betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Magnetic quadrupole transitions in the relativistic energy density functional theory

Abstract

Background: Magnetic quadrupole (M2) excitation represents a fundamental feature in atomic nucleus associated to nuclear magnetism induced by spin and orbital transition operator. So far it has only been investigated within the non-relativistic theoretical approaches, and available experimental data are rather limited. Purpose: We aim to investigate the properties of M2 transitions in closed and open-shell nuclei using the framework of relativistic nuclear energy density functional. The calculated M2 transition strengths could be used to constrain the quenching of the spin gyromagnetic factors. Methods: The M2 excitations are described using the relativistic quasiparticle random phase approximation (RQRPA) with the residual interaction extended with the isovector-pseudovector term. Results: The M2 transition strength distributions are described and analyzed for closed and open shell nuclei. The results are compared with available experimental data and the strength missing from the experiment is discussed. The evolution of M2 transition properties has been investigated within the 36−64Ca^{36-64} \rm Ca isotope chain. Conclusion: The main M2 transitions have rather rich underlying structure and their collectivity increases with the mass number due to larger number of contributing particle-hole configurations. Pairing correlations in open shell nuclei have strong effect, causing the M2 strength reduction and shifting of the centroid energies to higher values. The analysis of M2 transition strengths indicate that considerable amount of experimental strength may be missing, mainly due to limitations to rather restricted energy ranges. The calculated M2 strengths for Ca isotopes, together with the future experimental data will allow constraining the quenching of the gg factors in nuclear medium.

Introduction

Magnetic transitions probe the spin and isospin degrees of freedom of atomic nucleus and provide valuable information for a variety of nuclear properties. A major interest in nuclear magnetic transitions is strongly focused on dipole (M1) excitations which was subject of a variety of previous studies: for details, see Refs. [1, 2, 3, 4] and references therein. However, the knowledge on higher multipole magnetic transitions, especially magnetic quadrupole (M2) transitions and respective giant-quadrupole resonances (GQR) is rather limited, both from theoretical and experimental side. Several experimental studies [5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16] have elaborated highly fragmented M2 structure whose strength ∑BM2(E)\sum B_{M2}(E) is strongly suppressed compared to the theoretical results obtained either in shell model or random-phase approximation (RPA) [6, 11, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24].

Theoretical models which investigate excitations based on nuclear fluid-dynamics [25, 26, 27, 28] predicted activation of the twist mode, attributed to the orbital transitions caused by an effective rotation operator around zz-axis, that has also been experimentally studied in Ref. [29]. In this mode, nucleon orbitals as different fluid layers rotate in opposite directions, namely for z>0z > 0 layers rotate counterclockwise while for z<0z < 0 they rotate clockwise. Consistency check and comparison between different theoretical models can be done using sum-rule approaches, e.g., those developed in Refs. [30, 31, 32, 33, 34]. The M2 giant resonances have also been studied in early study both theoretically and experimentally in 38Si^{38}\mathrm{Si}, 90Zr^{90}\mathrm{Zr}, and 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}, using simplified particle-hole model, indicating mass-dependent quenching of the spin gyromagnetic factor gsg_s [35]. Mass-dependent quenching of magnetic transitions in nuclei has also been addressed in the model where spin-isospin core polarization is treated using dimesic function techniques [36]. It has been shown that the quenching effect increases with increasing mass number, in agreement with the experimental findings [36]. In high resolution electron scattering the isovector M2 transitions have been studied in 42,44Ca^{42,44}\mathrm{Ca} [37]. In Ref. [38] quasiparticle phonon model has been employed in studies of M2 transition probabilities in odd-A Sn isotopes. Apart of M2 excitations, higher multipoles λ>2\lambda> 2 [39], even going toward M8 [40] or higher spin states like M12 and M14 have been experimentally studied [41, 42]. In several theoretical studies with the non-relativistic methods [11], a wide fragmentation of the M2 mode can be described only by considering the two-particle-two-hole (2p2h) components.

The aim of this work is to provide the first relativistic-microscopic analysis of nuclear M2 transitions in the energy density functional (EDF) framework, and explore their relevance for possible constraining the quenching of the spin gyromagnetic factor. We have focused on M2 electromagnetic excitations composed from 1p-1h transitions, from 0+0^{+} ground state (GS) to 2−2^{-} excited state of even-even nuclei, based on the formalism of the relativistic EDF theory. In this approach, the ground state is described with the Relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov (RHB) model [43], and M2 transitions are investigated within the relativistic quasiparticle random phase approximation (RQRPA) recently extended for studies of magnetic transitions [44, 45]. The overview of the RHB model and the RQRPA is elaborated in § 2. A general expression for MλM\lambda transitions and other observables are given in § 2 A. The results for quadrupole magnetic transitions in specified nuclear systems 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} and 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}, as well as Ca isotope chain are presented in Sec. III. Section III D is dedicated to pairing effects on M2 transitions in open-shell nuclei 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 42Ca^{42}\mathrm{Ca}, 56Fe^{56}\mathrm{Fe} and 90Zr^{90}\mathrm{Zr}. The summary and conclusions are given in § 4.

Formalism

Theory framework employed in this work follows the formalism based on relativistic energy density functional recently developed in studies of M1 transitions [44, 45]. The nuclear ground state represents the basis for studies of excitations, and it is described by employing self-consistent RHB model as given in Ref. [43], with point-coupling interactions. The corresponding parameterizations employed in this study are DD-PC1 [46] and more recent parameterization DD-PCX [47] constrained not only by the nuclear ground state properties, but also by using the isoscalar giant monopole resonance excitation energy and dipole polarizability in 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}.

To describe M2 transitions in nuclei, we employ the RQRPA based on the point coupling interaction, that contains an additional relativistic isovector-pseudovector (IV-PV) contact type of residual interaction to account for the unnatural parity transitions [44], given as an effective Lagrangian density,

LIV−PV=−12αIV−PV[ΨˉNγ5γμτ⃗ΨN][ΨˉNγ5γμτ⃗ΨN].(1)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{IV-PV}}=-\frac{1}{2}\alpha_{\mathrm{IV-PV}}\left[\bar{\Psi}_{N}\gamma^{5}\gamma^{\mu}\vec{\tau}\Psi_{N}\right]\left[\bar{\Psi}_{N}\gamma_{5}\gamma_{\mu}\vec{\tau}\Psi_{N}\right]. \tag*{(1)}

For the DD-PC1 interaction, the IV-PV coupling constant has previously been constrained to αIV−PV=0.53⋅197=104.41 MeV fm3\alpha_{\mathrm{IV-PV}}=0.53\cdot197=104.41\,\mathrm{MeV\,fm}^{3} by minimizing relative error Δ≲1 MeV\Delta\lesssim1\,\mathrm{MeV} between experimental M1 excitation peak and theoretical centroid energies for magic nuclei 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} and 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} [44]. The same procedure is performed

in this study for the DD-PCX interaction, resulting with αIV−PV=0.63⋅197=124.11 MeV fm3\alpha_{\mathrm{IV-PV}}=0.63\cdot197=124.11\,\mathrm{MeV\,fm}^{3}. In this way all the model parameters of the relativistic effective Lagrangian density are fixed for M2 transitions.

For open shell nuclei, pairing correlations are described by using phenomenological Gogny interaction [48] implemented as in Ref. [49],

Vpp(1,2)=∑i=1,2e−(r⃗1−r⃗2μi)2(Wi+Biρ^−HiP^σ−MiP^τ),(2)V^{pp}(1,2)=\sum_{i=1,2}e^{-\left(\frac{\vec{r}_{1}-\vec{r}_{2}}{\mu_{i}}\right)^{2}}\left(W_{i}+B_{i}\hat{\rho}-H_{i}\hat{P}^{\sigma}-M_{i}\hat{P}^{\tau}\right), \tag*{(2)}

with parameters μi\mu_i, WiW_i, BiB_i, HiH_i, and MiM_i (i=1,2i=1,2) from the D1S set [48]. The VppV^{pp} particle - particle correlations in the RQRPA residual interaction has the same phenomenological Gogny form and parameterization as in the ground state calculation using the RHB model.

Magnetic transitions

In the general (Q)RPA framework, the λ\lambda-mode strength B(λ,ωi)B(\lambda,\omega_i) is represented by a discrete spectrum, where ℏωi\hbar\omega_i indicates the iith eigenenergy. The discrete strength B(λ,ωi)B(\lambda,\omega_i) of operator q^λν\hat{q}_{\lambda\nu} (−λ≤ν≤λ-\lambda\leq\nu\leq\lambda) for spherical systems is calculated as follows [49]:

\begin{aligned} B(\lambda,\omega_i)&=\left|\sum_{j_kj_{k'}}\left(X^{i,\lambda0}_{j_kj_{k'}}\langle j_k||\hat{q}_{\lambda}||j_{k'}\rangle\right.\\ &\quad\left.+(-1)^{j_k-j_{k'}+\lambda}Y^{i,\lambda0}_{j_kj_{k'}}\langle j_k'||\hat{q}_{\lambda}||j_k\rangle\right)\\ &\quad\times\left(u_{j_k}v_{j_{k'}}+(-1)^{\lambda}v_{j_k}u_{j_{k'}}\right)\right|^{2}, \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

where jkj_k and jk′j_{k'} are quantum numbers of angular momentum for single-particle (SP) states in the canonical basis. The ujku_{j_k} and vjkv_{j_k} are the RHB occupation coefficients, whereas Xjkjk′i,λ0X^{i,\lambda0}_{j_kj_{k'}} and Yjkjk′i,λ0Y^{i,\lambda0}_{j_kj_{k'}} are the corresponding (Q)RPA amplitudes [49].

The MλM\lambda operator in the relativistic formalism, which acts on Hilbert space with mixed spin-isospin basis, is given in a block diagonal form [44]. That is,

μ^λν=∑k=1A(μ^λν(IS)(11)k00μ^λν(IS)(22)k)⊗1τ(k)−∑k=1A(μ^λν(IV)(11)k00μ^λν(IV)(22)k)⊗τ^3(k),(4)\hat{\mu}_{\lambda\nu}=\sum_{k=1}^{A}\begin{pmatrix}\hat{\mu}^{(IS)}_{\lambda\nu}(11)_k&0\\0&\hat{\mu}^{(IS)}_{\lambda\nu}(22)_k\end{pmatrix}\otimes\mathbb{1}_{\tau}(k)-\sum_{k=1}^{A}\begin{pmatrix}\hat{\mu}^{(IV)}_{\lambda\nu}(11)_k&0\\0&\hat{\mu}^{(IV)}_{\lambda\nu}(22)_k\end{pmatrix}\otimes\hat{\tau}_{3}(k), \tag*{(4)}

where 1τ\mathbb{1}_{\tau} and τ^3\hat{\tau}_{3} are the unit and Pauli matrices in the isospin space. The μ^λν(IS)\hat{\mu}^{(IS)}_{\lambda\nu} and μ^λν(IV)\hat{\mu}^{(IV)}_{\lambda\nu} correspond to the isoscalar (IS) and isovector (IV) part of the MλM\lambda operator for kkth nucleon [50]. That is,

μ^λν(IS,IV)(11)k=μ^λν(IS,IV)(22)k=μNℏ(2λ+1gℓ(IS,IV)ℓ^k+gs(IS,IV)s^k)×∇[rλYλν(Ωk)].(5)\begin{aligned} \hat{\mu}^{(IS,IV)}_{\lambda\nu}(11)_k=\hat{\mu}^{(IS,IV)}_{\lambda\nu}(22)_k &=\frac{\mu_N}{\hbar}\left(\frac{2}{\lambda+1}g_{\ell}^{(IS,IV)}\hat{\ell}_k+g_{s}^{(IS,IV)}\hat{s}_k\right)\\ &\quad\times\nabla\left[r^{\lambda}Y_{\lambda\nu}(\Omega_k)\right]. \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

The empirical gyromagnetic factors for the bare proton (neutron) are given as gℓπ(ν)=1g_{\ell}^{\pi(\nu)} = 1 (0), and gsπ(ν)=5.586g_{s}^{\pi(\nu)} = 5.586 (−3.826-3.826) [51], expressed in the nuclear-magneton unit μN=eℏ/2mN\mu_N = e\hbar/2m_N. Since calculations are performed in the mixed spin-isospin basis, the isoscalar and isovector gyromagnetic factors are given separately for the orbital and spin components. Namely,

gℓIS=gℓπ+gℓν2=0.5,gsIS=gsπ+gsν2=0.880,(6)g_{\ell}^{IS} = \frac{g_{\ell}^{\pi} + g_{\ell}^{\nu}}{2} = 0.5,\qquad g_{s}^{IS} = \frac{g_{s}^{\pi} + g_{s}^{\nu}}{2} = 0.880, \tag*{(6)}

for the IS mode, whereas

gℓIV=gℓπ−gℓν2=0.5,gsIV=gsπ−gsν2=4.706,(7)g_{\ell}^{IV} = \frac{g_{\ell}^{\pi} - g_{\ell}^{\nu}}{2} = 0.5,\qquad g_{s}^{IV} = \frac{g_{s}^{\pi} - g_{s}^{\nu}}{2} = 4.706, \tag*{(7)}

for the IV mode.

The M2 transition strength from the R(Q)RPA is given as

BM2(Ei)=∣βM2IS(Ei)+βM2IV(Ei)∣2.(8)B_{M2}(E_i) = \left|\beta_{M2}^{IS}(E_i) + \beta_{M2}^{IV}(E_i)\right|^2. \tag*{(8)}

Here the IV-M2 amplitude is determined as

βM2IV(Ei)=∑jkjk′(Xjkjk′i+(−1)jk−jk′Yjkjk′i)(ujkvjk′+vjkujk′)⟨jk′∥μ^λ=2(IV)∥jk⟩τIV,(9)\beta_{M2}^{IV}(E_i) = \sum_{j_kj_{k'}} \left(X_{j_kj_{k'}}^i + (-1)^{j_k-j_{k'}}Y_{j_kj_{k'}}^i\right) \left(u_{j_k}v_{j_{k'}} + v_{j_k}u_{j_{k'}}\right) \langle j_{k'}\Vert\hat{\mu}_{\lambda=2}^{(IV)}\Vert j_k\rangle\tau_{IV}, \tag*{(9)}

with τIV=1\tau_{IV} = 1 (−1-1) for neutrons (protons). On the other side, the IS-M2 amplitude reads

βM2(IS)(Ei)=∑jkjk′(Xjkjk′i+(−1)jk−jk′Yjkjk′i)(ujkvjk′+vjkujk′)⟨jk′∥μ^λ=2(IS)∥jk⟩.(10)\beta_{M2}^{(IS)}(E_i) = \sum_{j_kj_{k'}} \left(X_{j_kj_{k'}}^i + (-1)^{j_k-j_{k'}}Y_{j_kj_{k'}}^i\right) \left(u_{j_k}v_{j_{k'}} + v_{j_k}u_{j_{k'}}\right) \langle j_{k'}\Vert\hat{\mu}_{\lambda=2}^{(IS)}\Vert j_k\rangle. \tag*{(10)}

In addition, the spin-M2 strength BM2σB_{M2}^{\sigma} and the orbital-M2 strength BM2ℓB_{M2}^{\ell} are obtained by retaining only the spin and orbital part of the M2M2 transition operator, respectively.

The moments mkm_k of discrete-strength distributions are defined as [49]

mk=∑iBM2(Ei)Eik.(11)m_k = \sum_i B_{M2}(E_i)E_i^k. \tag*{(11)}

The non-energy-weighted (NEW) moment, m0m_0, corresponds to the total summation of the transition strength, whereas m1m_1 is the energy-weighted (EW) summation of BM2B_{M2} values. The centroid energy is obtained as Eˉ=m1/m0\bar{E} = m_1/m_0, which represents an average energy of calculated strength distribution. The (Q)RPA response function RM2(E)R_{M2}(E) is defined as [49],

RM2(E)=∑iBM2(Ei)1πΓ/2(E−ℏωi)2+(Γ/2)2,(12)R_{M2}(E) = \sum_i B_{M2}(E_i)\frac{1}{\pi}\frac{\Gamma/2}{(E-\hbar\omega_i)^2+(\Gamma/2)^2}, \tag*{(12)}

where the discrete spectrum is smoothed by the Lorentzian distribution using the width Γ=1.0\Gamma= 1.0 MeV. Note that the width of the individual excitation can not

be considered in this framework, and further developments going beyond the (Q)RPA are required [52, 53].

For the discussion of our results, we also mention the Weisskopf estimate for the transition strength, that corresponds to the single-particle (SP) electric or magnetic transition [54, 55]. The Weisskopf estimate for the proton’s MλM\lambda strength is

BSP−Mλ≅1+(gsπ/2)2π(3λ+3)2R02λ−2μN2(13)B_{SP-M\lambda} \cong\frac{1+(g_s^{\pi}/2)^2}{\pi}\left(\frac{3}{\lambda+3}\right)^2 R_0^{2\lambda-2}\mu_N^2 \tag*{(13)}

with R0≡1.2A1/3R_0 \equiv1.2A^{1/3} fm. Note that the first factor is replaced to (gsν/2)2/π(g_s^{\nu}/2)^2/\pi for neutrons. Thus, the SP-M2 strength is roughly proportional to A2/3A^{2/3}, where AA is the mass number. That is,

BSP−M2≃1.45A2/3 μN2fm2.(14)B_{SP-M2} \simeq1.45A^{2/3}\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2. \tag*{(14)}

This is used as the M2 Weisskopf unit. For one excited state with the strength BM2(E)B_{M2}(E), the ratio of BM2(E)/BSP−M2B_{M2}(E)/B_{SP-M2} gives a rough estimate of the number of excited nucleons.

Results and Discussions

In this work the 0+→2−0^+ \rightarrow2^- transitions induced by the M2 operator have been evaluated for spherical nuclei. Calculated results are compared either with available experimental data, different theoretical approaches or both.

M2 transitions in 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}

As the first example, we investigate the doubly magic nucleus 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} with the RRPA with DD-PC1 interaction [46] Figure 1 shows the corresponding M2 strength distributions, including RM2R_{M2} (full), RM2(IS)R^{(\mathrm{IS})}_{M2}, and RM2(IV)R^{(\mathrm{IV})}_{M2}. The centroid energy of the full response amounts E‾=16.55\overline{E} = 16.55 MeV. The full M2 strength distribution is composed of two main excitation peaks, namely, low-energy peak at ≈8\approx8 MeV, and higher one at ≈17.5\approx17.5 MeV. One can also observe that the transition strength is dominated by the IV response, while the IS transitions have small contribution being visible only at high-energy region of the spectra. This dominance is mainly due to the spin gg factors: gsIV>gsISg_s^{\mathrm{IV}} > g_s^{\mathrm{IS}}. In order to assess the role of the residual RRPA interaction, the unperturbed Hartree response is also shown for comparison with the full calculation. Clearly, the residual interaction considerably modifies the unperturbed spectra, resulting in shifts of the energies of the two main peaks. We also calculate the NEW sum of the transition strength up to 50 MeV. That reads m0=∑BM2=1534.58m_0 = \sum B_{M2} = 1534.58, whereas ∑BM2(IV)=1453.83\sum B_{M2}^{(\mathrm{IV})} = 1453.83, and ∑BM2(IS)=73.59\sum B_{M2}^{(\mathrm{IS})} = 73.59 in the unit of μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2. This again confirms the dominance of IV component.

We decompose the full M2 strength distribution into the spin and orbital components in order to assess the relevance of their contributions. The corresponding spin and orbital response functions, RM2σ(E)R^\sigma_{M2}(E) and RM2ℓ(E)R^\ell_{M2}(E), are shown in Figure 1. One clearly reads that the spin response dominates over the orbital one through the whole energy range. However, the interference between those contributions is complicated. At the low-lying peak at 8.6 MeV, the spin-M2 response is larger than the total response. At the higher energies, the opposite result is obtained. By symbolically writing, the total response is determined as the absolute square of the two transition amplitudes, i.e.,

M2 strength distributions for $^{16}\mathrm{O}$

Figure 1. (Top) The M2 strength distribution for 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} based on the RRPA with DD-PC1 interaction: RM2(E)R_{M2}(E), RM2(IS)(E)R^{(\mathrm{IS})}_{M2}(E), and RM2(IV)(E)R^{(\mathrm{IV})}_{M2}(E) represent the full, IS, and IV-M2 response functions, respectively. The unperturbed full response at the Hartree level is also shown. (Middle) The same plot but for the RM2(E)R_{M2}(E) (full), RM2σ(E)R^\sigma_{M2}(E) (spin) and RM2ℓ(E)R^\ell_{M2}(E) (orbital) response functions for 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. (Bottom) The discrete M2-strength distribution for 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. Experiments A and B indicate Refs. [7] and [9, 10], respectively.

RM2(E)=∣βM2σ(E)+βM2ℓ(E)∣2,(15)R_{M2}(E) = \left|\beta^\sigma_{M2}(E) + \beta^\ell_{M2}(E)\right|^2, \tag*{(15)}

whereas RM2σ/ℓ(E)=∣βM2σ/ℓ(E)∣2R^{\sigma/\ell}_{M2}(E) = \left|\beta^{\sigma/\ell}_{M2}(E)\right|^2. Thus, at the low-lying (high-energy) M2 peak, the spin-M2 and orbital-M2 amplitudes have the opposite (same) phase to realize the reduced (enhanced) total RM2(E)R_{M2}(E) value. As the result, our NEW summation up to 50 MeV reads m0=∑BM2=1534.6m_0 = \sum B_{M2} = 1534.6 (full), ∑BM2σ=1492.2\sum B^\sigma_{M2} = 1492.2 (spin), and ∑BM2ℓ=44.3\sum B^\ell_{M2} = 44.3 (orbital) in the unit of μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2.

The available experimental data for 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} from Refs. [7, 9, 10] are listed in Table I. These data indicate a fragmentation of the M2-excited states among 12-20 MeV. Note that the M2-Weisskopf unit is BSP−M2=9.21 μN2fm2B_{\mathrm{SP-M2}} = 9.21\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 in this case [54, 55]. In contrast, the experimental M2 strength shows noticeably larger values than this Weisskopf unit. Thus, the M2 transition is expected as a collective process, where several SP transitions simultaneously contribute. These data also suggest that the Weisskopf assumption is not definitely applicable. For example, at 19.0 MeV with BM2expt.≅341 μN2fm2B^{\mathrm{expt.}}_{M2} \cong341\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 [7], the mean number of excited nucleons is estimated as 341/9.21=37341/9.21 = 37, being larger than the total mass number of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. Thus, the actual SP-M2 strength is expected to be more dependent on the quantum numbers of relevant orbits. Table I also displays the total summation of the experimental data.

As shown in Table 1, the M2-NEW summation of transition strength from the present RRPA calculation is somewhat larger than the experimental value, indicating that some strength could be missing from experiments. Especially, the calculated low-lying M2 state has not been reported in experimental studies.

Energy [MeV]BM2(E)B_{M2}(E) [μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2]Reference
12.5338 ± 9[9, 10]
12.96121 ± 24[9, 10]
16.8219 ± 2[7]
17.7813 ± 2[7]
18.5059 ± 7[7]
19.0341 ± 51[7]
20.30461 ± 162[9, 10]
∑BM2\sum B_{M2}
12.53-20.301052 ± 257[7]+[9, 10]
0-501534.58(This work)

Table 1. Experimental M2-excitation energies and transition strengths for 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. The NEW summation of BM2B_{M2} values from the relativistic RPA with DD-PC1 functional is also presented.

In order to analyze the underlying structure of each pronounced M2 state obtained in the RRPA calculation, Table IV in the Appendix is prepared. There, the major phph-transition components contributing to the M2 transition strength are listed. These components, denoted as bphπ,νb_{ph}^{\pi,\nu}, correspond to the contribution of each phph configuration to the summation in the transition strength, Eq. (3), for protons (π\pi) and neutrons (ν\nu), respectively. Thus, the overall transition strength is given as

BM2(E)=∣∑phbphν(E)+∑phbphπ(E)∣2.(16)B_{M2}(E) = \left\lvert\sum_{ph} b_{ph}^{\nu}(E) + \sum_{ph} b_{ph}^{\pi}(E) \right\rvert^2. \tag*{(16)}

The analysis of bphπ,νb_{ph}^{\pi,\nu} provides useful information on the structure of RPA states and their collective properties, as shown in previous studies [57, 58]. In particular, if more phph components have sizable contributions, thus involving excitations of considerable number of nucleons, one can conclude on collective nature of the RPA state. On the other side, if e.g., only one phph component is relevant, the RRPA state is of pure single-particle nature. By inspecting M2 partial contributions for 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} in Table IV, one can conclude that, all the protons and neutrons in the 1p3/21p_{3/2} and 1p1/21p_{1/2} orbits simultaneously contribute, whereas the deepest 1s1/21s_{1/2} orbit is not active. The most collective state is obtained at 17.81 MeV, with 7 phph configurations contributing to the overall transition strength. This collectivity is different than for the M1 transitions, where only a few LSLS-partner orbits can be active [44, 45]. There are also other M2 states which are composed of one or two phph configurations, such as those at 19.04 and 19.99 MeV.

The low-lying M2 peak predicted at 8.6 MeV is mainly from the 1p1/2→1d5/21p_{1/2} \rightarrow1d_{5/2} transitions of both protons and neutrons. For the absence of this peak in experiments, from the theory side one possible reason is the ambiguity of IV-PV residual interaction in QRPA. The M2-excitation energy is sensitive to the IV-PV coupling, where the finite ambiguities remain as discussed in our previous study on M1 and Gamow-Teller transitions [59].

M2 transitions in 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}

The M2-response functions calculated with the RRPA with DD-PC1 interaction for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} are shown in Figure 2. The transition strength is characterized by the main peak at excitation energy ≈15\approx15 MeV, and two additional peaks, i.e., low-lying one at ≈7\approx7 MeV and high-lying one at ≈21\approx21 MeV. The calculated centroid energy of the full response amounts Eˉ=15.48\bar{E} = 15.48 MeV. The corresponding NEW summations up to 50 MeV read m0=∑BM2=4915.5m_0 = \sum B_{M2} = 4915.5 (full), ∑BM2(IV)=5136.4\sum B_{M2}^{(IV)} = 5136.4, and ∑BM2(IS)=494.2\sum B_{M2}^{(IS)} = 494.2 in the unit of μN2 fm2\mu_N^2\,\mathrm{fm}^2. Figure 2 also shows the full, spin and orbital M2 response functions for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}. The

Figure 2. The same as Figure 1 but for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}.

corresponding summations give ∑BM2σ=4575.6\sum B_{M2}^{\sigma} = 4575.6, and ∑BM2ℓ=319.1\sum B_{M2}^{\ell} = 319.1 in the unit of μN2 fm2\mu_N^2\,\mathrm{fm}^2. It shows that the spin-M2 strength is significant, as similarly confirmed in the previous 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} case. In addition, one can find that, at the low-lying (high-energy) M2 peak, the spin-M2 and orbital-M2 amplitudes have the opposite (same) phase to realize the reduced (enhanced) total RM2(E)R_{M2}(E) value. This conclusion is consistent to the 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} case.

The calculated EW moment amounts m1=76.1×103m_1 = 76.1 \times10^3 MeVμN2 fm2\mu_N^2\,\mathrm{fm}^2 up to 50 MeV. This is larger than the RPA result in Ref. [11], 52.4×10352.4 \times10^3 MeVμN2 fm2\mu_N^2\,\mathrm{fm}^2. Note that the result in Ref. [11] includes the quenching effect, gs→0.64gsg_s \rightarrow0.64g_s, in order to reproduce the experimental data of M1 transitions [45]. For comparison, the experimental EW-M2 summation amounts 15.7×10315.7 \times10^3 MeVμN2 fm2\mu_N^2\,\mathrm{fm}^2 up to 15 MeV [11]. For the observed discrepancy between theoretical and experimental values in the present study, one explanation is the quenching effect on gg factors. For adjusting our EW-M2 summation to the experimental one, the quenching factor of ζ=15.7/76.1≃0.45\zeta= \sqrt{15.7/76.1} \simeq0.45 is necessary for all the gg factors. However, this strong quenching is not consistent to the M1 result in our previous work [44], where the minor quenching of ζ=0.8−0.9\zeta= 0.8 - 0.9 was appropriate to reproduce the experimental M1 summation. Another possible reason is the effect going beyond the RPA. Indeed in Ref. [11], the second RPA calculation for M2 transitions was also performed, where the better agreement with experiment than the pure RPA calculation was confirmed. This also suggests that beyond-RPA effects may be more (less) essential for the M2 (M1) transition, in which the collectivity is relatively strong (weak). However, similar beyond-RPA calculation but of relativistic version is still challenging, and going beyond the scope of this work. Note also that considerable M2 data especially of high energies could be missing from the experimental side due to the limited energy range [11].

Details on the composition of M2 transitions in 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} are given in Table V in the Appendix. The analysis of the relevant phph contributions to the main 10 excited states indicates that, both for protons and neutrons, the 2s1/22s_{1/2}, 1d5/21d_{5/2}, and 1d3/21d_{3/2} orbits are active for M2 transitions. In addition, the neutrons in ν1f7/2\nu1f_{7/2} are also contributing. On the other side, several transitions, e.g. 1p1/2∗→1d3/2∗1p_{1/2}^{*} \to1d_{3/2}^{*}, are forbidden, since their final states are occupied. Notice that the collectivity of M2 transition is shown as larger for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} than previously analyzed 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, simply because, in 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, the initial state has more orbits of the M2-active nucleons. In correspondence, the NEW summation m0m_{0} amounts the larger value for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}: m0(48Ca)/m0(16O)=4915.46/1534.58≃3.2m_{0}(^{48}\mathrm{Ca})/m_{0}(^{16}\mathrm{O}) = 4915.46/1534.58 \simeq3.2.

Epeakth.E_{\mathrm{peak}}^{\mathrm{th.}} [MeV]BM2(E)B_{M2}(E) [μN2 fm2\mu_N^2\,\mathrm{fm}^2]bph′b'_{\mathrm{ph}} [μN fm\mu_N\,\mathrm{fm}]bph′′b''_{\mathrm{ph}} [μN fm\mu_N\,\mathrm{fm}]phph transition
7.17834.41-0.76-29.69(ν2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π1d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
-0.593.56(ν1f7/2−1→1g9/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to1g_{9/2})
(π1d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
13.28122.26-6.85-0.13(ν1f7/2−1→2d3/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to2d_{3/2})
(π1d5/2−1→2p1/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{1/2})
1.73-0.18(ν2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π1d3/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
-2.02-0.18(ν1d3/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π1d5/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
-1.12-0.19(ν1f7/2−1→2d5/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to2d_{5/2})
(π1d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
-2.360(ν1f7/2−1→1g9/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to1g_{9/2})
14.00180.43-13.737.85(ν2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
-7.691.00(ν1f7/2−1→1g9/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to1g_{9/2})
(π1d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
14.41223.95-5.051.47(ν2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
-1.738.68(ν1f7/2−1→1g9/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to1g_{9/2})
(π1d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
14.61159.10-1.11-9.32(ν2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
-5.59-1.07(ν1f7/2−1→1g9/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to1g_{9/2})
(π1d3/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
0.211.57(ν1f7/2−1→2d3/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to2d_{3/2})
(π1d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
0.272.29(ν1d3/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π1d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})

Table V. The same as Table IV but for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}.

From Table V in the Appendix, the low-lying peak at 7.17 MeV is predicted with BM2=834.41 μN2fm2B_{M2} = 834.41\ \mu_{N}^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{2}. There, the most dominant contribution is from the proton transition 1d3/2⟶1f7/21d_{3/2} \longrightarrow1f_{7/2}. This transition is natural for the M2-selection rule. In comparison, however, the corresponding data in Ref. [11] between 6-8 MeV yields only ≃25 μN2fm2\simeq25\ \mu_{N}^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{2}. The RPA and second RPA calculations in Ref. [11] commonly predict the similar, minor strengths in this low-lying region of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}. Thus, the discrepancy in M2 transition strengths does not seem to be cured even if the beyond-QRPA effects are taken into account. Alternative reason is possibly the sensitivity of the RRPA energies on the IV-PV part of the residual interaction. By assuming that our RRPA energy, 7.17 MeV, is overestimated, the low-lying M2 peak may exist but below the minimum of experimental accessibility. In Figure 3, the M2 response as a function of the strength parameter of the IV-PV coupling is presented. There, one can find that the low-lying M2 peak is sensitive to the IV-PV interaction, similar to the sensitivity that was also obtained in the study of M1 and Gamow-Teller transitions [59]. Further experimental studies of magnetic transitions could provide additional constraints for the IV-PV interaction. From the theory side, improvement of the relevant SP energies could also result in modifications of the present results.

Figure 3. The M2 transition strength distributions for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} by changing the IV-PV coupling strength parameter, αIV−TV=βIV−PV⋅ℏc\alpha_{\mathrm{IV-TV}} = \beta_{\mathrm{IV-PV}} \cdot\hbar c. Note that βIV−TV=0.53 fm2\beta_{\mathrm{IV-TV}} = 0.53\ \mathrm{fm}^{2} is the default setting when combined with the DD-PC1 interaction.

M2 transitions in 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}

Figure 4 shows the full, IS and IV M2-response functions for the 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} nucleus, where one dominant peak and simultaneously several finite structures are confirmed. The centroid energy of full response amounts Eth=11.87E^{\mathrm{th}} = 11.87 MeV, that is slightly above the main peak excitation energy due to the tail of excitation strength extending toward 20 MeV. The NEW summations up to 50 MeV yield m0=∑BM2=35648 μN2fm2m_{0} = \sum B_{M2} = 35648\ \mu_{N}^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{2} (full), ∑BM2(IV)=35459 μN2fm2\sum B_{M2}^{(\mathrm{IV})} = 35459\ \mu_{N}^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{2}, and ∑BM2(IS)=6358 μN2fm2\sum B_{M2}^{(\mathrm{IS})} = 6358\ \mu_{N}^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{2}. Figure 4 also displays the decomposition of the full M2 strength into the spin and orbital components. In addition to the dominant spin response, a non-negligible contribution from the orbital response is observed, that is, the peaked around 10 MeV. There, a constructive interference between the spin and orbital components exists as RM2>RM2orbR_{M2} > R_{M2}^{\mathrm{orb}}. On the other hand, the destructive interference is also found around 7 MeV, but its effect is minor in this 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} nucleus. The corresponding summations up to 50 MeV are ∑BM2=35648 μN2fm2\sum B_{M2} = 35648\ \mu_{N}^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{2} (full), ∑BM2=25515 μN2fm2\sum B_{M2} = 25515\ \mu_{N}^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{2} (spin), and ∑BM2orb=6936 μN2fm2\sum B_{M2}^{\mathrm{orb}} = 6936\ \mu_{N}^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{2} (orbital).

Response functions and transition strengths for $^{208}\mathrm{Pb}$

Figure 4. The same as Fig. 1 but for 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}. Experiment A indicates Ref [12].

In Tables VII and VIII in the Appendix, particle-hole transition components of the main M2 peaks for 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} are presented. In comparison to other nuclei previously discussed, for 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} more complicated composition is obtained, especially for the two main peaks at 9.88 and 10.18 MeV. This is expected due to larger number of M2-active nucleons.

The experimental data on M2 excitations in 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} are summarized in Table II. In Ref. [13], if the experimental M2 strengths between 6–8 MeV are summed, the result reads ∑BM2=8500±750 μN2fm2\sum B_{M2}=8500 \pm750\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 [13]. Note that, in Ref. [13], the analyzing procedure with RPA refers to the experimentally observed Jπ=2−J^\pi=2^- peak at 7.47 MeV, and its result is confirmed by the MSI-RPA in Ref. [18]. The other RPA study in Ref. [19] gives 9700–12600 μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 within the excitation energies of 6.1–8.4 MeV. Other theoretical investigations have concluded

Energy [MeV]BM2(E)B_{M2}(E) [μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2]Reference
7.40449±89449\pm89[12]
7.91614±92614\pm92[12]
∑BM2\sum B_{M2}
6.428–8.0088500±7508500\pm750[13]
7.457–8.0085230±1305230\pm130[13]
0–5035648(This work)
0–9.8811785(This work)
0–8.973694(This work)

Table 2. Experimental M2 data for 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}. Note that the M2-Weisskopf unit is BSP−M2=50.9 μN2fm2B_{SP-M2}=50.9\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2.

11000 μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 [20] or 11600 μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 [21]. Indeed the M2 summation depends on the energy window available in measurements. By considering the present results with the DD-PC1 interaction outlined in our analysis in tables VII and VIII, if we sum up BM2B_{M2} values at excitation energies of Ex=6.46E_x=6.46, 7.45, 7.61, 8.69, 8.97 and 9.88 MeV, the result is ∑≤9.88 MeVBM2(E)=11785 μN2fm2\sum_{\leq9.88\ \mathrm{MeV}} B_{M2}(E)=11785\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2. This value is in agreement with other theoretical predictions and also comparable with the experimental data in Table II. For another example, if we limit our summation up to 8.97 MeV, then the total strength reduces as ∑≤8.97 MeVBM2(E)=3694 μN2fm2\sum_{\leq8.97\ \mathrm{MeV}} B_{M2}(E)=3694\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2, which is smaller than the experimental data. If the higher-energy M2 measurement becomes available, the comparison could improve the agreement.

We again mention the collectivity of M2 and its dependence on mass numbers. The Weisskopf estimate gives BSP−M2≃1.45⋅A2/3=9.21B_{SP-M2}\simeq1.45\cdot A^{2/3}=9.21, 19.2, and 50.9 μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 for 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, and 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} nuclei, respectively [54, 55]. On the other side, the present RRPA predicts the most excited state in each nucleus as shown in Tables in the Appendix: BM2=487.57 μN2fm2B_{M2}=487.57\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 at 17.81 MeV in 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}; BM2=1569.21 μN2fm2B_{M2}=1569.21\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 at 15.08 MeV in 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}; BM2=8020.14 μN2fm2B_{M2}=8020.14\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 at 9.88 MeV in 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}. Their ratios thus read BM2/BSP−M2=52.9B_{M2}/B_{SP-M2}=52.9, 81.7, and 157.4 for 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, and 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb} nuclei, respectively, indicating the mean numbers of excited nucleons, that seem to be over-estimated. Thus, as reliable measure of collective properties of M2 transitions we consider our detailed analysis of the phph composition in relevant excited states, as given in Appendix.

Pairing effect in 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, 42Ca^{42}\mathrm{Ca}, 56Fe^{56}\mathrm{Fe}, and 90Zr^{90}\mathrm{Zr}

Of particular interest here are the effects of pairing correlations on the M2 transitions. Our calculations are based on the DD-PC1 parametrization for the relativistic

RQRPA full M2 response function for $^{18}\mathrm{O}$

Figure 5. The RQRPA full M2 response function for 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}, RM2(E)R_{\mathrm{M2}}(E), based on the DD-PC1 parameterization and Gogny-pairing interaction. The response functions without pairing correlations and with full pairing in the residual RQRPA interaction are shown separately.

EDF [46], and pairing correlations are described using the pairing part of the Gogny interaction [48].

Figure 5 shows the RQRPA results for the full response function for M2 transitions of 18O^{18}\mathrm{O}. The response function without pairing correlations in the residual RQRPA interaction is also shown. In comparison to previously studied nucleus 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, open-shell system 18O^{18}\mathrm{O} displays rather different response. In particular, its high-energy part is fragmented into two strong peaks. The third peak at 21 MeV is indeed from valence neutrons in the d5/2d_{5/2} orbit, which was empty in the previous 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} case. By comparing two cases with and without pairing correlations, one can observe considerable pairing effects on the transition strengths, whereas their excitation energies are less sensitive. We perform similar analysis for 42Ca^{42}\mathrm{Ca} and 56Fe^{56}\mathrm{Fe} as shown in Figure 6. The response function for 42Ca^{42}\mathrm{Ca} displays a triple-hump structure, and its strength is strongly sensitive on pairing correlations. For 56Fe^{56}\mathrm{Fe}, the low-energy peak is absent in the full-pairing calculation, and the overall transition strength is rather fragmented.

Figure 6. The same as Fig. 5 but for 42Ca^{42}\mathrm{Ca}, 56Fe^{56}\mathrm{Fe}, and 90Zr^{90}\mathrm{Zr} nuclei.

We next investigate the 90Zr^{90}\mathrm{Zr} nucleus, because experimental data on M2 transitions have been reported up to the excitation energy of about 12 MeV in Ref. [11]. The calculated M2 response function for 90Zr^{90}\mathrm{Zr} is shown in Figure 6. There, three main structures are obtained in the strength distribution, with the most pronounced peak around 13 MeV. The RQRPA result for the EW summation amounts m1(E)=160.10×103 MeV μN2fm2m_1(E) = 160.10 \times10^3\ \mathrm{MeV}\,\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 up to 50 MeV. For comparison, the experimental data from Ref. [11] are available up to 12 MeV, resulting in the value as m1expt.(E)=23.6×103 MeV μN2fm2m_1^{\mathrm{expt.}}(E) = 23.6 \times10^3\ \mathrm{MeV}\,\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 for 90Zr^{90}\mathrm{Zr}. This value is considerably lower than our prediction. If we limit our theoretical consideration up to 12 MeV, the EW summation gives m1(E≤12 MeV)=13.67×103 MeV μN2fm2m_1(E \le12\ \mathrm{MeV}) = 13.67 \times10^3\ \mathrm{MeV}\,\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2, which is of the reasonable order with respect to the experimental value. Since several M2 peaks are predicted above 12 MeV, future experiments may additionally find higher transitions for complete information.

Another experimental investigation with the inelastic electron scattering [60], whose data were analized with the distorted-wave Born approximation, provides the NEW-M2 summation, ∑BM2expt.(E)=950±100 μN2fm2\sum B_{\mathrm{M2}}^{\mathrm{expt.}}(E) = 950 \pm100\ \mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 for the M2-excited energies between 8–10 MeV for 90Zr^{90}\mathrm{Zr}. For comparison, from our RQRPA, the same summation amounts 291 μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 in the case with pairing correlation. Indeed in our RQRPA results between 8–10 MeV, there is only one M2-excited peak predicted, and thus, the NEW summation becomes smaller than the experimental one.

The non-relativistic RPA study for 90Zr{}^{90}\mathrm{Zr} exists also in Ref. [11], where the EW sum of the B(M2) strength up to 12 MeV yields m1=112.3×103 MeVμN2fm2m_1 = 112.3 \times10^3\ \mathrm{MeV}\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2 (including the quenching of 0.6 in the spin gg factor), being higher than the experimental value. Similar to the present study, the second RPA calculation [11], that is based on rather different effective nuclear interactions and it does not include pairing, also result in pronounced low-energy M2 spin excitation, at ≈5\approx5 MeV. Therefore, one can expect that by extending presently experimentally covered energy range between 7-12 MeV, both to low-energy and high-energy regions, would result in more M2 transitions that would reduce presently existing discrepancies between the overall measured and calculated strengths. We note that by including couplings to complex configurations such as 2p2h2p2h in the second RPA [11], considerable fragmentation of the transition strength is obtained when compared to calculation based only at the RPA level. Therefore, it is expected that the structure predicted by the RQRPA would become much more fragmented if complex configurations would be included.

In Table III we summarize the NEW summations and centroid energies for open-shell nuclei with and without full consideration of the pairing correlation. In general, the pairing interaction reduces the NEW summation and shifts the centroid energy to the higher region.

Pairingm0m_0Eˉ\bar{E}
[103μN2fm2][10^3\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2][MeV][\mathrm{MeV}]
18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}no16.1716.87
full15.4017.91
42Ca{}^{42}\mathrm{Ca}no6.8914.06
full4.6214.81
56Fe{}^{56}\mathrm{Fe}no6.2916.47
full5.8717.80
90Zr{}^{90}\mathrm{Zr}no11.7813.09
full11.0214.53

Table III. The NEW summation, m0=∑EBM2(E)m_0 = \sum_E B_{M2}(E) up to 50 MeV, and the centroid energy, Eˉ=m1/m0\bar{E} = m_1/m_0, calculated with the present RQRPA for 18O{}^{18}\mathrm{O}, 42Ca{}^{42}\mathrm{Ca}, 56Fe{}^{56}\mathrm{Fe}, and 90Zr{}^{90}\mathrm{Zr}. Results with and without pairing interaction are compared.

M2 transitions in 36−64Ca{}^{36-64}\mathrm{Ca} isotopes

In order to assess how the M2 transition evolves with the increase of the neutron number along the isotope chain, we have calculated the RQRPA response functions in 36−64Ca{}^{36-64}\mathrm{Ca} isotopes.

Calculated predictions on M2 excitation properties for Ca isotopes could be useful for the future experimental studies. Two relativistic density-dependent interactions have been used, DD-PC1 [46] and DD-PCX [47], supplemented with the Gogny force [48] for the pairing correlations.

The calculated M2 response functions are shown for 36−64Ca{}^{36-64}\mathrm{Ca} in Figure 7. The transition strength distributions show no significant differences when comparing DD-PC1 versus DD-PCX results, neither in terms of fragmentation or transition strength. With increasing the neutron number, the overall M2 transition strength increases. Qualitative changes are especially pronounced in the low-energy part of the spectra which becomes more fragmented, and in neutron-rich Ca isotopes the main M2 peak becomes split into two peaks, which are of comparable strength for 60,64Ca{}^{60,64}\mathrm{Ca}.

The M2 full RQRPA response functions for Ca isotopes

Figure 7. The M2 full RQRPA response functions for Ca isotopes, shown for the DD-PC1 and DD-PCX interactions.

In Fig. 8 the M2 response is shown separately for the RM2R(E)R_{M2}^{\mathrm{R}}(E) (spin) and RM2L(E)R_{M2}^{\mathrm{L}}(E) (orbital) transitions. Similarly in the case of M1 transitions for spherical symmetric nuclei [44], the spin M2 transition is much stronger in comparison to almost-negligible orbital one. Thus the evolution of the M2 response in Ca isotopes is governed mainly by changes in the spin-response, which also determines the increase of the fragmentation of the spectra when moving toward neutron-rich isotopes. Due to small contribution of the orbital-response, it is difficult to conclude on its evolution along the isotope chain.

Finally, in Figure 9, the m0m_0 (NEW) and m1m_1 (EW) M2 summations are shown for 36−64Ca{}^{36-64}\mathrm{Ca} isotope chain, using the RQRPA with the DD-PC1 and DD-PCX interac-

Evolution of the $m_0$ and $m_1$ RQRPA moments for the $^{36\text{--}64}$Ca isotope chain

Figure 9. The evolution of the m0m_0 and m1m_1 RQRPA moments for 36–64^{36\text{--}64}Ca isotope chain, for DD-PC1 and DD-PCX interactions. Higher limit values correspond to the quenching of gg factors ζ=0.93\zeta= 0.93, and lower limit values to ζ=0.8\zeta= 0.8.

The $M2$ spin and orbital RQRPA response functions for Ca isotopes

caption: The M2M2 spin and orbital RQRPA response functions supplemented with the unperturbed RHB response for Ca isotopes, using DD-PC1 interaction.

tions. In this way we can observe the evolution of the M2M2 properties with increasing the neutron number in Ca isotopes. The model calculations are performed using two limit values for the quenching of the spin and orbital gg factors, ζ=0.93\zeta= 0.93 and ζ=0.8\zeta= 0.8, which were previously discussed in the study of M1M1 transitions [44]. Therefore, it allows one to infer how these limits in the quenching factors fit into the future experimental studies of M2M2 transitions in Ca isotopes. The figure also demonstrates rather weak model dependence over the whole isotope chain when using DD-PC1 and DD-PCX interactions. In Figure 9 we have denoted the overlap of the results obtained from the two interactions, that represents a theoretical prediction of this study for m0m_0 and m1m_1 moments, to be compared with forthcoming experiments. In this way, the analysis of M2M2 transitions, simultaneously with those of M1M1 transitions, can provide deeper insight into the quenching of gyromagnetic factors.

Summary

In this work we have investigated the properties of M2M2 transitions from 0+0^+ ground state to 2−2^- excited states in even-even nuclei, by using the RHB+RQRPA framework. Two density-dependent relativistic point coupling interactions have been used, DD-PC1 and DD-PCX, supplemented with the IV-PV term in the residual RQRPA interaction. The pairing correlations have been described

with the pairing part of the Gogny force. Model calculations of M2M2 transitions in 16^{16}O, 48^{48}Ca, and 208^{208}Pb provided insight into their structure and collective properties. The analysis of relevant particle-hole configurations confirmed that the main M2M2 peaks have rather complicated structure, different than single-particle transition, where nucleons in different orbits simultaneously contribute. With increase of the mass number the collectivity of main M2M2 states increases due to larger number of possible phph transitions. The calculated M2M2 transition strengths appear larger than available experimental data, possibly because (i) measurements are available only within rather restricted energy ranges, and/or (ii) beyond-QRPA effects are missing in the present approach. Similar results are obtained in earlier RPA and shell-model calculations, if no additional quenching is imposed on the gg factors. For the missing low-lying M2M2 peak in measurements for 48^{48}Ca, we point out that further experimental studies of low-energy M2M2 transitions could provide additional constraints for the IV-PV interaction, and clarify if additional M2M2 states exist at energies lower than presently available from the experiment. More complete experimental studies are expected as reference for benchmarking the model calculations. We especially emphasize the interest in two cases, i.e., (i) the low-lying region of 48^{48}Ca, where another peak of proton’s 1d3/2⟶1f7/21d_{3/2} \longrightarrow1f_{7/2} transition is predicted, and (ii) the region higher than 9 MeV of 208^{208}Pb, where its M2M2 response is predicted to have rather distributed structure.

We have also demonstrated that pairing effects in open-shell nuclei 18^{18}O, 42^{42}Ca, 56^{56}Fe, and semi-magic 90^{90}Zr have an impact on M2M2 transition spectra, by reducing the strength and shifting the centroid energy to the higher values. The evolution of the m0m_0 and m1m_1 moments in 36–64^{36\text{--}64}Ca isotope chain has also been investigated. By imposing the limit values for the quenching of the gg factors consistent with the analysis of M1 transitions [44], we provide the limits for m0m_0 and m1m_1 moments for M2 transitions within the Ca isotopes, that could provide useful constraints for the quenching of gg factors in nuclear medium. To our present knowledge, there in no systematic experimental data on properties of M2 transitions available for Ca isotopes except 48Ca{}^{48}\mathrm{Ca}. Thus, we hope that the predictions of this work could motivate future experimental studies on M2 transitions in Ca isotopes. Some preparations along this line of experimental research are already in progress [61].

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

We thank Peter von Neumann-Cosel for useful discussion on magnetic transitions. This work is supported within the Tenure Track Pilot Programme of the Croatian Science Foundation and the École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, and the Project TTP-2018-07-3554 Exotic Nuclear Structure and Dynamics, with funds of the Croatian-Swiss Research Programme. This work is supported by the “QuantiXLie Centre of Excellence” project co-financed by the Croatian Government and European Union through the European Regional Development Fund, the Competitiveness and Cohesion Operational Programme (code KK.01.1.1.01.0004). We acknowledge support by the Multidisciplinary Cooperative Research Program of the Center for Computational Sciences, University of Tsukuba, using Oakforest-PACS Systems (project No. xg21i064, FY2021), and T.O. acknowledges the support by Takashi Nakatsukasa and Hiroyuki Kobayashi in this program.

The analysis of contributing particle-hole transitions in M2 excited states

Here we display the components of M2 transitions for 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}, 48Ca{}^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, and 208Pb{}^{208}\mathrm{Pb} nuclei, on which discussions are presented in the main text.

EpeakthE_{\mathrm{peak}}^{\mathrm{th}} [MeV]BM2(E)B_{\mathrm{M2}}(E) [μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2]bphνb_{ph}^{\nu} [μNfm\mu_N\mathrm{fm}]bphπb_{ph}^{\pi} [μNfm\mu_N\mathrm{fm}]ph transition
8.60397.16-8.43-13.72(ν1p1/2−1→1d5/2)(\nu1p_{1/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
-0.302.85(ν1p3/2−1→2s1/2)(\nu1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow2s_{1/2})
(π1p1/2−1→1d5/2)(\pi1p_{1/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
(π1p3/2−1→1d5/2)(\pi1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
17.15206.731.85-1.29(ν1p1/2−1→1d3/2)(\nu1p_{1/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{3/2})
0.87-15.81(ν1p3/2−1→1d5/2)(\nu1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
(π1p1/2−1→1d5/2)(\pi1p_{1/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
(π1p3/2−1→1d5/2)(\pi1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
17.81487.57-1.3513.99(ν1p3/2−1→2s1/2)(\nu1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow2s_{1/2})
1.460.35(ν1p1/2−1→1d3/2)(\nu1p_{1/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{3/2})
1.48-0.23(ν1p1/2−1→1d5/2)(\nu1p_{1/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
(π1p3/2−1→2s1/2)(\pi1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow2s_{1/2})
6.960(ν1p3/2−1→1d5/2)(\nu1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
19.04158.74-2.53-11.93(ν1p3/2−1→1d5/2)(\nu1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})
(π1p3/2−1→1s1/2)(\pi1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1s_{1/2})
19.99123.27-8.47-2.29(ν1p3/2−1→2s1/2)(\nu1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow2s_{1/2})
(π1p3/2−1→1d5/2)(\pi1p_{3/2}^{-1}\rightarrow1d_{5/2})

Table IV. Partial contributions bphνb_{ph}^{\nu} (neutrons) and bphπb_{ph}^{\pi} (protons) to the dominant M2 transitions in the 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} nucleus. The EpeakthE_{\mathrm{peak}}^{\mathrm{th}} denotes the peak energy corresponding to the RRPA eigenvalue, and BM2(E)B_{\mathrm{M2}}(E) is its overall transition strength.

Epeakth.E_{\mathrm{peak}}^{\mathrm{th.}} [MeV]BM2(E)B_{M2}(E) [μN2 fm2\mu_N^2\,\mathrm{fm}^2]bph′b'_{\mathrm{ph}} [μN fm\mu_N\,\mathrm{fm}]bph′′b''_{\mathrm{ph}} [μN fm\mu_N\,\mathrm{fm}]phph transition
15.081569.211.44-6.82(ν1d3/2−1→1f5/2)(\nu1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{5/2})
(π2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
0.61-2.17(ν1d3/2−1→2p1/2)(\nu1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2p_{1/2})
(π1d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
-0.69-33.23(ν2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π1d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
15.57192.151.61-3.11(ν1d3/2−1→2p1/2)(\nu1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2p_{1/2})
(π2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
2.7313.41(ν2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π1d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
-1.490.94(ν1d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\nu1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
(π1d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
19.81119.602.83-1.22(ν1d5/2−1→2p1/2)(\nu1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{1/2})
(π1d5/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
-1.29-1.19(ν1f7/2−1→3d3/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to3d_{3/2})
(π1d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
-8.32-0.48(ν1d5/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π2s1/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi2s_{1/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
20.74302.61-9.01-1.22(ν1d5/2−1→2p1/2)(\nu1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{1/2})
(π1d5/2−1→2p1/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{1/2})
-2.38-1.46(ν1d5/2−1→2p3/2)(\nu1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})
(π1d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
-2.32-0.74(ν1f7/2−1→2g7/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to2g_{7/2})
(π1d5/2−1→1f5/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{5/2})
21.59165.43-1.492.76(ν1f7/2−1→2g7/2)(\nu1f_{7/2}^{-1}\to2g_{7/2})
(π1d5/2−1→2p1/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{1/2})
-0.63-14.92(ν1d5/2−1→2p1/2)(\nu1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{1/2})
(π1d5/2−1→2p3/2)(\pi1d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2p_{3/2})

Table VI. Continuation of Table V for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}.

Epeakth.E_{\mathrm{peak}}^{\mathrm{th.}} [MeV]BM2(E)BM2(E) [μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2]bphνb_{ph}^{\nu} [μNfm\mu_N\mathrm{fm}]bphπb_{ph}^{\pi} [μNfm\mu_N\mathrm{fm}]phph transition
6.461815.741.867.67(ν3p1/2−1→3d5/2)(\nu3p_{1/2}^{-1}\to3d_{5/2})
(π2d3/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
39.87-3.21(ν2f5/2−1→2g9/2)(\nu2f_{5/2}^{-1}\to2g_{9/2})
(π2d5/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
-1.88-3.35(ν2f7/2−1→2g9/2)(\nu2f_{7/2}^{-1}\to2g_{9/2})
(π1h11/2−1→1i13/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{13/2})
-1.11-0.48(ν1i13/2−1→1j15/2)(\nu1i_{13/2}^{-1}\to1j_{15/2})
(π3s1/2−1→3p3/2)(\pi3s_{1/2}^{-1}\to3p_{3/2})
7.45982.58-23.71-18.55(ν3p1/2−1→3d5/2)(\nu3p_{1/2}^{-1}\to3d_{5/2})
(π2d3/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
1.372.61(ν3p3/2−1→3d5/2)(\nu3p_{3/2}^{-1}\to3d_{5/2})
(π2d5/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
7.821.65(ν2f5/2−1→2g9/2)(\nu2f_{5/2}^{-1}\to2g_{9/2})
(π1h11/2−1→1i13/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{13/2})
7.61420.15-12.381.22(ν3p1/2−1→3d5/2)(\nu3p_{1/2}^{-1}\to3d_{5/2})
(π3s3/2−1→3p3/2)(\pi3s_{3/2}^{-1}\to3p_{3/2})
2.5137.45(ν3p3/2−1→3d5/2)(\nu3p_{3/2}^{-1}\to3d_{5/2})
(π2d3/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
-7.23-4.07(ν2f5/2−1→2g9/2)(\nu2f_{5/2}^{-1}\to2g_{9/2})
(π2d5/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
8.69336.461.09-3.02(ν3p3/2−1→4s1/2)(\nu3p_{3/2}^{-1}\to4s_{1/2})
(π2d3/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{3/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
2.49-2.09(ν3p1/2−1→3d5/2)(\nu3p_{1/2}^{-1}\to3d_{5/2})
(π1h11/2−1→1i13/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{13/2})
24.13-0.34(ν3p3/2−1→3d5/2)(\nu3p_{3/2}^{-1}\to3d_{5/2})
(π2d5/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
8.97231.8516.78-1.03(ν3p3/2−1→4s1/2)(\nu3p_{3/2}^{-1}\to4s_{1/2})
(π2d5/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
-1.62-1.69(ν3p3/2−1→3d5/2)(\nu3p_{3/2}^{-1}\to3d_{5/2})
(π1h11/2−1→1i13/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{13/2})
-1.240.37(ν2f7/2−1→2g9/2)(\nu2f_{7/2}^{-1}\to2g_{9/2})
(π2d5/2−1→3p3/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to3p_{3/2})

Table VII. The same as Table IV but for 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}.

Epeakth.E_{\mathrm{peak}}^{\mathrm{th.}} [MeV]BM2(E)BM2(E) [μN2fm2\mu_N^2\mathrm{fm}^2]bphνb_{ph}^{\nu} [μNfm\mu_N\mathrm{fm}]bphπb_{ph}^{\pi} [μNfm\mu_N\mathrm{fm}]phph transition
9.888020.141.58-1.62(ν2f5/2−1→1g9/2)(\nu2f_{5/2}^{-1}\to1g_{9/2})
(π3s1/2−1→1p3/2)(\pi3s_{1/2}^{-1}\to1p_{3/2})
9.84-1.16(ν2f7/2−1→1g9/2)(\nu2f_{7/2}^{-1}\to1g_{9/2})
(π2d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi2d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
-2.19-20.72(ν1h9/2−1→1i11/2)(\nu1h_{9/2}^{-1}\to1i_{11/2})
(π2d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
11.5592.71(ν1i13/2−1→1j15/2)(\nu1i_{13/2}^{-1}\to1j_{15/2})
(π1h11/2−1→1i13/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{13/2})
10.187843.68-3.914.62(ν2f5/2−1→1g7/2)(\nu2f_{5/2}^{-1}\to1g_{7/2})
(π3s1/2−1→1p3/2)(\pi3s_{1/2}^{-1}\to1p_{3/2})
-1.62-3.22(ν2f5/2−1→1g9/2)(\nu2f_{5/2}^{-1}\to1g_{9/2})
(π2d3/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi2d_{3/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
2.71-46.81(ν1h9/2−1→1i11/2)(\nu1h_{9/2}^{-1}\to1i_{11/2})
(π2d5/2−1→1f7/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to1f_{7/2})
-13.08-27.37(ν1i13/2−1→1j15/2)(\nu1i_{13/2}^{-1}\to1j_{15/2})
(π1h11/2−1→1i13/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{13/2})
10.781926.701.1832.23(ν2f5/2−1→2g9/2)(\nu2f_{5/2}^{-1}\to2g_{9/2})
(π3s1/2−1→3p3/2)(\pi3s_{1/2}^{-1}\to3p_{3/2})
-1.244.75(ν1h9/2−1→1i11/2)(\nu1h_{9/2}^{-1}\to1i_{11/2})
(π2d5/2−1→2f7/2)(\pi2d_{5/2}^{-1}\to2f_{7/2})
2.234.14(ν1i13/2−1→1j15/2)(\nu1i_{13/2}^{-1}\to1j_{15/2})
(π1h11/2−1→1i13/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{13/2})
16.241094.442.72-4.61(ν2f7/2−1→4d3/2)(\nu2f_{7/2}^{-1}\to4d_{3/2})
(π1g9/2−1→1h9/2)(\pi1g_{9/2}^{-1}\to1h_{9/2})
13.690.68(ν1h11/2−1→1i11/2)(\nu1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{11/2})
(π1g9/2−1→2f5/2)(\pi1g_{9/2}^{-1}\to2f_{5/2})
6.3015.49(ν1i13/2−1→1j13/2)(\nu1i_{13/2}^{-1}\to1j_{13/2})
(π1h11/2−1→1i11/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to1i_{11/2})
19.331888.2016.055.45(ν1h11/2−1→2g7/2)(\nu1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to2g_{7/2})
(π1h11/2−1→2g7/2)(\pi1h_{11/2}^{-1}\to2g_{7/2})
8.585.01(ν1i13/2−1→3h9/2)(\nu1i_{13/2}^{-1}\to3h_{9/2})
(π1g9/2−1→2f5/2)(\pi1g_{9/2}^{-1}\to2f_{5/2})

Table VIII. Continuation of Table VII for 208Pb^{208}\mathrm{Pb}.

References

  1. [1]K. Heyde, P. von Neumann-Cosel, and A. Richter, Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 2365 (2010), and references therein.
  2. [2]A. Richter, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 34, 261 (2011).
  3. [3]Y. Fujita, B. Rubio, and W. Gellety, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 66, 549 (2011).
  4. [4]R. Schwengner, S. Frauendorf, and B. A. Brown, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 092502 (2017).
  5. [5]G. E. Dogotar, R. A. Eramzhyan, M. Gmitro, H. R. Kissener, and E. T. Tinkova, Journal of Physics G: Nuclear Physics 5, L221 (1979).
  6. [6]R. Eramzhyan, M. Gmitro, and H. Kissener, Nucl. Phys. A 338, 436 (1980).
  7. [7]G. Küchler, A. Richter, E. Spamer, W. Steffen, and W. Knüpfer, Nucl. Phys. A 406, 473 (1983).
  8. [8]J. Kokame, K. Fukunaga, N. Inoue, and H. Nakamura, Physics Letters B 342, 199 (1995).
  9. [9]M. Stroetzel and A. Goldmann, Zeitschrift für Physik A Hadrons and nuclei 233, 245 (1970).
  10. [10]A. Goldmann and M. Stroetzel, Zeitschrift für Physik A Hadrons and nuclei 239, 235 (1970).
  11. [11]P. von Neumann-Cosel, F. Neumeyer, S. Nishizaki, V. Y. Ponmarev, C. Rangacharyulu, B. Reitz, A. Richter, G. Schröder, D. I. Sober, T. Waindzoch, and J. Wambach, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 1105 (1999).
  12. [12]R. A. Lindgren, W. L. Bendel, L. W. Fagg, and E. C. Jones, Phys. Rev. Lett. 36, 116 (1976).
  13. [13]R. Frey, A. Richter, A. Schwierczynski, E. Spamer, O. Titze, and W. Knüpfer, Phys. Lett. B 74, 45 (1978).
  14. [14]G. Peterson and J. Ziegler, Physics Letters 21, 543 (1966).
  15. [15]E. Boridy and J. Pearson, Nuclear Physics A 185, 593 (1972).
  16. [16]J. Friedrich, N. Voegler, and H. Euteneuer, Physics Letters B 64, 269 (1976).
  17. [17]W. Knüpfer, R. Frey, A. Friebel, W. Mettner, D. Meuer, A. Richter, E. Spamer, and O. Titze, Phys. Lett. B 77, 367 (1978).
  18. [18]W. Knüpfer and M. G. Huber, Phys. Rev. C 14, 2254 (1976).
  19. [19]V. Ponomarev, V. Soloviev, C. Stoyanov, and A. Vdovin, Nucl. Phys. A 323, 446 (1979).
  20. [20]B. Castel and I. Hamamoto, Phys. Lett. B 65, 27 (1976).
  21. [21]J. S. Dehesa, Ph.D. thesis, Rheinischen Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität zu Bonn (1977).
  22. [22]P. Ring and J. Speth, Nuclear Physics A 235, 315 (1974).
  23. [23]P. Ring and J. Speth, Physics Letters B 44, 477 (1973).
  24. [24]S. Krewald and J. Speth, Physics Letters B 52, 295 (1974).
  25. [25]G. Holzwarth and G. Eckart, Z. Physik A 283, 219 (1977).
  26. [26]G. Holzwarth and G. Eckart, Nucl. Phys. A 325, 1 (1979).
  27. [27]G. Holzwarth and G. Eckart, Nucl. Phys. A 396, 171 (1983).
  28. [28]G. Holzwarth and G. Eckart, Phys. Lett. B 118, 9 (1982).
  29. [29]B. Schwaiger, K. Pingel, and G. Holzwarth, Nucl. Phys. A 341, 1 (1980).
  30. [30]M. Traini, Phys. Rev. Lett. 41, 1535 (1978).
  31. [31]T. Suzuki, Physics Letters B 83, 147 (1979).
  32. [32]D. Kurath, Argonne National Laboratory Report No. 97/14 (1977) p. 161.
  33. [33]E. Lipparini and S. Stringari, Physics Reports 175, 103 (1989).
  34. [34]N. Shigeru and A. Kazuhiko, Prog. Theor. Phys. 63, 1599 (1980).
  35. [35]W. Knüpfer, R. Frey, A. Friebel, W. Mettner, D. Meuer, A. Richter, E. Spamer, and O. Titze, Physics Letters B 77, 367 (1978).
  36. [36]H. Toki and W. Weise, Physics Letters B 97, 12 (1980).
  37. [37]C. Rangacharyulu, W. Steffen, A. Richter, E. Spamer, and O. Titze, Physics Letters B 135, 29 (1984).
  38. [38]A. Vdovin, C. Stoyanov, and W. Andrejtscheff, Nuclear Physics A 440, 437 (1985).
  39. [39]J. Speth, Electric and Magnetic Giant Resonances in Nuclei (World Scientific, New York, 1991) p. 436.DOI
  40. [40]D. F. Geesaman, R. D. Lawson, B. Zeidman, G. C. Morrison, A. D. Bacher, C. Olmer, G. R. Burleson, W. B. Cottingame, S. J. Greene, R. L. Boudrie, C. L. Morris, R. A. Lindgren, W. H. Kelly, R. E. Segel, and L. W. Swenson, Phys. Rev. C 30, 952 (1984).
  41. [41]A. M. Lallena, Nuclear Physics A 489, 70 (1988).
  42. [42]A. Bacher, G. Emery, W. Jones, D. Miller, G. Adams, F. Petrovich, and W. Love, Physics Letters B 97, 58 (1980).
  43. [43]T. Nikšić, N. Paar, D. Vretenar, and P. Ring, Comp. Phys. Comm. 185, 1808 (2014).
  44. [44]G. Kružić, T. Oishi, D. Vale, and N. Paar, Phys. Rev. C 102, 044315 (2020).
  45. [45]G. Kružić, T. Oishi, and N. Paar, Phys. Rev. C 103, 054306 (2021).
  46. [46]T. Nikšić, D. Vretenar, and P. Ring, Phys. Rev. C 78, 034318 (2008).
  47. [47]E. Yüksel, T. Marketin, and N. Paar, Phys. Rev. C 99, 034318 (2019).
  48. [48]J. F. Berger, M. Girod, and D. Gogny, Nucl. Phys. A 428 (1984).
  49. [49]N. Paar, P. Ring, T. Nikšić, and D. Vretenar, Phys. Rev. C 67, 034312 (2003).
  50. [50]J. Suhonen, From Nucleons to Nucleus: Concepts of Microscopic Nuclear Theory (Springer-Verlag, Berlin-Heidelberg, 2007) p. 119.DOI
  51. [51]Y. Fujita, B. Rubio, and W. G. Gettelty, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 66, 549 (2011).
  52. [52]S. Kamerdzhiev, J. Speth, G. Tertychny, and J. Wambach, Zeitschrift für Physik A 346, 253 (1993).
  53. [53]R. Schwengner, S. Frauendorf, and B. A. Brown, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 092502 (2017).
  54. [54]V. F. Weisskopf, Phys. Rev. 83, 1073 (1951).
  55. [55]P. Ring and P. Schuck, The Nuclear Many-Body Problems (Springer-Verlag, Berlin and Heidelberg, Germany, 1980).
  56. [57]X. Roca-Maza, G. Pozzi, M. Brenna, K. Mizuyama, and G. Colò, Phys. Rev. C 85, 024601 (2012).
  57. [58]X. Roca-Maza, G. Pozzi, M. Brenna, K. Mizuyama, and G. Colò, Phys. Rev. C 85, 024601 (2012).
  58. [59]T. Oishi, A. Ravlić, and N. Paar, Phys. Rev. C 105, 064309 (2022).
  59. [60]S. Müller, F. Beck, D. Meuer, and A. Richter, Phys. Lett. B 113, 362 (1982).
  60. [61]P. von Neumann-Cosel, private communications (2021).

Paper details

vlnc:W_ewk93y7g
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents