2 + 5 ) H ( z ) + 8 z ( 2 z 2 − 5 z + 10 ) log z + 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 3 − 119 z 2 − 125 z + 8 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) − 8 ( 9 z 2 + 7 ) 3 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 44 z 2 + 2349 z + 1833 ) 9 (116) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{1,22}} = \frac{316(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l + 16\cdot(3z^2+5)H(z) + 8z(2z^2-5z+10)\log z + \frac{4(1-z)(12z^3-119z^2-125z+8)}{3z}\log(1-z) - \frac{8(9z^2+7)}{3}\pi^2 + \frac{(1-z)(44z^2+2349z+1833)}{9} \tag*{(116)} C P 1 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 316 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 16 ⋅ ( 3 z 2 + 5 ) H ( z ) + 8 z ( 2 z 2 − 5 z + 10 ) log z + 3 z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 3 − 119 z 2 − 125 z + 8 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 3 8 ( 9 z 2 + 7 ) π 2 + 9 ( 1 − z ) ( 44 z 2 + 2349 z + 1833 ) (116)
C P 2 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 16 z 2 3 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 11 z 2 − 10 z − 3 ) 3 (117) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{2,22}} = \frac{16z^2}{3}\log z - 4(1-z)^2\log(1-z) + \frac{4(1-z)(11z^2-10z-3)}{3} \tag*{(117)} C P 2 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 16 z 2 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 3 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 11 z 2 − 10 z − 3 ) (117)
C P 3 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 76 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l − 80 z 2 3 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 15 z 2 + 18 z − 1 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 176 z 2 − 381 z − 93 ) 36 (118) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{3,22}} = \frac{76(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l - \frac{80z^2}{3}\log z - \frac{4(1-z)(15z^2+18z-1)}{3z}\log(1-z) + \frac{(1-z)(176z^2-381z-93)}{36} \tag*{(118)} C P 3 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 76 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 3 80 z 2 log z − 3 z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 15 z 2 + 18 z − 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 36 ( 1 − z ) ( 176 z 2 − 381 z − 93 ) (118)
C P 4 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 20 z 2 log z + 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z − 1 ) (119) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{4,22}} = 4(1-z)(z+1)l - 20z^2\log z + \frac{4(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{3z}\log(1-z) - 4(1-z)(2z-1) \tag*{(119)} C P 4 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 20 z 2 log z + 3 z 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z − 1 ) (119)
C P 5 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 10 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 4 z 2 3 log z + 6 ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 112 z 2 − 741 z − 789 ) 24 (120) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{5,22}} = 10(1-z)(z+1)l + \frac{4z^2}{3}\log z + 6(1-z)^2\log(1-z) - \frac{(1-z)(112z^2-741z-789)}{24} \tag*{(120)} C P 5 , 22 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 10 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 3 4 z 2 log z + 6 ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) − 24 ( 1 − z ) ( 112 z 2 − 741 z − 789 ) (120)
C P 1 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 64 z 2 H ( z ) + 64 z 2 log z − 64 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 4 z + 2 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) − 64 3 π 2 + 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + 131 z + 11 ) 9 (121) C^{s|su,1,(1)}_{P_{1,12}} = 64z^2H(z) + 64z^2\log z - \frac{64(1-z)(5z^2-4z+2)}{3z}\log(1-z) - \frac{64}{3}\pi^2 + \frac{16(1-z)(2z^2+131z+11)}{9} \tag*{(121)} C P 1 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 64 z 2 H ( z ) + 64 z 2 log z − 3 z 64 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z 2 − 4 z + 2 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 3 64 π 2 + 9 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + 131 z + 11 ) (121)
C P 2 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + 4 z + 1 ) 3 (122) C^{s|su,1,(1)}_{P_{2,12}} = 32(1-z)^2\log(1-z) + \frac{32(1-z)(z^2+4z+1)}{3} \tag*{(122)} C P 2 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) 2 log ( 1 − z ) + 3 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + 4 z + 1 ) (122)
C P 3 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 32 z 2 3 log z + 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 4 z − 1 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) + 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + 7 z − 2 ) 9 (123) C^{s|su,1,(1)}_{P_{3,12}} = -\frac{32z^2}{3}\log z + \frac{16(1-z)^2(4z-1)}{3z}\log(1-z) + \frac{32(1-z)(z^2+7z-2)}{9} \tag*{(123)} C P 3 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 3 32 z 2 log z + 3 z 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 4 z − 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 9 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z 2 + 7 z − 2 ) (123)
C P 4 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 64 z 2 3 log z − 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 33 z + 1 ) 3 (124) C^{s|su,1,(1)}_{P_{4,12}} = -\frac{64z^2}{3}\log z - \frac{16(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{3z}\log(1-z) + \frac{2(1-z)(33z+1)}{3} \tag*{(124)} C P 4 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 3 64 z 2 log z − 3 z 16 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 3 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 33 z + 1 ) (124)
C P 5 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l + 8 z 2 9 log z − 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 7 z + 1 ) 9 log ( 1 − z ) − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 50 z 2 − 249 z − 267 ) 27 (125) C^{s|su,1,(1)}_{P_{5,12}} = \frac{32(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l + \frac{8z^2}{9}\log z - \frac{16(1-z)(7z+1)}{9}\log(1-z) - \frac{4(1-z)(50z^2-249z-267)}{27} \tag*{(125)} C P 5 , 12 s ∣ s u , 1 , ( 1 ) = 3 32 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 9 8 z 2 log z − 9 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 7 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 27 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 50 z 2 − 249 z − 267 ) (125)
C P 1 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 56 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 48 ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) H ( z ) − 12 z ( 8 z 2 − 13 z + 4 ) log z − 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 3 − 3 z 2 + 9 z + 4 ) z log ( 1 − z ) − 16 π 2 + 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 − 176 z − 149 ) 3 (126) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{1,12}} = -56(1-z)(z+1)l + 48(2z^2-1)H(z) - 12z(8z^2-13z+4)\log z - \frac{8(1-z)(12z^3-3z^2+9z+4)}{z}\log(1-z) - 16\pi^2 + \frac{4(1-z)(3z^2-176z-149)}{3} \tag*{(126)} C P 1 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 56 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 48 ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) H ( z ) − 12 z ( 8 z 2 − 13 z + 4 ) log z − z 8 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 3 − 3 z 2 + 9 z + 4 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 16 π 2 + 3 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 − 176 z − 149 ) (126)
C P 2 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 z 2 log z + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) (127) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{2,12}} = 4z^2\log z + 2(1-z)(6z^2-3z-1) \tag*{(127)} C P 2 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 z 2 log z + 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 6 z 2 − 3 z − 1 ) (127)
C P 3 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 8 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 12 z 2 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + 5 z + 1 ) z log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 24 z 2 − 469 z − 397 ) 6 (128) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{3,12}} = -8(1-z)(z+1)l - 12z^2\log z - \frac{4(1-z)(2z^2+5z+1)}{z}\log(1-z) + \frac{(1-z)(24z^2-469z-397)}{6} \tag*{(128)} C P 3 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 8 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 12 z 2 log z − z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 2 z 2 + 5 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 6 ( 1 − z ) ( 24 z 2 − 469 z − 397 ) (128)
C P 4 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 24 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 8 z 2 log z − 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) z log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 153 z + 121 ) 2 (129) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{4,12}} = -24(1-z)(z+1)l - 8z^2\log z - \frac{4(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{z}\log(1-z) - \frac{(1-z)(153z+121)}{2} \tag*{(129)} C P 4 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 24 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 8 z 2 log z − z 4 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 2 ( 1 − z ) ( 153 z + 121 ) (129)
C P 5 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 20 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 70 z 2 3 log z − 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z − 7 ) 3 log ( 1 − z ) − ( 1 − z ) ( 808 z 2 − 3 z − 363 ) 36 (130) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_{5,12}} = -20(1-z)(z+1)l + \frac{70z^2}{3}\log z - \frac{16(1-z)(5z-7)}{3}\log(1-z) - \frac{(1-z)(808z^2-3z-363)}{36} \tag*{(130)} C P 5 , 12 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 20 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 3 70 z 2 log z − 3 16 ( 1 − z ) ( 5 z − 7 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 36 ( 1 − z ) ( 808 z 2 − 3 z − 363 ) (130)
For weak row 11, seven rows equal those of weak row 22:
C P i , 11 s ∣ s u , c , ( 1 ) = C P i , 22 s ∣ s u , c , ( 1 ) , { i = 1 , … , 5 , c = 1 , i = 2 , 5 , c = 8. (131) C^{s|su,c,(1)}_{P_i,11}=C^{s|su,c,(1)}_{P_i,22},\qquad
\begin{cases}
i=1,\ldots,5,\quad c=1,\\
i=2,5,\quad c=8.
\end{cases} \tag*{(131)} C P i , 11 s ∣ s u , c , ( 1 ) = C P i , 22 s ∣ s u , c , ( 1 ) , { i = 1 , … , 5 , c = 1 , i = 2 , 5 , c = 8. (131)
The remaining three octet rows are
C P 1 , 11 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 316 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l + 16 ( 3 z 2 − 4 ) H ( z ) + 8 z ( 2 z 2 − 17 z − 8 ) log z + 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 3 − 191 z 2 − 197 z − 64 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) + 8 ( 9 z 2 − 7 ) 3 π 2 + ( 1 − z ) ( 44 z 2 + 2349 z + 969 ) 9 (132) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_1,11}
=\frac{316(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l+16(3z^2-4)H(z)+8z(2z^2-17z-8)\log z
+\frac{4(1-z)(12z^3-191z^2-197z-64)}{3z}\log(1-z)
+\frac{8(9z^2-7)}{3}\pi^2
+\frac{(1-z)(44z^2+2349z+969)}{9} \tag*{(132)} C P 1 , 11 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 316 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 16 ( 3 z 2 − 4 ) H ( z ) + 8 z ( 2 z 2 − 17 z − 8 ) log z + 3 z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 12 z 3 − 191 z 2 − 197 z − 64 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 3 8 ( 9 z 2 − 7 ) π 2 + 9 ( 1 − z ) ( 44 z 2 + 2349 z + 969 ) (132)
C P 3 , 11 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 76 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) 3 l − 8 z 2 3 log z + 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 − 27 z − 8 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) + ( 1 − z ) ( 176 z 2 − 1677 z − 525 ) 36 (133) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_3,11}
=\frac{76(1-z)(z+1)}{3}l-\frac{8z^2}{3}\log z
+\frac{4(1-z)(3z^2-27z-8)}{3z}\log(1-z)
+\frac{(1-z)(176z^2-1677z-525)}{36} \tag*{(133)} C P 3 , 11 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 76 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l − 3 8 z 2 log z + 3 z 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 3 z 2 − 27 z − 8 ) log ( 1 − z ) + 36 ( 1 − z ) ( 176 z 2 − 1677 z − 525 ) (133)
C P 4 , 11 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 4 z 2 log z − 32 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) 3 z log ( 1 − z ) − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 11 z + 2 ) (134) C^{s|su,8,(1)}_{P_4,11}
=4(1-z)(z+1)l+4z^2\log z-\frac{32(1-z)^2(2z+1)}{3z}\log(1-z)
-4(1-z)(11z+2) \tag*{(134)} C P 4 , 11 s ∣ s u , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 ( 1 − z ) ( z + 1 ) l + 4 z 2 log z − 3 z 32 ( 1 − z ) 2 ( 2 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − z ) − 4 ( 1 − z ) ( 11 z + 2 ) (134)
For external u u u with the equal-mass cut (s s ˉ s\bar{s} s s ˉ ), two common functions collect the repeated logarithm–dilogarithm terms:
Φ ( z ) = 3 log ( z β 2 ) log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 6 [ Li 2 ( − 2 β 1 − β ) − Li 2 ( 2 β 1 + β ) ] + 4 [ Li 2 ( 1 − β 2 ) − Li 2 ( 1 + β 2 ) ] − 2 [ ℜ Li 2 ( 1 + β 2 β ) − Li 2 ( − 1 − β 2 β ) ] − π 2 , (135) \Phi(z)=3\log\left(\frac{z}{\beta^2}\right)\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
-6\left[\operatorname{Li}_2\left(-\frac{2\beta}{1-\beta}\right)-\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{2\beta}{1+\beta}\right)\right]
+4\left[\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{1-\beta}{2}\right)-\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{1+\beta}{2}\right)\right]
-2\left[\Re\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{1+\beta}{2\beta}\right)-\operatorname{Li}_2\left(-\frac{1-\beta}{2\beta}\right)\right]-\pi^2, \tag*{(135)} Φ ( z ) = 3 log ( β 2 z ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 6 [ Li 2 ( − 1 − β 2 β ) − Li 2 ( 1 + β 2 β ) ] + 4 [ Li 2 ( 2 1 − β ) − Li 2 ( 2 1 + β ) ] − 2 [ ℜ Li 2 ( 2 β 1 + β ) − Li 2 ( − 2 β 1 − β ) ] − π 2 , (135)
Ψ ( z ) = 4 log β log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 3 log 2 ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 6 [ Li 2 ( − 2 β 1 − β ) − Li 2 ( 2 β 1 + β ) ] − 4 [ Li 2 ( 1 − β 2 ) − Li 2 ( 1 + β 2 ) ] − 4 [ ℜ Li 2 ( ( 1 + β ) 2 ( 1 − β ) 2 ) − ℜ Li 2 ( 1 + β 1 − β ) ] . (136) \Psi(z)=4\log\beta\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
-3\log^2\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
+6\left[\operatorname{Li}_2\left(-\frac{2\beta}{1-\beta}\right)-\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{2\beta}{1+\beta}\right)\right]
-4\left[\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{1-\beta}{2}\right)-\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{1+\beta}{2}\right)\right]
-4\left[\Re\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{(1+\beta)^2}{(1-\beta)^2}\right)-\Re\operatorname{Li}_2\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)\right]. \tag*{(136)} Ψ ( z ) = 4 log β log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 3 log 2 ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 6 [ Li 2 ( − 1 − β 2 β ) − Li 2 ( 1 + β 2 β ) ] − 4 [ Li 2 ( 2 1 − β ) − Li 2 ( 2 1 + β ) ] − 4 [ ℜ Li 2 ( ( 1 − β ) 2 ( 1 + β ) 2 ) − ℜ Li 2 ( 1 − β 1 + β ) ] . (136)
The real parts specify the boundary values on the dilogarithm cut. The coefficients are
C P 1 , 22 u ∣ s s ˉ , ( 1 ) = 112 ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) 27 β l + 16 ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) 9 Φ ( z ) + 16 z 9 Ψ ( z ) − 4 ( 616 z 4 + 256 z 3 − 104 z 2 − 18 z + 3 ) 27 β z 2 log z + 8 ( 376 z 3 + 220 z 2 − 92 z − 3 ) 27 β z log β + 4 ( 480 z 6 + 192 z 5 − 174 z 4 − 536 z 3 + 74 z 2 + 24 z − 3 ) 27 β 2 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 2 ( 1440 z 4 − 1412 z 3 − 1298 z 2 + 169 z − 36 ) 81 β z (137) C^{u|s\bar{s},(1)}_{P_1,22}
=\frac{112(2z^2+2z-1)}{27\beta}l+\frac{16(2z^2-1)}{9}\Phi(z)+\frac{16z}{9}\Psi(z)
-\frac{4(616z^4+256z^3-104z^2-18z+3)}{27\beta z^2}\log z
+\frac{8(376z^3+220z^2-92z-3)}{27\beta z}\log\beta
+\frac{4(480z^6+192z^5-174z^4-536z^3+74z^2+24z-3)}{27\beta^2z^2}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
+\frac{2(1440z^4-1412z^3-1298z^2+169z-36)}{81\beta z} \tag*{(137)} C P 1 , 22 u ∣ s s ˉ , ( 1 ) = 27 β 112 ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) l + 9 16 ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) Φ ( z ) + 9 16 z Ψ ( z ) − 27 β z 2 4 ( 616 z 4 + 256 z 3 − 104 z 2 − 18 z + 3 ) log z + 27 β z 8 ( 376 z 3 + 220 z 2 − 92 z − 3 ) log β + 27 β 2 z 2 4 ( 480 z 6 + 192 z 5 − 174 z 4 − 536 z 3 + 74 z 2 + 24 z − 3 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 81 β z 2 ( 1440 z 4 − 1412 z 3 − 1298 z 2 + 169 z − 36 ) (137)
C P 2 , 22 u ∣ s s ˉ , ( 1 ) = − 224 z 2 3 β l − 64 z 2 9 Φ ( z ) + 4 ( 424 z 4 − 104 z 3 + 6 z − 1 ) 9 β z 2 log z − 8 ( 216 z 3 − 36 z 2 − 8 z + 3 ) 9 β z log β + 4 ( 480 z 6 − 608 z 5 + 378 z 4 − 112 z 3 − 10 z 2 + 8 z − 1 ) 9 β 2 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 2 ( 1440 z 4 − 2080 z 3 − 182 z 2 − 5 z − 12 ) 27 β z (138) C^{u|s\bar{s},(1)}_{P_2,22}
=-\frac{224z^2}{3\beta}l-\frac{64z^2}{9}\Phi(z)
+\frac{4(424z^4-104z^3+6z-1)}{9\beta z^2}\log z
-\frac{8(216z^3-36z^2-8z+3)}{9\beta z}\log\beta
+\frac{4(480z^6-608z^5+378z^4-112z^3-10z^2+8z-1)}{9\beta^2z^2}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
+\frac{2(1440z^4-2080z^3-182z^2-5z-12)}{27\beta z} \tag*{(138)} C P 2 , 22 u ∣ s s ˉ , ( 1 ) = − 3 β 224 z 2 l − 9 64 z 2 Φ ( z ) + 9 β z 2 4 ( 424 z 4 − 104 z 3 + 6 z − 1 ) log z − 9 β z 8 ( 216 z 3 − 36 z 2 − 8 z + 3 ) log β + 9 β 2 z 2 4 ( 480 z 6 − 608 z 5 + 378 z 4 − 112 z 3 − 10 z 2 + 8 z − 1 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 27 β z 2 ( 1440 z 4 − 2080 z 3 − 182 z 2 − 5 z − 12 ) (138)
C P 5 , 22 μ ∣ s s , 1 , ( 1 ) = 8 β ( 2 z + 1 ) 9 l + 4 z 3 Ψ ( z ) + 4 β ( 16 z 3 + 5 z 2 + 9 z − 3 ) 9 z 2 log z − 4 β ( 32 z 2 + 22 z − 3 ) 9 z log β − 4 ( 8 z 5 + 21 z 4 + 7 z 2 − 15 z + 3 ) 9 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 128 z 4 − 1202 z 3 − 910 z 2 + 499 z − 48 18 β z (139) C^{\mu|ss,1,(1)}_{P_{5,22}} = \frac{8\beta(2z+1)}{9}l + \frac{4z}{3}\Psi(z) + \frac{4\beta(16z^{3}+5z^{2}+9z-3)}{9z^{2}}\log z
- \frac{4\beta(32z^{2}+22z-3)}{9z}\log\beta- \frac{4(8z^{5}+21z^{4}+7z^{2}-15z+3)}{9z^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
+ \frac{128z^{4}-1202z^{3}-910z^{2}+499z-48}{18\beta z} \tag*{(139)} C P 5 , 22 μ ∣ ss , 1 , ( 1 ) = 9 8 β ( 2 z + 1 ) l + 3 4 z Ψ ( z ) + 9 z 2 4 β ( 16 z 3 + 5 z 2 + 9 z − 3 ) log z − 9 z 4 β ( 32 z 2 + 22 z − 3 ) log β − 9 z 2 4 ( 8 z 5 + 21 z 4 + 7 z 2 − 15 z + 3 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 18 β z 128 z 4 − 1202 z 3 − 910 z 2 + 499 z − 48 (139)
C P 1 , 22 μ ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 316 ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) 9 β l − 4 ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) 3 Φ ( z ) + 2 ( 7 z + 9 ) 3 Ψ ( z ) − 2120 z 4 + 3020 z 3 − 1642 z 2 + 396 z − 57 9 β z 2 log z + 4 ( 856 z 3 + 1150 z 2 − 395 z − 12 ) 9 β z log β + 4416 z 6 + 1392 z 5 + 768 z 4 − 5692 z 3 + 2320 z 2 − 510 z + 57 9 β 2 z log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 2 ( 3312 z 4 − 5137 z 3 − 2074 z 2 + 158 z + 171 ) 27 β z (140) C^{\mu|ss,8,(1)}_{P_{1,22}} = -\frac{316(2z^{2}+2z-1)}{9\beta}l - \frac{4(2z^{2}-1)}{3}\Phi(z) + \frac{2(7z+9)}{3}\Psi(z)
- \frac{2120z^{4}+3020z^{3}-1642z^{2}+396z-57}{9\beta z^{2}}\log z + \frac{4(856z^{3}+1150z^{2}-395z-12)}{9\beta z}\log\beta
+ \frac{4416z^{6}+1392z^{5}+768z^{4}-5692z^{3}+2320z^{2}-510z+57}{9\beta^{2}z}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
+ \frac{2(3312z^{4}-5137z^{3}-2074z^{2}+158z+171)}{27\beta z} \tag*{(140)} C P 1 , 22 μ ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 9 β 316 ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) l − 3 4 ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) Φ ( z ) + 3 2 ( 7 z + 9 ) Ψ ( z ) − 9 β z 2 2120 z 4 + 3020 z 3 − 1642 z 2 + 396 z − 57 log z + 9 β z 4 ( 856 z 3 + 1150 z 2 − 395 z − 12 ) log β + 9 β 2 z 4416 z 6 + 1392 z 5 + 768 z 4 − 5692 z 3 + 2320 z 2 − 510 z + 57 log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 27 β z 2 ( 3312 z 4 − 5137 z 3 − 2074 z 2 + 158 z + 171 ) (140)
C P 2 , 22 μ ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = 248 z 2 β l + 16 z 2 3 Φ ( z ) − 6 z Ψ ( z ) + 2312 z 4 − 508 z 3 − 54 z 2 + 12 z + 1 3 β z 2 log z − 4 ( 936 z 3 − 126 z 2 − 41 z + 12 ) 3 β z log β + 4416 z 6 − 5584 z 5 + 2448 z 4 − 428 z 3 − 80 z 2 + 10 z + 1 3 β 2 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 6624 z 4 + 7700 z 3 − 1034 z 2 − 353 z + 6 9 β z (141) C^{\mu|ss,8,(1)}_{P_{2,22}} = \frac{248z^{2}}{\beta}l + \frac{16z^{2}}{3}\Phi(z) - 6z\Psi(z) + \frac{2312z^{4}-508z^{3}-54z^{2}+12z+1}{3\beta z^{2}}\log z
- \frac{4(936z^{3}-126z^{2}-41z+12)}{3\beta z}\log\beta
+ \frac{4416z^{6}-5584z^{5}+2448z^{4}-428z^{3}-80z^{2}+10z+1}{3\beta^{2}z^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
+ \frac{6624z^{4}+7700z^{3}-1034z^{2}-353z+6}{9\beta z} \tag*{(141)} C P 2 , 22 μ ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = β 248 z 2 l + 3 16 z 2 Φ ( z ) − 6 z Ψ ( z ) + 3 β z 2 2312 z 4 − 508 z 3 − 54 z 2 + 12 z + 1 log z − 3 β z 4 ( 936 z 3 − 126 z 2 − 41 z + 12 ) log β + 3 β 2 z 2 4416 z 6 − 5584 z 5 + 2448 z 4 − 428 z 3 − 80 z 2 + 10 z + 1 log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 9 β z 6624 z 4 + 7700 z 3 − 1034 z 2 − 353 z + 6 (141)
C P 5 , 22 μ ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 2 ( 16 z 2 + 10 z − 5 ) 3 β l + z Ψ ( z ) − β ( 4 z 3 + 2 z 2 − 6 z + 1 ) 2 z 2 log z + 2 β ( 2 z − 1 ) log β + 32 z 5 + 96 z 4 − 24 z 3 − 36 z 2 + 24 z − 3 6 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 256 z 4 + 1498 z 3 + 966 z 2 − 483 z + 24 24 β z (142) C^{\mu|ss,8,(1)}_{P_{5,22}} = -\frac{2(16z^{2}+10z-5)}{3\beta}l + z\Psi(z) - \frac{\beta(4z^{3}+2z^{2}-6z+1)}{2z^{2}}\log z
+ 2\beta(2z-1)\log\beta+ \frac{32z^{5}+96z^{4}-24z^{3}-36z^{2}+24z-3}{6z^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
- \frac{256z^{4}+1498z^{3}+966z^{2}-483z+24}{24\beta z} \tag*{(142)} C P 5 , 22 μ ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 3 β 2 ( 16 z 2 + 10 z − 5 ) l + z Ψ ( z ) − 2 z 2 β ( 4 z 3 + 2 z 2 − 6 z + 1 ) log z + 2 β ( 2 z − 1 ) log β + 6 z 2 32 z 5 + 96 z 4 − 24 z 3 − 36 z 2 + 24 z − 3 log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 24 β z 256 z 4 + 1498 z 3 + 966 z 2 − 483 z + 24 (142)
C P 1 , 12 μ ∣ s s , 1 , ( 1 ) = 32 ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) β l + 32 ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) 3 Φ ( z ) + 16 z 3 Ψ ( z ) + 4 β ( 60 z 3 + 18 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) 3 z 2 log z − 8 β ( 32 z 2 + 10 z + 1 ) 3 z log β + 4 ( 336 z 6 + 28 z 5 − 188 z 4 − 72 z 3 + 8 z − 1 ) 3 β 2 z log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 4 ( 168 z 4 − 54 z 3 − 49 z 2 − 3 z − 2 ) 3 β z (143) C^{\mu|ss,1,(1)}_{P_{1,12}} = \frac{32(2z^{2}+2z-1)}{\beta}l + \frac{32(2z^{2}-1)}{3}\Phi(z) + \frac{16z}{3}\Psi(z)
+ \frac{4\beta(60z^{3}+18z^{2}+2z-1)}{3z^{2}}\log z - \frac{8\beta(32z^{2}+10z+1)}{3z}\log\beta
+ \frac{4(336z^{6}+28z^{5}-188z^{4}-72z^{3}+8z-1)}{3\beta^{2}z}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
+ \frac{4(168z^{4}-54z^{3}-49z^{2}-3z-2)}{3\beta z} \tag*{(143)} C P 1 , 12 μ ∣ ss , 1 , ( 1 ) = β 32 ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) l + 3 32 ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) Φ ( z ) + 3 16 z Ψ ( z ) + 3 z 2 4 β ( 60 z 3 + 18 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) log z − 3 z 8 β ( 32 z 2 + 10 z + 1 ) log β + 3 β 2 z 4 ( 336 z 6 + 28 z 5 − 188 z 4 − 72 z 3 + 8 z − 1 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 3 β z 4 ( 168 z 4 − 54 z 3 − 49 z 2 − 3 z − 2 ) (143)
C P 2 , 12 μ ∣ s s , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 384 z 2 β l − 128 z 2 3 Φ ( z ) − 4 β ( 132 z 3 + 10 z 2 − 2 z + 1 ) 3 z 2 log z + 8 β ( 64 z 2 + 10 z − 3 ) 3 z log β + 4 ( 1008 z 6 − 1036 z 5 + 452 z 4 − 64 z 3 − 28 z 2 + 8 z − 1 ) 3 β 2 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 4 ( 504 z 4 − 594 z 3 − 15 z 2 + 5 z − 2 ) 3 β z (144) C^{\mu|ss,1,(1)}_{P_{2,12}} = -\frac{384z^{2}}{\beta}l - \frac{128z^{2}}{3}\Phi(z) - \frac{4\beta(132z^{3}+10z^{2}-2z+1)}{3z^{2}}\log z
+ \frac{8\beta(64z^{2}+10z-3)}{3z}\log\beta
+ \frac{4(1008z^{6}-1036z^{5}+452z^{4}-64z^{3}-28z^{2}+8z-1)}{3\beta^{2}z^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)
+ \frac{4(504z^{4}-594z^{3}-15z^{2}+5z-2)}{3\beta z} \tag*{(144)} C P 2 , 12 μ ∣ ss , 1 , ( 1 ) = − β 384 z 2 l − 3 128 z 2 Φ ( z ) − 3 z 2 4 β ( 132 z 3 + 10 z 2 − 2 z + 1 ) log z + 3 z 8 β ( 64 z 2 + 10 z − 3 ) log β + 3 β 2 z 2 4 ( 1008 z 6 − 1036 z 5 + 452 z 4 − 64 z 3 − 28 z 2 + 8 z − 1 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 3 β z 4 ( 504 z 4 − 594 z 3 − 15 z 2 + 5 z − 2 ) (144)
C P 5 , 12 u ∣ s s , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 32 ⋅ ( 4 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) 9 β l + 16 z 9 Ψ ( z ) + 4 β ( 20 z 3 + 4 z 2 + 36 z − 9 ) 27 z 2 log z − 8 β ( 2 z + 3 ) ( 10 z − 1 ) 27 z log β + 4 ⋅ ( 16 z 5 + 54 z 4 − 24 z 3 − 50 z 2 + 54 z − 9 ) 27 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 2 ( 64 z 4 + 1350 z 3 + 938 z 2 − 491 z + 36 ) 27 β z (145) C^{u|ss,1,(1)}_{P_{5,12}}=-\frac{32\cdot(4z^{2}+2z-1)}{9\beta}\,l+\frac{16z}{9}\,\Psi(z)+\frac{4\beta(20z^{3}+4z^{2}+36z-9)}{27z^{2}}\log z-\frac{8\beta(2z+3)(10z-1)}{27z}\log\beta+\frac{4\cdot(16z^{5}+54z^{4}-24z^{3}-50z^{2}+54z-9)}{27z^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)-\frac{2(64z^{4}+1350z^{3}+938z^{2}-491z+36)}{27\beta z} \tag*{(145)} C P 5 , 12 u ∣ ss , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 9 β 32 ⋅ ( 4 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) l + 9 16 z Ψ ( z ) + 27 z 2 4 β ( 20 z 3 + 4 z 2 + 36 z − 9 ) log z − 27 z 8 β ( 2 z + 3 ) ( 10 z − 1 ) log β + 27 z 2 4 ⋅ ( 16 z 5 + 54 z 4 − 24 z 3 − 50 z 2 + 54 z − 9 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 27 β z 2 ( 64 z 4 + 1350 z 3 + 938 z 2 − 491 z + 36 ) (145)
C P 1 , 12 u ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 16 ⋅ ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) 3 β l + 4 z Ψ ( z ) − 512 z 4 + 476 z 3 − 178 z 2 − 18 z + 3 3 β z 2 log z + 2 ⋅ ( 368 z 3 + 416 z 2 − 166 z − 3 ) 3 β z log β + 12 z 5 − 72 z 4 − 72 z 3 + 196 z 2 + 12 z − 3 3 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 72 z 4 + 926 z 3 + 857 z 2 − 196 z + 18 9 β z (146) C^{u|ss,8,(1)}_{P_{1,12}}=-\frac{16\cdot(2z^{2}+2z-1)}{3\beta}\,l+4z\,\Psi(z)-\frac{512z^{4}+476z^{3}-178z^{2}-18z+3}{3\beta z^{2}}\log z+\frac{2\cdot(368z^{3}+416z^{2}-166z-3)}{3\beta z}\log\beta+\frac{12z^{5}-72z^{4}-72z^{3}+196z^{2}+12z-3}{3z^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)-\frac{72z^{4}+926z^{3}+857z^{2}-196z+18}{9\beta z} \tag*{(146)} C P 1 , 12 u ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 3 β 16 ⋅ ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) l + 4 z Ψ ( z ) − 3 β z 2 512 z 4 + 476 z 3 − 178 z 2 − 18 z + 3 log z + 3 β z 2 ⋅ ( 368 z 3 + 416 z 2 − 166 z − 3 ) log β + 3 z 2 12 z 5 − 72 z 4 − 72 z 3 + 196 z 2 + 12 z − 3 log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 9 β z 72 z 4 + 926 z 3 + 857 z 2 − 196 z + 18 (146)
C P 2 , 12 u ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 48 z 2 β l + 320 z 4 − 116 z 3 + 18 z 2 + 6 z − 1 β 2 log z − 2 ( 176 z 3 − 48 z 2 + 6 z + 3 ) β z log β + 12 z 5 + 48 z 4 − 64 z 3 + 24 z 2 + 4 z − 1 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 72 z 4 + 298 z 3 + 137 z 2 + 20 z + 6 3 β z (147) C^{u|ss,8,(1)}_{P_{2,12}}=-\frac{48z^{2}}{\beta}\,l+\frac{320z^{4}-116z^{3}+18z^{2}+6z-1}{\beta^{2}}\log z-\frac{2(176z^{3}-48z^{2}+6z+3)}{\beta z}\log\beta+\frac{12z^{5}+48z^{4}-64z^{3}+24z^{2}+4z-1}{z^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)-\frac{72z^{4}+298z^{3}+137z^{2}+20z+6}{3\beta z} \tag*{(147)} C P 2 , 12 u ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = − β 48 z 2 l + β 2 320 z 4 − 116 z 3 + 18 z 2 + 6 z − 1 log z − β z 2 ( 176 z 3 − 48 z 2 + 6 z + 3 ) log β + z 2 12 z 5 + 48 z 4 − 64 z 3 + 24 z 2 + 4 z − 1 log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 3 β z 72 z 4 + 298 z 3 + 137 z 2 + 20 z + 6 (147)
C P 5 , 12 u ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = 4 ⋅ ( 14 z 2 + 10 z − 5 ) 3 β l + 14 z 3 Ψ ( z ) − β ( 40 z 3 + 62 z 2 − 252 z + 63 ) 18 z 2 log z + β ( 40 z 2 − 106 z + 21 ) 9 z log β + 292 z 5 + 216 z 4 − 168 z 3 − 440 z 2 + 378 z − 63 18 z 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 1168 z 4 − 1704 z 3 + 6356 z 2 − 2513 z + 252 36 β z (148) C^{u|ss,8,(1)}_{P_{5,12}}=\frac{4\cdot(14z^{2}+10z-5)}{3\beta}\,l+\frac{14z}{3}\,\Psi(z)-\frac{\beta(40z^{3}+62z^{2}-252z+63)}{18z^{2}}\log z+\frac{\beta(40z^{2}-106z+21)}{9z}\log\beta+\frac{292z^{5}+216z^{4}-168z^{3}-440z^{2}+378z-63}{18z^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)-\frac{1168z^{4}-1704z^{3}+6356z^{2}-2513z+252}{36\beta z} \tag*{(148)} C P 5 , 12 u ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = 3 β 4 ⋅ ( 14 z 2 + 10 z − 5 ) l + 3 14 z Ψ ( z ) − 18 z 2 β ( 40 z 3 + 62 z 2 − 252 z + 63 ) log z + 9 z β ( 40 z 2 − 106 z + 21 ) log β + 18 z 2 292 z 5 + 216 z 4 − 168 z 3 − 440 z 2 + 378 z − 63 log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 36 β z 1168 z 4 − 1704 z 3 + 6356 z 2 − 2513 z + 252 (148)
C P 1 , 11 u ∣ s s , 1 , ( 1 ) = 16 ⋅ ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) Φ ( z ) + 96 β z log z − 128 β z log β + 32 z ( 24 z 3 − 2 z 2 − 17 z + 1 ) β 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 8 β ( 12 z 2 − 8 z − 3 ) (149) C^{u|ss,1,(1)}_{P_{1,11}}=16\cdot(2z^{2}-1)\,\Phi(z)+96\beta z\log z-128\beta z\log\beta+\frac{32z(24z^{3}-2z^{2}-17z+1)}{\beta^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)-8\beta(12z^{2}-8z-3) \tag*{(149)} C P 1 , 11 u ∣ ss , 1 , ( 1 ) = 16 ⋅ ( 2 z 2 − 1 ) Φ ( z ) + 96 β z log z − 128 β z log β + β 2 32 z ( 24 z 3 − 2 z 2 − 17 z + 1 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 8 β ( 12 z 2 − 8 z − 3 ) (149)
C P 2 , 11 u ∣ s s , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 288 z 2 β l − 64 z 2 Φ ( z ) − 48 β ( 4 z + 1 ) log z + 64 β ( 4 z + 1 ) log β + 48 ⋅ ( 2 z − 1 ) ( 24 z 3 − 6 z 2 + 1 ) β 2 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 16 z ( 72 z 2 − 8 z − 7 ) β (150) C^{u|ss,1,(1)}_{P_{2,11}}=-\frac{288z^{2}}{\beta}\,l-64z^{2}\Phi(z)-48\beta(4z+1)\log z+64\beta(4z+1)\log\beta+\frac{48\cdot(2z-1)(24z^{3}-6z^{2}+1)}{\beta^{2}}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)+\frac{16z(72z^{2}-8z-7)}{\beta} \tag*{(150)} C P 2 , 11 u ∣ ss , 1 , ( 1 ) = − β 288 z 2 l − 64 z 2 Φ ( z ) − 48 β ( 4 z + 1 ) log z + 64 β ( 4 z + 1 ) log β + β 2 48 ⋅ ( 2 z − 1 ) ( 24 z 3 − 6 z 2 + 1 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + β 16 z ( 72 z 2 − 8 z − 7 ) (150)
C P 5 , 11 u ∣ s s , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 16 ⋅ ( 4 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) 3 β l + 20 β ( 2 z + 1 ) 9 log z − 40 β ( 2 z + 1 ) 9 log β − 4 ⋅ ( 10 z 2 − 9 z 2 − 5 ) 9 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 80 z 2 − 1218 z 2 − 44 z + 113 9 β (151) C^{u|ss,1,(1)}_{P_{5,11}}=-\frac{16\cdot(4z^{2}+2z-1)}{3\beta}\,l+\frac{20\beta(2z+1)}{9}\log z-\frac{40\beta(2z+1)}{9}\log\beta-\frac{4\cdot(10z^{2}-9z^{2}-5)}{9}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)+\frac{80z^{2}-1218z^{2}-44z+113}{9\beta} \tag*{(151)} C P 5 , 11 u ∣ ss , 1 , ( 1 ) = − 3 β 16 ⋅ ( 4 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) l + 9 20 β ( 2 z + 1 ) log z − 9 40 β ( 2 z + 1 ) log β − 9 4 ⋅ ( 10 z 2 − 9 z 2 − 5 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 9 β 80 z 2 − 1218 z 2 − 44 z + 113 (151)
C P 1 , 11 u ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = − 44 ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) β l − 2 ( 92 z 2 + 74 z − 37 ) β log z + 4 ( 92 z 2 + 74 z − 37 ) β log β − 2 ( 6 z 3 + 9 z 2 − 37 ) log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 144 z 3 − 2024 z 2 − 560 z + 331 6 β (152) C^{u|ss,8,(1)}_{P_{1,11}}=-\frac{44(2z^{2}+2z-1)}{\beta}\,l-\frac{2(92z^{2}+74z-37)}{\beta}\log z+\frac{4(92z^{2}+74z-37)}{\beta}\log\beta-2(6z^{3}+9z^{2}-37)\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)+\frac{144z^{3}-2024z^{2}-560z+331}{6\beta} \tag*{(152)} C P 1 , 11 u ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = − β 44 ( 2 z 2 + 2 z − 1 ) l − β 2 ( 92 z 2 + 74 z − 37 ) log z + β 4 ( 92 z 2 + 74 z − 37 ) log β − 2 ( 6 z 3 + 9 z 2 − 37 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 6 β 144 z 3 − 2024 z 2 − 560 z + 331 (152)
C P 2 , 11 u ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = 144 z 2 β l + 6 ⋅ ( 44 z 2 − 6 z + 3 ) β log z − 12 ⋅ ( 44 z 2 − 6 z + 3 ) β log β − 6 ( 6 z 3 + z 2 − 3 ) log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) + 144 z 3 + 1292 z 2 − 260 z − 35 2 β (153) C^{u|ss,8,(1)}_{P_{2,11}}=\frac{144z^{2}}{\beta}\,l+\frac{6\cdot(44z^{2}-6z+3)}{\beta}\log z-\frac{12\cdot(44z^{2}-6z+3)}{\beta}\log\beta-6(6z^{3}+z^{2}-3)\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)+\frac{144z^{3}+1292z^{2}-260z-35}{2\beta} \tag*{(153)} C P 2 , 11 u ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = β 144 z 2 l + β 6 ⋅ ( 44 z 2 − 6 z + 3 ) log z − β 12 ⋅ ( 44 z 2 − 6 z + 3 ) log β − 6 ( 6 z 3 + z 2 − 3 ) log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) + 2 β 144 z 3 + 1292 z 2 − 260 z − 35 (153)
C P 5 , 11 u ∣ s s , 8 , ( 1 ) = 2 ⋅ ( 14 z 2 + 10 z − 5 ) β l − 5 β ( 2 z + 1 ) 3 log z + 10 β ( 2 z + 1 ) 3 log β + 10 z 3 − 9 z 2 − 5 3 log ( 1 + β 1 − β ) − 160 z 3 − 2628 z 2 + 98 z + 133 24 β (154) C_{P_{5,11}}^{u|ss,8,(1)} = \frac{2\cdot(14z^2+10z-5)}{\beta}l-\frac{5\beta(2z+1)}{3}\log z+\frac{10\beta(2z+1)}{3}\log\beta
+\frac{10z^3-9z^2-5}{3}\log\left(\frac{1+\beta}{1-\beta}\right)-\frac{160z^3-2628z^2+98z+133}{24\beta} \tag*{(154)} C P 5 , 11 u ∣ ss , 8 , ( 1 ) = β 2 ⋅ ( 14 z 2 + 10 z − 5 ) l − 3 5 β ( 2 z + 1 ) log z + 3 10 β ( 2 z + 1 ) log β + 3 10 z 3 − 9 z 2 − 5 log ( 1 − β 1 + β ) − 24 β 160 z 3 − 2628 z 2 + 98 z + 133 (154)
Semileptonic coefficients with a massive charged lepton
For c → q ℓ + ν ℓ c\to q\ell^+\nu_\ell c → q ℓ + ν ℓ , with q = d , s q=d,s q = d , s and m ν ℓ = 0 m_{\nu_\ell}=0 m ν ℓ = 0 , define ρ = m ℓ 2 / M 2 \rho=m_\ell^2/M^2 ρ = m ℓ 2 / M 2 . The result below is for one charged-lepton species and uses the same operator basis and fixed prescription as the nonleptonic coefficients, with J 76 = 0 J_{76}=0 J 76 = 0 . Our normalization is
T 7 , ℓ S L , q = G F 2 ∣ V c q ∣ 2 M 2 6 π ∑ c = 1 , 8 ∑ i = 1 5 C i , ℓ c ( ρ , μ ) P i q , c . (155) \mathcal{T}_{7,\ell}^{\mathrm{SL},q}=\frac{G_F^2|V_{cq}|^2M^2}{6\pi}\sum_{c=1,8}\sum_{i=1}^{5}C_{i,\ell}^{c}(\rho,\mu)P_i^{q,c}. \tag*{(155)} T 7 , ℓ SL , q = 6 π G F 2 ∣ V c q ∣ 2 M 2 c = 1 , 8 ∑ i = 1 ∑ 5 C i , ℓ c ( ρ , μ ) P i q , c . (155)
The coefficients are independent of q q q at this order in the external soft momentum. The dependence on the mass of q q q resides in the operators. With C ℓ c , ( n ) = ( C 1 , ℓ c , ( n ) , … , C 5 , ℓ c , ( n ) ) \boldsymbol{C}_{\ell}^{c,(n)}=(C_{1,\ell}^{c,(n)},\ldots,C_{5,\ell}^{c,(n)}) C ℓ c , ( n ) = ( C 1 , ℓ c , ( n ) , … , C 5 , ℓ c , ( n ) ) , the LO coefficients are
C ℓ 1 , ( 0 ) = ( 2 ( 1 − ρ 3 ) , 6 ρ 2 ( 1 − ρ ) , − ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 1 + 2 ρ ) , 0 , 0 ) , \boldsymbol{C}_{\ell}^{1,(0)}=\left(2(1-\rho^3),\,6\rho^2(1-\rho),\,-(1-\rho)^2(1+2\rho),\,0,\,0\right), C ℓ 1 , ( 0 ) = ( 2 ( 1 − ρ 3 ) , 6 ρ 2 ( 1 − ρ ) , − ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 1 + 2 ρ ) , 0 , 0 ) ,
C ℓ 8 , ( 0 ) = ( 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) . (156) \boldsymbol{C}_{\ell}^{8,(0)}=(0,0,0,0,0). \tag*{(156)} C ℓ 8 , ( 0 ) = ( 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 ) . (156)
The NLO expressions are valid for 0 < ρ < 1 0<\rho<1 0 < ρ < 1 . Their massless limits are continuous.
C 1 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 0 (157) C_{1,\ell}^{1,(1)}(\rho)=0 \tag*{(157)} C 1 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 0 (157)
C 2 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = − 48 ( 1 − ρ ) ρ 2 l − 64 ( 1 − ρ ) ρ 2 (158) C_{2,\ell}^{1,(1)}(\rho)=-48(1-\rho)\rho^2l-64(1-\rho)\rho^2 \tag*{(158)} C 2 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = − 48 ( 1 − ρ ) ρ 2 l − 64 ( 1 − ρ ) ρ 2 (158)
C 3 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 4 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) l + 6 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) (159) C_{3,\ell}^{1,(1)}(\rho)=4(1-\rho)^2(2\rho+1)l+6(1-\rho)^2(2\rho+1) \tag*{(159)} C 3 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 4 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) l + 6 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) (159)
C 4 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 7 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) 3 (160) C_{4,\ell}^{1,(1)}(\rho)=\frac{7(1-\rho)^2(2\rho+1)}{3} \tag*{(160)} C 4 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 3 7 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) (160)
C 5 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 16 ( 1 − ρ ) ( ρ + 1 ) 9 l + 2 ρ 2 ( 5 ρ − 13 ) 9 log ρ − 20 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) 27 log ( 1 − ρ ) − ( 1 − ρ ) ( 148 ρ 2 − 204 ρ − 113 ) 27 (161) \begin{aligned}
C_{5,\ell}^{1,(1)}(\rho)={}&\frac{16(1-\rho)(\rho+1)}{9}l+\frac{2\rho^2(5\rho-13)}{9}\log\rho\\
&-\frac{20(1-\rho)^2(2\rho+1)}{27}\log(1-\rho)-\frac{(1-\rho)(148\rho^2-204\rho-113)}{27} \tag*{(161)}
\end{aligned} C 5 , ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 9 16 ( 1 − ρ ) ( ρ + 1 ) l + 9 2 ρ 2 ( 5 ρ − 13 ) log ρ − 27 20 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) log ( 1 − ρ ) − 27 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 148 ρ 2 − 204 ρ − 113 ) (161)
C 1 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 44 ( 1 − ρ ) ( ρ 2 + ρ + 1 ) 3 l − ρ 2 ( 59 ρ + 9 ) 3 log ρ − 2 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 28 ρ 2 + 37 ρ + 37 ) 3 log ( 1 − ρ ) + ( 1 − ρ ) ( 637 ρ 2 + 382 ρ + 331 ) 18 (162) \begin{aligned}
C_{1,\ell}^{8,(1)}(\rho)={}&\frac{44(1-\rho)(\rho^2+\rho+1)}{3}l-\frac{\rho^2(59\rho+9)}{3}\log\rho\\
&-\frac{2(1-\rho)(28\rho^2+37\rho+37)}{3}\log(1-\rho)+\frac{(1-\rho)(637\rho^2+382\rho+331)}{18} \tag*{(162)}
\end{aligned} C 1 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 3 44 ( 1 − ρ ) ( ρ 2 + ρ + 1 ) l − 3 ρ 2 ( 59 ρ + 9 ) log ρ − 3 2 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 28 ρ 2 + 37 ρ + 37 ) log ( 1 − ρ ) + 18 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 637 ρ 2 + 382 ρ + 331 ) (162)
C 2 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 24 ( 1 − ρ ) ρ 2 l − ρ 2 ( 59 ρ − 51 ) log ρ − 2 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 28 ρ 2 + 3 ρ + 3 ) log ( 1 − ρ ) + ( 1 − ρ ) ( 459 ρ 2 − 200 ρ − 35 ) 6 (163) \begin{aligned}
C_{2,\ell}^{8,(1)}(\rho)={}&24(1-\rho)\rho^2l-\rho^2(59\rho-51)\log\rho\\
&-2(1-\rho)(28\rho^2+3\rho+3)\log(1-\rho)+\frac{(1-\rho)(459\rho^2-200\rho-35)}{6} \tag*{(163)}
\end{aligned} C 2 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 24 ( 1 − ρ ) ρ 2 l − ρ 2 ( 59 ρ − 51 ) log ρ − 2 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 28 ρ 2 + 3 ρ + 3 ) log ( 1 − ρ ) + 6 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 459 ρ 2 − 200 ρ − 35 ) (163)
C 3 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 4 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 5 ρ 2 − 4 ρ − 4 ) 3 l − ρ 2 ( 47 ρ − 63 ) 3 log ρ + 22 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) 3 log ( 1 − ρ ) + ( 1 − ρ ) ( 1169 ρ 2 − 1003 ρ − 601 ) 36 (164) \begin{aligned}
C_{3,\ell}^{8,(1)}(\rho)={}&\frac{4(1-\rho)(5\rho^2-4\rho-4)}{3}l-\frac{\rho^2(47\rho-63)}{3}\log\rho\\
&+\frac{22(1-\rho)^2(2\rho+1)}{3}\log(1-\rho)+\frac{(1-\rho)(1169\rho^2-1003\rho-601)}{36} \tag*{(164)}
\end{aligned} C 3 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = 3 4 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 5 ρ 2 − 4 ρ − 4 ) l − 3 ρ 2 ( 47 ρ − 63 ) log ρ + 3 22 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) log ( 1 − ρ ) + 36 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 1169 ρ 2 − 1003 ρ − 601 ) (164)
C 4 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = − 12 ( 1 − ρ ) ( ρ + 1 ) l − ρ 2 ( 4 ρ − 9 ) log ρ − 2 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 2 ρ 2 − 3 ρ − 3 ) log ( 1 − ρ ) − ( 1 − ρ ) ( 90 ρ 2 + 311 ρ + 155 ) 12 (165) \begin{aligned}
C_{4,\ell}^{8,(1)}(\rho)={}&-12(1-\rho)(\rho+1)l-\rho^2(4\rho-9)\log\rho\\
&-2(1-\rho)(2\rho^2-3\rho-3)\log(1-\rho)-\frac{(1-\rho)(90\rho^2+311\rho+155)}{12} \tag*{(165)}
\end{aligned} C 4 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = − 12 ( 1 − ρ ) ( ρ + 1 ) l − ρ 2 ( 4 ρ − 9 ) log ρ − 2 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 2 ρ 2 − 3 ρ − 3 ) log ( 1 − ρ ) − 12 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 90 ρ 2 + 311 ρ + 155 ) (165)
C 5 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = − 2 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 3 ρ 2 + 5 ρ + 5 ) 3 l − ρ 2 ( 5 ρ − 13 ) 6 log ρ + 5 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) 9 log ( 1 − ρ ) + ( 1 − ρ ) ( 578 ρ 2 − 315 ρ − 133 ) 72 (166) C_{5,\ell}^{8,(1)}(\rho)=-\frac{2(1-\rho)(3\rho^2+5\rho+5)}{3}l-\frac{\rho^2(5\rho-13)}{6}\log\rho+\frac{5(1-\rho)^2(2\rho+1)}{9}\log(1-\rho)+\frac{(1-\rho)(578\rho^2-315\rho-133)}{72} \tag*{(166)} C 5 , ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( ρ ) = − 3 2 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 3 ρ 2 + 5 ρ + 5 ) l − 6 ρ 2 ( 5 ρ − 13 ) log ρ + 9 5 ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 2 ρ + 1 ) log ( 1 − ρ ) + 72 ( 1 − ρ ) ( 578 ρ 2 − 315 ρ − 133 ) (166)
For a massless charged lepton, ρ = 0 \rho=0 ρ = 0 , the NLO coefficients reduce to
C ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( 0 ) = ( 0 , 0 , 4 l + 6 , 7 3 , 16 9 l + 113 27 ) , (167) C_{\ell}^{1,(1)}(0)=\left(0,\ 0,\ 4l+6,\ \frac{7}{3},\ \frac{16}{9}l+\frac{113}{27}\right), \tag*{(167)} C ℓ 1 , ( 1 ) ( 0 ) = ( 0 , 0 , 4 l + 6 , 3 7 , 9 16 l + 27 113 ) , (167)
C ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( 0 ) = ( 44 3 l + 331 18 , − 35 6 , − 16 3 l − 601 36 , − 12 l − 155 12 , − 10 3 l − 133 72 ) . C_{\ell}^{8,(1)}(0)=\left(\frac{44}{3}l+\frac{331}{18},\ -\frac{35}{6},\ -\frac{16}{3}l-\frac{601}{36},\ -12l-\frac{155}{12},\ -\frac{10}{3}l-\frac{133}{72}\right). C ℓ 8 , ( 1 ) ( 0 ) = ( 3 44 l + 18 331 , − 6 35 , − 3 16 l − 36 601 , − 12 l − 12 155 , − 3 10 l − 72 133 ) .
Hadronic inputs
Meson matrix elements and coefficient contraction
In both heavy–light colour channels the operators P i , l i t Q C D P_{i,\mathrm{lit}}^{\mathrm{QCD}} P i , lit QCD of ref. [12 ] , eq. (2.33), give those of eq. (4) as
P 1 = 1 2 M ( P 2 , l i t Q C D + P 2 , l i t Q C D † ) , P 2 = − 1 M ( P 3 , l i t Q C D + P 3 , l i t Q C D † ) , P_1=\frac{1}{2M}\left(P_{2,\mathrm{lit}}^{\mathrm{QCD}}+P_{2,\mathrm{lit}}^{\mathrm{QCD}\dagger}\right),\qquad P_2=-\frac{1}{M}\left(P_{3,\mathrm{lit}}^{\mathrm{QCD}}+P_{3,\mathrm{lit}}^{\mathrm{QCD}\dagger}\right), P 1 = 2 M 1 ( P 2 , lit QCD + P 2 , lit QCD † ) , P 2 = − M 1 ( P 3 , lit QCD + P 3 , lit QCD † ) ,
P 3 = 1 M ( P 1 , l i t Q C D + P 1 , l i t Q C D † ) . (168) P_3=\frac{1}{M}\left(P_{1,\mathrm{lit}}^{\mathrm{QCD}}+P_{1,\mathrm{lit}}^{\mathrm{QCD}\dagger}\right). \tag*{(168)} P 3 = M 1 ( P 1 , lit QCD + P 1 , lit QCD † ) . (168)
Expressed through our operators, its eq. (B.13) has the prefactor $G_F^2M^2/(12\pi)$, half of ours. The VIA matrix elements, in the operator order of eq. (2.3)`, are given by
⟨ P ⟩ H ( 0 ) = B H M ( − Λ ˉ q , 2 Λ ˉ q , − 2 m q , m q , 2 3 ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 8 9 ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) ) T , \langle P\rangle_H^{(0)}=\frac{B_H}{M}\left(-\bar{\Lambda}_q,2\bar{\Lambda}_q,-2m_q,m_q,\frac{2}{3}(\bar{\Lambda}_q-m_q),0,0,0,0,\frac{8}{9}(\bar{\Lambda}_q-m_q)\right)^T, ⟨ P ⟩ H ( 0 ) = M B H ( − Λ ˉ q , 2 Λ ˉ q , − 2 m q , m q , 3 2 ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) , 0 , 0 , 0 , 0 , 9 8 ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) ) T ,
⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) ∣ M − 1 = B H M ( 0 , 2 ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) , 0 , 0 ) T . (169) \left.\langle Q\rangle_H^{(0)}\right|_{M^{-1}}=\frac{B_H}{M}\left(0,2(\bar{\Lambda}_q-m_q),0,0\right)^T. \tag*{(169)} ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) M − 1 = M B H ( 0 , 2 ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) , 0 , 0 ) T . (169)
The factor two in ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) ∣ M − 1 \left.\langle Q\rangle_H^{(0)}\right|_{M^{-1}} ⟨ Q ⟩ H ( 0 ) M − 1 is the descendant 2 C Q S R 2 / M 2C_{Q_S}R_2/M 2 C Q S R 2 / M of ref. [12 ] , appendix C. For P 5 P_5 P 5 , the heavy-quark EOM gives
P 5 1 = [ i M c ˉ D ↔ ν c − 2 c ˉ γ ν c ] ( q ˉ γ ν L q ) , D ↔ = D − D ← , (170) P_5^1=\left[\frac{i}{M}\bar{c}\overleftrightarrow{D}^{\nu}c-2\bar{c}\gamma^\nu c\right](\bar{q}\gamma_\nu Lq),\qquad\overleftrightarrow{D}=D-\overleftarrow{D}, \tag*{(170)} P 5 1 = [ M i c ˉ D ν c − 2 c ˉ γ ν c ] ( q ˉ γ ν L q ) , D = D − D , (170)
and likewise P 5 8 P_5^8 P 5 8 with t A t^A t A in both bilinears. In VIA, we have
⟨ − 2 ( c ˉ γ ν c ) ( q ˉ γ ν L q ) ⟩ H = 2 ⟨ Q S ⟩ H − ⟨ Q ⟩ H N c , \left\langle-2(\bar{c}\gamma^\nu c)(\bar{q}\gamma_\nu Lq)\right\rangle_H=\frac{2\langle Q_S\rangle_H-\langle Q\rangle_H}{N_c}, ⟨ − 2 ( c ˉ γ ν c ) ( q ˉ γ ν L q ) ⟩ H = N c 2 ⟨ Q S ⟩ H − ⟨ Q ⟩ H ,
⟨ i M ( c ˉ D ↔ ν c ) ( q ˉ γ ν L q ) ⟩ H = − ⟨ Q S ⟩ H N c + O ( Λ ˉ q 2 M 2 ⟨ Q ⟩ H ) . (171) \left\langle\frac{i}{M}(\bar{c}\overleftrightarrow{D}^{\nu}c)(\bar{q}\gamma_\nu Lq)\right\rangle_H=-\frac{\langle Q_S\rangle_H}{N_c}+O\left(\frac{\bar{\Lambda}_q^2}{M^2}\langle Q\rangle_H\right). \tag*{(171)} ⟨ M i ( c ˉ D ν c ) ( q ˉ γ ν L q ) ⟩ H = − N c ⟨ Q S ⟩ H + O ( M 2 Λ ˉ q 2 ⟨ Q ⟩ H ) . (171)
With ⟨ Q S ⟩ H = ⟨ Q ⟩ H M H 2 / ( M + m q ) 2 \langle Q_S\rangle_H=\langle Q\rangle_HM_H^2/(M+m_q)^2 ⟨ Q S ⟩ H = ⟨ Q ⟩ H M H 2 / ( M + m q ) 2 and M H = M + Λ ˉ q M_H=M+\bar{\Lambda}_q M H = M + Λ ˉ q , we obtain
⟨ P 5 1 ⟩ H = ⟨ Q S ⟩ H − ⟨ Q ⟩ H N c = 2 ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) N c M ⟨ Q ⟩ H , ⟨ P 5 8 ⟩ H = 2 C F ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) N c M ⟨ Q ⟩ H . (172) \langle P_5^1\rangle_H=\frac{\langle Q_S\rangle_H-\langle Q\rangle_H}{N_c}=\frac{2(\bar{\Lambda}_q-m_q)}{N_cM}\langle Q\rangle_H,\qquad\langle P_5^8\rangle_H=\frac{2C_F(\bar{\Lambda}_q-m_q)}{N_cM}\langle Q\rangle_H. \tag*{(172)} ⟨ P 5 1 ⟩ H = N c ⟨ Q S ⟩ H − ⟨ Q ⟩ H = N c M 2 ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) ⟨ Q ⟩ H , ⟨ P 5 8 ⟩ H = N c M 2 C F ( Λ ˉ q − m q ) ⟨ Q ⟩ H . (172)
We set m q = 0 m_q=0 m q = 0 , so that P 3 P_3 P 3 and P 4 P_4 P 4 vanish.
The dimension-six rows follow from the appendix of ref. [38 ] and, for the semileptonic channel, appendix A of ref. [39 ] , with the transport of eqs. (15) and (16) of the former at μ = M \mu=M μ = M , apart from the penguin-like contributions omitted in section 2. For a lepton,
C Q S ( 1 ) = − 8 3 [ 3 l + 4 ] ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 1 + 2 ρ ) . C_{Q_S}^{(1)}=-\frac{8}{3}[3l+4](1-\rho)^2(1+2\rho). C Q S ( 1 ) = − 3 8 [ 3 l + 4 ] ( 1 − ρ ) 2 ( 1 + 2 ρ ) .
Table 8. Baryon matrix elements ⟨ O q ⟩ B \langle O_q\rangle_B ⟨ O q ⟩ B at μ = M = 1.59 \mu=M=1.59 μ = M = 1.59 GeV in 10 − 3 10^{-3} 1 0 − 3 GeV3 ^3 3 , for one valence quark q q q , evolved from μ H = 1.0 ± 0.2 \mu_H=1.0\pm0.2 μ H = 1.0 ± 0.2 GeV with eqs. (17) and (18) , the errors giving the range in μ H \mu_H μ H . We use ⟨ T ⟩ = − 2 3 ⟨ Q ⟩ \langle T\rangle=-\frac{2}{3}\langle Q\rangle ⟨ T ⟩ = − 3 2 ⟨ Q ⟩ , and the Ω c : s \Omega_c:s Ω c : s column counts both strange quarks.
Table 8 gives the baryon matrix elements ⟨ O ⟩ B = ⟨ B ∣ O ∣ B ⟩ / ( 2 M B ) \langle O\rangle_B=\langle B|O|B\rangle/(2M_B) ⟨ O ⟩ B = ⟨ B ∣ O ∣ B ⟩ / ( 2 M B ) at μ = M \mu=M μ = M , with M B M_B M B the baryon mass, evolved from μ H = 1.0 ± 0.2 \mu_H=1.0\pm0.2 μ H = 1.0 ± 0.2 GeV with eqs. (17) and (18) . At μ H \mu_H μ H , those of Q Q Q , Q S Q_S Q S , T T T , T S T_S T S and P 1 , 2 , 3 P_{1,2,3} P 1 , 2 , 3 follow from the bag model of ref. [30 ] , appendix A, with its energies E u , d = 0.32 E_{u,d}=0.32 E u , d = 0.32 GeV and E s = 0.50 E_s=0.50 E s = 0.50 GeV. Those of P 4 P_4 P 4 and P 5 P_5 P 5 are new tree overlaps of the same bag model, with ( m u , d , m s , m c ) b a g = ( 0 , 0.279 , 1.641 ) (m_{u,d},m_s,m_c)_{\mathrm{bag}}=(0,0.279,1.641) ( m u , d , m s , m c ) bag = ( 0 , 0.279 , 1.641 ) GeV and radii ( 4.86 , 4.88 , 4.93 ) (4.86,4.88,4.93) ( 4.86 , 4.88 , 4.93 ) GeV− 1 ^{-1} − 1 for ( Λ c , Ξ c , Ω c ) (\Lambda_c,\Xi_c,\Omega_c) ( Λ c , Ξ c , Ω c ) . In P 3 , 4 P_{3,4} P 3 , 4 , m s = m ‾ s ( μ H ) m_s=\overline{m}_s(\mu_H) m s = m s ( μ H ) , run at LO from m ‾ s ( 2 G e V ) = 0.09 \overline{m}_s(2\ \mathrm{GeV})=0.09 m s ( 2 GeV ) = 0.09 GeV. They use the bag spinors and overlaps of ref. [30 ] , appendix A. The derivative in P 5 P_5 P 5 acts on the complete compact-support spinors, wall included, and its time components cancel. At μ H \mu_H μ H the antisymmetric colour wavefunction gives ⟨ P i q , 8 ⟩ = − 2 3 ⟨ P i q , 1 ⟩ \langle P_i^{q,8}\rangle=-\frac{2}{3}\langle P_i^{q,1}\rangle ⟨ P i q , 8 ⟩ = − 3 2 ⟨ P i q , 1 ⟩ . The evolution changes this ratio, but keeps ⟨ T ⟩ = − 2 3 ⟨ Q ⟩ \langle T\rangle=-\frac{2}{3}\langle Q\rangle ⟨ T ⟩ = − 3 2 ⟨ Q ⟩ .