betaFeedback

WorksEngineering

Risk Assessment of Fair Multi-Period Dynamic Operating Envelopes under Uncertainty

Abstract

Dynamic operating envelopes (DOEs) can allocate time-varying export capacity to distributed energy resources (DERs), and while they are not intended to make operations immune to voltage violations, they should guide operations to mostly remain inside expected values under changing regimes and residual forecast errors. However, although recent literature proposed many different techniques for implementing DOEs, there is sparse discussion of analyzing and quantifying the risk of using more or less conservative DOEs under uncertain operating regimes. Having this gap in mind, this paper develops a risk-oriented extension of a previously established fair distributed multi-period optimal power flow (OPF) framework, where fair or technical DOEs are fixed as first-stage decisions and the OPF leverages battery energy storage and renewable curtailment as recourse under regime uncertainties. An independent nonlinear AC power flow then computes a resulting ensemble, which is summarized by (i) voltage-violation probability, severity, and a persistence metric for consecutive out-of-band hours, (ii) curtailment and Jain and Gini indices, and (iii) model deviations. Different probability situations are assessed, ranging from uniform, sunny-heavy, night-peak-heavy, and adversarial, which separate the envelope design from the assumed operating distribution. An optional outer loop allows for fine-tuning a fairness–efficiency parameter under explicit violation and persistence budgets. The combination of the outer loop and the overall framework, which quantifies how often and how severely operating limits are exceeded, creates an auditable methodology mixing equitable export allocation, distributed recourse, and AC risk assessment for active distribution network operators, and this framework is assessed using up to 1000 Monte Carlo scenarios per mixture and DOE design.

Introduction

High penetrations of rooftop photovoltaic (PV), wind generation, and battery energy storage systems (BESS) expose distribution feeders to reverse power flow, voltage rise, congestion, and time-dependent scarcity of export capacity 1. Dynamic operating envelopes (DOEs) replace uniform static limits with network-aware, time-varying permissions 2, which often use optimal power flow (OPF) methods as an underlying tool for computing such operating envelopes in a dynamic, network-aware fashion 3.

In particular, branch-flow OPF models provide an efficient basis for radial distribution operation [4, 5], while multi-period distributed OPF extends this basis to storage and temporal coupling [6], and the use of the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) is often preferred for enabling such regional coordination, relying only on limited information exchange on the shared interfaces. Furthermore, the allocation of fair DOEs has been discussed as a way to promote more equitable access, which prevents favoring prosumers at electrically strong buses. Authors have proposed the use of proportional rules [7] and uncertainty-aware formulations [8].

No recent work, however, addressed these different multi-period and fairness aspects in a single formulation. As such, the authors’ preceding work introduced a framework to compute DOEs with fairness across a multi-period problem, applying a cumulative proportional-fair allocation on top of technical DOEs, solving six representative operating regimes with BESS recourse in a distributed OPF solved using regional ADMM, and checking each final dispatch with AC power flow [9]. The scenario-based results establish feasibility at the selected operating points, but they do not quantify how frequently limits are exceeded when the regimes occur with different probabilities or when forecasts contain residual errors.This is particularly important having in mind that DOEs do not intend to make operations immune to large violations (else, they would be far too conservative); still, operators need to know how often they would incur deviations given the selected parameters when deriving DOEs. This gap motivates the present work, and the main contributions can be summarized as:

  • The use of a regime-mixture uncertainty model built on six interpretable stress regimes, enforcing proportional equity, which are then solved and validated as per [9];

  • The establishment of an AC ensemble protocol to report violation (i) probability, severity, and persistence, (ii) curtailment and Jain and Gini indices, allowing for a same-distribution comparison of fair and technical DOEs, and (iii) model deviations;

  • The introduction of a computationally efficient lightweight outer loop that tunes fairness–efficiency parameters, having in mind the explicitly derived voltage-risk budgets.

Research on DOEs spans technical envelope computation, equitable allocation, uncertainty-aware design, and probabilistic validation, as reviewed comprehensively in [2, 3]. Existing studies have developed Monte Carlo and nonlinear power-flow validation [10], weighted proportional fairness [7], chance-constrained fair DOEs [8], separate technical and equitable allocation stages [11], bargaining-based allocation [12], and stochastic or robust envelope construction [13, 14, 15]. CVaR has also been applied to risk-aware DSO–microgrid coordination [10]. Unlike these approaches, the present work fixes previously computed fair or technical DOEs before sampling and evaluates them using paired multiperiod AC ensembles with scenario-dependent BESS, curtailment, and emergency recourse. Its contribution is the combined assessment of cumulative fairness, CVaR, nonlinear AC feasibility, and temporal persistence.

Deterministic DOE Model

This section restates the inherited multiperiod DOE/OPF model in self-contained form, so that the risk layer that follows can be read without consulting [9] for every symbol. Operationally, the workflow is staged: technical envelopes are computed first; fair envelopes optionally redistribute that capacity under a budgeted equity criterion; for each uncertain realization the chosen envelopes are held fixed while BESS, curtailment, and (if needed) emergency demand response act as recourse; finally, the consolidated injections are validated by nonlinear AC power flow.

Network and Recourse Dispatch

Let N\mathcal{N}, E\mathcal{E}, T\mathcal{T}, P\mathcal{P}, and B\mathcal{B} denote the sets of buses, radial branches, time periods, renewable prosumers, and BESS units, respectively. To make the inherited aggregation explicit, Min=1M_{in}=1 if prosumer ii is connected to bus nn and zero otherwise, while Jig=1J_{ig}=1 if DER gg belongs to prosumer ii and zero otherwise. Hence bus-nn DER injection aggregates ∑iMin∑gJigpg,t\sum_i M_{in}\sum_g J_{ig}p_{g,t}, and prosumer-level energy quantities aggregate the same devices over T\mathcal{T}. For each branch (i,j)∈E(i,j)\in\mathcal{E}, the active and reactive flows are Pij,tP_{ij,t} and Qij,tQ_{ij,t}, and vi,tv_{i,t} is the squared voltage magnitude at bus ii. We adopt the lossless LinDistFlow equations

Pij,t=∑k∈child⁡(j)Pjk,t+pj,tL−pj,tR+pj,tch−pj,tdis,(1)P_{ij,t}=\sum_{k\in\operatorname{child}(j)}P_{jk,t}+p^L_{j,t}-p^R_{j,t}+p^{\mathrm{ch}}_{j,t}-p^{\mathrm{dis}}_{j,t}, \tag*{(1)}
Qij,t=∑k∈child⁡(j)Qjk,t+qj,tL−qj,tDER,(2)Q_{ij,t}=\sum_{k\in\operatorname{child}(j)}Q_{jk,t}+q^L_{j,t}-q^{\mathrm{DER}}_{j,t}, \tag*{(2)}
vj,t=vi,t−2(rijPij,t+xijQij,t).(3)v_{j,t}=v_{i,t}-2(r_{ij}P_{ij,t}+x_{ij}Q_{ij,t}). \tag*{(3)}

Voltage and thermal limits, renewable availability/curtailment, and the fixed-envelope export cap associated with (1) are

v‾≤vi,t≤v‾,Pij,t2+Qij,t2≤Sij,max⁡2,(4)\underline{v}\le v_{i,t}\le\overline{v},\qquad P_{ij,t}^{2}+Q_{ij,t}^{2}\le S_{ij,\max}^{2}, \tag*{(4)}
0≤pi,tR≤pi,tR,avail,pi,tcurt=pi,tR,avail−pi,tR,(5)0\le p^R_{i,t}\le p^{R,\mathrm{avail}}_{i,t},\qquad p^{\mathrm{curt}}_{i,t}=p^{R,\mathrm{avail}}_{i,t}-p^R_{i,t}, \tag*{(5)}
pi,tR≤di,t,(6)p^R_{i,t}\le d_{i,t}, \tag*{(6)}

where di,td_{i,t} is the published (technical or fair) DOE. The intertemporal BESS balance, together with its power/energy limits and terminal-state condition, follows the multiperiod storage treatment in [2] and the implementation in [9]:

eb,t+1=eb,t+ηchpb,tchΔt−pb,tdisΔtηdis.(7)e_{b,t+1}=e_{b,t}+\eta^{\mathrm{ch}}p^{\mathrm{ch}}_{b,t}\Delta t-\frac{p^{\mathrm{dis}}_{b,t}\Delta t}{\eta^{\mathrm{dis}}}. \tag*{(7)}

The inherited recourse cost in [9] includes grid exchange, curtailment, BESS degradation, and a prohibitive emergency-flexibility penalty; positive emergency demand response therefore denotes restored, not strict, feasibility.

Technical and Fair DOE Families

The technical envelope dtechd^{\mathrm{tech}} is obtained from a network-constrained export-capacity problem. The fair envelope dfaird^{\mathrm{fair}} redistributes a constrained aggregate budget while respecting

0≤di,tfair≤di,ttech.(8)0\le d^{\mathrm{fair}}_{i,t}\le d^{\mathrm{tech}}_{i,t}. \tag*{(8)}

For each prosumer ii, define EiR,avail=∑gJig∑tpg,tRΔtE_i^{R,\mathrm{avail}}=\sum_g J_{ig}\sum_t p^R_{g,t}\Delta t, Eicurt=∑gJig∑tpg,tcurtΔtE_i^{\mathrm{curt}}=\sum_g J_{ig}\sum_t p^{\mathrm{curt}}_{g,t}\Delta t, and Eiacc=Eiavail−EicurtE_i^{\mathrm{acc}}=E_i^{\mathrm{avail}}-E_i^{\mathrm{curt}}. The acceptance ratio is

ηi=EiaccEiavail+κ,κ=10−6max⁡j∈PEjavail,(9)\eta_i=\frac{E_i^{\mathrm{acc}}}{E_i^{\mathrm{avail}}+\kappa},\qquad\kappa=10^{-6}\max_{j\in\mathcal{P}}E_j^{\mathrm{avail}}, \tag*{(9)}

where κ>0\kappa>0 is a numerical regularizer that prevents division by zero without materially changing ratios for nonzero availability. For the curtailment-based Gini index, χi=Eicurt/(Eiavail+κ)\chi_i=E_i^{\mathrm{curt}}/(E_i^{\mathrm{avail}}+\kappa). Ex-post acceptance equity is then measured by Jain’s fairness index (JFI),

JFI=(∑i∈Pηi)2∣P∣∑i∈Pηi2,(10)\mathrm{JFI}=\frac{\left(\sum_{i\in\mathcal{P}}\eta_i\right)^2}{|\mathcal{P}|\sum_{i\in\mathcal{P}}\eta_i^2}, \tag*{(10)}

and the Gini coefficient of {χi}\{\chi_i\} detects concentration that may be hidden by a high acceptance-based Jain index:

G=∑i=1∣P∣∑j=1∣P∣∣χi−χj∣2∣P∣∑i=1∣P∣χi.(11)G=\frac{\sum_{i=1}^{|\mathcal{P}|}\sum_{j=1}^{|\mathcal{P}|}|\chi_i-\chi_j|}{2|\mathcal{P}|\sum_{i=1}^{|\mathcal{P}|}\chi_i}. \tag*{(11)}

A one-parameter family of fair envelopes dfair(θ)d^{\mathrm{fair}}(\theta) can be defined, where θ\theta represents the aggregate-budget scaling factor β\beta, the allowed fairness–efficiency gap δ\delta, or a uniform/network-sensitive derating factor. The DOE is fixed before uncertainty is sampled; only BESS, curtailment, and emergency flexibility are treated as recourse decisions.

Stagewise Objective Functions

The framework contains three optimization stages and their objectives must not be conflated. Let Cop(x,ω)C^{\mathrm{op}}(x,\omega) denote the grid-energy cost minus export revenue plus renewable-curtailment, BESS-degradation, and emergency-flexibility penalties.

The technical stage maximizes feasible envelope capacity through the equivalent minimization

min⁡dtech  −∑i∈P∑t∈Tdi,ttech(12)\min_{d^{\mathrm{tech}}}\;-\sum_{i\in\mathcal{P}}\sum_{t\in\mathcal{T}}d^{\mathrm{tech}}_{i,t} \tag*{(12)}

subject to power-flow, DER, BESS, voltage, thermal, and substation constraints. After applying

Dtcap=βt∑i∈Pdi,ttech,(13)D^{\mathrm{cap}}_t=\beta_t\sum_{i\in\mathcal{P}}d^{\mathrm{tech}}_{i,t}, \tag*{(13)}

the fairness stage determines dfaird^{\mathrm{fair}} and the associated nominal dispatch by

min⁡x,dfair,Γ Γ+λcEcurt−λu∑i,tdi,tfair+λo∥dfair−d0∥22(14)\min_{x,d^{\mathrm{fair}},\Gamma}\ \Gamma+\lambda_cE^{\mathrm{curt}}-\lambda_u\sum_{i,t}d^{\mathrm{fair}}_{i,t}+\lambda_o\left\|d^{\mathrm{fair}}-d^0\right\|_2^2 \tag*{(14)}
s.t.0≤di,tfair≤di,ttech,∑idi,tfair≤Dtcap,(15)\text{s.t.}\quad0 \le d^{\mathrm{fair}}_{i,t} \le d^{\mathrm{tech}}_{i,t},\qquad\sum_i d^{\mathrm{fair}}_{i,t} \le D^{\mathrm{cap}}_t, \tag*{(15)}
Eicurt≤Γ(Eiavail+κ),Ecurt≤Ecurt,tech+δEavail.(16)E^{\mathrm{curt}}_i \le\Gamma\left(E^{\mathrm{avail}}_i+\kappa\right), \qquad E^{\mathrm{curt}} \le E^{\mathrm{curt,tech}}+\delta E^{\mathrm{avail}}. \tag*{(16)}

The small terms λc\lambda_c, λu\lambda_u, and λ0\lambda_0 break ties without replacing the min–max fairness priority.

For each sampled realization, the DOE is fixed and the recourse stage solves

min⁡xωCop(xω,ω)=[∑t∈T(ctimpptimp−cexpptexp+ccurt∑ipi,tcurt)+cdeg∑b(pb,tch+pb,tdis)+cDR∑ipi,tDR]Δt.(17)\min_{x^\omega} C^{\mathrm{op}}(x^\omega,\omega) = \left[ \sum_{t\in T}\left(c^{\mathrm{imp}}_t p^{\mathrm{imp}}_t-c^{\mathrm{exp}}p^{\mathrm{exp}}_t+c^{\mathrm{curt}}\sum_i p^{\mathrm{curt}}_{i,t}\right) +c^{\mathrm{deg}}\sum_b\left(p^{\mathrm{ch}}_{b,t}+p^{\mathrm{dis}}_{b,t}\right) +c^{\mathrm{DR}}\sum_i p^{\mathrm{DR}}_{i,t} \right]\Delta t. \tag*{(17)}

The emergency coefficient cDRc^{\mathrm{DR}} is prohibitive. Therefore, pi,tDR>0p^{\mathrm{DR}}_{i,t}>0 identifies security restoration and is reported as strict infeasibility, not as normal recourse.

In the distributed implementation, each regional objective contains its local share of (11) plus the scaled ADMM consensus penalty. Formally, for region kk,

min⁡xkωCkop(xkω,ω)+ρ2∥xkboundary−zω+ukω∥22,(18)\min_{x^\omega_k} C^{\mathrm{op}}_k(x^\omega_k,\omega)+\frac{\rho}{2}\left\|x^{\mathrm{boundary}}_k-z^\omega+u^\omega_k\right\|_2^2, \tag*{(18)}

where zωz^\omega is the global consensus variable and ukωu^\omega_k is the dual multiplier. ADMM changes the solution mechanism, not the centralized economic objective:

Cop(xω,ω)=∑kCkop(xkω,ω).(19)C^{\mathrm{op}}(x^\omega,\omega)=\sum_k C^{\mathrm{op}}_k(x^\omega_k,\omega). \tag*{(19)}

Regime-Mixture Uncertainty

Discrete Regimes and Residual Error

Let Ω={ω1,…,ω6}\Omega=\{\omega_1,\ldots,\omega_6\} denote nominal, high-PV/low-load, high-wind, peak-load/low-renewable, night-peak, and mixed-congestion regimes. A categorical law π\pi assigns occurrence probabilities.

