WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Convergent trajectories of relativistic electrons interacting with lasers in plasma waves
Abstract
The dynamics of relativistic electrons interacting with a laser pulse in a plasma wave has been investigated theoretically and numerically based on the classical Landau-Lifshitz equation. There exists a convergent trajectory of electrons when the energy gain of electrons via direct laser acceleration can compensate the energy loss via radiation. An electron beam initially around the convergent trajectory evolves into the trajectory, making its occupied phase space volume decrease exponentially while mean energy remain the same. This mechanism can be used for cooling relativistic electron beams especially those produced in plasma-based acceleration.
Plasma-based electron acceleration has made significant progress in the last decades. Plasma waves with both longitudinal accelerating fields and transverse focusing fields for electrons can be produced as wakes of either laser pulses or charged particle beams [1–4]. Tens of GeV energy enhancement of electrons has been achieved via electron beam driven acceleration [5]. Electron beams with energy up to the order of 10 GeV have been produced via laser driven approaches [7] [6]. Besides of achieving high energy electron acceleration, many efforts are devoted to improving the beam quality, which is important for applications ranging from X-ray free electron lasers [8, 9], and QED physics [10, 11], to electron-positron and photon colliders [12]. Electron beams with energy hundreds of MeV and relative energy spread down to per-mille level, which is compatible to that in the state-of-the-art conventional accelerators, have been produced in several experiments [13, 14, 15, 16]. Nevertheless, achieving such beam quality for electron beams with energy well beyond GeV in plasma-based acceleration remains a challenge.
Cooling via radiation damping is an effective method for improving the quality of electron beams, as has been adopted in conventional damping rings, see, e.g., [17]. In a typical damping ring, electrons radiate energy in the field of the bending magnets and meanwhile regain energy via radio-frequency acceleration, allowing an electron beam to maintain its mean energy while reducing its emittance. This works due to the damping feature of radiation reaction. Radiation damping occurs naturally in plasma-based electron acceleration since electrons inevitably experience betatron oscillation under the transverse focusing fields [18, 19]. The effects of radiation damping on the electron dynamics, acceleration, and especially the electron beam quality have attracted much attention [20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27].
The transverse oscillation of electrons in plasma waves can be modulated and enhanced by applying an interacting laser, known as direct laser acceleration (DLA) [28, 29]. This sets a configuration where electrons gain energy and radiate energy simultaneously, similar to that in a damping ring. In this work, we show that, when the interacting laser is strong enough so that the energy gain of electrons via DLA can compensate the energy loss via radiation, there exists a convergent trajectory around which an electron beam evolves into the trajectory with its occupied phase space volume decreasing exponentially and mean energy remaining the same. This can be exploited for cooling relativistic electron beams, especially those generated via plasma-based acceleration.
A schematic plot of the configuration is shown in Figure 1 (a). An electron beam is confined in the cavity of a fast-moving plasma wave and interacts with an ultra-short laser pulse which comoves with the plasma wave. For simplicity, we assume that the phase velocity of the plasma wave is a constant, and the group velocity of the interacting laser equals to , which is achievable by adjusting the interacting laser, the plasma, and the driving source of the plasma wave. We first consider a case that the interacting laser pulse is right-hand circularly polarized (RHCP). We use a cylindrical coordinate system , where is the plasma wave propagating direction. We focus on the interaction near the laser axis where we can use a plane wave approximation for the laser electric and magnetic fields, , and , where is the laser group velocity, the phase difference between the laser field and the transverse oscillation of the electron (Figure 1(b)), and the laser wavenumber and frequency, respectively. The self-generated electric and magnetic fields in the plasma wave can be expressed as and , which can be written as functions of a rescaled coordinate .
Figure 1. Schematic plot. (a) A relativistic electron beam (blue disk) interacting with a circularly polarized laser pulse (yellow region) in a plasma wave cavity which can be driven by either a laser pulse or a charged particle beam (not plotted). When the energy gain of electrons via direct laser acceleration can compensate the energy loss via radiation, there exists a convergent trajectory around where the cooling of the electron beam occurs. Instantaneous forces on electrons at the convergent trajectory, which is a helical curve with both and fixed, in (b) (–) and (c) (–) projections, where denotes the phase difference between the laser electric field and the transverse oscillation, and the included angle between the movement direction and -direction.
Since the laser pulse copropagates with the electron beam, the interaction between them is usually weak so that one can write the equation of motion of electrons in the classical Landau-Lifshitz approach,
where, in relativistic limit , by taking the leading term, the radiation reaction force becomes
here is the classical electron radius, and are the Lorentz forces perpendicular to and along with the direction of the electron velocity , respectively, is the external Lorentz force with the electric field and the magnetic field , denotes the electron Lorentz factor, the vacuum permittivity, the light speed in vacuum, and the electron mass and charge, respectively.
By introducing the dimensionless variables, , , , , , , , , and , Eq. (1) can be rewritten as
where , and is the force of the plasma wave fields in the radial direction. We look for stable fixed points of the equations at where the derivations of the variables, i.e., the left hand sides of the equations, are all equal to zero. We mark the value of a variable at the stable fixed point by putting a bar over it. Letting the right hand sides of Eqs. (6),(7),(8) be zero, we have
By making use of Eq. (11) and , one gets
where . Furthermore, according to and Eqs. (9)-(12), in the limit of , one has
By making use of Eq. (10) and letting the right hand sides of Eqs. (3) and (4) be zero, one gets
By combining them and making use of Eqs. (9),(12),(13), one obtains
This indicates that the electron beam tends to be accumulated to the center of the plasma wave cavity in the longitudinal direction where the longitudinal wakefield vanishes and therefore the assumption can be satisfied and maintained locally even after long propagation [30, 31]. Then one has and thus . Furthermore, according to Eqs. (5) and (10), one gets
By combining Eqs. (15) and (17), and introducing and , we have the equation of ,
We focus on the condition of , under which there are two solutions, , , where gives a restriction condition for having real solutions,
This corresponds to the condition that the laser field is strong enough so that the energy gain of electrons from the laser can compensate the energy loss via radiation. It is challenging to investigate the stability of the solutions analytically. Numerically, we have found that is stable and is unstable. The former solution corresponds to a physical configuration where the laser force along the radial direction pulls the electron inward, while for the latter one the laser force pushes the electron outward. This coincides with the results obtained from the simplified models in Refs. [32, 33, 34]. Therefore, we have
It is shown that the convergent trajectory corresponds to a helical curve in real space with a fixed radius and a constant phase difference with respect to the laser field. In this RHCP case, the balance between the energy gain and the radiation loss is achieved all the time for electrons at the convergent trajectory. Actually, Eqs. (14), (15) and (17) correspond to the balance of the instantaneous forces in the direction of , , in -direction, , and in -direction, , respectively, as is shown in Figure 1 (b) and (Figure 1c), where denotes the included angle between and -direction. Furthermore, in the frame comoving with the plasma wave, the convergent trajectory becomes a closed circle. Therefore, the configuration presented here can be seen as a moving micro damping ring with radius and moving speed .
In order to see more details of the cooling process, the Landau-Lifshitz equation has been solved numerically. The interacting laser is assumed to be a RHCP plane wave laser with laser amplitude and wavelength , corresponds to . One can increase the cooling efficiency by increasing the electric field of the interacting laser although more complexity may arise. For the plasma wave, we assume so that the phase velocity of the plasma wave is . Without loss of generality, the plasma wave fields near the longitudinal center of the plasma wave cavity ( where ) are approximated as , , and , with . Then, one obtains , , , and . It is noticed that the quantum radiation effect [35, 36, 37, 38, 39] is neglectable since , where is the Schwinger limit of electric field. Totally randomly selected test electrons have been calculated in a Cartesian coordinate system with the variables initially normally distributed around a point at the convergent trajectory (, , , ) with standard deviations , , , and , where , , , , and [40]. Figure 2 (a-Figure 2c) shows the initial distributions of the electrons in the phase spaces , , and , re-centered to the corresponding values at the convergent trajectory except for , respectively, where and . The corresponding distributions after 20 ns are shown in Figure 2 (e-Figure 2g) in which the electrons are much more close to the convergent trajectory, resulting in a significant reduction of the occupied phase space area of the electron beam. The distributions of the electrons in the space spanned by , re-centered to , at and ns are shown in Figure 2 (d) and (h), respectively, confirming that the theoretical result of the convergent trajectory works well.
Figure 2. Distributions of electrons in phase space (a,e) , (b,f) , (c,g) , and (d,h) the space spanned by , re-centered to the values at the convergent trajectory (with bars over them) except for , at (a-d) and (e-h) ns, obtained by numerically solving the Landau-Lifshitz equation for electrons initially near the convergent trajectory (see text for more detail). Notice the different scales for the left and right panels.
In order to have a comprehensive understanding, the evolution of the occupied phase space area in different directions is shown in Figure 3. Since the distribution of the electrons in each phase space is always elliptical-like, the occupied phase space area is calculated as the determinant of the covariance matrix of the phase space coordinates, , where corresponds to the phase space , , and , respectively. It is seen that drops almost monotonically (Figure 3 (a)), indicating that the electrons are well confined in the radial direction.
Figure 3. Evolutions of the occupied area in the phase space in different directions (black solid curves), (a) for phase space , (b) for , and (c) for , normalized by the corresponding initial values, obtained from the numerical calculation in Figure 2. The red dashed lines represent exponential decay (a) , (b) (c) with fitted parameters ns, ns, and .
The long term evolution can be well fitted by an exponential decay , where the lifetime is ns. On the other hand, electrons spread out quickly in direction at the beginning (in 0.1 ns) [41], resulting in a sudden increase in by a few hundredfold. This suggests that the phase space structure near the convergent trajectory may be complex. A more dedicated research is required. Nevertheless, afterwards, the electron beam in the phase space shrinks in both and directions. Although strong fluctuations exist at the early stage ( ns), the overall evolution of can still be approximated as an exponential decay, , as is seen in Figure 3 (b), where characterizes the spread rate at the beginning, and the lifetime is fitted as ns, indicating a higher decay rate than that in the radial direction. In direction, the situation is similar to that in direction and one has the fitting with the same lifetime ns, except that the spread rate at the beginning is one order of magnitude lower (Figure 3 (c)).
Although the discussion above is for RHCP lasers, it is clear that for left-hand circularly polarized lasers the result is exactly the same except that the direction of rotation of the helical trajectory is opposite. For linearly polarized lasers, convergent trajectories still exist as long as the energy gain via DLA and the energy loss via radiation cancel each other out in betatron cycles. For instance, by using a LP laser with the same laser intensity and the same setup used in Figure 2, we have observed similar efficient cooling process of the electron beam, although the mean energy keeps oscillating around even after 30 ns.
In summary, there exists a convergent trajectory for relativistic electrons interacting with a laser pulse in a plasma wave as long as the laser field is strong enough so that the energy gain of the electrons via DLA can compensate the energy loss via radiation. For an electron beam initially near the convergent trajectory, its occupied phase space volume reduces exponentially over time while the mean energy is maintained, resulting in high efficient cooling of the electron beam. This plasma-based cooling configuration is featured by high efficiency and relatively small size, making it especially suitable for improving the quality of electron beams from plasma-based accelerators, which is important for various applications including X-ray free electron lasers [8, 9], QED physics [10, 11], and colliders [12].
Bin Liu acknowledges the support of Guangdong High Level Innovation Research Institute Project, Grant No. 2021B0909050006. Bifeng Lei acknowledges the support of the Science and Technology on Plasma Physics Laboratory, Grant No. 6142A04210110. Xueqing Yan was supported by the NSFC (Grants No. 11921006), Beijing Outstanding Young Scientists Program, the National Grand Instrument Project (No.2019YFF01014400).
References
References
- [7]Constantin Aniculaesei, Thanh Ha, Samuel Yoffe, Lance Labun, Stephen Milton, Edward McCary, Michael M. Spinks, Hernan J. Quevedo, Ou Z. Labun, Ritwik Sain, Andrea Hannasch, Rafal Zgadzaj, Isabella Pagano, Jose A. Franco-Altamirano, Martin L. Ringuette, Erhart Gaul, Scott V. Luedtke, Ganesh Tiwari, Bernhard Ersfeld, Enrico Brunetti, Hartmut Ruhl, Todd Ditmire, Sandra Bruce, Michael E. Donovan, Michael C. Downer, Dino A. Jaroszynski, and Bjorn Manuel Hegelich, “The acceleration of a high-charge electron bunch to 10 GeV in a 10-cm nanoparticle-assisted wakefield ac- celerator,” Matter and Radiation at Extremes 9, 014001 (2023), https://pubs.aip.org/aip/mre/article-pdf/doi/10.1063/5.0161687/18286148/014001_1.5.0161687.pdf.
- [8]C B Schroeder, W M Fawley, E Esarey, and W P Leemans, “DESIGN OF AN XUV FEL DRIVEN BY THE LASER-PLASMA ACCELERATOR AT THE LBNL LOASIS FACILITY,” Proceedings of FEL 2006 (Berlin, Germany, 2006) , 455–458 (2006).
- [9]F Grüner, S Becker, U Schramm, T Eichner, M Fuchs, R Weingartner, D Habs, J Meyer-ter Vehn, M Geissler, M Ferrario, L Serafini, B van der Geer, H Backe, W Lauth, and S Reiche, “Design considerations for table-top, laser-based VUV and X-ray free electron lasers,” Applied Physics B 86, 431–435 (2007).
- [10]K Poder, M Tamburini, G Sarri, A Di Piazza, S Kuschel, C D Baird, K Behm, S Bohlen, J M Cole, D J Corvan, M Duff, E Gerstmayr, C H Keitel, K Krushelnick, S P D Mangles, P McKenna, C D Murphy, Z Najmudin, C P Ridgers, G M Samarin, D R Symes, A G R Thomas, J Warwick, and M Zepf, “Experimental Signatures of the Quantum Nature of Radiation Reaction in the Field of an Ultraintense Laser,” Physical Review X 8, 031004 (2018).DOI
- [11]J. M. Cole, K. T. Behm, E. Gerstmayr, T. G. Blackburn, J. C. Wood, C. D. Baird, M. J. Duff, C. Harvey, A. Ilderton, A. S. Joglekar, K. Krushelnick, S. Kuschel, M. Marklund, P. McKenna, C. D. Murphy, K. Poder, C. P. Ridgers, G. M. Samarin, G. Sarri, D. R. Symes, A. G. R. Thomas, J. Warwick, M. Zepf, Z. Najmudin, and S. P. D. Mangles, “Experimental evidence of radiation reaction in the collision of a high-intensity laser pulse with a laser-wakefield accelerated electron beam,” Phys. Rev. X 8, 011020 (2018).DOI
- [12]C. B. Schroeder, E. Esarey, C. G. R. Geddes, C. Benedetti, and W. P. Leemans, “Physics considerations for laser-plasma linear colliders,” Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 13, 101301 (2010).DOI
- [13]L. T. Ke, K. Feng, W. T. Wang, Z. Y. Qin, C. H. Yu, Y. Wu, Y. Chen, R. Qi, Z. J. Zhang, Y. Xu, X. J. Yang, Y. X. Leng, J. S. Liu, R. X. Li, and Z. Z. Xu, “Near-gev electron beams at a few per-mille level from a laser wakefield accelerator via density-tailored plasma,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 214801 (2021).DOI
- [14]Wentao Wang, Ke Feng, Lintong Ke, Changhai Yu, Yi Xu, Rong Qi, Yu Chen, Zhiyong Qin, Zhijun Zhang, Ming Fang, Jiaqi Liu, Kangnan Jiang, Hao Wang, Cheng Wang, Xiaojun Yang, Fenxiang Wu, Yuxin Leng, Jiansheng Liu, Ruxin Li, and Zhizhan Xu, “Free-electron lasing at 27 nanometres based on a laser wakefield accelerator,” Nature 595, 516–520 (2021).DOI
- [15]R Pompili, D Alesini, M P Anania, S Arjmand, M Behtouei, M Bellaveglia, A Biagioni, B Buonomo, F Cardelli, M Carpanese, E Chiadroni, A Cianchi, G Costa, A Del Dotto, M Del Giorno, F Dipace, A Doria, F Filippi, M Galletti, L Giannessi, A Giribono, P Iovine, V Lollo, A Mostacci, F Nguyen, M Opromolla, E Di Palma, L Pellegrino, A Petralia, V Petrillo, L Piersanti, G Di Pirro, S Romeo, A R Rossi, J Scifo, A Selce, V Shpakov, A Stella, C Vaccarezza, F Villa, A Zigler, and M Ferrario, “Free-electron lasing with compact beam-driven plasma wakefield accelerator,” Nature 605, 659–662 (2022).DOI
- [16]M. Galletti, D. Alesini, M. P. Anania, S. Arjmand, M. Behtouei, M. Bellaveglia, A. Biagioni, B. Buonomo, F. Cardelli, M. Carpanese, E. Chiadroni, A. Cianchi, G. Costa, A. Del Dotto, M. Del Giorno, F. Dipace, A. Doria, F. Filippi, G. Franzini, L. Giannessi, A. Giribono, P. Iovine, V. Lollo, A. Mostacci, F. Nguyen, M. Opromolla, L. Pellegrino, A. Petralia, V. Petrillo, L. Piersanti, G. Di Pirro, R. Pompili, S. Romeo, A. R. Rossi, A. Selce, V. Shpakov, A. Stella, C. Vaccarezza, F. Villa, A. Zigler, and M. Ferrario, “Stable operation of a free-electron laser driven by a plasma accelerator,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 234801 (2022).DOI
- [17]Paul Emma and Tor Raubenheimer, “Systematic approach to damping ring design,” Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 4, 021001 (2001).DOI
- [18]E. Esarey, B. A. Shadwick, P. Catravas, and W. P. Leemans, “Synchrotron radiation from electron beams in plasma-focusing channels,” Phys. Rev. E 65, 056505 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12059723
- [19]S. Corde, K. Ta Phuoc, G. Lambert, R. Fitour, V. Malka, A. Rousse, A. Beck, and E. Lefebvre, “Femtosecond x rays from laser-plasma accelerators,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 85, 1–48 (2013).DOI
- [20]W.A. Barletta, E.P. Lee, R. Bonifacio, and L. De Salvo, “Limitations on plasma acceleration due to synchrotron losses,” Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 423, 256–259 (1999).DOI
- [21]P. Michel, C. B. Schroeder, B. A. Shadwick, E. Esarey, and W. P. Leemans, “Radiative damping and electron beam dynamics in plasma-based accelerators,” Phys. Rev. E 74, 026501 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17025550
- [22]I. Yu. Kostyukov, E. N. Nerush, and A. G. Litvak, “Radiative damping in plasma-based accelerators,” Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 15, 111001 (2012).DOI
- [23]V. Shpakov, E. Chiadroni, A. Curcio, H. Fares, M. Ferrario, A. Marocchino, F. Mira, V. Petrillo, A.R. Rossi, and S. Romeo, “Plasma acceleration limitations due to betatron radiation,” Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 909, 463–466 (2018).DOI
- [24]Angel Ferran Pousa, Alberto Martinez de la Ossa, and Ralph W. Assmann, “Intrinsic energy spread and bunch length growth in plasma-based accelerators due to betatron motion,” Scientific Reports 9 (2019), 10.1038/s41598-019-53887-8.DOI
- [25]Ming Zeng and Keita Seto, “Radiation reaction of betatron oscillation in plasma wakefield accelerators,” New Journal of Physics 23, 075008 (2021).DOI
- [26]A A Golovanov, E N Nerush, and I Yu Kostyukov, “Radiation reaction-dominated regime of wakefield acceleration,” New Journal of Physics 24, 033011 (2022).DOI
- [27]Aihua Deng, Kazuhisa Nakajima, Jiansheng Liu, Baifei Shen, Xiaomei Zhang, Yahong Yu, Wentao Li, Ruxin Li, and Zhizhan Xu, “Electron beam dynamics and self-cooling up to pev level due to betatron radiation in plasma-based accelerators,” Physical Review Special Topics - Accelerators and Beams 15, 081303 (2012).DOI
- [28]A Pukhov, Z M Sheng, and J Meyer-ter Vehn, “Particle acceleration in relativistic laser channels,” Physics of Plasmas 6, 2847 – 2854 (1999).DOI
- [29]Silvia Cipiccia, Mohammad R. Islam, Bernhard Ersfeld, Richard P. Shanks, Enrico Brunetti, Gregory Vieux, Xue Yang, Riju C. Issac, Samuel M. Wiggins, Gregor H. Welsh, Maria-Pia Anania, Dzmitry Maneuski, Rachel Montgomery, Gary Smith, Matthias Hoek, David J. Hamilton, Nuno R. C. Lemos, Dan Symes, Pattathil P. Rajeev, Val O. Shea, Joao M. Dias, and Dino A. Jaroszynski, “Gamma-rays from harmonically resonant betatron oscillations in a plasma wake,” Nat Phys 7, 867–871 (2011).DOI
- [30]S. C. Wilks, J. M. Dawson, W. B. Mori, T. Katsouleas, and M. E. Jones, “Photon accelerator,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 62, 2600–2603 (1989).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10040033
- [31]E Esarey, C B Schroeder, and W P Leemans, “Physics of laser-driven plasma-based electron accelerators,” Reviews of Modern Physics 81, 1229 – 1285 (2009).DOI
- [32]B Liu, R H Hu, H Y Wang, D Wu, J Liu, C E Chen, J Meyer-ter Vehn, X Q Yan, and X T He, “Quasimoonoenergetic electron beam and brilliant gamma-ray radiation generated from near critical density plasma due to relativistic resonant phase locking,” Physics of Plasmas 22, 080704 (2015-08).DOI
- [33]Ronghao Hu, Bin Liu, Haiyang Lu, Meilin Zhou, Chen Lin, Zhengming Sheng, Chia-erh Chen, Xiantu He, and Xueqing Yan, “Dense Helical Electron Bunch Generation in Near-Critical Density Plasmas with Ultrarelativistic Laser Intensities.” Scientific reports 5, 15499 (2015).DOI
- [34]Z Gong, R H Hu, H Y Lu, J Q Yu, D H Wang, E G Fu, C E Chen, X T He, and X Q Yan, “Brilliant gev gamma-ray flash from inverse compton scattering in the qed regime,” Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion 60, 044004 (2018).DOI
- [35]A Di Piazza, K Z Hatsagortsyan, and C H Keitel, “Quantum Radiation Reaction Effects in Multiphoton Compton Scattering,” Physical Review Letters 105, 220403 – 4 (2010).DOI
- [36]A. Di Piazza, C. Müller, K. Z. Hatsagortsyan, and C. H. Keitel, “Extremely high-intensity laser interactions with fundamental quantum systems,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 84, 1177–1228 (2012).DOI
- [37]N Neitz and A Di Piazza, “Stochasticity Effects in Quantum Radiation Reaction,” Physical Review Letters 111, 054802 (2013-08).DOI
- [38]Marija Vranic, Thomas Grismayer, Ricardo A Fonseca, and Luís O Silva, “Quantum radiation reaction in head-on laser-electron beam interaction,” New Journal of Physics 18, 073035 – 14 (2016).DOI
- [39]C N Harvey, A Gonoskov, A Ilderton, and M Marklund, “Quantum Quenching of Radiation Losses in Short Laser Pulses,” Physical Review Letters 118, 105004 (2017).DOI
- [40]For an electron beam with much larger phase space volume, the electrons initially near the stable fixed point with ψ ∼ ψ₁ can be cooled to the convergent trajectory, similar to that in Fig. 2, while others initially near the unstable fixed point with ψ ∼ ψ₂ may spread out and lose energy quickly, as is demonstrated in the Supplemental Material at [URL will be inserted by publisher].
- [41]See Supplemental Material at [URL will be inserted by publisher] for more details.