WorksPhysics and Astronomy
High-pressure synthesis of boron-rich chalcogenides B12S and B12Se
Abstract
Two boron-rich chalcogenides B12S and B12Se isostructural to α-rhombohedral boron were synthesized by chemical reaction of the elements at high-pressure - high-temperature conditions. The crystal structures and stoichiometries of both compounds were confirmed by Rietveld refinement and elemental analysis. The experimental Raman spectra of B12S and B12Se were investigated for the first time. All observed Raman bands have been attributed to the theoretically calculated phonon modes, and the mode assignment has been performed.
Introduction
Boron-rich compounds isostructural to the -rhombohedral boron (-) have become the subject of extensive theoretical 1-11 and experimental [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23] [12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17] studies due to their unusual properties and potential technical applications.[18, 24] [14] One of the most attractive features of boron-rich compounds is their outstanding mechanical properties. For instance, the reported hardness values of boron suboxide () varies from 24 to 45 GPa.[25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31] Thus, boron suboxide is believed to be the hardest known oxide. Numerous works have been devoted to the investigation of its phase stability,[32] [3] compressibility,[32, 33] [34] phonon 35-37 and thermal 34,38 properties, etc. However, other boron-rich chalcogenides, unlike boron suboxide, are still poorly studied.
Up to now, there have been only a few reports on the synthesis of boron subsulfide () 39-41 and boron subselenide ().42 In all these studies boron chalcogenides were synthesized by chemical reaction between elemental boron and sulfur/selenium in graphite or tantalum crucibles at high temperatures (1200-1600°C) in Ar atmosphere. The chalcogen content “” varies from 0.9 to 1.3 in , and from 0.9 to 1.1 in . This is not surprising taking into account relatively low boiling temperatures of elemental sulfur (718 K) and selenium (958 K). Thus, the synthesis conditions (e.g. starting reagents ratios, maximum temperature, heating time, etc.) influence significantly the final stoichiometry of the products.
The loss of elemental sulfur and selenium during the high-temperature synthesis of boron chalcogenides can be prevented by applying high pressure. For instance, the high-pressure – high-temperature (HP-HT) synthesis provided a reproducible stoichiometry of many boron-rich compounds, such as [21], 17, 43, and 44. Thus, there are strong grounds to believe that HP-HT synthesis can ensure the reproducible chemical composition of boron-rich chalcogenides as well.
In the present work, we performed HP-HT synthesis of and . The crystal structures and chemical compositions of both boron-rich chalcogenides were confirmed by Rietveld refinement of the powder X-ray diffraction data and elemental analysis. The Raman spectra of both compounds have been experimentally observed for the first time. Based on ab initio calculations, we assigned all observed Raman bands.
Experimental
Polycrystalline samples of and were synthesized at 6 GPa and 2500 K by reaction of elemental boron (Grade I ABCR) with sulfur/selenium (both Alfa Aesar, 99.5%) powders mixed in 15:1/18:1 molar ratios. The compacted mixtures of starting reagents were loaded in hBN capsules (to isolate the reaction mixture from graphite heater) and placed in the high-temperature assembly of a toroid-type high-pressure apparatus.45 After reaching the required pressure, the reaction mixtures were heated at 2500 K for 3 min, then gradually cooled down to 1500 K during 10 min and quenched. In order to remove unreacted boron, the recovered samples were treated with 3N nitric acid (ACS, Alfa Aesar) for 20 min at 370 K, washed by deionized water and dried at 400 K.
The structure of as-synthesized compounds was studied by angle-dispersive powder X-ray diffraction at Swiss-Norwegian Beamline BM01, ESRF.46 The wavelength of the monochromatic beam from a bending magnet was set to 0.6866 Å. Diffraction patterns were acquired during the 20 s in Debye-Scherrer geometry with rotating quartz-glass capillary using PILATUS 2M detector (high purity LaB was used as an internal standard). The crystal structures of both compounds were refined using Maud software47 (Figure 1).

(a)

(b)
Figure 1. Rietveld full profile refinement fits of powder X-ray diffraction patterns of (a) and (b). The insets present the unit cells of both compounds in hexagonal setting.
The chemical composition of and powders was studied by energy-dispersive X-ray analysis using scanning electron microscopes FEI Quanta 200F with X-Max EDS system (Oxford Instruments) and Hitachi SU8010 with SDD X-Max^n EDX system (Oxford Instruments).
Raman spectra were measured in the 100-1600 cm range at ambient conditions using Horiba Jobin Yvon HR800 spectrometer calibrated with single-crystal cubic Si at room temperature. In order to check for possible resonant effects and/or photoluminescence, the measurements were performed at two different excitation wavelengths: 473 nm and 633 nm. None of those phenomena have been observed for both compounds.
Computational
The lattice parameters and atomic fractional coordinates of trigonal and phases were optimized using a linear combination of atomic orbitals (LCAO) method implemented in CRYSTAL17 code.48 The starting unit cell parameters and atom coordinates were taken from the experimental data. Improved all-electron double-zeta valence basis sets augmented by one set of polarization functions (pob-DZVP-rev2)49 were chosen for boron, sulfur and selenium atoms. The accuracy of the calculation of the bielectronic Coulomb and exchange series was controlled by the set of tolerances, which were set to , , , , and . The Monkhorst-Pack scheme50 for an k-point mesh was used to integrate the Brillouin zone. Self-consistent field calculations were performed for hybrid DFT/HF WCGGA-PBE-16% functional.[51] The percentage of 16% defines the Hartree-Fock admixture in the exchange part of DFT functional. The tolerance for the total energy change was set to .
To calculate and phonon frequencies the direct (frozen-phonon) method implemented in CRYSTAL17 code[53, 54] was used. Raman intensities were calculated by using a coupled-perturbed Hartree–Fock/Kohn–Sham approach.[54, 55] The parameters of the optimized unit cell as well as atomic coordinates are collected in Table IV. Raman spectra were constructed by using the transverse optical (TO) modes and by adopting a pseudo-Voigt functional form[53] with a full width half maximum parameter set to 1.
| Atom label (Wyckoff) | Site occupancy | ||||
| BS | S1 () | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.1186 | 1.01 |
| BS | B1 () | 0.4366 | -0.4366 | 0.0479 | 1.01 |
| BS | B2 () | -0.1787 | 0.1787 | 0.1400 | 1.01 |
| BS | , Å | 5.8966 | |||
| BS | , Å | 12.1135 | |||
| BS | , Å | 364.76 | |||
| Atom label (Wyckoff) | Site occupancy | ||||
| BSe | Se1 () | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.1217 | 1.01 |
| BSe | B1 () | 0.4352 | -0.4352 | 0.0467 | 1.01 |
| BSe | B2 () | -0.1836 | 0.1836 | 0.1397 | 1.01 |
| BSe | , Å | 6.0496 | |||
| BSe | , Å | 12.1603 | |||
| BSe | , Å | 385.42 |
Table IV. The lattice parameters of the optimized unit cell and atomic coordinates of BS and BSe.
Results and Discussion
Crystal structures of B12S and B12Se
As typical --related compounds, boron subsulfide and boron subselenide have rhombohedral symmetry ( space group). The refined lattice parameters of and were found to be in good agreement with the literature data (Table I). The unit cells of both compounds contain two independent boron atoms (in Wyckoff positions) and one sulfur/selenium atom (in Wyckoff position). All atomic coordinates and bond lengths are presented in Table II. The slightly distorted -icosahedra are placed in the corners of the unit cell and on one of the unit cell main diagonals. S/Se atoms have a tetrahedral environment, including three B atoms belonging to three different boron icosahedra and one S/Se atom. According to the Rietveld refinement, the occupancies of sites by S and Se atoms were found to be 55% and 52%, respectively. Since all boron atoms constitute -icosahedra, the occupancies of sites were fixed to 1.0 by default. The results of Rietveld refinement are in good agreement with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy data: the elemental compositions of BS and BSe are 92.5(1) at% B and 7.5(1) at% S and 92.6(1) at% B and 7.4(1) at% Se, i.e. for both compounds. The final reliability factors () were converged to 2.4 for BS and 0.5 for BSe, which indicates the excellent refinement level (Figure 1).
| Compound | , Å | , Å | Occup., % | , g/cm | Reference |
| 5.8196(2) | 11.9653(5) | 55 | 2.34 | pw | |
| 5.80 | 11.90 | 2.33 | [39] | ||
| 5.810(2) | 11.94(2) | 48.5 | — | [40] | |
| 5.8624(9) | 12.147(4) | 65 | — | [40] | |
| 5.8379(6) | 12.036(1) | 59.9 | 2.36 | [41] | |
| 5.8307(5) | 12.028(2) | 60.9 | 2.37 | [41] | |
| 5.8273(3) | 12.025(2) | 62 | 2.39 | [41] | |
| 5.9385(1) | 11.9144(2) | 52 | 2.90 | pw | |
| 5.9041(4) | 11.947(1) | 2.97 | [42] |
Table I. Lattice parameters, S(Se) occupation of sites and X-ray densities of and : present work (pw) and literature data.
| Atom label (Wyckoff) | , Å | Site occupancy | ||||
| BS | S1 () | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.0934(2) | 3.1(1) | 0.55 |
| BS | B1 () | 0.4419(2) | 0.5581(2) | 0.0437(2) | 3.6(1) | 1.0f |
| BS | B2 () | 0.5004(3) | 0.4996(3) | 0.1948(2) | 3.9(1) | 1.0f |
| BS | S-S, Å | 2.230(20) | ||||
| BS | B2-S, Å | 1.790(10) | ||||
| BS | B1-B2, Å | 1.862(14) | ||||
| BS | B1-B1, Å | 1.890(30) | ||||
| BS | B2-B2, Å | 1.776(9) | ||||
| Atom label (Wyckoff) | , Å | Site occupancy | ||||
| BSe | Se1 () | 0.0000 | 0.0000 | 0.08501(1) | 1.5(1) | 0.52 |
| BSe | B1 () | 0.4360(2) | 0.5640(2) | 0.0481(3) | 2.0(1) | 1.0f |
| BSe | B2 () | 0.4955(3) | 0.5045(3) | 0.1953(3) | 1.5(0) | 1.0f |
| BSe | Se-Se, Å | 2.020(30) | ||||
| BSe | B2-Se, Å | 1.872(12) | ||||
| BSe | B1-B2, Å | 1.812(14) | ||||
| BSe | B1-B1, Å | 1.830(30) | ||||
| BSe | B2-B2, Å | 1.802(10) |
Table II. The atomic structures and bond lengths of BS and BSe.
The occupancies of sites by S/Se atoms in BS and BSe refined in our study are close to the values obtained previously 40-42 (Table I). An attempt to place a single S/Se atom in site (between two sites) as it was proposed by Matkovich 39 resulted in not satisfactory profile fit convergence of the Rietveld refinement. Moreover, a replacement of the S/Se atom by B atom in positions as it was done previously (e.g. BSeB)42 led to significant refinement deteriorations and, hence, high values. Thus, despite the partial occupancies of sites in BS/BSe unit cells, we exclude a possibility of the S/Se atoms “slide” to Wyckoff position or their partial replacement by boron atoms.
The ~50% occupancy of site in BSe can be explained by the short Se-Se distance (2.02 Å) compared with the covalent radius of selenium (1.20 Å). In other words, BSe unit cell is too small to accommodate two Se atoms. However, the same logic cannot be applied for BS: S-S interatomic distance is 2.23 Å, whereas the covalent sulfur radius is 1.05 Å. The nature of the partial occupancies of sites in BS remains unclear. As follows from Table I and Figure 2, the larger values of site occupancy in boron subsulfides expectedly lead to the expansion of the lattice parameters (particularly, along the -axis) and increase of the calculated densities. Unlike boron subsulfides, larger values of site occupancy in boron subselenide surprisingly result in the lower calculated density and shrinking of the unit cell along the -axis (Table I).
Figure 2. Comparison of BS lattice parameters versus occupation of 6c site by S atom obtained in present work (red balls) with literature data (black balls).
Raman spectroscopy study of BS and BSe
Unlike recently synthesized orthorhombic boron-rich chalcogenides, -BS and -BSe,[56] the Raman spectra of rhombohedral BS and BSe contain broad "noisy" bands in the 150-1250 cm range (Figure 3). According to the symmetry analysis, the acoustic and optic modes of boron-rich chalcogenides (42 atoms per unit cell) at Γ point can be presented as follows:
Figure 3. Experimentally observed (solid lines) and LCAO calculated (red lines) Raman bands of (a) and (b) at ambient conditions. The positions of the predicted Raman peaks are traced by red dashed lines, the corresponding phonon modes are indicated.
are IR active modes; are Raman active modes for the point group.
The theoretically predicted Raman spectra of BS and BSe (at K) are presented in Figure 3 (the positions of the theoretical Raman bands peaks are denoted by red dashed lines). The wavenumbers of the calculated Raman active phonon modes () and the experimentally observed Raman bands () are collected in Table III. As it follows from Figure 3 and Table III, the theoretical and experimental data are in good agreement (as it was also observed in our previous Raman studies [57, 58]): the average difference between experimental and theoretical data is less than 3.5% for (with a maximum value of 6.1% for 486.2 mode) and 1.5% for (with a maximum value of 6.3% for 477.9 mode).
| BS | BSe | |||||
| , cm | , cm | modes | , cm | , cm | modes | |
| 319.2 | 323.3 | A | — | 199.6 | A | |
| 355.3 | 355.2 | E | — | 231.5 | E | |
| 458.2 | 486.2 | E | 449.6 | 477.9 | E | |
| 625.0 | 677.2 | A | 645.3 | 644.6 | A | |
| 640–770 | 731.8 | E | 660–730 | 697.5 | E | |
| 640–770 | 754.1 | E | 660–730 | 711.7 | E | |
| 640–770 | 761.9 | A | 741.1 | 745.7 | A | |
| 813.2 | 824.8 | E | 812.1 | 804.3 | E | |
| 944–1170 | 1039.2 | A | 900–1135 | 1020.7 | E | |
| 944–1170 | 1047.6 | E | 900–1135 | 1024.1 | A | |
| 944–1170 | 1093.7 | A | 900–1135 | 1038.4 | A | |
| 944–1170 | 1095.1 | E | 900–1135 | 1062.8 | E |
Table III. The frequencies of the experimentally observed Raman bands at 633 nm excitation wavelength () and Raman active modes predicted by CRYSTAL17 (), respectively. The overlapped bands groups (or too large bands) observed in experimental Raman spectra are presented by the corresponding frequency regions.
Using the visualization procedure built in MOLDRAW software,[59] the theoretically predicted phonon modes were attributed to the oscillations of two main structural elements of , where : triangle composed of ‘B1’ polar boron atoms (further, unit) and atom linked with three different ‘B2’ equatorial boron atoms (further, -(B2) unit) of -icosahedra (Figure 4).
Figure 4. BX (X = S, Se) unit cell in rhombohedral setting. The polar (B1) and equatorial (B2) boron atoms of B-icosahedra are shown by green balls, S/Se atoms are shown by yellow balls.
The low-frequency and modes (323.3 and 355.2 for and 199.6 and 231.5 for ) were referred to S/Se atoms oscillations (parallel and perpendicular to the -axis) and the corresponding slight distortions in -icosahedra. As it follows from Figure 3b, and modes have not been experimentally observed for in the 150-400 range. The most probable explanation for this phenomenon may be the low intensity of the corresponding Raman bands and the low signal-to-noise ratio of the whole Raman spectrum.
The modes of (458.2 ; 731.8 ) and (449.6 ; 697.5 ) can be assigned to the tilting of units and twisting oscillations of boron atoms in -(B2) unit leading to the tilting of the whole icosahedra around different unit cell directions. Meanwhile, the modes of (754.1 ; 824.8 ; 1047.6 ; 1095.1 ) and (711.7 ; 804.3 ; 1020.7 ; 1062.8 ) correspond to symmetric and asymmetric stretching/twisting oscillations of B–B bonds and stretching/rocking oscillations of B–X bonds in and -(B2) units, respectively. It might be roughly assumed that vibrations of units lead basically to the distortions of the icosahedra and, thus, to distortions of the intra-icosahedral bonds, whereas -(B2) vibrations result in vibration of the inter-icosahedral bonds. It should also be noted that the amplitude of the -(B2) vibrations are more significant at the highest frequencies, while for the unit it is the opposite.
The modes of (625.0 ; 761.9 ) and (645.3 ; 741.1 ) correspond to the symmetric "parasol" oscillations of -(B2) units, thus, resulting in distortions of the intra-icosahedral bonds. The modes of (1039.2 ) and (1024.1 ) refer to the symmetric stretching of B–X bonds in -(B2) unit. Finally, the modes of (1093.7 ) and (1038.4 ) were assigned to the symmetric stretching of units. The two latter modes of both boron-rich chalcogenides lead to the distortions of the inter-icosahedral bonds.
Taking into account a good agreement between theoretical and experimental data the phonon modes assignment provided above for the calculated Raman spectra of both compounds is also fear-relevant for the experimental spectra. The accuracy of the present mode assignment suffers from the noise and broad Raman bands that lead to the bands overlapping. Nevertheless, these features are rather typical for the Raman spectra of other boron-rich compounds (e.g. [60] or 35). The more precise description of the phonon modes of and might be done with the help of first- and second-order Raman scattering.37
Conclusions
In the present work two new stoichiometric boron-rich chalcogenides, and , were synthesized at high pressure – high temperature conditions and studied by powder X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy at ambient pressure. According to the Rietveld refinement of synchrotron X-ray diffraction data, both and have rhombohedral symmetry and belong to the space group (No 166). The observed Raman bands were assigned to the phonon modes and associated with the corresponding atomic movements.
ORCID IDs
Vladimir L. Solozhenko https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0881-9761
Notes
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank Drs. I. Dovgaliuk and T. Chauveau for assistance with Rietveld analysis; and Drs. V. Bushlya and A. Jamali for help with EDX/SEM measurements. This work was financially supported by the European Union's Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Program under Flintstone2020 project (grant agreement No 689279).
References
- [18]Albert, B.; Hillebrecht, H. Boron: Elementary challenge for experimenters and theoreticians. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2009, 48, 8640-8668.DOI
- [19]Slack, G.A.; Morgan, K.E. Some crystallography, chemistry, physics, and thermodynamics of B₁₂O₂, B₁₂P₂, B₁₂As₂, and related alpha-boron type crystals. J. Phys. Chem. Solids 2014, 75, 1054-1074.DOI
- [20]Slack, G.A.; Morgan, K.E. Crystallography, semiconductivity, thermoelectricity, and other properties of boron and its compounds, especially B₆O. Solid State Sci. 2015, 47, 43-50.DOI
- [21]Solozhenko, V.L.; Kurakevich, O.O.; Turkevich, V.Z.; Turkevich, D.V. Synthesis of B₆O boron suboxide at pressures up to 1 GPa. J. Superhard Mater. 2005, 27, 12-16.
- [22]Cherednichenko, K.A.; Gigli, L.; Solozhenko, V.L. Thermal expansion of boron subnitrides. Solid State Comm. 2018, 275, 21-24.DOI
- [23]Cherednichenko, K.A.; Solozhenko, V.L. Thermal expansion of α-boron and some boron-rich pnictides. Solid State Comm. 2019, 303-304, 113735.DOI
- [24]Orlovskaya, N.; Lugovy, M. Proc. of the NATO advanced research workshop on boron rich solids, Springer 2009.
- [25]McMillan, P.F. New materials from high-pressure experiments. Nature Mater. 2002, 1, 19-25.
- [26]Solodkyi, I.; Xie, S.S.; Zhao, T.; Borodianska, H.; Sakka, Y.; Vasylkiv, O. Synthesis of B₆O powder and spark plasma sintering of B₆O and B₆O-B₄C ceramics. J. Ceram. Soc. Jpn. 2013, 121, 950-955.DOI
- [27]Badzian, A.R. Superhard material comparable in hardness to diamond. Appl. Phys. Lett. 1988, 53, 2495-2497.DOI
- [28]Mukhanov, V.A.; Kurakevych, O.O.; Solozhenko, V.L. Hardness of materials at high temperature and high pressure. Philos. Mag. 2009, 89, 2117-2127.DOI
- [29]Rizzo, H.F.; Simmons, W.C.; Bielstein, H.O. The existence and formation of the solid B₆O. J. Electrochem. Soc. 1962, 109, 1079-1082.
- [30]R. Sasai, R.; Fukatsu, H.; Kojima, T.; Itoh, H. High pressure consolidation of B₆O-diamond mixtures. J. Mater. Sci. 2001, 36, 5339-5343.DOI
- [31]He, D.; Zhao, Y.; L. Daemen, L.; Qian, J.; Shen, T.D. Zerda, T.W. Boron Suboxide: As Hard as Cubic Boron Nitride. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2002, 81, 643-645.DOI
- [32]Nieto-Sanz, D.; Loubeyre, P.; Crichton, W.; Mezouar, M. X-ray study of the synthesis of boron oxides at high pressure: Phase diagram and equation of state. Phys. Rev. B 2004, 70, 214108.DOI
- [33]He, D.; Shieh, S.R.; Duffy, T.S. Strength and equation of state of boron suboxide from radial X-ray diffraction in a diamond cell under nonhydrostatic compression. Phys. Rev. B 2004, 70, 184121.DOI
- [51]Wu, Z.; Cohen, R.E. More accurate generalized gradient approximation for solids. Phys. Rev. B 2006, 73, 235116.DOI
- [53]Dovesi, R.; Saunders, V.R.; Roetti, C.; Orlando, R.; Zicovich-Wilson, C.M.; Pascale, F.; Civalleri, B.; Doll, K.; Harrison, N.M.; Bush, I.J.; D’Arco, P.; Llunell, M.; Causà, M.; Noël, Y.; Maschio, L.; Erba, A.; Rerat, M.; Casassa, S. CRYSTAL17 User's Manual (University of Torino, Torino, 2017).
- [54]Pascale, F.; Zicovich-Wilson, C.M.; Lopez, F.; Civalleri, B.; Orlando, R.; Dovesi, R. The calculation of the vibrational frequencies of crystalline compounds and its implementation in the CRYSTAL code. J. Comput. Chem. 2004, 25, 888-897.
- [55]Zicovich-Wilson, C.M.; Pascale, F.; Roetti, C.; Saunders, V.R.; Orlando, R.; Dovesi, R. The calculation of the vibration frequencies of alpha-quartz: the effect of hamiltonian and basis set. J. Comput. Chem. 2004, 25, 1873-1881.
- [56]Cherednichenko K.A.; Mukhanov V.A.; Wang, Z.; Oganov, A.R.; Kalinko, A.; Dovgaliuk, I.; Solozhenko, V.L. Discovery of new boron-rich chalcogenides: orthorhombic B₆X (X = S, Se). Sci. Rep. 2020, 10, 9277.DOI
- [57]Cherednichenko, K.A.; Sokolov, P.S.; Kalinko, A.; Le Godec, Y.; Polian, A.; Itié, J.P.; Solozhenko, V.L. Optical phonon modes in rhombohedral boron monosulfide under high pressure. J. Appl. Phys. 2015, 117, 185904.
- [58]Cherednichenko, K.A.; Le Godec; Y., Kalinko; A., Mezouar, M.; Solozhenko, V.L. Orthorhombic boron oxide under pressure: In situ study by X-ray diffraction and Raman scattering. J. Appl. Phys. 2016, 120, 175901.
- [59]Ugliengo, P.; Viterbo, D.; Chiari, G. MOLDRAW: Molecular Graphics on a Personal Computer. Z. Kristallogr. 1993, 207, 9-23.
- [60]Shelnutt, J.A.; Morosin, B.; Emin, D.; Mullendore, A.; Slack, G.; Wood, C. Raman spectroscopy of boron carbides and related boron containing materials. AIP Conf. Proc. 1986, 140, 312-324.