Conditional residual error ξ∣ω\xi|\omega perturbs load, PV, and wind trajectories while preserving the physical character of the parent regime. The implemented nominal model uses truncated, temporally correlated errors with σL=3%\sigma_L=3\%, σPV=8%\sigma_{PV}=8\%, σW=10%\sigma_W=10\%, temporal correlation ρ=0.75\rho=0.75, and truncation at three standard deviations. Common random numbers pair fair and technical DOE evaluations. Tuning and test seeds are separated. Sample sizes used later are N=600N=600 for the developmental Uniform noise ablation (Table V) and N=1000N=1000 for the held-out Uniform/Adversarial tests at β⋆=0.80\beta^\star=0.80 (Table IV); the adversarial fair/nominal ablation cell remains a preliminary N=34N=34 entry.

Algorithm 1 Stochastic CVaR–Recourse AC Evaluation

  1. Input: network and profiles; fixed DOE dd; mixture π\pi; conditional residual model ξ∣ω\xi|\omega; sample size MM; CVaR level α\alpha; persistence horizon HH.

  2. Output: samplewise AC states and recourse; p^viol\hat p_{\mathrm{viol}}, severity, p^pers\hat p_{\mathrm{pers}}, expected curtailment, CVaR⁡α\operatorname{CVaR}_{\alpha}, Jain/Gini, failure counts.

  3. Draw common-random-number samples {(ωm,ξm)}\{(\omega_m,\xi_m)\} from π(ω)p(ξ∣ω)\pi(\omega)p(\xi|\omega).

  4. For m=1,…,Mm=1,\ldots,M, fix dd and construct the realized load, PV, and wind trajectories.

  5. Solve recourse (11) by regional ADMM; on nonconvergence, apply the disclosed centralized recourse fallback and record its share.

  6. Record BESS dispatch, curtailment, emergency DR, objective value, convergence status, and runtime.

  7. Fix the consolidated injections and run an independent nonlinear AC power flow; retain failed solves.

  8. Compute bus-hour exceedance, severity, ΔVAC\Delta V^{\mathrm{AC}}, run-length persistence, daily curtailment, and samplewise Jain/Gini.

  9. Aggregate means, maxima, CVaR⁡α\operatorname{CVaR}_{\alpha} via (17), emergency recourse, fallback share, and failed-solve rates.

tbl:I presents the probability assigned to each operating regime. The uniform law assigns equal probability to all regimes, whereas the sunny-heavy and night-peak laws emphasize ω2\omega_2 and ω5\omega_5, respectively. The adversarial law assigns 80% of the total probability to the critical regimes ω4\omega_4 and ω5\omega_5, thereby assessing DOE performance under more stressful operating conditions.

Samplewise Evaluation Pipeline

For each sampled (ω,ξ)(\omega,\xi), the selected DOE is fixed. The recourse DOPF is then solved by the existing regional ADMM implementation. If ADMM does not converge, the disclosed centralized recourse fallback is used and its share is reported.

The consolidated DER/BESS set-points are passed to an independent nonlinear AC power flow. Failed optimizations and failed AC power flows are counted and reported; silently discarding them would bias the risk estimate downward. The empirical bus–hour violation rate is

p^viol=1∣M∣∣N∣∣T∣∑m∈M∑i∈N∑t∈T1{Vi,tAC,m∉[V‾,V‾]}.(20)\hat p_{\mathrm{viol}}=\frac{1}{|\mathcal{M}||\mathcal{N}||\mathcal{T}|} \sum_{m\in\mathcal{M}}\sum_{i\in\mathcal{N}}\sum_{t\in\mathcal{T}} \mathbf{1}\left\{V^{\mathrm{AC},m}_{i,t}\notin[\underline V,\overline V]\right\}. \tag*{(20)}

It complements, rather than replaces, scenario-level feasibility. This study reports failed-solve, emergency-recourse, and fallback shares; day-level bootstrap intervals are not tabulated.

Algorithm 1 evaluates a fixed DOE under uncertainty. For each sample, it solves the recourse dispatch using ADMM, validates the solution through nonlinear AC power flow, and calculates the resulting risk, curtailment, and fairness metrics.

Risk, Equity, and Persistence Metrics

Voltage severity for sample mm is defined as

ei,tm=max⁡{V‾−Vi,tAC,m, 0, Vi,tAC,m−V‾}.(21)e^m_{i,t}=\max\left\{\underline V-V^{\mathrm{AC},m}_{i,t},\,0,\,V^{\mathrm{AC},m}_{i,t}-\overline V\right\}. \tag*{(21)}

We report its sample mean, conditional mean given ei,tm>0e^m_{i,t}>0, 95th percentile, and maximum. Model error is

ΔVi,tAC,m=∣Vi,tAC,m−Vi,topt,m∣,(22)\Delta V^{\mathrm{AC},m}_{i,t}=\left|V^{\mathrm{AC},m}_{i,t}-V^{\mathrm{opt},m}_{i,t}\right|, \tag*{(22)}

with both ensemble mean and maximum retained. Expected curtailment is the sample mean of ∑i,tpi,tcurt,mΔt\sum_{i,t}p^{\mathrm{curt},m}_{i,t}\Delta t. Expected Jain and Gini metrics are averages of samplewise indices, not indices computed after pooling all samples.

Algorithm 2 Risk-Budgeted Fair-DOE Tuning

  1. Input: candidate set Θ\Theta; technical DOE dtechd^{\mathrm{tech}}; tuning and test samples; ε\varepsilon, εpers\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pers}}; reference law π0\pi_0 and TV radius 0.20.

  2. Output: selected θ∗\theta^* and independently tested DOE dfair(θ∗)d^{\mathrm{fair}}(\theta^*).

  3. For each θ∈Θ\theta\in\Theta, construct dfair(θ)d^{\mathrm{fair}}(\theta) subject to 0≤dfair≤dtech0 \le d^{\mathrm{fair}} \le d^{\mathrm{tech}} and the fairness/efficiency constraints.

  4. Run Algorithm 1 on the common tuning ensemble; record regime losses L^k(θ)\widehat{L}_k(\theta), risk upper bounds, and strict-feasibility failures.

  5. Discard θ\theta when a voltage or persistence upper bound exceeds ε\varepsilon or εpers\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pers}}.

  6. Select θ∗\theta^* minimizing the worst-case loss max⁡q∑kqkL^k(θ)\max_q \sum_k q_k\widehat{L}_k(\theta) over 12∥q−π0∥1≤0.20\frac{1}{2}\lVert q-\pi_0\rVert_1 \le0.20 (mean-plus-CVaR (19) is the nonrobust alternative).

  7. Freeze dfair(θ∗)d^{\mathrm{fair}}(\theta^*) and re-run Algorithm 1 on the independent test ensemble; report both tuning and test statistics.

For a loss variable LL, upper-tail risk is measured using [16]:

CVaR⁡α(L)=min⁡η∈R{η+11−αE[(L−η)+]}.(23)\operatorname{CVaR}_{\alpha}(L)=\min_{\eta\in\mathbb{R}}\left\{\eta+\frac{1}{1-\alpha}\mathbb{E}\left[(L-\eta)^+\right]\right\}. \tag*{(23)}

Here LL may denote daily curtailment, operating cost, maximum voltage severity, or emergency recourse. CVaR complements the mean by emphasizing the worst 1−α1-\alpha fraction of the regime mixture or Monte Carlo ensemble.

The run-length persistence metric distinguishes isolated spikes from sustained stress (H=3H=3 h primary; sensitivity H∈{2,4,6}H\in\{2,4,6\}):

Ipers(m,i)=1{max⁡trunt⁡t[1{Vi,tAC,m∉[V‾,V‾]}]≥H}.(24)I_{\mathrm{pers}}(m,i)=\mathbf{1}\left\{\max_t\operatorname{runt}_t\left[\mathbf{1}\left\{V^{\mathrm{AC},m}_{i,t}\notin[\underline{V},\overline{V}]\right\}\right]\ge H\right\}. \tag*{(24)}
p^pers=1M∣N∣∑m=1M∑i∈NIpers(m,i).(25)\widehat{p}_{\mathrm{pers}}=\frac{1}{M|\mathcal{N}|}\sum_{m=1}^{M}\sum_{i\in\mathcal{N}}I_{\mathrm{pers}}(m,i). \tag*{(25)}

Undervoltage and overvoltage persistence are reported separately because their remedies differ.

Proposed Risk-Budgeted Outer Loop

For a finite candidate set Θ\Theta, each θ∈Θ\theta\in\Theta generates a fixed envelope dfair(θ)d^{\mathrm{fair}}(\theta). A tuning ensemble estimates curtailment, export, voltage risk, and persistence. The selected parameter solves

min⁡θ∈ΘE^[Ecurt(θ)]+λRCVaR⁡α(L(θ))(26)\min_{\theta\in\Theta}\widehat{\mathbb{E}}\left[E_{\mathrm{curt}}(\theta)\right]+\lambda_R\operatorname{CVaR}_{\alpha}\left(L(\theta)\right) \tag*{(26)}

subject to

p^viol(θ)≤ε,p^pers(θ)≤εpers,(27)\widehat{p}_{\mathrm{viol}}(\theta)\le\varepsilon,\qquad\widehat{p}_{\mathrm{pers}}(\theta)\le\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pers}}, \tag*{(27)}

or equivalently maximizes expected export. To limit selection bias, feasibility is checked with an upper confidence bound on each empirical risk, and the chosen θ\theta is re-evaluated on an independent test ensemble. Because Θ\Theta is small, grid search is transparent and parallelizable. This calibrates envelopes under risk budgets; it is not a formal chance-constrained guarantee unless stronger sampling assumptions are enforced.

In the reported robust instantiation, the empirical objective is replaced by the worst-case expected regime loss max⁡q: 12∥q−π0∥1≤0.20∑k=16qkL^k(θ)\max_{q:\,\frac{1}{2}\lVert q-\pi_0\rVert_1\le0.20}\sum_{k=1}^{6}q_k\widehat{L}_k(\theta), where π0\pi_0 is the reference regime law, L^k\widehat{L}_k is the estimated regime loss including curtailment and emergency restoration, and q=(qk)k=16q=(q_k)_{k=1}^{6} is a probability mass function over the six regimes (i.e., an adversarially reweighted mixture). The confidence-bound voltage and persistence constraints remain active.

ExperimentFactorsOutputs
Mixture shiftFour laws (Table I)Risk, severity, persistence
Envelope typeFair vs. technical (same π\pi)Curtailment, Jain/Gini, risk
Noise ablationRegimes vs. nominal ξ\xiUniform development (N=600N=600)
Robust tuning/testβ∈{.60,.65,.70,.75,.80}\beta\in\{.60,.65,.70,.75,.80\}β∗=.80\beta^*=.80; test N=1000N=1000

Table II. Minimal experimental matrix

RegimeCurt. [MWh]JainGinimax⁡ΔV\max\Delta VStrict
ω1\omega_1 nominal5.763.9985.1244.0082Yes
ω2\omega_2 high PV17.528.9920.1096.0055Yes
ω3\omega_3 high wind12.177.9817.4216.0076Yes
ω4\omega_4 peak/low RES.0711.0000.8910.0069No
ω5\omega_5 night peak.0001.0000.1173.0062No
ω6\omega_6 mixed9.898.9965.1697.0048Yes

Table III. Verified six-regime baseline from [9]

Algorithm 2 evaluates Θ={0.60,0.65,0.70,0.75,0.80}\Theta=\{0.60,0.65,0.70,0.75,0.80\} over all six regimes within a total-variation ambiguity radius of 0.20. All five candidates had feasible (zero training failures; identical emergency energy), so none is rejected. The worst-case training loss decreases from 42.266 at β=0.60\beta=0.60 to 40.300 at β=0.80\beta=0.80, yielding β∗=0.80\beta^*=0.80. The selected envelope is then frozen and evaluated over a single test seed, with 1000 samples per probability law.

Case Study

The base case is the IEEE 33-bus radial feeder over 24 hourly intervals with 15 PV units, 8 wind units, and 8 BESSs. The installed renewable capacity is 4.8 MW PV plus 1.9 MW wind; the BESS fleet totals 2.4 MW/7.2 MWh. The original network study used 0.90–1.05 p.u. as its hard voltage range and βt=0.70\beta_t=0.70 from hours 10–16. Nine regions are coordinated by a distributed OPF solved using ADMM. AC validation fixes the optimized injections and recomposes substation exchange, including nonlinear losses. Because the risk layer is evaluated only on the balanced IEEE 33-bus feeder already used in [9], the present study provides internal validation but not cross-feeder generalization; an unbalanced IEEE 123-node or utility feeder is required as an external test.

Table II summarizes the experiments. The paired developmental ablation uses 600 uniform samples per DOE/noise setting. The final independent test uses 1000 samples for each reported probability law, with runtime, failures, emergency recourse, fallback, fairness, and physical risk reported jointly.

Results and Discussion

Regime-Only Baseline Results and Ensemble Reporting

The existing six-regime runs in [9] provide a deterministic baseline before residual-noise sampling. ADMM converged in 208–234 iterations. Curtailment was largest in the high-PV/low-load regime (17.528 MWh), while the Jain index remained at least 0.9817 in renewable-curtailment regimes. Peak-load/low-renewable and night-peak regimes required 0.0807 and 0.0137 MWh of emergency demand response, respectively, and therefore were not strictly feasible without additional flexibility. AC model deviations were below 0.01 p.u. and no voltage or thermal violations occurred under the adopted 0.90–1.05 p.u. band at the six representative points. These zero counts must not be generalized to unsampled residual errors.

CC is daily curtailed energy. Both rows use β⋆=0.80\beta^{\star}=0.80, nominal residual noise, and centralized recourse fallback. Violation, persistence, optimization-failure, and failed-AC counts are zero.

Table III presents the deterministic results from [9]. The high-PV regime produces the greatest curtailment, while all regimes maintain high Jain indices and small voltage deviations. However, ω4\omega_4 and ω5\omega_5 are not strictly feasible because they require emergency recourse. Figure 1 shows the same tradeoff graphically: renewable-rich regimes produce the greatest curtailment while maintaining high Jain indices, the Gini index reveals unequal curtailment in some regimes, and orange bars mark emergency-recourse failures.

Regime-dependent fairness and AC-validation results

Figure 1. Regime-dependent fairness and AC-validation results: (a) renewable curtailment and ex-post Jain and Gini fairness metrics; (b) maximum AC-versus-LinDistFlow voltage deviation, where orange bars identify regimes requiring emergency recourse and therefore lacking strict recourse feasibility.

AC-Ensemble, Residual-Noise, and DOE-Type Results

Table 4 reports the independent test of the selected robust DOE. Both probability laws contain 1000 successful nominal-noise samples. All optimizations and AC power flows succeed, and no voltage or persistence event is observed.

π\piNNE[C]E[C] (MWh/day)CVaR.90_{.90} (MWh/day)ExportJainGiniStrict fail (%)E[DR]E[\mathrm{DR}] (MWh/day)Runtime (s)
Uniform10006.56417.1831.366.9955.289032.8.01853.688
Adversarial10001.95413.153.405.9985.298073.2.04215.338

Table 4. Independent 1000-Sample Test of the Selected Robust DOE

Under the selected robust DOE in Table 4, the adversarial law reduces expected curtailment relative to uniform but more than doubles strict infeasibility (32.8% to 73.2%) and expected emergency restoration. Jain’s index remains high under both laws, whereas Gini stays near 0.29–0.30, so equity of acceptance does not remove the adequacy risk exposed by emergency recourse.

