WorksMathematics
Expected amenable subalgebras preserving core commutants
Abstract
We prove that every inclusion of von Neumann algebras with separable preduals and a faithful normal conditional expectation contains an expected amenable subalgebra such that , where denotes the continuous core of M. This resolves the relative bicentralizer conjecture in this setting.
Introduction
An inclusion is expected if it admits a faithful normal conditional expectation . Such an expectation makes the inclusion compatible with modular theory: a faithful normal state on extends through to a state on whose modular action preserves . For a faithful normal state on , the continuous core is , with its canonical copy of .
We ask whether an amenable expected subalgebra of can impose exactly the same commutation constraints as on the whole core. Equality of commutants inside alone does not answer this question: the core also contains the unitaries implementing the modular action. Our main theorem retains these additional constraints.
Theorem 1.1. Let be a unital inclusion of von Neumann algebras with separable preduals, and suppose that there is a faithful normal conditional expectation . There exist a unital amenable von Neumann subalgebra and a faithful normal conditional expectation such that
Here amenable means injective.
The canonical core isomorphism associated with a change of faithful normal state fixes , so the stated relative-commutant equality is independent of the state used to define the core.
History and the relative conjecture. Popa’s solution of Kadison’s problem for irreducible expected inclusions with separable preduals and type II bottom factor provides a model for finding amenable subalgebras that retain prescribed commutation properties [15]. For type III factors, modular asymptotic centralization supplies a related approach. The bicentralizer of a faithful normal state consists of those elements that commute asymptotically with every bounded sequence asymptotically centralizing the state in predual norm. Connes introduced the problem of its triviality in the classification of injective factors [3, 4]. Haagerup solved the amenable type III case, completing the uniqueness theorem for the injective type III factor [5]. For type III factors with separable predual, he characterized triviality by norm-density of faithful normal states whose centralizers have trivial relative commutant [5], Theorem 3.1. His proof uses Popa’s construction to find a maximal abelian subalgebra of such a centralizer that remains maximal abelian in the ambient factor; the expectations onto the centralizer and onto its abelian subalgebra compose [5], proof of Theorem 3.1.
Masuda introduced a relative bicentralizer in the finite-index setting [13], Definition 4.1. Ando, Haagerup, Houdayer, and Marrakchi constructed the canonical relative bicentralizer flow for expected inclusions with type bottom factor [2], Theorem A. This extends the absolute flow discovered by Haagerup and independently by Marrakchi, as described in that paper. The structural results of Houdayer and Isono [6], Proposition 3.4 and Theorem 3.5 and Marrakchi’s absolute flow-ergodicity theorem [9], Theorem D underlie the absolute reduction used here. Marrakchi formulated the relative bicentralizer conjecture and proved that, for separable preduals, it is equivalent to the conclusion of Theorem 1.1 [10], Conjecture C and Theorem D. Our theorem therefore resolves that conjecture positively, including inclusions with arbitrary centers and types.
Marrakchi’s recent Theorem B [11] gives an expected amenable subalgebra preserving for general expected inclusions with separable preduals. Theorem 1.1 preserves the commutant in the continuous core. Applying the earlier result with upper algebra would require an expectation from onto , which the original inclusion does not supply. The binormal-state and zero-shift completely positive map of [11], Lemmas 2.1 and 2.2(1) are essential inputs to the proof below.
The absolute problem and the recent announcement. Houdayer and Marrakchi have announced that every type factor admitting a faithful normal state has trivial bicentralizer [7], Theorem G; their theorem statement has no separability restriction. Section 3 gives an alternative proof of its separable-predual instance as part of our relative argument. The multiplication maps and spectral resonance of [7], Section 8 are closely related to this absolute comparison. Their paper also develops relative bicentralizer theory for tracial group actions; the general expected-inclusion core-commutant conclusion of Theorem 1.1 is obtained here through the relative tensor and core argument.
The companion [14], Theorem 4.1 and Section 5.1 develops a complementary absolute argument through bounded recovery: for a state with scalar centralizer, a fixed multiplication defect whose modularly averaged squared norm has positive limsup along unit vectors with spectral supports shrinking to one point can be detected by uniformly bounded algebra elements. The binormal-state identity used here also admits the iteration that yields the relative estimate uniformly in tensor length and flow shifts.
An abelian consequence. A maximal abelian subalgebra, or MASA, satisfies . Another part of Marrakchi’s characterization gives such a subalgebra with a precise core commutant. For an expected , we view inside using the expectation onto and its composition with .
Corollary 1.2. Under the hypotheses of Theorem 1.1, there is a maximal abelian subalgebra with a faithful normal conditional expectation such that
Proof. Apply [10], Theorem D, (4)(6) to Theorem 1.1. ∎
For an irreducible expected inclusion of factors, Kadison’s problem asks for a MASA in that is also maximal abelian in . The corollary gives such a MASA with expectation under the additional core condition : its commutant in then lies in , and hence equals . This is the expected formulation identified in [10], Conjecture B and the discussion after Theorem D.
Proof structure. The analytic work concerns the case where is a type III factor. Choose a faithful normal state on and extend it by . The relative bicentralizer consists of elements that commute asymptotically with every bounded sequence in asymptotically centralizing . It carries a state-preserving flow . Section 2 recalls these objects and the binormal-state identity used below. Existing bicentralizer criteria reduce our task to showing that the extension of to has fixed algebra .
The connection with multiplication is the central point. Set , , and . Consider maps from to , initially given for and by
We prove that these maps are isometries and that
where generates the modular action on and generates the bicentralizer flow on . After a change of coordinates in the core representation, acts on alone, whereas an element fixed by the bicentralizer flow acts independently of the coordinate. They therefore commute. This is the required fixed-point criterion.
The absolute theorem supplies the isometry assertion. If that theorem failed, the standard reduction would give a nontrivial factor equal to its own bicentralizer and with scalar modular fixed algebra. Its two multiplication maps become isometries after averaging the modular action. A binormal eigenstate identity gives their spectral comparison; reflection then forces a spectral lattice condition incompatible with modular ergodicity. Section 3 carries out this argument, and Section 4 applies the absolute theorem to obtain the unaveraged relative isometries.
To prove the relative comparison, Section 5 packages words of arbitrary tensor length into states on one fixed operator algebra. The binormal-state identity yields an estimate uniform in tensor length, all intervening flow parameters, and the location of the total modular energy. The packaging maps are completely positive but may be nonnormal; a spectral cutoff argument justifies the functional calculus they require. Section 6 removes the energy restriction by repeatedly testing a hypothetical discrepancy. Averaging the comparison contraction with its proposed unitary value loses norm wherever they differ. Random shifts capture such a difference with probabilities whose sum diverges, while the same probabilities bound the propagated error. The resulting expected norm loss exceeds the available norm, so the comparison is exact.
Finally, Section 7 proves the core fixed-point identity and derives the weak Dixmier property: every weak* closed convex hull of an -unitary orbit in meets . Marrakchi’s characterization then supplies the amenable subalgebra. Existing results handle the other factor types; a central decomposition and averaging over the center give the general inclusion.
Acknowledgment of related work. Houdayer and Marrakchi credit GPT-5.6 Sol with counterexample exploration and an initial strict-outerness proof, and GPT-6 Astra with a singular tracial-state ingredient in their resonance strategy [7], p. 7. They report checking and rewriting those proofs and retaining responsibility for their work.
Modular notation and bicentralizer inputs
The absolute proof and the relative tensor estimate use states on the bounded operators of the standard Hilbert space whose left and right marginals are prescribed and whose modular energy is concentrated at one point. We first state the resulting bicentralizer identity and the completely positive maps that shift its energy parameter.
We use standard modular theory [17] and the modular-invariance criterion for state-preserving expectations [16]. We may assume that the algebras are nonzero. Choose a faithful normal state on and extend it by ; denote both states by . Put
Scalar products are linear in the first variable. Our predual module conventions are
The left and right standard actions are denoted by and , with ; we usually omit . If is invariant under , its state-preserving expectation identifies with a subspace of . Write for that projection.
Fix a free ultrafilter on ; all state ultrapowers below are Ocneanu ultrapowers [1]. For now is a type factor. Its relative analytic bicentralizer consists of those for which strongly whenever is a bounded sequence in with . Equivalently, is the part of commuting in the state ultrapower with the centralizer of . It is modularly invariant and has a -preserving faithful normal expectation .
The flow convention. Write for the bicentralizer flow in the following logarithmic convention: an element of modular frequency , meaning , satisfies
With the multiplicative parameter of [2], this means : modular frequency corresponds to . The flow preserves and commutes with its modular action [2, 10].
Proposition 2.1 (Binormal states and spectral shifts). In this setting the following hold.
(i) If a state on satisfies
then, for ,
(ii) For each there is a unital completely positive map such that
These maps need not be normal.
Part (i) is [11], Lemma 2.1, based on the binormal-state implementation [10], Theorem 2.9. For part (ii), we combine the zero-shift map of [11], Lemma 2.2(1) with the eigenoperator characterization of the flow in [2], Theorem A(ii). The construction below determines the spectral shift in convention (1).
The shift construction. Let be the map from [11], Lemma 2.2(1), which has the properties in part (ii) for . Choose a finite row of partial isometries of modular frequency with . Such rows exist by [2], Lemma 3.4 and the proof of Theorem A(ii). Starting with bounded representing sequences , take the modularly smoothed lifts
Modular convolution commutes with passage to the ultrapower [1], Lemma 4.14; since has frequency , these are still lifts of . Translation of the convolution kernel shows that their modular orbits are uniformly norm-continuous in . Define
The row normalization makes the limit unital. The right algebra and commute with all row entries, so they are fixed. Relation (1) gives the left restriction .
For the spectral formula, the modular action passes to the ultrapower [1], Theorem 4.1. Hence, for each , strongly along ; the equicontinuity just obtained makes convergence uniform on compact -intervals. Now for . For a function of the form , with , we may therefore integrate the finite-row conjugations to obtain
Compact-uniform convergence of the row coefficients and the tail bound justify passing to the limit. Density gives the formula for all . This calculation fixes the sign and uses no normality of or .
Binormal states at a nonzero frequency. If the last hypothesis of (i) is instead , apply (i) to . The fixed right algebra belongs to the multiplicative domain of , so
The two marginals remain because and preserve it.
The absolute bicentralizer
We first use the binormal identity to settle the absolute problem. This will make the ordinary multiplication maps for a relative bicentralizer isometric in Section 4. In the absolute argument itself, averaging the modular action provides the two isometries to be compared.
Theorem 3.1. For every type factor with separable predual and every faithful normal state on , one has .
Two established facts reduce the proof to a spectral contradiction. If the absolute conjecture fails, the self-bicentralizing reduction of [6], Proposition 3.4 and Theorem 3.5, recalled in [2], gives a nontrivial type factor with separable predual and a faithful normal state satisfying
The absolute bicentralizer flow is ergodic [9], Theorem D. Neither fact assumes fullness. The averaged products, reflection, and spectral resonance below follow the architecture of [7], Propositions 8.8–8.10. Here the averaging uses the modular action, and the binormal identity supplies the comparison between the products.
Proof. Suppose that the theorem fails, and choose as in (6). Put and . Let implement on , so that . Since the flow preserves the state and commutes with its modular action, and strongly commute.
Two products after averaging. The scalar fixed algebra implies that the weak* averages of over converge to . Indeed, any cluster point is modularly invariant and has state value . We use this factorization to turn the two orders of multiplication into isometries. Let be the symmetric translation-invariant mean obtained from these interval averages as along an ultrafilter. Quotient bounded measurable -valued functions by the null space of , and complete to a Hilbert space . Define on elementary tensors
The inner products of the images of and are, respectively,
Both equal . By linearity and completion, are isometries. Translation is unitary on and satisfies
From eigenstates to the product identity. We claim that
The binormal identity first compares the two sides on vectors whose -spectrum lies in a short interval. Translation covariance then lets us combine these comparisons without accumulating an error over the intervals.
For a unit vector , define the state
The modular averages just computed give ; here . Moreover, . For modular-analytic , put , so that . The definitions of and give
These identities extend from to every by continuity. Suppose the spectral support of a sequence of unit vectors is contained in intervals shrinking to . Every weak* accumulation state of then has spectral evaluation at . By (5),
Both vectors on the left have squared norm , so their difference tends to zero.
This convergence is uniform when the centers range over a fixed compact set and the interval lengths tend to zero. Otherwise choose violating vectors and a convergent subsequence of centers, and take a weak* accumulation state. The preceding argument gives a contradiction. In this step the varying test may be replaced by its limit: the common left marginal and Cauchy–Schwarz bound the change by
which tends to zero. Thus no operator-norm continuity of is needed.
Analytic vectors are dense in , and all maps being compared are isometric. Hence the same local conclusion holds for a fixed , with replaced by . Spectral calculus gives
whenever and . Consequently, for , a fixed compact interval , and fixed , there is a function such that
when has spectral support in an interval of length at most contained in .
Translation covariance shows that commutes with the spectral projections of . For , partition into finitely many disjoint Borel intervals of length at most and write . The vectors are orthogonal, so
Letting and then using density proves (7).
Reflection forces a lattice. Define . Symmetry of makes a unitary involution on . On elementary tensors,
Similarly , where flips the input factors. Applying to (7) and composing with gives . Substitute this back into (7) and cancel the isometry to obtain
Let be the support of the joint spectral measure of . The tensor-product spectral measure has support , so the continuous phase in (8) satisfies
If contains two linearly independent points, pairing with them confines to the inverse image of under an invertible linear map. Thus is countable. If spans a non-axis line, choose a nonzero ; then , and any point satisfies . Again is countable. In both cases the joint spectral measure is supported on countably many points, so has pure point spectrum. The remaining possibilities put on a coordinate axis and give or .
Excluding the spectral alternatives. A modular action with scalar fixed algebra has no Hilbert-space eigenvectors other than multiples of ; we recall the argument of [12], Lemma 2.1. Let be the spectral projection of at . For , the bounded character averages
satisfy and . A weak* cluster point represents this vector, since converges to for every . Thus , and the separating property of gives . Density of shows that any nonzero eigenspace is detected by a nonzero such eigenoperator.
For this , both and lie in . Hence is a nonzero scalar multiple of a unitary . Since , the KMS identity gives
Therefore , and then itself is scalar. It follows that the only eigenvectors of are multiples of . They cannot span because is nontrivial. This excludes pure point spectrum, including . Finally, would make the bicentralizer flow trivial on , contradicting its ergodicity. All alternatives are excluded, proving the theorem.
The two relative products
Return to an expected inclusion with a type III factor; remains arbitrary. Keep and put
Let implement on . Since the flow preserves , these unitaries commute with the modular implementation on . The absolute theorem makes multiplication in either order isometric. This will let us compare the two products on the fixed Hilbert space .
Lemma 4.1. The expectations satisfy
Consequently the maps
extend to isometries from to .
Proof. Applying to the asymptotic commutation condition gives , by Theorem 3.1. State preservation determines the scalar. For and ,
which characterizes . Using for the first product and for the second gives
Polarization and completion prove the assertion.
Define the contraction and the unitary on by
Thus
Our goal is . The next section compares arbitrarily long words in these operators on vectors with narrowly supported total modular energy. Section 6 will turn that uniform estimate into the exact identity.
An estimate uniform in total modular energy
For , work on . Let act on the th copy of , and let act on that copy together with the common last factor . Write for the total modular generator on . For arbitrary real numbers , set
Here every acts on alone. Replacing each in by gives , because those unitaries commute with all the shifts.
Proposition 5.1 (Uniform energy estimate). For every there is a function with as such that
for every , every , and every unit vector whose -spectral support lies in an interval of length . The same function works for all these choices and for all positions of the interval.
The estimate must remain uniform even when both the tensor length and the shifts vary. To achieve this, we express a coefficient of through a state on the single algebra . The state will have fixed left and right marginals, while its modular distribution records the sum . Proposition 2.1(i) can then be applied in one fixed state space.
For , define a kernel by
where the operators are obtained backwards:
The operators here act on by left multiplication.
Lemma 5.2 (The iterated kernel). Formula (15) defines a unital completely positive map , possibly nonnormal. It satisfies
For modular-analytic , put , so that . Then, for and ,
Proof.
Construction and marginals. Take finitely many elementary tensors. For , apply the recurrence simultaneously to their two indices. At each stage the operator matrix is multiplied on the left and right by the adjoint and the original of the diagonal matrix of that position’s labels. Its positivity is preserved, and complete positivity of preserves it at the next stage. Taking the final coefficients therefore gives a positive scalar kernel. For , the identity reduces this kernel to
the Gram kernel of the elementary tensors. Applying positivity to now bounds the quadratic form by times the tensor norm squared. Thus the form depends only on the tensor vector, extends to the completion, and defines a positive unital map. The same argument with an additional matrix index proves complete positivity.
For , the first map produces with state value . At a subsequent stage, an element is replaced by . Its state value is
using . Iterating this scalar identity gives the left marginal in (16). For the right marginal, the full right algebra is fixed by each , hence belongs to its multiplicative domain. Right multipliers commute with the labels and pass through every stage, while factors the labels as above. For , use and the fact that the fixed projection also belongs to every map’s multiplicative domain. Since , the recurrence gives the same Gram kernel as for . These computations establish all of (16).
The modular unitary group. First extend the spectral formula for each individual from to the functions . Its restriction to is a homomorphism, so that algebra belongs to its multiplicative domain. For , it follows that
The ranges of these cutoffs span a dense subspace of . Consequently ; these unitaries also belong to the multiplicative domain. No limiting operation has been passed through .
In the kernel recurrence, commute to the right across each , using . The next map replaces the left factor by its state value. The resulting coefficient is
which proves
A nonnormal map need not preserve weak operator integrals, so this identity alone does not yet justify (17). We next show that the coefficient states needed to recover continuous functions are supported inside a compact spectral interval.
Spectral cutoffs and continuous functions. Call bandlimited if it admits a finite bound such that, for every interval ,
Such elements are strongly dense. Indeed, convolve the modular action with an approximate identity having smooth, compactly supported Fourier transforms. If the Fourier support of a smoothing kernel lies in , the resulting element has the displayed transfer property: testing against scalar Fourier kernels shows that spectral pieces separated by more than have zero matrix coefficient.
Two operations in the kernel preserve a suitable interval on which a positive operator vanishes. Suppose that annihilates the spectral subspace associated with an open interval . For , , so the multiplicative-domain identity gives
The cutoff ranges span the spectral subspace for ; thus annihilates that translated interval. If has transfer in , the preceding transfer rule also shows that annihilates every interval with .
Apply these rules to a diagonal kernel with bandlimited labels , of transfer bounds , starting from . Translating by each and shrinking by each leaves an open interval about zero whenever
The final operator then annihilates , whose modular energy is zero. Hence its diagonal kernel coefficient vanishes. For a finite sum of bandlimited elementary tensors, choose one that works for every term; positivity and Cauchy–Schwarz make the off-diagonal coefficients vanish as well. These tensor sums form a dense subspace of .
For a unit vector in this subspace, set and . We have proved . Cauchy–Schwarz therefore yields
The transfer property applied to also puts in the -spectral subspace for . Our choice of therefore places the spectral distribution of on in as well. Both sides of (19), evaluated on , are thus determined by functions restricted to this same compact interval. Finite linear combinations of the exponentials form a uniformly dense self-adjoint algebra in . Uniform approximation now proves
Continuity in and polarization prove (17) on the whole tensor product. The radius may depend on the labels, shifts, and tensor length: only the resulting exact identity will enter the uniform estimate.
The word coefficient. First, (11) and state preservation of give
The identity follows first for and then by density. It shows that moving an output test backwards through keeps its last factor in . To compute a word coefficient, take elementary tensors and record the adjoints of the successive test labels as
Each belongs to . Because the right multiplier is fixed and lies in the multiplicative domain of every , the recurrence for gives . Its final coefficient is .
The same recurrence computes the coefficient of backwards from its output vector. Moving the output test across applies , and (11) moves it across by replacing with . The last coefficient is again . This proves (18) for elementary tensors; linearity and continuity give the general case. □
Proof of Proposition 5.1. First restrict to data for which the spectral support of on lies in . The state
has both marginals equal to and satisfies . By (17), along any sequence of such data with , every weak* accumulation state satisfies for . Proposition 2.1(i), applied to the fixed operator , and (18) give
for every modular-analytic . Since is a contraction,
so this difference tends to zero. Density of analytic vectors and contractivity give the same conclusion for each fixed . The conclusion is uniform in , the shifts, and : otherwise a sequence of violating choices would have an accumulation state in the state space of the same algebra and contradict the argument just given.
For the ideal word, the same spectral localization gives
Combining these bounds proves the centered estimate. Finally suppose the -support of lies in any interval of length . Choose so that the containing interval for is centered at zero, and replace the final shift by . This replaces and by and . Their difference has the same norm, and the input vector is unchanged. The centered estimate therefore proves (14) with all the asserted uniformity. □
Repeated tensor tests
We now prove that the comparison is exact, using only the uniform estimate and the operator structure in (12)–(13). A discrepancy between and makes their average lose squared norm. Yet arbitrarily long words in these averages remain uniformly close, after time averaging, to the ideal unitary words. Random recentering will capture the discrepancy with a nonsummable sequence of probabilities, forcing more total norm loss than is available. The sampling must control the approximation error as well as detect the discrepancy; independent sampling provides the same probability factor in both estimates.
Lemma 6.1 (Hybrid words and time averaging). The estimate (14) holds with the same modulus if any subset of the is replaced by , or if all are replaced by . For every there is a probability density on such that, for every unit without a spectral support restriction,
The statement includes the hybrid and averaged words.
Proof. If no remains, the word equals . Otherwise disintegrate the replaced positions over their -spectral variables. On a fiber with values , each replaced acts as the shift on , and the sum of the remaining energies lies in the original interval translated by . The interval’s length is unchanged. The fiber vector in the remaining positions need not be a simple tensor: Proposition 5.1 applies to every such vector, with the same last factor . If a fiber has spectral multiplicity, expand in an orthonormal basis of that multiplicity space and sum the homogeneous squared bounds. Integrating proves the hybrid assertion. Convex expansion proves the assertion for ; the coefficients of the expansion sum to one, independently of .
Choose an even real -normalized smooth function supported in an interval of length , and put , with unitarily normalized Fourier transform. For the bounded operator , vector-valued Plancherel gives
Here Plancherel is applied to and then to its image under the bounded operator ; no commutation of with is required. The Fourier sign does not matter with this choice of . Each vector on the right is spectrally localized as required by (14), and
Apply the homogeneous form of that estimate and integrate.
Theorem 6.2. For the operators in (10), one has .
Proof. Suppose otherwise. Density of compact-spectrum vectors gives unit vectors and with and . By strong continuity there are and such that
Use this fixed in Lemma 6.1. Choose so that , and choose with
The repeated experiment. Fix a finite terminal length . On one product probability space choose with density and mutually independent parameters
all independent of . At position put the fresh input . Starting with on , propagate using . Let denote the result after positions, and let be the ideal result with in place of . Since commutes with the shifts on ,
Condition on every parameter other than . Then is a fixed unit vector, the input is , and the successive conjugations form an averaged word with fixed shifts summing to zero. Lemma 6.1 therefore gives
For , both vectors are .
A definite loss at each captured test. At step , insert the fresh position into and apply on ; call this input . Let be the analogous input formed from . The parallelogram identity and contractivity give
Define the random projection
where the first factor is a scalar indicator and the second acts on the previous positions. For , interpret as zero. The projection commutes with , and the last-position shifts. Put
We claim
Here integrates all parameters involved, including .
For (24), disintegrate the previous ideal vector over . Its last factor is , and . The interval lies in , so the probability over of capturing it is exactly , as illustrated in Figure 1. For , the probability over of is . On these fibers the current last factor is , so (21) applies. Integrating, and using the mass at least of , proves (24).

Figure 1. Capture at step , shown schematically. For an ideal spectral value , the entire capture interval lies in the sampling interval, giving probability . The actual propagated error has no assumed spectral bound; for any of its spectral values the capture probability is at most .
For (25), fix and all parameters from the previous steps, so that is fixed. No spectral support bound on this error is available. For every real ,
The spectral theorem therefore gives the quadratic-form inequality
Also for every fixed . The two current sampling parameters are independent of each other and of the past. The fresh vector has norm one, while commutes with and does not affect its norm. Consequently
Now integrate over and the past parameters to obtain
by (22). Since , this proves the claim.
The contradiction. Since commutes with the step operators, . The triangle inequality in the mean-square Hilbert space, followed by (23), shows that the expected squared-norm loss at step is at least
The constant in parentheses is positive. On the other hand, inserting a unit fresh vector and applying the outer shift do not change norm. The losses therefore telescope from one and have total at most one. Since , choosing sufficiently many steps contradicts (26). Hence .
The continuous core and the general inclusion
The multiplication identity now determines the fixed points of the bicentralizer flow in the core. We recall why the core fixed-point equality yields an amenable subalgebra, then prove that equality in coordinates adapted to . The final reduction passes from factors to an arbitrary center and invokes the existing amenable-subalgebra theorem.
The core criterion. For a type III bottom factor, the bicentralizer in the core and its flow have the following description. Here uses the same asymptotic commutation condition on bounded sequences in , with the state on . In the realization , with group unitaries , one has
The algebra identity is [10], Proposition 7.2; the action extends the flow on as in [10], Proposition 8.6, proof. One inclusion in the desired fixed-point equality is automatic:
This inclusion follows by combining [10], Proposition 8.1 and its proof, Theorem 6.20(5), and Proposition 8.4. We will prove the reverse inclusion. Equality is equivalent to the relative bicentralizer conjecture by [10], Proposition 8.6. For an expected inclusion, that conjecture is equivalent to the weak Dixmier property for :
With separable preduals, (29) is equivalent to the conclusion of Theorem 1.1, by [10], Theorem D.
Proposition 7.1. If is a type III factor, then
Proof.
The algebra generated by and . By Theorem 6.2, is unitary. Since are isometries, this implies , so their ranges agree. Put . The common range is : it contains , is invariant under left by its description and under left by its description, and is contained in . Applying adjoints gives invariance under the generated von Neumann algebra. Both and are modularly invariant, so the expected algebra has a canonically embedded core inside .
Coordinates adapted to . Use to identify with . In these coordinates left acts as , left acts as , and the modular group is
Represent faithfully on with constant base algebra and group unitaries
where is the translation representation. This is the usual regular crossed-product representation after conjugating its variable base algebra by the modular implementation. Conjugate by on the first two positions. This removes the twist from the action of , which now acts on alone, and transfers it to the core of . Since commutes with , the algebra is represented, at spectral value , by
The two transformations in (30) are the same flow: on it is , and on it multiplies by . Thus these fibers are a fixed normal representation of composed with the core bicentralizer flow at , by (27). More explicitly, if and is the fixed regular representation on , the representation of an element is
This normal direct-integral representation agrees with (30) on generators, so the formula applies to the entire crossed product.
The fixed algebra. If is fixed by the core bicentralizer flow, then in every fiber. It therefore acts on alone, while acts on alone. Hence it commutes with , proving
The opposite inclusion is (28), so the fixed algebras agree.
Proof of Theorem 1.1.
Factor bottom algebras. For a type III bottom factor, Proposition 7.1 and [10], Proposition 8.6 and Theorem D give the weak Dixmier property (29). The state on is a strictly semifinite weight, as required there. For a bottom factor of any other type, the same weak Dixmier property is [10], Proposition 4.11. These factor cases allow arbitrary upper algebras.
Disintegration over the center. For a general , put and . The passage to makes central in both algebras, so that we can apply the factor cases fiber by fiber. The modular action of fixes pointwise. Consequently is modularly invariant, and restricts to a faithful normal expectation . Moreover,
inside the chosen core, by [10], Proposition 4.7.
Disintegrate over the common central algebra , using the probability measure determined by . The bottom fibers are factors because ; the upper fibers need not be factors. The simultaneous disintegration theorem for operator-valued weights gives faithful normal fiber expectations and compatible faithful state fibers [8], Propositions 2.1–2.2 and Theorem 2.3. Indeed, is -bimodular, and its fiber weights satisfy , so they are conditional expectations. The state identity and the modular actions also disintegrate, as in the proof of that theorem.
To see the resulting core compatibility, write , where . The regular representation of the core on is given by
Both formulas act fiberwise. A countable family of algebra generators and the rational translation parameters generate the fiber cores; the common central algebra is already present in the representation. Thus with the corresponding copies of . Separability supplies these standard measurable fields. The factor cases and the direct-integral criterion [10], Proposition 4.12 now give the weak Dixmier property for .
Averaging into the central commutant. We have proved the weak Dixmier property inside . To apply it to an arbitrary , we first average into this smaller core. The weak* compact convex hull of its orbit under is preserved by the commuting affine maps , . The compact-convex fixed-point theorem for commuting affine maps gives a common fixed point . One can obtain it by taking rectangular Cesàro averages for each finite family of commuting maps, then using compactness and the finite-intersection property. Since , this point belongs to the weak* closed convex -orbit hull of . That hull is -invariant. Applying weak Dixmier averaging inside therefore produces a point of still in the original hull. This proves (29) for the original inclusion.
The amenable subalgebra. Finally [10], Theorem D, (3)(4) supplies an amenable subalgebra with a faithful normal conditional expectation and . The expectation is faithful and normal by the meaning of “with expectation” in that theorem. Unitality is automatic: if , bimodularity would imply , contradicting faithfulness. This proves the result.
References
- [1]H. Ando and U. Haagerup, Ultraproducts of von Neumann algebras, J. Funct. Anal. 266 (2014), no. 12, 6842–6913. arXiv:1212.5457v3.arxiv.org/abs/1212.5457
- [2]H. Ando, U. Haagerup, C. Houdayer, and A. Marrakchi, Structure of bicentralizer algebras and inclusions of type III factors, Math. Ann. 376 (2020), 1145–1194. arXiv:1804.05706v2.DOI
- [3]A. Connes, Classification des facteurs, in Operator Algebras and Applications, Part 2 (Kingston, Ontario, 1980), Proc. Sympos. Pure Math. 38, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1982, 43–109.
- [4]A. Connes, Factors of type III₁, property L′λ, and closure of inner automorphisms, J. Operator Theory 14 (1985), 189–211.
- [5]U. Haagerup, Connes’ bicentralizer problem and uniqueness of the injective factor of type III₁, Acta Math. 158 (1987), 95–148. doi:10.1007/BF02392257.DOI
- [6]C. Houdayer and Y. Isono, Unique prime factorization and bicentralizer problem for a class of type III factors, Adv. Math. 305 (2017), 402–455. arXiv:1503.01388v3.DOI
- [7]C. Houdayer and A. Marrakchi, The classification of flows on II₁ factors and Connes’ bicentralizer problem, 2026, version 1, September 10, 2026. arXiv:2609.11462v1.
- [8]R. Ichihara and S. Kawakami, Disintegration of operator valued weights, Scientiae Mathematicae Japonicae Online e-2007 (2007), 693–699. Publisher PDF.
- [9]A. Marrakchi, Full factors, bicentralizer flow and approximately inner automorphisms, Invent. Math. 222 (2020), 375–398. arXiv:1811.10253v2.arxiv.org/abs/1811.10253
- [10]A. Marrakchi, Kadison’s problem for type III subfactors and the bicentralizer conjecture, Invent. Math. 239 (2025), 79–163. arXiv:2308.15163v3.arxiv.org/abs/2308.15163
- [11]A. Marrakchi, Kadison’s problem and ergodicity of the bicentralizer flow, 2026, version 2, 11 August 2026. arXiv:2606.26366v2.
- [12]A. Marrakchi and S. Vaes, Ergodic states on type III₁ factors and ergodic actions, J. Reine Angew. Math. 809 (2024), 247–260. arXiv:2305.14217v3.
- [13]T. Masuda, An analogue of Connes–Haagerup approach for classification of subfactors of type III₁, J. Math. Soc. Japan 57 (2005), 959–1001. doi:10.2969/jmsj/1150287301.
- [14]OpenAI, Bounded recovery for modular spectral averages, OpenAI Math Release preprint OAI:Bounded-recovery-for-modular-spectral-averages-September-23-2026, 2026.
- [15]S. Popa, On a problem of R. V. Kadison on maximal abelian ∗-subalgebras in factors, Invent. Math. 65 (1981), 269–281. doi:10.1007/BF01389015.DOI
- [16]M. Takesaki, Conditional expectations in von Neumann algebras, J. Funct. Anal. 9 (1972), 306–321. doi:10.1016/0022-1236(72)90004-3.DOI
- [17]M. Takesaki, Theory of Operator Algebras II, Encyclopaedia of Mathematical Sciences 125, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2003. doi:10.1007/978-3-662-10451-4.DOI