WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Critical collapse remains discretely self-similar at large D
Abstract
When matter collapses at the threshold of black hole formation spacetime typically has an emergent continuous or discrete symmetry, depending on the matter content. For the Einstein-Klein-Gordon model in any finite dimension D>3 the associated critical spacetime solutions exhibit discrete self-similarity, characterized by the echoing period Delta. Combining analytical and numerical results with dimensions up to D=200 we predict Delta remains finite at infinite dimension D, contrary to a recent conjecture. We find the fit Delta=1.6439+10.37/D-O(1/D^2) and provide an explicit large-D model.
Introduction
Critical phenomena analogous to second order phase transitions were discovered in gravitational collapse by Choptuik [1] who numerically evolved the Einstein–Klein–Gordon equations (we set )
assuming spherical symmetry. Smooth one-parameter families of initial data were considered, such that the evolution leads to black-hole formation for parameters and dispersion for . At the threshold , the evolution approaches a critical solution separating these two outcomes.
The critical solution has three remarkable properties: First, it is universal within a given model, i.e., its form is independent of the particular family of initial data. Second, it develops a pointlike naked singularity where the Ricci scalar diverges. Third, it has an emergent symmetry, namely discrete self-similarity (DSS), characterized by Choptuik’s echoing period . See [2, 3] for reviews and [4, 5, 6] for pioneering developments. Critical gravitational collapse is relevant to numerical relativity [2, 3, 7, 8, 9, 10], cosmic censorship [11, 12], quantum gravity [13, 14, 15, 16, 17], and primordial black holes [18, 19, 20].
Moreover, the critical solution governs the behavior of near-critical evolutions. In particular, the mass of black holes formed just above threshold obeys the scaling law
,
with a universal exponent [1] depending on the spacetime dimension . This exponent can be obtained by linearizing around the critical solution and determining the growth rate of its single unstable mode [21]. Constructing the critical solution is therefore essential for predicting the behavior of near-critical gravitational collapse.
Until recently, critical DSS solutions were known only numerically. Recently, a large- expansion was used to construct analytic DSS solutions [22]. Treating the spacetime dimension as a parameter and expanding the Einstein–Klein–Gordon equations [1] in exploits the simplifications that arise at large dimension. The inverse-dimension expansion has proved useful in numerous other gravitational contexts [23, 24, 25, 26]. However, the resulting DSS solutions have important limitations: the Ricci scalar and scalar field are not generically finite in the limit , and the associated two-mode toy model is consistent only for , beyond the range currently explored numerically, [27, 28]. Furthermore, the conjecture [29] may imply that the large- expansion requires a reorganization.
In this Letter, we address these issues by combining numerical and analytic methods. We construct critical DSS solutions up to and determine their echoing periods. We reorganize the large- expansion to ensure that the Ricci and matter scalar remain finite and nonzero in the infinite-dimensional limit. Our numerical results show that the echoing period approaches a finite limit, , ruling out the conjectured vanishing of . We also develop an improved large- model that captures the large- behavior of the numerical solutions.
Einstein–Klein–Gordon equations
The field equations (1) in spacetime dimensions and the associated DSS geometries are discussed in [29]. To numerically implement them in that work, Martín-García–Gundlach (GG) gauge was used [30]. Since the present solver relies on the computational infrastructure of Reiterer–Trubowitz (RT) we use their gauge [31].
where is the RT echoing parameter and is the metric of the round -sphere. The smooth functions and depend arbitrarily on the radial coordinate .
Under we fix to be periodic with normalized period while is quasiperiodic, with being Choptuik’s echoing period. The scalar field is antiperiodic, , and the loci and are, respectively, the center and the self-similar horizon (SSH). For fixing the coordinates completely one is still free to choose the origin of which we shall come back to in the numerical setup.
The geometric meaning of the RT echoing parameter is to rescale the null coordinates between two adjacent fundamental domains, . It is related to the Choptuik echoing period
where is the period average of the null derivative of the scalar field along the SSH, evaluated at the SSH, see Eq. (29) of [29] for a definition in GG gauge; alternatively, in RT gauge we have .
Following RT we introduce variables
with null derivatives . This definition implies under . Together with the gauge choice (2) the Einstein–Klein–Gordon equations (1) in arbitrary spacetime dimensions reduce to a set of equations with :
A key aspect of these equations is that they are only bilinear/quadratic in the variables , which is exploited in the numerical implementation below. For , Eqs. (5) coincide precisely with Eqs. (11) in [31], with .
As explained by RT, we reformulate this system in terms of five independent equations on a parity extended two-dimensional domain that includes also negative radii, . Introducing the parity operator by the action , we impose and for $i=2,3,4. Having expressed all by , it is sufficient to solve the versions of Eqs. (5) for the variables on the extended domain to find a unique solution of the full Einstein–Klein–Gordon system for . Additionally, are constraints. The independent set used by our solver is, similarly to RT, given by . Next, we summarize some details about the used algorithm [32].
Numerical Setup
For solving the system above we use a spectral method on the domain , expanding in a Fourier basis in and a Chebyshev basis in . The representation of a function through its modes ,
converts the field equations (5) into matrix equations.
We solve for a finite set of these modes with and to approximate the critical solution, translating all non-linear terms in the equations to convolutions given by explicit bilinear operators in spectral space. This infrastructure is directly adopted from Sec. 3 in [31]. The remaining translational freedom in is fixed by setting and, starting from a sufficiently close initial guess, we use a Newton–Raphson method to converge on the critical solution. Taking the parity and periodicity conditions of the functions into account we obtain degrees of freedom where the first two factors are the mode numbers, the factor comes from real and imaginary parts, and the numbers in parentheses are symmetry factors of the functions . The degree of freedom fixed by -translations is balanced by the constant . Typically, after four iterations the residual is brought down to , where is the weighted -norm as defined by RT, with . Starting from we sequentially increase in steps of , taking linear extrapolations of the two previous converged results as initial guesses.
As discussed in Appendix B of [29], at successively larger values of a second (singular) solution branch approaches the critical solution. This renders the Jacobian close to singular and requires increased numerical precision to converge on the regular solution branch. In [29], this constrained the authors to with double precision arithmetic. The infrastructure by RT allows surpassing this difficulty by using the gmp library [33] in C which allows storing dyadic numbers in terms of two arbitrary-precision integers and . All internal arithmetic is performed with exact operations on these objects. Rounding only becomes necessary once the Jacobian is inverted at each Newton step, which we need to do with increasingly higher precision as grows.
Numerical Results
Using the numerical procedure discussed above, we construct critical DSS solutions up to . The numerical results for the physical fields are displayed in Figure 1. The solution is visually dominated by the lowest-lying Fourier and Chebyshev modes, which matches with the converse observation [29] that for very small dimensions there is a lot of UV-drama, especially in the center. Evidently, this does not happen at large-.

Figure 1. Numerical solutions for the four fields (top left), (top right), (bottom left), and (bottom right) in dimensions as functions of and .
Figure 2 displays the RT echoing parameter , together with a large- fit with . Remarkably, the curve for flattens already around near its asymptotic value. We fit Taylor expansions to the numerical data over the range from which we estimate
Figure 2. Echoing parameter . Black line: numerical results. Dashed/dotted lines: large- fits.
The data presented in Figure 2 are incompatible with the conjecture [29] of vanishing at large since quickly approaches a finite value.
Combining the fit (13) with the relation (3) establishes the inequality . Thus, assuming we can trust the fit (13) we predict a lower bound for the Choptuik echoing period
Figure 3. Echoing period . Black line: numerical results. Dashed/dotted lines: large- fits. Other sources at low : SO [27], BPBKH [28], BK [34], and Bland’s Ph.D. thesis [35].
Figure 3 displays our results for the Choptuik echoing period up to . The inset also displays earlier results from the literature for comparison. To see how close we are to the lower bound (14) we fit independently using our data, finding [36]
Comparing (15) with (14) reveals that within our accuracy we are saturating the bound. This asks for an explanation, which we shall provide after reconsidering large- analytics.
Refined Large- Analytics
Recently, we obtained analytic results at large [22] and a perturbative expansion that allows to determine all observables order by order. Our solution depends on one free function , where is the GG time [37]. In our previous work we were agnostic about the large scaling of (other than implicitly assuming it does not diverge too strongly with ).
In this work, we propose the scaling
with an order-one function . The proposal (16) has a numerical and an analytical motivation.
The numerical motivation is that the scaling (16) explains why the bound (14) is saturated: For the quantity vanishes and thus the exact relation (3) reduces to . Therefore, if there was an independent reason for (16) we would establish an explanation for the saturation of the bound (14) at infinite .
The analytical motivation provides such a reason. As shown in [22], the Ricci scalar at large-,
diverges in the limit . However, exactly for the scaling (16) we get a finite result for (17). Moreover, as shown in the SM to [22] also the scalar field
remains finite only for the scaling (16). This provides sound geometric and physical reasons to insist on (16).
The scaling (16) simplifies the analytics of [22]. We provide here results for the first nontrivial terms of the metric functions , and the matter functions , [38]:
Combining our analytical results with the large- fits [7], [9] and the exact equality (3) establishes a relation between the -norm of and the first few expansion coefficients,
The extrapolated large- scalar profile is well approximated by the following closed-form expression [39], improving upon the two-mode model of Ref. [22]:
The asymptotic expansions of and independently fix the frequency, , and normalization, , leaving only two fitted parameters, and . Equation (22) is a Fourier expansion in odd harmonics, with successive mode amplitudes exponentially suppressed as , where .
Figure 4 compares the numerical results for , transformed from RT to GG gauge, with our perturbative predictions, demonstrating excellent agreement for , , , and . The gauge transformation and perturbative calculations are detailed in the SM.
Summary and Outlook
In this Letter, we numerically constructed DSS solutions of the Einstein–Klein–Gordon equations up to spacetime dimension . Our results show that Choptuik’s echoing period approaches a finite, nonzero value in the infinite-dimensional limit (15), contrary to the conjecture [29]. This is surprising because it means that even at infinite dimension there is a pure number encoded in this theory, namely
Thus, critical collapse remains DSS at large .
We reorganized and simplified the perturbative large- expansion of [22] such that Ricci and matter scalar remain finite at infinite by rescaling the free function arising in this construction, see (16). Curiously, the leading order terms in the Ricci scalar (17), , and the matter scalar (18), , are homogeneous in space. This homogeneity does not correspond to an isometry of the metric to order and is broken by subleading corrections.
Moreover, we combined numerical and analytical results to provide an excellent large- approximation (22) for the free function that depends on two free parameters that we fitted, a damping constant and a phase .
Several questions naturally arise from these results. An outstanding analytical challenge is to derive large- numbers like (23) from first principles rather than extracting them from numerical fits. This will likely require to add instanton corrections of the form to our power-law expansion in . Additionally, it may be necessary to extend the solution beyond the SSH and to match with the Rozali–Way regime [40]. Perhaps some of the methods developed in the discussion of large- dynamics assuming continuous self-similarity [41] can be applied to DSS as well, in particular, a separation into slow and fast dynamics at large . It could also be rewarding to attempt a derivation of the large- approximation (22) and the fitting parameters therein.
Given that we ruled out the conjecture at large , it would be interesting to revisit the corresponding low-dimensional conjecture, namely as [29]. This will require substantially higher spectral resolution, in particular considerably more Fourier modes, since the solutions develop increasingly pronounced short-scale structure as the dimension decreases.
A further direction would be to extend the large- critical solution all the way to the Cauchy horizon and investigate its smoothness properties. In , the corresponding analysis found the metric and scalar field to be but not [30, 42]. It would be interesting to determine whether this regularity persists in the large- limit, or whether the limiting solution exhibits different smoothness properties.
Another important observable is the Choptuik scaling exponent , which characterizes the black-hole mass near threshold, . A recent determination using the AI system Claude [36] suggests as . Although this result has not yet been verified by human analysis, the limiting value is eminently reasonable [26] and merits further investigation.
Finally, it would be worthwhile to explore how robust the large- analysis is under generalizations of the model. These include relaxing spherical symmetry, considering different matter fields and self-interactions, and studying other gravitational theories or matter couplings. Such extensions could establish which features of the large- critical dynamics are universal and which depend on the particular matter content and symmetries of the Einstein–Klein–Gordon system.
Acknowledgments
Acknowledgments. We thank Craig Clark for discussions and Nathan Moinvaziri for correspondence. CE acknowledges support by the DFG through the CRC-TR 211 “Strong-interaction matter under extreme conditions” – project number 315477589 – TRR 211. This work was supported by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) [Grants DOI: 10.55776/P33789, 10.55776/P36619, 10.55776/PAT1871425].
Supplemental Material
In this Supplemental Material (SM), we elaborate on some technical aspects pertaining to the main text. While none of the material in this SM is crucial, it can be helpful for explicit checks, for pushing the large- perturbation theory to higher orders, or for refinements of our explicit large- model presented in the main text.
This SM is organized as follows. In the first section, we explain our choice of the numerical scheme that was used to produce the numerical results discussed in the main text. In the second section, we transform from Reiterer–Trubowitz to Martín-García–Gundlach gauge. In the third section, we list the first three non-trivial orders in the large- perturbation theory. In the fourth section, we construct an explicit large- model that is exploited in the main text. On the final page, we display in Table I our numerical results of the echoing period in dimensions between 3.046 and 200; for comparison we added as a final entry our best-fit result for . The results for have sufficient accuracy so that we trust all displayed digits, and we checked that varying the number of Fourier or Chebyshev modes does not alter these digits. The results for contain also data from our previous work [29].
| 3.046 | 2.454367 | 3.112 | 2.825094 | 4.35 | 3.376097 | 4.95 | 3.233510 | 12 | 2.389189 | 58 | 1.815397 | 130 | 1.722127 |
| 3.0465 | 2.458274 | 3.113 | 2.829191 | 4.39 | 3.366930 | 4.955 | 3.232331 | 12.25 | 2.375503 | 59 | 1.812598 | 131 | 1.721541 |
| 3.047 | 2.462156 | 3.114 | 2.833257 | 4.4 | 3.364618 | 4.96 | 3.231153 | 12.5 | 2.362324 | 60 | 1.809890 | 132 | 1.720964 |
| 3.0475 | 2.466012 | 3.115 | 2.837291 | 4.41 | 3.362298 | 4.965 | 3.229976 | 12.75 | 2.349623 | 61 | 1.807267 | 133 | 1.720395 |
| 3.048 | 2.469844 | 3.116 | 2.841294 | 4.42 | 3.359971 | 4.97 | 3.228800 | 13 | 2.337375 | 62 | 1.804726 | 134 | 1.719835 |
| 3.0485 | 2.473651 | 3.117 | 2.845267 | 4.43 | 3.357638 | 4.975 | 3.227625 | 13.25 | 2.325554 | 63 | 1.802263 | 135 | 1.719283 |
| 3.049 | 2.477433 | 3.118 | 2.849209 | 4.44 | 3.355298 | 4.98 | 3.226450 | 13.5 | 2.314139 | 64 | 1.799875 | 136 | 1.718739 |
| 3.0495 | 2.481192 | 3.119 | 2.853122 | 4.45 | 3.352953 | 4.985 | 3.225277 | 13.75 | 2.303109 | 65 | 1.797557 | 137 | 1.718202 |
| 3.05 | 2.484927 | 3.12 | 2.857005 | 4.46 | 3.350601 | 4.99 | 3.224104 | 14 | 2.292445 | 66 | 1.795308 | 138 | 1.717674 |
| 3.0505 | 2.488639 | 3.121 | 2.860860 | 4.47 | 3.348245 | 4.995 | 3.222932 | 14.25 | 2.282128 | 67 | 1.793124 | 139 | 1.717152 |
| 3.051 | 2.492328 | 3.122 | 2.864685 | 4.48 | 3.345883 | 5 | 3.221761 | 14.5 | 2.272142 | 68 | 1.791002 | 140 | 1.716638 |
| 3.0515 | 2.495994 | 3.123 | 2.868482 | 4.49 | 3.343517 | 5.005 | 3.220591 | 14.75 | 2.262470 | 69 | 1.788940 | 141 | 1.716132 |
| 3.052 | 2.499638 | 3.124 | 2.872251 | 4.5 | 3.341147 | 5.025 | 3.215920 | 15 | 2.253098 | 70 | 1.786935 | 142 | 1.715632 |
| 3.0525 | 2.503259 | 3.125 | 2.875992 | 4.51 | 3.338772 | 5.045 | 3.211263 | 15.5 | 2.235199 | 71 | 1.784985 | 143 | 1.715139 |
| 3.053 | 2.506858 | 3.126 | 2.879706 | 4.52 | 3.336394 | 5.065 | 3.206622 | 16 | 2.218343 | 72 | 1.783087 | 144 | 1.714653 |
| 3.054 | 2.513993 | 3.127 | 2.883393 | 4.53 | 3.334012 | 5.085 | 3.201996 | 16.5 | 2.202440 | 73 | 1.781240 | 145 | 1.714173 |
| 3.055 | 2.521043 | 3.128 | 2.887052 | 4.54 | 3.331628 | 5.105 | 3.197387 | 17 | 2.187410 | 74 | 1.779441 | 146 | 1.713700 |
| 3.056 | 2.528010 | 3.129 | 2.890685 | 4.55 | 3.329240 | 5.125 | 3.192795 | 17.5 | 2.173183 | 75 | 1.777689 | 147 | 1.713233 |
| 3.057 | 2.534896 | 3.13 | 2.894292 | 4.56 | 3.326849 | 5.135 | 3.190505 | 18 | 2.159695 | 76 | 1.775982 | 148 | 1.712773 |
| 3.058 | 2.541704 | 3.131 | 2.897873 | 4.57 | 3.324456 | 5.145 | 3.188219 | 18.25 | 2.153211 | 77 | 1.774318 | 149 | 1.712318 |
| 3.059 | 2.548434 | 3.132 | 2.901428 | 4.58 | 3.322061 | 5.149 | 3.187306 | 18.5 | 2.146890 | 78 | 1.772695 | 150 | 1.711870 |
| 3.06 | 2.555090 | 3.133 | 2.904958 | 4.59 | 3.319664 | 5.151 | 3.186850 | 18.75 | 2.140727 | 79 | 1.771113 | 151 | 1.711427 |
| 3.061 | 2.561671 | 3.134 | 2.908462 | 4.6 | 3.317265 | 5.153 | 3.186394 | 19 | 2.134715 | 80 | 1.769568 | 152 | 1.710990 |
| 3.062 | 2.568180 | 3.135 | 2.911942 | 4.61 | 3.314865 | 5.155 | 3.185938 | 19.5 | 2.123126 | 81 | 1.768061 | 153 | 1.710559 |
| 3.063 | 2.574618 | 3.14 | 2.928976 | 4.62 | 3.312463 | 5.157 | 3.185482 | 20 | 2.112080 | 82 | 1.766590 | 154 | 1.710133 |
| 3.064 | 2.580987 | 3.145 | 2.95426 | 4.63 | 3.310061 | 5.159 | 3.184? | 20.5 | 2.101540 | 83 | 1.765153 | 155 | 1.709713 |
| 3.065 | 2.587288 | 3.15 | 2.961320 | 4.64 | 3.307657 | 5.169 | 3.182752 | 20.5625 | 2.100256 | 84 | 1.763750 | 156 | 1.709298 |
| 3.066 | 2.593522 | 3.155 | 2.976684 | 4.65 | 3.305253 | 5.179 | 3.180481 | 20.75 | 2.096449 | 85 | 1.762379 | 157 | 1.708888 |
| 3.067 | 2.599691 | 3.16 | 2.991545 | 4.66 | 3.302849 | 5.189 | 3.178215 | 21 | 2.091485 | 86 | 1.761038 | 158 | 1.708483 |
| 3.068 | 2.605796 | 3.165 | 3.005924 | 4.67 | 3.300444 | 5.199 | 3.175954 | 21.5 | 2.081984 | 87 | 1.759728 | 159 | 1.708083 |
| 3.069 | 2.611839 | 3.17 | 3.019843 | 4.68 | 3.298039 | 5.209 | 3.173697 | 22 | 2.073239 | 88 | 1.758447 | 160 | 1.707688 |
| 3.07 | 2.617820 | 3.175 | 3.033323 | 4.69 | 3.295634 | 5.219 | 3.171444 | 22.5 | 2.065799 | 89 | 1.757194 | 161 | 1.707298 |
| 3.071 | 2.623741 | 3.18 | 3.046381 | 4.7 | 3.293229 | 5.229 | 3.169197 | 23 | 2.053322 | 90 | 1.755968 | 162 | 1.706913 |
| 3.072 | 2.629602 | 3.2 | 3.094740 | 4.71 | 3.290825 | 5.239 | 3.166954 | 23.5 | 2.047598 | 91 | 1.754768 | 163 | 1.706532 |
| 3.073 | 2.635405 | 3.25 | 3.193154 | 4.72 | 3.288421 | 5.249 | 3.164716 | 24 | 2.039855 | 92 | 1.753594 | 164 | 1.706156 |
| 3.074 | 2.641151 | 3.3 | 3.267213 | 4.73 | 3.286018 | 5.259 | 3.162483 | 24.5 | 2.032430 | 93 | 1.752445 | 165 | 1.705785 |
| 3.075 | 2.646841 | 3.35 | 3.323462 | 4.74 | 3.283615 | 5.269 | 3.160254 | 25 | 2.025294 | 94 | 1.751319 | 166 | 1.705418 |
| 3.076 | 2.652476 | 3.4 | 3.366252 | 4.75 | 3.281215 | 5.279 | 3.158031 | 25.5 | 2.018435 | 95 | 1.750217 | 167 | 1.705055 |
| 3.077 | 2.658056 | 3.45 | 3.398625 | 4.76 | 3.278815 | 5.319 | 3.149185 | 26 | 2.011840 | 96 | 1.749137 | 168 | 1.704696 |
| 3.078 | 2.663583 | 3.5 | 3.422791 | 4.77 | 3.276417 | 5.349 | 3.142604 | 26.5 | 2.005494 | 97 | 1.748078 | 169 | 1.704342 |
| 3.079 | 2.669058 | 3.55 | 3.440402 | 4.78 | 3.274020 | 5.359 | 3.140421 | 27 | 1.999387 | 98 | 1.747041 | 170 | 1.703992 |
| 3.08 | 2.674482 | 3.6 | 3.452721 | 4.79 | 3.271625 | 5.369 | 3.138242 | 27.5 | 1.992233 | 99 | 1.746024 | 171 | 1.703646 |
| 3.081 | 2.679855 | 3.65 | 3.460729 | 4.8 | 3.269188 | 5.379 | 3.136062 | 28 | 1.986410 | 100 | 1.745027 | 172 | 1.703303 |
| 3.082 | 2.685178 | 3.7 | 3.465201 | 4.805 | 3.267991 | 5.389 | 3.133901 | 29 | 1.975334 | 101 | 1.744050 | 173 | 1.702965 |
| 3.083 | 2.690452 | 3.71 | 3.465727 | 4.81 | 3.266794 | 5.409 | 3.129581 | 30 | 1.964958 | 102 | 1.743091 | 174 | 1.702631 |
| 3.084 | 2.695678 | 3.72 | 3.466142 | 4.815 | 3.265597 | 5.419 | 3.127429 | 31 | 1.955218 | 103 | 1.742150 | 175 | 1.702300 |
| 3.085 | 2.700856 | 3.73 | 3.466449 | 4.82 | 3.264401 | 5.459 | 3.118874 | 32 | 1.946055 | 104 | 1.741228 | 176 | 1.701973 |
| 3.086 | 2.705988 | 3.74 | 3.466653 | 4.825 | 3.263205 | 5.489 | 3.112515 | 33 | 1.937423 | 105 | 1.740322 | 177 | 1.701649 |
| 3.087 | 2.711074 | 3.75 | 3.466756 | 4.83 | 3.262010 | 5.499 | 3.110407 | 34 | 1.929273 | 106 | 1.739433 | 178 | 1.701330 |
| 3.088 | 2.716115 | 3.755 | 3.466771 | 4.835 | 3.260815 | 5.5 | 3.110196 | 35 | 1.921567 | 107 | 1.738560 | 179 | 1.701013 |
| 3.089 | 2.721111 | 3.7554 | 3.466772 | 4.84 | 3.259621 | 5.75 | 3.058068 | 36 | 1.914268 | 108 | 1.737703 | 180 | 1.700701 |
| 3.09 | 2.726063 | 3.7555 | 3.466772 | 4.845 | 3.258427 | 6 | 3.009483 | 37 | 1.907347 | 109 | 1.736862 | 181 | 1.700391 |
| 3.091 | 2.730973 | 3.7556 | 3.466772 | 4.85 | 3.257234 | 6.25 | 2.963826 | 38 | 1.900773 | 110 | 1.736035 | 182 | 1.700085 |
| 3.092 | 2.735839 | 3.7557 | 3.466772 | 4.855 | 3.256042 | 6.5 | 2.920939 | 39 | 1.894521 | 111 | 1.735223 | 183 | 1.699782 |
| 3.093 | 2.740664 | 3.7558 | 3.466772 | 4.86 | 3.254850 | 6.75 | 2.880644 | 40 | 1.888568 | 112 | 1.734425 | 184 | 1.699483 |
| 3.094 | 2.745447 | 3.7559 | 3.466772 | 4.865 | 3.253659 | 7 | 2.842753 | 41 | 1.882893 | 113 | 1.733642 | 185 | 1.699187 |
| 3.095 | 2.750189 | 3.756 | 3.466772 | 4.87 | 3.252468 | 7.5 | 2.773476 | 42 | 1.877477 | 114 | 1.732871 | 186 | 1.698893 |
| 3.096 | 2.754892 | 3.76 | 3.466763 | 4.875 | 3.251278 | 8 | 2.711790 | 43 | 1.872302 | 115 | 1.732114 | 187 | 1.698603 |
| 3.097 | 2.759555 | 3.77 | 3.466677 | 4.88 | 3.250089 | 8.5 | 2.656569 | 44 | 1.867353 | 116 | 1.731369 | 188 | 1.698316 |
| 3.098 | 2.764178 | 3.78 | 3.466502 | 4.885 | 3.248900 | 8.75 | 2.631083 | 45 | 1.862614 | 117 | 1.730637 | 189 | 1.698032 |
| 3.099 | 2.768763 | 3.79 | 3.466241 | 4.89 | 3.247712 | 9 | 2.606874 | 46 | 1.858074 | 118 | 1.729917 | 190 | 1.697751 |
| 3.1 | 2.773311 | 3.8 | 3.465896 | 4.895 | 3.246524 | 9.25 | 2.583850 | 47 | 1.853719 | 119 | 1.729209 | 191 | 1.697473 |
| 3.101 | 2.777821 | 3.85 | 3.463028 | 4.9 | 3.245338 | 9.5 | 2.561926 | 48 | 1.849538 | 120 | 1.728513 | 192 | 1.697198 |
| 3.102 | 2.782292 | 3.9 | 3.458488 | 4.905 | 3.244151 | 9.75 | 2.541026 | 49 | 1.845522 | 121 | 1.727828 | 193 | 1.696925 |
| 3.103 | 2.786730 | 3.95 | 3.452553 | 4.91 | 3.242966 | 10 | 2.521079 | 50 | 1.841660 | 122 | 1.727154 | 194 | 1.696656 |
| 3.104 | 2.791130 | 4 | 3.445453 | 4.915 | 3.241781 | 10.25 | 2.502022 | 51 | 1.837943 | 123 | 1.726490 | 195 | 1.696389 |
| 3.105 | 2.795495 | 4.05 | 3.437381 | 4.92 | 3.240597 | 10.5 | 2.483796 | 52 | 1.834365 | 124 | 1.725837 | 196 | 1.696124 |
| 3.106 | 2.799825 | 4.1 | 3.428501 | 4.925 | 3.239414 | 10.75 | 2.466348 | 53 | 1.830916 | 125 | 1.725195 | 197 | 1.695863 |
| 3.107 | 2.804121 | 4.15 | 3.419848 | 4.93 | 3.238232 | 11 | 2.449629 | 54 | 1.827591 | 126 | 1.724562 | 198 | 1.695604 |
| 3.108 | 2.808382 | 4.2 | 3.408840 | 4.935 | 3.237050 | 11.25 | 2.433593 | 55 | 1.824382 | 127 | 1.723939 | 199 | 1.695347 |
| 3.109 | 2.812609 | 4.25 | 3.398275 | 4.94 | 3.235869 | 11.5 | 2.418200 | 56 | 1.821284 | 128 | 1.723326 | 200 | 1.695093 |
| 3.11 | 2.816804 | 4.3 | 3.387336 | 4.945 | 3.234689 | 11.75 | 2.403410 | 57 | 1.818291 | 129 | 1.722722 | 1.643911 | |
| 3.111 | 2.820965 |
Table I. Echoing period , computed in Ref. [29] for and in this work for all other dimensions.
Choice of numerical scheme
Choptuik’s original code evolved one-parameter families of initial data in time and checked whether or not there is an apparent horizon to decide if a black hole has formed. Using this code, he discovered the echoing period in is approximately given by
Variants of this approach were subsequently used by Sorkin and Oren [27] and Bland et al. [28, 35] to study critical collapse in higher dimensions, obtaining echoing periods up to . One limiting factor of these codes is that gradients become very steep in higher dimensions [23, 26]. Another inefficient aspect is that one needs to construct many spacetimes and only asymptotically approaches the critical DSS solution.
Gundlach circumvented this inefficiency by constructing the critical DSS solution directly, thereby reducing the problem to a nonlinear eigenvalue problem in which the echoing period is an unknown to be determined [21]. As explained in great detail in [30], it is sufficient to construct numerically a solution for a fundamental domain in the past patch, i.e., a trapezoid region bounded in space by the center and the SSH, and bounded in time by one period . They used spectral methods in time, i.e., a Fourier decomposition, and shooting methods in space. This code allowed a more precise determination of the echoing period,
Generalizing their code to arbitrary dimensions , Ecker et al. obtained results for echoing periods both in lower and higher dimensions [29]. However, a crucial limiting factor was identified in their Appendix: besides the regular DSS solution, the equations also have a solution that becomes singular at the SSH. At large , the singular branch becomes increasingly difficult to distinguish numerically from the regular one. Near the SSH at , its leading singular contribution scales as , where is slowly varying and tends to zero at large . Since the exponent grows approximately as , distinguishing the two branches by a Taylor expansion requires a number of terms that grows with , making the calculation increasingly expensive. Mainly for this reason, [29] did not progress beyond .
Reiterer and Trubowitz used the same idea of Gundlach to solve a nonlinear eigenvalue problem. A key difference is their use of spectral methods in space in addition to a Fourier decomposition in time. Expanding all functions in Fourier and Chebyshev modes (as stated in the main text) converts the Einstein–Klein–Gordon equations into a set of nonlinear matrix equations. With their choice of variables, the equations are at most quadratic in the unknowns, so the linearized operator depends linearly on the background solution. This feature adds to the numerical stability of their scheme. Additional advantages, such as arbitrary precision integer arithmetics and a judiciously chosen split of the spectrum into UV and IR modes that are treated differently, are explained in detail in their original paper [31]. While the main task of their work was to prove that Choptuik’s critical DSS spacetime exists, a byproduct of their analysis is unprecedented precision in the determination of Choptuik’s echoing period,
The precision achieved by RT in motivated us to adopt part of their infrastructure in our solver to reach our goal of finding critical DSS solutions and the associated echoing periods in large .
Transformation from RT to GG gauge
To compare our numerical results obtained in RT gauge with the analytical large- expansion derived in GG gauge [22], we construct the coordinate transformation between the two gauges and derive the corresponding relations between their field variables. The GG metric is given by
where and . It is related to the diagonal metric
through the coordinate and field redefinitions
In RT gauge, the line element reads
Equating the angular components of (S4) and (S7) identifies the areal radius,
Rather than determining the two coordinate functions and independently, we introduce a single function through . Equation (S8) then immediately yields
Since the SSH is located at in RT gauge and in GG gauge, the corresponding boundary conditions are
The remaining function is determined by imposing the defining property of polar-areal coordinates, namely the absence of a mixed metric component . Using the RT null derivatives , we can express this condition as
To evaluate these derivatives, we use the RT field definitions . Together with (S8) and (S9), this gives
where . Substituting into (S11) and collecting derivatives of , we obtain
with
This first-order linear PDE for completely determines the coordinate transformation and depends only on the RT echoing parameter and the numerical fields .
We solve Eq. (S13) using the method of characteristics. Parameterizing the characteristic curves by and , the total derivative along a characteristic is
Choosing , Eq. (36) reduces to
The GG time coordinate follows from Eq. (32),
where the derivatives of can be expressed directly in terms of the numerical RT fields,
We thus obtain a closed system of three ODEs,
For each initial RT time , we integrate this system inward from the SSH at to the regular center at , subject to the boundary conditions
The initial value of the GG time coordinate follows from Eq. (33). In particular, Eq. (41) implies
which can be integrated to give
where we fixed the remaining time-translation freedom by choosing .
The quasi-periodicity of the coordinate transformation, , provides an independent expression for the echoing period,
This agrees with the corresponding relation obtained from the RT fields at the center,
and provides a useful consistency check. The identity between the two integrals is a consequence of periodicity of , quasi-periodicity of and regularity of at the center. At the SSH , where at the center we have . The difference between these expressions becomes a total derivative with . Since , the corresponding integral vanishes , which establishes the identity .
In practice, we reconstruct the RT fields from their Fourier–Chebyshev coefficients and evaluate them directly at arbitrary points along the characteristics. The plus fields are obtained from the parity relations , . We then integrate Eq. (42) using an adaptive ODE solver for a set of initial times covering one complete RT period. The resulting coordinate transformation is used to reconstruct the GG fields, which are subsequently interpolated onto a rectangular grid in .
Having determined the coordinate transformation, we reconstruct the four GG fields , , , and from the RT solution. The GG matter fields are defined by
where denotes the scalar field in the GG normalization. The RT matter variables are , where denotes the scalar variable represented by the numerical spectral coefficients. Introducing the normalization factor , the transformation follows from the identities and . Combining these with the RT null derivatives gives
For the numerical spectral coefficients employed here, the normalization is . Thus, both GG matter fields are obtained directly from the numerical RT variables without explicitly reconstructing the scalar field.
The transformation of the metric function follows from the norm of the areal-radius gradient, . Using the definition of in Eq. (29), we obtain
The remaining function can be reconstructed from the RT variables using together with . Consequently,
Finally, the GG metric function follows from the exact radial field equation . Imposing the SSH boundary condition gives
The integration is performed at fixed GG time , after interpolating onto the rectangular GG grid.
The expressions for and contain apparent singularities at , which are removed by evaluating their regular center limits. In particular, one finds
An independent check of the transformation is provided by the exact GG center constraint
Together with the independent determinations of in Eq. (46), this provides a test of the coordinate transformation and the normalization of the matter fields.
At large , the reconstruction of in Eq. (50) involves the subtraction of nearly equal quantities. To reduce numerical cancellation, we evaluate this expression using and with a numerically stable evaluation of .
The coordinate and field transformations presented above are exact at finite . The large- expansion is introduced only when comparing the transformed numerical fields with the analytical results. In particular, the numerical GG matter function at the center directly determines the large- integration function through
Simplified large- perturbation theory
The perturbative expansion of [22] simplifies considerably upon using the scaling of the free function discussed in the main text, . Inserting the series expansions (primes denote derivatives with respect to )
into the equations of motion in GG gauge,
yields the next-to-leading order (NLO) corrections
and the next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) corrections
with
Note that (S39) together with the expansions (S35) implies to leading order (LO) , which explains why can only depend on . The other LO expressions in (S35) follow immediately from solving the equations of motion (S36)–(S39) to LO.
Construction of the large- model
We summarize here the construction of the large- model introduced in the main text. Our strategy is to extrapolate the numerical scalar profiles , obtained for dimensions up to , to infinite and identify a simple analytical representation of the limiting function.
We first introduce the rescaled center profile
where is the normalized GG time coordinate. In this parametrization, all profiles have period and satisfy the half-period antisymmetry . Consequently, they admit a Fourier decomposition containing only odd harmonics,
For each dimension, the coefficients and are determined by a linear least-squares fit to the numerical profile. Before comparing different dimensions, we fix the arbitrary time origin by aligning the fundamental Fourier harmonics, such that and .
We then assume a regular expansion of the normalized profile in powers of ,
To determine the function , we independently extrapolate each Fourier coefficient according to
The leading-order profiles are therefore reconstructed as
This procedure determines from the numerical solutions, without imposing a particular analytical ansatz for its shape.
To identify a simpler representation of , we express its Fourier coefficients in terms of amplitudes and phases,
We find that the amplitudes decrease approximately geometrically, , while the phases exhibit an approximately linear progression, , modulo . These observations motivate the ansatz
which provides a smooth, closed-form approximation to the limiting numerical profile for .
Importantly, the normalization of this ansatz is not an independent fitting parameter. As derived in the main text, the asymptotic expansions of and imply
For the toy model (S58), orthogonality of the Fourier modes gives
Imposing the analytical normalization therefore fixes
The model consequently contains only two free shape parameters, and . We determine these by minimizing the squared differences between the first four Fourier coefficients and those predicted by the ansatz ,
where is determined by Eq. (85) for each trial value of . With this procedure we arrive at the results for the shape parameters and . Substituting this approximation into the large- expressions for the metric and matter fields yields the center profiles compared with the numerical solutions in Figure 4 of the main text.

Figure 4. Numerical results for from Figure 1 transformed to GG gauge and compared with large- approximation, to be contrasted with Fig. 2 of Ref. [22]. White solid lines: exact numerical profiles at . Black dashed lines: corresponding large- predictions of Eq. (22).
To assess the validity of our large- model, Figure 5 compares the numerical solutions for , and with the NNLO perturbative predictions over the full domain. The relative root-mean-square (RMS) deviations, indicated in each panel, decrease systematically with increasing for all four fields, , , , and , providing numerical evidence that the finite- solutions indeed converge toward the proposed large- model.
Figure 5. Comparison of the numerical solutions (gray surfaces) with the NNLO predictions (orange dotted meshes) of the large- model for , and . The relative RMS deviations over the domain are indicated in each panel.
References
- [1]M. W. Choptuik, “Universality and scaling in gravitational collapse of a massless scalar field,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 9–12.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10053245
- [2]C. Gundlach and J. M. Martin-Garcia, “Critical phenomena in gravitational collapse,” Living Rev. Rel. 10 (2007) 5, 0711.4620.
- [3]C. Gundlach, D. Hilditch, and J. M. Martín-García, “Critical Phenomena in Gravitational Collapse,” 2507.07636.
- [4]A. M. Abrahams and C. R. Evans, “Critical behavior and scaling in vacuum axisymmetric gravitational collapse,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 2980–2983.
- [5]C. R. Evans and J. S. Coleman, “Observation of critical phenomena and selfsimilarity in the gravitational collapse of radiation fluid,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 72 (1994) 1782–1785, gr-qc/9402041.DOI
- [6]T. Koike, T. Hara, and S. Adachi, “Critical behavior in gravitational collapse of radiation fluid: A Renormalization group (linear perturbation) analysis,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 74 (1995) 5170–5173, gr-qc/9503007.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10058700
- [7]M. W. Choptuik, T. Chmaj, and P. Bizon, “Critical behavior in gravitational collapse of a Yang-Mills field,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 (1996) 424–427, gr-qc/9603051.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10062809
- [8]B. Bruegmann, W. Tichy, and N. Jansen, “Numerical simulation of orbiting black holes,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 (2004) 211101, gr-qc/0312112.DOI
- [9]P. Bizon and A. Rostworowski, “On weakly turbulent instability of anti-de Sitter space,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 (2011) 031102, 1104.3702.DOI
- [10]P. Bizon, M. Maliborski, and A. Rostworowski, “Resonant Dynamics and the Instability of Anti–de Sitter Spacetime,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 115 (2015), no. 8, 081103, 1506.03519.DOI
- [11]R. M. Wald, “Gravitational collapse and cosmic censorship,” pp. 69–85. 10, 1997. gr-qc/9710068.
- [12]L. Lehner and F. Pretorius, “Black Strings, Low Viscosity Fluids, and Violation of Cosmic Censorship,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010) 101102, 1006.5960.DOI
- [13]S. Ayal and T. Piran, “Spherical collapse of a massless scalar field with semiclassical corrections,” Phys. Rev. D 56 (1997) 4768–4774, gr-qc/9704027.DOI
- [14]T. Chiba and M. Siino, “Disappearance of black hole criticality in semiclassical general relativity,” Mod. Phys. Lett. A12 (1997) 709–718.DOI
- [15]R. Goswami, P. S. Joshi, and P. Singh, “Quantum evaporation of a naked singularity,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006) 031302, gr-qc/0506129.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16486681
- [16]M. Tomašević and C.-H. Wu, “Unveiling horizons in quantum critical collapse,” JHEP 04 (2026) 151, 2509.03584.DOI
- [17]M. Tomašević and C.-H. Wu, “Quantum critical collapse abhors a naked singularity,” Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026), no. 10, 104029, 2509.03587.DOI
- [18]J. C. Niemeyer and K. Jedamzik, “Near-critical gravitational collapse and the initial mass function of primordial black holes,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 5481–5484, astro-ph/9709072.DOI
- [19]V. Vaskonen and H. Veermäe, “Did NANOGrav see a signal from primordial black hole formation?,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 (2021), no. 5, 051303, 2009.07832.DOI
- [20]V. De Luca, G. Franciolini, and A. Riotto, “NANOGrav Data Hints at Primordial Black Holes as Dark Matter,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 (2021), no. 4, 041303, 2009.08268.DOI
- [21]C. Gundlach, “The Choptuik space-time as an eigenvalue problem,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 (1995) 3214–3217, gr-qc/9507054.
- [22]C. Ecker, F. Ecker, and D. Grumiller, “Analytic Discrete Self-Similar Solutions of Einstein-Klein-Gordon at Large D,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 136 (2026), no. 19, 191401, 2601.14358.
- [23]R. Emparan, R. Suzuki, and K. Tanabe, “The large D limit of General Relativity,” JHEP 06 (2013) 009, 1302.6382.DOI
- [24]R. Emparan, D. Grumiller, and K. Tanabe, “Large D gravity and low D strings,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 (2013) 251102, 1303.1995.DOI
- [25]R. Emparan, R. Suzuki, and K. Tanabe, “Evolution and End Point of the Black String Instability: Large D Solution,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 115 (2015), no. 9, 091102, 1506.06772.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26371636
- [26]R. Emparan and C. P. Herzog, “Large D limit of Einstein’s equations,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 92 (2020), no. 4, 045005, 2003.11394.DOI
- [27]E. Sorkin and Y. Oren, “On Choptuik’s scaling in higher dimensions,” Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 124005, hep-th/0502034.
- [28]J. Bland, B. Preston, M. Becker, G. Kunstatter, and V. Husain, “Dimension-dependence of the critical exponent in spherically symmetric gravitational collapse,” Class. Quant. Grav. 22 (2005) 5355–5364, gr-qc/0507088.
- [29]C. Ecker, F. Ecker, D. Grumiller, and T. Jechitl, “Critical spacetime crystals in continuous dimensions,” SciPost Phys. 20 (2026) 176, 2602.10185.DOI
- [30]J. M. Martin-Garcia and C. Gundlach, “Global structure of Choptuik’s critical solution in scalar field collapse,” Phys. Rev. D 68 (2003) 024011, gr-qc/0304070.DOI
- [31]M. Reiterer and E. Trubowitz, “Choptuik’s critical spacetime exists,” Commun. Math. Phys. 368 (2019), no. 1, 143–186, 1203.3766.
- [32]We explain in the Supplemental Material (SM) the rationale behind our choices for the numerical setup. More details of our numerical results and the documented code will appear in a future publication.
- [33]T. Granlund and the GMP development team, GNU MP: The GNU Multiple Precision Arithmetic Library, 6.3.0 ed., 2023.
- [34]J. Bland and G. Kunstatter, “The 5-D Choptuik critical exponent and holography,” Phys. Rev. D 75 (2007) 101501, hep-th/0702226.DOI
- [35]J. B. Bland, Dimension Dependence of the Critical Phenomena in Gravitational Collapse of Massless Scalar Field. PhD thesis, University of Manitoba, 2006.
- [36]A similar result was obtained independently by Nathan Moinvaziri, who used the AI Claude to determine the critical solution in dimensions up to D = 61, see https://github.com/mmoimvaz/choptuik-large-d.
- [37]See the SM for the coordinate transformation between RT and GG gauges.
- [38]The SM displays two additional subleading orders in ε.
- [39]The combination of analytics and numerics that leads to this approximation is discussed in the SM.
- [40]M. Rozali and B. Way, “Gravitating scalar stars in the large D limit,” JHEP 11 (2018) 106, 1807.10283.
- [41]C. R. Clark and G. L. Pimentel, “Black hole critical collapse in infinite dimensions: continuous self-similar solutions,” JHEP 11 (2025) 017, 2504.10590.DOI
- [42]C. Gundlach, “Understanding critical collapse of a scalar field,” Phys. Rev. D 55 (1997) 695–713, gr-qc/9604019.DOI