Nominal residual errors use (σL,σPV,σW)=(3%,8%,10%)(\sigma_L,\sigma_{PV},\sigma_W)=(3\%,8\%,10\%) with N=600N=600 except †^{\dagger} preliminary N=34N=34.

Table 5 isolates the effect of the residual-noise model ξ∣ω\xi|\omega before the robust outer loop is applied. Under the Uniform mixture, moving from regime-only to nominal noise raises expected curtailment and CVaR0.90_{0.90} for both fair and technical DOEs, and increases the fair-DOE Gini from 0.326 to 0.411. Technical DOEs remain less curtailing and more equal by Gini. The adversarial fair row is a preliminary N=34N=34 run and is reported only for completeness; the adversarial technical row (N=600N=600) shows lower curtailment and CVaR than Uniform, consistent with scarce renewables in ω4\omega_4–ω5\omega_5, but higher expected emergency demand response.

MixDOEE[C]E[C]E[C].90E[C]_{.90}CVaR.75_{.75}CVaR.80_{.80}Ginireg_{\mathrm{reg}}Gininom_{\mathrm{nom}}E[DR]nomE[\mathrm{DR}]_{\mathrm{nom}}
UniformFair7.057.9617.5318.69.326.411.0179
UniformTech.5.155.9215.7816.96.181.194.0179
Adv.Fair†^{\dagger}2.482.3115.0716.13.424.678.0452
Adv.Tech.1.801.4912.9611.72.114.116.0432

Table 5. Developmental Residual-Noise Ablation

Across Tables IV–V, zero AC-band violations coexist with substantial strict-infeasibility rates that are restored by emergency demand response (e.g., 37.3%/30.5% on Uniform regime-only/nominal developmental samples, and 78.3% on adversarial regime-only samples). The recorded fallback share is 100% in every exported ensemble row, so these Monte Carlo results characterize the disclosed centralized recourse fallback and AC audit rather than samplewise distributed-ADMM convergence.

Demonstrated Robust Outer Loop

Table 6 reports the five-candidate robust tuning grid that produces the β⋆=0.80\beta^{\star}=0.80 envelope tested in Table 4. All candidates are feasible with zero training failures. The worst-case loss decreases monotonically, so β⋆=0.80\beta^{\star}=0.80 is selected before the independent test.

β\betaWorst training lossMean DR sum (MWh)FailuresDecision
.6042.266.10980Feasible
.6541.664.10980Feasible
.7041.121.10980Feasible
.7540.659.10980Feasible
.8040.300.10980Selected

Table 6. Distributionally Robust Outer-Loop Candidate Grid

The independent test underlying Table 4 uses 1000 samples per law. Centralized recourse succeeds for every sample, but the ADMM convergence flag is false throughout (100% fallback), so the AC statistics must not be read as samplewise distributed-ADMM convergence.

Mixture Interpretation

For a regime metric YωY_\omega, mixture reweighting changes its expected value without changing the underlying regime outcome:

Eπ[Y]=∑ω∈ΩπωYω,(28)\mathbb{E}_{\pi}[Y]=\sum_{\omega\in\Omega}\pi_\omega Y_\omega, \tag*{(28)}

Using Table I, expected curtailment is 7.573, 11.188, 4.614, and 2.298 MWh/day for the Uniform, Sunny-heavy, Night-peak, and Adversarial laws. The adversarial value is lowest only because its stressed regimes have little renewable availability; those regimes instead increase emergency recourse.

Lawω1\omega_1ω2\omega_2ω3\omega_3ω4\omega_4ω5\omega_5ω6\omega_6
Uniform.167.167.167.167.167.167
Sunny-heavy.15.40.15.10.05.15
Night-peak.15.08.07.15.40.15
Adversarial.05.05.05.40.40.05

Table I. Regime-mixture laws used in the minimal experiment

Figure 2 therefore shows that minimum expected curtailment is not minimum operational risk.

Probability-weighted operational outcomes

Figure 2. Probability-weighted operational outcomes: (a) emergency demand response required in each operating regime and its expected value under the four probability laws; (b) expected renewable curtailment under the same laws. The adversarial distribution produces the greatest expected emergency recourse despite exhibiting the lowest expected curtailment.

Figure 3 gives CVaR0.90_{0.90} values of 17.528, 17.528, 16.458, and 14.853 MWh/day. The corresponding probability masses on emergency-recourse regimes are 0.333, 0.150, 0.550, and 0.800, confirming the adversarial law’s greater exposure despite lower curtailment.

Curtailment risk under the four probability laws

Figure 3. Curtailment risk under the four probability laws: (a) expected daily curtailment and upper-tail CVaR0.90_{0.90}; (b) probability-weighted contribution of each operating regime to expected curtailment. The respective regime-only CVaR0.90_{0.90} values are 17.528, 17.528, 16.458, and 14.853 MWh/day.

Figure 4 identifies the most stressed regime per metric and marks emergency-restoration dependence. Tables IV and V extend this regime-centre fingerprint to residual-noise sampling and fair/technical comparison, in which we can verify that AC-band events remain rare, but emergency-restoration rates stay material, so risk cannot be read from curtailment or voltage counts alone.

Verified six-regime risk fingerprint

Figure 4. Verified six-regime risk fingerprint. Colours indicate stress normalized independently within each metric, whereas the annotations report the original physical values. The strict-failure column equals one for regimes that require emergency demand response to restore feasibility.

Discussion

No AC-band violation was observed and model deviation remained below 0.01 p.u.; nevertheless, ω4\omega_4 and ω5\omega_5 required emergency response, so violation frequency must be read with persistence and strict feasibility. Jain exceeded 0.9817, yet Gini reached 0.4216 and 0.8910 in stressed regimes, confirming that high Jain values can hide concentrated curtailment. Consistently, Table VI selects β⋆=0.80\beta^\star= 0.80, and Table IV shows the corresponding 1000-sample tests with no optimization or AC-flow failures. Still, strict infeasibility of 32.8% (Uniform) and 73.2% (Adversarial) and a 100% fallback share preclude equating these outcomes with samplewise ADMM convergence. Completing sunny-heavy/night-peak ensembles, noise-sensitivity sweeps, and a second feeder remain open.

Conclusion

This paper extended the deterministic fair multiperiod DOE and regional ADMM framework of [9] with an out-of-sample AC risk-assessment layer. The inherited six-regime baseline already shows the interpretive need: high-renewable regimes dominate curtailment, whereas peak/low-renewable regimes can require emergency flexibility despite low curtailment. The proposed common-sample ensemble therefore evaluates fair and technical DOEs jointly through violation frequency, severity, CVaR, persistence, confidence intervals, and equity rather than declaring a DOE fail-safe after a few feasible scenarios. The risk-budgeted outer loop further converts those statistics into a transparent envelope-selection rule. Results remain conditional on the assumed regime probabilities, residual-error model, voltage band, and solver reliability.

Future work will estimate time-varying regime probabilities from feeder data, extend the model to unbalanced three-phase networks and correlated contingencies, develop distributionally robust risk budgets, and test rolling-horizon recalibration with faster distributed recourse on hardware or utility-data case studies.

References

References

  1. [2]G. Lankeshwara, R. Sharma, R. Yan, W. Tushar, and T. K. Saha, “A Review on Network-Aware Control of Distributed Energy Resources under the Dynamic Operating Envelopes Framework,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 217, p. 115696, 2025.DOI
  2. [3]A. Wickramasinghe, M. Vilathgamuwa, G. Nourbakhsh, and P. Corry, “A Review of Dynamic Operating Envelopes: Computation, Applications and Challenges,” Modelling, vol. 6, no. 2, p. 29, 2025.DOI
  3. [4]M. E. Baran and F. F. Wu, “Optimal sizing of capacitors placed on a radial distribution system,” IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, vol. 4, pp. 735–743, Jan. 1989.
  4. [5]S. H. Low, “Convex relaxation of optimal power flow—Part I: Formulations and equivalence,” IEEE Transactions on Control of Network Systems, vol. 1, pp. 15–27, Mar. 2014.
  5. [6]R. Pinto, R. J. Bessa, J. Sumaili, and M. A. Matos, “Distributed multi-period three-phase optimal power flow using temporal neighbors,” Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 182, p. 106228, May 2020.
  6. [7]K. Petrou, M. Z. Liu, A. T. Procopiou, L. F. Ochoa, J. Theunissen, and J. Harding, “Operating envelopes for prosumers in LV networks: A weighted proportional fairness approach,” in Proc. IEEE PES Innovative Smart Grid Technologies Europe (ISGT-Europe), (The Hague, Netherlands), pp. 579–583, 2020.DOI
  7. [8]Y. Yi and G. Verbič, “Fair operating envelopes under uncertainty using chance constrained optimal power flow,” Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 213, p. 108465, Dec. 2022.DOI
  8. [9]P. S. Quessongo, D. Gebbran, and C. Unshiuay-Vila, “Fair dynamic operating envelopes using distributed multi-period optimal power flow and Jain index for active distribution networks,” in Proc. IEEE Latin American Congress on Electricity Generation and Transmission (CLAG-TEE XVI), pp. 1–6, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2608.23444
  9. [10]M. Ge, W. Lai, Y. Sun, and S. Dong, “Risk-aware dynamic operating envelopes for DNO-MG coordination in active distribution networks,” in Proc. 8th Int. Conf. Information Science, Electrical and Automation Engineering (ISEAE), 2026.DOI
  10. [11]M. R. Alam, P. T. H. Nguyen, L. Naranpanwe, T. K. Saha, and G. Lankeshwara, “Allocation of dynamic operating envelopes in distribution networks: Technical and equitable perspectives,” IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy, vol. 15, pp. 173–186, Jan. 2024.DOI
  11. [12]Z. Jiang and Y. Guo, “Bargaining-based approach for dynamic operating envelope allocation in distribution networks,” IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, vol. 16, pp. 3588–3600, Sept. 2025.
  12. [13]B. Liu and J. H. Braslavsky, “Robust dynamic operating envelopes for DER integration in unbalanced distribution networks,” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, vol. 39, pp. 3921–3936, Mar. 2024.
  13. [14]A. Koirala, F. Geth, and T. V. Acker, “Day-ahead dynamic operating envelopes using stochastic unbalanced optimal power flow,” Sustainable Energy, Grids and Networks, vol. 40, p. 101528, Dec. 2024.DOI
  14. [15]W. de Carvalho, F. Capitanescu, C. Rasic, J. F. Toubeau, and F. Vallée, “Robust Dynamic Operating Envelopes in Unbalanced Three-Phase Distribution Systems,” arXiv, eess.SY, 2607.08578, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2607.08578
  15. [16]R. T. Rockafellar and S. Uryasev, “Optimization of conditional value-at-risk,” Journal of Risk, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 21–41, 2000.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_efm2s74k
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Engineering

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents