betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Charmonium production in a thermalizing heat bath

Abstract

Using the Remler formalism for the creation of composed particles, we study charmonium production both in thermalized and thermalizing boxes, which contain charm and anticharm quarks. The thermalizing box studies include the lowering of the box temperature, the spatial diffusion of charm and anticharm quarks, which are initially confined in the central region, as well as the combination of both, what imitates heavy-ion collisions. Comparing numerical and analytical results we demonstrate that the rate of the original Remler formalism has to be supplemented by two rates to obtain, for t→∞t\to \infty, results, which are consistent with the statistical model predictions: i) a rate, which takes into account the temperature dependence of the Wigner density of the quarkonium during the expansion and, in the case that a heavy quark potential is not implemented in the Monte Carlo approach, ii) a rate which comes from the change of the relative distance between the heavy quark and antiquark. These results provide the basis for future applications of the Remler formalism to heavy-ion collisions.

Introduction

Quarkonium is a bound state of a heavy quark and its antiquark. Since the object is flavorless, it is often called hidden heavy flavor meson. Several decades ago Matsui and Satz suggested the suppression of quarkonium production in heavy-ion collisions as a signature for the formation of a quark-gluon plasma (QGP), because the color screening, which exists only in a deconfined phase, prevents the heavy quark pair from forming a bound state [1].

Quarkonium suppression was indeed later observed at the Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) and the Relativistic heavy-ion Collider (RHIC) [2, 3]. As the collision energy increases, however, more and more heavy quarks are produced and the possibility of regeneration of quarkonia emerges also because the cc and cˉ\bar{c} from different primary vertices may form a quarkonium. In fact, the nuclear modification factor of J/ψJ/\psi, which measures the normalized ratio of J/ψJ/\psi produced in heavy-ion reactions as compared to pp collisions, is larger at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) than at RHIC and larger in mid-rapidity than in forward and backward rapidities, though the temperature is higher at LHC and in the mid-rapidity region [4]. Therefore the study of quarkonium production in heavy-ion collisions is not simply focused on the dissociation in a hot dense nuclear matter but also on regeneration in a QGP [5, 6, 7, 8] or when the QGP hadronizes.

In the seventies Remler devised a formalism to study the production of composite particles in heavy-ion collisions by using the Wigner representation of density operators [9, 10, 11], which was successfully applied to deuteron production in heavy-ion collisions [9, 12].

Recently an attempt has been made to use the Remler formalism to study quarkonium production in heavy-ion collisions [13, 14] as well as in p+p collisions [15]. A distinguished feature of this approach is that the temperature and therefore a QGP time dependence of the Wigner density of the quarkonium is taken into account. Such a dependence is predicted by lattice gauge calculations [16], which show that below the dissociation temperature (above which a J/ψJ/\psi is not stable anymore) the root-mean-square (rms) radius of a J/ψJ/\psi depends on the temperature.

In this study we apply the Remler formalism for quarkonium production in a thermal box by using Monte-Carlo methods. Contrary to simulations of heavy-ion collisions, box simulations have the advantages that everything is controllable and analytic solutions are available. The equilibration of the quarkonia in the box is achieved by scattering with virtual particles at a given temperature. The asymptotic distribution can then be compared with statistical model predictions. The statistical model, which has successfully described the particle production in heavy-ion collisions, provides reliable solutions for the quarkonium production [17, 18].

We first briefly review the Remler formalism in Sec. II and present the solutions for quarkonium production in a thermalized box in Sec. III. In the next section we carry out box simulations for four different initial conditions and present our results. In Sec. V the necessity of an additional term, which is responsible for spatial diffusion, is explained. Finally, a summary is given in Sec. VI.

Remler formalism

In the Remler formalism the multiplicity of a quarkonium state Φ\Phi, PΦP_{\Phi}, in a NN-body system, composed of heavy (anti)quarks, is asymptotically (for t→∞t \to\infty) obtained by

PΦ(t→∞)=Tr⁡[ρΦρN(t→∞)],(1)P_{\Phi}(t \to\infty) = \operatorname{Tr}[\rho_{\Phi}\rho_{N}(t \to\infty)], \tag*{(1)}

where ρΦ\rho_{\Phi} (which is assumed to be time independent) and ρN\rho_{N} are, respectively, the density operator of the quarkonium and of the NN heavy (anti)quarks.

In practice we cannot solve the time evolution of the quantal N-body density matrix without approximations. In the past it turned out that very satisfying results are obtained, if one does not study the time evolution of the density matrix itself but that of the Wigner density distribution, the Fourier transform of the density matrix, and approximates, guided by the mathematical work on the solution of the quantal Vlasov equation, the quantal Wigner density distribution by an ensemble of classical phase space distributions of point like particles. Averaging over this ensemble, one can calculate observables, which agree remarkable well with the experimental results. This procedure is the background of the Boltzmann-Uehling-Uhlenbeck (BUU) (cf. [19, 20]) and the Vlasov-Uehling-Uhlenbeck (VUU) [21] approach, which are widely used to describe the results of heavy-ion collisions with center of mass energies between few GeV and several TeV (cf. [7, 22, 23]).

In these approaches the particles scatter and move on curved trajectories due to a mean potential, created by the fellow particles. If this potential is absent or neglected one talks about a cascade approach. If heavy (anti)quarks are described in the cascade mode, where only scattering and free streaming but no potential interaction is present, they will have diverging trajectories. Therefore, even if the heavy (anti)quarks are initially confined to a space region, asymptotically we will find

lim⁡t→0PΦ=0,(2)\lim_{t \to0} P_{\Phi} = 0, \tag*{(2)}

because two and more body correlations are lost in this approach. To overcome this problem one introduces a rate

Γ=dPΦdt=Tr⁡(dρΦdtρN)+Tr⁡(ρΦdρNdt)=Tr⁡(dρΦdtρN)−iTr⁡(ρΦ[H,ρN])≡Γlocal+Γcoll.(3)\begin{aligned} \Gamma= \frac{dP_{\Phi}}{dt} = \operatorname{Tr}\left(\frac{d\rho_{\Phi}}{dt}\rho_{N}\right) + \operatorname{Tr}\left(\rho_{\Phi}\frac{d\rho_{N}}{dt}\right) \\ &= \operatorname{Tr}\left(\frac{d\rho_{\Phi}}{dt}\rho_{N}\right) - i\operatorname{Tr}\left(\rho_{\Phi}[H,\rho_{N}]\right) \equiv\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}} + \Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}. \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

The Hamiltonian is decomposed into

H=∑iKi+∑i<jVij=H1,2+HN−2+∑i≥3(V1i+V2i),(4)\begin{aligned} H = \sum_i K_i + \sum_{i<j} V_{ij} \\ &= H_{1,2} + H_{N-2} + \sum_{i \ge3}(V_{1i} + V_{2i}), \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

where KiK_i and VijV_{ij} are, respectively, the kinetic and interaction terms and

H1,2=K1+K2+V12,H_{1,2} = K_1 + K_2 + V_{12},
HN−2=∑i≥3Ki+∑i>j≥3Vij.(5)H_{N-2} = \sum_{i \ge3} K_i + \sum_{i>j \ge3} V_{ij}. \tag*{(5)}

Using the cyclic property of traces,

Γcoll=−iTr⁡ρΦ[H,ρN]=iTr⁡ρN[H,ρΦ],(6)\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}} = -i\operatorname{Tr}\rho_{\Phi}[H,\rho_{N}] = i\operatorname{Tr}\rho_{N}[H,\rho_{\Phi}], \tag*{(6)}

and supposing for simplicity that Φ\Phi contains the particles 1 and 2 we obtain

[HN−2,ρΦ]=0,[H1,2,ρΦ]=0,(7)[H_{N-2},\rho_{\Phi}] = 0,\qquad[H_{1,2},\rho_{\Phi}] = 0, \tag*{(7)}

because HN−2H_{N-2} does not affect ρΦ\rho_{\Phi} and ρΦ\rho_{\Phi} is a eigenfunction of H1,2H_{1,2}. The collision term in Eq. (3) is then simplified to [12, 13]

Γcoll=−i∑i≥3Tr⁡(ρΦ[V1i+V2i,ρN]).(8)\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}} = -i\sum_{i \ge3}\operatorname{Tr}\left(\rho_{\Phi}[V_{1i}+V_{2i},\rho_{N}]\right). \tag*{(8)}

For a S-state the density operator of the quarkonium, expressed in Wigner representation, is approximated by

ρΦ→WS(r,p)=8exp⁡[−r2σ2−σ2p2],(9)\rho_{\Phi} \to W_{S}(r,p) = 8\exp\left[-\frac{r^2}{\sigma^2}-\sigma^2p^2\right], \tag*{(9)}

where rr and pp are, respectively, relative distance and relative momentum in the center-of-mass frame. The width σ\sigma is given by the rms radius of the quarkonium.

The classical phase space distribution of point like particles can be expressed as

ρN≈∏i=1Nh3Nδ(ri−ri∗(t))δ(pi−pi∗(t))(10)\rho_{N} \approx\prod_{i=1}^{N} h^{3N}\delta(r_i-r_i^*(t))\delta(p_i-p_i^*(t)) \tag*{(10)}

where ri∗(t)r_i^*(t) and pi∗(t)p_i^*(t) is the phase space trajectory of particle ii. The time derivative of the density matrix is then given by

dρNdt≈∑ivi⋅∇rρN+∑i>j∑νδ(t−tij(ν)){ρN(t+ϵ)−ρN(t−ϵ)}(11)\begin{aligned} \frac{d\rho_{N}}{dt} \approx\sum_i \boldsymbol{v}_i \cdot\nabla_r\rho_{N} \\ &+ \sum_{i>j}\sum_{\nu}\delta(t-t_{ij}(\nu))\{\rho_{N}(t+\epsilon)-\rho_{N}(t-\epsilon)\} \tag*{(11)} \end{aligned}

where tij(ν)t_{ij}(\nu) is the time for the ν\nu th collision between the particles ii and jj. The first term implies free streaming between instant scatterings, which are described by the second term. The second term in Eq. (11) is equivalent to Eq. (8). Therefore,

Γcoll(t)≈∑i=1,2∑j≥3∑νδ(t−tij(ν))×∫d3r1d3r2d3p1…d3rNd3pN(2π)3N×ρΦ(r1,p1;r2,p2){ρN(t+ϵ)−ρN(t−ϵ)},(12)\begin{aligned} \Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}(t) \approx\sum_{i=1,2}\sum_{j \ge3}\sum_{\nu}\delta(t-t_{ij}(\nu)) \\ &\times\int d^3r_1d^3r_2d^3p_1\ldots d^3r_Nd^3p_N(2\pi)^{3N} \\ &\times\rho_{\Phi}(r_1,p_1;r_2,p_2)\{\rho_N(t+\epsilon)-\rho_N(t-\epsilon)\}, \tag*{(12)} \end{aligned}

and we obtain for the multiplicity at time t′t'

PΦ(t′)−PΦ(0)≈∫0t′dt{Γlocal(t)+Γcoll(t)}.(13)P_{\Phi}(t')-P_{\Phi}(0)\approx\int_{0}^{t'}dt\{\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}}(t)+\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}(t)\}. \tag*{(13)}

We note that Γlocal(t)\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}}(t) contributes only if σ\sigma in Eq. (9) changes with time [13].

quarkonium in thermal box

The multiplicity of a quarkonium Φ\Phi can be obtained in the coalescence approach by projecting the phase space distribution of the charmed quarks onto the Wigner density of the Φ\Phi state [24, 25]

NΦ=dd1d2∫d3p1d3p2d3r1d3r2(2π)6×fQ(r1,p1)fQˉ(r2,p2)WS(r,p)=dd1d2∫d3P d3p d3R d3r(2π)6×fQ(r1,p1)fQˉ(r2,p2)WS(r,p),(14)\begin{aligned} N_{\Phi}&=\frac{d}{d_{1}d_{2}}\int\frac{d^{3}p_{1}d^{3}p_{2}d^{3}r_{1}d^{3}r_{2}}{(2\pi)^{6}}\\ &\quad\times f_{Q}(r_{1},p_{1})f_{\bar{Q}}(r_{2},p_{2})W_{S}(r,p)\\ &=\frac{d}{d_{1}d_{2}}\int\frac{d^{3}P\,d^{3}p\,d^{3}R\,d^{3}r}{(2\pi)^{6}}\\ &\quad\times f_{Q}(r_{1},p_{1})f_{\bar{Q}}(r_{2},p_{2})W_{S}(r,p), \tag*{(14)} \end{aligned}

where fQ(r1,p1)f_{Q}(r_{1},p_{1}) and fQˉ(r2,p2)f_{\bar{Q}}(r_{2},p_{2}) are, respectively, the heavy quark (QQ) and heavy antiquark (Qˉ\bar{Q}) distribution functions, r=r1−r2r=r_{1}-r_{2}, R=(r1+r2)/2R=(r_{1}+r_{2})/2, p=(p1−p2)/2p=(p_{1}-p_{2})/2 and P=p1+p2P=p_{1}+p_{2}, and d1d_{1}, d2d_{2} and dd is, respectively, the spin-color degeneracy of QQ, Qˉ\bar{Q} and quarkonium. rr and pp in the Wigner functions are the distance and the relative momentum of the heavy quark pair in their center-of-mass frame. Since we are studying heavy quarks with a mass much larger than the temperature, we can safely use the Galilean transformation instead of the Lorentz transformation.

We assume an uniform distribution of QQ and Qˉ\bar{Q} in space,

(2π)3dNSVd3P=dπ3d1d2∫d3p d3r fQ(p1)fQˉ(p2)e−r2/σ2−σ2p2=(σ2π)3/2dd1d2∫d3p fQ(p1)fQˉ(p2)e−σ2p2,(15)\begin{aligned} (2\pi)^{3}\frac{dN_{S}}{Vd^{3}P}&=\frac{d}{\pi^{3}d_{1}d_{2}}\int d^{3}p\,d^{3}r\,f_{Q}(p_{1})f_{\bar{Q}}(p_{2})e^{-r^{2}/\sigma^{2}-\sigma^{2}p^{2}}\\ &=\left(\frac{\sigma^{2}}{\pi}\right)^{3/2}\frac{d}{d_{1}d_{2}}\int d^{3}p\,f_{Q}(p_{1})f_{\bar{Q}}(p_{2})e^{-\sigma^{2}p^{2}}, \tag*{(15)} \end{aligned}

because

∫d3re−r2/σ2=2πσ3Γ(3/2)=(πσ2)3/2.(16)\int d^{3}r e^{-r^{2}/\sigma^{2}}=2\pi\sigma^{3}\Gamma(3/2)=(\pi\sigma^{2})^{3/2}. \tag*{(16)}

In the nonrelativistic (or heavy quark) limit one can take a Boltzmann distribution for fQ(p1)f_{Q}(p_{1}) and fQˉ(p2)f_{\bar{Q}}(p_{2})

1d1d2fQ(p1)fQˉ(p2)e−σ2p2≈e−E1/T−E2/T−σ2p2≈exp⁡[−(2mQ+p122mQ+p222mQ)/T−σ2p2]=exp⁡[−(2mQ+P2/2+2p22mQ)/T−σ2p2].(17)\begin{aligned} \frac{1}{d_{1}d_{2}}f_{Q}(p_{1})f_{\bar{Q}}(p_{2})e^{-\sigma^{2}p^{2}}&\approx e^{-E_{1}/T-E_{2}/T-\sigma^{2}p^{2}}\\ &\approx\exp\left[-\left(2m_{Q}+\frac{p_{1}^{2}}{2m_{Q}}+\frac{p_{2}^{2}}{2m_{Q}}\right)/T-\sigma^{2}p^{2}\right]\\ &=\exp\left[-\left(2m_{Q}+\frac{P^{2}/2+2p^{2}}{2m_{Q}}\right)/T-\sigma^{2}p^{2}\right]. \tag*{(17)} \end{aligned}

Substituting Eq. (17) into Eq. (15) we obtain

(2π)3dNSVd3P=dexp⁡[−(M+P22M)/T](σ2π)3/2∫d3pe−{σ2+1/(mQT)}p2=de−E/T(σ2σ2+1/(mQT))3/2,(18)\begin{aligned} (2\pi)^{3}\frac{dN_{S}}{Vd^{3}P}&=d\exp\left[-\left(M+\frac{P^{2}}{2M}\right)/T\right]\left(\frac{\sigma^{2}}{\pi}\right)^{3/2}\int d^{3}p e^{-\{\sigma^{2}+1/(m_{Q}T)\}p^{2}}\\ &=d e^{-E/T}\left(\frac{\sigma^{2}}{\sigma^{2}+1/(m_{Q}T)}\right)^{3/2}, \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

where M=2mQM=2m_{Q}. Assuming mQ≫1/(σ2T)m_{Q}\gg1/(\sigma^{2}T) we find,

(2π)3dNSVd3P≈de−E/T.(19)(2\pi)^{3}\frac{dN_{S}}{Vd^{3}P}\approx d e^{-E/T}. \tag*{(19)}

Since σ2=8/3⟨r2⟩\sigma^{2}=8/3\langle r^{2}\rangle with rr being the quarkonium radius [24, 25], the assumption is justified if

mQ≫38⟨r2⟩T.(20)m_{Q}\gg\frac{3}{8\langle r^{2}\rangle T}. \tag*{(20)}

It is hence valid even close to the critical temperature TcT_{c}, supposing ⟨r2⟩∼0.5\sqrt{\langle r^{2}\rangle}\sim0.5 fm. We note that from Eq. (18) that the charmonium abundance at T=200T=200 MeV is about 77 % of the statistical model abundance for mQ=1.5m_{Q}=1.5 GeV.

Therefore we expect that in a heat bath the statistical model and the coalescence approach yield a similar multiplicity. Strictly speaking, there must be an attractive force between the heavy quark and the heavy antiquark to form a quarkonium and the mass of the quarkonium is therefore less than twice the heavy quark mass. In this study, however, we assume that the binding energy is small and therefore the J/ψJ/\psi is weakly bound in a QGP [26, 27, 28]. The inclusion of heavy quark potential in the Remler formalism [13] will be discussed in a future publication.

The coalescence model of Eq. (14) is closely related to Eq. (1) [24], since

PΦ=Tr⁡[ρΦρN]=Tr⁡(∣Φ⟩⟨Φ∣P_{\Phi}=\operatorname{Tr}[\rho_{\Phi}\rho_{N}]=\operatorname{Tr}\left(\lvert\Phi\rangle\langle\Phi\rvert\right.
×∣Q1Qˉ2…QN−1QˉN⟩⟨Q1Qˉ2…QN−1QˉN∣ρij)=∣⟨Φ∣Q1Qˉ2…QN−1QˉN⟩∣2ρii,(21)\begin{aligned} \left.\times\lvert Q_{1}\bar{Q}_{2}\ldots Q_{N-1}\bar{Q}_{N}\rangle\langle Q_{1}\bar{Q}_{2}\ldots Q_{N-1}\bar{Q}_{N}\rvert\rho_{ij}\right) \\ &=\left\lvert\langle\Phi\lvert Q_{1}\bar{Q}_{2}\ldots Q_{N-1}\bar{Q}_{N}\rangle\right\rvert^{2}\rho_{ii}, \tag*{(21)} \end{aligned}

where ρij\rho_{ij} is the density matrix element of the NN-body density matrix ρN\rho_{N} and the eigenstates ∣Φ⟩\lvert\Phi\rangle are taken for a basis of the ccˉc\bar{c} states.

The Remler formalism starts from the same equation (1). Therefore we can test this formula in a thermal box, which is completely controllable and for which explicit and analytical solutions of Eq. (19) can be obtained. That the numerical realization of the Remler formalism gives the correct result in a box is a prerequisite for its application in numerical simulation of heavy-ion collisions.

box simulations

In this section the Remler formalism is tested in a box in which the heavy (anti)quarks are in thermal equilibrium as well as for three scenarios in which their initial momentum distribution and/or their initial spatial distribution does not correspond to the equilibrium distribution.

static thermal box

We prepare a box of size 1003 fm3100^{3}\,\mathrm{fm}^{3} in which we place charm quarks and charm antiquarks in thermal equilibrium at T=200T=200 MeV. Charm (anti)quarks scatter off artificial partons which have a thermal momentum of T=200T=200 MeV and are not affected by the scattering. The interaction rate is fixed to 1.01.0 c/fm. To remove boundary effects, we extended the box by 3 fm in each direction but for the analysis we exclude the extended volume.

Figure 1 compares the charmonium multiplicity as a function of time from statistical model calculations, assuming that the quarkonium mass is twice the heavy quark mass, as in Eq. (19), from Eq. (14) and from Eq. (13), which are named in the figure ”statistical model”, ”Wigner density” and ”time integration of Γ\Gamma”, respectively. The charm quark mass is assumed to be 1.5 GeV and and we take a charmonium radius of 0.5 fm. The results are an ensemble average of 200 events. The colored band indicates the statistical error. One can see a slight difference between the statistical model and the Wigner projection, which originates from the approximations in Eqs. (17) and (19).

Figure 1. (Color online) Charmonium multiplicity as a function of time in a box of 1003 fm3100^{3}\,\mathrm{fm}^{3} at T=200T=200 MeV calculated in the statistical model, from Eq. (14) and from Eq. (13). Charm quark mass and charmonium radius are taken as 1.5 GeV and 0.5 fm, respectively.

One can see that the time integration of Γcoll\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}} does not deviate from the dashed and solid blue lines within the statistical error. The reason we will explain now.

We define the Wigner projection at tt,

W(r1∗,r2∗,p1∗,p2∗;t)=∑i=1,2∑j≥3∫d3r1d3p1…d3rNd3pN (2π)3NρΦ(r1,p1;r2,p2)ρN(t),(22)\mathcal{W}(r_1^*,r_2^*,p_1^*,p_2^*;t)=\sum_{i=1,2}\sum_{j\geq3}\int d^3r_1d^3p_1\ldots d^3r_Nd^3p_N\,(2\pi)^{3N}\rho_\Phi(r_1,p_1;r_2,p_2)\rho_N(t), \tag*{(22)}

where r1∗,r2∗,p1∗,p2∗r_1^*,r_2^*,p_1^*,p_2^* characterize trajectories of (anti)charm quarks in Eq. (10) projected to quarkonium state, see Eq. (10).

Since the projection is carried out in a homogeneous box, one can separate the spatial dependence, which will be a constant in time, such that

W(r1∗,r2∗,p1∗,p2∗;t)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t)Wr.(23)\mathcal{W}(r_1^*,r_2^*,p_1^*,p_2^*;t)=\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t)\mathcal{W}_r. \tag*{(23)}

Then Eq. (13) is expressed as

Pϕ(t′)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗;0)Wr+Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t1+ε)Wr−Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t1−ε)Wr+Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t2+ε)Wr−Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t2−ε)Wr…+Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t′+ε)Wr−Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t′−ε)Wr.(24)\begin{aligned} P_\phi(t')={}&\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;0)\mathcal{W}_r\\ &+\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_1+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r-\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_1-\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r\\ &+\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_2+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r-\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_2-\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r\\ &\ldots\\ &+\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t'+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r-\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t'-\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r. \tag*{(24)} \end{aligned}

where t=0t=0 is the initial projection time where only the production term appears, which corresponds to Pϕ(0)P_\phi(0) in Eq. (12). We number the scatterings of heavy quarks or antiquarks by ”ii”. tit_i is the time of the iith scattering in which either the charm quark or the anticharm quark is involved and both, production and destruction term, appear. We note that Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t)\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t) in the above equation means Wp(p1∗(t),p2∗(t))\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*(t),p_2^*(t)).

Since there is no scattering of charm quarks with a light quark between t=0t=0 and t=t1−εt=t_1-\varepsilon,

Wp(p1∗,p2∗;0)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t1−ε).(25)\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;0)=\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_1-\varepsilon). \tag*{(25)}

The same applies to each following time interval between collisions:

Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti+ε)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti+1−ε).(26)\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_i+\varepsilon)=\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_{i+1}-\varepsilon). \tag*{(26)}

Thus, most of the terms cancel and only the Wigner projection at the end of the last collision remains:

Pϕ(t′)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t′+ε)Wr,(27)P_\phi(t')=\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t'+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r, \tag*{(27)}

where p1∗p_1^* and p2∗p_2^* are still the thermal momenta of the charm quark and anticharm quark. The time integration of Γcoll\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}} fluctuates around the Wigner projection for a system in thermal equilibrium at T=200T=200 MeV.

One can see that the statistical error in Figure 1 increases with time. The reason is as following: Whenever scattering happens, a new Wigner projection is added and the old Wigner projection is subtracted as in Eq. (24). Since the box is already in thermal equilibrium both the addition and the subtraction are random fluctuations. As a result, like for all random walks, some events deviate far away from the thermal average as time passes. That is why the statistical error increases with time, while the average value stays near the thermal equilibrium.

B cooling down of (anti)charm quarks

Now we apply the Remler formalism to charm and anticharm quarks in a box of the same size in which the initial temperature of (anti)charm quarks is 400 MeV, but their number is same as in the previous subsection. In other words, only their thermal momentum changes. Initially it is given by a thermal distribution at T=400T = 400 MeV and then cools down to 200 MeV through the scattering with the artificial partons, which are assumed to have a thermal distribution with T=200T = 200 MeV.

In this case Eq. (26) is still valid. The only difference is that the initial momentum distributions of p1∗p_1^* and p2∗p_2^* correspond to the thermal distribution of T=400T = 400 MeV. Then they gradually change with time, through scattering with the artificial partons, to the distribution corresponding to T=200T = 200 MeV. Simply expressed, though it is not quite true, Eq. (24) will be like

Pϕ(t′)=Wp(T=400 MeV)Wr+Wp(T=399 MeV)Wr−Wp(T=400 MeV)Wr+Wp(T=398 MeV)Wr−Wp(T=399 MeV)Wr⋯+Wp(T=200 MeV)Wr−Wp(T=201 MeV)Wr.(28)\begin{aligned} P_{\phi}(t') ={}& W_p(T = 400\ \mathrm{MeV})W_r \\ &+W_p(T = 399\ \mathrm{MeV})W_r - W_p(T = 400\ \mathrm{MeV})W_r \\ &+W_p(T = 398\ \mathrm{MeV})W_r - W_p(T = 399\ \mathrm{MeV})W_r \\ &\cdots\\ &+W_p(T = 200\ \mathrm{MeV})W_r - W_p(T = 201\ \mathrm{MeV})W_r. \tag*{(28)} \end{aligned}

However, if the radius or σ\sigma in the Wigner function of Eq. (9) depends on the temperature, Eqs. (25) and (26) are not valid any more:

Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;ti+ϵ)≠Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;ti+1−ϵ),(29)W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_i+\epsilon) \ne W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_{i+1}-\epsilon), \tag*{(29)}

because the temperature at t=ti+ϵt = t_i+\epsilon is different from that at t=ti+1−ϵt = t_{i+1}-\epsilon. Therefore, it is necessary to add the rate Γlocal\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}} as in Eqs. (3) and (13), which is expressed by [13, 14]

Γlocal(t)=Tr⁡(dρΦdσ(T)dσ(T)dtρN).(30)\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}}(t) = \operatorname{Tr}\left(\frac{d\rho_{\Phi}}{d\sigma(T)}\frac{d\sigma(T)}{dt}\rho_N\right). \tag*{(30)}

Then Eq. (24) changes to

Pϕ(t′)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;0)Wr+Wr∫0t1dt(∂Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t)∂σ)(∂σ∂t)+Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;t1+ϵ)Wr−Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;t1−ϵ)Wr+Wr∫t1t2dt(∂Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t)∂σ)(∂σ∂t)+Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;t2+ϵ)Wr−Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;t2−ϵ)Wr⋯+Wr∫t1t′dt(∂Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t)∂σ)(∂σ∂t)+Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;t′+ϵ)Wr−Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;t′−ϵ)Wr.(31)\begin{aligned} P_{\phi}(t') ={}& W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;0)W_r \\ &+W_r\int_0^{t_1}dt\left(\frac{\partial W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t)}{\partial\sigma}\right)\left(\frac{\partial\sigma}{\partial t}\right) \\ &+W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_1+\epsilon)W_r-W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_1-\epsilon)W_r \\ &+W_r\int_{t_1}^{t_2}dt\left(\frac{\partial W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t)}{\partial\sigma}\right)\left(\frac{\partial\sigma}{\partial t}\right) \\ &+W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_2+\epsilon)W_r-W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_2-\epsilon)W_r \\ &\cdots\\ &+W_r\int_{t_1}^{t'}dt\left(\frac{\partial W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t)}{\partial\sigma}\right)\left(\frac{\partial\sigma}{\partial t}\right) \\ &+W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t'+\epsilon)W_r-W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t'-\epsilon)W_r. \tag*{(31)} \end{aligned}

Since nothing changes between t=0t = 0 and t=t1−ϵt = t_1-\epsilon except of the temperature dependent σ\sigma

∫0t1dt(∂Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t)∂σ)(∂σ∂t)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;t1−ϵ)−Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;0),(32)\int_0^{t_1}dt\left(\frac{\partial W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t)}{\partial\sigma}\right)\left(\frac{\partial\sigma}{\partial t}\right) = W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_1-\epsilon)-W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;0), \tag*{(32)}

ignoring the temperature change between t=t1−ϵt = t_1-\epsilon and t=t1t = t_1. Therefore, one arrives the same result as in Eq. (27):

Pϕ(t′)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;t′+ϵ)Wr.(33)P_{\phi}(t') = W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t'+\epsilon)W_r. \tag*{(33)}

The upper panel of Figure 2 shows the time evolution of the effective temperature, which is defined by

Figure 2. (Color online) (upper) Effective temperature of (anti)charm quarks as a function of time and (lower) the same as figure 1 but with and without the contributions from Γlocal\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}}.

Teff=23⟨Ekin⟩,(34)T_{\mathrm{eff}} = \frac{2}{3}\langle E_{\mathrm{kin}}\rangle, \tag*{(34)}

where ⟨Ekin⟩\langle E_{\mathrm{kin}}\rangle is the mean value of the (anti)charm kinetic energy. We note that due to the approximation of Eq. (34) the initial and the final effective temperatures are a bit higher than the real initial and final temperatures, which are, respectively, 400 MeV and 200 MeV. One can see that the temperature reaches its final value before t=100t = 100 fm/c. The radius of quarkonium is simply modeled as

⟨r2⟩=0.5(Teff0.2 GeV)2 [fm](35)\sqrt{\langle r^2\rangle}=0.5\left(\frac{T_{\mathrm{eff}}}{0.2\ \mathrm{GeV}}\right)^2\ [\mathrm{fm}] \tag*{(35)}

such that ⟨r2⟩=0.5 fm\sqrt{\langle r^2\rangle}=0.5\ \mathrm{fm} at T=200 MeVT=200\ \mathrm{MeV}, a reasonable approximation to the lattice results [16]. The lower panel of Figure 2 corresponds to Figure 1. We have added the magenta line, which is the result if we apply only the collisional rate, Γcoll\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}, whereas the orange line is obtained if we take the sum of both rates, Γlocal\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}} and Γcoll\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}. The multiplicity of charmonia starts from a lower value than in equilibrium at T=200 MeVT=200\ \mathrm{MeV} because a larger thermal momentum lowers the Wigner projection. The orange line recovers the equilibrium multiplicity at about the same time when the temperature of the box reaches its final value. One can clearly see that the inclusion of Γlocal\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}} is necessary to obtain a results consistent with the assumed equilibrium.

expanding (anti)charm quarks

Now we confine the initial (anti)charm quarks within a smaller box of size 503 fm350^3\ \mathrm{fm}^3 in the center of the large box, assuming a momentum distribution of the (anti)charm quarks, corresponding to T=200 MeVT=200\ \mathrm{MeV}. The density of the charm and anticharm quarks in this smaller box is therefore 8 times higher as compared to the above discussed configuration.

As time passes the charm density decreases and the number of charmonia converges to that expected for a system in equilibrium in the full volume. One can see in Figure 3 that the multiplicity, which is given by the solid blue line, indeed converges to the number expected for a system in equilibrium. The time integration of Γcoll\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}, however, does not catch up with the decrease and remains higher. The reason is that Wr\mathcal{W}_r in Eq. (24) now depends on time and we obtain

Figure 3. (Color online) Same as figure 1 but initial spatial distribution of (anti)charm quarks is restricted to a half-sized box.

Pϕ(t′)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗;0)Wr(0)+Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t1+ε)Wr(t1+ε)−Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t1−ε)Wr(t1−ε)+Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t2+ε)Wr(t2+ε)−Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t2−ε)Wr(t2−ε)⋯+Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t′+ε)Wr(t′+ε)−Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t′−ε)Wr(t′−ε),(36)\begin{aligned} P_{\phi}(t')={}&\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;0)\mathcal{W}_r(0)\\ &+\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_1+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r(t_1+\varepsilon)\\ &-\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_1-\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r(t_1-\varepsilon)\\ &+\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_2+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r(t_2+\varepsilon)\\ &-\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_2-\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r(t_2-\varepsilon)\\ &\cdots\\ &+\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t'+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r(t'+\varepsilon)\\ &-\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t'-\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r(t'-\varepsilon), \tag*{(36)} \end{aligned}

Eqs. (25) and (26) are still valid, but the two terms do not cancel any longer:

Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti+ε)Wr(ti+ε)≠Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti+1−ε)Wr(ti+1−ε),(37)\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_i+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r(t_i+\varepsilon) \ne\mathcal{W}_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_{i+1}-\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_r(t_{i+1}-\varepsilon), \tag*{(37)}

because Wr(ti+ε)\mathcal{W}_r(t_i+\varepsilon) is larger than Wr(ti+1−ε)\mathcal{W}_r(t_{i+1}-\varepsilon) due to the spatial diffusion of (anti)charm quarks. This is why the equilibrium distribution of (27) cannot be achieved in this scenario.

cooling and expanding (anti)charm quarks

Now we imitate heavy-ion collisions by combining the two previous scenarios, in other words, heavy (anti)quarks are initially at a high temperature and densely populated in a small volume. As before the initial temperature is given by 400 MeV and the initial volume by 503 fm350^3\ \mathrm{fm}^3. Then they cool down and expand in space. Therefore the projection probability first increases with time due to the momentum loss, as in Figure 2, and then decreases due to the spatial diffusion, as in Figure 3. However, one can see in Figure 4 the multiplicity, obtained by the time integration of Γcoll\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}, differs from that obtained by applying the Wigner projection directly and from that, which is given by the statistical model.

Figure 4. (Color online) Combination of figure 2 and figure 3 for the initial conditions of (anti)charm quarks

V spatial diffusion term

The discrepancies between the statistical model and the time integration of Γ\Gamma in Figure 3 and Figure 4 originate from the calculations of dρN/dtd\rho_N/dt. Since ρN\rho_N is the density operator of NN (anti)charm quarks, it includes both spatial and momentum information. But only momentum space information has been taken from the comparison between Eq. (8) and Eq. (11). In other words, only the interaction terms are taken into account and the kinetic terms (the free streaming) are neglected in Eq. (11). The spatial diffusion is attributed to the kinetic terms in K1K_1 and K2K_2 of Eq. (5). In principle, it must not contribute to dρN/dtd\rho_N/dt because heavy quark and heavy antiquark are bound by the potential V12V_{12} and move together as shown in Eq. (7). However, in standard cascade simulations we have only free propagation and instant scatterings [12] and it is still challenging to properly implement microscopic potentials in numerical simulations [13, 29].

We therefore propose that the following term should be added to Eq. (3) if a standard cascade approach is employed

Γdiff(t)=Tr⁡(dΦdr⃗⋅dr⃗dtρN),(38)\Gamma_{\mathrm{diff}}(t)=\operatorname{Tr}\left(\frac{d\Phi}{d\vec{r}}\cdot\frac{d\vec{r}}{dt}\rho_N\right), \tag*{(38)}

and for an S-state it will be (see Eq. (9)) of the form

Γdiff(t)∼−2σ2r⃗⋅v⃗ WS(r,p),(39)\Gamma_{\mathrm{diff}}(t)\sim-\frac{2}{\sigma^2}\vec{r}\cdot\vec{v}\,W_S(r,p), \tag*{(39)}

where v⃗=dr⃗/dt\vec{v}=d\vec{r}/dt with r⃗\vec{r} being r⃗Q−r⃗Qˉ\vec{r}_Q-\vec{r}_{\bar{Q}} in their center-of-mass frame. Then the inequality of Eq. (37) can be removed through

Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti+ε)Wr(ti+ε)−Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti+1−ε)Wr(ti+1−ε)+∫titi+1dt Γdiff=0.(40)W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_i+\varepsilon)W_r(t_i+\varepsilon)-W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*;t_{i+1}-\varepsilon)W_r(t_{i+1}-\varepsilon)+\int_{t_i}^{t_{i+1}}dt\,\Gamma_{\mathrm{diff}}=0. \tag*{(40)}

In fact, if the bound state is perfectly described in the simulations, even Γlocal\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}} is not needed, because the equality of Eq. (29) will dynamically be restored:

Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;ti+ε)=Wp(p1∗,p2∗,T;ti+1−ε).(41)W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_i+\varepsilon)=W_p(p_1^*,p_2^*,T;t_{i+1}-\varepsilon). \tag*{(41)}

As temperature decreases, the binding of quarkonium will be stronger so that the relative distance rr decreases and the relative momentum pp increases, which compensates the change of σ\sigma with temperature.

Figure 5 shows the time evolution of the multiplicity of Φ\Phi including Γdiff\Gamma_{\mathrm{diff}} in comparison the cases already studied

Figure 5. (Color online) Same as figures 3 and 4 but including Γdiff\Gamma_{\mathrm{diff}} of Eq. (39)

in figures 3 and 4. One finds that including Γdiff\Gamma_{\mathrm{diff}} the time integration of Γ\Gamma is now in good agreement with the statistical model predictions. Considering the results of our study of the Φ\Phi multiplicity in a box, the best and simplest method to obtain the asymptotically correct values is to add to Γ\Gamma a diffusion rate Γdiff\Gamma_{\mathrm{diff}}

Γ(t)=Γlocal(t)+Γcoll(t)+Γdiff(t)=∑i=1,2∑j≥3∑ν∫d3r1d3p1⋯d3rNd3pN(2π)3N×Φ(r1,p1;r2,p2){δ(t−tij(ν))ρN(t+ε)−δ(t−tij(ν−1))ρN(t+ε)},(42)\begin{aligned} \Gamma(t)=\Gamma_{\mathrm{local}}(t)+\Gamma_{\mathrm{coll}}(t)+\Gamma_{\mathrm{diff}}(t) \\ &=\sum_{i=1,2}\sum_{j\geq3}\sum_{\nu}\int d^3r_1d^3p_1\cdots d^3r_Nd^3p_N(2\pi)^{3N} \\ &\times\Phi(r_1,p_1;r_2,p_2)\left\{\delta\left(t-t_{ij}(\nu)\right)\rho_N(t+\varepsilon)-\delta\left(t-t_{ij}(\nu-1)\right)\rho_N(t+\varepsilon)\right\}, \tag*{(42)} \end{aligned}

where ν\nu means ν\nu th scattering of i=1i=1 or of i=2i=2. Consequently, to be consistent with statistical model predictions, one has to supplement the old projection probability of particles i=1,2i = 1, 2 (the second term in the bracket) by a new one (the first term in the bracket) whenever a scattering happens to i=1i = 1 or to i=2i = 2. Then the change of the temperature, reflected in the change of σ\sigma, and of the spatial separation of (anti)charm quarks between t=tij(ν−1)t = t_{ij}(\nu- 1) and t=tij(ν)t = t_{ij}(\nu) will completely be canceled. This approach is also more natural than Eq. (12), which assumes an instant interaction between t−εt - \varepsilon and t+εt + \varepsilon, because it increases ε\varepsilon to the time between two scatterings. We note that the combination of Eq. (32) and Eq. (40) yields

Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti+ε)Wr(ti+ε)−Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti+1−ε)Wr(ti+1−ε)+Wr(ti)∫titi+1dt ∂Wp(p1∗,p2∗;t)∂σ∂σ∂t+Wp(p1∗,p2∗;ti)∫titi+1dt ∂Wr(t)∂r⃗⋅∂r⃗∂t=0.(43)\begin{aligned} &\mathcal{W}_{p}(p_1^{*},p_2^{*};t_i+\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_{r}(t_i+\varepsilon) \\ &-\mathcal{W}_{p}(p_1^{*},p_2^{*};t_{i+1}-\varepsilon)\mathcal{W}_{r}(t_{i+1}-\varepsilon) \\ &+\mathcal{W}_{r}(t_i)\int_{t_i}^{t_{i+1}} \mathrm{d}t\,\frac{\partial\mathcal{W}_{p}(p_1^{*},p_2^{*};t)}{\partial\sigma}\frac{\partial\sigma}{\partial t} \\ &+\mathcal{W}_{p}(p_1^{*},p_2^{*};t_i)\int_{t_i}^{t_{i+1}} \mathrm{d}t\,\frac{\partial\mathcal{W}_{r}(t)}{\partial\vec{r}}\cdot\frac{\partial\vec{r}}{\partial t}=0. \tag*{(43)} \end{aligned}

summary

The Remler formalism has been advanced to study the production of J/ψJ/\psi in a thermalized expanding system. In this study we have tested the Remler approach for J/ψJ/\psi production in thermalized and thermalizing boxes, composed of c and cˉ\bar{c} quarks. The goal was to verify whether the numerical, Monte Carlo based, realization of the Remler algorithm gives the right asymptotic solution for t→∞t \to\infty, which can be calculated analytically.

We started out with calculations in a completely thermalized box, where we find that the Remler formula produces the results which are consistent with that of a statistical model calculation. Then three different types of thermalizing boxes have been investigated.

In the first scenario the initial temperature of the charm quarks is high. They cool down with time through collisions with background particles and finally reach thermal equilibrium at a lower temperature. The multiplicity of the charm quarks is kept constant. We have found that the temperature derivative of the Wigner function is required to assure that the Remler approach agrees for large times with statistical model calculations.

In the second scenario charm and anticharm quarks are initially concentrated in a smaller box and then diffuse in space. The last scenario, which we studied, is the combination of the first and second one: The initial temperature of the charm quark is higher than that of the background particles and (anti-)charm quarks are concentrated initially in the central region of the box. Then they cool down and diffuse in space. This is a simple model for the expansion of the midrapidity QGP, which is created in heavy-ion collisions. We have found that in the second and third scenarios the discrepancy between the multiplicities, calculated in the Remler approach and in a statistical model, does not disappear even for t→∞t \to\infty.

We identified the origin of this discrepancy: it is caused by the fact that in the numerical realization of the Remler algorithm, as presented in [12] for deutrons, the expansion of the system between two subsequent collisions is not taken properly into account. Neglecting the potential, it treats the c and cˉ\bar{c} quarks as freely moving particles between two collisions whereas in reality they are bound when they form a quarkonium. Introducing a diffusion rate, which adds to the local rate and the collision rate, this discrepancy disappears. We note that recently also an approach has been advanced which includes the ccˉc\bar{c} potential in an approximate way [13]. It would be interesting to verify whether the equilibrium is obtained without a spatial diffusion rate. In conclusion, we have found that also for an expanding system, which cools down, the Monte Carlo realization of the Remler formalism describes correctly the approach to equilibrium .

Acknowledgements

The authors acknowledge valuable discussions with P.-B. Gossiaux. We acknowledge support by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) through the grant CRC-TR 211 ’Strong-interaction matter under extreme conditions’ - Project number 315477589 - TRR 211. This work is supported by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement No 824093 (STRONG-2020). The computational resources have been provided by the LOEWE-Center for Scientific Computing and the ”Green Cube” at GSI, Darmstadt and by the Center for Scientific Computing (CSC) of the Goethe University.

References

References

  1. [1]T. Matsui and H. Satz, Phys. Lett. B 178, 416 (1986).
  2. [2]B. Alessandro et al. (NA50), Eur. Phys. J. C 39, 335 (2005), hep-ex/0412036.
  3. [3]A. Adare et al. (PHENIX), Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 232301 (2007), nucl-ex/0611020.
  4. [4]L. Manceau (ALICE), Nucl. Phys. B Proc. Suppl. 234, 321 (2013), 1208.6488.
  5. [5]L. Grandchamp and R. Rapp, Nucl. Phys. A 709, 415 (2002), hep-ph/0205305.
  6. [6]L. Yan, P. Zhuang, and N. Xu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 232301 (2006), nucl-th/0608010.
  7. [7]O. Linnyk, E. L. Bratkovskaya, and W. Cassing, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 17, 1367 (2008), 0808.1504.
  8. [8]T. Song, K. C. Han, and C. M. Ko, Phys. Rev. C 84, 034907 (2011), 1103.6197.
  9. [9]E. A. Remler and A. P. Sathe, Annals Phys. 91, 295 (1975).
  10. [10]E. A. Remler, Annals Phys. 95, 455 (1975).
  11. [11]E. A. Remler, Annals Phys. 136, 293 (1981).
  12. [12]M. Guyalssy, K. Frankel, and E. a. Remler, Nucl. Phys. A 402, 596 (1983).
  13. [13]D. Y. A. Villar, J. Aichelin, and P. B. Gossiaux (2022), 2206.01308.
  14. [14]D. Y. A. Villar, Ph.D. thesis, SUBATECH, Nantes (2021).
  15. [15]T. Song, J. Aichelin, and E. Bratkovskaya, Phys. Rev. C 96, 014907 (2017), 1705.00046.
  16. [16]D. Lafferty and A. Rothkopf, Phys. Rev. D 101, 056010 (2020), 1906.00035.
  17. [17]A. Andronic, P. Braun-Munzinger, and J. Stachel, Nucl. Phys. A 772, 167 (2006), nucl-th/0511071.
  18. [18]A. Andronic, P. Braun-Munzinger, K. Redlich, and J. Stachel, Nucl. Phys. A 789, 334 (2007), nucl-th/0611023.
  19. [19]J. Aichelin and G. Bertsch, Phys. Rev. C 31, 1730 (1985).
  20. [20]W. Cassing, Lect. Notes Phys. 989, pp. (2021).
  21. [21]H. Kruse, B. V. Jacak, J. J. Molitoris, G. D. Westfall, and H. Stoecker, Phys. Rev. C 31, 1770 (1985).
  22. [22]H. Petersen, D. Oliinychenko, M. Mayer, J. Staudenmaier, and S. Ryu, Nucl. Phys. A 982, 399 (2019), 1808.06832.
  23. [23]M. Bleicher and E. Bratkovskaya, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 122, 103920 (2022).
  24. [24]T. Song and H. Berrehrah, Phys. Rev. C 94, 034901 (2016), 1601.04449.
  25. [25]T. Song and G. Coci, Nucl. Phys. A 1028, 122539 (2022), 2104.10987.
  26. [26]S. H. Lee, K. Morita, T. Song, and C. M. Ko, Phys. Rev. D 89, 094015 (2014), 1304.4092.
  27. [27]P. Gubler, T. Song, and S. H. Lee, Phys. Rev. D 101, 114029 (2020), 2003.09073.
  28. [28]T. Song, P. Gubler, J. Hong, S. H. Lee, and K. Morita, Phys. Lett. B 813, 136065 (2021), 2009.08741.
  29. [29]N. Krenz, H. van Hees, and C. Greiner, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 1070, 012008 (2018), 1805.10798.

Paper details

vlnc:W_ejbchjn8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents