betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Counterexamples to the clamped-plate eigenvalue ratio conjecture

Abstract

Ashbaugh in 1999 conjectures that the ball maximizes the ratio of the second to the first eigenvalue for the vibrating clamped-plate problem. We disprove this conjecture by constructing smooth connected domains in every dimension d≥2d\ge2. The construction starts with an interior sphere on which the displacement is required to vanish. The first two eigenvalues have the same relative increase at first order, but the second increases more at second order. This gives a strict increase of their ratio, which survives approximation of the sphere by finitely many codimension-two supports and their replacement by smooth holes. We identify the limiting Sobolev spaces through trace estimates and logarithmic cutoffs, and use the geometric construction for the buckling problem to obtain connected perforated domains.

2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 35P15; Secondary 35J40, 49Q10, 74K20

Introduction and main result

In 1955–1956, Payne, Pólya and Weinberger [26] conjectured that the disk maximizes the ratio of the first two Dirichlet eigenvalues of a planar membrane. Its Euclidean extension states that, for a bounded domain Ω⊂Rd\Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^{d}, d≥2d \ge2,

λ2(Ω)λ1(Ω)≤λ2(B)Bλ1(B)=jd/2,12jd/2−1,12.\frac{\lambda_{2}(\Omega)}{\lambda_{1}(\Omega)} \le\frac{\lambda_{2(B)}{B}}{\lambda_{1}(B)} = \frac{j_{d/2,1}^{2}}{j_{d/2-1,1}^{2}}.

Here Rd\mathbb{R}^{d} is Euclidean space, B={x∈Rd:∣x∣<1}B = \{x \in\mathbb{R}^{d} : |x| < 1\} is the unit ball in Rd\mathbb{R}^{d}, λk(Ω)\lambda_k(\Omega) are the eigenvalues of −Δu=λu-\Delta u = \lambda u with u=0u = 0 on ∂Ω\partial\Omega, ordered with multiplicity, and jν,1j_{\nu,1} is the first positive zero of the Bessel function JνJ_\nu. The Laplacian is Δ=∑i=1d∂xi2\Delta= \sum_{i=1}^{d} \partial_{x_i}^{2}. Ashbaugh and Benguria proved this sharp inequality in every dimension, with equality for balls [4, 5]. The planar ratio question also appears as Problem 77 in Yau’s problem section in [27].

The membrane problem connects spectral geometry with acoustics: the vibration frequencies are proportional to λk(Ω)\sqrt{\lambda_k(\Omega)}. Kac’s question of whether one can hear the shape of a drum asks whether the full Dirichlet spectrum determines the domain [21]. The PPW problem instead asks what geometry can be inferred from an extremal relation between just two frequencies. For a homogeneous isotropic thin elastic plate, bending leads to a fourth-order equation. In the linear model wtt+cΔ2w=0w_{tt} + c\Delta^{2}w = 0, where ww is the transverse displacement and c>0c > 0 depends on the material and thickness, the squared frequencies are cc times the clamped eigenvalues [17 Chapter 1]. Their ratio is independent of this material factor. Interior clamps provide a means of changing the low vibration frequencies; the small-patch analysis in [23] provides a mathematical model for this effect. The higher-dimensional problem is the corresponding elliptic spectral problem.

Motivated by the membrane inequality, Ashbaugh formulated in 1999 the analogous ball-ratio conjecture for the vibrating clamped plate [3 Section 4, equation (4.6)]. To state it, let H2(Ω)H^{2}(\Omega) be the Sobolev space of functions with square integrable weak derivatives through order two, and let H02(Ω)H_{0}^{2}(\Omega) be the closure in that space of the smooth compactly supported functions Cc∞(Ω)C_{c}^{\infty}(\Omega). The clamped eigenvalues Γk(Ω)\Gamma_k(\Omega), ordered increasingly and repeated according to multiplicity, are defined by

∫ΩΔuΔv dx=Γ∫Ωuv dxfor all v∈H02(Ω),0≠u∈H02(Ω).\int_{\Omega} \Delta u \Delta v \, dx = \Gamma\int_{\Omega} uv \, dx \qquad\text{for all } v \in H_{0}^{2}(\Omega), \quad0 \ne u \in H_{0}^{2}(\Omega).

On a smooth domain this is equivalent to

Δ2u=Γuin Ω,u=∂νu=0on ∂Ω,\Delta^{2}u = \Gamma u \quad\text{in } \Omega, \qquad u = \partial_{\nu}u = 0 \quad\text{on } \partial\Omega,

where ν\nu is the outward unit normal and ∂ν\partial_{\nu} denotes normal differentiation. Put

R(Ω)=Γ2(Ω)Γ1(Ω),ρd=R(B).R(\Omega) = \frac{\Gamma_{2}(\Omega)}{\Gamma_{1}(\Omega)}, \qquad\rho_d = R(B).

The conjectured inequality is R(Ω)≤ρdR(\Omega) \le\rho_d. The identity Γk(tΩ)=t−4Γk(Ω)\Gamma_k(t\Omega) = t^{-4}\Gamma_k(\Omega) for t>0t > 0 makes RR invariant under similarities, namely translations, orthogonal transformations and dilations.

Two related plate problems must be distinguished from this ratio question. Rayleigh’s conjecture minimizes the first vibrating-plate eigenvalue at fixed volume; it was proved in dimensions two and three by Nadirashvili and Ashbaugh–Benguria [6, 24]. Plate buckling instead has the equation Δ2u=−ΛΔu\Delta^{2}u = -\Lambda\Delta u, with spectral parameter Λ\Lambda, and a Rayleigh quotient involving the Dirichlet energy in the denominator. Universal inequalities for clamped vibration eigenvalues, including [13, 20], estimate higher eigenvalues in terms of lower ones by constants independent of the domain. Such estimates do not establish the particular constant ρd\rho_d. Related inequalities and ball spectral formulas for polyharmonic operators are developed in [10].

The membrane analogy is delicate because fourth-order Dirichlet inverses need not preserve positivity. Boggio’s formula gives a positive Green function on a ball [9], whereas the behavior on general domains is substantially different [18, 19]. A second difficulty is that small clamped inclusions can leave a nonzero constraint in the limiting energy space. Kropinski, Lindsay and Ward [22], and Lindsay, Hao and Sommese [23], analyzed planar small-clamp limits and the surviving point-value conditions. The latter work also studied ring configurations and their low eigenvalues. Felli and Romani [15] obtained capacitary eigenvalue asymptotics for polyharmonic problems with small holes. These works supply the small-support perspective underlying our construction. Our contribution is to produce a strict violation of the ball comparison and to realize it by connected smooth domains in every dimension.

Dai, Sun and Zhang [14] disproved the corresponding buckling eigenvalue-ratio conjecture in every dimension. The spherical constraints, codimension-two holes and logarithmic cutoff mechanism are shared by the two constructions; we use their geometric arguments by reference. The spectral calculation is different. The denominator is ∫u2 dx\int u^2\,dx here, instead of ∫∣∇u∣2 dx\int\lvert\nabla u\rvert^2\,dx for buckling, and the ball modes involve both JνJ_\nu and IνI_\nu. In the buckling construction the relative first-order shift is 3ϵ/23\epsilon/2 and the relative second-order gain in the ratio is ϵ2/8\epsilon^2/8. Here the first-order shift is 3ϵ3\epsilon, while the second-order coefficient depends on hν(κ)=κIν′(κ)/Iν(κ)h_\nu(\kappa)=\kappa I_\nu'(\kappa)/I_\nu(\kappa); its strict comparison between the first and second ball modes is the essential spectral step. Moreover, we transfer the strict inequality through two spectral limits, identifying the limiting trace spaces and using compactness in L2L^2. This differs from the quantitative surface-penalty and trial-function estimates in [14].

A codimension-two submanifold has dimension d−2d-2 and a two-dimensional normal space. A closed tubular neighborhood of radius η\eta consists of points at distance at most η\eta from it. We write Sm\mathbb{S}^m for the unit sphere in Rm+1\mathbb{R}^{m+1}. Our main theorem is as follows.

Theorem 1.1. For every integer d≥2d\ge2, there is a connected bounded domain Ω⊂Rd\Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^d with C∞C^\infty boundary such that

R(Ω)>ρd.R(\Omega)>\rho_d.

It can be obtained by removing from BB finitely many disjoint closed tubular neighborhoods of smooth embedded copies of Sd−2\mathbb{S}^{d-2}. In dimension two these are pairs of small disk holes; in dimension three they are solid torus holes (see following Figure 1).

Both eigenvalues increase when extra constraints are imposed, yet their ratio can exceed the ball value. Indeed, domain inclusion gives

Ω⊂B⟹Γ1(Ω)≥Γ1(B),Γ2(Ω)≥Γ2(B).\Omega\subset B \quad\Longrightarrow\quad\Gamma_1(\Omega)\ge\Gamma_1(B),\qquad\Gamma_2(\Omega)\ge\Gamma_2(B).

but it does not compare their relative increases. Our construction separates these increases only at second order. Thus the first-order calculation along this family does not detect the failure of the conjecture. The sign of the second-order term must therefore be determined separately; the membrane comparison gives no such information.

The proof has three steps. First, require u=0u=0 on an interior sphere of radius 1−ϵ1-\epsilon, leaving its normal derivative free. This is an intermediate constraint, not yet the boundary of a hole. For each fixed ball mode, Lemma 3.1 gives

constrained eigenvalueball eigenvalue=1+3ϵ+23+hν(κ)4ϵ2+O(ϵ3).\frac{\text{constrained eigenvalue}}{\text{ball eigenvalue}}=1+3\epsilon+\frac{23+h_\nu(\kappa)}{4}\epsilon^2+O(\epsilon^3).

The common term 3ϵ3\epsilon cancels in the ratio. The function hν(κ)h_\nu(\kappa) is strictly larger for every mode belonging to the second ball eigenvalue than for the first mode. Proposition 3.2 therefore proves a positive second-order gain. Two checks are essential: the eigenvalues constructed by the radial calculation must actually occupy the first two positions, and the remainder must be smaller than the positive quadratic term. The proof checks both, including the possible multiplicity of the second eigenvalue.

Second, replace the sphere by finitely many latitudes. In dimension 2 a latitude consists of two points; in dimension 3 it is a circle. Adding more latitudes imposes more value conditions. The corresponding eigenvalues increase to those of the spherical constraint, as proved in § 4. Once the strict gain on the sphere is fixed, a sufficiently large but finite collection retains it.

Third, enlarge each latitude into a small smooth hole. There is a boundary-condition issue here: a hole requires both u=0u=0 and ∂νu=0\partial_\nu u=0, whereas the latitude requires only u=0u=0. Section 5 proves that the additional derivative condition can be imposed with an error tending to 0 in H2H^2 as the holes shrink. The reason is the two-dimensional space normal to each latitude: a cutoff varying with the logarithm of the normal distance has sufficiently small derivative cost. The same estimate works in every dimension. We use the geometry in [14] to keep the complement connected.

The order of these choices matters. We first fix a sphere with a positive spectral gain, then fix finitely many latitudes, and only then choose positive hole radii. Section 6 bounds the error at each step by less than half the available gain. The resulting counterexample is a smooth connected domain. The remainder estimates and the two approximation limits are both needed to preserve the strict inequality. The identification of the limiting spaces complements general higher-order domain stability results [2, 12].

Section 2 collects the standard variational, trace and ball spectral facts. Section 3 proves the strict increase under a spherical value constraint. Section 4 treats approximation by finitely many latitudes, and Section 5 treats their replacement by smooth holes. The choices preserving the strict gap are combined in Section 6, which contains the proof of Theorem 1.1.

Variational tools and spectral data on the ball

We collect the standard facts used below in three lemmas. The first fixes the direction of the variational comparisons, the second specifies the traces and regularity needed at an interior interface, and the third records the ball formulas. The separation of variables and the defining series of the Bessel functions are classical and are not rederived. Throughout, BB is the unit ball, dxdx is Lebesgue measure, and surface integrals use the induced measure. The form spaces and coefficient vectors are taken over the real numbers.

Closed form spaces and traces

Write

Q(u,v)=∫BΔuΔv dx,(u,v)=∫Buv dx.Q(u,v)=\int_B \Delta u\Delta v\,dx,\qquad(u,v)=\int_B uv\,dx.

Functions in H02(Ω)H_0^2(\Omega), with Ω⊂B\Omega\subset B, are identified with their zero extensions. All form subspaces below are closed in H02(B)H_0^2(B) and infinite dimensional.

Lemma 2.1 (Variational comparisons). The norm ∥Δu∥2\lVert\Delta u\rVert_2 is equivalent to ∥u∥H2(B)\lVert u\rVert_{H^2(B)} on H02(B)H_0^2(B), and the inclusion H02(B)↪L2(B)H_0^2(B)\hookrightarrow L^2(B) is compact. For every closed form subspace VV, its eigenvalues satisfy

λk(V)=min⁡E⊂Vdim⁡E=k max⁡0≠u∈EQ(u,u)∥u∥22,V1⊂V2 ⟹ λk(V2)≤λk(V1).(1)\lambda_k(V)=\min_{\substack{E\subset V\\ \dim E=k}}\ \max_{0\ne u\in E}\frac{Q(u,u)}{\lVert u\rVert_2^2},\qquad V_1\subset V_2\ \Longrightarrow\ \lambda_k(V_2)\leq\lambda_k(V_1). \tag*{(1)}

If u1,…,uku_1,\ldots,u_k are L2L^2-orthonormal eigenvectors on VV, then

∥∑i=1kciui∥22=∑i=1k∣ci∣2,Q(∑iciui,∑iciui)=∑iλi(V)∣ci∣2≤λk(V)∑i∣ci∣2.(2)\left\|\sum_{i=1}^{k} c_i u_i\right\|_2^2=\sum_{i=1}^{k}|c_i|^2,\qquad Q\left(\sum_i c_i u_i,\sum_i c_i u_i\right)=\sum_i\lambda_i(V)|c_i|^2\leq\lambda_k(V)\sum_i|c_i|^2. \tag*{(2)}

Proof. These are the standard consequences of compact embedding and the min–max principle; see [17 Chapter 2] and [1 Chapters 4 and 6]. For clarity, the norm comparison follows from

∥D2u∥22=∥Δu∥22,∥∇u∥2≤C∥D2u∥2,∥u∥2≤C∥∇u∥2.\|D^2u\|_2^2=\|\Delta u\|_2^2,\qquad\|\nabla u\|_2\leq C\|D^2u\|_2,\qquad\|u\|_2\leq C\|\nabla u\|_2.

The first identity holds by integration by parts for Cc∞(B)C^\infty_c(B) and then by density; the other two are Poincaré inequalities. The weak equations give Q(ui,uj)=λi(V)δijQ(u_i,u_j)=\lambda_i(V)\delta_{ij}, which proves (2.2). Formula (2.1) then gives the stated inclusion comparison.

References

  1. [1]R. A. Adams and J. J. F. Fournier, Sobolev Spaces, second ed., Pure and Applied Mathematics 140, Elsevier/Academic Press, Amsterdam, 2003.
  2. [2]J. M. Arrieta and P. D. Lamberti, Higher order elliptic operators on variable domains. Stability results and boundary oscillations for intermediate problems, J. Differential Equations 263 (2017), no. 7, 4222–4266.DOI
  3. [3]M. S. Ashbaugh, Isoperimetric and universal inequalities for eigenvalues, in Spectral Theory and Geometry, E. B. Davies and Yu. Safarov (eds.), London Math. Soc. Lecture Note Ser. 273, Cambridge University Press, 1999, 95–139. https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0008087.
  4. [4]M. S. Ashbaugh and R. D. Benguria, Proof of the Payne–Pólya–Weinberger conjecture, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. (N.S.) 25 (1991), 19–29.DOI
  5. [5]M. S. Ashbaugh and R. D. Benguria, A sharp bound for the ratio of the first two eigenvalues of Dirichlet Laplacians and extensions, Ann. of Math. (2) 135 (1992), 601–628.DOI
  6. [6]M. S. Ashbaugh and R. D. Benguria, On Rayleigh’s conjecture for the clamped plate and its generalization to three dimensions, Duke Math. J. 78 (1995), 1–17.DOI
  7. [7]Á. Baricz, S. Ponnusamy and M. Vuorinen, Functional inequalities for modified Bessel functions, Expositiones Math. 29 (2011), no. 4, 399–414.DOI
  8. [8]Á. Baricz, S. Ponnusamy and S. Singh, Cross-product of Bessel functions: monotonicity patterns and functional inequalities, Proc. Math. Sci. 128 (2018), article 36.DOI
  9. [9]T. Boggio, Sulle funzioni di Green d’ordine m, Rend. Circ. Mat. Palermo 20 (1905), 97–135.
  10. [10]D. Buoso and P. Freitas, Sharp inequalities and asymptotics for polyharmonic eigenvalues, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 64 (2025), article 295.arxiv.org/abs/2506.12791
  11. [11]D. Buoso and P. D. Lamberti, Eigenvalues of polyharmonic operators on variable domains, ESAIM Control Optim. Calc. Var. 19 (2013), no. 4, 1225–1235.
  12. [12]V. I. Burenkov and P. D. Lamberti, Sharp spectral stability estimates via the Lebesgue measure of domains for higher order elliptic operators, Rev. Mat. Complut. 25 (2012), no. 2, 435–457.DOI
  13. [13]Q.-M. Cheng and H. Yang, Inequalities for eigenvalues of a clamped plate problem, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 358 (2006), 2625–2635.DOI
  14. [14]G. Dai, Y. Sun and Y. Zhang, Counterexamples to the buckling eigenvalue-ratio conjecture in every dimension, arXiv:2611.13018v1 [math.AP] (2026). https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.13018v1.
  15. [15]V. Felli and G. Romani, Perturbed eigenvalues of polyharmonic operators in domains with small holes, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 62 (2023), article 128.DOI
  16. [16]G. B. Folland, Real Analysis: Modern Techniques and Their Applications, second ed., John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1999.
  17. [17]F. Gazzola, H.-Ch. Grunau and G. Sweers, Polyharmonic Boundary Value Problems: Positivity Preserving and Nonlinear Higher Order Elliptic Equations in Bounded Domains, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1991, Springer, Berlin, 2010.DOI
  18. [18]H.-Ch. Grunau and F. Robert, Positivity and almost positivity of biharmonic Green’s functions under Dirichlet boundary conditions, Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 195 (2010), 865–898.arxiv.org/abs/0705.3301
  19. [19]H.-Ch. Grunau and G. Sweers, Positivity for perturbations of polyharmonic operators with Dirichlet boundary conditions in two dimensions, Math. Nachr. 179 (1996), 89–102.DOI
  20. [20]Y. Jin, S. Pu, Y. Wei and Y. He, New universal inequalities for eigenvalues of a clamped plate problem, Potential Anal. 61 (2024), 597–623.DOI
  21. [21]M. Kac, Can one hear the shape of a drum?, Amer. Math. Monthly 73 (1966), no. 4, part II, 1–23.DOI
  22. [22]M. C. Kropinski, A. E. Lindsay and M. J. Ward, Asymptotic analysis of localized solutions to some linear and nonlinear biharmonic eigenvalue problems, Stud. Appl. Math. 126 (2011), 347–408.DOI
  23. [23]A. E. Lindsay, W. Hao and A. J. Sommese, Vibrations of thin plates with small clamped patches, Proc. R. Soc. A 471 (2015), 20150474.DOI
  24. [24]N. S. Nadirashvili, Rayleigh’s conjecture on the principal frequency of the clamped plate, Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 129 (1995), 1–10.DOI
  25. [25]NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions, Chapter 10, Bessel Functions, Sections 10.2, 10.25 and 10.29. https://dlmf.nist.gov/10.
  26. [26]L. E. Payne, G. Pólya and H. F. Weinberger, On the ratio of consecutive eigenvalues, J. Math. and Phys. 35 (1956), 289–298.DOI
  27. [27]S.-T. Yau, Problem section, in Seminar on Differential Geometry, S.-T. Yau (ed.), Ann. of Math. Stud. 102, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 1982, 669–706.

Paper details

vlnc:W_esb2b73c
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents