betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

On the spectra of strong turbulence on water surfaces

Abstract

Here, I give a brief history of the theory, with twists and turns, and list possible predictions for the spectra of the direct cascade of gravity waves on the water. The description of long waves is straightforward within the weak-turbulence theory developed by Zakharov and his school. As the energy cascade proceeds to shorter scales, the mean surface steepness grows, and wave-breaking events appear with increasing frequency. Considering surface cusps, Phillips suggested a wavenumber spectrum (with a wrong magnitude, as I argue here) and a frequency spectrum whose whole form is incorrect. The right form for the frequency spectral slope due to breaking waves was suggested by Kuznetsov. Here we estimate the magnitude and argue that the frequency spectrum is expected to continue unchanged through the whole cascade. The transition from weak to strong turbulence in the wavenumber and spatio-temporal spectra is due to spectrally nonlocal interactions and happens earlier (at larger scales) than the dimensional estimate suggests. As a result, the magnitude of the strong-turbulence spectrum is not universal but depends on the pumping for a sufficiently long weak-turbulence cascade. The reason for nonlocality is likely that breaking of shorter waves is determined by the magnitude of the longest wave on whose crest they are running.

Universal spectra hypothesis

The subject of this note are the spectra of the squared surface elevation:

⟨η2⟩=∫d2k⟨∣ηk∣2⟩=∫Φ(k,ω)k dk dω=∫dω Ψ(ω).\langle\eta^2\rangle=\int d^2k\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle=\int\Phi(k,\omega)k\,dk\,d\omega=\int d\omega\,\Psi(\omega).

We are interested in the asymptotic at large k,ωk,\omega where we expect some degree of universality and scale invariance, so we look for power-law spectra, ⟨∣ηk∣2⟩∝k−x\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle\propto k^{-x} and Ψ(ω)∝ω−y\Psi(\omega)\propto\omega^{-y}. In such a limit, it is also tempting to assume spatio-temporal self-similarity: Φ(k,ω)=Ψ(ω)ω−2af(ωa/k)=⟨∣ηk∣2⟩k−1/ag(ωa/k)\Phi(k,\omega)=\Psi(\omega)\omega^{-2a}f(\omega^a/k)=\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle k^{-1/a}g(\omega^a/k) with

ω∝k1/a,a=y−1x−2.(1)\omega\propto k^{1/a},\qquad a=\frac{y-1}{x-2}. \tag*{(1)}

The first attempt to predict the spectra was straightforward and elegant: In 1958, Phillips suggested that ultimate short-wave asymptotic is universal, that is determined solely by the gravity gg. Simple count of dimensionalities gives up to a numerical factor

⟨∣ηk∣2⟩≃k−4,(2)\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle\simeq k^{-4}, \tag*{(2)}
Ψ(ω)≃g2ω−5.(3)\Psi(\omega)\simeq g^2\omega^{-5}. \tag*{(3)}

The first formula seems physically transparent, as it corresponds to the Fourier transform of a wave cusp with an order-unity angle, giving ηk∝1/k2\eta_k\propto1/k^2. The wavenumber spectrum (2) is so appealing since it is the first example of a critical-balance hypothesis: the mean squared surface slope (naive dimensionless nonlinearity parameter), ϵk=k4⟨∣ηk∣2⟩\epsilon_k=k^4\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle, is scale-independent and of order unity. On the contrary, the frequency spectrum (3) had no physical picture behind it, but according to (1) gives a=2a=2, which corresponds to the dispersion relation ω=gk\omega=\sqrt{gk} valid for small-slope waves. Here we see the first contradiction, as the wavenumber spectrum assumes, on the contrary, order-unity slopes.

Weak turbulence

The first consistent derivation of the spectra was made by Zakharov who developed the weak-turbulence theory for small-slope waves [3, 4], where both the wavenumber and the frequency spectra can be obtained as exact solutions of the wave kinetic equation [5]:

∂nk∂t=∫dp2dp3dp4 λk2342nkn2n3n4(1nk+1n2−1n3−1n4)×δ(k+p2−p3−p4)δ(ωk+ωp2−ωp3−ωp4).(4)\frac{\partial n_k}{\partial t}=\int d\mathbf{p}_2d\mathbf{p}_3d\mathbf{p}_4\,\lambda_{k234}^2 n_kn_2n_3n_4\left(\frac{1}{n_k}+\frac{1}{n_2}-\frac{1}{n_3}-\frac{1}{n_4}\right)\times\delta(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{p}_2-\mathbf{p}_3-\mathbf{p}_4)\delta(\omega_k+\omega_{p_2}-\omega_{p_3}-\omega_{p_4}). \tag*{(4)}

Here we defined nk=ck⟨∣ηk∣2⟩n_k=c_k\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle, where ck=g/kc_k=\sqrt{g/k} is the phase velocity. For surface water waves, the interaction coefficient λk234\lambda_{k234} has dimensionality cm−3\mathrm{cm}^{-3} that is proportional to the third power of the wavenumber (and does not depend on gg); the full expression can be found in the Appendix. By a simple power counting, we see that the wavenumber spectrum carrying constant energy flux P∼λ2n3k6P\sim\lambda^2n^3k^6 must be nk≃P1/3k−4n_k\simeq P^{1/3}k^{-4}. Zakharov and Filonenko substituted this into (4) and showed that all integrals there converge, and the right hand side turns indeed into zero [6]. Since for weak turbulence Φ(k,ω)∝δ(ω−gk)\Phi(k,\omega)\propto\delta(\omega-\sqrt{gk}), then

⟨∣ηk∣2⟩≃ug−1/2k−7/2,(5)\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle\simeq ug^{-1/2}k^{-7/2}, \tag*{(5)}
Ψ(ω)≃ugω−4.(6)\Psi(\omega)\simeq ug\omega^{-4}. \tag*{(6)}

Here we followed tradition and introduced u≡P1/3u\equiv P^{1/3}. Since PP is the energy dissipation rate per unit mass per unit area, then uu has the dimensionality of velocity (related to the speed of wind or wavemaker) and makes the subsequent formulas particularly transparent. Note that the convergence of the integrals in (4) made (5,6) local, that is independent of the pumping scale (yet they remain dependent on the pumping rate). The weak turbulence theory was expected to be valid for waves whose mean squared slope is less than unity or (equivalently) whose fluid acceleration kvk2≃k(ηkkωk)2kv_k^2\simeq k(\eta_kk\omega_k)^2 is less than gg for any kk-wave. We estimate from (5):

ϵk=kvk2g≃uck=kkn,kn=gu2.(7)\epsilon_k=\frac{kv_k^2}{g}\simeq\frac{u}{c_k}=\sqrt{\frac{k}{k_n}},\qquad k_n=\frac{g}{u^2}. \tag*{(7)}

We see that ϵk<1\epsilon_k < 1 when k<knk < k_n. The wavenumber knk_n is when breaking of a single kk-wave is expected.

The weak-turbulence spectrum (5) matches the universal cusp spectrum (2) at knk_n. Similarly, the spectrum (6) would go into (3) at ωn=gkn=g/u\omega_n = \sqrt{gk_n} = g/u. It is thus tempting to conclude that we have (5,6) to the left and (2,3) to the right of knk_n, ωn\omega_n. This is incorrect. The reason is the spectral nonlocality of the frequency spectrum and of multi-wave interactions.

Sweeping and ω\omega-spectrum. First nonlocality is related to the frequency spectrum. The spectrum (3) is self-contradictory, as stated above. Experiments and observations consistently show Ψ(ω)∝ω−4\Psi(\omega) \propto\omega^{-4} (see e.g. [20]). Phillips in 1985 accepted the spectra (5,6) (without ever mentioning Zakharov) and suggested that (2,3) should be “interred with dignity” [2]. I would not do that for (2), since the cusps on a stormy sea can be seen by a naked eye. However, the data showed ω−4\omega^{-4} even when wave breakings were abundant. The simple observation which resolved this controversy was made by Kuznetsov in 2004, who noticed that cusps passing through any point produce jumps in time derivative of the elevation which give Ψ(ω)∝ω−4\Psi(\omega) \propto\omega^{-4} [13]. Let us add to this that the magnitude of Ψ(ω)\Psi(\omega) must be proportional to the mean squared speed of cusps running through a measurement point divided by the time between cusps, that is to ωkvk2\omega_k v_k^2. This means that the frequency spectra cannot have a universal pumping-independent asymptotics. The main contribution into sweeping is due to longest waves (from the weakly-turbulent part of the spectrum), where vk2≃uckv_k^2 \simeq u c_k and ωkvk2≃ug\omega_k v_k^2 \simeq ug is independent of kk, so that the frequency spectrum (5) must be the same for weak and strong turbulence. Sweeping is thus the first manifestation of spectral nonlocality making the frequency spectrum at however large ω\omega dependent on the pumping rate at low ω\omega.

How straight are the cusps? Could we now call it a day, assuming that the frequency spectrum is unchanged while the wavenumber spectrum turns from the pumping-determined spectrum (5) to the universal spectrum (2) at knk_n where they match?

Not yet. The Phillips wavenumber power law (2) was questioned by Kuznetsov [13]: It may seem from the simple consideration above that it is enough to know the order of surface singularity to predict the spectrum: shock (jump) gives ηk∝1/k\eta_k \propto1/k, cusp gives ηk∝1/k2\eta_k \propto1/k^2, etc; squaring it, one gets the wavenumber spectrum. This is true in one dimension only. At higher dimensions, the form of singularity matters. As was shown by Kadomtsev and Petviashvili for acoustic shocks [16], Saffman for vorticity shocks [15], and generalized by Kuznetsov for general cases including surface cusps [13], the spectrum of randomly placed straight singularities must decay with kk faster by an extra factor k1−dk^{1-d}. Model computation illuminates this result. Consider a straight cusp of the length LL given by η(x,y)=e−∣x∣/L−(y/L)2\eta(x,y)=e^{-|x|/L-(y/L)^2} and denote θ\theta the angle between the wavevector and the cusp normal. The Fourier transform is given by ∣ηk∣2=[L−2+(kcos⁡θ)2]−2exp⁡[−(kLsin⁡θ)2]|\eta_k|^2 = [L^{-2}+(k\cos\theta)^2]^{-2}\exp[-(kL\sin\theta)^2]. We see that each cusp line contributes to the spectrum a jet with an angular width decreasing as 1/kL1/kL; averaging over the angle θ\theta, Kuznetsov obtained at kL≫1kL\gg1 [13]:

⟨∣ηk∣2⟩≃1/k5L.(8)\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle\simeq1/k^5L . \tag*{(8)}

If true and if there is a self-similarity of Φ(k,ω)\Phi(k,\omega) then (1,6,8) give a=1a=1, that is ω∝k\omega\propto k. Maxima of Φ(k,ω)\Phi(k,\omega) at straight lines in (k,ω)(k,\omega)-plane are frequently observed, yet it is unclear whether they dominate enough to provide such self-similarity at large k,ωk,\omega. Note, however, that (8) is true only for straight fronts in real space, which is the case for acoustic shocks. I don’t think that this is true for wedge-shaped breaking water waves, but it is ultimately for computations or measurements to settle. For non-straight cusps, I expect that the Fourier spectrum is independent of the angle, as for a model of a circular cusp, η(r)=e−r−R/L\eta(r)=e^{-r-R/L}, where ∣ηk∣2=2π[L−2+k2]−2|\eta_k|^2=2\pi[L^{-2}+k^2]^{-2}, giving the asymptotics k−4k^{-4}. This is similar to the enstrophy-cascade spectrum in 2d incompressible turbulence, which follows Kraichnan’s ⟨∣vk∣2⟩∝k−4\langle|v_k|^2\rangle\propto k^{-4} rather than Saffman’s k−5Lk^{-5}L despite the presence of the vorticity shocks, since the latter are not straight but curved [17].

Interaction renormalization and nonlocality. To establish the magnitude of the strong-turbulence wavenumber spectrum, one needs to know at which kk it matches the well-defined weak turbulence solution. That requires an honest calculation of the validity limit of weak-turbulence theory rather than the dimensional estimate (7). The first-order correction to the kinetic equation is the renormalization of the interaction vertex λ1234\lambda_{1234}. As was noticed by Rosenhaus and Falkovich [10], even when the integrals in the kinetic equation converge for Zakharov solution, the next-order corrections could be magnified by divergences: nonlinearity is enhanced by nonlocality in non-equilibrium. The first (one-loop) correction to λ1234\lambda_{1234} is obtained by the standard perturbation theory [9] and is as follows:

∑pq[λ12pqλpq34(np+nq)ω1+ω2−ωq−ωp+ϵ+4λ1p3qλ4q2p(nq−np)ω4+ωq−ω2−ωp+ϵ].(9)\sum_{pq}\left[\frac{\lambda_{12pq}\lambda_{pq34}(n_p+n_q)}{\omega_1+\omega_2-\omega_q-\omega_p+\epsilon}+\frac{4\lambda_{1p3q}\lambda_{4q2p}(n_q-n_p)}{\omega_4+\omega_q-\omega_2-\omega_p+\epsilon}\right]. \tag*{(9)}

Substituting here the weak turbulence spectrum, nk≃uk−4n_k \simeq uk^{-4}, we obtain δλ/λ≃ukkp−1/2=ϵk(k/kp)1/2\delta\lambda/\lambda\simeq ukk_p^{-1/2}=\epsilon_k(k/k_p)^{1/2}. We consider for simplicity the pumping (or spectral peak) wavenumber kpk_p to be the smallest in the system and cut the divergence there. It is important to note that the IR divergences are due to non-resonant interactions. This is why there are no divergences in the kinetic equation which contains only resonant interactions.

An important conclusion is that wavenumber spectrum must change from weak to strong turbulence when the relative correction is of order unity, that is at the wavenumber

k∗=g/ucp=kpkn .(10)k_* = g/uc_p = \sqrt{k_p k_n}\, . \tag*{(10)}

Here cp=g/kpc_p=\sqrt{g/k_p} is the phase velocity of the longest (and fastest) waves. The physics behind that second nonlocality could be that wave breaking starts not for isolated waves with the critical slope (and wavenumber knk_n) but for waves running on the crests of long waves [11] and at a level of steepness significantly smaller than critical [12]. Indeed, the fluid flow of a large wave distorted by a small wave gives the fluid acceleration kvp2=kucpk v_p^2=k u c_p, which is equal to gg for k=k∗k=k_*. At the same wavenumber, the Doppler shift due to a large wave, kvp=kucpk v_p=k\sqrt{u c_p}, exceeds the linear frequency gk\sqrt{gk}. That spectral nonlocality may also shed some light on the seemingly absurd relation between the statistical distribution of breaking waves over speeds and the weak-turbulence spectrum (5) where no breaking occurs [2]. Direct computations seems to support this relation [18, 19]. That could be explained if indeed breaking waves preferably ride on longer waves from the weakly-turbulent part.

Frequency renormalization. ω~k=gk+2Σk\widetilde{\omega}_k=\sqrt{gk}+2\Sigma_k. The expansion in powers of nonlinearity is as follows:

Σk=∑qλkqkqnq−∑pqrλkpqr2(npnq+2nqnr)ωk+ωp−ωq−ωr+iϵ+⋯(11)\Sigma_k=\sum_q\lambda_{kqkq}n_q-\sum_{pqr}\frac{\lambda_{kpqr}^2(n_pn_q+2n_qn_r)}{\omega_k+\omega_p-\omega_q-\omega_r+\mathrm{i}\epsilon}+\cdots \tag*{(11)}

The first term Σ1\Sigma_1 in (11) is degenerate since λkqkq=q(k⋅q)\lambda_{kqkq}=q(\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{q}) for q≪kq\ll k as can be found from the below expression for λpqkr\lambda_{pqkr} [20, 21]. The IR log-divergent contribution, Σ1=2λ(k⋅R)\Sigma_1=2\lambda(\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}), is proportional to the vector R=∫qqnq dq\mathbf{R}=\int q q n_q\,d q. For a momentum-carrying distribution, the renormalization is nonzero: Σ1≃ukcos⁡θlog⁡(k/kp)\Sigma_1\simeq u k\cos\theta\log(k/k_p). That, however, does not change the renormalized kinetic equation, since the linear in kk terms cancel out both in the frequency delta function and in the denominators of the loop integrals. For isotropic spectra, Σ1=7π2uk/8\Sigma_1=7\pi^2u k/8, that is positive and linear in kk [28]. Absence of a power-law divergence, means that Σ1≃ωk\Sigma_1\simeq\omega_k at k≃knk\simeq k_n. That frequency renormalization does not directly influence the wavenumber spectrum of the energy cascade yet could be probably observed in Ψ(k,ω)\Psi(k,\omega).

The second term gives Σ2≃−u2k5/2/kpg\Sigma_2\simeq-u^2k^{5/2}/k_p\sqrt{g} - because of power IR divergences, the contribution into the integral of (5) exceeds that of (12). We find that Σ2≃ωk\Sigma_2\simeq\omega_k at the same k∗k_* when the vertex renormalization starts to matter. We conclude that weak turbulence must turn into strong at k∗k_*.

The new spectra. The strong-turbulence spectrum ⟨∣ηk∣2⟩=Ak−4\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle=Ak^{-4} that match (5) at k∗k_* is as follows:

⟨∣ηk∣2⟩≃k−4ucp=k−4kpk=k−4ϵp1/2.(12)\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle\simeq k^{-4}\sqrt{\frac{u}{c_p}}=k^{-4}\sqrt{\frac{k_p}{k}}=k^{-4}\epsilon_p^{1/2}. \tag*{(12)}
Ψ(ω)≃ugω−4(13)\Psi(\omega)\simeq u g\omega^{-4} \tag*{(13)}

Would one had chosen (8), ⟨∣ηk∣2⟩=Bk−5\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle=Bk^{-5}, then B∝u−1/2B\propto u^{-1/2}. This is a very dramatic statement - the decrease of the spectrum magnitude with increasing pumping because of an extreme nonlocality. While seems paradoxical behavior is not impossible - it was recently predicted (bit not yet observed) for spin-wave turbulence [24]. Note that the frequency spectrum is proportional to u=P1/3u=P^{1/3}, while the wavenumber spectrum — to P1/6P^{1/6}. The magnitude of (12) is suppressed relative to (2) since the breaking waves occupy less area: kp/krk_p/k_r rather than kp/knk_p/k_n. Apparently, (12) is valid only for ϵp=kp/k∗≤1\epsilon_p=k_p/k_*\leq1. When k∗k_* reaches kpk_p so that turbulence is strong already at the pumping scale and breaking waves are space-filling, the universal spectrum (2) must be realized on the whole interval k>kpk>k_p. At higher pumping, all the excess of energy spills into foam, and the turbulence level saturates:

⟨∣ηk∣2⟩≃k−4,(14)\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle\simeq k^{-4}, \tag*{(14)}
Ψ(ω)≃cpgω−4.(15)\Psi(\omega)\simeq c_p g\omega^{-4}. \tag*{(15)}

The wavenumber (Phillips) spectrum is truly universal, while the frequency spectrum does not depend on pumping but depends on the speed of the fastest waves. It is unclear to me whether the frequency spectrum continues to be Ψ(ω)≃ugω−4\Psi(\omega)\simeq u g\omega^{-4} when a wavemaker with the frequency ωp\omega_p generates flow with the surface speed uu exceeding cpc_p.

One needs numerics to establish how long spectral interval must be for the nonlocal interactions to dominate. Preliminary data by Vladimirova show that, depending on the configurations of wavevectors, local and nonlocal interactions could give corrections of opposite signs, and that one needs at least two decades for nonlocal effects to dominate δλ1234\delta\lambda_{1234} for comparable wave numbers [28]. One needs to compute numerically the overall contribution to dn1/dtd n_1/dt of the one-loop correction.

Symmetries of the different spectra. Original dynamical equations are invariant with respect to the transformation ηk(t)→λ2ηλk(λ−1/2t)\eta_k(t)\to\lambda^2\eta_{\lambda k}(\lambda^{-1/2}t) which corresponds to

Ψ(λk,λ1/2ω)=λ−5/2Ψ(k,ω).(16)\Psi(\lambda k,\lambda^{1/2}\omega)=\lambda^{-5/2}\Psi(k,\omega). \tag*{(16)}

The hypothetical spectra (2,3) respect this symmetry of the original equations [8]. Pumping imposes the scale kp−1k_p^{-1} and the time u/gu/g. The spectra (5,6) are local, that is independent of kpk_p, yet they break the symmetry (16), which can be restored by rescaling the flux u→λ−1/2uu\to\lambda^{-1/2}u. The wavenumber spectrum (12) depends on both the pumping magnitude and the scale. The ultimate wavenumber spectrum (2,14) is universal, while the frequency spectrum depends on kpk_p.

Are there self-similarities in k,ωk,\omega-plane? The weak-turbulence spectrum is concentrated on a single line in (k,ω)(k,\omega)-plane: Φ(k,ω)=ug−1/2k−7/2δ(ω−gk)\Phi(k,\omega)=u g^{-1/2}k^{-7/2}\delta(\omega-\sqrt{gk}), that is self-similar with a=2a=2. Strong-turbulence spectrum is unlikely to concentrate on a single line and even have any space-time self-similarity. Indeed, applying (1) to (12,13) suggest not ω=gk\omega=\sqrt{gk} but ω∼k2/3ε1/3\omega\sim k^{2/3}\varepsilon^{1/3}, where ε(u)=g(ucp)1/2\varepsilon(u)=g(uc_p)^{1/2}. Such Richardson self-similarity (squared distance proportional to the cube of time) is unlikely to be observed since it contradicts the frequency renormalization described by (11). This renormalization is generally complex, that is describes spectral broadening as well, most likely as Σk∝k3/2\Sigma_k \propto k^{3/2}. In addition, sweeping by longer waves must produce ω∝k\omega\propto k. The spectrum Φ(k,ω)\Phi(k,\omega) then is unlikely to be self-similar in the strong-turbulence regime.

Let us briefly discuss the spectrum anisotropy. Within weak-turbulence theory, the isotropic spectrum is stable with respect to small angular perturbations [3]. The slowest-decreasing is the first angular harmonic proportional to the wave momentum flux: the cos⁡θ\cos\theta-correction to (5) decays as k−4k^{-4} and to (6) as ω−5\omega^{-5} [26]. The latter should not be mistaken for (3). This isotropization at small scales is supported by the numerics of the kinetic equation (see e.g. [25]). On the other hand, observational data on wind-driven waves show bimodal angular structure developing at higher kk [22]. That could be that strong-turbulence spectra (of breaking waves) tend to break into narrow jets. For review of experiments, see [30].

The nonlocalities, derived above, may shed light on the remarkable observation by Korotkevich that long-wave condensate plays a role in formation of strong-turbulence spectrum k−4k^{-4} [14]. Indeed, our derivations show that both δλ1234\delta\lambda_{1234} and Σk\Sigma_k diverge for spectra steeper than nk∝k−7/2n_k \propto k^{-7/2} which is true for all spectra considered including the inverse cascade nk∝k−23/6n_k \propto k^{-23/6}.

Conclusion

The most important and readily verifiable prediction is that the amplitude of the Phillips spectrum is non-universal but grows with the pumping strength until it saturates.

Formulas (10,12,13,15) are the main claims of this note. They are plausible suggestions based on the computation of one-loop corrections and on physical arguments. At this point it is unclear if the spectra (12,13,15) are realized and whether they correspond to a critical balance and a constant energy flux.

The predictions possibly amenable for experimental and numerical verification:

  1. The deviations from weak turbulence start at k∗k_* rather than knk_n. The deviations could be observed from either steepining of ⟨∣ηk∣2⟩\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle or straightening and broadening of the maxima of Φ(k,ω)\Phi(k,\omega) in k,ωk,\omega-plane.

  1. The frequency spectrum Ψ(ω)\Psi(\omega) is not expected to change upon transition to strong turbulence, yet the wavenumber-frequency spectrum Φ(k,ω)\Phi(k,\omega) must change significantly. One possible form of spectral broadening is given by (11) where we now substitute (12):

Im⁡Σk∝gkucpkkp(17)\operatorname{Im}\Sigma_k \propto\sqrt{gk\frac{u}{c_p}\frac{k}{k_p}} \tag*{(17)}
  1. The wavenumber spectrum of strong turbulence, (12), has the Phillips scaling yet non-universal amplitude dependent both on the pumping rate and the peak wavenumber. An alternative prediction is (8) where one needs to put either L≃kn−1∝u2/gL \simeq k_n^{-1} \propto u^2/g or L≃k∗−1=ucp/gL \simeq k_*^{-1}=uc_p/g (for a long weak-turbulence cascade). In both cases, the amplitude of such spectrum is expected to decrease with increasing pumping uu. The simplest way to distinguish between the alternatives is to see whether the strong-turbulence spectrum increases or decreases with increasing pumping.

From the analytic theory perspective, the following questions naturally appear:

  1. If indeed the wavenumber spectrum decays faster with kk when the nonlinearity grows, that must mean that the effective interaction contributing the energy cascade is getting stronger. The relative vertex renormalization L=δλ1234/λ1234\mathcal{L}=\delta\lambda_{1234}/\lambda_{1234} where δλ1234\delta\lambda_{1234} is given by (9), must be computable by combining analytics and numerics. Since different configurations of wavevectors give different signs (for instance, it seem that collinear give positive L\mathcal{L} that is enhancement[28]), one needs to integrate over 2,3,4 to get the sign of the overall contribution to dn1/dtdn_1/dt and see how long must be the spectral interval for nonlocal contribution to dominate.

  1. Is there an equation of which either ⟨∣ηk∣2⟩∝k−4\langle|\eta_k|^2\rangle\propto k^{-4} or k−5k^{-5} is a solution? Dyachenko and Newell argued that k−4k^{-4} does not correspond to a constant flux but rather is a balance between wave interaction and dissipation [29]. I believe to the contrary, inspired by the recent success in deriving the critical-balance spectra for focusing Nonlinear Schrödinger equation [23] and spin waves [24] as constant-flux solutions of renormalized kinetic equations.

  1. Critical balance is where the dimensionless degree of nonlinearity is independent of kk. Remind that this degree is not the naive ϵk\epsilon_k but L\mathcal{L}. For any nq=Aq−γn_q=Aq^{-\gamma} with any meaningful γ\gamma (γ>7/2\gamma>7/2), we have from (9): L≃k3/2Akp7/2−γ/ω~k\mathcal{L}\simeq k^3/2 A k_p^{7/2-\gamma}/\widetilde{\omega}_k. That could be independent of kk and uu if one substitute ω~k\widetilde{\omega}_k in the denominator by Σk∝k3/2\Sigma_k\propto k^{3/2}, see (17). Could it be justified by any plausible summation? For example, bubbles for the vertex renormalization with ωk→Σk\omega_k\to\Sigma_k inside every bubble.

Assuming spectrum (12), could one analyze the whole perturbation series and establish leading diagrams in the renormalization of the vertex and the mass operator Σ\Sigma? Could one then self-consistently derive a close kinetic equation, whose solution is (12)? Does this solution correspond to a constant energy flux?

  1. All the infrared divergences show that the multi-mode interaction of short nonlinear waves is mainly with the long weakly nonlinear waves whose statistics can be assumed Gaussian. This suggests an effective renormalization scheme based on the explicit averaging over the long waves from the outset.

I apologize for many omissions in the unsystematic list of references below.

References

Appendix

The interaction vertex is a function λpqkr\lambda_{\mathrm{p q k r}} of four two-dimensional vectors with a zero sum: p=(a,b)\mathbf{p}=(a,b), q=(c,d)\mathbf{q}=(c,d), r=(r,0)\mathbf{r}=(r,0), k=p+q−r=(a+c−r,b+d)\mathbf{k}=\mathbf{p}+\mathbf{q}-\mathbf{r}=(a+c-r,b+d).

Let us define Qkpq=(q/kp)1/4(kp+k⋅p)Q_{\mathrm{k p q}}=(q/kp)^{1/4}(kp+\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{p}), then

Ukpq=−Qk,−p,q−Q−k,q,p+Qp,q,−k,U_{\mathrm{k p q}}=-Q_{\mathrm{k,-p,q}}-Q_{\mathrm{-k,q,p}}+Q_{\mathrm{p,q,-k}},
Ukpq′=Qkpq+Qqkp+Qpqk,U'_{\mathrm{k p q}}=Q_{\mathrm{k p q}}+Q_{\mathrm{q k p}}+Q_{\mathrm{p q k}},
Akpq=Ukpqk−pq,Akpq′=−Ukpq′k+pqA_{\mathrm{k p q}}=\frac{U_{\mathrm{k p q}}}{\sqrt{k-p}\sqrt{q}},\qquad A'_{\mathrm{k p q}}=-\frac{U'_{\mathrm{k p q}}}{\sqrt{k+p}\sqrt{q}}
Z0123=U0−1−0−1′A23−2−3′+U0+101A2+323−U020−2A313−1−U202−0A131−3−U030−3A212−1−U303−0A121−2.Z_{0123}=U'_{0-1-0-1}A'_{23-2-3}+U_{0+101}A_{2+323}-U_{020-2}A_{313-1} -U_{202-0}A_{131-3}-U_{030-3}A_{212-1}-U_{303-0}A_{121-2}.
V0,1,2,3=(k2k3k0k1)1/4[2k02k1+2k12k0−k0k1(∣k0+k2∣+∣k1+k2∣+∣k0+k3∣+∣k1+k3∣)].V_{0,1,2,3}=\left(\frac{k_2k_3}{k_0k_1}\right)^{1/4}\left[2k_0^2k_1+2k_1^2k_0-k_0k_1(|k_0+k_2| +|k_1+k_2|+|k_0+k_3|+|k_1+k_3|)\right].
Wpqkr=V−p,−q,k,r+Vk,r,−p,−q−V−p,k,−q,r−V−q,k,−p,r−V−p,r,−q,k−V−q,r,−p,k,W_{\mathrm{p q k r}}=V_{\mathrm{-p,-q,k,r}}+V_{\mathrm{k,r,-p,-q}}-V_{\mathrm{-p,k,-q,r}} -V_{\mathrm{-q,k,-p,r}}-V_{\mathrm{-p,r,-q,k}}-V_{\mathrm{-q,r,-p,k}},
λpqkr=Wpqkr+14(Zpqkr+Zqpkr+Zkrpq+Zrkpq)\lambda_{\mathrm{p q k r}}=W_{\mathrm{p q k r}}+\frac{1}{4}\left(Z_{\mathrm{p q k r}}+Z_{\mathrm{q p k r}}+Z_{\mathrm{k r p q}}+Z_{\mathrm{r k p q}}\right)

Capillarity contributes the frequency ωk2=gk[1+(k/kc)2]\omega_k^2 = gk[1 + (k/k_c)^2] where kc2=q/σk_c^2 = q/\sigma. Note that dimensional nonlinearity parameter k4ηk2k^4\eta_k^2 depends neither on gg nor on σ\sigma. It is unclear how capillarity modifies the wavenumber spectrum ηk∼k−2\eta_k \sim k^{-2}. If kc<k∗k_c < k_*, then capillarity takes over from gravity in the weak-turbulence regime. Cubic nonlinearity ηv2\eta v^2 gives the three-wave interaction coefficient Vk12≃ωk1/2k3/2V_{k12} \simeq\omega_k^{1/2}k^{3/2}. Together with the decay dispersion law ωk=(σk3)1/2\omega_k = (\sigma k^3)^{1/2}, they give the spectrum nk=u3/2k−2/Vkn_k = u^{3/2}k^{-2}/V_k, which corresponds to ηk2≃k−4(u/ck)3/2=u3/2σ−1/4k−17/4\eta_k^2 \simeq k^{-4}(u/c_k)^{3/2} = u^{3/2}\sigma^{-1/4}k^{-17/4}. Cubic nonlinearity parameter is ηv2/σ(∇η)2\eta v^2/\sigma(\nabla\eta)^2. Only if we relate velocity and elevation by the linear relation, v=ωηv = \omega\eta, that coincides with the internal nonlinearity parameter ∇η\nabla\eta. Naively estimated, such nonlinearity ϵk=k4ηk2=(u/ck)3/2∝k−3/4\epsilon_k = k^4\eta_k^2 = (u/c_k)^{3/2} \propto k^{-3/4} decays with kk, which suggests that such turbulence is weak at however large kk. To check if it is true, one needs to compute the corrections to the frequency and the vertex of interaction; they behave according to the estimate if the respective integrals converge.

It is straightforward to show that the integral for the frequency renormalization,

Σk=∫∣Vk1k−1∣2n1(k3/2−∣k−k1∣3/2−k13/2+iϵ)−1k1 dk1,\Sigma_k = \int|V_{k_1k_{-1}}|^2 n_1(k^{3/2}-|k-k_1|^{3/2}-k_1^{3/2}+i\epsilon)^{-1}k_1\,dk_1,

converges at k1→0k_1 \to0, when ∣Vk1k−1∣2∝k1m1k2m−m1=k17/2k|V_{k_1k_{-1}}|^2 \propto k_1^{m_1}k^{2m-m_1} = k_1^{7/2}k. The imaginary part of Σ\Sigma give the k−ωk-\omega spectrum broadening, which indeed was found numerically to scale according to the dimensional expectation: Σk∝k3/4\Sigma_k \propto k^{3/4} [31]. The one-loop corrections to the kinetic equation were computed in [32] for the 3-wave case. For lim⁡q→0Vkq,k+q∝qm1k2m−m1\lim_{q\to0}V_{kq,k+q} \propto q^{m_1}k^{2m-m_1}, one finds the following IR properties: For Va,VbV_a,V_b at p5→0p_5 \to0, the first lines give k0m1+d−γ=km1−mk_0^{m_1+d-\gamma} = k^{m_1-m}. The same convergence one finds in the second and third lines because the two nn-factors and two ω\omega-denominators are each proportional to p5p_5 and cancel each other. The propagator terms don’t have cancellations in the nn-terms, but have one-power cancellations in the last terms of Pa+PbP_a+P_b and Pc+PdP_c+P_d, which makes Pa+Pb+Pc+Pd∝k0m1−m−1P_a+P_b+P_c+P_d \propto k_0^{m_1-m-1}. All converge for capillary waves. We conclude that if the pumping excites weak capillary turbulence, it is getting weaker along the cascade. What if pumping excites strong turbulence?

Without gravity, capillarity allows an ultimate Crapper wave, when the surface self-touches enclosing of air bubbles in the trough [33]. That corresponds to a shape singularity η∝∣x∣\eta\propto\sqrt{|x|}, where the derivative turns into infinity at x=0x = 0. The capillary singularity is stronger than the cusp, and suggests slower-decaying Fourier spectrum: ηk2∝k−3\eta_k^2 \propto k^{-3}. It is likely that on such a wave, the radial acceleration v2/ηv^2/\eta is comparable with the capillarity acceleration σk2\sigma k^2, so that the nonlinearity parameter ηv2/σ(∇η)2≃1\eta v^2/\sigma(\nabla\eta)^2 \simeq1.

Such capillary waves of sufficiently high (yet sub-ultimate) amplitude have negative-slope parts, which are impossible for a finite gravity. Therefore, gravity-capillary waves are always smooth — gravity prevents bubbles while capillarity rounds cusps making their radius of curvature 1/kc1/k_c so that the capillary acceleration is equal to gg. How exactly capillarity modifies Phillips spectrum at k>kck > k_c?

References

  1. [2]Phillips OM. “Spectral and statistical properties of the equilibrium range in wind-generated gravity waves,” 156, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 505–531 (1985)DOI
  2. [3]V. E. Zakharov, V. S. L’vov, and G. Falkovich, Kolmogorov-Zakharov Spectra of Turbulence, second edition, Springer-Verlag, 2025.DOI
  3. [4]S. Nazarenko, Wave Turbulence. Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, 2011.
  4. [5]K. Hasselmann, “On the non-linear energy transfer in a gravity-wave spectrum”, J. Fluid Mech. 12, 481-500 (1962).
  5. [6]V. E. Zakharov and N. N. Filonenko, “The energy spectrum for random surface waves,” Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 170 1291–95 (1967) [Sov. Phys. Dokl. 11, 881 (1967)].
  6. [8]A. Newell and V. Zakharov, “The role of the generalized Phillips’ spectrum in wave turbulence,” Physics Letters A 372 no. 23, (2008) 4230–4233.DOI
  7. [9]V. Rosenhaus and M. Smolkin, “Feynman rules for forced wave turbulence,” JHEP 01, 142 (2023).DOI
  8. [10]V. Rosenhaus and G. Falkovich, “Interaction renormalization and validity of kinetic equations for turbulent states” Phys Rev Let 33, 244002 (2024)DOI
  9. [11]Irisov, V. and Voronovich, A., Numerical simulation of wave breaking”, Journal of physical oceanography 41(2), 346-364 (2011).DOI
  10. [12]Griffin, O. M., R. D. Peltzer, and H. T. Wang, 1996: Kinematic and dynamic evolution of deep water breaking waves. J. Geophys. Res., 101 (C7), 16 515–16 531.DOI
  11. [13]E A Kuznetsov, “Turbulence spectra generated by singularities”, JETP Let 80, 83–89 (2004)DOI
  12. [14]A. O. Korotkevich, “Simultaneous numerical simulation of direct and inverse cascades in wave turbulence,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 101 (2008) 074504.DOI
  13. [15]P. G. Saffman, “On the Spectrum and Decay of RandomTwo- Dimensional Vorticity Distributions at Large Reynolds Number”, Stud. Appl. Math. 4, 377 (1971).DOI
  14. [16]B. B. Kadomtsev and V. I. Petviashvili, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 208, 794 (1973) [Sov. Phys. Dokl. 18, 115 (1973)].
  15. [17]Kuznetsov, E. A., and Sereshchenko, E. V. (2015). Anisotropic characteristics of the Kraichnan direct cascade in two-dimensional hydrodynamic turbulence. JETP letters, 102(11), 760-765.DOI
  16. [18]Wu J, Popinet S, Deike L. Breaking wave field statistics with a multi-layer model. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 2023;968:A12. doi:10.1017/jfm.2023.522DOI
  17. [19]Jiarong Wua, Stephane Popinet, Bertrand Chapron, J. Thomas Farrar , and Luc Deike, “Turbulence and energy dissipation from wave breaking”, arXiv:2503.00309v1
  18. [20]A. Pushkarev, D. Resio, V. Zakharov, “Weak turbulent approach to the wind-generated gravity sea waves”, Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, 184, 29–63 (2003) https://doi.org/10.1016/S0167-2789(03)00212-4
  19. [21]V. P. Krasitsky, “Five-wave kinetic equation for surface gravity waves” Phys. Oceanogr. 5 6, 413-421 (1994)
  20. [22]Hwang, P. A., Wang, D. W., Walsh, E. J., Krabill, W. B., and Swift, R. N. “Airborne measurements of the wavenumber spectra of ocean surface waves. Part II: Directional distribution.” J Phys Oceanography, 30(11), 2768-2787 (2000).doi.org/10.1175/1520-0485(2001)031<2768:amotws>2.0.co;2
  21. [23]Vladimir Rosenhaus, Natalia Vladimirova, Gregory Falkovich, Universal regimes of strong turbulence in the multi-component Gross-Pitaevskii model, arXiv:2511.14068
  22. [24]Jiang Liu, Vladimir Rosenhaus, Gregory Falkovich, “Degrees of universality in wave turbulence” arXiv:2512.04866
  23. [25]Badulin, S. G., Geogjaev, V., and Pushkarev, A. “Katz-Kontorovich Anisotropic Solution in Simulations of Ocean Swell”. Available at SSRN 5202934.
  24. [26]A. V. Kats, V. M. Kontorovich, “Anisotropic turbulent distributions for 471 waves with a non-decay dispersion law”, Soviet Physics JETP 38, 102-107 (1974)
  25. [28]N Vladimirova, Private Communication.
  26. [29]Dyachenko S, Newell AC. Whitecapping. Stud Appl Math. 137(2):199-213 (2016).
  27. [30]Falcon, E. and Mordant, N., 2022. Experiments in surface gravity–capillary wave turbulence. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 54(1), pp.1-25.DOI
  28. [31]Luc Deike, Daniel Fuster, Michael Berhanu, and Eric Falcon, Direct Numerical Simulations of Capillary Wave Turbulence Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 234501 (2014)DOI
  29. [32]V Rosenhaus, D Schubring, MSJ Shuvo, M Smolkin, Loop diagrams in the kinetic theory of waves, Journal of High Energy Physics 2024 (6), 1-32arxiv.org/abs/2308.00740
  30. [33]Crapper GD. An exact solution for progressive capillary waves of arbitrary amplitude. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 1957;2(6):532-540. doi:10.1017/S0022112057000348DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_emtdzcz4
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents